Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Clause 8

Clause 8 artwork

USPTO Director John Squires' 'Foxhole Buddy' Tells All, Previews Message at Upcoming House Hearing

Mar 22, 20261 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The story of how John Squires became USPTO Director doesn’t start inside the Beltway. It starts on the Appalachian Trail, with Doug Pittman camping under shooting stars the night after Trump won the election. Pittman - a serial entrepreneur, inventor, and self-described “foxhole buddy” and “wingman” of Squires - drove up from Georgia to sit down with Eli for this episode., fresh off a meeting with the new director himself. What he shared was a rare inside account of how Squires ended up in the job, what he walked into, and why Pittman believes the USPTO finally has the right person at the helm. “Andrei went to Trump and said I’ve Got Your Man” The short version: it was Pittman who planted the seed. The moment Trump won, Pittman texted Andrei Iancu - the former USPTO director - from a campsite on the trail. Other names were circulating, and he wasn’t a fan of what he was hearing. His answer was John Squires, his own patent attorney. Iancu’s response: Do you think John would do it? Pittman said he’d ask. When he did, Squires’ reaction was immediate: “Doug, you’ve lost your mind.” But Pittman kept pushing, and Iancu worked his magic with the new admistration. Then Howart Lutnick got confirmed as Commerce Secretary. Squires and Lutnick already had a bond forged after 9/11. When Lutnick landed at Commerce - the patent office’s parent agency - the pieces fell into place. “Andrei went to Trump and said, ‘I’ve got your man.’ Long story short, that’s how John became USPTO nominee.” In this episode, Doug discusses: * Journey from son of a pig farmer to serial entrepreneur - including selling his first company in 1998 without ever opening his own envelope * How a billboard spotted on a drive to college with his son inspired the invention that led his first patent, and the years-long journey to get that first patent granted * Why he cried when the patent arrived - and why tears of joy turned into “tears of unhappiness” * How John Squires led his enforcement strategy and and the twists & turns of that impacted Squires’ view of the patent system * Litigation funders walking away over Section 101 and PTAB exposure * The litigation saga, including the experience of having a judge handle a patent case for the first time * Meeting with former USPTO Director Kathi Vidal and Doug’s unvarnished take on her legacy * The PTAB problem, the injunctive relief gap, and what needs to happen for independent inventors to feel comfortable with the patent system * Squires’ upcoming testimony before the House IP committee - and why Pittman thinks it’s a pivotal moment * His “1-8-8 Project,” his advice to Squires to “push the limit,” and the personal picture he sent the director to serve as a daily reminder in his role 📌 Presented by Tradespace - where ideas take flight. Disclaimer This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.voiceofip.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Clause 8, the number one podcast on intellectual property, trusted by top in-house counsel, judges, and policymakers worldwide. Hosted by Eli Mazur, we bring you in-depth conversations with the personality-shaping IP, brought to you by TradeSpace, where ideas take flight. If you enjoy conversations like this, take a moment to subscribe at voiceofip.com and stay connected to the leading voices in IP. Today, we're joined by Doug Pittman,

a serial entrepreneur and patent owner who's experienced firsthand the highs and

SPEAKER_00lows of the innovation journey. From building and exiting multiple businesses to developing patented technology and navigating complex litigation, Doug brings a unique, ground-level perspective on the patent system. In this episode, we explore his path into IP, the challenges of licensing and enforcement, and his insights into how the system can evolve to better support inventors.

SPEAKER_01So today we're lucky to be joined by Doug Pittman, somebody who we've had some friendly battles over the years, you know, some banter. And I got to know Doug when he's a serial entrepreneur. And I got to know him as he was enforcing his... Patents and a long-running patent litigation. I got him to know that time. He reached out to me, had a lot of thoughts. But more recently, something interesting happened where the attorney who was leading that effort, helping him lead that effort, John Squires,

SPEAKER_01became the USPTO director. And I found that out actually because of Doug, because Doug told me he was helping him in that effort to become the USPTO director. So, Doug, thank you so much for joining Clause 8. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for allowing me to come. And I appreciate the invite. You know, I don't do this much, but... You're a special guy. You're a fighter like me, and I like to help people. So, yeah, I'll be glad to open up and try to give you some insight.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's great. I appreciate that. You know, we're recording in D.C. You drove off your truck from Georgia for this, but you mentioned that you actually met with, you were at the USPTO, you met with John Squires. Before we get into your story, anything, I guess, any impressions from that, anything new that you heard?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, you know, when me and John meet or talk or on the phone or whatever, we always have some pretty good in-depth conversations. I mean, there's been quite a few times where John's told me, Doug, you've lost your mind. and uh that's okay you know we we we have some really really good conversations and he doesn't i don't expose anything that uh when we when we communicate text um stuff like that i don't i don't i don't really expose any of

that because we've got some what's called deep sick secrets and uh you know i i just try to help him yeah

SPEAKER_01but but maybe like Anything about what the patent office is focused on and where they're going?

SPEAKER_02Well, you know, John is... When he first started... You know, he got the nomination. I always ask him, I said, John, are you sure you want to do this? I mean, it was it's just a mess. I mean, he would always say, yeah, we you know, somebody's got to do it. And, you know, Judge Rader back a couple of years ago, we were in a conference and Judge Rader said, you know, guys, we need a hero. You know that that John is to me, that hero. John doesn't need that position.

SPEAKER_02The position needs John. And if, you know, John was my attorney. Yeah. He was my, he had, he run my team. And him and Andre, I introduced him to Andre.

SPEAKER_01And that's Andre Yonko.

SPEAKER_02Andre Yonko, former UPS director, when Andre was, had left the USPTO. Yeah. Me and him had a conversation, a lot of conversations. And how I met Andre was we were at a conference, and I went up to him as a patent owner. I was invited to a conference. I try to get invited to these things sometimes. But this was an important one, and I wanted to go. And I met him, and he was on a panel.

SPEAKER_02This was after he was director? Yeah, this was after he was director. I went up to him after the panel, and I said— I said, I want to get a picture with you. He said, okay. He said, why do you want to get a picture with me? I said, because my patents may not be worth anything, but at least I'll have the picture with the guy that signed them. So he was like, okay. And from that point on, which has been several years, we've become friends. So I introduced him to John because I wanted him to be a part

of our legal team.

SPEAKER_02And him and John then built a relationship over the years. So it's a long story. I was on the Appalachian Trail hiking in 2024. And this was just after Trump had won. And this is going to sound crazy to people, but I was camping and it was a beautiful, beautiful night. And all of a sudden I knew Trump had won. I didn't know how he won because the stars were – they were shooting stars.

SPEAKER_02So I said, you know, Trump's got to win. But I was in Dalton, Massachusetts. I guess you were a Trump fan. On the Appalachian Trail. And, yeah, I mean, you know, that's part of the scenario. But— Yeah, I was in Dalton, and I actually texted Andre, and I said, so now that Trump's in the presidency,

SPEAKER_02who are we going to put in as USPTO director? He says, I don't know, Doug. Who do you suggest? I said, well, you're going to do it. I actually got to text him back and forth. He said, I don't think I'm going to run. Now, this was not—this was— in between a couple of weeks. But at that time, I asked him, who's he going to run? He said, no, I don't think I'm going to do it this time. So he went and— Did it surprise you to hear that he didn't want to do it again? Well, I didn't know how it worked. I didn't know how it worked.

SPEAKER_02I didn't know if you could. So I just asked him. He said, well, I don't think I will. He said, who do you think would do it? I think at that time they were talking about— the Google guy. And I'm just, that's all I'm going to say, the Google guy. And we all know who that is. And nobody wanted that.

SPEAKER_01The Intel guy, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And, and I was like, you know, we can't have that. He said, who do you visual? For the record.

SPEAKER_01It was a Vishal Amin. Yeah. See, you speak better.

SPEAKER_02I'm from the North Georgia. There's a lot of rumors about him.

SPEAKER_01Atlanta area. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02There were rumors about him doing it. And I was like, well, that can't happen. It cannot happen. Um, And so he went and he said, who do you think? And I said, well... Do you have any idea? And he said, I really don't. And so I said, what about John Squires? He said, do you think John would do it? I said, I don't know. I'll ask him. And so the conversation began. Have you ever talked to John about it before? No. No, no, no, no, no. We didn't even think about it before. I didn't ever think about it before the election. But what happened was,

you know, John being my patent attorney, and we had just got out of PTAB.

SPEAKER_02It had just hit. I was pissed. I mean, I was mad because when you have 44 shareholders that are depending on the patent system and you lost in PTAB to three judges that basically didn't even know your technology, oh, I was fuming. And I couldn't get anybody to really get moving on it either. So I know we're going in different directions, but I just want to build up to where –

SPEAKER_02The USPTO, we had lost it, and John was the attorney, and we had lost in federal court, and John was the attorney, and John was pissed. I was pissed. I mean, when I first— Were you pissed at John? No. I was pissed at the system because I was introduced to John from a guy that I brought in to be my CRO of my company, Board Active, back then. Yeah. And he introduced him. He said,

SPEAKER_02Doug, if this guy takes it, it'll go to the next level, which John is an outstanding lawyer. He is the absolute – I mean, he did all he could do. I mean, he is strong. He knows the laws. He is very – small business oriented. And he, um, really, really, uh, worked hard to, to try to get us to a certain point and level, but John, I was pissed and I was pissed. And so,

SPEAKER_02you know, getting back to the story, um, of all this coming together, um, you know, I, I, I tell John that, you know, when John got first got the, um, um,

SPEAKER_01So go back, I guess you told, you said, Andre, you'd ask John. So you asked John what was John's reaction, I guess, when you asked him whether he'd be interested in becoming the USPTO director. You've lost your mind.

SPEAKER_02So we've, you know, but, you know, it all I turned it over. I mean, I really just let them work through it. You know, there was a lot of people that helped get this thing moving so that John become USPTO director. But the bottom line is, is Andre went to Trump and and said, hey, I got your man. Long story short, he said, I got your man. And John, that's how John became USPTO nominee.

SPEAKER_01And what do you think made, obviously, you know, Andre knows a lot of people in the pattern world. What made him think like, you know, John is the right guy for the role at the time.

SPEAKER_02Because I pounded it in his head.

SPEAKER_01Andre, we got to have John.

SPEAKER_02And then once it got in my mind that John was wanting to be there, me and Andre had some pretty good conversations about, you know, making it happen.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02But, uh, you know, Andre was always secretive about, you know, his conversations and such, but yeah, Andre, and then there was other people involved. Don't get it. Don't get me wrong. There's other people. It took, it took some effort to get John in as, as the USPTO director. Yeah. But, um, you know, the main thing I say is you just got to start that conversation with the right people. And if you want to get things done and that's, that's what I wanted to do.

SPEAKER_01It's an amazing story because obviously there's probably, uh, people who dream about having a role like USPTO director and are kind of built their whole lives about it. And then you, you know, John wasn't even thinking about it and you kind of put him in touch and it kind of randomly happened. Do you know, like, I guess you probably, you know, there was some coverage of that, you know, there's other people up for that role. Oh, yeah, there was some people up for that role, and there was a lot of friction out there.

SPEAKER_02And you remember those, if you saw the social media, LinkedIn and stuff, there was a lot of back and forth, under the table type stuff going on. I mean, everybody was pushing their own person. And even some of the inventor groups were very ticked.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's an interesting, I guess, aspect to that because – You know, you're an inventor, you're an entrepreneur, you went through like the worst of what the patent system has. And you're like, you know, I've asked for John, he's a good guy. But some of the inventor groups were saying, well, you know, he's a former blah, blah, chief IP council of Goldman Sachs, and he's testified on behalf of like patent rights. What do you think ultimately...

SPEAKER_01helped him get the role. Like, what do you think, ultimately? Why did the Trump administration really...

SPEAKER_02I mean, Andre had a lot to do with it. There's no doubt. Did John know Howard Lutnick as well? Yeah. He had worked with Lutnick down at Cantor Fitzgerald through 9-11, which is a tremendous story. I don't know if anybody's ever heard it, but it's a tremendous story between those two and how they work together and they become friends and things like that.

SPEAKER_01So he already knew. Yeah, he knew.

SPEAKER_02When Howard got nominated also, then that just kind of 360 and everything.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It worked. If Howard Lottnick went to the treasury, it might've been a different story. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02But, you know, um, you know, and then we can get into the conversation about, you know, how that's, you know, to me, how that's working. Yeah. Uh, between the USPTO and the department of commerce, you know, I went to John and, uh, I was very appreciative and John invited me to the USPTO, his swearing in ceremonies, both of them. And I went to the department of commerce, which is where they, uh, The first patent office was. And it's incredible. It's an incredible piece of art.

And I was just in awe being in with the other people that were there at the ceremony.

SPEAKER_02And, you know, Howard was there and things like that. But it was just a tremendous experience. to see John get sworn in as the USPTO director. You know, when John, when I first hired John, John said, Doug, I says, he says, I don't take cases unless I make millions. And I was like, well, I hope he takes my case. Yeah. Because, you know, I thought it was good patents. He read them and thought everything was good. And so, you know, it just goes back to the guy, just the quality of,

SPEAKER_02Absolutely fantastic, smart man. Like I said, the USPTO is so fortunate to have him as their director. Even though he's ticked off a lot of people, he knows he's got to fix it. He's got to repair, reform that patent system for anybody to be able to get paid.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I want to get back to it, but I want to kind of... Tell a little bit about your story, you know, how you got, you became involved in the pan system. You grew up on a farm. So can you tell us, like, You start from there?

SPEAKER_02I'm the son of a pig farmer. My dad had hundreds of pigs at certain times of my life. It was just a constant rollover. Every Monday morning, I remember getting up at 3 o'clock in the morning to load trucks to take the pigs to the market. Did you think you'd become a farmer? No, I knew I wouldn't become a farmer. That's something I didn't want to do at that time, but as a child, I grew up that way.

SPEAKER_02But the thing that now that I've been in the patent system, farmers are massive in the patent world because if you think about it, a farmer has to – fix things immediately. They have to, they can't run down to the hardware store back, you know, in the days you're far, you're, you're a long way from, from the towns and things like that. So you have to repair things. So, and farmer is the most, one of the more inventive people out there in the, in the whole marketplace. And, My dad has made several inventions that as a child growing up we used,

and I have them hanging on my wall because they're a reminder not only that farming

SPEAKER_02is good. And did he file for patents? No.

SPEAKER_01He should have.

SPEAKER_02They were some really cool inventions that he did. So you're saying even after your experience he should have filed for patents?

SPEAKER_01No.

SPEAKER_02That was pre-AIA, before Obama signed off on killing small businesses. But the ability for a farmer to be able to make things as they need it, that's critical in the farming world. But I didn't ever think that I would be a patent owner for sure. I didn't ever think I would invent anything for business. When I was going down the highway— And taking my son to college.

SPEAKER_02And I saw a beautiful creative, a beautiful billboard. And I didn't know what it said. I didn't know what it meant. And I didn't know where it was. And I didn't know anything about that brand. But I saw that beautiful visual and creative. You know, we all have done it. You look at a billboard and you're like...

SPEAKER_01What was your first business? I know you started a business during the dot com.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I was actually I started out as a landscaper.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You know, I was in school and my my my high school football coach was played under Bear Bryant. And he thought he was Bear Bryant when he coached us. I mean, he was massive, and he was – I mean, he just thought he was Bear Bryant. And anybody who knows Bear Bryant from Alabama will know what I'm talking about. And so he taught us never to quit. That's the thing about never quit. Don't quit. Don't quit. Don't quit. Fourth quarter. Fourth quarter. Everything's fourth quarter. You win it in the fourth quarter, and we won.

SPEAKER_02We were good during our era. I think we lost three or four games max. Yeah. But it was because we were prepared. And in the fourth quarter, you know, we were we were we outperformed because we were in shape and we were just ready to nail it. So, you know, as we got into the into the. landscaping after school and stuff uh i got into landscaping

went from i was um doing uh all kind of work i worked with a guy that uh said doug if you ever want to he said you're a real good sales guy if you ever want to get into um selling

SPEAKER_02copiers uh let me know he says um we'll um I'll be glad to hire you. And it was with Canon USA, which Canon was a good brand. But I had like 20-something employees, tractors, trailers, this, that, and the other and everything. Well, I did a job one time in the middle of summer, 103 degrees, 20-something, three loads of side delay and bulldozers and things like that. But... And it was hot. And we worked our butts off.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. It was a guy that, you know, it was a pretty wealthy individual in Atlanta. And at the end of it, I got paid. And then about three days later, his check bounced. Oh. His check bounced. And I had had enough. Yeah. This was after several years. I had enough. But when I got that, I think it was a $100,000 check that bounced. And it took me two weeks to collect it. Yeah. And I had to threaten the guy to put him in jail in order to get it. I finally got it when I went to the sheriff's office and was

going to write a

SPEAKER_02warrant to call him up and said, hey, get him there. But anyway, long story short, I called up the guy, the cannon said, OK, I want that job. And so I took that job, did it for a year or two, worked with actually worked with those seven copiers. Which was liquid copiers. I sold those. And then a company called Danka bought them out. Danka Business System. It's a long, long, long story short. Danka bought them. Did really well with Danka. Salesman of the Year. Blah, blah, blah. So that's when I knew I could sell.

SPEAKER_02So I wanted to do my own thing. Yeah. And back in the 80s, they didn't have office depots and office magazines and things like that. They used to do these little catalogs. And those catalogs was from a company called B.A. Parr out of Nashville. And it had everything in there, and you could order right there. So I went into business selling pens, pencils, and things like that to businesses. Back then, fax machines were just coming on. So you could fax before it was illegal. You could fax out all kind of orders.

SPEAKER_02I mean, documents and get orders. I mean, orders were coming in like crazy. And so I made a lot of money. But back then, if you you don't remember because you're too young, but I do. But they did not sell computers. uh except ibms and then all of a sudden they did they started you could do built to spec computers yeah well my my dad actually used to uh build computers and sell them in his house in our apartment yeah and so i so companies were like i in the in the catalog they had computers leading edge packard bell these

you know all types

SPEAKER_02leading edge people were buying them like crazy But they also were like, well, can we change things? And I'm like, I don't know. But I ended up going into a company in Alpharetica, Pionics. I worked with those guys to do built-to-spec computers. And so I started working those. And from that point on, I went into retail. I said, well, if all this is building, and so I've got retail stores. And then all of a sudden, I was going to franchise.

And so I had like three stores going to five and a guy come out of Atlanta.

SPEAKER_02He worked with Cisco. He come out of Atlanta and bought me out. Okay. He said, I said, he come in and he said, he said, Doug, he said, he's on build, buy your business. I said, I don't want to sell it. I said, I'm fixing to expand going five. I'm gonna do franchise. I already went to an attorney to get a franchise agreement, starting to do it because I had to, I had to process down. So they, um, said, well, anything's for sale. So he said, I want to come in and meet you. Brought his attorney. He said, get your deal done and I'll get my deal done.

SPEAKER_02Put it out on the table. He had an envelope. I had an envelope. What year was this? 1998-ish. So this was a good time to sell that kind of business. Great. Absolutely a great time to sell. And I had done the volume and stuff. And so I didn't He opened up his envelope, and it was four times more than I wanted. Four times more. And I'm like, I think we could do this. I never opened my envelope.

SPEAKER_02I never showed him my envelope. Matter of fact, I still have that envelope. Yeah, it was sealed. And so it's just a good memory. So I didn't work for a couple years and retired and played. I started hiking. Which is something that, yeah, we'll talk about. So then you were saying you were driving with your son to college and you saw the

SPEAKER_01billboards and this is your second. Well, the second one was I was in the supply chain inventory control business.

SPEAKER_02And I went to, I was working with a company that my dad worked with and they had one warehouse and they didn't have an inventory control system. So I developed and built that for them. I was a Microsoft certified C&E engineer. But I had another guy help me with setting up that inventory control system. And they went from one to 14. But when I did that one, a guy out of Minnesota come in and saw what I had done. And he actually bought me out of that. Okay. So I didn't really have anything going.

SPEAKER_02So you had the golden touch. Yeah, well, and so I went to work with another guy that was in the supply chain and got him up and going and rolling. I didn't own it or anything. I just helped him in a position. And then I got that guy up to a point to where— After a year and a half, he went and sold it. And he went to Costa Rica, and I ain't seen him since. But then, like I said, I retired. Not retired, really. I was, like I said, hiking and doing things.

But then I was taking my son to college, and I saw that beautiful creative. I didn't know what it said, didn't know what it meant, didn't know anything about it.

SPEAKER_02And the family was like... You know, gosh, you know, I wasn't going to turn around and go up to the next intersection, come back and look at it. So I said, there's got to be a way to bring that back down to the end user, someone that could interact with that brand. So I actually, my patents were to create a visual product. and bring it down to a mobile device so the customer could engage, move, measure, and retarget with that brand.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02It's called visualmatic technology.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it's a great idea, and obviously you saw others using it. But what made you think of—was that the first patent applications you filed at that point?

SPEAKER_02What made you, I guess— Well, I didn't think about even patent. I went and did research on it. Yeah. I spent a lot of money on research. I had my sons doing things like— Doing geolocation. Send me the geolocation of this billboard as you go up the road and things like that. So I knew that it would be geolocation-based. But I didn't really have a clue to what the invention was going to be. And I wasn't even really thinking about a patent. As I built my company, I started a company based on that. And that's the thing about it.

SPEAKER_02I started a company, Eli. Yeah. And when I started that company, I had visions as a small entrepreneur, and I was thinking, wow, this could be big. I did marketing studies, and I even went to New York to talk to some Wall Street guys and made them sign NDAs and things like that on what it could do. Yeah. And they were like, Doug, this could be massive. Because at the time, there was nothing like it.

SPEAKER_02I mean, there was, you know, there was geolocation and there was, you know, notifications and things like that. But the ability to take a visual and bring it down to a mobile device so a consumer, you know, could take that. Well, I took that a little step further. I made it an audience-based thing. platform so that if you're in like a stadium, a brand could geofence that stadium and also interact with those particular app users. I knew all this was coming down to the geolocation and apps and

things like that.

SPEAKER_02So it took me years to get that mentality. I actually went to an out-of-home company. I had an app myself. And then the out-of-home company said, Doug, nobody will put... your brand, your name on their brand. They won't do it. They just won't do it. So as I was driving back, I called up a friend of mine and I said, you know, we've got to totally change this whole mindset and concept. I went from an app to a software company. So we, on the road, I said, we're not going to make it.

SPEAKER_02We won't make it. So we started developing. I developed it three times. But I needed money and I needed money bad. So I started asking friends for an investor. Yeah. And friends became investors. And those investors, one of my first investors said, Doug, you need to patent this. And I'm like, I don't know. Well, I said, you know, what is it? Why do we need to patent it?

SPEAKER_02I didn't even really know what a patent meant. I really didn't. I knew that it was an invention, and I knew that you got a certificate, and back years ago, you got paid for licensing agreements and things like that. But I just did not know... what I was getting into. I really didn't. But I met up with some attorneys. So your friend convinced you, the investor convinced you to get those patents.

SPEAKER_01You started that process. You obtained those patents and you're still trying to build the business. At what point did you realize, hey, somebody's using our technology and we'll need to enforce this? Or what made you come to that conclusion?

SPEAKER_02You know, when you're an inventor and when you file a patent, I think it was 2016, 2015 or so when we started writing the patent. But the thing about it was we really worked from 2014 until 2016, which is about a year and a half, two years, to even get the thing filed. Me and my attorney would actually sit down because we needed to vet it. We worked hard. We worked very hard.

SPEAKER_02We would go and whiteboard it. Because what I knew is he needed to understand what my technology was. That's a big thing that happens with patent attorneys, patent prosecutors, is they don't really understand what the pure technology is. So, you know, you have to do a deep dive. An attorney has to have a great relationship with that patent prosecutor in order to make it – Really viable. But we did all the right things. We worked it. We got it down.

SPEAKER_02He understood my technology. He wrote the patents. He sent them in to the USPTO, and we sat and waited. And waited and waited. It was like three years before I got my patent. Now, in between that, they did all kind of back and forth. And the patent examiner was a 30-year veteran. She was someone that— Turned down 24 out of 25 patents that came her way. She just wouldn't give them.

SPEAKER_02She worked with the big boys. She worked with the Microsofts and people like that.

SPEAKER_01And do you know, did it end up in one of those business method art units? Was it like a difficult part of a patent office? It wasn't.

SPEAKER_02It was difficult. It was just unbelievable that a small inventor could get that patent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Must have had a really good patent attorney.

SPEAKER_02Well, at that time, I thought he did. Until you go to federal court and you go to PTAB, you don't know how good or bad your attorney is. I've always said your patent is only as good as your first lawsuit. And there was mistakes made that people brought out. I guess so what – you obtained the patent. I guess what made you kind of think like – Well, when I obtained the patent, it was at our Christmas party in 2019.

SPEAKER_01So this was – By the way, did you meet with the examiner yourself or no? No. No, no.

SPEAKER_02No, he kept me away from the examiner. I would have blew it probably, but – But, yeah, you know, let me talk to him. I mean, there are some things I could say, but I don't want to get the guy in trouble. But we did some things. So I knew what was going on. But so at the Christmas party, I actually cried. Yeah. I did. I cried when I received it because I was so overwhelmed with emotions and such. But looking back on it.

I thought those were tears of cheer, but they were not tears of cheer to be.

SPEAKER_02Those were tears of unhappiness because I had no idea. Because at that time you thought it was like, you got the pattern? I thought I was brilliant. I thought I was, I'm an inventor. And, you know, so we kept filing more and more and more and more patents. Which is a good strategy, obviously. Yeah, we were building our portfolio to where I think we had 14 or 15 patents.

SPEAKER_01So then, I guess, what made you kind of decide to, I guess, start trying to enforce your patents?

SPEAKER_02Oh, it got out into the marketplace. Because we were marketing it. And we did crazy, stupid things looking back on it, like send out letters to corporations saying, hey, we want to talk to you about doing a license agreement. Yeah. I mean, we sent at least 200, at least 200. And I'm not talking about us as a company. I'm talking about legal groups because that was the strategy. Okay, let's send them out. Not threatening. We're not threatening them.

SPEAKER_02We're not doing anything like that.

SPEAKER_01So you found an attorney. So I guess you had your product and you saw that people started using your inventions. Right. I'm guessing you found a lawyer who said, all right, we should... Well,

SPEAKER_02you know, it was part of our legal team. You know, we found lawyers and things to go after. And did they warn you, like they said, those lawyers, did they say, well...

SPEAKER_01This was a hard time to enforce bad acts.

SPEAKER_02No, no, no. This was before it was hard.

SPEAKER_01This was like 2020-ish. No, this was still hard. I mean, you said after AIA got passed in 2010. It was already hard. I mean, Section 101 was a concern. Right. This was... But those attorneys, what was the expectation? You thought, like, you'd send those letters and— We thought we would get some people to want to do

SPEAKER_02license agreements, and we were trying to do what a business does. Hey, let's get it out. We didn't threaten. There was no threatening of litigation or anything. I told them, do not do that. That's a bad strategy. Yeah. I said, let's just try to let them know, number one, let them know we're in the business. Number two, let them know that we want to share our innovation, which is what an inventor does. So you kind of want to work with them together, yeah. And did anybody respond positively? No. No. No one. Every one of them said, don't contact us again.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02Most of them said, or they turned it over to their lawyers. And we got letters back saying, we're not, you know, we don't agree with it. We don't want to do it. Now, these were nice letters. These were not threatening letters. These were in any way, foreign president. We were surprised. I understand. Like, I'm surprised your lawyers were surprised. Because this is kind of a... These days is what you expect. These days. Now, this was back, like I said, this was back in 2020-ish, 2021.

SPEAKER_01But I guess from your perspective, putting lawyers away, I guess, you've been an entrepreneur, a small businessman in your life. I'm guessing you're the kind of guy like, you know, you pay your bills. And that's somebody, a company's using your technology and you tell them that and you have a patent and they're like, And they just refused to pay to license your technology. No, they refused to talk.

SPEAKER_02To talk, yeah. I'll tell you this. Let me tell you what I did. Google. Yeah. We talked to Google. Yeah. We were on the phone with them. I'm not going to say who the attorney was, but we were on the phone with Google, and my attorneys were on the phone with them, and Google told us, said, Doug, you've got great patents. You've got great technology. He said, but we're not going to license you, and we're not going to buy you. That's when I knew there was trouble. And did they say why? They just said, we don't want it. We don't do that. We don't license.

SPEAKER_02We don't buy nobody. And again, that's when I knew there was big trouble. That's when I went. Oh, wow. And I knew we were in trouble. And sometimes it's the smaller companies who are more willing to license. Yeah, we went after mid-sized companies too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because they're more practical, I guess.

SPEAKER_02Well, you know, our strategy was, okay, we'll go after mid guys and, you know, maybe they'll do business with us. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01No. Same response. Yeah. And, you know, they probably had their attorneys telling them not to do that. So I guess what did you then kind of decide? You don't want to throw out to them. What did you decide? All right. We got to. We got to go after an infringer. Yeah. We got to go after.

SPEAKER_02An infringer.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And then we picked out a midsize infringer. I was kind of excited.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Which is a company everybody, you don't mind me. No, no, I don't mind you. It was Foursquare, right? Foursquare. Yeah. So I guess it's a company that people know, but obviously it's, you know, and I guess your attorney's decided, I guess, time to file a lawsuit, right? Remember, my attorney was John Squires. Okay. So that's actually part of the story. So So you had attorneys who were doing the licensing. Was John Squires involved in that, or did he get involved after?

SPEAKER_02He was involved in that. He was involved. I mean, he was my main attorney, and he had help, no doubt. He had other attorneys that he was working with, but, I mean, John was— you know, very, very into the, okay, you know, I've seen John's work. It was unbelievable, the work that he did in order to prepare for all of this.

SPEAKER_01But was he concerned about, like, the PTAB in Section 101? I know when he saw your parents, he said they're strong parents, but was he concerned about? He was concerned about he wanted to stay out of PTAB.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. He wanted to stay out of PTAB. We was in federal court. We went to federal court and that was a disaster. You know, the judges up there, they actually added a judge for our case and it was his first case. Before we get to that point, obviously, like litigation, one thing about litigation, like...

SPEAKER_01Smaller company like yours, it takes a lot of resources, right? And I'm sure you were calculating that. Like, what was your thinking about, like, you know? Well, we went through litigation funder applications where we went and talked to John.

SPEAKER_02We talked to many, many litigation funders. And back then, litigation funding was... I mean, 101 and PTAB was absolutely their scare tactics. I mean, it had to be a very, very, very tight case.

SPEAKER_01If it was like a hint of 101 issues, they didn't want to take it.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I had big litigation firms. One of them is, I'll tell you, GLS Capital told me. GLS said, Doug, you've got great patents and such. But he said, your patents... He said, we're just— They're in Chicago. He said, we're afraid of 101 and PTAB. He said, otherwise, we'd write patents galore. I mean, Anoop and all those guys. I know them all. I know all these guys. I've been to these big conferences, and they invite me to go speak on panels.

SPEAKER_02I just got out of a panel in Houston.

SPEAKER_01Yes, so I guess back to your story is that— You were, I guess when you started doing litigation funders, at that point you kind of knew there might be some issues, but that didn't discourage you kind of from... No,

SPEAKER_02because I had John.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02John knew what he was doing. I just turned it all over to him and let him handle it. And we filed the cases. He had an associate that worked with the cases. It was under another group, but he actually was a teammate with this guy. And we went and filed the case. And, um, and we thought it was a pretty good case. Yeah. And, and like I said, we've got to a judge in Delaware who was the first time judge,

SPEAKER_02which, which is not a great, it was a horrific because he'd never done a patent case, never done a patent case. Matter of fact, he come up with something stupid. And if he's on, I hope he hears me as was stupid. He said, uh, that it was, uh, you know, something that Homer Simpson did in one of his, their cartoon episodes. And, uh, And everybody was like, that don't even make sense. He didn't even understand our technology. Well, just the fact that a judge would say that kind of dismiss your

creativity.

SPEAKER_02Well, what I did was – and this was the controversial part of this – What I did was I said, you know, we had come down a point to where they threatened PTAB. We're going to go PTAB, PTAB, PTAB. But I said, no. I said, we're not going to be afraid of PTAB, but we're not going to give away our company. We're not going to share licensing agreements with no payments and things like that. So because there was some formalities in the case itself,

I actually dismissed the case.

SPEAKER_01Oh, you dismissed that case.

SPEAKER_02I got it dismissed.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02So they did not get a judgment, and we didn't get a judgment. I just dismissed the case. But it was only because of a flaw is they didn't actually answer the suit. Okay. So did you file—was that the end of a litigation trial? Well, they then, the next day, because we let it, we went, you know, the time limit. They had one day, they wanted to do all five, but they didn't have time. I played the game with them. I run the clock down so that they couldn't do all five.

SPEAKER_02They only did two. Yeah. And so. We did two what? They did two patents.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. P-tabbed.

SPEAKER_01Oh, P-tab. Okay. And so you were having this battle at the P-tab.

SPEAKER_02Well, the battle with the PTAF started because they filed the next day. Yeah. And then all of that started. John didn't like that fact. that we didn't go along with the shared licensing and things like that. So that was one of our arguments.

SPEAKER_01So that's funny, but it's like you had a stronger opinion. You're like a guy like you, and I know inventors and entrepreneurs. It's interesting. I guess you thought you had a stronger opinion. You have to listen to your gut, I guess, on that one, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02No, when you're in the battle, and that's what it is, is a battle.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02You know, you've got shareholders that are pounding on you. Doug, what are we doing on the litigation? Because investors do not— fund lawsuits they just don't do it and when it comes they don't want to be a part of it so is your company and at any point in time during that you're like I should have even gone down this road of enforcing patents I should have not gone down the road of getting a patent I should have went fast and first yeah

SPEAKER_01And, you know, so you're going through this whole battle. You know, that's when I kind of got to know you. And, you know, a great part of your story is that you actually reached out to the last director of the USPTO, Kathy Vidal, to kind of share your perspective with her about what was going on with the PTAB. Can you tell us about that? Do you really want my opinion of that? Well, just tell us about that meeting. She did give you an hour of your time, from what I understand. So how did that go?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we've had several conversations. And I knew I was in trouble when the first time when we talked, she said, I was trying to get to know her and say, hey, I'm a hiker, blah, blah, blah. Because I think she does hiking and stuff like that. She said, just get to the point. And I'm like, OK, this is where we are. But she listened. Yeah. And I was wondering while she was listening, and she called me up. She would actually call me up one or two times to ask me questions. But I found out.

SPEAKER_02You know, that was during her six-month. If you remember, she had a six-month tour where she was getting all this information from all these

SPEAKER_01small inventors and things. But did she say anything when she heard your story? Did she say, like, was she empathetic? Did she say— Oh,

SPEAKER_02I mean, she was— Or kind of just— She was just, you know, listening, but she really didn't have a response or anything like that. She said, well, we'll look into it and things like that type. You know, there were some words, but basically it was, we'll look into it, blah, blah, blah. But— Like I said, that six-month tour that she did, she did that with many of the other inventors. So it wasn't just me. The whole inventor world, you know, she did what she did. But it wasn't to help us. It was to stab us in the back.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. She stabbed us in the back because she used a lot of things that we told her. And this is not just from the inventor. She used things that we expressed to her in order to help her big tech buddies. Like what is an example of that? I mean, you know, well, cases. I mean, I know one inventor who— had a case who confided in her, and she was actually—she sealed the files and actually fixed it

so that the

SPEAKER_02inventor couldn't even talk to USPTO anymore. I mean, it was the small inventor with her was her resources in order to help the big guys.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah. I guess, to be fair, obviously, I have no respect for Kathy Vidal. She's absolutely the worst director, the worst director that USPTO has ever had.

SPEAKER_02Worst, Michelle Lee. She left John a mess. Yeah. She absolutely left John the absolute worst director where she had over a million cases sitting because she didn't enforce... She did not make the examiner's work. And so, therefore, John come into a backlog and... Yeah. All I was going to say is that she was part of an administration that was not very

SPEAKER_01patent-friendly. And she was the director who's... She was horrible. She was the line. And I could imagine she's hearing your stories and she might... I'll tell you, she's got me blocked on LinkedIn.

SPEAKER_02I know that. And that's okay. If she's listening, I hope she knows that people send me her junk and stupid comments on LinkedIn. But I know because I know from what I've heard is that she wasn't fully happy about

SPEAKER_01some of the stuff that the last administration was doing. And maybe that's why she left early.

SPEAKER_02I heard somebody say there's no politics in patent office. I'm thinking baloney.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, there's politics in everything.

SPEAKER_02Baloney in everything.

SPEAKER_01So I guess go back to your story. So they filed these PTABs, and I'm guessing they did get invalidated patents.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, you had two of them. They had three judges that had no idea. Again, no idea. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Did the other side try to invalidate them under Section 101? Did they survive that?

SPEAKER_02They just said they were unpatentable. And so they just threw them out. I didn't, at the time, which John corrected this, thank goodness, an inventor couldn't go in front of the PTAF. Yeah. Because, I mean, lawyers are afraid for an inventor to go in front of the P-Tab, most of them. Most people think an inventor is a white coat guy. He wears a white coat and hat and things like that. They think we're dumb, but inventors are very, very smart. Now, there's some that can't talk their way out of a sack,

but most inventors...

SPEAKER_02are very smart. And the thing that I said, I said, why couldn't an inventor get in front of them and explain our technology? If they would have known our technology, they wouldn't come up with their stupid ruling. My legal team at the time, you know, took it over from, you know, work with, with, with that whole process. And, uh, You know, it cost so much money to do those things. I think it was almost $300-something thousand dollars.

SPEAKER_01I'm guessing after that, after those were invalidated, I guess, kind of a litigation kind of— Oh,

SPEAKER_02it killed us. It killed us, yeah. It killed us. Yeah. It killed my company. It killed the investors.

SPEAKER_01Were they ever open to settling at any point during this time or now? No. No. And kind of probably they knew what they could get. So you go through this whole experience, you know, and I ask a lot of, because I talk to a lot of inventors on Clause 80, you know, it's like, I'm done with the pound world. Let me forget about this. But you've obviously stayed involved in it.

SPEAKER_02Well, I knew that I'm even here because the word needs to go out. I'm not the only inventor that this has happened to, by far. I think there's... 15,000 to 20,000 inventors that AIAs kill over the years. And we've got to change the system. We've got to reform the system.

SPEAKER_01So what do you think... Are there changes that need to happen that – Yeah, some of the things are – I'm trying to get it so that patents are awarded after

SPEAKER_02they've gone through PTAB 101, all those things, all the courts, not federal courts, but through the PTAB and make PTAB a part of the examination process. So I want all that before the – before the award of the patent.

SPEAKER_01Do you think there's a role for a PTAB? Because obviously, you know... Oh, there's an award, yeah. Not every examination is going to be perfect. There might not be priority found. Do you think you should be able to challenge, I guess, let's say you find a new priority or something after the fact. And you get sued. Do you think somebody is allowed to be able to bring that up to a PTAB instead of having to go through a litigation?

SPEAKER_02Nope. They got to go. Once it's awarded, it goes to federal court. It'll be put into the federal register. The federal register would know that they're in there. There's a new patent. It'll be up to the companies to go in and examine. It'll be up to the companies to go in and start fighting. There'll be like an 18-month period in order to fight that. And once it's awarded after an 18-month period on the patent... Then anything after that goes to the federal courts.

SPEAKER_01It's interesting because obviously I know John, he knows a lot of pound-sized people, but his practice was more than that. He saw all kinds of things through his career. What was his impression of how a PTAB was operating? What was his saying that part of the government? What was his impression when you were going through that?

SPEAKER_02I mean, he was afraid of the PTAB. He knew it was messed up. Yeah. Because he saw the statistics, I guess. Well, I mean, he just knew that it was a challenge.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But he really didn't fear the PTAB in reality because he thought we had a really,

SPEAKER_02really good... Strong case. Strong case. And that... That we would be able to win. What he didn't know is that how these judges were so intent on killing businesses.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So after he saw what happened to you, what do you think his impression was of the P-TEP at that point? We got problems. Yeah. And I guess it kind of reigns in. So obviously he's been doing a lot of, you know, the USPTO obviously is even before he stepped into his role, they were doing some stuff to kind of reign in the PTAB, give a settled expectations. And then he came in and he kind of, he took it on himself. You know, he didn't want to pass the buck. He said, I'm going to decide if things get instituted or not.

SPEAKER_01I guess any thoughts about what he's doing and kind of that.

SPEAKER_02Well, yeah. During the confirmation period, there was a lot of back and forth. I can't expose all the conversations for sure. But him being a part of— Back and forth between whom? Between me and him. Oh. Yeah. And other folks. And— He was in the foxholes with me. Yeah. And him being in the foxholes, he knew what it was like in order to go through the PTAB and the federal courts and why we lost and all the things that were wrong.

SPEAKER_02He knew this. He saw the system. He sees the system. Yeah. He knows that it's not a fair system.

SPEAKER_01And what do you think he saw that went wrong? Like what was from his perspective?

SPEAKER_02I mean, the whole system was wrong. Yeah. The Constitution specifically says that as an inventor, we're to be protected. Yeah. There is no protection. Injunctions are gone. I mean, that's common sense. You've got to have an injunction in order to make these people come to the table to do license agreements. There's no incentive. The only incentive is the efficient infringement. It's kind of like the Panoptix case. Look what happened there. Half a billion dollars was awarded to those guys,

and then three trials later, Apple wins.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. And with a zero deficit, you know, that's that's after hundreds of millions of dollars spent on legal fees.

SPEAKER_01I guess what about the pan office, I guess, in terms of what do you think he thinks needs to be done with the PTAB?

SPEAKER_02And he didn't say this, but I've heard other people. I'm not going to tell you who said it. They said we need to fire PTAB. PTAB needs to go away.

SPEAKER_01And that's... And I don't have closely, I guess now, it seems like they're settling in where there's a role to play for the PTAB where errors were made during examination. Do you think there's like... Do you think now, I guess, you know, obviously there's legislation that creates the PTAB. Do you think where we are now is kind of a good point where we are with the PTAB? I think we should.

SPEAKER_02And I think PTAB is just going to be a modified examiner. That's what I think should happen and will happen.

SPEAKER_01So you don't think any post-grant stuff? I guess, like, what else do you think, like, the panel office should be? I guess maybe you could give us, like, let's say you're the PTO director or, like, what do you think of that?

SPEAKER_02I tell John he needs to get me a desk beside him. But, yeah, we are – I mean, the thing that – His office has just got so much to do. He can only do so much, though. That's the thing about it, and he knows that. You can only do so much. We've got to have Congress in order to get this thing going so that innovation starts to get back into America. I do a lot of research, and I cannot find anybody that has won a case in the last seven years.

this has been a small inventor that has gotten patents that has been able to win a case.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Nowhere. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, I know some have succeeded. Seven years. I know some have succeeded. Not, uh, maybe, but I guess I've successfully been able to, uh, Right, but it is very rare. It is maybe one out of a hundred. I don't know.

SPEAKER_02I've not been able to—I've not seen a case. I mean, there's cases where they get the crumbs, per se, but really winning a case for a small inventor that's— If I get a patent, in other words, if I get a patent and I go up against a big company and I win $200 million— You know, it's just not out there. And that's the patent. In the patent world, you know, in the patent world, you just want to share the innovation. And all these inventors, that's all they want.

SPEAKER_02That's all they want to do is share it.

SPEAKER_01I guess from your perspective, it would have been better off. You never even ended up in the litigation if you could have just licensed your technology in the first place.

SPEAKER_02I would have never filed a case.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02If I would have known what I know now, I would have stayed. I would have advised my lawyers, no. And I think, you know, it's not to say that they didn't know what they were doing. But as a business owner and a CEO and a founder of a company, knowing what I know now, I would have never exposed it. So you mentioned in the beginning about some of the crazy ideas that you bring to John.

SPEAKER_01And it's too crazy for John. Can you share what are your ideas?

SPEAKER_02Me and John have a great conversation. We laugh a lot and things like that. But in our texts and back and forth and stuff, one of the things that I said was, John, you need to shut the USPTO giving out patents down. He's like, Doug, what is wrong with you? I said, look, I know that you, you know, the gist of conversation was I know that you've got a job to do. You've got revenue and things like that. But until a patent is worth something and you get this thing fixed, shut it down. I said,

what you'll do then is send a message to Congress and Senate and the USPTO and the

SPEAKER_02world that, Hey, we got to fix this thing so that patents are valuable.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think you've been pretty vocal, I guess.

SPEAKER_02No. About talking about how entrepreneurs should have faith in the patent system.

SPEAKER_01What do you think needs to happen? What is it that needs to happen for you to say it's a good idea to get a patent to a small entrepreneur?

SPEAKER_02I've got four ideas. And I shared one with John prior to him going into the USPTO. Yeah. But I've got four ideas that are really, really good. But I'm not going to file for them until the system's fixed and reformed. But what – I call them my deep six secrets because I'm going to take them to my grave. But these are – one of the big things that I can advise entrepreneurs and people

SPEAKER_02that are now getting patents is Number one is you find your patent prosecutor. And number two is it's a team. It's not individuals no more. You've got to have a patent prosecutor. You've got to have a patent litigator. And you've got to have a patent litigation team to be a part of your team. patent idea that's coming out to the marketplace. And I know it's hard for a patent attorney and a patent litigation attorney to work together,

but a patent litigation attorney needs to see this before it goes to the examiner.

SPEAKER_01I mean, if you had to pick one thing that needs to happen with the patent system for you to have faith, hey, Now that this happened, I'm going to file patent applications for the other ideas you have. What is the one change? If you had to make one change, if you had a magic wand.

SPEAKER_02You've got bills out there now that need to be passed. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So it's section 101.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, all those bills need to be passed. But the biggest thing is injunctive relief.

SPEAKER_01Injunctive relief. Okay. Okay.

SPEAKER_02We've got to have the injunctive relief. One of the things also that you asked me a while ago about, you know, what other thing that John said I lost my mind on is I told him that the patent system needs the federal government to back when a patent is awarded.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Just like the IRS, the Department of Justice and people like that, they need to back an inventor when he gets a patent saying, OK, that patent is this strong and we're going to back it. And if you infringe, we're coming after you.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's interesting. And obviously, there's stuff like that. I've had inventors have told about maybe if there was some kind of criminal –

SPEAKER_02No, they're not going to be no criminal. That's a civil matter. It's a civil matter.

SPEAKER_01But then you at least stand by their work, because obviously if a PTAB in Veldys is a patent, then they're on the side of a PTAB, and that is kind of a— It's a mess.

SPEAKER_02The whole system is a mess. John's cleaning up the mess— step by step, piece by piece, bit by bit, day by day. And it's interesting you mentioned the legislation because obviously John,

SPEAKER_01he can't single-handedly pass the legislation, but everything that he does now could be undone by the next administration or the next director. And it seems like Do you sense that's what the PTO is going to focus on, on kind of helping the legislation?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. You know, the USPTO office is going to do what they can do the max. My motto to John is push the limit. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Push the limit. Well, I guess, you know, last administration thing that I was keeping captain from Capitol Hill is that USPTO wasn't supporting the legislative efforts. And I think, obviously, if Trump wants something Congress to pass, it helps a lot. At least where we stand now.

SPEAKER_02There's a lot of work going on in the background. One of the things that I know doesn't work is walking the halls of Congress because I've done it. I've walked the halls of Congress. I've gone into these congressmen, senators' offices. You meet with the staff and those staff members, yeah, they act like they're interested, but they don't care. I mean, they get a hundred people in a day. You're just another one of those hundreds. And so that's why I said, when, when this happened, when this happened, when I lost my patents and I called up,

SPEAKER_02I was on a couple of inventor conferences and things like that. And they had no idea what to do, how to do it or anything like that. And, and I actually told a couple of mentors and said, I'll do something about it. And, and so I'm, I'm, Not individually, because it takes a lot. And I've had a lot of people help me through my 188 project. I call it the 188 project.

SPEAKER_01Article 1, Section 8.

SPEAKER_02Article 1, Section 8, Clause 8. And what I'm trying to do is get that Constitution back as our main focus. And I keep telling John, push the limits, because it's all about the Constitution. If we don't have that to protect us— We have a constitutional right in order to innovate. And the front of a patent is very, very clear, but it's not happening.

SPEAKER_01To you, what will count the success over the next three years? Like what will say, hey, this has been a— If you can file a case and you actually get movement on that case. Yeah, like a settlement or an injunction. So, you know, it seems like to really be— Make the changes that you think are necessary. There really will need to be legislation passed with the USPTO.

SPEAKER_02Oh, there's going to have to be a combination of USPTO. John's going in front of the Congress here pretty soon. Yeah. That's a very important meeting, and he's going to be able to explain and express to those guys that we need their help. I mean, we've got to have congressional help or, like I said, you get another administration come in and they'll undo everything that he's done –

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I guess he's going to be testifying before the House IP Committee, and I bet there's going to be some congressmen there who think— Oh,

SPEAKER_02there's going to be some fights and arguments and yelling and screaming. Big tech folks are—you know, they're screaming right now because of his director's discretion and all the things that he's doing as the director, which one of the things that—one of the recent rulings was that he does have that power. They hate it. Absolutely hate it. And I know, like, you know, obviously you've met a Howard Ludnick and John knows him.

And, you know, once in a while you have a creative idea from Howard Ludnick.

SPEAKER_01I mean, do you have any concern about that the administration might go in a different direction on patents?

SPEAKER_02Well, my concern is that everything's big, big, big. You know, they talk about all the big guys. Yeah. And one of the things that I'm really pushing is, OK, don't forget about the small guy. I know you guys are saying patents are incredible, but you've got to reverse and reform this thing so that it does have meaning, and it doesn't have meaning right now. And the fact that one of the former – solicitors and director of PTAB.

SPEAKER_02Me and him got into a conversation on LinkedIn, and I actually had him to admit the fact that he agreed that the patent system right now is a Ponzi scheme.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And, you know, I think you're referring to Tom Krause, who was in the last administration solicitor, and obviously he's not a fan of patents, but... It seems like you and him share the opinion that – It's friendly respect.

SPEAKER_02We have varied opinions.

SPEAKER_01I'm not going to – I think you want to end up in different places, but I think where it is now, the pan system, I guess you have some opinion.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we got a lot of differences. And that's, you know, he's on the opposite end. He's not a fan of the current administration for sure. But, you know, my message is, is okay, if... since you were in control all those years and you wasn't just somebody, you wasn't just a number, you were at the top. Why didn't you do something about it?

SPEAKER_01Well, I think he doesn't like the things that are happening now. He likes the things that were before. But yeah, I guess, you know, as we were wrapping up, I want to kind of, Give you one more chance to kind of anything else you want to share about something that, you know, you've known John all through years. You've said he's been in your foxhole with you. You know, you're his wingman. Anything that you think people should know, you know, about John, about Patent Office, about where this is all heading? Anything you want to share with Closet?

SPEAKER_02John Squire is absolutely incredible. This is a calling for him. He doesn't have to do this. He's a big-time lawyer. He didn't have to jump into this. People should appreciate him, and they should respect the fact that he's in that position and the fact that he's even giving in an effort or trying and that they need to support him. You've got to give the guy a chance. And what do you think his ultimate goal is? Like you should where your goal is? To reform the system so an inventor like myself can get paid. I send him to give him a reminder—

SPEAKER_02I sent him pictures of me and my investors, my main investors, my first five investors, spent millions of dollars on a small company that they thought was going to take off. It should have climbed the ladder, and we should be a multimillion-dollar company right now. But because of our patent system, it failed. And I send him a picture and remind him all the time. John, you have only a limited amount of time. Go in there. Keep going.

SPEAKER_02Keep building. I encourage him to keep changing things. I said your time is limited. There's only going to be so much time that you've got. Make every day, every hour count when you're in that office. Do something to help because when you get out, it's over. All you're going to do is go to these conferences and talk about it. Enough talk about it. We've got to have somebody to do something. And if you do everything that you've got done, when you finish, you can walk away and say, I did all I can do.

SPEAKER_01Doug, thank you so much for coming on Clause 8, telling your story. It was great to have you finally on and sharing your insights about everything you know, so about John becoming director and what he's trying to do there. So I appreciate it. I'm sure we'll keep having our friendly debates.

SPEAKER_02Go for it. I appreciate you allowing me to come on. It's been refreshing. It's been fun. And, you know, I hope it gives some insight on where we're at and where we're going. And I really think that... The patent system is changing, and I hope it continues to make it so that inventors all over the world can feel good about it. But until the things change in the patent system, just be very careful on what you do.

SPEAKER_02There's a lot of people out there doing propaganda-type stuff. That you really want to be aware of. They're out for your money. Inventors, they're out for your money. And you've got to be able to decipher that. You cannot allow people to manipulate you saying things like IP. You can finance IPs from banks. Banks do not finance. finance IP. They'll use it as a revenue security model,

but they do not, no bank will do an IP.

SPEAKER_02So you got to be very, very careful on all the people out there that, you know, they need to make money and I understand it, but you cannot, the unknowing and prospective inventor must be always on beware. And if any of them out there needs help, I'm on LinkedIn, please follow me and I'll be glad to help.

SPEAKER_01All right, Doug, this was great. Thank you. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for listening. New episodes of Clause 8 come out every two weeks, so be sure not to miss them by subscribing at voiceofip.com or wherever you listen to podcasts. And if you enjoy Clause 8, please leave us a five-star rating to help others find the show.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Companies Miss 95% of Their Inventions

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Austin Walters saw the AI boom coming as an inventor on more than 650 patents. Now the IP Copilot founder explains how companies lose most of what their engineers invent. He spent two years at a major patent filer...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “Nobody Won Until I Won”: Perry Saidman, the Godfather of Design Law

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    Perry Saidman passed away on October 15, 2026, less than a month after we recorded this conversation. Perry built the market for design patents. His win in Avia v. LA Gear, a sneaker knockoff case, helped prove design...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Coke Morgan Stewart Tells Her Story

    Oct 13, 20261 hr 41 minAudio

    When Coke Morgan Stewart became acting director of the USPTO, much of the patent world knew little about her. In this episode of Clause 8, Stewart, now President and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP),...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Patent Litigation Really Moves: IAM, IP Fray, and MLex Reporters on the Year in IP

    Sep 29, 202645 minAudio

    To open the season, host Eli Mazour brings together three journalists who cover intellectual property for a living: Olivia Rafferty of IP Fray, Nisha Shetty of IAM, and Inbar Preiss of MLex. They discuss what happens...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Via Eyes "De Facto" Standards for Future Pools

    Jun 2, 202651 minAudio

    Kevin Mack, the new president of Via Licensing Alliance, joins Eli for the Clause 8 season finale. Kevin talks about Via's plans to build its next patent pools around "de facto" standards - technology the market adopted...

    Credit the people on this episode