CLUBLAND STORIES August: using your partners club, are strokes are given in a playoff, the area underneath a bridge, handing a ball into the hole, & playing from an NPZ- THE GRQ PODCAST EP121
38 minAudio
Episode 121 of the GolfRules Questions podcast is back to the OG of Rules Questions - ClubLand Stories Today’s episode features a greensomes question about using the partner’s club, whether strokes are given in a match play playoff, what is the area underneath a bridge, hitting a ball into the hole with your hand, and playing from a No Play Zone, we also have the GRQOTW for 121 that you can try wrap your head around. GRQOTW120:Eight strokes. Andy the Average Golfer played a ball that was dropped under free relief (which wasn't available to him) and as he did not have intention to drop that ball as an unplayable (even though that is where he arrived at after finding out the free relief wasn't available), he has played from a wrong place. He was required to drop a ball with the intention for it to be an unplayable, not just play one that was dropped previously by him and in the correct relief area.GRQOTW121: Andy the Average Golfer is playing a stroke round at Wombat Hills. On the 9th hole, he hits his 2nd shot way left towards the driving range. Among all of the other golf balls, he finds his ball and plays his 3rd stroke towards the green. After 1 chip and 3 putts, he holes out. As he is waiting at the back of the 9th green, waiting for others to finish the hole, a staff member walks down and advises Andy that the driving range is OOB. Andy asks the staff member what that means. Neither know, so they approach you as a member of the Committee for assistance. What is Andy the Average Golfer's score for the 9th hole?GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Episode 121 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast is back to the OG of Rules Questions Club Land Stories. Today's episode features a Greensome question about using the Partners club where the strokes are given in a match play. Playoff What is the area? Underneath. A bridge. Hitting a ball into the hole with your hand and playing from a no play zone. We also have the G. RQOTW. For 1/21 that you can try wrap your head around. See referee David Blake that
he's obviously talking to one of the rules officials up by the Green. Hey everyone, golf rules questions podcast back again. This is episode Stuart. I can't even remember because you've done the last three in a row. What episode is this? Three in a row, maybe 5121, today 121. So you did 120 with Graham Scott? This is 1/21. I'm Blakey, welcome back to my own podcast. Basically, I've been away, I've been busy and I haven't managed to prioritise the Golf Rules
Questions podcast. But it didn't matter because in the process podcast, McPhee, Stuart McPhee, as he likes to be called, I think that's what his dad named him, has been looking after the place and doing an amazing outstanding job and just as outstanding as his golf was today. What did you shoot today? Playing par +8. Thank you, Blakey in. Par Now for those of you who don't know par, it's like playing a type of match play
against the course. So it's a stroke play event, but it's a type of match play where you try and beat the course on every hole. And he's had plus 8 + 8, so he had and he wiped the 1st hole, so he's had nine wins. That's his. Outstanding. He would have spanked the course and hopefully he comes home with the massive prize of 25. Dollars in the shop, Massive payday. So let's get let's get going because I'm, I'm short on time here again.
Golf Rules Questions Podcast episode 120 Question of the Week. I can't see. Yeah, Blakey, it's. Taking so long that I haven't I can't even remember GRQOTW is that Yeah, that's it rolls off the. Tongue, I think that's the acronym, Yeah, go for 1:20. What was it do it? And welcome back to you, it's good to have you back. GRQGRQO TW120. Andy, the average golfer, is playing a stroke round at Wombat Hills on the seven 8th hole. Andy plays his tee shot white left and after a brief search he
finds his ball. However, it is right next to the stone carved Wombat statue which the committee has deemed an integral object. The statue interferes with his area of intended swing, so after advising Danny the D Grey golfer, his marker but he'll take free relief, he identifies the nearest point of complete relief and drops another ball into A1 club length relief area. Stewart walks over and tells Andy that the statue is an integral object and there is no
free relief, so he must correct the mistake. Accordingly. Andy properly identifies A2 club length relief area from the original ball which has not been moved in order to take now unplayable ball relief. He realizes the drop ball is within the unplayable ball relief area. He then plays the drop ball which lands on the green. He takes 3 putts to haul out and reports a score of 6 to Danny. 5 strokes and one penalty stroke
for the unplayable. Before submitting his scorecard, Andy, the average golfer, asks you Blakey, as a member of the committee, to confirm his score for the seven 9th hole. Well, this is this is a weird one. So he dropped under a free relief, which he wasn't allowed to. So the only relief option that he was entitled to when he had found his ball was 19.2, Is that
right Stuart? Unplayable. That's what he decided to do because he couldn't play it up against the but he. Did the one that he dropped and played was not the one that he was not the one that was intended to be dropped and played under unplayable? Which to be honest with with yeah, with everyone. It blows my mind. There is no in this situation. He didn't get lucky because his intention was different to the one that actually should have been dropped and played from
within that relief area. So even though he's played from the correct relief area, it was with the ball that was not dropped with that intention to play from that relief area. So we're still going to give him a penalty of one for the unplayable and then he's also got a two shot. No, because he played from the relief area. It's just a one shot penalty, right. So it's AI think he's. Taken the wrong.
Place one shot penalty and then he's played from the wrong place. Yeah. Even though it's from the correct relief area, it's going to be a general penalty. Interesting thing about the interesting thing about this, Blake. Yeah, I, I, that's what I believe the answer is. The interesting thing is if you read every word of Rule 19, including clarifications, you will not see the rules say that to drop under an unplayable, you need to have that intention when
you physically drop the ball. You have to go to committee procedures to actually see those words. Which is 6 point. 88C something, you should find it. But. It is in committee procedures. And then there's four dot points that you can read about inapplicable rules taken relief and all that kind of thing. So check that out. If you're definitely, if you set on a committee, you should definitely have checked that out. So the one shot penalty for the
unplayable is guaranteed. Then you've got the two shot for wrong place. Sometimes I sometimes I get that wrong thinking that he's played from the relief area, but it wasn't dropped in a wrong way. It was dropped with no intention. So effectively he's just a play. He's just played a ball that's just been lying there and he's gone. Oh well, that's in my relief area. I'll go and play that. That's the easiest way to as to how he gets that penalty is it's as if someone else has dropped it for him and three holes prior
3 hours prior and it's just gone. Oh, that's in my relief area. I'll just play that one. That's a good, good example. Yeah, it was just sitting. Just happened to be sitting there. Trying to work, you know, I'm trying to help everyone. I'm trying to help myself as well. That's so complicated. So I don't know what the in score was, but it must have been something like nine or something. Like that? Well, it'd be eight, yeah. So it'd be the five strokes plus the three penalties. But still took the unplayable one. OK, so you just add 2 to the six. 8 for the wrong place. So it is under committee
procedures section 6C8 and C8 refers to handling ruling. When player proceeds under rule that does not apply and it actually in the first bullet point it says as rule 19.1 unplayable ball requires a player to have decided to proceed under it before taking release. The committee may not apply rule 19 to that particular example. So that's where it says that when dropping the ball under a playable, you have to know This is why I'm dropping that ball
and you can't get lucky in the relief area. Perfect, perfect. Right. We've we've left it a couple of months. We've got a club land stories for August. We there's a fair few, so we'll try and get through half of them and then we'll just go with the flow. As I said, this one will be a short one today and we might do a Part 2. We appreciate all the clubland stories that get sent in to us. Obviously they're it's so entertaining and usually we don't go through them until live
on the podcast. So sometimes we're scratching our heads trying to work out what the actual answer is. But here we go. We've got one from Ruin who was a fantastic supporter and love long time listener of the podcast. It's Greensim's match play. I believe you have previously referred to this format as Ambrose, basically two sides of two partners. So it's a type of Ambrose. I think it's it's what we're
both. Oh, here you go. Both partners tee off on every hole and then they choose their best option and then they play foursomes from there. So yeah, so foursomes it's alternating stroke, one player Tees off, but greensons, you add in both players can tee off and then they choose the best one. And the person who doesn't own that ball gets to play it anyway. Espin and his son Magnus are partners and they've reached the 8th hole. It has. It has started raining quite heavily. And Espin attempts to put on his rain cover on the bag.
Unable to do this with ease he gets overly frustrated. Meanwhile his son Magnus takes his shot off the tee and comes back to his now seething with frustration. Father Magnus tries to calm down and says let me do it here hold this and hands Espin his driver. While Magnus calmly puts on the rain cover he hears the well recognisable sound of a driver hitting a ball. He turns around and Espin, quite proud of himself, has sent his ball straight down the fairway. Espin gets back to his bag and sees his driver standing in his
bag with his head cover on and Magnus now confirms Espin's suspicion. You've used my driver Dad. Naturally, they notified their opponents about the breach instantly, and both Magnus and Espin had a full bag of 14 clubs, so there's no sharing of clubs involved. What actions were taken? We always have this in the clubland stories. What actions? In case you do come up with the answer or you're still, you know, talking to the committee about it. Ruin goes on to say nobody was sure which rule would apply since this was green SIM. Would this side lose the whole
or just the option of playing Eastman's ball? They agree with their opponent that Eastman's ball is no longer an option and to play Magnus's ball instead. They lost the whole, no further action was taken and no request for a ruling was made. But out of Kuriosk curiosity, they did raise the question with me and a few other rules persons. After a few days. There's been Greensim which isn't covered by the rules of golf. The closest thing we could find to the situation was the four ball rule 23.9 A2 which would have meant an adjustment penalty of 1 hole after hole 8.
But since the result was accepted after 19th and Espen and Magnus's favour and made official on the scoreboard, I believe the result stands and cannot be adjusted under Rule 20.1 B 3. I can't wait to hear your analysis of this. Let's have an Odense Golf Club on the par four 8th hole early June. What are your first thoughts on that one, Stuart? I got confused I think about the second sentence in. What was the so but then? Someone's hit someone else's club. Yeah, yeah.
So they're they're playing Greensome, so they're partners and the first player plays with his own club and the second player plays with that same driver that that first player used. And is it a loss of hole for the whole team because they're playing match play? Or is it just the fact that they can't use that ball where the player used the the club that they weren't allowed to use? If we digress, this is almost what you and I chatting about yesterday or the day before that.
A penalty can go away if that provisional ball never becomes the ball in play, or that penalty goes away if that stroke is replayed and and never counts towards the whole score. This is almost similar. It's all if we continue with that ball, it's going to be a penalty. How about we go and just play the other ball? Yeah, that's, that's the the way that I'm looking, the way that I'm heading down. I can't see why they, as I said, this kind of, it's a modified form of foursomes basically.
It's not what I would call Ambrose because Ambrose, you play, everyone gets a shot every time and you choose the best. This would be a modified version of foursomes. So you could have a look at 22, but 22, you know, goes, it goes. There's never a situation where you can play 2 balls, you know, from the same place and have an option of picking them. So that's why they, that's why Ruin went to 23, because as a
four ball you do get that option of playing two balls at the same time. You know, it hasn't helped anyone's play. It hasn't. It hasn't, you know. Disadvantage the other team. Disadvantage is a good, good word to use. Disadvantage the other team. So I would say that ball there doesn't count because it wasn't used with a club that was allowed to be used. And so the only option they have
is to use the other ball. And if the other ball went out of bounds, then one of them, the one that didn't hit it out of bounds, would have to play from the. Team play next. Three off the tee. But yeah, I mean, they said that they agreed. And so there was it was it was match play. So they figured it out that way, but and they were happy with it. And you know, the opponents agreed with that was the result. And in the end they ended up winning and they submitted the score and, you know, the committee had knew the official
results. So it is what it is. But yeah, that's how I sort of see it. And it is an important part of match play that you just mentioned that if everyone agrees, as long as we're not deliberately ignoring a breach and agreeing to ignore that breach, if everyone agrees and everyone's happy and we agree on the match score and someone Tees off on the next hole, happy days, we're locked in. That's the match score. Yeah, that that's how I say, you know, this type of thing where it's a modified game, you know, the committee has to come up
with a with an answer. And if I was? Fair. If I was on the committee, I would just say, well, that one didn't count as long as you didn't use it. If they used it well then you know it should have been lost a hole right next one. Yes, Yep. And AB Staleford round par four. Player has two handicap points on this hole. Ball on green for four strokes, so they could two-part and have two points. Basically player putted the ball
which stopped very short of the hole. Player tapped the ball into the hole with hand instead of using a Golf Club. They realized they shouldn't have done that. Was the ball holed or was it just moved? What should have happened in light of recent podcasts where player used puttered grip to putt ball into hole in Stanford. They wiped the wiped the score for the hole. Discussion of the round with playing group clarification to be sought by golf rules questions. This happened at Northern Golf
Club podcast. What's your answer? There's been definitely no stroke made. So when you put it in with your hand, it's definitely not a legal stroke. That's just moving your ball, which is going to cover a penalty because it was a deliberate move, like it was an accidental movement. That was a deliberate action to move the ball. So they're short of the hole for five, they've moved their ball, that's one penalty stroke. So it takes them to six. So they all they've got to do is put the ball back and they've still got to putt for a .7 for one.
Yeah, Yep. Now interesting enough, I agree with you that that's not a stroke. But what if the, what if their hand was touching the club, say they were holding their club head really, really low down and it just they, they sort of, you know, a horn went off or there was an earthquake and they sort of moved, jumped and it hit their fingernail. You know, what would you say
that that was, I guess there was a stroke made even though it hit you, you know, it's a terrible stroke, but it's still a stroke made. And then that wouldn't be, you know, like a putter grip type thing. No, that's a forward movement of the club. Yeah. To strike the ball. To strike the ball and it's just a, it's just a terrible. It's like really bad stroke. It'd be like hitting your ball with the shaft. And I don't, I think that's different. I mean the. Puzzle, I mean, the actual shaft. Yeah. OK, OK, that's right.
But in this case, their intention was to hit it with their hand. OK, so it completely just caused the ball to move. And definitely not hold. Doesn't matter where it ended up, just going to put it back. Pack a penalty stroke 9.4 B and complete play the whole. OK Brixy Glenow Golf Club has an internal OB area. I love internal OB's. I'm the only one Green turf nursery left of the par 512th hole. Tee shot goes left and the ball lands next to a state tree. Complete relief is required from the state tree local rule.
It's very common in Australia that local rule for straight state trees. Protect the young tree, but. Also the tree because they're trying to protect these young trees and nearest point for a right-handed golfer would have the relief area inbounds. But your stance in the OB area OB is indicated by white stakes. Can you drop the ball such that your relief area is inbounds but your stance would be out of bounds? What if the OB was a fence and you could not stand OBOB? As in out of bounds.
I like to say OOB out of bounds. The only reason I say that is OB for me is original ball. For us, yeah, I. Definitely understood what you meant by OB but podcast. As the player would be standing out of bounds to strike the ball in the relief area close to the out of bounds. The player took relief on the other side of the state tree such that the both the stance and relief area were inbounds and provided a much easier recovery shot. Where did this happen? Glenelg Golf Club, Stuart, What
do you think of that one? Well. We know you can stand out of bounds to play a ball that is on the course inbounds. So the nearest point of complete, complete relief and dropped within the relief area in the course or on the course inbounds and you have to stand outside. Bad luck. That's fine, you can do that. If it was a fence, then well, you've got an issue, but it's still your relief area and your balls still in play. And then you've either got to take an unplayable you and I think may have discussed a similar situation to this a little while ago where we said
you could probably make an argument that if you're right up against the fence and had no shot, your only shot would be to turn around and play left-handed. So if you wanted to have a go at the hitting the back of the club and actually advance the ball. And then you might have interference from that stake tree again. And then you could take a further relief procedure by saying and putting forward a case that you want to play left-handed to advance the ball. So. That that's a great point because in this situation, if the out of bounds was as as it's an internal out of bounds, the
out of bounds might be just another fairway. If someone said I'm going to play left-handed, I would say that's not reasonable. No, not within internal with the mistakes. But if it was, and I'm not saying maybe, yeah, I mean a fence, a fence or a tree, and they said, Oh well, I can't play it that way because of the fence, I have to try and play left-handed. That might mean that their nearest point is back further back for away from the hole. If it was a Cliff edge, you
know, would be reasonable to say you can't play right-handed or whatever it is and you have to change it to the other dexterity. But yeah, the point's well made there is that this player is actually taken free relief in the wrong, wrong relief area and should be docked general penalty for playing for a wrong place. There is no rule that stops you from your nearest point of complete relief not being the
nearest point because you're standing out of bounds. OK, good, good. Thank you, Briggsie. Good question. And he's up for another one playing Staleford. Staleford's a very popular game in Australia. Very popular. You can, you know, wipe a hole when it doesn't ruin your afternoon playing Staleford. New turf is laid on the front left side of the 10th green. This area is marked as no play zone. Free relief may be taken outside
the no play zone on the fairway. Second shot lands in the no play zone. Ben plays a shot from inside the no play zone onto the green and Marks picks up his ball. Ben realizes his mistake and returns to the no play zone and drops his ball outside the no play zone correcting his mistake. Ben chips on in two parts riding down a score of five. Ben made a general penalty. Ben made general penalty a whole lot worse by attempting to correct. And this happened at Glenel Golf Club as well. This question. I ran through that very fast. Sorry but this question looks a
lot like a question that was in a drop zone episode or edition recently. Is that would that be correct? You've plagiarized someone's Climb Land story into your into the drop zone. That's one way of looking at it. What is the answer? What would what would? What would we give the answer for in the dropping zone? Well. I think Briggy sort of answered it there a bit, that if you make a stroke from within a no play zone, that stroke counts, but you do get the general penalty
from playing from a wrong place. So when he's put it on the green and marked it and lifted his ball, that ball, that ball on the green, that ball was in play, there's nothing to correct and he should have played his next shot from the green whilst adding the general penalty. So the fact that he's now got his ball in his pocket and he's walked back to the drop zone for that no play zone and put a that ball or another ball back into play again and then made a stroke at it, he's going to cop another general penalty for playing from a wrong place again because he should have been playing from the green.
I've actually got a YouTube video of this one putting on the green and you take the one club head length away because your ball mark is in the way. You putt from that incorrect spot, don't hold it, and then you go, Oh my mistake, and you replace it on the correct spot and putt it again. You've actually got four stroke penalty now, yes, so. Very similar, yeah. It's it pays in that case, it pays very much pays to know the rules.
And that playing from a wrong place yes, the only sorry like there's been cop trying to correct it. Sorry, the. Only the only time you have to correct the wrong place is if it's a serious breach and you know the it's the committee's decision as to what a serious breach is. But in my mind, it comes back to how big an advantage was that advantage more than, say A2 shot penalty, that type of thing. So, you know, tipping around the green, very unlikely to be a serious breach, Could be up to
the committee, but very unlikely. Committee's always right even when they're wrong, but it's worth highlighting that 14.7 serious breach or wrong place is the second situation in which you can complete play of a hole with a second ball if you are not sure whether it's a serious breach or not. Right Nico, I had a call from the club captain, bear in mind I'm his vice captain, asking for a ruling, albeit this was after the event and he had been in a friendly match at Kennyworth Kenilworth Golf Club in the UK,
my home club. Our fifth pole is stroke index one and is a dog leg left long par four with a ditch across the fairway roughly 140 yards from the green and out of sight of the tee. The ditch is a dry ditch. It is about two meters wide across the whole of the fairway and has a pipe buried below the floor of the ditch to carry water about .75 meters down and the floor is covered by large pebbles on either side of the fairway. Across the ditch are two bridges about 5 yards into the fairway
each side. You can walk down either side and cross the ditch using one of the two bridges. The captain reasonably high handicap shouldn't matter, was playing his second shot to clear the ditch towards the green and had mis hit the ball which went into the ditch, bounced around the pebbles on the right and ended up in a rabbit hole dug under the bridge. Remember, the ditch is dry. The ditch itself is clearly marked with red stakes. These are positioned at reasonable intervals all the way across, including immediately on either side of the bridge.
The captain was calling to confirm his view, which I believe was accepted at the time and he should be allowed free relief as the rabbit hole was dug under the bridge. Not disputed as I know that was the case. He was 100% sure his ball was in it because he could see it and recovered it. And because the bridge was not in the penalty area. As the red stakes we have at the side of the bridges, you surely mean that the penalty area ends there. The bridge is in the general area and therefore an immovable obstruction. This is their thoughts. And then the penalty area continues again from the other side.
His Neko's response to the captain was that the red stakes, irrespective of whether they're next to the bridge or not, identify the whole area as a penalty area. There is nothing in any local rule to indicate otherwise. The bridge wasn't there for in the general area and if Nico had been adjudicating in a competition he would have said he wasn't entitled to free relief and should have taken the penalty like a man or or words to that that effect as he is the captain. This happened in Kenilworth Golf Club Watcher UK. What are your thoughts on that
one, Stuart? Well, this again comes down to the comedian, how they've marked that hole, how they've marked the Dutch and the bridges over that area and whether it's in the penalty. Yeah, whether it's a penalty area. And I suspect just from what we're hearing there that the whole area is a penalty area, including the bridges that cross this area. The bridges are within the penalty area, as many are in different courses. The way they market, they don't often stop penalty areas that the bridges and the bridges are being in the general area. So in that case, the ball's in
the penalty area, no entitlement to free relief from an abnormal course condition with it, which an animal hole is. If they've taken a drop outside that penalty area, then they're obviously going to cop the 17.1 penalty plus the wrong place penalty. You're looking at three penalty strokes. But again, it comes down to the marking. Was the ball in the penalty area or not? And I suspect from what we're hearing, it was. I'm I'm the same with you in my idea. In my eyes, the the bridge is definitely in the penalty area. It's just where which part of the bridge is in and which part of it's out.
It could be a long walkway in the general area and then into the penalty area part of the bridge because that's the part that's over the ditch, ditch and bridge. And people Colin to understand from why Maddie so So it's definitely in the penalty area. And as you said, he's taken 17.11 shot penalty without knowing he can get lucky, but probably unlikely. Unlikely in this situ scenario
in that he could drop in the correct relief area. Even though we just. Even though we talked about this in the GRQOTW where you have to have the intention to play under the the correct rule, you don't. It's not the same for free relief and for penalty areas. That's only for lost ball and unplayables. Anyway, that's a sidetrack. In my mind, the only way that this would not be a penalty
area, the part under the bridge was not a penalty area, is if the committee drew it up that way and we're allowed to draw it, draw it up that way. In this, in my mind, if there's a rabbit hole underneath, they weren't allowed to draw it up their way. I mean, it's ridiculous to have a bridge, sorry. It's ridiculous to have a ditch that's part of the general area just because it's under a bridge. Yeah. If it was completely cemented with a pipe and moveable
obstruction pipe going through, if you know, for the listeners out there, if you can think about that, I would allow that to be a moveable obstruction with the penalty area going on either side, but I would not allow if it was just pebbles and rocks and and loose dirt and stuff like that. What's a? What's a? If it wasn't a general area, would the caveat of a reasonable stroke might come into it as well? Yes and no. I mean, he could get down really low and say that he's going to hit like all you got to do is
say you're going to hit. It's got to be reasonable to hit like a six inch backswing and chip it out sideways. Yeah, that, you know, it gets tougher for a reasonable stroke if there's trees, big tree, big Bush, you know, your ball's 40 foot in the air or something like. That and the gap between the pebbles and the on the side of the bridge. Could be 30 centimetres, could be a foot, it could be no way of getting a making a stroke. We don't know without saying. You couldn't, Yeah. So in that case, not only is it you couldn't even go and play a stroke, but you couldn't even get to it.
In that Case, No chance, right? Good one and Nico, thank you very much for and we hope we helped you out there. We we agree with you Nico, basically, and we look forward to you when you're captain of Kennyworth. OK, guess who? Guess who? Colin from Wymaddy. Very good match. Play foursomes match that goes to the 19th and beyond.
Just like Toy Story, a stroke play round is also being played that also includes a match between the two pairs. Oh my God this sounds confusing already. How can you foursomes match in a stroke play round? How are they playing? Yeah, How are they playing individual stroke play? They're playing foursomes. Players have started on hole one and finished on the 18th, tied in their match and then presided to play another five holes to get a result. A week later one of their players asks if it goes to the 19th, 19th, should the shots be given again? The players would have started
on one and carried on until the 5th until a result was decided. And then he goes on to say, not entirely sure but this, but use this from the RNA. How ties will be decided in a handicapped match to stroke. Our index allocation set by the committee should be used to determine where handicapped strokes should be given or received in extra holes. Unless the terms of the competition stayed otherwise, a tie in a match should not be decided by a stroke play playoff. As I say, I'm not sure if this was the right decision, but plus it was a week later and the
winners were asking the question as they have another match to play. Sorry we were too late because this happened six weeks ago, Colin, but let's just say, let's forget about, let's just answer the question. If you play a match, the handicaps are given for the first eighteen holes. Then if you continue that match, you get your 18 hole handicap again. And it's not like it just stops. And I guess that's the easiest
way to saying it's Stewart is your handicap is an 18 hole handicap. For nine holes you halve it and for 36 holes you double it, right? Is that? Is that the easiest way to say it? Yep. And you continue in the same order and you can do the same order. So of course it depends on what match play index. We know we use a particular match play index in this country, which is very, very common. And we know that hole one is not index one. So in other words, you'd play
good chance you'd play the 1st hole or the 19th hole of the match. And there's no handicap strokes to be given because it's by the way. 18. Right, you have to get the whole 8 before you got the first one. We call it Universal Handicap, Universal Match Play Index, right? And it's only in Australia. It is very widely used though. In Australia, yeah, it's not universal. So like for example, if if the if the handicap strokes to be given worth three, that would only get one on the 4th hole because that's index three in
the match the. Gardener's run you're talking about. No the match play index. Oh yeah, right, right, right. Not the stroke playing index. The the universal only used in Australian match. Play index eight is 112 is 2, four is 3 and 16 is 4. I think yeah. And. 118 And so if they played an extra five holes, in those five holes only one handicap stroke would have been given and it would be on the 4th hole if they're using that index. If if three shots in your situation would have been three shots, OK. Yeah, yeah. We won't talk about whether
there was a foursome round and a stroke play round at the same time. As I'd like to see. That Colin write in again about that, that's blown my mind. Thank you very much, everyone who submitted. So thank you very much everyone. Podcast. Do you want to go through the 121 GRQOTW please? I Do GRQOTW for episode 121 is as follows. Our favorite, Andy, the average golfer, is playing a stroke round at Wombat Hills. On the 9th hole, he hits his
second shot way left towards the driving range among all of the other golf balls. However, he does find his ball and play his third stroke towards the green. After one chip and three putts, he holes out as he's waiting at the back of the ninth green waiting for the others to finish the hole. A staff member walks down very quickly and advises Andy that the driving range is out of bounds. Andy asks a staff member What
does that mean? Neither. No, So they approach you as a member of the committee for assistance. What is Andy? The average golfer's score for the 9th hole. Did I come second? That's what I want to know. Is something back in the 9th hole was? I was I coming? Did Andy win the comp when I was in second place? Well, fortunately he hasn't cleared off on the 10th yet. Oh, OK. So he's just waiting at the back of the ninth, Yeah. That that would definitely change my view as to whether he
he's gonna be penalized. So he's waiting at the back of the ninth, others are still putting out and someone's come down from the from the clubhouse and gone. Did I see you play from over on the driving range? Because that's how the bounce and Andy's gone. So what does that mean? And of course, the staff member didn't know. And because he's not DK and Andy didn't know. So they've grabbed you. What's his? Yeah, what's his? Score right? Excellent. Hopefully you have a crack. I know Ruin will have a crack on YouTube. That was that was a tricky one,
but the good thing is he didn't tee off in the 10th yet. So never know, the committee might be able to help him out. Thank you everyone for listening in. It's been a long time between drinks of you hearing my ditch and and bridge accent. Thank you very much again for Stuart podcast McPhee for looking after the podcast the last few months and and we'll see how we go going into the next few months as well. Get those clubland stories in.
I had been away on live and Asian Tour so I might get, I'm writing up a blog so you can read that in the latest drop zone or maybe the next drop zone if I get to it. But thank you everyone for listening in and contributing. Thank you, Stuart. My pleasure Blakey, good to see you back. Right. Let me hope, let's let's pray that I've recorded this thing. Oh, Jesus. Yeah, I know. Oh, it's.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...