Walking and Scoring - THE GRQ PODCAST EP73 GRQOTW #72 Helen incurred two penalty strokes. Stuart and Blakey cover: The role of a walker-scorer. Setting up a course for both play by both professional men and women. The second opinion. GRQOTW for #73 - Gerry is playing Fraser in a match and on the par 3 17th hole at Wombat Hills with the match all square, Gerry hooks his tee shot into long grass. After Fraser plays his tee shot into a greenside bunker, Gerry plays a provisional ball which comes to rest 10cms from the hole. As they start walking towards the green, Gerry declares his ball lost and asks Fraser to not look for it. Knowing Gerry has a possible tap in for a 4, Fraser decides to start searching. As Gerry moves to his provisional ball on the green, Fraser thinks he has found Gerry's original balland calls out, "I have found it". Gerry taps his provisional ball in and replies with, "it doesn't matter, I declared it lost and I have putted". Fraser isn't sure of the Rules and requests a ruling - what is the ruling?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode and Opals questions podcast.
Welcome everyone, to the episode 73, the golf rules questions podcast and and one podcast for rules of golf probably because it's the only one. Let's do it. Welcome along co-host of the golf rules questions podcast. How are you? Thanks for like, you're very well. And I should add to that that in the last week, I have caught up with a state referee and a national referee both who told Listen to this podcast and only a few weeks ago I had a member from our own club whom I've
never met email me a rules, Creations go. Oh, by the way I'm a member of the same Club as me and I listened to you and Blakey and blah blah blah and okay, well people do listen to this and if it is the only one then so be it. But it's a good one. I appreciate that. What club are you at Stewart? Gardner is run and is you've got a photo of that in your background. I do correct. And of course, I play quite often. I'm with the captain Rhea seddon and mutual friend. And so yeah, if you are listening to this on Spotify you
probably won't see that photo but if you are watching us on YouTube, you'll definitely see it. And I've got a photo of the club that I'm currently. Yes, it is a golf operations manager, currently golf operations manager, spring belly, which is it in the sand belt? We've been seeing the Australian Open. This week with Kingston hafen Victoria looking in unbelievable condition. Well, I can tell you Spring Valley is in amazing condition
right now as well. We actually hosted the Monday qualifier for one of the one of the courses to host the Monday. Qualifier last Monday for the Australian Open just just the guys went and played there and the best scorers for under getting through. So So it was in fantastic condition and should say, of course, I was a referee for that and I have a story from that, I'd like to raise with you on a
rule side of thing. The second best school is minus 2 or 3 guys. And we actually did a two-hole playoff to sort out who is that last person to get a spot at the Australian Open but totally agree. You having just walk the fairways of Kingston Heathen, Victoria, the last few days I've been incredible as you weren't you like to use Mint is just incredible condition. At Spring Valley was no less than eyes sometimes. Yes, that's an interesting one that for under got in.
There were two people to go through from the 80 or so who initially play or signed up for that Monday. Qualifying to under was the next best scorer with three players on to under, and they had to have a 1/1 play of my store. You know stroke play playoff it just a knockout here to find out who was going to be the one person from that to under to get through. And someone made a par on the 88
first time round, and they got straight through. But then, the two players who didn't make it straight through, this would have to be one of the worst playoff situations in history, and it happens if a lot. There's not the first time that's happened to Heavens nearly every week, actually, You play off or the alternate spot. So if it's only for if one of the Yeah, one of the six who got
through on the Monday, qualifying. If one of the employee at, you know, illness emergency medical type thing. If one of them pull out, then the alternate alternate number one goes through, and we made it up to Ultimate for. So it's a strange playoff. You want to talk us through that one's too early. Yeah so far as you say, if one of them had a mysterious car, Didn't one of the alternates would get through.
Yeah. So the as usual as you explained so that we just gonna play 18 repeatedly and after a while if they were keep going then what a chosen 10 which have also in that picture right behind you? And yes as you said they both all three spray their t-shirts on the 18th. One guy got within, got onto the green mat 5 meters made his for the other two didn't made five so straightaway. That first guy was in to the Australian Open and the odd
feeling of actually walking back down the 18th. Fairway with them because the two of them are now not in the Australian Open, clearly disappointed that they've missed the opportunity and they've got a playoff for, what alternate positions, one and four as it turned out. So off they go down again. I heard a story about the second time they walk back down the 18th as well. But yeah. And then they both I think one made of four on 18 playing At the second time he then became the alternate number one, and the other guy mr. Park of maybe two meters for a 4 and therefore became alternate
number four. And as you say it wasn't an alternate to get into the Australian Open field. It was just an alternate for one of those six that qualified on that Monday. So very, very slight chance of them. Of course, playing at the event. Did you keep an eye on that as to whether one of them got through? Could I keep a no, I didn't know completely. Because I went straight to the June's, read all. And then of course, histrionic do something. Completely lost sight of it. Sort of, in the revision mirror, I didn't really look at it.
I should have looked back because those players also might be on the list. For getting through to the Australian Open by their own PGA Tour of australasia status, yet, more All European to a status Climbing Center of the three people in the playoff, two of them are amateurs. Yes. Yes, and the amateur got through in the end. The one who first one, I think
he's a pro. So this is my, the pro sorry. The party lost. So he was the one. So this is this is this is the interesting thing so that Pro who finished ultimate for he could still he might have been. Yes. Yeah, he might have been number three for the full field have PGA Tour australasian so this is exactly this isn't necessarily rules but It's quite it is part of the match committee and so this is quite interesting, so we've tried to explain it. We probably haven't been as
simple and as clear as possible. Okay? So you've got Monday, qualifying to get six guys out of 200. Get into the Australian Open. I mean that's fine. That's easy. Simple done. A lot of those players are still if they're professionals. Still can get through on the categories that they have created for themselves by playing well previous tournaments playing well that to a school or playing, not quite
as well at to a school so they can get through to the full field through those categories. If other people Pop out so you might have 10 people drop out and so they will select those 10 people from the categories first. Okay. So it's most important from the categories first Then they allocate these six spots for the Monday qualifier, and let's say the for alternate, that's another category that category only goes through.
If all four of the six drop out, okay? And so that Pro who finished fourth, he still might have been, we don't know but he might have been number two or yeah, next in line because of his category on the PGA tour of australasia. But the the a You and I talked to one pro who finished Monday qualifying in any finished, one at the odds PGA. And yeah, he was up there, but
he can, he can get through. So it's yeah, it's be. It's a rarity for an alternate for the qualifier to get through, but we do it. Anyway, I would think so just in case mysterious car accident, mr. All, yeah. Explain caring for some of them get covid. Although I think, of course, I think you're allowed to play with go with those rules. But yes, a to of the qualifiers were in the same car and something happened and then the two alternates would get
through. So you here you are, you've got the situation where the playoff? It's not like that. Two people had power in the last person had a bogey and he gets older it for and this he's out. The winner had a part and he's finished. So I'm going to go, you've got to go back, down the 1800, go back down the Ada, or the playoff hole. Just to get this album that spot. Number 10 you both getting in. Are you know you're both getting an ultimate. Scott would one getting 41 in one's getting for and of course
you know no one's going to go we'll just flip for it or whatever because you know major that one chance getting the off pods open and it comes off and you're like a while I flip for us you just play them. So you know they're walking back down the Fairway of the say they have to go to the tea. Just for a, not just a chance, and a very, very low chance, but a chance on me. But yes, a chance of getting in the water or a horrible feeling. Yeah, well I've got a story
about that playoff. I also have another rule story about that qualifying round. But did you want to answer a rules question from another? Yeah, we probably should get into g oq o TW 72 and then I like to share with you a couple of real stories. I saw one involved me as a referee from that particular and from the playoff, you just spoke about then you remember G IQ o TW for 72 and but I could look it up, I have it right here already.
Yeah, you go for Italy Helen finds her ball in a red penalty area and moves a loose impediment next to her ball. However, in doing so her ball moves Thinking that, that might be a penalty. And in an attempt to avoid the penalty, she then decides to pick up her ball and take lateral relief from the penalty area. How many penalty Strokes in total? Well, she cannot avoid that penalty for.
For causing your ball to move. So, at that time, when she picked up the loose impediment she wasn't Planning on taking penalty relief. So she still gets that are balls and play effectively and she's still thinking, she's going to play it as it lies. She picks up the Loose impediment. And Cause of boredom over to one-stroke penalty. Then she decides that she's
going to take penalty area or the leaf. That's another penalty. So should be total of two. Now, this brings a question of my mind. if you, if you say that you're going to take penalty area relief, Pick up a loose impediment, cause the ball to move. Can you avoid that penalty? Because you said you were going to take penalty area relief? It is one of the exceptions are
all 9.4 in applying a rule. Yeah, but I reckon that that sounds like your circumvented circumventing a roll. Just so that you can avoid penalty. You're real sorry but your intentions are your real intention was not to take a year or area relief. It was to see if you can move the loose impediment without. Are you saying that played in changes their mind? They hey guys I'm just going to just going to take relief in the
penalty area here. Reach down move loose impediment to move their border to pick up their ball. Lift the ball from the course to take that relief. Move the listen pediment. Ball doesn't move your arm actually. I think I'm going to play this a lat. Yeah, I said I almost think that that's That's wrong. Hello my see. Anything wrong with it though. As you know, I don't see anything. I don't think I've done anything wrong. So, so if you okay, so if you haven't done anything wrong, If it does move do you get
penalized? Yes, as you haven't lifted your ball. You've moved lifted the loose impediment. Okay, so your ball is sitting there you've said, hey guys, I'm just going to take a relief. Come back, move the loose impediment your ball then moves. Yeah, the question is now, is there a penalty for that ball moving I think is what you're asking. Yeah, I would think if they go to play that ball as it lies.
Well, they need to replace it, if they're going to play it as it lies, otherwise, they're going to recall incur more than one. They need to either going to plays allies, I need to put it back and take and play it and then take a one-stroke penalty. If they go on to take relief in the penalty area, I don't think you can. I mean it's like they were moving this Branch out of the way to get access to their ball. It's a very interesting situation. I think you've declared your
intent to take relief in the penalty area. So it's very similar actually to moving a tree interpretation on put for a 1 when Plasma was dislodged from a tree but not evident that case is searching for your ball. This this case you're not searching for you and you can see you can see your ball. I really do, think if you said,
I'm just going to take relieved, and you made that quite clear. It's clear what the intended. I mean, you talk about, you talk a lot about intent. And how often a committee way, referee will ask the player to clarify their position on something. Clarify their intent. Well they can easily say I was just I was just about to pick up my board. Exactly. Bit. Absolutely, they could say that. What's the problem? Rick?
I dropped it. I dropped it out of the side. Outside the relief area. It doesn't sound good. That does it? No, no, it doesn't not at all. It does it? But I think you wouldn't even know the player had done that or was going to do that all that was their intent. Actually, just a very clever use of the rules. And I don't like circumventing. I'm the biggest opponent to getting around stuff and circumventing but I just I think you can be very clever with it,
and be. Okay. That doesn't sound. It doesn't sound like using your rules to advance. It sounds like changing your intention to Europe. Changing changing. Yeah, your honesty of you are agreed. But again, if you declared, hey, I'm just going to take it or, you know, to your mark or the nearest other player. I'm going to take a relief, you know problems, move the loose of head up and go actually didn't move on what he did and then he
did. Anyway, you wouldn't even have to go back to them and say actually I changed my mind before you made the next stroke, just hit the thing that were most sort of understand again that I get that one. I don't like it but I get it. Okay, you can change. Change your mind like that. But if it does move right in say, I was just trying to grab it as you say that person then has to go to sleep at night and sleep. Well, I've often I've heard you say that before David, right?
So let's move on. So you've got a couple of stories I do from that. So let's go back to the playoff because you explain that and I mentioned you and you were actually Behind the Green watching all this and we've quite a few other people watching as well and as it. So the first playoff hole has been done first. Amateurs through, he's got spot in the Australian Open the other two need to now play for alternate, as you see one. And as I walked, I sort of asked around because I was in a car. I said I was there, can we grab another carton?
Just Ferry them back and it was a quick know like it walk, you know, so off, they walk back down but of course, halfway down the Fairway, they drop their bags. The two players pull out their driver and continue walking. Now, one player had put his bag. Why off the side into the rough? The other player put his bag, smack. Bang in the middle of the Fairway. And, of course, I've already I didn't know this at the time because I already driven down to the 18th to. I've looked back and I've seen this bag sitting right in the
middle of the Fairway. I don't know if it was left of center, right? Or Center because it was smack bang in the middle. And then I just thought, and I thought about it, straight away about laying down an object on the course to help with alignment, do you wanna play? And I brought this up to you as we drove as well. I drove back to the behind the 18th green. I mentioned this to you and you remember what you said to me and can you, repeat what you said to me, just said, you have to find out the players intention. So if they left there on purpose, yeah, there's apparently, and the team point.
To the sign to be one. I think to me to is holding the shouldn't think like this, you know. Shouldn't they are think it is. Oh you've got the rulebook right. That's pretty good though. Getting pretty close. So Yes, I think it's their intention was. Yes, they meant to aim at it and there's a penalty. And if they were just relaxing Lee putting it there because they don't want to carry it all
the way back down the 88. Then I get that but he's the other player. Put his bag right up against the trees. Well, off the Fairway. I didn't remember that one, but are you suggesting that he was trying to stop his bull going into the truth? No, not at all. What I was saying was that was the best place to put your bag was getting out of the way of play as opposed to smack bang in the middle of the Fairway, and he just looked odd. It looked fishy. It looked a bit this just isn't. I mean, imagine, yeah, as you say, clarify, the intention of light, why'd you put your bag?
They're all. I didn't want to take it all the way to the 18th tee. Okay, that's fine. But why don't you put it on? With the other guy did I think what was the perfect perfect line? That's where I want to hit my ball over. I think it was more a case of what am I going back down? This hole to play this shitty playoff, as it turned out, that was the guy who won. Alternate number one, he won the next play of all. He wanted. Yes, yeah. The guy. He almost hit his back to. He, landed his ball. And it kind of rest at exactly the same distance as bag ones
from the team. The kid. No, I didn't notice it. Yeah, which was pretty impressive. Was just out to the right-hand side so actually lined up perfectly as we should have come on. Yeah, the referee but I raised it with my with the employee from the national sporting body, I did. Raise it with him. Well we were all, you know, him better than I do. There's about About 45 us around behind the green and we were laughing about it and I see you did.
Yeah, I'm going to just yeah. Yeah, yeah. The time it took for him to walk down that hole. Yes, we're all the time it took to talk about it and he done that on purpose. But we, you know, basically it just be talking to the player about the intention. It didn't seem like much of it, if any, any advantage to us. So we didn't even Even think twice about it because you know, it's a flat whole, you can see everything.
You can see The Greening and see the flag. You know what, you know you've just played the whole. We saw no benefit whatsoever of where he put his bag it would have been interesting if it actually hit it. I'd say that that would have been accidental as well. Yeah, because it wouldn't have been any advantage there from being a couple 3 meters for further forward or something like that. So we just let it go. And you ask the question we see though you're going to ask the
player that we're not too fast? No. Yeah. You had a couple other stories from when I was one other which I think wonderful. Yeah. Rises more interesting situation. And that was there were two of us. Us to referees out on course and I get the call over the radio to go to hole 17 for a second opinion. And I wanted to run this by you and the specific situation we can talk about it but it's really not the issue. It was more the ruling under rule 20 point to or something like that.
You know, resolving issues in stroke play and I was wondering about who can call for a second opinion, because it'd be my understanding all this time that players go. You know, I want use these words because I'm not happy with that first ruling. Can we get a second person to come in and, you know, and talk about it? Please or, you know, discuss it with it. So I get the call for the second opinion. I go over to the situation and I provide the player relief. Well, I thought the place could have got relief as opposed to
the first referee who denied that person relief. And the way the rule is written, I think is it's the referee That can call in for a second opinion rather than the player asking for a second opinion. And it's almost like the referees giving doing the player a favor by saying, okay. I will call in someone else to provide their opinion as well. So I was interested in your thoughts about that situation. Yeah, so it's actually on the, it depends on the hard card for
The tournament is to. Whether the pliers entitled to a second opinion, basically, the rules say that the player is not entitled, right? To a second opinion. The second opinion is called and by the first referee and if they are unsure or they want to help the player under because they, you know, the referee might be like I'm 99% certain 100%
certain, he just wants to calm down the situation is say okay, yeah, we'll get a second opinion in here for you. That's fine. Then it is the referee. And they what I'm saying is they might be swayed by the player. Hey, it's that can't be right. I need a second opinion and referees like I'm 100% but I'll help you out and get you to, you know, calm down a bit sweet. We can get another referee and
he's just on the next hole or something like that. So it is the second opinion is from the referee, but if the hard card says that every player is eligible for a second opinion, it's actually the player that can call them for the second opinion and on the US PGA Tour, I believe they do have that a player can call them for the second opinion. They don't get that element for third opinion, but they do they
do for the And so that's what the second opinion is all about. And to be honest, you know, you know, want to see as a referee and I want to stuff anything up. You might have forgotten something or you think that it's quite harsh and you just bite years. That's how you see it. So you rule on it that way, but you say sure we'll get in the second opinion. Can someone come to whole 15 for a second opinion? So excuse me.
So in that particular case, you talked about the referee being 100% sure but surely when the player immediately comes back with John not. So sure about that. Can I get a second opinion like straight away? You think the referee now? Only feels 98%? Sure or 95%. Sure, and not 100% sure in some cases. Yeah, well, I had one I talked about in the last podcast and one in Morocco. when I was sort of it was uneven surface, could have said that it was It was
Will tire marks, but it was so far off the Fairway. Actually Annex. I was just not was, I certainly like sure of it. No, I wasn't 100%. He was he wasn't happy about it so I could have called for a second opinion, but I was in the end even though it was sort of unsure, I was actually Sounds a bit weird, but I was actually
sure of my decision. I was like, Nana, the decision is you don't get any free life and I'm not going to get a second opinion and for you, you know, another referee could say that you could get relief and other referee could say you couldn't. I'm decided that you couldn't Even though I'm sort of it's a gray area that's probably easier way to describe it's a gray area. In this case, I'm 100% sure I'm not going to give you free relief and I'm not going to get a second opinion and for you.
Where's that other one in Egypt? On you. It was going to be a tough rolling but I didn't didn't like that he was going to try and get free relief from. We was it just seemed like an abscess. There was a possibility that he had an offense, but it seemed like a ridiculous. It was an unreasonable shot. That's, that's the best way to say. So even though, even though he could have had, it would have been unreasonable shot to assume that he would dig down through big rocks. I'm about five inches to hit
this pipe and I've but then in that case, because on your referee was about 40 meters away, I said you want a second opinion. Do you want a second opinion and he said no. So, so that's that. So I did offer that one but I did kind of know that referee would have denied them. Anyway, right, maybe the play knew who you were players. Don't know who I am. I'm not annoyed he doesn't count. I'm not that famous. Anyways, sending you know what
they say about probably it should be seen and not heard not hurt. Yes. So in this particular case I treated that when I got called over the radio to go and provide assistance, I've driven over course, other two players have played on this play is just still sitting there with the ball, just off the edge of the Fairway and I sort of treated it as a new situation as if I had just arrived at the same and I've gone through. So the referee who was standing near, didn't say anything, I've just gone straight to the play. How can I help his explain?
What's happened? And I'm going through the thought process, you know, going through the thought process of relief or not. And I've said yeah, I've got no problem with you getting relief here. And that's how he's perceived it. And so, I guess, you know, should I have gone to the other referee first? Should I have seen the Ian not made a ruling turn to the other referee and said to him, this is what I think or was I right to just go straight away to the play. You know, you're fine, you can take really fair. Let's just work at your nearest
Point complete relief and and proceed. You asking my opinion or what the Yeah well I mean it really is it really is an opinion based on experience or being taught by others so as soon as that referee hands it over to you they get they get out of the way. Nine step in, with more information or of all. What do you think of this? They have decided to give it to the this first, the second referee, or as we said it could
be in the hard card that they have to give it away. And you kind of know, like, you're 100% know that the blade didn't get relief. Yeah. If they got free relief, they weren't even asking me. Ask you for a second opinion. So you know that the is one reason that yeah, we won on. Only one reason that you're there. Yeah. So, but the rep other Reformation, say, you know, jump back in and go. I, I wouldn't have Denver Relief here, but, you know, that, okay. And you don't need it. You just find out the information for the player.
Yeah, from the Caddy's, if you need to find. And so, you should be the only and suddenly the referee, they should probably even just leave drive off and drive off. Don't hang around and Yeah, and move on to the next. So this is poses another question which I don't think is covered anywhere in the rules but I'll just pose it to you. That Y is if I'm the referee called him for the second opinion, why is my ruling carry greater weight than yours?
And let me put it into a specific example. Let's say you were the first Referee on the scene and you said sorry James there's no way you can't get relief. It's not a reasonable stroke. Whatever the reasons might be and James says look, I'd like a second opinion. You know Rory Stuart's just on the other farewell, get him over. I drive over you drive off, I look at the situation and go oh no that's fine. Yeah just find your nearest point of complete relief and pleasure Club limping go. So I guess the question is why is my ruling carry more weight than yours?
You were probably correct and you and I catch up afterwards and you say did you give him relief? I said yeah and you go, you idiot. No you shouldn't have because of this I've got oh yeah, I forgot about that. Well, it always hmm in most cases, do it. The second opinion is by a small senior staff. That's obviously not the case. No offense to either of you. We clean our phrase exactly with limited referees and a small one hole, one round playoff.
So round one round off our effectively, it is a play one round qualifying that's that's not the case but if in the normal case of having three referees / 9, And Rovers, two Rovers per nine, and an adornment director, overlooking the whole thing. If I was on the fifth hole, I've calling one of my Rovers, There. Yeah, and if the Rover was there
and he needed a ruling, he would call him either the other Rover or the tournament director. Now, as I said, that's not the case in this situation. But that would be, that would be why, or where they would sort of come from. In terms of that second opinion, you get a second and you call a referee and that has more experience than you. Not. That's a very good answer. Thank you. No, worries any others, you have
any other. Well, that's just a qualifying done. Had something that things at June's may do but nothing. Make sure did have one thing about the June's men. The I don't know if you know the genes that will apply their a handful of times and really enjoyed the course the second hole. Yeah I go second hole elevated green and over the back of the growing just drops off dramatically and it's just really thick bush. You can't even walk down through there and there was one big tree branch that have been filled
sitting at the top of that rise. Anyway, guys ball flies and goes over the back, took a bit of time to find it and it was buried right under this tree branch and I mean so big, not a branch. I'm in a tree. Three significant could hardly touch the ball with your Club let alone make a stroke at it, right. It was that very done anyway, so those look to me, I just happen to be there unplayable. I see you have three options. Go back back. As far as you're sorry. Back to we just passed by back on the line which was horrible down this steep incline. Just wouldn't have me how to
drop a ball, let alone client or lateral. And of course he's immediately gone to lateral, but even lateral was horrible. And I just thought this is a great situation. In most cases with an unplayable, you almost almost inclined, not to tell them throw conditions because they're never going to take that option. You know, in 99% of cases, of pliers, I'll take the Striking Distance and as I said, you always feel silly offering that as an option to them, but but you do anyway, in this particular case, I reckon this guy, Head and Shoulders Above
the Rest. He'd best option was by far to go back down to where he just played his second shot from and blade again from me and just hit a different club and lean it on the green rather than flying the green. Because back on the line was next to Impossible. Lateral was almost as bad and he took some time to clear a lot of loose. Impediments and crap out of the way to even find a spot where you could drop the ball ended up making an egg or something. On the whole where is he? Could have landed on the green for four and two part of her six. He was That good really good enough for it but he flew the groom anyway.
Just a more, an observation that in most cases, I feel silly saying all your first option is stroke and distance, but you first, but an option is stroke and distance. In this particular case, Really wasn't the only option, but I'm wondering how many players don't even think about stroke and distance. It's really interesting. I don't think I've had too many where I've taken them back to their last previous spot, played from, but In the Pro game.
And this is what I see a lot with the pro game at differentiates, from the M2 game is. It's it's, you know, each shot is important and they will take their medicine when they know they It will save those so much more calculating is what is the difference that I see the amateur? Doesn't want the feeling of.
I have to go back down. It looks. So I'm going to put that group, you know, they're going to see me walking back down the hill or walking back down the hole. It's going to be so embarrassing, I'll just try and, you know, I have surely, I can make up and down from here somewhere. Where's the pro will be calculated? Be more calculating, they'll be like, okay, my best bet to make this lowest score on the whole is actually the Go back to where I play and I can you drive me back down there? Yeah, sure, make their worries. So I've certainly seen it. I've had seen it happen with
professionals. It doesn't happen too often because usually there is some kind of lateral and that I want to give up the distance, but the amateur definitely doesn't want to give up the distance more for an ego thing than anything. But yeah, it's a good point. You make They don't feel silly sometimes even offering stroke and distance. When you know the number take it you've been at the Australian Open which concludes today you've been at the Australian Open not as a referee this week but as a walker scorer, I was
going for that. We thank you. And for those who don't know, for those who don't know what a walker score is that all these major events is every, single group, as a person like myself, with a clipboard with the score sheet and a radio, and once all three players or two players, whole layout, you actually record their scores and all where they have shop, where they made their Strokes from, and how many parts and where they hit the Fairway or not and you report their whole school, excuse me, through to a central location. Ation and as used really for two
things, it's used for updates on the website and is also used for the broadcast. And so we going to the next tee and we could saw it saw a big school board and I saw one of our players who was in the top 10 and and sure enough 30 seconds after I graduate it through walking off the other green, the scored updated on the school board so that's what the Walker score is doing every group. As I said that these major events has a walker scorer how was it both causes the Kingston Heath and Victoria the is today's Observatory yesterday both causes Were in incredible
condition. Just phenomenal. Would you like use it meant? You know, just I couldn't believe how good the courses were how good the fairways were the groom's, just looked perfect. One thing I think I can tell, you know by the size of the event is how many generators you here? It's just the purring of generators everywhere with, you know, powering School boards or concession stands or air conditioners and there's just so many generators and cables. Running in so many different places.
How was it my first group on Thursday was a group of women? They really struggled scoring wasn't great. Morale wasn't great. The best score in that group was plus five. The best scoring wasn't great or I wasn't Good Friday. Also Kingston he followed a guy, a bunch of guys. Much better, much better scoring bit more of a buzz. It was all good. What I did notice that how many referees there were actually at the Australian Open special yesterday. Victoria, it was so many referees.
I think almost the last 10 groups had a walking referee. Plus they're all the guys and girls in carts. Just plonked on a side of a fair way somewhere. Obviously, a lot of people, you know, and a few people I know that I said hello to and I don't think they were doing a lot. Well, because as I said, the last thing groups will have walkers will head walking referees. I know the walking referee in our group didn't do a thing. Just, you know, walked around for five hours. So I would suspect some of those other peoples are sitting in a
car. Probably did less than that. Yeah. But there are a lot of referees here today at Victoria. That's for sure. So what we take out of that is referees, don't do anything. We don't really need them. Sorry, I don't think that's exactly what. No, they definitely needed. You know, maybe they needed more in the You know, I guess if the standard of the gulf is lower, you're more likely get into
those situations of all searches unplayable and other things, you know, taking relief hitting provisionals, all that sort of stuff, or in the scene of the got ya, or if the standard of the course is lower, you might be a lot more GUI if it rained, which it hasn't rained in Melbourne for six days. It's amazing. Heading right now on sale for six months, it seems. Yeah. So the standard golf yesterday. I three women people would know, you know, Jenny shin and Sarah came in Australian, their ball
striking was unbelievable. They just hit almost every single V way. They hit the ball. So straight when you hit Fairways and greens and the only time you make a blemish as hit a greenside bunker occasionally or three part, there's not a lot of rulings in there. Actually the with that group the referees would have been pretty busy. They might have even broken the clock. Ha ha. Well, you and I spoke about this beforehand and there was one play with that group. And I had mentioned that there
was one plane that group was really slow, and I timed her once or twice on a few shots. Just off to the side, had my stopwatch out and just really, really slow. She around was five hours, always be around was five hours. The first two days, my two rounds were for 54 55, something like that yesterday was right on five hours and they were behind. I thought, yeah, there's one We're walking down 17, and you can look across and see 18. You couldn't see it in the past five, you couldn't see any players really gone. How was the actual court? Because the woman in mean played
on the same course, right? How was the setup of the course in comparison to mean a woman? Like obviously if man's heading, And I do I might be able to one bounce, stop it. Whereas a woman may have been able to she might be sort of a nine or wedge. I'm if you've got feedback that woman can stop 7, irons and tell me, but that's not my
experience. So then then you want to sort of create put the tea locks positions where man's hitting us, it an 8 or 7 iron ore. Whatever you want. And then you want the woman to be hitting about the same distance or not the same distance, about the same club club was that was a course, set up very similar to that Kanye and I think so, yeah, because there were quite a few holes where both men and women played off the same T for example, the first of Victoria, very very short 240.
M, you know, par 4, They're all playing off the same T. The 10th similar although that's not a drivable par-4 but 10 both, Not the same. Take quite a lot of holes. They were basically taking off the same spot. Now, in two of those cases, it was of half or four men, par 5 for women, okay? Okay. It was a short Par 3. They're all Hitting off the same to. Yeah. The uphill. What I was going to say 16th 716? Yeah. 16th uphill, 150.
So they're both eating off, you know, both Hitting off the same T. Seventh uphill, both eating off the same to just you know. Holes like that where you know hitting basically the same to it's very interesting because that means that they a they couldn't have put the guys off for any further back any way. That would be the longest course they probably had for the Gods. For the women, they will. If you just think about it from stats and error rate of having a
longer shot and not being as accurate. They will play slower, that is just a guarantee that you so yeah, if the woman played slower with that kind of sick course setup, I wouldn't be surprised at all. Like I would actually think that that is five hours and great but I would think that that was normal, do you know what I'm saying? Yeah, I do actually just think of the fourth hole now the fourth now for told I would definitely 20 meters in front. Now I can picture it.
Yeah, but as There were a lot of T's where they actually take off all the tee markers. Are the three of them all abilities as well, all through them with sort of within five minutes of each other. Yeah. Right now the means would have had bought hoarding around it. whereas the women would have had hoarding unless it was in the way of the men as error warning, when you mean by that, the T boards How did they are? So if it was the same T both, it had men and women on the same board.
Yeah. It might have had a 5-meter difference with the women men and one. Is it 5:30 something like that? Yeah. Or if they were 20 meters in front they just have a smaller not a wraparound signage but just a on the side. Yeah, you know forth you know par-3 14th. Eight women. Yeah, because it wouldn't be, I wouldn't have thought so yeah it's yeah. Very good stir and that was. So you've taken the day off
today even though they need their best Walker score there. Thank you, they did. But I did get compliments on my walking this morning and when you sign up for the are they just saw hear you loud and clear all day? Very professional because, you know, just that Common People start talking before the the signal even kicks in, you know, that sort of basic stuff and how The button and start talking straight away, all they start talking as they press a button. And of course, it takes a second to click in, so you gotta wait for here, that you're going to click wait for the do.
Do, do, do do, then. Start talking just by sea as we would say in the military, right? He'll radiotelephone. Procedure just basic sort of proceed anyway, that aside I did. This is episode 1 of The Walker score. A big place. I don't know if they'd get much of a following the the I should tell you a quick story about day one. At Kingston heave, I'm at the first. He with my boobs with my school board, my radio school, shit, my radio, ready for my group to come to the First Tee and what have you?
And probably 10 minutes. 40 Tom is right at midday and it's quite a few people around the first he but there's not thousands. And this guy comes up to me because I've got my volunteers shirt on guy comes up to me and says, oh, if they change the tee times around I said yeah they've shifted them by five minutes. So like I was at 12:00 Ma'am, it's bolt and they're just moved them something like I said, Oh I thought Cameron Smith was turning off here at 12:05 and I said, I said it in the nicest possible way.
I said, I think you'll find he's playing at Victoria today at which point he didn't give any thank you or I didn't realize or he just skulked off. He just lowered the head. Started flipping through his phone again and just stormed off almost like a can't believe I went Ooh this wrong Golf Course. Right I may have got the wrong first. He had to hit, I had asked a walker score, tell me I was wrong. Now I'm going to go and pay for
another set of car parking. Just to go and see Kevin Smith or I could leave my car here the whole night and come back in the morning and I might catch him. Is he tees off on the fourth by the time I get there so for those who don't know, Kings native Victoria are not that far away but it must be four or five, k's as the crow flies. Yeah, I think so. I think it would be I think it would be a lot better and it's a hard one to do. There's only basically one or two courses that you could actually do it on. It would be a lot better if they played the torrents at courses
that were Night is and shanab Ansari. So Royal Melbourne's got 36 holes, that would have worked Victoria and Royal could have cheered 18, just walk across Reserve wrote yeah, hunting down the Metro I was quite a few of them could have done it. That's about it Peninsula. King's words got 36 hole. Yep. But it that the fact that they were so far apart, even though they are the most world-class golf courses.
Yeah. Yeah, the fact that they were so far apart, does you do lose a little bit? So hopefully, hopefully some will stick their hand up next year and say, hey, come and play it out 36-hole facility. Yeah, because that, you know, the Vic opens been running the 36-hole facility. Yep. For twelve ten years ten years so they do and I was going to say about the course set up. The guys on the PGA tour of
australasia actually have a ton ton of experience and knowledge about setting up a golf course for me and women because they've done it for the last 10 years. Yeah, it doesn't quite sound like they having the woman so far back with the men, as I said, does slow down the woman a lot more than it, probably should. And the speaker and you can see from the scores as well, although they you know, maybe
the scoring is more about the field and the quality of field and since the current leader is on 14 under and the and the cut was plus 13, where's the men's was a lot tighter with the current leader - 11 and the Cup being plus 2. So maybe it's more about the quality field. So in that instance it's you know some would say I'll push the woman further back because we've got minus 14.
But then they've cut the cut was plus 13. He answered. So you don't really want to push them to fit too much further that, you know, we're not going to say. But, you know, if yet, if you have the women further closer to the Closer to the t is short, a whole, you can actually put the pins in lat a little bit trickier spots. I'm but then again that would affect I had them in play if you have them all the way back. Ty it's a tough thing that cool setup.
Hmm. It's a tough one to get right when you have men and women. Yeah people differ very differing abilities. Excellent. You got any other stories for us yesterday from yesterday or or anything there Stewart and I just wanted to peyser bit slow then actually time myself that probably could have you know, we know on the hard card or it's you know, 50 40 40 and you know, I think every single shot I timed was Welly well in excess
of 50 seconds. Which one which is okay, if the groups and position it exactly of course, of course, I'm like a time it might mean that the group in front of position. But if exactly our position in the first a the referee came over and said all the group just letting you know the group in front of him put on the clock and then I felt we were actually struggling and that's not my responsibility. I shouldn't say. We I just happen to be walking with that group. We were struggling, you know,
sort of Kpop with him an hour on the clock anyway. Just a few did you do today that the referee speak to and you are the players and you and the other players or to directly speak to the players and then spoke to you guys? No, just overheard. I mean I wouldn't have spoken to the walk. Score is no no, not at all. It's not know. Hey, hey Walker Zagora. No no I got one job. You've got, you've got to write faster and walk fast. I mean, I think That's a really
cool thing that, you know, you're a good burdening, budgeting bludgeoning. Don't know the word, you know, you're a rookie referee. Who's really keen on refereeing a lot more tournaments. Just hearing that kind of player management. Yes, it has speak to players. That's, you know, that's an really Priceless advice. So one of the referees on Thursday or Friday, which
having, you know, the guys I'd sit here. We said hello to you and he said I'll you see keen on the rules. Are you said I'm learning every day? Yeah every time I go out there, I'm learning something. Yeah. Anyway I think the key role that Walker scored actually does play is in the event of an emergency or in the case of one day on Thursday, the rare, the player turned to me and said can I get a ruling? Of course it. Yeah I'm on my way. Now it inside. I'm so worried so good. I said yeah I'll call him in. So of course you get on the
network and just because that's the only way I've actually really I'm can waive one day and but they're driving the other direction. You know this is Stuart. Can I get a yeah? Sure rolling nated on hole 12 boy. Sorry the radios broken. I'm just gonna have to I'm gonna have to step in radios broken. Yes. So this is G. You are and your nearest point of relief and blah blah blah. Yep, go for it. You're good. Actually, I didn't I didn't I didn't on the back of 16.
One of the girls had to lifting difference. Just they'll both off The Fringe and by putting and she's marking it and, and she's holding it with the old pincer movement. And I just, I know, Katie said to me, I'll look at it. Isn't that funny? She's holding it with the way. She's holding it. The Katie saying to me and then I caused A referee mode straight away and we're just waiting, we're just off the side chatting and I said well, you know, you don't have to hold it like that but it is actually a good practice because it actually makes it with you. And I have spoken about this before, you know, makes it quite
clear to everyone else, you are making no attempt to clean that ball and then the player comes over and which heading, and just the three of us are chatting having a good walk around on a Thursday afternoon. And I said, you know, there's nothing wrong. Nothing wrong with you actually. Just placing it on the ground and letting go of it because he was holding it for quite a while. Because I don't want to do that. I said, well just don't roll it. Yeah, it don't put it down and roll it. I said it's unemployment just going through, you know, just back in referee mode and I said something play, just put it there. And anyway, she eventually did
you put it on the ground? Of course, you would know. You could be in my shoes right now. You are so Keen to talk about rules and that why we there to assist players and you're so Keen to jump in that mode of assisting a play, but I made it very clear. I said I'm on official today. Day. So don't take anything. I say, you know, it's serious part of me but anyway, that's about it. Thank you for that clock in. did you have a little costume in you, like Suck it off. You don't even want to do that.
I did have it on only rules man and then. Yeah, and they jump into the trees and you put it back on me like that. It's Clark, Kent back again. He's just telling this girl is telling me, this girl was exactly, you had one job and for you, hit it right, very good, very good. Should we finish off the episode 73 with a GI Q? OD W? Yeah, I've got one here. Ready to go for you unless you've got one prepared. Now go for us to.
Okay, this is a long one but you'll follow along this GI Q 0, TW 4 episode 73, Jerry and Fraser, applying a match. If I can match it. One bite Hills and they're on the path through 17th hole. The match is all square. Jerry tees off and hooks his tee shot left into long grass. After play, Fraser plays his tee shot into a greenside bunker Jerry, declares and plays a provisional ball which comes to
rest. 10 cm from the whole as I start walking towards the green jury declares his ball lost and says the phrase are, please don't look for it. Knowing Jerry has a possible tapping for a full phrase that decides to go over the area and start searching as Jerry moves to his provisional ball on the green phrase that thinks he's found Jerry's ball and calls out. I found it. Jerry TAPS in his provisional ball and replies with, it doesn't matter. I declare declared it lost and
I've already pardoned him. Frasier isn't sure the rules and requests a ruling. What is that ruling? So you're absolutely certain that Jerry heard Frazee yell out that he found able found it. Jerry goes, hang on tap. I mean for for look doesn't matter. I mean I mean no. Really. Yeah. Interesting, interesting, very
good. Anything else to add Stewart for you? Wrap up episode 73. Not just a lot of golf. A lot of events coming up. Yeah so just run us through. You got Cathedral Invitational the next days. So is Cathedral and Invitational Monday Tuesday. Correct Invitational small field. I think there's public and TV on the Tuesday maybe so that they don't get I didn't get a practice round or is it a Pro-Am?
No. Wow I'm sorry. There are images in the field but it's not a pro ain't no, no probably not. Yeah, I hate it. Pay them. You know, not that. I mean amateurs who pay to play and and then and then what? What's going to keep playing? Super Six. Oracle's that says that this weekend? Correct. Yep. Starting Thursday. So that's why the gippsland Invitational try to just pop in there because they didn't have anywhere on the Calendar. Okay, got you and then and then yeah so they can give something super 6 and then I won't do
Sunday but I'll do the first three days and then some Victorian amateur overall, Melbourne touring amateur championship at Royal Melbourne for two days, like the finals and the lbl assigned scorer for sign score and not scoring any more and assign referee for one of the women, semi-finals and therein. We hit the sand or invitation or the week before Christmas. Now those four fantastic courses Which for that? I Kingston height. Yeah, tie one row. Milburn Ya, Ya.
Ya Allah and Peninsula. Kingswood South. Okay. I think could be North one of the weirdest further gippsland Super 6. What causes that same as last year? You are not read War Eagle, Waterloo, the said lots of drivable, par 4 words. Exactly. Remember you vividly from last year, you were down in that area? Was a lot of drivable par 4 Words. Yeah. Six and seven hours. And yeah, I remember and there's a lot of waiting as a result of it.
And I'm has been five and six. Mmm. Actually five? Yeah, we're around the corner. Drive will ya? Hang on, one two, NOS, 3 & 4. That's what it was. Three. The drawable corner for up the hill 5. If you're really Brave, you could have a crack at that 6 up the hill sevens of 5:30, I think.
And then eight must have been a path 3 and then nine back to the clubhouse or something. Yeah right here. Good luck with all them. Thank you, and thank you, everyone. For listening to episode 73 will Tune in next week after and still give us a rundown. The cathedral and get Gibson. Thanks for liking all good. Cheers guys.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...