Clubland Stories August 23 - THE GRQ PODCAST EP97Join this channel to get access to perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/join SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules. GOT A CLUBLAND STORY - Submit it here https://forms.gle/Jga9wNrnwUVFUQD98 GRQOTW 95No penalty, but it is certainly cause for a warning from the Committee for rude manners.If the behaviour continues, a Committee would certainly be correct to breach the player for Code of Conduct.Forgetting to move the marker/ball back and then played from a wrong place.A mixed Greensomes stableford mix-up - thank goodness it was stableford.A revisit of the couples/pairs tournament in Canada.GRQOTW 96 - Blakey and Stuart are playing in an individual stroke round at Wombat Hills. On the 9th hole, Stuart's ball becomes embedded in the putting green after his 2nd shot. Not knowing what to do, he asks Blakey, who jokingly tells him he must drop the ball within a one club length relief area on the putting green, no nearer the hole. Stuart does this. Blakey then notices Stuart's ball on the green away from the embedded spot and with no ball marker down. Blakey tells Stuart that he was only joking and that you cannot get embedded ball relief on the green. How must Stuart proceed and are there any penalty strokes to either player?GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/ DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE? Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en) OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY Https://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestions LISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules #GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
You are about to listen to episode 97 of the GRQ Podcast and we have a special guest with us today, the highest ranked referee in the nation, Mr. Podcast McPhee himself. OK, he isn't really a guest, but he definitely is. Special Podcast and Blakey cover off more clubland stories, including from Canada, England, and of course, our homegrown Mr. Roberts is looking for more clarification. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast.
Stewart's one of our highest ranked working rules officials that we have one of the best we've got and he knows, he said. Hi everyone, welcome to the GIQ Podcast Episode 97 with podcast. McPhee and Blakey here. Hello Podcast, how are you? Hello, Blakey. Very well, How are you? Very good. We saw each other yesterday for a round of golf. It was their first game of golf in. Or my first game of golf in in a while. Or our first game of golf
together. In a long time. But the sun was shining and some parts were made and it was very it was very good day for some. So you know we here before we press record on the podcast, we have a an agreed to run down. We have an agenda we're going to run through and I see you've added one state of Blakey's golf game. When did you put that in? I didn't say state of Blakey's golf game. I just said we had a good game together. I know, but it seems like you've added this item and you wanted to talk about your golf.
I mean, I could have added another five items in on the amount of rules you broke yesterday, but thank you. I appreciate you not including those declaring your ball lost, taking a club length. They in a club length to mark, to move your marker away. No, that wasn't a rule broken, but you lift it left a pretty big indentation on the green. So I think, I think that's why I missed my part on that one.
You know, I did that for a reason because it was so obvious that people don't do that. Yes, they move a ball marker on the green for interference. Oh, I knew what you were doing. It was very, it was very gamesmanship of you. Anyway, back to your game. Did you play OK yesterday? I played pretty well for my my ability, so I got. I got the most out of my ability, I'd say. Certainly did. Did you have any specifics for us? We've got 30 seconds here. Well, I started with three. Birdies, which is which is
fairly rare. Hold a few, hold a good putt on one and three. We played a Gardens run as as I said, it was a beautiful day and then the the wind got up, probably got up about hole 5 or maybe maybe hole six. We did see one of our group members sink their buggy into the water on six, which was well, it wasn't actually that funny, but it is now. But he took on a lot of water.
He actually, we didn't know this. We thought they were just pissing around and wasting time and we're like hurry up, what are they doing? But his buggy rolled into the water and then he lost quite a few balls and teas. So he's. I think he's gonna go back and get them because he's what? Well, he won club. Man of the year or club person of the year. Yeah, he's a great club guys, Sort of guy. Every club needs 20 of. And he was. He was fantastic to play with too. So that was I had a really good
group of of people yesterday to play with. But yeah, it started with three birdies, good birdie on the 7th as well. Made a couple of easy bogeys on some of the easiest holes. And then and then lost the ball. That was my big rules Blue for the day. Hit one down This Dog Leg Part 5. Hit it pretty well, but we thought it's way out to the right somehow. Somehow.
We started searching. Search for three minutes and then. You guys kept you guys carried on left my bag right beside a ball in the middle of the fairway that turned out to be my ball in the middle of the fairway. Had a wedge into a par 5. Ball was obviously lost. And I had to wipe that hole in the Stableford, but that that was disappointing. But I rallied and made a birdie and an eagle coming home to
shoot around 2 under. So good day for me. How was your day? It was a very good very good game to watch yesterday. And you start with three birdies, had four at the turn. As you say, you should have birdie 10 had we found that ball earlier. And then it finished off very, very nicely with an eagle on 17. Yeah, that was a that was a fun eagle on 17, very, very fun. And then a good up and down on 18 too. Just so anyway, it was, as I said, enjoyable.
And Ray said I could do it any time. But I think, I think I've retired now. On a high, I'm not sure I need to play golf ever again. So you certainly played very, very, very well yesterday. Anyway, we're not here to talk all about my golf. Your golf was a little bit. Well, it just wasn't your day. It wasn't. Thank you. It's very generous. And you got towed off in the match of course. Again. Again and so GRQOTW for episode 96.
What was the question? You and I partners in a full ball match play. You've scored five on a hole and I had a part for four which I missed. I was a bit disappointed by that. So before either of our opponents have completed, play the hole. Stewart moves his ball back to where he just putted from and makes a practice stroke towards the whole. The opponents are clearly not happy and they call in a referee what is the ruling look, so the the score is already done for that team, for you and I.
I scored five so whether it's a net five or five, the question just says 5 and that's our best score and then you've gone and had a practice pot whilst the hole. Was still in question because the opponents are playing. It's just a. It's just poor behavior by by yourself, you know, code of conduct. Possibly the referee could come in and give you a warning. But no penalties would or should be applied at this stage.
I mean, if it kept happening hole after hole, yeah, you could start. You know, the referee could start dishing out a penalty but or the committee could, but just in this one off case, just give them a warning. Hey, you just got to wait. I mean, it's such a simple thing to just wait until the hole's finished to then have a practice, but there weren't any local rules saying that practice putting after you finish the hole on that green was prohibited. So there's no issue there, but
it's it's. It's just a behavior. Code of conduct? Type situation, you know, Did you delay play? Not really. For what, 10 seconds? 5 seconds? Probably for a practice part. But yeah, probably just a good warning from the referee then. So you were on? Another podcast recently. Do you want to talk us through
now? I'll play the little recording, and it was talking about a specific. Type of rule, but do you just want to We'll go into that rule. But firstly, do you just want to talk about the experience of getting on another podcast? Because I mean you are Podcast McPhee, so it should you have. It's not the first time you've been on. Another podcast. You've been on a couple of finance podcasts before, but this one was a G1 and they specifically asked for your
expertise in the rules of golf and you just want to talk about your experience on that one. Thank you. Which was very humbling. So I was away, as you know, I was away just last week in Queensland visiting family and I just out of the blue got a phone call. From the host, one of the cohosts of this particular podcast. I don't know if we'll name drop, but and it was just, hey, it's, you know, I'm going, oh, you know, he said, oh look, we're about to record a podcast. You know, I'm really hot on this particular issue at the moment,
this particular potential breach of a rule. Can we talk about it on the podcast? I said happy to. OK, we'll call you back in 30 minutes and we'll be, you know, recording and stuff. I said OK, so I sort of hung around. They did tell me what the rule was like, the actual topic. I phoned you simply to say, hey, this is about to happen. Anything I should really concentrate on? And of course you helped and said I'd focus on this and this. I said, yeah, I thought of one of those.
That's a good idea, which I did. And then sure enough, in 40 agonizing minutes later, they rang back and it was OK, We're going to put you on mute. For two minutes we'll intro the section and then we'll unmute you and go to you. And then I was just a back and forth over the phone for four or five minutes and they hung up on me after at the end And then at the end said oh how good's that? We've got our own rules official on tap whenever we need him, so we'll have to get him back and etcetera, etcetera. So it was a lot of fun and I
believe it's a reasonably popular podcast in Australia as well. Yeah, well, they will play the. The clip right now for you. This is Talk Birdie to me with Nick Ahern and Mark Allen. Alright, you finished your party pie. You ready to go on the back 9? Certainly AM. Just before we get to Stuart McPhee, I'm I'm really looking forward to this because Stuart's one of our highest ranked working rules officials that we have one, one of the best we've got and he knows he's stuff. He's actually got a podcast on rules.
Fantastic. Ask what the name is going to get to him. But there's big news. We talked about Lafia last week and we had the Dan a Lafian intro last week. Thank you so much for that and did it work? Well, it appears to Nick, whatever you did now, you took this on and you took this as a responsibility to fix the issue. Whatever you did worked because we have got. Two. I love it. List is in Latvia. Well, I have to thank Bruce Shaw, who I played golf with his
son-in-law obviously made the call across the family in Latvia and we've done it. We've broken the market. I think we leave that there. We do have one, one person who wrote in said. How about you look at Poland now, because you've got zero there. I think we'll. I think we'll leave that right. I reckon Lucas Club was anchoring only just but anchoring and you're not so sure. Touch and go. Alright, well, Stuart McPhee, like I said, is a working rules official, one of the highest ranked that we have in this country. He's got his own podcast, Mark G'day.
Stuart, thanks for joining us. Thanks Mike. Thanks for having me. What's the name of your golf rules podcast? Golf rules questions. Beautiful. We'll have to listen in. I'm gonna have to listen now. I've sent you the footage that I took off my television of Lucas Glover and it was on about the 15th or the 16th hole. And it looks highly suspicious to me, which is enough for me to say that is anchoring because I see other players, Stuart, like Adam Scott, who keeps his hand well away, but that one just looked like it was a step too
far from me. But I'm not a rules official. Stuart, what about you? Well, you know, I probably think it is as well. But the problem with this particular rule is there's a big butt, and the butt is how do you prove it? Now, just to clarify, the actual rule about anchoring, it's just not the forearm or the hand. It actually came with the club itself, physically pressed up against the stomach or the chest. I think one thing we can be very easily fooled with is just because the forearm or the club itself touches the clothing,
doesn't mean there's a breach of the rule that the club itself or the hand or the forearm has to actually sort of be, you know, that physical anchor into that chest or the stomach. That's the issue and I and I think the issue is. You know, how do you prove it And we've got mechanism, you know, ways to do that. But I think on the surface it's it may look like that, but it doesn't automatically mean there's a breach of that rule. Yeah, it looked a bit touch and go for me there, Stuart. So Mark and I have debated about this previously as well. What about Bernard Langer? Cuz his left arm definitely looks as though it's kind of pushing against his side, and that his hand and everything is
not anchored. But it looks as though he's. Sort of his elbow and and the forearm looks as though that is anchored. Have you seen his action and what do you think of that? Yeah, yeah, definitely have. And I think if you had to compile a list, and there's not that many on this list that actually use the long part of skill, but he'd be right towards the top of that list where you'd have a suspicion of, you know, his technique. And what we would do is if we had suspicion of a plane, let's say we were officiating and saw that plane, you had suspicion, the first thing you'd probably do is talk to the chief referee or the tournament director and just raise it with him. Another referee may have mentioned that.
If there's some history there and you think, yeah, I've heard this before, maybe the tournament director might actually go and follow that player for a few holes and watch them part and keep a closer eye on that. And I think the next step would be just simply asking the player after the round and it really just comes back to the integrity of that player. And you know, that person gets. So did you anchor? I think we saw you on 16, Were you anchoring? You know, she pressed it up against chest and the player says no. You know that player has to go to bed that night and sleep well. You know, it's similar to did
you cause the ball to move and the player goes, no, I didn't, I didn't touch it, I didn't cause it to move. OK, well, we've got nothing to, you know, nothing to counter that. So we're going to go with what the player said and I think this particular rule, it's really hard to. Unless you really saw, you know, the whole shirt being pressed out of the way and the skin is completely, you know, the club has clearly been pretty forcefully put into the chest. It's a really hard one to prove. I think this one does come down the integrity of the player. Yeah, it is a vague one in that regard. But now is the rule written like and getting into the you know
the weeds on this I guess, but if the player comes back and said well actually yes, I did anchor looking at that but I didn't intend to. So his intent to be part of it. Yeah, look, intent is a big part of a lot of rules. This is not one of them. So the the the reality is that if you actually do, you know, create that anchor, that physical contact with the chest or the stomach, make that stroke, the stroke does count, but you do incur the general penalty to, you know, 2 strokes and stroke play for that stroke.
I I've got a way around this. When you talk to the play before around and say, you know, give us a look at your technique. If what they show you on the practice putting green on Tuesday and Wednesday is very different on Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday. So for instance, if you can see daylight between the hand and the shirt on Tuesday and Wednesday, and then on Sunday you're seeing what I showed you, surely then you could almost come over the top of the player
and say, listen, this isn't what you showed us on Tuesday and Wednesday, sport, and we've had enough. We're going to get you. Yeah, absolutely. I remember every every event is run by a committee, has a championship committee, a tournament committee, you have a chief referee, tournament director, you have rules officials. But there is a body of people, a committee responsible for running, whether it be the PGA or Golf Australia or whoever. There's a committee and they ultimately have ultimate authority to do what they want. Realistically, there's a saying in rules and that is the committee is always right, even when they're wrong, right.
They have that much power so they can quite comfortably step in. And you know, and you guys know, you know, players have certain reputations, certain players do, not all do, but they have reputation. Maybe they're a little bit close, you know, getting to the edge with a particular breach, the way they do something. And this might fall into that category. And you would definitely have a conversation with the player. You know, the player has a reputation to uphold. The player doesn't want to know, be known in the locker room as you know, flaunting the rules. And you guys know that, but you don't want to have that cloud over your head. Stuart, you've been fantastic. We'd love to get you back on
from time to time when we've got little questions to ask because you've been fabulous about this one. Of course, love to. All right. That'd be great. Thanks, Sue. Thanks, Stuart. Thanks guys. Thanks for the chat. It's nice we've got our own. Rules official on on tap. How about that? That's the Is he on the payroll there? What are we? What are we gonna do? He knows he stuff. I'll tell you what we gotta do. We gotta get him to do a top five rules that players think they're that. Players don't know they're breaking that. Most of the time they are breaking or something like that. We've gotta get that done. Yeah. So that was the Talk Verdict To
Me podcast. That podcast. McPhee. Yes. Starred on Talking about Anchoring. Now anchoring is an interesting topic. It was only bought in about 6 years ago after a couple of mainly because a couple of Tour pros won some major championships. We're using the long handled powder or the arm lock or the. What was the other one?
The stick it into your tummy lock. The belly puddle, that's the one. And so the rules bodies got together and decided that it wasn't really in the spirit of the game and wasn't traditionally how you know you should be swinging the club freely away from any type of anchoring. So they came up with this rule, continuing to allow these lengthy putters, but that you weren't able to lock it into.
Your anything above the elbow or using your hand indirectly to lock in the powder so that it acts like a pendulum motion rather than freely swinging. And I thought, I think you spoke really well about the the topic, about the situation. You know it is up to each committee to, you know, if there is an issue to talk to the player about that and then it.
It really does come down to the player and their integrity as to whether they believe they are anchoring or not even believe whether they are anchoring or not. So I think you spoke really well because obviously you know that podcast wants. A little bit more of a click Back top situation where you talk about hot topics and you then you move on to next week. Whereas here on a rules podcast, you know it's like a glacier. The the earth is not moving fast
on these things. On this podcast we're not really into Click Back top stuff, we're just discussing, you know, the rules that apply to the game of golf every day. So it's it's an easy one to sort of he's cheated and he won the tournament, you know, cheating. Well, OK, let's. Step back a little bit and just look at actually how the. Rule is or what the rule is and how it actually is applied.
Whether we agree with the rule or not. Whether we agree with the fact that? You're still allowed to use long handled putters, all that kind of thing, what it actually is and what people think it is. That's where we need to try and make sure that it's as close as possible. So well done on that podcast. Thank you. I appreciate that. I you said something that actually a rule says rule 10.1 about preparing and making a stroke and you'll like this. The underlying principle is that golf is a game of skill and
personal challenge, and the idea of fairly striking the ball is so that club does swing fairly, so it doesn't have some stabilizing or steadying point, you know, up against the up against the chest, right? The club supposed to swing freely. Excuse me. I also think with that rule, as I said maybe once or twice on that podcast was the word integrity. Because if it was a procedural thing like taking relief from a penalty area and how they did that and how they dropped it. And that'd be a lot easier on a video to sort of assess or to
sort of work out, you know, where they took unplayable or where they marketable or something like that. But part of me, that thing, how do you prove it unless you put a sensor on everybody's chest, right, To measure pressure, Yeah. So it's just one of those unique rules where you've really just got to ask the player, and the player knows the answer. Nobody else, you know. Yeah, and it's actually on the actual stroke itself. So you can actually anchor on the backswing. As long as you take it off. On the forward swing, you
haven't anchored. Anchoring is only for the stroke and when you hit the ball, not for the back swing, which is an interesting a good technicality concept. So no, very well done on that. As I said, whether we agree with it or not, that is the rules. But it's funny that you you talk about, you know, the the integrity of the player and that kind of thing and and and the freely swinging and what the
game of golf actually is and whether it's a test, you know, the the the divot one comes up. Weekly. Daily. Probably. Oh, we should always get a free relief from the divot. But you know, I said it in last week's podcast that whether your ball was in a divot or near a divot or whatever, you know that that's not a penalty. If you hit your ball down the middle of the funeral fairway, it's not a penalty to be in a divot. It's a test of your character.
And that is essentially what golf is. But we seem to be going away from that. And now it was my skill to get my ball down the middle of the fairway and was my skill to get it from this perfect lie under the green that I disagree with that entirely. Golf to me is more about testing you on every shot, testing your character and you don't have necessarily a perfect lie. And golf is not supposed to be fair.
It mimics life. You know, if you have, if you can run the fastest, does that mean that you will always win the the race? You know the 100 meter race or whatever it is? No, because there's other things that come into life like injuries and personal situations and that is exactly what golf is similar and mimics life. There are other things that come into it other than being the best at, you know, a certain skill.
There's many people that have missed out in life. This is really a a terrible. Run. But there are many people that have missed out in life, even though they are extremely talented, just because they had different tests over that time that didn't get them into certain, you know, races or championships or up up through business. But you know, another one that came out recently was we should change the outer bands. It's too penalizing again, you know, penalizing.
On on what on your character you know is it Is it too? Is it too difficult to ask that you try and? Keep your ball in the in the course within the course you know is losing your ball to penalizing to penalizing to who you know it's. We're simply asking that you accept that you need to keep your ball within a certain area
and the test is on you to accept that. It's not, you know, you go to the driving range and you hit it and you try and hit it straight, great. But, and there's going to be a time when you can't hit it straight or you miss it, and then you have to accept. The consequences? Oh, but that's too penalizing. Well, you know, toughen up basically. Right before I keep going on that on that ramp there, let's
get into clubland stories, which we which we really love. I've got one here from C by C by my opponent and I are in a match at the beautiful Predator Ridge Resort in British Columbia, Columbia, Canada. I am one down starting the 18th hole. Both have. Both of us hit great drives down the fairway, leaving about 140 yards into the 18th green. I am slightly away and I hit my approach shot into the lake that protects the 18th green, so he's
in the lake for two. My opponent hits the green and is about 8 feet from the flag. He takes his penalty area relief dropped within two club lengths of the red penalty area, and plays his fourth shot onto the green, about 12 feet from the flag and roughly on the same line as his opponent's ball. He asked his opponent to move his mark to the right by one club link, club head, not, not a Stuart McPhee club length, one club head. And the opponent, while doing so, jokingly says. Could you imagine if I didn't
move this back and lost the hole? Oh no. I miss my bogey putt and gets it, conceded for a double bogey. So this guy's putting for a birdie? CBY Cby's had a had a double bug, he says. So he's got three parts for the win from 8 foot. Yeah, I pick up my ball and tend to go retrieve the flagstick a few feet away while I'm bending down to pick the flag. My opponent had already puttered his birdie putt. I say to him, Did you move your
mark back and your ball, basically? And he tells me that he did not. My opponent then asked me what happens. He stated up there, Could you imagine if I didn't move this back and lost the hole? And now he's going, oh, what happens? I'm innocent. Don't penalize me, I say. CB what? I says he lost the hole and the match is halved. My opponent claims that I should have reminded him to move it back, and that not doing so was unsporting. What about?
What about the own? Bonus on the the player to move his mark back after he even after he said he has to move it back. My opponent did send his booty part very quickly and I maintain I did not see that he didn't move his mark back. However, even if he did, even if I did, my view is that in match play and I do not need to protect him from himself. I agree if I would, you know, I would ask him to move it back if if.
I could if I knew it was there, but if he doesn't, I didn't do anything wrong. So CBY, you haven't done anything wrong. How the guy couldn't remember after he literally said what if, how funny would it be if I got a penalty. It's just that's completely on him, his own fault. And for him to then turn around and say, oh, but it's unsporting of you, it's a reach, yeah,
that's that shows his character right there. This was the first of five matches. The other four were four ball matches. In a Ryder Cup trip, my my team needed to win four or five matches or we would lose. Whether my match was 1/2 or loss, it did not impact the outcome of the tournament, but it is still discussed to this day and that was summer 2022, Predator Ridge, Canada. You know for CBY he's probably not even thinking about the other guys ball marker. He's still disappointed that he put his second shot into the
water and he's ended up with a correct to lose the match, right to not even give himself a chance of having that match. He that's where his mind is. How disappointing he's not thinking right I've missed it what what's my opponent? He's in fact almost realized that he's got three butts to win in fact so he's one up the other guy so he's only got a half the hole. He's got four butts from 8 foot and he still wins the match, right, So he's not thinking about the guy's ball marker. Unsportman's I think that's an
unfortunate reach that probably in the moment that guy probably shouldn't have said. But he said it obviously disappointed himself just going off the the one sided story, I back the storyteller. 100% Did you get the other guy writing? Yeah, that's right. That's right. If if you are the other player, tell us your side of the story. But but it's it would be pretty hard to beat. So if I may just digress. So this reminds me of that
incident we spoke about on this podcast in my Perth trip that I thought that guy's probably a little bit bored of the playing area. And as I'm slowly walking around to not be heard and distract the plies about to hit and I slowly walk around and the instant I see these balls in front the club is striking the ball And had I had another one second and he hadn't have hit it, I would say well stop, stop. You need to bring it back in. It happened yesterday. You set it to apply yesterday right outside the Ting area and you go, hey, you need to move. People do that, right?
Most people do that. Had I had another second, I would have said that. So when I didn't, of course, the second side of the story was I stood there waiting, you know, seeing it was outside the Ting area, stood there waiting. He he didn't. I've gone, oh bang, you're outside the Ting area. That's not what happened at all. But that was the bad guy. I was the bad guy. But it comes back to a word you just used describing this opponent, and that's onus. It's your ball. You have a responsibility to do the right thing. It's not up to everyone else to tell you you're about to do something wrong or anything like that.
This guy had, it's his ball. He moved the ball marker. He needs to put it back. This guy should have teed off, should have put teed up his ball inside the team area and we wouldn't be having this conversation pretty. Pretty simple. If you take the onus and you look after your own what you you can control the controllables. You shouldn't have any issues. I don't know if you noticed this yesterday. Every single time I teed up inside a teeing area yesterday, I was about 30 centimeters behind the forward edge. No, I didn't. I didn't know. I do that deliberately now, so
there's just, I'm never going to have an issue with just being ahead, having gone through some of this stuff this year. Did you notice where I was? Teeing the ball up close to the forward edge, Absolutely, yeah. Gaining every millimeter. I don't think it would have mattered yesterday, but the way you played, it's always, it's just always been a habit, you know, I just always make sure I'm within or you know, very close. I've got a, I've got a mate and he is engine engineer, so it makes sense. But he is so close to the front every time and we go, oh, we
think. You know, we'll walk around, we'll go, I said. I think that's a bit. A bit forward and we'll walk down and go, Nah, it's right on the line. And he does it all the time. He's so good at doing it that we just don't even think about it Now he's like, Nah, it'll be right on. He's almost got the laser out. Yep, Yep. And he has that laser kind of mind, You know, that engineer engineering type brain where he just has this feeling of where it is and he gets it right every time. It's freakish. There'll be a good community
question coming up. How much of the ball needs to be with inside the teen area? It has to be at least all of it. At least we're going to be more actually. That is a good. That is a good question because can some of the ball be outside the teen area? Is the last. Without answering it now, but. The latest community question I told you I said this will be this is the easiest question you can we can get the question for the latest community question. Is are you allowed to declare
your ball lost? And I put the level at. Easy. I should have put the level at. Very easy. And what did I say? What did I say to you? Were you quoted a percentage that you thought forecast it would get it incorrect? And what was that percentage? It was pretty high. I think it was over 70. It was set. I quoted 78%. I said. I thought it was a bit of a reach. This will be the easiest question that 78% of people will get wrong and you know the number now.
I don't, but if you do, you have a calculator handy. Yep, in my head. It's it's around about. It's close to 240 / 832 OK. 28%, 832, I probably did 732 or something. Yeah, 28.829%. OK, so 71% have got it wrong? No way. Correct. 29% have got it right. Oh, that's incredible.
That's on Instagram. Instagram aren't quite as good as the Youtubers plus. I think that they get it wrong on you. On Instagram, they come over to YouTube and they get it right. So, so they kind of. Bulk it up a little bit. Wow. But 71% believe that you can declare your ball lost. I had someone do that yesterday. Yeah, that was you. But we know that that was. What about you calling provisional halfway through your swing?
I was, I was trying to play provisional and I thought I'm going to tee up here and and almost hit it. And because they'll be stroking distance if I don't say anything. And I'm wondering if someone is going to you or the club captain, we're going to jump in and say are you playing a provisional or were you just going to be quiet and not say anything? And it got to the point where I was about to hit it and I thought I'd better say something because you guys are not going to say anything. I wasn't going to say anything.
It would have been actually would have been interesting if you hadn't said anything. Well, whether or not we will, you're going whether I had called it on you or not. Well, no. Well, I'd call it on myself. I know it's what it is. Stroke and distance as though no discussion to be had But yeah, no, that was, that was pretty funny. But then then what did you say? I'm just going to play this one just in case. What was the. Yeah, that was the one. Just in case I can't find the first one. That's right. That's right.
And then and then Ray said he usually says I'm proceeding under Rule 18 something. I didn't point through it. It's exactly what I say every time. Yeah. Anyway, so digress. We we do digress. So that was that was a community club community question club land story from CBY. Now I've got another one from Ian Cavill during that was that's what he put down as his nickname. But I'm assuming that's his name as well.
During a mixed green Sims Stableford competition, Wow mixed green Sims Stableford both tee off, select the best, then alternate shots where men played from yellow T's and ladies played from red t's. Steve and Jane were playing as a peer. Jane decided to tee off first from the red tee, but played an earshot. She then immediately replayed the tee shot. Hitting it down the fairway after Jane had hit her ball down
the fairway, Steve then hit his tee shot from the yellow tee. Steve's tee shot went out of bounds so they decided to play Jane's ball. After three more shots, the ball was hold and Steve claimed 5 for the hole, 4 actual strokes plus an airshot, giving them one Staleford Point on the hole. Oh my God, did Jane play out of turn as Steve should have played the next stroke with her ball? Did Steve play from the wrong
place? AS2 strokes have been played with Jane's ball so Steve was no longer entitled to hit his tee shot. Did Steve play out of turn? All of the above questions, questions, questions. What actions were taken to resolve the situation? After much discussion, the committee reduced their score to no points on that hole. As there were several breaches, however, we are still not sure exactly how many strokes they had on the whole and what penalty applies if it was stroke play and match play. This was in Peterborough, England at Nene Park Golf Club. Nene Nene.
So greensomes, just to confirm, is like so you both T off. You then hit each other's ball. You don't select one after the tshirt, you go and hit each other's ball. You select one after the tee shot. Oh, you don't go and play each other's. And then after the second shot, select one. OK, so it's just both tee off. Then you select which one you're going to proceed with and then alternate shot after that. Yeah, correct. So the so clearly they've
proceeded with, I forget the lady's name, but the first ball with the Jane, they've clearly proceeded with Jane's ball because the other guys hit out of bands and they haven't proceeded any further with that. So the issue is applying at a turn bit, isn't it? Yeah, well. Firstly, do we address the fact that Steve? So James hit and then she's hit again. Yeah, that's the biggest issue for mine. And Steve hasn't even hit yet. So I I can look past that because in the sense that, I mean you only need to proceed
with one. Imagine if we were applying Canadian foursomes and you hit, oh, I hit just a really, really big drive and we wanted you to hit in we just go, you know, I won't even I won't. Yeah, you say I won't bother. We'll just proceed with yours. Surely that's an option. Do you? Well, to to look up whether you have to play in order of the tee shots before you play that selected ball. I mean, you can't. You can't select the best when you both are down there.
Both are down there, but. Maybe you could Do you? Do I even have to hit off? Exactly. And but then if I haven't hit off and I then decide to head off, is that playing out of order? And I'm not sure the rules are. I think the rules would be silent on that and this is issue with some of these peripheral type formats. Yeah, correct. Although they're not really on the edge.
No, actually they've got it in the book now. They didn't have it in the book 2019, but they do have it in the book now. Green Sims is the variation of four Sims where both players part both partners play from the team area and one of the two tee shots is selected. The partner whose tee shot was not selected then plays the next stroke in. Each subsequent stroke is made in alternating order until the balls hold. For example, if the tee shot of player A is selected at the 1st hole, player B will play the next stroke. In play a plays and so on until the ball is hard.
That's till the ball is hold, sorry both players in play from the Ting area, the 2nd hole and the process is repeated. Our other variations of green Sims include Pinehurst foursomes, which is the one where you tee off, you switch and then you hit again and then you choose. Which is the one I thought of, yeah. Or Chinese Or Saint Andrews Green Sims, where players decide before starting. The 1st hole of the ram which player will play the second stroke on all odd numbered holes and the other player plays the second stroke on all even number holes? Wow, this selection of each, but
anyway. That's not applies to us. So it's just the green Sims. I mean, you have to. It doesn't specifically say, it only gives us sort of a paragraph. On all the rules of a green SIM, but it's it's a modified foursome. A variation of foursome. So you'd probably go back through 22 and find you know that they have to play in order. So let's let's do 2 scenarios here where James made her tee
shot, missed the ball. OK, ball is still within the Ting area, still on the tee. That's fine. She then hits her shot. She then hit by hitting the shot again or trying attempting the shot again. We'll go down the path that they've selected that as the best shot to take, which in hindsight it was, but no one knew that at the time. We'll on this, on this scenario,
we'll forget that Steve then went and played his shot and headed out of bounds that it wasn't out of order. We'll just, we'll just say OK, that was allowed because he was allowed to hit a tshirt in whatever order he wanted as well. That's not quite true, but let's just say it's OK just for this scenario. So Jane's hit out of 10 or Jane's hit it was Steve was supposed to play from the yellow.
And Jane played from yellow SO22 Death 22.3. On each whole, the partners must make each stroke for the side in alternating order. Penalty for making a stroke in the wrong order in breach of rule 22.3. General penalty. That's in stroke play. The side must correct the mistake. To correct the mistake, the right partner must make a stroke from where the side made the first stroke in the wrong order.
They haven't done this. So that's a zero points. I actually think that's the ruling, excuse me, That's what I'm leaning towards is the fact that forget Steve hitting it out of bounds, they've selected James Ball, they've been played in the wrong order, which means general penalty. Any shots after that don't count, including penalty strokes and it must be corrected. And they haven't done that 14 off to start the next hole, so zero points. Lucky it wasn't stroke, otherwise it would have been too cute. I'm, I'm thinking the same
thing. I'm glad it's a Staleford. So I mean this is just over one point, but that's fine. Ian just wants to know if this was if the committee proceeded correctly and I think they've proceeded exactly right now if we actually do bring in the fact that Steve hit out of order. I think it's it comes down, it'll be the same era. I actually think that the scenario too, You don't look
past the fact that Steve's played out of order. Even though he is allowed to have that tee shot, he has to hit that tee shot before that ball is selected surely, right? I mean, if you think about it, if Jane then hits that ball and. It goes into a good spot or it goes into a really bad spot. Steve then plays, knowing that they really want to use his shot
because maybe Jane hits it out of bounds. She takes an air swing, then she hits it out of bounds. They know that Steve's is going to count and they it's that slight difference in thought process. You know, maybe he doesn't take driver, maybe he takes on just to hit, hit the fairway. It's a it's a slightly different because they've had that you could almost say it's an advantage, even though it's. Technically, it's not it, and also is at the same time because he knows where that other ball
is regardless. The other thing, with Jane playing in the wrong order, clearly hitting that ball again, it's almost like the game stops, pauses for a moment and anything that happens after that, you know, we've had these discussions separately, sort of nothing matters anymore almost. So the fact that Steve then teed it up, you couldn't say, oh, we put another ball in play, No, no, no, there's there's still a breach that remains unresolved that needs to be corrected and that is the wrong order that needs to be fixed first.
Yes, you can get penalty for asking for advice or you know other stuff, but everything else almost pauses until you correct that wrong order mistake. Yep, now another one to this, another one. To add to this, a slightly different scenarios Jane's hit. Her. Then she's hit what should be Steve's shot. So then that's a 2 stroke penalty as you said.
Nothing else matters until it gets fixed. Steve then plays. From a wrong place and trying to correct that mistake because he plays from the yellow gets a further two shot penalty will say it's not a serious breach and So what are we up to now? 13456 and he hits it out of bounds, which is an. Error of play.
So that's seven. And Jane needs to tee off from the yellow playing around. And playing your 8th, They're playing their eighth shot, so I feel like they're gonna have zero points on that one. I would think so. I think, you know, Jane having the air swing and then hitting that ball has almost committed that team to playing that ball. I agree. It's they've made a commitment, they, she said. We're selecting this ball, yeah. And then she's just having to play in the wrong order.
But yeah, because you're having a second shot at a ball in, you know, you start to play the hole in a sense. You're having a second shot, You're having a go. One of the, you know, one of the competition conditions in green Sims. Is that you select the best, she selected the best, the ball's still in the thing area. Still on the team? Well, better than the other bands. One, as it turns out, as you said, that's right in hindsight. Right. So that we're all good with that one then. Nice. Yeah, that's OK. That's a good one though. That was a very good one.
Thank you, Ian. Love those clubland stories we've we've been getting a lot of the four Wall foursomes, Green Sims, Pinehurst, all that kind of stuff lately, which, you know, I wouldn't say that I was that definitely not expert. I would definitely be on the easy to medium category on that one, but love it. So just keep sending them in. Next thing you know we'll get a a scramble question. Are you allowed to stand on a back on, back on the line, all
that kind of thing now, Mr. Roberts wanted to bring up and just before we do that, actually it. We had a question from DK and I think we put in the episode 95 or 96. I'm from DK about the Bunker. And a ball going outside the bunker and then the player raking it because he was worried that the ball would roll back into the footprints or his damage and he raked it whilst
the ball. His intention was, and we were pretty clear. DK was pretty clear that his intention was to improve his conditions and he but he then said it was caring for the course which they said, no it wasn't. But we've had some word from the USDA about this. So because it was like 2 conflicting rules in a way wasn't it? There was yeah yeah. General blanket permission as opposed to a There's what? Sorry. Can. There's what you can and can't do under rule 12.2 B, and it actually lists what you can and
can't do. And so, because it's precise and what it lists that you can do, it overrules any generalization of what you generalized. Prohibition of what you can't do in 11.2211, point 311.3, so it overrides anything that you can't do in 11.3. So the word is DK.
If the ball is outside the bunker, you can basically do anything you like, even improving your conditions. That potentially, potentially, if the ball comes back into the bunker, but once the ball is back in the bunker, then those prohibitions are back and forth, turn on and almost again. Correct. So if it's out, it's it up in the air. You've hit this 20 meter high lob shot and while you're up in the air, you quickly rake your bunker. Your footprints, that would be
OK, whether it was caring for the course or just because you didn't want the ball to go into one of these footprints. When the ball is outside the bunker, it is OK, so it allows you. Anytime the ball is outside to rake, to rake the bunker, yeah, you're right, 11.3 Deliberately altering conditions to affectable emotion. But once the ball is back in the bunker, then you're restricted
as prohibitions. Yeah, keep back in. OK, so we'll clear that up. Let's get into Mr. Roberts is also bringing up a question from episode 91 from CK about the the story of the different paths for this tournament, which he thought was a mixed tournament. But. CK said it was a couples tournament or a peers tournament. So it could be men and men, females and females, males and females, you know, male, female
playing together and when the the difference of PA, who is the gross winner. And I said you have to leave it up to the committee to decide before the tournament starts what they're going to do if. Because we agree that 72 would be the lower score than 73. That's not up for discussion, but if it should be, in my mind it should be the score relative
to part if you both shoot par. Or you both shoot one under, it's a tie and then it needs to be worked out through count back or play a whole playoff, that type of thing. But it this needs to be discussed by the committee prior to the tournament starting, not once the situation occurs. So if I can just bring that down to a really basic level at club level where I asked you about this last Wednesday, there was
only three of us in our group and we played a common format called split sixes. And what about the 5th, 6th, 7th hole? It was a misunderstanding between myself and the guy running the split sixes over the way points were being allocated and the lesson of that moral of that story for me, and it relates exactly to what the committee here is, you need to clear be very very clear about all of that before you start play the 1st hole. Before you begin the event, you just need to be very clear that
how those things, they can't possibly foresee every possible scenario. But the one that I had and the one that this club has had, I think are reasonable to sort of expect and they need to sort out what those things are before everything starts. So you're not sorting it out on the 7th hole like I was or trying to or in this particular case after the 18th hole and trying to work it out. Yeah, totally agree with that. Right. So we just want to, we had a couple other community questions
that we wanted to go through and just on a couple of the answers. We're getting some mixed success. The latest the true false one before yesterday's one was pretty easy. We got 88% on YouTube and hitting a provisional ball you must use the same club that you used for the stroke at the original ball. That of course is a furphy. That is false.
You can use whatever club you want and hitting whatever shot you wish to hit. We had a couple of how many strokes? Big P2 putts on 2 putts for a par on the par 313th hole at Wombat Hills Golf Course. Big P then grabs his ball out of the hole and drops it onto the green to hit three practice parts towards the hole. He then picks up his ball and heads to the next tee. On the way to the next tee, he stops by a practice putt in green and hits two practice putts.
He then reaches the 14th tee and makes a score of four down the 14th hole. Ross then questions Big P's actions. Prime to teeing off how many strokes has Big P had on the 14th hole? So what? Of course we were. Talking about the 14th hole and. Rule 5.5 be restriction on practice strokes. After completing hole, after completing the play of the hole you can. There's certain areas of the the course that you're allowed to
practice putting and chipping. And that of course is the prior that the previous green played on any practice, green on the course and the next team near, on or near the next team area. And of course Big P was within those areas that he was practicing. So he incurred no penalties and 64% of people got the answer as four. So that was very. Good, nice.
Have you got the latest? How many strokes with your 3 club links back from the front of the tee? I23 club links on the tee? Maybe the in stroke play, Stewart makes a stroke at the ball 3 club lengths back from the front of the team markers and his ball goes into a red penalty area. He goes down to that red penalty area and takes a drop into a back on the line relief area before Ross tells him of the Ting area error back to the
correct Ting area. He goes and he now hits his shot onto the fairway. Stewart hits his next stroke onto the green very close to the hole. As he is walking up to the hole, he can see that the ball is overhanging the lip of the hole. He gets to the hole and waits 20 seconds as he thinks the ball is still moving. His ball then falls in how many strokes has Stuart had on the hole and the options were four through 7. 456 or 750% Got this one right. Chose 5.
The answer is five and the answer is five because. When Stewart played from outside the team area, he got a 2 stroke penalty and he had to correct his error. There was the hole had started but there was no ball in play. He dropped a ball into play and taking relief from the penalty area even though he wasn't allowed to but Ross. Then he realizes Ross tells him his error. And he can correct that error for no penalty under 14.5. But he still gets the penalty from teeing up outside or
playing from outside the team area. So he corrects his error, plays his ball onto the fairway three, and then he hits his ball onto the green four. He walks up to the hole, waits more than allowed 10 seconds and then his ball falls in. It does not matter I how many times I said this I don't know, but it does not matter. It does not matter if you think your ball is moving or someone else thinks your ball is moving, or it even is moving when it is
overhanging the hole and you have already waited 10 seconds. If you have already waited 10 seconds, the ball is at rest. As per rule 13.3, your ball is at rest. How many times do I have to say that? Your ball is at rest. It doesn't matter if it's if you think. It's moving or you can see it moving. It is at rest in accordance with the rules in. Accordance with the rules, it is at rest. So now when it falls in, you get
a penalty stroke if you hit it in. You own. It'll only be one stroke. You won't get a penalty for hitting a moving ball, or if it drops in. It's a penalty stroke, but your hole has finished so. He ended up with eight, five. And then of course we had the one yesterday, which currently 71% have gotten wrong. You are allowed to declare your ball lost. That is false. And this is this is verbatim from the rule.
A ball does not become lost as a result of the player declaring it lost. A ball is lost if not found in 3 minutes after the player or their caddy begins to search for it. Lost is a specific term. It doesn't mean what you think it means, as per the English Dictionary. It's a status of the ball. It is a status of the ball. It is a specific term to describe the status of the ball after three minutes of
searching. If you if you never start that search time. And you put another ball into play. That original does not become lost, it becomes an abandoned ball. You can always take the stroke and distance option for your original, but your provisional cannot act as your stroke and distance option after you've found your original ball in bounds and within the three minute search time so.
And we've had a lot of these community questions are actually pretty fun for all of us, and I'm learning just as much as anyone. We now move on to our GRQ OTW 97. Go ahead podcast star of the Talk Dirty to Me podcast McPhee Show. We should OK, I can't top that GRQ OTW episode 97 This
something happened yesterday. Blakey and Stewart are playing in an individual stroke round at Wombat Hills on the 9th hole. Stewart's ball becomes embedded in the putting green after his second shot. Not knowing what to do, he asks Blakey, who jokingly tells him he must drop the ball within A1 club length relief area on the putting green no near the hole. Stewart does this. Blakey did notice the Stewart's ball on the green, away from the embedded spot and with no bull
marker down. Blakey tells Stewart that he was only joking and you cannot get embedded ball relief on the green. How much Stewart proceed and are there any penalty strokes to either player? I totally forgot that that happened yesterday with that. That was very fun. The whole time I was thinking I'm, I'm gonna, I'm gonna stuff it up here, but I can't wait to hear the. Everyone will have to wait for the answer because I am going on tour next week, so we've got the
International Series, England up at close house in Newcastle and then the week after we've got the Fairmont, the Torrance course at Fairmont in Saint Andrews. So I will be away for a couple of weeks and then we will get back into podcasting. Although if the timing is right, you never know, I might be able to record one while on the road. We'll see. We'll see what we can do.
But for those of you waiting for the next one, most likely it will happen when I get back. OK. Thank you very much for this episode podcast. And again, thank you very much for your game yesterday. My pleasure. The the round yesterday. Not specifically your game, I think I almost threw up watching that. But thank you everyone and make sure to give us a review. Again, only give us a good one,
don't give us a bad one. But if you do have feedback that criticism or negative, we're always happy to to take that on board and try and change and make this you know a podcast for the people. So be be you know, send that in and if you haven't got your name down on the drop zone, I'm assuming that everyone has, make sure to send me an e-mail golfrules.questions@gmail.com to get your.
To subscribe to the free rules newsletter which Podcast puts together, and it's fantastic. Thank you everyone for episode 97. Speak to you again. See you again soon for episode 98.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...