THE GRQ PODCAST EP67 CLUBLAND STORIES Co-hosts: Stuart McPhee and Blakey Stuart provides the answer to GRQOTW66, making sure to clarify the difference between two club-lengths and taking a lateral drop from a yellow penalty area. Then we speak about interesting clubland stories, including: foursomes and fourball situations, ball interfering with another ball, and what constitutes a mark, practicing during play of a hole, who is responsible for the handicap. GRQOTW for #67 - Playing in a foursomes stroke event at Wombat Hills, Andy the Average Golfer and Big P are partners. On the 2nd hole, Andy the Average Golfer tees it up, tees off however hits the ball OB - while they are working out what to do next, they realise that Andy the Average Golfer has played from the teeing area of another hole, ie the wrong teeing area - who plays the next shot, from where and what stroke number will it be? Make sure to add your answer to the YouTube video: https://youtu.be/xh7RVKPpxqA
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode and Opals questions podcast.
Hi everyone, episode 67 and the golf pros podcast coming to you recorded, not live with myself Blakey and Stewart. McPhee alongside me as you have been for the last. Let's say almost 15 min, my sidekick co-host for the last 15 and row. Almost Thanks. Yeah. But I feel quite indifferent about being here. So, thanks for having me.
Well, fantastic, you be you playing golf tomorrow. We always say that. I just say it's great to be here. So I thought I'd just throw in something different. Yeah. Well, we did say, we did mention there last week and you have gone to the effort of changing up this week, which I don't worry. It wasn't lost on me. Okay? But yeah, so you're playing golf tomorrow. I will be playing golf tomorrow with a former Club. And a former Club Captain who I think I've only played with once before. Yes. Playing golf tomorrow.
Where'd you shoot on Saturday? 33, I think 33 points. It's my son. Yeah, sorry, it's funny. You know, most parts of the world apart from the state. If someone said, I'll let you shoot you go r79, 8095 off the stick in Australia. It's just stale food points. It's just, what are your point? You know why did you shoot their
you points? I had a dog of day 24 points. Yeah. One the comp 40 points it's not did not did not know how to ask anyone. Although I say if it's a they say, even if it was like, it was pie, I guess that shit LED say Plus 1 or minus 1. Also you know if it was straight round we got that's him. That's right. But at the same time, gets converted back to stay. Open net. All net. So you can always still say you
stay with the points. Maybe it's the case that stay off. It is 95% of the competitions and the Empire and stroker a 5%, and it is a universal measure of how well you played bass on. Yes, right. And it's not like to it if I said no. Five people go. Oh, that's great. You broke 100. I'm like, yeah, I'm awesome. I'm awesome. Five anymore. I'm not plus 3 if you say, I said 76. Yeah, that's really good. You're like not on +3. Yeah, exactly, right. I was pretty young, pretty
disappointed on this thing. I miss the cap. How so anyway, so they had 35 points with a 33, I had on satellite 33 33 points with a He's setting me up here. He will not tell you thank you very much. Thank you. I have my identical. Yeah my third Eagle in just under two years. Yes. Wow, it's pretty exciting
powerful. Yeah. Trying out a new club drove the green and one putted? Mmm. That'd be great, even in these wet conditions. Yeah, that's pretty good. All the way. You want to do that every six months and I have a good shot at. Do you get paid out for the Eagles? I reckon you do. Hear you automatically, get onto the results, shooting again, some prize of some monetary value with. We're supposed to have an eagle's nest at Spring Valley and we haven't had it the whole time that I've been there. The supposed to be bringing it
back in, but all those people, they've had a whole one had a legal or missed out so I'm for. So we do have an eagle's nest but it's restricted to only two holes In size, got an eagle at the 9th and the 18th. I think it is. So you must get an eagle on one of those holes to actually score the nest, and they'd like the two hardest part falls on the club cause no nines, not sorry nines on overly difficult syndics. 788 a bit harder index for I think 33 both par fours.
Yeah, right. We're gonna get get into it. Thank you. I mean, well done for your Eagle. Thank you and thanks for bringing it up. I was pretty happy. So GI Q 0, TW 466. What is the answer? Go ahead Stewart. So this was if you remember, big p hits into a yellow penalty area but he can't play from where it lies so he decides to pay take penalty area relief. You measures out two Club lengths from the estimated point of entry into the penalty area to take collateral relief. However he doesn't use any teas or any other objects to Mark out
the bounds of that relief area. And then he drops a ball correctly within the relief area ball comes to rest within the really fairy plays is next stroke. Including the one penalty stroke for taking penalty area relief, how many penalty Strokes must big p. Add to his whole school and I do remember at the time you sought clarification on, you know, we're trying to sort of draw the picture of exactly where he did drop, but of course, the key word in the question, obviously, a picture would be much better. The keyword in the question was lateral, and we know and the idea being that he was in a yellow penalty area, and he's
taken lateral relief, which we know is not one of your options under yellow penalty area. So the red herring I guess was that you that he didn't use any teas or similar objects to Market a relief area. Do you need to use anything to Mark out a relief area of like you know you don't if you're taking the drop you don't have to mark out anything and then you but it's up to you like it. If I always give this advice, if you're dropping on the extremity of the two Club lengths or
extremity of the one Club length, whichever it is then it's always good idea to Market out. If you're dropping as near as possible to that sort of nearest point of my life and you don't really need to Mark anything but the nearest point of relief just as a reference point you know that's it that's good card if you're marking on the end so you're going to drop on the extremities and there's a chance it'll just roll out just indicate that with the tea or some similar object anyway. So came to rest in a relief area, the problem was that he chose an incorrect relief area
and I would argue or suggest that is actually played from a Wrong place, because he took relief laterally, when under yellow penalty, or you only have two options, and that's previous Place, played, and back on the line. So that would be two strokes on top of the one for taking penalty area relief. Good, not a serious, break the wrong place. Play sounds pretty good, and sorry for the lack of clarity on drawing that picture. Hopefully the word lateral was enough of people don't realize and laterally and yellow shouldn't have been the same
since. Yeah. It should not be in the same sentence that is But, you know, with the back on the line, if you just say within two Club lengths, well, it could still be within 2 x 1 x. It could still be back online. It is also within the to club links, so that's why it was just good to get some, of course, some clarity there. Right. So this episode episode 67. I know that you've got a few tucked away that you've been wanting to talk about clubland
stories. So this will be the big clubland episode. I've actually got a couple just to make sure that you get a breath in, but she always shoot away with your first clubland story will do and we just full transparency or full disclosure. I even run any of these by you before. There's a choice spoken right now. So, Some of these going to be able if, you know, out of nowhere but just really, really odd. But the first story, the first clubland story is in the last week or two, we played quite a
few Ambrose events scramble event. So a team of four, you know, choose the best spot Market lift, and in all four players need to place a ball within one Club length. No nearer. The whole similar conditions to that point to that spot. Chosen to take, you know their next shots to then, you know, No, continue that process. We all know what a scramble and Ambrose's. But what I saw amongst my team on more than one occasion by two players was the manner in which they placed the ball. So we know that under 14.2,
there's only one way in which you place the ball and that is to set it down on the spot and let go of it and it should, you know, stay at rest on that spot. And I, what I found with two players is on more than one occasion. In both in the general area and on the putting green was they dropped the ball on the ground? No proper relief, not sort of dropping from knee-high, just threw it on the ground and then would maneuver the ball into the correct spot. But they wanted using their Club whether it be an iron, or
whether it be their putter on the putting green. And I said that to them afterwards and of course, neither of these two players would do that. If it was an individual round individual stroke around but they did it. When the rules are quite clear about saying, place a ball within one Club length, no nearer, the whole similar conditions, and I believe, there's only one way in which you can place a ball. Yeah, that's right. And they even said this even interpretation. We might have even done a
community question for that one. So yeah, no, no getting past a penalty there. But obviously it's Ambrose and clearly the fact that you don't have a marker is a breach of the rules and Ambrose. I've actually as you know I've actually written a A few pointers on if you are running an Ambrose event as the committee, what you could think
about in terms of modifying the rules of golf, obviously you're not allowed to modify the rules of golf in a singles event for wall foursomes, but we all know that and Ambrose is a novelty event and these are some of the other things to think about. You know, whether you do drop it or whether your place, it whether you allow Bob, link to Club head to foot whatever.
So yeah, go and have a look at those type of things but there's there's plenty of little things that yeah, it happens. Dear loud. Tapping in the, in the Ambrose. You don't think of played certainly at my previous Club, this one on golf trips. I think it's the tapping is allowed but if that person misses your then committed to making your neck stroke from that spot. Yeah, service person misses the tap. And if I miss it, well, you've already been committed to making an extract from that spot unless it was it.
Yeah, right, I, yeah, okay, that's fair. I think I've put in, imagine this scenario. You have 24 putt for birdie player. One leaves a ball foot short on the line and Splunk fumbling around for a coin to spot the ball. After this play, early to leaves their ball, six inches short, and is fumbling around for the coin, the spot. The ball. Now, player, 3 has a Minefield apart through. Committee can adopt a local World announced happens to be cleaned up even if a lower score can be achieved. Yeah, but I might add that in.
That's a, that's a good one. So It says here whilst the argument might be the different people have different ideas of what happen is that the committee can easily specify this by stating within a handstand or carbon core with them. Hot links the Pilar if they really want to. I mean you just people know what it's happening. Is it's it's an unmissable, perfect, various, it can be missed but it's basically now we know that we know the club here. Sorry. The hand Spain or something. Someone might be within 30 centimeters of foot and go y'all just finishes off.
Yes, and just misses him and massage and it's true for me, it's by Supply absolutely High Supply. And to be honest, I don't mind that you've got this insurance. I hear you're your idea of if you miss, it's bad. Like, I mean, you move on from the birdie but I don't mind that idea that you've got this guarantee or this insurance that you've already got a par and then everybody likes for ya and ever run as long as as long as everyone is playing the same game. I mean, it's not exactly right.
Uh, so that was Ambrose and you gave them a little talking to which I did have to add. I eat. So there's the next one's about the same group. Only one instance of this particular bridge but I said to him afterwards I said you know, I noticed a few things today and they know I know the rules and you know we've had this discussion before the last thing you want to be doing is all around going you know all throughout your round or four hours going you can't do that. You're going to do that that's wrong you don't want to be that person. No. A really really wrong and they
clearly gaining an advantage or not applying a penalty when they should, then you definitely say something. But when they, I thought that was a there's no list of what's significant infraction and what's a minor and all those sorts of things. But I think that that falls under the category of, okay, they didn't actually place it correctly on the 14.2, but they put it within an area within the relief area. We got a relief area, but within the area that supposed to hit from, I mean, I would even oh, it even as a committee, I might even write that down on my
thing, I haven't got a deal. I'm already is to say, you can roll the ball into a spot with your club, right? So that's a modification when playing under Ambrose. Yeah. As long as it's within that. Yeah, I can probably. So I probably saw it more on the green. Yeah, there's just a smoother service. I threw it down, roll the jealousy, the ball marker, stopped it, and then took their part. Yeah, no, you don't do that, but I saw it plenty of times. Yeah. So what was the what was the next one? Well the second one in the same group and this is only one
instance. In fact, on the 18th hole, I took my drive only it was off the Fairway, but it was a bit further down than the next one we could have chosen. And just to give us Within Reach of the green and I was on a downslope. And the guy I think actually put his ball on the ground and I ask you, I'm gonna ask you a question about this. Put his ball on the ground stepped away. So they had a bit more of a look of his at his shot and then his ball rolled forward. It probably around 20 to 30 cm rolled forward without any
hesitation without any comment. He just leans down. Picks the ball up and puts it back to where he had originally placed it. And then hit his tee shot. So of course the question to you is how long, you know, he's put his ball down. It's now at rest and then it moves. What's the Gap? You know, how long does it need to be for that to have come down and natural forces or not? Having been placed at rest for me and there's nothing in the book about this.
It's just that whole idea of what does it mean to be at rest? But my opinion. Is two to three seconds. Yeah, so if it's been at rest for 2 to 3 seconds, then if it moves, if it's subsequently moves after that, then it was caused by something. Yeah, one of them is it as opposed to if it moved after one or two seconds? To me, that means it was never at rest.
It was never settled place that rest. Yeah, that's right. So I say to the three seconds. Now, I've heard you say that before, and I think that's pretty fair. Actually the, you know, it's like if you place the ball at rest and as you're moving your hand away from the ball and moves, even that was half a second. After you let go of it, it's still probably as you're saying it, probably was never actually at rest when you took your hand away. Exactly half a second. You know, and you're not even
allowed to push the ball in, but obviously, it was never settled. It was still effective, whatever it was, whatever it was, it was still moving. Where is it's at rest and then it suddenly caused or pushed it. And yeah, that is The new spot after that, unless you're on the green, this was definitely three to five seconds. Something like that. Like he had stood up again sort of having. And then we all saw it move and he's just realize it's a really quickly, just picked it up and put it back in and I spoke to
him afterwards about that. What does that the other guy greed? And sorry, another person in the group agreed? And, you know, I didn't even think about that. Yeah, this is a guy that's always a little bit flippant with the rules. You know, a regular group Death by far. I mean, you talk The club Captain is very good with the rules. Another guys plan to log it off and then this guy who's for, he just having to be him that you know he's Ball moving. He's picked it up and put it back. Yeah yeah.
Well I think he finds it funny to me. I've got some better ones though. From one or two, others who care less about the rules, they're coming up, they're coming up but maybe you've got one, right? I've got one from my great source, they are so So woman's foursome woman's foursome via a hits from the tee On a par three and hits it into the water and happy with her swing. She walks off the tee. Drops All Balls onto the ground
and plays four strokes to a spare green. 70 meters away. What is the result? What do you reckon? Let's say 15 meters, right? She's moved off to the side and Noida dirty shot. Yeah. Well, the other people still playing but they were still
playing. And she's just going over there and drop four balls and hit them onto another on the practice green. So you would have to think I'm going to rule six point, which one you need soft on me. Sixpoint, not six. So again, not sex. No, I won't be 6.6. No, I mean it's not 6 W 5, is it? Sorry. I thought was during the pie of a whole, but okay, five during
the round. Your hands. So you're lazy and needs to talk about when your plant between two holes. So they act like they're 5.5. So I'm going straight to 5.5. You have to see during round. Yeah. Practicing during round. So, no, practice strokes while playing a whole, but there are some exceptions there are times. You can actually hit a ball and they're not considered practice strokes. They include a practice swing mate with no intent to strike the ball, hitting a ball, back to a practice area or to another player. When done solely, As a courtesy
or strikes straight Strokes made by a player in playing at a whole whose result has been decided. So that's some of the exceptions that you can actually heat a bouldering pie of a holiday, not considered, practice strikes and one. In fact, one of my Club Lane stories is about just that, which we'll get to later, but that to me, just I go straight away to practicing during play of the whole Rodeo. So, let's see your penalty. So I I don't think, I don't think there was any intent for
those balls to be the ball in play. So, I don't think there was any intent for that play to go arrive. Just drop this on the course. I'm going to hit this is now a ball in play partner. We've played from, you know, I don't think that's, I don't think that was the intent of the player. Well, I think the question, would you hand down to then? Well, it's obviously the general penalty for breaching 5.5. But then it's a matter of how many I'm assuming. It's just one, One jeweled is awful.
Why do you think won? Only that Force too many for General panel, you know, for one for every instance, you know? I mean it's It's almost a noise should come back to the committee. It's almost a almost a conduct issue as well. I mean, it's just almost unacceptable to be doing there. I mean, that's a discussion we can have, you know, separately there. So she has no idea. So we're not going to give her some kind of code of conduct but yeah, it's nothing.
I would say, it was a related act, you know, it's awful, I would just get the two shot, she would just get the two-shot penalty. So, all Or if you hit three, you should hit five, it would still be related act, what linkage maybe warts are unless you maybe walk down, you know how to break walk in other two minutes with her partner and then did it again. You'd be inclined to think in a different area different area did it again? Maybe maybe just maybe or if her playing if a partner had hit a
shot. The partner has hit a shot, there would be an intervening act, someone's head, so I can relief or something. Someone said something that would be n into. There would have been intervening act. What, if a partner went down and took relief from the penalty area balls in play, now, in the relief area, and she did it again. I would think that would be a new act, a new bridge, because they're taking relief. Where is my related?
X 1 Point. We don't like to stroke is the obvious 11.3 see for interpretation. Making a straight. Yes. Oh the partner made a stroke becoming aware the brakes are someone tells it and then putting a ball in play. Let's try players balls on the tree breaks. Free bonuses. Improving conditions. Sochi. Then prove it earlier.
It was an issue. Yeah, I guess, I guess the, the taking relief, Imagine. But you've a partner rain down, dropped a ball, and she don't need the third one, they need a fourth. That's right, you could get three then I think that's a separate two separate page, three separate, right? Because their Partners taken relief, could make it. Then she said in a practice shot and say, yeah, that was My son acceptable, that good.
That good stories in public. So I would have to think just running through the numbers. So they fit one from the Teen area to start play the whole its stroke. One, should they take relief from the penalty area? That's their second shot and play. Abby would play the third shot from the relief area, but they've got to add the general penalty. So, now they lying, five. Yeah, that's it five year. That's right. And play, Abby would have to get the ball from the relief area, from the penalty area, not the persons, having off. Sorry the person Play is busy having some factors in play a has to go again.
You begin their six-shot, right. So that was my first clubland. Your turn again, that's really go. I've only got two, you've got a few. That is a rip apart. Well, this one's a republic. Never seen anyone do this before in my life. This was individual stroke play. This is on the 15th hole, greenside bunker, two balls. Really quite close to each other and I mean, like hand span closed and I could hear them discussing. As I walk past with my buggy and I could hear them barking my lipstick and Eye Lift It. Bubba. And I just turned around said, guys whoever's first apply if they think the other balls in
their way you're allowed to Market and lift it. That's fine. Just lift it for interference. I didn't say, you can't clean it. That's not related to the story, but I did say, yeah. If it's in your way, you just supplier to lift, and sorry, to Market and lift it. So they decided to do that. However, how did they mark it? Well, how is it easy question for you, how you supposed to Market before you lift that ball out of the bunker? Meditate something wrong, an artificial object. T is no longer is this going to,
okay? Keep going or do know what a tea is very common. This is even a ball marker. Just something artificial you know, something small to Mark the spot where that ball has been lifted from. So the person didn't put an artificial object in the person who was required of had been asked to Remove the bowl because of interference G, e--'s 56-degree wedge and Mike's a severe indentation into the sand twice to form an inverted V.
Where the point of the V is at the spot where is about to lift his ball. So it's Christmas 56-degree wedge. Do get into the bunker drawn. A line about 30 cm long about a foot long. Yeah, he's done it again to form a v. Yeah, of either, as I said, the point of the V is now where he's ball is, and And pixies ball up and moves out of the bunker. So, the first player can make his next stroke from the bunker. Okay. That's how we Mark the ball. Yeah. Well, that's the issue I've never seen that ever done before I'm happy with that.
Really. Yeah. Okay. I'm happy with that. Why is that? he's foot and Mark in the you know, to get his to reference with bullets and then would be able to have a good accurate idea of where the ball would go.
So, you could put it back. I concerned about touching the sand at all. Not really not in this sea, was doing it on purpose. I mean, you know, the tough thing is maybe someone can reach out to me and tell me I'm wrong. Previously, we did allow someone to put a footprint. Right beside their bill. Yeah, you know, and that could be used as a way to mark. I know, it does say, Artificial,
you need to use something out of issue, doesn't well, the word Mark is placing a ball marker right behind, all right. Next to the wall, holding a club on the ground right behind, but that's not doing that. Placing a ball marker, the ball Mark. And then it says, the bull market has to be something out of this issue typically. Yeah, I mean, you don't, you don't use a tea in Mark, you know, the surface of the could bring to Market ball, you need to use an artificial object, an artificial object. When used to This portable to be lifted such as a tea.
Coin object made to be a more ball marker or another small piece of equipment. He does it. Say before the firmest Mark the Spot, is it say that the market has to be left in place? For what does it maintain? Does it say that the marker? Has to be lift and place. Does it have to stay there? There's the artist so I still don't place it below. Market would mean to put it in
the place it. Yes. To Mark the Spot of the ball right behind, or right next to the ball. Yeah, I'm with your soda, but does it say that? Does it say that you have to leave the ball marker and stay in place? So then I'd go to 14.2 replacing the ball on the spot. because
well, an interesting one, you know I saw the face of the USDA Facebook the other day had that you could Mark your ball With your you couldn't Mark your ball with your hand, as you want it unless unless you are wearing a glove. Okay. Unfortunately checked. Ma'am. It's blew my mind. My sayings. You can use your shoes. You can use your foot but I definitely only if you're
wearing a sock or a shoe but I take your shoe off and put it in this trying to work out if so this person is Mark the Spot with two lines which would almost be the most accurate way you could mark. Where the ball is. I'm okay with it. But remarkable? You need to use an artificial object. He's used the club. Yeah, but he hasn't left it, it's very funny. Where's away today?
Where does it say that you have to leave it there? That's what I'm asking and I gotta tell, you know, I probably have never rule read. Oh, by the way, you do need to leave it there. Until you return to the spot. He's marked the spot. Do you agree that he's marked the spot? Yes. But has he marked the spot correctly. It's like dropping and dropping if I drop a ball, doesn't mean I've actually dropped it in accordance with the rules of golf. Mark to show the spot where the
ball is at Rest by either placing a ball marker right behind or right next to the ball or holding a club on the ground right behind her, right next to the ball. And what you are saying is, if okay, I've put the club there, I'd Mark the Spot, but I haven't left the club there. That's right. So you know how some of those ball markers have a little Start on it, or a little. It can create a hole in the ground, right?
Not, you know, it's not like a 20 cent coin, it's an actual former, it's got a little leaves us leaves of something, a mark on the ground that hole. Can actually help you identify where your, to replace your ball. Correct. Yep. And I'm happy with that. But are you had to do that? Yeah, it just says to place. It doesn't say that it doesn't actually specify. I must say though whatever conclusion. We draw. I've never seen that ever before. Well, I had to see this is the this is where I get to.
I've seen this happen but it was prior to 2019. So I just don't I've never asked the question of whether you can still do this. Use two lines that you've drawn with an artificial object as your am. I oh, we have to add that to the list of questions. I need to ask the owner I just like, where does it say where you need to leave the ball marker in place? I mean imagine golfer on the professional tour, marking the spot on the green, lifting their ball, and then 30 seconds later
going on mobile or markers waste of time. They'll just come pick it up. Well, that's only provided. He knows exactly what it replaces the job. Yeah. But I'll now I don't think the rules allow that night. It's probably the fact that we've never seen. That's true. I've never seen this. I means when you're working with a club, you need to hold a club on the ground and that's often you'll see that on the green with a putter. Just see if they want to rotate it. You know, they just really want to just rotate the ball for the
hood. Other to the spot. The word whole means to keep it there. Yeah. Them literally just hold the putter down for two or three seconds, while they just rotate the ball. Give it a quick, wipe replace it and then bring their powder off the ground. Where's the word place doesn't necessarily mean that you allowed to take. Get away. I stood there. Maybe you've removed it. With that is true. That is no. No, I'm with you. There you have definite as long as you have placed it. As long as you know this why you've moved everything away but you still put the ball back and
exactly the correct spot, right? And that's the key at the other day, we need to buy some spot. That's right. That's the absolute key. Are you going to get penalized? Hmm, I just want, I just want to know if I'm happy for someone to say place means it needs to stay there until you move. Your Born. In which case, I would say, that the two Lines drawn in the bunker would be a brute. I certainly on the spot. Gave him that impression.
Which is fine. I don't think I always try to lean on the. You can't do it before you can do it, because then, then you're not going to get penalized if you actually. Can't. I can't do it. And because you haven't done it and you're not going to get penalized if you can do it, because you haven't done. So then they have the most important thing was the guys smash, that lie.
As the other person, recreated the lie in the side. This stage I'd walked away while standing on the other side of the Green. Let's imagine, then most fun part. No, it wasn't. I didn't think about that. I just thought I said guys you know it's said I don't think it's supposed to Market like that the way you doing and the guy goes, oh, it's but I thought you suppose you'll have to touch the sand. Now, what's the right there are reasons why you are allowed to touch the sand? I gave you old strike in the sand and anger or leaning on it while you're waiting or you. Mumbling and balance and all that sort of stuff.
And I said, there are you, you are there's a little bit more freedom in doing that now, but I've just never, I just don't think you need to put an object down or I can't remember what I said but I didn't see the splash out shot and what damage that caused the other person's life. But I'd walked away that point. Yeah, fair enough. Um, and that's fair though, that's probably the most interesting from a rules perspective is what potentially might happen to that belie. The other ball that's been lifted for interference. That's the most important part. Hmm. Most important. Part is that it gets recreated, it's not a suit. Most similar lie.
It's a it's a recreation. All right. Yet next week's one from you. This is a doozy. So we said the lasses of this? No I think it was. This one's even better. This is in a full ball, better wall or baseball and run the third hole, Par 3 and my partner playing off 20 plus puts his tee shot. 20 meters in front into the water and just and doesn't put another one in play. Just put the ball in the pocket. That's it.
He's now walking. All and on just pin-high, just off to the right chip on 42. I have a better 5 m putt for par, don't get a shot. So 4342 he's out of the hole, right? So I'll meet for the team and he says, I said, I've got this for a three and he goes. So, can I have a practice pup? I said, well, technically, if you're out of the hole, the result of your hole has been decided shot. You make as long as you're not, you know, holding up the field and everything is technically
not a practice stroke. Technically technically, there's no breach. So he puts his ball right next to mine on the ground now, and he says, I'll put this first. I said, no, no, no, you can't, no, no, you can't do that. Pick it up and this guy could not care. Less, right? He's one of those. Just could not care less. He's out there just to enjoy himself almost It's duster and the other guy from the other team. Who's our marker said you can't. I don't think you can do that, was it? He definitely can't do that. And not now nothing. I was going to say would have had him.
Pick it up nothing. No way. He was going to pick that ball up so I simply turned around and face the other direction and I didn't watch him part and so I could hear him putt. So he putted left it, a foot short of then turned around after the ball. Will come to rest and go On Riders, my turn to play. So I thought this through up a few interesting rulings regarding as testing the green, a breach, helping your partner in for ball, you know, under 23, under rule 23, and then me
having that penalty as well. Yeah. So I thought I'd again, I've never seen this but this guy's, that sort of guy who would do something like that. I think I did my best to turn around and actually not watch the part. I was facing in the opposite direction deliberately. Yeah, well, knowing it was wrong, it has to be the breach happens. I mean, it helps right 23.8. So if it didn't help you because you completely ignored it. Okay?
Okay. Let's think about how could it help you if you weren't watching it? It was, what's that? That was the intent, wasn't it? There was no Dew on the ground, was it? No. So it was completely clear, dry, whatever? Correct. It's not just an O Lord. How was their ass? And I'm not no indication of where we call. We could the sound of the putt, could you analyze the sound of that good? Not that good.
Well, I mean, it does say, Play is great. Help Spartans Partners, apply it. I get the penalty needed. Help my play. That's the fact that I turned around and deliberately knowing the rule deliberately turned around and look the other way actually save me from having a breach. I believe it did. Yeah, believe it did like is if this person is allowed to practice Park, we know his intent is intent was very clear, that's right, but if he's
allowed the right next to my ball, to show me the line, if he's allowed to practice part, He is a lad as he only had practice Pop. I think he is, he's out his balls in his pocket. He's recording is 0 stable for points for that hole. So if he's a little practice part, The mean that's not a breach. So it's not examples of when players reach helped Partners playing. So the breach could have been. I mean, the reason why he was partying was to test the role, like he was rolling a ball on the road.
He was testing that and nobody you're allowed to test the the green if you're already out, right? So what they're saying is if you to right beside each other And he pops. You're allowed, you know and you're still both in the hole. He Pat's you allowed to watch, of course. Yeah, that's different. Cuz that's not a, he's not breaching a rule. No, and we know under, you know, was it, 6.4 order of play. We know, you can decide which way to go and all that stuff. It's okay. In this case he hasn't reached a
little but his breach would actually be in trying to help you. Who is still in the hole, which correct his intent was clear when he placed his ball next to mine. And if I had seen the whole it can't be a breach. If he doesn't help you which if you don't watch it can't. You can't be helped. It's how I see again. I've never seen that before. I've never seen someone go. Oh, you know what? Give me a second. I'll just put my ball. Have a pup for you. I didn't even think I would play with it first neighbor again. He is he has a reputation.
What a decade. So I didn't watch I'm proud as I didn't watch what I did. Definitely didn't. I definitely do. Well, why is it? You know, we were having a chat the other day. That's very similar to the The advice-giving like obviously you can give advice in a full-bore for some, I get that but the whole spectator advice. And how you're supposed to go stock? Can you please stop? And if you don't actually Place, safely stopped being your
tacitly approving it and you would get the penalty. But in this case, it turned around which is your action of trying to stop being helped. Well, that's a that's a yeah. That is a do fit true things. I've never seen before the one that identities 56-degree wedge Into the Bunker and carving out these massive lines and then a four ball partner out of the hole goes, you know what? I'll help you. I'll just put a ball on the green number pop up for you and show you the line. Maybe it's ingenious.
Maybe it's just smart. Maybe it's trying to trying to help but to hear. That's right. My turn. Mixed forces of evil forces. I'm going for some question. The end maybe tees off on a par three hits it out of bounds. Man steps up and hits from the men's tee. Is this correct or should be, or should he be hitting the third shot from where the lady has
hit? Don't dance they. Yeah, man is then told by another competitor that the shop should have been taken from the ladies tee. So man, then hits shot from the ladies in correction onto the Green in whole precedes with two putts into the hole. How many shots has that lady and that man scored foursome next foursome on that hole. A few more than I would like.
Yes. Is it is it almost a double? And I'm in double digits, is it almost a high so I didn't count on. So it's a one off the tee went out of bounds through out of bounds hitting the third, man hits from male tea. Yep. Which will say wasn't close. So, that's a third shot, okay. And I would argue you need to add maybe two more on top of that. Doesn't matter where that ball went As Told by another competitor.
That was wrong. So plays from Ladies tee. We say that person. Then put another put another ball into play from the ladies tee. Is that what they did? You could yeah and hit that ball onto the green. They're born to the ground into powder 3 part of it. Well, I need a Don't know what it is. I'm going to get a calculator. Three. Plus I reckon that's it. I reckon is double digits. Is it?
What is it? I think it's 10:00. I think you're spot on five shots. And fought penalty Chaucer. I didn't end up that way but that that makes the yeah, that sounds right. This is the lady shot was correct. The Man's first shot so provide it wasn't a serious breach and we'll assume probably wrong to assume. They will assume that the man's T is behind the razor, the behind. Yeah, so could be a serious breach, but 99.9% violets not going to be or as a committee.
I certainly wouldn't call Little serious, bro. So then that's so that balls in play. Measure of gone in the hole that would have been a good thing because it will save them about. Yeah, so three off the t plus 2 for the wrong place 5. He's done it all again wrong, place again. 82 Parts, 10. Yeah, have fun.
Some grits are all that really happened. We probably are this club and stories. Right. You're, You're gone. You've got a couple more. I think how they stack up, first ones a quick one. So the next one is a quick. One happened to me on Saturday. So Iraq up at the 10th tee, our First Tee of our first hole of the day and I'm on the back tees and I see my three other players still walking towards the next T lies in the white t. So I'm going guys we're not
playing a blues today. That's another three of us are blowing off whites. So not to be Isabel I said, okay, I'm in southern Iran. I said okay I'll play off the whites as well. Of course, that means my handicap needs to be adjusted. I've run up the pro shop from the 10th tee just said guys, explain exactly what I just explained to you. Can you put me off the Whitey's? I said yeah just log out of the you know, get out of the scoring app. If a key in your handicap will be adjusted. So sure enough I do that, get back in my handicap has changed but not to the correct
handicapped. My marker who also got out of his at got back in again, has seen that, my handicap has changed but it wasn't to my correct handicap. For those teas, I know because I play off those t's every Wednesday and my question simply do the captain. And another player I said, I'm clearly right now with my scorecard with the app. I'm clearly I have the wrong handicap. I said, who is responsible for ensuring that? I have the creek handicap is that the player or the committee And the other player said,
committee and a, our friend Captain Ray said, the player was, it's a 50-50 obviously, and the player is responsible and I said well done. Right under rule, three point three be, it's the player which we do would think it's to be the committee, but it's not. It's actually the player is responsible to ensure that the correct handicap is on their scorecard. I'm saying it's not really a massive clubland story. It's actually never happened to
me where the app was wrong. It was that was off by three Strokes. So yeah, so that's right. It's the player because you do know, but it's the player. But what about when just looking up the document from Gulfstream about, High School record on the whole night.
So the key is may not returning my scorecard until it has been fixed. That's the curl that that's right so you've had plenty of time to fix it. So the issue was it? What you're looking at? There is now we if you return a scorecard with a higher handicap than it should be, there's an issue. If you return a score card with a handicapped that's lower than it should be. Then I think that's accepted. Yes, that's correct. But I'm just trying to find out and I'm not going to be able to find it in time and it sounds
crap on podcast, but where if you are using the electronic system? Yes, you actually don't get away with it but you aren't penalized because it's not really your fault. I'll keep looking So that's that one. Okay, we'll all the. Yeah. The key is like if a player returning the scorecard without the right handicap, here's what can happen. If it's higher, this is the, you
know, if it's lower. So there the two things. But of course, I didn't return, my scorecard of not submitted it through the electronic through my phone through the app. I've gone straight into the Pro Shop acting as the committee on the day and just said, here's a situation. We need to fix this please, before I submit my scorecard because of course, my handicap was higher than it should have been So yeah, I just never seen that before. Okay, so I just I just knew enough to not submit the scorecard. Then I'll handle it later that
it was wrong. I have a look and see about this computer at thing. All right, so what's the next one? You've got this one. You don't see this very often either. So we get back to Ambrose and scramble and the term, you know, the terms of the competition were of the group of for all players needed to have a minimum of three drives That age group would take, pretty standard rule Sage playing at a minimum of three, and the maximum was 64 any one player. So minimum three maximum 60k a group Rings up.
The Pro Shop during the round, the Pro Shop acting as the committee for the competition on the Day, brings up the pro shop and said, hey guys is the maximum for one player six or eight and the person from the Pro Shop said, oh, you know, problem is 8. Yeah, and so, Then that group have had one player. Hit a seventh and an eighth tee shot for each of the terms of the competition. Yeah, and it didn't just got discuss later about and I was
reading as today on the committee procedures about what happens when a ruling is, in fact, Incorrect. And what happens? And whether it be can be corrected or not, you made the whole competition, null and void, right? No, I don't believe that happened. So what what are you, what are you supposed to do? Do it? He's a good question. I just know. It just can't be. I mean, if a referee makes a
mistake and it's found out and you can be corrected, my understanding is, it should be corrected, but this one can't be good, but distance just can't be on this. Team has had one player, have a 7th and 8th, tee shot, and I don't think there's any way any penalty can be brought to that time. Would it be disqualification or anything less? They've even done the right thing. They've actually rung up for a ruling in a sense that actually wanted to clarify.
And it clubland like that at the start of the Year about what, what, what a team did. And it was something along those lines. What was it? I remember, and I think they even they ended up winning as well but it was Not kind of maybe if I remember, I'll come
back to it. Yeah. I mean he stopped up, are you going to? It's a novelty of me and you going to null and void the competition? No, not really and lucky for the other teams. Yes. But it's the committee area era in the, you just blame a committee in bed like a for the pressure was if it was a board event. Yeah, well, that's why pro shop staff should know the rules better than anyone.
If it was a border being, are they need go abroad? Leslie, would ya? It's morbid further? Yes, I'd probably give it a bad luck that, that stuff up by the Committee Member or the showed you an advantage agent acting for the committee meant that. Yeah, you got. It needs to be rectified. Yeah. I love you. Let's see the next one. Actually, that might be it. I've got one more. We can probably leave for another time. I'll keep building up my library.
I've got all these stories. No, give it a crack, because I'll be away next week. I've got a little torment and going to, and I'll be away for the week after, and during that we need to try and do I think over the next couple of weeks? Hopefully, the connection is right. We might do rule. 3 point 1 and point 2 and then we'll do a party and do rules 3.3. So give it a crack at doing this
and then I can keep going on with this handicap stuff up. Well you brought it up, where are you going biking? Thailand next week. And what's that for and that is the live golf Bangkok. Well yeah they live golf Bangkok invitation so that adds a new course to Stone Hills. I have no idea about it so we're not staying too close to it but
yeah well shells, every day out there will be nice to war. Little bit and then the week after I've been invited working for the Asian tour. To go to Jeddah and do fantastic. Do the live golf Jitter or Saudi Arabia. So we I was at the Royal brains course at the start of the year, the Asian tour. So I do know, their course, can get a bit windy.
It's very Sandy over there. But yes or two weeks on the on the road in the air I should say and then I'll be back mid-october. That's fantastic. Here we go. Try not to if I see someone. Pop the ball. Four foot on a 40 foot putt.
I can't see the screen video to come soon. Yes. I'm going to try and pop that open tonight actually because you sent me through the video so if I can do the commentary for that that would be good because that are in that was hilarious. I actually watched I went you know, so everyone was laughing about it today it's the first times in the head. I was like nice Bubba, Watson. If actually flattered or duct tape up a couple of years ago And hits it was like a Thief cottony His about six foot.
So it has happened before. And then remember the Rickie Fowler he has six inch pot 1 inch so everybody funny as well, so it's happened. But yeah, it was it was unfortunate that the referees didn't quite get that one, right? If that had betio footage, which I wish they'd I don't know. Yeah. You never know these circumstances for the stuff, but if they had, maybe they were seeing it in a different light but with that kind of thing, if the downswing has started, you
have to deliberately miss the ball, whether you stop it shorter or you go over the top of that around it, you have to deliberately miss the ball or not to be called a stroke. Like a Potter breaks in half. Know, if you start the downswing and deliberately miscible sorry, and let us love in the club breaks in half. And you stopped short.
It's still a stroke. Well, that's what the interpretation of. Stroke is. We're going to look. So if you start the, if you don't start the downswing in the club breaks and you can't make a stroke because it's not a conforming Club. It's not a clot. What? They would consider a club if the club is deflected, And
that's cool that's still a stroke. So let's try up like a printer. If the clubhead separates from the shaft doing with downswing, in the player, continues the downswing with the shaft alone whether or not the ball is struck with the shower. Oh okay. The clubhead separates in the shark Finning downswing in the player, continues as downswing. The shop alone with a cupboard falling, instructing the door. The clubhead separates from the shaft during the downswing, and the player continues, the downswing of the sharp line. So if you sort of throw a fishing line out there broke the head off, but stopped stopped
there. Then that same, it isn't a strike. So you see you're right. But if you kept going and we passed the ball with the shaft, that would be considered a stroke. Anyway, we're on a tangent here, right? Yeah. Well, it's that's call it quits. We'll get that video up. That's for sure. We're Absolutely. I'll try and get out as soon as I can and will get this podcast out ever.
So doubt episode 67. Right, what do we got? Gr Q? OT w67, go for it. Stuart I know how much you like your foursomes so we're going to force them as again. I remember that recent foursomes event we had it won battles so playing in a foursome stroke event at one bad Hills. Andy The average golfer and big p. Our partners on the second hole. Andy the average golfer. Tees it up tees off however hits the ball out of bounds while they are working out what to do
next. They realize that Andy the average golfer has played from the Teen area of another hole. IE the wrong team area. The question is, who plays the next shot for the team from where and what stroke number will it be? Mariana. Good luck. I think I need to clarify anything. Fantastic thing.
Everyone safe travels. Thank you very much. I will. Yeah, from our time in next week for my hotel room. No doubt and and we'll get getting. One it on the ear, so speak sense to thank you.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...