Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

Spotters That Can't Spot - THE GRQ PODCAST EP78

Feb 8, 20231 hr 10 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Spotters That Can't Spot - THE GRQ PODCAST EP78 GRQOTW77 - Two penalty strokes, Rule 17.2 Clubland stories from Andy and JKnox. - are bark chips placed around a tree an immovable obstruction? - a ball is embedded in the side of the hole, is it holed? Discussion about score for match play results. Spotters, are they useful if they can't actually see the ball? GRQOTW78 - Stuart wants Ross to show him his indentification mark, but Ross refuses, is there a penalty?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to episode 78 of the grq podcast on this episode. We answer the gr Q OT w77. We cover a couple of clubland stories including whether bark chips around a tree are an immovable obstruction. We delve deep into the end score in a match. And finally, Stewart, and Blakey both have been busy on tour and share a couple of the rules stories. We hope you enjoy this episode. Goal is a test of character before it is a test of skill and

playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Hey, everyone, welcome to the grq podcast. 78, your hair with Blakey. I am in Saudi Arabia. We've just finished the Saturday International and Stu has also joined me, and he's just finished at ranfurly. What were you doing at ranfurly? Still Thanks Mikey and hello to you this morning. I was there for the Victorian. Open qualifying round on the

Monday before the Vic open this weekend and I also did just finish four days at corporate muruga. Golf Club up on the Victoria New South Wales border as well. With a very nice, very good finish on Sunday afternoon Who what was this qualifying score for unsourced? Sarah, Jane Smith won, the Golden Burger, the TPS, which is a, which is a fantastic effort. That's two women winning in a row on the PGA tour of australasia which is great. Abraham answer. One the Shady International wire

to wire back to the yeah. Wider wire lead after the first round. Didn't give it up. What was the winning score at the Mondeo qualifying to get into the Vic open? So interestingly enough, I had a just sitting out there in the on the course waiting for ruling to be called and I had a father walk past and he said to me, aren't you know what the you know what the best scores are and all this sort of stuff. I said actually I haven't been tracking the schools as you as you are on the course sometimes you're not abreast of you know who's playing well and he's not

playing well. We see players will ask unless it's Sunday. Afternoon is Chatter amongst the right you know on the radio amongst the referee just sort of keeping tabs on You know, exley's by one or they just bogeyed at whole that sort of stuff anyway. So I rang up and found out that -9 was leading this morning. Next best was 6-under and then I think what was going to make qualification was maybe four or five under to actually get in to this week's event. Did they have a player?

I had to leave. Unfortunately for another engagement, I believe there would have been a playoff happening and then the women were playing this afternoon right now. Putting the woman on this afternoon. Do you know how many women would play? I did say the sheet. I'm going to go there and say maybe 40. Yeah, something like that. Hmm. Robert probably for 25 spots and no comment. There was certainly a lot more men, treaty start? About maybe 12, matches. Each side groups of three 3672,

something like that five spots. Yep, correct. Right, let's get into very good. So we've both been refereeing and we will talk through some of our refereeing highlights from the week. First of all, we better get into the gr Q, OT w77 answer. So the question was in stroke play clears, tee shot comes to rest within the margins of a red penalty area, but not in the water. So you makes a stroke at the board, it dribbles down the bank

into the water and cannot be played Leah. Drops another On the banquet, in the penalty area, in the proper relief area for the rule 17.1 D1. They decide not to play again from that lie, and drop a third ball with into complex and not nearer the whole than the spot where the ball originally crossed into the red penalty area. Clear plays from the, this series of events, how many naughty Strokes has the player

gotten? What's your thoughts Stewart? Well, to thoughts that come to mind is, she's proceeded to take relief twice, that's the initial thought. She's proceeded under strike conditions, so 17.1 D12, gone back to where her previous stroke was made. Which may have only been one or two meters back, but you're entitled to do that within the penalty area. So, that's the initial thought is she's dropped their once then decided not to play that ball, and then decided to take, Relief

outside. Therefore, you would then think. Well, that's the second drop, but if you actually go to 17.1 D, 17.1 D1. All of these are Under the penalty of one stroke, the three options and the first one of course is stroke and distance. The player may play the original ball or another ball from where the previous stroke was made. And sorry, the question was then raised by dropping that ball with you intend for it to be in play under that rule.

Has she incurred the one-stroke penalty yet because she hasn't yet played the original or another ball from where the previous stroke was made. Whereas the other two options are the plane, may drop you Regional or another ball outside, the penalty area, etc, etc! Back on the line or lateral and that's soon as you drop that you've incurred. The A one-stroke penalty. So I was in a bit of two minds about whether it's one one-stroke penalty or two, one stroke penalties, I think the

obvious answer is to but I'm not convinced. Well, it is too and if we just head over to rule 17 point, who if you look at a, it goes when ball played from penalty area, comes to rest and same or another penalty area. Then you have all those rule options relief Options under 17.1 As well as. Slang from your last place fight

within the penalty area. So you've got to stroke and distance options. Effectively one is inside the penalty area and one is outside. Now, you can opt to go straight to the one outside. Or you can go straight to to cobbling. So you can go back on the line, outside the penalty area, or you can choose to drop it that last base plate, inside the penalty area.

But if you do so you do that for a parody of one. Even if you don't play it, you still get the penalty of one for dropping it. You then you still have those options of going outside the penalty area for another penalty stroke. So you're correct. It is 2 times 1, Hillary Strokes total of two penalty strokes and I think one of the things that I learned very early on in 17.2 covers is Is if your ball is in a red penalty area or yellow,

you can have another ten Strokes, you can take some penalty drops, you can take some free drops, another three Strokes, you never ever lose that estimated point where the ball last crossed into that penalty area. So you always retain that ability to get out using multiple web sorting. Yeah. If only the Unplayable still had that rule, you know, like can you remember Kevin Na when he had a six year? I remember, you mentioned here in the jungle if he always had

the option of going back to the Tang area. That could have saved him a lot of pain. You would have done it like Strokes earlier. Yeah, actually I'm good at that's a good idea actually. I'm going to encourage them to adopt that even if you have seven or so shots in the in the forest you can always go back and play. Start the whole again, almost but just don't that'll fit any of those Strokes. You got to keep a nice Trails. Exactly. Start the whole again, those scare stroke still count the

penalty, stroke still count. But you get to start the whole again. I like that idea. Like, if you get that through whilst the latest change to putting a ball back into plain and it rolling into another area of the course, and being able to replace, it is known commonly as the Rickie Fowler rule. You don't get that through, we may call that the Kevin our rule. Yes. Yeah. That's right. That would be exactly what would be called. A boy brought some /. Kevin are definitely not want. My name attached to that.

So great. That was question, 7 E7 Z RQ, 0 TW. Now, we've had a couple of blob Land Story. What's the word applications? No submissions. Perfect. A couple of clubland story submissions. And we can we're going to roll these out today as Stuart. And I've said, over the previous podcasts, you can submit a story

clubland story to the Google form and we will address it on the podcast. So, we're here. We have Why not from and forego, I don't really want to radiate their Gmail or their email account, can I? But thank you and forego. So a small Gumtree about 3 meters in height and 4 inch diameter trunk. So pretty small on the first hole is on the edge of the

Fairway, locates it located on the edge of the Fairway. It has a ring of bark chips around it. It's the only Tree on the whole with this ring of Bart. It's not staked, it's not under two Club, lengths, and height should the player get relief if they're in the bark chips? Now, the club President says, it's a garden bed and relief is free relief as possible. But this person is not in agreeance and thinks it is a play as it lies situation.

What what sticks out at you with that? Kind of question or comments during immediately I'm thinking too, loose impediments and the fact that that bark, all that bark is still attached to the tree attached, natural object. Therefore they are not loose impediments. And my initial that what jumps out is. We could explore the garden bed, a little bit further but

initially, I would think that's a player's that lies or take envelope along the believe the bark chips are not from the tree. I believe the bark chips. You know, a cut up free and then they've been placed around the tree. Uh-huh. I should every bit of that as a bit of a beautiful calculation. Almost yes, correct understood. Well now you can start making the argument that it's an obstruction.

It's artificial. Yeah, but factors been man-made, it's been using natural objects. You've constructed this thing for appearance, sake, for the tree to look a bit nicer. You could make an argument that all of a sudden, it's an obstruction, it's an artificial object. Yeah, that's that's very true. So something that's something not natural. Is it then cleaning the man. Yes, interfered natural turned into an obstruction, isn't it? I think you can make an argument and it was it's not naturally

there, the plaque main language, black replies, it laws or they could remove the individual bark chips as loose impediments or they could take free relief from its signal to removal of structure. Yeah I think it's not aside and obstruction. It's sitting on top of it. I tend to agree with that. I don't like it. I agree that it should be a pleasant lies.

I think when it really comes down to, is the committee really needs to say. Okay, this is an integral object, exactly. Or this is a garden bed type area, and we are wanting you to take your giving you free relief. Now, you know, when you make local rules, there's two reasons that you'd make a local rule 1. Is you're trying to protect the course?

That's probably the most important. I don't think, you know, there's a small Gumtree but I don't think You're really trying to protect this tree. It's not small enough. So, I wouldn't have free relief to protect the tree. And the second reason is to protect the player and personally, I wouldn't if it's

what it says on the edge of the Fairway. It really depends on where our closes the fee waivers really close. Then possibly, you're trying to protect the player there, but I prefer the players that lies or play the courses, you find it type situation and I would actually inter tend to make that an integral object that bark around the tree and integral object.

At the same time, the owners of the club, the members of President, the committee and the like probably don't want people coming up with their 7-iron and hacking away at the ball lodged. In this thing that they've made to wrap around the tree, they probably don't want people swiping it with with their clubs to damage it. Possibly, I, why do they even put put it there in the first place? Exactly. But if it is that for that beautification of all, this looks really nice, but I don't know, you know, picture would be great.

I thought it would be great but again, they probably don't want people swiping at it with their clubs. Because you have other guy, you know, it's you got two players at lies or taken apart. I'm not I'm not taking on global whack. Let's get this thing out of there. No damage the Damage it. They probably don't want that. Yeah, possibly. Yeah, the interesting thing is possibly, it was, you know, it was not growing grass around the area and it didn't look very nice. So they did put the bark chips for that beautification. And the easy thing to do is just

whack something around it, which looks natural and call it an MP's ID on their local rules of the easy thing to do and just keep flies away from it. Yeah, I just stick a stake it, right? Soda. Yeah, you know. Yeah. I mean you really wouldn't want to put like any kind of Stone or something. So, if it's so close to the feeling, hmm. But something you don't want to you. Don't you want a white line around it all the time. On knows it's something natural, which, which clearly identifies the area of that.

Nope, laser small, small, small steak with a really small with just, a little mpz door. Gee, you are. And then they can do. They can choose to take relief or not. Yeah, yeah. But it definitely needs to be this kind of thing, definitely. He needs to be described in the local rule addressed, correct? Yes. That's because you say you're saying, you know, local rules are design, you know, protect the course protect the player but it's things that are specific to that course that you're not going to find it.

A lot of other causes that's why they appear on the local rules. You know, on the third hole, there's a penalty area down there. If you think, bye-bye, you're allowed to hit a provisional. For example, there might be a local rule, which says, that, because it's specific to that whole on that cause that you're not going to find on other causes, that might be bad. Painful. But that's why you have like rules. It's a bad example because we don't want to promote that. Local. No, no, that's why. That's why I corrected myself. You know what I'm saying? You know, specific to that, of course. And this could be an example of something specific to that

course. Well, that's right. There mean add another course they could have called it an even bigger object at a different course, I could have called, and no play zone, and another course, part of call it GUI, the local rules are really there for players information, providing information to the player about the cause And you don't want to play as ball ending up in that position of right up against the tree or inside the bark and every I look into each other going. What do we do? Yeah exactly. We want them to know what to do. Keep playing move on and it could it could be a situation

where you do provide free relief but not for stance so they can stand on the back and play but yeah that's definitely one that they need to address. The local rules will send that out to and fair go thank you very much for your Situation. And you have any others, feel free to submit another one and into anyone else. Feel free to submit one. We have another one from J. Knox. A question raised in our club, a ball was hit and slam dunks in

the hole. When going to take the ball out of the hole, it's found embedded into the wall of the whole. No part of the ball is in the hole. Is it still deemed as being whole? Ugh. What do you think about that one? Can you can you first of all, can you imagine it? Well, I'm trying to picture it, so it's in embedded in the grass, beside the hole on the green and it's wedged in there, but it's not below the surface

of a whole. The ground nor is it resting up against the flagstick, I'm assuming. Yeah. Correct. In which case I suspect that person needs to have another stroke to tap it in. Yeah, this is the complete me. Only seen a ball where it's embedded in the side of the hole. And if it's embedded in the side of whole, with part of the ball, breaking that circumference of the hole, Dean. So we've got a part of the ball

breaking inside if you look straight down into the hole. Yeah, Yeah. I'm seeing part of the ball break in the circumference, then you only question you have to ask is is the whole ball below the level of the putting green? Exactly. Now, if the cup, the plastic insert or metallic insert has only been cut in inch down from the top. It is very unlikely that the

whole ball will be below the putting green, because I think you remember how the diameter of a ball, I think it's 1.68 or something like that. Right, one point six eight inches. So there's one point six eight inches. I'll check it out later then and the top of the cup is only one inch below sir. Then physics tells me that that cart or Max tells me that that can't work, right? But if the cup is cut the

plastic inserts cut even further down or there is no plastic inserts, you don't need a plastic insert for a hole. Then if all of the ball Falls below the level of The Cutting green, the ball was whole if a Tiant has broken that's edge of the whole. Yes, when we see we're looking down, we see looking down. You can see it exactly. It doesn't bargain this conference so that's you know if it hasn't broken scum France, don't worry about. We don't even have to ask the second question.

Broken, the circumference where you can see it when you look straight down in the second question, is it all of it below? The putting green? If it is hold, if it's not, then Mark your ball. Try and repair the pitch Market, repair the damaged, replace your ball. If your ball won't stay at rest, you place it again. If it doesn't stay at rest, you move it slightly so it's no nearer. The whole I don't know if you could get near the huh and make sure it comes to rest and then

as you said, it's going to cost an extra stroke. Yeah. So just to clarify. So when the ball is hold when it's not completely below the surface of the green, it needs to be resting up against the flagstick. Yes, and not there's an interesting one, not at not with the flagstick aggressed against the ball, but the ball at rest against the flags, right? Yeah. So if the ball was apprehended,

if the ball was embedded in its not at rest against the flagstick. But the flag sex on a slot on a slope, then the flagstick is at rest against the book. Hmm, which wouldn't care period. That was, that was two Club. Lengths stories from our Google forms, which is great. So anyone else who has one, please feel free to submit and we will address it here on the podcast. I believe you have a couple of slob land stories, too.

This one is this one take. This is not really a real situation. It's more of a discussion on the role of people in a competition. So this is a real conversation. I had with a Groove. I was flying with a week or maybe last Wednesday and we're talking about going on golf trips and talking about one particular person who's a regular on trips that I go on, who is a cheat? A known cheat has I'm caught countless times throwing a ball

out from behind the tree, kicking it out. All sorts of stuff has openly admitted and yes, I know I cheat I can't help myself, etcetera, etcetera, that's not really the issue. That's just really leading us to the bigger issue. I think, although that is a pretty big issue, but I was talking to these people are, you know, and I've heard he cheats and two people go straight away, you know, I have seen him, I have physically seen him, he definitely does, you know, On situation, I could see his ball just in the thick, grass off the edge of the Fairway.

I turn around to walk away immediately term, turn back. He probably thinks I'm not watching and I saw him just pick it up and throw it out. So I know each other I've seen him and then he went on to say, this is in, this is the killer, he then went on to say something along the lines of. But at the time, I didn't want to say anything because I wasn't his marker. Right. And I thought, wow, I just think that is a really, really big

misunderstanding of the role of a marker or the role of other people in stroke play. That's right, the role of other people. So that I just found that a fascinating. He was dead serious. Look, I didn't want to say anything because I wasn't his market so it's not my place. I found that fascinating. What do you think he should have done? Said something. So either to the player, the player to play on. Well, I okay. So let's have a think about this. You could certainly say immediately to the player.

Can I just ask what you were doing there? I think is probably the softest way of doing it as opposed to run straight over and start poking in the chest. But can I ask what you were doing? Wasn't your ball over there? Etc, etc. I think the marker is probably one of the last people I speak to I think the next people I would speak to would be the committee. I would probably say something to the Mark. I didn't bother. Why did you see what happened there? Just letting you know. I'll be I'll be pursuing this with the committee for example, if he doesn't change his school,

definitely say something on the market. Hmm. But on the market wouldn't be the first person. I was Victor. More than likely. I will eat well. I would probably yell out to say, hey, what are you doing? Exactly. Yeah. Who knows what you're doing and then and then see where that went and it would baffle me if he tried to deny it or she tried

to deny it. Hmm. And then go and then if they did, or they did try and deny it, I guess, I guess we go. Did anyone else see that happen? Hmm. And then, I'd almost if they did write it out of fucking sorry. I'd almost Oh my smoke off. Hmm, I just fan. And I thought you'd find it. I mean, you've told me what you believe the role of a marker is

and I thought it was a very good description, but I just found that fascinating again. I'll repeat myself that he said, well, it wasn't my problem because I wasn't his Market had. I been his marker. I may have said something, but I was just another player in the event. So I wasn't gonna say anything. I was on his mind. I wish you'd lost by a shot that by then we see whether he would. I'd have said anything, exactly. It's like it wasn't his problem, because he wasn't his marker, and I think that was, I think

it's almost wrong. It's wrong, and right? And there's a wrong price. He's playing against he's in the field. But I wonder how many other people in clubland, think. Well, I'm really not concerned about what that plays doing. Because I'm not his marker. He's not my problem. Let's move on his marker. I'm going to pay very close attention, possibly, not that close. But you know I'm following any shots, he said but if he's not mine, I'm not worried about it. I would think that the person this is off the cuff, I would

think that the person who has the most rules knowledge in the group, Okay, we're close eye on every well and you and I have spoken about this previously and I know of several other players, people go and golf trips and the like who count everybody else or Strokes every hole. Now, they may or they probably don't mark them down. But when someone goes off and says to his Mark writer for they'll know, straightaway didn't know before unified. Yeah. I mean because I just can't, they can't everyone else's Strokes. They know exactly how many

strokes other people have had I wish you didn't. I do it. Yes, but I wish I could transfer that into counting cards. Yeah. Look, I'd around maybe only three or four weeks ago, just one hole. Guy walked off says, I know 641. I said, make sure he didn't have a 7 now. I know this guy. Well, I played with him. Are you sure you never see them? He goes, oh, oh yes, even our

what simple as that, why? Because I was counting shots. I knew a Jeopardy had doesn't happen very often but it only happened a few weeks ago. I said to my girlfriend all the time when we play golf she's like I had a they have a double. I was like no it was more like that was more like a triple or quad-a. She's like you know Fallen at all. Did you? She's like you're not going to can't the one that I missed it. I was like, why don't you try to hit it? She's like yes, that's tight. Yeah, she loved playing golf with you he does. She does love buying out with me. That's what does magic doesn't

listen to the podcast? I'm sure I'm sure that's exactly what you told you. It's what we have lied in five months if you're right. So we've sorted out the role of a marker now, you had another plan. Why do? And just to finish on that point just to say State? What you told me years ago, you believe the role of a marker. Not that this person thought it was his problem because he wasn't the Marco. But you always told me the role of the marker was to be the eyes and ears of the committee It was to provide information to the

committee, should the committee need to investigate something and try to ascertain the facts. You just there as a representative, almost it should be holding too often but that's what your role is really your. That's yeah, that's a good way of putting it and overall you know the committee is there for the whole field of players. So in effect you are one representative of the whole field of the play. My net as a referee. You were both referees.

That's what we are. That's who we're acting for. We're not acting for us. The rest were 8 were acting for, you know, the rest of the players. Hmm. And they would think if you're, you know, Do the rules but address the rules properly. And Play by the rules. We don't play that if you roll a correctly, That they would hope that you do that for everyone else. Exactly.

Again, and yet another clubland story still. This all I did this also involves rule 3 and this was a simple as. Yes, I played an affordable match board event on Sunday. We were to down on the 17th green to down on the 73. My opponent. And I had ten-foot putt side-by-side with my opponent to putt. First, she made the putt matches over, right. To prevent us from having He further chance to win, we shook hands.

And then, I actually parted as well made my part as well, which is probably not relevant as we already lost the match. He said, did we lose two down two, and one, one down, it's no big deal. I just want to know. How do they accurately reflect the result of that match? To which I replied to him. But I thought that was interesting about how we record the results of matches, That's

on, that's in the rule book. I'll read this out and hope that I've chosen the right one. In a match between a and b, a is one up playing the last hole in the following situations in. Considering these actions, there's a win by one hole or two holes, similar to your situation. So I first first one B is on the Green in three strokes but a long way from the hole, a plays his third stroke from the edge

of the green and it comes to rest about a foot from the hole. Be goes over and shakes hands with a So, remember that. A is one up playing the last. Yep. So be went over to a and shook his hand in the first scenario second scenario. B is on the green and two strokes a-holes, his third stroke and be shakes hands with

a Okay, dude, scenario. A place is second shot from the Fairway on to the green. Be second shot, misses the green and plugs in a bunker. Be immediately walks over a and shakes his hand All scenario, B is on the green and six strokes, but a long way from the hole, a Places third stroke from the edge of the green and it comes to rest about one foot from the hole be goes over and shakes hands with a.

And then the first scenario a is on the green and two strokes beep. Lasers. Third stroke from the ferry, I love the green and the ball comes to rest about one foot from the hole be goes over and shakes hands with a The handshake between the players is deemed to represent an agreement to concede each player's. Next stroke So that's basically the rule accordingly in situations scenario, 1, 2, 3, a wins, the match by one hole.

Because they shook hands and be still had an opportunity to have a heart. In situations four and five. A has won the final hole and wins the match by two holes. So you guys shook hands. So I was incorrect. It doesn't actually matter if you Well, I think if, you know, I think I wasn't me creep. If you pick your ball up. Yep. That's not. That's not a concession by your opponents for your shot. So they would win three and one, but if they came and shook your

hand or you win and shook their hand, then they've conceded your next stroke and you lose two or two downs, though. We're very interested to see if the current rule book has something similar to that. Roll to your decision to 32. 332 outcome change no but it has been eliminated it. Now it is now covered by three point to be too.

Three. Three-point to be too. A concession is made only when clearly communicated this can be done either verbally or by an action that clearly shows the players and tensor can see the stroke the whole or the match such as making a gesture. If the opponent list they're born, breech were all because of a reasonable misunderstanding at the Players. Statement reaction was consistent blah blah. So basically What is a concession? Concession is.

Oh no. Its next stroke a hole or the match and they didn't say we can see the hole. They just shook your hand. Which means you basically, it means you can see the next stroke. So I think, at the highest level, how many competitions that involve match play concern themselves with the margins in the end, maybe they are go to the Ryder Cup, for example. Now I'll put on television Thomas and, you know, Spieth 17

and 6. But doesn't matter. I still not want to point. That doesn't actually matter because we remember from Jack Nicklaus conceding that part to can't remember that. But Darren Darren Darren Darren No, I'm thinking another one you talkin about. Nah, it's that part. And that meant that they tied, the u.s. retire u.s. retain, so they didn't look back at match

scores or anything like that. So, Ryder Cup solheim president's, they obviously don't local pennant that we are involved with. Not me anymore. But you local pennant, they definitely keep an eye on them on the max scores but very really. Oh. Actually it was it last year or the year before when it actually had made a difference.

It did, there was one division that it made a difference and they had to go back to Who out of the number ones, who had the best record? And then I think they had the same and then that went to who one out of the two of them. So I guess that didn't really come down to actual match results but I think then they might have been. Yeah. So don't actually come down to the, you know, seven and eight or a seven and six or five and

four. But it definitely came down to how many shot matches the number one. That one. Exactly. Yeah. But not by the margins, not by the margin. So maybe that maybe that is redundant now. Hmm. So my thinking it is and I think back to your comments not so long ago. In a previous podcast about the rules of golf USGA RNA, don't concern themselves. With what a birdie is going to care what a bogey is. And I tend to think about, you know, these events that concern

themselves with was it to a at 2 on 1. 3 & 1 are NAU, is she? I don't care. They just telling you how you win a match or how you lose a match. That's what they're concerned about. Yeah, I mean, if it's in the book, I still think that it they do concern themselves with it. We the die. Some words have been significance. It's for today was very black and white. How do you win a match? You know, your opponent's

disqualified opponent concedes or your one more holes in our holes left in the three ways you win a match. Maybe they don't. Maybe they don't really care about it. Was it to on one or three? One or two up? I don't know. Well, I think do they care? I think, you know, because at the end of the day, all these rules, they run their own championships as well. So they need to be black and white on how they running them. Of course, you know, they run.

That you know, the junior Ryder Cup or whatever it is or the or the genius that GB and ibises the us or whatever it is or gbr versus Europe and stuff like that. I still think that they care, you know, but every thought every T crossed and everything. They created a set of rules and then other people said, oh well can we just use yours and they said, yep, sweet. Then it got adopted worldwide. So I believe they do, you know? They do also play by them but

the signal of the actual result of a match. Yeah. As we've talked about it is probably pretty, pretty small. I mean, that's not to say that, you know, gardeners run tomorrow creates a match play event and says the winner. Of, you know this head-to-head match play and it's an individual match for a winner is not the person who wins the final match because there won't

be one. It's just whoever has the biggest difference exactly in which case they would said about the ways in which they would determine in calculating, that be very clear about that spot on and then because the rules are written the way they are. That allows them to say we play by the RNA rules, right? I think we've crossed that one on. Now you had a couple of covering bruger, which you've been really do.

I'm just just thinking about time and whether we leave it for another podcast over quite a few stories from there. And I'm sure you have some from Jitter or in Saudi Arabia. We can crack. Oh well, I'll still go another 30 or 40 minute. Okay, you know, I certainly have let's go to let me just go back to my notes that I was actually, knowing, we would do this, you know, the next podcast at some point, I'm sitting out there on the course, and I'll bet not forget that one. I'll write that one down, so

we're going to bring it up, I'll give you one line the whole time. Taking you had nine. I only had nine. It's crazy very quiet, he's if he's going. Okay. So first hole, par 5, young lady. I think she was from Thailand, just flew the flute agreeing went over. Well, I didn't see how the ball got there, but it eventually came to rest behind the green up against a boundary fence. And sure enough.

I was cold to it, and this boundary fence was a Cyclone Fence, but it wasn't steals like plasticy. So I was actually quite movable. You could, you know, easily push e, push your weight up against it and move it around quite easily. And of course, she's asked for my help and I said, how can I help? And with very, very softly spoken. She was just explaining I, you know, can I get relief from this? And I said, no, I said that. As it's a boundary object is no free relief. Available from the since I said the only options you have to

play the ball as it lies or take an unplayable ball relief. And there are three options for that and I said, you can't go back on the line because back on the line is back out through the fence. So that's out, your only options are go lateral, which would provide her very, very small sliver of relief area up against the fence or two, of course, proceed under stroke and distance and go back. There's two points that I wanted to raise one. The time she took to make a decision with her caddie whom I

assume was her father, the time they took was excessive and I probably learned something from that that I stepped away after I provided her those options. I just stepped away, only a few meters to talk to the other, two players who were listening in, which king brings me to my second point in just a moment. But I probably should have just stayed that one or two meters closer to apply that smallest bit of pressure. Come on. You need to make a decision if she took way too long, in the end, she proceeded under strike

conditions. In the end. She jumped in my buggy in my car, and I drove her back to where she best estimate. Where she hid her last shot from dropped played, I drove her back. Meanwhile, the other two of actually hold out, right? Because the rest of waiting, on The Fairway waiting to get up and the other rest of the other. Two of hold our standing on the next tee, which actually was on that far away. One of them yelled out to me. Is that am I right ahead? I said, you just go You're ready. Just go. And we can watch her whole are destroyed in distance shots, actually put in the bunker on an into parted. So one was the excessive time,

but more importantly, I thought was whilst this time was going on the other two players were listening in. And they were talking to me about, I could she do this, can she Stand Out of Bounds to hit that ball and hit it back? Can she do this? Can she do this? And they weren't talking amongst themselves. They were quite loud and I said to them afterwards. After I drove her back end of the ferrite 170 meters and came back up to the green and talk to those other two players. I just said to them, just a friendly warning.

You need to be very careful about what you say. And I was very friendly about it and they were very receptive. I said, you need to be very careful about what you say that it's not perceived to be attempting to influence the player in what they do. Because I was told me about all she could go outside the face, you know, and like a stroke from outside the fence, you know, hitting the ball and etc, etc. I just said that I'd says and it's I've never had that situation before it was a first for me. I think they were you can tell they were quite appreciative of what I said. I said it with a smile and it

was a friendly warning. I said just going to be careful about what you say that someone doesn't perceive that as attempting to influence the player. I almost saw it and I hate to be sexist about it. But this was a really young small young girl, and it was almost like these guys were trying to step in and help her out, you know, and be strapless about and try to exactly and try to help her out of this, what was really a difficult situation. And it really was, she was right up against the fence had no shot.

Only option was to go back and play it again. It was almost all trying to be yeah. Big brother trying to look out for her and I just said, just be careful about what you say. You need to probably keep it to yourself. Off of it because they were quite vocal about it. But that said, it's not, it's not what they said. It's at the volume that they said it. It sounds like That was his wife for the fates. Yeah. And a caddy the the welcome to have a conversation amongst themselves but any kind of influence would could be

construed as a bath. Yeah which is why I provided a warning. I didn't think it came anywhere near close to warranting. A right guys that you know it's too straight seeds or anything like that. It was just a conversation. I had with him too and I think genuinely they appreciated the fact that I said it with a smile and said Ted just just be careful next time. Yeah. Yeah. Right. As I said it was a new situation for me. I've never had that thing I've ever heard that one. Nice.

Another one from Colton. Brew. Yeah but I've got a juicy one the next hole. So forget the same everyone or know. Completely every day. 1 Day 2 s whole. So blind shot. You're playing actually over the ladies tee which is in front of you and then down to a flat you cannot see where you're balling. Zup. So this is when I rock up, I'll get the phone call, get the call over the radio Iraq up player is coming out of the trees a little bit distressed. I said, how can I help?

He explained as follows, I hit my tee shot way left and I knew it might be in trouble so I played a provisional ball which ended on The Fairway, I said, okay good. He said as I came over the hill, I could see the spotters. So these are the volunteers, assisting the event. I could see the spot as waving at me and sort of pointing to the ground. Hey we found your wallet right here. Landed here we saw it. You know you it's okay. We've got it at that point.

I have walked past my provisional ball and I picked it up. I've moved over to the area where the spotters are waving me down only to discover that the ball they had found and we're pointing it was not my ball, I did from the tee. We searched for another 3 minutes and I couldn't find it and he said to me, what do I do? So again this was a new one. For me is one you to rule but I've never had this happen for real. I probably read this question many times, but never seen it happen to apply Real Player trying to make the cart, trying

to make a living. And it happened to him and he was a little bit upset when I told him the rule. So you know the rule as well as I do better than I do. It's a real shame with the their spotters and they're like, oh I've got a ball inside well and that's it. That's really annoying. Was it was that on the fifth top Second hole. Second of the old course. What do we play when was your course? Whichever one has the first five holes on one side of the road

and the rest on the other side. Doesn't it rerouted the course then? Okay. First is a par-5 down the fence to wear this fence was where the tiger or the day before. Yeah. S bag path through the MW went off, BMW went off yesterday, took video of the player retrieving the ball, one hundred and thirty six thousand dollar car. That was all very exciting. Then when the past 3 to the 3rd hole Visa correct was 177 M so that the first hole used to be

the one that your head away from the play from the Pro Shop. A little path for okay? And then the second hole was down below it and you came back and you're heading towards the road, okay, so I'll just talk about this conversation. I had with the player. I just for a moment, I said to him, we need to go back to where your provisional was, but then, of course, I had to tell him and we need to add one penalty stroke because you've lifted your ball in play.

Well, To say that he was a bit filthy and be upset was an understatement is an understatement. Yeah. So it's going. So I said look, let's go back. We'll find where your where you actually picked up your provisional. Was this place that ball? Replace it. If you don't know if it's yours just best estimate by this stage, it was filthy. And then to add salt to the wound as we were driving back. I was driving back. He was walking back to the location of his provisional. We could hear the spotters Behind us back in the tree.

All, very excited that they had, in fact, found his original ball after all, but of course, it was after three minutes had elapsed. So this player did not want to know anything about that. You're gonna have such a good taste in the mouth when he goes back there next year. Especially on that hole. So as he walked off the green, I said Look by my calculations, you've had a 7 because he was hitting his fifth shot from where his provisional ball was before he picked it up.

I think I'm kind of that correctly. Three for you. And then he playing five from there. After the one-stroke penalty for lifting is going play in my two shots said, and I said, I believe the other seven, he was beat up said he wanted to talk about you know, about the spotters and what role they play. I've said to appease him, I said look what I'll do is I'll talk to the tournament director, now about it and see if we can just you know not make a deal but just talk to him about that. I did that knowing they would be no way out of the one-stroke penalty but I did it to make him

feel a bit more at ease. Before he played another 16 holes. Yeah, that's right. Nice work. Yeah, I'm just looking at the map of Cobham, Brogan are, so that's the first second. And then the third part. Sorry. In 45 and then you come back over the road. Correct. So that's a good citizen turn left. That's a sick soul.

And that's sixth. and then, You are now at the top of the hill, we all closet. What's the green? The green that's near the 60 is that the 9800 9,500 lines out on the course. Did they change the clubhouse? There's a club house near the 88. Yes. Yeah. Wow. I didn't always the one right next to the, yeah. So, and we had to have a shuttle to take players to the 10th tee for the first two days.

So, the old Car park. Yeah, that's at the back of the 6th grain, correct, not in use anymore as a clubhouse. Ah, that's it. Used to be where it's the 18th was the one behind that and the first so that was, that was used as I go down the hill powerful. Okay, in the short par-4 drawable Quite drivable. No, not really.

Many way not long, maybe they extended it. I am - that old Clubhouse was used for violent. All the volunteers media were in there and some accommodation I didn't realize that they've changed it. They must have done that a few years ago. Haven't been up there for a while. Okay, yeah, yeah. So that used to be the okay. Okay, so that's so the because the guys that own it. Yeah, work. Were the sporting club so they must have gone. Well, we own that bit over

there. We've just bought that hope that there Maybe they'll put more accommodation them or something. A very good man. I had, did you have any others that come? I do but I think it's your turn. No, no, I need to get yours all out because I can do a big run of mine at the end if I can remember them. So, go keep going with. Okay, talking about spotters, I had on the 10th hole yesterday, so this is the first day for I

had two spotters who didn't even play golf. And really didn't know what to do. But and I could this is a par 5 and a blind, tee shot and I could just see this woman watching them hit and then just looking in the complete wrong area to watch the ball. Go overhead. It was a bit comical, her husband's, on the other side of the Fairway, sitting in a chair, just enjoying the afternoon, but it just made me think about You

know, we've got to cut them, some slack in that they are and and poor player on the second hole who ran afoul of one. When they thought he's vanished born, it wasn't his ball at all. All these people are volunteers and most of them are club members will locals in the area wanting to help out. And I heard one on the 13th hole, either was yesterday for talking to one of her friends is older woman talking to one of her friends talking about her role. A whole and she was doing this and what having she said, see

those red steaks over there in there was red stakes on the grid, penalty area left of 13. She said to her friend on that's out of bounds. They don't want to get it over there. My first thought that was funny. The spotters, you know, some of them, no golf better than I do and play golf better than I do. And they're, they're doing a wonderful job but some of them are not so golf Savvy in describing that area on the left of 13 which was a red penalty area. Of course, there's that a bounce off. It was a little funny.

Yeah I mean you get your volunteers where you get your volunteers I hope they enjoyed it. Maybe they start golf after that but I guess then there needs to be a better training for Volunteers. That's not something greed. PGA, probably has time to do but, you know, they should I agreed. So, on this 10th hole is woman, who didn't know even where to look and I could see her steering of the distance across

the Fairway in the Bulls sailing over here and now thud, you know, 70 meters to her left and she still looking for the poor in front of her which was just hilarious. But just a simple things of hey, when they hit the ball and they pick up their teeth straight away, for example, it pretty With the shot when they hit the ball. If they extend their arm out all the way to the left with their Club, the indicating something simple, little things like that. You can lean a little bit one way or the other. That's an indication of where perhaps roughly to look, simple

things like that. Now, most golfers know all that but it just so happened these two on. This particular yesterday were not golfers and didn't know that. And of course, I've heard one player go past me and he's done the extension of the left arm. He's gone past me and you should have heard what he was saying. Go to the spotter but not directly, definitely not directly under his breath. But you could tell he was incredibly frustrated. And of course, I went down and help him search. We found his ball all okay? Because it's tell he was frustrated.

And then I and I spoke to the PGA, people about this and they put it into perspective and they said, you know, they are there to help their volunteers, but the players shouldn't be, they're there to help the players still need to play their own game. Play golf, and not rely too heavily on. On the spotters. Yeah. But that's that's a bit tough because if someone's telling you something or not, all you expecting them to be there and doing something they can actually get in the way. Definitely.

Don't want them to have faking which, you know, which happens and which is even worse. So I can see like, yeah. Okay. Some of the players just take their concern or take their anger out as tragic. Someone else? When it's not actually You know, warranted and they were actually, just just doing it that it could be a tree, you know, they just doing it because they're trying to get let go of some, some anger, hmm.

But other times, you know, like the James grass and I like he's actually been Not easy. The other ways been not only not helped, but actually they've told him to do something. That indirectly you he shouldn't have done and for those who don't identify mention his name. So that's because I told you the story that's the guy. He picked up his provisional when he shouldn't have on the second hole. That's right. No one's going to be listening

to this podcast knows, yes. But yeah. I mean, that's, that's rough. you just need like, sometimes I'd say it's better, just not have the Not have the spot of there at all. I think the safety of this is important in that particular case. They were standing in the middle of the. She do play a valuable role in standing in the middle of their way until the players on the Fairway had hit their second

shots and then walked off and people on the 10th tee knew. Then it was safe to play. Yeah but that wasn't a very important role that is important role but you know one of the caddies could have done that if there wasn't the someone there one of the caddies because said you know they were smart enough stood At the top of the hill. Thanks for waiting for the little place. So, you know, you'll find a way to make it work. Yeah. It's when it's when the volunteer hasn't been given too much training and then they become a liability or month.

Hmm. Whatever. The only, the only other one I sent you the photo of this was the cart path, right? Of 5th, green, and right next to the car path was a chain fence, going through posts. So I gave quite a few people. I wanted to hear about this one. You want to hear about it? Yeah, yeah, yeah. I was like, oh, what do you say now? I've got heaps of, I've got heaps of information about this. Well, what she's about to sell these all I was saying, was

quite a few people on that path. Quite a few people, they need to feed with by the chain fence, and I just took the players through to really procedures so because they were two separate, abnormal course, conditions, not that they want to hear that expression. But I just said, because they should all look. If I go that way off the path, I'm gonna have, you know, I said, that's, that's fine. Let's just drop. Let's get relief in the past. If you then have relief from the chain fence, and whatever you old, then will then go through the procedure all again. I think the point and it happened to quite a few players. I think the point I wanted to make was another player was well-known in Australian golf. You'd know him was, he was on

the path and he said, what's happening here. I said well we would engineer as Point here. Got to get the stance off the path out of here near as Point Club lengths. If you have in a very Bubble Bobble is going on, okay? Thinking he's not doing better, get over the trees. Back onto his hole, I said, of course, you can play it as it lies as well, and he's gone. Oh yes of course. Like and then he actually ended up playing the ball off the path. It was a much better angle, to actually get it back through to the Fairway that he was playing. And I think every now and again,

when players either born a path, they not forget but it's not first and foremost in their mind that they actually still have the option to play the ball as allies when I said, Add that to him. It was almost half surprised. But uh yeah of course and then he ended up playing that and actually taken that option that's because their first initial thought is, now I'm going to get a free drop. I'm going to get the ball in my hand. I'm going to get a free drop. Where's my best place? Yeah, my best grass not the gravel.

Yeah, it's not even that it's not even what they're playing off. Its I'm getting the ball in my hand and I get the basically almost place it where I want to. Place where I want to put it. Yeah, that's what they said control. That's what they're thinking. So, you know, and then when you say well, you'd be dropping in the bush, they go. Oh, that's not fair. All right, where you can play as lives. Oh, well, have two. So this is probably the most and

I'll be perfectly open here, the most attitude of ever had towards a player. Once I'm proud of it but I am human and on right 10 meters away from this very incident a situation we're talking about is the right hand side bunker on on 5 and right in the middle of that bunker was a drainage plastic drainage cap on top of the drain and the play was right in there, sitting on top of the plastic or metal. I didn't go in to touch it, but it was plastic or metal and he's ball was sitting on that and he's called me over and he says,

I can get for you and get free relief. I said I'll but I have to drop it, right? I said you have to drop it within the bunker as. Yeah, he's really upset on it's going to be on a downslope and lava and I said well you can always play it as it lies as well as he doing because you really upset and and almost a know what would they put that you actually I think he said something, why would they put it there? I've got to take a relief. Now in this downslope blah blah blah and so I thought you'll give me a bit of attitude here. Maybe not directly at me, but I could feel it because I

represented the rules of golf. You know why? And the course and the committee and I just said back to him with the tiniest bit of attitudes, is he? Well, you can play it as it lies, right? Anyway, that was all just been perfectly. I was probably the most attitude I've ever had towards apply and it wasn't really that much. But I did have a bit of bite in my voice. I think if yes, if you calling that attitude I think you're you're thinking over thinking it still, there might be, I was no no.

But I had a bit of an attitude when I was it, would stop complaining because you're still got the option of applying his little eyes. You don't have to drop it there at all. That's right. Well with that last 10 years probably that's enough for me I think I'm just gonna cover one because I think I got on TV for a couple that gonna get you to check but Patrick Reed on the third round, he hit his drive and a bit of lead.

Tape that he has on the back of the driver came off. It didn't cut, fully, come off it. It half came off, unstuck unstuck and he called me and said, can he replace it? I said, yes, that's permitted to be replaced and then he asked me if it Polly came off. Could he replace it? And it got lost going to replace it with new LED tape and I just wasn't certain.

So it wasn't a do-or-die. We need the answer right now situation. So I said I'll come back to you. I just do some research or come back to you. He played the whole out, the next hole is a par 3 so I knew I had a little bit of time. I did find the ruling before he started the past three, but I knew that I did have a little bit of time. I'm and firstly I got on the radio and said, hey guys are just got a situation about a club, I'll put it in our message system.

So like WhatsApp or messenger or whatever we have a message system of Team, I'll put it in the message system so you can read it and give me an answer. But in the same time, I went into my book and I have a look and lo and behold, there's a clarification Right? There about Led tape that states that you can you, if the piece of lead tape comes off, you can use new lid tape to put it on and that's fine.

Okay, now, You know. A lot of things can cross your mind. I'll, what if you put in too much lead table? Not enough would change the club if you think about the pros and I know who it was Patrick Reed. You think it, always trying to angle here but really, they don't want a different Club from what they've been hitting on the Range or what they've been heading or week. They he'd be trying to make sure it was exactly the same. Now, I know that that name suddenly Sparks up or he's

trying to A cheat. But there was nothing like that. He was just simply asking a question and it was all fine to just put the tape back down or if it did come off or he couldn't get it stuck back on. It could certainly put a new piece of tape on so that was that was basically the only one I wanted to talk with all the other one. Actually, I posted on YouTube was about a guy I denied and

free relief from this big rock because the big rock is a loose impediment. So a couple of the caddies got together. Move the rock down the hill and then he was fine to play it as it lies. Yeah. It was funny. I went into that situation. He's not such a nice guy that the player and he said, you know, what kind of do I get from Life know, you don't, but it is a loose impediment, the neck, the player. Another player said, I, we, we

can just move it then, can't we? And, you know, didn't spark my You know, sort of advice giving as what you've thought about with your situation but now it sort of does. But you know, I would have said the same thing. I said, well it's a loose impediment, you can move it. So it's not really advice influencing how to break the rules or play by the rules. It was immoral. It's a loose impairment. You're allowed to move it, so I'll be happy with that. But then they moved and managed

to get that on. On my own phone, not that I went up to encourage that that I was able to get these footage of their moving the rock, on my own phone. We will get into filing finished off this episode with G RQ. O TW 78. Go for it. Stuart episode 78. Here we go. See what I'm also applying a match at wombat Hills in the

first round of the wombat Hills Cup on the first hole. I'm sorry on the First Tee Ross asked Stuart what personal identification Mark. He has on his ball and student refuses to answer saying only I'm playing a structure this infuriates Ross who are Seguin insisting, Stewart, is required to answer when sure does, not reply, Ross. Request, a ruling from a nearby referee, what is that ruling? They're all disqualified. Right now you give me the answer

away. Sorry. Have a have a crack at the question. And we will see you for episode at 79 of the GU G RQ, o TW actually just before we leave. What do you got on this week? Stuart, are you going to the Vic open? I am not going to the Vic open. No, that's one of the best stories and Victoria and you're not even going to the vet and that's it. That's very nice. Very kind. Thank you. Have you got any windy next one next to me? Then hopefully some more PGA stuff coming up soon in the next

month or so. All right. So now I've got Oman this week guitar next week and then I'll be home. Fantastic safe, travels. Thank you very much. Yeah, listen out for 79 in the coming weeks. Thank you, everyone.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode