The GRQ Podcast #77 GRQOTW76 - Two in total. Chris Kirk - Sony Open Davis Thomson - The American Express Clubland Stories Stuart - Loose impediments left near the hole. Can an opponent move those loose impediments? Blakey Player A hits his 2nd stroke long of the green, thinking it may be out of bounds correctly plays a provisional He searches for the ball and finds it just under the 3 minutes mark He return to get a club and when he goes back he can’t find the ball again Stuart - Follow up on last weeks fourball during an individual stroke round. GRQOTW77 In stroke play, Claire's tee shot comes to rest within the margins of a red penalty area but not in the water. Claire makes a stroke at the ball and it dribbles down the bank into the water and cannot be played. They drop another ball on the bank within the penalty area in the proper relief area for Rule 17.1d(1). They decide not to play again from that lie and drop a third ball within two club-lengths of and not nearer the hole than the spot where their original ball last crossed the edge of the red penalty area. Claire plays on from there. For this series of events, how many penalty strokes has the player gotten?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, there in the giq podcast, 77th a day, we cover the answer for g oq o TW 76 is a couple of rulings from the tiller putting Chris Kirk and Davis Thompson. We have a couple of clubland stories from Stewart, as well as one from Blakey. We also, look back at last weekend, a couple of rulings that created a bit of bamboozlement and delve a little bit deeper into that. And finally rounding it out, we've got the gr Q OT w77 for you to try and guess the answer.
Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill and playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Welcome everyone to episode 77 of the grq podcast that's right. The golf rules questions podcast, where we cover everything. Go of rules related wakey here and joining me. It's of course, Stewart McPhee. Hello Stuart. How are you? Hello Blackie.
I'm very well. Thank you. How are you? Yeah. Yeah. Good unemployed and loving it. So, I mean, I am But then again, I fly on Monday to Jitter for the first of three tournaments. So we've got Jetta Oman and Qatar, or Doha Qatar, 3 tournaments there.
So across the other side of the world, that sounds amazing. Will you be away from home for three weeks? Yes, but that's not coming. Not coming back. Don't tell the burglars there. Well, speaking of burglars, we digress just for a moment. Of course, you're in a new Abode. Yes. Yeah. And no one shall know where I live. Both still in Melbourne. Yes it is. It's good. You can see I haven't quite set up the background yet but
Haven't done a Roscoe and said that with golf pictures and golf clubs and stuff like that, but I'll get there. She'll get there. I'm spending a lot of time and when you garan just enjoying that, Let's get into it. GI Q OT w76 answer and we had a couple of people at least a couple of people reach out and tell us what the answer was. Darryl must have been an easy was it there, okay.
Now I think it was interesting, that's what I thought and also our favorite David grieve on YouTube so thank you both and I'm pretty sure both got it spot-on. So The question is ND, the average golfer hooks, his product shot on the fourfold, wombat Hills and the ball bounces off of concrete cart path into the rough and he marks and lifts his ball to see if it is capital pract, there's a scuff mark on the ball. So the size that he is allowed to substitute this fall, he replaces another ball on the
spot, and miraculously gets it on to the putting green, with his next stroke on the putting green Rosco. Jin's Andy whom shows in the scuffle Ross strongly disapprove of substitution 2nd lifts that ball and replaces it with the original ball on the spot, on the putting green and holes out how many counties Strokes if any does ND the average golfer incur
Stewart. What is the answer? Well, it's a total of Two Strokes but there's actually two separate penalty. So for each each, Each subject neither substitution were allowed. So for each substitution is a penalty of one stroke. We could of course also say that it was only a month ago, that was a general penalty but it's now been reduced to one penalty stroke and rules 6.3 be, which talks about the ball used or six point. Three is the ball. Used in place of a whole and it says, if a plane makes a stroke, it incorrectly substitute of all the player gets one penalty
stroke. However, they must then play out the whole with that incorrectly substitutable Also even if Ross strongly disagree with Andy and he was right to do so they should have actually left the ball as it was and continued play the whole with that incorrectly substitutable. And by any going on, well, I better switch it back. He's actually getting breached another rule. The same rule a second time. Therefore there are two one-stroke penalty. Is that any must add to his whole score? Now, why was he allowed to substitute a ball? The first time?
It's got a scuff mark on it. So, Shirley see, if your ball scuffed-up, you can change it. Well, we did say, cut all cracked is probably the key words and just a little, excuse me, little scratch. Couple of marks off the concrete path. Would not be adequate, would not be sufficient to what's the word I'm after. I guess, be enough to allow you to substitutable for it being damaged, damaged use cut, cracked open, you know a
clear-cut or crack along the surface of the ball. A couple of scuff marks is not enough. Sorry, a scuff mark wouldn't be considered cutting of the skin in so I would I would think if you looked under a microscope it is clearly there is now Damage Done to the skin of the ball but I wouldn't think that's sufficient to Warrant a substitution for a cut or crack ball. So two shots in total penalty Strokes ND.
One of the how many hits did he have? I'm thinking he had a birdie, there are any the average over hooks. His approach shot bounces of a concrete path. If it's his approach shot legislative path for is therefore to is it onto the green to padded. So that's 5. And then we're going to add the two penalty Strokes easy to potable. One part, We didn't say, just hold on with it actually. So India was on PS3, so he's on
43. And then you hold out, let's say, you pulled out for a part. You hold out for part six. Yeah, spot on. Okay. Well, bad luck, Andy. But there is very good. As you said, it would have been General penalty 25 days ago. Score, a'ight. But now it's only score of 6 and on the important bit, is sorry, sorry. But I think the important bit is the fact that if you do make a
mistake by incorrectly, substituting a ball or use play the hole with that, you know, you don't try to correct it, you don't fix it and there's the same with the wrong place penalty as well, unless it's a serious breach. Yeah. And this is a serious breach wrong place. You just continue. Why even though you play for a wrong place, don't try and fix it because then you've just going to go and play for another wrong place. I've actually made a video on YouTube with Henry about that one. Very that. I just want to.
I wasn't going to come to this, but I thought we might as well it had a lot of comments last week or from last wheel, from last episode about your ruling. We are player was searching for a ball. Yeah. And in the search they cause their ball to move off the original position. And then, while they were calling for you, it moved back onto what they hundred percent.
Would you say 100% believe or not any more than 95% at least, 95% definitely that was back in the exact same position. And we just was discussing where the the player actually had to go through the procedure. Of lifting and placing it. You happy. Now we've got no issue here. Will you happy to say that you were wrong if you're wrong?
But we still had a bit of confusion about whether you were actually wrong or not. Hey, how do you feel after thinking about it for at least two weeks and in speaking with a lot of people about it, I think I could have asked, I think the important thing is he did play for the right spot. So that's probably the most important part of that whole procedure was he did play from the correct spot. The issue was, did the ball get back to that spot in the correct
Manner and how do I have my time again? And I thought there was an unusual situation, a ball moving during Search Is Not Unusual. Fact, for it to return by itself is probably unusual, so that may happen. Again, it may not if it was, I think I would then ask can you tell me about? Can you describe to me when it moved? How long before it actually moved back? And it was really just within the space of moved away and came back you could make an argument that ball, in fact did not move at all because it didn't come to
rest on another spot. It just oscillated So I'd probably ask a few more questions to go. Did it actually move, we not physically move, but in accordance with the rules and the definition of move did it actually come to rest on another spot. So if it did, and it was there for a split second and then it returned by itself. I think then the correct procedure would be then for the player to definitely lift it up and simply replace it back on that spot. Because the longer the time between it going off, the
original and coming back to the original, could have potentially changed the LIE through Natural Forces when yeah. So I guess you know now the balls on imply a little balls. I won't say that. So we were together, you know, under all know. I'm under Nine, we work out right this for ways, a ball can move and unless it's known or virtually certain that it's been moved by the player or caddy an
outside influence or an opponent in match play and we say it's been moved by natural forces in this particular case. So let's say the ball has moved back by natural forces that we're just on a blade of grass and gravity just took it back down to where it was at rest before it was found, which is the correct spot. If it's been moved back by that the play. You should really be the person who lifts that ball and replaces it back on that spot. I think it is a question of again. Did it actually move? The definition of move is come
to rest on another spot and if it never really came to rest on another spot and sort of just moved as part of the search and then a split second later just rolled back. I think you could make an argument that it didn't actually move in the first place. Who are we getting the facts from here? Who Who Are You relying on to tell us the story? Well, in this Particular case it was the player. I was having a conversation with the caddy and then there was another player who was over then, you know, just over listening into the conversation. We were having and the my main conversation with that player
was, is it back where it needs to be? It wasn't, how did it get back? How far did it move? My photo because was it needs to get back on that. Correct spot. So that was the question. I was asking that was my line of questioning was, are you sure this is where it was? When it came to rest after your tea shop. Yeah. You this the spot because I'm pretty sure I said, well if you don't know exactly, we use best estimate. Is this? Where it is? You know, just the spot and that's when I asked the other player. Do you think that's where it was? And he said, yep, I'll say,
well, we're all comfortable. If not known, use best estimate, we're all comfortable. That's the best estimate of where the ball was at rest. After the tea shop before it was found it's at the correct spot sir, very much my focus in that line of questioning with the all the Ation, I have with that player. Yes. from what you're saying, aye, what necessarily thinking and it can give you 95%, but if
you can or if they can In effectively, the ball has never moved. So you're ruling. If you were happy that it was at least 95%. Virtually certain the ball was in the exact same spot that it was originally when they found it, initially searching for it. It's never moved. How do you touch lift a ball? Why? What rule tells you that you have to lift the ball that hasn't moved?
No, not exactly. So I'm not I'm of the opinion that if you were happy as the referee, I am telling you the ball was back in and let's say the exact spot and they were at least 95% and that's this is going on to what all the rules are telling us you know reasonable judgment and least. 95% the ball is not move. Because when we say the ball is
not moved, we're going under the definition that might have come out of the spot and going back to the exact same spot. Under the definition that has not moved. If it hasn't moved, you don't touch it. If having set you, if you were probably like, I would have been a bit more cynical and see, and for the likelihood of that happening is less than 95 percent. Then then it's a different situation. We say, are you really sure let's just be safe and go
through the procedural. Hoarding rule, 14 or 9.4 whatever. Seven point, whatever. Important point to Richard on the spot, let just lift the ball up. Put it back into the spot that you believe it was. Okay. So because you had less than 95 percent. You do that more than 95%, don't touch it. It's back in the same spot because it near the move according to the people that were there.
And I put this to you as well. That the player and caddy may have a diff different shanor definition of move than you and I would I am I go, I did this intended this, I play with like that move. I put my life on the fact that a move but you and I will go actually didn't move in accordance with the rules because it didn't come to read some another spot. Correct correct. So so when you hear, when he said it moved, it may have actually just done that. That's when, if I was to have this situation again, I might just inquire a little bit
further, as in can you please describe to me what you saw, when you think the ball moved and then return back yet. Original spot. Yeah, so, I mean That's you know, the ruling itself. If anything, I don't think it's necessarily wrong. Maybe even get all the facts but it's certainly a learning curve for you as to how you actually dive deeper into getting exactly the information that you want. To make the right decision but the actual ruling that South
where we'll never know if you're happy. That it was at least 95% then why don't they why would they are sir? Yeah I suppose about four or five times. Like I was really hey this is the most important thing here is it needs to be in the correct spot and I've got the caddy and I got the other player who's listening in. You know, sort of watching in where the ball is. I asked multiple people are we comfortable? This is in the right spot. That to me was the most important part how it got there. Yes. I probably could have. Done some more digging in conversation, but to me, the most important part was being in the correct spot.
So, this is the difference between knowing the rules week, we might claim to know the rules. But us trying to understand from just the average golfer or a professional golfer. They don't understand the definitions of the rules of golf as we understand them. For example. Moved. Yeah, exactly. So hold I've been having a, you
know a couple of three or four days of some absolute Joy with a couple of people on Instagram trying to help them understand the definition of hold you know if the ball is partly in the whole Not a rest against the flagstick. It's that's not a hole under the definition of whole know what if you put your foot in a hole? Yes, your foot is in the hole, but if your whole body is not in the hole, then under the
definition, you yourself are not. Hold. Yeah. Yeah. You know it's a stupid down in elegy for a for a ball but so taking a stake In the rules as referees, us taking the rules, but actually asking the player questions and then try and connect those two together. That's the biggest skill or the talent of actually being a referee that met their player management and try to understand
what actually happened there. I'll say it again. Are, you know, I have to referee for many years to come. I'm not sure I'll come across that situation ever again. Notable move during the search. The more we move during the search plus, then it returning by itself, Act of the spot. That's a funny one way. A crooked umpire, although crickets having a funny tiled time moment with the man cared situation, but it quickly on fire, you know, they give out Albie's. Probably once again, will they? At least have to do to Kato MLB every game?
I bet. There's something engulf, you might get asked. no, and a different ruling or certain rule that once a year, you know, there's so many be real Orleans, it could occur and golf. And there's a referee you have to be across all of it plus gather the facts from the player who is bias for the playing part of a you know another plan that
group who is cat is. Yeah yeah. Well the Katie they could be friends they could be enemies. You going to get a different view? It's It's it's an unbelievable guy. No reply. We known golfing family asked about rules and what you need referees. And that I said you have no idea how much can happen to that white ball. Yeah. You different things. Can happen to him. Yeah. How many different places that can go? I'd like your friend on cricketing followers. What does lb what's that refer to leave before? So it's before we could leg
before Wicket. It's not just Okay. So these bold where the ball hits the stunts and it would be very boring if there was no dismissal called League before, because someone could just paired up, put all their pads in front of the wickets and stop the ball from ever hitting the stunts. So they came up with this concept leg before, and basically, the ball itself has to hit the body, any part of the body except a glove.
I've been holding the bat and the hand and bring again, very, very technical. Now wasn't expecting this but this is all good. Oh well, I love Cricket so much. So yes. But so it's LED before because usually your legs are about the same height as the the wickets. But if you put your head down there and tried to headbutt the ball, Phil over here, you could still be be out for League before because you've got your body in the way. So that's why I said it's your whole body, but yeah.
It has to be hitting in line and has to be going to hit and stunts and it must have hit your body before it hits the bat or the glove and not venture outside leg stump and not the Jets. I'd like to start but I can put you outside off stump and they have been very technical and that's the stop above. The idea of that is to stop the ball with his bowling at the leg. Stump all the time, it was bowling outside leg, and then putting all the fields in the leg anyway. Okay. Back to golf. So, I saw, now posted this a couple of times with the Justin
Thomas did it, won't I think and Nick Taylor had a really weird one. And the situation is at the Sony Open where one of the holes, I think it might be. The night goes down below beside the driving range and the driving range itself is out of bounds. And then they erected a massive fence. To stop balls going flying each way and that fences are temporary and move obstruction. So you can actually be sort of against the fence or what the out by the fence.
But then you get this nice lovely, nice, drop out closer to the Theo I and I saw Chris Kirk was Beneficiary of that ruling. Couple of weeks ago, couple weekends ago. The one that Sony Open was the second weekend of January and then another PGA Tour ruling. It's not really a ruling but Davis Thompson. If you saw this, the American
Express 72nd hole, you have to hold the part to get, get the tire with John rum and then He it hit the heel if the flagstick in from 48 feet which sounds normal to us and actually hit the flagstick and canned off. It was, it was traveling Affair Pace. But a lot of people were saying, oh, if you'd taken the flag stick out, it would have been in it would have been. And so I saw that there was a
creating a bit of a huff and a puff. Do you, are you a flag? Keep her in there or no? I'm sorry. No, I guess it wasn't so long ago that you couldn't have it in when putting effectively, but then you could. But, of course, covid came around, and we weren't allowed to touch them. So I believe that club level so many people have got used to putting with the flagstick in. I prefer it out unless I'm 30 meters away on the other side of the green. If I'm anywhere within 10 meters 85 m in, I definitely want the
flag stick out. I just creates, I've just seen, you know, 1 in 100, hit the flags, he can pop out. Out. And I go why why have that working against you? Some of lakes about person is my long answer that question. Yeah, me too. I'm the same as you. If it's a mid-range to long range and on the first apart, I'll leave it in just because I'm a fast player, but if it's anywhere around that 10-foot, I'll go and grab myself with no one's around and I'll just pop it out and lay it down on the green-eyed.
I'm actually don't, like holding onto the flagstick either, you know, people saw Take it out my swap it around before I usually just take it out and drop it on the ground. I want to get rid of it but I try and take it out for those shorter parts. Now a bikie question with a little tap in and you want to flakes. Yeah. Can you hold on to that flag stick while you make your stroke? You can hold on to the flag stick while you're making your stroke. Just don't use it as a prop to
whole galaxy. Yeah. And like a very good whole dance like a part of that answer very good don't use of any balanced or helping you. Yeah that's right now. So that happened that so now the one that no one sort of realizes still part of the rules is the fact that you can still have the flagstick attended. You know, don't get very often attended or tended, I usually say 18 but you don't see it at all.
If you do see a still set on the PGA tour with the caddies and whatnot but yeah it's still an option. Yeah, just you can't. If you have it tended you can't have it lifts in in the balls traveling towards the plagues that you must take it out. I'm sorry quick. When they are now publishing stories. I'm sorry, the rules definitely refer to a six letter word and I think you'll find most people just abbreviate that to tend the
flagstick here to Yugi, but it's definitely attend as you know, we present it, almost 10. So, I'm glad that I was Yeah, we haven't had any responses from toggling stories form. We obviously haven't posted enough places but you have a club and story for us or you don't want to truly I do. None of them are contenders for clubland story the year but
excuse me. How about this one? This really happened? At a course down on the Mornington Peninsula. You would know very well, be windy today says my mate. So there are some small branches and bunches of leaves lying on the Greek. In, I have the shot from just off the green about 12 meters or so. It was a small branch of leaves just to the left of the hole around 10-15 CM way. I think to myself, maybe this is really, really good luck. And I proceeded to part towards the hole that almost put it in
but I just missed, was it okay for me to deliberately leave that Branch there? Knowing it would assist me. Was the question that this person asked. I answered him, but that was a Club Lane story. So very, very windy leaves and twigs and branches everywhere. And it just happened to be one right there, right next to the hole and he thought this can be to my advantage. Can I leave it there? Or should I remove it? Excuse me, lucky person. Lucky person.
Yeah, so what did you respond? Well, I said to him, you know, one of the most important principles of the game is to play the courses. You find it. Yeah, and he's well, he's an example where you haven't deliberately put that object, therefore that loose impediment there. It just so happens to be there and as long as you didn't make any improvements or anything to affect the cats, I think there is nothing wrong with leaving that there to make you a next roke. Even if it'll provide you an advantage.
Yeah, very good. And I guess added to that, you know, as long as you don't wait for it to happen. Delay fly, and waiting for a branch to fall down. We will hang on, hang on to very precarious. I think it's about to fall. Yeah, I've got a follow-up from that and this was actually just a hypothetical. I also answer this one as well to this person, but let's say the same situation with that Branch right next to the hole really quite in an inventor. Just position and the opponent
in match play ceases and goes up, that's definitely an advantage. I'm going to go and move it. Can I tell him not to do that? And part before he moves it can I ask him not to remove that loose in betterment and II had a lot longer. Answer to this question for him, I'm going to go with the answer is player can play with it in that position. The opponent is not allowed to
touch it if the player wants to fly a with it in that position, Find a slightly different response. I said there were two parts to this. I mean, I basically gave the general statement that you can move loose impediments anywhere on Iraq the course without penalty. If your ball moves when you're doing it that's a separate issue. But you can't you know move a loose impediment if it's going to affect the ball in motion. So I said before you puttered, I couldn't see what would stop. The oponent going over and
moving that loose impediment and doing so without penalty, I couldn't see her. And why it would be similar to the you saying, your opponent are I'm going to go and play the provisional. I really don't want to find that original Ball. Please don't look for it, but the opponent does it. Anyway and goes, and looks at you. Well II saw it similar to that, please. Don't move that Branch. Wow, what a great position that branches. I'm going to part and the opponent says no way and runs over the hole and gets the branch out of the way before you put it on. I said it would be a different
situation if you made your putts. So you've made the stroke the ball is in motion, and then your opponent has moved that loosen him and I thought that would be a different situation because you've moved an object to effect of all emotion. Well, I point three players deliberate. So we you and I disagree. There are. So let's say the stroke hasn't been made and they just walk up to the Greenie opponent goes. I'm going to get that out of the way and I'm the plague.
Oh, no. Don't don't move that. That's going to help me. Any opponent says, no, I'm moving it. And you think that's okay, well, I think it can move loose impediments. Anywhere and at anytime, as long as it doesn't affect of all in motion and this ball zombie motion yet. I think that's not okay by the opponent. Okay. Very good. Well, we need to find out the answer and, of course not. It's a listens. So a point three, listen to this and let me know whether you think this changes your mind,
okay? A point three players, deliberate actions to alter physical conditions to affect another players ball at risk for stroke to be made. 8.3 a when eight, when rule 8.3 applies, this rule only covers a player's deliberate actions to alter physical conditions to affect another players ball at risk for stroke to be made by that other player. So, when it says player, Covers a player's deliberate action their lives say that's the
opponent. So, this rule only covers of an opponent's deliberate action. It does not apply to a player's action to deliberately deflect or stop. Another Players Ball in motion or to deliberately alter any physical conditions to a credible mark under arrest. That's covered under 11 come to 11.3 which he said So the ball was at rest and this is the one that covers, it rule 8.3, be prohibited actions to alter other physical conditions. I player must not deliberately take any of the actions listed
in rural 8.1 a 8.1. You know what a point one is. All the cats in everything except is Aladdin one. I see if there's a lad and roll, I put one base, a, or D to improve or worsen the conditions affecting the stroke of another player. Or alter any other physical conditions to affect. We are another Players Ball might go or come to rest after that players next stroke or later stroke or where another Players Ball rest.
My girl will come to rest of it moves before the stroke is made an exception. There is no penalty under the rule, the player, Alters any other, any such other, physical conditions, to care for. The course, such as smoothing Footprints in a bunker or replacing empty. And you can see we never thought of loose impediments. I always know that loose impediments have nothing to do with conditions affecting the stroke. That's right. It's we're not part of the LIE, the ball or anything like that. So when we talk about 8.1 a actions and it allowed move in a break growing or attached
natural object or lose impediments, not one of those removal of obstruction, integral object, boundary object, not one of those T marker move a loose impediment or movable obstruction into position, such as to build a stance, when improve the line apply To improve the line of play. That's why I think loose impediments are separate from physical conditions. We have found the clarification. Now, the mapping from 2018 2019 and it's even looked at the
deers and 1:41 there's and 23 tbsp. Risen outcome change. I don't know what the outcome changes yet and will read this clarification, but the clarification 8.1 d, 2/1. Examples of conditions. Sorry. So their application 8.1. D 1/2 buyer is entitled to have loose impairments or mooc or obstructions left where they were when Bullpen direst.
Generally speaking a player's entitled to the conditions affecting the stroke that they had will nibble can direct any player. May move loose impediments and move, obstructions rules, 15.1 and 15.2. But if this worsen the condition actions affecting the stroke of another player that player May the forest or the conditions by replacing the objects and a rule 8.1. D for example, a player has a downhill pipe and picks up loose impairments between their ball and the hole but deliberately
leaves some behind the whole another player. Removes the loose intentions behind the hole in might have served as a backstop for the Players Ball. Since the Flyers conditions affecting the stroke have been worsened, they are allowed to replace the loose impairments. so, I believe You tell me if I'm wrong here. That the player could replace them. But is the outcome change, the fact that the opponent of fellow
competitor. Another player does not get penalized. Hmm. Well, it's a thing that says, the plane May restore them. I just find that last sentence. Since the players conditions affecting the stroke have been worsened. What conditions affecting the stroke have been worse? And in this particular case, The conditions affect stroke that they had any player May remove. But if this worsen the conditions affecting the stroke of another player, So how is
removing those loose impediments serving? As a backstop worsened the LIE, the ball area of intended swing are intended Stones line, apply or relief area. Well it's worse than that. Possibly line of flight. Now I know, I know, I get you. I saying I agree that. that doesn't actually come into the conditions affecting a stroke, but the clarification seems to say that it does on this case
because I've got an example, the exact absolutely. I had a part in pretty much exactly what your simulation was. Yeah I guess you can go back to your mate and say If the plot, if the opponent, if the player doesn't want move in the opponent whilst they not going to be penalized for moving it, the player can then go and put them back. Could actually put it back again, May restore the conditions. I mean, again, I'm a bit confused by that last statement since the players conditions affecting the stroke have been
worsened, I mean, yeah. Anyway and then I can't see how the outcome change, you wouldn't penalize because this could go on. For all day, all day go back and forward for the opponent and there's no penalty for the player restoring the conditions. So, no, listen, I'm not really sure if that is an actual outcome change because I point 3, it says references 8.1. There's this clarification and it also references. The rule 8.3 I could be on a
nice dance, the two of them and put it in a in a point, 3 says penalty for breach of rule 8.3 General penalty. I totally understand that 8.1 really doesn't She says, moo-velous impediment or movable position in movable trucks into position, but that's not what's Happening Here. So yeah, I, you know, I just as I said, I know the 2018 looks
better and it was just in my mind. I was like, I'm sure that's something there. Yeah. As I so yeah good. This is a never find it. It's light or very well done in finding it. Yeah, that wouldn't go too well on the exam, but Anyway, I guess a, I guess it says it right there, that the player can let have it left there, even if the
opponent moves it, the player can move over there. Yeah, I got one more Club lien which is actually related. Was just a follow-up question. From last week's. This was the individual stroke play, but the 4 Ball Match play on the side and they played out of order to assist his partner even though technically wasn't his partner, And all the person I actually sent our podcast of this person's and make sure you listen to this because this is you guys and he said could I then just go up and pop my ball even though it's closer to the
whole. Can I just put my ball without saying anything to my partner? Is there anything wrong with doing that even though it's a disadvantage to myself and of course, the rule does clearly state that the two players must come to an agreement. To play out of order to provide an advantage. So if the one if the one player just went up and blade and didn't say anything even though his mate, my know why he's playing out of order and nothing is spoken. I think I think it'd be okay, 6.4. I that's an interesting one
because it's like, you are deliberately knowing again this comes back to this, you know, the rules you're almost worse off than if you don't. Yeah, yeah. So it says, specifically, if two or more players agree to play out of turn to give one of them an advantage and one of them plays out Of turn, each player who made the agreement gets the general penalty. Is that on the top of page 95?
Are you looking at the I'm online Summit. 6.4 be one just above 6.5. Correct. Have to agree and he would be a hard case to prove you to walk up and go why did you play it as affordable? Because are just really golf. Just wanted to hurry up. We behind to agree and not at each other and know the pretty
hard to prove would nodding be okay. You know, like pointing. And, you know, yes, I think that tacitly, I think that's coming to an agreement. It doesn't have to actually be spoken word as well. I wouldn't have thought so If it could be if it's clear. I mean, you know you would go up and ask the question. You asked the question, wouldn't you did you to agree?
Well, we didn't say anything. No. But no, but did you look at each other and nodded and point and you knew what you were doing. Yeah, I would agree with that. So so in that case, what you're saying is, as long as it was nothing, no action, no agreement. It looked like an agreement. In that would be fine. And that would be effectively really golf. It would look a bit strange. Yeah. Yeah. If the other person is ready anyway, yep. But And that would that be using
the rules to your advantage? Not sure it's route. Using the rules to your advantage. I think it's using the rules. Clearly. Leave early but not in the spirit. No, potentially not awesome to say that. And I say not in the spirit, you know, if you're a fast player, I could understand. But if you're if it's the first time, you've done all day, Yeah, to some people I know the four
ball side bet is much more important than their stable, four points at the end of the round. Yeah. That's because they've got a one in two chance of winning the Fall Ball side of it. And they've got a one in 2200 stroke play, and I've got an eye on Bandit handicap. They've got no chance of winning this. They will fit. Anyway, so right there. You guys. It's a good point. Yeah, I'd say I'd say, as long as it was nothing, nothing at all. But if you start, if you do it once and you do it like six
times in a row and that would be very hard to actually happens. It's turns around where you have the exact same line, and yeah. Yeah. But if you did it and you play together often and you did it every time I'd start to say, well, It's effectively an agreement it would but then you're the third or fourth player would have to think something's fishy here. Something's not right about now that and most and most wouldn't think that you have to at some point in time calling yourself out on.
Well I don't know they're pretty pretty keen on winning the song of head football match fly, aren't they? Yeah. Knowingly officiating yourself going. Alright, so I because you know the side bit smaller. It's me and that is there. Yeah that's the. Now you so that was the second
one third one almost. Yeah I have one. Andy hits his second stroke along of the green thinking, it may be out of bounds, he correctly plays a provisional, everything's alright so far so I'm with you so far it searches for that ball and which means it's which ball the ball that was hit longer, be green, okay, that you thought maybe out of
bounds, He searches for that original ball, and finds it just under 3 minutes. He returns to get a club and when he comes back he can't find that all again. We've had we've had, this is a question, I believe so. I said, you know what happened. Tell him tell him what happened and he said the partners after they stopped laughing, see with
him, send him back to where he originally played from and said that he has to play stroke and distance in that. The provisional doesn't count. Can't play the provision. and so it's not, you know, clubland story over the year but that is almost slows in the fact that They got it, right? Like I just want to say that. I am. I am surprised. I didn't, I didn't say.
No, I just don't like the provisional. I'm blown away. Yeah, I said, did they know the rules and and the person telling me was like, not really, it was just the fact that it was so funny to them, and then they made the guy pay for beer because he lost the ball, they defend So what do we say in that situation where your ball was in Long Grass? But while I was one of the first things, I was taught very, very early on situation happened.
I've got all good. I found it, you know, under five minutes. Probably at the time walked away and someone goes stop. Grab your hat, throw it on the ground. It was the first thing. I'm one of the first things I was taught ya. Go, why don't you put a club there? I think that's probably harder to. I think the club could disappear into the long grass coordinates, but there's a chance that Take your head off with, on
the ground said. I guess that's it. That's a good one. Although it's try to either, that's a good one. So now, do you have any others first, you know, II just need to go scrounging around for more clubland. Stories, there are plenty out there. We just need to, we employ more people. We just need to hear them. There's some amazing Stories out there every day, of every week. There are people out there playing Club golf with an unusual situations. Coming up, we just need to hear about them and we never discuss them. You want to find ones, you know, we're people.
Have a difference of interpretation for what the definition is. They think it's the definition means this, but the definition actually means this. I'm going to really push it for now and I'll I'll get so I'll get us. I reckon I'll give this five at least by next. It was a very, very good. I'll try to do the same. I'm not overly confident. I back to your provisional and Andy I cannot believe at least one of them said, no, no, no. First of all, is lost. You've got to play the provisional.
I can't believe at least one of them didn't say that Shirley, yeah, it's well done. Very well done. If I knew who they were Now, go through those question of the week, 77, you ready? Oh good. He's sitting there and in stroke play, please tee. Shot comes to rest within the margins of a red pen we area, but not in the water. Flair makes a stroke at the ball
and dribbles down the back down the bank, into the water and cannot be played. Clear drops another ball on the bank with in the penalty area in the proper relief area for rule 17.1 D1. They decide not to play again from that live and drop a third ball within two Club lengths of and not near the hole than the spot where their original ball last cross the edge of the penalty area.
Clear plays on from there, from the series of events. How many penalty Strokes is? The player incurred? First clarify, one thing, so the she's made a stroke inside the penalty area, and it's just dribbled forward and gone into the water. She's then decided to take stroke and distance. Yes, and gone back and dropped and that ball is now dropped in the relief, he came to rest in the relief area, in the, in the penalty area and is now in play.
Yes. I did not make a physical stroke at that ball decided. No, I'm getting out of here and goes back to the point where the ball last frost. Into that grid penalty area and took 17.1 D3. Lateral relief from that penalty area for at last. Yes, thank you. Okay, thank you that let's let's hear it goes down. David, anyone else who wants to get open and nuns drop in and tell us the answer. That one fantastic episode. Thank you, Stuart.
It's 77. Come to a close. And engulf on the horizon. And you know, I got the event with the PGI of australasia next week, up on them up. Ari River on the border between Victoria and New South Wales, which I'm very much looking forward to but not anywhere near as exotic as the places you're about to go to is a very, very safe travels to you and I hope all that goes well for you. Thank you. Is the rosebud one? This Wiki correct starts. Thursday Australia. Rosebud this weekend. Murray river which your
refereeing at correct. Followed up by the Vic. Open Victorian. Open, are you doing the vicar? I am not. Not yet. Not yet. I think you got to be on site with golf. Australia for that one. No comment. Well, neither of us are. So, there we go already. I'm eight. Thank you. He hit this, do the editing and seen the south of the listeners ASAP.
Thank you, everyone for listening and watching in wherever you are and make sure you get those clubland stories in to us asap.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...