GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140
1 hrAudio
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates with the Southern California Golf Association. Joining the SCGA to help conduct some tournaments - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140 GRQOTW140: A player has a caddie, and fires them after four holes. The caddie then continues to watch the player play, and then on the 7th hole, the player hits a ball into long grass, the ex-caddie goes to search for it and is there for 45 seconds before the player arrives to search. The ball is found 2mins and 45secs later. Is this ball still the ball in play? GRQOTW139: The player moves a loose impediment that the ball is sitting on. They then realised the ball is sitting on the loose impediment, so they replace the loose impediment exactly as it was so that the ball is in the same position. Is the ball considered to have move and therefore the player gets a one stroke penalty? GOLF.AI https://www.instagram.com/golf.ai_/ https://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestions https://www.tiktok.com/@golf.ai_ Whatsapp: +1 (415) 517-0843 Free-call: AUS - +61 2 5023 1831 UK - +44 1302 490357 USA - +1 706 770 4406
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
But episode 140, the GRQ Podcast. We have special guest Marcel Smith back on the podcast and this time she is filling us in on her first referee experiences working with the Southern California Golf Association and some of their tournaments including AUS Open Qualifier. As always, whether you are sweeping the front doorstep or contemplating the taste of the second muffin, please enjoy the GRQ Podcast presented by Golf dot AI.
Hey everyone, welcome back to the GRQ podcast hosted by Golf dot AII am Blakey. And this week I have Marcel Smith from girlfriends guide to go girlfriends guide to Golf. And I was just kind of say always trip myself up because I'm thinking about what I'm going to say. But you have been on the podcast before, so thank you very much for agreeing to come back. As great, Always great to be here, always great to be with you. OK. Before we get into that episode with Marcella, we will just go through the GRQO TW139 that
Jason Smith asked in the last episode. Question was if you move a loose impediment or a branch to see if it's a loose impediment and the ball is, the ball moves when you move that loose impediment and then you put the loose impediment back and the ball was in exactly the same location. Has the ball moved and you get the one shot penalty or the ball
has not moved and you don't get any penalties? Jason has the answer, OK. There, there's 'cause there's, there's, there's a multitude of answers to this. There, there, there's end of, you know, it's almost like this is you're you're at a bar with five rules officials and you want to start an argument. Go, go through it. Go through it one more time. OK, your ball is lying on a loose impediment. A limb is broken off. Let's say a limb is broken off a tree. Your ball, your tee shot comes to rest on this limb. You go and you pick up the limb and you and as you pick up the
limb, the ball moves with the limb and you notice that your ball is moving. So you put the limb back to where it was and say the ball. Let's say the ball moves like. 1/2 an inch. 7mm I don't know what y'all use in metric world. So. And, and, but then when you put the limb back the ball, the the ball comes back with it. Let's say, you know, the ball is like stuck between 2 little forks in the limb or something like that. The ball doesn't roll around or anything. You just pick it up and you see the ball's going to move and then you put it back down. I mean, if the ball is now back
in the exact same spot, then there's no penalty, right? I won't, I won't put this on The thing. Is that right? Yeah, well, it depends. There's a we, we, we sought out a whole bunch of answers and requests and everything. And, you know, there's one side of the argument that said that the ball moved. And could you could you say for certain that the ball was in exactly the three-dimensional space? Yeah, yeah. That it started in and the other side of the argument was is like, well, if you set the limb
back down and the ball is stuck in the limb, then it's still in the same place. So I, I don't know, I just, I just wondered what your take on it would be. I mean, yeah, I mean I'd ask, I'd ask the player and say Are you sure? Like how sure are you? Grove always tells me not to ask closed ended questions. Always ask. Open-ended, open. Ended questions? Absolutely. Would would, how sure are you that the ball is in the same
spot from where it was? And then I just have, you just have to leave it up to the player as to what they come up with. You know, and, and, and to me, I applaud that. To me, that's the I, I believe in so much in the game of golf that the game of golf is the game of honor. And a lot of times I leave things up to the players. When I'm out there making rulings, I ask them. Thank you for that, Jason. And now back to episode 141 Mar Salesman. Actually, we have been chatting lately, just going through.
I still call them the new rules, but they're not really the the new rules, are they? No, they're, well, 2019, but they're still new to a lot of people. A lot of people have no idea some of the major changes that were made. Yeah. Yeah, and even even though I still get tripped up with some of the changes in 2023, they were so subtle and I just, yeah, still learning them. So it's always, it's always a learning journey. The rules of Golf, as you would
definitely know with the some of the ladies that you look after and your girlfriend's guide to golf clinics. They're they're still going strong, Marcel. Yeah, so we call it the girlfriends golf experience. And yes, it's definitely still growing strong, teaching them all over the country. And it's a great way for women to, you know, specifically women who haven't grown up in golf for them to feel more comfortable on the course and feel more less
intimidated and feel comfortable asking any question they want. We actually go out on the golf course on one hole and start out in the teeing area, work our way through, you know, relief for abnormal course conditions and unplayable balls and relief from penalty areas and just work our way all the way down to the putting green. And it's such a great experience to hear them support each other during the clinic and hear them provide some answers. Sometimes they're right, sometimes they're not right. And it's just so helpful to
dispel all the misunderstandings that are out there in the world of golf, especially in clubland as you call it. Yeah, Clubland. Yeah, a vital part of our of this podcast. From all the quirky queries and comments and questions that we get, what would you say would be your most most asked question in one of your experiences?
Well, you know, kind of my signature rule that I talk about is stroke and distance, but I call it the Louis Vuitton rule. And I basically explained to them that they can take stroke and distance for a ball anywhere on the golf course anytime. And we go over it again and again and again in different scenarios because that's stroke and distance and sometimes is obviously required if your ball is OB or lost. And it can be your option for lots of things like penalty
area, unplayable ball. And so when we go over it, we'll talk about it in the classroom before we go out in the course. And we go out on the course and we talk about it early on and then we talk about it again and we just keep talking about, and then I'll get a question, you know, an hour and a half, two hours later and they'll go, are you saying that I can go back to the location of my last shot? You know, they'll ask that question, something that I've talked about 6 times already. And the reason is it's so hard to believe that you can use
stroke and distance to your advantage whenever you want and take control of it. It's so hard for people to believe that. And if they've been playing for a while or they're brand new, they're like, wait a minute for one stroke. I can do this thing. What are you talking about? So I get asked that over and over and over again and almost in every zoom I do because I have an online Academy called the girlfriends golf Academy. And on that as well, we talk about it and we just have to keep re reinforcing it, reinforcing it that you deserve
to be in control of your game and sometimes that's your best option. Yeah, it's interesting that you say that. I mean, it's my favorite rule, the unplayable 19.1 and obviously stroke and distance is one of those options and then back on the line and lateral. And The funny thing is we golf dot AI. We posted the because it was the US Open last week. We posted this, this podcast will go out probably four weeks after that. But we posted about the most
famous rules incident at the US Open, which for us was Phil Mickelson, I think it was back in 2018 when he ran after his ball and played it while it was moving and it looked like it was going to go off the grain. And you know, I said like this, this was a dumb decision by him. It caused them the stroke and two shot penalty when he could have just let it go, grabbed
another ball, placed it on the green, taken unplayable. And he'd have exact same part and he'd, you know, have more experience on how to play it, blah blah, blah. And it's only just going to cost him one shot penalty and save strokes. And everyone was like, yeah, but it's not unplayable. You can still see it. You can still have a stroke at it. I was like, well, that's for the player to determine. It's unplayable is not screwed. Unplayable is. I don't want to be here. Well, and and you don't actually
even have to call it an unplayable. You just say stroke and distance or in our case, Louis Vuitton and you just play from your last place played and it just cost you one. Obviously that's in your penalty area, your bunker anywhere or on the putty green anywhere your ball is. And I think the reason the pros don't use it, and often the men on my social media, the ones that you're talking about, the same people who are posting and making comments about it, I think the reason they don't even know about it is they think they hit every shot 320 yards, right?
And so in their mind, you hit a shot into, you know, when you plug it in a bunker and it you were 320 yards away. So of course you're not going to go all the way back, sort of the walk of shame or the drive of shame back right to where you where you hit that shot. So in their mind, everything's a long shot. Well, in reality, for women who are newer to golf and lots of other players, we're not hitting that far. We see it, we see it go get plugged in a bunker. It's sitting there.
I don't have that side way thing standing with one foot. You know, I, I, I don't have that shot and I know it when I see it. I don't need to walk up and get it and then start saying what are my in playable options? My best option is to hit right here, drop the ball that's in my pocket and let's play again. And that is stroke and distance slash Louis Vuitton that we call it. And I think most, as I said, pros don't know. Phil didn't know he hadn't used that. He's probably never used it as a volunteer. You know what I'm saying? It's something he's only used it
when he had to for a lost ball or an OB ball. So the pros don't know about it, right? And they should certainly when they and, and they, I don't know if anybody putted their ball off the green this last week at the US Open, but in plenty of circumstances, they do put it off the green. And you, you might want to just re retake that putt. Like you said with that, you know, it's a second shot at something, right? You know, the, you know, kind of where, how it's breaking and what the speed is. Why not do it again for one? Yeah, exactly right. I don't know if anyone putted
off the green, but I reckon there would have been someone. I mean, every year at the Masters, someone putts off the green on hole 15. If you're up the back and you're putting down towards the pond and it's just, it's almost just a guarantee that someone's going to putt off the green there. And yeah, then you can, yeah. Even if it is in, as you said, even if it is in a penalty area, you can take stroke and distance. That's one of the options when your ball was in a penalty area and just go back to your last,
your previous place played. It's a, it's a really good one. I think it's pride thing, you know, I think you say, oh, the men don't know. I think they even if they did know, they'll be like, oh, no, I I'm going to try and play it. You know, regardless of what you know, whether that's a good decision, I will try and play it. Sometimes it's a bad decision, but that's what they want to do. And you know what? And and they're entitled. And if you're a pro or you're a plus handicap, good for you.
Go for it. You, you've got that in your bag. You've done it before and you can do it. But so many of these positions that the ball is in, some of these women and other players have never hit that strange situation, that strange shot before with a strange lie. And you know what, just go back to the last place played it. It might. It might save you some strokes. Yeah, absolutely. So how many, how many clinics are you running these days? Is this a daily thing, a weekly thing, a monthly thing, or? You know, yeah, it's just sort of as needed.
It kind of comes and goes depending on the season and the region. You know, certain, you know, it's downtime here, it's offseason where I live in Palm Springs area right now. But you know, other areas of the of the country it's it's it's full on golf season for them. So that really kind of depends on on the season and the demand. But what I'm really focused so right now is that Girlfriends Golf Academy, which is a 90 day Academy for women where we go on and I have I think there's 38 lessons in there very well, you
know, a PowerPoint presentations and I'm narrating them and you see videos and visuals and there's, you know, specific lessons. And then we do once a week Zoom. So we go live and I teach something and I take their Q&A's live. And that's one of the things that really makes this program stand out. You know, there's a lot of golf pros out in the country that our, you know, PGA professionals are very good at what they do, at teaching a swing and managing tournaments and just doing everything for their members. But they don't necessarily want
to take that live Q&A about the Rules of Golf because they might not have been to a workshop in a few years and they're not up to date. And so it's really hard to get access to someone who's got some answers. And I know you have a great way to get some really good answers on the Rules of Golf as well. Yeah, yeah. Golf day. Yeah. It's really blowing my mind. It's just so, so easy to get stuff. But, you know, there's still that time for those one-on-one. So if if people wanted to book
you at their Golf Club, how would they get in touch? Marcella. Yeah, it's Mark Marcella at Girlfriends Guide to golf.com. Marcella with 1L and, and they just booked me, but they could also go on my website and look at it at Girlfriends Golf, Girlfriends Guide to golf.com and yeah, absolutely. And we, we make basically a custom presentation that is very experiential. And I also speak at the PGA Show in Orlando, FL with a colleague of mine about how we use experiential learning techniques
to help, specifically to help women feel more comfortable on the golf course and feel more welcome. And then obviously learn the rules. And, you know, I had taught a, a Zoom session today, a one hour session from my Academy ladies. And when I was leaving the session, I, you know, I thank them for being there, but I thank them for their time and investment in the Academy because when they are interested in and committed to learning the rules and the etiquette and the course behavior, they're not
only making their life easier and better, they're making everybody else on the golf course things better for them. They're caring for the course, repairing their damage. They're understanding what it feels like to keep up and have a good pace. And, and I think that's just a huge, can make a huge impact because so many people have been coming to golf recently, which I'm excited about, right? I'm super excited that golf has such a huge popularity. However, where are they learning the etiquette?
Where are they learning how to properly prepare, repair their pitch Marks and divots and what the difference is and, and what their pace is supposed to be? And, you know, where are they learning that? Because we can't just go somewhere. We can't go to someone's house when we're invited and trash it. We don't rent a hotel room and trash it and leave. We don't go to a restaurant and trash the restaurant, have a great time for two hours and
leave. Yes, we're going to eat. We're going to enjoy it. We might have some crumbs, but we're not destroying the furniture. We're not putting dents in there that can't be repaired. We're not leaving stains of food all over the floor that once they dry up, you can't get them off, right? We are being considerate, you know, and I think that that's so important. If we were raised well, we should understand that there might be some protocols to every situation we go into. Let's learn what they are. Let's learn how to be considerate golfers and be part
of a community that cares about each other and respects each other. So that's so important to me. It's not just about Country Club golf, but it's about how can we all enjoy the experience better on a better golf course because we're taking care of and we understand why you don't do some of the things that people are doing right now and why you don't bring to excess, get completely inebriated and have a fistfight because that those are the most popular viral videos.
And it I mean, I watch, it's not like I'm not watching too. I'm watching but it's disgusting. It's it's not what I would call golf. Yeah, we we shouldn't encourage that stuff. It is funny to watch, but I'm glad it's not me or my family or my Golf Club that's involved. Right. It's it's, it's not appropriate and we shouldn't glorify it.
And it's dangerous. People are getting extremely hurt. And the fact that people think that's OK, it is not right. There's nothing wrong with it. Being a gentle woman and a gentle men's sport, there's nothing wrong with that. Doesn't mean you have to where all the buttoned up, you know, I, I you can get a little more fun with your with your attire depending on where you are. That's fine. But you do need to to learn how to behave and interact with other people and care for the course for sure. For sure.
Yeah, absolutely. I I, I guess this, this was just sort of built into me or just, you know, naturally that's how I felt about golf. And then to see how other people sort of treat the game, yeah, sort of blows my mind a bit. But that it is here and there we we are having a big influx of newer golfers and some of them don't care about, you know, the traditions of the game and what actually golfers.
I have that conversation with a lot of people you know, golfers about. The mental side of the game before it is the physical side, but people sort of don't seem to realize that. But we'll, we'll get there. I hope so. I hope we're not encouraging that the waste management, you know, complete, you know, drinking till they can't stand up anymore thing because that is just, it's just I don't believe that's good for golf in the long run. There might be some quick cash
in that in the beginning, but I don't think it's good in in, you know, in the long run. And there's so many ways to have a great time there. You can have a great time, you can have one beer or whatever your situation is, but you can have a great time. You can have a wonderful time and laugh and you know, and you don't have to be serious and you don't have to keep your score. And if if if you're not a, you know, quote, UN quote, good golfer, which I hate that term, as we, you know, reflect on ourselves because we shouldn't be comparing ourselves because, you know, Rory doesn't think
he's a great golfer every day either. You know, like we're all always thinking we could have done this and we could have done that better. But even if you're not at a point where you're going to be able to keep score all the time or, you know, enter competitions or whatever, that's all good, you know, and that's fine. You should, you have every right to be out there on the course having a great time, but your pace needs to, you know, you need to be in position keeping up with the group ahead of you and you need to know how to care for the course and all that. So yeah, super, super important. And I've really, as I've started
officiating, which you know you well, I've been teaching the rules of golf for probably 9 years ish. And when I met you, I was obviously newer to the rules, still learning them, got my certification eventually from the USGA. And as I have, you know, been progressing in my knowledge, I've been invited by the Southern California Golf Association and, and other
people that run different little, you know, not professional but competitive tours to officiate. And you have encouraged me for so many years to do it. And so have some other friends, good friends who are rules officials. And I just didn't, I wasn't ready. I didn't want to do it. And and I am now and I am thoroughly, thoroughly enjoying it. Yeah. So you've had a couple of couple of guys out on the courts
officiating, which, yeah, I encourage it because it shows a different side to the rules. You as a referee have to sort of, you know, the rules can be quite Gray, but you have to try and make it as black and white as possible and then treat situations the same. Yeah. I'm just, you know, thinking about situations where players have got in and you know, I've yes, I can see that you get
relief and then other ones like no, you're putting it on. You know, there's no interference there with your swing. It's just terrible shot, like it's just a terrible lie and you're trying to get something. It's like you're sort of wasting my time. But anyway, so how was it? What? So what? What sort of tournaments did you do and and how was it? So I've done a number of different events for SCGA, Southern California Golf Association and including recently two US Open qualifiers
and a California Amateur qualifier. And I was very nervous about those because I thought the players would be more intense and there's a lot more on the line for them. Their dream of competing in AUS Open, Maybe they maybe they had before or, or never have, but they they certainly have that dream. And some of them have the talent, you know, to get there. And so I was very nervous. And I, you know, I'm very
comfortable in front of, you know, a group of women or men at a club on the course on a zoom, answering rules questions. It happens a lot at dinner and stuff like that too. And I'm very comfortable, you know, do I have every answer off the top of my head? No, but I have a good number of them. And I'm certainly comfortable, you know, finding the answer quickly if it doesn't come straight to my mind. But I'm very comfortable with, with all of the complications of a lot of the rules of golf and certainly a lot of the things that come up every day for
people. And but I wasn't comfortable. Like, how am I supposed to be as a rules official? You know, I want to make sure I'm not, you know, getting into their head in a negative way. I want them to be happy that a rules officials nearby that they could ask a question of. I want them to perceive rules officials as support, not as, you know, the police, you know, that are ready to, to grab them, you know, and, and so that was important to me and just making
sure I do everything perfectly. And so I, you know, I asked a lot of questions and boy, there's some very interesting things that came him up. You just mentioned, you know, when someone's doing something, you know, he's trying to take advantage of it just reminded me there was someone who his ball was very close to a sprinkler head in the fairway and close, but I had gotten there first. It was a hole and it was #7 at the Grand Del Mar. And I had gotten there first
because I'm trying to spot balls and help them deal with a penalty area that was yellow and some other issues on that hole. So I saw it first. I walked over to it and I looked at it and pictured what his stance would be. And I thought, no, he's not entitled. He doesn't have interference from this. It's very close, but I don't believe he has interference. But just put that in my mind. I went off and found the other ball, etcetera, etcetera. Well, sure enough, the players walking over there and he doesn't know I've been at his ball already. And he tells another player, Oh
yeah, I'm, I'm going to take a drop. And, and I, I just looked over at him and I'm just sort of waiting thinking, is he really going to do that? And I start to walk over and he hadn't made a move for it yet. And I was going to stop him if he made a move and ask him, can you tell me, tell me what you're thinking? It's kind of how, what I'm kind of using right now is tell me, walk me through this, right. So I start to yeah, because I, you know, I don't want to guide them. I don't want to, you know, I just want to hey, hey, walk me through this. So, but I didn't have to because
as, as I approached him, he kind of saw me and went, oh, let me look again and let me think about it. And then he's like, never mind. So he, he didn't, he didn't try to take relief because he really, truly did not have interference, right? It was just visual distraction, which of course is not enough to get interference from an abnormal course condition. So that was interesting. There was another one where at this was at Ironwood in the
desert and that was this player. There was a lot of desert and some desert which is a bunch of just, you know, dirt and bushes is penalty area. Some desert is no play zone and some desert is general area. Well, on this particular course, all the desert was general area, so a couple of holes were going to be very challenging. And so I was on one of those holes, I want to say 13, but I can't remember now. So I'm on one of those holes and there were some balls getting
sprayed left and right. Desert, desert. And so I'm over there dealing with a player or watching a player who said I I'm going to take some relief from an animal hole. And he's saying that he he had interference for his stance on the animal hole. So I said, OK, but wait, now just a second. We had some unreasonable stroke possibilities here because the ball was also at the edge of a Bush.
So it was a Bush that it was kind of under and somewhat in that he was, I'm going, OK, Is he just is he really looking to go straight to the flag here? And he wants because he can, you know, distance wise, he could get there if the Bush wasn't there. So is that what he's really after or what is he thinking? So I said, OK, so you know, what do you think and walk me through this. And so he goes, well, I would stand here and I'd punch it out here into the fairway. So that was fine.
He had he could reasonably hit that shot and punch it out and he had interference. So no problema I did that. But had he said, oh, you know, I want to do this, that and the other and go straight for the flag, then obviously it would have been unreasonable for him to have that shot. So that was interesting just because I was wondering how I would say that, you know, when I'm teaching the rules, I just say it. I'm not worried about anybody's feelings. But when you're on the golf
course, like, how do I say it? So I didn't have to tell him that he that he couldn't have it. Just say sorry. Just say sorry. The rules don't allow it and then it's not because it's not. I know you're the referee making the decision, but you're not, don't think of you as making the decision. You're just telling them what the rules are. And you're saying, OK, so the rule says that you don't get relief. And the rule says you do get relief, you know, like that. So it's it's I'm just telling
you what the rules are. And in this situation, knowing what the rules are, they would say that you don't get relief because you don't have interference. That's not me telling you. It's like, it's like that reminded me of Happy Gilmore #1 when the guy from the bank comes and says that grandma owes $275,000 in back taxes and she's like, it's it's not like I'm taking the furniture over to my house. Yeah, I'm not. It's, I'm not penalizing you so I can win this tournament.
The rules say that that's a penalty or the rules say you don't get relief or the rules say you do get relief in that situation. So just blame it on the rules. Like Meli Vanelli. Yeah, yeah. No, that's that's a great way. It's not that I'm not going to give you relief that the rules don't allow you to have relief. Yeah, that's great. Yeah. It's not. It's not you. You, you know the rules better than they do. And so you're saying you've called me over because I know
the rules. You want to know the rule. The rule says you don't get relief. Right, yes, well, there was another gentleman that was. Just to interrupt you. So that one there where he wouldn't have got relief if he played towards the flag, but he got relief because he was chipping out once. He wouldn't have got. No, no, go ahead. Sorry. Well, he wouldn't have got relief if he was if he was trying to say that he could hit his shot towards the flag because in reality it was in the
Bush and there was no way a club was going to get through that in that direction towards the hole. So he that was unreasonable, had that little animal hole not been there, he would not have hit that shot towards the flag or the hole of the green. He would have had to make another plan. And he apparently knew that or just logically didn't try to take advantage. So he he was not trying to take advantage, he was being sincere. OK, OK.
And then, and then, so then he said he was going to chip out and then he didn't have an defense. Correct right, right right He didn't he didn't have interference from that animal hole and he also was fine to you know he was far enough from the Bush that way to where you know there might have been 1 little branch that could have been in the way but it wasn't and he was able to hit punch it out He. Just took his medicine. Yeah. Good. And any others? Did you have any others? Plenty. Probably, yeah. There was 1 gentleman who oh
gosh, I was, I was on a just perched above a green and also watching tee shots just past that. So the tee, the green was, you know, feet, right, super close or green to tea was super close. And so I'm in kind of kind of dealing with two things at once, which I love because that's one of the reasons I didn't really want to officiate is I don't want to watch grass grow. I mean, like, I like to be busy and it looked a little on the boring side. And if you're not ranked up here in the rules official world, it
can be kind of boring because you're really more of a time keeper as you and all of your audience that are rules officials know. So I get bored very easily. So anyway, at that point I've I has multitasking, which was great. So I'm watching these guys come up and several of them are hitting their ball over the green and this one in particular hit it into some very thick rough over the green. And when he went to make a really what could have been perfect flop shot, he hit his
ball twice accidentally. So I didn't, I was watching, I didn't necessarily notice that. But he said to the other player, oh, I just hit it twice. And the other player goes, don't tell me, tell her he saw me. And so I waited and, and I said, oh, we could talk about it when you're done, go ahead and play. And so then he, he finished out the whole hold out. And he said, oh, yeah, I, I hit it twice. I said, well, did you intend to do that or how did that go?
And he's like, oh, no, it was just an accident. I said, OK, I said, well, there's a change that you might not know about, but in 2019 it's no longer a penalty if you accidentally double hit your ball, so you're good to go. It's like, really, Really. I didn't know that. I said yes, isn't that great? See, those are the, you know, those are the good ones. Those are the ones where it's positive and they go, thank you so much for being here. And you know, you've saved me a shot because I was going to add a shot on because I didn't read the rules from 2019. So, you know, you don't get those very often, you know,
because most of the time they call you over when they're in a crappy shot or crappy spot after a crappy shot. So most of the time you're either denying them in the bushes or they somehow find a rabbit hole or whatever. But this one, when they thought they were going to get penalized, you've said, I mean, it was a, it was obviously a terrible shot in itself. But yeah. And those are the nice ones. So I'm glad you got. Yeah, And I was happy. And I, I, you know, I'm trying
to smile. I mean, sometimes people look at me and they think I'm somebody's wife and I'm just a volunteer. And they're like, oh, ha, ha ha. Did you see where my ball went or something? And and then, you know, it's, they don't know, you know, the thing says rules on it, but, you know, they're just assuming and that's OK. But I'm happy, yeah, to to give them some some good news. The other thing that that I learned that was interesting and I know I've talked to you about it and I've talked to my friend Jimmy about it, SCGA rules official who's been another
mentor to me for many, many years, is that you know that when does that clock start? When the player begins searching for their ball, that three minute clock. And, and what's my role as a rules official who's spotting right now to help players find their balls? And what I found was that, you know, they're teeing off from such a great distance. I don't necessarily notice the guy with the white shirt versus the tan shirt, you know, whatever whose ball it is that went over into this desert, you know, bushy area versus this one.
So I thought, gosh, I need to make sure that I'm starting the clock at the right time. So I said, are are you the player or are you the caddy? As the people start walking towards me, walking to this area where I'm about ready to start. And sometimes they're like, Oh, no, that I'm, I'm just helping him and or they go, it's his ball or because I, I need to know who's there Is the is, is, do you have a caddy? Because not everyone did, but some OK, if your caddy's here, I
start my clock. If you're here, I start my clock. If it's just the other fellow competitors, I don't start my clock. So I, I, you know, I needed to know that. So that was one thing that I decided to do that was helpful. And you know, is that how you would do it as well? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I actually that gave me a great question in my head that I think I'm going to use for the GRQOTW. Yeah, absolutely. You know the whole searching for
the ball, obviously it's the caddy. You know in the tournaments that we officiate, not just me now we officiate most of the time the player will have a caddy, whereas club land, they won't have a caddy. And so the. The high end, the high end clubs like La Hantan, when you came and stayed with me for 2 1/2 weeks and wouldn't leave and drank me and ate me at a house and a home. Yeah, we have caddies there. So yes, that is true. That is true.
That's such a .05% of the population that. I Yes, yes. That's not the club land that I speak about although, right, Although their rules knowledge isn't that great either. So you know, those caddies should jump on golf dot AI, but you know, most of the time club land 99% they don't have caddies. And so then it's just, you know, it's just the player that is starting the search or a partner if they're playing in a four
ball. But let's just keep it simple. Most of the time it's just the player. So you know, you know the player if you're watching and you other time you know, and then you start the clock. But other times, you know, I've gone into situations where I'm just watching another hole and then over there I look and there's a group of people just starting the search. And the first thing I'll do is I'll grab my clock timer, stopwatch, phone and click search time. All right, I'll start it and then I'll get over there and
then we'll, we'll look and it's kind of awkward, you know, because no one wants to lose a ball. So they're all a little bit on edge and whatnot. But you know, I'll say to someone, whose ball is it? I'll just go, whose ball are we looking for? I'll try and ask a caddy and hopefully it's not the caddy that it's the caddy of the thing. And I'll just that they're afraid to tell me whose ball we search for. Oh, that guy. And then also the second question will be, did he play a provisional? Yes. No. And then if it's a no, I'll be like, OK, I'll get ready to drive him back.
If it's a yes, Do we know where the provisional ball is? Yeah, it's in the middle of the field. OK, great. And then I'll ask them how long do you reckon we've been searching for? And one of them, hopefully one of them go, oh, Steve, you had a clock on. You put the clock on. Like one of the caddies put the clock on and Yep, we've got a minute 50. And then I'll look at my clock and it's like 40 seconds of like, OK, they were searching for a minute before I got there, blah, blah, blah. Or someone might say, oh, no, maybe about two minutes.
And then I'll look at my clock and it says 2 minutes 20. I'll be like, OK, well, it's at least 2 minutes, thirty, you know? So because, you know, they were searching before I got, I started the clock. So then I'll just go, OK, we've got 30 seconds left and, you know, that's the best estimate that we can do. We couldn't be absolutely accurate because I didn't know when they started and they didn't keep a time on it. So yeah, just those little questions. It's especially for say a new referee, you know, this is what
how I was experiencing it when I was starting to, you know, do these tournaments is you don't really want to talk to the player. You don't, you know, it's kind of awkward because they're just about to lose their ball possibly and couple one shot penalty or even if they don't lose the ball, they're in a horrible location. So, you know, and so you don't want to just go in there and say, give me all this information. It's like we sort of be quiet and just try and search for this
golf ball. But over time you realize, you know, you need this information to do your job and all the other players. This is this is one of the funniest things that you start experiencing. All the other players want you to do your job, but they won't say anything. So they want to know that it's, they're only searching for three minutes.
They want to know, you know that you're going to, you're getting ready to take them back or whatever. You know, all those little things. They, they want you to do your job, but they won't. But then at the same time, they'll sometimes they'll defend the player even though in their mind they're like, like I had one where, you know, they were, we were talking about whether it crossed, so whether it crossed a bank in a red penalty area and
jump back in. And the, the player was like, Oh yeah. And was sort of a bit not sure. And I, so I asked the other person, the other fellow competitor, we don't call them another player in the group. And the other player in the group was like, oh, I'm not sure. I'm not sure. I was like, OK, you know, you're both not sure. We don't have at least 95%, you know, 95%, it's in there, but we don't have at least 95%. It's crossed.
So we have to go back down the fairway and made that decision. Driving back down there, drops, hits. And then I drive back and I say, yeah, we just had to, you know, to the fella, another player in the group, he goes, Oh, yeah, definitely didn't cross. And I'm like, well, why didn't you stand up and say that when I didn't know This is in my head, but I was like, well, why don't you back me up when we were going through this conversation? But they sort of, they don't want, because they've got to play with them for another two hours or 2 1/2 or 4 hours. They don't want to sort of have
this confrontation because then, you know, when you're out there and there's a bit of confrontation or tension amongst the group, it can really affect that player and how they play. And they just want to focus on their own game and hope. And everyone, you know, sticks to themselves and know everyone plays by the rules. So that's why they want the referee to get involved and do the hard bits, you know, have the confrontational thing. And that's why when you become a referee, a lot of that is there and like there is that
confrontation because you're doing the job for the rest of the field basically. And if you don't like that it's even in golf, even we talk about, you know, it's a gentleman's game or it's a gentlewoman's game, even in golf that is there. And that's what you're getting paid to do. If you are getting paid, hopefully that's that's what we're there doing it. You know, that's the whole timing thing as well. Like, yeah, the, the slow players, they don't want you to
time them, but they want you to time the other slow players, right? Right. So, well, they want you to do your job so that they people stay out of their way and don't slow them down, but they don't care about slowing other people down. Otherwise, if they did care, if they were aware and they did care, they wouldn't do it. Or unless they're absolute wankers. Yeah, well, you know, knowing me as well as you know me, do you think I'm someone who shies away
from confrontation? No. No. So I'm in the right. I'm in the right place. You are. You are, so you should get more into it, I mean. I don't, yeah, I don't have a problem calmly because I'm super calm, right? I don't have a problem calmly giving them the information and telling them, as you said, the rules don't allow you to do this or the rules require that you're going to come back and do this, you know, So I don't have a
problem doing that. I think I was nervous about these two, particularly the US Open qualifiers, because I want to, I want to blend in with the other officials. I didn't want to be more, I don't know, more eager or I just I want to do everything right. And when when a rules sort of potential violation comes up, I want to be able to and I am comfortable walking up and saying here's the scoop.
But we have a policy and you may be familiar with it. I don't know what it is on the tours that you officiate, but it is anything 2 stroke penalty or more, you know, call it in on the radio. And one of the ways I've learned the most from, it's not about learning the rules while I'm there because I have that knowledge, but learning the procedures for the rules officials for situations that come up. One of the things that's helped with that is listening in the radio, you know, just hearing
what's going on now one of the groups I officiate with one of the guys is just super funny and just makes funny comments all day and breeze commenting and and that's, you know, it's fun. But you know, in addition to that, you're hearing what someone's asking. The scenario is is popping up for someone and you're hearing someone else sort of above that person. Official. Yeah, it's that's correct. It's a 2 stroke must da da da must go back and play again the whatever it is.
And I think that hearing those in real time we're very good. Now, one came up, and I don't know if I told you about this, but this was at a junior event and the kids were allowed to have caddies as long as the caddy was not a parent or guardian. They could have any other caddy they wanted. And a player, a young girl had a caddy and at some point it was determined, I believe it was seven holes in, it was determined that the person that
was her caddy was actually her parent. And so it kind of came up in the conversation and then it was, you know, is this one of those rules that we know it's a, a, a 2 stroke penalty, but is, is there a maximum on two holes? So would her maximum penalty have been 4 strokes or is it limitless? And so there was a lot of conversation going on about that in the radio. And I just found that fascinating because I would have
not encountered that any other place listening to your podcast or in any other way, right? So those real life scenarios and not just the fact that, yes, it was limitless, how many strokes, you know, penalty strokes you're going to incur for that, but also how they have that conversation with her and how that plays out, you know, kind of fascinating really, but also heartbreaking because we're talking about a junior player. So, yeah, so that's one of the reasons I'm I'm, you know,
stepped up and finally did it, even though I didn't want it to be super hot out. I didn't want it to be raining. I didn't want to get up at 4:30 to get on the course by 6. I mean, those are all the reasons I didn't want to officiate originally years ago when they asked me to start getting involved. But it's worth it for the experience I'm getting and that different perspective because it's going to make me a better rules educator to have that perspective that not everyone in clubland needs to know some of
these things. But it still helps me to better understand the mindset of the player and how how those procedures go, what the results are and how we walk through and and and and handle things when when things aren't perfect. Yeah, yeah, the, that's a great way the perspective of yeah, the, the different, it's not a different application of the rules, but it's a different way of applying the rules.
I don't think that makes sense, but you know, because if you're not a player, you're not another player in the group, you are a referee. You're there to just tell the rules. You don't have a slice of pie in the game. As in you know, you won't be coming second or first or third or last. You are just there to help the others out. And it's an interesting sort of look at it too, because you know, the high you up you get doesn't mean that they know more
rules or they have done more study. They might have had such more situations sometimes, but usually those players are so good that, you know they're more in the fairway. So they have less situations, but then they have access to higher rules, officials, etcetera, etcetera. I mean, I know that some players know the difficult questions, the difficult situations better than the easy ones because they're in those difficult ones and they remember them. You know, where's the, the
simple ones? They sort of get tricked, tripped up many times. But you know, where's up that sort of higher level you, there's a little bit of an unwritten rule that you don't approach the player and you wait for the player to call you over. Whereas down in the lower levels, you know, you're trying to save people or you're trying to help them out or you're trying to help the rest of the field out and you kind of need to get involved as a referee.
And then the person goes away and goes, wow, I didn't know that. Whereas in the amateur game, there's not so much money on the line, whereas in the pro game there's money. There's videos watching. So later on the committee just goes, oh, you did something wrong there. Two shot penalty, $50,000 off, blah, blah, blah. Where's the amateur game? It doesn't kind of work like that. And it's better that we go into those competition tournaments and educate, get involved, not overly get involved, but just
for blatant ones, get involved and say, hey, did you know it's this, this, this. And then they'll go, oh, no, I didn't, thank you very much. And then they can teach someone going forward. Well, and, and then if we're going to, you know, if, for example, a player during search, during this one particular hole, as I was mentioning in the desert, where there's so many balls going right or left, and there could be two players in a foursome that were, you know, had lost a ball or potentially lost a ball. And so one player was walking up to a ball near a Bush and just
goes right down to pick it, you know, without putting a mark, it just and I go what it and it was too late. And he picked it up and looks at it and he puts it down. I said, is that your ball? And he said, no, it wasn't mine. I said, well, that's I said, well, that's good because you must put a mark down before you lift the ball to identify it. I said, if that were your ball, that would have been a one stroke penalty. Just good for you to know. And he's like, really? And you know, these guys are
competing to, to get into a spot at the US, sorry, at the, yeah, the US Open. So they, they should know that. But, you know, so I did my, I did my best to stop it, but it, you know, it was too late. And luckily it wasn't. His ball educated him for next time and hopefully he'll educate some one as well. Yes. Now I have a GRQOTW that I thought of just during our conversation. So OK, so this is the GRQO
TW140A player has a caddy and they play four holes and then they get into a bit of an argument and the player sacks the caddy. And so now the player has to carry their own bag and but the caddy for some reason sort of stays nearby for a couple of holes. And on the 6th hole, the player hits it in the bunda and they we
all sort of go around over have a look and the caddy, the ex caddy gets there first and starts looking. And then about 45 seconds later the player gets there. And then the ball is found at 2 minutes and 45 seconds from once the player arrived. So that was about 3 minutes. You can do the math 3 minutes thirty after the ex caddie gets
there. So it has that ball been found in the time or is the ball lost? That's my GIQO TW140. That's a good one. And I'm not allowed to give you my answer because it'll ruin it for everybody else. So I won't stay. You can. Tell me the answer and I'll I'll put it on. I will. I will.
I don't know. I can't hear you anymore. There we go, say it again. Thank you very much, Marcella, for coming on the podcast once again. It's always great to have you on and it was fantastic that you've got this new experience of actually officiating. So just one question, are you going to do me anymore? Yes, I am I I am going to pick them and choose them carefully
based on weather, what time, what. Time is the first tee time. The the first tee time location, weather and the food because I had some really good food at the Grand Del Mar and Ironwood. It was wonderful salmon salad. You know, so I'll, I'll, I'll make my selections carefully, but yes, I will continue into next year and I'm excited about it and just really love being around the extreme professionals at the SCGA and want to definitely continue that I'll.
Tell you one thing that you have to do is you have to become an assigned referee for a match. That is cool. Or I mean, you could be a walking referee with a stroke play group. I'm not sure if you've got any torments that you know of that they do organize that, but that would be great. But if you can be in a signed referee for a match, that's heaps of fun. Just just walking with groups is is way better than roving as well. Yes, so I'm going.
My friend, a female referee is going to be officiating the USAM at the Olympic Club. And so I'm going to be with her. I'm going to be near her. I'm not with her, I'm not inside the ropes. But I will be following her for the last three days because I want to. I'm going to be jotting down notes and things because I want to talk to her about that. She will be assigned to matches and I, I, I can think of nothing better I would love than to
literally be assigned to a match in that way and walk with the player. So I'm really looking forward to that and I'm thankful that she's going to spend some time with me and, and give me some, some help and, and just educate me on some of the scenarios that came up and, and why things went the way they did. So I'm really, I've been to one USM before, which is at Pebble Beach, which was unbelievable when Hovlin took it from Devon Bling. And I just loved every minute of it. So I'm really looking for that's, that's pure golf.
And any of your listeners who are going to be at the US Ammo Olympic, please send me a note. I'd love to to hear from you and love to see you and connect with you so. That that's awesome. Yeah. One thing about that, like when you when you work with another referee, because I was going to say you could be an observer, but most times the observer goes forward and is near the tee shots or near the grain for the second shot. So then near the tee shots again.
So you don't really spend that much time with the actual referee, but if you can actually just walk nearby and just don't distract her. But just, you know, there are times, there are a lot of times in golf when, you know, you got this down time when you're walking. Yeah. And just pick the brain and just see what's happening. And, you know, I'm sure she'll have a couple of who's away. That's usually the most common one for match play. But yeah, that's a that should be a great experience. Well done on jumping up putting.
Your hand up. She, she's another mentor and the fact that she's female is fantastic. And I just want more women to find positions and jobs and passions here in the world of golf. And so anything that she and I can do to help forward, that is super important to us. Yeah, well if anyone has is going to the Olympic Club, great. Or if anyone has any referee roles for Marcellus, shout out she. Can only after 9:00 AM. Temperature between 65 and 90°. What else?
Good food. I think, I think you'd be suited for Liv. That's what I think you'd be suited for. All right, I'll go. It's. It's fantastic to talk to you, get you on the podcast again. So thank you very much, Marcel, for joining us. Thanks Blakey, always wonderful to be with you.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...
GUEST: Elisa Hermes, an update about recent US OPEN qualifying tournaments and Rules worshops that Elisa has been running, we also discuss golf as an outdoor spot - THE GRQ PODCAST EP138 GRQ137 - David hits his tee shot...