Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

Constitutional Safeguards: How the 4th, 5th, and 6th Amendments Protect Your Rights

Apr 30, 202522 minAudio

In this episode of Consider the Constitution, host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey welcomes back Kendra Johnson, assistant Public Defender in Fairfax, Virginia, to explore the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments. Johnson explains how these amendments form the backbone of criminal procedure in America and protect citizens from government overreach. The discussion begins with an overview of each amendment: the Fourth Amendment protecting against unreasonable searches and seizures, the Fifth Amendment covering rights such as protection against self-incrimination and double jeopardy, and the Sixth Amendment ensuring the right to a speedy trial, impartial jury, and legal counsel. Johnson shares insights into the historical context of these amendments, explaining how the Framers developed these protections in response to abuses they had witnessed under British rule. The conversation highlights landmark Supreme Court cases that have shaped these rights over time, including Katz v. United States, which established the "reasonable expectation of privacy" standard; Miranda v. Arizona, which created the famous "Miranda warnings"; and Gideon v. Wainwright, which guaranteed the right to an attorney even for those who cannot afford one. The episode concludes with a discussion of emerging challenges to these constitutional protections in the digital age, including questions about surveillance technology, online trials, and artificial intelligence in the criminal justice system. Johnson emphasizes that these amendments are vital not just for those accused of crimes but for all citizens, as they establish boundaries on government power that protect everyone's liberty regardless of who holds political office.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

SPEAKER_02Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_03Hello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey with James Madison's Montpelier. The United States Constitution is often talked about in a grand, sweeping way. We use phrases like the foundation of democracy or the supreme law of the land. But what does the Constitution really mean when we're thinking about our day-to-day lives? At its core, our founding document isn't just a piece of paper that governs our institutions.

SPEAKER_03It's the contract between the government and its people. And nowhere is that contract more critical than when the power of the state is used to investigate, accuse, and prosecute individuals. And that's where the Fourth, Fifth, and Sixth Amendments come in. Today we're discussing how these three amendments form the backbone of the criminal procedure and how they are essential to protecting individual rights. How do these protections work in everyday life? And why do they matter?

SPEAKER_03Not just for those accused of crimes, but for all of us. To help us unpack these questions, I'm joined by Kendra Johnson, assistant public defender in Fairfax, Virginia. Before returning to public defense, she taught criminal law and criminal procedure as a visiting assistant professor of law at Liberty University School of Law. Miss Johnson has a Master of Laws from Howard University School of Law. And she obtained her JD from Liberty University School of Law, Magna Kumlaude.

SPEAKER_03Kendra has also been on our show in the past. So it's wonderful to have her here back in the studio. And I encourage our listeners to go and check out her first episode on privacy rights. So, Kendra, welcome back to Montpelier. Thank you for joining us today. Thank you for having me again. So we're going to be talking about these three amendments: the fourth, fifth, and sixth. So before we dive in, can you give us a very brief overview of what each of those amendments is, what rights they protect?

SPEAKER_01Sure. So we start with the Fourth Amendment. Broadly, the Fourth Amendment protects citizens from unreasonable sources and seizures. And then you have the Fifth Amendment that encompasses quite a few rights. So there's right to grand jury indictment, there's double jeopardy, there's also the right against self-incrimination, which most people know from the Fifth Amendment. I plead the fifth. And then there's due process, which is just the right to a fair trial. And then we have the Sixth Amendment, which is the final one that we'll be talking about today. And it also encompasses a lot of rights.

SPEAKER_01So there's a right to speedy trial, there's a right to an impartial jury, which I think most people maybe associate that with the Sixth Amendment, the right to confrontation, so confronting and cross-examining witnesses that are against you in a trial, and then assistance of counsel. So those are the main ones that are encompassed within each of the amendments.

SPEAKER_03And these rights are so critical. And we'll talk a little bit later about how these rights have evolved over time. But when we think about James Madison and how he's thinking about these rights, most of our listeners know about the 1787 Constitutional Convention. We've talked a lot about that on this show. And it's right after that document, this founding document is signed after that summer. And several key states are really seeking for more protection of individual rights.

SPEAKER_03And that kind of prompts Madison to draft what we now know as the Bill of Rights, these first 10 amendments. So what is Madison thinking when he's writing the fourth, fifth, sixth amendments specifically? What is it about these rights that he and these other framers are concerned about?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I am not a historian by any means, but um, from what I know or what I've researched about the process, is that in England there were a lot of searches that were very broad. So they used to have something called like a king's warrant and people would just come and they would search. And the law in England, as it developed, they required something like particularity. So the warrant requirement in the Fourth Amendment was put in the Fourth Amendment to ensure that when government actors were coming and they were searching someone's house, they did not have broad discretion to search any and everywhere, was to protect the public from that overreach.

SPEAKER_01And that theme is what led to the adoption of each of these amendments. So one of the concerns that was present in the Constitutional Convention is that they had a lot of states who were reluctant to join into this federal government because they were concerned about this overreach potentially continuing. So when we talk about the Fourth Amendment, they're concerned about general warrants. They're concerned that the King's warrant, people would come in and they would search their property without any kind of restrictions. In the Fifth and Sixth Amendment, it's a lot of the trial rights.

SPEAKER_01So what's to prevent the government from just trying people without any kind of public process? And if you're tried in private, there's not really any accountability. If you are brought into a place and a confession is beat out of you, then your confession might not be a good confession. So these are the types of things that had been practiced historically. So the people, the states, when they were seeking input from the people within the states, these were a lot of things that were coming up in those discussions because of the abuses that they had seen.

SPEAKER_01And sometimes even when the laws in England were practiced properly, when they were practiced in the Americas, they were not adhered to. So there was a fear that the government would essentially engage in this kind of overreach or processes that might undermine the right of the people.

SPEAKER_03That makes a lot of sense given we hear a lot about on the show the concerns that Madison and others are debating. They're going back and forth on, well, how is this going to work with this very powerful federal government? Are states going to be still able to make their own laws? How are those two entities, state versus federal, going to get along? So it makes sense that these amendments are reflecting that concern of a strong federal government. And as I mentioned earlier, these rights are not static.

SPEAKER_03They have changed over time based on the context of what's happening in the United States over the centuries. The Supreme Court also plays a major role in interpreting these rights over time. Are there certain Supreme Court decisions that have affected how these rights are applied today? Any ones that you think are particularly important to pay attention to?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I'm going to try to highlight maybe one key decision for each amendment. So I think for the Fourth Amendment, I would probably go with Katz versus the United States. That opinion is one of the opinions we talked about last time I was on the podcast. And that opinion interprets what constitutes a reasonable expectation of privacy for the first time in the 20th century before a person didn't have a reasonable expectation of privacy right, before a government actor only was considered to have searched if they committed a physical trespass on a person's property.

SPEAKER_01And there was a Supreme Court opinion that had upheld a wiretap because the wiretap did not constitute a physical trespass, and they were able to obtain statements from that individual without violating the constitution. In Katz, there was no physical trespass, but there was an expectation of privacy that Mr. Katz had in his telephone calls. He went into a telephone booth, he shut the door, and he was trying to have a private conversation. And the government placed a listening device on the outside of that booth. So the government said, we didn't commit a physical trespass.

SPEAKER_01We haven't done anything wrong under the Fourth Amendment. But the Supreme Court comes in and says, no, what Mr. Katz sought to exclude were the contents of his conversation. That's why he went into the booth and he has a reasonable expectation of privacy and the things that he sought to conceal from the public. Now, what he knowingly exposed to the public, that's a different question. I think there are some hypotheticals out there about, well, if they read Mr. Katz's lips, you know, they could see his lips. They weren't doing anything wrong by looking at what he knowingly exposed. But Katz just ends up being such an important decision for interpreting when you have an objectively reasonable expectation of privacy that the government can intrude upon that.

SPEAKER_01So it did add some protection, maybe a little bit more teeth to the Fourth Amendment. For the Fifth Amendment, I think probably the most notable case is Miranda versus Arizona. Most people are familiar with Miranda warnings or have heard about Miranda in a TV show. And most people can recite the Miranda warnings. Not a lot of people know about the history of that case, but Miranda versus Arizona is discussing that part of the Fifth Amendment that protects people against self-incrimination.

SPEAKER_01So you can't be compelled to testify against yourself. And what Miranda did was it was in this time where there were a lot of court opinions that looked on a case-by-case basis and determined, okay, did the government actors do enough to compel this person to testify against themselves? For example, did they beat the person? And then after beating them, they confessed. That would be a coerced confession. So there were opinions where people were interrogated for several hours or denied food or water.

SPEAKER_01And those types of cases kept coming before the court. So in a somewhat controversial opinion, I will say, some justices don't think Miranda is rooted in the Fifth Amendment and should not be a good law. The Warren Court, Justice Warren, who wrote the opinion, said, okay, whenever we have people in these types of scenarios, custodial interrogation, there needs to be some protections for those individuals before they are asked to speak against themselves in a way that would incriminate themselves.

SPEAKER_01So that's where those warnings came from. And that's where the court specifically stated they have to be advised that they have a right to counsel, that if they can't afford counsel, that one would be appointed to them, that they have the right to remain silent, and that anything that they say can be used against them. So that's like a really big decision for the Fifth Amendment.

SPEAKER_03And we think about that. I'm hearing all of the crime shows that I've ever watched in my head as the detective arrests the person and reads those warnings. And to me, it's always like, oh, now I know this guy's going to be prosecuted or they're going to go to the jail with them. But it's rooted in this idea of, hey, actually, the government needs to be ensuring that there's a level of protection for people so that they aren't confessing, so that they do know their rights as they're in this situation.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And it ends up being an opinion, I think, that law enforcement even really appreciates because they know that if they go through the warnings, that they have assured the person of everything that they need to know. I think from the community standpoint, Miranda warnings actually happen really fast. And a lot of people don't even realize when they happen and they'll just start talking. So you have to really, as a citizen, be aware that you do have that right to remain silent and it can't be used against you. So when an officer asks, Do you want to speak to me? And you know you're in an interrogation, you have the absolute right to say, No, I have nothing to say.

SPEAKER_01I'm invoking my right to remain silent.

SPEAKER_03What Supreme Court case would you choose for the Sixth Amendment?

SPEAKER_01I think for the Sixth Amendment, I would choose Gideon versus Wayne Wright. And it could be because I am a public defender that I had chosen that case. But Mr. Gideon, Clarence Gideon, was an individual who was brought to court and he could not afford counsel for his defense. He put on his case the best that he could, but no counsel was appointed to him. So he wrote his own petition to the United States Supreme Court, arguing that he should have been entitled to counsel, even though he couldn't afford to pay for counsel himself.

SPEAKER_01And the Supreme Court says, based on the Sixth Amendment, that's absolutely a right that's available to you. So when a person is faced with a criminal charge that involves jail time, then a public defender can be appointed to them at no cost to them for the proceedings. They might have to pay costs on the back end if they're convicted, but they don't have to put up the money to hire the attorney first. They will be able to have the same protections of counsel that other people who could afford counsel have.

SPEAKER_03Kendra, I love these examples that you've chosen. These are clearly really monumental cases. And it makes me think about how far we have come since the Bill of Rights was ratified in 1791. You know, these rights, this right to remain silent when you're being arrested, or the right to have counsel, even if you can't afford an attorney, it's so essential to the American fabric and the fact that these are rights that have evolved from the original amendments, I think is really powerful.

SPEAKER_03And so along that thought line, I think a lot of our knowledge as Americans does come from some of these television shows or even crime novels. How accurate is all of that? Are we actually getting a good representation of how our system works? I think it depends on the show.

SPEAKER_01Maybe. So some of some things are exaggerated.

SPEAKER_00I will say that is in my family, I everybody loves watching crime dramas, but I am notoriously, I'm notorious for being like, I don't, you know, want to watch the the crime drama because I am objecting in my head to things that are coming into evidence. I'm looking at police officers, like smacking somebody up and saying, oh my gosh, that would never happen. They could never get that confession in.

SPEAKER_01So sometimes it is a little bit exaggerated, I think, for the drama of it all. And I think too, sometimes, for example, they have a lot of people who confess and the TV shows pretty quickly, like, you know, after all the pressures put on them, they just choose to confess. But a lot of people do invoke their right to remain silent. And then, of course, sometimes with the shows, maybe they'll comment on something in a trial that they're not technically allowed to comment on in real life. But I do think that they do a lot of it for the drama aspect of it to draw people in.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. So when we see scenes of people being taken into custody, legally, under the Fifth Amendment, officers are supposed to read the Miranda warning. What happens if officers don't read that Miranda warning? And what happens if a person does decide to speak after they've been given that warning?

SPEAKER_01One of the things in a criminal trial is that your statements can be used against you. They're in the warning so that people are aware that anything that you say to the officers, it can be used in a trial against you. So I'll start with what happens if you do decide to speak to law enforcement. So if they read you your warnings, then you have the opportunity to waive your right to remain silent. In the Miranda decision, it just has to be a knowing and voluntary waiver. So if a law enforcement officer is like holding a gun to your head and saying, you need to waive your rights, then obviously if you waive your rights and talk after that, that still wouldn't come in, even though they've read the warnings, right?

SPEAKER_01Because then that's still coerced. It has to be knowing, meaning you have to be aware of them. So they have to read the rights correctly. It doesn't have to be word for word, but enough so that you're advised. But if you choose to do that and you waive your rights, then the responses to any questions that law enforcement asks you, that can be used against you in a trial. So if you are telling a story about what happened, your version of the story, and you later recant that version or change that version, that's something that can be used against you.

SPEAKER_01Any admissions can be used against you in a trial for the crime that you're charged with. The other aspect of it is if you do choose to invoke the right to remain silent, then obviously the fact that you invoked your right to remain silent can't be used against you because you absolutely have that right to remain silent.

SPEAKER_03And Kendra, this is underscoring the importance of the legal profession itself. There's a lot of nuance and complexity to these amendments and how they've been interpreted over time. And we've been talking about these instances of what if a crime is committed or this or that. But why should all of us, all of us living here in the United States, be concerned about these amendments? Why are they important to all of us, whether or not we're involved in a crime or anything to that degree?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think they're important from a citizen standpoint because politics is always very difficult. Who's in office can change from one administration to another. And as a citizen, regardless of who's in office or who's in power, you want to know that there is something undergirding what those officials are doing that they have to abide by. And I think for any citizen, just knowing that you have a right to not have your home searched and the government just come in and search your home for no reason, that is something that's very important to every citizen, not just a citizen who might be accused of doing something wrong.

SPEAKER_01But even I think in recent media, we've seen people's houses maybe wrongfully searched by accident, right? But imagine if there was no process, they just could do whatever they wanted. That would be very scary, I think, for a lot of citizens. I think also it would be it would be interesting to live in a society where you had to testify against yourself or you had to incriminate yourself and you had to waive every defense that you could ever have to a crime. So I think that these protections are important for all of society because there was a time in our society where particularly African Americans were not being treated the same way.

SPEAKER_01There were lynchings and things like that happening in the South. And it's really interesting. Some of these cases that we see, they helped prevent some brutality that would have led to wrongful convictions. So having these protections, I think, are very important because it does, it undergirds the government, it keeps them accountable. And when the law is followed and it's correctly interpreted, then it can protect even the minorities in society.

SPEAKER_03As we wrap up our conversation, Kendra, what do you see on the horizon for these three amendments shaping our experiences as Americans moving forward?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think technology really does create challenges for these amendments and how much as a society we have to wrestle with the balance between desiring technology to advance in a way that can be helpful for things. For example, solving crimes. People want crimes to be solved. If you are a victim of a crime or you've had a family member who was a victim of a crime, you want those types of things to be solved. But at the same time, like anytime you yield too much, then it can affect not just the case that you're involved in, but every other person's rights moving forward.

SPEAKER_01I think for the Fourth Amendment, definitely with drone technology and mass surveillance, that is probably the biggest challenge to the Fourth Amendment right now. Um, how much is the government going to be allowed to surveil? It's potentially endless. I think with the Sixth Amendment, probably the most interesting thing that could shift is, at least in the criminal space, the right to confront and cross-examine witnesses against you. With the digital era, does that mean that you still get to have a physical person?

SPEAKER_01Will we be in trials online? Will we be doing AI trials? Will that be okay? Or will that violate our Sixth Amendment right to confront and cross-examine witnesses against us? I think for the Fifth Amendment, that one also encompasses obviously due process. So there could be due process arguments even with the advancement of technology as to whether someone's given proper due process. So just a lot. I think honestly, as we advance in society, the biggest challenges that I've seen before the court have involved this interplay between technological advancements and what do these amendments mean in our time, given that our society has advanced so much.

SPEAKER_03You've given us a lot to think about in terms of how much purview should the federal government have and where is the boundary for our own personal rights. So it's that question of yes, societal good, but we also have to have our own individual liberties. And I know that's a question that James Madison and others struggled with, but as you mentioned, this is a question that is still relevant today, that we're still asking ourselves, especially as we have this new technological age, this AI. And it'll be interesting to see how it continues to shape kind of the criminal landscape.

SPEAKER_03So thank you so much for shedding light on all of this and joining us today for this really enlightening conversation.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for having me. I enjoy having these conversations. So it's a pleasure to be here.

SPEAKER_03And thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you'll subscribe and share the show with your family and friends. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode