The Old Course at St Andrews, Immovable Obstructions Out of Bounds, and more... | THE GRQ PODCAST EP61 GRQOTW#61 Gerry hits his tee shot way left into some thick bushes and therefore decides to play a provisional ball, which lands in the rough on the left hand side of the fairway. Gerry finds his original ball within 3 minutes however it is deep within the bushes and clearly unplayable. His lateral and back on the line relief options are equally impractical so he decides his only option would be to return to his previous place played. Having already played his provisional from the teeing area and to ensure he doesn't delay play any further, he plays his provisional ball from where it was lying and counts that as his 4th stroke. Is this permitted? We clarify the IVORs that came out of last week. Stuart and Blakey delve into the Rules situations that may pop up at the Old Course, St Andrews for the 150th Open Championship. We look at a few community questions and what constitutes water on the surface. Enjoy
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode of the golf rules questions podcast.
Hi, everyone. Welcome to episode 61 of the GoPros questions podcast. You'll hear with Blakey as your host and my co-host. This week again is Stuart McPhee. If they have you along Stuart, thanks Blackie. Good to be here and by good to have you along what I mean is. Pretty much a backbone of the show. Now, my disorganization doesn't help and you're very generous only after picking up all the
pieces to make sure this thing gets to every every week or every team of IT team Turin of every ten days. Yes, yeah, it is a team effort. I mean there's one guy doing all the work and Swans around and doesn't doesn't do anything right. First of all, we're going to, we're going to talk some open rules this week. First, round of the open. It's finished. We're going to get through the golf balls question of the week.
Come alive is from last week, big Ivers by myself. Not great. And then we'll talk a few of the community questions that were put up recently. So, yeah, let's get into it. Golf rules question of the week for episode 60 was Stuart. So this is Ross on the last hole, hit near out of bounds but he's ball remained in bounds in the general area. And then when taking his stands for his next stroke, he had to And on a concrete pipe, which
was embedded in the ground outside the course boundary, which was interfering with him. And I just simply ask what the options were for that. So for that the concrete pie being artificial is automatically an obstruction and it just needs to work out of its movable or immovable and it's embedded in the ground, it's concrete. Therefore it's immovable. And normally you have you get free relief if your ball is on that or it interferes with your area intended stance or are Area of intended swing. And in this case it interview with Ross's area of intended
stance. However, there was one problem with this one and that was that the object itself. The immovable obstruction was outside the course. Boundary there for Ross, was unable to get free relief from that immovable obstruction. So his only options were the one that you gave away and that was, he could play it as allies and the only other options available to you in word to take unplayable for Relief under one of the three options. Level to him but that's it. Nothing for free. Very nicely explained their Stewart.
So 16.1 a to relief allowed anywhere on the course except when balls and County area relief from interference by the abnormal course, condition is allowed under rule, 16 .10, nearly when both that abnormal course condition. It is on the course and it even has in Brackets, not out of bounds. Sounds. So the pipe that still it was talking about was out of bounds. Hence, why Rosco couldn't get free relief from that one?
Here you go sir. As I said in one of the comments so why I remember that is immovable obstructions. I want to for abnormal course conditions, the key word being course. And of course this was not on the course. Therefore you don't get relief. Same with temporary water outside. The core is not on the course. Yeah. That's and that's a good one. What about Tim? Water in a tree. But what about temporary water and it's right, you know, have rains. Okay, I'll get that. And then already is sitting on
the leaves of the tree. It's the tree and downs, and you cut in the trees, and vans you come along, and you go to place shop. But there's water dripping down your neck from the leaves and you go. I've got temporary water. Can you, can you claim temporary water? They're still don't know. I'm Gonna Leave. Try to guess what? We have a look at the definition of temporary water. Any temporary accumulation of water on the surface of the ground, the ground. Okay.
So would you think that Leaves of the tree with a surface of the ground. I know it's almost the equivalent of rain. I certainly wouldn't think it was the surface of the ground, so no free relief there. Yeah. Is there an obstruction is there an obstruction? Whether it be under a rule or local rule that you could get relief from if it was lying out of bounds, if it was situated out of bounds, This is my
thinking face just two things you can think of if something was both out of bounds and in bounds but it's the same object, I'm just thinking aloud here. Part of me. This one is well, an easy one. But would you say that if you
were standing on a jacket or a towel, right? If you're standing on a towel, the fact that you get to remove that tell would you call that relief? The fact you get 2. So the jacket or towel is a movable obstruction. Yeah and you are moving eared but I wouldn't say you are you getting relief but your balls not moving you know ball is not moving as a result of that. I always think when you're taking really cue balls, going to end up in a different spot, maybe that's not the technical
definition but that's how I think of it as you're taking relief. From something you're moving away from it. In that case, it's the object itself to getting moved away and your ball remains were it, is yeah, interesting. I would say it says 15 point to this rule covers free relief. That is allowed from artificial objects that meet the definition of move or obstruction. Okay relief from move obstruction, 15.2 a removal of movable obstruction. So effectively it's a
technicality. There you are taking relief. That's right, my if you're standing on a towel, you get to move the tower, you get effectively that saying that that is a a type of relief. Sure. That makes sense. Yeah, I mean you could you could almost argue both points there and say well the heating is relief, remove the obstruction but you're just removing the movable destruction. I mean, in a case of jackets getting relief, it's getting out of the way under to. Yeah, that's right. Under two and three, it actually
States relief in boards in Oran, so that would be That would be, it may be a technicality. I'm happy to argue it both ways on that one but I'd say you are getting relief if you are moving. Yeah, struction away so it doesn't interference and so do. As I said I think the objects getting relaxed, not you. But anyway, something's happening and there is some release there is relief available, right? So thatthat was a technicality but that wasn't the one I was initially thinking of the other
one I was thinking of was the local rule If 23. So local rule, if twins temporary removal obstruction. Yes, temporary immovable obstruction. So that is off the course. You still can get a line of sight thing as a yes, you can. So say, there's a boundary that goes around, you know, dogleg right to left 5:30 whole and
they situated a TV Camera TV tower, something like that, outside the course. And that player. One of the cut, the dog leg out about over the other bands, then if it interferes with both, their line of sight and line of play and the local rule f23 has been adopted, then that player would be able to get free relief. so that's the only one I could only real one I could think of But there you go, and
also about that question, which was good question. I think David grieve. Got it again on the YouTube. Put his hand up for an answer out on YouTube. So, well done, David, thank you very much, for contributing, it was great. Now, first of all, first of all, we have to go through some Ivers of the week. I knew that one might possibly be in either and that is the Just got myself a bit. Confused.
But if you're, if you hit an original ball in a provisional ball because you think it's lost or out about lost outside the penalty area or out of bounds and you Come up to them and you see that you can't work out which ones, which then you have to choose one and that will be your provisional ball. And SJ emailed me and said you didn't, you didn't quite get that one, right? And What I said was almost right
but it wasn't, but it was almost it was that if you choose a provisional Ball but if they both go into a penalty area. So you're thinking it's out of bounds or out lost outside of penalty area. They but but they happened to both go into a penalty area, then you can choose one and that's your original and then you can take penalty relief from that one because you're in a penalty area and you know, you're in a penalty area with your original but If you choose to play one being the one that you play will be your provisional ball. Now, if one is outside and one
is inside, One. Is it outside while it's inside and I'll just read this. You can the answer is ready. The answer is player. Must choose one ball and it is the provisional special case of both in the Pas unique and only works because there is certainty. The original ball is in the PA. So if ones inside ones outside, you choose one and that is your provisional. Now, if you choose the one that's inside, you can play, as it lies or you can take penalty relief if you choose the one
that's outside. Leslie, you're going to be playing your for from the outside and then if it is in a terrible position, you can still do that unplayable option. But the most important thing here is marketable, so you can identify, which one's the original and which one's the provisional. And lastly, in this the second one's a really big stuff up and I'm really embarrassed about it, but SJ call me about this one as well. We were discussing excess clubs and we're all good with stroke
play, you know, Add the two shots to the first and second hole. But we also said or I said you and stableford you added to the first and second hole, which is not correct. Because, yeah, you could. And we talked about this for about a couple of minutes. You could have a wipe and then so having those excess clubs really isn't a penalty because a wife, as a wipers of what equals zero points, but that is not the case, 21 Rule 21.
Point and the stale biscuit 21.1 c 1 1 c 1 x s shared added or replace clubs. If a player breaches rule 4.1 be the committee will deduct two points. If they preach applies to only one hole or four points applies to tour more holes under rule, four point one be from the players total points. So that's where I stuffed it up. Players total points. So if you have 36 points and you
had excess carbs are finished with 32 points, Etc. And then par think it's a similar situation in part that you lose two holes but I won't make that mistake again. I will read yeah, one whole applies to one hole, or if it's two or more holes, you lose two holes. So if you finish to down your now for down similar to regardless of what Hold on those first to hear it correct?
Correct. So if you had two wins it's not going to matter. It's all about your total and score. Total of holds 1 versus whole flossed and pass a similar to match. Players are right. We've got over the nasty little overs that have stuff like the roles. I should read the rule book of it, gonna look like you're in your defense, the provisional ball, original ball confusion, you actually didn't get that wrong at all. We And both outside and what the ruling is.
We mentioned both in the penalty area and what the ruling is because it certainly the originals are and you take can take relief and play it. But the one where we didn't know the answer to and we said we need to find out was when there's one in and one out, which you've now actually, obviously found out. Well, that's that's nice defense, but not knowing the rules and getting it wrong. It's still the same thing in my eyes, Okay? Especially when we A pinnacle golf rules Christians golf pros
podcast you know the southern hemisphere. So yeah so thank you everyone who keeps listening trusted way will be gaming, right? Right. Moving on so the Open Championship, hope you've been watching? I mean used to it. Are you talking about talking to the fans? I did watch this. Yeah, I did watch maybe two
hours of the first round. Watched a few Australians play and I could feel through the television the atmosphere which is funny to say but I actually felt it just by yeah it was just incredible to watch and Don't watch a lot of European Golf purely time zone a little bit and stuff. But I watched, I really enjoyed the gulf that I watched yesterday in the first round. And some really, really good
scores and some obviously not so good scores and here, I'm thinking a lot of under par and of the eyes of playing really easy, in this drivable par fours, which is a lot of players a plus 2 or worse. Yeah, I saw that Justin roads and Eric been ruin pulled out because of injury and two players that came into the championship because of those pulling out Aaron rye and the kuya is Sony.
I think from Japan, they both finished three over an interesting one. That Alex noren was first alternative but he decided to stay in the states and not come over and play. So, missed out an opportunity there, but maybe just thought that the trip to Scotland wasn't worth it. I mean, you know, it's a major so that the guys have to play on this course it would be a lot of people that this course wouldn't set up. Well for that link style that, you know, we're seeing a lot of
hard bounces. You just got to make sure that those hard bounces go and straight. The middle of the Fairway. Well, then, rather than into the course, I've had the absolute pleasure and luck to have referee there for a Dunhill links, which I probably mentioned on this podcast. Was it episode 61 probably are mentioned at about 58 times and it's I've got to be honest, it's
not the best course for spectators. Ali, because you're all on the outside so you can't go up the middle because up the middle is holes. Like you're basically if you up the middle you're basically on The Fairway so you could you just got to go around the outside and just watch like the arena similar to an AFL game or NFL game or state of origin the other day, which Queensland one, which I was very happy about and so it isn't interesting.
It is an interesting, you know, the atmosphere of the town is something else though. I've never felt that, you know, everyone's a golf nerve when they go to that place. It does have the third oldest university in the UK, but which is, you know, another little piece of history for it. But just the fact that it's you go there and just walk around the streets and you just people were, yeah, there's like seven courses within Throwing almost within throwing this distance of
the 10. And yeah, it's a pretty awesome. Pretty neat feeling and just this 150th Championship. Just ranks it up even further. So yeah it's a it's pretty cool. Okay. So you said it's Unique from a spectator point of view is it unique from a refereeing point of view from a rules point of view? Yeah so from a rules point of view and the rules will be very similar. I'm to what we had to what they've got this week, There's not that much going on, you
know, even the cart paths or the road that travels inside the course. So, there's a couple of Roads inside, the course was one that crosses the 88, and the first not really a play for these players now, but there's a road that crosses, the 18th and the first sets an integral object, there's no free relief. If if you want it, you can play it as it lies or you can take an unplayable. So that's that's one. The other one is that well, that
rock wall. That's a boundary object, right? Of a 17. So that's there's no free relief there from there obviously, but it's a pretty clean course. There's a County area that goes through there, the burn and some front of one and so on. The identity. There's it's just it just be unplayable was there basically and whether it's an unplayable in the bunker or an unplayable in the course is lots. Of course around there.
Yeah, not not too much else going on and very what we would say. It's a very clean course. So when you're refereeing, it's not windy. And it's not raining. You're really not going to have too many issues so it's going to just be a lot of watching hopefully good. Golf. Mmm. What about the bunkers that I ever posed any issues with the rules? It's like how difficult some of them can be definitely unplayable because their faces just so in end like in Australia
we would have our bunkers the way that we sort of the sort of design bunkers in Australia as they pack the sand on the side. And they have it into a bowl shape and then flap a little flatten them in the mall, in the middle. Whereas there they have almost straight up and down bunker faces at stacked Turf, bunker faces, which gives it this really awesome. Look, but the sand doesn't bevel
out it's just it's just like a right angle mode. So if your ball I can just roll up right beside the edge, right beside the face. And yeah, good luck getting that out, anywhere or anyway, like, it's not going to It's not yeah you can't go towards the whole kind of go backwards. Hopefully can go sideways or as Victor hovland found out in the first round. I think he took an unplayable for when a bunker so you're dropping in the bunker from an
unplayable. It's a one-stroke penalty. If you wanted to go back outside the bunker, it would be a two-shot kill. Couldn't imagine a golfer at that level taking on that additional relief. Option to drop it outside. The bunker it hasn't happened. Often surely it's happened but I don't think it's happen that often not at that level. I wouldn't think because they, they think, okay, if I dropped my ball, I should be able to get up and down because I prefer to be in the bunker but you know be interesting if say if you plugged up and underneath the
lead Edge, And there was trees and fun of you or something. And you thought I will if I drop in the bunk I'm just gonna have to chip out. If I drop outside the bunker, I can still hit a 3-wood near the green or something like that. That would be an internet, would probably be the only time that that could be enacted or would be enacted with you mentioned. The road committees obviously are able to make objects integral objects, and you don't see very often.
I don't think, so. Why do committees do that? Why do they make something an integral object? Say in making something in table object is all about that. Object becomes a challenge for the golfer playing that course. So, You know, a tree is not an artificial object, but it is a challenge when it's growing on a course and an artificial object,
like the road on the road, whole bad decided. Okay? That is the challenge. That is part of the challenge of the whole, if you hit it right of it, Ben and you come a right of the green and you come to rest on that road. Yeah we're challenging you to try and put your balls close to the hole from playing off the road. So that's what it's all about. It's creating this extra Challenge and it's always, you
know, a lot of that comes from like a traditional manner is it's always been there. So it's always going to be like that, you know? If if we Of course. A hundred years ago. And then today we put a seat or a Sandbox, you know, toilet block or something. Yeah. Yeah, as a toilet Bots are block a challenge that we want the golfer to.
I mean, you have to obviously, you know, going to get free relief, it's going to be similar to a tree. I'm going to get free relief from line of play. If it's built there. Permanently But you know, you might be able to get immovable obstruction relief if you have interference with your swing, but a tree would not obviously it's it's just play it as it lies. So, yeah. So that's the open will.
We've got three more days of watching it and will be interesting to see. I don't think we have too many rules issues. The only kind of rules issue that I think would blow things up would be if someone didn't sign their card or sign the card for wrong school. That would be the biggest issue, but rest assured, if there's anything out there, we'll do our best to find it and get it washed. That's right. And for the first two days especially and they do it won t. Start the only And I wouldn't do want a start is if the weather
was going to pack in and if the weather was going to pack in, they would run a Tutti, start the eighth, the terrible with all the crappy thing about to tee start, especially at Saint Andrews, or the old course, is the 10th hole is almost the furtherest whole almost the furtherest whole from the course. So that have to fiery them down there and golf carts the refereeing side of it, the they Have they have a referee walking with every group on the first
two days and sometimes some of the observers as well. So it would be how many groups in the playing of three ball kind of 50/50 two groups. So got fifty two groups. So they have 52 referees, plus a few observers. So maybe gets up to 5. Plus now had the Thule referees will be driving around in carts and if it's cold, they'll be
huddled behind a gorse bush, which is what I did had. I think I had socks on my hand because I didn't have any gloves. So I use socks somewhere here. It was that cold, but they'll have so all in all their referee plus Observer list, That you around 74, almost as many players. Yes, it's interesting. You say that given the course, doesn't lend itself to have a lot of rules issues and it is quite clean and open. And it's interesting that there is so many, so many referees or
officials there. Well, I've always horse, I've always told you Stewart that the bigger the tournament. The smaller the field that they get the more referees. Obviously, this is not a small field as 156 players but the big of the tournament, the room, all the referees, you know? They just want someone to get there as quick as possible to help, right? Yes. The biggest nightmare about all that. Would be how many radios you need. And probably how much sunscreen you need for the referees.
But now it's yeah, I wish everyone a great week. It's fantastic being 150th at the home of golf. That is very cool, right? Shall we move on to what got a video here where it is here with you? So I was going to bring up Wills Ella, Tauruses situation. Yes, it wasn't just on your own YouTube channel. Yeah, we posted that last week that was at the Scottish open.
It was I was 16th hole round one of the Scottish open and we'll he's just off the green and chips on his ball, lips out of the hole and continues on and comes to rest in a very rare situation comes to rest on another book, another players ball marker, which was Fitzpatrick, and a bull market. Just so happen to be a poker chip, doesn't matter what it was, but the ball. He's ball came to rest on top. Another pliers or markers. So what did they have to do by key to sort that out? I just want to talk about Fest.
That is just how it came to rest on top of that. Like it actually, you could try it another thousand times. It would be, you wouldn't get it. It's just incredible that actually came to rest. It just is so much more Chance of a trot like slightly rolling off, but okay, so the ball was come to rest on a movable obstruction. The immovable obstruction is Someone else's marker bull market?
Yeah, we talked about this in the video will could play the Bulls lies. It is his shot. He is further away assuming that. And I'd say, Matt Fitzpatrick does this assuming that method to Patrick puts his bull market behind the ball, then it was well shot so we'll could play it off the corner of the poker chip. He wasn't going to who, who in their right mind ever would. So he marked his ball basically
behind that marker, then that came along with his Putter and lines has had their head. With a tray or a TI o or flag. Don't his it as a lesson for you. Well actually I'll put this in the drop zone as well. Don't align your Club head, or your putter head when you're doing a marking to the side and don't line up with a person.
Yeah, it's it's happened before because that person might move and then you don't know where where your where your beacon in the Yeah, you know, far off you just ruined your. One of my lame jokes. I use on a golf course. He's right, he's right, well, I move my ball marker for interference moved out of the way, and I line it up and I say, you know, John don't move because of you. It's one of my Lane jokes. I can't use it anymore, I'm
sure. Yeah, I'm sure Ray would appreciate our so. So anyway, that's come along moved as. Ball marker part of head length being Wills replaced his ball. Gone through his process, made the putt for par. Well, done. Well then Matt just reverses the process puts the club head, or the putter head down. So it's the market back down and then replaces the ball in front of them or the bull market, and he made his putt for par as well.
I mean, he knew the exact line, so if you'd missed, it would have just been on his stroke. So well done on those two again. But that was, yeah, that was really interesting situation. And of course, the difference is a being on a movable obstruction, if it was anywhere else like in the general area, he wouldn't be placing it on that spot. He would be obviously dropping it if it came to rest on a movable obstruction be dropping in a relief area, but as it was on the green, obviously, he was able to place it on the spot.
Below next instruction. Yes but on spot on his throne I think of it. Yeah it was in the in The Fringe and it someone yeah. Your mom gave us a good noise or interference or something. Yeah. And it came to rest on that, on that ball marker in The Fringe team. You'd be dropping it already from directly below where the ball will come to rest within the club lie. Yeah. That that I don't want to say that would never happen but they
would just be so strange for that to happen. Now, the other, the we are, we have posted that ages ago. The funny thing was A couple of people ask well, can you can you I don't know if it was just sort of that situation, but it was also recently have people of our state. Can you move Mark your ball with your putter head and you, and I had created that video that we're when we were shooting it healed and that you know how to markable.
So I've been able to send a few people that video which has been good and you put that up in the in the drop. And so, I hope everyone is enjoying the Drop Zone. So yeah, it's a fun for us to create it, so we hope that everyone's enjoying it. Yeah. Talking about the Drop Zone and all the other things that we create and put out the community question, And now we went over a
few Community questions last week of their few more that you'd like to sit through. There are. So I want to talk about the most recent one which was Tyson and I think only twenty three, twenty four percent of people got this, right? This is you laid out a scenario of Tyson playing a whole accidentally moved his ball in the general area. Put it into a bunker unplayable. Took relief, hit it on, hit the flag, secret was in the hole and you just ask everyone. How many strokes has he had for that whole? And Made the comment on the on the video that I think we're people will get this wrong is in
the bunker and sure enough, only twenty three twenty four percent got it. Correct? But the question that was raised which I thought is worth discussing now is Tyson has dropped outside the bunker and he's ball is unplayable in the bunker. It's embedded I should say he's taken it out of the bunker and played and the question came up and I'm going to ask you now is that when you play a provisional ball, you must clearly announced and make that known to others. That you were doing that. If you are taking unplayable, wall relief, is it at same
obligation or same requirement to say, hey guys, I'm dropping it outside the bunker. I'm proceeding under, you know, 19.2 whatever it is, or not in point three of us would say. And, you know, can I take? Sorry, I'm just going to take this unplayable relief, you know, is there that same requirement to announce? That's what you were doing? No. There is no. Yeah, there's no luck. Okay, no, let me put it another
way. It's a good idea to yes. And how your marker is going to find out what your score is and adjudicate it confirm, it is you're going to have to tell them what you've done or tell her what you've done, but you're not going to get penalized if you don't. So that's why I mean by no current not going to get penalized by not telling someone how you're proceeding. But I would strongly recommend it and also, they would need to
know what you're doing so that they can certify that your score is correct. If you, if I saw you doing it, obviously, you would already tell me, but if I saw you doing it, I'm going to ask a still. What are you doing there? And if you said, I'm just taking a drop outside the bunker, I'd go. Is that back on the line? Knowing full? Well, that it probably is. Is that back online? Yes, I go.
Okay. Two shots there and you go to shots. I'll put it back. Yeah, go this one shot. Then I don't know if they will know that, that if you choose to take relief under a rule and you pick your ball up and then you decide that you don't want to make. Yeah, you don't want to take relief under that rule. Well, now that rule doesn't apply and you've lifted your ball 9.4 and get a penalty.
And I don't know if people are going to argue that. Well, one of the exceptions as you're proceeding under a rule. But while you are, Or you were mmm but you didn't. So that exception doesn't apply anymore. So if you put your ball back, you're going to get apparently. You can change your mind before you drop it. But once you've lifted, it is a really good interpretation and 9.4 that goes through all the details.
Actually, I'll say exactly because people hate When I want to sort of leave it really into go and search. It's 9.4 B6 and it talks about player list below under rule 16.1 be that allows free relief but then decides not to take free relief and it goes through Five Points as to what you can do and how much it's going to cost you. I mean, the better the better idea would be to still take
relief, even though it might be a really crappy. Situation. Still, it'll take relief and then becoming a penalty anyway and then maybe Tate and I mean, yeah, and then maybe take a penalty or life L option after that, which you could still go back to your last place, played your previous place play because you haven't made a stroke in that whole situation. You incur penalty strokes, but you haven't incurred or Kelly stroke but you actually haven't made a stroke. I had I think I went over in the
podcast. Just when we were referring, it Munna. I actually had a player. Take two. Unplayable. Bull's eye drops. So you found two Club lengths. Dropped it. Found another two Club, lengths. Dropped it to get try and get himself out of a situation as premeditated right from the start. But it was like, it wasn't for Ecology, but you know, is he knew what he was doing to get across for Club lens. It's good premeditated right from the start premeditated.
But from the end, Anyway, we want something done in a rabbit hole a tautologies, but yes, chai tea. It's a tautology. Ford plane is my favorite anyway. We'll stop here. So so yeah. He premeditated he decided from the start. Okay, if I drop a ball here it's not going to get into a position that I like and if I drop it and then I would so drop it to here and then that'll get me. Hopefully get me up here UPS. You however, I can drop again.
I said, you know, you go back to the tee now. Stuff that. Hmm. So so you know I see it as an equivalent of it's a proceeding under 18.1 and so that's something you don't have to announce. And that is, you know, I vividly remember now situation on the 7th hole of this course, and there's a penalty Area, Yellow. 50 meters in front and I'll just get it straight in there. And I was so annoyed that I've just had a bad tee shot and knowing my relief options from that. Yellow penalty area were. Can it be any better than me, line from the Tegan?
I've actually just retweet a ball up and I could hear someone behind me goes, is he buying a provisional? And someone else said. Well, I don't think you can there Whispering themselves, and I didn't say a word. And of course, I've just hit this second ball from the Teen area and I know now that I proceeded under strike conditions like it was a relevant, my ball was in the yellow Peril, dear, it was irrelevant what they were saying and talking about provisionals. I ignored them because I was so annoyed that I just hit Spool so poorly. The original one into the yellow but I didn't have to announce that. By may just hang up and going
again, everyone knows now. 313, you own? Yeah, you only have one option there. I actually had 112 whole Kingston Heath and I hit left and there's a little creek that runs down the left hand side of the 12th hole care, Kingston. Hey, if it's a par 5 and I had left, I thought oh that's definitely in the penalty area. And sort of dropping back on the line would be crappy, and it was
a duck hook. So, I was like, I'll just hit another one and I just hit another one knowing that I was playing on the stroke and distance. Goddamn, they have found that my bowl would actually jump the penalty area and was beside the Sphinx and I probably could have chipped it out and be playing three rather than three off the tee. So it was a dumb move to you. What, I thought was just use the rules but perfectly legal. It was exactly what I was allowed to do, even though it was a dumb move now, is there another Community question that
you want to get there? Actually it was a that was a good one, wasn't it? Like I think they're I think we'll do a few more of those. How many shots is Rosco had or how many shots as Michelle had type thing. I don't mind it. Now it's just a matter of Us. Coming up with so many different scenarios to pack into one whole. I'm sure young your imagination with the rules of golfers. It's just right right in the early stages and when you're in the early stages, that's the
best stages because you just come up with all these Phantom full things that could happen. So yeah, exactly. I'm Ivan match, play question for you doing a talk much play just for a second. Yeah, go for it. So, this is question 96. I'm going back a little bit here. So this is when Jerry and I were playing and I thought, I could take relief and Jerry didn't, and I did anyway. So Jerry requested a ruling.
And made that clear to me and on the next hole it was a pro you know staff member drove past who knew the rules pretty well and Jerry's is all got a question for you just on the last hole Stewart did this. And Didn't, I didn't think he could by Allah and the staff member, exploring, the rule and Jerry and I agreed and then Jerry finds out later after the match that in fact, that staff member was wrong and that I wasn't able to take relief. And I just wanted your thoughts about with match and what you can agree to and, you know,
whether you can sort of revisit the situation later once the match is finished or whether you Hey what's the situation there is with agreeing with the result of a hole? No, I mean if you don't know, know the rules and then you ask someone and they give you their opinion and You agree with it. Both of you agree with that. Being you have, you have effectively Decided what result. Yeah, redesign of the result for
that hole. As long as you don't know the rules and you don't know, you know, you don't know that you're agreeing to disregard a rule or something that you can't approach him. You know, if they're if you request a ruling then obviously you're going to go to the committee but you can change that at any time. So I request a rolling. I know this is the real. Read the book and you read the book and go. Okay, I agree with that. I don't request a role effectively saying, I don't request a role in anymore or my
favorite making a claim. No no, no. That's I don't know where they got rid of that, I like making you claim. It's like the language. It's requesting a rolling and actually you did some it wasn't acting it, you have real life, it was harming away stuff. And we posted that video When you tried to say that my, whilst
of yours ball was, yes, whilst your ball was rolling. I can see that your next stroke and you said no, no, no, you've conceded the stroke where the ball is still rolling. Anyways, your work is I thought, I thought I was, right? I really feels right. Then you weren't acting it'll So it was good. But yeah. No, I was requesting requesting a rolling. If you both come to an agreement on, what the whole score is, then that's fine. Another one.
Even if it's threats, are even if it's three holes later. Yes, and start you speak to the club, Captain he goes. Yeah that's right. You can do that and it's okay no problem. We agree a lot of the time. This will happen. When you it'll be on the front nine, you get through the nine. you go to the Pro Shop, you ask the pro, there's no idea and you know there are some there are some pros that do study the rules but there are way more that don't have don't and they hate they hate when a member
comes and ask them something and they don't know the answer to that is not, that is not in the pit, you know the pro Playbook. The pro Playbook is even if I don't know an answer, I will just give them an answer which is usually wrong, which is horrible, which is - so I'm really calling out, we should have like a, you know, how they have like International woman's week or a international anything food week, we should have an
international PGA pros, need to learn the rules week. That would be, that would be good. Here, I am spitting chips when I made to Ivers from last week. But, you know, at the same time, even some, they get even some of the most basic rules wrong. And it's the it's the most basic ones that you want to get, right? Because as the most common ones, the Hawaiians are happened the most awful, I still vividly. Remember if I might quickly to Club championships and the caddy, it was preferred lies in
unfortunately because of course the fairways are in horrible shape. And the Katie said to the pro always that preferred like, we clean our And if our guys not now you got going and so they applied the rail. And he asked me to Katie asked me light, I'm going to get that answer for me so they'll the PGA going. The so I don't mean to holler. But the pro the Plover Pro from the club said, you can't. I said well, that's unfortunate because you know, you're taking relief. And yes, you can even of course, he even he was even more annoyed, you know, that he could have played the whole round and
didn't clean their ball, once we're not taking a preferred line. Even under E2 or E3, you can clean your balk at you. When you told me taking my life from anything. You can. Yes, okay, choose cleaning ball. So I would like to think you can play it on that one. Now Jeff is an e to a where you just, you could move your ball to a different spot but you weren't allowed to clean it and having a clean ball prefer that,
you know, that pro at that time, going to go on, you know, actually, I'm not really sure. Let's just check. We wish we wish to him. It only take 60 seconds to I'm one of the club that we know who knows the rules or wouldn't take long night anyway and certainly for a club you know for an event like that being a Club Championship and I vividly remember all three people, the player, the Katie and the pro right now, it's not important to know everything. It's important to know what you don't know.
Yeah. Yes. Is that, that's not a tautology. Because at all, it's a Buddhism. So, with the community questions, like, there's plenty of that you've already got now over 100 Community questions. And I did this myself when I first learned of your channel, went back through and answer them all and there's just a lot of good questions in there and we'll keep pumping them out. And and I think it provides good folder for us to talk about on this podcast as well. Go back into Old questions and
just raise them as issues and talk about the rule. Just like we did them with the match. And agreeing to the result of a hole after requesting a ruling on that, very whole. Yes, and, you know, unlike the share market, which I listened to your chat with Roscoe on the my love, golf podcast, how do you really driving at the same time? It was really good. It was, it took me three three, three times, three Journeys to and from work. Well, you weren't driving with
you listening to music at, okay? But it was really, Good, but unlike the share market, which changes all the time and I guess you sort of do have some basis points. Oh okay. This if oil goes up, everything else goes up top thing because we make everything out of oil then we make everything with oil. But apart from that kind of thing. You know, the rules of golf, we've only got 24 rules, a lot of our questions are going to be similar.
Yeah, situations are going to be similar. There's not really too much scope, or there's a fine. Art, isn't it? Yes. Is there's not too much bands. I mean, there's always new little things like the ball coming to rest on a poker chip, or salmon. Hitting the ball with their legs. Placed on either side of the one applying liner play, that kind of thing. There's always going to be a little things but really, you know, it's still written in the rules, it still? Happened before and they have they know about it.
And so they wrote a rule for it. So there's not really going to be too much of that going on. So you know you could have you could have listened while we're actually going to do this. But you could you know, if we're done 24 episodes on rule 1 2 3, 4 5, 6 up to 24, possibly done, you know, more importantly we should do a podcast episodes on the definitions because they are more are the most important part of the book and then you Could do some podcast issue episodes on the local rules.
So, yeah, you could probably do a hundred podcast episodes just on talking about, you know, the text in the rules of golf, fine. And that would be it, you'd be done, but we like talking about them and the situations that do occur week-to-week on the tour or and clubland. But at the same time we just, we just need to everyone to realize that we will. Go over. We will rehash old stuff many many times as just with the finite stuff.
That is in the book. That is going to happen. A normal will always going to tell you stories about how I went to this tournament and refereed in the storm refer Eden and whatnot. So as you're sure it's tough. Hopefully keep you keep listening and and ask questions since some questions and then get some questions on there. And talking about any of you got, we'll finish it up there. If you got the golf rules question of the week number 61,
let's do it. I do talk about proceeding on a stroke and distance this very question. I do. So this gr Q 0, TW 4, episode 61 Jerry hit his tee shot way left into some thick bushes and therefore decides to play a provisional ball which lands in the rough on the left-hand side of the Fairway. Jerry finds his original ball within three minutes. However, it is deep within the bushes, and clearly unplayable. His lateral and back on the line, relief options for
unplayable are equally impractical. So he decides, his only option would be to return to his previous Place. Played, having already played his provisional ball from the Teen area and to ensure he doesn't delay. Play any further, he plays his provisional ball from where it was lying and counts that as his for Stroke is this permitted? I've got a video on that one. So if you go down and check out my YouTube and watch the video, you'll know the answer. Great question and well voiced.
Thank you. Clear. And concise. No tautologies know you should. You got to throw some in there next time? All right. Thank you very much. And for the, for the episode thinking of under listening and make sure you like And subscribe, the Roscoe thing to do. And also More importantly, don't watch the open, enjoy, let watching Links Golf and The Prestige of such a torment. So I hope everyone enjoys the
next three days. Thank you, Stuart. Thanks, Mikey speak to you next time. See you mate.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...