COMMUNITY QUESTION | THE GRQ PODCAST EP60 GRQOTW#60 On the closing 18th hole at Wombat Hills, Ross' drive comes to rest near OB, however it remains in the general area. When taking his stance to play his next stroke, he stands on a concrete pipe embedded in the ground which lays outside the course boundary, which is clearly interfering with him for a reasonable stroke. What are Ross' options to take any relief? The community question gives real insight into the public's understanding of the Rules of Golf, and also has Blakey tied up in a mess. We go the last few questions, explaining further the answers and why the definitions are the most important part of the book.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode of the golf rules questions podcast.
Hi everyone, welcome to episode 60 of the GoPros questions podcast with your host flaky and co-host again this week. Stuart McPhee, welcome Stuart, thank spiky. Great to be here again and congratulations on reaching 60. Yeah, thank you had cast. That's very cool. Thank you. Very much. Whereabouts in the world. Are you at the southeast Queensland? Better hit on head on back to Melbourne. Shortly enjoying it up there. Yes. And okay, thank you some Tom way with the family. Thank you.
So you didn't date the golf clubs and no, not not enough room in the car and all my children put their stuff in. So how's it feel now that your I mean, you are You know, an author and have been on many podcasts, but to be on the, the great, my love of golf podcasts, how was that? I was humbled to even be thrown up on the board as an option. So I think Ross does a great job, he's just maybe he's got
better. I maybe he's not a natural, he's got better at just hosting and having a conversation with people and getting answers out of people, it's just a really good host. He just does things really well. It was, it was a lot of fun. Thank you. Yeah, I certainly enjoy his interview podcasts. He's really gotten some really cool people on that. You, you just never never heard of Titans thing in the Gulf space. And yeah, it's, you know, they
do though in their own right outside of golf. There might be semi-famous, but in the Gulf, They're not, but they love golf and they love the game and that's what this whole podcasts it up to be that the my love of golf. You know, people have this life outside of golf but they still have everyone connects together a chain that in the golf world and you know, the golfing Community is a small place so it's pretty cool. The interviews he does.
I try to encourage him to do a lot more. Well done on getting on there. Thank you now he's very good at it. So Without further Ado, we better get into the gr Q 0 TW 4 episode 59 which was I was a football match with Ross and phrase are playing against Helen and Charlotte and it was just an issue of a concession and what that meant. And we know with rule, 6.4 order of play match play, it is an issue. You do need to abide by order of play, although you can't agree.
Every now and again to do that but you do need to abide by that order play. And but with when it comes to fall ball, if it's one of your players that is next to play, you can actually choose which one of you play, even if someone's a lot closer to the hole. So what Fraser decided to do that? Because he was closer to the hole and he was going to give Ross a line on the Putt and he had two putts to win the hole. But before Fraser was able to putt, he's pup was conceded by either Helen or Charlotte, but he putted anyway. Way, and we know that when you concede, it doesn't matter what
you do after that the whole, you know, the concession is valid so that stroke was in and was in for a five. But because he putted and because it would have assisted or did assist his partner in his line of play. There isn't there is an interpretation with regards to concessions and fall ball that actually Ross's score can't count for that side anymore because he's been assisted by his partner and phrases. Score is the score for the team. So, In actual fact, he ended up making a five, come on,
Charlotte were already in for a for. So they won the whole even though Ross, had two putts for a win, fantastic. And I think one of our longtime listeners David grieve got that one, right? He submitted an answer on the on YouTube, so, well done David. But an interesting, an interesting situation and interesting answer or ruling after that, because You know, I think it used to be and correct me if I'm wrong anyone out there but it used to be that the player players incurred, the
penalty. Where is this Don? They're saying, well, there's no, the penalty is that we, you can't count that school because you've been assisted. So where is it motivated to shop family? Before in this situation? Effectively is the same answer. But if Helen and Charlotte were in for a Marine Corps for six or seven? I mean, Ross made his 45 but
also got the penalty and then Fraser, right? Probably miss those adding who wasn't, but in the other person, you know, 3 palette or for jacked, for an eight or whatever, then it would be the same answer. But, yeah. An interesting one, I kind of like it. It makes it really simple. Hey, you're not allowed to do this, if you've done it. Well, Because you've assisted your partner, we're not going to count that school. So that's pretty cool. Hmm. So yeah. Nice work Stewart. Good.
Good question. That one. Have you been playing a lot of phorbol competitions? It's not a lot. Not a lot. Oh yeah yeah I haven't played a lot myself not in the last 12 months or so but what's it like for ball? No I mean it's sorry what I should say is a lot of occasions. The four balls get thrown up on the first. Hey, so you play the informal on the side for more match? Yeah, out of the competition. Now they definitely play a lot of four ball competition in the
syllabus at Spring Valley which A lot of the membership. Well half of em shit like and half the moon should hate because I have them ship, just want to play individuals, they will feed or par and get their score and you know with that that g a handicap app where you can see everyone's handicap on there. That's really. Increased that participation and your individual handicap and how
you're going against your friends. So, you know, they used to have the used to be an old handicap at but more, that one, an official and unofficial one, which was such a great idea that golf Australia decided to steal it and Is like them out of the market but now that it's here, most people on it. And yeah, it's really good.
It's really good for social groups as well. Like I've got my own my one that heals golfers on my one that Hill Golf Club members on there is about father, so keeping track of all them. So yeah, it's good. Good out there. They're to use, right? So we've had a few things going on. This is I think we're delayed. This podcast was. I think the last one was about 13 days ago. So there's a fear being fair, few things happened, including a
lot of Julie questions, which have Always divide was divided the group. I think there's there's only been one in the last two or three months that we've gotten over 75 percent majority. So yeah they always seem to divide people. Have you got any that you want to any specific ones that you want us to talk about it? Is that I do there is a few I think we'll go back to a few questions ago when there was an original ball and a provisional
ball found in the same bought from the same player and that player was unable to distinguish, which was which And so the question, of course, was in, how does the player proceed? Do you have to go back and play your fifth shot? Do you pick one player to your third shot? To pick one. Plays your first. They were the options, roughly speaking. And this divided a little bit, but I thought, if you could just talk about what the situation is in regarding hitting an original and a provisional and then obviously not being able to
distinguish between the two, please. Yes. Oh, if you fan both bowls within the three minutes, being and you bet you can't work out which ones which then And instead of declaring that, well, then both being lost the rules. Do give you this nice situation where you can choose one and that becomes your provisional ball and that this is important to note because it does get a
little bit tricky, but that is for when it's in the general area. Okay? So if we just keep it nice and simple, you put one into the the scrub Another in a similar spot to get over there, they're both toddler sixes, you don't know which ones which well choose one. You can choose whichever one you want the best lie, the worst lie. And that one is now your provisional ball and that's in the general area. If one's out of bounds and ones
in bounds. In the one that's in bounds is your provisional ball if you don't know which is which and you know, that's That's the fairest way. You can do it next year. Really nice way to do it. Probably morphe away would be, you know, you're being dumb enough. Not to put a monkey on your bowline, knot established, which ones, which that he should have to go back to your last year, previous Place played, but I've said, okay, there's two balls they're just choose one and you can have the worst result which is your provisional now, it does
get a little bit hairy if you hit your ball into a penalty area. Yes, so if you hit both balls and go penalty area and you didn't know that it was a penalty area. Then you get to then, obviously one of them as your original. So you get to proceed and disseminate point one day. As long as you didn't know that, you'd hit them both into penalty area. But if you both, if you find both of them, then you can
proceed at a 17.1. They bore with the original bull if one is in the penalty area and one is outside the penalty area. I think I think it gets a little bit. Yeah, it does. It does get a little bit trickier if you want to choose the one in the penalty area, then that one can be original and you get to drop under 17.1 D. But if you choose the one outside the penalty area, That one is your provisional if you playing me forth rather than the
other. Yeah and you're playing fourth, think that's how it works. Is that how you remember it? I don't remember that one specifically. I know they both in the penalty area, you're actually better off than both being in the general area. You know, I should've done what I should look at this the other day and I should have reiterated, what I was looking at. Maybe I'll just cut this part out of the podcast. Anyway, we'll get back to you with with that but the first most important Point here is put
a mark on your boat. So it's interesting, you know, you talked about that that I've had this happen to me where, you know, you play your and we can all could be, lost can be wherever guys, I'm going to play a provisional ball. I know, I've had some one side of me. What is it? I said it's a ball. He said, no, no, what is it? I said it. I said it's a provisional ball because he wants me to say it's a Callaway X or it's a, he wants me to say, well, my original was a vis and my and I don't believe in, please correct me if I'm
wrong. There's nothing in the rules. That says, when you play professional ball, you must say, oh, by the way guys, the my original was a Titleist 3. This is a Timeless 5, I don't believe there's any where in the rules that actually say that now, it doesn't mean it's not common practice and it - it's not actually good practice but there's no requirement under my understanding to actually do that yet. Of course something will believe you absolutely need to distinguish between the two before you play the provisional ball. Ask you a question first, did you tell everyone what Paul you
your original was that's the point on like today I said no one on the First Tee will very few people on The First Tee. I got. By the way guys, I'm playing a Titleist for today. So I'm sometimes wonder why we need to know. I don't I don't tell them I mean even if you do you know if you change the ball at the 2nd hole you don't tell anyone like it's definitely. Okay let's let's look at the way the rules of golf. Look at it now we're going to penalize you if you don't tell people what full you using know, so then going that way, if you
don't get penalized for not telling people whether it what your original and what your provisional ball, Then we don't have to do it if you're going to get penalized you have to do it then and exactly. And and I'm the one taking the risk by not saying, oh, by the way, guys, my original was this, this is my provisional, it's this. I'm the one taking the risk in the, in the event. They end up one meter apart from each other yet. Even then. I know. Which is which anyway, well that's right. Ally on the plays Integrity To Go actually.
And when someone says I found it here, it's at all. Actually, guys. That's my provisional. Well, thank you. Let's keep searching for the original. I mean, that it comes back to the Integrity of the player. Yeah, that's right. It's the Integrity of the player honestly, so yet. No, that's, that's an interesting situation. I'll get back into that other situation and come back with an answer next podcast. But another Community, it is tricky one. When you hit two balls and ones in the penalty area, ones out sir.
Another Community question was tossing from the middle of the Fairway, spraying a shot towards out of bounds and it actually goes out of bounds and what his options were and it was interesting to see how many people chose the sort of that model, local rule. In other words, how many people didn't choose? Previous Place plague but actually chose the on a you can drop it up near where it went out. So there must be something in place somewhere where people believe that's where you can proceed for a ball that's out of. And so quite a few people, crop maybe better quarter got the wrong. So this is just bad. Bad publicity at the time, you know, the media Outlets just ran
with it and said, new raw and place drop up where you think you lost your ball. It's like that's not that's not a rule of golf. That's a local Rule and not that many clubs in certainly Australia. The UK. They don't have that in place. Whereas the u.s. I think you get shot if you don't have that in place, But you didn't hear you never say it on the tour, like the never going to adopt it on the to it says, in the book for General play, not Elite amateur and
professional tournaments more, social stuff, more social stuff so and that's probably possibly what they play in. The states, is more just amongst your mates. Whereas, in Australia, it's a competition field amongst the members of the club. You know who had? And the best score of the day amongst the 50, 8250 300
players, who played that day. Hmm. So yeah, so it's a good one. Yeah, I love checking that question out. There you wrote that one which is, which is good. Yeah. How one that I wrote the last one? Yes, about I was trying to work out how to how to write this one. So Michelle has taken relief.
She's allowed to cleaner balls, you can change your ball and then she's gone over to her relief area. This is one I5 don't over relief area and not drop the ball but she's let go of the ball, okay? Yeah. In that English language, that is the same thing. In the rules of golf language, that is not the same thing. But YouTube with their answer, their polling answer only gives
me 65 characters. So I had to try and write in what the answer is in the 65 characters. Now, I use the term dropping, which a lot of people took Thanks to, which is fair enough. Because dropping means when to drop your ball, with the intention of it being back in play. Now, Aunt, sassy, she didn't have intention. She literally just dropped her
ball accidentally and so that was the correct answer. Because when you drop a ball, With the intention. Then you're putting it back into play and that's a correct drop if it's inside the relief area, while a lot. If you drop it from shoulder height, that would be an incorrect drop. So this correct, drop incorrect drop. Whereas, if you let go of the ball, it's not a correct drop or an incorrect drop.
It's a nothing drop. It doesn't even come under the understanding of what a drop is. And so because you haven't got the intention to put it back into play. If you don't have the intention to put it back into play, Then basically you've thrown the ball or you've kicked the ball or the ball was out of play on, haven't put it back in. So if you hit that ball, even if it is, in the relief area, it's a wrong bull. Yeah, that's a big difference. Now, obviously, you know, I did answer that.
That's how I put the answer in the YouTube rules answer. When I father say, it's just a little tip fed that the ball was not back in play. Because she didn't have intention. She accidentally dropped it, you know, she bumped it and it fell out of her hand, whatever. But yeah, the term dropping dropped means that the player did have intention to put the ball back into play, which she didn't. So the bull was not back into
play, even if it was in the really fearing, imagine imagine saying to someone. Imagine if Michelle was bending down young and let go of the ball, Atlee heart. Someone, 15 meters away. Saw this. It comes drops to the ground. Doesn't go anywhere else, please lie in the relief area and then she picks it up again and then someone else goes, what are you doing? Imagine if Michelle said, ah, I didn't have intention to put it back in class and she's dropped it from the high or she's sorry,
she's accidentally. Let go of it from the hydrogen with the other players would say, well, I did Chuck in that fourth answer. To say how many people would think that it was a test drop. So, you know, that's right. Like you know, it's an interesting situation because the rules are so precise we we both know that and we We're happy with how, you know? I'm speaking for both of us. We're happy with how precise they are.
We enjoy that specificity of the language of the rules, you know, and getting it just right. For 95% of golfers out there. They don't know that the term dropping is a specific term that actually takes into, your takes into account, your mental thoughts processes. They don't know that.
If they saw someone as you said, if they saw Michelle let go of the ball and they sauce to it, dropping the ball to the it would still be the same thing weeks. He'll be dropping. They The bull. So you know this is not an excuse. It is it does sound like an excuse at probably know. It's not an excuse. It's just YouTube give me more characters for my own answers but also, you know, there is
this whole rules education. You've got to start somewhere and you got to go to Just try and mold people. You can, you know, if I go and do a rules course, rules Workshop, I know that half of them will fall asleep. Hmm. It's just, you know, I'd like to say that I'm not boring, but the topic that I've chosen to speak about certainly can be. Usually you just get people to ask questions because they'll if they ask a question, they'll
listen to your answer, but for everyone else's question, they don't care. I've actually had Three people ask the same question because they listen to when you talked about the answer their question, but they couldn't give a shit. When you answer the same question and people a lot of people there will be people that listen to everything intently and now looks so strangely at that's the second person that asked it going. Did you not just listen to Fred asked the same question, I've had that many many times, but
okay. you know, a lot of people, when you go to a rules do rules of golf Workshop, if you can get your participant, your the audience, to remember three things, three rules of golf changes, you know, you can't touch sand in a bunker near your ball but outside of that area, you might be able to, you know, like, leaning on your club and you're not going to get Lized.
Yeah, that's a change. Oh, I thought you weren't allowed touch sand at all. Yeah, that's the old me out. There are some areas where it's not as restrictive as it was before, you know, if you move, cause your ball accidentally to move on the putting green, it's not, you know, if you can get them to remember three things, you've done. Well, you've done. Extremely well. They're not going to remember any more than that. So, you know, if you're Buddy. It certainly if you're studying for exam you can go and listen to someone about the rules of
golf but usually you only want to hear the answers to your questions and that's why studying for the rules of golf and just go do your own questions and exams and work out the answers. And and then yeah, go and ask experts about the rules, but you're talking about dropping now and you're not the only person who's told me this how important the definitions are So you looking at doing a rules workshop and doing by doing the exam and learning and people if
people are interested, they really should start reading through the definitions. Yes. How incredibly critical layer to the rules. Yes. If I'm teaching someone like one-on-one coaching. I would spend as long as it takes to go through the definitions and reiterate the definitions and all they need. I said, you know, rules, wonderful, 24, basically processes, but you need to know the language of the rules, which is in the definitions and I have
no idea why they put the definitions at the back of the book. But if you just use your smartphone, it's just Category now, sorry, it's not real yet the back but the deaf. You can't, you can't read 1224 without knowing what the definitions are. Just mean almost almost every sentence. Almost every sentence, not quite all. But so many sentences have a word from a definition. Yeah. And the difference that's how critical they are. Yeah. Yeah. If it doesn't have a word.
It doesn't have a word that's defined in the definitions in that sentence and it's probably Superfluous because the 1224 is the process that you, the player is going to go through. And so, you know, even every sentence that has ball always and the definitely, what is it bull? What is a whole was a penalty area? What is dropping? What's a movie theoria? Bubbling, lava thing, wrong ball, wrong place.
It's so important to know the definitions. And If you know the people are going to pick up on when we write these questions you know those little things and that's fine that's how we learn. We don't want to teach anyone the wrong thing but at the same time you better try and connect the rules of golf with the English language and just help people learn even a little bit. If they watch the video then
hopefully that would help them. The answer. I've got one more Community question for you is certainly plenty more but seeing up to 105 now but another one was Ross, being caught with 15 clubs, so he's already played nine holes, you've got to the practice grown halfway between your ninth grade and tenth team. Realize our got a bit of a wait here, probably gonna get a little bit of a practice stuff. Anyways, just talking and someone goes all these new sticks. You got here Ross and he got 15 of them and of course, other people here. And what's up, Henry? I think 99% of people would
know. That is a Don't-ee. I did not 99% of people wouldn't know specifically what that penalty is but they know what's wrong. So I was one of those situations where it's not obvious to people what the penalty is but they know it's a penalty. So let's talk about mmm. Well, it is quite a strange. I would actually consider it a strange, it makes sense, but then I'm probably biased, but I think it would was quite a strange penalty. So the penalty is in stroke. Play that you get a two-stroke penalty for every hole that it
happened with a maximum of four strokes. So in a stroke around you, you're thinking okay, that's fine. My 90 now becomes a 94. That's easy, you know and then you just take your handicap off after that and you get your net. But what about? In-app are around. You know, my does your - to now became minus 6. No, that's not, that's not how it works. You know, because that
potentially could be for lost holes. Okay? Well - to become a minus minus 4. Well, possibly. But no, that's it. And that's why I think it's strange. That's probably where I would land. I would go. Okay, you just - to, for me score, you - four-stroke most four points from your stableford, or yet add four shots on to your stroke, but the ways they've gone out. Is you add the two penalty Strokes. Times two penalty Strokes to the first and second holes.
And so you're right. I think 99% of people wouldn't know that penalty. And so if you had birdies at the first two holes, you've now had two bogeys. If you've had two bogeys, you've now had two triple bogeys again in the stroke round. It's not going to mean any difference, the stableford round. You might have had three points in their head on both holes. You've been there have one point, but if you've had a wife on both wires, mmm, you still had a white, a white goes to a
what, you know, and wipe in for people that don't know that colloquial term is zero points. So if you had zero points, you, you add two shots to your score and you're still Zero points. So, it's kind of it's actually almost beneficial. I'm not saying go out there with 15 points. Hope you don't get caught because that's disqualification. But you know, if if it happens and you've had a bad to First holes then yeah then you get that penalty for the first for
the first two and which might not make any difference at all. And it's interesting that Ross could be going, hang on, I actually haven't used that club. I've got it was in there having used to but of course, that counts for nothing. Yes, yes, good point. Exam. One answer or what if he hasn't used it? Well, well, I was one of the questions. The answers we putted. Well was it isn't your thing? And I think someone did a success. Okay? And one more thing I'd like to ask you is if Ross is just about to tee off and goes our because we know, you know, what he does for his business and the like
and he's got a few extra clubs in there and he goes actually I've got 15 clubs in here. I didn't mean to have this one in. I'm going to I'm I can't I don't have time to go back to the car but I'd like to take this out of play. Heck and Ross do that without leaving on the First Tee and picking it up for hours later or not, picking up that someone took it. Yeah, well, I mean, he must take the club out of play, must take it out of play and there's ways. They suggest turning it upside down, that kind of thing. But if it's a big driver here,
that might be a little bit hard to turn upside down your bag. Simply you must simply announce it, and I think, My friend, my friend, Jerry had a similar, had a situation in a college and it was on it was only a podcast as bit. He never says ago in Fraser and I co-hosted Weiland and Jerry came on. And he was saying how this college player had this situation, he's going to have to
comment and tell me that I'm wrong but and the situation but he didn't declare the other club out of play. So And who's actually disqualified. Because not only your find out but you also have to declare club or clubs out of Play. It is part of that, you know, that rule you can't just continue on even though you found out about it. So because people want to know or we need to know which club of the 15 or 16 or 18, which clubs
you're not going to use for the rest of the round even if you haven't used one, That point we need to know which ones are definitely not going to use. So, You need to make that declaration. It's only a declaration of what it's an announcement to your other players. Yeah. Whatever your mark or the others and just let them know Silly me. I've got this extra wage guys. I'm not going to use it today. Yeah just like making an announcement for a provisional boom.
Someone else not needs to hear. You can't just mother it to yourself, right? Yes, Rory. Oh yeah. Yeah, Rory's car think, I've actually had this situation. Where do we find the keys? Don't remember. But I definitely had something like this and you know, if It's the same as like a golf cart excetera. Can I set this thing up like he?
And then you can go for explain the differences between movable and immovable. So it is in the Valero Texas open. It was the first round, the 17th hole, a drivable, par 4. And Rory, is almost gone pin-high the right. And his ball has come to rest underneath a motor vehicle, a car, which is there as part of some sponsorship, just sitting there, it's not going. Way. And so it's sitting on their income, like a stroke at it. So if you want to talk about his options with regards to whether that's considered a movable or
immovable and what happens then please? Yeah, so it's a movable obstruction. The car is movable. You can get in there, turn it on Drive Away movable obstruction obstruction because it's artificial. This Will's goes back to the definitions instruction because it's out of Fishel movable. Because there's a way of moving. I mean even if you put it in, neutral took the break off, you could push it out of the way now, because no one was there the keys weren't there?
That makes it a little bit hard. You know, even if you got 10 guys pushing it because the brakes on the wheels, aren't going to turn, it's going to be a little bit difficult. So now it becomes an immovable obstruction and in your course your course to or my course, it would be animu and immovable obstruction, the only Raising it becomes a temporary immovable obstruction. On the PGA tour is because they have the local rule in place adopted at the adopted.
The local rule. How many clubs have adopted a local rule for temporary in move or obstructions not many to? Yeah. That's right. So then you can't just find, you can't just go oh well it's a temporary removal. You know, if this had a pending your club and you It's near the maintenance, share than someone's parked at there and they're off cutting grass. You can't just say, ought to tempering temporary removal function. If they haven't adopted that local rule, if you wanted to play two balls, possibly the
committee. Could have a look at that situation. But again, you adopting a local rule after the fact. So that would be, that wouldn't be right? So it becomes a movable truck. And you could take the light from it under 16.1, but you wouldn't be able to get line-of-sight relief and the 16.1 then might be bad for the trainee who left his Pajero out
there or something like that. If you've don't get free relief from you, then you hit that had a knife shot straight into his windscreen but he probably should the park it there in the first one. But because DJ tour and most of us have adopted a ti0 like rule, they can go over and say Well, that's Not supposed to be there, it's an immovable production. That's not supposed to be there. During the course not like a toilet block, which is permanent. So now becomes a temporary and move obstruction.
So, Rory was able to get line of sight in line of play because his line of play in his line of sight, they're virtually the same thing. He was able to get relief for that. Now, the edge of the car, It's not the age of the ti o, so the age of the car plus a club, length is the age of the ti 0 and then from there you get your relief area. Okay so it's the object.
Plus a club length. Either side is the ti 0 and then you get a club length from that edge, and that's your relief area on an equidistant Arc. So if it's 50 meters from the to the flag, it's 50 meters to the flag at this point. It's a club length being you get that further comlink. So, Rory nearly nearly hold that shot, although it didn't really help him. I think he missed the cut and that's all Oh good. Yeah, yeah, I don't know if
you've been up in Queensland. I don't think you saw this. That happened on It's Tuesday. They must happened. Maybe Saturday. Yeah, it was a, I need to do a thing. I do is either second round or third round. Oh no. It was first round. It was on Friday. And Dylan for tally, ball came to rest under a tree. Now, it's a little bit hazy and I needed look really look at the footage but it's a little bit hazy as to whether his ball was
in an abnormal course condition and animal whole or not and he was arguing the point. Well, I have it interference with an abnormal course condition. With the animal whole, I should get free relief and the referee was it sounded a bit interesting? But the referee was going along the lines of. Well, you can't play the shot. Even if the ball was in the hole so you wouldn't get free relief and you're going to have to take
line of play. Yeah. You're going to have to take an unplayable and they took line of play in there, whatever. But you know, people ask me or if it's down in the hole, of course, you're not going to be able to hit it, so like a reasonable strike. So how you know? No one's going to be able to hit and make a reasonable stroke of the ball. That is in a hole. So, how would you Get free really. Well, if the bow is underground,
then it's the entrance to the hull. That's where the bull the location for the ball. Is effectively went underground to determine your nearest point of complete relief and thus, your relief area. So it's underground. You don't take it from where it is on the ground. You take it from where the entrance to the hole and and with work it out from from there, if it's not underground, then you just work it out from
where is located and it's not underground and work at India's point of complete relief. Now, those locations the entrance, and when it's not underground, if you have a reasonable stroke and it's just the adhan animal, whole, that's stopping you from making a stroke, then, You don't get when you do get free. Like, so it's just the animal holds make stopping you from making a reasonable stroke. You do get free relief. Where is it?
Whereas, if it's the tree or a bush that's stopping you from making a reasonable stroke, then you wouldn't get free relief even though your ball is in this abnormal condition. So you know I it's a bit interested. It was about hazy as to what actually where the ball actually was located on it. I actually think we see it but I have to review the footage and then hopefully pop out a video of that one. So he was denied relief, he was denied belief in had to take an unplayable and animal whole
would be one of those definitions as well but people can really see them. Yeah. And what it actually specifically means. Yeah. And where it stops and starts where does an animal whole stop and start? And what it includes. Yeah, exactly exactly. Oh, good guy. So any other community questions you want to chat about or any other situations to. It's probably a few Community questions, but it's been good to
get the engagement back and we're pumping them out regularly and getting a lot of people vote and comment. And of course, some of them are a bit sort of hasn't been a lot of middle ground. It's either 75%, get it right. Or 25% get a ride, a lot of me 20 grand. So they're all that's something anyway. Yeah, that's few Community questions were going through the extra clubs, the dropping and what that definition means, the original and provisional ball and whether you should identify
what your provisional ball is before you play it and Tyson hit again of bounds and dropping, he shouldn't be. But whether that's an option of him, dropping over weenie, he's more went out. Yeah, we spoke about Rory would Again, we talked about movable and immovable obstructions and guess what? They have their own definitions. Yes. And we can find out exactly what a movable obstruction is and the ease of moving it and not damaging it or the course and time and all that sort of stuff. So that's why it's so important people read up on what those definitions are. Yes. Absolutely. And of course we know that sorry
I was just like as we know movable and immovable obstructions are covered on completely different rules. Yes. Yeah it's important to understand the difference between them. Yeah. Absolutely. The definition in the the process is under a rule. so, do you care coming to the end of the episode 60? You have a golf rules question of the week as we time. Could I typed it up almost home? Absolutely denies the me. You know like that listening to the Milan golf podcast.
I was like I'm lucky to have stir because I just rolled out of bed and I was like I either do a podcast yet. We haven't done one in a week or so and yet here you are. Hey, you give, yeah, you've been busier than me. You've been up for two hours. You've got everything structured for me. Well, I caught this question out. You talkin about how organized I talk this out. Literally minutes as I set then
this desk minutes before we started thinking I probably need to get a question because you're going to do one last time but didn't enough. But I'll just write one just in case and I'll have it for next time in case you had one so. Well that's right. I was going to drink going. I forgot what it was. Okay, I'm ready to go, right? So you can't get out to, okay? Golf rules question of the week, number 60. Paul Ross. Again, on the closing 18 hole at one bad Hills Ross's Drive comes to rest near out of bounds. However, it does remain within
the general area when taking his stance to play his next stroke. He stands on a concrete pipe embedded in the ground, which lies outside. The course Foundry, but is Really interfering with him for a reasonable stroke. What are Ross's options do take any relief, right? So roses balls in bounds but he standing on a artificial object, that is outside the boundary and we wonder if he gets a what
types of relief and you don't know what everyone's talking about. Absolutely. Is he allowed to proceed under? He can play the balls. Laws. It's a free hand, it's an easy area for your answer. It's amazed you want easy option. So get that one off the table so what other relief options? It can only act like real relief. Options are there for Ross whether it's free or penalty, what are his options? Fantastic. Well, thank you very much for co-hosting with me for episode 60 Stewart, always a pleasure.
Thank you really, really enjoyed it. And have a safe drive home with the family. So back to Melbourne, is it We're leaving. Correct and two days or so. Yeah, two-day drive. That kind of yeah. Yeah, make sure you rug out because it's cold in here. Okay, will do. Thank you everyone for tuning in and we'll be back soon with 61
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...