Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Clause 8

Clause 8 artwork

AI Boom Calls for New Copyright Law, Says USPTO Chief Behind the DMCA

May 19, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

Bruce Lehman, head of USPTO from 1993 to 1998, joins Clause 8 for a wide-ranging conversation about the modern IP system, the internet boom, and why the AI era may require a new copyright response from Congress. Lehman helped shape internet-era copyright policy from the USPTO, including the work that led to the WIPO Copyright Treaties and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). He also played a major role in the broader 1990s pro-IP moment, when the United States was strengthening IP rights globally through TRIPS, WIPO, and trade policy. Now, Lehman argues that courts have spent the last two decades weakening copyright through an expansive view of fair use - creating a system where AI companies can train on massive amounts of human-created content without giving creators a meaningful stake. Asked whether new legislation is needed to protect creators in the AI age, Lehman does not hesitate: “The short answer is yes.” The episode also covers: *Lehman’s “patent pendulum” theory and why he believes the US is now in a low-protection IP era *How the DMCA emerged from the Clinton administration’s internet copyright work *TRIPS, WIPO, and the globalization of IP rights in the 1990s *Bayh-Dole and the rise of the university-to-startup pipeline *Lehman’s historic confirmation as the first openly gay man confirmed by the Senate *His role in turning the USPTO into a “prominent perch” for national IP policy *Gilbert Hyatt, submarine patents, and SAWS *USPTO telework, examiner retention, and modernization *His message that current leadership should “stop tormenting the Patent Corps” *The limits of AI - and why Lehman thinks it lacks the "metaphysical" spark behind true invention *Judge Pauline Newman and her pro-patent legacy Watch the full episode and read the companion post on Voice of IP: https://voiceofip.com/ Subscribe to the Clause 8 YouTube channel for bonus content: https://www.youtube.com/@clause8 Disclaimer This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.voiceofip.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to Clause 8, the number one podcast on intellectual property.

SPEAKER_00If you enjoy conversations like this, take a moment to subscribe at voiceofip.com and stay connected to the leading voices in IP. Today we are joined by one of the most consequential policymakers of the modern era, Bruce Lehman. As the head of the USPTO from 1993 to 1998, Bruce was a central architect of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and a lead creator in global IP modernization. In this candid conversation, Bruce breaks down his patent pendulum theory to explain why

dominant industries eventually turn against strong IP protections once they achieve market power. He offers a blunt assessment of why recent case law has been catastrophic for creators and explains why true innovation is something AI can never replicate. from the halls of the House Judiciary Committee to the future of the globalized economy.

SPEAKER_00Stay tuned for an unfiltered masterclass in intellectual property.

SPEAKER_02I wasn't sure anybody even remembered who I was.

SPEAKER_01Let's start from the beginning of, I guess, your IP journey. You were born in Wisconsin. You grew up in Wisconsin. You went to school in Wisconsin. You got your first job in the legislature there. What brought you to D.C.?

SPEAKER_02The U.S. Army brought me to D.C. It was the Vietnam War and I was commissioned as a lieutenant in the Army. The bottom line is I ended up being posted in Washington. so I'm very proud of my military service but I'm very careful to say that I'm a Vietnam era veteran but not a veteran you know I had a really cushy desk job in Washington and I was going to go back to Wisconsin and then at the last minute the job that I'd lined up fell through and the U.S.

SPEAKER_02Justice Department had offered me a job and I didn't want to take it but I took it because I didn't want to be out of work and so I went over there for a few months absolutely hated it I decided if I'm well I was actually in the criminal division but it was in the national security section and there are great jobs in justice but I didn't have one I was put to work writing certiorari memos in other words reviewing

criminal cases which had been lost by the government you know because of double jeopardy generally you can't appeal but to look for opportunities to appeal a decision it was boring as hell I had a horrible boss couldn't stand it and I said I

SPEAKER_02I'm only staying in Washington if I can have a real Washington job. And that meant not being a civil servant. I wanted to be, I was terribly arrogant. And I thought, well, I'll work in the House of Representatives as a committee counsel. And in the Senate, I'd work either as a committee counsel or as a legislative aide because the Senate works a lot differently. Those jobs are more fungible. So I went to my senator and my congressman and said, here I am.

And a couple of months later I got a call and at the age of like 28 or 29 I became

SPEAKER_02counsel to the Laos Judiciary Committee.

SPEAKER_01And who was the congressman who put you? The congressman from Madison, Bob Castamire, who was a very liberal, very liberal congressman.

SPEAKER_02Well, in fact, the person in that seat right now, Mark Pocan, is probably one of the most left-wing members of the House. So it's historically been a really liberal area with Madison and everything. and he was a senior, very senior member of the committee. So he had a subcommittee that could have practically whatever he wanted in it. It was called the Subcommittee on Court, Civil Liberties and the Administration of Justice. And among other things,

SPEAKER_02had a big sweeping portfolio. For example, I worked on the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, what became a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. But it also included all the patents, trademarks, and copyrights. And there had been a long-running effort to revised the 1909 copyright law. And so I was put to work on that. In fact, we're having the 50th.

SPEAKER_02There's going to be a Zoom conference on May 7th of the living, still surviving living people that who worked on that legislation. And then I was put to work on the patent policy provisions of the Non-Nuclear Energy Research and Development Act of 1974, I had never taken an IP course in law school I had not a clue

but when you're writing the laws of the country you have to have to get to learn pretty fast but

SPEAKER_02you know I found with lawyers like actually You know, in more recent years, I've worked sometimes as an expert witness with with patent litigators and, you know, a lot of them, a lot of the best ones aren't aren't even patent lawyers. I mean, per se, they're really good litigators, but the best ones are super smart and they can absorb the most complicated

SPEAKER_02technology and figure out how to make a case for their clients. And so, I mean, that's what being a good lawyer is. So anyway, I tried to be a good lawyer and so I learned that subject matter.

SPEAKER_01So did you like that IP? policy issues more than the other issues?

SPEAKER_02Well, no, not necessarily. I became fascinated by it because it's really interesting. And I think it wasn't, you know, the thing that I ended up working on the post-Watergate reforms, which, among other things, led to FISA. We had big oversight hearings over the FBI, and it was sort of the stuff of the movies. and that was fun.

SPEAKER_02Everything was exciting and fun, but the IP stuff, I really immediately could begin to see its importance because even then, I mean, it sounds quaint now. I mean, the technologies at the time seemed like the Stone Age now, but we were on the cusp of a technological development revolution.

SPEAKER_01This was the late 70s, early 80s, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, they're actually, this is an important point. I mean, if anybody wants some wisdom from me, I used to, for many years give a speech that I called the patent pendulum speech. A lot of people used to identify me with that and how since the Constitution, since we're having this, this is the 250th anniversary of the revolution, not,

SPEAKER_02of course, the Constitution, which was 1789. And by the way, my lifespan has been one third of that time. you know we've gone through periods of high protection and periods of low protection and so like for example in the 19th century inventors were some of the most famous people. Abraham Lincoln has a patent, and the patents were extremely important.

SPEAKER_02But what happens is, and they spurred technological innovation in this country and the other countries that had patent systems like Germany and UK. and Japan, by the way, which adopted patents in the 1870s. But then what happens is you develop these industries that become phenomenally successful and dominant and are consolidated,

SPEAKER_02and they lose interest in intellectual property. In fact, generally speaking, often times they become hostile to strong patent protection because they want to be able to steal the little guy stuff because their prosperity depends on market power if they have market power they don't need IP and and so what happens then is you that sets in. Well, then, as in all things, when people get in power too long and they get too rich,

SPEAKER_02they get too lazy, everything, of course, they become less competitive. And particularly in an era of international trade and so on, they start to lose market share. And So then you have to do something about it. And so that's when all of a sudden, well, maybe we ought to take a look at the patent law again. And so You know, we had that period. I would say we had pretty strong patent protection.

SPEAKER_02Even, you know, we had antitrust laws that came, but we had pretty strong patent protection, I would say, certainly up into the early first part of the 20th century. And then we had the Depression, and we had World War II. And, of course, then we had this huge infusion of government funding, of technology, which... spurred a huge technological revolution.

SPEAKER_02And so at the end of the world, you know, we dominated everything with, you know, automobiles, electronic industry, chemical industry, and so on. but these companies were just enormous they had tremendous market power well then what happened is you know the Japanese started coming into the picture and whittling away we lost our consumer electronics industry and so

starting and that's

SPEAKER_02when I first got involved in this in the 1970s really even started maybe under Johnson and it was bipartisan you had both in the front offices of corporate power and then also in the government you had people say we've got to take a look at this and so there was actually I think the National Association of Manufacturers or something set up a

competitiveness council there

SPEAKER_02was a government equivalent to that and there was basically review and one of the most important things that was done, which I worked on and became law, was the famous Bayh-Dole Act, which is a pretty simple statute, but I think had an unbelievable impact because government was financing all

of this basic R&D.

SPEAKER_02And the rule always was that, which, you know, would seem logical to a lot of people. By the way, the government insisted if you got government money, you should, if there were identifiable, patentable inventions, you should file a patent application. But once you got the patent, the rule was that if government spent one dime to finance it,

SPEAKER_02if you were a university or a government laboratory person, that it had to be licensed on a non-exclusive basis to all taxpayers. Well, you know, that just obviously there's no incentive to invest because the basic research, particularly the kind done in academia, You know, is, I mean, when you look, say, at the pharmaceutical industry, I mean, the, you know, you've got to go, you know, where the capital is involved,

SPEAKER_02the enormous investments is clinical trials, all those sorts of things. It's not really, you know, identifying the basic invention. And so we changed the law. and it's unbelievable the effect that it had and so I remember the first time I ever went to Silicon Valley it was actually to look into prison issues out there and what's now Silicon Valley and that area south of San Francisco was pretty depressed

you know today it's one of the richest places on earth and when you think of what

SPEAKER_02is Silicon Valley it's in the northeast you have UC Berkeley and you have University of California San Francisco which is the life sciences campus of University of California system then you go down to Stanford and then you go across to the Lawrence Livermore laboratory and so you have all of this world-class science. And so today,

SPEAKER_02because of the Bayh-Dole Act, you can be a professor at Stanford, you can invent something, and of course you know the rule is because you have to file the patent before the disclosure that means that before any scientist can publish before you can give a speech about it you know These universities, they have a patent committee that reviews the work, and then if they feel there's patentable subject matter,

SPEAKER_02patent application is filed, which the university owns, and it's a big source of revenue for, like, my alma mater of University of Wisconsin had the first patent licensing operation in the world and has a multi-billion dollar endowment just from that. And you see that University of California has the biggest one by far in the world. And so the professor, now he doesn't own the patent, university does, but guess what? When a venture capitalist puts together some money and they start a firm,

SPEAKER_02He of course gets on the board of directors, he gets stock options and so he ends up a billionaire continuing his job as a professor and also getting money to finance his research and then he can win the Nobel Prize. I mean, he's got everything and that's what happened and that's why so we had this huge boom. It was hugely successful and then

you know we this extended out it there's a copyright component to all of this too because of content industries and copyright and and that was something that was very central to the Clinton administration's economic and trade policy and but

SPEAKER_02what's happened now is that it was so successful we're back to that situation where market power is everything because these guys have market power they don't want to be bothered by some NAT patent holder you know if you're a Mark Zuckerberg and so we're right back again and we're in a period of low protection I would say and you're even hearing stuff about the Bayh-Dole Act and stuff like that,

SPEAKER_01about maybe marching rights and all that. So you could definitely see the pendulum, like you said, the other way. Well, the great irony is that all these people, I mean, the Obama administration, was filled with all of these information should be free etc etc and of course they had a love affair a little bit with these emerging Silicon Valley companies of course now they're all over with Trump you know I mean uh so so

much for that um

SPEAKER_02yeah uh I guess it was a perfect recipe for anti-patent sentiment because the large tech companies and I guess some on the more progressive ideological side who think Well, there's a big copyright component to that because obviously software is copyrightable subject matter but also content I mean that fits into the AI thing right now and we've had some in my view absolutely catastrophic the evolution of the case law over the last 20

years has been catastrophic also in expanding the doctrine of fair use to something that's just

SPEAKER_01you know

SPEAKER_02vitiates copyright and you see it in AI. I mean, I guess one reason I'm not worried about, I mean, we can worry about AI, but I'm not worried about ultimately AI taking over everything is that basically what AI does is it soaks up all the existing databases of content.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then it's able to sort through them and focus on it and organize it into

SPEAKER_02something useful, maybe even to the point of, for example, being able to write new code and things like that. But what it does cannot do, and this element that maybe a lot of people don't understand about the VATIN system, is that true innovation comes from the ether. And in fact, what's the test for getting a patent? Novelty and non-obviousness.

And that's why we have an examination system, because you have to prove that. That's why the invention has to be something that is not obvious to one ordinarily

SPEAKER_02skilled in the art and has never been known anywhere in the world before. Unlike copyright, it is not a copying test. And so where's it coming from? Well, it's coming from somewhere out there. in the ether. And it's interesting when we used to have the first to file system,

SPEAKER_02I mean, the first to invent system. For patents. Yeah, we had to have the... Interference. Interference, yes. But it's interesting that just an interesting phenomenon, I think, throughout history is that you tend to find these inventions popping up all over the world.

SPEAKER_01Parallel inventions, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yes. Otherwise, it's sort of dawning on human minds. And so there's this metaphysical element to it. And that is, I mean, who knows? I don't believe that is something AI can do or does. However, coming back to copyright, What AI companies are doing is that content database they're soaking up is data created by someone else.

Under the current case law, basically, those content creators whose works have been published

SPEAKER_02are being used by this database have no stake in it. They have no right. And I think that is just fundamentally immoral. It started out with Google. I've always been against Google. When we had some cases, there was a famous case about... Google versus Oracle? No, this was a copyright. Google was... They basically digitized libraries It was a library case And

the Association of American Publishers A lot of publishers brought litigation Because in my view, correctly Even if they weren't copying exactly They were still making commercial

SPEAKER_02use Out of the previous work Absolutely, yeah and so as I recall it's been a long time since I've read the case but it was determined it was like a card catalog for example so you know the court said well this is nothing more than you know it's like a card catalog card catalog thing for uh it's not the whole book it's just because you're you're only but if you uh go if you do

google something

SPEAKER_02you you You will get whole excerpts, and if it's in the area of, for example, visual arts, like I've worked a lot with professional illustrators, you'll see the whole illustration often. and so that just opened the barn door and then also going back even earlier in the software cases the transformative doctrine you know in other words if you transform

SPEAKER_02the work then you know you have a I can steal it card. And so you had this whole period of weakening right at the time you were having these new technologies and particularly The Silicon Valley internet based content companies just went to town with that and now they're just the most awful evil organizations on the planet.

SPEAKER_01So I want to circle back to that, but obviously during your time when you were head of the USPTO, you helped pass the Digital Millennium Copyrights Act, which was the rise of the Internet and I think like Napster and all that. And that was partially to strengthen copyright at that time. Now there's conversation, like you mentioned, about AI. and you are hearing about some deals between content providers and these AI companies,

SPEAKER_01but do you think new legislation is needed to strengthen?

SPEAKER_02The short answer is yes. I think I just turned 80. My life has been one third of the history of this country since the republic, since the constitution. Just if you think of the two other 80-year periods, what's happened, the changes that have taken place. Unbelievable. And again, you see this pattern where we're at the end of a period. My life, you know, I was born a couple of weeks after the end of World War II into

the Atomic Age and

SPEAKER_02into the Golden Age of America. I think we were on a slow decline. But with President Trump's second election, we've gone over the cliff. And so that era is totally finished. And and so right now we're in a deconstruction period we're in I mean which is always very painful I mean and a lot of people end up suffering where the old world has to

SPEAKER_02kind of collapse before a new one can be built, but since I spend a lot of my life in legislative policy with regard to copyright, always one of the most difficult things in trying to keep up with technology and amend law is that you have all the existing interest groups. It's very hard to write something from scratch.

And I would say the statutory changes that have been made during this entire period that I described were things that weren't just necessarily wholesale revisions. But we're now at a period when everything is going to be basically so destroyed that The next generation of policy makers who are just now starting

to appear on the

SPEAKER_02scene will basically have, I think, the permission from the electorate to really just write all new rules governing all these things. And one of the things that clearly has to be done, historically, we're at a period a little bit like the end of the Gilded Age. And you had a progressive followed by a progressive era when you had antitrust

SPEAKER_02laws, you had regulation of consumer laws, various types of regulation of

SPEAKER_01So we were talking about how in Congress when you worked there, it was a pro-IP era and you got to work on a lot of that. And then Bill Clinton gets elected and you become the head of the USPTO. Can you tell us a story about that? How did you get chosen for that position and why were you interested in that role? I knew I was going to be a lawyer when I was 14 years old but I was interested in politics and government and I never saw I mean I now realize

lawyers can earn a good living and I did but I didn't approach it from I didn't go to law school to

SPEAKER_02make money I wanted to um you know promote truth justice in the American way and so I was really interested in public service and so on and so you know when I left the hill I realized you know I The time had come when I needed to and one of the nice things about the IP thing is that that was one thing you could at least make some money from and so I became a partner in a law firm and did that but I always wanted to I

always had this idea that well the firm was a firm called Swidler and Berlin doesn't exist anymore it

SPEAKER_02was eventually merged into Bingham McCutcheon and was very successful law firm during the period of time I was there and but I wanted to go you know my objective was to go back into the government and since I had the moment I made the decision to stay in Washington and go with the committee as opposed to go back home to Wisconsin I realized that if I was going to be involved in the political world that it would be as an

appointed official not as

SPEAKER_02an elected official and and I also figured well You know, the highest you can expect to get without the finger of God touching you is basically a subcabinet officer, an assistant secretary, undersecretary. And so I had my eye from that time on the Hill on the PTO because I could see its potential. And so when Clinton came in, I went for that.

SPEAKER_01What did you mean you were able to see its potential? What were you able to see before you got the role?

SPEAKER_02Well, first of all, it's a sub cabinet Senate confirmed position. But I also could see that it could be a lot. I remember when I was a young lawyer for the committee. I think it was what became the AIPLA every year had a reception for patent examiners the patent office was in horrible shape and you know these patent and

SPEAKER_02they would have it on the hill in like the cannon caucus room and would go to the thing and it would be pretty pathetic all these guys in their white short sleeve shirts their pocket protectors and then scarfing up the sandwiches and so on and so forth and patent office was underfunded under that was one of the big reforms we made is to change that and um

SPEAKER_02So it wasn't, in fact, the head of the patent office, even though it was, you know, had been really part of the Constitution, reported to an assistant secretary, reported to an undersecretary. And so before I left the Hill, I started, I helped to check and change that and make it working with Reagan's patent commissioner, Jerry Mossingoff, and we did all these reforms.

SPEAKER_02But the big part was reforming the patent office and creating making putting on a fee funded basis raising commissioner to a to an assistant secretary reporting directly to the secretary so I mean you're now going to to you're just one step away from the president. And so I went into private practice then and waited my time.

SPEAKER_02And I thought, well, this is a good thing. And I knew all the people. I knew a lot of connections. And... and I campaigned for Clinton. You know, I was pretty active in the Clinton campaign and I was nominated.

SPEAKER_01What was the confirmation process like, you know, going through that for the first time at the time?

SPEAKER_02It was a breeze. I had no problem. I was confirmed. But that's... There's a reason... Well, I mean, it's particularly... important because probably the most historic thing that I've ever done is that I was the first openly gay man ever to be confirmed by the United States Senate. I wasn't the first gay person because Roberta Ackermberg, who was my Assistant Secretary of HUD,

SPEAKER_02had been a San Francisco supervisor. She was confirmed like a couple of months before me, but when her confirmation came up a the Senate voted against her. Jesse Helms, the senator from North Carolina, gave his big famous speech where he said, I'm not voting for a damn lesbian. I was confirmed unanimously. And I knew when I was in the, when I had it made is that when I went up to see Senator Thurman and he said,

SPEAKER_02I want you to know I'm supporting you. and that's because I knew Senator Thurman and I knew all of the... I remember I was supposed to see him in his office for my courtesy visit and there's a big room behind the Senate community chamber. And it's where everybody goes. All the staff hangs out there. And, you know, senators go there when they want to take a break from the committee room.

SPEAKER_02So they said, well, he was presiding over the committee. And so I said, well, you've got to meet him in that room. So I walked in this room, which is filled with all these people that I knew, you know, every last one of them, all of the staffers and and I knew everybody and I was a member of the club. I am a card-carrying member of the deep state. Well, that's a great story. Absolutely. 100%.

That's a great story that shows how personal relationships, you know, make a difference.

SPEAKER_01You know, you obviously were involved in a lot of those issues. Were there any pressing issues when you came in? You were like, this is what I want to accomplish as the USPTO director that really stood out to you. Definitely. Yes.

SPEAKER_02Oh, definitely. Yeah. It's hard to appreciate. Things have changed so hugely in such a short period of time. It's hard to appreciate how recent a lot of things that we, you know, the device you have in your hand, how recent that is. When I was a young lawyer and I was working on this legislation, I would...

write things out on a yellow pad or any memos or any writing committee reports and I'd hand them to a secretary who would type them up in an IBM Selectric typewriter and then we would go back and forth so finally we had a good copy and I could send

SPEAKER_02it off I mean that's how primitive things were then and Obviously, computer technology, I mean, we had the PC and everything by 1993, but you have to remember what we think of as the Internet technology. The Internet itself was created earlier as a DARPA project,

SPEAKER_02but it was basically for academia and the military, and you still had to have the numerical addresses. It was Tim Berners-Lee at CERN in Geneva, the Center for European Nuclear Research, who invented the World Wide Web system. And that year was 1994. So when we started this work, and in fact, one of the first things that President Clinton did is that he set up a...

SPEAKER_02It was a part of this whole policy review process of reviewing... trade policy and industrial policy. And one of the parts of it was to set up something called the National Information Infrastructure Task Force, which was in the Commerce Department. And I was put in charge of

SPEAKER_02developing the intellectual property piece of what became that report. So that's... And if you... I think I have a copy of it. If you look in the back of it, you will find a proposed statute, which is the genesis of the... It's the bones of the Digital Money and Copyright Act.

SPEAKER_02But it also... It worked on both domestically and internationally. So we created this template and then we took it to Geneva, both the WTO and the WIPO. And then that was the genesis of the WIPO project. Yeah, well, yes, all of that.

SPEAKER_02And then, so we were working both internationally and domestically. And so the final domestication domestic legislation for a lot of that was really the WTO implementing legislation. But but we and I started working on that almost immediately, you know, practically from the first day on the job. And that was a process, as I said, it was very collegial.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I was over at the White House regularly and having interagency meetings with my peers in other cabinet departments that had you know other pieces of that for example I mean antitrust it was a piece on antitrust and well the nice thing about it was that I guess that's why I think the administration was very collegial maybe it's because IP was it

was so mysterious to

SPEAKER_02most people that everybody else pretty much did whatever I I didn't get any. I mean, people just basically deferred to me on these other departments and policymakers who did not defer to me and where ultimately you have a statute. that looks quite different from the one in the back of that report is once it gets in the legislative mill and you have all and even in Geneva I

mean the lobbyists get into it and and that's a exceedingly frustrating process but of course you know I was pretty equipped to deal with that too because I'd spent my life up until then

SPEAKER_02with all of those people So when you stepped into that role as USPTO director where all these lobbyists

SPEAKER_01trying to contact you and say, hey, I know you're watching this for a while, but these are the actual issues with the patent system. Anything that kind of stood out to you, what others thought at the time about the patent system?

SPEAKER_02In my career as a policymaker, I guess you could say, I mean, I've always, you know, I believe in openness, transparency, democracy. And so I've always had an open door to any interest group of whatever ilk. Everybody has a right to be heard. And so, yeah, there was just a lot.

SPEAKER_02We had Roundtable, as I recall. Yeah, we had a whole series of hearings. In fact, it's just coming back to me. Oh, yeah, we had a... like Congress has hearings we had a whole series of hearings and roundtables and you know inviting industry people in and academic experts and so on and so forth on a level that was far more You know, extensive and granular than you could do in a congressional hearing. Although,

I will say congressional hearings today are nothing like those when I worked for

SPEAKER_02Bob Castemire on the House Judiciary Committee. I mean, you see these scripted hearings, you know, the five-minute rule, everybody has five minutes. Witness has five minutes. I mean, you're talking about some, you know, mind-boggling statutory change. And, you know, the witness is supposed to, you know, even a cabinet officer has five minutes to talk about it. And then each member of the committee has five minutes to grandstand and it's just a farce.

SPEAKER_02I remember I used to, one thing about Bob Castamire who I worked for who was really a great statesman, this guy, we had a 20 minute rule but he would never stick to it. So we'd get these people that would come in and they would drone on for an hour or more and he would just let them talk. but uh and in fact he I think he had a cast iron rear end I would you know I sat next to him on the dais and I'd have to go to the bathroom

during the hearing he never did and uh and these hearings would go on for hours um but what happens then is that the members of congress actually learned something so that he was a

SPEAKER_02powerful legislator but he he didn't just simply have to rely on me to tell him what to do although he was quite receptive to my suggestions because he actually knew a lot about stuff because he had I mean when you're when you're writing the laws of the country one of the one of the things I can appreciate now which I didn't appreciate then I was so arrogant as this young 29 year old lawyer I mean there wasn't anybody in

the whole country that wouldn't answer my telephone calls or come to my office I mean the most important law professors and business people and so on and so forth so I started

SPEAKER_02you know taking it for granted you know that But, you know, they so you got the information that you needed.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, in your first year, you spoke about, you know, the get strips legislation got passed, which is this international agreement related to international agreement where, you know, panels would be enforceable around the world. And it kind of goes. This goes hand in hand with that pro-patent atmosphere, which you had in Congress, and it seems the Clinton administration also supported that. One thing I guess that started creeping up in the 1990s was this talk about submarine patents.

SPEAKER_01Do you remember when you first heard about that issue? And I guess, what did you think about it at the time? It was a big issue during my tenure and it was very much involved in the debate

SPEAKER_02over going from a first to invent to a first to file system and A lot of people thought that I was very unreasonable. I mean, a lot of the independent inventor community really did not like me because I was so strongly pushing for first defile.

SPEAKER_02And it's not because I... If I personally... were the lawmaker for the world, I would have kept our system, the first to invent system, which I think is the fairer system. But you have to remember that this whole thing was... I mean, the whole vision was we're going to have a new globalized economy and we are going to be at the top of it. And that means we have to have an international set of rules

that you have to

SPEAKER_02negotiate with other companies, the countries, I mean. The issue for the Trump's GAL legislation was really more about the term starting from the

SPEAKER_01grand date versus the filing date, right? Specifically before it was 20 years from... That's correct. Sorry, 70 years from grand date and now we have it 20 years from filing date. That's correct.

SPEAKER_02But that was the international system. All of our trading partners in the other industrialized countries used the other system. And if we wanted to get our way on a lot of this other stuff, we had to... commodate them on some things and that was an absolutely bottom line that was that that they were not going to cave on and and so that's why we ended up

going that route and but one of the arguments for that by the way was to do away with submarine patents I didn't I have to say myself personally I never felt that

SPEAKER_02submarine patents were particularly a problem yeah and you know you talked about Gil Hyatt which you know I got involved with him a little later on I may or may not you know agree with everything but there's no question looking at by the way those files he was not in my view he was completely abused and mistreated Do you remember that?

SPEAKER_01I guess at the time I think it was Jerome Lemelson and Gil Hyatt

SPEAKER_02Hyatt, I had no contact with Hyatt. The one who just was vicious was Lemelson. He spent a lot of money fighting me and also personally attacking me.

SPEAKER_01But do you remember dealing with that when you were USB2 director?

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_01And what was, I guess, internally, what was driving? I knew nothing about Hyatt's thing I knew nothing about his case yeah so at the time I guess internally decisions were made yeah yeah I have to remember the USPTO now has what I think 13 or 14,000 employees it has you know 10,000 examiners I mean

SPEAKER_02the head of the office is not going to be involved in most cases. And the only time I did get involved in individual cases, and I did on a couple of occasions, was where there were major policy or presidential matters. But in terms of interfering with the work and the judgments of

the examining corps,

SPEAKER_02including the senior leaders of it, I basically didn't interfere with their judgment very much.

SPEAKER_01were you surprised when you learned about that story yes I was I was and disappointed I have to say and you know by the way I have the utmost respect for the senior civil servants that I worked for over the years but you know given my where I came from I also that's one reason why going way back to the beginning I

SPEAKER_02didn't want to be a civil servant because I think there is a uh a limit on the decision-making authority of civil servants. In a democratic system, it's ultimately policy decisions have to be made by the political appointee who is, as I said,

there was one person in between me and the president of the United States,

SPEAKER_02and the president of the United States was elected by the people.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's interesting because I guess these civil servants, because of things they must have been hearing about submarine patents, took it on themselves to implement this program where at least Gil Hyatt argues that the director was to issue no more patents. I mean, one other thing that I guess about the story that interests me is how long it's lasted, right? Let's say some civil servants made a mistake, but somebody could have come in over the last 30 years and say, all right,

SPEAKER_01let's resolve this. Well, yeah, I have to say, Mr. Hyatt, I don't think really took my advice.

SPEAKER_02He decided to go a different direction. I see. you know it's funny because I think about that a lot I think about it a little differently because if you're a litigator you know how to litigate right so if you're a hammer you just know how to hammer and that's what you might encourage a client to do even though there might be well you know it's not necessarily black and white I mean I mentioned earlier in this conversation that some of the lawyers that I have the absolutely most respect for in the world are some of these patent litigators who are just like

SPEAKER_02Voice of IP voice. Voice of IP voiceofip but you know uh the case gets settled and that is particularly

true I think today at least in certain fields like I in the last group of cases that I was involved in were cases involving biologics and the legislation that has been passed that sort

SPEAKER_02of mirrors the patent term uh restoration legislation, you know, where you can, the nature of the life sciences, the pharma industry has changed so hugely. There used to be a big, you know, like a great wall between patent-intensive pharma companies and then generic companies. But today, particularly in the area of biologics,

SPEAKER_02you know, you have, and I think that's partly because, and I'm, you know, I'm not the I'm a little weak on the law and technology here now but it's partly because things that give you exclusivity are much weaker than traditional compound patents, for example, on a chemical compound. And so these big pharma companies now are involved.

SPEAKER_02They have generic operations. And even if they don't, I mean, look at the big thing right now semaglutide and you know these I mean look they're like about four different products and they're also they're all basically the same thing but each one of them has its own intellectual property and so what what happens is that is oftentimes they'll end up bringing you see if you bring

a case a patent

SPEAKER_02case that's basically going to nullify a patent.

SPEAKER_01So I want to go back just to the Hyde story. I guess from their standpoint, you know, they went a route of litigation, which has been kind of 30 years. They went up to the Supreme Court one. Now they're back at the Supreme Court. You know, you mentioned the circuit petition, which I guess is almost 2012. So now I guess like almost 14 years later, back at the Supreme Court. And the issue there is about latches. I don't know how much you've kept up with that. I

SPEAKER_02I haven't kept up with that case at all, really. I'm kind of a little bit surprised to know that it's still going.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so we have another cert petition pending right now before the Supreme Court because they're asking the Supreme Court now. They weren't successful at the Federal Circuit, and they're asking the Supreme Court to take a look at that.

SPEAKER_02Well, sure, partitions are pretty hard to win.

SPEAKER_01But they did have one victory at the Supreme Court before, I guess. They did? They did, yeah, because they weren't allowed to present certain evidence to the district court, and they went all the way to the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court ruled 9-0 on their behalf that they were able to introduce some evidence. You know, I just haven't followed it. I didn't. Yeah. This has been a long journey. I mean, are you familiar with the SAUCE program that was created? I mean, you spent a lot of time in government. I'm familiar with it now.

SPEAKER_01I wasn't familiar with it before. Does that surprise you with something like that, like what's created in the government? Some of the people that were involved in that are people that I have a lot of deep respect for.

SPEAKER_02But once I ex post facto was exposed to what happened. I just really would have to say I completely disapprove of the operation they set up, the decision making. And it goes to that point that I made earlier about the division between being a civil servant and being a policymaker. I don't like what has happened there, but, you know,

back during my tenure, you know, PT, you know, reexamination was far more restricted process. And so I wasn't generally that involved in it, but there was one case, as I recall, where

SPEAKER_02Actually, a couple of cases where I really got involved in things that I guess might have been involved litigation. And one of them was, you know, sometimes the extreme right and the extreme left come together. And so you had one of the issues was the whole question of patents on human beings. And so there's this guy,

SPEAKER_02Jeremy Rifkin, I think it was his name, this was a career he built on this, where he was on the crusade that the wicked scientists and pharmaceutical companies were about to create chimeras, where you'd be half human and half, I guess so that you could maybe harvest organs and so on and so forth now I have to say personally I have nothing I have no problem with if you call that a

chimera with with engineering a pig yeah that has a heart that can more easily be trans transplanted

SPEAKER_02into a human I'm all for was the big issue. So they were trying to, they basically tried to set up a test case where, you know, put us in the position where we would you know they could bring this and I forward and I intervened I'm kind of mixing up my different procedures here but one of the very very rare

powers that the head of

SPEAKER_02the office has is is to, you can disapprove of patents on the principle of order public, you know? And I think it might be that case. I intervened and used that. A couple of times I got involved in things that were technically But your director actually did that recently as well They were technically litigation but there was a my opinion important policy question

and one of the there's one thing that really you know gets my juices flowing as I can't stand

SPEAKER_02anti-science I am believer in science and any political position or movement. I mean, science sometimes has to be regulated, but to outlaw areas of scientific endeavor and inquiry and innovation is something that I am, generally speaking, very hostile to.

SPEAKER_01One last question about the Hyatt saga. There's obviously new political leadership at the USPTO. Any advice to them about how they should approach this long-term situation or any thoughts about that, I guess?

SPEAKER_02I don't have any advice for them on that. I do have advice for them, which of course they wouldn't take. And that is that they should stop tormenting the patent core. They should reinstitute... yes they should reinstitute telework and they should bring the by the way I was absolutely tormented by the patent examiner's union so I'm Popa

but they this whole Russell vote agenda you know agenda that they have adopted is just utterly contrary

SPEAKER_02in fact I can't imagine trying to run to actually accomplish the mission of the patent office.

SPEAKER_01And I think they're recognizing that because, I mean, examiners still, most examiners work remotely and they are hiring new examiners. So I think they recognize, I think they announced they need to hire something like a thousand.

SPEAKER_02Well, I just, I want to say one thing about that. You know, the USPTO is, their telework policy is not something that was adopted during COVID the USPTO was the first large organization in the world to adopt telework and that goes back before the internet under Jerry Mossinghoff Reagan's head of

the patent office and

SPEAKER_02I work with him on that and in fact they had to develop a whole special technology to permit electronic you know I'm talking about electronic examination. I'm sorry. Fast forward. It's our regime. It was Al Gore. Al Gore was part of the Reinventing Government initiative.

SPEAKER_02We were selected as a guinea pig organization to test out telework, basically, for our employees. I, at the time, was not particularly enthusiastic about it, but I was a loyal lieutenant, and Gore himself personally was interested in it. would speak to me about it. And so we implemented it. And it was mind-boggling the impact that it had.

SPEAKER_02I would say one of the most difficult, interesting thing about running the Pattern and Trademark Office is that's why I think the dual title is undersecretary of commerce and director of the USPTO is actually quite appropriate because director of the PTO part is you're basically the CEO of an organization. The undersecretary of commerce part is the policy part where you're the advisor to

SPEAKER_02the administration on intellectual property policy issues, including international issues and so on. And so in terms of the administrative piece, I would say the most difficult problem I had, which is always a problem, the problem of patent pendency and keeping up with it and so on. And one of the difficulties we had is that we would have...

SPEAKER_02You know, we would hire new patent examiners out of school. And, you know, it takes three years for them. In fact, as you probably know, you know, and I think there have been issues recently with that. But, you know, you have to of a supervisory patent examiner sign off up until three years. And obviously, it's going to take a junior patent examiner a period of time to really learn the job. And so back then,

SPEAKER_02what we were experiencing is that after three years, the PTO was pretty competitive, particularly after we improved the pay structure Voice of IP voice. You know, then you got ultimately the benefits of all the government, you know, retirement and perks and everything.

SPEAKER_02Then it started to, I mean, you're never going to compete with, you know, senior executive positions in the private sector. You know, more or less just junior, I mean, mid-level tech positions and so on. You know, I think the government's pretty, and the job security, which they used to have, all those things are pretty good. But you get this point at three years where there would start to be this pay differential because, as you know, a patent

examiner can go out and be a patent agent and automatically can register even without taking the exam and so at least that was the case yeah there was anyway so

SPEAKER_02you would get all these people that I remember when I was at Aiken Gump I mean we would hire these people I think we I'm talking 25 years ago we paid them $90,000 a year I think was much more they get in the government and so we were losing people I don't I think I can't say today but as of the end of 2024

SPEAKER_02So we had a third of the employees turned over every year. It was a huge problem. Just when they start to know their job, they left. that turnover rate was down to, I don't know, 4% or 5% as of the end of 2024. Now, I think it's all different now because, you know, Doge came in and fired and tortured people and,

SPEAKER_02you know, all these things. So I don't know where they stand. But that reform of telework transformed everything and you know even the and I don't know how they're handling that but even as you probably know you probably practice if you assume you practice there I mean the the PTAB hearings I mean you'll have the judges will be in different parts of the country the three panels the lawyers

will be in different

SPEAKER_02places and I mean it works beautifully and and to just Well, yeah. Throw that out the window is going to reduce efficiency and quality.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think they're definitely going to keep it to work for examiners, but the PTIP, I guess, I think some people didn't like the judges were remote. So I think they are changing that.

SPEAKER_02Why don't they like that?

SPEAKER_01Because I guess if you're a, let's say you're a patent owner and your patent is about to be invalidated, I felt, some of them felt that it wasn't right. Well, then it doesn't make a difference whether they're sitting in Washington or they're sitting

SPEAKER_02I have to say that after the PTAB got put into, obviously that was after my tenure, but I would go to a lot of these conferences and meetings with them. And I mean, the credentials of some of these people were just amazing. I mean, and I think, you know, compared to but one and one of the reasons I think that you could really attract high level people was because they could they could tell a word yeah and

absolutely and I think that's why we used to kind of knew that they couldn't get rid of the

SPEAKER_01examiner's As we're wrapping it up, I guess one of the things we were discussing before we were recording about all the people that you got to know in the IP world I think you've known every USP2 director except Kathy Vidal One of them you mentioned Judge Pauline Newman Can you just tell us a bit about how did you first meet her? Pauline Newman?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, this goes back to when I was on the Hill It actually goes back to the patent term, the Hatch Waxman Act. And she was a, I think it was the, I don't know if it was the EIPLA or the American Patent Law Association had a little committee and there was a group of three or four corporate patent counsel

SPEAKER_02from and one was from, and they were all really high level people, one was who later became head of the PTO himself, Chief Patent Counsel General Electrical, it's terrible, Harry, Harry, Voice of IP voice.

and she was in that group and so they would come and visit me regularly and I became with her it was more than just I became a personal friend of hers and I remember once she used to have an apartment in she was living in Philadelphia then

SPEAKER_02but she had an apartment in New York in Greenwich Village and a little studio apartment. I remember one time I went up there and I went to her apartment in Greenwich Village and we went out for dinner in the village. She's a tremendously interesting person. When she was a Voice of IP voiceofip

but she is an absolute rock she is as pro-patent as any human being can possibly be and that's why she's been a thorn to a lot of her colleagues because she comes

SPEAKER_02almost without exception down on the side of the patent holder Number one I thought was interesting you crossed paths was John Squires back when

SPEAKER_01he was chief, I guess, chief IP counselor, chief bank counselor, Goldman Sachs. Do you remember? Yeah, well, I didn't, you know, I didn't have anywhere close to the relationship with him.

SPEAKER_02With him, it was just, I believe, I went and talked to him when I was trying to get support for my not-for-profit, and he couldn't have been nicer. But, you know, business... I mean, he was a pioneer in business method patents because he developed a patent program for Goldman Sachs. I mean, people in the financial industry previously never thought in those terms. voice.

SPEAKER_02He was really a leader in that. I can't remember if it was on those issues. Anyway, I visited him in New York a couple of times at his office and he was a really nice guy.

SPEAKER_01I was just curious about, you know, you're retired now, but what, out of all the things you could be doing, what made you choose to get involved in an organization that promotes music?

SPEAKER_02My life has always been associated with the law of creativity, of course, both on the artistic and literary side and the technology side. From just a boy, I have... Voice of IP voice. I left Washington and so I you know went to concerts and operas

and plays and stuff

SPEAKER_02constantly and so now that I don't have to work anymore I don't want to have any pressure at all unlike some people I know who just have to keep going I feel here I live the life of a I'm an 18th century aristocrat like somebody who's living at Versailles and so their day consists of getting ready for the concert or the

theater that they're

SPEAKER_02going to. and I've become involved in Sarasota as a huge performing arts, so I'm involved with the Asolo Repertory Theater and we have an acting conservatory here I'm involved with and then I am past board president of this chamber music organization called

La Musica and under my leadership really we had a it's been going for 40 years but the old maestro was

SPEAKER_02an Italian guy was like uh 90 years old and he basically couldn't come anymore after COVID so we had a big crisis of leadership and we ended up recruiting this woman Wu An who is the director of the Chamber of Music Society of Lincoln Center which so it doesn't get any better than that you know I mean that's the epitome of the world and so now La Musica has become basically you know Lincoln Center in Sarasota

SPEAKER_01Any particular music, you like to listen to, you said classical music, but any piece or anything, composer, you mentioned Mozart, but you like to

SPEAKER_02It's not my favorite at all. I tend to like, well, you know, your taste changed a little bit, but I guess I like, you know, for a long time, I really like what I would call late romantic music like Rachmaninoff. I mean, starting maybe with Brahms, Rachmaninoff. I've developed more of an ear, I think now for 20th century and now music. Oh, that's pretty cool.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for joining Clause 8 and telling part of your story.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for listening. New episodes of Clause 8 come out every two weeks, so be sure not to miss them by subscribing at voiceofip.com or wherever you listen to podcasts. And if you enjoy Clause 8, please leave us a five-star rating to help others find the show.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Companies Miss 95% of Their Inventions

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Austin Walters saw the AI boom coming as an inventor on more than 650 patents. Now the IP Copilot founder explains how companies lose most of what their engineers invent. He spent two years at a major patent filer...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “Nobody Won Until I Won”: Perry Saidman, the Godfather of Design Law

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Perry Saidman passed away on October 15, 2026, less than a month after we recorded this conversation. Perry built the market for design patents. His win in Avia v. LA Gear, a sneaker knockoff case, helped prove design...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Coke Morgan Stewart Tells Her Story

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 41 minAudio

    When Coke Morgan Stewart became acting director of the USPTO, much of the patent world knew little about her. In this episode of Clause 8, Stewart, now President and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP),...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Patent Litigation Really Moves: IAM, IP Fray, and MLex Reporters on the Year in IP

    Sep 29, 202645 minAudio

    To open the season, host Eli Mazour brings together three journalists who cover intellectual property for a living: Olivia Rafferty of IP Fray, Nisha Shetty of IAM, and Inbar Preiss of MLex. They discuss what happens...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Via Eyes "De Facto" Standards for Future Pools

    Jun 2, 202651 minAudio

    Kevin Mack, the new president of Via Licensing Alliance, joins Eli for the Clause 8 season finale. Kevin talks about Via's plans to build its next patent pools around "de facto" standards - technology the market adopted...

    Credit the people on this episode