Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

YouTube Community Question Run-Down - THE GRQ PODCAST EP99

Sep 4, 202359 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

YouTube Community Question Run-Down - THE GRQ PODCAST EP99 GRQOTW98 Answer: Sharon played from a wrong place that was also a serious breach, as they should have taken stroke-and-distance for their ball out of bounds. They failed to fix their mistake in time and therefore the only penalty for them is disqualification. Podcast and Marcela go through the last five Community Questions on YouTube. GRQOTW 99 During an individual stroke round, Stuart's ball lies in a greenside bunker on the 17th hole at Wombat Hills. He makes a stroke and the ball flies right over the green and into a red penalty area behind the hole. In frustration, he calls out, "what am I doing wrong?" Blakey standing nearby, says, "Mate, you need to take more sand during the shot." Stuart then rakes the bunker. After considering his penalty area relief options, Stuart decides to proceed under stroke and distance and drop in the same bunker that he just played from, which he does. Are there any penalty strokes to either player?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

With Blakey still away on tour, Stewart and Marcella look after episode 99, Stewart taking a little bit too long to answer Giq OTW 98. Then they get into the last five community questions with explanations and what percentage were correct and incorrect. They finally finished off with a GIQ OTW 99. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Stewart's one of our highest ranked working rules officials that we have one of the best

we've got and he knows he's hello and welcome to the Golf Rules Christians Podcast Episode #99. We are getting very, very close to that fantastic achievement for the podcast of episode #100. My name is Stewart McPhee no Blakey again that this week he is overseas in the United Kingdom working for the Asian Tour is giving me permission to just do one more podcast without him in the driver's seat. Well, I'm joined again today by a friend of the podcast,

Marcella Smith from The Girlfriend's Guide to Golf. Marcella. Welcome back. Thank you. Nice to be back. I guess Blakey must have approved when he looked at our little video when he was on tour and thought I was. I don't know about two thumbs up, but maybe one thumb up, I don't know. Let's go with 1 1/2, Yeah, I think he was, I think he was OK with the product. Hopefully the listeners have tuned in again for another episode with you and I discussing all things rules of golf. So it's great to have you back.

Thank you very much for your time and helping us out again with the podcast again this week. Happy to be here. Well, we're going to turn right to you because we always start the podcast with the answer to last episode's golf rules question of the week, which Marcella as as a guest of ours last week we asked you to write that up, which you did. Do you have that handy please? Just to read out again to refresh people of that question please. Sure, that question was Sharon

and Nina are playing an individual stroke play tournament at the Santa Luz Club in San Diego. A beautiful place with two other competitors in there foursome. Sharon pulls her tee shot on the 8th hole. And thinks she'll find her ball in the bushes. After the other ladies tee off, Sharon starts looking for and finds her ball in about 90 seconds. Her ball is just beyond where a white obese steak is.

Not wanting to go all the way back to the tee, Sharon assumes she can use the model local rule E5 and drop a ball into the fairway for a 2 stroke penalty, which she does. The other ladies weren't aware that Sharon was found, that Sharon's ball was found out of bounds until Sharon casually mentioned it on the ninth tee. And that ninth tee is across a long St. and a great distance from the 8th hole. And at that time the other ladies informed Sharon that if

her ball was OB, she would not be allowed to drop it in the fairway as they do not have model local rule E5 there. At that course. So since Sharon didn't want to slow down play for the group behind her, she said she'd just taken 8 on the whole and move on. So what's the ruling? I think Sharon might be in some trouble and we can just sort of narrow down to the what has she done wrong? Well, easy. E5 wasn't available, but even if it was, you know, she could come

out. But let's say it's not available. What option does she have available to her when her ball has been found out of bounds? As we know, if your ball is lost or out of bounds, you are limited to one option and one only, and I believe it's your favorite option for the unplayable ball. It's the same option, right? So that's your only option under that she didn't play Provisionable, as you mentioned, model local rule E5 was not available. Her only option was to proceed under stroke and distance and

return to the team area and make another stroke, which would have been of course her third, third stroke when she dropped in the fairway. She has, for all intents and purposes, under rule 14.4, she has put a ball into play and she's continued play that ball from that spot. The only problem is by putting that ball into play she's played and making a stroke at it she's played from a wrong place. Then we need to determine whether that playing from a wrong place is a serious breach or not, because people play from

wrong places all the time, but they're not disqualified if they begin play the next hole because it wasn't a serious breach. The problem with Sharon is the only place she was supposed to play that ball from was back at the team area, and so the committee would definitely rule by dropping one in the fairway however many yards in front. She has gone to significant advantage by dropping a ball there playing from a wrong place, and we know that if that is not corrected before beginning a stroke to begin the next hole, or if it's the last hole around returning a scorecard, that results in,

unfortunately, Sharon, only one thing, and I think you're on the same page with me here, Marcella, what is that one thing that Sharon's facing? Yeah, the big DQ, the big DQ. No one likes DQ against their score. I don't think. Yeah, that's the qualification every day of the week. Yes, and that that. Serious breach is if they have a significant advantage by playing from the wrong place, and it could be because it's significantly closer to the hole, or it could be because it

no longer is behind a tree, or in super thick rough or in the middle of a Bush, or something that's drastically different. It's a significant advantage to where their ball should have been, where the right place was. Then it is considered a serious breach and that's where they do have to correct it. And that's in stroke play, yes, but on And the interesting thing about 14.7 and serious breach or not is there is no distance

provided, and what you have just done is provided some really good examples of where in fact playing from the wrong place may be further away from the hole from where you should be playing from, but it could still be considered a serious breach because it's the significant. The exact same or further away, but still if the committee would need to determine, and it's absolutely up to the discretion of the committee to determine whether that player going to significant advantage or not. And all those examples you mentioned are perfectly valid.

You know what was the condition like to get distance for one moment? What was that player facing by playing from there compared to where they are now? And I remember digressing a little. I remember Lydia Coe not so long ago, thinking preferred lies was in place and three holes in a row in the middle of the fairway, lifted her ball, placed it somewhere else very close and made a stroke. And on the 4th occasion asked the question, Someone brought it to her attention she'd already lifted it and was about to place it, and they said no, no, no. Preferred Lies has not been in place, so she's played from a

wrong place, three holes in a row. But that was OK. There was no disqualification because there was no serious breach. Yeah, that's definitely up to the committee. And as we know, under 14.7 there's even an opportunity for the player, if they are not sure on the spot whether that is a serious breach or not, whether the committee would deem that a serious breach or not. They can play a second ball in stroke play and again let the committee work that out. Yeah, Sharon knew that she should go back.

But she also knew that going back is such a long distance. This is a really long distance to get back to that spot and or the T on the 8th hole. And she knew it would slow people down. So in her mind, she's like, oh, my maximum's like A7, I'll take an 8 and we'll move on, right? OK, so do you know if it was a maximum score round or? No, it was just a stroke. Play metal. It was a stroke. OK, OK, definitely a stroke round. OK. Because as we know there are options if you are playing a

Stableford round or a par bogey or a maximum score that you can just at any time say just give me the maximum, you know the worst possible score for that format. So be 0 points in the Stableford, you know, minus in parole bogey or the maximum score for that hole that the committee have done. But if it's stroke, stroke, stroke, proper stroke, you need to hole out every hole. Yes, Sharon would clearly be disqualified as soon as she made a stroke to begin the next hole way over the road a long way

away with no intent to come back, Correct. Sharon hope she enjoyed the rest of the day after she was advised that she would be disqualified. OK, very good, very good question, please. And I know again Blakey keeps track of those people who have. So I don't have unfortunately right the second people who have responded to that question and that Blakey keeps track of of all that Okay. I have some community questions now as our listeners would know and hopefully they know on the YouTube channel, Blakey posts

regular community questions, you know, true or false and all mainly how many strokes and he'll provide a scenario and at the end how many strokes. So I was just going to for today's podcast, spend a bit of time going through some of those community questions and we can go through the responses and the reason why the answer is the answer. And interestingly for today, I actually had the inside, I have the percentage of responses that were correct and you may be

surprised by some of those percentages because some of the questions today, the percentage correct was less than 50%. So most people got some of these questions wrong. So we'll go through some of those if you're OK to join me with that. And we'll go through the questions and we can discuss the answers. Yes, you guys ask a lot of difficult questions. They're very layered, very light, yeah. And of course, and as we'll find out with one of them, in fact, where most responses were incorrect for a lot of people,

when you read the comments on YouTube, a lot of people just missed one item. And that's all it takes to get the wrong answer. And you know, you've done the USGA exam, I've done it. And you know, with all those exams questions, no good missing out on one item. But getting the rest of the scenario correct, you need to get it all correct. So that's what's happening in some of those. Excuse me. So does that bring up a bad memory of the USGA exam? Oh, it was, yeah. It's not a pretty day.

And when you take it online or I'm imagine in person too, but it's not a it's not a pretty day. It's very intense. And you have all your snacks and there's a Proctor there, so someone is watching you. You don't know who they are. You don't see them as well. But someone from, I believe, a testing company? Probably not even USGA. Not sure, but someone's watching you. And they're controlling your computer or prohibiting you from having opening anything else. And you literally are, you know, the 1st 50 questions are closed book and then 50 questions open book, which actually, in my

opinion are more difficult than the closed book. But you know, someone's watching you and you're eating your snacks and you're talking to yourself. In my case, I'm talking to myself. I'm yelling at myself. And you know you're you're look, you're watching the time and you're circling things and coming back to him and then you've got to get up to go to the restroom. And so it's just it's a very, it's uncomfortable and it's stressful and you know the time is ticking. But you're, you know, you try to focus through all of that and you may know the material.

And sometimes I feel like if you were my my instructor or giving the exam to me. Audio like verbally and you just asked the question. I could answer those questions. But when Now you put these paragraph formats with Susie and Mary and Johnny and all the things they did and you know, then they went to the store and they got on the bus and then they paid $0.50 so they got off the bus. I mean all these things that aren't necessarily relevant to a rule. Now my mind is gone woo woo woo.

And so it's yeah there. It's a it's a difficult time, but I'm looking forward to taking it again. Wow, that's very good. If you're doing it again, I think I'll do it again next year. Me. Too, you're already you've already got expert status, you're good. I just have advanced status, so I need thank you. Yeah, I think maybe for the challenge and I think it forced me to study like I really prepared and studied. So it it was really helpful in that sense. It provided me something to work towards. I will say two things I agree with you. I thought the closed book section was really quite

straightforward. There's a lot of definitions and I flew through the closed book section, the open book section. When I've got this big fat book to help me, I found far more difficult. You're just back and forth between so many multiple rules trying to work it out and my brain after four hours was post. It was fried. I was fried anyway. It's not fun, but that's how you can really respect people who have their certification from

the USGA because you know, not only do they know it, but they also know how to take a test. But you know our Blakey boy, he passed his and got, he got advanced certification, which is still very good at the age of 18. So yeah, very good. Not so long ago. Brilliant little boy. Very good. All right, well, we'll start with these community questions. This one is quite straightforward and not surprising. Most people got this correct.

These are in no particular order. I've just copied and pasted them from the YouTube community questions section. The first one is a hole. A hole made by a worm is not an animal hole. Which relief under rules 16.1 is available, but both the worm and the cast that it makes are loose impediments. So any hole dug by a worm is not an animal hole. And the way we answer this, firstly, if I went to the definition of animal, an animal is any living member of the

animal Kingdom, including other humans. Sorry, other than humans, right? Any living member of the animal Kingdom. So a worm is an animal. However, when we get to animal hole, any hole dug in the ground by an animal, except for holes dug by animals that are also defined as loose impediments, such as worms or insects. If we go to loose impediments, you know any unattached natural object, but it also includes worm, insects and similar

animals that can be removed easily and the mounds or webs they build such as worm, cars and ants. They're all loose impediments. So the answer to that question is true, but it really just highlights the importance of the definitions. It. It really does. And I remember early on someone saying all the definitions are so important, I'm going, yeah, but they're not even in the rules. They're like at the back, you know, they're not even rules. 1

to 34 at the time, 1 to 24 or whatever it might have been. Now, 1 to 25, it's like an appendix. Like it's at the end, like it's can't be that important. And then people really started to convince me that definitions are critical, paramount anyway. So that was the first question. Any comments on the definitions? Well, just like we talked about last week, we were talking about stroke. And practice swing and practice stroke. If if you're reading a rules question or someone is asking you a question or telling you a story and they're using the word

stroke, you're assuming they're using the definition. Or they say my ball moved. Well, did your ball move under the definition in the Rules of golf, or did it just move? In the definition of the, you know, Merriamwebster dictionary, right. So that's what's so important about it because you're like, yeah, I know what moved means. It moved. I saw it. Well, different story under the rules of golf as to whether or not it moved. So yes, those, that's where anyone if you want to take your exam, whether it's the USGA or

something regional, you should start. Just read the definitions. In fact, you guys have a podcast. How dry? How dry is this? You hear you guys are alternating reading the definitions, but if you are going to be studying for your exam or you're trying to learn this stuff for your own game because you're a highlevel player or a caddy or a club pro, it's a perfect thing to listen to when you're driving in your car. You're going to read it at home. Probably not.

You're going to be distracted by life right when you get off work and you go home. But if you're driving somewhere and you've got 20 minutes, yeah, you want to listen to that podcast because you guys are reading it and it's just where else in the world are you going to get that info? And you you hear it a couple of times, you're like, oh, OK, I got it. There's a distinction here on this. So yeah, it's it's helpful for for the rules geeks or the rules nerds of the world. I had completely forgotten about those two podcasts where we read

through the entire group of, I think there's about 74 of them, all the definitions and we alternated as you mentioned and I had completely forgotten and I'll dob him in here. I think soon as we stopped recording, Blakey said something like so close to falling asleep doing that podcast. Yes, it was dry. But you spot on. If you are going to take this to the next level and do exams and want to officiate, the definitions are, I won't say

everything, but they are close. They are so critical. And there's very few sentences in the rules of golf that do not have a defined word in that sentence. That's they make up. They're the glue. They make up the rules. You know, every sentence always refers to something in a definition. Yeah, they're everything. So that question really just came down. Even if you didn't know, you could quite easily find the answer and the answer was in fact the answers or the answer was to be found in the definition is nowhere else. It wasn't even the rules of

gold, but was in the definition so to speak. OK, so not surprisingly 81% got that response, got that answer question correct. And that is of all the ones I have today, that is in fact the highest percentage correct. OK, the next one. So this is a how many strokes scenario. These are the ones you like. Marcella when the players stop halfway around and go and grab a chocolate bar and and tried to distract you with the question and and they did something with their clubs and then you know is

that a penalty on anyway. On the 1st hole at Wombat Hills Fantastic Golf Club. On the 1st hole at Wombat Hills Stewart's ball is lying on a cart path in the general area. After his tee shot, he decides that he wants to take free relief as per rule 16.1. Because he has interference from the immovable obstruction for a reasonable stroke, he works at his nearest point of complete relief and then he lifts his

ball from the course without marking the original spot. He drops another ball within one clip club length of his nearest point of complete relief, no nearer the hole, and the ball comes to rest inside that club length. He takes four more strokes to hold out, and the question was simply how many strokes for that particular situation for? Was it me? Yes, for me, playing that hole, the 1st hole. Marcella. Do you know the answer to that? Yes, that's five, that is five.

So what about so taking relief from the car path, that's OK, that's for free doesn't cost you anything. And I think where people got this wrong and I'll tell you now 65% got this correct, 65. So let's say the other way, 35% more than 1/3 got this incorrect, and I think the most common misunderstanding here was the requirement, or I should say no requirement, to in fact mark the spot of the original ball

before you lift it to take free relief from that immovable obstruction. Do you think that would be a common misunderstanding? People thinking you have to mark that spot before you lift it? It's funny because it's it's kind of the opposite. So many people don't realize you need to mark the spot when you're lifting your ball to identify it, right? So many people think you don't have to do that, but yet they do think you have to mark it when you're going to take relief from something. So it's it's funny that they have many people have the complete opposite understanding. Yeah, it's and I remember one

line in the rules, it must be under 14.1. Where whenever you are required to replace the ball and replace means exactly the same spot. Whenever you are required to replace the ball, you must mark it first. You must not suggested must including on the putting green. If you are lifting it and putting it back on exact, you mark it first. Everyone knows that. But around the course, like you said, if you're lifting to identify, I have seen that myself where they just lift half

an inch off the grand one cinema they lifted up rotated to see there, there it is and just put it straight back again. You think there is no harm in doing that. They haven't moved it, it's back where it was. They haven't gotten any advantage, but they haven't followed correct procedure as you said, and they haven't marked it first and that would incur a penalty if my understanding of the rules is correct understanding. Of the rules is correct. So you know it's interesting

that I do see it a lot people taking relief they'll put now I don't think that's a bad thing. I think it is a good habit because if you're distracted hey I'm still looking for my ball and off you run to help someone else and come back and go where was now we know best estimate is OK if not known but it is a good habit to go well there it was. I have seen people mark the nearest point of complete relief first before then lifting the ball as a habit, but again, there's no requirement to mark.

Yes, and that's. What I do is I'll mark that nearest point of complete relief where my you know, where I'm basically using the club I would be using for the shot and when I teach the rules on the course, that's what I recommend that they do. And always saying is this is not required, it's more of a should, it's not a must. But it's a good idea to do that and also if there's anyone around you maybe that doesn't know the rules as well. If you're if you're in a tournament and you're marking out that one club length or two club lengths, depending on what

kind of relief you're taking, if you're marking it out, then it it's kind of clear to everyone. And again, not required. Not required on the PGA Tour either. And not required during a tournament. It's just a good idea so that people don't get stressed. And I'm all about avoid the appearance of impropriety, avoid the stress, avoid people being uncomfortable or having a weird feeling or thinking that you did something wrong. But you only have time to do that if you're efficient the

rest of the time, as we talked about that last week. So you can't, you know, take forever to measure this thing out when you're chatting away the whole time. So be efficient with it. But I I think it's a good idea to market. I I think that's a great point and This is why I turn to you often because you're the one doing your clinics, you're out on course, you have people standing around you, you're in a bunker, you're on the green and you're going through all these mechanics and procedures. I think that's a great point you make about why provide anybody the opportunity to have any inkling that you are doing

something wrong until you create that tension or stress. And if you go through that procedure of marking out two club lengths nearest .1 club length, even though the rules don't, you don't have to. But why not for your own benefit and for everybody looking on going he or she, that they know what they're doing. I can see that I'm not going to have any doubts from now. And they can. They're clearly comfortable taking relief following the procedures. They know what they're doing. Yeah. And I think there's any kind of a slope because it's going to probably run out.

And you do want to make sure sometimes you think it ran out of the relief area, but maybe it still is in the relief here because you just estimated or eyeballed it. Maybe it's still in the relief area, so you really shouldn't be taking another drop because it it you think it rolled outside. So I think any kind of a slope or strain sort of terrain, I think it's really a good idea for that as well. And one thing regarding that, I think a lot of people are under the misunderstanding that. If you are taking relief, for example lateral relief for a red penalty area and it is sloping

towards the water, that when you take that drop you're not allowed to stop it from going into the water going past that red line again and you are allowed to stop it as long as it's clearly obvious. That it, it's going to continue rolling, then you can stop, you know your ball in motion so to speak, when clearly it's going to just take off and exceed where it's supposed to come to rest and then you can cuz obviously you don't want to waste too.

Nice new Golf balls just taking free relief. I'm sorry, penalty relief for a for a penalty area. I've done that myself and had someone question me that on that I I had my driver out to measure the two club lanes, then laid it down on the red line knowing the ball was going to roll that way. Stopped it twice and someone said you can't stop it. I said, well it's obvious where the ball is hitting, it's hitting anyway. You spot on. There's no issue with that. If it's obvious, as you say

that, that that's exactly where the ball is going, do you think? That Blakey, you know, I know he doesn't compete a lot anymore because he's out officiating all over the world, but. Do you think he would do something just for fun? Do you think he would during a tournament, a fun tournament, Nothing too serious. Do something for fun to get a rise out of people around him that is that looks controversial or looks like most people think, oh, you can't do that. And just to get a ride, I mean, don't you think that's his

personality, that he would do that for fun? I must take some credit as well. I do that a lot myself to get it right. Absolutely I do because it's fun and I did it. I had a conversation just last when. Yes, I think, sorry to answer your question, I've played with him, you know, maybe 5-6 times. I think he's beaten me in that match every single time. He, yeah, he, he would definitely do that. And he's, you know, kicking his partner to make a stroke, you know, he's kicking with his foot, that's his stroke.

You know, just doing, is that allowed? He's saying he's putting everyone on the spot. And definitely, I'll tell you one thing I did last week was we have preferred lies. So we're just about to come out of winter, winter And so, you know, slightly sloppy, muddy conditions. We have preferred lies and the relief area is simply 1 handspan. And so my balls lying there and I'm about to take relief. And So what I do is I grab a second ball and place it, you know, within 6 inches of my ball in play and I just put it there.

And then I called someone, I said he was standing very close. I didn't make too much of an effort for him. I said is this OK? And he was very confused. I said, well, I've just put that other ball down. And one other person who thinks I know the rules very well says yes, you you can do that. You can use another ball as a ball marker for your ball in play. I said, well, it's not a ball marker because it's 6 inches away, right? And a ball marker needs to be right next to it. So it's not a ball marker. I said no, that's my ball in play. And he said, well, you can't do because it just looks odd, you

know, having not marking it, lifting it and putting it somewhere else even though you don't need to mark it, but having 2 balls right next to each other that are both mine. And so the guy said, no, you can't do that. And I just went through or if you're taking relief on any rule anywhere on the course, you can use another boy. He said, no, you've got to use the same ball, the whole hole. I said, well, I'm going to put my life on it. And he goes, oh, he goes, oh, that's right. You know the rules. Yeah, OK. But to him, it just looked someone else.

I said. And you know, with my club, I actually tapped my original ball, actually tapped it back to my bag. I didn't make a stroke. I literally just tapped it back. I said that's now wrong ball as I'm explaining it all to him, getting all very nerdy. But I do it. I play with the club captain often, you know, really good rules, knowledge. Not not as active anymore, but and I'll do a few things and ask him and we, we have a good laugh about it because it does put him on the spot for five seconds of whether I'm able to, you know,

proceed. So I think it's a lot of fun and while we out there on the golf course, we are not elite players. I'm out there for one thing and that's to enjoy myself. So some of these little things help me enjoy myself that little bit a little bit more. Yes, well and and I do a lot of that too. Not to get a rise, but just ask the question hey, can you do this, can you do that? Just to help and my friends appreciate it, Blakey and I played in Lake Tahoe in a Pro AM. One pro and four amateurs. And it was just such fun. And there was a little bit of

drinking during the round. And not by me, of course, but by everyone else and literally the. He had to go into. I have a video on it. He had to. He hit a ball into the water into a penalty area and he had already lost so many balls that day that he literally took his shoes off and went into the water to get to find a ball. And I'm not talking knee height, we're talking thigh height.

Got completely drenched to to get his ball and it's. It's a great video we we should show. It's hilarious. And yeah, he's a great competitor, but things happen. No one could spot him 5 or 10 bucks for another ball at the term. Anyway, that's we couldn't even better that it's on video. That's fantastic. Yeah. So we got 65% correct, Got that correct. That was the question of me and taking relief from the cart path and we digressed a little bit, which is good.

Talking about relief and procedures for that. This one, this was quite straightforward. The question was now this was true or false. You may have the flagstick left in or removed or attended for a stroke no matter where your ball is on the course. That was it. You may have the flagstick left in or removed or attended by someone else for a stroke no matter where your ball is on the course, and the answer to that is true. 80% got that correct. The rule says the plan may leave

the flagstick in the hole or have it removed, which includes having someone attend the flagstick and remove it after the ball is played, but must decide before making a stroke. There is normally no penalty if a ball in motion hits the flagstick. This rule applies to a ball play from anywhere on the course, whether or sorry, whether on or off. The putting green 80% got that correct? I made the comment on the YouTube channel just to reiterate because someone asked a question about something they weren't quite sure and I just

said whatever choice you make, you need to make it before you make your stroke. And then once you're you've made your stroke, you are stuck with that choice. And that's the just the two points and good rules of thumb to remember Make the choice before making the stroke, and once you make the stroke, you are stuck with that choice. No running up and trying to remove the flagstick when you had chosen to leave it in. So 80% got that correct. Marcella, any any stories from your clinics with the flagstick?

Just that Sometimes people are under the impression that you can only repair damage to the green. When your ball is on the green, if you see damage and you're going to chip up there, or you're very close to the green and you just run up and fix it, a lot of players are under the impression you can't make that repair to that damage until your ball is in the is on the green and that is not correct. So a lot of misunderstandings about when you can do things.

Yeah, I agree with that. I definitely see people who are just short of the green and there's they want to repair and they don't know whether they can or not. They will ask the question, but you're right. They assume it's not until you are on your ball is lying on the putting green that you can make those repairs, but you can make those repairs anytime and. And another little sort of golf wives tale is when a ball is in the hole, someone hold out. And the other players are under the impression that it's a

penalty if they hold out when that ball is sitting in the hole. Yeah, we had this sort of half intellectual conversation about a month ago in a little group chat that we are with, which Blakey is a part of. And we were talking about a ball in motion going into the hole and striking another ball at rest, which of course, in stroke plays a penalty. And so we're having that intellectual discussion of its hit another ball and that ball was at rest and it was on the putting green because the hole

is on the putting green. And so we don't want to nerd out too many people with that conversation. But you're right, it's like if the ball's there for pace of play, you know, the person might have holed out from the bunker and they're raking, they're they're excited and happy, but they're raking a bunker. They can not going to be able to retrieve that ball for another 4 minutes. Meanwhile you're all playing, goes in and hits that ball as you say. That's no problem, but as long as it doesn't hit that ball and bounce back out again then you'll be upset. Yes.

Well, not surprisingly, 80% got that correct. Not so successful with this. Next I knew. I just knew this question would trip people up. It's a simple question but not yeah it should be a simple answer, but question was your ball is just off a putting green. It's not the green you are playing to, it's not the green for the whole that you are playing your feet for a normal reasonable stroke. Your feet are standing on that putting green to make your next

stroke. And the question was simply you may play the ball as it lies and it was simply a true false. You may play the ball as it lies. Am I selling that particular green that we are standing on? But it's not the whole, not the green. For the whole that we are playing, what do we call that green? We call it a wrong green and it's interesting because it's that's a foreign concept. I I don't know why that is. But no one has ever heard of.

For many casual players have never heard of a wrong green. It it's probably because it's unusual. To end up with a ball on a wrong green, not the green for the hole that you're playing at the time and it's just no one's ever heard of. They're like, what is a wrong green? Yeah, so yeah, wrong green. You're not allowed to play from there, whether it's on it or it's your stance or air of intended swing or stance are on it. So you you must take relief from

it and I think that's where the confusion would have come in. The fact that the ball was you know I think clarifying the ball wasn't on. Yeah, the ball is just off it. So the ball is not on the wrong green. You are standing on it. But your ball and I knew that would trip people up and I've and I've seen this actually with a state level referee that they just got this confused that well the ball's not on the wrong green. You'll you'll find you're good to go. But I'm standing on it now that your ball's not on it. So I knew that would trip people up. I didn't think it would get such a low response.

In fact, 43% of people got that correct and we'll swap that around and say 57% for a true, false 50% got that wrong, clearly thinking that the ball was off, you're OK to play. Had they made that stroke with their, you know, stance on the green for a reasonable stroke, I think that might be a penalty coming their way. Marcella, what have they done wrong? It's a 2 stroke. It's a general penalty, 2 stroke penalty and stroke play. And they must take relief from it.

Yeah, they must, interestingly enough. And it does say for a reasonable stroke. So you can't be like really stretching the right foot out as far as you can, you know, to get one little toe on the green and go to a referee, look, my little toe is on the wrong green. Can I take relief, please, because the referee could easily deny you. Is reasonable stroke in the definitions. I don't think it is fact. I'm almost it's. Interesting because it it really, that really is such an important term and when I was

teaching recently in Tahoe and quite often the director of golf or some of the other golf pros at the club will attend, which is great because they see what I'm teaching their ladies so that they can back it up if. Questions arise later, but they also see and can get MSR credits for their continuing education credits with the PGA. So that's kind of cool. So they often join in. And I was teaching at a club and I was talking about this reasonable stroke where my ball

was on, well, my stance was on a cart path. But the ball was up against this huge boulder that was really an immovable obstruction, because it's not it. What couldn't reasonably have been moved, Even if Tiger and all of his fans were there to move it, it could not have been moved. So but it was a boulder and it literally was sitting up against the boulder. And I created that shot for myself so that I could explain

reasonable stroke, which just means that if you. Think you may be entitled to real free relief from an immovable obstruction, like a cart path. It must be a reasonable stroke. So if there were just grass there and no cart path, no immovable obstruction, and my ball were sitting up against this boulder, I had no shot to the right, to the left, really anywhere without an injury, right or breaking my club. There was no shot.

So it wasn't reasonable to think I was ever going to hit that. So therefore I am not entitled to free relief from that immovable obstruction, that cart path. So I'm teaching this and the director of golf's going, I've never heard of that. And you know, sometimes I hear people say that I go okay, Yeah, you never heard of it. He's like, no, but but really I've never ever ever heard of that. And what I read into him was that can't be true. You know he's been playing

forever and you know so it's interesting that the so many people haven't heard of concepts and or definitions that are really important And and if I'd love I mean this was sort of related to a reasonable stroke when you talked about this wrong Green. But I'd love for you guys to post a question, a tough one like this about reasonable stroke because everyone thinks if your stance is on that cart path automatic, you're entitled to free relief.

And it's not automatic. That's a that's a great point. And I think 1 the things that I was taught early on was if I was in that position with a player and they was saying I, I want free relief and I'm saying no, and they're going, oh, come on, why not? I would ask the question and I think you you mentioned this in your answer was in your comments were if that immovable obstruction was not there, if that abnormal course condition was not there, what would you do? And if they say, oh, I'll

probably have to take it unbliable or I'd be hitting it backwards, OK, there you go. So what whatever option you would be choosing, you wouldn't have interference from that abnormal course condition. So don't use that as an excuse. I wouldn't take that tone with the player, obviously, but that's the that's the issue that if that wasn't there, what would you do? And they're going well, I'd have to take it on playable. But here's your answer. It's not a reasonable stroke, no free relief, simple.

Anyway, that's a great point. Reasonable stroke, not in the definitions, but and again open to interpretation. Open to a referee on the spot and Blakey and I have had this conversation before when you have. A rules official, a referee who plays off a handicap, or I think you call like an index of like 25, so I wouldn't call them a great golfer. And they're officiating an elite amateur professional event. So one person's definition of a reasonable stroke may be different to that elite player

because the rules official is lucky to break 100, you know, so they had that different look. On what is reasonable, what a player can do, and I think I'm not saying that's automatically gonna be an issue, but I think it's very important for a rules official for a referee to keep that in the back of their mind. Yeah, I think that is really important. And and I think, you know, most most of the time we're dealing with you know, traditionally men who've been athletes for a long

time, they've been playing golf, you know, for 30 something years And and they have in their bag or in their skill set these unusual, you know, very hingy shots or an unusual stance or backwards and you know left-handed. You know, the all that stuff that they can probably execute fairly well. Whereas maybe a female doesn't have to be a female but someone who's newer to the sport and newer to anything handeye. I'm painting a picture of myself here. If if you can tell and so that

person can't reasonably hit it, you know, backwards, underhanded, left-handed, whatever, standing on one with one leg up the tree and you know it. Just it's that's not reasonable for them. So what What is the skill set of this person? And I also think, you know, as far as whether or not they can really hinge, if this is a woman who's a 38 handicap, she's just lucky to connect with the ball. And so to think that she's going to hit this real, I mean, I'm, I'm, I'm not being, I'm not

being rude, you know, But it's like we're happy to just be out there hitting the ball squarely. And so when you have to have such an unusual hinge or, you know, to try to do a flop shot or all these things, that's not reasonable to think she can do that. So sometimes whether or not she's got interference from a drain and sprinkler head, I think as a referee you can be a little more lenient knowing what that skill set is of that player. So it's it's a great point and for everyone that's listening

that is a PGA teaching pro and is sort of unofficially officiating right at their club, that's I think that's important. Very good. Thank you. So we'll get to the last community question. Again, how many strokes? This is one of the scenarios that people love and again you miss out on one, you're going to get the answer incorrect. And I can tell you now less than half got this correct. So the question was in stroke play, Tyson hits his ball on the par four 3rd hole into the rough

on the right side of the fairway in a similar spot to Marcella. He walks down and sees the ball. He thinks maybe his. But he cannot be certain. He lifts the ball and it turns out to be his, so he replaces it. He then hits his ball into a green side bunker. After grabbing his sixty degree 60 degree wedge, he walks into the bunker that his ball is in and prepares to play his next shot. He takes 2 practice swings,

touching the sand both times. He then hits his ball onto the green. Tie some parts with the flagstick left in the hole and holes adding two parts. How many strokes has Tyson made for the 3rd hole? Now I'm not going to put you on the spot and say, hey, did you count all that up? But what it will do is I think you have the answer anyway, don't you? You've gone through that question yourself. I I didn't count it right now, but I can tell you the two issues that come up, maybe there's more. But the two issues that should be coming up in people's heads

and the first one is lifting a ball without putting a mark down first, lifting a ball and play. And so he did that. That is a one stroke penalty and assuming he replaces it on the original spot, that's all it is, is a one stroke penalty. And then that making those practice wings in the bunker that touched the sand. So the question on that one is how many penalty strokes does he have? Is there a limit? Was there what we call an

intervening event which did just change a little bit more in 2023? So can you explain the intervening event and when that is at 1.3 where you where you know what your limit or your maximum penalty for something can be? Yeah. So, yes, you're right. So in 2023, they introduced this concept called intervening events. And I've had a lot of discussion with people, again with Blakey and others about this in the last month, trying to clarify a lot of issues that I probably the ruling bodies didn't even

think about. So there's two intervening events. One is completion of a stroke. Sorry, I should go back. One, we used to call these related and unrelated acts. So if you committed a whole bunch of. You know, possible breaches, if they're all sort of related and tied in, you know, sort of lifting a ball and putting it somewhere else, wasn't three stroke penalty, it was only two. It was playing from the wrong place. Because though we're related and so they've ditched those terms and they've come up with intervening events and intervening events simply separate breaches. So it allows you to, if you

commit 10 different breaches, but you do the first four without an intervening event in there somewhere, then you only take the maximum of those four. You don't add them up. So the intervening events are completion of a stroke, and the second one is being aware or becoming aware of a breach, including if you are uncertain whether you're breached the rule or not. So that uncertain bit almost provides blanket coverage. But in this particular case, let's say Tyson had no idea, but you spot on about the marking

the ball. By the way, for identification, that's clearly A1 strike penalty. And the second one was brushing the sand with two practice strokes. Was there an intervening event in between that particular, you know, those two swings, You were playing the hole as well. If Tyson made that practice wing, brushing the sand and you saw that and go, you can't do that. That's a breach of the rule. You can't brush the sand in a practice swing. And then he did it again. Now we're looking at 2 separate penalties for those two situations.

Because in the middle, the player became aware, was told of the breach. Even if they didn't know, they are still uncertain whether they've committed a breach. That thing that's an intervening event. So now you're looking at two general penalties. As the question was written, that was at a swing brush of the sand. Another swing. That's really just one. Well, that is one general penalty for those two actions. Spot on. Yeah, we could spend a whole podcast on intervening events. That's a new concept. It has provided its fair share

of confusion, but that's it. Completion of a stroke or being aware or becoming aware of a breach, Yes. And so that ball that in stroke play Tyson, by the way, is Tyson a real person? I believe all these names are real people. Yes, I most of them have been and I know many of them that you use a lot. Roscoe and. But I don't know Tyson. Is he cute? I've never met no comment. I've never met Big P and Andy, the average golfer. Yeah, I don't know. Most of them.

Big Pi need to know. Yeah, can they all DM me please? I just need to know I need to put a face with the name. Yeah, so this we're playing stroke play and he lifts the ball. So if he lifts a ball and he's again stroke play, he's lifting a ball, it's my ball. He lifts and goes, oh, that's Marcella's ball, he puts it back. There's no penalty for that Okay, That's so strange. If we were playing in match play

because I'm his opponent and he lifts my ball, there is a penalty for that okay. But he even we're playing in stroke play, It was my ball, no penalty, but it because it was his ball, there was a penalty and it's just so I mean again, if you put that one out alone, just the fact that he lifted it, he didn't mark it and he replaced it, turns out it wasn't his ball, it was my ball. You just throw that one little fact out, you're going to get less than 50% people saying that's correct. I'll take that to another, I'll

take it to one more level and that is if Tyson and Marcelo were playing and we're looking for your looking for both, looking for, searching for both balls. And Tyson says to you, Marcella, I think this is yours here. Do you want me to check for you? Do you want me to see if it's got your pink markings? Sorry to stereotype whatever your ball marking is. Wait, why? Why would you be stereotyping me? There you go. So if Tyson says to you,

Marcella, I think this is your ball, do you want me to check for you and you go, yeah, please do. And then they lift it for identification without marking it. Guess who's getting a penalty? Marcella, Because they've acted. That player has acted with your authority. And so effectively, anything they do with your authority, the breach goes back to the player. Had Tyson not said anything, as you just mentioned, and just lifted it up and he's going feel that wasn't my ball. No penalty puts it back. Marcella, your ball's here.

Thank you. No penalty. If it was his, then damn, I should have marked it first. But if they did it with your authority, and that's probably something else a lot of people don't know about. You know, certainly with marking procedural things, you know, people can get your authority to do something for you. An example is on the green. You've hit out from a bunker. It's in the way of everybody else's. And this can be another podcast as well. That and you, I call that Marcella, You, your ball's in the way. Can we just mark it for you or something like that? And you say, yes, please do

that. There's all sorts of rules associated with that. It's now you know, it's now out of play. If we put it somewhere else. It's a wrong ball, not at wrong place and all those sorts of things. And it's anyway just comes back to acting with someone's authority. You know what? And I sure do miss Blakey, because if he were here he would have some one liners just about this whole topic of what we're discussing right now about why you shouldn't be lifting another player's ball without permission, blah blah blah blah. We know he'd have some some good

ones there and yes I'm. Sure he would miss you, Blakey. Of course. Well, we know Episode 100 is next, and we know that it's only fitting that he is front and Center for Episode 100. So whenever that happens, I hope I get an invite. I hope I'm invited along for to give 30 seconds worth of content. Yes, we do miss him and I hope he's. I'm sure I chat to him every day, so I'm sure he's having a great time, but I know he's having a great time.

Where he is still not home for another week or two. But yes, we do miss him and it is his podcast that he has like a reunion party with Big P and Andy and Tyson. Then I get to meet them all. It's Helen and Charlotte. There's a few other people there that we use in the rules questions, Yeah. So no surprise there, 48% got that correct I think probably. Again, it would have come back to the marking at first to identify probably caught people

out. That's one stroke. But if we know in a USGA exam, that's enough, that's incorrect. You know, you need to be able to know every single thing that's happening in that scenario to make a ruling to help that player out. So, OK, well, I'm going to get to in just a moment, the golf rules question of the week for episode 99 before we do that. Marcella, do you have any? Anything else you'd like to talk about or any other comments? I would just like to the next time we're together. I'd love to spend a few minutes on wrong ball and how it's so

interesting in match play. There are some little nuances about timing. One is discovered. If two people both play a wrong ball, it's kind of twisty, turvy, and I and I and I like it. And I think that that would be a fun thing for you to do a community question on and and then also discuss in detail because that one is, again that that's a doozy. There's so many that people can actually do what I do, which is work the six, the circuit and at a bar.

Basically, you go to a bar at a great club like Pebble Beach or Pinehurst and you just start chatting and say that you love the rules and then start making bets and then the $20 bills are just flying. This. We could do this for a living Stew. Really. OK. Oh, yeah. It's a great way to make extra cash. Pays for your dinner. It's good. I had never thought about that, but I certainly will. Now that you've brought it to my attention, what a good idea. We can discuss that off air.

We'll we'll stop recording and we can chat about that further. Well, my salary should. You know what, I'll do the golf rules question of the week and then I'll do my wrap up and say thank you to you. So this is the golf rules question of the week for episode #99. During an individual stroke round, Stewart's ball lies in a greenside bunker on the 17th hole at Wombat Hills. I'm very I'm just not that good. In bunkers. He makes a stroke and the ball fly.

I just skinny it. Ball flies right over the green well back into a red penalty area behind the hole. In frustration, I yell out, what am I doing wrong? Blakey, standing nearby, says, Mate, you need to take more sand during the shot. Stewart then Rakes the bunker. After considering his penalty area relief options, Stuart decides to proceed under stroke and distance and drop back in the same bunker that he just played, from which he does.

Are there any penalty strokes to either player? That's a good one. There is a hint there is at least one penalty stroke. There's there's penalty strokes coming. That's all I'll say. So don't give me, don't give the answer of no, It's all good and zero. There is definitely some penalty strokes there. So thank you. I just wrote that up before reflecting my wonderful sand game, my wonderful bunker game. So as always, if you want to have a crack at that question, please let Blakey know through

the usual way, through YouTube, message him and get an answer in for that golf rules question of the week. And Marcella, I won't put you on the spot and get you to answer that. Because we want obviously the fans to chip in and answer that question. Well, I will wrap up by saying, Marcella, what a pleasure. Thank you so much for joining me for these last two podcasts. In Blakey's absence, I'm going to put forward an argument he can definitely come back for 100. Maybe you and I should do 101 and we'll see what he says.

There's still so much content. We have a lot to talk about, so I think I'm definitely inviting myself back. I'll invite myself over to dinner anytime, and I'll invite myself back on your podcast for sure. Very good. Well, it's been an absolute pleasure to have you along. So thank you very much for spending some time joining us on this podcast. It's been great. For everyone else, thank you very much for your time and listening in or watching in on YouTube. It's been great to have your company and I'm very, very excited. About looking forward to episode #100 when Blakey is back.

Looking forward to that and we'll speak to you then. Thanks very much.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode