Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Clause 8

Clause 8 artwork

“Nobody Won Until I Won”: Perry Saidman, the Godfather of Design Law

Oct 27, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

Perry Saidman passed away on October 15, 2026, less than a month after we recorded this conversation. Perry built the market for design patents. His win in Avia v. LA Gear, a sneaker knockoff case, helped prove design patents could be enforced. He co-founded and led the firm that became Sterne Kessler, then left in 1990 to start Saidman DesignLaw Group, the first firm in the country dedicated to design patents. In this episode: - How a sneaker knockoff, and his best deposition, put design patents on the map - Founding what became Sterne Kessler, and why he walked away - How Apple v. Samsung did more for design patents than 22 years of his marketing - Claiming the "DNA" of a product, and the appendix "trick of the trade" - Why the wrong design patents end up litigated - Range of Motion and the Egyptian Goddess sentence he called "a gift to infringers" - "Specialize, specialize, specialize," and leaving the top of the mountain Clause 8 is sponsored by: Junior AI (http://docs.junior.law/) - Your legal team's documents, drafted in your team's style. IP Copilot (https://ipcopilot.ai/) - Discover, manage, and protect your IP. Chapters 00:00:00 The Avia shoe case and how he got into design patents 00:04:12 Creating the market for design patents 00:07:24 Founding the firm that became Sterne Kessler, and why he left 00:22:00 Apple v. Samsung and where companies should start 00:29:41 Design patent strategy: functionality, solid lines, the appendix and GUIs 00:41:43 LKQ, examination and common mistakes 00:50:01 Egyptian Goddess and Range of Motion 00:55:22 Replacement parts, advice for lawyers and finding a niche 01:04:05 Leaving the top of the mountain This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.voiceofip.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01So nobody respected design patents because they were very easy to get around and nobody won until I won. I had to create the market, then sell the market. I said, I'm not a patent attorney anymore. I'm a design lawyer.

SPEAKER_02Perry Sedman sat down for this conversation on September 22nd, 2026. He passed away on October 15th. So let's start from the beginning. How did you get into design patterns?

SPEAKER_01Well, it's kind of a long story, but, you know, it's interesting. I went to an AIPLA dinner dance. It was 1978. And I sat at a table with Joe Potenza and his wife. Joe was a partner at Banner Birch. That's what it was called at the time. And we got along. It was a great, great party. A few months later, Joe calls me. Banner Birch represented Nike. And Phil Knight, you know, was very protective.

SPEAKER_01So Joe told me he got an application from a guy, a different guy, who invented some running shoes. And he said, Phil Knight said, no, we can't. Are you in a position to take the case? The inventor is coming to D.C. tomorrow and wants to meet tomorrow morning. So we met at 17th and K Street late at night. He handed me the file. There was one U.S. and four foreign files. So I went up and I reviewed everything and I met with the inventor

SPEAKER_01whose name was Jerry Stubblefield. And it turns out he was the founder of... Avia, which was an upstart running shoe company, and I wound up doing all their patent and trademark work for quite a while. And the main invention of Jerry Stubblefield was a concave outsole. So when you hit the ground, it went like a trampoline, right? And the shock went this way instead of this way.

SPEAKER_01All of your shoes had this concave outsole.

SPEAKER_02So the first thing that you hopped in was with a utility patent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I fought hard for that. Yeah. The first tennis shoe was introduced in 85 and within six months it had been knocked off by a company named LA Gear in Los Angeles. The thing about this knockoff, it looked almost exactly like the Avia shoe, but it was flat at the bottom, no concavity. So my hard-fought utility patent was useless, right?

SPEAKER_01So that's when I said, well, it looks alike. Let's get a couple of design patents. So we got one on the upper, the leather part, one on the rubber part, the outsole. Sued the bad guys in LA District Court, and after a while won a motion for summary judgment. The two design patents were found valid, infringed, willfully infringed, entitled to treble damages and attorney fees, all in summary judgment. So L.A. Gear did me a big favor by appealing to the federal circuit.

SPEAKER_01And a year later, it was a 25 page decision affirming everything that happened in the district court. I had so much fun working with the designers in that case, as opposed to Nothing against them, engineers and scientists. I said, I'm not a patent attorney anymore. I'm a design lawyer. So I started to market in that particular niche. My partners at the time were not thrilled about this. This was Sedman Stern, Kessler & Goldstein, because there was all this utility patent work.

SPEAKER_01What are you doing, Sedman? So push came to shove, and I decided... Let's start a firm, me, to specialize in design patents. So Sedman Design Law Group was born in 1990.

SPEAKER_02So before that happened, I guess you were aware of design patents, you just never saw an opportunity. I actually came across this 1987 Washington Post profile of you. You were the managing partner of that firm, which you mentioned, which became Stern Kessler, which is now the biggest IP firm in the world. You were managing partner sitting in your office. And in that article, you were trying to convince everybody that design patents is something worthwhile, which like you mentioned, you were managing partner of this firm.

SPEAKER_02You could have just like Focused all your time on all the other work were you getting? Why did you think it was important enough to focus on this design stuff?

SPEAKER_01Well, in my ignorance, really, I thought the Sevilla case would put design patents on the map. What I didn't realize is the poor reputation that design patents had already. So I had to create the market. Then sell the market. You know, two things. The market wasn't there. Nobody liked design patents. Oh, they're useless, easy to get around sheep.

SPEAKER_01You know, no good. Even in spite of the Evia case, it was tough sledding for a while.

SPEAKER_02Why did they have a bad reputation?

SPEAKER_01Well, because the patent lawyers who prepared them didn't know how to prepare them to have a broad scope, right? So they were very narrow in scope. It's like having a utility patent. Patent claim that's this long, right? Easy to design around. So nobody respected design patents because they were very easy to get around and nobody won until I won. So, um... They had a bad rep. Oh, interesting.

SPEAKER_02So I guess before that case, which you handled, there was a lot of unsuccessful attempts at enforcing design patents because of their breadth.

SPEAKER_01That's right.

SPEAKER_02And I guess when you were preparing those first design patents, what made you think about, I should take into consideration the scope. How did you go around planning what those first design patents should be like?

SPEAKER_01Well, in the beginning, I was as ignorant as everybody else, right? We did a search for utility patents, and if the guy's invention was not patentable in a utility sense, we said, well, we can get you a design patent. I mean, that was a standard comeback line. So I had to learn little by little. And the Avia case was just the beginning, really. I mean, the broken lines that we used, you know, broken lines represent unclaimed subject matter.

SPEAKER_01So there was a lot of sophistication that developed over the years using broken lines and solid lines. It really got very sophisticated, you know, very soon. When I went to talk to a designer who had this product that he put on the table, I said, if you had to, what would you define as the DNA of this product? What would you hate for a competitor?

SPEAKER_01And that's what we focused on in solid lines, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02That's a good way to think about that. Can you tell us a little bit more, obviously, about how you ended up founding the firm when it became

SPEAKER_01Sternkessler, that story? When I left in 1990, It was Sedman Stern. So they lopped off my name when I left. And, you know, I actually, at that point in time, I was really a workaholic.

SPEAKER_02Well, can you tell us a story first of how did Sedman Stern come about that Zero Touch sharing with me?

SPEAKER_01Well, I left a small firm I was with. And what firm was that? Berman, Eisenberg, and Platt. And I was of counsel to that firm.

SPEAKER_02Well, you told me you started your career at Oblon at the time, right?

SPEAKER_01Oh, I went from Oblon to a soul practitioner to Berman and then to Rob Stern and Ron Snyder. Yeah, bounce, bounce, bounce, bounce. Didn't like it at Oblon because we were basically just translating Japanese English patents to English English patents. Yeah. That was the job. I liked being on my own, but nobody beat a path to my door because I was young. I looked young.

SPEAKER_01I thought I knew everything, but I didn't realize every five years your knowledge doubles.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I basically did farm out work when I was a sole practitioner. I would go to several firms who had excess work, mostly amendments, you know, and they would hand me the work. I would go back to my office. I would write the amendment, I would give it to them, and they would pay me. And that's how I lived for a couple years. At Berman, they had a partner named Ted Bischoff, who had a big docket.

SPEAKER_01He retired, so I joined them. It's interesting because Berman was born in the 30s, I mean the firm, and they were an advertising firm. They advertised in Popular Mechanics. And Popular Science. Send in your invention with $75 and we'll do a search. So they had this bevy of dedicated and faithful inventors in Iowa.

SPEAKER_01In Ohio, doing farm equipment, all sorts of things. So I was kept very busy at Berman doing those things. And my methodology never changed. I had a search done, got the search, first did the drawings. Then made a parts list, drafted the claims, and picked up the dictation machine and drafted the spec. And that was Monday through Saturday. And by Saturday, the case was done. That was amazing.

SPEAKER_01They charged the client by the page of drawings. If it was a one sheet case, you got charged X. If it was a two sheet case, why do I remember that? You got charged Y. Four sheet case, bonanza. Yeah. That was interesting, but I was of counsel and making a lot of money because they paid me a percentage and I was working my ass off. When time come to talk partnership, I was making more than the other three guys and they wanted to make more than me.

SPEAKER_01So that was not satisfactory. So then I began to look around and I remember Rob Stern. I do electronic searches.

SPEAKER_02You're telling me you wrote to him some April function. I really liked Rob.

SPEAKER_01He was He was aggressive, he was young, bright-eyed, bushy-tailed. So I went over there and they took me in. The office was right above a topless strip joint. Oh, it's funny. We used to take kids there to interview them. It was very distracting. Yeah. So that was kind of the genesis of Sedman Stern. Oh, when Ron Snyder left, he finished a big case, a big litigation against GE.

SPEAKER_01And he worked flat out for six months on that case. Then he disappeared for six months. So Rob and I looked at each other and said, that's the end of Snyder. So Rob and I had a disagreement. Was it going to be Sedman and Stern or Stern and Sedman? I said, Rob, you don't know how to draft a patent application. I do. So I have 10 more years of experience. So it's got to be Sedman and Stern.

SPEAKER_01So that's the way it panned out.

SPEAKER_02And did you have a vision for the firm? Like at the time, did you have a dream for what the firm could be?

SPEAKER_01Actually, we did. We made friends with a lawyer at Finnegan named Larry Hefter. And Larry was such a nice guy, I forget the connection. But we used to go to lunch with him, Rob and I, and he explained how Finnegan worked. And they worked on a consensus model where if they had 10 guys at the time, if all 10 guys didn't agree, they didn't go forward with the decision. So Rob and I thought that this was great.

SPEAKER_01This led to agreement and consensus on any big decisions. So we kind of adopted that model, thanks to Larry and thanks to Finnegan. And it worked for quite a while.

SPEAKER_02But, you know, you mentioned you did mostly preparing patent applications, prosecuting them. How did you get into litigation?

SPEAKER_01Well, first we got into trademarks because a fellow named Abe Bogorod had been with Chagru. He was still with Chagru, actually. And I just learned Rob Stern who came from Chagru as well. Yeah, so is Snyder. And he used to be on the TTAB, Abe. So he came over at lunchtime and basically taught Rob and I trademark law.

SPEAKER_02Over one lunch?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, over lunch. And he was great. He was a great teacher. And we learned it. We learned it. It was wonderful. Litigation? That came really later. I think of VIA. It may have been the first litigation, and it was great. It was my first deposition. I was really nervous. Sitting across the table was Greenberg, the president, and had both shoes on the table, our shoe and the knockoff, the L.A. gear shoe.

SPEAKER_01And you couldn't see the logos. So I handed Greenberg something I had marked as Exhibit A. I said, could you identify Exhibit A? And he took it and said, well, that's one of our shoes. Then he turned it around and saw the Avia logo and said, oh, no, no, that's

SPEAKER_00There are a lot of AI tools being built for lawyers. What stands out about Junior is where it came from. Junior grew out of patent lawyers and law firm leaders who spent years thinking about how technology could make sophisticated legal work more efficient. That shows It's backed by integrations with 11 patent offices,

SPEAKER_00Trademark data, federal case law, and SEP standards. And its web platform, Universe, pairs that data with examiner history to help draft amendments and arguments based on what has actually worked, including on Section 101 rejections for a particular examiner. You can learn more at junior.law.

SPEAKER_02How big was the firm in 1990 when you left?

SPEAKER_01I think it was maybe 20 people or so.

SPEAKER_02Did you have any hesitation, like, you know, help build up this firm?

SPEAKER_01Of course, of course. It was my firm. You know, I was the managing partner for many years. And yeah, it was a certain amount of regret. You know, we had our disputes like any family. There were five partners and we wound up, you know, disagreeing about the direction of the firm. They wanted to, they, one particular guy wanted to do away with consensus management, for example.

SPEAKER_01So we fought about that and a few other things. I was, designs, I want to do designs. He said, let's do the work that's on the table, which is utility patent work. You know, working as an alcoholic cost me one marriage and I didn't want that to happen. So I wanted to kind of slow down, work regular hours, no Saturdays, no Sundays, you know, 9 to 6. And that was not the model for a big DC firm.

SPEAKER_01The model was 1,800, 2,000 hours a year. And I wanted nothing to do with that. So the attraction of Sedman Design Law Group, the way we sold it, was your money or your life. If you want the money, go downtown and work for a firm that wants 2,000 hours a year. If you want a life, come to work for us. You won't make as much money, but you'll have your evenings and weekends free, you know, by and large.

SPEAKER_02And what was your, like you said, you had to build the market. You know, it's not preparing to design patent applications. It's less work than preparing utility applications, would it be fair to say? There's not much prosecution. There's not as many disputes. But what was your vision, I guess, when you started?

SPEAKER_01What I actually did was I used my utility patent experience... And knowledge and applied it to design patents. In other words, the duty of disclosure was the same, regardless if you were doing a utility patent or design patent. Handling a one or two rejection was the same. It needed identical prior art reference. So there were these things by analogy that I applied for my utility patent knowledge

SPEAKER_01to design patents. And I lectured and I wrote and I got on what's now called the CLE program. I wrote many, many articles. And then I had some luck. A guy called me from Florida. And he said, have you ever been an expert witness in a design case? I said, no. He said, well, it's really easy. Let me tell you what's involved. Long story short, I did my first gig as an expert witness.

SPEAKER_01Expert witness, which was a wonderful thing for me, for anybody, because somebody else, his law firm, was doing the heavy lifting. All I did was came in the room as the most knowledgeable guy in design patents in the whole room, and I did my spiel. I charged ginormous fees as an expert, and I went home. So that practice grew tremendously.

SPEAKER_01And I loved it because, you know, very little work. Well, I had to do some work. I had to write an expert report, sometimes get my deposition taken. But it was very, shall we say, profitable.

SPEAKER_02You mentioned that when you started first doing design work, it came out of you doing utility pattern work. What was your vision for just marketing, just doing the design work on its own? Who were you thought would be the clients or the situations that you would be helping when you first?

SPEAKER_01I thought the clients by and large would be companies that Had finalized what their product would look like and wanted to stop the knockoffs. You know, it's not company A versus company B who copies one design. It's... It was at the time and still is the stuff coming in from Asia. You know, you want to stop that flood of knockoffs from ruining your market.

SPEAKER_01So that's the way I tried to sell it because that's where the value was. You know, that worked a little. Well, you know, you said you proved,

SPEAKER_02you know, in the AVR versus LA Gear case, you proved that you could be successful enforcing design patents. But what was the resistance towards it? Or was it just like people still weren't comfortable with the idea of design patents? What was the...

SPEAKER_01Yeah, again, they weren't using broken lines to maximum advantage. They weren't using them at all, actually. They didn't care about the duty of disclosure. So all these patents were suspect. And when they asserted them against a copycat... It was viewed as a very easy to get around, just change a few eyelets or change a logo or move this around,

SPEAKER_01and there was no infringement. You know, the test for infringement is whether weather The two designs are substantially the same, look substantially the same. So you change a few things as a competitor and they're not substantially the same. So it was easy to get around. Would you say it's a fuzzy test, right? For somebody like, how would you explain that to a client? It's very subjective, very subjective. At one point in time, when we did the L.A.

SPEAKER_01Gear case, the Avia case, nobody knew how exactly, you know, it was your question, how do you evaluate this subjective test? So I was so nervous. I heard Donald Chisholm. You heard of Chisholm? Yeah. He wrote the book. My copyright, yeah. Yeah, as a witness. He did a deposition. He wrote an expert report. He concluded that they were substantially the same in overall appearance.

SPEAKER_01So it carried the day. The judge was impressed.

SPEAKER_02You know, you're obviously wearing an Apple hat and obviously the Apple versus Samsung is a very famous design panel law case. What impact do you think that had on the design panel law practice?

SPEAKER_01I would say, and I'm not exaggerating, Eli. I would say all the marketing I did from 1990 to 2012 paled by comparison with what happened after Apple beat Samsung and got a $1 billion verdict. Corporate America woke the F up and said there's money in design patents. And there was a flood of companies now who wanted to get design patents

SPEAKER_01to protect their stuff because Apple showed how valuable they can be. So it was great. It was wonderful for the law firms.

SPEAKER_02Do you think it's lucky how it turned out? It wasn't a slam dunk case, don't you think, from a design perspective?

SPEAKER_01Well, there were a number of Federal Circuit decisions on various aspects of the case. The one that went to the Supreme Court was the question of what was an article of manufacture, right? So that phrase appears in 171. Your design must be for an article of manufacture. More importantly, it appears in 289, where the successful design patent owner can get total profits of the article

SPEAKER_01of manufacture. The question was, do those phrases mean the same thing in those two sections? And it was hard fought. And the Supreme Court, the question was, can you get profits only on the entire product as sold? Or can you get profits on only a part of the product that's sold, right? Which is very important because if you get total profits on a vacuum cleaner, it's much bigger than the total profits on the handle for the vacuum cleaner.

SPEAKER_01So the Supreme Court said you could get either one. Either the product is sold or a portion of the product. And that was the case.

SPEAKER_02So that's pretty powerful because if you get a utility patent for small functionality versus a design patent over the whole product, the design patent is more valuable.

SPEAKER_01It can be. It can be. Depends what the infringer is selling. Are they selling the whole product? Usually not. Usually they change a few things. They're not stupid, right? They change a few things to avoid infringement. And if your total profit is limited to the entire product that's sold, it's pretty easy to avoid the damages that that would result in. So that question has never been decided.

SPEAKER_01How do you determine what the article of manufacture is to calculate total profit? It went back to the lower courts and they fussed. And eventually, most of the courts adopted the four factors that were listed in the DOJ amicus brief before the Supreme Court. I'm not going to recite the factors because I don't remember them. But there were four factors,

SPEAKER_01and every district court and the federal circuit said these are the four factors, even though the Supreme Court didn't mention them.

SPEAKER_02So you said, you know, once that decision came out and Apple won, everybody woke up to it. But as we sit here today, do you think design patterns are utilized in the way they should be or are they still underutilized?

SPEAKER_01I would say the firms that know what they're doing, and there are only a handful, utilize them and utilize them very well. Yeah. There's still a lot of firms and solos and small firms who don't understand the nuances of design patterns. And you see it all the time in litigation. Somebody's claiming the whole thing when they should have claimed the DNA.

SPEAKER_01And it's a losing case. And those are the ones that get litigated, right? So they result in decisions that do not help the system, right? The ones that are good don't get litigated. And so you have a bunch of not helpful case law. I won't say bad, but I say not helpful. You know, the design patent law, I think, suffers as a result. And the clients say, why should I get a design patent when all these bad decisions are coming out?

SPEAKER_02And I think because of infringement tests, you can be kind of lulled into thinking, well, somebody's going to subjectively think whatever's important is going to... Looks similar enough for it to be infringement. So maybe let's help them out, some of those practitioners who might be listening to this, or maybe some in-house counsel at a company that hasn't really been filing design patents. Where would you recommend a company start thinking about what should they be getting design patents for?

SPEAKER_02They might have all kinds of products and services, and they might be getting utility patents. But where do they start thinking about, you know, maybe this is something we should also consider design patents for?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think two areas, if they are putting out consumer. If the budget allows, they should get another design patent on the DNC. You got to start somewhere.

SPEAKER_01You know, that's the general advice. Now, companies with extremely large budgets, you know, get design patents on every piece of every product that they can that they think is novel and not obvious. If you want a good example, look at Apple's portfolio because they have the Stern Kessler firm that does a great job. Which actually has a big design practice now. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Huge, huge. And we do too.

SPEAKER_01We represent a segment. When I say we, I mean segment design law group of which I am of counsel now. We do a substantial part of Apple's work as well. You know, we're small, but we still get the work. And when you say the DNA

SPEAKER_02of a product, you're saying not just the product as a whole, but different components that make up the

SPEAKER_01whole thing. Just suppose with this microphone that this This particular circle here or this particular shape is unique. Suppose previously they had gone like this and now they go like this. Well, you certainly want to get a design pattern on the shape of this head or a shape of this apart from the rest of it. So you put this in solid lines, right? And you put the rest in broken lines.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Simple.

SPEAKER_02Another concern I guess that comes up is, you know, if you're also filing utility patents on a product, you know, you're filing on the functional stuff. Is there a risk when you're filing a design, then you're saying it's ornamental and then utility? How do you navigate that kind of concern?

SPEAKER_01Well, it comes up more in trade risk law, which I will not get into. In design In patent law, I have a particular view of functionality. And that view is every design consists of parts which are utilitarian, which perform a function. Every single piece on this mic performs a function. And I could go through it and name the function.

SPEAKER_01They also, the same pieces, have a shape. And you can protect that shape with a design pattern. It doesn't conflict with utility. Because it just protects the appearance of it, even though it is functional. I like to use the word utilitarian. So, Sport Dimension is a case that talks about this. Just because it performs a function does not mean that it's not ornamental,

SPEAKER_01does not mean that you can't get a design patent on it.

SPEAKER_02What if in your utility patent you say because of that shape, that's why it has that utilitarianism? Are you running into issues there?

SPEAKER_01It is possible to draft the claim, and I did this once, that reads on the shape of a product. I did it for one of those square apple adapters that had rounded corners, very unique at the time. And I wrote a claim that read on the shape of that adapter. It doesn't happen a lot. It was kind of a test case. But it's possible to do that.

SPEAKER_01More often, however, the shape is not what is emphasized in a utility pen. It could be mentioned in the spec that this particular shape gives certain advantages, but it's always the function. You know, it's always in a utility pen. It's how it works, not how it looks.

SPEAKER_00Companies are constantly innovating, but capturing those ideas and deciding which are worth protecting can be difficult. IP Copilot uses AI to uncover potential inventions in the tools teams already use. It connects those ideas, invention disclosure, That's what makes IP Copilot such a natural fit for Clause 8 this season. Discover, manage, and protect your IP at ipcopilot.ai. [music]

SPEAKER_02I guess the next step is, let's say you decide to file a design pen application is, as you earlier said, decide what's going to be in solid lines versus dashed lines. Can you tell us a little bit more about how, is it an art or can you make it more of

SPEAKER_01like a rigorous kind of approach? If you have a budget. Yeah. Not unlimited, but if you have a budget to file five design, you know, the thing about a design patent, you only get one claim. One claim. So if you want a scope, you got to file five or 10 design patents from the broadest to the narrowest. And you can imagine with each design patent, you are adding solid lines.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. The first one, very minimal solid lines. The last one, maybe all solid lines. But that's how you get a scope of protection. Am I answering your question?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah, So maybe let's start for that first filing. Did you just... Is it all solid? Yes.

SPEAKER_01First filing is all solid. Okay. Here's a trick of the trade. There's a practice for filing what's called an appendix with your first application. And the appendix can be 20, 30, 50 pages long and consist of other embodiments of the design. Yeah. It gets the original filing date.

SPEAKER_01So if you want to file a continuation before the first patent issues, you are entitled to that original filing date and you can pick any one the appendix to file on. It becomes its own application. It's examined. And when it issues, it gets a 15 year term.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Imagine. I am filing continuations now that were originally filed in 2001. And each one that issues gets a 15-year term because in design patents, they're measured from the issue date, not from the filing date. The other cool part... The appendix can have a piece of furniture, a chair, it can have a lighting fixture, it can have a car, or it can have the same kind of product that you're claiming.

SPEAKER_01You're not limited. It's really weird, isn't it? And there's nothing in the MPEP about this. Nothing. I kind of invented it. Back in 2001, and it worked.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, you know, I've obviously, you know, I do some of this work and I design panel work, but I've really studied how different firms do it, including your firm, of course, and Stern Kessler. And there's a huge variety. So, for example, sometimes you see a filing. It's filed with 30 different figures of different interfaces. And sometimes you have separate filings that go after particular

SPEAKER_01types of interfaces. The 30 is the same idea as the appendix. Because what they'll do, file a preliminary amendment canceling everything but one environment. And they will use the five that they cancel for continuations. It's the same idea.

SPEAKER_02So I guess, you know, you said if you have a... Not an unlimited budget, but you want to get like five. But let's say, and I know you told me it's not the area that you're most focused on, but let's say you have like a new web interface or something like that, or a new app or something like that. And you're planning, right, how many Any design applications will I file in the beginning? Should you just file one with a huge appendix with everything? Or how would you think about that?

SPEAKER_01The same rules apply to a GUI. The thing about GUIs that you don't find in... Other designs or utility patents is you can claim animations from state A to state B to state C to state D that the GUI moves and changes from each one. And that's something that you cannot do with other design patents. So that's a very valuable thing when you have something that changes

SPEAKER_01the way it looks through a series of states. And do you think those are much more difficult in French? It depends again on the talent of the guy who's drafting the application.

SPEAKER_02You know, another thing, obviously, in the Apple versus Samsung case, to the extent that you talk about it, but, you know, there were other designs out there that kind of had some aspects of it. And it was kind of navigating both the validity and infringement pieces there. And obviously, the icons aren't ever going to be exactly the same. The text is not going to be exactly the same. The colors won't be exactly the same. How do you think about that piece, that to have enough for it to be valid versus making sure you're not,

SPEAKER_02you will have infringement, I guess?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think it was the array and the colors that got Apple over the hump on that, the screen, the home screen. Because the individual icons were not the same as Apple. Samsung. But there was a great piece of evidence in that case. And Samsung had tried for years to compete with Apple. And they They found a memo from Samsung's executives to their engineers.

SPEAKER_01It basically said, copy the Apple iPhone. So that was a very cool piece of evidence. Not all the Apple Patents were found to infringe, but enough of them that the damages really mounted up quickly because of the volume of sales. So validity and infringement was determined by the Federal Circuit. The Supreme Court had this very narrow article of manufacture issue, right?

SPEAKER_01So validity and infringement was not in front of the Supreme Court.

SPEAKER_02Well, actually, just to circle back, in terms of when you're filing a design patent, and there might be very distinctive, and I don't want, not as a term of art, but there might be very unique aspects to that, like a specific color or specific text. Right. Would you include those or would you include those, not include those, include those in dashed lines?

SPEAKER_01Well, it depends how unique it is. Yeah. And... You could claim a single, you know, square. You could claim the color, which is usually limiting, right? Each thing that you claim limits your claim. So if you do rounded corners, you... You're excluding square corners. If you do yellow, you're excluding red, right?

SPEAKER_01If you do a piano, you're excluding a violin. So the more information you have in that icon, the less broad, the more narrow is the claim. So you have to decide what it is before you file. Yeah. And then I guess you could go broader, like you said,

SPEAKER_02with continuations. You know, last thing about, specifically about GUIs, obviously the USPTO issued guidance this year about the fact, you know, it was kind of an outdated aspect that you have to... Explicitly tied to an article of manufacture. Obviously you have now all kinds of creative interfaces that might not be. What do you think about that guidance?

SPEAKER_01I think it's ridiculous. I mean, to have to put a computer screen in broken lines, I mean, what's the point? But the general counsel of the patent office looks back at this 1992 case that held that the GUI itself is not an article of manufacture. Yeah. So for a long time, you have to put these screens on the patent as a broken line.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if that's the case today because I don't do much work in that space. Maybe it's changed in the last few years, but I'm not the expert in that.

SPEAKER_02I guess we'll have to see what the courts actually end up doing. Yeah. Another, I guess, more recently, the LKQ case about obviousness went up to the federal circuit. Everybody was concerned that the federal circuit was opening up the floodgates on all kinds of designs being obviousness. There would be more one of three rejections.

SPEAKER_01The LKQ case. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02At the patent office. We haven't seen that. Does that decision concern you? No.

SPEAKER_01You know, if you think about it in a particular way, it's very easy to understand, right? First of all, understand that the Supreme Court loves to smack the Federal Circuit on the nose. I would say in every case, the Federal Circuit is concerned that the Supreme Court is going to reverse them, and they don't want that. That's number one. Number two... You've got the KSR case, right,

SPEAKER_01from the Supreme Court that says obviousness, when you judge obviousness, you need a flexible approach, right? And you need to go through the Gorham steps religiously, one, two, three. Well, that hasn't been the approach of obviousness on the design patent side. You can say what you will. There's a body of 50-year-old, 35-year-old case law that was a framework for obviousness,

SPEAKER_01but it wasn't that flexible, and it didn't follow, by and large, So all the federal circuit did was really say, we don't want to get slapped around by the Supreme Court, so let's bring the test for obviousness of design patents into accordance with KSR. That's what they said. But I don't think it's had much effect, to be honest.

SPEAKER_02I think that answers it. What about like the examination itself? You know, it's, I guess, very easy. Once you apply, once you file a design patent application, the patent office usually just, you know, makes some formalities, some minor issues, but usually just issues the patent. Does that concern you? Do you think it would be better if the examination at the patent office was a little more stringent, or do you think it kind of makes sense for design patents?

SPEAKER_01There's a certain group percentage of design patents that are filed by people who don't know what they're doing, especially from Europe, right? I have this sophisticated background or practice that U.S. practitioners do. So I've seen case after case come in with all solid lines, you know. And more than one embodiment, subject to restriction requirements,

SPEAKER_01those are the cases that wind up getting prosecuted in the patent office. U.S. practitioners, by and large, are more sophisticated, and they file cases that sail through. So, you know, there's a guy who, Patton Leo, what's his name, Dennis Crouch? Yeah. And he publishes the statistics and he says things like getting a design patent is like getting a rubber stamp.

SPEAKER_01They come in, you stamp it, and they go out. It's like a registration system. It's like they have in Europe. You just register designs. They're not examined in Europe. I really like that, actually.

SPEAKER_02So you don't have an issue with that characterization? No.

SPEAKER_01I think designs ought to be registered, ought to be cheap and quick. The problem today is that they take a long time. It's like two or three years' pendency for design patent, during which you have no protection. In Europe, one day. And you have some level of protection. And if a competitor wants to challenge the validity, he can file, I guess,

SPEAKER_01what's called an opposition or something like that and challenge your one design patent, right? And then it's examined. Why examine the entire universe of design patents when they'll never be litigated? It doesn't make any sense.

SPEAKER_02You know, you mentioned that, you know, some still do that, but they just file something in solid lines, just get that one issue design patent and kind of think that's enough to protect them, but it's likely not. Any other mistakes that kind of stand out to you that you see being made with design patents?

SPEAKER_01Well, you know, there's this restriction requirement practice. Yeah. And you need to be very careful, right? Because you generally don't want to file embodiments that are obvious in view of each other because they'll be kept in the same case, right? Yeah. And Deemed, therefore, substantially the same.

SPEAKER_01So an infringer can come along and make a third one between the first two and say it's substantially the same. Or he can wait until you divide your two and make a third one and say it's not substantially the same. So restriction practice is very tricky and you have to handle it in a certain way. And you can make mistakes pretty easily, yeah.

SPEAKER_02So what was your advice? Obviously, you know, somebody gets a restriction, they file divisional to make sure they don't leave anything on the table. Any other advice you would provide?

SPEAKER_01Find a design patent lawyer who knows what that may sound. Yeah. Kind of, you know, basic, but it's a sophisticated area that not a lot of patent lawyers or design lawyers know about. You have to really get into it. Yeah. Well, part of it is, I think,

SPEAKER_02you know, it's still an art. I think there's no... I think it's much less precise than you doing utility work, right? There's a lot of it come through. Do you feel like in your gut the right path or is it more systematic than that when you look at issues like that?

SPEAKER_01There are not a lot of issues like that, really. Like you said, most of them sail through. So that's one issue that you asked me to identify, which is complicated, and you have to be careful about. Nothing else particularly comes to mind. There's the old broken line, solid line thing, but, you know, If you don't know about that, you've had your head in the sand.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You mentioned you've been... There's some... Clients you've been filing, their continuations for 15 years, I think you said. Obviously, you know, a product is not on the market anymore. I mean, is it kind of a cost decision? You know, if you sell the product, you know, another $4,000 or whatever it is to file a design application, it's probably worthwhile. Is that kind of you? If the product is

SPEAKER_01not on the market. Oh, sorry, if it is on the market, yeah. It's whether the competitor's product is on the market. Yeah. Then you want something to go after them with. So we look at what's left to claim. Maybe it's just the handle. And they're copying the handle. The hell with the rest. So they go after a patent on the handle. You said you kind of had to build the market for design patents

SPEAKER_02and then... Is there anything else that you think kind of you would like to improve about, besides this thing that you mentioned, anything else that stands out to you about that you would like to improve about the design patterns system?

SPEAKER_01To kind of make it a more... Well, you know, we haven't mentioned the big case. Were you going to get to that? No. The big case now pending is range of motion. The question in that case, I have to back up a little bit. Egyptian goddess from 2008 is the case for determining design patent infringement. In that case, the court did away with the Point of Novelty Test and said the sole test

SPEAKER_01for determining design patent infringement is whether the two designs are And I'm paraphrasing, substantially the same in overall appearance. And doing that analysis, the court, as it tends to do, went through, oh gosh, 60 years, 70 years, 80 years of case law. It took them five or six pages to do that. And in just about every one of those cases...

SPEAKER_01They described how the court compared the patented design and the accused design, quote, in light of the prior art. So they used the prior art as As a baseline, as an objective way, the only objective way, to compare the patented and accused designs. And you can appreciate this. If the patented and accused designs. If either the patented or accused designs are closer to each other in appearance

SPEAKER_01than either is to the prior art, chances are there's infringement. However, if either the patented or accused designs are closer to the prior art. In appearance, chances are there's no infringement. So the prior art is a frame of reference that is necessary. Now, the Federal Circuit in that case did not say you always have to consider the prior art.

SPEAKER_01In fact, they said the opposite. After doing this analysis for five or six pages, And saying the sole test is substantially the same, there was one sentence in the opinion without any precedent, without any explanation, that basically said, if the two designs are sufficiently distinct, you don't have to consider the prior line.

SPEAKER_01It was a gift to infringers because they go into court and say, our two designs are sufficiently distinct. Motion for summary judgment of non-infringement granted. Now, what does a court do when they have two designs? How do they determine whether they're sufficiently distinct? There's no guidelines. No court has ever said you have to evaluate A, B, C, and D. They don't do that.

SPEAKER_01There's no case law about how to do that. And what courts do do is they identify four or five differences, and there are always differences, little differences. And they say, well, five differences, they're sufficiently distinct. Now, range of motion is all about challenging this sufficiently distinct range. Standard or test.

SPEAKER_01And there was a dissenting opinion by Chief Judge Moore in that case that says this is ridiculous and we have to correct this from Egyptian guys. So Range of Motion lost the case on the merits. There was a petition for rehearing. I wrote an amicus brief supporting the petition. They're very hard to get granted. The petition was denied,

SPEAKER_01and I have it on good authority that the Supreme Court will get a petition for cert in the next month or two, trying to get that case up there. Of course, the chances of getting cert are close to zero, but So, but maybe we've planted seeds that future litigants can bring up and get the federal circuit to have an, it has to be an en banc rehearing because Egyptian goddess was en banc.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. The only way to change that is another unblocked decision. Anyway, that is to me like the biggest issue facing the profession today. We'll see how long that takes

SPEAKER_02to get corrected. Right, right. But hopefully some of the people are listening to this and they'll take it to heart. You know, I want to end with some questions. Final questions, you know, we have you here, so I want to get as much of your wisdom as I can. You know, you've obviously mentioned Apple, and you've seen other companies that've built successful design patent programs. Anything, I guess, about their experience as a whole, about how they managed to build a successful design patent program along

SPEAKER_02with their utility program?

SPEAKER_01Well, I'll mention something that we have not talked about, but there is an area of companies who get design patents on replacement parts, right? So imagine a tractor. It has these teeth at the bottom for digging. They wear out. And in come the knockoffs that look exactly the same and sell for,

SPEAKER_01I don't know, half the price, a fraction of the price. And the company that owns these... Teeth, the IP to the teeth, get design patents on that shape in order to stop the knuckles. And that is rampant. That is a real moneymaker for the company that owns these design patents. And there's a whole bunch of companies who do this, which is not the standard approach, right?

SPEAKER_01It's not like... Well, they have invented new teeth, but it's not like a consumer product. That's where design patents really come in, is consumer products that are produced in the millions and knocked off from Asia. That's where you really need design protection.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and those work really well, obviously, with the different online marketplaces. There's third-party sellers, and you can take those down. Right, right.

SPEAKER_01There's firms that are very sophisticated in suing unnamed defendants, you know, like, and sophisticated ways of going after Apple and not Apple, sorry, Amazon, not Apple. Freudian Slipman. Amazon and other resellers. Over the years, they've been developed to a high art.

SPEAKER_02Out of everything we talked about today, or maybe something else, if you meet a patent attorney who's never dealt with design patents, what's the one piece of advice you would give them if they are going to help somebody with that?

SPEAKER_01Go do utility banks. Read the papers. Start at the beginning. There's a lot of literature out there. And read the cases. You know, Professor Caton. Back in the day, you know, the Reverend, the Reverend Caden, he gave us the best advice when we were in his class. He said, read the cases. Because it's only by reading the cases you get a feel for what's going on in the law, right?

SPEAKER_01So I would say read the cases, you know.

SPEAKER_02There might be a law student or a junior attorney listening to this, and they might be thinking, wow, that's pretty cool how Perry Sandman, he identified an area of law and kind of created a niche and built kind of a whole career about it, and he became the go-to expert on it. Any advice about... Finding a niche that's worth

SPEAKER_01specializing it. Do exactly the same thing. Get your broad legal degree in, I don't know, business. Business law, corporate law, but pick an area that is neglected, underutilized, figure out why, and hold yourself out as a specialist in that area. And, you know, chances are maybe you're the only one or you're one of a few and you can build

SPEAKER_01a reputation so that when people want an answer to a question in that area, they will come to you. So I say specialize, specialize, specialize. Generalists, you know, don't make it.

SPEAKER_02You know, but how do you figure out of that niche? You know, it's important enough or big enough to be worthwhile. Any thoughts about that? Or, you know, or how do you structure that niche, you know? Like you did for prosecution, litigation, you know, if you just held out yourself as an expert on, any thoughts about that? Building a practice, I guess. How do you pick on this? Yeah, how do you, or how do you, yeah. Or you figure out if a niche is really worthwhile. Let's say you become an expert, I don't know, In a very specific type of plants for plant patterns, you know?

SPEAKER_01It's probably not a good niche there, but... Well, one easy way, it doesn't always work, follow your passion. Something you love, something you're attracted to, something you can put your sweat, tears, toil into and see where that goes. Another thing is to go to conferences and listen to what the expert speakers are talking about.

SPEAKER_01And maybe they're talking about problems that need to be solved. And pick up on that, you know, pick a problem and research it and see how widespread it is or how narrow it is. And, you know, maybe there's only two pages about it in your textbook. And, you know, feel around, do some research, yeah.

SPEAKER_02You know, you were obviously an electrical engineer major. You practiced in utility patents. Why do you think design patents was such a good fit for you?

SPEAKER_01I was not a natural engineer. I could not look at a circuit, just look at it and tell you what it did. I had to figure it out. It was hard for me. Looking at a design was easy compared to looking at a circuit. So I was very happy to get away from electrical engineering because I had to work at it.

SPEAKER_01With designs, I don't know if it came naturally. I don't know if I had this aesthetic sense in me. But I will tell you this. After working in the field for 30 years, when I walk into a restaurant, I either say, Wow, or what were they thinking? It just hits me immediately, the aesthetic sense.

SPEAKER_01I do it with this room, and it's just beautiful in here. I love it. I love the white piano. And the Herman Miller chair that you took out of here. So somebody here has a good aesthetic sense. It's either you or your wife. My wife. She listens to my input. So were you artistic before? No. I was the kind who said, honey, go buy an armoire.

SPEAKER_01I don't care. Just go. Go buy it. So I was very Very laissez-faire until I started getting into designs, design patterns. Then my awareness, right, was increased little by little until I really cared what things look like, right? So it developed over time.

SPEAKER_02That's interesting because I started this podcast and I feel like I've, I never considered myself a creative person, but because of this podcast, it kind of grew within me. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That's cool.

SPEAKER_02You know, I always ask, actually, that I usually finish off on the question about what would you recommend to junior attorneys? But I think you have a very interesting experience in that, you know, you started what's now the largest IP firm in America, at least, Sir Kessler. You moved, then you started Design Law Group. Now you have your own practice. You know, there's likely a managing partner out there who's listening to this, who's maybe on top. They reached the pinnacle,

SPEAKER_02you know, what they worked for their whole career or had a IP somewhere. And they're thinking like, is this really what I meant to do the rest of my life? What advice would you give them about kind of thinking about that and kind of finding the courage to maybe do something different?

SPEAKER_01I guess it comes naturally to me. I think about my Kool-Aid stand when I was a kid. I sold potholders door-to-door that my sister and I made. I was a fuller brush man for a while. I had territory. I went door to door and sold brushes out of a suitcase. I did all sorts of things to make money when I was a kid. So going from one thing to another was kind of very natural for me.

SPEAKER_01I'm not saying it's right for other folks, but for me, you know, big deal.

SPEAKER_02What if somebody's like, they're thinking... They're in the King of the Mountain and they're thinking like, is this something that I should just, now that I'm King of the Mountain, I should just try to find a way to stay here or look for a different mountain, I guess. It depends.

SPEAKER_01What you're trading off, right? What are you getting in exchange for staying versus leaving, right? So you evaluate that. If you have to give up a lot just to stay where you are, maybe it's not worth it. I am an independent cuss. I hate to have bosses. This goes way back. I like to be my own boss. I like to call the shots.

SPEAKER_01I don't like to listen to assholes. And that's just who I am. So if the sacrifice for staying there means that I have to be fourth or fifth in line and answer to some CEO who doesn't know what they're really talking about or wouldn't make the decision I would make because I view myself as a really fair guy. Then it's not worth the sacrifice.

SPEAKER_01I would leave.

SPEAKER_02It's a trade-off. It's practical for you. Yeah, yeah. Any final thoughts?

SPEAKER_01Well, this has been really fun. More fun than... Than I thought it would be. And I really, I mean, going through my history and the career and bringing up Joe Potenza. Hi, Joe. If he's still practicing, I'm not sure. Going over that was great fun. And thinking about the evolution of design patents was cool.

SPEAKER_02Well, thank you. Thank you for coming on Clause 8 and sharing your story and sharing how design patterns came to be what they are today.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to Clause 8. Subscribe at voiceofip.com for more IP conversations and find extra content on the Clause 8 YouTube channel. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Companies Miss 95% of Their Inventions

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Austin Walters saw the AI boom coming as an inventor on more than 650 patents. Now the IP Copilot founder explains how companies lose most of what their engineers invent. He spent two years at a major patent filer...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Coke Morgan Stewart Tells Her Story

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 41 minAudio

    When Coke Morgan Stewart became acting director of the USPTO, much of the patent world knew little about her. In this episode of Clause 8, Stewart, now President and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP),...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How Patent Litigation Really Moves: IAM, IP Fray, and MLex Reporters on the Year in IP

    Sep 29, 202645 minAudio

    To open the season, host Eli Mazour brings together three journalists who cover intellectual property for a living: Olivia Rafferty of IP Fray, Nisha Shetty of IAM, and Inbar Preiss of MLex. They discuss what happens...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Via Eyes "De Facto" Standards for Future Pools

    Jun 2, 202651 minAudio

    Kevin Mack, the new president of Via Licensing Alliance, joins Eli for the Clause 8 season finale. Kevin talks about Via's plans to build its next patent pools around "de facto" standards - technology the market adopted...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. AI Boom Calls for New Copyright Law, Says USPTO Chief Behind the DMCA

    May 19, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    Bruce Lehman, head of USPTO from 1993 to 1998, joins Clause 8 for a wide-ranging conversation about the modern IP system, the internet boom, and why the AI era may require a new copyright response from Congress. Lehman...

    Credit the people on this episode