Campus Safety and Free Speech: Police Training for Constitutional Rights
25 minAudio
As college campuses continue to serve as vital sites of activism, protest, and public debate, university police face the complex task of upholding First Amendment freedoms while ensuring the safety and wellbeing of diverse campus communities. In this episode, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey sits down with Chief Timothy Longo, Associate Vice President for Safety and Security at the University of Virginia, to explore the delicate intersection of constitutional rights and campus safety. With over 40 years in law enforcement, Chief Longo shares insights on how university police navigate the delicate balance between protecting First Amendment freedoms and ensuring campus security. The conversation covers the unique challenges of policing diverse academic communities, the importance of constitutional training for officers, and practical approaches to managing expressive conduct while maintaining public safety. Chief Longo emphasizes the critical role of empathy, collaboration, and deep constitutional understanding in modern law enforcement.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. Today's episode tackles a topic that's both timely and deeply rooted in constitutional principles. How do universities uphold freedom of expression while also ensuring the safety and well-being of their campus communities? As college campuses continue to be sites of activism, protest, and public debate, university law enforcement faces the delicate task of protecting First Amendment rights while also maintaining order, preventing harm, and navigating competing demands from a wide range of stakeholders.
SPEAKER_02To explore this intersection of constitutional rights and campus safety, I'm joined today in the studio by a guest with a very unique perspective. Chief Timothy Longo, Associate Vice President for Safety and Security, and Chief of Police at the University of Virginia. He brings more than 40 years of experience in law enforcement leadership and higher education to his role. He joined the Baltimore Police Department in 1981. And then after retiring in 2000, Chief Longo joined the Charlottesville Police Department, serving in the capacity of Chief of Police until he retired from the Charlottesville Police Department in 2016.
SPEAKER_02Later that year, he joined the faculty of the University of Virginia's School of Continuing and Professional Studies to create a master's degree in public safety. Chief Longo also serves as an adjunct faculty member at the law school, where he teaches police use of force and guest lectures in a host of other programs related to the criminal justice system. So obviously, with these decades of experience in policing, now transitioning into a university setting, Chief Longo brings valuable insights. And it's an honor to welcome to the studio today.
SPEAKER_02And we're so happy to hear what he has to say.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Katie. It's good to be here with you again.
SPEAKER_02So I want to dive into your role at the university. So as I mentioned, you have this long history of policing in these two different cities, as well as a host of other experience in consulting, for example. But what is it about university policing surprised you or was quite a change from your previous history?
SPEAKER_01You know, when you're in municipal policing or policing any community, the constituents that you serve are interacting with you every day. You see them on the street, in the workplace, in the churches, and the gym and the grocery stores. I have constituents on the grounds of the University of Virginia who live all over the world, who I may never meet. Or if I do meet them, it's on the day of final exercises. People in the medical center who come from all over the world, who may be here for a couple of days to a couple weeks. What they have in common is they've brought the person or persons they love most in the world here to our grounds.
SPEAKER_01And they've entrusted the care of those persons to people like me and our university colleagues who all of us have responsibilities for safety and security on our grounds. And to have that relationship with that constituent thousands of miles away that I may never meet and know that they expect as much a from me, if not more, than the people that uh I would see every day in the city or in the municipalities where I've worked. That's the biggest difference. And the other thing I would add too is living so close to the grounds and interacting so closely with its leadership.
SPEAKER_01I just never realized how privileged we are there to have people come from all over the world with various thoughts, ideas, and backgrounds and perspectives on life. The various leadership throughout our nation and Congress and our Supreme Court and our various states' governors, who also allow the people they love the most to come to our university to learn and to live and to experience life and to interact and provide services to that caliber of leader and know that they feel confident of our ability to do so has been a real honor and privilege and something that I won't say surprised me, but I never much thought about before.
SPEAKER_02I appreciate you noting these various aspects of what it's like to oversee policing or safety on a campus. And I really never thought about it, encompasses much more than just, you know, the students or professors. There is not just the administrators, but there's the universities, hospital, all these people coming from all over the world, as you mentioned. And in a way, it's almost like the campus itself, the grounds are it's like a small city, maybe a little different than our traditional city, but there's a distinct kind of culture there.
SPEAKER_02And how does that unique environment influence your approach to policing in that context?
SPEAKER_01I've always said that policing is balancing the rights of individuals against the interests of the government. And the counterbalance is always the expectations of the community that you serve. What is the style of policing and the amount of policing that they're willing to tolerate and accept or otherwise allow to take place in their community? When you're on the grounds of a place like the University of Virginia, one of the most leading institutions of higher education in the world, and you have a world-class medical center and health system, one of the finest law schools in the nation, the business school, the nursing school, the medical school, I could go on and on.
SPEAKER_01People with uh not just tremendous intellect but curiosity about the work that you do. And uh they too have expectations that they're willing to share, some louder than others. But when I think about policing strategies and policy, I have to think about the constituents that I'm serving, their background, and their experience here. Again, they're coming here for a brief period of time from all over the world. I have no way of knowing what their experiences were with law enforcement in the countries from which they come or even the communities in our nation from which they come.
SPEAKER_01And so being open to listening and welcoming that feedback, and I don't get it, quite frankly, as much as I would like. The relationship between policing and communities are still stressed in our nation. I I tend to think we're making progress, but I'm not naive to the fact that there are people that come with a level of distrust and cynicism. And my job is to try to do my best to win them. I don't mean that in a trite or disrespectful way, but to gain their confidence and respect. And the only way in which to do that is to try to find a relationship or means by which to develop that relationship.
SPEAKER_01And the other opportunity that I have to is I just don't oversee the police services on the university grounds, but also emergency management and threat assessment and safety and security technologies and a host of other public safety facets that cause me to think about the approach to safety in a much broader way than I would if if I were just the chief of police.
SPEAKER_02Your role really does encompass so much in terms of, as you said, emergency management, ensuring the student safety. And as you were talking, it made me think about how these folks that are coming to the grounds, they're bringing their different contexts, their different worldviews. They have their own cities, communities, but they're choosing to visit the University of Virginia. So there's almost this higher accountability, or as you said, expectation. And it's about balancing that. And you referenced you're here at Montpelier today because you're instructing a law enforcement seminar to help guide other professionals and teach them these best practices and how you do strike that balance.
SPEAKER_02And I'm wondering if you can speak more to that, like the challenges in trying to strike that balance. How do you ensure, or to the best of your abilities, ensure, safety of people on the grounds while also trying to respect these rights, particularly for our conversation today, First Amendment rights?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell It's incredibly hard. We are a state agency, we're a government entity, we're not a private institution. The Constitution is our guiding light. It's the mechanism by which everything will go back to. And as I told my colleagues this morning, we were talking about the First Amendment. And when you think about the five protections that are codified within the First Amendment, if you just think about those five things and set the remainder of the Bill of Rights aside, really important things to be able to express yourself. Expression's not just word, it's other means of communication that express thoughts and ideas.
SPEAKER_01Your freedom to believe, your freedom to push back on the government, the freedom to record the government in action and memorialize it and have that memorialization find its way into social media. Those things are all important aspects of our Constitution and the First Amendment. And then by the same token, while it's important to protect an individual's rights to engage in those activities, it can't be at the expense of the safety of others. It can't be to the exclusion of other students' ability to be able to access our services on grounds, or to feel that that the university either acquiesced or did something that permitted certain things to occur that denied them the opportunity to enjoy all the amenities that the university has to offer in the way of an educational institution and a healthcare provider.
SPEAKER_01And then most importantly, to ensure that expression doesn't incite violence or incite hostility in others, give rise to the breach of public peace, result in imminent lawlessness. Because at the end of the day, when that encroaches into the public space, it puts others at risk. And you know, at the end of the day, my job is to help preserve the safety and security of our grounds and the precious assets that come there to live and to work and to study and to visit.
SPEAKER_02Chief Longo, do you find that there are different sets of expectations for expressing First Amendment rights, but also beyond that, in terms of you have students there, and that's a broad group. That could be undergrad, graduate versus maybe like professors or parents. Are there different sets of expectations? And how do you navigate that?
SPEAKER_01There absolutely are. Anytime you bring a different perspective into the room, your background, your own experiences, your upbringing, your education, your personal belief system will all influence your thoughts and ideas about a particular thing. And that may be contrary to the views of the person sitting next to you or across the room or down the hall in the dormitory, or teaching in the classroom around the hall, across the hall. And so it's difficult to balance those varying perspectives and expectations. And when that arises, because there are people that want to advocate and to engage in expressive conduct that could cross that line of hostility, that could preclude or otherwise prevent other students from enjoying the great things that the university has to offer academically and from a healthcare perspective.
SPEAKER_01And at the end of the day, if I focus on what can I do guided by our Constitution and the cases that have interpreted its meaning to keep these people with varying thoughts and ideas safe.
SPEAKER_02And you noted an important point about respecting these rights, but not allowing people expressing these rights to encroach on the rights of others. Peaceably assemble, for example, it's not just the right to assemble. Peaceably assemble is an important part of that right.
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell It's absolutely an important part. And when you look back over your shoulder at the encampments that occurred across our nation last year and the legal implications of those that have found their way either in to courtrooms or in technical assistance letters from our Justice Department to point to things like Title VI and other means by which the constitutional rights of others were actually infringed upon by the expressive conduct of a group or groups of individuals that come to that space to exercise what they believe is their First Amendment right to engage in thoughts and ideas that may be adverse to yours and mine.
SPEAKER_02And the First Amendment, I think it's important to point out, says the US government can't infringe upon these five rights. Later that was extended to the state, so the states couldn't infringe upon those individual rights.
SPEAKER_01Yes, by some time in the 1940s, which all five aspects of the First Amendment had been incorporated against the states through the 14th Amendment due process clause, keeping in mind that states, even before and certainly now, have their own constitutional provisions that in many ways mirror our federal constitution. But you're right, the federal constitution was drafted to address the conduct and actions of the federal government. But over time, the vast majority of those provisions of our Bill of Rights have in fact been incorporated against our states, the First Amendment being one much earlier on than some others.
SPEAKER_02Students or anybody expressing their opinions or exercising these rights on a college campus that's privately owned versus state funded, like UVA, the rights are different. And how do you find students' expectations for what they can and cannot do in terms of exercising these rights? And how do you navigate that in your role as both head of the police division, but also this emergency management and emergency response?
SPEAKER_01Well, it's a joint responsibility. I share that responsibility with a number of colleagues across grounds and my colleagues in student affairs and I are oftentimes at the hip on these issues. We have a mutual responsibility to participate and contribute when the construction of certain policies and procedures that talk about expressive conduct, that articulate reasonable time, place, and matter restrictions that the Constitution permits to help govern expressive conduct, if you will, in such a way that it does not disrupt the university's operation, interfere with the rights of other students, or create imminent lawless behavior, which is not constitutionally protected, as you know.
SPEAKER_01But it's a shared responsibility. And I think the clarity of our policies, the means by which they're disseminated and communicated to the bodies that are expected to adhere to those policies is of critical importance. And our university, like a lot of others across the nation, took a retrospective look at some of our policies last summer and did some work in aligning them with time, place, and matter provisions such that the university could continue to operate in a way that was efficient and serve the needs of our students, faculty, and staff and visitors in the event expressive conduct were to take place on our grounds.
SPEAKER_01The importance of communicating that in such a way that it was understood is incredibly important. But the reality of it is you're always going to have people from all walks of life that are going to disagree on where you land. And that's okay. And sometimes that's okay results in litigation or review by higher authorities. And that's okay as well. We live within a system of justice that is in place for a reason. Uh we have to respect it and and trust that it will do the the work that it's intended to do. And then whatever the end result is, act accordingly.
SPEAKER_02And James Madison was very much not only aware of, but in support of people having different opinions. That's sort of the point of a democracy, in a way, is we all get to have our thoughts and opinions. And it's good to talk with people that aren't necessarily agreeing with you on all aspects. But it's how we go from there, how we treat the other person. Are we making sure that we're respecting them? Are they respecting us? And it sounds like from what you've described, Chief Longo, that you collaborate closely with other departments.
SPEAKER_02So this is not just you or your department making these decisions. There's a lot of collaboration. And it sounds like there's active engagement with trying to think about how do we respect the rights of individuals to exercise these freedoms, but then also thinking broadly about ensuring safety.
SPEAKER_01I think that's right. You know, we talk a lot about best practices and law enforcement. And I'm oftentimes asked, sometimes on the witness stand or in deposition, what does that mean? When you say what generally accepted policing practices, where does that come from? Is that your opinion? Or and to the extent I'm able to mention the law, I always start with our practices that we've adopted have its origin in our constitution and the cases that have interpreted its meaning. But it's also we rely heavily upon our professional organizations like the International Association of Chiefs of Police and the Police Executive Research Forum.
SPEAKER_01In this case, the Virginia Association of Chiefs of Police and campus law enforcement executives who collaborate on a regular basis with respect to what's happening on our college campuses. How are we responding to it to ensure that there's a level of consistency with our operational service delivery and the manner in which we go about our work, our strategies, if you will. And if we do that, and we do on a regular basis, it ensures that those practices are in fact generally accepted, that it's not my way because I'm the chief.
SPEAKER_01These are practices and strategies that are used at state institutions across the land and in cities and counties across our nation as well, because again, they're driven, they all have their origin in the same place, and that's our constitution.
SPEAKER_02So when we think about today's college students, they've grown up with a different set of expectations about speech, safety, authority than in previous generations, a different time, different context. How has this new generation of students informed how you do policing at UVA, but also how you train your officers?
SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell Well, you asked the question initially about the distinctions between municipalities and college campuses are our constituents are very curious. They're not shy in sharing their opinions about how you do your work. And it takes not just a thick skin, but an open mind to be receptive to that and to listen and to adjust your strategies when it's either necessary or feasible or the responsible thing to do. I share with my colleagues all the time, you know, our constitution's the floor, it's not the ceiling. And sometimes the space in between the two gets filled from the ideas and expectations of the people that are the recipients of your services.
SPEAKER_01But you gotta be willing and open to listen. But on the other hand, the constituent needs to have an open mind and be able to come to the table and listen as well and share their thoughts and ideas in ways that are civil and respectful. And it's important from my perspective when I'm talking to young officers is that the two most important tools you bring to work with you every day aren't on your utility belt. It's your heart and your mind. And if you lead with them first and you're able to express yourself in such a way and listen in such a way that you're receptive to the ideas of others, particularly when those others are your customers.
SPEAKER_01They're the people that are receiving your services every day. That level of maturity and professionalism will go far in ensuring that the brand that we represent is protected and sustains itself over time as those students come and go from year to year.
SPEAKER_02I love the idea of yes, best practices, it's rooted in US Constitution. We're also looking at, you know, what other universities are doing, other organizations, but this idea of your heart and your mind. So you can have all that foundation, and that's really important, but kind of using your head, but also being empathetic and compassionate, being key parts of policing. And can you speak a little bit more about that? And sometimes officers are put in these very challenging situations, these gray moments.
SPEAKER_02How can you best instruct them, kind of using what you've just described to address those situations?
SPEAKER_01I I tell my colleagues, particularly the younger colleagues that don't have the life experience or professional experience that I've been blessed to develop in the last 44 years, that we are privileged to do the work that we do as intercessors in the best and worst times of people's lives. And that empathy, that compassion, that understanding is really important when we're showing up for the scene when something really bad has happened. And whether that person that we engage first is a suspect, a victim, or victim's family member, understanding what has just occurred and conducting yourself in a way to recognize your first and foremost responsibility is to honor and protect the sanctity of human life.
SPEAKER_01And everyone enjoys that. You know, we do find ourselves in situations where we have to make quick decisions, but it's also important that we don't put ourselves in those situations by not planning, by not coordinating our response, by not communicating, by not thinking about the resources available, by by taking the time to step back sometimes and slow the situation down to try to gain a better understanding of what's happening so you don't find yourself having eliminated all other potential outcomes to where now you find yourself in having to do something that you'll never ever be able to take back.
SPEAKER_01Regardless of what a court says about it down the road, it doesn't matter. You live with your decisions for the rest of your life. There's no pause, there's no rewind, there's no can we do a do-over? No. You've made a decision, you've acted. And if you've acted because you didn't take the time to slow things down, step back and evaluate, then we're gonna have to deal with that. So the more I can communicate down on the front end, it's like building muscle memory is that um I realize that you're faced with what the courts have often said, tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving circumstances.
SPEAKER_01But at the end of the day, could you have found yourself in a different place had you did the following things? We spend a lot of time I I've seen this over the course of my career, spending a lot of time trying to justify what we do or didn't do. Well, at the end of the day, um everything we do is an opportunity to learn to strengthen ourselves, to become better. And sometimes we don't always get it right. But we have to have the moral courage to say we didn't get it right, and then think about ways to prevent this from happening again.
SPEAKER_01And if we start with the understanding that sanctity of human life comes first, and that includes everyone's life, everyone, in every set of circumstances, I think we'll find ourselves in a better place. Maybe that's wishful thinking. I I hope not.
SPEAKER_02I think what you're describing is really profound and recognizing that law enforcement officers are often put in situations that are incredibly challenging, tense, high stakes, but they're confronting situations and people, as you noted, in the worst moments of their lives. And as we wrap up this conversation, kind of following on that line of thought, do you have any thoughts or guidance that you would give to other law enforcement officers who are faced with these challenges, um, particularly officers who are kind of struggling with First Amendment issues in their communities and what they can do to lead and be prepared as you were describing?
SPEAKER_01Well, I think the first thing we have to do is do a better job at training police officers on what the First Amendment is and what it isn't. We do a good job at preparing them for tactical situations, how to respond to that unruly crowd, how to disperse that demonstration after an unlawful dissembly has been declared or a new trespass order has been given. And sometimes that involves force. Do you understand the why? Do you understand the First Amendment implications of that? And do you understand how we arrived at making the determination that the First Amendment has been run afoul to where we now have to act?
SPEAKER_01That protection the First Amendment provides to that person engaging in that expressive conduct has been lost by certain types of activities and behaviors. Doing a better job at walking them through what the law says and how it is that the law came about to be is as important as it is to train them to do a tactical response to disperse that crowd. And much can be said about other areas of the law where we could do better, but I've always thought you've got to do a better job at teaching the First Amendment in a way that police officers can operationalize it in real time when they have to.
SPEAKER_02I really appreciate that kind of parting thought. Uh that's a good reminder, I think for all of us in any profession, but particularly policing. It's the why. On a deeper level, why are we here? What are we doing? What's the purpose? But then what are we enforcing here and what are the parameters and having that foundation? I think that's how you, in a situation, are able to use your heart and your head to respond.
SPEAKER_01I think so as well.
SPEAKER_02Well, Chief Longo, I want to thank you so much for being here at Montpelier, for training the law enforcement officers joining us here today, and for speaking with me and for your decades of service. What you do is so significant, and you've really helped the Charlottesville community as well as UVA. Thank you so much for everything that you do.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Katie, and thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_02And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you'll share this show with your family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...