Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

Clubland Stories September - THE GRQ PODCAST EP102

Oct 22, 202351 minAudio

Clubland Stories September - THE GRQ PODCAST EP102Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/joinSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rulesGRQOTW101 - Although Andy has done the wrong thing, by dropping under Rule 17.1d(3) when he wasn't allowed to, because his original ball was found outside the PA, he was able to pick up the dropped ball and continue play with the original ball for no penalty.Clubland Stories1. Reasonable judgement on whether a ball is in a Penalty Area or OOB - Geoff2. Player accepts a penalty that he didn't incur - DK3. Jimbo doesn't replay his stroke after his devious friends stop his ball - Jimbo4. Marker doesn't know whether player is telling the truth - CBY5. Peter moves his ball without first marking it - Colin6. Ball in motion accidentally hitting equipment - Zuma GolfGRQOTW102Blakey and Stuart are playing a match at Wombat Hills. It is Blakey's turn to putt on the 1st green and he removes the flagstick from the hole, placing it on the green behind the hole. Blakey's putt is way too hard and believing the ball will definitely hit the flagstick, Stuart rushes over and picks up the flagstick. Blakey's ball continues to roll past where the flagstick was on the green. Blakey is not happy and requests a ruling. Are there any penalty strokes and what happens next?.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

You are listening to episode 102 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. This week Stuart and Blakey dive into Clubland stories and there are plenty to catch up on this week. We cover situations where the committee has to get involved to make a determination, including one where the players are trying to play faster. Then there is the player who accepted a penalty when they didn't have to because they didn't know the rules. We also deal with a couple of moving ball incidences And what is the peeling stroke play if you don't replay the stroke?

We hope you enjoy episode One O 2. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Hi everyone, Welcome back to Golf Rules Questions Podcast. This is episode 100 and to I'm Blakey alongside me is Stewart McPhee or some know him as Stew are.

They going to go on the podcast? Oh, there you go. I totally forgot about it. Oh. I bet you did. Well, I've been, I've been away, got had live golf. But now I'm back. And more importantly, we're going to get into clubland stories because we know that you've missed them and we have missed talking about them as well. So how you been? Podcast Well, yeah, pretty good, thanks. Not travelling as much as you have though. Well, I did go on holiday, but not as far as you for your work and being on the golf course.

Enjoying that? Yeah, no, it's it was good. That was the 4th time I've been in Jeddah in 20 months, so and it was hot. It was very hot. I think one day it got up to 43 degrees or something like that, so. Maybe with AC, not an F when we talk about degrees, yeah, which is what. But I'm hanging out with a lot of Americans, so they work it out and they're like 01215 or something like that. And then the hot, the hot wind sort of came off the off Africa.

And I think we managed that pushes it up too. And I think we managed to crack half a century in Celsius and almost 120 in in Fahrenheit too. So it was hot. Yeah. And one of the coolest things actually call us, not not by temperature, but one of the coolest things. The back nine at Royal Greens actually has lights around every hole. And we had this, unfortunately not the front 9, otherwise we'd

probably probably play the championship there during the night. But we managed to play the first live golf caddy championship, so all the caddies from all the teams played a scramble together. And some of them are, you know, extremely good golfers, some of them not. So. I was a walking scorer for the Stinger team. We managed to get to, I think we got the eight under but after for nine holes, but we lost by two shots.

The Smash team and the Iron Heads team got in the playoffs down the 18th and it was the first time the Iron Heads have seen the podium. So that was pretty good for them. Obviously they were ribbing it to their players because the players haven't seen the podium, but that was really cool. You know, It was. It was still like 28 degrees at at 10:00 at night, but the sun wasn't beating down on us so it wasn't as bad. But yeah, hopefully we'll keep that going. That'll be a tradition going on next year and the year after, so

that was really cool. You know, just on that because you don't see them play. It's easy to lose sight of the fact that a lot of caddies are actually. Pretty good golfers, and in fact, a lot of them are on that path to become professionals themselves and maybe just feel like that last hurdle just fell short a little bit. So I can still play very, very, very good golf. Just didn't make it to that final level. But you don't see them play, so you don't even think about whether they can play or not. But a lot of them can, Yeah, absolutely. It does help.

I think you know if you are getting a caddy that you want to help read greens that you get someone who has obviously done it themselves, got down to a scratch or something like that. As I said, not every caddy is like that, but there were a hell of a lot of good golfers in the caddy ranks that and then you know some of the players were out as well. They came out like the I was walking scorer with the Stingers. The whole Stingers team went the whole nine holes and they were carrying on yahooing and it was

just brilliant. It was just really gave it a great feel and unfortunately our guys didn't get over the line, but it was just fun to be No 10. 10 10 under was two teams had 10 under. That was 2 Eagles, 2 pars and five birdies. No one par 2 Eagles and 6/6 30s. So yeah, really good golf. So let's get into episode 102.

Firstly, the golf course question of the week for 101 podcast. GIQOTW Episode 101 In an individual stroke play event, Andy, the average golfer hooks his tee shot left towards a red penalty area on the 3rd hole at Lombay Hills. His group searches for around around one minute in the thick grass outside the penalty area and frustrated, and he drops a ball using lateral relief from the red penalty area, even though it is not known or

virtually certain to be in the penalty area. He's about to play his next stroke with the dropped ball when someone else finds his original ball in the thick grass outside the penalty area well within the three minutes of search time. Which all must Andy play? And are there any penalty strokes? OK, so Andy actually gets really lucky with this one, so he's he's dropped the ball without having virtual certainty. So without having that at least 95%, no virtual certainty that

has balls in the # area. So that's an incorrect drop, or a procedure that he's not allowed to proceed under. Then he hasn't played it yet, so he's just simply dropped it into play. But he hasn't played it. Someone else comes along and finds his ball outside the penalty area. He's actually allowed to pick up the ball that he dropped because he proceeded incorrectly and go and play his original ball for a second shot.

So he gets really lucky with that one. Now Stuart, I've got a question for you. What happens if the guy or the person didn't find it outside the PA in the long grass but they actually found it inside the PA in the long grass? Is the ball that he dropped the ball in play or does he have to pick it up and re drop it now because he's got the 95% virtual certainty? That's a really good question. I would suspect if he is dropped based on the correct relief area and therefore the correct reference point. And it just so happens to be,

yes, there's ball there and it clearly lasts across the edge of the penalty area. Way you've identified the reference point for relief, I think you'd be OK if of course you realize, well, no, I'd actually cross a lot further up or a lot further back changing that reference point. You would definitely. I mean, you have to change. In fact you must, as one of the clarifications under rule 79.1 that says you must actually change and actually go and pick up that ball and correct that. Don't know for certain, I reckon you'd be OK. You now have knowledge of

virtual certainly, even though when you dropped, you didn't. That is an interesting one. For the second one, where the ball has, it's a different last point. Crossed on the edge, Last edge, crossed spot on the edge. I never get that one right. Yep, we're great. Pick the ball up, drop it under the new. But do you need to drop it? So we'll go to 14.5 when a player has substituted another ball for the original ball when

not allowed under the rules, or the player's ball in the play was replaced, dropped or placed in a wrong way, wrong place, or using a procedure that did not apply at the time he dropped it, that procedure did not apply and he didn't have KBC. It just so happens. I mean, I could see an argument both ways, and I could certainly see someone going well when he dropped it. You use the procedure that did not oblige and therefore the player may correct the mistake without penalty, only allowed before that ball is played.

And I could see an argument for going look if it's in the right spot, which would be unlikely that it was exactly the reference point. Unlikely. Excuse me, but I mean, good chance probably that reference point was not exactly. Where it probably entered, where they where aiming just frustratingly decided to drop. So we might get back to you on that one I I can see an argument for both ways as well. He proceeded incorrectly. It does say the player may correct the mistake.

So is it now no longer a mistake, right, because the ball was found? And now we have certainty and now we have certainty, yeah. Or is it a case of yeah, but you you have to correct the mistake by picking it up and dropping it, even though that might be now the correct relief area. And if someone thought that and they thought they were doing the right thing by going, oh, I need to pick it up and drop it again. Because when I dropped it initially it was under the wrong

and then they picked it up and dropped it again and they now playing from a wrong place because what they had actually done. Was correct. When the committee comes up, no, no, no, it was fine. You didn't have to drop it again at all. I'm going to have to ask someone that one. Oh, we'll definitely look at our own little network where we throw these. That's too. That's too difficult for me. I'll, I'll take it another step at the end of that round if he's marker or one or two of the other players in the group, said Hey, on the 3rd hole, Andy

dropped from that penalty area. There is no way that was in that penalty area and he dropped mentioned that committee then. They'd have to gather all those facts. And if he didn't drop, sorry. If he dropped when he wasn't supposed to, and then obviously didn't find the original ball so, and of course then his only option was then to return to the T, then you're talking about far serious, much more serious consequences. That marker or that group person didn't. Another person in the group didn't say anything at the. No, no. Probably should have, but they could have even expressed. But then he was just beyond frustrated.

I mean, if you're a part of the committee, would you ask that person why they didn't bring it up at the time? Yeah, but then what? What would the correct answer be? Why didn't you bring it up at the time? And then, oh, Andy's. Andy's got a fiery temper. I didn't want him to punch me. Well, that's I wouldn't as a committee. I wouldn't take that. I'd I'd be more leaning. Towards the play I I said to him I didn't think it was in the dominance, that's the but I don't mean he didn't want to believe me. He didn't want to buy it. Well that's he was just frustrated that would be the the correct answer if you said something and.

Now it's. And we've had this situation at The Players Championship and I forget. I forget. I think the player was Daniel Burger. Yeah. And the other two, Victor Hoffman, maybe in the other one and one other. Both going right and both going. There's no way across there. Yeah. And Hamburger's going, yeah, dude, the other two is 2 against one and maybe four against two. If you think of caddies, you know. Yeah. What kind of committee do then? And I like the fact that the other two players are not just protecting the two of them, they're protecting 142. Yeah, that's right.

And. That's protecting the rest of the field by doing that, yeah. Correct. Anyway, right, We'll get back to you with an answer about whether someone drops under the incorrect procedure and then turns into the correct procedure, whether they need to redrop or they continue with the ball played as it lies. If the relief area is exactly the same, and when I say exactly the same, of course you're just going to estimate where the ball

crossed into the penalty area. So what if that estimation is going to be the same spot regardless of whether you were to find it or not find it? Agree. Yeah, absolutely. We'll find out. As I said, I think it's more likely than not to be in a different spot that way. They just happen to drop, but how about actually that could be you've probably already sorted it out, but that could be our golf balls question of the week one O 2. We know I've already gone from that could be because we want you to come back to us and tell

us the answer and if you can't, obviously we will find out the answer. Yeah, that'll do. So the question for GOQ, this is so funny because then we do it for Quest Episode 100 with Ross. We did the GRQ at the both GRQ answering question at the end. There may be some. Now we're going to do issues. Now we're going to do the GRQ. We'll, we'll save it. We'll keep. We want people to keep listening in. Well, it's clubland. Story Just listen to Oh well,

everyone wants to hear, everyone wants to hear the clubland story, right? Let's go Jeff Par 4 on the tee. Outer Bounds runs from the tee to about halfway out of the fairway on the right hand side. The rest of the right hand side consists of hazard or penalty area all the way to the green. All this area is full of grass and trees. If the ball enters here, it is hard to find Playing match play. My opponent drives towards the outer bounds and hazard on the right hand side. Either of us or neither of us can confirm the correct location.

My opponent says it went into the penalty area. I say it went out of bounds. What is the ruling as if it's as a as if it is out of bounds it becomes three out of the T If it's hazard then it's third shot is taken down at the entry point to the penalty area. Just wondering what the answer? Is. I'd like to know what happened. So Jeff, you, you know, playing match play, you just need to work out the best, the most accurate place that this is

going to be. Obviously you're saying something, they're saying something. It's a he said, he said. Or he said, she said, whatever the cliche is and the facts of the case, you know, if it's 300 meters off the tee and your opponent hasn't hit it past 240 all day, I think we know who the aunt who's correct. However, if it's 180 off the tee and your opponent usually hits it at least 240 on the fly, it's more likely that it's going to

be the opponent. Will you agree with that? Yeah. So you really just need to work it out between the two and a few. And if you can't work it out, then you're going to get the committee involved, IE Stewart and I are the committee at the moment and we are going to say exactly this. We're going to ask the questions that you need to ask of the situation about who is more likely to be right and then work it out from there. I should add about, you know, we

talk about this a lot, the difference between strike play and match play and with match play, it's about protecting your rights. And your opponent, unlike a field in stroke play and you can't see most of the players, your opponent in match play is right there and you're in a position to protect your rights. And if the player thinks no, my ball's definitely in the penalty area it's probably maybe poor course marking. I I believe this is hypothetical but probably poor course marking to have all that thick grass outside the penalty area, to not be very clear that it's in there. But that aside it comes down to

look. I believe it's. I believe my ball is in a penalty area. It's my ball and I'm going to proceed as I see fit, which then puts it back onto the opponent to go, well, I feel strongly enough where I'm going to request a ruling or I'm going to let him go with let him go and that comes back to the opponent. Then to go, well, how much do I want to protect my rights? And the easy thing to do of course is to request a ruling, at which point the player goes, what does that mean? And the opponent says, well, this is, we'll work it out, you know, with the committee and. In a in a way you hope the match

is not hinging on that one hole and maybe the Hatch. The match is already over one way or the other anyway and you get to the item hole and you know the match is still open and you don't have a result for one hole. In a way either that players played from the wrong place or they proceeded correctly and lost the whole like they played from the wrong place. So you would come back to the committee and this could take 1015 minutes or the pro shop in their absence and you would ask the questions you just said. And you know, what if this was really serious? You drive them all out. You drive them out there and say, right, let's have a look. Not searching for the ball, but

have a feel for right. Where would that ball likely gone? You know, I'm, I'm thinking aloud here, but tee up five and show me how far you're hitting them today. Now. Something like that, you know. Thinking that in my mind too, you get to try and reheat it to see if they could hit. It like 5 just give me your best shot. And the opponent could be sitting there going great, cuz I know there's no way he's reached that penalty area, no way in the world. So it's either lost in the thick grass or it's out of bounds. I'm in the right, he's gonna apply for the wrong place, et cetera, et cetera. So anyway, there's all those options available to the committee. What if it's right on the right

on the line and you know that person then blast like you know hitting a a soft cut out there and it only goes 200, whereas then you just start aiming little drawers, see guys draws 280 and you're like you know who's going to win there. It's it's not an easy situation, but at the end of the day, I think if you know if it's bad light and you can't do that, what it's going to come back to is most likely going to come back to the player. The player is going to have the

benefit of the doubt. You know, the committee might have some history with this player, knowing that this player isn't the best with their integrity and honesty. And he has to live with that. And you know, they might come back to haunt them. And that's allowed because why wouldn't it? You know, if you've got a dodgy history, then you should cop that. But at the end of the day, if both people priests, they're

like, no, that's a bad example. If both people, you know, I was going to say lawyers, definitely not both people are uphelding citizens, definitely not politicians either. Then at the end of the day it comes back to the benefit of the doubt for the player so. And at the final bit, the committee will have to make a decision. Yeah, one way or the other. If they get out of $0.50 coin to flip it, well that's that's their call.

But they need to make a decision. I think the benefit of the player comes, yeah, the benefit of the doubt goes with the player. Yeah, I'm just saying whatever way they come up with a decision, it's the committee's decision in the final. Yeah, that's right. Well, I hope, hope you got that one, Jeff. Right. We've got another one from DK. In a match, Player A hits the second stroke on the 4th hole and a red penalty area. He drops correctly into the general area using lateral relief before playing his next stroke. The ball rolls back into the red penalty area due to natural

forces. The player and his opponent discuss the situation and both agree that he must take another penalty drop. He gets up and down from this point, recording 6 strokes against his opponent's five strokes. Although player A recorded Loughlin's hole on this hole, he goes on to win the match. Oh nice, the player mentions the situation. The committee member who advises they did not need to take another penalty and they should have listened to GRQP this week

for David and Podcast to discuss the situation. He calls you David and I, and he calls you podcast, right? DK, you've seen this like, ages ago, but thank you for bearing with us. Yeah, the way I got tricked into, I won't say tricked. He got advised the wrong thing and agreed with it. And that's the way it sits. This one actually changed 1 January 2000 and three 2023.

And if you're after taking relief and your ball was at rest, it rolls, getting pushed by gravity, sun, water, wind, natural forces is what all those things come under then. And it goes into a different area of the course. So it goes from general area to green general area to bunker general area to penalty area, bunker to green bunker to penalty area. You get the point.

Then you just replace it. OK, You replace it where it was at risk after you'd taken relief. No penalty. Just put it back. No penalty. We call this a Ricky Fowler rule, don't we? Ugly. Yeah, given that whole I re I re uploaded that one with new text. Yeah, I think the text or I commented on it, so. Rule 9.3 covers ball move by natural forces. Exception 2 to 9.3 if the player puts the original ball or

another ball into play by dropping, placing, or replacing it. So that's what this player's done by dropping it from a relief area. A penalty area and natural forces cause the ball at rest to move and come to rest in another area of the cause or out of bounds. The ball must be replaced on its original spot, which if not known, must be estimated. No penalty, just put it back. Yeah, and also having the Thorborn Olson on the European Tour. Unfortunate, but that was back then and they got the penalty,

extra penalty, but nowadays you'd be OK. And it's interesting you talk about the two players agreed therefore, and they didn't knowingly agree to a wrong rule like to not applying something, they just both. Well, they would have been right. They would have been right. Last year, yes, they would have been, but it's like the fact that they both agreed that that player can't go back to the committee later and go, oh. Actually the pro shop told me this or the the golf shop told me this and what do we do now? Well they can go back and then

the committee fires the golf shop but if they got it wrong but actually someone know they got it right. Actually I think someone someone messaged me the other day oh it's killing. So I had I had one the other day. This is going off the outside of the club land stories, but it is a club land story. This guy who knows the rules and you know we all all get one wrong every now and then. He knows the rules in a foursome, hits off from outside the teeing area.

Caesar's mistake gets his partner to hit off from within the same teeing area. And he said, Oh no, I think I've stuffed it up. And he de cued himself, went into the golf shop and they said no, no, you did the right thing. You're back in the competition. Why did he DQ himself then? Because they played out the hole. Sorry. So when he got his. They didn't correct it. He was supposed to correct it and take the two shot penalty. It was stroke player got his

partner too and got himself to play because he played from outside the team area, but he got his partner to play. So they played out of order. So they've got the two shots and if someone said something it would have been four shots. But they got the two shots for the outside the team, then they would have got the two shots for the out of order. Which still needs to be corrected, but both. Which is actually just two shots because no one knew. Or whatever intervening event. No intervening event, even

though he knew but he didn't know. We've talked about this before. So then but he still needs the most important thing. He still needs to correct that error, that mistake. And he they didn't. That team didn't. And once they got to the hole, once they got to the next team area and teed off on a mistake, I had to DQ goes into the Golf Club and the Golf Club said no, no, you did the right thing. You're back in the competition. And he said is that right? And I go, no, but we did, you

know, we all, he said I should have known it. And I said, I understand that. But everyone gets one wrong and you're supposed to rely, you'll be able to rely on the golf dot to know the rules because they someone tells them what happened and they get to sit there and go, where's the book answer is this. But they didn't. They just said no, no, you're right. So. That the situation we had is a what? What is the ruling in our drop zone newsletter a month or two or three. Of course a lot of. Remember, there was a lot of.

Disagreement with our response, remember, though, Yeah. And we had the USGAS backing, remember? Is that the one? Yes, because you and I, as partners, you take off outside play. That's right. And I've gone to correct it from inside the turning area. Yeah. How many penalty strokes? Where's the next shot pro played from and what stroke it will be? And it was definitely two general penalties. Yeah. Yeah, a lot of people don't know. Nothing matters until you correct the turning area because they because we knew of, we were aware, right? Well, it's just, I saw it as it's almost an additional a lot

of thought, A lot of people thought nothing, everything stops until that teeing area mistake is corrected. Yeah, but then we've compounded the issue by actually, you know, playing out of order. Now we've attempted to play from inside the teeing area, but out of order, both of which need to be corrected. You still need to play for inside the teeing area, not me. So I said there was a ball down the V way, you know, So where's the next shot made from? Who makes it and what stroke number will be? And a due from the teeing area still, and it'll be the 5th. We need to send that drop zone to that golf shop I'm going to

go. Back not to Kevin. He's all over it. I'm going to go. No, I'll send it on to Kevin and tell him to send it right. So he answered a few there. Jimbo. I love this Jimbo from Canada. Jimbo had a 10 foot putt to save par and a par 3 hole. OK, this was a friendly game. They always are. He struck his partner at the lip of the hole. His playing partner knocked it back to him. Jimbo felt that the ball was still moving and had a chance to tumble into the hole.

The other playing partners, after having a hearty laugh, agreed. Oh, the perpetrator agreed to consider the ball hold and if I moved on to the next hole, and reviewing the rule afterwards, it seems that the perpetrator should have been assessed the general penalty and Jimbo should have replayed his putt since he didn't. I believe Jimbo would also be assessed the general penalty had it been a tournament round, but his putt counts as a stroke as well, 11.2 C two. My question is, can Jimbo

consider his ball hole with that stroke and therefore would have a score of five? Would the rolling be the same if the ball came to rest but was sent back to me prior to 10 seconds elapsing? I've got to fill it. I've got the question. First question before we even get going, was the ball at rest on the lip of the hole when it was hit back to it? Well, it says here the. Ball was a heat of motion. Jimbo felt that the ball was still moving and had a chance to tumble in the hole and everyone agreed, so he struck. So the ball was still moving.

At the lip of the hole, his playing partner knocked it back to him. So was it still? Yes, in motion. It was still in motion well. Do you reckon it sort of come to the lip? It said. Jimbo felt that the ball was still moving and everyone agreed. OK, all right. I'm happy with that, so. All in Motion has deliberately, deliberately hit, deliberately deflected, which is an issue for the other. So the stroke must be replayed by Jimbo. So you can't count a ball to behold.

Actually you can in one instance. Do you know that? Instance is this the ball at rest on the top, on the lip of the hole or not? No, jeez. So on the Jimbo's case, he played from the putting green. Yes, we'd say it says Jimbo had a 10 foot putt to save par. Let's say he's on the putting green. Sure, if he's not on the putting green. Oh you're talking about it's yeah, you estimate where. Yes.

OK. OK. So Jimbo, listen to this. If you you don't actually say that you're on the green or not. But we assume, which is terrible, we assume that you were on the green. So if you're on the green, you must replay the shot, OK? The perpetrator gets the general penalty, as you've said, which is right, and you have not finished the hole, so you've only had two shots. You cannot accept a three, and you cannot accept A5 either. You haven't finished the hole,

so if it's a Stableford then you get 0 points. If it's a par round you get a minus, or if it's a maximum score you get the maximum score. If it's a stroke round, you'd be disqualified. OK, right. The perpetrator, as I said, as we said, gets the general penalty. So you cannot consider the ball hole, but but if you were off the green and you can have a 10

foot putt of the game you're in, the rule it states that if someone deliberately stopped your ball, we have to estimate where it would have come to rest and place it there. And if that was in the hole, if everyone agreed that it would have come to rest in the hole, you can place it in the hole, but we need to know that. Very important. I'm, I'm going to assume that you're on the green, but very, very important information. Were you on the green or were

you not on the green? Big difference, massive difference, and the penalty still applies. So a player gets the general penalty if they deliberately deflect or stop any ball in motion, whether it's their ball or. An opponent's ball or another playing stroke play. If you deliberately deflect or stop any ball in motion, you get the general penalty. Now for if it's if your stroke is made from the green. We know what you just said before. Cancel replay. Replay.

If the player replays, the player must replay the stroke by playing the original ball or another ball. But what you were just saying there before need to find this. When the ball would have come, so we've played a stroke from off the putting green, and when the ball would have come to rest on the putting green, the player must place the original ball or another ball on the estimated spot where the ball would have come to rest that can be in the hole. And if all the players are going, that was definitely going

in the hole. So unfortunately you don't have very good friends. Jim Boone, they they ruined your round. Jimbo felt guilty, guiltily accepted the score of three. Unfortunately didn't have a sign have to sign or turn his card, so it was just amongst friends. I mean if this was match play, it's slightly different because if you all agreed not knowing we're not aware of the rules and not agreeing to not play by. The rules if you did, as long as

you didn't do that, as long as you weren't aware of the actual rule and everyone said, Yep, Yep, you've had a 3IN match play then you've had a three. But strike play is a lot different, Very good. Thank you very much Jimbo for your question. That was a good one that was probably sent seven weeks ago. We we apologize. Hopefully he's still playing golf. CBY OK CBY A story from when I was a referee that I found funny, A referee at a local amateur individual stroke play

competition. Working late into the first day. A call came over the radio for rules official being required on the ninth tee box in my zone. I proceed proceeded over to the ninth tee box and my golf cart, taking about 3 minutes to get there. Upon arrival I was told by the group of three players that A they had been warned that they were out of position, read pace and play and B in order to try and make up some time one of the three golfers had gone ahead and his tee shot and there was a ball out on the fairway.

The rules issue that was presented was that the players marker had not seen the tee shot so was concerned that he could not certify the scorecard. In the marker's words, how do I know it's his first shots? It's his first shot. Maybe he already lost one in the trees. And what should we do? I understand. Yeah. OK, so what's what's happened is say I'm still on the green and I finished but Stewart's already gone to the tee because the pace of play and want to try and

speed up and he already hits and now I come and go, Well, how do I know that's your first? That could be you could have hit one in the trees. OK, I informed the players that it was not the markers role to observe every single stroke the player makes and the failure to do so is not an issue. And to get on with it I said that if the player has saved that it is his tee shot then we will take him at his word. Needless to say, after calling for a rules official, my transit time, the time to get all the facts and the time to inform players to get moving, they were further out.

This interaction made me review the rules more closely on that are and not on that are and not and not stated to be markers obligations. There are a lot of things that a marker must do under rule 3.3, and clearly a marker that there's also a player cannot observe the other player at all times during the play of the whole. My take is that it is still ultimately falls to the player and his or her integrity to report accurately the number of strokes taken on the whole to the market and not the opposite. I know you have discussed markers on the podcast before.

You love markers then, but would like your take on what instructions could be given to players on how to act as a market. It seems there is some confusion. Another one from Canada, August 2023. That was two months ago. How terrible were we? Fantastic. CBYI think you're you're pretty spot on. You got anything to add to that, Stuart? No, just you don't want to get me started on the marker. But no, I just think like, you're right, you cannot watch if if your player that you're if I'm marking your card, probably

more likely the other way around, you're marking my card and I'm in the trees. You're not going to come over and stand 5 meters away and watch me make sure I get out. I'm going to come out and go. Actually, I had an extra 1 in there. I'm actually out here for three. You can't be watching every single shot. I, our friend Captain Ray was my marker on Saturday and I was right behind a tree had no option but to hit take an unplayable told the guy nearest to me. I'm just taking an unplayable who wasn't my marker just to tell someone else. When I caught up to Ray close to

the grain, I said I'm actually there for three. I took an unplayable as we walk, off he goes, was that a four? I said no it was a five. I took the unplayable. So sometimes you Mark Marcus is he's they're in their own game they're not going to watch every single shot and I I understand where those other players are coming from. He could be 5 off the tee and you don't know but. You know well, as I say, I know it's easy to cheat, but it's also very easy not to cheat. So let's take him the take the

player by his word or her word, and until we until guilty, and until innocent until proven guilty. And when they are guilty, ban them from golf. Yeah, because full weight of the committee. Because golf. Is not for them. Golf is not for them. It's not about cheating. It's all about your character. So yeah, I'd. I'd kick them out of the club. No, that's all. That's all good. I'll tell you I I was at an

amateur tournament myself. Just on this pace of play. This young girl went ahead with Dad was on the bag. And she hit off and then played a provisional. And I walked up to them because the the immediate response, unfortunately, the immediate posture was defensive. It was like, what's this official coming towards me? Dad's sort of almost ready to attack me to defend his daughter. And I just said, look, the first thing you really should be doing, they really should be doing is making it very, very clear because the players have just walked up and seen you hit off and they don't know.

It's a provisional. They think it's your first one, so you just need to be. And she didn't say anything. And I said you just need to be very open about, hey guys, let's see that when I just hit, that's for provisional. I'll be searching up on the left for it. You know, she was young and good golfer. But I just thought it's important to, as you say, to not have any doubt about what's happening and whether it was the marker or someone else, just tell someone else what's going on and keep them up to date. As I said, they would have only hit us. So, you know, hit that second ball and Gone All. That's her T-shirt. And it wasn't. Do you want to read this one?

They wasn't happy what you just said then. It reminds me of the players and caddies that I have to deal with in the professional game. You know the caddie will be, they'll be backing up their player and you're like come on mate, like you know we all saw it you, you know it's, I know you don't want to lose your job by being defensive but you know, getting defence, getting the back up of your player. But well, I'm talking more pace of play, like you guys are so

slow and do. You want me to read this one? Because I can't read it or I'll read it. I realise you struggled like that. I really mate lot older than you. All right, you, you can go. This is from Colin from Y Maddie, Colleen. Roger, Brian and Peter are playing with par 3 second at Y Maddie on Wednesday. I won't say that Peter is on the green for one while his other playing partners are near the hole, but not on Peter's on the green. Happy about his shot, Brian tips

on and is heading towards Peter's ball which is not marked yet. Peter, seeing Brian's ball heading towards his ball, taps his ball Peter's. Out of the way so it doesn't hit his ball, Roger says. There is a penalty of some sort because his ball wasn't marked. What is the penalty? The group assessed A1 shot penalty, which Peter agreed to. Peter had a four. So is it or did he so? I'm just going to get the names here right, So Peter's on the green, yeah.

And he's the ball that's about to be in the way, yeah. And then Brian? Ships on who moves the ball, Peter. So. So Colleen and Roger are just spectators, so don't worry about. Any two players, there's two, there's two players involved, got it? Peter's on the green foot one. Brian's the player because he hits and then Peter becomes the player when he hits his own ball into the hole whilst Brian's ball. Out of the way, So what is the ruling? So it doesn't hit his ball. Roger says there is a penalty of

some sort because his ball wasn't marked. What was Peter thinking? Well, he wanted to get his ball out of the way, but he should. Have just left it there. Was he trying to protect the field? I think he was trying to help Brian. I mean, help Brian not stop Brian's ball. OK, so we don't, well, we don't know where the hole's here. No, no. Peter's ball. Of course, we're Peter's ball. Leads in relationship, so we do know that if Brian. Ships out of the bunker.

And hits Peter's ball. Brian now plays his ball where it comes to rest. Yeah, right where it lost Peter simply. Replaces his ball, Right. Right. So we know that. OK. Peter, however, has seen. Hang on, there's a ball coming my way. I need to get this out of the way, right. However, yes, Peter has unmarked the spot before lifting it, right? Is that your answer? No, I haven't given an answer. I don't give an answer. Does Peter get penalised for moving his ball with a stroke?

Was was it a stroke though? Well. Yes, he chipped it out. I mean, he tapped it in. Peter's seen Brian's ball heading. Towards his ball, taps his ball, taps his ball out of the way. I. Thought he even taps it as it makes a stroke. Just. Moved it out of the way. Well, first of all, well, we we can't assume anything. Did he tap it to make a stroke or did he tap it to get it out of the way? I think we're going to assume the first one. OK. I don't think he's made it right. He hasn't made a strike. Second one to get it out of the way.

Yeah. Yeah. Sorry. OK, tap it out of the way. Yeah, to simply move it out of the way, see if he. Made a stroke. It would be one stroke and no penalty, just made a stroke. But he's. Moved it out of the way. Forget about taps as Boiler, he's moved it out of the way. Correct. Deliberately not, accidental without. Marking it so it's a one stroke penalty, so when you were going. At me. I'm thinking you're heading towards no penalty. I think we tapped it as I may have tapped it in. There's definitely a penalty

here, but. The way you were wording it up, I'm going Why am I not seeing? Why would you tap it out of the way? I have no idea. Just leave it there when you say tap. That's a tap it in. You don't say tap it out of the way. You say, say move. It out of the way? Sure. Well, I think hit it out probably. Just hit it out of the way with the putter, Yeah, hit it out of the way. You don't. Clearly, I would. From reading that, clearly no intention to make a stroke. There was no way that was a stroke towards the old school that was just moving it out of the way. Just so happened to do it with the foot or a putter, whatever it wanted to be.

That is clearly moving your ball in play. You know, spot that needs to be replaced should have marked it first using an artificial object just right a bit that that's a clear one shot penalty. As far as I'm Roger is correct 9/4 9.4 B. Or 14 point 14.1 Roger is spot on. So Peter has. Well, it looks like Peter's replaced the ball. Assume with. It doesn't actually say. Well, assume would just put it back they.

Say replaced his ball, drags it back in with his club. Oh no. Would you give him? Would you give him? That's not how you replace a ball. I just bark just because of it. There's no intervening event. Well, when they sit, yeah I'm just trying to think, well, when they're yelling, hey, that's a one shot pen or do you know it's not. He drags it back. And doesn't replace it correctly that isn't intervening. Absolutely. It is 2 one shot. We're just making up stuff that. Or if happened, grabbed it back and then Roger say something. Yeah, then we're OK. It's only one. Right. Oh my God. Intervening. So then try to make them easier.

Yeah, try to get for those. Well. They got the unrelated and related acts, but. No, that's the Cleveland chopping all the other set I was just making up that he's dragged towards his ball. Trap taps his ball. I just tapped it in the hole but obviously not. You played it. Why, mate? No. I haven't driven past past Why, matey? But I haven't played then it's one for when I get back to get back. Mum and Dad's right next one. Zuma Golf piece of fun worldwide.

The player made a stroke from a bunker and accidentally hit the other player's club at rest on the green. What actions were taken to resolve the situation? The player hit it as it lies, with no penalty. But if, But the question is if the player, if it was the player's own club, is there a penalty? And the seven two weeks ago, oh, that's not too bad for us, right? Zuma Golf. So as long as the club wasn't left there on purpose by anyone

to affect where the ball came to rest, there is no penalty regardless. So if it's left there by an opponent, if it's left there by another player, if it's left there by the player themselves, as long as it wasn't left there on purpose to affect where the ball could have come to rest, then the fact that it hit it accidentally, there is no penalty. Can we do the exact words? So if a player's ball, that's your speciality.

I think it's if a player's ball in motion accidentally hits any person, including the player or outside influence, there is no penalty to any player. This is true even if the ball hits the player, the opponent, or any other player, or any of their caddies or equipment. So it's just zero penalty if it's all accidental. If a player's ball in motion, played from anywhere except the putting green, accidentally hits any person, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera, the ball must normally

be played as it lies. And in that case, it's at the club comes to rest play as it lies now, the whole time that you're reading that, which is correct? I was thinking is it specialty or speciality? Is it Caribbean? Or Caribbean? No, But can you actually say speciality? I don't know what, I'm not sure. You're key. You just didn't. No. I sort of add what's it add those things, you know what are they called? Like David has 22 syllables.

That's it. Oh. OK, wasn't really. Don't add a syllable. I don't know anyway right? Should we get on to GRQOTW number? 102 Or have we? Do you want to say one or do you want to just use the one that? I think we need to do a bit more research. Perhaps we'll do the research. OK, so you. Yeah, podcast must do a Really. We can only do one thing here, and. Let's prepare the GIP IP companies So and you're gonna I I might say get away from me. Wasted my time coming here, you. Make it up.

Are we good to go, GIQ? O TW102, Yeah, correct. You and I are playing a match, speaking. Of hitting stuff. So I won. Yeah, we're not. There, yet you would have won. Blakey and Stewart are playing a match at Wombat Hills. It is Blakey's turn to putt on the first green and he removes the flag stick from the hole, placing it on the green behind the hole. Well out of play. Blakey's putt is way too hard and believing the ball will definitely hit the flag stick, Stewart rushes over and picks up

the flag stick. Blakey's ball continues to roll past where the flagstick was on the green. Blakey is not happy and he requests A ruling. Are there any penalty strokes? And what happens next? I listened to that one, so that was good. But the key is, though, you listen to it at the start of the next episode, because that's when you put on the spot. If it's next week, I should be able to remember. No, actually, that's a rely I won't be able to remember.

Thank you once again for coming over for episode one O2 and filming in person again. So yeah, enjoy the rest of your day. Thank you my. Pleasure. Good to see you. Good to see you back from all your travels. Yes, been bought it back into the production. Studio again. Thank you. When's your next time, QLD? PGA first week in November. Oh yeah, up in Brisbane. Very good, very good. You've got some family out there too. I do Not much. No, I do not.

Some family you'll be able to say hello. I'll be busy at the tournament. Well, thank you everyone for listening in and if you have any more pub land stories, please send them through. We've got a few more to get through and we'll do that next week. So keep firing them in. We love to talk about them. Excellent 102 done.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode