GUEST: Tim Murphy - Rules expert, and frequent TGRS contributor speaks with Stuart about his Rules journey. And make sure to listen to the end for Tim's GRQOTW - THE GRQ PODCAST EP110
GUEST: Tim Murphy - Rules expert, and frequent TGRS contributor speaks with Stuart about his Rules journey. And make sure to listen to the end for Tim's GRQOTW - THE GRQ PODCAST EP110 We also have merchandise that you can purchase so that you are representing the best Golf Rules podcast in the world. Grab a t-shirt, a hat, or even a hoodie featuring the Rules Roo, or the Wombat caddie.And now whether you are in your car, or going for a walk, or just taking a break after mowing your lawn.Enjoy this episode of the GolfRules Questions Podcast.GRQOTW109:Danni scored a six as the ball dropped was incorrect, but she was lucky enough to have found her original ball within the three minutes, and as per Rule 14.5, she continues with her original ball.Tim MurphyWorking with the Wisconsin State Golf Association.His favourite round at Erin Hills playing alongside the person he believes is the best Rules educator on the planet.Going to the USGA Referee school, and hearing Stephen Cox's little nugget of advice - 'The players do not care how much you know the Rules'.The amazing resource of The Golf Rules Samaritan that Fraser Nicol has produced.GRQOTW 1010:Barney the B Grade golfer hits his approach shot into a green side bunker on the short 15th hole of the very prestigious golf club at Wombat Hills. The ball is in the middle of a large collection of temporary water in the middle of the bunker. As the only relief area in the bunker would put the ball in a very difficult position on a slope, Barney decides to take BOL relief outside of the bunker. After making this decision, Barney walks into the bunker to retrieve his ball. In doing so, he creates footprints. Barney retrieves a rake and smooths the footprints, and then correctly drops his ball outside the bunker…but instead of using BOL relief, he has changed his mind and has now taken S&D relief, from a distance fairly close to where BOL relief would have put him. Before playing his shot, Barney notices that the raked footprints are in his line of play for the short shot over the bunker to the hole that was a mere 6 feet onto the front of the green. After playing his shot, how many total penalty strokes has Barney incurred?GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
For episode 110 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast we have a real treat. Mr. Tim Murphy, all the way from Little old United States of America, joins Stuart Nott Podcast McPhee to chat about his journey with the rules of golf, where it all started, how he became an expert, the brilliant mentors he has had along the way, and the great community of people that keep him entertained. Educated on a daily basis. Tim also has a couple of rules he would like to see updated, or at least give us some help with the clarification. And of course, as the guest, Tim
has brought his own GRQOTW, so listen all the way to hear that doozy. But just before we get into that episode, I want to encourage you that if you like these podcasts, please share it with a friend or two, send them a link, and get them listening. As well as the podcast, Stuart and Blakey also produced The Drop Zone, which is a weekly rules newsletter that gives you some helpful hints, a few rules questions and there is usually a funny video to keep you entertained and educated. So send us your e-mail address if you have yet to sign up. And when you receive the
newsletter, make sure to forward that on to your captain or manager at your club. They are free to distribute it to all of their club members. We also have merchandise that you can purchase so that you are representing the best golf rules podcast in the world. Grab AT shirt, a hat, or even a hoodie featuring the rules Roux or the wombat caddy. And now, whether you're in your car or going for a walk or just taking a break after mowing your lawn, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Stuart's one of our highest
ranked working rules officials that we have one, one of the best we've got and he knows he's. Hello everyone and welcome to episode 110 One One Zero of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. My name is Stuart McPhee. Others try to force other names onto me, but I like Stuart so we can go with Stuart today. I'm on my own today. Blakey has not joined me today, but what I'm going to do is have a great interview with a very, very experienced person in the
rules of golf and also golf in general, and I'm looking forward to very much having that chat with him. I'm joined today by a gentleman whose name is Tim Murphy. Tim, welcome to the Golf Rules Presence Podcast. It is great to have you with us. Thanks Stuart. And I'm I may have a tendency to call you podcast based on historical info, but I'll just stick with Stuart. You know, Blakey Blakey will be thrilled to hear that when he does he the introduction to this episode.
So it's great to have your company. Thank you very much for joining us and thank you also to everybody around the world who I know listens into this podcast and also on YouTube team. We will get to the Golf Rules question of the week from last week's episode before which I'll read out in just a moment. But before we do, that you have an extraordinary amount of experience in the game of golf starting at a very young age through to now both playing and cutting and obviously running tournaments. And as a rules official, would you mind just sharing with us a
little bit about your experience, please? Yeah, I in short, I'm just a golf nut. Stewart. I was introduced to the game at a very young age by my father at age 10, and I was fortunate enough. In our little hometown of Lacrosse, Wisconsin. We had a club that allowed access to junior players six days a week where we could. One day we had to play with the parent for those other five days we could go out as kids and play, and that's what we did. And we didn't have a practice range.
So we we we many days played 36 holes. I started cadding at the age 10. The rates at that time were $2.75 for a single and if we were lucky enough to get a double we got 375. And you add a quarter tip to that and it took, it took a lot of a lot of bags to to bank some money. At the end of the day, I grew up playing the game, played it a lot, loved it. And as I got into my working career, obviously the plane
became much, much less, moved around quite a bit. So I got to see a lot of different golf courses in my home state of Wisconsin, but as well as Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina and and Florida was able to teach my son the game. He became an accomplished player, a collegiate player. He played in the USA and with the first two days with Ricky Fowler when Ricky was a a senior in high school. So that that's always a fun moment. I never was a great player but I
I had moments of brilliance and I qualified for the US mid AM one year and then and then after I retired I qualified for the US senior AM. My claim to fame in both of those. I did not make match play in either one of those events, but but at least I qualified and I was the oldest qualifier participant in the qualifying round, so I felt taken on the young bucks. In both of those cases was was a lot of fun. I retired from John Deere in 2019 and that's when I really
started devoting more of my time to rules officiating versus versus playing. I got introduced earlier on when I had a good stint back in Wisconsin for about 13 years and and was very much involved with the Wisconsin State Golf Association and and really cut my started to cut my teeth and and rules there and then now with the with the North Carolina excuse me with the Carolinas Golf Association which is based in in pioneers but they have responsibility for both North and South Carolina two really great organizations very very
very professionally run and I'm fortunate to be involved with both of those. I've I've I'm going to pass on the game to my grandkids. I have my my 3 grandsons all under the age of nine. They have they've purchased them their clubs. My granddaughter turns 5 in in in next year and she'll get her set of clubs then and we'll just see my granddaughter does a better my my daughter had a great swing she had a better swing than my son and he never
took up the game. So maybe I'll have better luck with my granddaughter. Well, thank you, Tim. That's great. Thank you very much for sharing that story about your, you know, incredible journey in golf and doing all those different things and now still, of course, playing a very, very active role still. Well, as with our episodes of the Golf Rules Questions podcast, we always have our golf rules question of the week. And Tim, I've asked you to respond to last week's question and I'll just read it out for everybody. Danny, the D Grey golfer hits her tee shot way left into thick
bushes on a four 10th hole at Wombat Hills. After one minute of searching, she finds and identifies her ball and decides to take unplayable ball relief. Unable to retrieve her original ball, she drops another ball correctly in the lateral relief area. As she is working through her yardage book and waiting for others to play, a child crawls under the Bush and retrieves her ball. The child asks the caddy if he
can keep the ball. When the caddy realizes it's not Danny the Degrade's golfer's ball at all, the caddy advises Danny and they continue searching for her ball, finding it about one minute later. However, unfortunately, 5 minutes have now passed since she began searching originally for that ball. She picks up the drop ball and and continues play with the original ball holding out in five more strokes. She Tees off on her next hole. What is her whole score for the 14th hole tip?
Well, that's a that's that's a good one. And this is going to be a great example of where the rules can be your friend and not necessarily always your detriment. Danny has dropped under an inapplicable rule in taking a relief under 19.2 C, because when you take unplayable ball relief either laterally or back on the line, you must know the position of the ball. The only relief she couldn't have taken for unplayable would have been 19.2 A, which is stroke and distance. So she did not know where her ball was and took a drop, and
that's going to be a problem. But she's not yet played that ball, so rule 14-5 A is going to be her saving grace in that she's allowed to correct that mistake once that other ball was found. She's got that ball on the ground. Now she's got 2 balls. She would act appropriately and and picking up that ball that she dropped. Continuing with good fortunate rules, she originally searched for one minute and in the definition of lost and I'm quoting here, if the search
begins and is then temporarily interrupted for a good reason, like when the player has mistakenly identified the wrong ball, the time between the interruption and when the search resumes does not count. So all that time that accumulated up to 5 minutes does not count. So the only time that counts is the one minute before and the one minute after. That's under the three minutes. So that original ball is now in play. So she's had the one stroke, she's had the additional 5 strokes, She's had no penalty stroke. So her score for the whole is going to be 6.
And then fortunately for her or for the for the young child that found the ball, Danny signed her glove and and gave it to her and everybody was happy at Wombat Hills. Very happy place at Wombat Hills. You know, it's interesting you talk about the rules being your friend. Like you know, I deliberately wrote that question saying she she identified her ball and you feel like but she hasn't there should be some penalty. She's done something wrong. Imagine a referee there saying before you take unplayable, can you just make, can you just
confirm for me that's your ball and the player goes, yeah, yeah, that's that's my ball and she's done that and she's done that incorrectly. You feel like, yeah, she's your rules are a friend. I mean, obviously you your answer is correct. And it's just like, wow, she's getting away with something there. And I obviously threw in the 5 minutes hoping that would lead people to think, oh, I think she's in trouble now and and then of course I added at the end, she Tees off on the next hole, which of course brings in to people's minds eyes. She hit a wrong wall. You know, it's a disqualification on the table, which that's why I put that into
the question. But you're right, that 14.5, you know, what's that general principle that you are stuck with what you got right. But she didn't get a lot right, so she wasn't really stuck, was she? No, no, she she was fortunate. Very, very fortunate. Terrific. Thanks Tim. Well, you know, back to your introduction and you talked about starting in the game at a very young age, earning a very small tip, which I assume at the time was fantastic. The quarter tip, you mentioned it a little bit in your
introduction. I'd like to just delve a little bit more into this. You know, you started playing at a very young age. You're clearly an elite golfer without being professional. In the amateur game, you can obviously play very, very well at a very high level. You've played a lot of golf. Was it in the early days? The rules were just secondary, They were just an inconvenience at times, or just something you weren't that interested in because you knew enough to get by? I mean, what sparked that initial interest in the rules when you were playing as often as you were?
Well, I think the answer to the first question is, is pretty much going to be the same for any any amateur that plays a lot of golf and is that you, you know the fundamentals, you know how to take a drop with the exception of back on the line. I've seen some very elite amateur players not understand what that is. But you know how to take a drop out of a penalty area, you know about stroke and distance, you know about moving your ball, I mean and and everybody plays the game. But when you get into competitive golf and and situations that are out of the
norm, you're lost. So when I moved back to Wisconsin in in 2000 and in 2000 and I was asked to be a director of the Wisconsin State Golf Association. In the states, state golf associations are affiliates of the USGA. They run the tournaments for the for the USJ in their respective areas. The qualifiers go to the national events and it was expected that as a director that you volunteer a certain number
of hours at the tournaments and if you were certified then you served as a rules official. I really wasn't too interested in drafting traffic or in in selling shirts. I wanted to be a a rules official. So I I I set out the path and said how does this happen. So I was really fortunate to have three people who served on who served as directors as well who are are mammoths in the name of rules in my opinion. One was Jim Reinhard who was former executive committee member of Wisconsin State Health
Association and former rules Chair for the USDA and he currently sits on the Rules Committee for the Masters at at Augusta. So he's he's still very much involved in that role and he was instrumental in bringing the US AM and the US Open to Aaron Hills. So he that's how much of AA power player he was in that arena. Another guy was Mark Reineman who was also on the executive committee and of the WSJA. He was former executive committee of the USGA and was
chair of the Rules Committee in 2019 when the new rules took effect. So he was the main liaison with the USGA and the RNA and bringing those quite major rules changes in 2019 he now lives in Pinehurst. Sadly he just lost his wife Wendy who was who was also a very very much engaged in in in the with the US mid am for the women. She was in very much involved with the women's open when it was held at pine needles and
just a really really really nice lady. And then the third guy was John Morissette. John was the former director of rules for the USGA and he's the smartest rules guy that I know of. He's just he he he makes him he knows everything but he makes makes it very simple when he communicates rules and why and when and he's worked every major around the world and he joined Aaron Hills prior to the USAM. I think Jim Reinhart was
instrumental in bringing him over and and he and he became director of competition that still holds that role up at up at Aaron Hills. I think they're going to host the, I think they're going to host the US mid am coming up if I'm not mistaken. But there's three really good guys that it was through these guys that I really starting exploding my interest in, in learning about the rules. OK. When we were sort of chatting back and forth before, you know, in the last week leading up to this, you have obviously played thousands of rounds of golf, but
you said there was one that stands out as your favorite. Can you tell us a little bit about that please? Well, I am going to Scotland next summer and I'm taking my son and my son-in-law. So this this my favorite round so far might be replaced with the with our round at Saint Andrews. But we'll see. Yeah I I I mentioned Aaron Hills. It's my all time favorite golf course and when I was moving from Wisconsin down to Florida, John Deere offered me a move
down and I had to leave. The WSJI made my resignation public and John Morissette called me up and he said, Tim, come on down. Let's play one more round at Aaron Hills and I'll get the tee time. And we we got a tee time at 7:30 in the morning on a glorious June day. Just not a cloud to sky, just the two of us with caddies and with my interest in rules. Obviously I had all kinds of questions with John and we spent 3 1/2 hours just talking about me asking questions about all
the different majors that he. It was a rule to the official end where he had problems with players, where were difficult situations, who were the nice guys, who were not the nice nice guys. And it was just it was like opening up an entertaining movie for me. I just thoroughly enjoyed that. I very much appreciated the gesture that that John offered me and the experience was over the top. So I cherish that round and I wish I could do it again so. Is there anything from that round and that conversation you had that still sticks with you
today that you'd be willing to share? Just whether it be a story or a principle in the rules or the way you go about refereeing a particular situation, Is there anything that sticks with you from that conversation or that round of golf? Yeah not so much about particular rules or rule situations because that that was early on in my rules journey and I was still a pretty much a novice but but I was more interested in in difficult situations like and and and he described it I'll I'll I'm I'm
not going to throw a player under the bus but he told me about some players that were were were really really nasty folks and you know I you don't see that on TV. Right. You just you just see there was 1 comical comment that he made about Ernie Els and you know Ernie Els is is known as the Big Easy and he made a comment about the fact that Ernie's big but he isn't necessarily always easy and so so apparently he Ernie's got a pretty tough demeanor when
it's when he has interactions with rules officials not not in a mean sort of way but just he's just you want to make sure he gets it his way. And if you recall the incident in the Masters I think it was Ernie Ells when he wanted at one time he hit way left on hole #11. This is several years ago and there was material there that was piled and it was clear that it was not piled for removal. But he asked an official and he got that answer and he didn't like it. He wanted another official and he got an answer and he didn't like it.
And he asked another official and he finally got the answer that he wanted. And one of the fellows said, Yep, it's it's piled there for removal, and he got relief. Wow. So the persistence paid off. Just kept asking the next person, the next person, the next person isn't that interesting. I think when we begin our rules journey and we pick up, you know, the book or whatever version we have at the time and we start reading through chapters and we're learning things we probably don't appreciate at that time, that if we ever apply this for real with real people and real players,
it's not going to be easy all the time. You just don't walk into a situation and go, yeah, you can take a drop, just pick your reference point, blah blah, blah. You can have those. Maybe altercation is not the right word, but they certainly can be tense moments with a player who is not clearly not happy with their current predicament. We don't read about that in the In the Rules of Golf book, do we? No, no they don't. And we sort of not prepared for them, no. You also, when we were in preparation for this, we were talking about your journey of playing a lot of golf at a high
level, and then for whatever path you took with the associations and the like. Then we had to begin this journey of actually taking the rules a bit more seriously, a bit more study. We need to now become qualified, accredited, and the like. You told me about an exam. You didn't study for because you were playing regularly and you knew enough to get by out on the course, but the exam result just maybe humbled you a little bit. Are you able to share with us the lead up to the exam please? Yeah, It was actually the very
first USGA PGA3 day rule seminar and that I ever went to. It was out in New Mexico, and Jim Reinhardt actually was one of the instructors. And it's followed by the hundred question exam. And I was cocky. I mean, I it's not that, you know, I read the book. It's not that I didn't read it. I read the rules. I went through the three days of presentation. I paid attention. It was all interesting. But my attitude was, I mean, I know this stuff. And so when guys were checking out after dinner early, instead
of having a cocktail, they were going to their rooms and studying. And I just didn't feel the need to do that. So I took the exam. There was a bit more stressful than what I had anticipated. And when I got the results, my score was a 72 out of 100. And that's the equivalent in golf of a of a quadrupled bogey in my in my opinion, reality set in. And that's when I knew that. There's a little bit more to this than just knowing the, you know, the basics. If you're going to be a rules official, you have to understand
this stuff and these guys do, and if you're going to get to that level, I needed to change my attitude about how I was going to approach the rules of golf and and fortunately I did so. Excuse me, would you agree that when you start off and maybe you do for for us it'll be an RNA level one, you know, one hour exam, 60 questions I think relatively straightforward. After that you think I've achieved something. I know rules that I didn't know previously and then the next level up is a level 2 and that's
you know two days another exam. Even at that point I think people think I've probably I probably know everything I need to know now and at each level we don't appreciate how much more there is to learn and and maybe maybe you're in that similar boat where you knew a fair bit but you didn't know what was not known so to speak. How much was still left to know? Oh, without a doubt. In fact I admire the the different levels that you have. With the RNA we have the option
of taking an 80 question exam here. But in terms of of in terms of rating, you know if you want to get your expert rating you have to take the 100 question exam and you have to get 90. Previously it was 93 before 2000 and 1993 was the requirement for expert and with the noodles came in 2019. I think that changed the 90. So I don't know if it's because they're just being nicer, they wanted more experts or whatever, but that that I'm a type A
personality. So that was always my goal. I was not going to be happy with, certainly wasn't happy with 72 and I think my next score was probably like an 85. I wasn't happy with that and my next score was like maybe an 88. I wasn't happy with that and I wasn't going to be happy until I achieved that expert status so. Well, I I did the exam the first time around 12 months ago, studied 2 weeks, I got roughly the score that I wanted and I got the certification that I wanted. Even studying for that I think
made me realize wow, I mean, I mean there were X questions I still got wrong now that X is less than 10, which is nice, but there was still questions I really didn't understand and I got the wrong answer even then, I think I still wow. I mean, I know people that have got 9998. I didn't. But even then there's still gaps and I found that exam very, very stressful and I couldn't imagine doing that exam having not prepared. I just would have found it even more stressful. Have I not prepared for that exam?
You know, I found it incredibly tough. In fact, you mentioned the RNA. If I can come back and mention the USGAI think you are so fortunate to have that body that is so active in education, having so many staff dedicated to educating regular golfers, associations, you know and the like. I mean the number of seminars and workshops they run, the fact that they had the accreditation. I think and we're going to talk about very shortly about the three day seminar you attended which had next to nothing to do
with the rules of golf and was to do with the referee. I think USGA do a fabulous job of educating people and and I should add, making it available to basically anybody, including me living in Australia, you know, and being able to avail myself to that. Yeah, I think that's a good job. Yeah. Yeah, you can. You don't have to be a rules person to sign up for one of these seminars. Although, I mean, there are people that literally sign up because they want to learn more about the rules. And that's the reason why they
limit, I think, questions to like two or three a day from from people during the seminar. Because those folks are asking them. They're asking is 8 an hour. And and we all know those people. We all know who those sort of people are. You know, this big book of over 500 pages with both the RNA and the USGA logo on it. You know, there's there's rules and then there's the definition and committee procedures and other things. But there's not a lot in this book about being a referee and applying our knowledge for real on a golf course in real situations where the
consequences are important because it involves a player trying to make money, earn a living, etcetera, etcetera. Or even in the amateur game, you know, game world, ranking points, qualification for the next event, etcetera. You said you attended a three day seminar about specifically being a referee. I would love to hear just 5 minutes about what you learnt in that seminar place. Well, it was by far my favorite three day seminar that I ever went to with the USGAPGA. And it was last year and it was,
I was a last minute somebody told I went to the I went to the regular rule seminar at Pinehurst and Dave Hampton mentioned to me, he said, hey, are you are you going to. I didn't. I really hadn't paid much attention to it. So I was able to sign up and go at the last minute and it was it was incredible. It was. It was not about the rules. Maybe the one thing that was about the rules was we went over Tios quite a bit, but but other than that, it was not about the
rules. It was down at TPC Sawgrass, great venue. It included just about the entire USJ staff. This is the first time they've ever done this. So they really were flying blind. They didn't know how this was going to go. But they had. They had. They had some people in this thing that were Steven Cox, who was on the PGA Tour, Missy Jones and Brian Fahey from the LPGA Tour.
Missy was the lady that remembered the confrontation at the. Solheimer cup where I remember there. Was a lot going on there with confrontation with players and caddies, and she told us that whole story. Jordan Harris from the Korn Ferry Tour and Todd Satterfield from the PGA Tour champions. These people just didn't give presentations. They engaged with us for the three days. I mean, really got engaged with us to teach us how to be better referees. So it was about how to handle caddy interference, player conflict, resolutions, issuing
penalties. It's not fun to issue a penalty, but you know how to, how to do it and then get out of there. I think, I think one of the key statements that I just really kept with me was, I think it was Steven Cox said. You know, you got to understand, OK, the player doesn't care how well you know the rules, he doesn't care. And so as a rules official, don't go in there quoting this and quoting that and naming rules. He doesn't care. He just wants help with his
situation, that's what that's all he wants. And I that just resonated with me and and I thought it was such good advice. Our final Test for the seminar was a you got called randomly, you didn't know you had it, you had a tee time, you got called out there and there were five situations. You didn't know what they were. And so these people that I mentioned before, along with USJ staff, they were role players and and so you had five different situations and you had to deal with it.
So you were judged on whether you gave the right ruling. You were judged on your demeanor, your approach, whether you asked the appropriate questions to try to find out the facts and and then you got a grade. You know, they they assessed you on all 5 situations and then you got a grade. It it was just it was fun, it was extremely informative and it was hugely beneficial in terms of of how I changed my approach to to being a rules. Fix Wow. Can I just ask about one word and that word is sorry? Did anyone talk about sorry?
Do you ever say sorry to a player? Do you definitely not say sorry to a player if you know you can't help them or you need to apply a penalty? You know that that question never came up, but what did come up? Is it? It is. And I I think it was Missy Jones that said this. She says, look, you're not trying to be the player's friend. And so saying you're sorry kind of leads down that path and maybe you're trying to be their friend. The facts are the facts and the rules are the rules.
And, you know, your job is to try to keep players out of difficult situations. But sometimes that can't always happen. The incidents already happened. You've got to find out what happened and and then give the ruling. So and and and then the advice is why don't you give the ruling, Get out of there. Right, right. And another interesting thing that I that I after I thought about for a while I thought was really good, Even though you're not required to provide a second opinion if if a player asked for one and I and especially on the
tour, I mean they grant it but they're not required to, yes. But the advice was when you call in a second official for a second opinion, call him in give him the information and then leave. Let that rules official take over. Don't stick around. And at first I thought, well geez that's kind of kind of strange. Why won't you both be both there and and and and and they said now the best thing is to get out
of there. That guy coming to back you up is just as knowledgeable as you are. You've given him the facts get out of there 99 times out of 100 he's going to give the same ruling as you did except except in the masters were there any elves? But, but but I thought that was pretty good advice. Give your advice and the same thing with the ruling. Give the ruling. Get and get out of there. Oh, look, I don't have anywhere near as much experience as you, but like, I remember some of the things I was told early on was #1, don't comment on the situation that player finds
himself in. Don't talk about, whoa, you know, wow, that's not a good predicament. Or I found myself in that position on Friday. You know, the players obviously have zero interest in hearing about your own golf game and your situation. And the second thing was don't mention rule numbers. Don't talk about rule 9.4 B unless they which they are unlikely to do unless they specifically ask you. So you mentioned then about Cox saying they don't care how well you know the rules, and I think almost accompanying that is
don't rattle off well 9.4 B exception 2 is this or exception 2 to 9.3 is this and they don't want to know anything about that, do they? No they're going to look at you like you got square eyes when you do that they they they just they they don't want to hear it. I I actually had an event one time where another official we were both on the scene and the other official said actually made the statement said jeez they should have marked that ground under repair.
I don't. I don't think that was the right comment. It should have made, right? I I still remember my second ever professional event which I did with Blakey and I remember there was a wait on a drivable path four and the group had just left and it was already group waiting. And I thought, I'm new to all this, you know, we shouldn't talk to the players too much unless they talk to us. I thought I wanna learn. I was so new I wanted to learn. I went up to the group and I said do you have any tips for being a good referee?
I mean they were just chatting about anything. They were talking about TV last night. They weren't too focused on their game at that point in time. I asked, do you have any tips for me? New referee and one of the players said, and I I still know who it was. He said don't mess around, just get in, tell us what we need to know and go. He said don't don't take any longer than you need to and I thought that was good. He said Just tell me what I do I get relief or not? If so, how do I go about it and go? I thought that was good advice. You know, that might not be
shared by other players, but I thought that was interesting insight from a player. He doesn't want to be standing there for 8 minutes talking to a referee. Yeah, just as you said, Get, get out of there. That's exactly the advice that we got at that seminar was get in, give the ruling, Get the facts, give the ruling, and leave. I guess another perspective you mentioned about I mentioned the word sorry. You mentioned about being their friend, sorry not being their friend. In a way, There are situations where you're trying to be a friend to the rest of the field, to all the other players, because you're obviously there
to protect the field and but so you're almost being their friend without being the player's friend. Look, I think just having a think about what you could talk about in three days with that amount of experience in the room, you talked about all the USGA staff there, all the heavy hitters being there. I think that would just be a wonderful, wonderful event and I'm no surprise that you say it's the best one you went to and all the things you were to learn and I would love to attend one. I think that would just be fantastic.
I think, I think it's next week to back down at TPC at Sawgrass again. And I think this year it sold out. I mean fast. The word got around of how good it was and it sold out fast. Have a question for you about being a referee. And you are a very, very, very good player who's played a very high level amateur. Do you think your playing ability effects your effects? You being a referee, do you think being a very, very good golfer, maybe even an ex professional, you might see situations differently to
somebody who plays off, you know, 30, who's lucky to break 100? Do you think there's a difference in those two people in the way they referee? Do you think it helps you, hinders you when you see situations? No. And I I I still to this day like last week ago Sunday I did a a a Peggy Kirk Bell Junior Girls event out of one of our local course and that was age, I think it was ages 12 to 18 in
different divisions. And you see some higher caliber players and some less caliber players. You know, whether you're doing a a USAM event or whether you're doing a North and South event or whether you're doing one of these junior events, the rules are the rules. I would say that with the younger players there's a bit more instructional effort to try to more of an explanation so that they so that so it's not just the result that they learn
the why a little bit you can't obviously you can't go on forever you don't want to give a rules clinic but but I think that just a little bit more effort in terms of explaining the why with the younger or the inexperienced player. Having said that at AUSM qualifier I saw a player he hit a ball into a penalty area. I was up on the hill and and then I saw him drop back out into the fairway and I knew there was a problem and as soon as he and I got on my way and as
soon as he hit it the the the horn blew for suspension of play. So I went and picked him up and and and I said what come back here and and explain this drop to me and so I understand this and he he just said I was taking line of line of play relief. My ball entered the penalty area this way and and I was and I had to inform him that there was no line of play relief. It's back on the line and he really didn't have that option And I said you need to make sure you had two penalty strokes to your score for playing from the wrong place. But the thought that left me was
that how many times has this kid, he was probably 21 years old. He's been. He was a great golfer and he's been playing tournaments since he was probably 12 years old Ajga and college golf and whatnot. And. And how many times has he taken that relief and thought he was doing the right thing and and and just as important, his fellow players allowed him to take it, not thinking that he was doing anything wrong. So.
You know, you know, Blakey and I talk a lot about what happens and we have our clubland stories, What happens at clubland. And when you have, you know, four guys or 4 girls always playing with each other, what they must get away with just would boggle the mind and that would be an example. I don't think he was probably deliberately trying, but that was probably genuinely his belief about what he could do with taking relief from the penalty area. But what must go on at golf courses all around the world where the player thinks they're doing the right thing, the others in the group are
comfortable with that. Don't think there's anything wrong, You know, the lack of knowledge, I guess, of even basic procedures like dropping. No, that's when you were saying that I was thinking, yeah, what about the other guys in the group watching this thinking that's OK, But you said it as well. They're OK with that drop. Or they don't want to question him on it, maybe. I don't know. But OK, Excuse me. You mentioned also in our exchange of notes about David Stabler, a person who is very, very well known around the world
in the rules of golf with extraordinary amounts of experience. And he said something to you or said something you heard from him about the importance of understanding the concept and the relationship of the rules rather than trying to memorize and remember lists. And I know a good friend, Jeff Ward and Blakey, we talk about this a lot about 'cause I started off memorizing lists, I can tell you, you know the two exceptions are 9.35 to 9.4. Replacing a ball on a spot is 4 times.
You don't have to use the original. I remember that. That's how I remember them. Now I'm learning. Others, including yourself, are saying that's good, but there's a better way to understand the rules, the the, the concepts and the relationships. Would you mind just explaining that why that's so important, please? Yeah and and David by the way was one of the USGA guys down at that seminar at Sawgrass and one of the role players and he I happened to draw him and and and he could get a he could get an acting award.
So we all know how well versed he is in the rules. But I I think he has a demeanor when he when he teaches rules and I've had him as an instructor as well in one of these classes, he just. He makes you feel comfortable with it. He has a sense of logic that he approaches to it that that isn't so much black and white. He just he molds in the logic. And he said, he said don't study one more rule until you read The Principles Behind the Rules of
Golf, which was Richard written by Richard Tufts 5060, seventy years ago. I don't know how long ago, and I'm going to make a couple of quotes here that that back up. You know what I'm saying? Tufts quoting here running through the rules are underlying principles that, like steel rods which lie beneath the surface of reinforced concrete, serve to bind together the brittle material and give it strength. And they also said the basic principles, fortunately, are simple, logical, practical and expressive, Whereas these
principles are seldom specifically referred to in the rules. They are well recognized but by all who work with the rules and conserve excellently as a guide. So once and I did read that book after he suggested I read it and I was spending too much time trying to memorize versus trying to conceptualize. And the first time I heard the presentation of status of the ball was by David. And if you go on the USJ website now and I think you paid $25 and
they do an excellent job of going through the 25 rules. But there's one on there that's the status of the ball. And that one is the best one on there because it just it really ties in specifically 2 rules but it relates to to many, many others. It ties in 6.3 and 14.4 where when players ball is back in play when the original ball is out of play and then a ball used in a play in the hole. And the way they go back and forth and talking about the status of the ball just relates in so many different ways.
Once I felt comfortable with relying on the principles things just became easier to me. You know, I realized that I don't have to memorize everything. There's our exam is is 50 parts closed, 50 questions closed part, 50 questions open book and the closed part are the ones that you should know right? I mean, those are the, you don't want to spend time, but there's a reason that they give you an open book because that book you carry with you out on the golf course. And if and don't be afraid to use it, you know, in most cases, I don't think I have to, but
it's there if I need it. And and besides, as you know, many times there's idle moments out there on the golf course if you're official. So having that book there gives you something to do. OK. So, So I thought that was really great advice from David and and I still have that book and it's a great book, not very long. Funny you should talk about that presentation. In my preparation last year to do the USGA 100 question exam, I
went through the Virtual Rule School and I watched all those videos you just spoke about, including one separate from rule that I'm voting for was the status of the ball. And I remember Jeff telling me before, oh, you've got to watch that presentation. It only goes for 38 or 40 minutes or something like that. Who would think you could talk about that topic for 40 minutes, right? And they do. And it all makes sense. And I too found that presentation excellent about thinking about how a single ball like this can change status from
different actions from different things happening as you play the whole. I too found that presentation. I found that in fact I found that entire virtual rule school watching all those videos. I thought it was excellent. I mean, I literally just read through the rule book, but I like the way they read through the rule book and explain different things. But that status of the board does stand out for me as well. I actually did quite enjoy that. Might just start to wind up here a little bit timid and just with a few maybe rapid fire questions, just sort of quick,
you know, clearly extensive experience. You've received the expert certification on more than one occasion from the OSJA by sitting the 100 question exam. Is there still one rule that sticks out that maybe is a weak point or just still confuses you every now and again? Is there anything fitting to that category? I think rule 1.3 C four presents many people some challenges. Is this intervening events? That I guess? What? What's that? Is that intervening events that I guess?
It it's just that it's it's multiple multiple penalties and and it's based on whenever an issue like that is presented on golf rules Samaritan, it gets a lot of response and a lot of different So I know it's frustrating to a lot of people. I mean it it it's clear that completion of a stroke is an intervening event, and they state that being aware, becoming aware of a breach of a rule, including when a player knows they breach the rule, when the player is told of a breach, and when the player is uncertain whether or not they have a
breach. That brings in a lot of subjectivity to me, right? And so in a situation where an official has to consider multiple penalties, in my opinion things have to be crystal clear. I mean, you you've got to make a decision here, and it's not a fun situation, and things have to be crystal clear. For example, when a player is told of a breach, that's clear to me, that when he's told of a breach, that's an intervening event. Yet I understand that the
current guidance is that it may require an interview with the player to determine if he believes what he was told was true. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, OK, well, that could be a simple fix to me. Then say if he's told of a ruling that is accurate, then that's an intervening event. But but to to introduce the fact that there still may be doubt even though he's been told and I don't know that, that to me adds to the confusion. I think they've got some more work to do on that to to to
tighten it up. No, I couldn't agree with you more. I I agree that there's two intervening events. Completion of a stroke is very straightforward, but this being aware, becoming aware, even if you are uncertain, and I remember maybe Stabler said this, that now more and more in the rules and officiating that establishing the facts, sorry, establishing the intent of the player and what the player's thinking is becoming one of the facts that we need to consider perhaps more than ever before.
I'll rephrase that. Understanding the intent of the play and the thought process of the play is now becoming one of the facts that we need to consider when, you know, giving a ruling, I'm with you that you're right about the discussion on that group, about intervening events and even the uncertainty. You know, you tell me, Stuart, you cannot do that and I go, I don't agree with you, but clearly now I'm uncertain that should be an intervening event. You know, just even if I said no, no, you're wrong. I don't agree with you. Surely I'm 1% uncertain.
I'm not 100% certain. OK. Next one, is there any rule you would like to introduce or change an existing rule? Well, many would answer free relief from divots and I'm I'm not going to be one of those because I'm a traditionalist. I say play the ball where you find it and you get good breaks and you get bad breaks and it's an outdoor game. Are going to be my 3 responses. So pace of play is a real issue for me and the current structure for local rules. For pace of play policies they're specific but they're rarely enforced and I think rule
5.6 could use some teeth. So for instance, unreasonable delay of play is different depending on who you ask. Some pre shot routines in my opinion are delaying is unreasonable. So if you go to clarification 5.681 they consider going from the green say if it's a short par 3 going from the green back to the tee to retrieve a club
that you left there as unreasonable delay subject to penalty. I can assure you there are pre shot routines that take longer than that. So I, I, I you know I don't know what the answer is but I I I think there has to be a real I I don't think there ever should be a warning. I mean I think if a if a if a group is out of position I think you don't have to give them a warning. I think if they're out of position rules officials should say hey you're subject to be in time 40 seconds anytime you don't have to give you a warning
40 seconds is the standard anytime throughout the round not just when you're out of position and and if they get a 42nd violation then they get the warning and the next one that the penalty process until you put starting and put some teeth into into pace of play. I just, I just think it's and exercises takes up a lot of time at rules officials for with no result. It's yeah, that's a great point. I think it's interesting that rule 5.6 almost says pay supply
should be considered unreasonable. Delay apply should be considered. But committees, it's your problem. You decide on your own pay supply policy, you decide on how you are going to implement it rather than rules stipulating specific penalties. You know, if you do not hit a shot within 40 seconds, once it's your turn, bang, There's nothing like that. It's up to the committee almost. It's like the ruling bodies have said, you work it out. We're just saying it's a thing and you should consider it right. Maybe. This is probably going to have the same response.
Any rules that you don't like or frustrate you? Well, I just gave you two that frustrate me a little bit. But I think rather than a specific rule, what frustrates me? First of all, you know that there are times when you read through this book, as many times as you've read through this book, that all of a sudden you read something that that you you don't. You say, wow, the light goes off, you've read it 100 times, but all of a sudden it hits you like a brick.
That said, I didn't realize that. But even though you've read it and so you've always, you're always learning in this journey, you're always learning. And one of the things that frustrates me is, is that this issue of guidance. You know one of the things that the rules bodies did the USGA and RNA back in 2019 when when 10.2 B four was introduced about the restrictions about standing behind, they very quickly, very quickly about even by the time
the books got printed they made a clarification. And and because it used to be that if once the player took his stance and the caddy was back there, he could not be reversed And then they quickly changed that to that if the if the player, the caddy steps away and the player gets out of his stance and then comes back in. OK so. So I know it can be done. So an example I'll give you is playing a wrong ball. So a stroke made at a wrong ball and any more strokes before the mistake is corrected, including
strokes made in any additional penalty stroke solely from playing that ball do not count. So 6.31 says meaning of penalty stroke solely from playing that ball. Lists examples of penalties that are not disregarded because they also applied to the ball and play, and one of those is playing a wrong ball. It's in there today. But the current guidance is that once the once the wrong ball is played, the world stops. Anything involved with playing that ball, including playing another wrong ball, is not going
to count. Well, that'd be such a simple one to change with the clarification. Yet they So not everybody's getting that guidance right. Of all the rule officials around the world depending on what level you're at, not everybody's getting that guidance, but everybody would have that guidance if they simply made a very quick clarification and addressed it. So I I I just, I'm not a big fan of guidance. I'd like to see black and white. You know, I just see you know we have guidance in trying to determine reasonable judgments
and I'm OK with that. We have, you know we have guides when when trying to determine intent and I'm OK with that. But to me that's it's pretty clear. Either it is or it isn't, and if it isn't, say so. It's. Very, very interesting. You say that I had one of my own rulings dissected, which I brought up on this very podcast, dissected amongst many, many experienced people. And many say, well the USGA have provided guidance on this. And I don't think I said this in that discussion. But what I felt was, you know, if I'm dealing with a player I can go off the rules of golf,
the tour hard card and local rules for that event. I can't go off something that someone posted on a Facebook group, which is that guidance. And the other thing that I find interesting is that how often we, we fall under RNA jurisdiction in Australia and how often we hear about guidance from the USGA. Maybe it was a situation they hadn't considered before. They've thrown it around the lunchroom, come up with a response and provided guidance.
And then we sit here and think did they run that by the RNA first like did they go across the point, hey guys, do you agree with this because you know, I know Jeff has contacted Golf Australia as one example saying hey we just read about this on the USGA site, this is the RNA. I agree with this, this is a game changer and I think it was in relation to that wrong ball and how you know hitting a wrong ball and then hitting another wrong like a second ball is another wrong ball in the changing guidance and we're going, I wonder if the RNA have discussed this as well or agreed
to that position. So I'm with you. I think the the formal process is to through the quarterly updates clarifications rather than a Facebook post. I'm not being critical by any stretch. I think the USJUSJ do an incredible job of being very, very active with all of this. But I I I share that frustration I guess is what I'm trying to eventually get to that it's interesting that so many things can happen to a little white ball like so, so many things can happen on a golf course.
That's phenomenal and still things that have not been considered previously that we're still coming up with new scenarios. My name is Marta Khan. Yeah, I'm sure, I'm sure there is and I'm probably certain as that just you talked about the golf rules, Samaritan Facebook group, the USGA have their own Facebook group. Do you have any comments you'd like to make? That's where obviously Blakey got a hold of you through that group to have this very interview that we're having now. Do you have any thoughts about those sorts of environments, those mediums, those groups and what they do for the rules of
golf and what they do for people like yourself? Yeah, I I have a they're both good groups. You get, you get different audiences in in the respective groups. Usjs or you know anybody who's a member of the USGA that who's interested in the rules or not is going to comment on there And sometimes it's not very friendly. But the TGRS, if, if anybody heard the interview on golf Rules questions with Fraser and Nicole, and what an incredible story.
And if you didn't listen to that, you, you know, not only him bringing TGRS, you know, into a some people do wordle, some people do crossword puzzles. I do TGRS every day. I mean, I'm reading posts in there every day. And then on his own personal story about having such a short period of time, how he he went through the process of becoming certified and where he's at today. I consider it my constant study guide because there are more people on there who are a lot
smarter than me from around the world who are on there giving their opinions and and there is, there is conflict of opinions, but it's done so in a very professional and a in a very cordial way. And if you think the rules are just crystal clear, just get on that page for about 3 days and you'll find out that some of the smartest people in the world are in disagreement on things. And that's what makes it an an infectious thing to study for me.
There are people who I do not know, I've never met, that I've interacted on on Facebook with it. I know that if I went to wherever they were at, if they're in Australia or if they're in Scotland or whatever, I could sit down. We give each other a Big Bear hug and we'd have a beer. And I've never met them. That's how much interaction that you have with those folks, you know. And there's some incredible ladies on that site and there are some incredible ladies who are who are involved in the rules. Laurie Ballet is one of them and Cecilia Leslie is another one.
And Liz Cantu and Carolyn Sider and and and we remember Wendy Reinerman was so, so very good. These, these these ladies are smart and they are sharp and I learned from them. I learned from them and I appreciate their involvement in that site. And of course without TGRSI never would have been introduced to the questions, which I think you guys need to take a bow. I think you do. I listen to you on my four mile walks. You only have them once a week. So I've gone back now and listened to all previous episodes or they're in the
process of listening to that. And you and Blakey have done a great job in creating the podcast and and and and and you make it interesting and you also make it fun and that's why it's an easy listening to me. It makes my my walks go. So congratulations on that. Well, thank you very much for saying that. That's very kind. Thank you. Just don't listen to whilst operating heavy machinery, walking is OK, but not heavy machinery. Thank you very much. That's very nice of you to say. Well, with that we might just draw it to a close. And as we do with all our Golf
Rules Questions podcast, we finish with the episodes Golf Rules Question of the Week. And Tim, I've asked you as our guest today to deliver this week's which you have written this week's golf Rules Question of the week. Take it away Tim, please. OK, so this is golf rules question of the week #110. Barney, the B grade golfer, hits his approach shot onto a greenside bunker on the short 15th hole of the very prestigious Golf Club at Wombat
Hills. The ball is in the middle of a large collection of temporary water in the middle of the bunker. As the only relief area in the bunker would put the ball in a very difficult position on a slope, Barney decides to take back on the line relief outside the bunker. After making this decision, Barney walks into the bunker to retrieve his ball, and in doing so he creates footprints. Barney retrieves A rake and smooths the footprints and then correctly drops his ball outside
the bunker. But instead of using back on the line relief, he's changed his mind and he's now taking stroke and distance from a distance fairly close to where the back on the line relief would have put it. Before playing his shot, Barney notices that the raked footprints that he had that he had raked in the trap are in his line of play for that short shot over the bunker to the hole that is a mere 6 feet from the front of the green. After playing his shot, how many penalty strokes has Barney
incurred? Very, very good. Thank you, Tim. So we've clearly got some issues with Barney entering a bunker to retrieve a ball, making some mess in that bunker. And before making their next stroke with that bunker very much on their line of play, they alter the surface of the ground. They go in there with the rake and they tidy up that footprints in the bunker and they've taken unplayable ball relief. How many penalty strokes will Barney have to add to their whole score team?
That's a very, very good question. Thank you. And I look forward to people as they do often contribute with their responses, what they think the answer is. Thank you for delivering that team. Well, team, thank you very much. This has been a terrific chat. I really appreciate your time. I appreciate you sharing with us your experience. I can't wait to edit this up, get it over to Blakey and he can post it and get it up for all those people on that golf rule Samaritan website to have a listen to. Thank you very much for your time. It's been great to talk to you. Yeah.
Thank you, Stuart. It was a lot of fun. Appreciate it. Well, that's it for this week's episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast, Episode 110. My name is Stuart McPhee. It's been great to have your company and we look forward to talking to you next on the Next Golf Rules Questions podcast. The.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...