Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

CLUBLAND STORIES October: We have a playing two-balls story, was this moved ball a penalty?, an unfortunate incident about a suspension of play, and MLR B-3 - THE GRQ PODCAST EP124

Oct 7, 202457 minAudio

Clubland Stories is back with the October edition as Episode 124 of the GolfRules Questions podcast. DK has two questions, including assisting another player in his group with a two ball situation. David is wondering why his friend Tom was disqualified for continuing play after a normal suspension, Brian asks about MLR B-3, and the no-penalty myth makes its way to Waimate. Thank you to all our contributors for submitting clubland stories. GRQOTW123 Answer Marvin was allowed to make a stroke at the moving ball, but taking three minutes to make that decision as the ball crept closer to the hole would be an unreasonable delay to play. GRQOTW124 Question T/F If a ball-marker might help or interfere with play, a player may move the ball-marker out of the way if it is their own ball-marker.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Clubland Stories is back with the October edition as episode 124 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. DK has two questions, including assisting another player in his group with a 2 ball situation. David is wondering why his friend Tom was disqualified for continuing play after a normal suspension. Brian asks about MLRB 3 and the no penalty myth makes its way to Wymany. Thank you to all our contributors for submitting Clubland Stories. So whether you are in your car or going for a walk, please enjoy the latest episode of the

Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Oh, you see referee David Blake there, He's obviously talking to one of the rules officials up by the green. What? Nothing kicked up. Let's go. Hey welcome everyone to the GRQ podcast episode 124.

I'm Blakey and alongside me is my Co host Stuart McPhee. Hey Blakey, how are you? Good to be here. I'm good, I'm good. How are you? You know, I'm very well. You know, I met someone yesterday who came up and we were talking about raw stuff and everything, he says. Oh, and I'll listen to your podcast as well. I couldn't believe it. It's fantastic. So probably a few people in the last week or two have physically come up to me and actually knew who I was, knew who you were, and listened to our podcasts.

And This is why we do it. So always enjoy a podcast, always enjoy a chat with you. And it's nice to know people are out there listening to our podcasts and being slightly entertained with our content. Did he have the crappy experience of the 123 episode? Why? What was the crappy? Experience because I reckon about 70 people, the people who love this podcast the most. And when I say love I'm not, I'm not sure they do love it, but

they listen to it. The first 70, it's like you get the 1st 70 within about six hours. Right. Every week and they would have those first 70. If you are one of the 1st 70 I would suggest you go back and re listen to 1/1/23 because we re uploaded it after it shot itself. It did not mention that specific podcast though. It was just a specific situation of uploading in Adobe Premiere Pro to YouTube and it didn't like it, so we redid it.

And not just YouTube to Spotify as well. So we redid it. And if you haven't gone back and listened, I'd suggest you do because it was a good, it was a good episode. I mean I droned on a bit about setup and stuff for Asian Turkey school, but we enjoyed ourselves. So go and take a listen right? First things first, the GIQOTW for 123 was Marvin hit his ball into a Creek and then waited 3 minutes while the stream took

his ball closer to the hole. Andy, the average golfer, wasn't very happy about this and so-called in a referee to help them with the situation. What are we dealing with first here and then what is the Answer Podcast? Well, we're dealing with, although there's a, there's a sort of an exception to it. We're dealing with hitting a ball that is moving. Is that right? He actually made the stroke at a ball that was moving. Yes, that's correct. When the actual stroke was made. Now I just need to find that. Sorry.

OK, It's under 9.1 all right. No, it's under 10.1 DI. Just went to 10.1010 point one DI didn't go that far, do you? Thank you. As I said, you cannot play a moving ball. We saw that with Phil Mickelson unfortunately playing a moving ball on the green and was penalised as such. However, exception 3 to that, that you're not permitted to play a moving ball as you're

saying, the rule 10.1 D exception 3 is a ball moving in water. When a ball is moving in temporary water or in water in a penalty area, the player may make a stroke at the moving ball without penalty. Or of course, they can take relief from that penalty area or temporary water and lift the moving ball and take relief. But you are actually permitted to make a stroke at that moving ball if it is in a penalty area and there's no penalty for doing so. I forgot what Marvin did after that, but there's no penalty attached to doing that. You could probably, and I can understand why people would get

upset. You could probably raise an issue about how long you waited to make that stroke. You know, we do have this thing called, you know, unreasonable delay of play. I think it's 5.6. Probably 3 minutes is probably not sufficient to probably make a claim on that, but probably puts an asterisk on that person's actions. But no penalty for playing the moving ball. Pretty good. I I like it. I I probably would. 3 minutes probably would give them a penalty for unreasonable delay.

And I think that 3 minutes, I don't know if you put it in there on purpose with regards to the time allowed for a ball search, the fact that many groups will spend 3 minutes doing something and we think, come on, you need to get moving. But of course, that player is quite entitled to spend that 3 minutes looking for their ball. So I don't know if you chose that time deliberately for that purpose. But I mean, if they spent 5 minutes waiting for that ball to continue moving closer to the hole being carried by the water and they're making a stroke at some point, yeah, everyone's going to get upset with taking that period of time, you know?

I don't have that kind of brain power to do something that deliberate righty. Oh, so this week we're going to get into October Club Land stories, although some of the stories are were submitted to us before October, but we've got the October edition of Club Land Stories. The first one is from Brian Hole 12 at Strathfield Golf Club has

a red penalty area running along right along the right hand side of the fairway potentially impacting the T-shirt. We have local rules in place, which is local rule 12th hole. If a player believes their tee shot on the 12th hole may have finished in the penalty area, the Cooks River a provisional ball may be played from the drop zone. It's a blue stake near the bridge. All penalty drops from T shots must be taken either at the designated drop zone or replayed from the T with a stroke

penalty. Dropping further up the line of the penalty area on this hole is not permitted and so the local rule dictates that if your T shot enters the penalty area, you then must either play again or use the designated drop zone with a one shot penalty. Lateral relief and back on the line relief are not available. We also have a local rule which allows a provisional ball to be played from the drop zone if there is uncertainty about whether or not your ball is in the penalty area. So Brian had his ball and it was

heading towards the penalty area but he wasn't certain that it was that had it had entered the area. He then hits a provisional ball from the drop zone he found. He found his ball in the penalty area and decide to continue playing with the original ball from inside the penalty area. Although this turned out to be a bad decision, bad decision for the score, he believes that this was correct under the rules.

His further question is what were his other options? Could he pick up his ball and use the provisional ball that he had already hit? Or does he need to return to the drop zone and hit another ball, bearing in mind that he's now found the original ball, meaning the provisional ball was now out of play and this happened obviously. 12th hole Straffield Golf Club in New South Wales. Stuart, I think you can help us out with this one. Guys that implying that I can't

help you out with most of the club questions, but Stuart, hey, this is your lucky day. You can help the. Time I'd take over and talk too much so all I do I'm essentially going to give me the opportunity I. I am going to say this local rule is an authorised local rule under B3, which Stuart was going to tell us anyway. I. Was going to mention model local rule B3, which I know you love Blakey and I say that with the most sarcasm I can. I know you hate this rule. So this rule is if you're not sure if a ball's in a penalty

area or not, you can play a provisional ball under this model like rule B3 which you hate. So what I find interesting here, so the player has actually played a provisional ball from the drop zone which the committee has put in place for that penalty area. And once the original ball is found, effectively the committee are now giving the player the choice without a continue play with the original ball or the provisional ball was hit correctly because it was dropped. The drop the drop zone for a ball that is in a penalty area.

So the player now can choose, unless I'm mistaken. Yeah, that's what model local rule B3 is saying. And that which is probably. Play here at Strathfield. Which is probably the reason why you don't like it, because you're now giving the player the choice whether they can. I mean, what the play, what the person submitting the story is saying is, well, I have to abandon my provisional because I found my original. And of course, under normal, normal circumstances, under 18.3, that is exactly right. But in this particular case, that's not the case at all.

Again, the rules are providing you that option where you can continue to play with the original ball or you have played one provisionally because your ball is now known to be inside that penalty area. And he could have played that provisional that he had played from the dropping zone. And we could talk about dropping zones as well. And we can also talk about the committee removing two of the options available to players under a red penalty area as well-being. 17.1 D 2:00 and 3:00.

Yeah. Well, I mean, we could talk about them. How about we do talk about them, OK? Let's do that. I will say one thing about the dropping zone is no, I think it's more along the lines of the dropping zone. You know, you, you set up courses more than I do. And we use dropping zones for specific purposes, make it easy for players for an option. But when have you ever known a dropping zone to be compulsory? I'd be say really.

I'm not sure that I've ever made Oh, actually, no, I don't think you actually made a dropping zone compulsory. I I do know of them and they have happened at Clubland actually maybe when I was at No, I was going to say when I was at Spring Valley, but that was just you compulsory, like it was a no play zone so you had to take relief but we didn't actually have a dropping zone that you had to take relief into.

You could still go near his point. Yeah, that's right. So it's it's always an an extra option. So now I can't recall too many situations or no no situations with me involved where I've and a compulsory dropping. Zone. I guess my general commentary. SO model local rule E1 covers dropping zones and typically 99.9% of the time committees use them as an additional relief option to players rather than

not only you absolutely must go there. You know, players often choose them because they're easy and they're obvious and they don't have to work out relief areas, they can just go to the dropping zone. But it's interesting that a committee says no, no, that's exactly where you have to play. But they're actually now taking away 2, you know, relief options available for a ball in a penalty area, which I find odd as well. I I do wonder if the the back on the line doesn't make you know there's not an option because it's up against the boundary. The way it's physically like, yeah.

But I'm just wondering why the lateral leaf is being taken away. And I'd love to have a take a look at the like an overhead shot of this, you know, is it such, is it created such that it sort of looks like you're always dropping closer to the hole or something? No, it's a good point you make about back on the line. Typically drop zones are even thought about in the 1st place because we think they can't even go back on the line.

There's just no back on the line option that goes all the way back through to the penalty area and then it's the boundary fence. There is no option but the lateral. That seems odd to take that option away from them. And we're not saying that there's no viable valid reason of them removing it, but I just never even heard of that being taken away. Like why even have it as a red penalty area in the 1st place? Just call it a yellow penalty area. You're right, and typically you know what the dropping zones do is provide an additional relief option for players rather than

substituting or taking away and giving them one back. But. Yeah. But yeah, I mean, you could just call it a yellow penalty area and you've got stroke and distance and then the back in the line. Back in the line. Yeah, but that might not be a thing because of the boundary or just say that's not available and then they have the dropping zone on top of that. So, you know, why call it a red one and then take away the lateral relief option? I'm not sure. As I said, you know, it might be

a valid reason. I'd love to see if an overhead shot of the of the whole. But back to the actual model like rule that they've got in place, it does allow you to choose if you, if you find your ball, if you don't find your ball, the provisional ball is the ball in play. And then because they've taken away those other rule, those other options, it, it actually does make it a lot simpler, a lot cleaner. Yeah.

I mean, 'cause I just, you know, going around doing these workshops, I didn't realize that provisional ball was so difficult to understand. And so if you're, if provisional ball's so hard to understand, then you're introducing something else about provisional balls in a penalty area. You know, it just makes it a lot, lot harder. It's like provisional ball's hard enough, penalty area's hard enough. Combine the two.

Makes it even harder from my point of view. You know, one of the funniest things and, and you probably get this a little bit more now that you're answering rules questions from around clubs now that people don't realise, you know, they play by their rules and they say their rules, hopefully the rules are golf and their local rules, their club. But they don't realise those local rules are only local to them. And then they go and play other places and just assume that what they do at their club they can

do elsewhere. Like, you know, if you go and play at a club, that if you play at a club, you know, every week and it's the only club you play at and it doesn't have penalty areas. Yeah, when you get to another club that has penalty areas, it might be quite difficult to understand what you're supposed to do. So yeah, come back to the point combining penalty areas and provisional balls into a local rule just for me. It just seems like a recipe for disaster is probably the easiest

way to say it. Well, you're just saying then about going, you're doing your own thing all the time at your club and then going somewhere else. I can think of two things related to penalty areas. 1 is when players have never seen a yellow stake before and they go to another course and see a yellow penalty area. It blows their mind because they don't know what to do. And the other thing is when a committee deems penalty area stakes as immovable. So, you know, all the time you play at clubs, you can't touch them. And then you go to another club and someone just pulls it out of the ground and hits and you go, you can't, you can't do that. And the guy from that club goes what are you talking about?

Course I can. That, that happens a lot on tour actually. And you, you know this, that you're playing a tour event at the course and you know, you've got a walking scorer who might be the captain of the club or might be on the committee or just, you know, just a really good member of the, of the, of the club. And they're The Walking scorer. And the player wants has got interference with a stake. And, you know, hopefully The

Walking scorer doesn't get themselves involved, but it might just be that they. Want. And try and think that they're helping, which is fine, but the player goes, oh, I'll wait for a referee. And you go over there as a referee. The first thing you do is you walk in, you pull it out and throw it on the ground and then just walk away. Drive off. I'll wait for the package. But the player's happy, but everyone else is just like, what the hell just happened? I told you the story from the Queensland PGA Championship last year. Well, your fellow ex countrymen. It must have.

It must have sat in my head. And so. But it, it it didn't just happen to you. It's happened to me. Yeah. And then and then you, you might be, you know, hanging around afterwards like a bad smell. And that person, The Walking squad comes out and goes. What? What was that? You're not allowed to remove. Yeah, penalty area stakes at this club and you go. I've been on the committee 52 years, yeah. And that in your club, in your tournament, your competition,

that might be true. But this, we're playing a different tournament with a different set of local rules. And in our local rules, if it's movable, it's movable. Anyway, back to. The, and I wanted to mention one other thing about your situation back to the club land story was there's very few times when you're not permitted to play your ball in play as it lies. So when he found his ball in the penalty area and it was the ball in play, I should say if it's a

ball in play, he's permitted to play it. Yeah, the very few times you're not allowed to play it. Yeah. So go through those. But yeah, if it was, I think we said if it wasn't found, the provisional ball is ball in play. But if it was found, the B3 does give you the option. You play the original as it lies. You don't get to take the original and go back and choose a relief option. You've already taken your relief option by playing the provisional.

And then if the provisional is in a stuffed air position, then you just have to, yeah, choose between the two. Which you don't like. And I get. I get that. If the original has been found, yeah, I, I don't like but again, this is quite this is quite interesting this one because they take away the lateral relief. So even if you want to. Do yeah, you see the penalty, the ball just inside the penalty area. Yeah, take the leaf for the original that. Yeah, that's, that's right.

What if you hit your provisional in the penalty area? Then you play the provisional. You play the original. If you found it or you, you go back taking relief for the provisional, not the original. What I find with that say that I know we don't know where the dropping zone is, but you may find your ball just inside the penalty area, like half a metre inside the red line and lack of relief. The Dropping Zone's an e-mail that you get every week, Stuart. Yeah, the the lateral relief option may have you 100 meters

forward of where you're hitting that third shot from the dropping zone. I don't know, I don't know the layer of the hole, but it just seems a little unfair to remove that option if you know where it crossed last cross the edge of that penalty. You can just drop it right there anyway, as opposed I'm. Not going to make the statements like that because I don't know the hole. But no, no, again, don't know the layout. As I said, I kind of like this. I don't. I just don't know why you would call it red when you've taken away the lateral relief call. It two of the three options. Call it yellow, that helps. And B, yeah, I don't know what

it looks like. So there's no use sort of making those kind of assumptions, but taking away those two options does help in actually having instigating this local rule, adopting this local rule anyway. Simpler for players. Yeah. But yeah, then there's another part of it, you know, if you do adopt these, this local rule B3, it's another part that you have to try and explain to your members. Yeah, educate your members about YEAH. There's a specific penalty area

on this course that you are allowed to play a provisional, but when you play a provisional it's this or this. If I may digress a little, had a conversation last week. They want to bring in a penalty area on the left of 1 hole only in a 36 hole complex and excuse me and I sorry, put in a penalty, not a penalty. I'd take that back. They wanted to make model local rule E5 in effect just for that one hole where you come out from to the fairway and play, you

know, take two penalty strokes and continue play the hole which you have laws left. Yeah, under model local rule E5. And I just simply said if you do adopt this, there's that further education for your members. Or you could encourage people to play a provisional ball if you're in any doubt, right? So if there's any doubt left, you won't find it or is out of bounds, encourage them to play a provisional ball and we just make it simpler. Anyway, we were just having that conversation last week. Sorry. It was nothing to do with the penalty. It was not a local rule E5. Yeah, but education members try.

I mean, sometimes the rules can be harsh. I understand that, but I think the education of the simpler rule is easier than the education of the tougher rule. And people have known about a provisional ball for a long time. That's yeah, that's right. And. Why we have it? No, Why? We have it in the rules. Yeah, they've only had sort of a small change to it in the, you know, in that big rule change, and that was just. You used to be able to. It used to be, now, I'm sorry, I'm going to confuse people, but it used to be that if you hit

your ball from where you thought your original was or nearer, they had a better way of saying it than what I just said it. Then the provisional was the ball in play. Now it's just nearer. So it used to be at or nearer, now it's just nearer the hole. Then the provisional ball becomes the ball in play. But yeah, it's basically the same, right? Moving on to, I hope that answered. That was a long club land

answer. Brian's question right next one is Colin from Wymaddy, Rule 9.4 B. You know that one, Stuart. Ball lifted or moved or whatever? Yeah, your own ball. Playing that 18th at Wymaddy Stableford round, Tom is below the green in the general area. Below the green. I think he I means in the it's a depth out there in the dip. Tom is chatting to his playing partners, just swinging his club back and forth but not practice swinging.

When he clips his ball backwards he replaces his ball to the comments of his fellow players saying no penalty. They changed that rule a few years ago. Collin thinks that is not correct and with the haggle and the balance thinks a penalty shot should be added. But mob rule prevailed and no penalty was taken. General opinion in the club was no penalty. Colin checks RNA website and finds a video explaining accidental swings and tee box, January and putting green. Colin makes no headway so decides to ask the real experts

and they lost the haggle by 1 hole. You've been robbed Colin. Robbed. Is that a penalty, Stuart? Unfortunately, it is. So the ball's in the general area off the putting green. We know in the teeing area and on the putting green, you can be the clumsiest golfer and you can accidentally move your ball all over the place and there's no penalty for doing so, whether you're taking a few practice swings or not. But if you're in the balls in the general area, and I know you'd love this rule, you need to be very careful around your

ball and accidental movement or otherwise you move your ball in play, you're going to cop one penalty strike for doing that. Exactly right so Tom has caused his ball to move in the general area. That's a one stroke penalty. He does need to replace it. They were correct about that. But he's going to get a one shot penalty and you should demand your money back going I'll. Definitely go to the committee about that. Next one DK.

No, no. Playing a awesome stroke event at Dingo Jones, Player A hit his T-shirt on the 13th hole whilst her partner and another side playing in the same group were having a lovely chat beside the tee box. The others don't see the shot, but Player A said she had a good one that went over the small Crest at the start of the fairway and down the middle. The group walk over the Crest and down the fairway but cannot locate the ball anywhere, even

though they suspected it would have been in the middle of the fairway. The players searched for three minutes but the ball was not found. The players come to the conclusion that a crow must have taken the ball away. There is no other reasonable explanation. Player B drops drops another ball, the approximate location that a partner believes the original ball would have come to rest. They play out the hole and record 5 strokes before continuing on with their round. After the round, the players report what happened to the committee and the debate ensures

about or enthuse about whether this was the correct procedure or not. For further context, there is a fairway bunker on the side with. There is light rough either side of the fairway but there's no thick grass or fescue. There is no penalty area. There are some trees in the rough but they have high limbs and there are no bushes. Furthermore, there's been no other instances of crows taking balls and there was no crows spotted in the area when the players were on that hole. What happened to this DK's?

So funny. What happened to this? This group or the players? The committee agreed to disqualify the side after weighing up the facts, believing that although it was probable the ball was moved by an outside influence, there wasn't virtual certainty that a crow took the ball and the player made a serious breach by playing from the wrong place instead of returning to the tee. Where did this happen? On a crowless golf course at Dingo James, Yeah. I mean, what can we say?

When DK puts puts a story in, it's pretty close to the truth, so. And he gives us the answer too. If you, I think the committee will write in this one, I mean, if you, if you can't just claim that someone took your ball or something took your ball. If you don't have any evidence and just because your ball is not where it should be, is not is not enough evidence. It actually isn't because there's a lot of people out there that think their ball has gone somewhere. You know, they hit it 250 meters

when they only hit it 200 meters. They hit it straight as a knot as an arrow when they you know, it had a massive cut on it. It there's there are other possibilities of where this ball could have been. It could have just been sitting in the bunker. It took a terrible bounce, you know, hit a sprinkler head in the middle of the fairway. And it was over a blind Crest. It could have hit the bag of another player playing in the group in front and gone late. Number one rule, if you can't

find your ball, you don't have any evidence that someone stole it. Then stroking distance, bad luck. That's pretty pretty straightforward. I don't get how people would mixing that up with there's something else. Then I think, you know, they say it's probable, but probable is not 95%. It's not known or virtually certain, maybe a dangerous. And we say this and we say this all the time that KVC is a very high standard.

You have to reach 95% is a very high standard. It's 19 times out of 20 that's what happened. And and I think the question at the start mentioned that the player hit, but everyone else was sort of not watching anyway. They were doing their own thing or talking to themselves or something. I think something like that. But so another just backing up what you said that often the ball doesn't go where we think it went or we didn't see it cut light or something and that ball could be anywhere. Yeah, DK submitted this last month, a month ago and then we

actually had a massive chat about crows in our Asian Tour Q school because we did actually have crows. And we again we to reiterate, we positioned spotters on one hole particularly because crows were just flying down and picking up the balls. So. Well trained crows. Those awesome volunteers help us out, but if you don't have, you know, evidence, then, yeah, bad luck. All right, we've got David here

in our club Stroke Play Championship. I was paired with Tom. Another Tom on the 14th hole. I had marked and lifted my ball when the horn blew, suspending play for the day due to darkness. Tom then marked and lifted his ball. I said wait as we've already started the hole, we can finish, let's do that. Tom agreed, replaced his ball when we finished in the hole in the clubhouse.

In the clubhouse we were informed that Tom was DQ, but I was OK Tom said he didn't understand and neither did I. This happened at the Quicksand Golf Club in San Angelo, TX. Can you explain to David why David was OK but Tom was dequeued? Why was he dequeued though that you? You were supposed to supply the

answer to that, Stuart, so well. We know that. Sorry, I believe I'll give you a quick thought process of what I'm saying. Yeah, if you. It says that it was suspended due to darkness, so it wasn't an exactly. So it's. Not a immediate suspension. Exactly. It's a play is suspended. You stop now, or you can finish out the rest of the whole. If one of your group has started that hole, you can go keep going.

So Tom decides to stop, which is completely fine, Marks and lifts, and then he's convinced to continue the hole when the committee hasn't resumed play. OK, I've just found it. That's what found the question. I found the answer in the rule. No, I found the answer, yeah. That's what I'm thinking. So have we got, have you got a clarification that speaks to

that exactly? So I'm just in 5.7 and as you said, under 5.7 about what's the official title of 5.7, stopping play and resuming play. So in a 5.7 B, it covers the two types of committee suspensions. 1 is immediate as you mentioned, which is clearly danger and we see that often. We say lightning in the area, it's just stop play, it's dangerous to continue to play. So that's a stop straight away. But the other one is a normal suspension, which is say

darkness, which is in this particular case or maybe a few greens are coming a little bit unplayable with a bit too much water pooling. So they'll call that a normal suspension. And if you're playing a hole, then you can continue to play that hole if, but if you continue to play that hole, you can either complete it or stop. So you can actually get up to the green and go, oh, didn't realize there was so much water here. And you can actually then stop. However, any, I'm just reading it here. What players must do when.

Yeah, sorry. Go on. Once the players complete the hole, stop before completing the hole. They must not make another stroke. Exactly, that's that's what I was getting into. So because Tom has decide to stop and that was his intent to stop. Marking the ball and lifting it I think is a very clear action. I assume they've always in the general area, not on the green or somewhere else on the course. I don't think it matters. You're allowed to mark it wherever on the course you want.

No, but I think if you're on the putting green and you marked and lifted your ball and then replaced it, you could say no. No, I was just continuing to play the hole. I was just marking my ball on the green. Saying no no, but what is your actual? No, I get that. But there isn't there is an excuse for doing that on the putting green in a general area. There's not. Clearly, if you marked and lifted that ball, you really don't have any other intention. Well. Anything defensible is there. If well, you do, if you're in the general area, you could say no, no, I was just cleaning my ball and give me a one shot. Doing that would be better than. Through that plausible.

That would be better than than. I understand. Than a disqualification, I'm not. Saying I was just identifying it. I'm just saying. And the committee could have looked at that and gone well. What was your actual intention? Were you just cleaning it and LED them down that path if they really wanted to help them out but they. You would think that person would go, yeah, would go. No, no. I thought we were stopping. Didn't know we could keep playing. I stopped and then there's obviously then continue to play the hole. That's where the issue is, yeah. Yeah. So David, because Tom decided to

stop and it was pretty clear from what you've written in the question or the the Clubland story that he did decide to stop. He must now not continue and as the the committee just went by the letter of the law that. 3rd bullet point. 75.7 B2 Once the players complete the hole or stop before completing the hole, which is what Tom did, they must

not make another stroke. Unfortunately though, 5.7 B is quite clear about once you make that decision to stop, you've stopped. You're committed, pot committed. You're you're committed to that action. Yeah, exactly right. And that hence David, that is why Tom was penalised as. And hopefully online next time. As unjust as it sounds, that is how the rule was written. It does seem like a harsh penalty, especially when the other 3 in your group are still playing. But what do you think? And the other three keep playing

in, hole out. Which is allowed. Absolutely right. That's why I think it's such a harsh penalty and then they have to. All you did was put a. For the next win, it resumes play. They have to wait for you while you. All you did was put AT in the ground and lift your ball up and you disqualified. I know you put it back and played it, but you know what I mean. Right, next question from Simon. They play. Simon played a four ball Staleford in a competition competition against other local clubs with two middle-aged ladies in the flight.

It was a very pleasant game but the other ladies were constantly watching what we were doing and once in a while commented on our procedures taking relief. Being a club referee myself, I noticed their rules knowledge was not, so to speak, of a very high level. At some moment I saw one of them lift a ball, shake it a bit and replace it for no apparent reason in the middle of the fairway. She didn't mark it, I said, what are you doing? She said. There was a bee on the ball. I said, but then you can just play it. She said. Certainly I cannot, I couldn't

hit AB, That is pathetic. Her partner arrived and confirmed, of course we cannot hit AB, we are animal lovers. As a referee, I doubted whether I should accept that. But on the other hand, we had a wonderful day and I didn't want to spoil it by getting into a dispute with some nice ladies. In fact, that was not all she lifted, not her own ball, but that of her partner playing full ball. The lady was allowed to handle the ball of her partner when applying the rule, but then again, in this case she didn't follow an applicable rule. So I had to tell her that there

was not only a penalty stroke, but since she lifted her partner's ball, the penalty was not for herself, but for her partner. At that moment they had already so many strokes that they couldn't score Stanford points in that hole anyway and I was certain that they wouldn't accept to play a ball with AB on it, plus not understand whether one lady lifted a ball and the other lady would have had to count a penalty stroke. I decided the best thing to do was leave it and just say OK, we continue to have a pleasant game. This happened in the Netherlands a couple of week weeks ago. So because they only had 28

points or less, the rules don't have to apply. This is, I mean, this is what, this is what Simon's saying, you know, is a pleasant game with pleasant people, and he didn't want to ruin it by getting the the rules involved. And it's it's. Basically what I say, all my workshops, those who have a good knowledge of the rules of golf are continue considered bad sportsman.

Yeah. I mean I understand where you're coming from. You don't want to get offside with these people and golf is a small community, but at the same time you know it's on them that they have to play by the rules. If they sign up to play a game. You have to play by all the rules, especially when the game of golf is self officiating. If you could just sneak 1 past the umpire or referee I would

understand. You don't have to tell them and they can just do it, but. Because it's selfish officiating. You're supposed to play by all the rules, not just the chosen for a few. And they have a vested interest in what the other people are doing because they're in the same competition as him. Yeah, but as I said, if they don't win then. Oh, that's right. Points. 28 points or less, you don't have to worry about them. I always forget that exception. Yeah, Rule 26. It was 25 but we moved it.

Are you not going to say digress? Our last two clubland stories have been from other countries and one from the United States and from the Netherlands. That is fantastic to get clubland stories from anywhere but especially from overseas and nice to know everyone was in. Colin from New Zealand all the time. OK, that too. That just seems really close by. Thank you, Simon. We're not. We're certainly not hassling you because you obviously have knowledge of the rules. I knew they were doing the wrong thing, yeah. And straight away.

And I would just. You know if. Then rules knowledge is not so high. Pretty poor, it seems. You're just going to have to help them out. If if you don't want to give them a penalty, understand, don't tell me, but at least at the very least just educate them. And that's, and that's the best that we can hope for because as I say to most people, you know, it is selfish officiating. It is build on integrity and honesty.

But they the rules are very hard to learn and as a beginner you learn them over time by playing with other people. The the bad thing is if you play with people that don't know the rules then you learn bad habits. Knowing you're as well as I could, but. From the right people, then. I'm not saying you're going to learn straight away in your first game, second game, third game, because these situations take a long time to you know, to come up and some may never do, some may never do. But if you can at least educate

them, then they'll know for next time. OK, she doesn't want to hit a ball with the B on it. Tell her that she can try and move it with AT by trying to touch the B or. Send it on a journey with your 5 seconds. Take penalty relief for a penalty one. That's probably an easier situation for her. Go answer. And leave the ball where it is and use another ball substitute, yeah. For a penalty of one, no. No, I'm saying yeah and taking the relief option. You said like penalty area, sorry, as in penalty relief are

unplayable, go back on the line. Or just substitute a ball and. Drop another ball. I had a player last Wednesday who on the 12th hole left were looking for his ball. Probably close to 3 minutes. I found it said I think it's here. He comes down, it's in thick grass, picks it up, puts it back down. Yeah, that's it. And so I like you said education. I didn't say anything at the time, but we're in the lounge afterwards and I said are you interested in learning about something you did wrong today? He goes, yeah, yeah. I said on the explain what happened. I said you've got to mark it to

one penalty stroke. I just said I hate to bite you on the bum when you're playing a match against someone and they pick you up for it and you don't know, just trying to help because again, you say you don't want to be that bad guy. You and I are both very bad guys and people don't want to play with us like. Yeah, I don't even want to play with myself. Anyway, moving on DK again, I was playing for once. He obviously does. He works more than he plays. In a tournament recently which

had an 18 hole stroke play event on my home course. Upon check in with the pro shop, I collected my scorecard and was advised that all bunkers are out of play due to heavy overnight rain and resultant damage to the bunkers. To confirm, I asked if this meant the bunkers were GUR and I could play the ball as it lies if it happened to have a favorable lie. I'm a much better bunker player than I am a chipper these days. The pro said you must take a drop out of the bunker if your ball was in it.

OK, no play zone ACC it is I guess. On my way around the first few holes I noticed most of the bunkers were in poor condition and could completely understand them being deemed gur. It appeared the greenkeepers had driven a machine through each bunker to try and churn up the sand and silt. There was deep tread tire tracks throughout the bunker bases but they were all unraked. No time to completely repair them before the tournament commenced. On the 6th hole a fellow

competitor in my group hit their T-shirt to the right and ended up in what I know as a sandy waste area. We got to the ball's location and the ball was in a terrible lie with clumps of wet sand all around it. He said I'll take a drop outside of this bunker. I stopped him and said hang on, I'm pretty sure this is a sandy waste area, it is not actually a bunker. He looked at me like I had two heads and then said this is clearly a bunker. I looked at the area and could see that the greenkeepers drove the machine all over the sand.

It had the same tire tracks as the other bunkers throughout. It was in terrible condition and definitely should have been GUR in my opinion. But there was one key difference for me. There were no bunker Rakes to be seen. I said to the player, if this was supposed to be a bunker, wouldn't there be bunker Rakes in it like all the other bunkers? He couldn't believe it and was baffled at the situation. I could see that this logic made sense to him and it probably had some credibility as this was my home course. He'd not played there before. This was the perfect time for me to bring out my favorite rule. Why don't you play 2 balls and

we can check when we get in? Oh. I reckon he would have looked at him like he had three heads after that three, not realizing this was an option. It made complete sense to him and life came back into his face. It took some of the heat away from me too. I didn't want to get into any arguments over a drop. He played the original and then a second ball from the relief area. He played out the hole with both balls and on went on. We went to chop it around the rest of the course we checked with the pro shop acting on behalf of the committee. Very important to know that after the round, who in fact

confirmed the area was a sandy waste and not deemed a bunker, the score from the original ball counted in the play actually thanked me for letting him play 2 balls. Despite this I do think that the area should have been GUR because the track the tractor drove all through it and I'm almost certain others in the tournament would have taken free relief without any doubt of being the correct procedure. It also got me thinking, what if that that area was an MPZACC and the player played two balls as he was unsure how to proceed. Would he get a general penalty for playing a ball from an MPZ

in this instance? Would love for the brains trust to discuss on the pod. Thanks lads, nice work DK. What do you think about all that, Stuart? Love the fact that people are out there promoting 20.1 C three and then he's playing 2 balls in stroke play. Love it. Here's my first comment. There's a couple of things stuck at me. Obviously DK knows the two ball rule. What? Yeah, trying to get someone to

play. Very impressive. Very impressive. Which is the which ball did the player nominate? Did he mention that to count? It doesn't nominate. OK. But because he wasn't allowed to take free relief, that mean the second ball. Played in the lead area. Wasn't it would have been a two shot penalty, general area, wrong place. Yeah. So he had to take the score with the original.

Which he played from the waste area. Yeah, yeah. As it lied so I should say yeah. I mean, it's interesting because the the tractor drove through all of it and if there were deep wheel marks, the committee, I mean, obviously the the pro shop acting on behalf of the committee, they could have actually gone out, gone out to that area, taken the player out and said, where was your ball?

Are you? That's that's actually in our mind, That's Dur. So you were allowed to take free relief and given him, but obviously no one did that and they just said no, you weren't allowed to take fair relief. So bad luck. Although if it's a sandy waste area, I mean it's a waste area, you know, each. You're expecting a perfect life. It's not necessarily shitty, but in my mind, if you you get what you get when you go into those places. Yeah, typically not in the

middle of the fairway. Yeah, spot on. But yeah, the, the playing, the two balls. The the second really thing that sticks out to me here is when he said others in the tournament would have taken free relief, free relief without any doubt of being the correct procedure. So because DK knows the rules so well, he's actually, and I don't

want to encourage, discourage this, he's actually disadvantaged the other person or because he's playing with him, people who aren't playing with DK or aren't playing with you or aren't playing with me that don't know the rules, they can just do whatever they like. Which which? In my mind, I'd really hate, I hate that you could play with a rules nerd. You could play with someone who knows the rules, which is about 1% of the population, and you

might get more penalties than you would do if you play with 99% of the population. Or yeah, not get the same brakes that other groups are giving their mates. Yeah, take a drop out of that, mate. That's right, just go for it. Take a free drop. Take a free. Drop yeah, that's yeah the they said it was all out of play so just get out of there Oh, I don't think it's a bunker. No, yeah, of course it is Darren, but it's all sand it. Worries me a little bit, but what? Can you do? Unless every group has a walking referee at club level.

Imagine. If making the adjustments in handicaps. Imagine if you had to pay on a on a Saturday for a volunteer or no for a paid person as you're walking referee to go. Around with you part of your fees. It would actually be great for the referee union. As I said, imagine the handicaps are to move. We've had a referee with them all the time. That'll blow out, I'll tell you that. No comment. I mean the handicap system's rubbish anyway because no one

plays by the rules, so how can you justify the the correct handicaps? A well done in the DK for knowing the rules and presenting us with two hotline stories today, but. And he's and he's what he did want. A question asked would he get a penalty for playing the ball from the MPZ in this instance? I think if that became the ball in play then yes, but if it wasn't the ball that was chosen in the end, I don't think so. I don't think it's like that 6.3 C clarification where solely

from playing that ball. No, no, because you can't play. You can't make a wrong place penalty with a different ball. That's what I mean, like ball that you hit solely playing with that ball. Yeah, in that particular case, that penalty is attached to that ball. And certainly with two ball, the two ball rule, they actually specifically say, you know this this, these rules apply specifically for this ball and these rules apply specifically

for that ball. So if that area was a no play zone, the fact that he's played from the no play zone mean would mean that that ball is not correct in the relief taking. And yes, there would be a penalty applied if it became the ball and play. But the one that was actually correct, or more correct, we'll say the one that was the relief was taken would be become the ball and play and then you don't

incur the wrong place penalty. If I mean to make it more complicated, if you played from the no play zone with one ball and then the relief area or where you dropped was actually into another no play zone and you did play it from there, then the committee would have to decide which one would be the

board account. And I would think it would be the one that you did take relief because you are supposed to take relief, but then you've still played it from the wrong place. You were closer to doing the right thing because it was an effort made. That's what I think. Yeah, how the committee would, yeah. And that's how if I was on the committee, that's probably how I would. You're closer to doing the right thing by taking relief, even though you took relief in the wrong place. OK, that's very good. That's all of our Clubland stories and DK leading the way.

He's now on 17 Clubland Story. We love them. We also had Colin contribute again, he's now on 12. Brian had his second one, so he's now on two and then we had a couple of newbies as well and and Simon and David. So thank you everyone that contributed to the October edition of Clubland Stories. I now have a simple, I think simple GRQOTW for episode 24 No 124 and it is this.

If a ball marker might help or interfere with play, a player may move the ball marker out of the way if it is their own ball marker. That's a true or false question. Truer file server ball marker might help or interfere with player. Player may move the ball marker out of the way if it is their own ball marker. Hopefully everyone gets that one right. Thank you very much podcast. Any final words? No. No. Are we going to pop up our or sort of, you know, pump up our

podcast that we want to do soon regarding something about being rogue? Because we need to commit to doing that. I reckon it'd be a lot of fun. Yep. Yep. How many stories we're going to do? Committee's gone rogue? How many stories have we got so far? I reckon 6 or 7. We'll probably just need to do it next next episode or the episode after that. And what we should do is put a call out if anyone out there at their club thinks that committee's done something that's probably slightly off and they've gone a bit rogue, we'd love to hear that because we'd

love to discuss it. Without naming the club, of course. Well that is that is the shout out. Also, along with what DK sort of said, does your just think about this? Does your pro shop A know the rules? Probably not B act on behalf of the committee. This is very important. Does the pro shop act on behalf of the committee? If they don't, then when you come in and you ask a question and the pro shop says one thing

and that's not correct, you can still be liable for disqualification. But if they do ACT on it, are they up with the play on what the rules are and can give you the correct answer and that the committee would actually give as well? Very good. Thank you very much everyone for listening or watching wherever you are in the world. Get those clubland stories in

again and hopefully we can do a N1.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode