Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

The Constitution Before the Constitution with Dr. Zachary Deibel

May 20, 202636 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Before the Declaration of Independence, before the Constitutional Convention, colonists were already debating the meaning of a constitution - and it didn't look anything like the document we know today. Dr. Zachary Deibel, assistant professor of history at the Virginia Military Institute, joins Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey at Montpelier to trace the constitutional ideas that shaped the American Revolution. Drawing on the writings of John Dickinson, the legacy of the Glorious Revolution, and the colonial charters that defined the relationship between the King and his American subjects, Deibel unpacks why the dispute with Britain wasn't simply about taxes - it was a fundamental disagreement over the meaning of liberty itself. He also explores a theme that resonates well beyond the 18th century: when two sides decide there is nothing left to learn from each other, that's when the shooting starts. This episode is supported in part by the Virginia Law Foundation.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

announcerWelcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H.

announcerSmith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

Katie Crawford-LackeyHello and welcome back to Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, with James Madison's Montpelier. In this episode, we're going to rewind the clock back to the days before the American Revolution and just after the French and Indian War. Now, this conflict between Britain and France, and France's indigenous allies, fought between 1754 and 1763, was essentially about control over North America.

Katie Crawford-LackeyBritain, trying to protect its territory, the colonies, ultimately wins, but victory comes at a cost. Britain's national debt skyrocketed. To address this, Parliament passed new taxes on the colonists, like the infamous Stamp Act, arguing that the colonies should help pay for their own protection. As we know now, some of the colonists were outraged by this. But what I think is particularly fascinating is the logic they used to challenge Britain's authority, not just economically, but politically and constitutionally.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThey weren't simply angry about paying a tax. They were debating the very nature of law, government, and rights. Questions about representation, authority, and the meaning of constitution were at the heart of their arguments. And these debates would help shape the emerging American identity. So today we're diving into these constitutional ideas with the help of our guest, Dr. Zachary Dybel, who is an assistant professor of history at the Virginia Military Institute.

Katie Crawford-LackeyHe teaches courses on the United States history, the American Revolution, and the Atlantic world. He also served as a secondary social studies school teacher for eight years before earning his doctorate in history at Binghamton University. His research explores the intertwined histories of learning and politics in 18th century America. Zach, it's wonderful to have you in the studio with us today. Welcome.

Dr. Zachary DeibelThank you so much. It's it's awesome to be here. I'm really excited for this conversation.

Katie Crawford-LackeyI feel like those folks who have a background in both teaching, K through 12 students and at the college level really have kind of an extra skill in being able to talk with the public. So again, just really excited to have you here talking about this subject, which we haven't really covered on any of our episodes in the past. So, Zach, you uh prepared me leaning up to this conversation. There was all these great readings I looked over, and you introduced me to the words of John Dickinson. Now, Dickinson, he's eventually going to be involved in the American Revolution.

Katie Crawford-LackeyBut before all of that, he is a Pennsylvania lawyer who writes publicly about growing frustrations in the colonies. He writes, Americans' happiness is founded on their constitution. Their security, liberty, and prosperity would each be prompted by preserving that constitution in unabated vigor throughout every part. So I want to pause here because he's writing that in 1768. The drafting of the United States Constitution doesn't happen for almost another 20 years.

Katie Crawford-LackeySo what exactly is he talking about? I mean, we haven't had the revolution yet, it hasn't started. So when he's saying constitution, what does he mean? What's he referring to?

Dr. Zachary DeibelIt's a great question. I think one of the misconceptions that we tend to have about constitution as a concept is we define it in the terms of our constitution, right? We think that constitution means the United States Constitution. But for an English person or a North American colonist in British North America, they would have thought of the Constitution less as a document and more as an arrangement. So a constitution was, if you think about the root of the word, right, it constitutes a society.

Dr. Zachary DeibelIt is helping to structure the arrangements, the relationships, the dynamics of a society. And for a guy like Dickinson, his understanding of the constitution that governs his society draws on a lot of different influences, both historic and contemporary. And especially for the English, it's hard to understand their ideas about constitutionalism without going back to the 17th century, right? And the English Revolution, the Glorious Revolution, the settlement after the restoration of this kind of big question about the balance of power in England, right?

Dr. Zachary DeibelIf we think about the English Civil War going all the way through to the English Revolution and the Glorious Revolution, they're trying to balance who has power within that political arrangement. So when you have parliament, the king, the courts, the common law, local authorities, how does that arrangement work? And it's not really until 1689 that the English sort that out because they're recovering from an era of Stuart monarchs, so the Stuart dynasty or the Stuart family, who were constantly trying to assert more authority as the monarch with each passing Stuart king, right?

Dr. Zachary DeibelSo Charles I famously refuses to call parliament in the 1620s, leading to the English Civil War against Oliver Cromwell and the parliamentarians. But the idea was that by the time you get to 1689 and James II, who's the last kind of Stuart monarch, is sort of forced out of power by William of Orange and the parliamentary supporters of the Orange faction, what they end up doing is they say, look, we have to put this issue to bed because the king and parliament will always be fighting each other for power if we don't sort out where that power lies.

Dr. Zachary DeibelSo to bring it back to North America, Dickinson is writing, you know, 70 years, 80 years after this settlement, but the Glorious Revolution settled this concept that it's not subjecthood to an absolute monarch that defines someone who is English. What defines them is that their political arrangement is dictated by a constitution that governs the way their society is set up. It involves the kind of inherited common law, it involves the major documents of British political history, so things like Magna Carta, things like the Petition of Right, the English Bill of Rights that comes out of the Glorious Revolution.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd it's that sort of constitutional sensibility that I think Dickinson is appealing to when he's writing in the 1760s, because when Parliament starts to uh assert itself as having more authority than that settlement had previously ascribed to them for the colonies, that's when the colonists start to say, well, wait a minute, we thought we lived in this one arrangement, and now you guys are trying to set up this other arrangement that goes beyond what we had originally agreed to.

Katie Crawford-LackeyI find this context very helpful because in my head, at least, I often think about, you know, okay, the colonists at this point in time, 1760s, 1770s, they're thinking all of these things, being influenced by like great writers and philosophers. However, they are living in this other context of the British crown and what's happening overseas, and their expectations are being kind of guided by that. And it sounds like there's, you know, over the centuries, this power struggle with the monarchy.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd so the, I guess, expectations that the colonists have in this kind of constitutional arrangement that you referenced is changing or shifting. At this point in time in the mid-1700s, what is the expectation that colonists have about their rights or how, you know, the relationship between the colonies and the crown?

Dr. Zachary DeibelAaron Powell My answer would would probably depend on when in the 1700s we're talking about, because I think it it changes over time. And it changed, and the other kind of question I would ask is where, right? So the understanding of some of these relationships varies in the different colonies. Another kind of understanding we have that, or something we know that helps contextualize the way we think about this is that the individual colonies have very different histories and different relationships with this constitutionalism. So if you think about a place like Virginia, Virginia has a long attachment to the Anglican Church.

Dr. Zachary DeibelIt has a long attachment to a more hierarchical arrangement with the colonial kind of creation of the colony itself. Whereas if you look at a colony like Massachusetts, they have a long history of being a separatist colony, where you have the Puritans and the Pilgrims kind of forming the con forming the Plymouth Colony and Massachusetts Bay in sort of a dissenting opposition to the 17th century religious structure of British rule. So what that means is that by the time we get to the mid-1700s, when, as you in your preface where you talked about the Seven Years' War, when Britain comes out of the war and even before they're finished with fighting the war, they're very concerned about making sure that the colonies as a whole understand the arrangement that is going to exist after the defeat of France.

Dr. Zachary DeibelThey're going to be incorporating territories like French Canada. They're going to be incorporating formerly Spanish territories, they're going to be having to figure out how that trade network is going to work with their West Indies colonies. And so for the British, the priority is trying to teach the colonies in a way how they fit in that arrangement. But as I said, each of the colonies have their own histories, their own understandings of where they fit. And one of the things a lot of these colonies invoke when they start to get upset with the new constitutional expectations of the 1760s is the colonial charters, right?

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd the idea that the king charters colonies throughout the restoration period, even some before, but you know, the restoration period and then into the early 1700s, the colonies all start to acquire these royal charters, which means the king himself is kind of giving approval for this colony to exist. Before the Glorious Revolution, Parliament wasn't really involved in that. I mean, parliament played a role in regulating trade, but the charter is more historic than that relationship. And so when Parliament passes things like the Stamp Act or the Currency Act or the Sugar Act, those laws, some of the colonists are fine with it because they say, well, it just has to do with regulating trade.

Dr. Zachary DeibelBut others start to be wary because they say, well, our relationship is we have our own colonial legislature, we have our own colonial political system, and all of that is acting under the prerogative of the king. Why do we have to listen to anything parliament is directing us? Because they're not really part of this conversation in a way, right? It's the historic relationship of the colonies ties itself to the king, which is why when we get to the arguments over independence, you know, if you read what the colonists are writing throughout the 1760s, early 1770s, all of their complaints are lodged against the ministers, right?

Dr. Zachary DeibelSo people like evil George Grenville and the Stamp Act or Parliament. But they never really accuse the king. In fact, a lot of times they're writing asking the king to intervene on their behalf. They're saying, you know, hey, King George III, save us from these corrupt ministers who are trying to pollute the constitutional relationship we've had for so long. And once they realize the king is unwilling to do that, that's kind of the last recourse they have. And that's why they have to turn to independence in their minds, right? Because the king is the protector of those colonial charters.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd if he's not willing to stand up, then no one is. And so I think for the colonists, it's working through the constitutional system of as they protest some of these policies.

Katie Crawford-LackeySo knowing that, Zach, that some folks, some colonists are actually looking towards the king to protect them from what they see as parliament or these ministers making decisions or levying taxes that they don't think they're part of the conversation, as you said. Where do ideas like liberty, security, and prosperity start coming into this conversation when we think about the lead up to the American Revolution?

Dr. Zachary DeibelI think one dynamic I try to reiterate to my students is if you want to know when Americans are most patriotically British, right? If when is it that colonists in North America are most bought into the British system? It's really like 1763, right? At the end of the Seven Years' War, Britain is coming out, they have beaten Catholic and absolute monarchy France, right? They've secured the empire, the rule of Britannia is, you know, everybody's singing it in the concert halls and things like that. And part of the reason why they are so gung-ho about being British in British North America is because they believe that they have a type of liberty that no one else has.

Dr. Zachary DeibelEnglish liberty is the thing that binds the Constitution together. If this idea of an English Constitution is all these formal and informal, written and unwritten dynamics at work that constitute the arrangement, it's liberty that is the glue holding it all together. And for someone like John Dickinson, he is or or Benjamin Franklin or any of the founders, the reason they are so excited about the prospect of what lies ahead for the British Empire is because they know their liberties are secured by this constitution.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd yet, the very first measures of reform to govern that empire immediately throw into question what they thought they understood liberty to be. So for colonists, they start to say, well, wait a minute, I thought having English liberty meant that I am free in the context of my colonial society, I have representation in my colonial legislature, I have certain rights when it comes to the judicial system, I have freedom of commerce, I have all these kind of things that are protected by English constitutionalism.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd in the immediate aftermath of the Seven Years' War, you have the proclamation line limiting their settlement, you have the Stamp Act limiting their access to printed materials based on a stamp and really what amounts to censorship, different trade regulations that are going to impede their ability to free trade as they were hoping for. And so what becomes clear, you know, I've noticed in the research that I've done, is that by the time you get to the Stamp Act crisis and the late 1760s when Dickinson is writing this letters from a farmer, the colonists are coming to the realization that they have a very different understanding of liberty than what the British government believes liberty to mean.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd the British are realizing the same thing. And it's that disconnect over how people are learning about their liberties that I think leads to some of the intractable disputes that are going to give way to, well, if we have this understanding and you have this understanding, there's nothing left for us to argue about. And it just becomes now a movement for political separation.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThis kind of calls to mind for me the differences in generations as well. You know, at the start of the American Revolution, Benjamin Franklin, for example, he's 70 years old versus someone like James Madison who is 25. So there's definitely a generational difference there. And I'm assuming Ben Franklin is experiencing a very different kind of colonial America than James Madison, what he grew up in. And, you know, we know these men were thinking about what does liberty mean?

Katie Crawford-LackeyBut your explanation really shines light on why that question became so important during this time period. It's this difference in, I guess, definition of what liberty meant given by the British Crown or the Parliament versus what colonists think their liberty is. And so it sounds like this period of curtailment. Again, you mentioned kind of the settlement line, paper due to the Stamp Act or other taxes. Is that what leads to the American Revolution? Is that kind of the catalyst for the conflict that arises?

Dr. Zachary DeibelYeah, I mean, I think that the causes of the American Revolution will be an evergreen scholarly debate for many years to come. I think what I'm noticing is I think part of one one of the causes is this uh disconnect about what it means to have freedom in a society defined by those freedoms. And that debate that we see colonists like Franklin or Madison or Dickinson having is just as evergreen as the revolution itself, right?

Dr. Zachary DeibelI mean, we still have those arguments today. And I think if we're going to try to see some of the revolution from a vantage point that we can understand, it's that they don't have it all figured out, right? I mean, uh John Dickinson, a lot of what I have been thinking about, Dickinson in particular, comes from Jane Calvert's new biography of Dickinson, which is a fantastic uh book. Everybody should check it out, Penman of the Revolution. But Dickinson is one of these examples, much like Franklin, who they're really testing ideas. They're they're experimental.

Dr. Zachary DeibelI mean, Franklin and the Albany Plan of Union, even before the Seven Years' War, is a big experiment. Like he is trying to figure out is there a way to unite the colonies and some of our indigenous allies under this definition, right? And again, this is a very optimistic reading. I'm sure we can also read the ways these people are also trying to preserve their own self-interest and things like that. But I also think if we're going to look for causes of the revolution, sorting out the meaning of liberty is a really big piece of a lot of these people's understandings of why they're starting to resist and what's motivating them to go protest in the streets.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd I think that's an important piece if we want to understand, you know, it's one thing for Dickinson or Franklin to be writing these things and pamphlets. It's another thing to get a bunch of people to sign up for an army that's going to fight against the British. And so a lot of their efforts are not just about how do I understand liberty, but how am I going to communicate this and really teach it to the rest of the American population that this is happening and we need to be guardians of our own liberties. And in the same process, they have to negotiate with that audience as well. So when they have protesters against the Stamp Act and the Sons of Liberty have to respond to what the mob is telling them, just as much as they can prescribe some of this to the people themselves.

Dr. Zachary DeibelYou know, I see it as part of this dialogue and conversation that isn't necessarily, you know, they don't just sit down in August of 1765 and say, let's start a revolution, guys. It's a long discursive process, this argument and discussion. And it's why a lot of them aren't their goal is not separation at the beginning. I mean, we think the revolution is this thing that's coming, right? It's this looming over the edge, but in 1768, they don't know that, right? Dickinson doesn't know that the revolution's going to happen. And in fact, he's a great example of someone who really is very much so committed to trying to preserve ties to Britain as long as he can.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd Franklin's the same way. So, I mean, yes, there are, you know, there are turning points for every all of the different founders, but one of the things when I teach the American Revolution class, I always encourage students when we learn about the revolution, we tend to look forward, right? We stand in 1765 and we look forward to 76. Well, I want to encourage us to, as we move through that timeline, don't forget to look backward too. That when you get to 68 or 74, when the first Continental Congress meets, they're looking at the moments that they've experienced. They can't look ahead.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd so that's where this understanding of English constitutionalism is constantly in their conversation, in their dialogue, because as you said, the federal constitution isn't coming for another 20 years. So they don't know that that's on the horizon. It's more of a conversation of, well, how did we get here and how are we going to cope with the moment in front of us? And so that's why I think a lot of these debates are recurrent, they're dynamic, right? Their opinions change, there's a lot of debate and discourse. And it's not just one kind of straight line to the declaration.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThis is something that comes to my mind quite frequently when I'm, you know, engaging in history. It's that the American Revolution is not inevitable. And I think sometimes we look back and we're like, oh, Civil War, that was inevitable, or this event or that event. But it's not. And there's these really key moments that lead up to it. But to your point, the American Revolution is kind of the culmination of all of these moments, events, all these things from the past. And when we think about that moment of conflict and everything that happens before, I'm assuming that there was not just this conversation about what does liberty mean, which as you referenced, that's while we hear from people like Ben Franklin, James Madison, and so on, we hear their thoughts.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThis is something that's happening across different ages, ethnicities, even though we don't have record of some folks and what they were thinking about it, geography, different colonies. So there's a lot that has to happen to get to this point. But what does the thought process look like in terms of balancing liberty and trying to define what it means for the colonies with practical? Concerns about stability and security?

Dr. Zachary DeibelYeah, it's a great question. I think for the revolutionaries, that balance becomes more important in certain moments than in others, right? So when they're trying to get people in the streets to protest the Stamp Act, security isn't their primary concern, right? But when they're trying to set up a continental army and they need people to follow orders and answer militia musters and set up a draft into the Continental Army, security and maybe curtailing some liberties becomes more important.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd I think that dynamism is recurrent throughout the revolution. And then of course, when we get to the post-revolutionary period, when we get to the 1780s, security becomes the big concern of the day. I mean, the Shaysites in Massachusetts or the lack of security and fear that Britain's just going to invade again and we don't have a federal government strong enough to defend the United States. That's where some of the curtailing of those liberties takes place in the form of a national constitution, right? They they see the revolution's excesses have gone too far.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAt least that's that's one interpretation. But I also think that they are very mindful of that balance. It's almost clear that they know that there will never be a perfect balance between liberty and security, right? You can't have complete liberty, you can't have complete security. And they draw a lot of their thinking from what they're seeing around them. So one of the great indicators of this is if you look at the grievances in the Declaration of Independence. So the we we fondly remember the poetic text of the Declaration, but the grievances are really important to kind of getting inside the heads of colonists as they're experiencing the day-to-day.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd actually, my former PhD advisor, Rob Parkinson, has a new book coming out about the grievances. Um, that's fantastic. But what they show us is that the colonists are targeting specific actions that they see the British government having taken that infringed on their liberties in a way that also infringed on their security. So one of the examples, the third grievance, the famous grievance around representation, right? This is where we get the idea of no taxation without representation, right? Well, it was actually a grievance more about the fact that Parliament had stopped the colonies from adding representatives to their colonial legislatures as they expanded westward.

Dr. Zachary DeibelSo they had passed the proclamation line in 1763 to stop colonies from moving westward and potentially getting into conflicts with Native Americans. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

Katie Crawford-LackeyBecause they had just fought this big war where they're trying to protect the colonists from that. Trevor Burrus, Jr.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd as you rightly pointed out, things like the Stamp Act, the revenue was meant specifically to pay for protection of the colonies. It's a big I think you you can probably find USS3 textbooks that say, well, you know, they wanted the Americans to pay off the debt. And it's like, actually, that isn't at all what that tax was for. The tax was specifically for protecting the colonies from Native Americans, from the French, from a future war. So that was one big priority, but they also prevented each individual colony from when they would expand westward and establish, say, a new county or a new town. Typically, if that county established enough population, then they would get representation in their colonial legislature.

Dr. Zachary DeibelBut to discourage that westward settlement, Parliament was saying, actually, you can settle if you want, but you're not going to get any more representatives in your assembly. And our the British government appointee, the governor of the colony and his governor's council, they didn't want to have to work with this like a huge colonial legislature. And the complexities of that, I pointed out just to say when you say something like the rallying cry of no taxation without representation, it's not just about the fact that they don't have a say in parliament. It's about the way parliament views the idea of representation, is increasingly at odds with the way colonists themselves view it.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd they think representation is the way we express our freedom, we express our interest in government, the way we hold government accountable. It's also the way we protect ourselves. It's an instrument of security because if the government's doing something we don't want, then we have representatives to help us take recourse. And so when parliament kind of infringes on that liberty or restricts that liberty or tries to change it in a way that the colonists are really uncomfortable with, it shows us that they see any threat to liberty as also a threat to their security, that they those two things are interrelated with one another.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd so when they list these grievances, it's part of that balance that they're objecting to. I mean, in a more kind of visceral example, Jefferson's famous grievance outlining how the British government is turning Native Americans, enslaved persons, and foreign mercenaries, specifically like Hessian mercenaries who have arrived in North America, it's a very strong statement that Jefferson makes about there's an anxiety that the king is actually siding with all the people who used to be America's enemies, whether it's the Native American frontier nations who now the British are enlisting to fight against the rebelling colonists, the German states that reflect some of the European politics of the day that the North American colonists don't really care about.

Dr. Zachary DeibelBut then they're also inciting insurrections among enslaved people to try to get them to rise up against colonial enslavers. And we see this with Dunmore's proclamation in Virginia in 1775. And I guess what I point to that grievance as well to show those are freedoms and liberties that the colonists have particularly come to understand, that they get protection from Native Americans, that they have a liberty to enslave, that they have these are these are parts of their colonial society that have been built up over the generations. And when the king refuses to preserve those things, it's a bridge too far to their security.

Dr. Zachary DeibelThey're afraid for the security of their estates if the people they enslave can join an armed force to fight against them. And so I think the grievances are a really good window into what Americans are thinking at the moment, at least the Americans who are involved in the declaration, what they're thinking about this meaning of liberty and security and what they value, what they balance, what they want to see addressed in the moment of the revolution.

Katie Crawford-LackeySo, Zach, you just brought up like a million more questions that I want to ask you. However, we are towards the end of our program. I might have to have you back on the podcast so we can explore further. But as we wrap up, there is kind of one pressing thought because the way that you're laying out this history, you see the mindset behind Britain and why they're taking the action that they're taking. You also see the colonists and you better understand why they're responding the way that they are. And I kind of see the logic behind why Britain is levying these taxes.

Katie Crawford-LackeyIt makes sense. They're trying to protect the colonists. The whole no taxation without representation, it kind of loses some of that, like, you know, patriotic vigor when you think about, well, you know, folks aren't supposed to be settling beyond a certain boundary line, and they are. So again, it just helps you better understand history and why things are playing out, why they're making the decisions they're making. Why is it important to approach history in this way? How does it help us understand not just American history at this point, but how does it also inform our present?

Dr. Zachary DeibelYou know, one of the things that I've seen a lot of my work tries to think about how these conversations are debates about ideas, sure, but they're also debates about how to get those ideas to the people. In other words, how to teach people and to educate them on your position. So for the British, it's really important that we instruct Americans on how they can access their liberties in a productive way in a new empire that's much more expanded than it was before, that has a lot of problems to sort out, and we need them to understand why this system has to work a certain way.

Dr. Zachary DeibelFor the Americans, they're almost approaching it in the exact same way by saying we really need to teach people about why these fundamental liberties and these natural rights are so important to the way the colonial societies have worked since the 17th century. If we let them go, if we give up some of these freedoms, well then we aren't really Britons anymore. We aren't entitled to those English liberties anymore. We're just vassals of the English state at that point. And so what I see in this story is two very different visions.

Dr. Zachary DeibelNeither vision is particularly wrong, right? I think sometimes we have a tendency to want to say one side was right, one side was wrong, and that's the end all be all. I don't necessarily think that the British are wrong in suggesting that the way that English liberty works plays out the way they're trying to teach the Americans. No, you don't get the same level of representation, but that's okay because colonies just can't, right? It won't work that way. And the British aren't wrong in presenting that thesis. But I also think the American colonists aren't wrong to suggest these are liberties and norms that they have lived by for generations.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd I think maybe one of the lessons to take away is that, especially in the context of an educational dialogue, when two sides that have very different opinions decide they are no longer willing to learn from each other, that's when the shooting starts for the American Revolution. That's when we reach that impasse where two different groups just simply can't converse anymore because they feel like the other side is completely unwilling to learn anything from their position. And I think in a time when we have such intense polarization, we have a lot of discord over even the meaning of the founding in a lot of ways, we should take a lesson from some of the revolutionary moments where this educational impasse can have really damaging effects to a society.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd as much as the colonists are willing to go along with it for the purposes of the revolution, a lot of them later in their life reflect on this. And you can see some of the changes. You know, I think of the very famous curate Montpelier, you guys have a sign, I just walked by it today, of the very famous letter that James Madison writes in 1822 to William Barry about education. And, you know, he's he has that great quote about needing to arm ourselves with knowledge and if we want to be our own governors, right? But in that letter, he also says that the great aspiration of a free people should be to understand that liberty and learning go hand in hand.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd those two things have to be balanced with each other, they have to be appreciated along with each other, and that if you want to prioritize liberty, you also have to be willing to learn, whether it's from people who agree with you or disagree with you. And I just think the fact that Madison here in 1822, decades after he's involved in all these revolutionary moments, is able to reflect on that and understand. I like to think that maybe he's reflecting on the fact that sometimes there are moments where it's better to learn from others and not to just assume that there's nothing you can learn from them and show that willingness and that openness to the other side.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAnd maybe, maybe not. Maybe in 1822, Madison would say, no, the British were wrong. But I like to think that maybe in his older age, he's starting to look back and say, you know, that we always have something to learn.

Katie Crawford-LackeyI think that's one of the most intriguing aspects about Madison is that some scholars criticize him for changing his mind on things. But I think that is such an asset that he is willing to hold strong in his opinions because he's done his research. He's this really profound intellectual person. However, he is not above listening to somebody else's ideas and changing his mind. And your conversation today about the American Revolution, for example, it's not British were wrong, colonies were right, or vice versa.

Katie Crawford-LackeyThere is so much complexity interweaved all throughout. And it's this complexity and nuance that informs the present. It informs all those little moments, all those decisions. And this really key point that you touch on is a theme we haven't fully, I would say, explored in the podcast before the idea that liberty and learning go hand in hand. And in order to have liberty, you have to have learning. And that means listening and understanding and being open. And that is something I see less of.

Katie Crawford-LackeyI think we all need a little bit more of that listening because we don't want to get to that impasse point where we think we have nothing to learn from someone else or another group or whoever it may be. So thank you for that message. I think it's very profound.

Dr. Zachary DeibelAbsolutely. Don't thank me. It's James Madison, right? But yeah, I think there's always stuff to learn from the founding. And I think that this complexity that you're pointing to and the contingency of the past is something that we should remind ourselves of in the present because things are just as complicated and contingent now as they were then.

Katie Crawford-LackeyWell, thank you so much, Dr. Zachary Dybel, for being here at Montpelier with us today.

Dr. Zachary DeibelGreat conversation. I appreciate you guys having me.

Katie Crawford-LackeyAnd thank you to all of our listeners. I hope you enjoyed this show. Please share it with your friends and family. And join us again in two weeks as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode