GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139
59 minAudio
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own ClubLand Stories to the podcast presented by GOLF.AI, and tries to catch Blakey out with a ball moved, or has it not moved, that is the question.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
That's for the committee to decide. That's it. That's exactly. And the greatest lard ever is I think Arnold Palmer said. Or Jack. It was either Arnold or Jack once said, you know, committee needs to be an odd number and threes too many. Hi everyone, this is the GRQ podcast episode 139. I'm Blakey.
It's presented by Golf dot AI. As you know, if you haven't been on Golf dot AI used it yet, get on it. You can get it on the web, you can get it on WhatsApp, or you can even just call up in the US, the UK and Australia. We all have landline numbers for them. So give Golf dot AIA call especially or use especially if you're a pro shop. I've got a special guest this week. We've had him on before and he's just been fantastic to speak to Jason Smith from Texas wrote
with co-authored with Woodrow. Yep yeah. A guide to being a golf rules official and it is fantastic. So if you are looking to become a rules official, let's definitely the first place you go, don't even go to the rules. Just go straight to a guide to being a rules official. And then it'll teach you about the rules as well as where to go to find, you know, rulings and stuff like that. And that's what we're going to talk to talk about today is all
about how to be a rules official or just how to know the rules. Yes. Welcome, Jason. It's great to have you back. Hey, thanks, Blakey. Man, I just love it. I love your stuff and it's an honor to be on here and and bless you. We're on two different sides of the earth doing this, which is just absolutely amazing. I won't tell you right now. I'm actually in Guthrie. OK, I officiated this morning, the junior Byron Nelson, the final round of junior Byron Nelson in Dallas quickly drove home and I've got a wedding
tomorrow up here in Guthrie. And so I drove all the way to Guthrie, just right next to Oklahoma State, Stillwater, who just won the national championship and golf. Some of the fabulous players, Stratton Nolan and Alan Brat and the coaches up there just super great. I was officiated the Big 12, the sorry golf is inside of me going like crazy. We we've got we got so much going on the the NCAA's just finished up the men's, women just finished theirs up here in the United States. Oklahoma State won the men's and just phenomenal.
The great kids. Three of the boys of the five on the team are from Texas and kids that I've grown up at Junior Golf, knowing I'm sitting there texting them while they're playing it at the Omni Resort. And that was fabulous. And then we got the US Open here in another week. And so we and in Texas, we got the Texas AM, which is a huge state thing going on and we got a lot going on right now and golf is fabulous. So let's dive into some club land. That is awesome. Well, actually, let's see, let's talk to talk about how to learn
the rules. So we'll get some club land questions. Definitely. We've got some lined up, but I know you, you're into music, you're a music teacher and we went through your story of how you learnt the rules and then you would got yourself involved and volunteering and stuff like that. And that's actually just as a tangent. All this, all these tournaments that you referee at, do you just, do you do them volunteer or do you get a little bit of a
payback, you know, just to cover expenses or, or you get paid full time? No, I, I, I would say 95% or 99% of the rules officiating that I do is all volunteer. I did the Big 12 this year. The Big 12 covers our expenses and they're really nice to us and good to us and everything else. So Kim Ricci, when you hear that, make sure you, you note that I said that y'all were awesome for us and y'all took care of us and everything else so that you have me back in the future.
That's always a good one. But everything we do with the USGA is all volunteer. Everything that we do with our Texas Golf Association is all volunteer. And they, they'll, you know, they, they buy us lunch, they give us a lot of swag. We get a lot of shirts and hats and we're, we're very blessed for that. And but you know, it's, it's just people that, that love golf. They love seeing great golf and they get passionate about the rules. And, you know, you start getting involved with your allied association, you start networking.
And the next thing you know, you're on a USJ committee and you're, you know, running tournaments for USGA. And you know, the USJ after 25 years put gives you a pat on the back and a pin to put in your hat that says you've been a 25 year. I'm almost there. I think this is your 15 or 16 for me for volunteering and working with the USGA and the Texas Golf Association, so. That's that's incredible. And and you didn't even we headed this on the last last episode. You didn't even start in Texas. You started in Oklahoma,
Oklahoma and they didn't want you. Yeah, well, I I was a newbie and an outsider. I was a Texan coming into Oklahoma and and it's been nice because now I've reconnected with a lot of those guys. Like I said today, I'm in Guthrie, but I reconnected with a lot of the guys in Oklahoma. And and so, you know, I've got to come up here and work like the the Big 12 was at Southern Hills. Oh my gosh, just magical golf course. Perry Maxwell design. So, but, you know, reconnected with a bunch of those guys and, you know, when you're first out, yeah, you're the new, you're the new person. And, you know, it's so the the
person in charge of running a tournament has to have some faith or trust that, you know, the rules, that you know how to interact with players, that you know, how to handle situations and that they can trust you to do it. There's not, I mean, because a lot of times as a rules official, we're just out on an island. You know, you're out there in the corner of a golf course monitoring 3 or 4 holes. And I mean, there's you have a radio and that's about it. Radio and a rule book. And so, you know, just do you. And until it's your team, until
the OIC, until you network and people know you, it's hard for them to trust that you're going to apply the rules correctly, even though you may have a 95 on a score, Level 3 in TARS, or whatever else it is. But just because you've made a number or you sort of reached a certain level doesn't mean that you're a great person to be applying the rules out on the golf course. So, so if someone, if someone wants to learn the rules, first of all, if if someone wants to
learn the rules just because they're starting the game, right, not, not to be an official just to start the game, how would you, what would you recommend they do to to go about that? I I tell you, you know, you your website golf AI is got a lot of like little short snippet videos, like one minute, 3 minute videos over the rules. I think that's a really good starting place. USGA has got a lot of like short quizzes, like 10 question quizzes, videos that are also one or two minutes long.
But my now and that's if you're just kind of wanting to kind of scratch the surface and kind of OK, how do I handle a penalty area? How do I handle a cart path? How do I you know, what, what, what is nearest point of relief? What does that mean? But you know, once you kind of start getting into it, what I tell them to do is to just get a rule book. And you know, Lou Blakey's got a site general. Area. Yeah, general area and, and, and that's a great place to go. But I tell you, if you get with, you know, I don't know in
Australia how y'all's are set up, but y'all, there you go. It's a good texting word. Y'all how y'all got it set up. But we have an allied golf associations all across the US, Texas Golf Association, Metropolitan Northern California, Southern California, and you get in contact with those allied golf associations and they will start helping get you orientated, orientated to being a rules official if you're wanting to dive into it. But my study tip, here's the biggest thing for me, when I started making the leap from
thinking I knew the rules to understanding the rules when when I made that leap for me, what I would suggest everybody do, get a notebook out, set it down, open your rule book and don't start with rule number one. That's that's probably the worst place to start in the rule book. Go to like rule 14. I mean, let's just go straight to the deep end, rule 14, rule 18 and kind of read the heading and go right down. OK, this is what I know about how to drop a ball, or this is what I know about lost balls.
And you write down some notes, then read the rule, read straight through it, and then go to some of these videos, like on your website, US JS website and, and listen to some explanations on the rules. And as you learn something new, write down what you're learning new. What is it that you misunderstood? What did I, what did I think I knew? Oh, you mean that a penalty area is on it's 2 club links. I thought a penalty area was one club link. Well, write that down. That penalty area is 2 club links. Oh, the ball has to stay in the,
in the, you know, relief area. It can't roll out of it. No, yes, the ball has to. So you write down the things that you didn't know or that you misunderstood and just keep a journal of it and then just keep working through rules. That's and when I sat down and kind of made myself do that, that's when I really made the jump to understanding the rules instead of. You know, do you, do you play a lot at the moment, Jason? Yeah, I do. Not as much as I want. Probably twice a week, 3 * a
week if I can. I mean that that is a good place to also to start and and learn in the rules, right? Clubland So I played on men's league all the time. Clubland I tell you, somebody asked me and said, Jason, why do you know the rules so well? And I said, well, if you saw the guys I play with. So what I what I do a lot of times while I'm playing with guys is I'm sitting there reciting the rule that they're breaking while we're playing. No, but I'm reciting it in my head. I'm please, people, do not take the club.
Don't take your rule book to club golf. You're not going to make many friends that way. Yeah, yeah. I mean, I started this, you know, obviously started this golf with questions just because that was the easiest thing. The easiest way for me to learn the rules was just questions. Was just asking people questions, asking myself questions and then trying to find out whereabouts in the rules. It was questions. You know, questions has a bit of a competitive side to it. You know, when there's a
question, it's like I want to get it right or wrong. I don't why I don't want to get it wrong. I want to get it right. Whereas just reading the book for me, for me was was a bit too hard. But if I had a question in mind and I was looking for something that that was sort of what helped me the most. And I tell you, I tell you. Probably the one the other bit of advice I always give people about wanting to learn the rules. Also, just start with the definitions. Oh yeah, 9 times out of 10, if
you know the definitions, the definitions will answer your questions. Yep, absolutely. What's a wrong ball? What's what's a ball in play and what's a wrong? Ball. Which is, you know, what's a head, what's not? Which is kind of strange that they moved to the back behind the rules. I always thought that it should be. I always thought that it should be at the front. I was happy that it was at the front. I was. I thought it was strange that they put it at the back. And you mentioned you mentioned that you kind of started in clubland. What one of the things that got me into the rules, I was president of our men's Golf Association. And I was that guy who kept
going to the pro going, OK, Johnny did this out on the course. What's the right ruling? OK, Johnny did this out on the course, what's the right ruling? And finally the pro just backed in the big decisions book. And now our what we call clarifications book. We had a big decision book and he finally, he just gave me his one day. He says, here you go, Jason, just take this. There's an index in the back. Just go find it and you'll figure it out. Yeah. And so and that's, you know, sort of like what you're talking about. That's that's how I learned a whole lot of the rules. Was just trying to find it in the book.
Yeah, that that's a, that's a cool like, you know, it's as I said, it's competitive. You're trying to find it, you know, work it out and, and a lot of these rulings or situations, they pop up once a year, once a decade. You know it hardly ever happens. Or they as they always say, it only happens on the test. Yeah, yeah, that's right. Well, you know, I could write a test of all the once or never happens. Like I I asked a group of guys
just recently, you know, you're allowed to and this one, I I don't know the answer. You might be able to help me out, but you can wear protective pants. You can wrap a towel around your legs as a way of protecting your legs. And this could be this could be next to a cactus. This could because the ground is muddy and you want to kneel underneath a tree or something like that, right? You can do that. You can wear the protective pants. You can wrap the towel, but you're not allowed to put the
towel down. You're not allowed to put the pants down and then kneel on them. OK, I'm oh, I find that grey, but I I'm OK with it, right? I've accepted it. The thing that gets me is what if you put wrap the towel and then the towel falls off after after you kneel down? Right. So OK, now have you built a stance or are you still is it
still wrapped around your legs? OK, so I always like this and this is this is one of the great things about my brain is that I treat like situations like that's what they always tell us in rural school. Treat like this. OK, you have lead tape that's on the back of your club. Yep. OK. And you go through and you and you swing the club and the lead tape falls off. OK, What are you supposed to do now at this point? You are allowed to replace the lead tape and if it doesn't stick you can place new lead
tape in the same position. And so I would probably say the towel would be the same way. You can try to reattach the towel to your legs, and if they won't then you can try to get a new towel. I like it, I like it. It's never going to happen, but now I think I've got the answer. That's what I I like I said, it's it, you know, it's part of your equipment in some way. So I would treat the like
situations alike. I like it. I mean, I, I, the way I would sort of maybe look at it is should we penalize that person? They've gone to the process of trying to wrap the towel around their legs and now they're kneeling on the towel, which is what would have happened anyway. The towers now fell off as if it, as if it had been laid down, which we would penalize them for that.
But should we penalize them for this? And I'd probably same similar to you, I'd say that's, that's unfortunate. No penalty? What? What? Like what's the Janet Jackson and Justin Timberlake thing? Was it wardrobe malfunction? Yeah, wardrobe malfunction. Yeah, was that that Super Bowl? Super Bowl? That was a Super Bowl, Yes. We won't. We won't talk about any farther than that. The young kids will be out there like Googling that one. Yeah, yeah, Jason, because young kids listen to this podcast.
Hey. I was, I'm a cheering golf AI with a bunch of the junior golfers this weekend. Yeah. So, yeah. So you never know where it is going to be listening to it. So like to actually, that's a great, great call like, you know, golf dot AI with juniors, at least at least they won't have to talk to adults and they'll just be able to bring up or text. They love texting. So that works really well and. The Golf Club AI thing is right up their alley. That's right, but. I think your golfers, I'm talking like the 13 to 18 year
old. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's what I talk about, yeah. Yeah, and to them, they're used to it. Just pick up my phone and ask the. Question. Yeah, and most of the time, you know, they're out at it if they're playing with their friends at their at their high school tournaments or whatever else and they know their coach doesn't know the answer to it. I mean, and that's what I was sharing with them. I said how many times y'all been out and y'all are, you know, y'all are trying to do a qualifier for who's going to be on the travel team and you get into an argument on a situation. I said there goth dot AI just just pick it up and use it. Yeah, you'll be faster than
trying to hunt it in a rule book which you none of y'all know how to read anyway. And this is this is a bit of a tangent, but going off how to learn the rules right, one of the things at golf dot AI, we I do need to teach it a little bit more and and everyone can help as well. If you are a, you do know the rules really well. Go and use it right. And if you know that the answer is wrong, tell it. Just say, hey, that's incorrect.
Have you? Have you OK? It's a good example. And because I'm not, I will not say that golf dot AI is 100%. I'd love it to be, but it's not. But here's a good example. I asked it what a best ball was. Do you know what a best ball was? Yeah. It's in it's a type of four ball where you play against other people, a group, A-Team or or whatever, right? Right, 22 on 2 like are are you targeting? It's like one on two or one on three. Three right, but their lower
score against the other team's lower score. Something like that. I've never played it. I know where it is in the book, but I've never played it and really, no. What is it? A variation of this form of match play known as best ball, where an individual player competes against the side of two or three partners, right? So two or three playing against one. Right. So it's and it's a modification of like type of baseball, type of four ball. It's type of four ball, but it's
only one versus 2 or one versus 3. Anyway, I, you know, I asked it and it said something along the lines of a four ball is blah, blah. And I go, no, I didn't ask what a four ball is. I want to know what a baseball is. And you need to read paragraph 3 of 23.1 or something like that, right? And it comes back and it comes back and goes, Oh yeah, sorry about that. You're, you're correct. I've read it now.
And a baseball is one person playing two or one person playing 3. So we can help. I mean, if you know AI, if you understand AIAI is about artificial intelligence, but it how it learns. So I would, I would highly, I'd love it if every referee, you know, highly skilled rules official got on there and told it when it was wrong that that would be so helpful to the, to
the overall, Yeah. Increased intelligence of it. OK. Instead of going from 80% goes to 90. Like crazy, I'll wear that thing out. For good, just just go for it and and you've got the phone as well. So in the US, so you guys can just ring up Jim or Chris or whoever it is. I should get my voice on. No, no one would understand my voice if I had it on there.
Can it be like Google navigation or Apple that you know like maps where you can change the? Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's on the phone. We've only got one voice. It's the American voice. But on on the website and the browser, yeah, you can have whatever voice that we've got. We've got about 12 so far. There's, there's two Americans, I think, or three Americans. There's a Spanish lady, there's a Kiwi lady, there's an Englishman, an Irishman, Indian
lady. It's yeah, there's, there's plenty of sort of options there. And I mean, that would be that would be a cool thing going down the track where the pro or the rules person at say Texas Golf Association or Texas State Golf Association, you know, if, if that person we they could just plug in their voice and send it out to all the clubs in that region. They'll go. I need to ask Brad. And then you're asking AI.
But it sounds like, Brad, the rules go from Texas. OK, I'm going to, I'm going to dive way deeper into this now because all I've done is, is look on your YouTube channel and see all the clips of you using it and everything else. So now you've got me. I, I'm, I'm going to sit around probably on the drive home and I'm just going to keep calling it. Yeah, keep calling and and if it gets it wrong, just say hey, you got that one wrong. You need to, you know it. Sometimes it has and this is what I was sort of getting at. Sometimes it has like difficulty and I can understand why it would have difficulty.
And, you know, this is going back to how to learn the rules. There's a big difference between the English language and the rules of Gulf language. They're both, they're both English. But, you know, moved is a good one. There's a couple of others. Yep. That's yeah. So those type of things where you know what it means in English, but what it means in the Rules of Golf is not totally different, but quite different. And so whereas a new beginner
would struggle with that, AI can struggle with that a little bit. And you need, it needs to sort of understand the context, you know, dropping a ball, it will only think of dropping a ball and then it will go, OK, the rules of golf says that dropping a ball, the ball becomes in in play or whatever. But it needs to know it needs to learn what the intention of the person dropping the ball. If you say accidentally dropped or I dropped, it thinks that's the same thing.
Oh, I. Guess that's OK. So I dropped is I put the ball in play or I wanted to put the ball in play. I accidentally dropped, you know, I was walking in my bag and I accidentally dropped it would still think the ball was in play. And it's like, no, you need to learn, especially if it says accidentally, then you didn't have that intention. So those are little things, you know, why it's not going to get to 100%, but if you like some of the cool things about it and
this wasn't, you know, I know it's presented by golf dot AI, but this wasn't a all about a paid promotion of telling golf dot AI, but just explaining it to to you. You know, you can go on there. And I tried to ask it how many full stops are in the rule book. It didn't come back to me with the answer for that, but I asked it how many times is clearly unreasonable in the rule book and it came back, came back in about 25 seconds and said that it was in there 12 times or
something. Like if I asked you, Jason, tell me how many times clearly unreasonable was in the rule book? I wouldn't. I wouldn't have a clue. Reasonable judgement, You know, all those little things, OK, what? How? How many rules have required reasonable judgement? That type of thing. OK, well, all right. Yeah. I mean, I, I mean, there's no way. I I mean, my brain is not, I mean, I know the rules of golf, but I don't think of the rules in that way.
You know, I would have to, I'd have to stop. It would take me longer than 25 seconds, but I'd have to stop and think through each rule and go, OK, would that be in that rule? You know, this is something going back to learning the rules of golf. I I remember when I first started learning the rules of Gov USGA would send us out these notebooks. They were like a spiral bound. Yes, I've got one of those, yes. Yeah, you know what? And, and it would, and it would have like, it would have like a word or a sentence or a scenario. And then it would say, OK, how
many, you know, which decisions apply to this or how many rules or what are the rules that apply to this? And it would give you a hint that there might be like 3 rules and 10 decisions. And then it forced you to have to go and find them in the rule book and, and learn how to navigate the rule book. I, I thought that that that was a, that was a really good thing. And so kind of going off what you're talking about with AI, like how many times is reasonable judgement in there? Well, that would be something that would have been in this notebook.
Like go find all the places that you know knowledge or virtual certainties mentioned. The RNA and I don't know if they still do it, but when I last did the TAZ course TARS as tournament administrator, referee school, when I was blasted, they would send out a pre tournament, a pre tars workbook. And that's exactly what was in the workbook. You know, how many times is this
rule here? How many penalties? Yeah, it was it was more than just true false. It was go and find what rule number this term is written in or something like that. You know how? Many times you know what are all the rules and clarifications that this term is used. In Yeah, yeah. And, and and you know that that was a big help to, to learn the rules because then you, you're navigating your way around the book and the amount of times I would read and I'd go, OK, I
found it. But then I'd read on the next sentence or the next sentence, you know, in the next paragraph and I'd go, oh, you know, I found something new. I'd be like, oh shit, I didn't know that. And you're like, and then you're writing that down and you're like, oh wow, that's right. You know, and that's, that's exactly, I mean that that's how I started learning the rules also was out of that. And I think in, in the one that USJ, this is, you were talking about just being competitive, also against the rules, because the one USJ would send out, it
would tell you like, OK, there's five instances or 7 instances. And you know, and I would sit there and end up spending like an hour trying to find all 7. You know, no, it's not good for me to find, you know, three. No, it's not good enough to find 5. No, I want to find everyone of them. And you know, so back then in the, in the decisions book, man, I'd be going through that index like crazy. I'd be. It didn't. What I tell you, The other cool thing that that taught me was how all of the rules work together because you would find an instance, OK, hold on, you
know, dropping the ball, OK? It's not just rule 14. It's rule, you know. 16. 18 it's rule 11, you know, and so all of a sudden you're going holy crap, you know, dropping the ball is. Yeah, it's interconnected. I was having a discussion with someone about, you know, and I'm not very good at this, so he probably was almost, almost going to get me. But we're like, the penalties for moving a ball are all under
Rule 9, right? No, yes, yes and no. Right, that's yes, that's the, that's the OK. So if you if you this is the argument. If you move a loose impediment and you cause your ball to move, then all about moving loose impediments is under Rule 1515 by 1. So do you get the penalty under Rule 15.1 or do you get the penalty under Rule 9.4? Well, but if you rule, if you read 15.1, what does it tell
you? Well, this and this is what I was trying to get at him. It says that if you cause your ball to move, you get a one stroke penalty under Rule 9.4. Exactly. And that and he's like, you got a quote in 15.1. I was like, well you don't because the penalty is under 9.4. It doesn't say and and then under 9.4 it doesn't say you caused your ball to move by moving a loose impediment that's not under this role. You have to go to rule 15.1.
It doesn't say that. But the flagstick, God bless it. One time the flagstick was in like 7 different places. You know if a ball hit it or if you hit the player attending a flagstick, you know it was like. If you hit. You know what I'm talking about, You know, like that one used to just drive me crazy because it was like, OK, but where do we give the penalty under if it. OK, but was the person on the green, Were they off the green? Did they do it while the ball was in motion? Was it deflected?
And all of a sudden you're you're in six different places in the rule book. And yeah. So I've got a club land story here. They haven't given me the nickname which is fine. A small gum tree 3 meters hot, 3 meters high with a four inch diameter trunk. I love how he's using using metric and imperial at the same time. 3 meters high and a four inch diameter truck trunk on the 1st hole on the edge of the
fairway has a ring of bark chips around it. It's the only tree on the whole with this ring of bark. It's not staked or under 2 club links in hot. Should I get relief if I'm in the bark chips or he means does he if he has interference with the bark chips? It's just the bark chips, it's not the the tree. So it's like the bark hanging off the. Tree. No, no, you could call it wood chips. Do you call it wood chips? Wood chips. Wood chips. OK. OK. So it's bark on its wood chips when it's off?
Yeah, it's someone's taken that and and put it in a wood chipper and turned it into wood chips and then put it around. Yeah, yeah. And so have they turned it into an artificial object or is it just ground under a pier? Possibly. He's asked the club president. And the club president said that it's a garden bed and relief is possible, but but this person doesn't, doesn't agree and thinks it's just a play it as it lies.
What's the rule? So let's say, Jason, there's no local rule and we just have to work out whether it's ground under a light, ground under repair, or it's a movable obstruction or it's an immovable obstruction or it's integral object. Well, the the the way that I've always played it is that they're loose impediments and you can move any of them as long as your ball doesn't move. Yep, I agree with that. Yeah.
And so if you need to move some to to do whatever to you feel would make it so that you can make a better stroke as long as the ball doesn't move, you can move any of them you want to. Yep. Or as many of them as long as the ball doesn't move. And then I'd look at you and say play hard. Let's go. I I just believe. I'm in agreeance with that. I I think it's just AI mean if you're especially if you're just in the rough. I mean, I'd even say the same if you're in the fairway. But I'm I'm like that. But what I want, what I want to know from you is if you put wood
into a wood chipper and turn it into wood chips, have you, have you put it through a process that's made it now an artificial object? And I don't I don't know the answer to that. Ice. Now we're back to like the ice scenario again, you know, is it manufactured ice or is it, is it still Tipperary water? You know I until somebody puts something on a notice or local rule. I agree I'm. Just I'm just going to say that it's still loose impediment and
not. Loose impediment slash 2. When loose impediment becomes obstruction, Loose impediments may be transformed into obstructions through the process of construction or manufacturing. Right, OK. Has have you put it putting it into a wood chipper? Have you done any construction or manufacturing? See. And that that's where I say no. And I agree. Now, now, see, this is what, and this is what my brain thinks of whenever it says, you know, construction or manufacturing is
whenever you take a tree and you make it into a bench. That agreed agreed you know and and if you if you take. Construction. If you take rocks and put them, turn it making a wall out of rocks. Or to hold a cooler or something. Right. Have you turned it into? Have you constructed or manufactured to make it into something? Yes, now it's now it's an obstruction. So the wood chips, have you
changed it into something? I mean, you know, it would be very hard to say that it was an artificial object simply because if bark fell off that tree and was exactly the same size as the wood chip, deer wood chip, parts of the wood of the ring of bark or whatever, it would be too difficult to tell if that was a moveable obstruction or a loose impediment. You know, I guess somebody could also get into it because I have a friend of mine who owns a a mulch business and they actually
do treat and do some chemical things. They they grind up and then they put it into the bags and they make mulch. Mulch and wood chips. Same thing. Same thing. Yeah, yeah. And so they do some things to that mulch so that it lasts longer and looks prettier around your house. Yep. And so you know, is that manufactured? Yeah, that's. Through sense of construction could be transformed and and see. Now here's the keyword. You know what the keyword in loose impediment slash 2 is though?
Transformed. No, Maybe. OK. It doesn't say it is just as that it may be. So once again, until somebody puts it in the notice or local rules, I'm still sticking to loose impediments. OK, OK. I'm, I'm in greens with everything that you said. I think back. To where the lawyers wrote this crap. You said you said it the best when you said they just need to write a local rule for that.
They say, yeah, you know, they need to say wood chips or mulched areas are loose impediments or, you know, or just say they're natural. If you just say they're natural, then there's no relief for as an obstruction either immovable or movable and they're natural. They're definitely going to be loose impediments. And that's you've. You've fixed it. I don't want to deal with players if you say that wood chips are now obstructions. Yeah. Oh my, Oh my gosh, no, I don't
want. I don't want to deal with that out of course, because. We did that. We had at Mexico, they had some off the path and the path was concrete, so that was an immovable obstruction, immovable. But then off still sort of just off the path, they had these piles of wood chips. You know, it must have been that the path had been worn down or whatever it was. And so I think we gave relief for the wood chips that were adjacent. So each one was each single one was a loose impediment, but the
as a whole you could get relief if they were adjacent to a cart path. Now, the same thing with rocks. We do that all the time with rocks and gravel. Yep. You know rocks and gravel are loose impediments, but if they're adjacent to a cart path then they're considered to be part of the cart. Path yeah. So I think in this case, you know, it just it's up to the committee to make sure that they write on their local rules what they want it to be and how the players should should trade it. And once again, if this is happening at men's league golf, just decide over the bar so that
next week y'all, y'all don't. Don't, right? We've got a, we've got a, an audio question from Jason's friend Ken from Texas. So let's play that one. Hi, this is Ken from Texas. I've got a question on a ball. If it is plugged in the face of the bunker in the sand, what are my options on on that particular item? Thank you. So as you said, this happened
recently. Yeah. Do you want me to get the whole back story on this? Yeah. Because I asked you did so this actually happened at AUS Open qualifier final stage. Final stage, OK. Final stage he was open qualifier professional golfer and Ken was actually Ken phenomenal rules official in the state of Texas great friend and he was telling me a story and I was like, dude, you got to send this one in. You got to because it seems so simple. I mean for if you have a if you have a certain level of knowledge of golf rules, you
hear this and you go, Oh well, the the answer is obvious. Why, why are we discussing this? It was a tour player that it happened to and argued with Ken because of he didn't like the answer that Ken gave him and and ended up asking for a second opinion. And we all know in the rules now you're not entitled to a second opinion, but I can obviously go get one if it makes you feel happier and it makes you put a ball on the ground and hit it and let's get on, you know. And so that the player, what the player wanted was to drop out of
the bunker for one penalty stroke and take an unplayable live back online. Take the flagstick, take the ball, go back online out of the bunker, drop. And so when you first read the unplayable ball roll, it says back online as far as you want. But what you have to do is then you have to read about when the ball is in a bunker. So I don't know if you want, if you want to take it up from there and and tell us what our options we have like what three options, maybe four options. The interesting thing is that
unplayable for outside of penalty area because penalty area has its own thing under 17.1. So 19.1 is outside of penalty area and it's also outside of bunker because 19.2 is when your ball was in a bunker. Right. Right. So 19.1 is in the rough in the fairway on the green those those
places, I guess there's no other places. But 19.2 is bunker and that's because they give you this, it will a they keep you in the bunker for two of the options and they allow you outside the bunker for one option and then the other option stroke and distance. It just depends where you last were. So you could be in the bunker, then you have to stay in the bunker. If you were off the tee, then
you'd go back to the tee. So option one previous place played wherever that was. It could be in a penalty area that could be in the fairway, that could be in the bunker. Same bunker could be in a different bunker. Option 2 back on the line inside the bunker and then option 3 inside the bunker. 2 club lengths, half circle, they're all one shot penalty, one shot penalty, and then your fourth option, which they bought in in 2019, two shot penalty, back on
the line outside the bunker and you could drop into a penalty area. You could drop into another bunker. But it's going to. Cost you two shots. Yes all right, so wonderful explanation of this and and and that's what a lot of people don't understand is to get completely out of the bunker it if you didn't start in it, let's preface it with that. If you didn't start in the bunker, if you're if you're shot that got you there was in the bunker to get completely out of the bunker, it's going to be two penalty strokes and most people
forget that they don't and that's what the the the tour player didn't understand. He thought it was just one penalty stroke and and that's, and that was added just in 2019 actually is when that was added so. Did did Ken say? Did Ken say which option the player finally went with? The one stroke 2 club links in the bunker. Yeah, OK, OK. Because I mean, I, I wouldn't, you don't see, I don't know if I've ever seen a professional use the two penalty strokes.
And, and actually this is one of my questions that I always try and trick people. When is there a two shot penalty in match play? Oh oh God bless. Don't do this to me on. Well, yeah, I've just given you the answer. So you you just, you just got the answer. Right, right. Well, I mean, obviously getting out of a bunker. Would be two struck. It's the only two shot penalty. Yeah, exactly, exactly. Every every general penalty is A and then and it says that in the 19.2.
It doesn't say it's a general penalty, it says it's a 2 stroke penalty. It's a. Stroke penalty. No. What about No I'm. Aggression is total 2 stroke penalties. Right, Yeah. Everything else is accumulation penalties like having a caddy multiple times or you know. Yeah, yeah. And that's a general penalty for each breach. Breach. Yeah, that's where you accumulate. Or and then the other one for clubs is in match flight is a not accumulation, not a loss, a
whole. It's a. Adjustment adjusted. Adjusted where they. Adjusted, adjusted score, adjusted whole score or whatever. It's a match score. Just a match score. Now we're getting off into like anything that's. Right, I used to figure out how. To think about, it's like how quickly could I lose a match in match play? Oh, OK. I worked this out under the old rules and we're obviously a lot better than with the old rules. It was, I think I worked it out and you might disagree with me. I can't remember, but it's it was, it was either 4 and 15 or 5, five and 14.
I just I think it was 5. And 14 That's what I was thinking. It was incredible. I loved it. It was. It was like giving. Caddies, too many clubs. I mean there was like I forgot all the adjustment. Pills turning up turning up late or something. Late. Yeah, yeah. I mean, you could be like 5, you could be like 5 down after one hole or. Something that's right, that's right. That's what it was. It was, it was something like 5 and 15, five and 14. It was unbelievable. It was like, Oh yeah, I could, you know, if I was like 1010 nights, you know, if I was like
10 nights the best, I was like, no, it's not. Y'all work it out and send us the comments. Actually, I should go, I should golf dot AI, but that's, I mean, I'd have to say golf dot AIA AI go back to 2018 and tell me the quickest way you could lose a. Man, All right, so here you go. Another clubland story that just happened today. I had one where ball was was on a cart path and it was 14 yards
to the flagstick, but it was like the cart path and the flagstick were like in a perfect curve. And so it's like, so now we got to figure out where the nearest point of relief is, but the the flagstick gets on a perfect arc with the cart path. And so we were trying to figure out where 14 yards would ever be where he wasn't on the cart path. And we put AT down on one side and went to the other side and shot him with the range rider put AT down, went back to the ball and I said which T's closer
and he looked at me and he goes, shouldn't you tell me? And I go, you're the player. I said, you know, you're going to have to live with this, you know which? So then he went and stepped it off. He got nervous and so he stepped it off. I was like, there you go. And he goes, I think this one's closer. I said there you go, there's your nearest point. Have you ever had have you ever had the situation where you've had two nearest point of complete relief? Yeah, actually #9 at Lakewood Country Club in Dallas, and it happens quite a bit there
because that's, and this was actually on #11 of another course that we were at. But yeah, I mean, you get that and it's the exact same. And you, you just got to choose. I mean, the players just got to, you just got to make a choice which one. And you know, and at that point it might be which one might you have a better lighter drop in? I had, you know, I had one at World Golf Match play at Austin Country Club. Yeah, beautiful. On the 12th hole, the par 5 down the hill and there's that road
that goes just under the hill and a lot of players would get onto that road and I had and I stepped it off chicken steps. So just one foot, 1 foot, 1 foot, 1 foot. Yeah, I stepped it off for the player and I was like, I'll I've got 6 or 7, whatever it was for both. You choose whichever, whichever side you want. And when it made a choice, it was. I was like, I've never had that before. No, well, I tell you sorry. Now here, here's another good
clubland story is Tios like fans? We have tons of fans on post around greens here and. You call, you call them Tios. Yeah, we we always on our notice local. We call all those fans as Tios. Which is funny, because they're technically they're technically always there, aren't they? Yes, the fan can be taken off the post. These fans, a lot of these fans, they can be taken off the post to be serviced or maintenanced
or whatever else. OK, but just so I. Mean are they temporary? Yeah. The the post isn't but the fan is. But we we play them as Tios but we also put in the notice to the players that they get to choose. If that TIO is in interference, they could choose either side of the TIO. And it is so funny when you see a player and they in their eyes light up that they get to choose to go to either side because nine times out of 10, there's one side that's way better than another side. And I had, I had one, I had one
the other day. Oh my gosh, it was a junior qualifier, junior USAM qualifier. And the kid and I sit there, I said, before you touch that ball, I said, let's measure out and figure out what's going to happen. You know where you're going to end up. Because he was on a cart path that was going to end up. And once he did that, he was going to end up dropping behind the TIO. And then from behind the TIO, he was going to make another drop. And here's a, here's a crazy thing. If you drop from a cart, if you're taking obstruction relief from a cart path and you end up dropping in a situation where
you have TIO interference, can you then take relief for the TIO back onto the cart path? No. Yes, you can. There's no restriction on the. There's no restriction on the. I know where your relief area could be. It could be on. The instruction, sorry. You, I mean, you have to take full relief from the TIO, right? If you're taking full relief and that's dropping on the car path. Yeah, that's fine. I thought, yeah. The way I was thinking in my
head was you were dropping back behind the TIO and saying no, Yeah, I no, no, that's right. Yep, that's right. And so then the player, so I was working through this with the player. It's something the player realized, OK, I'm going to take relief from the cart path and that's going to get me over here by this TIO. Once I get to the TIO then I'm going to get to drop again and I could drop into the. Cart on the other side. So then we start working it out and he ends up he's on like hard pan next to a boundary fence where he's basically got like
about 3 feet of room by behind the cart path to get to the green that's about 5 yards away from where his ball is. He ends up working this out and, and I told him I said don't touch the ball. I said let's work, let's work through this and see where you're going to end up before you decide to do it. And he ends up working getting on some nice beautiful grass. Had like a little 7 yard shot then off of grass. No interference from anything and his dad came over to me later. He goes, thank you so much. He goes, he goes, that was a
whole lot. And I said, well, it was only two obstructions and a TIO. It wasn't that much. And the Tio, you know, because they they the Tio. The way we worded on our notice to players is you get the, the you get a one club length corridor away and then you get another club length that you drop in away from that corridor once you choose which side or not that you're going to, you're going to drop on. So you really end up getting 2 club lengths of relief from a T I/O, which is that's a long ways. I mean it's 100 and something
inches when you use drivers. So that's spot on. And so and the kid was wonderful to it because he he was asking me questions all the way through it and everything else. It was a really good little educational moment and and everything else. And the parents were very thankful. But man, it's it's it pays if you got if you got fans on your course and things like if you you know those fans for keeping bent grass cool or things like that, and they're TI OS, it pays to know that rule, that one.
And that's A and anyway. The world of clubland, I, I mean, I like to, you mentioned it before, you know, I like to think of clubland as almost the situations that don't get on TV. That is me. That is clubland. You know, it is, you know, the amateur golfers, it is the people who don't have referees. It's the people they have to ask the pro shop for rulings. Predominant predominantly. But you know, if you're out there with a tournament and it's
a junior tournament or a senior tournament or a pro AM or something like that, right? That's still I still consider that clubland. Yeah, or your men's league. I mean, I can't tell you how many times in the men's league you know they'll see me. I'm. I'm probably playing in the tournament with them and I'll see somebody waving at Jason. Jason, come over there and, and of course, you know, we're playing men's league. We play like we'll pay $30.00 or $40 when we tee off to be into the, you know, into the men's league for that, for that
Saturday or Sunday or whatever else, you know, and they'll call. I'd say this is the funniest thing that they call me over. They asked me what the ruling is. And then and then I drive away and I turn around and as I look, as I'm driving away and guess what, they do the. Opposite whatever. Yeah, whatever the hell they want. They're like, no, we can't listen to him, you know, and it's fine. It's unfair. It's I mean, you know, I shouldn't be, I shouldn't be dropping off a cart path into worse condition. That's not fair. OK, yeah, that's the we all did.
Of course we get jeez, we get back to the bar and, you know, and everybody's talking about their round and then of course they always walk up to me and the the one guy goes, oh, Jase, when are we ever going to get relief from divots? Oh God, in the fairway. And I just, I just shake my head and I said never. You're never going to get relief. If we do. And so I said, as a matter of fact, I said to a guy the other day, I said, how about this? I said, I'll start giving relief from divots. Every time that you have a good line in the rough, you let me come over and step on your ball.
Yes, yes, that's right. Exactly right. You know, the day that we give free relief from a ball and debit is the day that golf dies. Absolutely. Because because golf is not about hitting it down the middle and having a perfect lie. Even though a lot of people think that's exactly what golf should be, that's not what golf is. That that's the opposite of what golf is. Golf is about hitting your ball and dealing with what you've got and then playing on and having
the mental fortitude, the character to accept the bad lies, the good brakes and whatnot. That is actual. GG is not about perfect and unfortunately this day and age people say they want to make it about being perfect and it's that. That would be horrible if if we ever lose it. Vote right, Vote right said it best. We give you 18 perfect lies. How many more do you need? Yeah, spot on. Yeah, spot on, spot on.
And you know, the way greens are these days, they they're almost so much better. I mean, you know, Augusta when it first opened was the speed was 7 1/2. Yeah. Now it's there. Yeah. So yeah, no, have you? I'm sorry. And I I've got to run and I know you've got to go to. Yeah, I got to go. Let's go. Have you? Watched the Bryson Dechambeau's playing a public golf course. I've heard of it and I've watched maybe the trailer.
Some of the tapes are awesome. Bryson said it best. He said playing public golf courses is way harder than playing Professional Golf course. Because you don't get the perfect lies. Yeah, we we don't have any. You have no perfect lies. Yeah, which I, I, I actually would, you know, when the PGA last thing, when the PGA said no to free relief from preferred lies at the recent PGA, I was so happy about that. I wanted to watch them have mud balls. I I wanted, I think that's real golf.
It is real golf there. There are rules in place for embedded balls. There's rules in place for temporary water play. Freaking golf. Do not let them put their hands on the Dang ball. Yeah, it's live, clean and cheek. I don't care. I agree, I agree. I love that lift, clean and cheek. We we say that is lift. Are we playing lift, clean and cheek today? I love. I want to watch some play with OK, I need to. I've got a mud on my ball. Instead of going for the hole, I'll just make sure I, you know, hit it low, roll it along the
ground, try and get to the front of the ground and then chip and putt and make par right? Right. Well, but also just the better players, if you if you have some mud on the ball and you can look, you know, if you're a good player in your experience with if you've played with mud balls before, you know that mud on certain sides of the ball in certain ways in certain situations, how that ball going to react. And that's just because you're a better player. That's right. You never have to use the blood balls. You have no clue. That's right. That's a skill that's being lost. So, alright, so everybody, here's the situation.
Your ball is lying near a loose impediment. You walk up to your ball and you start to remove the loose impediment. And as you start to move the loose impediment, you see that your ball is going to move or that your ball is moving and your ball does move. So you put the loose impediment down and the ball comes back to the rest as to where it started. And you call in a rules official. What is the ruling? Right. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Jason, for joining us once again. This won't be your last time, I'll tell you that. It's been absolutely fantastic talking to you again. Hey, and I'm going to I'm going to bang out on your on your golf AI go for. It. Go for. It. I've got to drive back home on Saturday and I'm just going to drive home and keep asking it questions all the. Time, please do and please teach it what you know. And it can only get better. I mean, it can't get worse, so it can only get better. And it's, yeah, I mean, I work
for them now, but I have such belief in it that this is going to be such a great technology for the masses of the club land people, and it will teach them how to play real golf as well. So that'll be fantastic. Thank you very much, Jason. Thank you. Have a great have a great weekend. You too. Cheers mate, Bye. Cheers.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Elisa Hermes, an update about recent US OPEN qualifying tournaments and Rules worshops that Elisa has been running, we also discuss golf as an outdoor spot - THE GRQ PODCAST EP138 GRQ137 - David hits his tee shot...