When Alice came down in 2014, much of the patent prosecution bar reacted with denial. Most practitioners hoped the USPTO, the Federal Circuit, or Congress would clean things up - and that adding some magic language to claims and specifications would eventually be enough. Eli Mazour and Ngai Zhang, separately, came to a different conclusion: there had to be a new, better way to obtain strong patents in the post-Alice world. They started comparing notes more than a decade ago, eventually converged on a shared approach, and now implement these strategies together at Foley & Lardner. On this episode of Clause 8, Eli and Ngai walk through what they actually do - their unique strategies for avoiding and overcoming Section 101 issues, why it's difficult for other attorneys to implement these strategies, and how they think their practice will be impacted in the age of AI. In this episode: * Why relying only on art unit prediction tools & wordsmithing is a losing strategy for § 101 * Why claim 1 shouldn’t be your broadest claim * How taking features out of independent claims helps advance prosecution - and how the strategy also leaves clients routinely surprised by how broad their issued claims end up * Examiner interviews as hostage negotiations: Ngai’s framework based on Chris Voss’s Never Split the Difference * Differing approaches that Ngai and Eli have on whether to push for an explicit on-the-record agreement before ending an interview * AI as a collaborator for patent drafting and prosecution * The importance of human interactions and communication for patent prosecution even in the age of AI Watch the full episode and read the companion post on Voice of IP: https://voiceofip.com/ Subscribe to the Clause 8 YouTube channel for bonus content: https://www.youtube.com/@clause8 📌 Presented by Tradespace - where ideas take flight. Disclaimer This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.voiceofip.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Clause 8, the number one podcast on intellectual property, trusted by top in-house counsel, judges, and policymakers worldwide. Hosted by Eli Mazur, we bring you in-depth conversations with the personality-shaping IP. Brought to you by TradeSpace, where ideas take flight. If you enjoy conversations like this, take a moment to subscribe at voiceofip.com and stay connected to the leading voices in IP. Today, Eli Mazur is joined by Nai Zhang,
SPEAKER_01partner at Foley & Lardner, for a deep dive into the art of patent prosecution. They explore Nai's first impression approach for navigating Section 101 rejections by leading with a technical story rather than business use cases. The episode also examines the psychology of examiner interviews, the application of FBI negotiation tactics to IP law, and how high-level human communication serves as the ultimate moat against being replaced by AI. It's a masterclass in the strategies shaping modern patent practice.
SPEAKER_01Let's jump in. Many of you know that I joined a new firm about a year ago and I actually joined a
SPEAKER_00nice team who, since I joined and before that, a long time before that, we've been just talking a lot of stuff about pen prosecution, pen drafting, what's happening with the pen practice. And, you know, I do this podcast and I'm like, we got to have you on so we could kind of... talk about the stuff we talk about and share with the world what kind of we do and how we think about things. So thanks for doing this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. Happy to do it.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, me and you kind of started practicing, you know, we both do patent prosecution at an interesting time right after Alice, you know, patent eligibility became a concern and it probably kind of informed the way we think about our practice because I imagine that if you were drafting applications outside of business methods, let's say, you just you know you get the inventor's disclosure you describe what they say in the legal terms you know you know find out what the priorities or whatever but for the stuff we worked on that wasn't quite sufficient and do you
remember that do you remember kind of becoming aware of that and kind of uh becoming aware of section 101 being an issue and kind of having to navigate that yeah yeah it was uh it was a time where everyone most people that you kind of talked to had no idea what to do
SPEAKER_02and I think you and I both had to experiment with a bunch of different things to actually find out what would work.
SPEAKER_00What do you remember seeing what wasn't working? What was your inkling of something, the regular approach wasn't working? I think what everybody else was saying at the time was that we just had to wait
SPEAKER_02until the laws changed and things that they were doing they were literally just putting physical in front of processor I don't think most people weren't coming up with a lot of creative ideas they weren't really trying a number of different things and actually that's I think I told you before right this is why this is basically how we met why I reached out to you because you were the first person to actually write an article about an article with actual practical advice about how to navigate one-on-one
and you know I do remember that time because I think it was like first Bilski came out right and which gave some false comfort to a lot of patent attorneys that all they had to do is put in like buy a computer and that would be sufficient and then Alice kind of came out and like crashing but it's funny you say that they just have to wait it out because I do remember I was at my first firm back then some advice
SPEAKER_00was like oh you just found the peel and then by the time the peel is done you know the problem will be fixed and then you can address it with whatever the trick is and people are looking for that one quick trick like you know put some stuff you know people were like you know you see a physical processor but some like throwing a computer into a patent application and not tied to whatever and you know that stuff wasn't working and you had to kind of find new ways and I guess the problem with that obviously is that
If you're trying to capture inventions that have to do with improving something
SPEAKER_00that's an improvement in the business world, what do you do? What do you do? And I guess, I don't know, maybe kind of tell us, tell your thinking about it maybe now or back then, how did you think about like, how do I get to a point where we can actually get a patent starting out with like a business invention?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So initially I was always focusing on like what the law was, what the law said, all these case decisions that came down. and there was one in particular, it was called Core Wireless and I think the turning point for me was when I attended this oral hearing and I argued in front of these judges about why our case was similar to Core Wireless and their response was that Core Wireless was about,
SPEAKER_02you know, an improvement for small displays Even though the claims said nothing about small displays and the court decision itself was based on other aspects, I realized that it's really important to have story integrated into our applications, right? Story about the technical improvement, why it provides that benefit. and that's how I came up with our approach that I like to call
again impression approach. and you know there's it's interesting you say that obviously there were a lot of core decisions and the problem with the core decisions is that they came out both ways uh but there were nuggets in them about like what could actually survive in this new world and some of those nuggets had to do with technical improvements and you know then people would um just you know write a patent application and then
SPEAKER_00they would stick it in their application technical improvement right And then they met the realities of what happened at... So, you know, you draft absolutely an application that you want to withstand if it ever gets challenged as a patent, but also you're trying to get a patent office. But even at the patent office, you know, examiners are like, come on, you just... You have a whole application about what this is really about, and then you put some improvement that's completely unrelated to it at the end, and they're like, we're not going to grant,
SPEAKER_00you're not going to overcome Section 101 rejection based on that, it's not going to be banalegible. And I think you kind of, you formulated, I think you have, you formulated kind of the kind of things that you were both talking about. It's really about telling a compelling technical story, not just in one little end of the paragraph, but throughout the application as you lay out. So before you start drafting that application, you have to get a step back and saying, this is the invention, but what is really the technical improvement?
And you might need to get that from inventors and you might need to figure that out.
SPEAKER_00That is a challenge now that I think about it. You have inventors, obviously, who are day-to-day, they're their task might be to improve things from a business perspective not to improve technology but then you need to find out like what is the technical improvement how do you do it or how do you kind of think about figuring that out as you're talking to the inventors or
SPEAKER_02I think what we typically do is we just kind of take this step back. We understand that the inventors are focused on their specific use case. So if it's, you know, if they're with a financial or fintech company, they're always talking about money, credits, debits, you know, transactions, and not really focusing on, you know, what kind of, what's the underlying technology that makes all these things possible, right? And so what we do is we take a step back, we focus on Why their particular invention works the way that it does and
what helps it work. And then formulating a strategy that focuses on the underlying technology and why
SPEAKER_02it provides whatever the technical benefit is.
SPEAKER_00You know, obviously, a challenge with that is kind of setting the the inventor's expectations, right? About trying to explain what we're doing with their invention. Any advice about that, about communicating? How do you think about that, about communicating with the inventors?
SPEAKER_02I'm fairly straightforward with it. I let them know that if they present their financial use case first, that they're going to get rejected because that's the first impression right if it's a if it's a fit if it deals with a financial use case is probably not patentable and that's the impression that a lot of patent examiners have and so the idea is that you present the technology first and then you present the financial use case afterwards right and so that the first impressions already said that it's about
the technology
SPEAKER_00And I think, you know, you kind of articulate as a first impression, and I think it's true in life, you know, sometimes you look at it, but I think what you were talking about, correct me if I'm wrong, is when somebody picks up the pattern application or pattern, what is going to be their first impression, you know, and we do, I guess, what are, can you talk about, like, what are the things that you do to kind of, as you're thinking about how to set that impression?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, the traditional thing to do is, you You write claim one, claim one is usually your broadest claim, and then you go narrow from that, but there's not really a requirement to make claim one your broadest patent, right? And we're not saying that claim one should be narrow, but I think that claim one should have context so that it's related to the story that we're telling. And so we, you know, the very first page, some people like backgrounds. If I'm going to have a background, it's going to be very, very short.
I'd like to tell the story, if I can, all in one page on the very first page.
SPEAKER_02And then on the very first claim, I like to kind of link that back to the story with the context that whoever the reader might be, it doesn't have to be the patent office, could be a judge in the future, a jury, whatever that might be, can easily realize that like this relates to the story and why it provides the technical benefit. yeah you know obviously like the title and I think part of important part of like
SPEAKER_00telling that story is starting If you're going to describe the problem that they were solving, the problem better be technical, right? Yeah, better be technical. You know, we weren't making enough money and then we figured out if we charge another dollar because then the first impression will be, no, no, you were actually solving a non-technical problem and now you've come up with some kind of rationale about our technical and then... Weaving that through, you know,
SPEAKER_00it goes to be, you know, there's obviously some stages, you know, it's like the denial and then after Alice came out, denial and then acceptance. And, you know, one thing that I think people realize eventually is that it matters a lot who examines the application of the patent office or the art unit. So there's all these tools. You know, a bunch of tools to predict where it's going to land in the U.S. patent office.
But the way a lot of even these tools are designed is people draft the patent application and then they wordsmith to kind of land in a different art unit.
SPEAKER_00And what's wrong with that? What it's like the...
SPEAKER_02I think all you're doing is tricking the predictor, right? You don't necessarily know where it's going to land at the patent office. And even if you end up being granted a patent, whether that patent is valid or not, that's going to be decided by somebody else other than the particular art unit examiner. yeah that's a good point you know we've actually seen and I've obviously written about it that some odd units as we saw that you know in the beginning like
SPEAKER_00You put AI to your claims, then it was an end of an AI art unit. Those are good things, but then they train those examiners on 101, and then there's a lot of 101 rejections there. So that's an issue if you're going to be kind of buying an application today and then getting it examined maybe a year from now, the art unit that you're, even if you end up in the art unit that you want to end up in, it won't, you might end up with a 101 rejection. And then, like you said,
you know if you get the patent application allowed and you're issued patent at that point uh you know whoever's on the other side is going to have endless resources right to kind of uh figure out what you you were wordsmithing there uh you know if you do get a one-on-one rejection you want to have that story actually in your application uh where you're able to kind of overcome that and wordsmithing alone is not going to let you do that uh even if you know it's even if you have like a half-baked first impression that it's technical right so if you do so
that's that's uh kind of
SPEAKER_00you know uh Let's, you know, I want to kind of take a kind of maybe a more detailed look at the approach. You know, let's say you figure out, hey, this was kind of a technical implementation before. and that was the problem, that technical problem that existed. This is the technical solution. As you draft the application, how do you work that in? You said you put it on the front page, but as you're describing different aspects of the application, what is your kind of, do you have any kind of thoughts about working that in in a way
that's- Yeah,
SPEAKER_00yeah,
SPEAKER_02yeah. No, I mean, we integrate all aspects of it throughout the application. It's definitely going to be on the first page. It'll be at the beginning of the detailed description. The features tied to those benefits are recited in the claims. And as we discuss those claims, we'll also discuss why certain aspects of the application or certain aspects of the claims have or provides those benefits.
SPEAKER_00And I think it's an important point. Ideally, you want the crux of your invention and the technical improvement to kind of coincide in that whatever amendments you might have to make to help with one to overcome let's say prior art will also help you kind of if you do have one-on-one rejection with that right and that that is it is difficult I guess what is it like you know you've uh obviously you know you have a you know you have a team of pan-agents who I'm guessing weren't weren't or
and attorneys who
SPEAKER_00weren't exposed to that approach before they started working with you. What is it like training somebody? How do you do that? To learn to do that, I guess that's what I'm trying to figure out. Really asking you, how do you learn to do that?
SPEAKER_02I used to think that it was a science. I used to think that you could literally just tell somebody what the rules, the guidelines are, how to do something like this, and that they could eventually... learning to do it on their own. We even did a presentation for one of our clients where we presented to, I don't know, 13 or 14 other law firms about what our approach was, how to do it. We gave them a bunch of different examples. And from what I saw and what I heard, quite frankly, I think maybe
one or two maybe even a few attorneys but like really nobody nobody learned to do it the way that we've done it and for us quite honestly it's it's it's always it's an evolving approach and we're always adding new techniques to it but I think it's something that I think it's an art I think that you have to practice it you have to get trained on it mentored there's a lot of back and forth but you just need the
SPEAKER_02reps
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess, you know, somebody's listening to this and, well, I guess, why do you think it's so difficult? And somebody listening to this and they're like, you know, I want to kind of do that. What do you think is a good point to start or something like any advice about kind of trying this approach? Let's say you were training somebody new. What would you tell them, I guess?
SPEAKER_02Quite honestly, I think part of the reason why it's so hard is because it's a lot of the aspects, even though the concepts seem very easy, a lot of the concepts themselves are contrary to what people traditionally do. For example, claim one, writing the broadest claim, making sure that you're not putting in any language that people might think might narrow it, but I mean, these things aren't aren't what typical patent attorneys do. And so even if you're teaching somebody this,
you might have other partners that train them to do it the traditional way.
SPEAKER_02And so there's these two competing approaches. I just tell them and I tell them that it's hard, that it's something that they need to practice with, that they need to focus on. Because I think by intentionally focusing on You know, this particular approach, that's pretty much the only way that you can learn it, like through practice, deliberate practice. You know, obviously, I do a presentation on this topic that you felt me come up
with. And when I talk to kind of new attorneys and I go through the presentation,
SPEAKER_00they're like, oh, yeah, this makes a lot of sense. I'm like, do you have any questions? No, no. And I think the difficulty comes up is when they actually get a disclosure. Right. And then they're like, oh no no this approach can't work this is going to be an application where we're just going to have to risk a one-on-one rejection and uh this approach is not going to work for that and kind of they're like no no this doesn't work and it does and it's kind of almost magic once you start using it in that you could reframe you could find out the technical story and find out for for things
that I guess if you
SPEAKER_00haven't done it before you like you said uh it would seem like um I don't want to say unnatural I guess to some people to bridge that gap as they're doing it and finding that out so I think that's a kind of a interesting point but yeah yeah no you're absolutely right that that is what I hear all the time that I see how it works for this example yeah but then they're like oh but it's really difficult to do it here I don't think that you can do it here yeah and then they just stop right and I think that's that's the problem is that
when they hit that
SPEAKER_02barrier and I think we're lucky now to play this because everything these days probably there's kind of technological implementation of it before so it's not really automating
SPEAKER_00something that was done manually likely which I I think was the case maybe when Alice first came out that they were actually automating some manual manual processes or whatever so that's the case you know the other part of piece I guess I want to talk with you is you know prosecution you know I think you have something we both kind of kind of join about is like we're both huge fans of examiner interviews right and I remember when I started practicing I and I might have told the story before is that
I had a partner who was training me and I was looking through our document management system and I saw other attorneys were doing interviews and they were reaching agreement and they were kind of relying on an agreement to move cases forward towards allowance so I brought it up to that partner who's training me and the partner goes there's no no no no you we're gonna present our arguments
SPEAKER_00in response, we're going to send to the pan office, they're going to send us another office action, and then we'll take it from there. And I think from his, you know, because of when he started practicing, he didn't think examiner interviews were effective. Right. And, you know, it took that just like back and forth. I guess what made you think examiner interviews work? Kind of what brought you around that?
SPEAKER_02I actually interviewed pretty much every single case. For me, it was helpful in terms of getting my story out there, explaining to the examiner how things worked. And then, quite frankly, you have all the data that's out there right now that indicates that examiner interviews, that they help, right? They help for allowance. But at the same time, I think what I understood prosecution to be is that you're
really working with
SPEAKER_02another person, right? It's not a robot on the other side, although sometimes it might seem that way. This whole job that we have that I thought was about law is really about people. And that's why I think examiner interviews can be very helpful. They're not always helpful, but I think they can be very helpful if you can utilize all the tools properly.
SPEAKER_00When you think about an interview, what's your goal? I know you have some...
SPEAKER_02I guess there's two primary goals. And to the extent that I even get one of them, I'm happy. And the first goal is always to understand how the examiner... is approaching or is interpreting our invention or our claims as well as the references. I think that's always useful because even if they end up disagreeing with me, and the second goal being obviously I want them to agree with me, but even if they end up disagreeing with me, at least I can take back knowing what they believe in,
SPEAKER_02what they know about our claims and the references, and then I use that to basically tweak our response.
SPEAKER_00It's crazy how many times you know me and you're a huge fan of uh examiner analytics so we know examiner analytics we look at the office action we look at the prior art and you form some kind of like you know let's say the first impression where they what the examiner is thinking and then you get on the phone and the examiner tells you something yeah completely different different where it might be super helpful sometimes. They're like,
SPEAKER_00oh, if you just do this, and you would have no way of knowing unless you got on the phone. And there's, for whatever reason, that happens because there's some dynamics at the patent office where the supervisor might tell them, like, the only way you can allow this case of X happens, but they don't want to put it in the office section or whatever it is, and you won't find out until you get a call. So just, even if your whole interview is just getting on the phone and, like you're going to say, and say, all right, What's on your mind about this application?
Even though it would be worthwhile, but part of a goal is the first goal, right?
SPEAKER_00Try to convince them our way. And I guess, how do you think about that? How do you convince an examiner? Because obviously by the point we get on the call with an examiner to do the interview, the examiner has already spent time, especially now that there's a first action file program, he has spent time, you know, examining this application, drafting the office action, putting his arguments uh you know together he's already made his first impression how do you get them uh to an agreement once they've already
kind of invested
SPEAKER_02themselves into that there's a book with a lot of concepts on this um I think I've probably mentioned to you many times, right? It's called Never Split the Difference. It's a book about... A lot of the stories on it are about FBI hostage negotiation scenarios, but a lot of it works here, even in examiner interviews, because I think what the examiner often wants is to also feel like they were
SPEAKER_02understood. right they want to get their piece across they want to feel like you you listen that you understood and then once that happens is is where the magic starts to happen right where they you acknowledge you know certain things you let them know that you realize that certain aspects of your claims may not be inventive but then then you can go on at that point to explain what the invention feature is right why it is novel over the art why it provides that technical
improvement right but I think you have to get to a point where they're not defensive where you know by getting them getting them to feel like they're understood that you've listened to them that you understood that that's when they start to open up right and I don't
SPEAKER_02know that that's been so helpful for me
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and let's connect to your point. You said, you know, actually, when I'm kind of training a new attorney or something or who hasn't done an interview before, one piece of advice I give him is like, if an examiner's talking, just let them talk because they might drop a nugget, even if they're disagreeing with you, they might drop a nugget that you can connect back to and say, oh, if you say that, well, maybe we do have something in our specification or application to support that and come up with an idea if it fits that. So that's, you know, I never thought about exactly that,
SPEAKER_00but yeah, listening to them is such a, making sure they're heard is such an important part of that. The other difficult part that I find is, because I guess maybe the green differences, I think maybe we're slightly different, but I think it's very important to do everything you can to reach an agreement. But some who aren't used to interviewing, they often hear an examiner says,
SPEAKER_00we disagree, and says, all right, examiners often say this, they say, all right, You laid out my section, it's agree, we agree to disagree, just go ahead and file a response, you know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00What's your thinking? Like, how do you get over that? You know, once you're at a point of disagreement with an examiner, how do you push forward through that, I guess?
SPEAKER_02To be honest, nowadays, I don't even ask... whether there's an agreement. I don't think I even put in the response that we ever reached an agreement or that no agreements were reached. I just kind of indicate what was discussed, you know, what my points are in the response. But quite honestly, like you said, right, a lot of times they're talking and they'll drop these nuggets. And, you know, if I hear certain things that they say, and I know I can link it back to the specification,
I'll actually say hey why don't we look at paragraph whatever that might be and say hey what do you think of this right and see how might we integrate this into the application so that you know for example it overcomes 101 and so to the extent that you can get the examiner to come up with those amendments themselves and have them kind of give those to you it's actually way easier because they came up with it right and then they're less likely to retract or change their mind about it because
SPEAKER_02they're the ones that came up with it Yeah and you know this is also an art and I think maybe it was like the difference in approach but you know my concern is always I'm doing this interview I'm getting somewhere with the examiner are they going to remember what we discussed when they pick up the response and I always think about like and I don't know what the right answer is is that at least if I get them to agree to something that will at least
SPEAKER_00correct but I think what you do is you know at least as you can document whatever they said in terms of like even maybe sometimes being specific and you know I approach like the interview summary like the examiner suggested blah blah blah or whatever as long as it's and they could look back at it and say yeah that makes a lot of sense you know it kind of gives me a clear mind and actually that brings me to another point that maybe it's part of what you said The third part of doing the interviews is leaving space open for the examiner to want to reach agreement with you,
SPEAKER_00even if you didn't do it during that interview, to kind of work with you after you file that response or whatever it is. How do you think about that and how to kind of make that happen?
SPEAKER_02I like throughout the interview, I'm always trying to get the examiner to provide their suggestions or comments. I'm always trying to get them involved in kind of coming up with the solution or at least make them feel like they're involved. And at the end of every interview, which I think that you do too, as well, is that you just invite them to reach back out if there's anything that we can do to expedite allowance and emphasize the fact that we want to expedite allowance.
SPEAKER_00and you know the way I think about it is and we can talk about some other strategies for that but it's easier for an examiner to call you and get on the same page than it is drafting a whole new office action and all that and you want to kind of figure out a way how you can make the examiner's job easier and I think that's a bridge to do that you know some of the other things obviously that's for interviews but You know, some things actually I learned from you is,
SPEAKER_00I mean, in general for maybe one-on-one or in general, like when you've prepared that response, when you amend the claims, you know, what's your general approach for that to kind of get to a good place with both, you know, getting the best possible result for the client in terms of, you know, what you cover and getting to a lab.
SPEAKER_02For me, the traditional approach is to basically make minor changes to the application or add on certain limitations to overcome the current rejection. My approach is different in the sense that regardless of what the original claims currently say, Voice of IP voiceofip
SPEAKER_02It's not really helpful. It doesn't provide a ton of context. Rather than just leaving it there, I'll just take it out, right? And so it seems oftentimes when I'm amending or making amendments to like a set of original claims, it seems like I'm taking out a lot of things, making significant changes. But really what I'm trying to do is I'm trying to make the claims both broad, concise, and at the same time make sense to the reader.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And that's a huge... you know huge part of what kind of we both do is that you know sometimes you see these allowed claims and they're like two pages long two pages long yeah and then you look through prosecution history and they kept just adding and adding and adding features right and you know one of those features that they added maybe three times ago comes and harms them like in prosecution history or whatever when you're talking about it but in reality What's the original claim? You know, you don't have to accept that, right?
If it was addressed well or it wasn't addressed, you don't have to accept it.
SPEAKER_00You could put it in the best light to kind of work with the examiner. And also, like, if the examiner, you know, cites a reference that says, receive information instead of receive a message.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00And your whole prosecution strategy is on doesn't receive a message. Right. and it's like even if there's a difference in that it's like you're not getting anywhere because the examiner is going to easily find a private art that tries to receive a message when you're preparing that response you're really trying to figure out the same thing you're trying to figure out when you address an original claim is like what are the best pen rights that we deserve in
light of the prior art that's been found and that we know about and that's reasonable because you also don't want to get a claim allowed that it's like clearly invalid based on
SPEAKER_00the prior art that's being cited. So it's like you actually we're on the same side as the exam where we want to try to find out what is what is fair and part of it is like taking out features like you said is that you don't need part of that is what you go back to before is that independent claim one is narrower your broader your other independent claims which are broader as you amend independent claim one and other independent claims those still remain very broad yeah and you know I've seen like a lot of times we've both on
the call with the
SPEAKER_00client the client is like shocked about that
SPEAKER_02Right, how broad we got it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, how reasonable of a scope we got. We really get a claim that really focuses on the crux of invention without having to put all this fluff to kind of make the examiner feel better about the claim being along. Right. Another strategy that I look from you, I guess, have come to really appreciate is that you do this thing where you focus on one feature of a claim, maybe one step of a claim, and you try to really put as much meat in it as possible. Can you talk about why do you do that and what's your thinking
about that? Because I think what I've seen in the past is that people just add a bunch of ancillary features and then argue that it's the combination of all those features
SPEAKER_02that make it inventive. What I like to do different is that I like to focus on what I think is the crux of the invention and then put in claims that are related to that, that support that.
SPEAKER_00And I think from a practical standpoint, you know, examiners, when they're, you know, 103 rejection, you have different, different like steps. They apply these steps for these steps, these steps. What you try to do is like, through those amendments to explain, like, why was this really new? And it's really the relationships between what's going on within that claim feature that really make it accountable. And then you told me it's like, an examiner's not going to apply three references for one step of the claim.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And that works because you still get a very broad claim and someone's like,
SPEAKER_00oh, no, no, why are you taking out those features? But it's like, no, no, when the examiner has to actually reject that, it's going to be very hard to reject that one feature.
SPEAKER_02Right, right, with four references or three references. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And you know, one of the things is obviously, I appreciate it because, you know, that kind of takes me to a nice conversation, but if you don't do what we do during the prosecution of an application, you might end up having to file a continuation application where you're trying to kind of accomplish goals. And sometimes you see these families where, you know, Thinks of like, I don't know, not to agree, but like four or five cons where they finally get to the scope that they deserve, which is great,
but then that client is going to have to pay for all these other cons for the maintenance fees and not to talk about like the prosecution costs and all that.
SPEAKER_00So that's kind of a huge advantage of that.
SPEAKER_02Right, right, right. We pretty much get everything that they wanted in the first go.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And I think then a con is really an opportunity to kind of really... find other coverage that's valuable in its own way.
SPEAKER_02I think so. Yeah, agree.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, we can't end this conversation without talking about what everybody's talking about, which is AI, of course, from all different angles. Obviously, me and you, we deal with a lot of AI inventions. So it's funny in some ways because I guess we should have seen the wave coming, right? Should have seen it coming. But it seemed like, no, that was kind of something that engineers came up with or whatever, but then a chat GPT hit and it's kind of impacting us all. So we're kind of thinking about it. I know you kind of do that in your own practice. You kind of, even before this wave,
SPEAKER_00you've always come up with like, which is something else you'd come up with, like, come up with little scripts, little macros to kind of make us more efficient. But now everybody's doing that. Everybody's like thinking about it. Or they're thinking about it. I guess maybe in this moment in time, like, what are you thinking about, like, AI in practice? Like, what do you think? This is going. Are you thinking we'll all be out of jobs? One thing I guess from our conversation that stood out to me is how much people to people is involved with the inventors, with examiners.
SPEAKER_00What are you thinking about the role of AI in our practice? I think it's going to make us be able to draft better quality applications for sure.
SPEAKER_02It's going to make that process much more efficient. I think that it will replace a lot of the crappy applications out there but I think I think what it will do is that it will certainly make it the applications that we prepare for certain people much better right I don't think that I think the way that the technology is going we're kind of
not really necessarily hitting a plateau but in order to get the improvements that we're getting right now it's costing a lot more and so I think that we might have a little bit more time than we think and we might have our jobs for a few more years
SPEAKER_02and so that might be enough for me I guess what are you seeing about the use of AI you know I was sort of like when it came out people had different theories about what you should be using AI for or not when you're drafting applications claims or background or like what are you seeing the use of AI that you think is working in terms of both on the drafting and the
SPEAKER_00prosecution side what you think are compelling use case right now whether it's for claims spec even drawings I think it's very good at preparing like a rough sketch draft right something that will give you ideas allow you to then take either pieces of that or come up with new prompts to have it generate you know different things I think it allows us to be a lot more creative because in the past you had to come up with all those things yourself right yeah
SPEAKER_02and now you've got somebody to kind of cooperate with, right? To work with, to collaborate with, to generate a lot of different ideas.
SPEAKER_00Usually prosecution budgets don't allow you. Exactly. And it's funny, me and you do that a lot. We love to talk about a specific case and kind of figure out the best way forward. But now you can do it on every case, like you say. Right, every case.
SPEAKER_02I don't have to call you every single time when I talk about something. I feel bad about it.
SPEAKER_00yes that's actually very interesting I never thought about it as a way to collaborate but I did think it's kind of a good tool in terms of uh Filling in holes or blind sides that you might not have had, which is, I think, the more compelling reason is not just being more efficient at it, but is like you said, making a better, more robust application, which will be expectation. You know, I think it is going to be replaced with, I'm less optimistic about seeing less crappy applications.
SPEAKER_00I think you'll see other crappy applications crappy in their own way because I think you'll see that there's a lot of fluff that's kind of makes these a lot of like I just meant that AI will replace the people that write the crap oh I see yeah but I see yeah because you know it's funny because I remember when it all came out there was all these kinds of stuff I'm like you know
SPEAKER_00Theoretically, you don't need a patent attorney. You didn't need it before AI. You can say, prepare something, we'll file it. Let's still file the application if that's what you're going after. And that's going to cost you zero compared to a patent attorney. But if you're trying to figure out how to really capture an invention in a valuable way, You need to kind of deploy those tools effectively.
SPEAKER_00And I like it. It's like a collaborator that you have that you have there that works. Any, I guess, maybe compelling, I guess, for drafting prospects or anything else, compelling uses of AI that you find. I know, you know, we maybe for like... Anything that helps like in-house and like invention disclosure is an issue. Anything that kind of sends out to you where you think like, hey, AI is something that people in our space should be thinking about.
SPEAKER_00It's kind of using. I think that anything that reduces the friction of the process is going to be good, right?
SPEAKER_02If we don't have to have a bunch of back and forths, you know, where you're sending emails back and forth asking an inventor to review, getting invention disclosures from the inventors like things like that that reduce the friction or the things that people have to respond to yeah I think that's going to be the most useful yeah it's all it's like uh some of that stuff is like just automating things right and that's I think there's a lot of work to do but I think that's the stuff that's excited me and you for a long time yeah pressing a button yeah if you could just press a button oh my gosh schedule that
exam interview yeah
SPEAKER_00exactly right and actually I just I don't know if you saw but uh The automated interview form is now behind Pattern Center now. So they just introduced it on March 9th. So I was like, the tools we built kind of make it more difficult. But those things that kind of reduce the friction and make it easier for everybody, I think that is an exciting aspect. Anything else I guess that kind of stands out to you as you think, I know you've done other stuff besides patent drafts and prosecution,
SPEAKER_00you've done some transaction works, you've been involved in some litigation, anything else that kind of stands out to you about stuff that you're thinking about in general these days about patents?
SPEAKER_02You know, one of the things I'm working on is communication. Yeah. I think that That in of itself is one way in which we can prevent ourselves from being completely replaced by AI. Human interaction is still a huge part of our job. It's a huge part of a lot of jobs. And so I think that getting better at communication, right? Taking a master course in communication is something that all of us should be doing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. and no, I think that's great advice. I had a startup client who's unsurprisingly starting a business in the AI space recently and very sophisticated person, like on all kinds of issues. I would defer to him. But I saw when he came to questions about patent protection, they didn't just put it in chat. they wanted my answer for every little aspect and uh I almost
wanted to stop to kind of compare my notes to what uh judge but I think it made me think of something like you know this person who's I think this person could even figure out that
SPEAKER_00these answers on their own uh But they saw value in coming to me and getting my thoughts and my expertise based on what I've done and what works, figuring that out and, you know. and I don't know how well I did with the communication part, but I did have to rely on that to convey to him to at least kind of make sure that he still saw me as a resource for that and obviously to add a value in a way that's
SPEAKER_00kind of meaningful, right? You don't want to, you know, it's funny. I feel like these days people get excited about stuff that AI can do that Google can do, right?
SPEAKER_02Right. like you could Google I have these symptoms or whatever I have these symptoms or whatever it is right and then the question becomes like do you trust the first Google search results or do you trust you know what AI maybe the AI gives you a more confident answer but I think at the end of the day like before you decide to schedule maybe AI I'm gonna go to a doctor yeah yeah you probably want to go to the
SPEAKER_00doctor but at the same time you know it's obviously Valuable to get that first input or maybe put you at ease. Right, right, right. So I think it's kind of guardrails of kind of putting that in. So I think that's a good moment to hand on, to get, you know, good advice there about kind of things we can improve communicating with examiners, with inventors, with clients, and with each other. Yep, yep. We've been trying to do on Clause 8, so hopefully keep doing it with the age of AI. Yeah. and I thank you so much for doing this thank you thank you for
having me thank you so much for listening new episodes of Clause 8 come out every two weeks so be sure not to miss them by subscribing at voiceofip.com or wherever you listen to podcasts and if you enjoy Clause 8 please leave us a five-star rating to help others find
Austin Walters saw the AI boom coming as an inventor on more than 650 patents. Now the IP Copilot founder explains how companies lose most of what their engineers invent. He spent two years at a major patent filer...
Perry Saidman passed away on October 15, 2026, less than a month after we recorded this conversation. Perry built the market for design patents. His win in Avia v. LA Gear, a sneaker knockoff case, helped prove design...
When Coke Morgan Stewart became acting director of the USPTO, much of the patent world knew little about her. In this episode of Clause 8, Stewart, now President and CEO of the Council for Innovation Promotion (C4IP),...
To open the season, host Eli Mazour brings together three journalists who cover intellectual property for a living: Olivia Rafferty of IP Fray, Nisha Shetty of IAM, and Inbar Preiss of MLex. They discuss what happens...
Kevin Mack, the new president of Via Licensing Alliance, joins Eli for the Clause 8 season finale. Kevin talks about Via's plans to build its next patent pools around "de facto" standards - technology the market adopted...