Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Consider the Constitution

Consider the Constitution artwork

The Original Constitution

Sep 20, 202338 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of Consider the Constitution, we’re taking a deep dive into the sections or articles of the Constitution - the document as it was signed on September 17, 1787. Our special guest is Dr. Jay Cost, the Gerald R. Ford nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), where he focuses on elections, politics, and public opinion. He has published several books about James Madison and the founding era, and his next book, Democracy or Republic: The People Under the Constitution, is due to be released by AEI Press later this year.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Consider the Constitution, the podcast that cuts through the noise and provides insight into constitutional issues that directly affect every American. Hosted by Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey and featuring interviews with constitutional scholars, policy and subject matter experts, heritage professionals, and legal practitioners, we examine the rights and responsibilities of citizenship. Consider the Constitution is brought to you by the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome to another episode of Consider the Constitution. I'm your host, Dr. Katie Crawford Lackey, Director of the Robert H. Smith Center for the Constitution at James Madison's Montpelier. I'm speaking with you today from Montpelier, Madison's plantation home located in Central Virginia. Today, Montpelier is a historic site, museum, and constitutional education center. On this episode of Consider the Constitution, we're taking a deep dive into the sections or articles of the Constitution, the document as it was signed on September 17, 1787.

SPEAKER_00I'm curious if any of you listeners know how many articles were included in the original Constitution before any of the amendments. Give it a guess and we'll come back to it later. And don't Google it, just take a guess. Our special guest today, who will be exploring this topic with us, is Dr. Jay Cost, the Gerald R. Ford nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. He focuses on elections, politics, and public opinion. He has published several books about James Madison and the founding era, and his next book, Democracy or Republic, The People Under the Constitution, is due to be released by AEI Press later this year.

SPEAKER_00And Jay, not only are you a visiting scholar at Grove City College and a contributing editor at the Washington Examiner, but you also currently teach high school at a small school outside of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Thank you for joining us as we consider the Constitution.

SPEAKER_02Thanks for having me, Katie. It's a it's a pleasure to be here. It's always great to be back at Montpelier, and I'm really glad to be here.

SPEAKER_00Now, upon its signing in 1787, the Constitution included, drum roll, please, seven articles, which doesn't seem like that many given how much these articles do. So the first three address separation of powers between three branches of the federal government the legislative, executive, and judicial. Article four outlines the state's relationships to each other. Article five explains the amendment process. Six establishes federal law as supreme. And Article VI describes the ratification process for the Constitution.

SPEAKER_00That is the framework of our government, what the delegates at the Constitutional Convention drafted in the summer of 1787. Now, obviously, our founding document is the product of many minds, but James Madison played a leading role in his creation. Because of this, he was recognized by his contemporaries as the father of the Constitution. But he's more than that. His contributions to our political system extended beyond even the Constitution. In fact, Jay, the title of one of your books is James Madison, America's First Politician.

SPEAKER_00What are the big takeaways we should know about James Madison and his influence on early America?

SPEAKER_02Madison, I think, remains somewhat of a puzzle in the American memory. It's sort of easy to envision certain people and slot them into specific roles. Jefferson as being the author of the Declaration, George Washington being the father of his country, Benjamin Franklin, you know, minister to France in a larger-than-life character, maybe the first truly American individual in our in our country's history. Madison is a little different.

SPEAKER_02Madison, by the way, was younger than all of them. I developed this idea in my book, as illustrated by the subtitle America's First Politician, is that Madison offers us a vision of how politics is supposed to work in a constitutional republic. And he does this in two ways. The first way is through his enormous contribution to the development of the Constitution itself. Madison was, as you suggested, and as Madison himself acknowledged, it was very much a team effort.

SPEAKER_02But Madison brought in a plan of government when he arrived in Philadelphia that really set the agenda for the discussions that follow. And what the finished product is in many respects is a is compromises, but built around that basic idea. And so that is a that the Constitution remains the framework in which politics happens. And I think, you know, one of the challenges we have today is we don't really even understand what politics is supposed to be. Politics is usually just people yelling at each other on their on our television screens.

SPEAKER_02But I would say that from Madison's perspective, politics is the venue by which social and economic disputes and conflicts are resolved and mutually satisfactory agreements are arrived at. That's the framework of the Constitution. It was intended to provide a forum through which Americans would resolve their disputes and find common ground. And so in that sense, Madison's original vision in the Virginia Plan definitely follows through into the into the Constitution.

SPEAKER_02But I I think also more than that is that when we look at Madison's career in public life more broadly, that is a through line in his biography. That is how he saw politics being understood. And I think that in many respects, Madison's political career was an attempt to embody that vision of politics being the place not in which we defeat our so-called enemies, but through which we find common ground.

SPEAKER_00And you reference how Madison arrived at the convention very well prepared with the Virginia plan. And you know, by that point in his career, he's already a seasoned politician. He served in the Continental Congress. He seems to have a deep understanding of what is, perhaps more accurately stated, not working in regard to the government structure before we have this convention. Can you give us some insight on what's going on in Madison's head during these formative years? What is he hoping for for some type of government structure?

SPEAKER_00What is he concerned about?

SPEAKER_02Those are great questions. I let me just add, too, to sort of key off of what you said. If we think about the founders and their sort of what do they bring to the table, you know, Madison was not a military guy, obviously. Um, five foot four, weighed 100 pounds, soaking wet, not the sort of person who's gonna inspire strike fear in the hearts of the red coats. He's a very prolific author, but never turned as great a phrase as Jefferson's We Hold These Truths to be self-evident. What he is, really, is for starters, he's a workaholic.

SPEAKER_02And it's also the other sense in which I mean the subtitle of my book, America's First Politician, is that where Madison finds himself in his life at this point is that Montpelier is his father's home, so that this is until 1801, when Madison is just about to turn 50 years old, this is his father's house. And he does not, unlike his younger brother Ambrose, does not get his own plantation. And what he becomes at a pretty early age is a professional man of politics, which we take for granted today because we have professional politicians, but this was a pretty new thing.

SPEAKER_02If you look at, like, for instance, Thomas Jefferson, Jefferson was constantly tending to the details of Monticello, or even somebody like Robert Morris, who was the superintendent of finance during the Articles of Confederation, he was also a merchant. So we have these statesmen who have basically, for lack of a better word, day jobs. Except for Madison, Madison doesn't have a day job. And so what he is able to do is he is able to throw his remarkable energy and intellect into the problems of politics.

SPEAKER_02And that's one of the remarkable things about him. Another is that he was, at the same time, you know, maybe in your life you meet people who are detail-oriented and then other people are big picture oriented. He was both. He was really very content to roll up his sleeves and get involved in the drudgery of government. This is a big reason why he gets sent off to the Confederation Congress in 1780, was just he had been working in the Privy Council and the Virginia government and showed up for every meeting, did everything that needed to do, needed to be doing, could speak French.

SPEAKER_02And if you look at his work at the Confederation Congress, I mean, you'd think Madison is a guy who's just debating the big ideas, but really what he's doing is working through the tax code or the lack thereof, right? So he he has that, and then, but he also has this really probably uh this classical education, having gone to the College of New Jersey and been educated by John Witherspoon, and having brought his prodigious work ethic there, pulled out an incredible education. So even as he's working through the details, he is aware of the big picture.

SPEAKER_02And what he's aware of is that the government is failing on a day-to-day because it doesn't accomplish the big things that it needs to accomplish. And the real problem was in 1787, the problem was the states. The problem was that the states had too much power and were exercising that power for their own benefit rather than the interests of the country. And Madison looking into the future and sort of projecting that trend outward, what he sees ultimately is disunion.

SPEAKER_02He sees that the bonds of brotherhood that had been forged during the revolution are gonna fray and then they're eventually gonna break. And he also sees related to this, he also sees the European powers, still Great Britain, actively undermining American unity. And in Madison's vision, conflict among the states on the North American continent is gonna bring about the need for standing armies, permanent military establishments, and ultimately the destruction of what we today call democracy, but what he would have called Republican government.

SPEAKER_02So the states are the problem. The condition is growing critical. And so his vision in Philadelphia in 1787 is to bring the states, basically to bring the states to heel. His what he really wants to do in many respects is he wants to transform the states back into a version of colonies, but not under the sovereignty of the king, but under the sovereignty of a national government whose legitimacy stems from the whole American people. So the states would become the vassals in a certain sense of Congress, but Congress would be representative of the nation.

SPEAKER_00You reference that Madison had this great education from the College of New Jersey, which is today Princeton. You also talk a little bit about his work ethic as well as his interest in compromise. That seems to be something that shows up throughout his career. Can you talk about what motivated this? Why was he so interested in trying to see both sides and bringing people together versus kind of advocating for his own personal beliefs?

SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Right. That's a great question. He had intellectual reasons for wanting compromise. Um, his vision of how a republic is supposed to function, it gets down to that. And I like to tell my high school students that Abraham Lincoln offers the simplest and probably best definition of a republic is government of the people, by the people, for the people. But the challenge, though, is okay, of the people and by the people, so popular or sovereignty is vested in the people and exercise through their representatives.

SPEAKER_02What happens, though, if it becomes of the people, by the people, but not for the people? In other words, how do we keep a democratic republic from becoming a democratic tyranny where the majority, once seizing power, exercise it for their own benefit at the expense of the minority? So you can imagine an election 51-49, the result is the 51 get everything, the 49 have everything taken from them. The problem in a simple democracy is that there's nothing to stop the majority from doing that.

SPEAKER_02So what is the solution? Well, historically in Europe, I mean, this is a problem that had been understood going back to classical antiquity. The Romans had a had a solution to it, and the British had a solution to it as well. The British solution was to blend, mix the rule of the people, so to speak. I mean, it was very limited franchise. I don't want to overstate this and read back our contemporary democratic ethos, but the House of Commons was supposed to represent the small-ish property owners against the House of Lords, which was the landed aristocracy and the church hierarchy.

SPEAKER_02So the idea was a mixture or blending of estates. And then you have a king overlooking the whole thing. And the Americans in 1776 foreclosed that as a possibility, right? Because George III never thought to create titles of nobility in America, so we don't have a nobility. We also don't have a king, obviously, so it's just going to be the commons. So what then stops the people from forming a majority that takes everything for the majority and robs the minority?

SPEAKER_02And the solution that Madison and I guess the the thing to bear in mind as well is that this is not uniquely Madison in the sense that this was his idea, but I do think because his ideas were so well received in Philadelphia suggests that this was on the minds of everybody, but I think he articulates it better than anybody else. So we can call it Madison in that sense. But the idea, though, is compromise and consensus. So that's the function of compromise. It's not just you and I have a disagreement about tax rates. You're at 20%, I'm at 10%, we'll meet at 15 and call it a day.

SPEAKER_02It's that 15 is the number that you can live with and that I can live with. Right. And so that 15 is the number in which you're not taking advantage of me and I'm not taking advantage of you. Right. And so fift and and to continue with that, like splitting the difference is not just a way to solve the problem, but splitting the difference is the way to build out a coalition that is larger, that includes more people, that's broader, that doesn't is not just a geographical majority. Because we for we tend to forget, I think, that place is very important in democratic politics, but is also more considered.

SPEAKER_02Like we have to go back and forth and actually hash it out. And that, I think, more than anything else informs Madison's political theory, which is this idea of consensus, the larger, the broader, and the more durable a majority is, the less likely it's just the many robbing from the few, the more likely it is that it actually reflects the national interest. And so the Constitution as a document is really designed to force Americans to find common ground, much as we just try to ignore that nowadays.

SPEAKER_02But that's its purpose. And that you can see often in his career, that's often what Madison is looking for.

SPEAKER_00And so when we think about Madison really devoted to this idea of compromise and consensus, I mean, obviously, at that point in time, it had never been achieved in terms of government structure on that level before. So it's quite an achievement what they created that summer. What of those ideals that Madison had, the aspects of compromise and consensus, how is that translated into the Constitution?

SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell It's translated in a number of ways. The very premise of the Constitution, you can see it in the um in Governor Morris's preamble, we the people of the United States. Right. To to create a national and when you compare that to the opening line of the Declaration, the unanimous declaration of the 13 states, right? The framers in Philadelphia in 1787 are really created declaring the existence of a people that hadn't really existed.

SPEAKER_02Even that act itself, because and Madison goes into this idea in Federalist X that the diversity of the American people, and I know, and let me just sidebar here and say, I know nowadays when we look back and think about the American people back then, and especially the citizenry, we're gonna see them as white male property owners, which they were, and and from our eyes in 2023, we're gonna see that as pretty um not very diverse. But there was an incredible amount of diversity. When we understand the sorts of the differing values, there were like religious differences were much more salient than even differences within Protestantism itself.

SPEAKER_02There were very salient differences between Baptists and Anglicans, for instance, today, and somebody who goes to a Baptist church could just as easily go to an Anglican church and not even think anything of it, but it's a big deal then. There was more meaningful ethnic diversity, even though it's a whites-only republic at that time. But again, nowadays, oh, I'm German American, I'm you know, Italian American, I'm, you know, we don't really think as much about those differences, but those were very meaningful. There were language barriers, uh, there were pockets of large swaths of the country that spoke different languages.

SPEAKER_02There was also, and I think probably more importantly, there was not economic integration that we take for granted today. Like you can go anywhere in the country and go to a McDonald's. That didn't exist then. There was no economic integration, it was very, very limited. There was also no cultural integration. So like everybody can watch, you know, um Star Wars on Disney Plus today. Um there's nothing like that. So you have pockets, you really have isolated pockets of cultural experiences and things like that. So when you think of it from that perspective, it's an incredibly diverse country.

SPEAKER_02Madison's argument is that the diversity is actually the strength. In a small republic, like in a state, um, you can have some social group or some economic group or some religious group basically act as a hegemon and boss everybody else around. This had happened in Rhode Island. It had happened in Massachusetts during the Confederation period, it happened in Virginia, even though Virginia is religiously diversifying. The Anglican establishment is browbeating the Baptists and also the Quakers.

SPEAKER_02And Madison's point is that on a national level, there's gonna be no hegemon. The Anglicans are not gonna constitute a national majority, so they're gonna have to bargain. And so also will the Congregationalists in New England and the merchants in Philadelphia and the plantation gentry in Virginia, they're gonna have to bargain with each other. Nobody's gonna get everything they want. Everybody has to come to the table. And that I think is the main really the the House of Representatives really just itself, we just take it for granted today, well, it's a democracy, but it's a national democracy, which as you said you noted, Katie, was had been untried.

SPEAKER_02I mean, nobody since Greece had done a democratic republic like this. The Republic of Rome was an oligarchy, Florence and Venice were oligarchies, England, Madison wouldn't even admit that it was a republic or even was close to it. So to do a democratic republic, but to do a democratic republic on a national level was really extraordinary. And Madison thought that this was actually our ace in the hole. And that's, I think, the cur the kernel of the Madisonian idea. And then it was added to checks and balances is an idea that the Romans had sort of invented or had perfected, which is a checks and balances in government is often a way, just as sort of like the National Republic is a way to keep any hegemon, hegemonic group in the greater public dominating.

SPEAKER_02Checks and balances are meant to keep an elite faction from dominating as well. So the whole thing is basically designed to get people talking with each other.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell I want to turn to the seven articles of the Constitution. So you mentioned checks and balances, and that seems to be something that the delegates who arrived there during that summer were thinking about. We can see what they valued looking at the articles today, the separation of powers, relationship between the states and the federal government, the amendment process. But I'm curious to know more about how that played out. Did they have a sense of those ideas going in?

SPEAKER_00You spoke about Madison having the Virginia plan. But what was the process of trying to figure this out via compromise and what was the end result?

SPEAKER_02That's a great question. You know, it's funny, there were some very heated debates, obviously, uh at the convention, and let and the the convention lasted a long time too. Um so we're recording this on the 16th of September, tomorrow's Constitution Day, right? So because it was finished on the seventeenth. They had begun at the end of May was when they had a quorum, I think like the twenty-fifth or twenty-sixth of May. So they were there all through June, July, and August. And they were there in Philadelphia in the summer, very unpleasant circumstances and in in a lot of respects as an indication of how fraught the meeting was.

SPEAKER_02However, that being said, it's really fascinating to see what they all agreed on. I'll give you an example. The notion of checks and balances was just something that they understood because they all had had a similar classical education. Um, so they had all read, for instance, or knew of Polybius, the Greek um historian um who wrote uh The Histories of Rome, where Polybius talks about the success of the Roman Republic being built on its constitution. They were, by and large, absolutely enchanted by the Roman Republic.

SPEAKER_02Jefferson as well was. If you come to Montpelier and you look at the portico, you can see the influence of Rome on Madison's mind because it's Greco-Roman. Um, if you go to the Capitol, even the name the Capitol comes from the Capitoline Hill in Rome. I mean, they were just fascinated with Rome. So they had this great example of Rome, and Rome's great success was checks and balances. So they had that. Um, another thing that I always think is really interesting, a lot of times, you know, it's a very fraught discourse in our country about the meaning and nature of the Interstate Commerce Clause.

SPEAKER_02And you would think going into the Interstate Commerce Clause debates that there would be, oh, there's some kind of revelation waiting in the primary documents from the convention, but there was really not. They just agreed that the government had to regulate interstate commerce, which was the phrase they agreed upon. So there's all these things that they basically agreed upon. What I think, though, the main sticking points at the convention really had to do with the distribution of power. Just and it's really fascinating to read in that respect, just a sort of like real raw political calculation and negotiation.

SPEAKER_02And the way I sort of like to characterize it is that intellectually, in the abstract, they believed in the necessity of a national republic where factions were balanced and checked. But in practice, there were many factions at the convention that when it came to their own interests, they were not like that. So they were sort of like nimbies. You've ever heard the phrase not in my backyard, they were sort of like nimbies. So the South wanted special protections for the institution of slavery. The small states wanted a guarantee of representation, the commercial interests in the cities in the East, Governor Morris wanted, like, for instance, the Western states to be represented at a lower rate than the eastern states.

SPEAKER_02Because while in intellectually they agreed with the need for a national republic, practically speaking, they didn't have the faith that Madison had in this idea. And so Madison, it's very ironic because he was very ground down by the by the project and late in life denied paternity of the Constitution. I'm I'm not the father of the Constitution, it was a group effort. But if you go back to 1787 in the fall, he would have denied paternity because he was like, this kid's not mine, you know, like it's yeah, there's no way I, you know.

SPEAKER_02Because he he didn't like it. He was so frustrated by he felt there were too many compromises. There were too many wins for the for the Southern faction, there were too many wins for the small states. There wasn't a large enough commitment to national government.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell And I'm curious if you can expand on that a little more about some of the concerns that weren't addressed in this document that they signed that September.

SPEAKER_02Well, they knew. I I mean I think the biggest one that they they refused to address was the issue of slavery. They don't even use the word slave in the Constitution. They use phrases that they had they had developed these sort of like terms of art that they had developed a couple years earlier when they were putting together a tax plan back in the 1780s. They knew that slavery, by and large, they understood that slavery was wrong, and there's a there's a surprising consensus in the room about the immorality of slavery, including among the slaveholders themselves.

SPEAKER_02If you come to Montpelier, there's a fantastic exhibition here called the Mere Distinction of Color, which is a phrase that comes from Madison's um one of his speeches about how we've seen oppression based on nothing more than the mere distinction of color. In other words, Madison understanding that slavery is wrong. George Mason called it the curse of heaven. But there was at the time, it's really interesting and unfortunate in retrospect to see, because we know what's going to happen uh in our history, and we can see them making their deal with the devil, really, is what they're doing.

SPEAKER_02It's really interesting to read their conversation about slavery with Lincoln's second inaugural, where, you know, America made its deal with the devil and the payments come due, is sort of the framework by which Lincoln understands the Civil War in this in a second inaugural. But there is this sort of common ground that exists within the convention on the issue of slavery, which is the South is embarrassed by it, but the North is willing to let it go. And you can see this in ri really kind of remarkable moments. And it's not really discussed very much until the real exception to that, I think, would probably be the South Carolina delegation and John Rutledge sort of pushing for a radical pro-slavery constitution.

SPEAKER_02And one of the hot button issues is the importation of enslaved people, which Virginia had already outlawed. But Rutledge, who's from South Carolina, wants the new government not to be able to regulate the slave trade. And that really just throws everything up in the air. And you can see this sort of like anger and outrage. But there's this really interesting moment in which James Wilson, who is a delegate from Pennsylvania, and of all of the delegates, was probably the close to being a modern-day Democrat, small D Democrat, not the Democratic Party, but sort of like really committed to universal suffrage, sort of like denouncing slavery and calling it evil and reprehensible.

SPEAKER_02And you'd think that here comes James Wilson, the Democrat, to like really make everybody feel it. But like literally in the next breath, he says, well, we need a compromise. Really, the only person at the convention who was took a stand on slavery was Governor Morris. At one point, Morris says, you know, if this is what it's going to be, I think we need to take a friendly leave of each other, is what he says. So Morris, through the pages of Madison's notes, comes across really impressive as a moral principled stand. But it's unfortunate in other respects because Morris was the sort of person who the more he talked, I think, the less he persuaded.

SPEAKER_02He was just one of those kinds of characters, so I'm not sure it really did very much. But you can kind of see them, you know, like the South is appropriately apologetic and appropriately embarrassed by slavery. The North is forgiving and indulgent of them. And so you can see slavery as this sort of thing that sits behind there and the inherent contradiction in Jefferson's declaration, this sort of universal statement of human freedom in a in a place that still is enslaving that I think at that point was something like 20% of the population was enslaved.

SPEAKER_02They recognize that tension, but they have resolved not to do anything.

SPEAKER_00As we from this present moment look back on this chapter in history, what wisdom can we glean from Madison, both his accomplishments, but also his shortcomings?

SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah, that's a great question. I think one of the things we need to do is not to deify the founders. Historically, I think we've trended in that direction towards doing that. I mean, like, my goodness, there's, you know, a giant obelisk in Washington, D.C., for George Washington. We tend to do that with them. And I think that that's probably the wrong approach. I think Catherine Drinker Bowen's book from the 60s was called Miracle in Philadelphia as this as if these guys are miracle workers.

SPEAKER_02Um, I think that's probably the wrong perspective. I would say probably the right perspective on them is reverence and respect. And maybe the word, the correct word is esteem, that we should have esteem for them. And recognizing that they did really impressive things and that this was a really impressive group of individuals. And I think one of the things that makes them so impressive is that they were, in many respects, willing to challenge the conventions of the day. The conventions of the day being this is how government is supposed to work.

SPEAKER_02Government is, you know, you you can't have a democratic republic that's just going to lead to mob rule. And they were willing to challenge that. I mean, they had, they weren't willing to embrace, you know, a direct democracy or anything. I mean, they understood the legitimacy of those critiques, but were still plunging forward with a version of democratic republicanism that the world had not yet tried. And insofar as they were doing that is pretty remarkable. And also, by the way, I should add, insofar as they were doing that, even as by 1787, the idea of democrat a democratic republic was not going very well in the United States at that time.

SPEAKER_02So the fact that they were willing, in a sense, to kind of double down, or like Madison's argument for why the Articles of Confederation had failed was basically like, well, we need to go bigger, was sort of his response. State-based democratic republic is not what we need. We need a national one. We need to go bigger. That's that's impressive. And I think that insofar as they were cutting against the prejudices and conventions of their day, really is what sets them apart. It's something I think we all aspire to to sort of like be able to see right from wrong above and beyond what the conventions of the day are.

SPEAKER_02But the reality is the respects in which they failed to do that, particularly on the issue of slavery. And again, not just on the issue of um those who themselves were slaveholders, but there were northerners as well who did known slaves that were willing to make a deal on this because in that regard, they were not beyond the prejudices of their day. They did not see beyond they had a glimpse or an understanding that this was going to be a problem in the future, but uh future generations will figure it out. And again, the framework in which you to read Lincoln's second inaugural is Lincoln surveying the damage, realizing that the bill has come due for the great national sin.

SPEAKER_02So I think that's the framework in which we should understand these men.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell And compromise, it seems, through this example, looking at Madison's life and his political career was both uh very much an asset, but also it seemed to have kind of not allowed the founders to address what needed to be addressed and push a problem off that, as you said, came due eventually.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah. I mean, and that I think ultimately is the r the reality is that compromise you kind of get a sense of this. He was not willing to compromise with Alexander Hamilton in the 1790s because he felt that Hamilton wasn't really a Republican, smaller Republican. Like compromising with Hamilton in Madison's vision was, in effect, allowing aristocracy and rule by the elite untethered by the masses, because Madison was an elitist belief that the better sorts of people should be in charge, but that that it should ultimately be anchored in popular sovereignty.

SPEAKER_02And he suspected that Hamilton didn't really think that. So compromising with Hamilton would have been allowing anti-republican views into the government. But see, that's exactly what they did with the institution of slavery in 1787, because slavery is at its core anti-republican. And they knew that. They knew that it was contrary to the principles of republicanism, because your rights to and this is sort of the way they saw things at the time as well, is that your political rights are actually derived from your natural rights, which are ultimately a gift from the creator that was just bestowed upon all human beings.

SPEAKER_02So they knew that that, like insofar as the enslaved community lacked political rights and civil rights, that they were actually being denied the expression of their natural rights. And that's an anti-Republican view as well. So that's where you know, where compromise works is if the people have the same commitment to a system of openness and a system of equal participation and equality under the law. In those circumstances, that's where compromise among fellow Republicans, like Jefferson in his first inaugural, says we're all Republicans, we're all Federalists.

SPEAKER_02That's what he's getting at. Like we all are basically, now that we've gotten rid of Hamilton, of course, but we are all basically committed to these same same essential values. That's the problem with slavery, is that and and ultimately, you know, why there could be no compromise once really got down to it, that Governor Morris was was right that like at the end of the day, it's like mixing oil and water.

SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell The definition of compromise that you just gave, I think, is really important to keep in mind. And that's one of the lessons to learn from the founders is that shared sense of commitment and openness and conversation, um, which is what's gonna keep our democracy going.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Yeah, I think we need to we and I this is the other thing too. I think that compromise is also we don't usually think of it this way, but I I think that it is, and we don't really talk about it in our society, but it is a civic virtue. A civic virtue is an obligation that the citizenry owe the state. We don't like to talk about that in the United States of America. We don't like to think of ourselves as being bound to something other than ourselves. We're a very individualistic nation. Regardless of what your political orientation is, America has this aggressively individualistic notion of the self.

SPEAKER_02But compromise is indicative of a broader virtue that I think has particularly been forgotten by the citizenry. And I think our political elites on both sides of the aisle have aggressively worked against inculcating this virtue. Because c what compromise at the end of the day is an admission that I do not have a monopoly on truth, that my moreover, that my understanding of the truth is ultimately wrapped up in my own self-interests.

SPEAKER_02And so therefore, I come to the political table not to get everything that I want, but to bargain and by extension, to give up on certain things. And the only reason you do something like that is recognizing that even though we all think we're right about everything, that's just the way human nature is. We when a when we have an opinion, we're convinced that we're right. But when we stop and reflect, it's a virtue, it's a civic virtue to recognize I have to be wrong about certain things.

SPEAKER_02I don't have a complete grasp of what the good of the whole community is. And so compromise is really like the act of entering into that community on a political level and talking with other people and figuring out, okay, I'm here, you're here, like where can we meet in the middle, recognizing that like I acknowledge the legitimacy of your viewpoint? That is something we don't do in this country anymore. We don't acknowledge the legitimacy of the views with uh with which we disagree.

SPEAKER_02And unfortunately, there there is money to be made, there is fame and glory to be found by actively encouraging people to view politics as a holy war between the forces of good and the forces of evil. And that is fundamentally contrary to Madison's view. It's fundamentally contrary to the founding view. If the founding fathers, I'll put it this way, if the founding fathers had that view, we would not have a country. That would be it. They would have walked away and we this would not be a country. That's it.

SPEAKER_00Dr. J. Cost, thank you so much for sharing your insights on Madison and the Constitution. You've given me a lot to contemplate, uh, and I hope to exercise civic virtue myself. So thank you so much for being with us. It was an honor to have you as we consider the Constitution.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Katie.

SPEAKER_00And thank you to everyone listening to this podcast. I hope you'll subscribe and share this show with your family and friends. And join us again next week as we consider the Constitution.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Statement at the Table

    Nov 18, 202634 minAudio

    A cup of chocolate in James Madison's day was breakfast, a luxury and a statement. Making a single pound by hand took almost all day. Harold Caldwell, a history interpreter at Colonial Williamsburg, joins Katie to walk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. That’s How Change Happens

    Nov 4, 202634 minAudio

    The Constitution begins with three words: We the People. But in 1787, who counted as “the people”? And what did it mean to take part in the political life of a brand-new nation? Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. You Can’t Defer the Maintenance on the Republic

    Oct 21, 202635 minAudio

    The Constitution created a government. It did not create citizens. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what people needed to know to govern themselves, and who should get the chance to learn it. Again and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Unfinished Constitution

    Oct 7, 202636 minAudio

    The Constitution began as an experiment. Once it took effect, Americans had to figure out what it actually meant. They did not agree. Host Dr. Katie Crawford-Lackey talks with Dr. Jonathan Gienapp, professor of history...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Declaration Is Our Inheritance

    Sep 23, 202624 minAudio

    The Declaration of Independence announced more than a separation from Britain. It made a claim about government itself: that people hold rights government did not grant and cannot take away, and that legitimate power...

    Credit the people on this episode