Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Constitutional Change: Articles V and VII with Dr. Beau Breslin

Jul 31, 202425 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Articles V and VII of the U.S. Constitution outline the amendment and ratification process. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey is joined by Skidmore College Political Science Professor Dr. Beau Breslin to discuss the two pathways for amending the Constitution and the high bar for making changes. This episode also touches on the importance of the Constitution's preamble, its evolution during the drafting process, and how it might be different if written today.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford and featured in interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners. We examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. When delegates met in Philadelphia in the summer of 1787, they drafted a blueprint for our new government. This constitution was composed of seven articles and established the structure of the federal government and defined the relationship between federal and state governments. But after it was signed by the delegates that September, it needed to be ratified by the states.

SPEAKER_02And that is Article 7 of the U.S. Constitution. And that's an article that we don't often talk about, as well as Article V, which outlines the amendment process. Today, we're going to consider both of these mechanisms and how it's important to make constitutional changes in context to our modern political climate. And I'm thrilled to welcome back Dr. Bo Breslin, who is the Joseph C. Palomountain Junior Chair in Government at Skidmore College in Saratoga Springs, New York. He holds a PhD in constitutional thought from the University of Pennsylvania.

SPEAKER_02Dr. Breslin is the author of A Constitution for the Living, Imagining How Five Generations of Americans would rewrite the nation's fundamental laws. Bo, it's so great to have you back on the show.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Katie, for having me back. I'm uh, as you know, Montpelier is a home away from home, so great to be back.

SPEAKER_02So I just mentioned Article 7, which is one that doesn't get as much attention, in my opinion. Can you tell us why this article was so important?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I will always argue that Article 7 is as important today as it was back in 1787, 1788, 1789 when the states were considering ratification. And I'll start there and then I'll talk, I'll tell a little story about uh about ratification, about Article VII in the late 18th century. Why is it important today? It's important today because I honestly believe that American citizens ought to have their own personal relationship with the Constitution.

SPEAKER_00The Constitution informs much of what we do on a daily basis, certainly everything we do on a political level, but American citizens ought to engage with the Constitution themselves as opposed to sitting there passively and thinking about, say, what the U.S. Supreme Court says. So I always encourage my students to go to Philadelphia and go to the Constitution Center Museum, work their way through the interactive museum until they get to the final stage.

SPEAKER_00And one of my favorite places on the planet is Siner's Hall and the Constitution Center Museum in Philadelphia. It's right there on Independence Mall. And that room, Siner's Hall, which is the exact same dimensions as the Assembly Room in Independence Hall where the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution were written, that room, Siner's Hall and the Museum, has full-size bronze statues of the framers of the Constitution. So, you know, Benjamin Franklin is there, George Washington at six foot three, looms over the entire group, James Madison is there, Alexander Hamilton, and so on.

SPEAKER_00But being with those folks, those bronze statues, is not the reason to go back to Siner's Hall. It is the opportunity to either sign or refuse to sign the Constitution. They have an interactive constitution that allows citizens today to decide whether or not they would ratify the Constitution. It's a phenomenally important moment in contemporary America to decide whether or not you would ratify the Constitution, warts and all, and I encourage everybody to go back to Philadelphia and do it.

SPEAKER_00So the idea that one has a personal relationship, one is engaged with the text of the Constitution, and one decides whether or not to ratify in today's political climate, I think is really important. And each citizen ought to make his, her, or their own judgment about that. Now, going back to the framing of the Constitution, the most revolutionary moment in American history is when Madison and his friends decide to scrap the Articles of Confederation and start anew. That's revolutionary because that was not their task in Philadelphia, right?

SPEAKER_00They were sent by state legislatures as delegates to tinker with the Articles of Confederation. They felt like they couldn't do that. And so they scrapped and started over again. Brilliant move on Madison's part to bring the Virginia plan and throw it on the table, because of course then the conversation becomes conversation about the Virginia Plan. I think you had a conversation with one of your guests recently where you're like, yeah, that's a really smart move. But ratification is super important in that moment because the framers of the Constitution, the drafters in Philadelphia, had no authority to write a new constitution.

SPEAKER_00So you need to get endorsement from the people after the Constitution is drafted and made public. And Article 7 has a couple of interesting features to it. It's the shortest article in the Constitution. The ratification of the conventions of nine states shall be sufficient for the establishment of this constitution between the states so ratifying the same. So one of the questions I asked my students, why nine? Why not seven? Well, a slight majority. Why not unanimity?

SPEAKER_00The nine was the number. And the main reason why Article 7 requires nine states to ratify is that that number was sufficiently large that Madison and his friends understood that if they could get nine, they probably could get more. They probably could end up getting all 13 states, including Rhode Island, because the four states that would have been outliers would not have wanted to be out of the Union. If you have seven, if the ratification clause only requires seven states to ratify, then six states could go their way like Europe and be their own politicians, be their own sovereignties.

SPEAKER_00But if you get nine and four are worried about sort of being out of the game, that was problematic. Of course, the framers knew that they weren't going to have unanimous consent right off the bat. But nine seemed like a very important strategic calculation because if they could get nine, they probably could get 13, which is a fascinating part of the story of Article 7.

SPEAKER_02And this is important to consider because it really ensures stability in that, as you mentioned, nine out of 13 is required versus if it was only seven out of 13, you have a large portion, perhaps not a majority, but still a large portion of the states that are not in agreement or are not supporting the Constitution. And many of our listeners likely know it was a challenge to get nine out of 13. That's why we see Madison, Alexander Hamilton, John Jay writing these Federalist papers trying to convince the states to ratify the U.S.

SPEAKER_02Constitution. So we know it was a challenge back in the 1700s, but we know today, too, it's also very challenging to amend the Constitution. And I think there is a connection between Article V and Article 7. Can you take us through what that connection is and why Article V is important to us today?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. The Constitution has been amended 27 times, 10 right off the bat, and the Bill of Rights. That story is worth telling too. September 17, 1787. Let's all go back in time to September 17, 1787. The Constitution is made public. And immediately there is criticism, not the least of which is that there's no Bill of Rights. And so the Anti-Federalists, those who opposed ratification, were allowed. I don't know if they were a majority. I'm not sure we know if they were a majority, but they were a very loud contingent of individuals who could make ratification of the Constitution difficult at the state level.

SPEAKER_00Madison, being the politically savvy and quite frankly, brilliant thinker that he is, says, okay, we'll add a bill of rights. Your podcast has talked about the fact that Madison and Hamilton both thought it was dangerous to uh have a Bill of Rights, but Madison backs down and says, okay, this is part of his campaign for being a Congress member. He says, I'll stand up in Congress and I'll propose amendments to the Constitution. I asked my students if they'd been to the National Archives, right?

SPEAKER_00Because the National Archives in Washington, D.C. has Madison's original text of his amendments. And there are, I mean, technically there were, what, 19? You know this better than I do, Katie. There were 19, and then they were consolidated to 17 different amendments. Of the 17, 12 make it through Congress, and then 10 are eventually ratified by the states. And that's why we have 10 amendments in the Bill of Rights. I also tell my students that Madison did not put this luminary First Amendment, this sort of first among equals, this anchor of rights and freedom and liberty in America is the First Amendment.

SPEAKER_00But for Madison, it ended up being the third. He had two other ones, one of which ends up being the 27th Amendment in 1992. 200 years later it passes. But the amendment process itself is tricky. And so when we think about only changing the Constitution 27 times, that's both good and bad. It's good because it suggests that the Constitution is not altogether flawed as much as it might be. The average age of a constitution around the world is only 17 years, and ours has lasted almost 250.

SPEAKER_00So when you only amend it 17 times after 1791, 27 times altogether, you might get the sense that Madison was right that it is a pretty solid, stable, excellent constitutional text. On the other hand, it probably could use some updating, and the bar is very high. And so we haven't had a constitutional amendment since 1992, and even that one was proposed by Madison back in 1789. What's interesting is there have been tens of thousands of amendments proposed in Congress over the 200 plus years that America has been in existence, and only 27 of them have ever gone through the gauntlet of Article V.

SPEAKER_00If I had my way, I would love to change that to bring the bar a little bit down so that the amendment process is not so difficult. And I think our Constitution would be slightly better off. The other thing I think is interesting to say in this moment is Madison's view about amendments. Madison was not a big fan of amendments, as you know. He has this very famous comment in Federalist 49, in which he talks about stability and he talks about reverence and veneration of the Constitution and frequent appeals to the people for amendments and otherwise would render or at least chip away at the reverence that the Constitution has.

SPEAKER_00The other thing that's interesting is that his original idea was that the Bill of Rights would be embedded into the Constitution. It wouldn't be a standalone document, sort of at the end, right? We think about our Constitution as having the seven articles, and then the Bill of Rights sort of at the end as an appendage to the Constitution. Madison thought that that too might give people pause and might make people nervous about the enduring nature or durability of the Constitution. And so what he really wanted was amendments that were embedded actually in the text itself in the original seven articles.

SPEAKER_00It ended up not being that's the case, but Madison was always thinking about the ways in which the Constitution maintained its veneration, its reverential status.

SPEAKER_02You talk about this high bar in order to amend the Constitution, and clearly there is. We've only had 17 amendments since Madison drafted the Bill of Rights and it was ratified in 1791. So can you describe exactly what it takes to amend the Constitution? What is the process required?

SPEAKER_00There are technically two different pathways you could take. Article 5 says the Congress, whenever two-thirds of both houses shall deem it necessary, shall propose amendments to this Constitution, or, and that's an important or on the application of the legislatures of two-thirds of the several states, shall call a convention for proposing amendments. So right there, first sentence, you have two pathways. Congress can propose amendments as long as two-thirds of both houses can pass it, or two-thirds of the states can call a convention for amendments.

SPEAKER_00Now, technically, they could probably call a convention to rewrite the Constitution altogether, but that's the two pathways. Both pathways require a second step, and that is three-quarters of the states have to ratify the amendment. And so regardless of whether or not an amendment starts in Congress or starts with state legislatures calling a convention, three-quarters of the states have to ratify. That's a very high bar. I could imagine, Katie, a situation in which that bar was lower.

SPEAKER_00Let's say not two-thirds, but let's say 60% of Congress members as opposed to 67% of Congress members and 60% of states. So the bar is quite high when you have these two-step processes with Congress and then ratification by three-quarters of the states. That's why we only have 27.

SPEAKER_02I want to dig a bit deeper into this idea of the process, the amendment process. But I first want to push back a little bit and see what you think about some of the things we just talked about in terms of, yes, it's a high bar to amend the constitution. But we also just talked about the need for nine out of the 13 states to ratify the original constitution. And we talked about how it was important to have not just a majority, but a really high number of states that were in support of the Constitution.

SPEAKER_02Do we need to apply that same logic to the amendment process itself?

SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely. Um I think if you have, if you go by simple majority in any configuration, Katie, that would be, I'm I'm willing to be a little hyperbolic here, that would be a disaster because you'd get regional differences, partisan differences, and all of a sudden the constitution changes by virtue of a simple majority. So I'm not advocating, although there are people who do. There are a lot of reformers out there who just believe in the small D Democratic principle and just want the majority to win almost always.

SPEAKER_00I'm not a fan of that. The Supreme Court uh and other institutions put a limit on the majority. I'm a big Madison guy. I think he was right in Federalist 10 that tyranny of the majority is a real thing. So I'm not a fan of uh simple majorities for amendments, but I am a fan of lowering the bar a little bit because it's a little high at the moment.

SPEAKER_02And we talked about the two different ways that the Constitution can be amended. Two-thirds of Congress or two-thirds of the states call a convention. Of the 27 amendments that have been ratified, what was the process for that? Was it Congress or was it the states?

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell So there's never been a convention called by the states. Though it's interesting, there is an organization out there that is collecting support for states to call a convention, and they're pretty close to getting the necessary two-thirds. What's also interesting is when you think about amendments and think about whether or not they expire, right? So some amendments have an expiration date. That is to say, if you don't get the necessary three-quarters of the states to ratify, it expires at a certain amount of time.

SPEAKER_00There are others, like our 27th Amendment, that didn't have an expiration date, and that's why 200 years later, after Madison proposed it, it's now part of the Constitution. One of the things that's interesting is does a state that decides it wants to advocate for a convention in 1975, still want to advocate for a convention today? Is there an expiration date on whether or not a state goes thumbs up on the idea of putting together a convention? These are interesting questions that the Constitution doesn't answer.

SPEAKER_00Often our courts have to answer it, but they are interesting constitutional thought experiments.

SPEAKER_02So all of the 27 amendments that have been ratified have been approved through Congress. Why haven't we had state conventions?

SPEAKER_00Wow, that's a really good question. Um I'm gonna be a little cynical here, Katie, and say, I just don't think the states can get their act together in the same way that Congress can get its act together. And maybe it's just proximity. That is to say, up until fairly recently, there weren't organizations that brought governors together, or there's this great organization that brings together the leaders of the state senates for conferences and so on. So I just think it was easier to do it in Congress and the states didn't get their act together.

SPEAKER_00That said, there's probably some political maneuvering here, which I think is interesting. Congress members will use the idea of amending the Constitution as a way to show their constituents they're working hard on their behalf. State legislators don't typically use that mechanism. Now, that's my cynical side, but it is absolutely true. I'm struck by the fact that after the Supreme Court makes the decision in Texas versus Johnson that allows flag burning as a show of free speech and free expression, you have Congress members all over the place advocating for a constitutional amendment that bars defacing the flag.

SPEAKER_00They know that it's not gonna pass, but Congress members are willing to sort of say to their constituents, see, look at me, I've got your best interests in mind.

SPEAKER_02If we think about two-thirds of the states can call a convention, well, 50 states, that's 34 states, would need to collectively decide that they want to do it. And it is a question of how effectively are we able to use this mechanism, this amendment process, to fulfill those ideals that are espoused in the preamble of the Constitution. And I think it's worth looking at the preamble because it frames the entire conversation of what the Constitution is meant to do.

SPEAKER_00For me, Katie, the preamble is my favorite part of the Constitution. It's sort of the soaring language of America's civic religion. It was sort of late in the convention in Philadelphia when folks said, you know, maybe we ought to have a preamble. And so the Committee of Detail crafting the Constitution, right? One thing that a lot of American citizens don't fully understand is that the framers in Philadelphia, those 55 delegates ended up being 39 signing, but those 55 delegates are not writing the constitution there.

SPEAKER_00They're passing resolutions and so on. And then somebody's got to go and write the dang thing. And so on August 6, 1787, they come out with the form, right? The seven articles, and they have a preamble. The Committee of Detail has a preamble. And the preamble says this. It's amazing. We the people of the states of New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Providence Plantation, Connecticut, New York, they list the states. We the people of the states do ordain, declare, and establish the following constitution for the government of ourselves and our posterity.

SPEAKER_00That was it. It was a list of states. We the people of those states. Governor Morris, who's the penman of the Constitution, right? A phenomenally important figure and a little bit lost in the history books, says, oh, no, no, no, no, no. That's not what the preamble ought to be. And so he takes his pen to the preamble and he comes up with the great lofty, we the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity to ordain and establish this constitution for the United States of America.

SPEAKER_00So without Governor Morris' pen, we would have kind of a mundane, boring preamble. But even Katie more so, more importantly, without the change that Governor Morris puts in to go from we the people of the states of New Hampshire and so on to we the people of the United States, that's a huge deal. Why? Because when you do that, you shift the focus, you shift the entire constitutional document to be a national or union document as opposed to a document that states are giving up some power like they were under the Articles of Confederation.

SPEAKER_00That shift is manifested by the preamble. We became a nation in that moment.

SPEAKER_02I find those words to be very powerful. And I think about them a lot being at Montpelier every day. We the people of the United States. Now, obviously, how the framers thought of we the people is very different than how we think of that today. And many of us have had to actively participate and negotiate and protest and participate in government in order to be included in that phrase, we the people of the United States. And I wonder how might we change it today?

SPEAKER_02Do we have this commitment to the Constitution and to equality? How do we capture that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that's such a great point. The preamble, as great as it is, missed something in 1787 for sure. And pieces of it are missing today. So in 1787, it is glaring that the word equality does not appear in the Constitution. And we can't claim that that missing word equality is somehow a product of the time, because of course Jefferson's Declaration of Independence, where all men are created equal, focused on the issue of equality.

SPEAKER_00So that's one thing that's one aspiration, the notion of equality is one aspiration that our preamble is missing. And so there's no doubt in my mind that if we rewrote the Constitution today, rewrote the preamble today, we would include equality and we would include the treatment of, in particular, enslaved persons, indigenous people, and women, all of which were not part of the original constitutional form.

SPEAKER_02Dr. Bo Breslan, I want to thank you for coming on the show again. It was fantastic to have this conversation. You left us with some very powerful questions, things that I'm certainly going to ask myself about what would my preamble look like? What would I want to be included? This has been very, very enlightening, and I appreciate you being on the show.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for inviting me.

SPEAKER_02And thank you to all the listeners that are joining us today. I hope we left you with some very interesting thoughts to mull over. I hope you'll subscribe and share the show with family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode