Podcast McPhee is back from his refereeing journey, and he fills us in on his Australian Open experience. We also delve into four Clubland Stories - THE GRQ PODCAST EP106
Podcast McPhee is back from his refereeing journey, and he fills us in on his Australian Open experience. We also delve into four Clubland Stories, including two from a now regular question-asker Mr Roberts as well as his close second, Colin - THE GRQ PODCAST EP105Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/joinSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rulesGRQOTW104 - Whilst the ball that was found was unknown to be the original or the provisional ball, it was definitely one of them, and so the player must play that ball as the provisional ball. The ball that was found after three minutes is lost either way, and therefore can not be used at all.Firstly, we cover a few Clubland Stories:- Mr Roberts wants to know what happens when a struck ball doesn't make its way out of a Red Penalty Area. This comes under Rule 17.2.- Colin wants to know if he proceeded correctly when his ball was stuck up a tree. He dropped within two club-lengths of where the ball was, and this was under Rule 19.2.- Mr Roberts goes again with another tricky one and Blakey and Podcast disagree on what spray foam is deemed to be. But they do agree Mary was able to get some free relief.- Chip gives us a situation that is probably pretty common in Clubland, where a player tries to play a provisional ball for a ball that most likely went into a penalty area.GRQOTW 106 - Big P has hit his tee shot into the red penalty area running down the right side of the 14th hole. After two minutes of searching, he finds and identifies his ball. He makes a stroke at the ball and only advances it 3m. Frustrated, he makes another stroke at it from inside the PA moving it very little and makes another stroke. Very frustrated, he says he is returning to the teeing area to start the hole again.Despite some objections from others in the group, he returns to the teeing area, tees up a ball and makes a stroke, and finishes the hole. There are no players behind waiting to hit.How many penalty strokes must Big P add to his hole score?..GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Episode 106 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast We have Stuart back talking about his experience at the Australian Open, but first we get into a couple of clubland stories that we need to catch up on. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Stuart's one of our highest ranked working the rules officials that we have one one of the best we've got and he knows he's.
Hi everyone. Welcome to another episode of the Golf Rules Questions podcast. This is number one O 6 and you're here with Blakey and podcast McPhee. Hello Blakey, Welcome back after your long journey of refereeing over the last month or? So. Thank you. Yeah. How's it feel now that you're world famous? That's been no, I don't know about world famous. That's good. I mean really enjoying it. Well, just enjoying being on
course and. And on TV, yeah. No, no. Enjoying being on course and applying what we talk about all the time and learning about this stuff and applying for real and helping players. I think it's the best fit of a job, just for helping. When? When I was, I must say, when I was mentoring you or presenting with Brian, the Level 2, the first Level 2 that you went to, we were going through the art of refereeing and one of the first slides had why you get into
refereeing and there was a dot point there to get yourself on TV. And I saw your face light up and I, you know, it was just at that moment that a light bulb just came on. You're like, yes, I am going to to become a referee just so I can get myself on TV and then finally at the Australian Open Sunday with the leader at the time you got yourself on TVI. Must say I do remember that dot point on the level 2 so and I'm just disappointed it took so
long. And there you have it folks, finally showing his true colours. When you set that one up and I tell you for me, I thought, I hit it. We need to get into that ruling but before then and and you're just general experience before then we'll quickly go through the answer to the GRQOTW for 1:05 which I had to do on my lonesome and I didn't even get. Give Fraser the opportunity to come up with a question and I
bet he would have come up with a doozy but this one was easily is tough. I believe GRQO TW105A player is searching for their tee shot and then finds a ball in the raft that he knows is a ball he hit from the teeing area. Their 3 minutes search time then expires. He then finds another ball and he knows this is also a ball he hit from the teeing area. The problem is he doesn't know which ball was the original and which ball is the provisional ball. What is the ruling?
What do you make of that? Stewart So when you say a ball hit from the turning area, obviously 2 balls were hit from the turning area. One was the original ball and one was a provisional ball. I think the fact that after three minutes a ball which we know for certain has been hit from the turning area, the fact that a ball has been found within the three minutes, I think what happens after that is irrelevant and I think then a decision needs to be made after that 3 minutes. We know that ball has been hit from the turning area. We can't identify or distinguish
whether it's the original or provisional. I think it's just got to work out, Sorry, you've got to say, well that's clearly our ball in play. However, because you can't definitively say it was the original, you've got to consider it to be the provisional and you'll be hitting your fourth shot with that ball. Yeah, really interesting one. I probably didn't know the answer when I asked it, and I probably still don't know the answer. But going off what I've seen in
the past, what you're saying is, is how I see it as well. The ball that you found within the three minutes, you have to work out whether that is a one of your balls or not. And if you work out that it is one of the ones you hit, but you can't work out which one it is, whether it's the first one or the second one. And then working out through the rules and what I've seen, you just work out that this is OK,
this is the provisional ball, and you must play that as the provisional ball. I mean, you've found a ball that you know is yours. You've found it within the three minutes. You just can't determine whether it's the original or the provisional. I can't see how you have to go back to the T and play your 5th. No. Yeah, I that would be true. In my mind, that would be a bit too harsh. Agreed. We know at Endpoints very
specifically, it says if you find 2 balls and you can't work out which is which, the rule is very clear on that. In this particular case, it's not so clear that I can't see any other way around what we have just discussed. The fact that it's, you know, you fit it from the training area, you know it's one of them, you just don't know which one. And I think you have to pay a price for that because you can't tell if it's your original ball or not. If you didn't find any, of course, then the provisional balls, now the ball and play. But you need to go and find it. And then we're going to have the discussion whether you get a separate 3 minute search time for either, in fact, if it's
tied in with the original search and on the proximity to the original. It's really important that we understand that it's within that 3 minutes that you need to find, you know, your original or your provisional after any fact. After the three minutes really don't help us out at all really. So you found a ball, you need to work out whether it's the original provisional. If you don't within the three minutes, it defaults as your provisional and play on from
then. Like rest quickly, a ruling. Last week. The week, sorry, the week before A cathedral with a well known player, now retired, now media person ball search. Fortunately he had about 50 people trying to help him find this ball. I was timing only because I haven't been there and I said you've got 30 seconds left and then I've gone. It was like 3 minutes and four seconds and I've gone. That's time. The play was like 5 minutes. I said that's time. Yes, OK.
I swear no more than five seconds later, one of the spectators go. I've found one here, so of course he walks up and goes, yeah, that's it. And he looks at me, he goes, not good. As I said no, I said sorry. I said no, not good sorry. Anyway, that's why it goes 3 minutes or three minutes. Yeah, that's that's the way it is. Not 3 minutes and 10 seconds. No, that's right, It's not 3 minutes, but if it's your mate, it's only two minutes 59. Well, depending on who you play with, could be 5 or 6. Yeah. Well, that's, I mean that's why
they brought it down from 5 because five used to be 10, yeah, three is 5 so we. Have seen the discussion recently about, you know, who's responsible the time. There's really no definitive, you know, player X is responsible, the market is responsible, the player is responsible. There's nothing in the rules that says if there is someone held accountable or responsible for timing that search. It depends if it's your friend or you know they're trying to beat. You. But is it interesting, though?
Because you know that time it's just one of those facts you need to establish. It should be the player. It's on the player and you know the European Tour are really good at this. The the first thing that they'll do when they walk into the area, who's timing? And if no one is timing, they almost find them. Yeah, like they write a letter to them saying this is not good enough. Yes, that's someone. Needs to have time on this ball. Set. Yeah, that's good. So there's nothing in the rules that can say that. But they too obviously can say no. This is one of their rules,
Yeah. And that's a good one. I like it. Yeah, I like it. Who's timing? It it's behaviour expected of their players and they expect it of every player, not just and so if a player doesn't start it, another. Player should Yeah. No, I like it a lot. As I said, there's nothing in the rules. It says it's most of the time. So I I think that's a fantastic idea. And you're right, it sort of falls under that umbrella of conduct. Yeah, playing within the spirit of the game, the integrity of the game. So that's really good to hear. I didn't know that. European Tour, fantastic with
that kind. I mean, they're really good at those kind of things with their relationship with their players and making sure that the players know basic rules as well. You know if if Jerry Maguire calls a referee over for a car path rule 3 weeks in a row, then that person has to front cover the rules exam. You know, because they don't. They obviously don't know the basic of a basic. Car part? Well, they don't, you think
Sometimes the players want immunity so they can't get it wrong because there's a referee possibly. Wanting directions. If it's a really basic one, you know, if it's if it's a difficult one where you're trying to work out whether you do actually have interference or you're just bludging it a bit, we can see that. But if it's just a basic. Ball in the car path. Yeah, or just do you have got your foot on it and you just want to drop it out then say and hit the same club in the same shot? Sure.
If it's one where I'm dropping out there, but can I now change my club? OK. That is easy for us. But for them maybe you know and mark their market going, hang on, hang on, you're going to have an edge now you have three difference that you know. Yes, yes. So we've got a few top land stories today and we've also got Stuart's experience. If you haven't read his blog, it's on golf course questions, Facebook, and it's also on the web page after we got the
website sorted. So you can go and read it. It's a fantastic read, but we will get podcasts, thoughts and feelings a little bit as well after these clubland stories. And we're also going to start, hopefully start if we have the time, a little a new little segment where we try and go a little bit more advanced and find discussions from. We had Fraser Nickel on the show last week for 1:05.
He runs a fantastic Facebook community for those people who want to or are learning in the process of learning the rules of golf. Not just for any average golfer who just wants to read these discussions and not contribute, but those are actually sitting exams who has a fantastic community called the Golf Rules Samaritan TGRS on Facebook. We're going to grab a few discussion points on some quirky rules and also up the USGA rule site.
So we've got a couple today, but we'll next time we're on, we'll do a lot more, but we'll get through our Clubland Stories podcast experience of the AO and then finish, hopefully finish with a few quirky ones from the TGRS. So this one's from Mr. Roberts. Firstly, may I say Blakey, it was you who started the Mr. Roberts bit because there are too many Davids. There are certainly too many Davids in golf. I will attest to that Mister
Roberts. Now the question. Issue 5th hole at Hilltop. 320 meter path ball with water all down the left side for 250 meters. Red penalty area peaks about 3 to 4 meters from the edge of the water and fairly steep bank from edge of the way to the water player A hits tea shot which came to rest in the red penalty area but not in the water. I'm not sure of this exactly, but for this question, let's say the bull entered the penalty area about 10 meters, the tea side of where it came to rest.
Player A cannot get a stance to hit up the fear way toward the hole, but can try to hit out straight up the bank 90° to the fear way. Player A makes a stroke, but alas, grass catches. Club head all moves up the bank but does not get out of the penalty area and rolls back into the water. Thinking this is a 17.2, Player A then has to take relief, which he does bilateral relief by dropping the ball into the play on the exact line on which he tried to hit the ball out of the penalty area with the second
shot. That is straight up the bank line sounds like a line of flight one shot penalty and then he plays his fourth up the fairway and the clubhouse. Later, well after Player A has gone home, I get caught over to a group of players enjoying post game refreshments. Two of these players were in the group with Player A and were discussing this incident with another player who called me over for an opinion. Player who was not the playing group thought that Player A should have gone back to the point of entry where his tee shot crossed into the penalty
area to take the relief drop. I checked rule 17.2 A and the associated diagram Fantastic diagram in the rules of golf which shows the ball in county area being hit in the direction of the hole and I agreed that player A should have gone back to point of entry and not dropped straight up the bank. Your thoughts please. Nothing. What came of this? Nothing really resolved because player A had gone home, his card had signed, was signed and in the system. I think a few as a few of us
learnt something. One of those hopefully this wasn't Club Championship. Otherwise because they weren't aware of the correct procedure, it would normally just be add the penalty on before the competition is closed, which would be two shots for playing from a wrong place. We actually covered this one, kind of covered this one with
Colin's last question in the last probably in probably in October where someone tried to take a line of flight for an unplayable, and that's basically what's gone on here. So 17.2 which podcast is about to go through and just give us the idea of the reasoning behind 17.2. But basically what happened was player A dropped in a wrong place for a one shot penalty played from a wrong place. So he's got the one shot penalty for 17, Rule 17 taken relief
from the penalty area and then he's got the two shot penalty for playing from wrong place in meters. In my mind as the committee is not a serious breach so I wouldn't DQ him, but he definitely should get the two shot penalty. Stewart, your thoughts on 17.2. Yeah, I can't add anything more than what you just said. Absolutely you can. Well, I know everything you just said, I would have said. Well, what is? What's the idea of 17.2? Is you never.
If your balls lying in a red penalty area and you attempt all yellow, well, you and you attempt to play it and make multiple strokes at it, but you can't get out. You never give up that point of entry as an option available to you to get out of that penalty area. So if your balls lying in a penalty and you take ten shots out of frustration to try to get out and you're now twenty 3050 meters further towards the hole, but now you're in a worse spot, you still have the option to take penalty relief out of that penalty area at the point where your ball last crossed into that
penalty area. You never surrender that option ever. That's what 17.2 is all about. But if your balls lying in a penalty and you make a stroke and your ball remains in that penalty area or goes into another one, you have all the normal penalty area relief options. So in this particular case, the fact that we've had that second shot to try to get up the bank and it wasn't successful is irrelevant. You know, you still remember shot counts. You've got to come back to where it is if you want to get out of that penalty or intake relief. That's what 17.2 is all about.
A advisor of ours told us that we have to disagree a bit more to make it a little bit more enjoyable to listen to. So this is the first time that I'm going to disagree with you. And it's not because you're wrong, it's that you're not quite not quite right. OK, the easiest way to do this is read the heading. This is what our friend Jeff would tell us when ball played from penalty area comes to rest in same or another penalty area. You still have all the options
that 17.1 provided you, Stewart said. That, But they could slightly change if the ball had gone out and come back in OK. Yeah, would you believe my GIQOTW for this week may or may not be related to this rule? Good, good. So in player A's case, Mr. Rob said the ball did not get out of the penalty area, so he's still
got the option of going back to the tee for a one shot penalty. He still got the option of lateral relief from where the ball last crossed into the penalty area, which was 10 meters from where the ball ended up T side. He's still got line of play. No back on the line, back on the line, thank you. Back on the line from that where the ball last crossed. With the point with the flag, but you can't drop it in the same kind of area. But you can't drop in the same one. You can drop in a different one, or in a bunker, or in a putting
green, wrong green. So you've got those 3 and that's it. That's it. Or or you can drop it within a club length of where you last played it from in the penalty area. It's like one of the only times you can drop it in the same penalty area. OK, so just just adding on that, if the ball does come out and go back in, now you've got a new last place crossed into the penalty area, which changes your
back on the line and changes your lateral relief. But you still have all the options of the one shot penalty. Dropping outside the penalty area or teeing it up with the tee up. Was your one of your last shots or you? What's your last shot? So played from the wrong place? Definitely. What's the What's the rule for playing from the wrong place? 14.7 you mean four? And oh, sorry, there you go, not 4 and 170. Yet excellent.
So that one does that. Any more to add? I actually we played golf the other day at Fair Freeway Freeway which is in Camberwell Golf Club Freeway Rockside Q right beside that works for the NE NE tunnel and I played pretty well but my friend didn't play so good and he hit one in the penalty area and it was sort of dog leg and he hit it in the
right hand side trees in here. And I go, I, you know, one of the options take lateral relief. And I said, oh, just I said oh you could take back on the line kind of laughing and he goes and he starts measuring the line of flight, You know, you know, he he wouldn't have got away with it and he would have thought about it and gone oh, and I can't do that. But he said oh just this way. And I go, no, it's not line of flight, it's back on the line which would have been on the other side of the trees. But trust me, he wouldn't have
got away with it. He would have, he would have thought. What am I doing? But he he did think about that at the start and then I had to correct them. So I. Said. That's why I only play with Blakey once again. Yeah, that's right. Right. So finished with Mr. Roberts. First one he he does have. Another does have another. Showing Colin back again and he's he's gone. Sigh. Probably because he knows it's just Mr. Robertson Colin that contribute the most.
Playing the par 3 second at Y Maddie. We'll know every hole at Y Maddie Sing Colin Tees often a group of five. Surrounding the green are ornamental conifers that have been trimmed from the ground up to about waist height, looking similar to Christmas trees in a semi circle about 5 or 6 meters apart. Upon reaching the green, Colin and his mates can't seem to find the ball, thinking it could have bounced up into the tree. As these trees do catch a few balls with a hard bounce, Colin
discovers his ball has lodged itself between a piece of loose bark and the trunk of the tree a few inches up. Colin takes an unplayable 2 club lengths from where the ball was lodged as the branches are still quite spread out at about waist height. Colin puts his next shot hunched over as he can't stand upright and eventually puts out for five. Just asking a question. Was this the right action to take under the tree or should he
have dropped the ball 2 club links away from the branches so he would have had a bit of stance? Did he have the correct number of penalty shots? Was he playing as unplayable from the wrong spot? What do you think Like. You heard me laughing about the second option, about taking the branches into consideration. Hang on guys, if I just come a bit further out here, then I'll take my two more, thanks. We know there's three options for an unplayable in the general area.
One that you don't need to know the location of the ball, with the other two you do and the other two are based on. This includes lateral are based on the spot of the ball, not the reason why it's unplayable, including tree branches. So yeah, so I think that player has proceeded correctly. Yeah, it says. Colin takes an unplayable 2 club lengths from where the ball was lodged. So the only things or there's two things to say about that, A that it wasn't near the hole and B that it was from the spot
directly below where the ball was. But if you think about it, if you do measure your club length like that, then you're definitely going to be inside the two club. Yeah, flat on the ground is definitely going to be wider, longer than, but it is from the spot directly below where the ball is and no nearer the hole. So that Colin sounds like you've done it correctly. It was a one shot penalty and you don't get the nicest point,
or that's probably under the nearest point, but you don't get you take your one shot penalty unplayable, but that doesn't necessarily mean that you get to drop in a nice spot. So you've yeah, it sounds like you've done it correctly. And of course, there's no guarantee that when you take an unplayable that your ball becomes playable. Yeah, it could have taken another hard bounce back up into the tree, exactly the same spot being within the two club lengths, and you'd have to either play it or take another unplayable. And. Another comment I'll make is the fact that you can take multiple.
Unplayables, Yes. So you take your lateral. Yeah, you take your lateral. 2 flat leads. Not good enough. Take another two flat leads. Correct. Add another Can you If you take an unplayable lateral and then it's in a crappy position, can you then take back on the line and where do you take that back on the line from? Where the ball is now. Right, so where the ball is come to rest because it's. Like, yeah, right. And then once you drop back on the line, can you now take another lateral?
Yes, yeah, you can just keep going. I don't know why you would, but then keep going. Once you've taken so you've got lateral and back on line lateral. Again. Can you go back to the team? If that was where your last physical stroke was made, yes. And that would just cut the other one more shot, of course. So you got one. 2-3 you'll be back. So your stroke and distance relates to the last where you actually made your last physical shot and and that's under rule on 19.2 something. 19 point
119.2. So 19.21 No Guarantee Ball will be playable after taking a relief. But the actual rule is 19. Yeah, sorry, 19 is unplayable 19.2. Is is it 19 point A or is it 19.2 A? The options, Yeah, so there's 9.12 and three, I think because three is bunker, isn't it? Yeah, OK, 9.3 is 9 point. 9.1 just tells us what an unplayable
board, right? 9.2, AB and C are your three options here, you know, just try the nuisance back on the line lateral. And then 19.3 is bunker because of course you have that additional relieve. Oh option available for a two shot penalty, the only two shot penalty and match point. It doesn't give you a lot of high use. Right, Mr. Rob, it's back again. Firstly, this will probably be the last story from May for 2023. So happy Christmas away from all golf rules. And we look forward to and he's written a poem for us. Actually, we'll leave the poem
to right to the end. We'll get to the questions first. Hilltop, Wednesday 22nd of November, Woman playing a Stableford event. This is a good one actually. Course Superintendent with Boom Spray machine spraying fairways. At either end of the boom spray, a dash of blue foam is expelled under the fairways about every 10 meters. The foam, which dissipates in a couple of hours, is actually a guide for the boom spray operator, so he knows the width extent of what has been sprayed and can keep spray lines straight with minimal overlay.
Mary hits Great Drive down the 5th down a 10th hole. It's a par 5. Mary and her playing group proceed down the fairway and alas, they cannot see Mary's ball anywhere. But after 2 minutes, less than 3A member of the group sees a ball and one of the bits of spray foam. Mary walks over, places a tee immediately behind the ball, then touches and rotates the ball to find her marking and states this is my ball. That was all fine. Judy, one of the playing group, laughs and says. I wonder if we can say foam is
water, like what we used to call casual water and temporary water now and you get a free drop. And the other member of the group, also laughing, says I'd love to watch you play it what What was resolved? Mary waves to a player on a parallel fairway and beckons are over to seek her opinion. After discussion of all involved, they decide the foam and the fairway's abnormal course condition and Mary can take relief without penalty and wipe any foam from her ball. Was the decision correct? Could the fun be defined as a
loose impediment and brushed away? The chances of this ever happening again would be greater than getting a hole in one. The story became the highlight of the day in the clubhouse gathering later. There's always a first time for something. Golf. What do you think? Without naming it correctly, would it be, you know, mutable, obstruction, Loose impediment? Something. Dew frostwater Something? What are you so propelled there without Narnia correctly? I have no issues with that person taking relief. Yeah, from that situation.
Yeah, it's artificial. We agree with that. Yeah. And artificial water. Artificial water, I wouldn't say is temporary water. I'd actually say that that's an obstruction. That's almost man made, yeah, with the foam in it. Well, it is. It is. It got there by someone's spraying. Yeah, like propelled air and all that sort of stuff. So like manufactured ice. So I would say that that's an obstruction, whether it's a movable obstruct, a movable
obstruction, or an immovable. Obstruction. I reckon if you try to move it, you break it apart, which means it's immovable. It should damage it. What happens if it's attached to your ball? Well, you're allowed to clean it and you're taking a leak. We're left from what? The very feet because if you. If it's an immovable obstruction, right, are you breaking it when you clean it? No, because you'll have to clean your ball when you're taking the leaf. And you're, well, not necessarily from a move obstruction. You're supposed to move this bone. Yeah, sure, And not the ball.
I think in this case you would make it immovable because as I said, if you try to move it you can damage it, but if it's a. Stuck to your ball? OK, you take the ball off, there's still some on the ground. What about the stuff that's on your foot? You definitely playing that on, right? Yeah. And you've broken. You've now broken the immovable obstruction. You have, but you're entitled to relief from it. It's almost like your balls on that immovable obstruction. You're entitled to free relief. Right, the immovable obstruction is on your ball. Hand on the ground. Still I that's why I'm saying wording it and coming up with
the precise technical how you would describe it. I think what's more important is I don't think anyone would have any issues, no. I don't think so either. I I think they've correctly taken relief from this abnormal course condition. It just it just gets me whether it's movable and movable obstruction. Well, you think it's very movable because you're you're almost blow it away. Actually I yeah, potentially. I think it is movable. And then if it is movable, then you don't get to clean your ball unless your ball gets.
Moved all right. Yeah, that's why I said, you know. You know, you pick, you pick the farm away, you're not going to be penalized if your ball. Moves, you know. But you don't. If the ball doesn't move, you don't get to. Put your pick, your ball up. This is what I say about any moveable obstruction, any obstruction that cannot be moved without unreasonable effort. So it doesn't, or without damaging the obstruction. And I think you're damaging it. You are, because you're pulling it apart. That's why I said moveable, and that's why I think that's fine.
That's why you said. Immovable. That's why I reckon it's immovable, because you're damaging it. Well, with that in mind, I would. Say cannot be moved with that unreasonable effort or without damaging it. You're damaging it. You're balls sitting on top of this immovable instruction. That's why I think you're entitled to relief. I that's why I think it's immovable instruction. OK. Does it say anywhere that you're not allowed to damage a movable? Obstruction. Is it saying where you're not allowed to damage a movable? Probably not.
Because if it's a scorecard you can reach. Yeah, you know it sure can. But what I'm saying is, by definition, any obstruction that you know cannot be moved without damaging it is immovable. And I'm saying if you start to move it, you're damaging it, You're pulling it apart or breaking into pieces anyway. We should disagree more. Without damaging the obstructs. What the fans want. That's right, cannot be moved without reasonably. Or without damaging it, and you weren't damaging it by moving.
But then it is disagreeing and dissipate in two hours, so it's damaging itself it. Is that's not a very concerned so. So then even on the I. Don't. Know if you look at it this way, if it if it dissipates and that is technically it cannot be, it cannot be considered damaging because that is that is the life cycle of the phone. The life cycle of the phone is that it it removed it, it disappears.
I mean. So that's not damaging. I'm not pounding my fist on the table. I'm not. I am. No. That's that's fine. I I don't think it's damaging to. I think the committee at that club would make a pretty reasonable decision and everyone would be OK. But I think the committee are not going to call it an immovable or no. No, they say. No, you're fine. That's gone. They're just going to call it an abnormal. Course, yeah, you're you're fine. Just take. It similar to temporary water, but temporary water. Does temporary water say that it's natural? Temporary was just a temporary
accumulation of the wool, and then it's not only there like in Victoria last week, any temporary accumulation of water on the surface of the ground. Yeah, I guess because it could come out of your house when you're irrigating some. Yeah, it does say or irrigation or an overflow from the body of water, but this because this has a specific type of chemical and. Yeah, that's why I think it's it's it's structured, it sounds. Yeah, yeah, I agree with that. We just.
I'm not sure whether it's movable or immovable, which of course are two different rules. One's 15.2116. Point one, there's two different ways you tackle. Comes down to the committee. Yeah, right. We're gonna move on. I. Know they're gonna be right. I'm saying movable. You're saying unmovable. But I'm not paying off yourself. But we but at the same time I say movable but I and agreed that the relief was and that situation was OK, which makes my sort of thought process wrong. But that's right. Right Next one from Chip. While playing a Path 3 island
green where the entrance to the green was on the back, a player hit her ball and rolled off the back of the green. Not having played this course, she was not sure if it was wet, AKA in a red penalty area or in the rough. She immediately walked over the drop zone about 20 yards closer, dropped the ball, caught a provisional and head on. Is that allowed? If she crossed the red stake into the water, the ball ended up caught in the rough and the
provisional was picked up. That's when this happened at Lone Tree Golf Course in Arizona. Wow. If she didn't know that over the back was a red state penalty area, then that's OK to that's OK to play a provisional. Ball but it's not. OK, to go to the drop zone. And call it a provisional. And call it a provisional ball. And now the drop zone is there. I want to see how they mark. It as an option.
As an option if you hit your ball in the Bell area. So she's almost admitting. Well, it's obviously there, yeah. Or it's. I'll play this provisionally. If it is in there, I don't need to come back to the drop zone. I'll play this provisionally. Because if we go down there and it's definitely in and, well, I've already proceeded correctly, I don't have to go back. Yeah, yeah. So she should have taken the one that she dropped. The one that she dropped was the ball in play as soon as she. Hit it, Yeah, unless there's the model local rule in place. Otherwise you do provisional. Be the ball 3 or whatever, I
mean the ball. Might be in a penalty. So. Which one are? You love, so yeah. So Chip, if she drops the ball in the dropping zone, unless there's local rules that we don't know about, she cannot call that ball a provisional ball. It's 20 yards closer to the green. It's the that drop zone would be an option under 17 that you had hit your ball in, that you knew
you'd hit the ball in the penalty area. It's unfortunate if there's rough there because you know, we know you can only the provisional if your ball might be lost outside a penalty area. And in this particular case, the seven is going open up the legs and the guys are on the tee going, oh, should we hit the provisional? Well, your ball's either in the penalty area or it's not. And if it's not, you'll find it, yes. Yeah. So you can't eat a provision, yeah. In this case, but in even in this case and even in this case, where if it was fairway into the
penalty area because she didn't know the hole. Yes. Oh yeah, that's but then surrendered by water though Island greens, Serena by. She's never Maybe she hadn't looked up and seen that the hole. Maybe it was in a? Tree. It's a penalty area. Yeah, yeah. But it could be just water, water and then out of the back because she's thinking, how's the mower get on there. That's what. Mower. Well, we know there's a wall grown in the back lawn Mower. Yeah. How do you say? We know there's a wall grown in the back. You have to, you know, hatch a
boat to get onto the green, but it's surrounded by water. We know there's a penalty area, we just probably don't know what color it is. Like I'm. I'm not going to debate her reasoning for why she thought it wasn't a penalty area. You are if you're not sure, you think that it's lost outside. I mean, she could have thought that there was rough before the penalty area, it could have been six. And she thought, depending on what other parts of the course, you know, played sort of similar to that. But the fact is she did not play
the provisional correctly by playing from the last place previous place played, she went to the drop zone. The drop zone would be an option, an option. And they were all 17. So that is the ball in play. As she picked up her ball in the rough, that was a ball and play. So it's going to be another shot. Henry. Sorry, she picked up the provisional. That's the ball and play. So it's another shot, Henry. And then she's playing a long. Ball and not corrected. And not corrected it. So DQ Good. Good question, Chip.
Love that, right? So that's all club level club land. He told me a few years ago. Not that we've known each other that long, but he told me this years ago. Two of the most commonly misunderstood rules. Both start with P. Yeah. I mean, you combine the two of them? Yeah. All hell bracelets. Yeah. And another one starts with UP unplayable. The provisional and penalty areas, Yeah, combine those two people go bananas with just confusion, understand. I I'd love to make them simpler the other way but I I just don't
see a way that doesn't also take away you know continue the challenge of the game and go. I mean if you want to make it easy you just go, OK, you've you can hit a provisional if you're drop your ball in the field that'll that's the easy. And the provision will be and you can play it anytime, like you can choose it as your ball when you die and not even worry about that would. That would take out a lot of. Oh, there's my unplayable. So there's my originally, it's unplayable. I forget about this gun play, that sort of stuff, which we know you can't do, but that
would simplify things a lot. Exactly. Happened at Sandbelt last week, that particular incident. Anyway, digress. Well, it's now your turn to shine. I'll just say about this ruling with I applauded the player. So I'm actually driving in for a quick lunch break and I come to the lead group. The last two players who after round three were one at 15, one at 11, and then daylight to 3rd and they're coming out of these bushes and then waved down to give them a drive back to the
team. OK, I said. And as we're driving back to the tee, because I'll just slow down, I'll pick up this ball, Here I go. What's that ball? He says. My provisional and I basically almost slammed on the bracelet. Hang on just a second. Hang on, hang on. What can you just describe to him what's happened? He said. I found my original. I wanted to take an unplayable. My best option for unplayable was striking distance. I said OK, thank you, continued driving back to the tee, we picked up his provisional.
I said thank you for not playing the provisional. He goes well. It pays to every now and again read the rules, he said to me. And I said well, well done for not playing the provisional ball as an option for stroke and distance. We're unplayable. Which round was that? Fourth round at Royal Melbourne E 5th home just over the road. 5th Home drove back to the corner to the tee and he he said to me he said Oh well every now and again I I open up the rule and he's the guy who won with a hole in one on the 16 hole Oh wow to get back into the lead.
Remember I phoned you? Oh. Wow, I said. How? So he had a He had a double. He had a double on that hole. It was 6 over through thirteen holes and now not in the lead. Yeah, Booty's 15. There's a hole in one and 16 didn't retake them. Did you see the hole one? I was standing behind the tee and heard the commotion and saw him throw the club and not in disgust. He's just throwing it back to the caddy, sort of. Then, you know, enjoy absolute joy. And I know, wait, why? And I took a video of him.
I've got a year on my phone. Took a video of him retrieving the ball at the hole and then, which I'd like to think went viral. What I did. Yeah, well, you. You put your camera there and you're like going out there because I. Know. And then you seen it on Channel 9, didn't you I? Didn't do that, but I didn't take that video, so you've had a lot of pretty happy about. It you've had a lot. Of. Experiences over the last six weeks. Yeah, done quite a few events, yeah, everyone.
Wants to know about the Australian Open. Not necessarily the time that you made sure to get your face on TV, but you know what was this? That was your first Australian Open. It was, you know, The funny thing about that camera? I've never seen it, of course. No, because one, there was 500 people and it must have been this little tiny handheld thing. And you know what? You know what every person is doing around that wall? They've got their phone out. So everyone was holding something and this guy just happened to be holding something a little bit bigger, but not as
if it was a massive tripod. You know, nothing, just this tiny little thing. So I didn't even have the cameras there because by that time I was told to, you know, to find out this fall as inbounds or not. I wasn't caring about people or cameras or anything, But back to the experience. It was a great experience obviously because of the crowds, gallery ropes, heaps of volunteers, heaps of volunteers on every hole. And I'll make a point of saying hello to those volunteers and what's your job today. And some are quite one in
particular was pretty military about very, very strict. And you go through the lakes under the tunnel to the 2nd hole and the players were as soon as they got out, you know that course as soon as they get out of the tunnel, they're turning right go up the path behind the tee to get to the second tee. And I was just happening to be sitting while this Marshall who's up the path and he's going to the players in case, Oh no, stop. No, you need to come up here. And I said, mate, let him go, they're fine. No, no, no. I've been told the players, I've got to walk up to this path and then go to the tee.
I said don't worry about it. He was really taking his job a little bit too. The caddies and the players couldn't really care less and they're coming up that path. They knew the tee was right there and I was just going to walk up this dirt track, turn left and they were there. I reckon every single point of crew did that. Anyway, back to that. Lots of volunteers, lots of gallery, lots of ropes. But you know, I wrote this in the report really quickly. I realized it was just a tournament. So we did all the usual stuff and we had our timing sheet and the T sheet and the local rules
and we had our radio and just monitor pace of play and it was just really another tournament. Now I got bigger on the weekend when, you know, the crowds were pretty amazing, as in fantastic sized prayers and you felt the buzz in the atmosphere. But really it was just doing what you do, doing what a lot of other guys do and girls just refereeing. So when I was in that group on Saturday, my first ruling was Lucas Herbert was stuck right behind on those advertising
boards and the guy goes, oh, what do I do here? I said let's move them. So the volunteer and the caddie lived there like just normal stuff. So it was great. I mean, great atmosphere, great event, really thrilled. I did it. If I don't do another, at least I can say I've done it. I know you've done 20 of them, but not quite. But it was fantastic. It was a great experience and you know, there was a lot more referees than I thought they'd be because of course the last, what maybe 5678 groups of both
Tees on the Sunday had a walking referee and you had all the Rovers as well. There's probably six of those, maybe 6 to 8 seen guys work in the DP World Tour, the European Tour, 2 referees and some admin staff. That was good just to see they did all the stuff the same way. It was good to see them maybe describe something a different way or it's just that was a great experience. And as I said, thank you for your kind words about the report. I really enjoyed writing that. It was nice to see so many people have read it and and written some comments because yeah, that was the experience.
It was terrific. Yeah, good. Son thought that was a bit too long, thought it was a bit like a novel and they weren't going to read it. That's their choice. But you know, another novel that they could read was Trading In a Nutshell can help you with trading, and it's written by Gilbert McKee. That's their. Choice 4th edition. Thank you. They don't want to read it. Don't read it. Yeah, well, that's that's what I was saying that's. Just and you know, your mother said. Can't say anything nice. Don't say anything anymore. Just if you click on it and see 2000 works OK go and read something else.
Exit there though. There's some good pictures there. I think you got it in about four or five of them. One of them, someone said stand there at your first Australian Open and I wasn't going to stand there, another referee said. Oh, OK. So I've got a couple of questions. What time did you get up there? What? What day? Wednesday. You got up there Wednesday. The touring started on Thursday. When When did you go and see the Lakes? When did you have your little referee drive around at the Lakes? The next morning, the day of
starting correct. So I was there early. I went out before played and started. So I remember the first time I'm on 2348, I've gone out there and I actually drove all the four holes I had played at once. So I was sort of familiar with the kind of, but I don't like, but yeah, just that morning. And then for the Australian, which was played on the Saturday Sunday that you're currently I. Was played all four days, but I was only there. Yeah, you were Saturday, Sunday. It was, but it was the only course being played on Saturday, Sunday, correct?
Sorry. When did you go and take a look at? Wednesday because we're there for the. Meeting. Yeah, yeah. And when did you work out where the boundary stakes were for all 7? Not early enough. Not early enough? Yeah, so. But, but you know, I wrote an article about this, unrelated to this, about the collaborative effort for refereeing. You know, someone said to me, I reckon they're spot on. 90% of our rulings are all the same.
Car path, temporary water, GUR, whatever it might be, it's every now and again. It's one of the unplayable common. It's a collaborative effort though. So you know, for that ruling I spoke to two people. I wasn't going to do it on my own because it was important. So it was that straight away, that collaborative effort of jumping on the radio and talking to two people. And I think in some of the few of the guys in the PGA have said this, if there's 1% of down, just get on the damn radio, right? It takes 10 seconds to get it right, to get the consistency,
just jump on the radio. And I used to think it was almost a an embarrassment to get on the radio. You talk about the guy that played three weeks in a row taking relief from a car path and the toured radium and said mate, you got to learn this rule. Imagine if you're jumping on the radio all the time about the same thing all the time, everyone else going to go and doesn't even know the rules when you do his Level 2, you know. So there's that. Unfortunately that's the stigma of your don't know the rules, so why you're even here?
But as I've always said, the referee is your friend. I've asked about from some pretty simple rulings just so I make sure and it gives you a bit of time as well. Then you can have just an absolute brain fade, yeah, where if you were asked 5 minutes ago, you would have known. If you were asked the next day, you would know. And for some reason you just weren't thinking clearly for whatever reason. Like a sugar, there could be just something stupid. But you just jump on the radio and someone else who is thinking literally knows the rule. Yeah, that's this. Oh yeah, of course it is.
Bang right. Rulings give them consistencies achieved. Yeah. So as I said, it's a very collaborative effort referee and I think good referees should jump on the radio a lot. And in fact, again, again, one of the PGA guys said to me who did maybe the Irish Open this year, he's come back and thought we don't talk enough on the radio, we're not talking to each other enough, like towards the end of a tournament we're entertaining each other with commentary about how the finish is happening, he said. We don't talk enough during the day about stuff that's going on there should be more of.
Them. I guess there's only about 3 of you doing rules on your tour. Though yeah, depending on yeah, depending on the event it'll be more of the pretty short. Start yeah. There'll be more of the big open, typically four, and one of them is the tournament director, typically four, yeah. That's pretty small and one of. Them is the tournament director. Yeah. He's doing other things outside the ropes as well, as well as being a referee. But he was saying, yeah, we don't talk enough on the radio. There should be more of it. And that's, you know, we talked about that post about what have you learned this year? To me, one of the things I've learned is the difference between technical knowledge and
practical application on golf course. I said this to your friend and our friend Marcella just not so long ago, that when you read all those Facebook posts or quizzes, every piece of information you need to make an answer to give an answer is presented to you. And the art of refereeing is you actually need to complete the question first before you actually work at the answer. And sometimes the rules can be really quite straightforward. It's establishing the facts, but it's a challenge. That's what's difficult. You've got to work. Out the question. What's the question before? When you get, the question
hasn't even been completed. You've actually got to finish writing the question when you get there, and that's the art of refereeing and any question given to you. Everything you need to answer it is there. When you're refereeing for real, that's not necessarily the case. Refereeing for real, you've got to, you've got to ask the question and the info on the answer. Some of the questions been asked by the player, you've actually got to finish writing it and then you get to the answer. By asking questions to find the facts that determine got the actual questions. 11 could be what areas, of course, Yeah, it's the ball line. That's pretty good. And you know, every question you read has that, yeah, always went
into blah blah blah. Anyway, so that can be the other referee. Great experience. I'm definitely a better referee because of just this. Much better. And you did the Sandbelt Invitational, which was amazing. I did Cathedral two days later after the. Cathedral was easy because it was good weather. Sandbelt Invitational. This is Melbourne weather summed up. Yeah, In summer, the first day was thunderstorms. Overnight. That morning, yeah.
And then light rain the. First day was flooding in Victoria, correct? And there's not many golf courses that could handle it. Victoria could handle it, but they had, they did have a massive lake on the 10th hole that's not normally there. So you had a lot of rulings there? That's the busiest I've ever done on the golf course. And then the next the next day was 34 degrees 34°C, so boiling. 90 ish a bit. More than 90, right? Yeah. So then players had to deal with heat stroke and all that kind of
thing and drinking lots of water. The next day it was cold, wet and miserable. Right, Yara? Yara wasn't that cold, but it was thunderstorm. Thunderstorm, Correct. That was a thunderstorm. Yeah. He had suspension, comeback, 2 suspensions, 2 suspensions within about an. Hour and a half, yeah, Correct. So we send them out for what, half a hole and then no. It wasn't bit more than that, but it wasn't long. Yeah. And then had to get them back off again. Yeah, we have one guy, he's a committee procedure thing for you. So we have one guy with the first suspension on the 18th
with a four foot part for part. Yeah, the other two guys had already finished, Okay for the other player. Other two player had already finished and they. Wanted. Which of course, is his marker as well. So that guys come in, how long are you going to be the suspension? Oh, it won't be less than an. Hour. I want to go home. And he's gone. Wouldn't mind going home. So of course we just arranged that when he had that one part A. Signed, he signed you. Signed, Correct. He signed the scorecard and I sat by the 18th green, watching him make that part on the resumption of play, radioed it through, said he did have a four on that hole.
So sorry, we went through that a little bit quick, too quickly. So what happened was this group two had already finished, one had a four foot putt. Bang, the horn goes. The marker wants to go home because he's finished. And so he signs the scorecard and then Stewart watch the player make or miss the four foot part and then sign that he had tested for that shot plus the other seventy shots that the player had. So it's that committee certifying even though the mark is gone.
We we do this on tours, do this. I've done this this year where guys want to finish that night, say Thursday night, and then they're coming back the next morning. But one guy doesn't want to finish that night. He wants to come back the next morning and finish his round. So the other two play out. This guy comes back and we attest to his score for that last hole. But yeah, and as. And as a comedian, of course, there's no higher authority in that event than to certify that
score. No. Technically it doesn't. You know the marker is determined by your committee. So the marker is just being the committee passed that was on the player as the market responsibility onto a committee member as the market, right. We're we're running out of time for 1:06. So what we're going to do is run through the GRQOTW 106. We did tease you about the advanced, but I think we'll get
those done soon in another podcast. But just running out of time, Stewart is going to give us the GIQO TW1O6 and then we're going to finish up. So, Stewart. We've talked about 7 point something before, didn't we, about four wheel penalty GIQOTW for one O 6 DP has hit his tee shot into the red penalty area, running down the right side of the 14th hole, say at Warm Bed Hills. After 2 minutes of searching, he
finds and identifies his ball so it's lying in the penalty area. He makes a stroke at the ball and only advance at 3 meters. Frustrated, he makes another stroke at it from inside the penalty area, moving it very little, and then again makes another stroke. Very, now very frustrated, he says he is returning to the team area to start the hole again, despite some significant and strong objections from others in the group. Off he wanders off, he goes back
to the teeing area. He returns to the team area, Tees up a ball and makes a stroke from the teeing area and finishes the hole. There are no players waiting behind. Did he? Once he completes play that hole? How many penalty strokes must BP add to his whole score? His score for that whole? How many pain in his strokes must BP add to his score for that whole? OK, I think I've got it. It's like one of the first ones I've actually listened to. But I do have one question.
Good. He makes a stroke, another stroke from inside the PA, moving it very little. It had come to rest before he made another Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. That's fine. So effectively he's had a tee shot gone into the RE penalty area, found and identified. He's made a second stroke at it inside the penalty area, stayed inside the penalty area, made a third stroke at it, didn't go anywhere and made a fourth stroke at it, all within his RE penalty area and gone. This is ridiculous. I'm not having a great day. I'm going back to the team, starting again. Well, if you've gotten this far to the GOQO TW106, you'll know
that we spoke about this and right at the start of the episode with one of the Clubland Westerns Clubland stories. So you should have this one all. How many penalty strokes must be PA? We're not asking for how many strokes, we're just asking for how many penalty. Strokes correct? Excellent. Another episode of GRQ, not as long as the one with Fraser, but it's that Fraser one has been really welcomed or really
enjoyed by a lot of people. So thank you very much Fraser Nickel for giving up your time. We will go into these TGRS discussions and USGA stuff in another episode, But thank you everyone for listening in for 1:06 and we will be back again, back with you very soon. Thank you, Stuart. Thanks Blanky.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...