GUEST: John Thorman - volunteer referee extraordinaire and author of 'Let's Get It Right' provides some curly scenarios from his book and talks about the referee craft - THE GRQ PODCAST EP129
In episode 129, Stuart chats with experienced Referee and rules expert John Thorman who is the author of the Rules Book, "Let's Get it Right". John talks about his start in the game, what sparked his interest in the Rules of Golf and his Rules journey. John mentions some of his tips about being a good Referee. Finally, John presents his own GRQOTW.The book 'Let's Get it Right' is available for free at https://issuu.com/dear_john/docs/dear_john_-_book_20162021?fr=sNDFkOTE5ODc3MTg GRQOTW128:David has nothing to answer for. He has the ability to change his mind if the removal of the tree meant his ball didn't move. When choosing to take an unplayble, the player has the ability to get to their ball, and if in the process the ball is moved, there is no penalty. GRQOTW129: Andy the Average Golfer is playing at Wombat Hills GC after an overnight rain. His ball lies on wet compacted sand in a bunker on the first hole. Thinking “lift, rake and place” is an option under the circumstances, Andy lifts his ball, rakes the area fluffing the sand, replaces the ball on the original spot, and plays his ball successfully from the bunker. How many penalty strokes, if any, does Andy incur? GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/ DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE? Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en) OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY https://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestions LISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules #GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
In episode 129 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast, Stuart chats with experienced referee and rules expert John Thorman, who is the author of the rules book Let's Get It Right. John talks about his start in the game, what sparked his interest in the rules of golf, and his rules journey. John mentions some of his tips about being a good referee. Finally, John presents his own Golf Rules Question of the Week for episode 129. Hello and welcome to the Golf
Rules Questions podcast. This is episode 129. My name is Stuart McPhee. No Blakey today, but I'm excited about having a special guest that I'll be interviewing very, very shortly and I'm looking forward to talking to him and learning some of his stories about the rules of golf. But before we do that, of course, we need to get to the answer to the Golf Rules Question of the week for episode 128. And the question was as follows. David finds his tee shot in a terrible lie with a large
unattached tree branch right beside his ball. He says that he is going to take an unplayable but then moves the tree branch and this causes his ball to move. Stewart didn't like this procedure and wants David to add 2 penalty strokes to his score, one for causing his ball to move and one for the unplayable. David is adamant that he was just moving the branch to get to his ball, but Stewart believes that had David moved the unattached tree branch and David's ball had not moved, he would have played it.
As it lies. They call you in to decide what is your decision. I cannot see a case for where Stewart's coming from with this. I would absolutely side with the player and David. He had announced his intention to take an unplayable. He was going through the actions to retrieve his ball. He's moved the branch out of the way. His ball has moved. We know one of the exceptions and there are five of them. We know that one of the exceptions to rule 9.4 is when the player is allowed to lift or move the ball because 9.4
applies the penalty for causing your ball in play to move. But one of the exceptions is there is no penalty when the player lifts the ball or causes it to move under a rule that requires or allows a player to drop or place a ball again or to play a ball from a different place. In other words, whenever you are applying a rule, you're allowed to move your ball and there cannot be any penalty for doing that. So in that sense, David's perfectly fine in the fact that he did 'cause his ball to move. If in fact, you know, he moved the tree branch out of the way
and then chose to play the ball as it lies and the ball didn't move. I cannot see any reason again why the player cannot change their mind and say, well, I know I said I was going to take an unplayable. I've been able to move the branch out of the way. The ball hasn't moved. And I cannot see a reason why David cannot change his mind and then continue to play the ball as it lies and not take an unplayable. There'd be no problem with that. But as it stands, if you did move the branch and the ball moved in doing that and then actually dropped correctly in the correct relief area under
the unplayable ball relief rule, probably under 19.2 in this particular case, then we'd apply one penalty stroke for taking an unplayable, but wouldn't apply anything else. So that's our answer to the golf rules question of the week for Episode 128. Well, let's get to our chat. So as I mentioned, I have a special guest today and I'm very excited about talking to this person. His name is John Thorman. John, welcome to the Golf Rules Questions podcast. It is great to have you.
Thank you, it's my pleasure. I always enjoy talking rules. Very good, as a lot of us do, and it's terrific to have someone equally passionate about the rules of Golf to come onto our podcast and chat to us. So clearly a lot of people listening into this won't know who you are. So you have a long history in the game, longer than most. Are you able to just tell us a little bit about yourself? I was new to the game at the at the age of 1415.
I didn't know what a six iron was then. I grew up on a farm, got exposed to the game by my uncle. I played a lot of recreational golf as a high school student, college and during my work career. No tournament golf, always recreational. And one thing led to another. I remember a round we were planned. I had my moments and I wondered
to myself, I hit a ball out of bounds and I wondered to myself, you know, should he just lay out and take a stroke and play on or what's the rule? What's the rule? I think I have to go back to the T And at that point I said how good would I be as a player if I played every stroke, every hole by the rules? And that's kind of what what set things off. I started learning the basic
rules and then then got into the more little more deeply into the into the body of rules Again, I played recreationally. My work career was as a chemical engineer. I did research, I did process development, I did troubleshooting, and golf was a diversion away from work.
And as the more I played, the more interesting the incidents became. I made contact in St. Louis, MO, with I'm. I'm in the heartland of Missouri and I made contact in Saint Louis with the Metropolitan Amateur Golf Association. And I asked them about the rules and they invited me to come to a few tournaments. And so on weekends, not weekdays, but weekends, I
dabbled in the tournaments and picked up a little exposure. This, this was probably 5810 years before I retired. And then as I approached retirement, I got more and more involved, took workshops, etcetera, and became a member of the Rules Committee for the Metropolitan Amateur Golf Association. I've I've worked.
That's my home association. I I refer to it in short, as Metro. I've also worked with the Saint Louis Men's District Association, Missouri Golf Association. I've done College Invitational tournaments, high school tournaments. I serve on the Crew for the NCAA Division Two regional tournament and do lots of USGA qualifiers. The Advocate PGA have done
tournaments with them, I've done Korn Ferry qualifiers. I think you get the idea. Very good. So I think certainly my experience has been that the impression I get is that most golfers, most players don't have much interest in the rules. Yet. There's a few of us like yourself and myself, where we seem to be different in that we are quite interested in the rules and and trying to know what is the correct way to proceed. Do you remember the moment you
had? Was there a spark? Was there a moment where you remember I need to get, I need to learn the rule? No one else seems to be interested, but I am interested. It was there a moment that started this journey for you with the. Rules. Yeah, that that point I mentioned about being in the middle of a round and I was having a good round, but then I just hit one out of bounds. Yeah. Yeah, and I says, you know, this isn't right, just laying it out. I've got to, I've got to do better. And of course, as you just said, most casual golf recreational golfers don't no and don't
appreciate, maybe don't have time for all the rules. But but I started digging. It was shortly after that I got a decisions book and I opened up the decision book and I've been playing golf for several years, many years. And I opened up the decisions book and my gosh, that was a foreign language. And to further the spark as I read the decisions, of course they had all these situations and I thought, Oh my goodness, this is a unique world.
And the more I read the unique decisions, the more enthralled I was with with the rules overall. Well, that's a great introduction to the reason why we have come together today and that is your book. And when you just talked about situations and scenarios in, can you tell us a little bit about your book please and what got you interested in doing that? It goes back to around 2014, 1516.
I'm a member at the Club of Port Chima in Sunrise Beach, MO. It's a Nicholas signature course. It's very nice course and our membership has on Thursdays, they call it men's day, a handicapped 4 ball stroke, 4 ball stroke play competition. We mix up members week to week and plays competition. I coordinated it and like you
said, a lot of a lot of recreational golfers don't know the rules and I was getting into rules pretty good by then and I thought, well, what can I do to expose these folks a little bit more to the rules. We wanted to play legit golf and so as the coordinator I sent out three emails a week. On Tuesday I sent out an e-mail saying we're please sign up.
We're playing Thursday morning. Wednesday night I sent out pairings and either Thursday night or Friday morning I sent out the results. Well, I started packing a little rules incident on to each e-mail and I, I formatted as a, as a dear John. Dear John, here's a question. What's the, what's the ruling? And I tried to add a little humor to it so that it wasn't completely boring. And I did that started that in 2016 and I continued doing that
through 2020. I accumulated quite a few of these and the, the, the pro at the, at the, at the club, said John. You know, if people read enough of these, they would learn the rules. He said you ought to write a book. Well, that goes in one inner, not the other. But I gave it, I gave it some more thought. And around 2020 I thought I'll do it. I don't know I'm going to do it, but I'll do it.
And I at the time, there were a few blogs out there in the Ethernet and there were also a few books in print. The books in hard print, my goodness, I think they were out of date before the print, the ink dried. And so I, I didn't want a blog and I didn't want a hard copy book. And I, I had seen an E magazine
and I said, well, I'll use that technique and do an e-book. It'll be digital. I'll be able to, to edit it, update it, I'll be able to add to it on an ongoing basis. And it'll be out there electronically. People won't need to have a lug around a paper book that's out of date before it, before they start reading it. So I, I got in contact with a very good friend, Jim, who's an
expert publisher and he, he navigated me through a couple software packages that I use for the e-book. And I leaned on some friends, very good friends to help me with proofreading and, and critiquing and editing, making sure everything you know, how the rules are. You've got to be very particular and specific or not precise or
things don't go well. And they're acknowledged in, in, in my, my ebook. Fred, Alvin, Woody and Mike, there are my mainstays through all this time and they continue to, to help me And I'm, I'm very grateful for that. At any rate, we, we wrestled through this is, these are 2016 incidents and the incidents didn't change, but the rules did. And so I had to go back and
rewrite those. Then of course, the rule, the rules had just been updated in 2019 very aggressively. And we, we got it into book form and issued it. I issued it, I issued it privately. It's it's the book is just a just a link. It's free of charge. There's no advertisements in it. It's my contribution back to the game and it's my way of all the
people that have helped me with the rules, it's my way of paying that forward. And like I said, I had several close friends. Lot of the lot of the material in the book I had questions but I didn't necessarily have answers to go with them. And what we couldn't figure out amongst my friends, I leaned on the USGA staff and I have
nothing but broad compliments for their help. There's a lot of material in the book that isn't necessarily explicitly stated in the official guide that I used to expand some of my answers and and stuff. So it's a it's a digital book, it's upgradeable, it's free, all you, all you need it, all you need is the link.
The leak hasn't changed since 2020, but the but the but the content changes every fall. Every offseason, I should say ours is from November 1st to May 1st. I make additions to the book. I make one a week and that's about 25 or 26 or the offseason. I put them in the back and then in the summer I mailed everything back into the body of the book in different sections and start over again the next
fall. I would point out that the book has you could flip pages if you want. There's a little arrow over the side just to flip pages or there's hyperlinks in there to navigate around. It's about 400 pages, so about about 303 hundred ish Dear Johnson there. And it doesn't have an index, but it has a search function, little magnifying glass at the bottom of the screen. And so if you want to look up
Acorn or Rule 13.1 or provisional, just do a search. And the rules as you know are they go across the whole spectrum putting greens, bunkers, penalty areas, whatever. And different words appear in in different different sections of the course, things like that. Knowing how often people confuse provisional walls, I'm sure
there's a lot of scenarios. Dear John, with provisional ball, when people search for provisional, I will make a few points. One, we will put the link in our show notes for this podcast episode both on YouTube and Spotify, so people can go through and check that out. The name of the book please? What did you call it? Let's get it right. Let's get it right, yeah? Thank you for doing. That of course, I also wanted to make mention of the USGA. So in Australia we fall under the RNA jurisdiction, but every now and again we do reach out to
the USGA. They provide timely, accurate, you know, great responses and I think they do a tremendous job at service, you know, serving the rules of golf community. I, I really do. So I no surprise when you say you leaned on them a little bit and they were very, very supportive and helpful. We also, in our correspondence prior to this chat, you mentioned our club land stories, and we sometimes joke that these are real because we wouldn't have the imagination to think of them, you know, to make them up.
And in that conversation between you and I, you were talking about some of your scenarios are the equivalent of our clubland stories. Are there any crazy stories or situations that you'd like to share from that book that would entertain our audience? I'd be delighted. Let me glance here. Oh, we had a, we had a situation at a amateur series that this is a tournament we conduct with
higher handicappers. But we have officials and the, the course that we played on had had a lot of rain and they hadn't, the maintenance crew hadn't been able to get out and get the fairways in the rough mode. And our, our groups started out and the maintenance crews ahead of them mowing the, the fairways. And there's quite a bit of grass clippings and there's, there's
piles of grass clippings in the fairway. They're trying to mow and, and then walk or come behind with a blower and disperse the clippings. Well, some of our groups got ahead of the blower and, and out in the middle of the fairway are these piles, significant piles of grass clippings. And the question came, came back over the radio. What are we going to do if somebody hits their ball into one of these piles?
Well, we just that's. That's very unusual. Usually the fairways and everything are pristine, so piles of grass was unusual. We decided that those were grass Philippines piled or removal. Therefore they were both loose and pediments and ground under repair. And so if the player could move the loose and pediments and have a free shot, very good. But if it was in the thick of of
the pile, we would give them relief abnormal coarse condition relief under 16 that one BI. Saw, I saw that photo actually and I think you had a photo and you could see the lines of grass clippings up the fairway. There was a fair bit. Yeah, it's it's on for for reference, it's on page 2O2. OK, another one that's a little challenging. I had, I had some help from a friend. This is a new friend that I met over the the Internet with my
book. It wasn't on the original group of people that I listed and acknowledged. His name is Stewart. He's another Stewart from down under. And he read my book and he gave me many useful comments and for sure for which I'm grateful. And in particular there was a I'm looking for my notes. And I just will interject there he is. I know that to do it and he is a regular listener to air podcast
OK, which is. Nice. Very knowledgeable. Very knowledgeable. Very So I I had a situation you might have you and Blakey might have mentioned it on the podcast. One of the more recent ones, player comes finds their ball nestled in thick, tall, tall grass. It's nestled on another above another ball.
And the question is what to do The other ball, a stray ball is a movable obstruction. So is the ball against the movable obstruction or on the movable obstruction? That's pretty subtle. And when we first wrote the Dear John, we bailed out. I bailed out and said, well,
it's a it's they have to make a judgement. OK, well then I got some feedback from Stewart. He he referenced some USGA Facebook discussions where the USGA chimed in and the ball, the players ball was against the stray ball, not on it. If you looked at it, you'd say
it's right on top of it. The, the trick here, the, the subtlety is if, if I gave you a corresponding example and I said, here's a rake next to a bunker, my balls rolled over and it's resting next to the handle, you would say, ah, that's a ball against a move, old obstruction. Maybe I'll mark the ball and I'll lift the rake. And if the rake, if the ball
moves, I'll replace it. OK, what is that 15.1, our 15.2 A1? OK. On the other hand, it might be that the ball rolls over and comes to rest on the head of the rake. Now the ball is on the rake, and by on we mean it is completely supported by the rake. All right for a for a ball
nestled in tall grass above another stray ball. Undoubtedly it's resting against. It's partially supported by the grass against the other ball. Were the ball resting on the stray ball, it would be one of those situations where you have a ball on a counter and you're trying to balance the. Ball. Directly on top of it. So, so that's the difference.
And then the ruling is that the the player can remove the stray ball and if they're regional ball moves in the process, they replace it. And of course if it doesn't stay, you replace it again and then nearest point will stay at stay at rest. The interesting part about that is this past summer there was another tournament and similar
situation except for a instead of being a a ball players ball resting against a stray ball, it was resting against a baby turtle in the grass. OK, now we don't have a movable and the ball was bigger than the baby turtle. OK, baby turtle. OK, so now this is an immovable obstruction. This is an animal not defined as
loose and and and. So what are the players options? Play it and hurt the turtle. Well, turtle soup, yes, yes, yes. That's pretty cool. That's pretty cool. You thought of that one first. You could try nudging the turtle, but this was a baby turtle. It it was scared to death. It wasn't going to go anywhere. You could try picking up the turtle and moving away. It's it's like, you know, stick underneath the paw. If you move the turtle, the ball
moves. You need a stroke and have to replace it. You could take unplayable relief, but that's going to cost you a stroke. And then to your point that you could make Kurt turtle soup play it as it lies. All right, So what happened in this tournament? I, I just, I just had the picture and I followed up on it. What happened in this tournament is, and this relates to the principles behind what we we just discussed, with a ball on or against the stray ball, in
this case an animal. The USJ has a model local rule E 13. It was new in July of 2023 and the player may remove animals not defined as loose impediments from near the ball. And furthermore, if the ball moves in the process, you can replace it without penalty. So that's a good model local rule to have on your sheet.
Especially if you have baby turtles. Baby turtles? Yeah, of course. Yeah. Yeah. So that was a that was a very insightful look. Look into the nuances of the rules. I think if I just go back to the grass clippings, I think such an important part of refereeing which is not spoken about in the Rules of Golf Official Guide is getting consistency. And you know the first referee that comes across this situation
on the radio, we make a decision that everybody hears that decision and we are being consistent throughout the rest of the round tomorrow, etcetera, etcetera. Such an important part of referee is getting that consistency. Yeah, there's a brief follow up to that. That was that was a couple years ago. This year we had a tournament and I get a call on the radio from another official and they say John players over here in the rough and their balls mixed
up with some grass clippings. Do they get relief? We was really asking for a second opinion because he'd read that, that dear John knew the answer, and the answer was the the grass clippings were loose and pediments, but they were not piled for removal in the rough. They were left there for decay. Yes. So, so no free relief. The difference between piles of clippings in the fairway versus piles of clippings in the rough. Exactly.
Yeah, anymore. Do you have any more? Do you have another one or two interesting scenarios? I know you have a lot in the book, but just. One, yeah, yeah, yeah. Here's a here's an interesting 1 involves involves a electrical transmission tower. We were doing a mid am qualifier for the UUSUSGA and on a par 5 there were some huge couple 100 feet tall electrical
transmission towers and we're talking cement base, 4/4 pillars, cement bases, beams, 4 beams going up to the to the transition lines and cross members. Everyone and player hit their ball just behind this tower. So their, their their line of play to the green is right through this tower. And it does not look optimistic.
These cross members, it's the the greens elevated. He's got to hit the ball up. And he he turns around. I happen to be over there. And he turned around and said, what do I do? How do I get out of this mess? And fortunately, we had a another model local rule in effect. E11E11. Yeah. And the way it was phrased, that's always important. Ball deflect by power line model
like local rule 11 is an effect if it is known or virtually certain that a player's ball hit a power line and then in brackets or tower or a wire or pole supporting of the power line during play the stroke, excuse me, does not count. The player must play a ball without penalty from where the previous stroke was made. See rule 14.6 making stroke from where the previous stroke was made.
So my vice recommendation the player was no worries, hey, go for it, go for it. If if you get through, all is well, fine. If you hit the tower, we're going to cancel your stroke. It never happened. You're going to come back and when you take stroke and distance relief, you'll be able to move your ball a stroke, I'm sorry, a club length to 1 to one side or the other.
So one way or another, you're going to get through or we're going to migrate to where you have finally get an open shot. Exactly, but you're not 5 club lengths to the right and now I have a clear shot. Can I have one more if you have? Time. Sorry, may I ask, do you remember what happened? How many strokes it took? Oh, I'm sorry. That's OK. Yeah, he got through on the first try. Oh. OK, well, I guess that risk was taken away and he just made a stroke.
It it it was a no lose situation. Exactly. Yeah, thanks. Thanks for asking. I didn't. I didn't, but it made a good Dear John. Yeah, absolutely. And important obviously when obviously most courses would not adopt or committees adopt E 11. But clearly if you have that situation, you would have that model local ruling place. We we have several tournaments over the years at that course and that's a standard on the on the notice for that, that particular course. Yeah, absolutely and absolutely. We've got time for one more.
Definitely. All right. Please go ahead. There was a we were having another tournament. This didn't happen in the tournament, but I was speaking with some some volunteers that were members at this club and they talked about on on see, it was a par five, I think the 12th hole, a player's drive hooked over to the green on the 15th hole and he made a hole in one
the 15th hole. OK, so the dear John aspect, it didn't happen, but it was like like a lot of other incidents that are in the book. It was fuel for a for a dear John, an interesting ruling. And the interesting part about this ruling was the wrong the 15th green is a wrong green. Wrong greens are in the general area and the ball was in the
hole. The hole was made by the greenskeeper. It's Gur. So the player had two options. They could take wrong green relief to the nearest point directly or they could do it in 2 steps. First take ground under repair relief from the hole and then do wrong green relief. Well, is it so happens there, there were a lot of trees
between the 12th hole and the 15th hole and it would have been in this case depending on where the hole was on, on the green, it would have maybe been to the players advantage to take ground under repair to get closer to one side of the green versus the other. The four bit, four and a bit inches made a difference. That the whole made a difference. Well, you get a club length from your nearest point of relief. That's that's where the the the leverage came in versus the club length was the was the
difference as to which side of the green the ball may go to or for relief. Wrong. Green relief. OK if this was purely a hypothetical, but clearly the 15th green was potentially being able to land on playing the. 12th it it, it emphasizes the point that that's a general area and you know, general area rules still apply. Yeah, yeah. OK, very good. Well, thank you very much for
sharing. Again, we have this similarity between your Dear John situations and our Clubland stories, which we absolutely love getting and reading and trying to respond to live on our podcast. So thank you for sharing for those. And again, mention of your book, clearly people who listen to this podcast are very interested in the rules. So they absolutely worth their time getting the link and going and having a look at your book and having a flick through. And I had a flick through of it just before.
And as you said, there are hyperlinks in there allowing you to, it's sort of the table of contents I saw at the beginning and go through the different sections. So terrific and the way it's been laid out in different areas of the course and the like. So we've spoken a little bit about refereeing and being on course. We, we soon find that the official guide, there's very little information about being an effective referee. There are some references in committee procedures, but not a lot. What tips would you give to somebody who wants to take their knowledge and start applying it
on course for real in real situations? What some of the tips you'd give an aspiring referee to being a good referee. Well, as you and Blakey point out in numerous podcasts, there are the rules and there's the craft of officiating. And it certainly helps to know the rules. That's not an easy task, but a parallel path is learning how to officiate and, and as you
pointed out, there's the committee procedures give a little help in the official guide. But if we, we work with our association, we're trying to develop a new generation. Your, your, your questions very apartment. We're trying to develop a new generation of, of younger officials to come in and take over with time. It's a, it's a cumulative process. It doesn't happen with one
tournament and one read of the official guide. It takes a lot of time and we encourage new people to contact the association and ask if they can shadow an experienced rules official. By that I mean right in the same cart. Spend the morning or a day riding with with an experienced official and just just talk
about situations they're doing on the course, talk about the whole they're on, etcetera. See how they deal with players, see what issues come up, how how they how they relate. You know, they'll, they'll hear conversations on the radio, they'll get the feel for what goes on amongst amongst officials rather than just watching, watching the players play golf. So I would, I would recommend the shadowing experiences. If you, if you shadow a morning,
you may get exposed to everything that can happen on a particular hole. And then you're sort of a local expert and maybe you can be a zone official on that hole in the afternoon. And then the next tournament, another course, another official, and repeat the process and start to get comfortable. I would highly recommend. We'll be highly recommending the GRQ podcasts. Little little point information here.
A friend of mine tipped me off to GRQ only a little over a month ago, early November. And I take walks in the morning, I listen to the podcast on my walk and I've listened to around 30 of them now. And there is a wealth of officiating information in there, a wealth you don't it helps to shadow with people, but they can listen to your podcast and and that's a nice plug for your podcast.
I was very calm. But it, but it's, but I, I'm, I'm genuinely honest, it's, there's a wealth of information in there. And I had another point I was going to make about that. Ask questions, ask questions and watch tournaments. Watch tournaments for the rules, watch tournaments for how officials handle things. Get all the input that you can. That's how I'd start new people out and then as their experience grows, give them more
responsibility. They can be starters. They can be zone officials. Just be involved somehow. Just get the on course, be involved some. Yeah, I think yeah, for a lot of us, and me included, I started as a walking at these professional events. I started as a walking scorer. So I was, you know, recording the scores for all the professional players and putting it through them on the app and radioing it through for the television broadcast. And that's how I, but I was involved and I was seeing how it all worked.
And it's just, yeah, get involved, get immersed, isn't it? We obviously have a passion for the game and the rules. So being involved somehow and hopefully it grows to something very special. Do you have a set of rules yourself on how you deal with players? Like, is there something you always say at the start when you come up to a player? Is there certain things you try to avoid saying? I think, I think what we recommend in our, in our associate we, we have a cadre of about 25 ish officials in the
Saint Louis area. I'll get to your question. And and we meet, we meet during the season April through October. We meet during the season once a month and it's about two hours a month and we go over officiating techniques and how to deal with with rulings, how to handle players, course marking, pace of play, etcetera. And our very first meeting every year we, we have a, a few slides
from quotes from John Paramore, Slugger White and Mark Russell. All right. And I've got, I got some others as well. One in particular I picked up from and this will get to your point out. What do you say? Slugger White in his comments said, I always ask when I go up to the player, how may I help you? OK, He's there to help you.
He's he's he's, he's trying to be be open and, you know, solicit, solicit, whatever your, your, your need is. All right. So that's the first thing we do. Another thing I picked up from Katrina Matthew, she did a interview with the the RNA. This has been a few years ago, but she listed the question the interviewer asked her, what do you look for in an official? And, and she's a Solheimer
captain, She's playing lots of golf, LPGA Tour European. And she says, I want them to be concise. I want them to be confident and I want them to be correct. And to that I would add one more that I picked up on your interview with John Robinson. Calm, calm. So I I would go up and say, how may I help you? And I tried to do the other four things.
Wow, that's very, very insightful. Be correct is a good one, but be concise, yeah? Yeah, they're not. They're, they're not Never, never quote rules. They, they're focused on their game, concentrating on their, their next shot. They just want to know if, where, where the if they get relief and if they do, where do they go? What are their options? Yeah, I had a casual conversation with the player at one point and I said, what are you looking for? And it was tell me what I need
to know and go away. Like, just get to the point. Tell me how you can help me and what my options are, and then do that quickly. And then let me, you know, leave me alone. And he wasn't being rude. It was just don't waffle. Don't talk to me for 2 minutes, you know, just be concise and tell me how you can help. No, that's terrific. And I'm very interested and I'll follow up with this with you after this chat. I'm very interested to get some of those other quotes you mentioned on your slides from some of those other people because I love that sort of stuff because they're so
powerful. Well, I know you've done the USGA exam as I have. You've done it multiple times, and you shared with me some of your scores, which are incredibly impressive. With all of that experience and all of that knowledge you have about the rules. Are there still? Is it just one rule that still confuses you just a little? I wouldn't wouldn't say I, I wouldn't use the the word confuse, but rule 5.7 D.
Of a sorry suspension apply. Some of the Yep, Yep and when a when the player resumes play has as the ball has have the conditions been changed? Has the ball move ball or ball marker moved? Who, how were the conditions changed? Was it in sand or outside of sand? And on and on and on.
It's very, and it's very involved. And I, I don't think just looking at the rule book and reading that most officials know exactly what to do. So I, I wouldn't, I wouldn't necessarily call it confusing because it is, it is there is black and white there, but it is involved and I think it's one of the more challenging corners of, of, of the rule book. Specifically, when a player has
marked and lifted their ball for suspension and they've come back to that spot to resume play and the lie has been altered or the conditions have been altered. That's what you're talking about? Yep. Yeah. OK, very good. OK, very interesting. Thank you. Are there any rules that you would like to introduce or existing rules you don't like and would like to change if you had a golden pen and you could sign a change? It's it's not a rule per SE, but I would, I would add my voice to
chorus of folks that you've had on your interviewed on your podcast about pace of play. And sorry, I should add 1 of Blakey's hot topics. I was talking about place supply or lack of place. And, and it's, it's an issue at all levels, juniors all the way up through seniors, amateurs through professionals all, all the tours, etcetera.
It's it's an ongoing issue Every everybody, everybody recognizes it. What I, I, if I had a magic wand, I wouldn't write a new rule, but I would I would like to see a way of sharing real time feedback on timing with players as officials, when when we monitor pace of play, the
first thing we do is we look at the we call it the Raguzzi sheet. Do you have that expression? Not that expression, no. It might be very similar. Sheet or will it time part? Yes, yeah, time, time to finish the whole. All that, yes. Yeah, OK, OK. We, we have a, a spreadsheet printed out and it, you know, the first group, so many men's
play the 1st hole, they should be done at this time, the next, next hole another time. And so we will, we will track groups and we'll see where they are. Are they ahead of pace? Are they a little behind? Are they a lot behind? The other thing we check is whether they're in position, how far are they? There's various guidelines for that, but how far are they behind relatively relative to the group in front of them?
And if things aren't in good shape, the next thing we do is we, we get a out of position timing form and we start monitoring how long individual players in the group take to make their strokes, their drives, their Rd. shots, putts, etcetera. And we as officials are monitoring all those parameters, time, par position, how long
they're taking strokes. But the players are busy playing their game. I I honestly wonder if they appreciate, you know how long it takes them to make a stroke. How often do they we we our scorecards for the players will have the time to finish hole printed at the bottom of of the scorecard beneath the hole. But how many players check that with their, with their watch, even even that?
And so if there was a way to have a something like a clip, something you could Click to the the belt, your belt or waistband or put it on your cap or something shoelaces, whatever, so that you could get some feedback. That's the operative word feedback on how you're doing with with pace and you can use your imagination if you, if you
got a little behind pace, maybe a yellow light or some kind of a vibrational buzz or something like that or a Ding. And if you got further behind, maybe a. Electric stock. Well, yes, electrocution. Not something something different, but something to get their attention and, and and make them make them aware. Otherwise, otherwise what we do as officials is whether the
players are aware of it or not, they get behind and then we I think the usual protocol is to wait until they tee off at the next hole after after they tee off, then we approach them and give them some unpleasant news and have an awkward exchange and and we go on. And it'd be nice, it'd be nice if, like I said, if I wave a magic wand, it would be nice to
have have it so players could get get feedback on their time and think about it. We've got distance nailed down, distance measuring devices. OK. You know shot link and GPS and carts and range finders etcetera. Also electronic scoring instead of a scorecard is becoming more and more prevalent.
So technology has may have a role here. How can you how can you relate timing information? How can you do timing even and and share that feedback with the player? And then the next question is, would the player respond to it? As you say it would, it would be immediate feedback they're. They could look an. Instant response. You know they're getting, yeah. Their last their their last five shots or ten shots or something
like that. You, you know what it's like looking at the sophisticated watches. If you had some sort of a electronic clip where that information could be glanced at that yeah, that'd be my magic wand move. You know, you mentioned about speaking to a group once they tee off and you know, I've just done that recently and you think to yourself, they know exactly why I've just hopped out of my cart and I've walked across in
their path. They know exactly what I'm about to say. And you sometimes think, you know, is it in one ear and out straight away? And then Blakey and I have spoken about this previously that we think sometimes the slowest players don't think they're slow, which doesn't help. It doesn't help. But if they were to have this immediate objective, you know, immediate response, clinical information rather than someone's opinion, yeah, that might change. Behaviour might change.
Yeah. Very good, very interesting. Is it obviously a contentious issue, basically? Very much so. Well, John, this has been an absolute pleasure to meet you this way and to have a chat with you about the Rules of Golf. You have offered to present our golf Rules question over the week for this episode, and we'd be delighted if you'd like to share with us your question for this episode, please. I'd be delighted. I've got one person, very important person that I didn't
mention in my my acknowledgements and it relates to everything, especially and including the, the e-book, and that's my wife. When I was sitting and working on this e-book and putting everything together, she had the, she had lots of patience, lots of support. She's a St. Very, very good all. Right, let's see, where's our question? All right, I've been listening to a number of podcasts, so I got the drill here. Andy, the average golfer is
playing at on bat Hills Golf Club after an overnight rain. How am I doing so far It's. Fantastic, Andy, the average golfer again at On Bat Hills. That's wonderful. Thank you, John. And his ball lies on wet compacted sand in a bunker on the 1st hole. There's no visible water. Thinking that lift rake in place is an option under the circumstances and he lifts his ball, Rakes the area, fluffing the sand, replaces the ball on
the original spot and plays the ball successfully from the bunker. How many penalty strokes, if any, does Andy and Kirk? Very good, Andy. The average golfer. It's not as good as you and Blakey, but. No, absolutely. That's a terrific question because there's a few issues to consider there. And I will give a hint, there are definitely at least one penalty stroke for end of the average golfer for his actions. That is fantastic. Thank you. We will post it again in our
show notes as the GRQOTW for episode 129. Again, John, this has been a pleasure. Thank you so much for your time and sharing with us some of your stories. It's been great to have you. Thank you Stewart, it's been a pleasure and an honour. Terrific. Thank you very much and thanks everyone else for listening. Look forward to speaking to you again sometime soon.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...