Clubland Stories July23 - THE GRQ PODCAST EP95Join this channel to get access to perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/join SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules. GOT A CLUBLAND STORY - Submit it here https://forms.gle/Jga9wNrnwUVFUQD98 GRQOTW 94 Answer: Ross was right to proceed under Rule 19.3, but unfortunately Andy convinced him otherwise, so he moved his ball in play and dropped it and played from a wrong place, which we didn't consider a serious breach. Total strokes 9.CLUBLAND STORIES#embeddedball#wrongball#outofbounds #bunkers #conditionsaffectingthestroke#wrongball#morethan14clubsGRQOTW 95 - T/FDuring the round, a player may access local weather information, including wind, temperature and humidity, through an application or internet browser on a multifunctional device.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/ DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE? Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en) OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY Https://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestions LISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules #GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The GRQ podcast finally gets into clubland stories for episode 95 Podcast and Blakey cover nearly everything from an embedded ball that stopped play for 20 minutes. What is a reasonable stroke when there is a bees nest? When spectators know a player has too many clubs to a couple of kids playing a wrong ball and a couple of stories about bunkers thrown in for good mix. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions podcast. Golf is a test of character
before it is a test of skill and playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Hi everyone, welcome back to the Golf Rules Questions Podcast Episode 95. You Got Blakey and Podcast McPhee alongside me. How Are You? Podcast. I'm well, Blakey, how are you? Very, very good. Now let's quickly get on to today's We've been putting them off, putting them off, and we're going to finally get into the clubland stories because we ask
everyone to do the yes. In the Clubland stories, we've been a bit busy, but then when I've sent them in, we haven't got to them quick enough. So we've got about 6:00 or 7:00 to get through today and then the next episode we'll get through the rest of them because we do love them and everyone loves them because they have a little bit of drama to them, as you'll find out from definitely from our first one. But firstly, let's knock off the GRQOTW 94 answer. What was the Question Podcast? Yes, the question from last
episode #94 was Ross is playing at Wombat Hills and his tee shot comes to rest in the only pot bunker on the course right up against the face. He decides to take unplayable wool relief and drop outside the bunker. He goes back on the line about 5 meters behind the bunker and drops correctly. Andy, the average golfer, reminds Ross that the club has not adopted the local rule, allowing outside the bunker unplayable relief, and he needs to drop inside the bunker. Disappointed, Ross picks up his
ball to correct the mistake and drops within the bunker. He takes four more shots to hold out. What is his score for? The whole? OK, so if you've been following on Instagram, you will have seen that I posted a image from the book about your options for taking an unplayable from a bunker. We talked about it in the episode last episode. Episode 94 before podcasting gave us the question.
Right so it's his tee shot into the bunker. So that's one. He's then decided to take unplayable back on a line outside the bunker, which is a two shot penalty. He drops it, drops the ball into play, and then Andy's pipes in which he shouldn't have been, was confident that he knew the rules. When he did not know the rules, he said there was a a local rule and it was not a local rule. It's a rule of golf 19.3 that Ross was able to use. So Ross then picks the ball up
that was in place, that's a one shot penalty. And then he goes and drops it in the bunker, which what he's actually done there is he's dropped it in the wrong place and he's played from the wrong place. So the picking up of the ball and the dropping and playing from the wrong place counts as a two shot penalty. So he's got the two shot penalty for the outside the bunker. It's got the two shot penalty for playing from the wrong place. So now up to five. And then he has four more shots at the hole out, which is a
nine. So he finishes with A9. Is that correct? Podcast. Yeah, just correct. So as soon as he took that drop outside the bunker correctly back on the line, regardless of what happens after that, he's now his whole score is currently at 3:00. As soon as that drop all implied that's at three with that two strike penalty for playing outside the bunker and as you say, picked it up, that's a one strike penalty because that balls imply we know that gets melded into the wrong place. Dropped it in the bunker, it was that next stroke that actually of course triggered the wrong
place penalty that first of four and then you had three more. So nine is correct. Absolutely. And the first two shot penalty is an error of play or an option that they had. And that's why it doesn't get merged in as just two shots. The first two shot was an error of play, the second two shots was a breach of playing from the wrong place. That's why they are two separate, two shot penalties. Yeah, the first one was a normal procedure like he was. He he went through everything
correct and then the wrong place. Penalty happens when the stroke is actually made, not when the player puts it in the wrong place. So the stroke is made. That was their sixth shot, and then they hold out in three more shots after that to get to 9. So hopefully a few people got that correct. OK, let's get into clubland Story number one. This is from a popular or a very familiar person of the show ruin Carl's Land from Denmark. Listen to this one.
This one has got my noodle cooking for months now. Hope you can help out on understanding the correct procedure. This all takes place as a team division match between my own club, Odence Golf Club and our competing club Odence Inventor Golf Club. Excuse me for my pronunciation of Danish words Division One, second highest tier in Denmark. To make it easier for you to pronounce their names, I'll call them Nick and Yarn.
Thank you Both brilliant players plus handicappers and both PGA certified golf coaches. They're all well. Well, they're on the 10th hole. I don't know the current score, but it's not relevant as they're fairly evenly matched. At this point, it's a power five, 500 meters. Both drive into the fairway onto the fairway about 300 meters. Jan lands his second shot on the green and Nick blocks his approach into a thicket of trees about 50 meters right of the green. They go on to find the ball in the in the in the within, just a couple of meters in the thicket,
embedded in some beer soggy soil. Nick is prepared to take free relief, but Yarn stops him and claims he saw it bounce once and hence it can't be embedded in its own pitch. Mark, you have a comment about that, Stuart? No, no, no, no. I'm just listening, sorry. I think, well that let's mark that down, that we need to talk about that. Nick didn't see it after it broke the tree line. They get into an argument about who's in the right and as they can't agree they decide to call the designated referee.
He is off site. This is normal in these division matches. Fair enough. And cannot get there in a reasonable time and tells them that they need to work it out themselves. This is referees. You don't need them until you need them. You know, they they could do nothing for four days, which I've I've had tournaments where I've done nothing for four days. But then when they are needed, they are needed in a big way. OK, continue. I assume he simply can't give a ruling because he lacks information. That's probably true. Or maybe you can give a better explanation just quickly.
No, that's probably the case. All he can say is embedded rule ball rule is this, this and this. What are the facts from the two players? Blah, blah, blah. But actually we will get into. I said we'll come back to that. So we'll get into that in a second. He might have been able to give a bit more help to the players that may have got the situation underway a bit quicker. Anyway, after this they both sit down and refused to play on for about 20 minutes.
So that's that's ridiculous. I'd almost disqualify both of them. Imagine for fields behind them. Maybe they are. Anyway. Yeah, just walk. You just walk them. You just go. OK, that holds half. That holds half. Now you're on the seven eighth. Next team captain comes by, states that he can tell them the rules about the inbidible and does so presumably correctly, but also states that he cannot interfere with the decision, which I presume is also correct. Yeah. If there's no referee allocated to that match then it's just for
the players to work out and sales or ask request a ruling to request a ruling for someone to come and give them interpretation and judgment on that. After about 25 minutes of disputing and a lot of silence, imagine Can you imagine how awkward that would be? Incredible. Nick decides to play the ball as it lies. OK, great Nick, Thank you. Wax it out of the thicket and then goes up and down for part yarn holes and two more for birdie and wins the hole.
They play the rest of the match in silence and yarn wins two up. Now what actions were taken to resolve the situation? The result was accepted by both players and no further actions were taken. Great, it's all done. This is not a live situation. It happened last year anyway, in 2022. OK, first of all, podcast. Now I want to be very clear about this because I agree with what you're about to say. Can your ball be embedded be
considered embedded after it bounced? Yes. Why? Why do? You But we know the first time. Let's say we're the first time it hits the ground. It's more than likely going to make the biggest indentation in the ground. But it doesn't mean I can't take a bounce and move and hit the ground again and make a further indentation. The way it was described it was it was boggy soil. In other words, I take that as soft. Therefore, more likely to receive a ball on its bounce and actually then become embedded.
We know that you can't be embedded, excuse me, in sand in the general area if it's not closely mowed, but this is soil, so that's different. Yeah, I believe it can be embedded. It may not be embedded a lot, but it still can be embedded. The word state. A player's ball is embedded only if it is in its own pitch mark. It doesn't say that the pitch mark must be made on the first
impact into the ground. A ball technically could still make a pitch mark on the bounce and the ball could come to rest in that pitch mark so that the ball is breaking. A part of the ball is breaking the level of the ground and therefore it is it could, it would be considered embedded. I think the first thing is whoever's given these guys the
information about the role of what is an embedded ball needs to say, well, if it's bounced, that doesn't necessarily mean that it hasn't become a bit. If. If it bounces out of its own pitch mark and comes to rest in someone else's pitch mark, that is not embedded because it's not in its own pitch mark. But you can have your ball embedded in a pitch mark and it's in its pitch mark, and that pitch Mark May have been made on the bounce.
Imagine if you looked around that area and around this 5 meter circle around and there was not one other pitch mark except the one that it's sitting in. You have to think that that pitch mark was caused by the ball landing in that spot, at least 95. Now if the ball was in sand and then as podcast mentioned, you know you can't, You can't have a ball embedded in sand unless it's in the fairway height. Grass cut the fairway height,
but this is in the rough. It was clear it was 50 meters right of the green. That's a long way how that other person saw that. Well, that you know, that's up to them. But that doesn't necessarily we're taking out the fact that it doesn't necessarily mean the ball was not in bed. Now they've had this, they've taken way too long. I mean, as I said, I would probably say you guys, you know, this hole's halved now and the next hole's halved. You got to walk those holes because you're too slow. But what is the real procedure?
I mean, I don't see the referee is doing anything wrong there necessarily. We don't know what kind of information you gave them about the embeddable. But I don't think see him doing anything wrong. He's he'd he'd take the facts and he'd give them the ruling, you know, based on what they saw. You and I didn't see it either, but we exactly right. We over the phone could have said, hey, just go, just a couple of things. Can you describe the area to me?
Is it soft, is it hard, etcetera, etcetera. It can embed on the in on a bounce and the other guy might have got, Oh well, I didn't think about that or Oh well, I didn't think it could. OK. I'm more open to it being embedded there. Yeah yeah, spot on and then. But they should have got on with it a lot quicker than what they did. You can't play 2 balls and match play. So what Nick should have done was he if he he could have just played the ball after taking free relief.
He said he he played as it lies so he's accepted it. He's accepted Okay. I can't take free relief, that's fine. But he could have taken relief under 16.3 and then at the end of the match they work it out and if yarn wins one up then he's not going to follow it up. If it's all square or Nick wins one up, you know it's probably going to get the referee involved, but. And it puts it back on the committee to make a decision and it speeds up play too. So I don't nothing sort of apart
from them taking too long nothing really stands out there that you know. And and obviously yeah there was there's a bit of silence awkward silence. They probably won't talk to each other for the rest of their lives but that's fine. That happens sometimes. That's a good thing. You know a reason not to talk to someone. So I thank you very much for that question and I'm sure hoping it's not your your first because I love that one. Right. Moving on to the next one from my old mate Colin in Why Maddie
Colleen is playing up the par 412 hole at Y Maddie when her third shot heads towards the road fence. Along the fence is chicken wire in various states of repair. When arriving at her ball, she finds that her ball is in the broken chicken wire and thinks it is out of bounds. Local rule out of bounds is determined by the nearest inside points of the fence. Post podcast thoughts on that? Nearest inside points is that coarse side or outside that'd be
coarse side. That's OK. That's not a local rule. That's just the rule we'll go. Well, you gotta. Well, yeah. You gotta define though how the boundary the course you do. But if you're defining it by a fence, the outer bounds is. You do need to tell us how the course boundaries. Yeah, later on it is actually discovered to still be in bounds. To be still in bounds, but in the broken chicken wire. What are her options? Right, what actions were taken? Colleen, thinking that she might have been out of the rounds, took the local rule E5 as
suggested by someone else and played from the fairway and just missed a part to get a point in the Stapleford round for the whole. Looking back, had Colleen played from the wrong place and what should she have done? Her playing partners also didn't know what the correct procedure was either. This happened in June at Waimedi, and Colleen still beat Colin on points that day. OK, so she's proceeded under an implicable rule because her ball
was actually inbound. So E5 doesn't apply because the ball was neither lost nor out of bounds. So she's taken that 2 stroke penalty, plus played from the wrong place, but the two shot penalty doesn't actually apply. Her only options were under an unplayable going back to the T or dropping within two club links or back on the line.
Are you talking potential issues with 14.7? Yeah, I potentially it's a serious breach, but she's still taking a two shot penalty. That's an interesting one. Glad. The good thing is it was a Stableford, so zero points. She had zero points because she missed the puck to get to the point and and that's good. So she's done nothing wrong. But what?
What would you do if the if you were the committee? What would you say to her when she comes and tells you this big story? First thing I'd say is try to determine whether it was in fact in bounds or not. But it sounds like it was. And could you have got relief free relief from interference from the chicken wire? And I think the chicken wire was part of the outer bounds fence. Ah, OK. So no, that's the answer to that question. No. So no free relief from the boundary fence.
So it's definitely part of the fence, yeah. Was the chicken wire? Yeah, even though it's in different states of prepare, because we all sometimes will see that it's in fact the posts. The mark that actually are marking the outer bounds and the chicken wire or other things actually are not part of the boundary fence. They're just there as a fence. But as you say, local rules will state how the boundary is the the fence posts are obviously, but the fence posts are holding up the chicken wire fence.
Sure. And in this case, as you're saying, the chicken wire is part of the boundary fence, it is, yes. So there's definitely no relief. From that now I've actually if you got any question now if I was committed now she's taken, she's taken local rule E5 and dropped her ball in the fairway which she's not allowed to take local rule E5. But she's done sorry thinking that she was, in fact, out of bounds. Yes, yes, that's right. So if So, what is?
That she wasn't out of bounds? No, she wasn't. So what is the applicable rule that applies here? It would have to be. All she's done is picked up her ball in play and moved it to the fairway, dropped it with intent and played it right. So it has. She had intention to take. Well, it wasn't an unplayable, was it? And it wasn't a stroking distance. It was this stupid local rule. Local rule which she which she loved.
Which was not applicable under these under this condition. OK, so. She's just moved to ball at rest and played it from from a wrong place, so she still gets that two shot penalty, so it's effectively the same thing, but is it a serious breach? Well, no, because she should have just played it from over near the boundary fence. So do you think distance wise not Had she did she have a swing if she didn't have a swing? Then you can maybe call it a serious breach. Yeah, like if she like she had interference from the fence and there were trees in there.
Because if she if she'd taken unplayable, she might have still had a terrible position. So might be a wander down. Well, if you're the committee, you know, the whole world, that's. Right. That's the time you would definitely ask, so as the committee you definitely ask and try and find out the facts as to whether it could be a serious breach. Yes. Which supply will not be forthcoming? Wow, their thoughts of their opinion on that? You just tell you the facts and then but it's a stale food. I just say it's disqualifying from the whole not. And she had zero points, so it's all it would. Have been disqualified.
That's right. But Colin wants to know if this was a strike ground, what would happen? I mean, the committee needs to find out whether it's a serious breach or not. That's the issue because that determines whether the disqualification or she's picked the ball up, that's in play and she's dropped it somewhere else and played from somewhere else. All right excellent. Moving on Dan. DK Hello Blakey podcast. Apologies for the that's brilliant. Apologies for the mixed Canadian forces mind being to the other week but appreciate you entertaining us now you
entertained us DK. This one perhaps little more straightforward. A player makes a stroke from a deep green side bunker. The ball lands on the steep turf above the bunker lip and starts to roll back towards the bunker. The player sees the ball coming back towards him and quickly smooths over the sand with a rake to avoid the ball coming to rest in his deep footprint. The balls the ball does in fact roll back to where his footprint was and comes to rest on a nice fluffy lie. A fellow, A fellow player in the
group sees us and believes the player has improved the cats and should be penalized. The player disagrees, exclaiming that he was caring for the course exception to rule 8.2 B. He's written that in there. What actions were taken to resolve this situation? General penalty applied to the player? Can the improved conditions be restored to avoid penalty? So his first question is was was
the player allowed to care for the course and the manner that they did, they cared for the course while the ball was still moving and they saw that it was coming to rest or most likely going to come to rest back where they just played from. And second question, could the player the ball rolled onto a nice fluffy lie? Could the player actually restore the conditions to the crappy lie? Well, I guess place the ball there to avoid penalty.
I think you know where I'm going with that last one but the first one. So if we look at 12 point 2B restrictions on touching sand in the bunker, there are no it's 12.2 B three, no restrictions after ball was played out of bunker after ball is played after ball. When a bunker is played and is outside the bunker or players taken or tends to take relief outside the bunker, the player may touch the sand in the bunker and smooth the sand in the bunker key for the course. This is true even if the ball
comes to rest outside the bunker and the players required or led by the rules to take a penalty as as in you've gone out of bounds or something like that. But but if the ball played from the bunker comes back into the bunker, the player takes relief by dropping a ball in the bunker or the player decides not to take relief outside the bunker. The restrictions and rules 12.2 B one and 8.1 again apply that ball in the bunker. So does that answer the question?
Not really. I don't you know this caring for the cause seems like it's always just thrown out as a blanket get out of jail free card. I don't think the the player can get out of. There's no that this definitely penalizers. I know, But you know what I mean? Like, there's this. And even this person has mentioned it, You know, they know they weren't carrying it. They know exactly why they were racking their bunker. Their intention? You. Know, but I I sometimes feel that players have this belief that there is a blanket get out
of jail free card and that was, Oh yeah, I was just caring for the course. Yeah, well, I mean their intention was to improve their conditions so they weren't just caring for the course and hence they got the general penalty and rightly so. Yeah, this is covered under you reckon rule 12 or rule 11.3, or does it really matter? 11.3 Deliberately removing objects. Which they're not all altering conditions to affectable
emotion, they're altering physical conditions. Yes. Yep, moving the same. I mean you can probably ping them under one or the other, but all the general penalty, so data is quoted 8.2 B, but that is when the ball was at rest. In this case the ball was in motion, so we've looked at 12.2 B and talking about caring for the course. You can do it once the ball was outside, but in this case the ball wasn't at rest outside and
the player did have an inkling that it was going to come back in and come to rest back in the spot where they had recently played from. So if we look at rule 11.3 and there's a clarification slash one, it's very similar to this examples where the play gets general penalty under 11.3 and in stroke play must play the ball where it comes to rest. So that answers both of their questions, or this is about to
answer both of their questions. The player's ball lies in the general area at the bottom of the slope. The player makes a stroke, and while the ball's rolling back towards the slope, the player presses down a raised piece of turf for the purpose of preventing the ball from coming to rest in a bad lie. Now you take out the general area, put in bunker, take out divot and put in right sand and you've got your you've got your two shot penalty there and he just then plays it as it lies. So even though he's improved his
conditions, you don't restore it and you can't restore it to avoid penalty. In that case, no moving on. Mr. Roberts 4 Wonderful guys playing at Hilltop 10th hole. Call us, call us. Hits his ball left and it comes to rest at the base of an old peppercorn tree. I'm arriving at his ball. Callers Say something like that's bad. It looks unplayable just then.
Jeff yells out. Look at don't move left. Look, there's a Hove of bees in the tree. Get away quick, Neil adds. Grab your ball quick, you can get a free drop. Bees are dangerous animals. In fact, I'm staying here. I am allergic to bee stings. I'm saying here I'm allergic to bee stings. Jeff pops in. What comes first, the unplayable lie or the dangerous animals? What do you think, Dave? We ought always turn to you for the rules.
Here's another person, Mr. Roberts. His first name is David. This is why I don't go by David, Dave replies. There are two different rules for unplayable and a free relief from the dangerous bees. And if Jeff stairs those bees up the nearest point of relief may be on the other side of the fairway. I can't quite the rule numbers but I think you can. You can't claim I can't quite the rule numbers, but I think you can't claim dangerous animal. If there's an existing issue that you can't take free relief from. If we wait a while I will look up look it up. Caller said no let's keep going.
And being a man of great principles says I said it was unplayable. So I'm going to take the penalty. Neil Butson Yes. Most rules of golf apply the penalty. You never get off easy. Let's check when we get in what actions were taken to resolve the situation. As outlined above, Callers takes the unplayable option of one strike penalty and two club links, lateral relief and did it very quickly at completion of play. Around the table of nice drinks, the rule book came out and David found 16.2 B 3, to which Jeff replied. You did the right thing callers, and not like you to be right,
Dave. Then the discussion went on about if callers had not said anything about the unplayable and may have been able to hit out with the back of putter, then he could have claimed free relief from the bees. Have another lemonade, boys. This this happened just the other day last week. So what were your thoughts on that one? That's a good story. It all comes down to a reasonable stroke. So you only get free relief for a reasonable stroke.
Now the last, basically the last sentence. If he was able to hit it out with the back of a putter, then he could have claimed free relief. If that was a reasonable stroke, then that is correct. I think the more the issue is where the player has said, you know guys, I'll just take an unplayable and then the other possible relief situation popped up and we know that. If you're going to take it unplayable, you pick up your
ball and then someone says, oh look, you're in G you are there. You can actually get free relief even though you've stated your intention. All you know to take it unplayable. Yeah, things can change. But to get that free relief in the 1st place, it needs to be for a reasonable stroke. And a reasonable stroke is to make contact with the ball to a reasonable place. OK, so you can't aim out of bounds and say, I I can make a
reasonable stroke of this. Yeah. But you're going to hit it out of bounds. Yeah. Well, you can't do that just to get free relief. So good on you. Call us for doing the right thing. And for Dave, looking it up and getting the, the ruling 16.2 B 3, which is dangerous animal conditions. I mean, bees. I mean, yeah, some people are allergic to bees. So I understand that. But these aren't necessarily that aggressive that they'll
attack you because if they sting you, they die, which they don't really like doing. Where's Wasps? They can sting and sting and sting. Repeatedly, but just on a rules of golf point of view, it just has to. It has to be a reasonable stroke. You just can't be saying free relief everywhere. It has to be for a reasonable stroke. If you can flip the part of backwards or the six iron backwards and hit it down the fairway or towards the green, not necessarily even towards the
green, If you can hit it back out towards the fairway, then that could be considered a reasonable stroke. But it can't be a situation where you're not even going to be able to hit the ball like you know it's 10 meters up in a tree or you're going to hit it towards outer bounds and and it would reach the outer bounds easily. So a good one David Mr. Roberts thank you. Another one from DK Stroke play. Player A makes a stroke in a ball that is at rest in a green side bunker.
The ball is bladed over the green into a red penalty area. The player chooses to play the next stroke from where the previous stroke was made for a penalty of 1 stroke before dropping. Another player in the group, Player B, states that they cannot proceed this way because they are not permitted to drop a ball in a bunker under the rules. Player A proceeds to take lateral penalty relief on the advice of Player B under rule 17.1 D 3. The facts are reported to the
committee. That is the strangest comment advice I've ever heard. He wants to go back to his last place player that he just played out of a bunker and someone says no, you can't do that. Now what actions we're taking to resolve the situation. No additional penalties are handed down in. The players are informed that the stroke and dips stroke and distance option for one penalty stroke is in fact available. A followup question for podcast discussion It's the podcast, not you. Can the player write the bunker smooth before taking penalty
drop in the bunker? I was just going to say there's no issue to resolve because the player did proceed under one of their options. It just wasn't the option that they wanted to. Yeah, that's right. He done. Everything correctly, he hasn't played from the wrong place because he's played from the right place under an option, but he wanted to go back to where he played from. One option one not three, under 17 point 1D. DK must have spent a lot of time in the bunker in the last couple of months. A lot of bunker questions, but so just like I read DK read you
12.2 B for your previous question, it applies again for this question. Once the ball was outside, whether it's gone out of bounds, it's lost, it's in another part of the course, the player can rake the bunker, smooth the bunker before they take their penalty drop back in the bunker. So that would be OK. I love that. Where and when did this happen? A bunker.
You're after a little bit more detail general looking for the course or country or, but they know that's very funny. Another one from Jimbo. I love these nicknames. This is brilliant. Jimbo hits his tee shot 20 yards left of the green on the 17th par 3 hole into moderately deep rough. He walks up to his ball and finds a padder lying in the grass. It turns out that Jimbo only carries 13 clubs in his bag. He checks the putter out and likes it's waiting.
He pitches at the six foot. May he use that fan putter for the rest of the round? What actions were taken? Jimbo didn't use it. He returned to the pro shop. He made the pup with his original putter. This happened in Ontario, Canada at Doom Valley. What a what a name for a golf course. Doom Valley. Thank you Jimbo. That's brilliant. If you only start with 13 clubs, doesn't matter how you add another club to your bag.
Unless, unless, unless it's someone who is a club that's already been selected by someone for that round. But I found Potter. I mean, well that's an interesting question. Podcast is. If you don't know that it's, someone else has lost it on the course. Can you add it to your Ford? And how often have you found a wedge, you know, sitting beside the green left from a group behind and you know that's for
sure there's someone else on the course, more than likely in that same competition that you're in. More than likely, as opposed to one that's in the deep breath that a player could have hurled after missing a, you know, 1 foot part or three-part could have been or. Earlier and having missed you know 4 putted and just said I don't like this club anymore and decided decided to dispose of it and then you pick it up and you like it, can you use it? Well, clearly the other player doesn't have any without any knowledge that someone else had
selected it for that round. Well, I think they deselected it. Though note to self, no one can deselect the club. And the I also was going to say the rules don't say how you. At that club, you know where it actually has to come from, and in deep grass beside the green doesn't say how you need to add where that club needs to come from exactly. You can. It can come from anywhere, but it just can't be someone else's. And how are you supposed, are you supposed to go through that
that information? When the grass is growing around it, trying to find a bit of rust, bit of rust forming on it, yeah, you're like, Oh well, it has. It's obviously not from today's round, so all I can say in regards to the rules, yes, the player can add another club to the bag because they only started with 13. They can't use someones that had been selected for the round, but they can use any other club. And it doesn't even have to be a putter. It could be anything or it
doesn't even have to be a driver. It could be. So that's the information I can give you there, Gemma. That's a great question. Right? Another one ruin again. We're hosting a rather big junior tournament where young scratch players from the whole country come to play. It's 54 holes cut off after 36. There's a roaming referee to whom all the players have a phone number in case of a rules issue. I'm in that car along with the senior ref. The situation happens on the first round, 8th hole where two of the three boys hit the ball
into the field. A it being a dog leg, right? It's very hard, or next to impossible to see where the ball comes to rest past the dog leg. They go on to find their balls sitting nicely in the fairway about 75 to 100 meters short of the pin and play on. They reach the green and realize they've been playing each other's ball from the fairway. They go on to correct their mistake by exchanging the balls so that they now had their own ball, presumably marking the spot where they picked up the wrong ball.
Place their own ball in that spot and putt out for what they think is A4 and A5 that each then each add 2 penalty strokes and proceed to the 9th T while they are teeing up. We referees roll up at the 9th near the green. We currently don't know anything about the breach. The mother of one of the two lads addressed as saying that the bulls might have boys might have a rules question. She didn't mumble something about a ball swap. At this point the boys have Ted off on the 9th and let them play out and approach them as they walk towards the 10th hoping to
find out that they had simply played the balls from a wrong position or that they had proceeded to replace and replay the shot. We get their story and through an unnecessarily hard interrogation get them to tell them this story. We were absolutely gutted what action was taken. We saw no other option than to have them disqualified and breach of rules 6.3 C and failing to hold out on a hole and proceeding to start the next. The mother was furious at us, so I'm guessing more on herself for letting us know of the breach.
But as I told her, this is not something we took any joy in doing and that the boys should call a referee whenever there is a speck of doubt. It's a question of sportsmanship and applying the rules correctly, not trying to get away with it. The boys were very understanding and accepting of the situation, but naturally gathered. Turns out one turns out the father of one of them is somewhat a national legend in golf and his comment to the situation when he was told was it's unfortunate but but perhaps they should try and learn the rules.
Then they had a good walk. Back to think things over as you turn around 3.55 kilometers away from the clubhouse. Oh my God. The third boy was placed in a 2 ball with one of the lads from the group behind. The word spread like a forest fire and after we got called out to everything. Even a ball that was accidentally knocked off the tee in preparation to making a stroke. Are very sensitive, brilliant, brilliant. What a great summary though, of what's happened. Yeah, that is fantastic.
Unfortunately a terrible situation. But yeah, you know, that's usually what happens. Guys get burnt by the rules and then they go, oh, maybe I should learn them. So just to clarify for those who are not quite sure they've realized if it. So wrong. Let's say they approach shots onto the green, and on the green they've realized they've hit each other's ball back on the fairway. And at that point there they've decided to mark and sort of swap balls back again. But Blakey, I don't believe that's what they should have done. Why? They've been disqualified, yeah.
So they've played a wrong ball. So you have to you, you take the two shot penalty or the general penalty and you have to go and fix your mistake. And the only way to fix your mistake is by going back to where your original ball was and playing your original ball from there if you're. And in this case, both the original balls are not there anymore because they've been hit by another player as a wrong ball. Yeah, if your original ball can't be easily found, you can replace another ball on that
spot. And they could have saved. They could have been saved if they hadn't teed off on the next hole. If they'd found out what had happened before they'd teed off then they could have fixed the situation. They need to be. And the strokes don't count with the wrong ball, So they. Well, The funny thing is they placed another ball in play and
played for a wrong breach, which from a wrong place, which was a serious breach. So they played a tee shot. I think only two of the three stuffed up, right? Yeah, two of the three boys hit the ball in the fair so they've Taed off. So it's one. They've hit a wrong ball, that's they're now on 3, they've been placed a ball into play on the green and say they had two putts. Well they've played from a wrong
place. Serious breach, so they get another two shot penalty. But they've corrected, yeah, I know what you're saying, but they've they should have also in any way. They should have gone back to the fairway obviously. And what you're saying is you're almost correcting 2 things now. No, I'm what I'm saying is when, if they did go back to the fairway, they'll be hitting their sixth shot. Because they're correcting the
wrong ball, but they're also correcting a. Serious bridge. Playing from a wrong place. Serious bridge. Yeah, correct. Yeah, so it's not just the wrong if they if they just continue to play with the wrong ball, the strokes don't count and it's just the two shot penalty. But they didn't. They swapped balls back. Put another ball in the plies. It's not the fact that they. It's not the fact that they
played with their correct ball at the start. It's the fact that they had the intention to put another ball into play that wasn't the wrong ball. Yeah, wow. Boom. But they're young. They'll make mistakes. Neither of them will forget it. Yeah, that's right. And that's the. That's the positive. And the correct ruling was made, you know, as. Ruined, correctly said. And you, you and I've had this conversation before. No committee wants to disqualify
a player unless it punch someone. Unless it's quite you know. No one wants to disqualify a player, so you don't want to. But there's no option. The committee had no option. They had one option. No alternatives. You know, No alternatives. And this is a status right? Next Kim, A significant club event peered event file. Now Kim sent me this as an e-mail and I've replied to her with this e-mail. But this is hilarious, this one. Well, when I say hilarious, I
would have done something things differently. I guess I'd say a casual observer to the match felt a player had a crowded bag and then I thought to be more than 15 clubs. There was no opportunity to ask. Felt not her place to ask the player or alert the opposition, but told two other casual observers who were all reluctant to raise the possible breach. Is not totally sure. There were 15 and the match concluded peer in question.
One comfortably result declared a prize given on the day. Rules were managed by the golf shop on staff on request. This was discussed between the three observers and the opportunity by stealth and opportunity by stealth Confirmed that one of the players had 15 clubs, no action taken. Decided to let it go. The question is how it should have? How the casual observers, the spectators should have handled it during the match? If not, how post match, say before final declaration
presentations. Did you understand that? I did, yeah. I've got So what happened was one player had 15 clubs, people who were watching the match because this was obviously a final. Fat bag. Well that there were 15 clubs but didn't say anything to anyone and just let it pass. And then they found out later that there was 15 clubs but they decided not to say anything. What do you reckon? Well, the first thing I would say is who's to say that on the very first tee that play with the fat? Bag said to the two opponents. A guys said this 56 degree wedge
year. Sorry, it's in the bag, but it's out of I'm not playing it today. I can put a cover on it if you want, I can, but I'm not playing it and could have made that declaration to the opponents. Who's to say that? Didn't that conversation didn't happen? No. That's a good point. I didn't actually bring that up in the e-mail. So what you're saying is stay out of it. Oh, there's a bit of that too, but I just think, who's to say that, you know, that comment wasn't made in before the match started. Look, they they chose to stay out of it, which is fine. And you're and you're right, the
players could have already had a discussion between each other. I was practicing with it and I forgot to take it out of the bag. The opponent might have already said just your bag is fat, yeah. Oh, well, yeah, now you mention it. I'm carrying 79 clubs. I I would say that the the opponents, I mean the spectators could have a word to the opponent. Just say, hey, we think, you know, not trying to start anything, but then it becomes. Then it comes down to the
opponent's option as to what they do. They could actually choose to ignore it. That's fine. I'm not too fussed, you know, Which is an option for them not to have an agreement that we're allowing 15 clubs without a. Penalty and talk about it. You're allowed to talk about it now. You're allowed to have a discussion. But just don't know yet. But you're not allowed to. You just to say, hey, I see that you've got 15 clubs, but I'm not going to, I'm not going to penalize you, you know, don't worry about it. You're not allowed to say, hey,
have you got 15 clubs? Yes, I have. That's right. I think it's a breach. Yeah, it is a breach. One, don't worry about, Forget about it. But if it's just a discussion where one person is basically talking and telling the other person that it's okay, don't worry about it. But for me personally, I think that that option should have come up. Would it, you know the 15 clubs, Would it really have made a big difference? It doesn't matter if it does. It's the The rule is you only get 14 and whether they use they might have only used seven for
the day, but the rule is 14 is the limit and it should be for the opposition. If the player has more than 14, it's the opposition has the option as to what they're going to. Do Has the limit of 14 been around for as long as you remember? Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. I can't remember it being any different. Maybe 10 back in the day, 150 years ago. Not sure, mate.
Yeah, there might have been it. The reason that there'll be a limit is someone put 25 clubs in their bag once. Yeah. No, that's that's how the I can guarantee you that's how the rules stuck. And they're like I hang on, hang on. We can't have this many clubs. Hey Martha, when's your what date's your birthday? The 14th of July Fourteen's the limit that we had that come to that. And we're worried that somewhere at the first Open Championship, some player was carrying eight and the limit was 7.
Yeah, that's right. Right, we've got three left. Golf gal Suzanne is playing a match against Connie. Suzanne plays her tshirt into a very wooded area on the course with bushes and rocks. She thinks her ball could be lost, so she announces and hits a provisional ball, which she stripes. This sounds like you 225 yards down the fairway. Suzanne loves her provisional and asks Connie not to look for her original ball.
Connie happens to be walking by the area when Suzanne's original ball may be where Suzanne's original ball may be. Sorry and sees what could be Suzanne's ball in a thick Bush and calls her over. Suzanne knows that she must identify her ball within one minute, so she fumbles with her clubs in a golf bag and delays arriving at the ball. She arrives after one minute and announces that she is later than one minute so she can play her provisional ball. I love that. Where and when did this happen
in my mind? So this is a hypothetical. Stuart, do you know about this whole one minute? Isn't this been something added Because we knew that you you had a reasonable time to go and identify your ball once it had been found, and that reasonable time could extend beyond that 3 minutes. Is this one minute being added in? Yes, but I don't think it's. I think it has been added, but I don't think it's quite been added as this person has. As you know, as you know precise
60 seconds, no, it's. It's more the case of. Let me see if I can find it. Well, I didn't point to a the player must promptly attempt to identify the ball, and is allowed a reasonable time to do so, even if that happens after the three minute search time has ended. This includes a reasonable time to get to the ball if the player is not where the ball is found. So I don't think making a making the claim that hang on, you know as soon as you call me over. I started my stopwatch and it's now 68 seconds that I've
actually got over here and identified my ball. And you could also make the argument that the search time didn't even start because the player it hasn't the search time hasn't started until the player has got there. So it's still got a. For three minutes the search time hasn't start, but there's this the situation where it happens after the three minutes. So they've kind of taken this one minute thing and I'm just trying to find out where it is. Let me see. I think it's under the prompt.
Yeah, you read it there. The player must promptly attempt to identify the ball. Even if this happens after the three minute search, and they added in a minute here, and it must be in a clarification. But it's not. It's not a, it's not as what they are talking about. Which one is it 18? Point 18.2 a 1/3 meaning of reasonable time to do so when identifying the ball. 18.2 a 1/3, it provides that a player must promptly attempt to
identify a ball that is fan. Winners believe that the fan ball could be the player's ball, and when attempting to do so, the player is allowed a reasonable amount of time to identify. However, so long as the player's ball is found identified during the three minute search time, the plan may take as much time within those 3 minutes to identify. But when a ball was found close to the end of the three minute search time, it is reasonable to allow the player up to one minute to identify the ball. For example, a player finds a ball in a tree 2 minutes and 30 seconds after the search began, but it is not immediately able
to identify as as there's it as there's. In this case, it is reasonable to allow the player one minute to try and identify the ball. Meaning if the player is able to identify the ball within the three minutes and 30 seconds after the search began, the ball was not lost. But if the player discovers the ball is not, there's after the three minute search time is finished, the ball is now lost and the player has no additional time to search. Similarly, when a ball is found close to the end of the three minute search time with the players not where the ball is found, Rule 18.2 A also allows a player a reasonable time to get
to the location where the ball is, and once there, it is reasonable to allow the player up to one minute. So the one minute is for identifying it, not the time it takes for the player to get to the ball. In this situation, the three minute search time hasn't even started because the player hasn't even started. But what that one, the example, just trying to think of an example of that clarification is if you if you're searching, you've already started the searching because you're the player or your caddy or your partner or your partner's
category started the search and then there is a ball. When you get to the ball and then it you've got one minute in which to identify as your ball, You're already there and you have one minute in which to identify the ball. It's if you're 50 meters down the fairway and oh, I've got your ball here or I think I've got a ball here, it's not one minute that 50 meters either. It's you tell you, you know, promptly make your way towards the ball and then you've got one minute in which to identify. So the question's taken that one
minute, but not quite put it in the right place. So the answer to that question, golf gal, is the three minute search time hasn't even started yet, so they need to now get in there. And if they keep pissing around and fumbling with their clubs and we could dock them two shots for undue delay. Well, I could say the committee could take it a step further. A serious misconduct. Yeah. Yeah. OK, CK we had a DK. Now we've got a CK Gem and I
played in the couples tournament yesterday for for the gross score prize, the women have a par 7318. Whole 18 is a par 5. The men have a par 72. The 18th hole is the par four. It is a four ball stroke play tournament and in that the best score of the two partners counts. Jim gets a four so that the score is counted. It is a par. On the other team the female gets a 5 so that the score is counted. It's also a par.
When the tournament ended we scored 72 including par on the 18th and the other team scored 73 including par on the 18th. For the female who who wins the tournament, the now, what actions were taken to resolve the situation. The committee said it was a tie but it was a baseball. So I think lowest wins has no handicap involved. Nothing in Rule 23 on mixed. That is one. That's a great question. That is one for the committee to
decide upon as to what is the winning or what is the yeah, the winning score effectively if you are playing par and there's different pars for a mixed event. Interesting, though. It's a gross event, not a handicap, not this, but how can how can you expect, yeah, I mean if if you go on the gross event, is it the overall score or is it
the overall score relative to par? Well, that's the confusion that unfortunately that committee has to deal with, given that, yeah, to me it's overall score. It's overall score in relation to par. You know, you're square, you're one under, you're 2 under, you're one over, you're two over. The committee said it was a tie. I agree it was a tie. And you go about having a having a tie, a playoff.
Playoff. If they have a playoff or if they want to do us, you know, because there's not much sun, but there would be in Canada, there's not much daylight, then you just do a scorecard tie. So with a gross event stroke, I sometimes think the power is almost arbitrary. It's redundant, exactly. In other words, you know the tournament. This week, the power of the course can be 36. That won't affect who wins the tournament. You know, whoever has a fewer,
fewer strokes, he's going to win the tournament. That's that's right. However, if you've got two different, in this case it was genders. But if you got two different genders or you got two different age groups, I mean it could be that the the the beginners, the youngsters have the par is 78 and then the pros are playing off the same course and they're playing off 68 or something like that. I mean you if you are allowing
two different groups to play against each other, you gotta define the committee has to define what is the the winning score. And I'm gonna say I'm, I'm comfortable with what that committee did like. Yeah, me too. I I mean, I understand that it's lowest score wins. I get that. But when? When it's, you know it's in relative, it's relative to their skill level and their skill level says that well the par on the 18th is for the females is a
par file. So I think it it was a tie and they just needed to have a playoff or determine how they were going to break that tie. I mean, we see that in junior Pennant in Victoria or in Melbourne, especially when girls are playing against guys and it's the par is the same, but when they play handicap, it's whoever's the higher handicap.
It's whether they get a shot on that hole or not. So that didn't really help you out in CK, but I agree with the committee. Sorry. But at the same time, the committee needs to work this out before the tournament starts, not afterwards. When? Yeah. And knowing ahead of time that that, you know, part of the ID toll could possibly pose an issue. Yeah, they should have. There should be a sentence in there addressing that even. Yeah, absolutely.
Ck's got another one for us. A path for has a Creek red penalty area running down the left side. Creek Red penalty. It then crosses over the fairway 300 out and marked yellow, then turns and goes down the right hand side all marked red. However it is marked with stakes and lines but there is a wide culvert. You walk over the yellow stop at the beginning of the culvert. Then there is a 5 yard walk over the culvert where at the end it is marked with red stakes and lines.
Wow the yellow stop at the beginning of the color. Then there's a 5 yard walk over the culvert where at the end it is marked with red stakes and line. So between the two there are no lines in play despite just few I cut grass above it. Question one, you see your ball going to the yellow, but when you get there it has floated down the culvert just past where the red line is above on the grass. Where does they, where do they drop? Well, your ball is still in the penalty area, but where was its last place that it crossed if it
has gone? Yeah, actually, because we got a tournament and I'm looking at over a tournament with Jeff for the end of September. This one, well, hopefully it doesn't come up, but it possibly could where this bridge has the pipe and we're looking at it going, OK, it's got grass over the top of it, but there are some gravel bits, so we'll make that an immovable obstruction. And the yellow penalty area will be here and it'll finish there and there'll be a drain
underneath this essentially a path, a grass, gravel path. So that's general area. So the ball was floated out of the yellow penalty area and now crossed into its last place that it crossed into was the red penalty area. So the ball was now in the red penalty area and you just workout where it last crossed into that the yeah, the last
cross, the edge and last edge. Cross Yeah. OK, so we're happy with that. Yeah, So where your balls ended up coming to rest determines your relief options as well. It's where it ended up crossing the last last, yeah. And so the fact that it's gone into a red, a yellow penalty area being gone through into the general area. And then through into red. Your ball was in red and it's
last crossed across a red penalty area. Right #2 What if you see your ball under the culvert but past the yellow line, not through to the red line. Is that now an inmovable obstruction, hence a free drop above despite it being in the Creek, but not in any area. Penalty area? Not in any penalty area. Clearly marked with lines on both sides, all the way down and across the fairway. This is why I do not like determining that these culverts or paths or whatever are.
Generally, because effectively getting this free drop out of water. But I can, you know, in a situation that we're looking at, it's the same, exactly the same situation. It's a immovable obstruction, You know it's a plastic pipe and it's a concreted culvert or concreted bridge, so it's it's now in in immovable obstruction. So yes, if your balls come to rest and you know it's in there,
it is in the immovable obstruction and you work out your nearest point of complete relief, which most likely will be straight above what actions were taken. Should have read this out first. They say that we're at first when and you drop it. I agree if you can't find it, but if you can see it in the red area, then I think you drop it there. Where into the red on top of the culvert is. You're right CK it's where it last crossed. If it goes into a yellow, out of a yellow, into a red, it's the red, not the yellow.
If it's all one, if it's yellow, if it just merges into from yellow to red, then the last place cross was in the in the yellow. But this one stops and starts again as a different penalty area, so it's where it last crossed. OK, very good. We've smashed through those clubland stories. If anyone has any queries, comments, questions, send them in writing to Podcast McPhee. Now let's get on with the
GIQOTW. And it's a true false question. During the round, a player may access local weather information including wind, temperature and humidity through an application or Internet browser on a multifunctional device. Is that true or false? If you need to listen to it again, just rewind the play list and or the podcast and just listen to it again. Thank you everyone for listening through on those clubland stories and get more in.
We love them. They they really bring the rules to a heed and we get to discuss and, you know, talk about more than just the rules, more about what the committee would do. So it's really good. Thank you very much everyone for contributing.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...