In this enlightening episode of Consider the Constitution, host Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey sits down with Dr. Dennis Rasmussen, professor of political science at Syracuse University's Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs. Their conversation explores the philosophical underpinnings that influenced the creation of the U.S. Constitution, particularly focusing on Enlightenment thinkers like John Locke, David Hume, Adam Smith, and Montesquieu whose ideas shaped the framers' thinking. Dr. Rasmussen, author of "Fears of a Setting Sun," provides fascinating insights into how the founders - particularly Madison - navigated between theory and practical application when designing America's system of government. The discussion reveals surprising details about Madison's disappointment with certain aspects of the Constitution, the founders' evolving opinions about their creation, and the remarkable durability of America's founding document despite its imperfections. This episode offers listeners a deeper understanding of the intellectual foundations of American constitutional governance and reflects on what lessons we might draw from the founders' experiences as we face today's political challenges.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackley and feature in interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.
SPEAKER_00Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.
SPEAKER_02Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. This May 2025 marks 238 years since the start of the Constitutional Convention in 1787, when a group of delegates gathered in Philadelphia with a bold mission: fix a broken government. As many of you history buffs know, instead of tweaking the system, the delegates scrapped it and created an entirely new framework, the U.S.
SPEAKER_02Constitution. And while we've talked about the Constitutional Convention in past episodes, our discussion today centers more on the philosophical underpinnings that influenced the creation of the US Constitution. Ideas that still resonate today. This is an opportunity for us to think more deeply about the principles that resonated with the framers and how some of history's greatest minds continue to guide us in understanding the evolution of modern political systems.
SPEAKER_02And it's a privilege to have Dr. Dennis Rasmussen in this studio today. He is a professor of political science and the Haggerty Family Fellow at Syracuse University's Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs. He is also the director of the university's political philosophy program. And his research focuses on the history of political thought, particularly the Enlightenment and the American Founding. Dennis has published five books, including The Infidel and the Professor, David Hume, Adam Smith, and The Friendship That Shaped Modern Thought, which was shortlisted for the Ralph Waldo Emerson Award and named a Best Book of the Year in The Guardian, Bloomberg, and several other media outlets.
SPEAKER_02Dennis, welcome to Montpelier. It's really an honor to have you in the studio today.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, and thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_02Well, in previous episodes, as I've mentioned, we've talked about the 1787 Constitutional Convention held at Independence Hall in Philadelphia. Now the delegates from the various states gathered to address weaknesses in the Articles of Confederation, which was the form of government at the time. And over that summer, from May through September, the delegates ultimately abandoned the Articles and crafted this new form of government, this U.S. Constitution. And James Madison in particular, but among others, studied not just the structure of ancient governments, ancient confederacies, republics, but he's also drawing heavily on the political thoughts of Enlightenment thinkers.
SPEAKER_02Can you tell us more about the influence these ideas had on the delegates, particularly Madison, and which of these Enlightenment thinkers are really at the forefront of the conversations they're having that summer?
SPEAKER_01Sure, I'd be happy to. Let me just say first, there's a tendency among people like me, political theorists, to almost reduce the founders to some philosopher, that they're kind of echoes of some earlier thinker, whoever the favorite one is of the scholar in question. These were very eminently practical men. They also drew quite a lot on history, of course, British history, Roman history, their own history of the state governments, very interesting differences between the state constitutions, and so they could see, you know, kind of what worked well, what didn't. New York had one of the strongest governors, and that worked pretty well, so maybe we should make a strong presidency, that kind of thing.
SPEAKER_01That said, they were, of course, deeply read in philosophy and deeply influenced by philosophical thinkers. There used to be a tendency for scholars to say, pick out one thinker and say, ah, this is really the mastermind behind the American Revolution. This is where the founders or the framers got their ideas. I think there's a pretty broad consensus now that they drew on multiple sources. I'll name just a couple of them. I think we have to start with John Locke. Locke's book, The Second Treatise of Government, is in many ways the founding text of liberalism in the broadest sense or classical sense.
SPEAKER_01And the opening paragraph of the Declaration of Independence is a pretty good summary of Locke's Second Treaties. The four self-evident truths that people are basically equal, we have inalienable rights, government has to rest on consent, there's a right to revolution. All these come straight from Locke. Another pair of thinkers I'll mention are David Hume and Adam Smith, both Scottish Enlightenment thinkers who had a big influence. Hume is often seen today as a kind of epistemologist and a philosopher of religion. Smith often seen as an economist, but both, I think, would have considered themselves first and foremost moral and political thinkers, and they influenced the founders quite a bit as well.
SPEAKER_01Then the final figure I'll mention, I think maybe the single greatest influence of all, is Montesquieu, the great French philosopher Montesquieu, whose book The Spirit of the Laws was drawn on. Actually, I mean both sides in the ratification debates, Federalist and Antifederalist alike, cited him all the time. It was almost sometimes like a wrestling match. Who could get Montesquieu on their side? Who could prove that Montesquieu would support their position, particularly on the issue of the separation of powers, but not a bunch of others as well.
SPEAKER_02That's an interesting point that you make, Dennis. It's not just these thinkers like Hume or Locke or Montesquieu. It's also these past governments, the Roman Republic, for example. Again, they're pulling kind of examples from British government, even though it's a monarchy, they're finding some things that you know works well that they're using, and then the state constitutions as well. What is it exactly about the Enlightenment, the thinking that's going on with the Enlightenment that the founders are so inspired by?
SPEAKER_01Well, the Enlightenment thinkers are thinking very practically about government, and that's very applicable to their situation when they're trying to create a new government. As I say, they don't often just take the ideas of a Locke or a Montesquieu and just say, well, how do we apply this today? They draw on them in a sort of holistic way. Although I will say, Jefferson once said of Locke's second treaties, Locke's little book on government is perfect so far as it goes. So he really drew quite a lot of inspiration from Locke, but then of course thought you need to move beyond that, right? It's an abstract theory, as Locke has written it down, and they're trying to apply this to real world politics and resolve real-world issues, as you said in your open, right?
SPEAKER_01The fecklessness of the Articles of Confederation. How do we strengthen the national government in the face of those kinds of problems? So it was a balancing act of trying to realize these broad ideals that they had gotten from these Enlightenment thinkers, but also see how they could be practically applied in a concrete way.
SPEAKER_02And it sounds like that's really where the challenge is trying to apply those theories from Locke, Hume, Adam Smith, and put it into practice through this new structure of government they're creating.
SPEAKER_01Right. Let me take another example. So Montesquieu is most famous for his theory of the separation of powers. He's the first philosopher to separate powers in the way that we know and love, where you have a legislative, executive, judicial. Locke advocated a separation of powers, but he did it slightly differently. He separated out what he called the federative power, which is the power over foreign affairs. And so they take this broad idea of the separation of powers into the three branches that we know and love today from Montesquieu. But his discussion comes mostly in a discussion of the English Constitution. And of course, they're not doing quite the same thing in America.
SPEAKER_01There's no House of Lords, the courts are going to play a slightly different role in America than they played there. So yeah, it's about adapting the broad ideals and making them fit the American context.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell And is there a way to almost parse out what is an original Jefferson thought, for example, or Madison thought, versus seeing how they're being influenced by people like Montesquieu? I think of Madison, for example. The separation of powers is such a key part of the Constitution, as we all know. How do we understand how he's taking Montesquieu's ideas and implementing it in the Constitution?
SPEAKER_01That's really tricky. I mean, the question of intellectual influence is always tricky. I mean, whether you even when it's just one philosopher influencing another, right? So how is Smith influenced by Hume is a very easy question, but which earlier thinkers are they really drawing on? Obviously, the easiest way is if they tell us, right? So Madison says quite explicitly in The Federalist that Montesquieu, as he calls it, the oracle, who is always consulted on this question of the separation of power. So he tells us that Montesquieu is important for him. You know, it's a fun scholarly game that scholars love to play in in terms of trying to trace these intellectual influences and maybe, oh, is there some forgotten pamphleteer who maybe was very important in ways that we don't realize.
SPEAKER_01It's kind of fun to do. I don't know. My tendency is more to take these thinkers at their own word and just try to understand what they were advocating and why, rather than always, again, trying to reduce them to an echo of one philosopher or another.
SPEAKER_02And so as we mentioned, this is a very challenging task putting theory into practice. And obviously, in my opinion, I think they did a pretty good job of it considering everything. But there are some major shortcomings of the Constitution. Slavery is a glaring one, obviously, but there are others. And I'm wondering if you can tell us a little bit about what concerns the founders may have had as they're not just drafting the Constitution, but after its ratification and as they're seeing it working as it's supposed to work.
SPEAKER_02But, you know, I'm thinking again, we have Washington, president, then we have Adams, Jefferson, Madison. As we go through the decades, what's working with the Constitution for them and what are they seeing as not working?
SPEAKER_01So I'm happy to talk at this at great length. So I wrote a book a few years ago called Fears of a Setting Sun that is about how almost all of the founders who lived into the 19th century, or even to the dawn of the new century, like Washington, grew anxious and in many cases deeply disillusioned with the government that they created. So the book centers on Washington, Hamilton, Adams, and Jefferson, each of whom sort of lost their faith in the American experiment at different times and for different reasons. So I associate a different theme with each of them.
SPEAKER_01For Washington, it was above all the rise of parties and partisanship. Hamilton, he just never thought the national government, the federal government, was sufficiently, he would call it energetic or vigorous, not strong enough in relation to the state governments. Adams was worried that the American people didn't have the requisite civic virtue to sustain a Republican government. And Jefferson had actually a number of causes for worry at the very end of his life, above all the sectional divide that was laid bare by the Missouri crisis over the expansion of slavery. Also he was very worried, almost the opposite of Hamilton, very worried about consolidation or centralization of power.
SPEAKER_01Really, the one figure who did not lose the Republican faith was the one who outlived them all, which is James Madison. He was actually quite disappointed in the Constitution immediately after its drafting. So we we call him the father of the Constitution, and we sometimes talk about the Constitution as embodying Madison principles. He's actually pretty disappointed by the end of the convention. He writes to Jefferson in Paris and says, even if we can get this thing ratified, it's not going to, as he puts it, answer its national object. That is to say, he was very worried about the potential for what he called majority faction, basically majority tyranny within the state governments.
SPEAKER_01He wanted some effective check on the state governments at the national level, including he wanted Congress to be able to veto laws passed by the states. He fought for this again and again in the convention, didn't get it. A number of other things he fought for at the convention couldn't get it. He wanted proportional representation in both houses of Congress, not just the House. He wanted this thing called a council of revision where the president and some members of the Supreme Court would sort of have a preemptive veto on legislation almost. One scholar, Forrest McDonald, counted up, I think there were seventy-one proposals that Madison either made the motion, he seconded the motion, or unequivocally supported the motion over the course of the convention.
SPEAKER_01And if I'm remembering the numbers right, I think Madison lost on forty-one of them. That is to say he lost more than half. And so again, we talk about the Constitution embodying Madisonian principles, and to some extent it does, but it's not exactly what he wanted. He was deeply disappointed. He came around pretty quickly over the course of the ratification process. I mean, he certainly sees it as a huge improvement over the Articles of Confederation. So he argues quite vigorously for it in the Federalist at the crucial Virginia ratifying convention in Richmond. And he seems to almost sort of convince himself of the virtues of the Constitution.
SPEAKER_01And then he remains more or less faithful to it all the way through. I mean, he lives to 1836, right? And this is almost the end of Andrew Jackson's second term as president. He lives so long and sees so much. And interestingly, he's the one founder who kind of retains his faith to the end. And so my book explores why did these other thinkers lose their faith and why was Madison the one exception that proves the rule.
SPEAKER_02This is such an intriguing conversation because we often talk about what Madison contributed to the Constitution or the other delegates, what did actually come out of the drafting, this process, but we don't often think about what didn't get included and what was Madison disappointed in.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So as I say, he wanted the national government, at least at this time in the 1780s, he wanted the national government to be more powerful than it was, better able to check the state government than it was. He sort of changed his tune in the 1790s. This is a, you know, it's a perennial scholarly question. He becomes Jeffersonian Republican, where he seemed to be such an arch federalist as recently as 1787, 88. And so whether he changed his mind or something about the country had changed, I mean, that's a perennial debate that I don't know that I'll weigh in on. But yeah, I mean the broader point is there's so much about the convention, so many things are really up in the air.
SPEAKER_01We almost tend to view the Constitution as inevitable, right? Like something like this is coming down the pike and it's going to take basically this form. I mean, really, when you read through Madison's notes, which are by far the fullest account of the convention's proceedings that we have, when you read through Madison's notes, there's so much that's up in the air, and things seem like they could go any way. Let me give you just one concrete example if I can. The selection of the president, right? We just had a presidential election a couple months ago. It was very rancorous. There are really only two figures, important figures at least, at the convention who wanted direct popular election of the president.
SPEAKER_01Those were James Wilson and one of my favorites, Governor Morris, who've also written a book about. They both advocate that the people choose the president. And everyone else saw this as just utterly preposterous. That the people could possibly choose, they'd be led this way by demagogues, they wouldn't be sufficiently informed of who the best candidates would be. And so the vast majority of people at the convention wanted Congress to choose the president. For almost the entire summer, the plan on the table included congressional selection of the president, which, you know, would have, if it had passed, would have gone a long way toward making our system a parliamentary system rather than a presidential one, if we want to use modern terms.
SPEAKER_01It was really only at the end, and again, thanks to the efforts of Wilson and Morris, that we have our kind of bizarre electoral college as they saw as the a second best option, but the closest that they could get to a popular election. And you know, the rest of the delegates were willing to go along with it because it solved some problems with the small states and the slave states that maybe we don't need to get into the technical details. But it was the closest that they could convince people to do to having people choose the president directly.
SPEAKER_02And Dennis, you were mentioning the concerns that founders like Washington had, Hamilton, Jefferson. And as you were speaking, those concerns were resonating with me today. So are there things that we can maybe look to in the framers that might help us better navigate politics today?
SPEAKER_01Yes, of course. One thing I like about returning to the founders is that because they're, you know, starting from scratch is too strong. They're again, they're starting from the state governments and all the things we've touched on. But because they're kind of starting from scratch, they're asking the questions at the highest possible level in a way that, you know, when we think in contemporary terms, how strong should the presidency be? Frankly, when a Republicans in the Oval Office, most Republicans want the president to be to be a lot stronger, and vice versa. How strong should the national government be?
SPEAKER_01You know, Democrats are a lot fonder of states' rights now than they were under Obama when the Democrats controlled Congress as well. And so people tend to craft or change their views of the broader system, the constitutional order, based on what's politically expedient at the moment. The founders obviously didn't do that. They didn't, you know, there was no one in these offices yet. And so reading the founders, studying the founders allows us to ask the question in a more broad way. You know, how strong should the presidency be just in terms of the basic structure of the constitutional order?
SPEAKER_01Not how should strong should this or that president be, or this or that Supreme Court be, or whatever it might be, but just thinking in terms of how the system should be constructed to make it work as efficiently as possible.
SPEAKER_02It makes me think about Madison's own political journey and career where, you know, when he is taking part in this constitutional convention, he's in his mid-30s and he still has like a full career ahead of him. He's going to go on and serve in Congress in the 1790s, he's going to be a Secretary of State under Jefferson in the early 1800s, and then eventually serve two terms as president. But that's a lot that's going to happen after this constitutional convention. And in my mind, I can understand why not just people today, but the framers too, they're setting up this structure, but then they're going to actually be part of this government.
SPEAKER_02And I could see how, you know, opinions might change, there might be some anxiety that arises as you are referencing. So how can we take inspiration from looking at Madison's life and applying it to ourselves today when we do perhaps change our mind on something? Should we be going back and looking at the Constitution and saying, no, this is the bedrock, this is what we need to look to and follow, even when there's a shift in power or parties?
SPEAKER_01I'm generally not someone who says at all that the founder's will or intent should be obeyed in all things, that they were somehow perfect or they got all the answers right. I do think Madison's a particularly interesting example to go back to the line I drew between him and the other founders from my book, given that he was the only one who retained his optimism throughout his long life. One of the reasons he retained his optimism was simply that he was, as he was called even at the time, the last of the fathers, right? He had been through so much, he had seen the country endure so much from his point of view that some of the worst things were the Alien and Sedition Acts, the War of 1812, right?
SPEAKER_01The White House is put to the torch by British troops. You get this very rancorous debate over the admission to Missouri as a slave state and the sectional divisions that that brought to light, the nullification crisis. I mean, he's just seen the country endure so much, and the more the country endured, the more durable it seemed to him. That is to say, if it could endure all those problems, couldn't it endure a whole lot more? And you know, now we're looking back, it's endured for 230 plus years, right? We've seen it endure much longer than than Madison had.
SPEAKER_01So, you know, maybe we uh the book is not a super optimistic book insofar as it's focusing on on uh most of these figures losing heart. But the the Madison part does give you a certain sort of optimism that if he could take solace from the fact that the Constitution had lasted a half century, well, 230 odd years is a lot, a lot more than that.
SPEAKER_02And as we close out our conversation today, that makes me think about what lessons we can draw from Madison. What can we look to or what should we find inspiration in as we navigate our current challenges today?
SPEAKER_01That's a big question. So let me pick back up where I just left off. The Constitution has lasted 230 whatever years. That makes it, as I'm sure most listeners will know, the oldest national constitution. The oldest constitution period that's still in effect is the Massachusetts States Constitution, which went into effect in 1780, almost a decade before the US Constitution. But the US Constitution has been in effect much longer than any other national constitution. Now, at the time, writing a constitution down wasn't at all taken for granted. I believe Corsica had me you know, there are a few other places it had, but of course Britain didn't have a written constitution, most nations didn't.
SPEAKER_01It's now become, of course, much, much more common. I think the only modern democracies that don't have a written constitution are Britain, New Zealand, and Israel. So most modern liberal democracies have a written constitution. In fact, I believe there have been something like twenty-two hundred written constitutions since the American Constitution, which means if you do the math, the average national constitution lasts something like fifteen years. It's very rare for a constitution to last fifty years, much less two hundred and thirty years. It's an enormous outlier in that regard.
SPEAKER_01That has both benefits and drawbacks, right? The benefit is it's lasted this long, it has the, you know, it's kind of proven itself over time, it has sort of popular attachment to it, where, you know, even if Americans gripe about this or that feature of the Constitution, they don't like the Electoral College or whatever it might be. There's broad reverence for the Constitution. You're you're you're not likely to win an election by going out and saying, let's scrap this thing. We we need to start from scratch. On the other hand, the fact that it was drafted, you know, more than two centuries ago by a certain elite that was white men who often many of them were slaveholders and so forth, that and it's just so overwhelmingly difficult to change, right?
SPEAKER_01To amend the Constitution. This is the framers often said, well, it's not perfect, but we can always change it. And I fear now that we can't change it. I I really I I rarely make political predictions, but I will go out on a limb and say there will not be a constitutional amendment in my lifetime. It takes two-thirds of both houses of Congress in three-quarters of the states to approve an amendment. And that's just an insurmountable obstacle when we have such close partisan divides in the country. So the downside of it lasting this long is we're stuck. We're stuck with this text we have.
SPEAKER_01And to what degree do we want to just mess around and pretend it says something different than it does? I mean, this is the perennial debate over originalism, living constitutionalism, and so forth. You know, it's a it's a big, big topic. But the great thing about it lasting so long is it does have the imprimatur of age, but the downside is we're stuck with the text for good or for ill.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell It's such a um kind of nuanced and complex thing. There is something pretty incredible about it being this enduring constitution, this enduring bounding document when you think about 15 to 50 years within a person's lifetime having a new constitution. Ours is pretty historically significant, and the fact that it was written down, the writing of a constitution at that time being pretty incredible. But yes, I think a a lot of a lot of citizens, a lot of people feel that sense of being stuck when you consider there's only been 27 amendments in 230 plus years, ten of those happening just a couple short years after it was ratified.
SPEAKER_02So it is a question, I think, for current generations about where do we go from here? And yes, taking inspiration from the founders, but also reconciling where we're at in this moment and how we not only just should be civically aware and active, but we really have to be. It's essential at this point.
SPEAKER_01Agreed.
SPEAKER_02It's just been really enlightening to hear about all the thoughts and founding texts that have been so influential to these men when they crafted this founding charter.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me, and thanks for the great questions.
SPEAKER_02And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe and share this show with your family and friends. And tune in again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.
A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...
The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...
The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...
The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...
The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...