Club Land, Community Questions, and Fans Picking up Golf Balls | THE GRQ PODCAST EP63
58 minAudio
GRQOTW for #63 - Big P tees off on the 2nd at Wombat Hills GC and the ball heads very close to the OB fence. He plays a provisional ball. Big P finds his original ball however it is unplayable and he proceeds to take lateral relief. Big P drops a ball correctly and the ball comes to rest in the relief area .... Big P goes to get a club and when he returns the ball has rolled OB. What does Big P do? SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules. Co-host: Stuart McPhee. GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/. DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE? Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en) OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY https://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestions LISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules #GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode of the golf rules questions podcast.
Welcome to Gulf Rose questions. Podcast number 63 here with Blakey and go for those questions and Stewart and my co-host back again. Putting yourself through this well done, thank you, happy to be here. Welcome aboard, you've been play a lot more golf that I have lately. How's that going? Okay, play to write this morning. We're starting to get back into a bit of form that will good
very windy this morning as you would know. Wow. Just so windy affects the ball so much. But now all good actually, you know, we've had a lot of rain here and the wind actually dries out. The course makes sense. Yeah. And you know, then you start getting, if you don't get rain in between that sort of really Dry wind in start getting summer conditions, pretty quickly that he owes. I was surprised how dry the
course was today, just having had a few days. Windii. No rain. I was really surprised our draw. It was and we are like, first week of August, I know your Club Captain quite well, and he has one of the best at policies and procedures. What is the, you know, off the top of your head, the wind policy at Gardeners room. No, I don't. The the one at Spring Valley that we use is if the there's a
gust of wind at the nearby wind measuring base station, but when did station, which is at moorabbin airport, which is just down the road. If it gas over 70. Two kilometers. Then we must shut the course down for half an hour. Okay, so if it's a gust, it's not a constant 72. It just has to Gus.
Just one really one reading and we have the clothes of course of 30 minutes. And then we haven't had a 72 gust over 30 minutes then we can allow people to go back home and play. Riley, if you're listening and let's do it all myself. No. The wind policy is Gardens run roughly just for interest at around 45 miles an hour. Yeah, just just for interest, I'd be interested to know. So yeah, that is good.
You know how I do km is Miles. I'm not very good. At that, the 5 5 & 8 is exactly the same five my pretty pretty close. Yeah. So then 40 For 50 and 80 for you. So if you go 50, take away 5 and then you have got the ATF to take away. 87572 got Cherry, good. Do you have a quick because you lived in the states for a while? Story checks out. Now, I just know it's one point.
Six zero. Nine. Three level 4 is the conversion commonly when used as 1.61 or 1.6? What about you got? A quick conversion for Celsius and Fahrenheit. I know. But I know there's an obvious one and one involves the number 32 and this. Yeah, I don't know the number, I don't know if top my head. Is it six times nine divided by 6? The number divided tongues 6 / 9 + 32. This is the textbook definition of drag racing.
Yeah, well let's get on to welcome back everyone. That's what we've still got you here. But will it go on to the gospels, question of the week? Number 62? If you want to reread that first year, I will so Fraser has a small Stone located immediately behind his ball, which is lying in a bunker knowing that he can remove loose impediments. In the bunker and after checking with his marker, if he agrees Fraser reaches down to remove it
but upon grabbing the stone, it breaks into many pieces as well as actually a clump of sand, not a stone. And I asked, what is the ruling? And you, and I discuss this situation previously. We know that in a bunker, you can remove loose impediments, you can remove move obstructions and the rules even allow Are you to even touch the sand a little bit in doing that? And there's no penalty for them. We know you can't test the saying you can't contest the condition. You can't touch the sand in a
practice, swing or even your backswing. You can't place the club on the ground before you shot. I believe in this situation, Fraser would get the general penalty because he's touching of that sand has potentially improved one of these conditions affecting the stroke and Rule a covered under rule 12 in the bunkers. But also Point one, I played that cause you find it. You can't remove or press down sand or loose soil. If it improves and the key word being, if it improves one of the
cats, one of the conditions affecting the stroke. So I think Frazier in that situation would incur the general penalty even though he thought it was a stone. Yeah. Unfortunate for Fraser but probably well, can't really check. You just have to get down as quick close as you can and because when I say you can't check, well, if you do check and you Broke. Ya conditions. Also create a potential advantage of the words you use,
and then you pretty much know yourself to the Cross. There, there was a situation with Rory. I think we've covered it earlier episode, but it was a situation with Rory. Rory, McIlroy early on, where he has gone down, thought he had was moving a stone and literally put his Some is four-fingered Iran. This and realize that This was just actually saying they're not rocks and eat at the time, he was penalized because it was
difficult to understand what he was sort of trying to say happened. So the referee on the site to see well, you know, from what the sounds of it you're penalized but then they after the round finished they actually wins call up the USGA and because of that X Change in the rules where there's no penalty. If you touch this and then it's
a bit what I'm trying to say is a bit more lenient these days. So here he'd gone into test that they actually hadn't improved as and they brought that he hadn't improved as y. So, you know, he hadn't picked up the sound, which was difficult are different to what phrases? And so they didn't, they took the penalty away from them. I removed that kind of the and rescinded, and he wanted to poison pen like that. In this case, Fraser has
completely removed it from the area and definitely a potential Advantage occurred. I remember, when you teaching me about this under rule 8, that, I mean, I could have my ball in play and I'm about to play it and I Could walk two or three meters away, and break a branch off a tree. But we know that you can't mean. Do you know Bend or move or break all these things but if it doesn't actually affect my stroke and it doesn't improve one of the conditions I can bake. Tim branches, there's no penalty
for doing that. It's got to be, it's got to be an improvement. They must be as you just said, there must be an improvement maybe because of carrying out those actions. Yeah, I mean if you go along if you hit the ball down the middle of the Fairway and you go along the side of the Fairway and remove every boundary, Like I think you're a prick, but you're not going to get penalized under rule 8 .1. You probably, you know, you probably should be penalized under 1.3 code of conduct as,
you know, so awfully to for your behavior. Hmm, But, you know, going to get stroke penalty under 8.1. No, mmm. So don't do that. So yeah, there we go. Yeah, qot w62. Good, good one there. Now, what have we had lately? What do we process lately on the video square? And the so the only videos since the last podcast was of nearly quarter one that's got quite a lot of views, it's performed
quite well and this was a Vivian shame Evian championship in France. We're on the final round. I can't remember the whole now. Maybe the six hole early on where she's pushed the ball, right? Gone down into the Sort of it a path where the spectators of walking and a woman. Very excited about her souvenir. Just picked it up started to walk on as if nothing had happened and the video is quite funny to watch How I thought it was quite funny how the course Marshall responded. Absolutely, absolutely brilliant.
He wasn't happy but you know you probably know and Spectator went from being very excited about a souvenir to being put back in it. Plus we're back in the box and anyway, so the ruling was, you know, what happens to the ball outside influences. Moved anyway, you can talk about that and also the referees getting together to work out the best estimate of where that ball is moved from. Yeah, well, I think you did my voice over on that one.
So, you know, and and by all accounts, that's why the videos doing a lot better than They're sick of the drunk bearded guys, soon, popping up in them in the corner. That's not true. That's what I know he's going to commentate when they click on the video. So, yeah, but then they share it with their friends when they hear that. They can actually understand what you're saying. Okay. Okay. So, yeah, I mean pretty pretty
good one. Pretty easy, one, that one. I think it most people watching it just going. What the hell is that lady doing who turns up for a golf tournament, and Slade and actually, you know, moves the ball like but you know, that's from us that have been took off towards so, that's it's pretty basic common knowledge, but maybe she was just like, oh, I'll go and have some, I don't even know if she'll ever turn up to the golf. Again, when I've do dealing with the course Marshall, and they,
that marry a lot of people would say, oh, that's good. We don't need the people like that and we need everyone there, but But she just needed some education and what not to do and she found that education by doing the wrong thing first. But yeah, so ball rest, move. Now that this was an interesting thing because she's actually put the ball back. She's replaced the ball. And as she was the one that moved it, she was allowed to replace the ball. But then, I've obviously decided that she didn't through camera
ever at evidence, they decided that she hadn't replaced in the right. And so they used camera evidence to allow Denali to place it in the right spot. Who knows if that actually was the right spot or was the best spot for Nellie, but If they didn't have camera evidence. Well, they're just You know, the person has moved it, put it back in the place that they estimated that they removed it from now. Could you get someone else to come along and get ready to get
the player the corrector when they believed it was correct in the first place? I know I would have found that funny if they had actually said I'll that player that person moved it and didn't put it back in the right spot or how would you know, you know, the only people that would see ball will come to rest if there. camera evidence, but they I guess the fan and in the Marshall does the Marshal go? I'm adamant and Madam. It wasn't in that divot it was
right there sitting up there nicely, I'm not sure. I'm not sure I've ever player came to me and said we have evidence that this was moved. I want to move it back to where I was so moved back to yeah. Move back to where it was. It was more over here. How do you know that? I just don't want to? Light from there. Okay. Who moved it? At person who put it back. Dead person.
And what evidence do you have? That? It wasn't in any other spot. Someone said someone said it wasn't okay. Okay. Well who was that? What was the deal? Can't understand what they're saying it's in French now. Let's yes it happened in Australia. Okay. Well, how how? They had convinced that you that it wasn't in 160, right? Okay, fine. We'll move that. How convincing is 20%. Well, how do you go up?
20 of the see you guys. I'm rambling on. I do just be an interesting situation of the popped up in front of that question without notice. Yeah, so Nellie's still 150 meters away. All comes to rest spectator. Picks it up course Marshall blah, blah blah blah. Put it Back. The person puts it back, where they think it came from, where she picked it up from Marshalls thinking. That's not where she picked it up from, you know, you need to be over there further. So the Marshal now, picks it up
and moves it, say 20 cm away, then nearly rocks up, spectator has disappeared. Nowhere to be seen of course Marshall goes. I'm really sorry. Just letting you know, you'll find out probably later but, you know, ball going to respect. I picked it up. She put it back, it wasn't in the right spot. So, I actually moved it. A wonder what would then happen if you know Nelly has. Now been advised that in fact, the person who moved it, didn't put it back on the sport because
we know about, who can replace the ball back on the spot. Certainly, if it's been moved down, it by any outside influence, and that course, Marshalls, not one of those people. Tom just pretty would that put Nelly then in a difficult position where she not knowing the rule and you guys all thank you, you've corrected that for me. Thanks very much. I appreciate it. So it's good now, is it? And the course module goes. Yeah, you know, that's definitely where it came from. Okay, thanks. And obviously plays a shot with the committee afterwards. Go, sorry, Nelly. That's a one-stroke penalty.
No, there wouldn't that? Tea shop, healing. I thought because of being replaced by someone other than the two people allowed to replace it, anyone will find it out but we'll have they placed it in the wrong spot. Now I've actually gone back in the right spot. There just hasn't been replaced by one of the people allowed to replace it. Well. Anyway, the question, whether it's one or two with the would mainly be in trouble. They potentially firstly, is it
was it on camera, did they get on camera, you know, in your hypothetical that? Yes. Yeah. Killing hypothetical nice. It was just, you know, cause Marshals come, let's not where she picked it up from Spectators runoff embarrassed cause module, just picks it up and moves it to which he believes. It's been picked up from tells Nelly as the only now arrived to see. No, look just saying, you know, someone pick up your ball, they put it down, that's not where it That's not where it was. So I actually just moved it back to where it was. You're good to go. Now, the guys are, thanks very much, appreciate that.
But of course, as I said, the only hasn't replaced it nor has the person in the outside influence, or the person who moved it hasn't replaced it either. Someone else has replaced it. You know, I know that's a question with that notice, but I'm just wondering if Natalie would be peeing later for the balls being replaced by someone, not allowed to replace it. That would be under 14.2. Yeah, well, maybe not there is an interesting question because that would be, very unfortunate for nearly, you know, working with a volunteer, not a referee, but just a volunteer, they're
just doing their best and helping out and who must replace pawns looking 14.2 be. Now if the player plays a ball that was replaced by someone not allowed to do so the player gets one penalty stroke. So if the because if the spectator is put it back and where they think it was Where are you from? Hat.
That would be archived because I didn't know they've just used best out of the estimated is to make wear them. So then when the put it back into that spot it's actually back in the correct spot when of course Marshall moves at in my hypothetical. Yeah, no, no. The when The Spectator puts effective, put it back in the correct spot because they've estimated it. Hmm. But the course Marshall then has moved it. So I know that that wasn't where it was. It was just over there. So, Clay. And this is what I was trying to
what I was. I've also you're leaning towards buying from a wrong place where I'm leaning towards it's actually now in the correct spot. It's just been replaced by someone inside. Yeah. Because because the wrong the where the fan replaced it too, is that now the right spot. Because they have estimated where Corrections are red and someone else has come in, whether it be the cause Marshall or the referee, using the video evidence that have gone. Well, that's not right at all. So now it's back in the right spot and then that Marshall, may be moving it back to the
original spot. Kind of is now. Is it an hour has actually now? Wrong spot. There's a good hypothetical for you. I mean, and surely you The rows are penalizing. I get it. But surely you can penalize. I think, I think of that case. And that's possibly what, you know, why, you call it a referee. And then once the referee came in and found out, how would we rule on that situation? I go. Okay, so what happened? The put it back and then I would
say the Marshal will how good in the estimate? Was it where they put it back on? It was only about 10 centimeters. Hmm, I'd say well, That's the new spot. We have to replace the there and use of course Marshall put it back or Nelly could put it back in. You know, that needs to be where it is. Or, you know, the cause Marshall goes, no, no, they just placed it over here, but that's 10 meters away. And so well, that's not that's not a good estimate show me where it actually becomes moved and now we can put it back into
that spot. Wow. I mean, you know, if a fan moves it and then puts it down and no one sees it. No, no one knows what happened and now they want one and now they're wiser than none. The wiser is no penalty, correct. But this is an interesting situation. Where was the ball back in play, When the fan, put it back, where they know that they had moved and then The marshals actually
moved it until wrong spot, right? If we know and we know if not known is the maiden but maybe it was known just not what the spectator but that information Alone by known by who. Well, the course manager might have seen it all goes. I know exactly where that ball was and where you put it down. So I do know where it is and you therefore, you're not entitled to use an S because it's known. Anyway, that's why the committee is there. That's why we have committee at tournaments to discuss all that. You in this really hope that the player wasn't penalized, but
there might be scope for them to be penalized son for the committee to make just make a decision on that one and whatever decision they make is final. And, you know, we got to go after the facts in that case, I don't think that thinking doing too much wrong. If you side one way or the other just makes you just try not to penalize the player for something. When they have had no downtime that control Yeah. And no action. And I think that's why players calling referees as often as I do, because it provides a me,
literally a get-out-of-jail-free card. Yeah. And that item that blanket coverage. There's true. And also Yeah, it unlike your golf and my goal, you know, there are all these variables and you know, of the fan, the fan. And they've got all these hands and arms and legs and bags, and everything can happen when it comes to things. So, an interesting thing
question without next so quick, you know, anyway, Let's move on. Discussion rules are written for stroke and Matt obviously, this is just something like this. It's occurred to me today. So I played in a park competition this morning and you, and I have run afoul of this. Just in the last week or two. The last one, or two, three podcasts, where the rules are very much written towards stroke play. So if you get matched us for a
second instant, in other words, you can't every shot your whole layout, you know, you complete the whole, every single hole. Ole and what we lose sight of sometimes is the fact that there are other forms of individual stroke-play there is, you know, stableford and parle / bogey, maximum score in the like. And so when we, you know, the this I came a run afoul of this last week when I talked about playing a wrong ball holding our that Ron ball teeing off on the next hole. And you said, what if it's stable fit and I'm going on what still disqualification? Well, no, it's not
disqualification because you keep playing, and I've just sort of lost sight just for a second. The fact that when you From the whole because you don't have to hold out when you're playing these other forms of stroke play. And I, as I said, I just find that and the one you were was the excess clubs having 15 clubs in your bag. We think, you know, General penalty for the first two holes maximum first, two holes. But of course, in stable for, that's not the case at all. It's just easy to lose sight of. I think the rules are very much written for your playing stroke. Every shot counts. You got a hole at every single
hole, but there are some variations are some exceptions. If only the whole out is one of them and I run and I run a foul of that just last week when you asked me about playing the wrong ball and teeing off on the next hole holding out with that wrong, we'll ya mean they solve it, it doesn't matter. If only is its tail for the power. Certainly in Australia, New Zealand, the most-played forms of the game. And and at why any type of match
play competition going on Spring Valley at the moment. It's just starting first round of next play this week and this is basically the only the club's only single match play handicap match. Play being you've got the club chance which is off the stick match play and then you've got a fallible match play as well, and then there's pain. X. So, the basically four forms of match play that you can play at the club, but most Tuesdays
Wednesdays, Thursdays, even mundane Friday with their Ball Camp. So they Sunday mostly just stay with it. Has chucked in them and yeah, our members don't even like power either. So, it's experience, how is the match play against the course online? Hmm. But the course always seems to win, so give me give you another example. So live in point to, is deliberately stopping or deflecting a ball in motion.
So if I'm heading towards the hole and it goes past a hole and you stop it. One normal circumstances 11.2 says, it's General penalty. You fear every day the week is, you're deliberately stopped my ball in motion but of course you playing stableford and I'm putting for one point. So it's all. I'm going to get a point where I'm going to wipe the whole and you stopped my part. There is no penalty, but the rules, don't say that the rules, say two-stroke penalty, then you go to, you know, rule 21.1, which is stable for. There's exception to the rule, eleven point two, which so there's different, as I said the
rules are written for stroke every every shot counts whole at every single time. But and that's where as I said, I've just write a grant of power that last week. yeah, and we had Yeah, that's that's the open part is going to say. We headed and horrible Community question, which we're going to talk about, but that was that was a match, blue ones match but but you know there are I'm starving. We should do more of the community questions around horrible importance because I mean that's that's how I learn.
I'm looking at it going, is that right? Okay, because I looked at that and I was like and I was like When I was making that question, I got it wrong and I was like, wow. Okay but we'll get to the second now. Clubland story that friends do. Well, I know you make a note of that. No I can't not gonna do it, I'm massive Loveland story. I do love clubland stories and and I know you love, you know,
stories from complain. So this happened this morning and you know, this is to be perfectly open. This is one of the things I really enjoy that soon as I walked into the members. Lounge this afternoon after my round. I've got three guys fourth joined. Three guys go. You know the rules. Can you help us with something? And I love that. And then of course, I'd love knowing the answer. And they've described to me a situation today where 13th hole greenside bunker left hand side of the green, three of them out of the four were in this one
bunker, it just so happened at the time. There was a member of the ground staff, working in that bunker, which there is a local rule. Let's says if there is ground stop working in a bunker that because bunker becomes compulsory gu r or now, of course I know Play Zone. Play is prohibited for health and safety reasons. While there's ground staff in that bunker so becomes no pleasure. In other words, they must take Willie anyway, but what's happened before? They've got there is the ground staff doing whatever. Work in the bunker has grabbed these three balls individually
and just throwing them out, right? Out of the bunker. So, they now just laying next to the Great. Just throwing them all out. They've arrived and going off at we're in the bunk and the guys on, you know, off throwing them out, two of them, two of the players proceeded to play their ball from where it now lies. Okay. And the third guy said, the three guys in the boat so I don't think you can play it from there. Like, the guys is throwing it out and they said, well, we can't play from there. I don't think he's thrown it out because he told us the ground
staff said you can't play from here. It's compulsory. GUI is probably the term to use. So we you know, he's throwing So we will play them from here. So sure enough two of them Clyde a bowl from where to come to race. After the remember, the grand staff had thrown them out of the bunker and the third guy says no, I don't think that's right. And I said to them, did you know that this person had thrown your balls from outside the bunker? Yes, we knew. I said, okay, because it would be different if you didn't know your ball, have been moved by
any outside influence and you just rocked up, seeing your ball on your plate at. That would be different. You'd be have no problem there but you now know that this screw and stop him but has thrown literally thrown your balls out of the bunker anyway. So two of them played it from where it was and I said I'm sorry you're not allowed to do that. What you should have done is recognize that you can't play from there and you just need to take and it's coarse ground under a pier, not penalty area, no play zone. You just need to find the nearest point of relief and and drop within a club length, you
know, near the whole outside the bunker and apparently that's what one of them did. But the other two didn't and I just thought, you know, we're does that happen. You know. You know that someone is just throwing the ball over there and you can do all that must be where I need to play. It from there and sure enough, two people have done, just that I wish one of them in throne and been thrown in the hole, but that would have been good at knowing these people, I'm sure he probably would have claimed it as well. So, what would you do? What would you tell them? Well, I just explained that
under the temporary local rules. It is, in fact, a no play zone so you couldn't have because one of those I would have known. I would have put it back in play and I said, well actually not allowed to play from there. It's a no play zone. You just need to find the nearest point of relief. I said well you guys Applied for a wrong place, add two strokes. It was past that have wiped the whole and I think that wiped it anyway because they know their ball has been moved by an outside influence. They know that can I put something to you, of course. Is it a wrong place?
Or is it a wrong ball? Oh, I knew. So. I was thinking about this before, I mean, was it put in that spot with the intend for it to be in play? Well, it wasn't dropped, it wasn't placed, it was literally picked up and thrown over there, so it was lifted. The guys picked it up off the sand. In the bunker, picked it up goes, I don't want this in here. I'm doing work in this bunker. I'm going to throw it over there. The players will know this when they get to me and I'll tell them and sure enough the outside influences said oh by the way, I have Your ball over there. So the ball in play hasn't been
lifted. I don't think for Relief, it's just been moved by an outside influence as if a bird would come in and swooped in and picked it up and then dropped it, five meters away and then they saw that bird moving their ball. They know it's we moved. This has been picked up by a person career because if he's not boring but it is a person. Yeah, I think I feel like I'm getting myself. I'm gonna get myself, confused boil, because if we look at 9.6, Because they announced her
influence. If it is no no virtually certain that the outside influence influence lifted or moved a Players Ball lifted all moved a Players Ball. Yeah, there is no Purity and the ball must be replaced on. Its original spot. Is applies whether or not the Players Ball with me. Found The players ball player. Purity supplying incorrectly substitutable or pine bow from the wrong price and break to grow at one point.
Six General County and Road 6.3 be 14.7 a and, so, This is I actually might need, I might need some assistance from. So I look at it as there's no penalty. The ball must be replaced. Well we know it sort of can't be right but you've got to follow through that procedure. So yes, it's got to be replaced back in the bunker that punk is
a no play zone. So then you need to carry out a separate procedure to take relief from that. Note plays own think now there's no, I'm just, I'm just trying to. Yes, they've made from Not where they should play for me, that's fine. I'm just trying to work out whether it's a wrong place or wrong ball now, I was thinking wrong, all because The boy has been lifted. and, Grown tour. So not put back in play, not
drop, back and play, not Place back in play. However, however I'm leaning, I'm going away from that. simply because This rule applies to the deliberate lifting of a player's boat rest, which includes picking the ball by hand rotating it, or otherwise deliberately causing it to move from that spot. Well, that did happen. Yeah. But Who can lift a ball who may
lift a ball and see, here's the issue. Is that lift is not one of the definitions. No, but is lifted under the rules, only by the player or any one player authorizes. He goes for that, but stuff, like the authorization, must be given each time. Tyler the Bulls player is lifted by than giving generally for the ramp so that ground staff member has not lifted their ball. Their, Heavenly lifted it. They've moved it, please. If anyone disagrees please let us know.
I think that the term lifted Is only for the player or anyone to play at all. I don't rise or the caddy caddy on the putting green and then green. But I'll put this to you. if where you and I are playing in a stroke play event, I hit my ball out of the bunker. I'm raking a bunker and my balls in your way. Yes, you mark the ball. You might mobile without
authorization. I would have liked to have asked you first but obviously, I haven't in this case. Bad luck. You're going to have to, you're going to have to answer for. If I if you pause that. We mean you guys you want to ask a question, all your eye knows, I will throw ization. I know that I should get your permission to Mark and get your role and why a little ball but I haven't in your story in your eye. Medical. I have a knot. You just think I'll do it myself so you lift it out of the way
and I'm you know, blackie blackie. He can't hear me. So I can't do it. I'm not listening you place it to the side. Yeah. And I play it from that spot. Yes, without knowing, that's fine because I didn't know I correct. My mistake. No penalty. Yes, you don't continue. You correct your mistake, no penalty. If you haven't teed off on the next hole. Did you know that, right? Hang on. So yeah, I don't believe you played from a wrong place
because your balls been moved by an outside influence and you were not aware that it's being moved. Correct, I'm Steve. No, technically, I have played from a wrong place but I'm not going to get penalized for it. So I believe there was an interpretation on there. Is it really points? It must be nine point, six is it? We're in agreeance that you've moved my ball place, it somewhere else. I didn't know played it from that spot because you didn't tell me I'm not going to get I'm not going to get penalized for
playing from wrong place but I must correct this. I must correct this mistake that has happened. So I didn't think that was the case because obviously the correct playing from the wrong place. I know. And it was what I want you playing the wrong. Playing a round ball. You must correct. Well, I read it the other day because someone actually asked me and so I was reading this one. So, if I've got this wrong, I'm going to be really pissed because I was reading, you know,
that's all right. I was reading it. And exploit know. So it's under, and the Annoying Thing is what was it more? There we go, got it here 9.6, slice 3, interpretation 9.6 / 34 player, learns the ball moved after stroke made, if information that the ball was, in fact, mufon outside influence. Only becomes known to the player. After the ball has been played, the player did not play from a
wrong place because this knowledge did not exist when the player made this stroke. Doesn't look like correcting but I never thought you had to correct playing from wrong place. Sorry, you haven't played the wrong place, that's what it's saying. Nine point six less four bought respire them in discovered to have been moved by outside edge outside influence. All turned out to be wrong ball. I have scales after paying his or her bald, anything movements? Of course. In the next area is made. Maybe that's what I was reading.
The play. Must correct. The mistake. Yep. New Dawn to the corresponding outside influence is that the key? Because the ball will come to rest out of bounds. I need to go back to this person, famous great mistake with the scary that Yes. It's nine point six three. So if I did not play for me one place because this so they just continue play from the unless
it's a serious breach been education. Wouldn't be us. now, I can't even remember if the question asked to me was, Did someone did throughout maybe someone did throughout that guy with the thing that confirmed it. So okay, so you don't you don't correct the error. But getting back to, this is a real tangent. We going on today, getting back to the original situation.
You have lifted my bowl. And I putted it from the wrong place. That's fine. 9.6 3 plate, keep playing with it. No penalty. What happens if you had told me, he said, hey, I've moved your ball. And then I play it from the wrong place. You'd left your mark and lifted my ball. You've placed it somewhere else.
Is marble a wrongful or how does it imply? Or is it in play? Wasn't returned to the chord notes. Has been moved inside. It wasn't return to the course with the intend for it to the in play, but it hasn't been lifted in the first place. Let's make moved, that's right, so if it hasn't been lifted, And it's not about of it's not out of play because I you did Mimi or Thor is 0, because you didn't give me Authority. I think the also has its own still in play.
Well, the definition Iran has been lifted from the course. Well, then play, the ball remains in play into his hole, except that is no longer in play when it is lifted from the courts. It doesn't say move to another part of the course. And we know that the lifting can only be done by the player or some other way or authorizes or caddy on the voting room. That's what we are assuming because just from the definition of 14.1 be someone has a
different interpretation of that over the love to hear. So you tell me, am I now play the wrong ball or a wrong place? I think I've played from the wrong place. I mean turns been moved by someone else rather than lifting. And you know, it's been mooc. Yeah. Unless I wonder if you can Authorize a change, that's already authorized a left up to, it's after the fact. And we've had this question,
we've had this question before in that same situation where you've now puttered. But you didn't know that, I'd move your ball and then you're walking towards the green, you go, what's that market there sure? Oh, sorry, I forgot. I actually did leave your ball and I moved it away and you go, oh well, I shouldn't have played it from the, I should be putting it back to that ball Mark. I better career. That and then you cause you're complicating or making a an issue for yourself when you actually didn't have an issue. Yes. Because any actually return it back to the ball marker which is
shouldn't have because your balls in plane anyway. Yes, it's a flavor wrong place anyway, that would be very easy for people to do. Oh my ball. My I should have played it from there, let me correct that. Well, a little rabbit hole. We went down there. Right? It's, I had a Club. Lane story. Okay. Remember fibers on as long as mine. Yeah, but I was driving up last week. It was just last week to tell Bob members to make sure they
entered for a competition. They could still enter for a competition. Even after they had finished their first round of this competition, which does seem a bit weird, but that's what the committee decided. What are you doing? So yeah, so it actually the entry because if they come into the clubhouse and they go, I had a great score. Well why don't you enter for the JH I next week and you might be able to qualify. Yeah. Okay, sure you're sure anyway so
I was driving up the screen and tell everyone. I'll tell this group specific group and I was Not that far off the green and I saw the ball move. Well maybe I didn't see the ball move but their player looked up and goes oh my ball mount has moved. Mmm, although, although Marcos bellet competitors, are looking at each other going. Mmm, Mmm. And the black, guys. All what I do.
And then I was such a short partner with them, putting our and, and then he just, I was wanting to jump out of the carton button, but In, they just part of it. And he had marked it because I remember that someone else is putting and then this guy had to replace his ball. So he had lifted and marked and lifted and placed it and they came off the thing. I said, I what happened there and they said, oh a ball move, And I got well, did you
basically Piper wrong place? You were supposed to replace it. He has moved on, they didn't care. They just totally ignored me. It I was like that guy won't be adding a penalty isn't a good score so I'm not so fast but they just even bring your towel in the rules. They don't you see them smash him in the face with the rules and it's like yeah, whatever they give. Just the idea from the south Sole guy, but there's my club
and story wasn't as quick as slow as yours as long as you. Well, let's get into some Community questions. Which one they want to start with? Well my sweet girl with the most recent one and it's the four Ball Match people asking for advice and this chain of questions that went around. Without I don't have the question in front of me. Exactly but it's just like player Arc but I am be were partners and then BRC and of course season the opponent's team and then see our study. And so it just went on and on and on and I think where the
confusion came in is we know that's the general penalty if breaching 10.2 and I think some of the confusion came about well, that team was the first to breach that rule and we know the general penalty in match play is loss of whole. Why didn't team one, you know, lose a hole straight away. Soon, as that first question was asked and that's probably where the confusion came in. So if you want to talk a little bit about what happens in losing a, well incurring, the general
penalty but in a four ball and what that means. Yeah, well, I mean I, I was I was so happy that this question Tim and Michelle partners and affordable match they're playing against Stewart and Charlotte. Now I'm a par-3 5th hole at one of the hills bloody tough hole before turning off. Tim asks Michelle what club she is going to use but Michelle's aren't sure. So she asked Charlotte or Club she's going to use but Charlotte was unsure. So she asked Stuart what he is going to use it Stewart doesn't
know. So he has Tim what Khloe's going to use the Tim, doesn't Anything. And then pays off either any penalties incurred. And by home, I think it's by whom, it's not by Hoover. I've heard it both ways. So yeah, I was pretty happy with this question. Third iteration, I didn't actually know the answer is. Yes you did. So, Tim has asked his partner, so that's fine. We shall is asked her partner's, that's fine.
Michelle has asked an opponent for advice. And Stewart has asked an opponent for advice. You know, they are both penalized. Why is it? It you know, the first breakthroughs by Michelle. So why doesn't Tim and Michelle lose and charlatans do it get the whole well unlike an individual stroke play individual, Max play where you know once someone makes a breach and gets a loss of whole pillow
T that's the end of that hole. In this case the sides both have two players and so there is nothing under 28 8.8 a or whatever it is 23.0 23.8. So it's ready for there is no twenty eighth inning 23.8 a here. They don't actually they don't actually disqualify that who work on the whole. So twenty three point eight,
eight counties other than disqualification. Purity normally applies only to play or not partner, when a player gets a penalty. In this qualification, that penalty, normally applies, only to the player and not also to his or her partner except in the situations coming. So, in this case, it's a in point to a situation, which is a general penalty, that's not a disqualification. So, it's just the player who breaches the rule gets the penalty. However, there are this
situations where the partner would also incur the penalty. Any penalty stroke sad alone, The players score score, etc, etc. Three situations when player breaches rule 4.1 be. So if you you and I are playing together and you have more than 14 clubs, then it's adjustment of our match score. So we could both win or be to up but then because you've got more than 15 clubs that's going to affect the match. Not just the fact that you you
yourself individually, lose Affairs to roll. So we'd be now back to Where the second situation when players break helps Partners play someone did try and argue that. You know Michelle asking Charlotte could have helped Tim's play. I disagree with that. Maybe if Michelle Charlotte and Charlotte had said something,
but, you know, even then I would be hard-pressed to actually penalize. 10 because Tim hasn't actually done anything wrong. The helping of the partners play would be pretty. Wide bow to stretch. Yeah it's only a physical action. It's normally a physical action like breaking a branch out of the way that also helps your partner as well. Maybe maybe this Navy, Michelle grabs Charlotte's club that Charlotte's going to use and
throws it at Tim? Maybe I like because you know, advice is never one that I think she'd be. I did. It's just so Rife and Club golf. I think you could easily continue, you could get rid of that rule together and continue and no make no difference to golf. I don't think so. I heard it today unless unless it slows down play and then that's a good way of getting rid of it, but I think plays slow enough without it so possibly there but I think that's a long,
bro. To stretch to actually picking on someone whose partner ask someone else. So, and in met the third one was when players breach hurts parents play. So if if Michelle Charlotte, what club she's going to use shallots as 6-iron and then Michelle breaks it. Well, I guess that could help Tim's play because Charlotte is now without a 6-iron.
Yes, I would think that's possibly. But again, very very It's the same Glide, boat a stretch or something. Yeah. Anyway, so I was pretty happy with that question. The answer is Tim plays. Charlotte after all that Michelle's, do it around analyze the loss of whole and Tim and Charlotte go head-to-head and I mean 19% of people got that correct? Yeah, yeah. And I'm surprised that almost two-thirds thought there was no
penalties to anyone because, hey advice, it's not advice, it's not really rule in the verses. Not rice is not a great not an issue. One of the guys, one of the guys playing today, it was as we were discussing incredibly windy today and he goes on we'll just you know just need to clean up a little bit Louise. I'm about to tell you if you guys aren't we just need to clean up a little bit lower today. He's saying I think that's I think that might be covered under 10.2. Is it the same as these grains are running so slow?
Well, they're going to run fast or slow. Today is there. Thus when you recognize looks like your Not grind. Is that it was one of the way I'll learn about the four ball match. Play not losing the whole for the team. But actually just disqualifying yourself out of that hole is I was on a golf trip to balls in the bunker. Two players from each team and they both play their shots out of the bunker. Got to the green and realize they played each other. Each other's golf course. So they're both played wrong balls and it was that exact
situation. I've gone way. I don't know what the rule is. They ask me later. I didn't know. I'd probably hadn't done any training or anything. I was just very interested looked it up and I found out that. Yeah, you're not out of the house, sorry the teams aren't out of the hole. It's just those two players are out of the hole even if even if you that opponent loses your ball, which takes you out of the hole because you have a lost ball. A pirate takes you out of the hollow of the law school because you can't find your ball.
And then you realize the opponent headed after 3 minutes, you would still there would still be a case of bad luck for you. It wouldn't mean that you win the whole with me that just sound like who you're out of line? If you didn't go back and play Striking Distance, blah, blah, blah. Yeah, good luck. Are we going for time? Do another Community question or we now, I think we wrap it up with the grq. OTW, I think a lot of people are
sick of me, talking about lifting the ball, What is it? Yeah, it's from other people tuned in tuned in chiming chiming contribute. Big part of the show with some rules from the club. Situations from the pole, imbroglio is from the club. Right. The grq ITW 463. Okay, I've got it here, right it
before big p get to go today it's a big Pete. He's off on the second hole at one bat Hills and he's ballheads very close to the outer bounds fence. He plays a provisional ball, BP finds his original ball. However, it is unplayable and he proceeds to take lateral relief. Big big, big p. Drops a ball correctly and the ball comes. Erased in the relief area. Big p. Goes back to his bag to grab a club and when he returns his ball has rolled out of bounds.
shot. A horrible shot. And it, right? It's nearly on the road, it is offense. Then, I've gone up to our founding of God, to assess it, come back down to look at what I'm going to do. And then my balls rolled down the hill. So, I'll down the hill onto the flat and actually giving me not a bad shot. and, I didn't, I had a bit of an inkling, but I was like, I'm pretty sure I just
play it as it lies. And I was like, to be a pilot. I think I just lies a lot. He's like, nah, she only back up there. So we'll get a referee, got a referee, and I can't remember who it was, but if I ever if I, if I remembered I would have It would probably was probably the manager of that team and he said now you have to put the ball back up there so I can cause it to move it. Just I walk down here and then I bought five days after me.
So now you have to put it back up there so you made me put it back up there and play it from. There was worse rolling I've ever had Chaka but that was before I work the gulf Australia, once I started going astray, I probably would then that person fighter. Anyway, so hopefully big peak and work out what he's got to do Palmer. I tell us what it came to rest after you dropped it. Then he dropped it correctly and it came to rest in the relief
area. He's walked away back to his bag to go and grab a club come back, and it's rolled out of bounds. Where where is this provisional? But he does have his provisional just sitting on The Fairway though. Maybe that's in a good spot. What if that's an option or have to wait till next week? Shirley I thank you very much Joe. That's fantastic. My pleasure always happy to help. Thank you very much. Everyone for tuning in.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...