LIV Golf Update | THE GRQ PODCAST EP70 I had the pleasure of applying my craft to the LIV Golf Bangkok and LIV Golf Jeddah events recently. Whilst there were too many rulings handed out, the weather conditions played a big part in how the tournament was shaped. Marcela marks her ball six inches from the 18th hole at Wombat Hills Golf Club, her last hole of the day, and then she watches the other players in her group finish out the hole. Then Marcela gets distracted, picks up her marker, walks off and goes and has a drink in the clubhouse. She is completing her scorecard and she asks her group 'What did I have on the 18th hole', and they couldn't come up with an answer. So what did Marcela score on the 18th hole, and what is the procedure if a score hasn't yet been recorded? Stuart's clubland examples pop up again.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hi everyone. Go first questions, podcast episode 70 on Blakey joined with joined with me. Joined joined by me joined by me. Joined by. I don't even know if that's all right. I've lost my words tonight. Anyway, joined by Stuart McPhee from Stuart. Thank you for that very kind introduction. Just blurting out stupid words, they can't even remember how to speak English. Some might say that I never did
now getting into episode 70 We have the golfers question of the week. Thanks Mikey. So the GI Q 0, TW 4 episode, 69 phrase has praised his tee shot, right on the fourth hole at one bed Hills and his ball comes to rest in thick grass and bushes. Fraser decides to take unplayable ball relief. However, lateral relief is equally bad, and he doesn't want to go back 240 meters to the T. So drops drops back on the line into a clearing in a penalty
area. Unfortunately, once it comes to rest in the relief area, it is unplayable again. As it is sitting in a Double Hull assuming phrase. I cannot play the ball from where it now lies. What are all of these options to make his next stroke? Well unfortunately for him. His only option is to go back to the tee. So there's a few rules at play here. Firstly is original ball is gone into thick bushes and he's decided to take unplayable or relief. And as we know you have three options in the general area to do that electoral back of the
line or previous place play. Jade and he's gone back on the line into a penalty right now. When you drop under unplayable you can drop it anywhere in the course for an unplayable ball relief, you can drop under a wrong green into a no play zone. You can drop into a bunker you can drop also into a penalty area, which is what phrase a has done. However, unfortunately for him, once it came to rest, it just sucked into a little animal hole. And an animal hole is one of our for abnormal course, conditions and Rule, 17.3 says that you cannot get relief.
From an abnormal course condition when your balls in a penalty area, that's what Fraser has and you can't take an unplayable again because you can't take an unplayable in a penalty area. So his only option is to take penalty area relief. Now, being a red penalty area, he's got three options, he can go, excuse me, can go lateral back on the line, all previous Place. Played however, the problem is there is no point of entry, how we entered into that penalty area penalty area because you didn't make a stroke to Move into that penalty area.
He's picked his ball up. Take an unplayable and dropped it in the relief area. So there's an interpretation under rule. 19 point to that says, because he didn't make a stroke to get into the penalty area, there's no point of entry, there's no reference point to take either back on the line or lateral relief from that penalty area. Meaning, his only option is to go to previous Place, played the last place. He made a physical stroke at the ball. Was back in the teen area. So that's where, in fact, he's only option is to make his next
stroke. There you go. Oh that was a fantastic question. Wasn't it Stewart, great answer that one. Thank you. Very interesting. So I wonder how many people got that one, right? now, if it says 70, What am I talking about? I'm talking about going to leave working live, golf Went to went to Bangkok. I need to win to Jeddah two weeks. In a row. They've golf, obviously, 48 players, 54, holes Bangkok are
starting time was to. No, it wasn't. It was Okay. It was 10:00 10:00 in the morning was Bangkok. 10:00 in the morning because he's finished around three of caught the bus at four. And one day, it took an hour to get back from this. New course, Stone Hills. Back to the Shangri-La in Bangkok. And another day Friday, it took
two and a half hours. It was about an 8 km trip. Yeah. It was hoping in Bangkok traffic traffic in Bangkok is some of the worst and, you know, You've got three lines but somehow they turn it into five Lanes, they have people racing down the shoulders. And you just like, what what's the use? You know, they are good at getting out of the way of the ambulance if the ambulance comes but you know if the NF the
ambulance had the hard shoulder and probably go a lot faster but there was one experience Bangkok terrible traffic but Golf Course amazing new golf course. He just be conditioned and macula Another thing touch never been applied before. Yeah, definitely every blade of grass. Was it hardly been touched hardly? So it was fantastic. He built it as a championship
course, for tournaments like this, and there's nothing else that Rivals. It's just so pure the designs fairly good. Yeah, it's pretty good design. It was more. The condition of the course. That was just So so so good and we're not going to be back there next year. I don't think, I think they're going to Singapore and then we might be back there in two years time, but it was, you know, it's fantastic.
The facilities or practice facilities? Amazing, I was on holds 7 and 11 and 12. Not too much going on there. I wrote and I wrote down all my rulings. I don't even think I had a ruling on Sunday. Well, Though, we had their winter storm and that was one of the scariest things I've ever been in. But I think I ended up with about 56 rulings over the day and pace of play with pretty good. So yeah, it was, it was not too bad. I was watching on Sunday live
when that lightning the crack through the broadcast was incredible and when the camera was right behind us and Johnson preparing to make his next stroke and they've heard and they've almost done. Just a bit shaken by it and very quickly. They were about to, they'll ready to mark their ball, bring the Marquis ball and sure enough very quickly. The siren went off, and they knew they were very, very quickly. It was incredible. Yeah. I was one of the closest to I guess he was, uh, Nate. And I was just down the other side of whole sex, and then
there would have been someone at the back of back of 8 and someone close 9. So wouldn't have been even being the closest? I would have been the third closest. But so I think my, it's so funny. You know, we use the horns so much now because the shotgun start is the what they call the Claxton, but we just call it a air horn. But the, we use them so much and they break so easily. No, we I had one and it just popped off the back of it popped
off. So if it pops off you Stuffed. But then you can put it back on and then you try to hold it. And, you know, you try and do one that mediate like long one which brings me to another point. I find it very weird. That one is an immediate suspension. I don't find that weird. I think that's normal to is a restart and three is a normal suspension. It's the one in the three. Okay but it's the to that gets me because what if you're you
know, what if people were like was that one? Or was that too? Is that three? And there's a big difference between the 1 and 2 and the 2 and the 3. Hmm But yeah, we use them a lot and we had different ones in you. Get different ones in Jeddah. It's not like you're just testing them out all the time because they believe loud. But the one in Jeddah that slightly popped off slightly differently. But yeah, it was, it was a good. It was a great torment. Anything unique in Bangkok about
the course, set up. Anything unique, rules wise across very often. It rained a lot, but it was mainly just the weather there. Well, we had a weather guy there and he had to look at the weather every minute, basically, because as they normally do, but just stuff can happen so quickly in In court because of the Heat and it just creates this. Yeah that's right. And then you know, he was looking at that and he was on the radio telling us going Okay,
it's just on the other side of the river. It's on the other side of the river. We've got something else coming soon, but this one should be just going around us, shouldn't be too bad and then all of a sudden bang and that was like what the hell was that? It was, it was so scary in the lightning as well. We're seeing lightning no, and Dustin Johnson's. The first thing he did when he heard it was put the umbrella. Well that's not the smartest thing to do but it started out really high but I think everyone everyone did that like that. That was It is it's not the rain, you just like, it's the
lightning that was going to kill you, but that was the first thing that we all did and I was I was underneath a tree and then everyone is laughing at me. But then the Thai people, they just walk around. They weren't too concerned concerned. They're just just walking around, you know, and all the white people were just running for cover. It was scared out of their minds and in the end of the fine, but there was about an hour and a half to two hour delay. Bye. And luckily we got them all back out there and what we thought was going to be because we teed off earlier and our earlier
because of that what we thought was going to be a terrific finish ended up being the same finish. Again. I think it was a 3:30 or something like that finish. So so that was quite over as well. Played that we teed off a little bit earlier but yeah. So that was that was Bangkok, was there anything? There wasn't really anything that you know, was that different, you know? With these u.s. rules guys. You know that done so many tournaments sits only tournaments up that worked with
so many people. You know, the bigger organizations around the world that they all do it. So similar these days that are already knew a lot of, a lot of what they already dead and how they already set causes up and stuff like that. But we had some interesting. However, most interesting thing was, As the trees, the trees have been transported and transplanted. Oh, I saw them all the fraying, all the support. I think there was only one tree on the course that hadn't been
change. Blindness was that was a big Oak near hole 17 and every so every other one had been put into the dug into the ground, and then they had the wooden supports around them and we ended up making the whole tree and the supports. A state tree, which is common in Australia. I guess most of our trees are young and we're trying to protect the tree rather than particular golfer. But in this case, they were more
protecting the golfer because they didn't want someone to get a relief from a steak over here, but no relief from the steak over here. But, you know, they still came to play and we still got asked questions about whether they T iOS and we didn't offer t.i. Oh it's a word. It's up to the committee as to what a TI H, but by definition they weren't then. We went to Jeddah and they actually have a couple of Strains scoreboards and we made
them T.I.'s. They're actually permanent scoreboards and we made them T iOS. They were out of the way, so I don't even think anyone near them, but you know, that they're there for the tournament, I guess. So you could say, you could argue that fact. But then we had this light poles around on the back, nine at Royal greens is light poles. And we didn't make the in t.i. eyes, which I agree with, but then one of the other guys is they are. Now, I reckon we should have And a couple of those like that,
another opinion. Yeah, that is it, okay? For you're not here for the You know, and they're not there for the tournament and not it's not like a temporary measure for the team. Like the screens are more. You could argue that just there for the tournament even though they currently live there, thus the lights hours. To me, it's just like a tree and it makes it may. Again, it makes that puts that focus on being more accurate off the team say, I'm sure they weren't in the middle of the VA
where they definitely knew it not the differently when they're in the middle of the rough. Anyway, we'll see what happens. I don't, I don't think we're going back to that one next year, but we could be back there in t0. Actually, I'll be there in February for Asian and Asian Tour event. The way there will be a little bit colder in February. It was 36 degrees every day and now I'm a roof off. Kind of guy with my car lover, roof off slip, under the Rope. But it was so hot.
Even for me we all agreed that we would leave the roots on the carts and it's probably a good thing probably would have been burnt to a crisp but I got the three holes out there on the water again and are on the other side of a road or something because I'm yeah and he really nice. We go underneath the tunnel. Yeah. It's on the other side of the road and Yeah, I got those three holes and just the wind. Was constant and even for
errors, only five hours. It's not their dainty hours but there's only five hours but still, you know, my face felt like they've been baked in an oven afterwards. Did you put forward to the committee? The idea that it should become a red penalty area? All that water, but they like that, it already is the Red Sea. That's why she I did. I think I did use that joke. as I think it was something along the lines of I'm glad it's in Gladstone. I'd say you made it was the
Yellow Sea and something like that. So we're done Dad. I've got some good mileage of it and I think I only used it once. Okay then I didn't even realize it when you said but I think one of the one of the guys who they are. You know you work with a worker couple of guys and one of them is sort of an older gentleman. I absolutely bout. We just got on like a house on fire even though he understand me half the time because I need
to really pronunce pronounce my words. That could really understands that what why'd you say? Why'd you say that? We got on like a house on fire. and, Yeah. AIDS. Yeah. Has a has a high faith in Jesus and God. And I was like, hey, I just, I
think I just saw in Moses out there. Or something like that. It was like It was like someone hit the ball. I was like is someone had their ball like way left and he walked towards the water and part of the water so that he could play his shot off the beach. Yeah that joke flopped as well. Anyway it was it was really
cool. It was really good is great to be there. Thanks a lot because of the 36 degrees of probably Talk to me a little bit more but you know when we had 144 remember how many we had in? See an international. Maybe they only had 120 they are a lot more people hitting it. Wider I these these 48 players are pretty good and so they keep pretty a lot closer to the be a lot closer to the green. So we didn't have as many rules issues. But yeah, it was it was fun on
the way raising the number of rules issues grow exponentially. When you hit off the Short Grass. Yeah. Yeah. When when there's more people and there's more people that could miss the cut and certainly grows. But yes, I didn't know think some of the rulings that we had you know if It was sort of interesting if you win in the Saint, in a footprint is no free relief. That's common sort of thing. But if you went into a deep
water wheel Mark in the sand, even we were prepared to give free relief for that. So there was just a couple of the things that we sort of talked about. I reckon my only rulings were are given as ball came to rest on a piece of Of plastic like literally a piece of rubbish and he said, is there peace black? I said, yeah, it is. And he goes, I can I put it up? Can I pick out the place?
You can just put the ball back down there. He probably asked, wasn't even thinking about it looked like he's going to play it and I was like, oh, you can move that he goes. Yeah, but what if I caused the Baltimore? It's a movable obstruction, you know, it's artificial. You be fun because I got was like, yeah, no you find and then he moves it and it doesn't move as. Next question was What if I What if I am addressing it and the ball moves?
I like well if you cause it to move its a penalty, if you don't cause it to move, then you're fine. Okay, you know, just as normal. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We had a couple of weird situations because is this a lot of pipe around the trees in the sand. You know, lot of irrigation prior. Yes. I've seen them yet and so it's a it is a weird situation because we don't give relief to 4 star. But we do give relief of bow and
arrow virginity of intended swing. But it's movable and this you can't move it. So I can move this part but then it stops moving and you're swinging and hitting it. Then we're going to give you free relief under an immovable obstruction. That's an interesting one because it's just everywhere. Yeah, yeah. So it's not surprising when someone calls you in, for that. But yeah they say the two weeks. Yeah they sort of a sort of takes ages but then all of a
sudden it's flown past as well. So and then you back on a plane and I think I was nine hours to from Jeddah to Kuala, Lumpur was nine hours and then Kuala Lumpur and Melvin was about eight or so yeah, just under nine, seven and a half. So I was back on Tuesday night and started work on. Moon. What a true professional. Yeah. And now I'm exhausted and stuffed. Right.
So you got any, any questions for me? No. But if you had to go through a few Club Lanes, stories, or yes, met her at a club. Lay in store for, you have one or two or, I've got a go from this question of the week, question, but I'm doing good. I've got two very quick Club Lane stories, okay? They're not really. Someone just doing the wrong thing, I will playing foursomes or week, or two ago and We called a three ball. It's a six players.
We have three more. All seams. No, you're three balls being played using pliers or three boys for the definitions three ball Mills. Something different. Okay. So we are six players. Three Partners playing three balls playing foursomes and r on the First Tee, two of them were like, peanut players, and my partner, and to others. And I just said, I'll guys just as a bit of a tip, just the
troop and play sending you on you, the rules, my partner did as well. I said this is a bit of a tip actually. Don't tell anyone elses, but you can actually change balls throughout most of the play, the whole. And they said, no, no foursomes, you can't do that. I said, no. But remember we have the preferred lies local rule in place. I didn't throw them with the. I didn't try the E3 their way, but I just said, remember we have preferred lies in the general area? I said, so every time you do that, you can actually swap ball until you get to the green. So they're all a bit excited
about the idea that they when it was his turn apply while would Mark, pick that one up and put his own ball into play only. The only comical bit came when they're almost every hole I could hear people talking about it was just before. They're about to hit on to the green. That would go. Hang on whose ball. Do we want to have on the green? Because once we're on the green, we can't swap it. So who's got that next part and all this sort of stuff and it probably cause more issues than I hadn't intended? I was really just trying to help
and so, you know, you can swap but as I said, it became a little bit more complicated when they're talking about here. So if we hit on hidden under the green next, that mean you'll be putting you want to part with your ball instead, so I'll hit your ball on anyway. Yeah, this is you don't bring that stuff up too confusing for was just trying to help anyway. I just, um, yeah, I'm good. There's this be honest. You weren't trying to help you just sort of trying to show, show your rules knowledge or maybe 50/50, Honestly, so whole
15 on the same thing. Foursomes a guys are having trouble in a greenside bunker where the point where they're going built into the face rolls bag swap over next guy, goes in belt into the phase comes back and swabbo and the rest of us is done and go. No one enjoys watching that she's I think that I think that a nine or ten but no one enjoys that whether you're watching it or of obviously involved and at one of their shots eventually just went smack into the face. In the manga and becoming bidded.
And I was watching and I immediately went over and said guys that's now no longer in the bunker, you can get free relief. Either side you got a tiny sliver you can drop and the guy just turned to me and said I would have had no idea what you've done. It had you not said that I would have had no idea what to do. So makes you think what does happen if someone can't definitively go over? And say, guys, this is a the situation. What do people do in that situation?
Yeah, yeah. He was very, he was very honest. Immediately said I would have had no idea what to do. Then they just they just hit it out or they just somehow take a drop back in the bunker, or maybe they do play it as it lies, and just absolutely give it everything. I actually saw a photo that reminds you just today because they had old Always been in a club and someone showed me a photo that they had embedded their ball in the 10th, the greenside bunker on the 10th, and it was too hard for me to
tell whether it was in sand or in mud. but, It had it was so far under that had a lip over the top of it. so, I was like, well, if it's in sand in the bunker, And you take an unplayable, can you take an unplayable by dropping it up above where the ball is? Which I don't see why not. I need to read more into it and then that would be a two-shot
penalty. Oh, could you dropping it outside the bunker? She's dropping it back behind. The back behind the ball. Back on a line from the flag back. All of it out right now. And on Angela 3 will get up. But it does say behind the bunker doesn't. Does it say that though just exactly the line is that behind? What has to be outside the bunker climate, take back on the rely, back on the line relief outside the bunker, that's all. This is, well, the morning
that's three videos would be, that would be allowed above the ball back behind it back on the line. 1, cm. That's right, doesn't say about being on the other side of the boat and that would be a two-shot penalty. So you know, 23, saves a tee shot one. Apply my tape back on the line relief outside the bunker. Under rule 19 point, and then you're putting for bogey, which is now the other point was if it was in this in the mud, not the same and it's actually in the general area and you can go
Above. Yeah. Assuming you have a relief area to drop it. Yeah, that's right. All it does is say refer back to unplayable, under-19 point to be reference point, is a point in the course, chosen by the player that's on the reference line and farther from the hold and the spotted the original ball. Yeah, you've done that by going back to CM, wouldn't object to down if you want. One Club length must not be here. The whole must be might be in
any area of the course. Yeah. And then if you cause a Rolls Into the Bunker and a bit of dropped in the general area, well let's look great girl, what are we Drop? Strike rate. Drop it not knocking and not a peasant life correct? Yeah. Very good. Look at it, the area and see whether I think it's Amador seeing, you know, it could be where sand is intended to be but the mud is drop-down because we've had a lot of rain lately.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. I thought the litmus test was is it touching sand? Definitely, but, you know, those bunkers where it's a real shiny face. Because the wind is blowing the sand away and that's again we're seeing. The suppose should be yeah would still be part of the bunker. So I might actually going to stick a ball and where he had it or just asking for the photo. Probably right. I think we're that's done for
Pub land. We got more and you've got material delivered as well. So there's always material. Yeah. That's right. Yeah, I'm going to get into. I think this is relatively easy but it just popped into my head and I thought stuff at all, ask it. So Stewart finishes. And I was gay Marcela finishes. The I didn't hole at one bed hilts. Sorry. So let's start again. Marcela mock Super Bowl 6
inches. From the 18th hole her last hole of the day. And then she watches her. Other players in her group, finish out the whole in Marcela gets distracted. Picks up her marker. Walks off. And goes and has a drink in the clubhouse. She's in marking her scorecard.
And she goes. I'll what do I have on the 88? And the other ones go. Oh, what did you have on the 18th? So the question is what did Marcella have on the 18th? And or what is the procedure now? As you can tell, as you can tell, that was a off-the-cuff question and I probably should have written it down but I don't believe it Robyn Sullivan blue
in all right? Yeah, that's episode number 70. Hope you got a kick out of that. Now I'm off to Morocco and Egypt. Fantastic very soon. Starting November. So we might record other. Now, the internet is over there, but we might record a podcast, if so, well and Morocco. I know another Egypt, fantastic stand. When we'll get an answer to what Marcela needs to do. Yes, we're not do or not, do how
many shots he's had while she's having shots. Thank you everyone, for listening. And episode seven short one today. So yeah, looking forward to the 71 on bit See you later, Stuart. Fairway to bike.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...