Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Clause 8

Clause 8 artwork

Coke Morgan Stewart Tells Her Story

Oct 13, 20261 hr 41 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

When Coke Morgan Stewart became acting director of the USPTO, much of the patent world knew little about her. In this episode of Clause 8, Stewart, now President and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP), sits down with host Eli Mazour to tell her own story and explain the how and why behind her decisions. Clause 8 is presented by:Junior AI - Your legal team’s documents, drafted in your team’s style.IP Copilot - Discover, manage, and protect your IP. In this episode: - Her path from English literature to the acting director’s chair, including the video call from a cruise ship where she learned she’d be deputy director - Her father, Judge Henry Coke Morgan Jr., and the $2.75 billion Centripetal v. Cisco judgment the Federal Circuit later vacated - Her first months at the USPTO: the backlog, the hiring freeze, the “fork in the road” offer, return to office and telework - IPR institution, “settled expectations” and repeat challenges, and why she puts the odds of the proposed PTAB rules becoming final at 60/40 - The reported move by Director John Squires to return institution decisions to PTAB panels, and the pros and cons - What she’d do differently, including a workforce council, plus AI and copyright Chapters:00:00:00 Introduction: who is Coke Morgan Stewart?00:13:10 Her father’s patent cases and the Cisco stock controversy00:27:00 Becoming acting director: how she pursued the job00:37:30 The call from a cruise ship00:40:47 Day one: backlog, hiring freeze and DOGE-era turmoil00:51:35 Settled expectations and repeat challenges01:08:13 The proposed PTAB rules and the push for legislation01:17:28 Squires and institution decisions returning to PTAB panels01:33:32 What she’d do differently: a workforce council This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.voiceofip.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02You know, this is like a campaign. I mean, I had no idea how you would even begin to surface your name. I would say 60-40, the rule's going to happen. That's what I would say. Return to office was an absolute mandatory administration priority, no exceptions. Not a single PTOB judge was

SPEAKER_01laid off. Welcome to Clause 8, the number one podcast on intellectual property, presented by IP Copilot and Junior AI.

SPEAKER_00When Koch Morgan-Stewart was named acting director of the USPTO in January 2025, a lot of people in the patent community had the same question. Who is Koch Morgan-Stewart? She actually wasn't new to the patent office at all. She spent 10 years there, including in the solicitor's office and senior roles. But she wasn't someone who spent years building a public profile in the pan community. Then, very quickly, she found herself running the agency at an unusually consequential moment. So I wanted to start before all of that with where she came from, how she ended up back at the USPTO,

SPEAKER_00what actually happened once she was there, how she made some of the decisions that have shaped the pan office since, and what she thinks will happen in the future. Coke Morgan Stewart, welcome finally to Clause 8. Great to be here. So before we get to your time at the patent office, I want to talk a little bit about your background because obviously you kind of jumped out into this scene and some people might not have heard your whole story. So maybe you can tell us how you first got into patent law.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So, you know, one thing that's different for me than many other patent lawyers, I don't have a technical background. And I think a lot back to, believe it or not, when I was in high school and my parents, my brother had been in the military and my parents were really into aptitude testing and doing things. You know, advising people on career change. So my brother had this aptitude testing done and then my sister did it and I did it. And the outcome of the testing, this is when I was 16,

SPEAKER_02was that I should be an engineer or a biomedical engineer, which is kind of interesting. And I was always very interested in math. And I started out in college pre-med. So I was always kind of on the STEM side of things. But over time, and I think it happens to a lot of people, especially in the United States, people get kind of turned off to math and science because the courses are weeder courses. And they're meant to filter people out, which is, I think, a crazy way to run an educational system to try and weed people out of math

SPEAKER_02and science. And I always was getting A's and A-pluses in my English classes, which felt good. So I ended up majoring in English literature.

SPEAKER_00So did you ever consider engineering or...?

SPEAKER_02Well, OK, so another interesting turn after I've been practicing law for a while, I actually was going to leave to go to architecture school. So I applied and was admitted to architecture school and was going to leave the practice of law. I don't know how many years I was in, maybe five or six years.

SPEAKER_00Just like George Costanza.

SPEAKER_02Right. Except for real. Yeah. And I talked to some of my friends who were in home building and design, and they said, if this is one of your passions, just do it. Just buy houses, renovate them. You don't need to become a licensed architect. So that's kind of been a side project of mine. But my point being is I've always been really interested in and comfortable with math and science, despite my degree. And I think it was kind of a natural evolution for me in the law to get into patents.

SPEAKER_00What made you go to law school?

SPEAKER_02My father was a lawyer. I grew up in Southern Virginia. He was a lawyer. He was managing partner of a small regional law firm and then became a judge, actually a federal district court judge in the Eastern District of Virginia. So law, I mean, I just grew up in the law. My sister, who was five years older than me, also went to law school. But I think oftentimes people gravitate towards what's familiar in law. Was that for me?

SPEAKER_00A lot of friends who I grew up with and their parents were lawyers would tell their kids, do anything but be a lawyer. But what did your dad say or what did you get a sense from his?

SPEAKER_02No, I mean, I really grew up, my dad was this huge figure in my life and I saw what he did and Was always very impressed by it. It's very different than big law firms here in like the D.C. metro area. I mean, he was in I don't know exactly how many lawyers were in his firm, but let's say it was like over the years, very between maybe 20 and 50 lawyers, very integrated in the community. He was a civic leader. He was president of the local bar association. He was very involved in politics. We used to have fundraisers at our house.

SPEAKER_02I'm not talking about fancy $200 a plate fundraisers. I'm talking about, you know, pitchers of wine in our living room. You know, people coming in and talking about issues that matter to the community. And so to me, that was incredibly inspiring. I think a lot of people today who maybe grew up in these like ginormous law firms and the billable hours, and I think it's a different experience. And so that kind of gets to the don't, you know, don't go to law school. By the way, my husband...

SPEAKER_02Who is retired now, but is a dentist. And his brother's a doctor. I mean, they all tell their kids, don't be dentists, don't be doctors. So I think it just happens.

SPEAKER_00No, it's funny because I was actually getting dinner with two friends who were patent attorneys. And we were discussing whether we would tell our kids to become patent attorneys. We're like, no. But then we were discussing whether we're happy we became patent attorneys. And we were all very happy we became patent attorneys.

SPEAKER_02It just depends on your kid's personality and skills. I think it's great for a lot of people.

SPEAKER_00So does your dad have a specialty or kind of a focus?

SPEAKER_02He was a civil litigator. He did a lot of kind of different, lots of kinds of different cases. As a judge, he actually handled a lot of patent cases. So that was interesting. And that coincided with my work and getting into patent law. So we had a lot of interesting conversations about that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So we'll get to that. I guess your dad became a judge when you were in college. Is that something you aspired to, I guess, when you first joined?

SPEAKER_02You know, it's funny because my family's always been involved in politics ever since I was a little girl. I mean, I talked about these fundraisers and we were stuffing envelopes and we manned phone banks. And on election night, unlike today, we would go to, you know, the headquarters of the party. And as a little kid, I would write the returns on chalkboards. And so, I mean, I just kind of grew up with that. And then it was always a dream of my father's to become a judge, which, you know, I watched the process.

SPEAKER_02I mean, it was incredibly difficult and involved. People just kind of zoom to the confirmation hearing and they don't realize the years and years of work that lead to that point. So I don't think it's a good thing to have that necessarily part of your professional development plan. I think there are different opportunities in your life where... You know, maybe it's possible, but and, you know, to follow my dad's footsteps would be a really incredible thing to do. But it's it's really so much luck that comes into it.

SPEAKER_02I just want to stay focused on my current job.

SPEAKER_00So then, you know, you said you became a lawyer. You thought about going to architecture school, but you stuck with the patent law thing and then eventually you joined the patent office. How did that happen? And I guess in the solicitor's office, how did that happen? And how's that experience?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I joined the patent office in 2011. So by then I've been practicing law for almost 15 years. I had been practicing patent law for almost 10 years. And I guess the easy answer is I had a little kid. My son at the time was about seven years old. And I I had a very active litigation practice at a big law firm, which was amazing, but also super long hours and going to trial.

SPEAKER_02And I wanted to have something that offered a little bit more balance. And that's really what led me to working at the patent office. And at that time, there were different hiring freezes. And I heard there was an opening and it was kind of a scramble to fill it before there was another hiring freeze. I don't know if this is a government wide thing or an office thing.

SPEAKER_00What was that experience? Obviously, you said you came from like a political family, but now you're kind of joining as a, I want to say, government bureaucrat, but kind of you have to do whatever the administration at the time expects of you. What was it like?

SPEAKER_02It was great. I mean, I loved it. The solicitor's office is a great place to work. I remember coming in, walking from the parking lot into the side entrance of the USPTO. And every day when I cross the threshold in the building, like stop, not literally stopping, but mentally stopping for a minute and just remembering how lucky I was to have that job. Because Appellate litigation is something that's very difficult to build a whole practice around, but that's mostly what the solicitor's office does.

SPEAKER_02I mean, almost entirely what it does. And it was just a, was and is a phenomenal job. I mean, we would post, I remember at the time we would post job postings and get like a hundred people applying for one opening in the solicitor's office and really super impressive, well-credentialed people and Academically and from law firms and clerkships and all that. So it was just a really amazing place to work.

SPEAKER_00Often heard to refer to as the dream job in patent law.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it is one of them.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So what was it like? Obviously, you know, it seems people within the solicitor's office probably had different views of their own on patent issues, but you had to kind of defend whatever the agency decision was. Was that difficult, easy? You know, what was that like?

SPEAKER_02Well, when When I started, coincidentally, we were in the midst of a massive rulemaking effort to implement the AIA. So that was a huge project. The Solicitor's Office was very heavily involved in that. My role is to help with a role on third-party submissions during examination, which was part of the AIA. And of course, we had inter-partice re-examination at that time, and we intervene in every single Interparties re-exam that went to

SPEAKER_02the federal circuit. So we were very active in those cases, which were super interesting. We're obviously defending decisions of the board on appeals from examination. So, you know, most of what the solicitor's office has done in the past are defending rejections by the examiners that have been affirmed by the board that go to the federal circuit.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So the solicitor's office spends most of its time defending unpatentability decisions of the office, the federal circuit. So I think that becomes a little bit of the muscle memory in the solicitor's office. And I think it's healthy that you have that kind of skepticism internally within the office. But I do think it creates a little bit of a culture within the office where they're very focused on rejections. And it's a completely different thing to be Outside the office or in the front office working on patent policy where,

SPEAKER_02you know, you're trying to balance all of these countervailing considerations and not just defending in some cases, and almost always we would be affirmed, rejection decisions of the office.

SPEAKER_00And I guess you get used to winning as well. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, it's a pretty generous appellate standard for the agency, which is helpful. But also, you know, the lawyers are incredibly well qualified and dedicated. And when we handle an appeal, we have a partner, but there's one lead attorney who does the entire thing soup to nuts. I mean, they know that record inside and out. We're given an incredible amount.

SPEAKER_02Brief them in great detail. So it's just an amazing position to be in to really, I mean, unlike anything you can get in private practice,

SPEAKER_00for sure. And just for obviously for those who have been solicited, what is like the interplay between those in solicitor's office and the rest of the agency? Like once you get a case, are you defending whatever you're being asked to position to take or is it kind of like you're providing input on a particular situation?

SPEAKER_02I mean, usually it's just balls and strikes. I mean, most of the cases are simple. I think after the AIA, there were a lot more policy decisions about AIA implementation. And I mean, these cases were going up and down to the Supreme Court on a regular basis. So it was much more policy driven. But the typical cases are more they're not controversial. But the solicitor's office is very involved. Across the office and advising, you know, the PTAB, advising the front office, you know, working on rulemakings and sometimes going to conferences or,

SPEAKER_02you know, giving speeches. So there are a lot of other things that it does as well.

SPEAKER_00So you mentioned your dad coincidentally started handling patent cases in his role as a judge and you'd have a lot of conversations. Anything you remember about those conversations about his view?

SPEAKER_02Well, it's funny because a lot of judges say they don't like patent cases, or that's what I've heard. There are certain judges who like them and certain judges who are happy to hand them off to someone else, and he loved them. So I think because the USPTO is located in the Eastern District of Virginia, and many people don't realize this, but when you file a patent lawsuit in Alexandria, which is outside the D.C. metro area, literally a block from the patent office, those cases go on a wheel. And they're randomly assigned anywhere in the Eastern District of Virginia.

SPEAKER_02So it can go to Richmond. It can go to Norfolk. A lot of people haven't heard of Norfolk. But because of that, you know, he had access to a lot of different patent cases and really enjoyed it. And people in the district knew he liked them. And so I think as a result, he ended up getting even more of them. In terms of just our talking about it, you know, I don't remember anything in particular except his fondness for them. I guess one thing that he said, which made an impression on me, is that, you know, he was a former trial lawyer.

SPEAKER_02And he said that so few cases now go to trial, but patent cases more often go to trial than other types of cases. And he really liked that.

SPEAKER_00You know, obviously, one of the more high profile cases that he handled was the centripetal case. Do you remember that time and kind of seeing all that play out?

SPEAKER_02You know, what I remember from that case at the time, although later I looked back and learned more about it, is that my understanding it was the first trial, live trial that happened during COVID. It was a bench trial. So that's what I remember him talking about, or just the logistics of, like, actually continuing the operations of the court during COVID and having, you know, witnesses testify virtually and I don't know all of the ins and outs, but to me, that was the biggest impression on me.

SPEAKER_02Of course, there were other events that happened later in the trial that became more prominent, but that was my initial impression.

SPEAKER_00You know, the reason I guess I'm curious to ask you about the case is the story about it that everybody knows is that your mom, I guess, on some Cisco stock, the trial came out in favor of centripetal, and then the federal circuit thought it was somehow unfair. From like a layman's perspective, it seemed like a ridiculous decision. Do you remember your reaction? And I guess maybe, you know, your job was kind of dealing with the federal circuit, and I'm sure you had a lot of admiration and respect for what they did, and then seeing that happen with that.

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, to be honest, my initial reaction was just incredible frustration with my mother Because she's in her late 80s, mid-late 80s, and she's like trading stocks all the time, which I have thought is ridiculous for a long time. Although I understand in this case the stock was recommended to her by her broker. So what happened was, you know, if you work in the government or you're a judge, you have to do financial disclosures and you have to disclose,

SPEAKER_02you know, all of your investments and things like that. So I think that's how my dad first found out about it. Which I think the trial was totally over and he had almost finished writing the decision. So at that point, it was kind of in a rock and a hard place because if he knew he was going to rule against Cisco and he sold the stock, even though we were talking about less than $5,000, if he sold the stock, then it looks like, oh, I'm trying to dump the stock before I issue, you know, an opinion that's fines against Cisco. So that's a bad look.

SPEAKER_02And if I Keep the stock, then I'm kind of maintaining a potential financial conflict. So that's a problem. So what he did was he put the stock in a blind trust. So it was completely up to somebody removed from him what to do with it, you know, to sell it or to keep it or whatever. And there's federal, there's a statute that talks about this and talks about conflicts and conflicts. You know, the question is, what is a financial conflict? Is there a de minimis conflict? Amount of financial interest.

SPEAKER_02I was thinking about this a couple days ago and I thought less than $5,000. I mean, I think about all of the things inside your home, your television, your washer and dryer or your car or all different kinds of financial interests that we have in publicly traded companies outside of stock. And if the limit is going to be $5,000 or less, Of course, we're talking about stocks versus actual assets. Well, I think that's interesting because

SPEAKER_00if you're using the internet, you might be using the networking equipment.

SPEAKER_02Right. And so if you go down this road of saying that conflicts of this nature result in a lot of work being vacated, whether it's by a judge or an agency, I think it's kind of an untenable line to draw. But I also understand that Brightline rules are easier to implement. The court could have said, okay, we find A conflict that was more of the first issue, but then, you know, what's the remedy? And the remedy could have been that it wasn't a substantial issue in the case

SPEAKER_02that affected the case. But the problem was that the verdict was then, I believe, the highest patent infringement verdict that any court had ever found. Over a billion dollars. It was almost $3 billion because of willfulness. And the combination, I think, of the, you know, the potential financial conflict of Plus, this super high damages award brought an incredible amount of attention on the case, brought in a lot of lawyers, appellate lawyers. Bill Lee was working on the case, among others.

SPEAKER_00Bill Lee from Wilmer Hill, the Apple attorney.

SPEAKER_02Yes, a very well-known appellate advocate. So, you know, all this attention was now brought into this case where there was this, relatively speaking, very small financial issue involved. So the case ended up being totally vacated and sent back. And by that time, my father had passed away and it was assigned to a new judge who had been on the bench for a little over a year now. And again, I think it was a bench trial. And ultimately, that judge decided that there was an infringement.

SPEAKER_02So to me, the takeaway from the case is more just the unpredictability of patent litigation and what we can do to make it more predictable in that case. But yeah, it's a wild case. There are obviously like PTAB portions of the case as well. That were indirectly affected by some of that, but it's very interesting.

SPEAKER_00Did it change your view of how the federal circuit might, or no?

SPEAKER_02I mean, the statute that they were interpreting is pretty, is what it is, right? And the question is, we're all lawyers, right? So can you say if something is de minimis, is it really a financial interest? So that's the first question to cross. But once you find it's a financial interest, then the question is, like, did it affect the outcome? I don't think it did. But when you're talking about a $3 billion verdict, if the court is going to err on the side of, you know, wanting a absolutely clean record, I mean, judges are human, too.

SPEAKER_02In fact, there was a study, I think, that came out in 2025 saying that the federal circuit, I believe, has... founds one or another error in almost every case where the damages have been over $500 million. And I think those cases naturally draw more scrutiny. But, you know, part of the frustration, I think, on the patent owner side is it almost suggests the more infringement there is, the harder it is to sustain an outcome. And that doesn't make sense.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I mean, the standard that the judges should decide on shouldn't be based on the amount of the verdict, right? Unless I'm missing something I defer to you.

SPEAKER_02No, but I mean, I mean, look at the case about like these poor children, you know, who were killed by their mother. I mean, any high profile case brings out emotion in people, brings out a lot of concern and like draws in policy considerations. And, you know, one of the benefits of our system is a human based system. Right. And, you know, people have concerns and and bigger verdicts bring more scrutiny. Right.

SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, there's a theory that obviously, which I think I'm guessing the study hints at is that when it is a bigger verdict, then the judges are looking for something to kind of bring it down to size, I guess. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't think intentionally, but I do think that more important cases, controversial cases, large verdicts tend to bring more scrutiny. I think they have more briefing. You bring in more sophisticated attorneys. So it's just a completely at that level of The appellate experience is completely different. I don't think I would ever say that any judge at the district court or the federal circuit or Supreme Court level like intentionally is looking to drive an outcome, like look for errors to drive an outcome.

SPEAKER_02But I think people are humans. And the more controversial the case and the bigger the damages verdict, then I think the more room there is for people to get concerned.

SPEAKER_00You know, you mentioned that every day you walked into the solicitor's office, you felt how fortunate you were, but eventually you went to work for the front office in various capacities. I guess, can you tell us about that and how's that experience?

SPEAKER_02Sure. So it's nice. It's not unusual for attorneys from the solicitor's office to go on detail, what they call detail, to the front office because the political team comes in at different times and they have different skill sets. So they're supplemented by career attorneys and not necessarily attorneys, could be anyone. So some people may remember that Jamie Simpson was on detail to the front office working for Director Lee under the Obama administration.

SPEAKER_02Director Lee stayed over. She didn't have a political team. I mean, everybody resigns, you know, at the strike of 12 when the new administration comes in, if not earlier. So she started to kind of fill out the team with some career people to support her until the political people came in. And I was one of the first people. So that's how I first went to the front office, which was, you know, kind of a crazy time for other reasons, because political transitions are always really interesting.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I didn't realize, but obviously nobody knew if Director Lee would stay on or not stay on. And so there was some careers. So that was an interesting time to join. I guess, how was that whole experience working in the front office? And then did you have any takeaways about the patent system or the patent office from your career there, I guess, first time around?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, it's a very different experience working in the front office because now you're talking about office policy and Interestingly, I told you when I started in 2011, it was all about AIA implementation. By the time I was working in the front office under Director Lee, AIA was also like a major topic because people were talking about implementation and abuse and harassment and the new administration and needing to make changes. So that was a really big focus of that period of time when I worked for Director Lee.

SPEAKER_02Ultimately, she ended up leaving and And then we had, you know, someone who on an interim basis performing the functions and duties and then Director Yonkou came in. So during that interim period, I went back to the solicitor's office. And then many people know Ben Haber, who was supporting Director Yonkou. He worked for a year. And he had come over with Andre to the office. He left and then I backfilled Ben Haber's position. That's how I ended up going back to the office. And then I ended up working with Andre throughout the rest of his term.

SPEAKER_02And then I worked as acting deputy for Drew Hirschfeld. So that was a pretty substantial period of time where I was in the front office working mostly on major legal cases and policy and PTAB issues.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So it's interesting, obviously, you were there for the beginning of the AIA, and then you were there with, I guess, Andre Iancu. He recognized maybe it's gone too far, and he was trying to rein in some of the accesses. But apart from that, do you have any thoughts about the U.S. PAN office as an institution or the PAN system as a whole, where it was in, like, 2021 when you were leaving, I guess?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I thought that we were starting to make a turn to kind of restoring more balance, especially with the PTAP proceedings. I mean, Andre loves to talk about the teeter-totter and how you are trying to maintain that balance. And if you do too much in one direction or the other, it's bad for the system. You know, we had tried to put through like an omnibus rule package before he left that kind of covered... A lot of the operational changes that had been made while he was at the office.

SPEAKER_02And I think we just ran out of time to get that through. And like today, there's some opposition.

SPEAKER_00Did you think that was going to be the case at the time? Like there's probably not going to be enough time for the rules package?

SPEAKER_02You know, I just I was funny. I was talking to an in-house attorney last week and they said, you know, why don't if you got why don't you guys just put out rules and not do all this discretion? And the person didn't understand that, you know, putting out a rule can take anywhere from 12 to 24 months, which is, you know, can be a good thing because there's a lot of public input to the rules. But it's not something the office can just do. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And it's possible that rule will never become a rule.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. That often happens.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know, you, and we'll get back to that, obviously, with the new proposed rule. But I want to talk about, obviously, how you became the acting director this time around. I guess, when did you start thinking about you might have an opportunity to do that? And I guess, why were you interested?

SPEAKER_02So I had never been a political appointee. I had always been a career government official. And after I left... I helped support Drew Hirschfeld during the transition from Trump to Biden. And so I did that for almost a year. And then I was teaching. And then very unexpectedly in Virginia, the Republican slate swept all three statewide offices. So Glenn Youngkin, one governor, Winsome. Earl Sears won the lieutenant governor, and Jason Meares won the AG.

SPEAKER_02And at that time, I was teaching at Regent Law School in Virginia Beach, where I grew up. And so there was an immediate need, kind of like Trump won, like we need lawyers, right? And I know this woman who has been working in government for 10 years, and she knows public lawyering. And so I kind of got swept into that, and I ended up being deputy attorney general for One of the deputy attorney generals for the state of Virginia serving under Jason Miara. So that was my first political appointment.

SPEAKER_02And as we talked a little bit about my family history, it always been kind of something happening in the background for me. So I think that was kind of the first time I started thinking more about political appointments. And then with a staggered election.

SPEAKER_00I'm just curious, how was that experience? Obviously, you had a... Very different responsibilities than dealing with patents. How is it like dealing with non-patent issues after your...

SPEAKER_02Well, that was in the middle of COVID. So it was like every controversial issue you can imagine. My portfolio was health, education, social services, and child support enforcement. So we were working on vaccine mandates and masking and school reopening and what was happening at the Virginia... State colleges, not just in terms of COVID, but, you know, education policy and instruction. It was very exciting. I will say there's actually a lot of overlap because ultimately most

SPEAKER_02of those issues are governed by federal regulatory regimes and statutory regimes. And the principles are the same. So that was super interesting. And so I stayed doing that for almost two years. Then someone had an extra ticket to go to the Republican Convention in Milwaukee. And I had never been. And it was very fun.

SPEAKER_00Do you want to think who it was or you don't know?

SPEAKER_02Well, let's not say.

SPEAKER_00Was it a friend or a... Yeah, a friend.

SPEAKER_02It was a friend. And I remember thinking to myself at the time because it just, it was going to be a lot of money, right? You had plane tickets and hotel. And, you know, at the time I was at a Melbourneese, so it was taking time away from work and my family to go to this convention. I'm so glad I went. It was amazing and very... It was inspirational, but also sad that the convention happened right after the president was shot in Butler. So the vibe of the convention was like euphoric.

SPEAKER_02I mean, normally the candidate comes in the last day of the convention, but because of President Trump and the whole situation with the attempted assassination, he came immediately. And so everyone was so happy that he was healthy and he was able to appear and he talked. And I had a friend who was working, helping to get in the green room, getting the speakers ready. And I got a backstage tour and I was able to meet, you know, a lot of elected officials and hear policy speeches.

SPEAKER_02And J.D. Vance hadn't been announced. And the first person I saw when I went to Milwaukee was J.D. Vance walking around Milwaukee with his kids in the Secret Service. So it was just so... For someone who's interested in politics, it was really exciting, really exciting time for me. And then to hear all the policy speeches. And of course, I saw some friends from Trump One who were at the convention, like Jason Clark was there. He was with the California delegation. I saw Chris Shipp there.

SPEAKER_02He was the state director for the president's campaign the first time around. Andre Yonkou was there. Just a lot of different people. You know, my old friends and colleagues from my patent office experience. And then, you know, there was some discussion about who the next director might be. And I remember talking to Andre about it and he said, you know, this is like a campaign. Like you have you don't just get it's not like someone says, oh, you would be qualified. Let's talk to you. I mean, you have to.

SPEAKER_02Really put your name out there. And I remember thinking to myself, well, like this is never going to happen. I mean, because yes, of course, I had served in this position in Virginia, but I didn't have any like immediate ties to the president or something like that or someone to call me. I mean, I had no idea how you would even begin to surface your name. There isn't like an application you can submit. But over time, just little things started happening, like people connected to the campaign and So did Andre

SPEAKER_00give you advice about how to run that campaign?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it wasn't so much that he was giving me advice about how to run it. He was just kind of stating, like, this is how it works. There's one position, right? There's the director position and, you know, in my case, the deputy director position. So it isn't like, oh, I want to go to DOJ or I want to go to White House Counsel's Office. I mean, there are not that many IP positions that are appointments. In the government. So, you know, I just started to kind of talk to people who were active one way or the other, might know somebody. And my goal was really just to get an interview.

SPEAKER_02And I thought that was going to be a win if I could just be interviewed. And frankly, I think that almost didn't happen because it was just so much happening with the transition and all the like The personnel decisions that were being made and you were seeing on the news how like people were flying down to Mar-a-Lago and meeting with the president and shaking their hand. I mean, I did not meet with the president, but I did interview with Howard Ludnick. I was able to get an interview, which was super interesting experience.

SPEAKER_02And I didn't know how long it would be. We ended up almost talking for an hour, which was huge. And he had a lot of ideas. He was very excited about the patent system. And I think we just hit it off and I was very fortunate. And then you have to interview with presidential personnel, which is like a completely different thing and has nothing to do with patent law. It's just more about the president's vision and whether you align with that. And at that point, I knew like there was a chance or there was a chance I could get an appointment in the administration for the PTO of some sort. So that's kind of the short story of how it happened.

SPEAKER_00You know, you wrote an article, I guess, as part of that process in August 2024, kind of envisioning what the second Trump administration might do on IP issues.

SPEAKER_02I wrote that in the hotel lobby at the convention. I was just like, because that's what everyone was talking about is what is the next administration going to be like? And I just sat down and I wrote it on my phone. And I remember showing it to Chris Shipp and a couple other people and saying, and then saying, like, I want to somehow get this published.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know, it wasn't, I guess, at least my reading of the article is pretty balanced. Not like they're going to completely undo whatever happened and whatever. It seemed like you were suggesting that the next Trump administration was going to bring balance to the IP system.

SPEAKER_02Well, this was after, remember, the other huge white paper that came out and the president disavowed it. So I didn't. It was in the top of my mind that it would be—

SPEAKER_00The white paper for the whole administration.

SPEAKER_02Yes, for the whole administration. So, I mean, the last thing I wanted to do was, like, tell the president what he should do on IP policy. So it was more just reading the tea leaves and guessing what the possibilities were, not my saying what he should do. Because I, you know, I think obviously that doesn't go over well with this administration.

SPEAKER_00What made you think that would be the approach or the—

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I think the administration is very focused on property rights, for one thing. That's, you know, a typical conservative position. Of course, you know, having worked in the front office under Trump One and under Andre's leadership, there was, you know, more or less consensus that the PTAP proceedings needed to be more balanced. And then the president constantly talking about, like, the forgotten men and women and, you know, bringing back manufacturing. And those are kind of A lot of the core issues that go to the foundation of

SPEAKER_02the patent system and the purpose for it. And typically, or at least it was in the Obama administration, is large technology companies were a little bit more aligned in the Obama administration. And so as you change from administration to administration, usually there's going to be policy changes. And most of the time, there's a change from... From when the party changes, even though patent issues are bipartisan and some of our biggest champions,

SPEAKER_02you know, are on both sides of the aisle and from both chambers. But I mean, to me, it just seemed natural that there was going to be a change. And then also given now Secretary Ludnik's role in the campaign and his experience with patents, it just didn't seem like.

SPEAKER_00He had transitions at the time.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. He was helping to head the whole transition. So it just didn't seem like. Given the experience of Trump One, plus Secretary Ludnik, plus the differences, you know, in kind of the sector alignment between administration to administration, that there wasn't there was going to be a change.

SPEAKER_00I'm just curious, like when you're going through that interview process, were you asked about your views about specific policy things or is it more like how would you kind of approach the role once you had it?

SPEAKER_02Well, one thing you do when you come in for an interview, the very first thing you do is you sign an NDA.

SPEAKER_00I don't want to get you in trouble.

SPEAKER_02So we don't talk about the interview specifically, but I will say that, you know, now Secretary Ludnick was very knowledgeable and passionate about the patent office. And I think that distinguishes him probably from many secretaries. I mean, certainly if you go back to the founding of our country, you had a lot of people passionate about patents, but in modern history, probably not at the cabinet level.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I mean, he's obtained 400 U.S. patents.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think it's over 500 now. Yeah, so...

SPEAKER_00Pretty impressive track record of relying on pan-systems. It's obviously had a big impact on his life as well. So when did you find out that you were chosen, if that's not under ND?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I remember. I'm a big cruiser. People who know me well know me. I like to know that I like to cruise. So I got a call from the secretary's scheduler saying that he wanted to talk to me. So I thought, like, this is it.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to find out

SPEAKER_02something. One way or the other. And so I remember having another video conference with him. I think he was in his car and I was on the cruise ship. Fortunately, I had a good internet connection.

SPEAKER_00It always happens when you don't have internet connection.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, right. We talked again for another hour. We went through so many different issues and his vision, everything he wanted to do. And like right at the end of the conversation, he said, and I want you to be deputy director. And I thought there was a chance I could be selected as director. And I think there was a chance. But for me... One of the things he valued was my knowledge of the office, that I'd worked there for 10 years. And I think his vision is he really wanted someone to, like, run the office and do, like, the day-to-day things and come in on day one.

SPEAKER_02So on that call, he said, we're going to New York. We're going to meet. We're going to start planning our beachhead team and everything. I want you to be with me and the team in New York next week. Okay. So I was on a cruise ship. Still working at O'Melveny, and it was the middle of winter, so I had no clothes. I flew from Houston to, I think it was Newark. I got an Uber from the airport.

SPEAKER_00I was going to ask you if I picked you up in a helicopter, but... No,

SPEAKER_02no, no, no. Now, I got an Uber from the airport. I stopped at Nordstrom on the way to the hotel. I bought two or three days worth of clothing because it was freezing cold in New York. I had no clothes. And we had meetings in New York, like planning meetings for the department. And it was amazing. Jameson Greer was there. The secretary was there. Some of his senior leadership team, William Kimmett, Jeff Kessler. Cooper Godfrey, just a lot of people who would ultimately become part of his core team.

SPEAKER_02And it was super inspiring. And I did get to fly on the secretary's jet from New York to DC. He was flying down. And that was an incredible experience. And got, for part of the flight, got to sit with the secretary and talk to him more about IP. So these are pretty exciting times for me. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Companies are constantly innovating, but capturing those ideas and deciding which are worth protecting can be difficult. IP Copilot uses AI to uncover potential inventions in the tools teams already use. It connects those ideas, invention How do you plan for, like, what you're going to do once the transition happens? How does that, uh,

[music]

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I had lots of plans. I had a legal pad with all these notes and different policy and operational issues. But I mean, the main thing that happened when I started was we had a backlog issue, which is a major problem. That's all people were talking about at that point. The secretary testified about it in his confirmation hearing. He said it was unacceptable. So that was an immediate operational issue we had to deal with. And then As it happens in any administration,

SPEAKER_02usually the first thing that, you know, the president starts signing executive orders and the very first thing that happens is there's a hiring freeze. So all regulatory activity stops, all hiring stops on like day one. And then, you know, with DOGE and, you know, the then acting leadership with OPM, I mean, it was just workforce stuff every day. So it was like backlog and workforce. You weren't even like really... Immediately able to deal with a lot of the other policy issues because it was just totally operational.

SPEAKER_00And did you expect it coming in or that's not something you could have?

SPEAKER_02I expected the hiring freeze, but how it's implemented. I mean, people don't realize we had outstanding offers that had to be rescinded. We had we had start dates that people had that had to be rescinded. And, you know, everyone said, well, the patent office is different and, you know, we're not taxpayer funded. Well, I mean, you're talking about like a huge administrative apparatus. I mean, it's not you can't on day one, you can't just like pick you don't even know who's working in certain parts the administration. You can't just pick up the phone and say USPTO is different.

SPEAKER_02I will say, you know, despite of like all of that and how difficult it was, I'm very proud. The credit really goes to the secretary that we're We were like the only agency outside of first responders in the military to get a huge hiring exception. We got a hiring exception to hire 1,200 patent and trademark examiners very early in the administration. So, I mean, to me, there were a lot of challenges and it was very stressful. But at the same time, USPTO was a huge winner in that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, it's easy to forget those times, but nobody expected that, I guess.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and every day, you know, there would be memos coming out from OPM saying, you know, at 2 o'clock in the afternoon, it would say at 5 o'clock in the afternoon, you need to send this message to your workforce. You know, or like the message that came out about the fork in the road email and the severance packages, we had no notice of that. And then all of a sudden, every single solitary member of the USPTO workforce and the entire federal workforce Except for, I think, again, like some very limited categories in the military and things like

SPEAKER_02that were basically given a severance package. Right. And I mean, it was a great deal for some people. Eight months of, you know, fully paid health insurance benefits. You were allowed to work on top of the severance package that you got. And a lot of people took it. I mean, over 300 examiners took it. We had several senior executives. Who took the fork? And, you know, that was kind of what it was like. I mean, you never knew what was going to happen day to day with respect to the workforce.

SPEAKER_02And it took a, you know, we were working the phones and we were fighting hard to distinguish USPTO from the rest of the federal government. But, you know, it was just a very active kind of tumultuous time, I would say.

SPEAKER_00So like one of these directives comes from OPM. Then the next thing you have to do is kind of contact the secretary to say we should get an exception for this because of.

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, and initially he like he hadn't he wasn't even the secretary yet. Right. So, you know, he was going through his confirmation process. So there you you didn't have a secretary to call. You had an acting secretary who was a career senior official in the department. We knew people in the administration and we were talking to OPM and we were talking to different people. We were making our case. And I think We were making great progress and ultimately did, but this wasn't the kind of thing that was going to happen, like, overnight.

SPEAKER_02It took some time.

SPEAKER_00Well, you know, it's interesting, obviously, you were able to keep, I don't think any examiners or APGA judges were laid off.

SPEAKER_02That's a commonly misunderstood fact, which is a lot of people think that judges, and particularly PTAB judges, were laid off. Not a single PTAB judge was laid off. Even probationary PTAB judges were not laid off, while some probationary employees were separated involuntarily. Less than 100 people. And I know it's very significant to them. But there are a lot of different processes for separating probationary employees.

SPEAKER_02But no, not a single judge was separated involuntarily. Of course, the judges were offered the work. The judges were offered, you know, different one-time payments and early retirement programs. I think there was also a lot of concern that the judges, regardless of where they live in the United States, were going to have to come into the office full time. So a lot of judges started looking for jobs. So ultimately, a large number of judges did end up leaving, but it wasn't because that they were told to.

SPEAKER_00How did you think through that? Because obviously at that point, I'm assuming you thought maybe the PTAB was out of balance. Did you think maybe the new blood would be good, especially if some judges left?

SPEAKER_02Well, there was no new blood because we weren't hiring. Right. I mean, some judges were leaving. No, I don't think it was like that. I think there were different policy issues. Provisions to implement. I mean, the secretary had a vision of some of the policy reforms he wanted to make for PTAB. So my job was to translate that vision operationally. And, you know, one early thing was taking the discretionary portion of the institution decision back to the front office as the statute provides.

SPEAKER_02So there's a lot of discussion of, you know, what the office is doing, whether it's consistent with the statute. But the statute specifically says that the director makes the institution decision. And, you know, from a policy, political appointee policymaker provision position, it just didn't seem fair or appropriate to put the judges in the position, you know, hundreds of different judges across districts. You know, hundreds of cases to be deciding, you know, policy calls for the new administration, nor do I think they like doing it.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I think they want to focus on the merits of the case and not on, you know, applying these multi-factor tests and writing very long decisions about, you know, how to implement that. So, you know, that was the first big change.

SPEAKER_00You know, we'll get some more of that stuff, but the other thing I guess you were able to keep in place was telework for examiners, which I thought actually was the people were much more skeptical that would be able to happen. I mean, how did you convince that?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, so there was a huge return to office effort, but one major exemption from it was were collective bargaining agreements. Yeah. When the president issued his executive order about return to office, there was a huge asterisk at the bottom, and it referred to provisions of collective bargaining agreements. So the PTO historically has been a very heavily unionized workforce. A lot of the CBAs had telework provisions in them. So the examiners were immediately exempted because of that.

SPEAKER_02So the question is, what do we do about the new examiners? The examiners are on probation. And then also a question of even if something's in an agreement, sometimes it's a management right. So those are the kinds of questions we were starting to balance. Now, in the early days, I mean, they were talking about putting tables in the hallways of the Department of Commerce and like putting people in the auditorium, like return to office was a mandatory process. Absolute mandatory administration priority, no exceptions.

SPEAKER_02I mean, people were being put in empty office buildings across the United States, like any place where there is federal space. If you lived in that city, you were returning to office and there was discussion about our actually renting office space. You know, it was COVID, right? So there's a lot of office space available. The PTO is going to be spending its operating reserves, renting office space, having everybody come back to the office. And, you know, there were different phases of that implementation. So the part of the workforce that was most effective was were those people

SPEAKER_02within 50 miles or those people who were near a regional office and had an office there. But as time went by, it was clear that it was just not realistic to be management right or not, bringing examiners and judges who lived across the United States Into physical offices where they may not even be working with people from the USPTO. So that was definitely a place where, you know, we, I think, successfully held the line that that just didn't make sense for our type

SPEAKER_02of workforce. I mean, to literally rent office space for people to work in where they weren't going to be with people from the USPTO.

SPEAKER_00One thing you did change is that for new examiners who are being trained, I think they did start within the offices. I mean, how did you think that issue through? Because obviously you talked to some people who were examiners a long time ago and they're like, back when I started, I could walk down the hall and I could discuss the case. But obviously there's a lot, you know, there's a lot of advantages to the telework and it's worked, I think, relatively successfully with patent office. But how did you think through that balance?

SPEAKER_02During COVID, the attrition rate for new examiners went to the highest level the agency's ever seen, almost 40%. And so we looked at that and said, well, what were the characteristics of that onboarding program? So people were hired remotely. They were trained remotely. They didn't spend any time in the office. And so It was certainly understandable during a period of COVID that it had to be that way, but then it remained that way. So that was something that we felt like had to be fixed. We wanted examiners to go back a little bit to the old,

SPEAKER_02not even not so old days of being in the office during a significant portion of their probationary period. So they can meet people and learn the office culture and be around the leadership team and have mentors and all of that. And we thought it would improve attrition and increase patent quality. I mean, time will tell. Whether, in fact, that's happened and then, you know, come up with like a more phased telework program, again, similar to to maybe how it was done some years ago. Now, I mean, prior to approximately 2006, people didn't even work remotely.

SPEAKER_02So it's still a relatively new thing, even for USPTO.

SPEAKER_00Going back to the institutions, you're taking over that. I don't know if you call it a doctrine approach that you're famously associated with is settled expectations. I don't know what you call it.

SPEAKER_02Everybody's favorite discretionary consideration.

SPEAKER_00How did you come up with that concept?

SPEAKER_02So, I mean, it came from, again, I think sometimes we're so used to a particular process that we kind of lose our orientation. So people in this, obviously, the Supreme Court-issued decision saying that the director... May institute and therefore has discretion not to institute. So that was something that was established relatively early on. But the way it was set up initially was the burden was entirely on the patent owner defending the petition to explain why the director shouldn't exercise his or her discretion to institute.

SPEAKER_02And if you step back for a minute, why is it entirely on the patent owner to say why? I mean, you're already kind of playing defense on So like the presumption is institution and then the patent owner has to explain why there shouldn't be institution. And so in looking at that, it was really kind of back to that principle, you know, that Andre's always talked about is balance. So both sides should have to explain, you know, why there shouldn't be a balance. AIA trial and why there should be an AIA trial.

SPEAKER_02And the only way to really get at this why there should is to try and take into account some of the reliance interests that the patent owners, well, not the only way, but one way was to think about their reliance interests. Also, the AIA has a provision in it that says that the office in promulgating regulation should take into account economic factors and the integrity of the patent system. And so it seems natural if you want to take into account like real world considerations like the economy and the patent system,

SPEAKER_02you'll take into account, you know, how long the patent has been enforced and is it being enforced and has it been commercialized and, you know, how many times it's been challenged and all these kind of real world issues that people rely on and trying to, you know, build businesses and hire people. So, You know, whatever you call it, like taking into account reliance, interest or settled expectations or whatever, I think to me is less important than we can't.

SPEAKER_02This isn't an academic exercise. I mean, these are real world assets that people build businesses on that people, you know. Research intensive industries license these rights. And I think the office and the courts can get very removed from that, those real world considerations. And we were just trying to bring that back as one of many factors to think about.

SPEAKER_00And did you think, correct me if I'm wrong, but one of the goals was to reduce the number of PTAP proceedings instituted for patents being challenged.

SPEAKER_02I don't think that was one of the goals. And I mean, people might scoff at that, but I remember, you know, Director Squires, for example, this has always stuck with me, what he said was like, He loves movies and he would always use analogies for movies. And he was talking about the movie Amadeus when there was a dispute about what he was writing. And one of the criticisms was there were too many notes. And it was like, what do you mean too many notes? They're just whatever notes are appropriate for that circumstance.

SPEAKER_02And that analogy is something that director Squires used a lot to say there isn't like a perfect right or wrong number. The idea is to stabilize the system. So if people are going to respond to the considerations and file different kind of petitions, then maybe the number of petitions will go up or stay stable. But if people are just going to keep filing routine positions, routine petitions that, you know, don't really You know, address important questions or deal with serious office errors or whatever else

SPEAKER_02the issue might be in the case, then, yeah, the number is going to go down. But it wasn't like, OK, we want the number to go down. How do we make it go down? It was not that.

SPEAKER_00I mean, to me, I guess, looking at the decisions that you were writing for institutions, at least to me, it seemed like there was an effort to kind of make it seem like there's a balance. Like some decisions were like, depending on who the defendant is, there might not be settled expectations depending on how clear the error is. That might be another factor.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, you can't say there's settled expectations if the office made a mistake. Or if there's been a big change in the law. But I mean, getting back to the original intent of the statute, I mean, initial estimates were there might be somewhere around 400 to 500 petitions a year. And it quickly went up to more than triple that number, like in some years, almost 1700 or more petitions. So, I mean, if there were was any intent to try and kind of right size it. It really was to get back to what was the original purpose of the AIA.

SPEAKER_02It was to address so-called bad patents. Not every patent the office issued, not every patent that's litigated in district court, but like patents where there were like significant problems and office errors and change in the law. And, you know, I think that's what we were trying to get at with these factors, which is like, let's be a little bit more discriminating on the kinds of cases we take so that it's not just You know, we're issuing the patents on one side of the building and then we're taking them back on the other and invalidating them.

SPEAKER_00But I guess taking a step back, maybe not exactly what the law is, but do you think it'd be better to have a bright line rule, like maybe something they have in Europe or where do you have Postgram review where, you know, you can challenge patents for this number of years and that's the rule. You know, nobody's arguing about the discretion or not. It's kind of a bright line rule.

SPEAKER_02That would definitely be better. I mean, definitely having, you know, new legislation that says, I think the whole point of the AA was kind of like a funnel, right? There was the third party submissions we talked about. So like ARC could come in early for a lot of reasons. People don't do that. And then the PGR window is a first nine months. There are more statutory considerations in place. And then that window gets narrower for the, you know, for IPR challenges. The problem is Like all that stuff was just left unaddressed.

SPEAKER_02So, yeah, I mean, I think we should have challenges maybe for the first year, you know, like come one, come all and challenge, you know, the patents. And then, you know, once things settle down, if you want to bring a challenge outside of reexamination, by the way, which is almost always available, if you want to bring this special kind of expedited challenge, then, you know, make your case as to why it's appropriate.

SPEAKER_01As opposed to

SPEAKER_02just pushing them all through.

SPEAKER_00You know, one of the things that you talked when you were acting director is maybe obviousness or one of three has gotten a bit out of control. And that's kind of in combination with what PTAB is doing. So you kind of, do you think that's part of it? Why kind of the PTAB became much more active in validating patents than anticipated? Do you think?

SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't think it's just the PTAB. I mean, of course, in district court, there's a higher standard, clear and convincing. But I mean, the whole system is basically set up to Question the patent grants that the office issued. Obviousness is a major problem. It's very subjective, you know, very, very subject to hindsight bias. And then you have these super low standards for reexamination and AIA cases before the office. So I really I mean, it is what it is.

SPEAKER_02And obviously where you interpret the statutes literally. But I do not believe it was ever the intent of Congress to. Create mechanisms to bring back every single issued patent for a potential, you know, redo before the office anytime someone is like trying to enforce it or license it. I mean, if that's how it was explained, if if it were explained that way to members of Congress, they never would have voted for something like that because it doesn't make any sense.

SPEAKER_02I mean, it is inconsistent with other provisions of the law, like the presumption of validity in the clear and convincing standard in court.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I think the point you made many times was if you do that enough times to patent, then statistically it will get invalidated at a certain point.

SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah. I mean, Corey Salzberg has an excellent example that he's talked about and he talked about in the PTAB listening sessions where... Literally, you know, some of their strongest patents would be challenged over and over. And the strongest patents will be the repeat challenges, right? Because they're surviving prior challenges. So these strong patents are going to be challenged over and over again, sometimes even under the same art or arguments. Maybe they get a new expert until it's invalidated. It's just going to keep going and going and going. And people say, well, that all changed because the office put policies in place long ago to deal with it.

SPEAKER_02But It has not changed. I mean, one of the first cases, I mean, it's gotten a little bit better, but, you know, even under the prior study that was done in the previous administration, repeat challenges still made up 25 percent of the petitions. We did a follow on study, which shows depending on how you measure is more like 50 percent or more of the petitions or multiple petitions. But yeah, I mean. One of my first cases that I had to deal with was a was a patent that had been challenged six times, including then two cases in front of the office,

SPEAKER_02one that was up on appeal to the federal circuit. And this was after a jury trial, you know, the patents surviving a jury trial. Again, I understand a different standard, but I mean, it is still happening. It was still happening. Right. And of course, it was happening with the ITC as well.

SPEAKER_00You know, you mentioned, obviously, Secretary Lutnik had a strong connection to the patent system, and he was a big champion about a lot of things that you did to kind of strengthen it. But it seemed he had such a strong familiarity that he had a lot of ideas that weren't kind of got a lot of attention. You know, the Wall Street Journal reported on patent value tax. He brought up margin rights and all that. How is it navigating those issues within the administration where you're the person who's in charge of patents and there's some patent ideas floating around?

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I think the way to look at it is, you know, the secretary is very passionate about the IP system. He's a huge champion of the IP system, but he also understands the tremendous value that it offers the United States. And a different hat he's wearing is an increased revenue for the federal government hat. Right. So it's natural that he's going to look around, you know, his portfolio at the Department of Commerce and all other aspects of government. I mean, obviously,

SPEAKER_02the gold card was a very famous example to say, like, you know, where can the government participate in kind of the IP economy? So, you know, OK. We saw with Intel. You want to have an infusion of money from the government? We want to stake in Intel. So, I mean, without getting into the specifics of what he proposed or didn't propose, because I don't think some of that he's ever, you know, spoken, a lot of this is based on inferences,

SPEAKER_02but he believes in the patent system and the tremendous value of it. And he's always looking for ways that, you know, something government is doing can Reduce the deficit, you know, increase our revenue.

SPEAKER_00What was it like for you?

SPEAKER_02It was exciting. I mean, especially for the first year, because I was an acting director, he was much more hands-on. So there were a lot more meetings and discussions with him about what he wanted. He asked lots of questions. He's very in the weeds on things. He likes to read primary sources. You know, he's really good at pushing back. So, you know, there were a lot of there were a lot of, you know, very substantive discussions about,

SPEAKER_02you know, what the office is doing and what it should do. And I mean, he like I said, he was one of the biggest champions of getting the hiring freeze exemption and he calls patent examiners oil drillers. I mean, that's how he views it. Like this is an economic investment for the country.

SPEAKER_00You know, you said, obviously, Liz, you quoted John Squire's thing, you know, the perfect number of notes, you know, I say what the perfect number of notes is. But once you start making those institution decisions, and obviously there was very strong opinions about it. Did you ever think like, well, maybe this is going too far? Maybe we're bringing the balance too much in the other direction?

SPEAKER_02I don't think so, because, again, there's always reexamination. Yeah. So people forget that. Even if IPRs disappeared tomorrow, you could challenge a patent any time for the life of the patent if you have a substantial new question of patentability in front of the CRU. And you have PGRs. So IPRs, it's like different layers, different layers of challenges. Again, I'm not saying there shouldn't be IPRs. I'm just saying, like, the sky is not going to fall if there weren't IPRs.

SPEAKER_02So to me, the question was, we should take up significant cases where the petitioner's Make a good argument that's in its appropriate use of office resources. And the patent owner doesn't have a particularly good response to that. And there were definitely cases like that. I mean, the Home Depot case is one example. I mean, that was an older patent where the patent owner had a particular enforcement strategy. I think it was against smartwatches or something. And then it switched over to focusing on hardware stores.

SPEAKER_02I mean, you can't really say that Home Depot was going to be expecting that and should have been on notice and should have been policing.

SPEAKER_00I think depending on who you ask. I mean, they do use a lot of technology.

SPEAKER_02But I'm just saying that's an example. I mean, it's not it's not meant to be perfect. Now, people say, OK, that's a lot of change from administration to administration. It's a lot of change within an administration. You know, we want stability. But yes, I want Congress to enact a legislative reform as well. But stability can't mean stability for the people that I was working for. I mean, stability has to be balance that's working for everyone. And that requires change.

SPEAKER_00When you were implementing settled expectations, were you concerned that re-exams were going to turn into these endless challenges? Or is that something that kind of

SPEAKER_02I mean, it was definitely a concern, but, you know, even in talking to the independent inventor community, of course, there are people who feel like all patent challenges should take place in the federal court system, okay? But by and large, I don't hear a huge outcry among the inventor community that the reexamination process is unfair. And by the way, interparties reexaminations now are resolved automatically. More quickly than IPRs. A big criticism of reexaminations was they took too long.

SPEAKER_02And that was on the office if it was taking too long in part. But I mean, I think it's turned into more of a concern because people are just repackaging the IPRs and they're bringing them over to reexam and their 325D issues and reexams don't really have a great mechanism for servicing that. You know, we put out a new process. We waived a regulation so that people could file papers before a finding of an S&Q where they could talk not about 325D, but just about the merits arguments that were made in a request.

SPEAKER_02But I mean, I don't think people understand that prior to our waiving that rule, when someone filed a request for reexamination, there was no Like regular mechanism for a patent owner to respond to that until an SNQ was found. Like that doesn't I mean, for someone who's, you know, practiced in the district court, that is a really remarkable feature of reexamination. So I definitely think there's more reform that needs to happen there.

SPEAKER_01Plenty of tools are being built for lawyers. Junior stands out because it comes from patent law, built by leaders who spent years focused on how technology could make sophisticated legal work more efficient. That shows in the product. Junior fine-tunes on a firm's own work product, for every type of document, so the firm controls how AI writes right inside Word. Its web platform uses examiner history to draft amendments and arguments based on what has actually worked.

SPEAKER_01You know, you

SPEAKER_00mentioned first time around when you were working for Director Iancu. He eventually, towards the end of his term, put a rule package together that didn't get through. This time around, I guess there's a rules package. I think when John Squires, I think, became a director that was formally proposed, Can you talk about that? I guess what you thought, you know, for the rule package, what should be in it, shouldn't be in it. And I guess, you know, just thinking about it and kind of how that's developing.

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, not getting into it too much because of my role at the office. But again, I'm not sure people fully appreciate that the rulemaking process is a very long, cumbersome process. And again, that I think is in part a feature. But I think the idea at the time was to start with something. Relatively simple, which is just can we agree that there shouldn't be repeat challenges absent extraordinary circumstances?

SPEAKER_02And I actually don't know what the current state of the rule is because after you put out a notice of proposed rulemaking, you get all this feedback and you have to write up responses to every single piece of feedback and then you can make adjustments to the rule. And if it's kind of within the scope of the comments, you don't need to go out again. So I don't know what the current state of the rule is right now, but the basic principle is, you know, if you want repeat challenges, you can have repeat challenges in court all you want. I mean, anytime you were sued, you can defend yourself.

SPEAKER_02You can have an affirmative defense of invalidity. But the question is, how many times are you going to have an administrative agency take it up? And I think that's what the rule is trying to get at.

SPEAKER_00I think it's been over a year or something like that where the rule has been hanging out there. So for 12 months, I guess one thing I'm hearing from supporters of the rules package, those I guess who are involved in trying to convince the administration, they feel like the enthusiasm isn't quite there. Are you worried that the rules package isn't going to make it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So, again, I mean, people think and they thought this when Andre was director, that the director has like a magic wand. Yeah. With respect to IP policy and can just kind of do whatever he or she wants. It is definitely not true. So, I mean, we have control over the draft rule language. And then it goes to the Department of Commerce. And the Department of Commerce, their lawyers and their policymakers and whatever, they review it. And then it goes out for public comment. And then as part of the public comment period,

SPEAKER_02OMB and their office, they have a regulatory office called OIRAH. Third parties can come in and talk to them about it. Different branches of the government can come in and talk to them about it. So at that point, it's almost out of PTO's hands. I mean, it just becomes like a government-wide issue. Now, certain rules are very technical and idiosyncratic and like, you know, they don't bring a lot of attention and they move through quickly. But, you know, rules that are Very consequential, go through this process.

SPEAKER_02So I don't think it's so much a lack of enthusiasm. I think it's just, this is part of the process. It's at OMB, everybody, not everybody, but many, many people can come in and kind of share their thoughts with the administration. And then ultimately, as that process winds down, as I understand it is, somebody is gonna have to decide whether whatever form this rule is currently in is gonna need to go forward. And I think those decisions are gonna be made Probably at a high level.

SPEAKER_00Well, for one, at least I've been told there's people within the administration who have different views as well on the rules. I guess if you had to, somebody who's watched politics closely, been with the administration, if you had to kind of guess how it's going to play out, what would you think?

SPEAKER_02I would say 60, 40, the rule's going to happen. That's what I would say.

SPEAKER_00Depending on who you ask.

SPEAKER_02I mean, you put 10 people in a room, they're going to have 10 opinions.

SPEAKER_00I guess, you know, rules or no rules, are you concerned next administration is going to come in or a new director and they're going to kind of just completely undo what you did and maybe what Director Squire tries to do?

SPEAKER_02I mean, again, it's always PTAB tends to be the focus. It's actually a very small part of what The entire agency does. I mean, you talk about examination. It's really the biggest part of office operations. So am I concerned that a new administration might change PTAP policy? I think they will. I mean, a new director in the same administration could change it. A new Republican administration with the same director could change it, a different party.

SPEAKER_02So, I mean, that's That's part of discretion. I mean, one example I might compare it to is like a prosecutor can decide which cases that it wants to bring. And it changes like the priorities change. The criminal enforcement priorities change in the administration and they change based on the leadership of the administration. So, yeah, I think that change is going to happen. You know, people say. That kind of change and unpredictability is bad for the system.

SPEAKER_02And I think they have a point. But the response to that is we need legislation. And the same people who advocate for predictability oppose the rules and oppose legislation. So if if people want predictability, which I think we need to have, then we need to get people together and we need to decide. To work together for the best of the system and realize that not everybody's going to get everything they want out of it. And I think one, to me, like low hanging fruit within Prevail is to say,

SPEAKER_02let's just raise the standards so it's the same as district court. I mean, this is not a reexamination proceeding. This is a expedited trial style proceeding where typically almost always there are no witnesses, no cross-examination. Everything's done on paper. Does not make sense that it's a lower standard than we have in district court that has all of these processes and procedures and the presumptions. So that just seems like an easy thing to fix. And I think if we raise the standard and we really focus on what was

SPEAKER_02the original intent, which is to address so-called bad patents, then we probably need less discretion, right? Because we're focusing on the most problematic cases and not just kind of these routine reviews.

SPEAKER_00So what I'm hearing is the way the law is today, you could do what you could do, but you can't change the policies to make sure they stick through unless you have legislation, right?

SPEAKER_02Well, we have precedential decisions. We have decisions of the office, whether or not they're precedential. We have guidance. Like, I mean, look at the patent eligibility guidance that Director Yanku put in place. I mean, that's what's held the test of time in terms of office operations. But yeah, I mean, I think there are other things the office can do to bring stability. I think guidance, documents are important, rules, obviously, precedential opinions and You know, legislation would be the gold standard, but that's just very hard to do unless it's like an 80-20 issue.

SPEAKER_00Actually, that's another thing you mentioned in your August 2024 article is that you expected the second administration to get behind some of the IP legislative efforts. I guess the two big ones come to mind are Prevail, like you mentioned, and Para, the Section 101. At least I haven't seen that. Any insights about why that wasn't the case or anything?

SPEAKER_02I mean, it's just all a matter of administration priorities. I mean, think about what's going on with immigration enforcement, for example, and the economy and now like the conflict in Iraq. So, you know, every single agency and every single policy priority is fighting for time and attention. And these patent issues are very much in the weeds. And I think, you know, if I had an hour with President Trump and I could sit down and explain to him the merits of these three pieces of legislation, I think He would be very much supportive of them,

SPEAKER_02but he is an incredibly busy person and the legislative agenda for the administration is full. I mean, he's trying to get through legislative reform with respect to, you know, voting and mail-in ballots. I just, you know, I think it's just a matter of kind of balancing time. But I think the secretary can be very impactful in supporting some of this legislation, you know, if it comes to that.

SPEAKER_00So I guess it's kind of hard to get on the agenda.

SPEAKER_02Is that what I'm hearing? Yeah. I mean, there's a lot going on. And I think for us IP lawyers, like we live and die on these issues. But I mean, you step one tiny step outside of our world and, you know, people are not following this. I mean, people are focused on kitchen table issues. They are not focused on, you know, patent eligibility and, you And that's one of the challenges. And one of the things I'm so excited to do in my new role is to really explain

SPEAKER_02the importance of these policies kind of outside the typical circles.

SPEAKER_00You know, just round out this PTAB discussion, which I know you said on a big thing, but we're recording this on September 22nd, so this might change once it's released. But at least there's been some reporting that Director John Squires is selling the APJs, that they're going to push the institution back to them, and that they're going to let them work remotely. I guess, any thoughts about that? And I guess, any concerns? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, there are pros and cons to both approaches. So, I mean, the main benefit of centralizing the institution decision is you get more consistency. I also think it removes that particular work stream away from the panels so that they can focus on the trial phase. But I will say that these decisions are greatly informed by the work of The judges. I mean, the judges have committees. They make recommendations. You know, you meet with the PTAB leadership. They brief the directors.

SPEAKER_02I mean, it's a very much PTAB-driven process. So I like it because of consistency and also policy alignment. And I think whenever you have, you know, 200 judges handling a lot of different cases, you're going to eventually have inconsistency. And I don't think inconsistency is fair either. To the parties on either side. And it's nothing, no criticism of the judges. I think it's just a practical issue. So I like centralization for that purpose. I also think there's a tendency,

SPEAKER_02you kind of get numb to these cases And when you're in the front office, like every single day you're dealing with stakeholders on both sides. And these patent rights are incredibly important. And, you know, it's not really the judge's job to address policy issues. I mean, they decide they decide the issues that are put in front of them. So I think there's a potential tendency to go back to the issue we had before, which is when we bifurcated the institution decision and we just did discretion. Now, we were weeding out some of the weaker cases,

SPEAKER_02but the institution rate went up for a period of time to 95%. So then we had the same issue, like, okay, what is the reasonable likelihood standard mean? And different judges had different opinions. Practitioners have different opinions. So to me, just centralizing that, having one process, having kind of the process we put in place where you had kind of red team, blue team looking at the petitions to Look for strengths and weaknesses was really helpful.

SPEAKER_02Now, I think we could still do that without the director having the final say. So there's a possible middle ground, right, where you don't go totally back to the panels, but you don't necessarily need the director involved in the day-to-day. So I'm not really sure where it's going to land.

SPEAKER_00Well, you said there's pros and cons. What are the pros of giving it back to the...

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I think it's a matter of... Time, too. I mean, there are a lot of important priorities that the office the undersecretary is working on. And I think it was definitely manageable to to have the front office more involved in these decisions. But there are a lot of competing priorities. And let's say this might take anywhere from four to eight hours a week. I mean, that time could be used for other things. I actually don't think that the director is spending 48 hours a week on this,

SPEAKER_02but like certainly in the early days. You know, there was probably a little bit like that. And also, I think there are different presidential decisions now. There's like more structure. I think potentially giving it back to the panels, there would be less variance because there's just a lot more guidance and structure now than there was.

SPEAKER_00You know, one thing, you know, if you follow some of the IP reporting, it's like, you know, John Squires instituted nine and denied 18 one day and then, you know, kind of daily reporting. You know, somebody might think like, is that too much power for one person to have? Do you think that's a reasonable way to look at that?

SPEAKER_02Well, it's a lot of power of an individual panel of judges as well. And the director is more politically accountable, of course, than the judges. That's the design of the system. But I mean, I think we need to begin with a presumption that people are acting in good faith. I mean, it isn't like the director or when I was acting director would just take petitions and kind of like throw them down the stairwell and see, you know, which one should go in. And of course, there are all sorts of different APA challenges that, you know, could potentially be in play if things like that were happening.

SPEAKER_02But It's a thoughtful process. It's largely informed and driven by the work of the career PTAB team. And the statute said the director makes the institution decision. Again, if Congress wants to change that, it can easily do it.

SPEAKER_00And Director John Squires pointed to that. Yeah. Statue language when he took over that power. When you were speaking as acting director, you often said, to illustrate what champions you have of IP system within the administration, you have, you know, obviously Secretary Lutnik, but also President Trump, you know, he kind of built his business empire based on trademarks and his books and copyright. I'm not sure if you've said that. Yeah. You know, it's been interesting to see kind of administration navigate the AI and copyright issues,

SPEAKER_00obviously, with large language models using AI, sorry, large language models using copyrighted works for training. And you saw administration recently take a position on that. Did that surprise you? I guess the position they took and I guess how do you expect it all? That part of the IP world to play out.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I thought that was a little surprising. And actually, I talked to someone about this and there was an article written about it. But again, this is kind of a part of the government process that people don't understand that at the district court level, there's a it isn't like there's this one person who coordinates everything that's said in every single court in the country. I mean, there is in theory, right? You have the attorney general. But You know, there can be some variance in briefs that are filed, especially at the district court level. So really when the rubber meets the road is when civil appellate and

SPEAKER_02the solicitor general get involved. And that's an incredibly rigorous process. So I was a little surprised by that brief. I would say I don't agree with some of the intellectual property analysis in the brief. I mean, I think people are trying to come up with pragmatic solutions where we can continue to develop these models while a licensing regime is developing and the courts are looking at that. But I wouldn't necessarily at this point, I think it's too soon to say if this is like the administrative position,

SPEAKER_02administration position. In fact, I think the president said something a little bit different. About copyright and AI training this spring. So I think that's, you know, to be determined, to be seen.

SPEAKER_00Well, what do you think the distinction is between what he said and...

SPEAKER_02I think his position, he gave a speech on this, was a little bit more nuanced and put out an AI plan was a little bit more nuanced. But... Ultimately, the president and the administration, I think, again, is just trying to be pragmatic. So we want to respect intellectual property rights to the greatest extent possible, but we can't get so bound up in a licensing model that literally we can't do training. And I think that's probably where the courts are going to come out to with some kind of balance. I mean, to me,

SPEAKER_02the issue that's particularly concerning is when there's training on pirated material or Or material that's behind paywalls or material that's specifically set aside, saying it's not for training or certain artistic works that aren't necessarily needed for training, certainly aren't necessary for national security purposes. So, again, I think we just need to find that balance.

SPEAKER_00You know, I saw an op-ed, I think it was the CEO of Ziff Publishing or whatever. He said, you know, it's kind of a, we have these licensing deals are happening. They're successful and there's a drop in the bucket for these, some of these companies to pay that. What do you think is, I don't know, what are the concerns, I guess, that you think the administration might have that isn't addressed by that position? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, this is emerging technology. So the licensing models are evolving. I don't think they're fully formed yet. But, you know, one change I think that's happening is it, you know, there used to be a discussion of like there just isn't enough material to train on, right? So it was like gobbling everything up that the models could possibly get and then also just like The AI machines themselves creating new materials to in turn train themselves on and over and over again. And I think there's a pivot towards focusing much more on like the quality of

SPEAKER_02the materials, the accuracy of the materials. And I think that's where licensing will really come into play because especially I've heard some of the smaller AI companies are much more focused on discrete AI training issues on high quality training material. So ultimately, I think there is going to be a shift towards like quantity, a quality over quantity.

SPEAKER_00Well, I was going to say, I feel to a different extent, but I think a lot of these companies recognize the value of copyrighted content and there being new copyrighted content.

SPEAKER_02And if there's training, there's not going to be new content created. And if there's not new content to be created, then there isn't going to be new training materials.

SPEAKER_00Well, before we get to some final questions, you are now the president of C4IP. Yes. So what is your vision for what you like C4IP to do and what your role?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So, I mean, C4IP to me is some of the most exciting work that I did in the first year of the administration in that, you know, we talked a lot about workforce and operational issues, and I'm in a position now where Where I can focus almost exclusively on policy. And we have an amazing board. So Andre Iancu and Dave Kapos are on it. Judge Michelle and Judge O'Malley are on it. We have former Secretary Locke, who's also ambassador to China. We have Lamar Smith, who's a co-sponsor of the AIA.

SPEAKER_02So we have this tremendous board of thought leaders and strategic thinkers. And then we have a Incredible executive team that manages. So basically, it's just another dream job, right? I mean, it's just like 90% being able to work on policy and also, like I said, getting out there and being able to speak outside of immediate IP circles and educate people about the IP system. I mean, to give one example, like a month ago, I was speaking in Virginia Beach and To a group of people,

SPEAKER_02like not lawyers, not engineers, nothing like that. It was just, you know, a group of people in Virginia Beach because I grew up there about the IP system and the history of the IP system. And they were so incredibly engaged and excited about it, especially kind of how it made its way to the Constitution and everything. The first patent act and some of the early inventions and how it contributed to the development of the United States. And, you know, I'm just excited about explaining these things in a way to make people care about them. I mean, someone said to me the other day, like, don't use the P word.

SPEAKER_02If you say patents, you know, people are going to run from you. They don't want to talk about it. But I mean, I think it's really foundational to our whole country. So I'm excited to get out there and make people care about it.

SPEAKER_00Any particular issue, I guess, in the patent or IP world that most concerns you or you think C4IP should really make an impact on?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I would say that the issue of injunctions, so that's captured by the draft legislation, the Restore Act, is, I think, a critical issue because it's fundamental to... You know, private property and real property in the United States that you control your own property and who has access to it. So I think there's a great failing there in our case law. So I think the Restore Act would not guarantee injunctions. It would just say. You know, it's part of our IP system that there is a presumption that you have

SPEAKER_02the exclusive right, which is described in the Constitution. I think that's super important. I think certain aspects of the Prevail Act, which would just bring more stability to these challenges. Again, there's some people who think we shouldn't have them at all. But I think if we can build consensus, which there should be, that The whole purpose of the AIA was to get to these so-called bad patents. And let's focus on the so-called bad patents and not every issued patent. Can we agree on that? And if we can agree on that, then I think we're a long way towards getting Prevail moving.

SPEAKER_02I think PERA is a little bit more complicated just because patent eligibility, you know, can be really challenging. But I think there's opportunities to simplify that as well.

SPEAKER_00You know, you mentioned that for something on IP legislation to happen, you need like 80% consensus. Do you think there is room for that to happen in the near future to get to that consensus on any of the issues you discussed, Eric?

SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, one thing we can do a better job of is bringing, like, you know, the business community in the States to members and explain the importance of their patent rights. I mean, I think the independent inventor groups are making some headway on this because if all they're hearing is from, like, large incumbent, you know, IP primarily implementers, You know, who are impatient, right? I mean, they just like the AI companies. I mean, they're impatient for change. Things are moving very quickly.

SPEAKER_02They want to remove what they perceive to be roadblocks. Like that message is getting through very well. But. Ultimately, the success of our country depends on the success of entrepreneurs and small and medium business owners. It is not going to depend on the success of our largest companies. So once the members hear that message, and I think when they hear about balance and the fairness of the system, I think there is a real chance of getting some of this legislation through

SPEAKER_02because it's just a fairness issue.

SPEAKER_00All right. Well, some final questions. What do people misunderstand the most about your time running the USPTO that you wish they'd understand?

SPEAKER_02I mean, two things. One, again, I think people think that the director or acting director has this incredible amount of power. And running an agency does give you a lot of power, but you are subject to all the The policies of the administration and the White House and everything else. And, you know, the patent office is part of the executive branch. So we can't always do our own thing, for one thing. And two, kind of to your earlier point, I think people believe that,

SPEAKER_02you know, so much of this stuff is just result oriented or, you know, not done in good faith or whatever. They just see what they want to see. And I think absent truly extraordinary problems or signs of poor character or illegal or unethical conduct or something like that, you have to assume people are operating in good faith. I mean, I've been practicing law. I've been in law now for almost 30 years, and I've represented people on both sides. I've represented patent owners. I've represented large technology companies,

SPEAKER_02you know, accused infringers, certainly small businesses and, you know, pre-AIA who are getting sued for patent infringement. So there are going to be people who don't believe me, but I think, you know, Fairness and consistency and stability. I mean, obviously, there are core policy positions and I'm a conservative person and, you know, I was an appointee, twice appointed at the state and federal level as a Republican. But, you know, I think we have to assume that people are operating in good faith and we need

SPEAKER_02to find consensus and we need to listen to both sides and, you know, just communicate better.

SPEAKER_00Obviously, you spent a lot of time at the PTO, including working in the front office. Is there anything you learned or appreciate better now that you had the acting director role for a year? Is there anything you kind of maybe appreciate better about the patent system, about the patent office, anything from there?

SPEAKER_02I mean, for me, it was very hard to get away from like the day-to-day operation of the agency and focus on other issues. Like, yes, we'd had stakeholder meetings and yes, I spoke, but just like really getting out there and engaging more outside the office, communicating more with stakeholders and with our own employees. I mean, I just feel like I was... It just felt like there was so much to do and so little time and so many different emergencies happening all the time that I feel like maybe

SPEAKER_02the balance of time I spent like at my desk actually working on operations versus like being out there and engaging with people and communicating with our workforce, I might have shifted that balance a little bit. It's hard to say. I mean, that was a really, really challenging time. Also, you know, we didn't talk about it, but the major changes to the union was Like if I could go back in time, you know, and we were I was planning to do this to create kind of like a like

SPEAKER_02a workforce council of sorts where you could get different aspects of the workforce outside of the executive team and kind of have some representation and some better communications with the office would have been something that I wish I could have implemented.

SPEAKER_00Do you think it'd be good for the USPTO to have some version of the union back?

SPEAKER_02You know. In conservative circles, government unions are very, you know, are a point of concern, even though I think the president is very supportive of unions generally. So if I had my political appointee hat on, it's very hard to say anything. The government unions are like critical to agency operations because there are already so many laws and protections in place as there should be for career civil servants. But, you know, we talked about Kathy Duda,

SPEAKER_02you know, before we got going and I used to meet with her every single week and she was great and brought a lot of things to my attention. So whether it's like formally a union or whether it's something where you're just constantly saying, Working with representatives, especially when you have a large workforce like USPTO, I think that's very important. And we did do listening sessions. We did have town halls with every single business unit, multiple town halls with the SPES. We had a giant like 10,000 person town hall with patents,

SPEAKER_02you know, but that's like one hour in a period of months. So I just think whether it's a unions or some other kind of system where you just have a feedback loop with the employees, that's really important.

SPEAKER_00Any advice to the next person who's chosen the acting director? What would you...

SPEAKER_02Oh, you mean deputy? To be the deputy?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, deputy. But essentially, they're going to come in after we transition, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I probably would have some advice kind of along the lines that I'm saying. I think there's a balance, right? Because I think there's real benefit to that hands-on work to run the agency. I mean, you're looking at budget issues. You're looking at IT issues. You're looking at administrative law issues, lawsuits, I mean, totally un-IP-related lawsuits and contracts. Just a million different things. And I think it's really important to be hands-on. And the secretary's very hands-on.

SPEAKER_02I mean, everybody knows he famously was reviewing all contracts over $100,000. But we saved a fortune based on that. And I mean, he read the contracts in some cases. And I think, you know, for that period of time where you're a government servant, I mean, it really is a 24-7 a day thing. So, I mean, I would say to, you know... Like in a new administration, new director that, you know, stay hands on, stay really involved, but also you have to be out there engaging with stakeholders and you need

SPEAKER_02to really focus on communications internally as well.

SPEAKER_00You know, let's say there's a young, ambitious patent litigators listening to this and they're saying, I want to be the next Coke Morgan Stewart. What advice would you give them?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I had a very unusual path towards being a patent litigator and a patent executive. So I don't know what advice I would give them. But I do think one thing I bring is like I didn't go the usual route. You know, I didn't was an engineer undergrad. I didn't go to law school knowing I wanted to be a patent lawyer. So I had years and years of exposure to different kinds of the law. Before I came to patent litigation, I think that adds a lot of value. But I mean, what I would say is, you know, don't hesitate to make changes in your career.

SPEAKER_02If you're not if you're not happy with what you're doing, if you're really interested in something, you know, just pursue it. Don't get hung up in kind of the day to day. I mean, we have to be real and pay our bills, but. You know, there have been periods of my time where I've taken jobs that are very lucrative and there have been periods of my life where I've taken jobs where, you know, I was paid like a school teacher, high school school teacher. And, you know, you have to, you know, if you if you really want to have a varied career and have different opportunities that will one day put you in a position to become a judge or lead an agency or get

SPEAKER_02a political appointment, then. I think it's good to kind of mix things up in your career and stay very involved in, you know, bar associations and things like that.

SPEAKER_00We talked about AI and copyright, but obviously a big thing during your time at the patent office was thinking about, like, how is AI going to be incorporated in the work that the patent office does? Any thoughts about that experience or, I guess, what do you think is the approach that the USPTO is taking, I guess, around it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think it's going to completely transform patent examination ultimately in a good way. I think the transition is going to be really challenging. But, you know, to be able to put in, you know, everything from the file history, to be able to have AI agents searching for prior art, to be translating art from other countries, to be inputting like legal frameworks and structures and every Supreme Court decision that's ever been issued and every Federal Circuit decision that's ever been issued. On patentability and having that at the fingertips of individual examiners is going

SPEAKER_02to be totally transformative. And I think it's going to make their jobs a lot more interesting. And I think it's really going, I mean, I think we have great patent quality now, but I think it's going to be brought to a whole new level.

SPEAKER_00Any final thoughts, anything you want people to remember from your time as acting director of USPTR or anything else?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, just to end on a positive note, I think, you know, it's just important that everybody listens to one another. I think sometimes people like to have positive feedback and they want to be in rooms where everybody agrees. And I think the only way we're going to make progress on a lot of these issues is to Get people with different perspectives together and decide that we have a common goal. And I think a common goal we really have right now is stability. And if we can get different people together in a room, I think we can achieve that through legislation.

SPEAKER_00From your words to a bad community. Well, Koch, thank you so much for coming on Clause 8 and sharing everything.

SPEAKER_01All right. Thanks for having me. Finally, after all these years. Thanks for listening to Clause 8. Subscribe at voiceofip.com for more IP conversations and find extra content on the Clause 8 YouTube channel. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Companies Miss 95% of Their Inventions

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Austin Walters saw the AI boom coming as an inventor on more than 650 patents. Now the IP Copilot founder explains how companies lose most of what their engineers invent. He spent two years at a major patent filer...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “Nobody Won Until I Won”: Perry Saidman, the Godfather of Design Law

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Perry Saidman passed away on October 15, 2026, less than a month after we recorded this conversation. Perry built the market for design patents. His win in Avia v. LA Gear, a sneaker knockoff case, helped prove design...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How Patent Litigation Really Moves: IAM, IP Fray, and MLex Reporters on the Year in IP

    Sep 29, 202645 minAudio

    To open the season, host Eli Mazour brings together three journalists who cover intellectual property for a living: Olivia Rafferty of IP Fray, Nisha Shetty of IAM, and Inbar Preiss of MLex. They discuss what happens...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Via Eyes "De Facto" Standards for Future Pools

    Jun 2, 202651 minAudio

    Kevin Mack, the new president of Via Licensing Alliance, joins Eli for the Clause 8 season finale. Kevin talks about Via's plans to build its next patent pools around "de facto" standards - technology the market adopted...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI Boom Calls for New Copyright Law, Says USPTO Chief Behind the DMCA

    May 19, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    Bruce Lehman, head of USPTO from 1993 to 1998, joins Clause 8 for a wide-ranging conversation about the modern IP system, the internet boom, and why the AI era may require a new copyright response from Congress. Lehman...

    Credit the people on this episode