Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

CLUBLAND STORIES - THE GRQ PODCAST EP86

Apr 26, 202359 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/joinSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules.GOT A CLUBLAND STORY - Submit it here https://forms.gle/Jga9wNrnwUVFUQD98.CLUBLAND STORIES - THE GRQ PODCAST EP86.GRQOTW #85 Marcela has until someone tees off from the next teeing area, to correct the match score..CLUBLAND STORIES - Preferred Lies - Provisional Ball vs Second Ball - Penalty Area Local Rule (B-3) - Teammates cannot give advice - Ball Not Found Options - Switching Balls Before Teeing Off.GRQOTW #86Big P's ball lies just inside a red penalty area on the 4th hole at Wombat Hills. His ball is playable and in taking his stance for a reasonable stroke, his left foot is standing in temporary water in the general area. He takes free relief and drops correctly within the relief area within the penalty area. He plays his 2nd shot, chips onto the green with his third and has two putts to hole out. What is his score for the hole and why?.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYHttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

In episode 86 of the grq podcast, we go through six delicious clubland stories that have been waiting for us, Stewart chimes in with another marker, conundrum, and Blakey fills us in on his live experience in Adelaide. So, grab a cup of sit back and relax, and let Blake Ian Stewart bring you the golf rules questions podcast. Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill and playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Welcome everyone to the grq

podcast episode 86. I'm Blakey and alongside me. I have my good friend at Stewart McPhee. Hello Stuart. How are you? I'm all flaky, but I don't think I had a greater weekend as you would have had over in Adelaide. Yeah, well, my boys has gone a little bit as we were celebrating partying last night on the back of, what was An unbelievable experience. It was actually, it was exhausting having that many people around and making sure that everything was going well

and going to plant. So it actually was exhausting, but it was an amazing, amazing event, and we look forward to it, all happening again, and Adelaide next year. Very good. So we have the we'll talk a bit about a couple of rulings from live later on in the program. But I really wanted to get the clubland stories out of the way or not out of the way to the listeners because you're the ones that have been asking the questions and I want to answer

those questions or we want to answer those questions as quickly as possible. But first, Stuart could you tell us the g oq o TW 4 episode, 85 Marcela and Fraser applying a matchup on bad Hills. Both players have a four on the 12th hole and as As they are walking off, the green Fraser says to my seller. That is a half. My seller says nothing. As they are standing at the 12th or 13th tee. And before either player has

started the next whole Mass seller says, actually I've got a shot on that last hole. So I won Fraser applies. No, that's not right. As we walked off the green. I said we were halved and you heard me and you didn't correct me. It is a hard whole Marcela request a ruling. What would you decide? Yeah. And a couple of guys on the YouTube, I'd through some answers there. So Darryl and David couple of regular contributors, which we absolutely love and they pointed out rule 3 point 2, D 3, which

is spot-on. So Marcela has up until the next buyer tees off or a player tees off from the next hole to correct. The understanding of the match score. So price is not quite right on that one and mountains. Marsala is now wonder what would happen if Fraser said do. That's a half and Marcellus is yep. That's correct. We both had a fall. Does she still have up until

when one of them begins makes a stroke to begin the next hole? Is she still had that opportunity to say actually I've just realized I get a stroke on that whole. I don't think that is correct. I think I've won. It should still have the opportunity to correct that. Yeah. Yeah. She does have that opportunity to correct that. I mean it's all about the the understanding of the score before another stroke is made basically. And so if Fraser who thinks he has the honor, please it up on the 13 and makes a stroke to begin play the whole and Marcela

goes I actually I just realized I had a shot on the 12th, bad luck. Can't correct it? Yeah, correct. Because the understanding wife Raisa could change the way that he plays the next hole. If he was down, he might be a bit more aggressive if he was up. He might be a bit more defensive than if another player comes along. And says, I actually I forgot to apply the shot that I get. Well, that's their responsibility. And if they hadn't done it in a timely manner, Ben, that's bad

luck on them. Really actually, I'm someone to 3.2 as well is a section called knowing the match score. The fact that both player and opponent had that responsibility, it was one of the questions I asked on my recent course was, why do we continue the match with? In fact, a school that's incorrect and they basically said along the lines of what you just said and that is that well one you have a not a responsibility to know but that actually can affect the way you then chain, you know, play the next hole based on your understanding Standing in the score. No good. Three holes later going. I actually know that score is

incorrect. We need to change it back because it's influence the way you played the last two or three holes so that was a really good answer. You've entered in Israel, why? I wrong match score actually becomes the real match score even if it's incorrect. Yeah. Someone on. Have you ever had that happen in him? And I part from theory. Is it? Have you ever heard that? Don't think so. No I'm sorry yes not for melt or you were talking about me when I was thinking about that. Definitely heard of one situation. Yes at my old Club

misunderstanding of a rule they but then soon as I began so they actually had a wrong match school which became the real match school. So yes was to do with conceding a hole and misunderstanding the rule That's, that's one of the first time you actually contacted me about, what the ruling. What I think it was. You know, the one. Yeah. That was like, a team for the Heritage or something like that is amazing. Tender Tenley, that's it. Yeah, yeah. I was just I was just just pop them out here like and I think I remember something like that

that's exact and you're going. Who is this guy constantly, especially with emails, please. Yeah, it's like, nah. Nah, nah, nah. Another one of those. But luckily for you, I am one of those rules nerds, as well. So, so yeah. What's that saying? You struck a chord? No, next resonating you mix with the people that you are talking very good. Alright, so my sellers in business thing to attract to the people that that you throw in that case Marcel I did.

In fact, when the whole yeah, correct and she takes off first as the honor. Now, let's get into To above 6 clubland, stories sitting in front of us. I think I've gone through most but they might have been one pop up the end and I wasn't sure of. So let's start with nickname::. Tell us about your rules situation, he Club so Club lengths, placing my playing partner, asked our group, what

this ruling would be, he was on The Fringe of the grains going to cut on. He asked if he took a club like placing on with green, was with this be allowed, what? Actions, no one really knew what the answer was. So my make just parted from where his bald head landed one of our group when we got in, ask someone who sort of knows, some of the rules said, that would be improving as li like, maybe taking a club link, from the Fairway under the rough. So you Tee It Up. Slightly forward shot or own long on. I don't know if you fellows and

discussed this before, but I'm not sure. What the correct ruling would be. So basically what Collins saying is the club, obviously has a preferred lies, local rule in place and that preferred lies is a club length. The player. I wanted to take the preferred Liar's Club length and and places both from the general area onto the green. And then they were having a discussion and they believed

that it would be similar from taking it from the rough, to the Fairway, right? Uncle. If the local rule for preferred lies, Also was in the general area. Not just the cat to feel a hive or less. Is that how you is that? Why you gathered from that situation? Yes, it was a model locally. Three, preferred lies was in place that preferred lie. The relief area is one Club length and they're simply saying can we move it? Assuming it was no nearer. The whole, can they move it from

the general area on to the putting green as part of that relief procedure? I think the more juicy operation. What is the answer there? Co are you? 32, as well as I do. That is a definite. No. The preferred lie is in the general area. You can't at the relief are. He's got to be in the general area. You can't put it on the green and I'll put this to you. I don't know of a situation in which you can get your ball onto the green without penalty. As intake relief and your ball ends up on the ground without penalty. Put me on the spot there.

No, I just well, you know, if it's a penalty area, the penalty, the green might be right next to the Penalty area can drop on the Green Tree overhanging a green, take an unplayable, drop it onto the green, but all of those incur a penalty. I can't think of any situations in which your ball can end up on the green after taking relief, but for free. Is anybody any free relief procedures? Probably restricted to the specify the area. The course you're taking relief. I see like think of a situation we drag race at the answer.

The question. No? Yeah, yeah. The answer: is, no, you can't place it on the Green from the general area even when that local rule preferred lie is in place now to your second point about rough and Fairway what you did. Point more like a question. If the local rule preferred lie is in place for the jinwu area and the general area is rough and fear at feel way. So includes both, you can

actually take it from the rough to the Fairway or from the Fairway, to the rough because you might find that you get a nice little tuft of grass in the Run. If the so that's that's a yes. If the local rule doesn't specify that it's a fertilizer for feel a height or cut to feel, I hide or less. And so if it just says, preferred lies in the general area in, you would be able to take it within that club lengths. If it was from rough, to feel our But if it was just capped a

feeling, I do less of it specified in the general area, cut the Fairway, height or less you would have, you would have to keep it in the Fairway. Or take it from the Fairway to the rough, you wouldn't have the option of taking it Taking a preferred light in the Run. Hope I made that clear. And if we went back to that, you would like to think the local rule in place. At that club would be very specific about the requirements for the relief area. You know, must be within one clubland. No nearer. The whole and in the general area, it would more than likely specify that.

Yeah. Yeah. Why do you if the club doesn't write down that local rule, Doesn't write the whole paragraph down. What do you do then secure? What does the rule say then? Well, is what I want, if they just wrote on the board, the fertilized in play and a preferred Hereford lies one Club later. No, no not at their. Well, okay, they specified one Club length. What would you do? Well I know what you and I would

do, what would you assume or? You know what? I you. And I would assume we would assume all day until like committee and abuse that you and I would know that. Going to be general area, we wouldn't be dropping it on the green. I'll place it on the ground as part of a relief. Procedure preferred laws are you would be able to do that. You would be able to share From the Rough to the Fairway if you wanted to sure if it didn't specify closely mine. Yeah, correct you. And you would know that it's no near the hole like that, that's what the e3l says.

It says, all that the default you just, you just want to try to get at it. You just go back to what the default tells us and that's under committee proceedings. There's local rules 8383, would you? And I would know and would follow. So that's when you asked me well I know what I would do but what would most Club golfers do? Hey my one Club length. No near the hole is on the green Beauty. Yeah yeah yeah and that's what we're doing. Colin. Is that Simona right chip?

Hello chip. Thank you for sending your questioning. Question about a rolling. I just finished listening to a question from to Bob. I think that guy's playing a red ball and then realizes that he had played a white. All most of the conversation was about to go pick up your ball, wouldn't it be playing the wrong ball since there was no reason given for switching balls? Thank you for the podcast. Good question. Chip, can you remember this club? Lane story. You know, do is Bulls going off

into the rough searching, his other. You know the other person is playing with his mate finds that he's your ball with your marking on it, but it's white. And to Bob's do know, I been playing a yellow ball all day or red ball all day. It's not mine. It's but you're marking on it. Yeah, but it's not mine. I've been playing yellow and then are searching searching. Can't find two minutes later to Bob goes actually you pick up that ball? Can you show me what that ball is? Again, please? And he looked like it. Ah, that is mine. Ball. I remember I teed off on this whole with a white ball. Not yellow.

That's my ball. What do we do now? I think that was the gist of that scenario which of course happened for real was it asking you remember if it was past three minutes? No, it was not within three minutes. Sorry, it was not passed. Three minutes. It was within the three minutes each time. So that's a minute later. That was lucky and they found that ball now. So we've spelled out what it was now. Chip saying was the player allowed to switch balls?

Switch bowls. Know the balls gonna be replaced. No, he wasn't. He was asking why if you're from the TV and if he'd been playing a red ball day. Oh yeah, that's right. That's right. From the team. Is it all from the tea? Unless the, unless the tournament event, local rule has a one ball or something like that. Then, of course, you can begin a new hole with a new ball. Yeah. So, so the answer to that chip is The ball has to be the same

from tee shot to putting it into the green into the hole. So unless, you know, you've lost your ball or you're allowed to substitute it. But after after the hole is finished, you can use any new ball old ball as long as it's conforming for for the next hole and you could use a new ball for the next hole after that and new board. For the next up, you could actually Use 18 different balls and 18 different holes. If you wish the switching of the

ball before you start, the whole is allowed as what we're getting it. Okay. And next one. Chip, again, it's just easy. Chipping in with a catalyst Royce, which we appreciate okay. I know this Breaks the Rules. That's not great. Start, I know this breaks the rules, but we have about 200 plus members of our men's group. So, case of play is very important. We have a whole that crests

about two-thirds of the way down this path. For if you're not, if you're drivers, not very good. You cannot see the front of the green. Um, your From your ball between you. And the whole is a ravine Red State. So County area and deep green side bunker, and a lot of bushes separating. So if your second shot is not long, you lose sight of it. I get the gist of where he's going with this instead of driving over the bridge over the rabine parking walking, 40 yards, the bunker. And each of the Ravine to look for your ball, we drop in front

of the red States, call it a provisional pit. In look for the original. I know you are supposed to look before you drop. We all know this but we don't want to waste six minutes or so executing what you're supposed to do, what is your suggestion? Yay, Sam. I and is my most hated local rule but considering that they are breaking the rules. I would definitely get your committee to research and possibly Implement local rule,

Stuart, you know, I don't know the number, you know, the number B know because I'm one off here, I think it'd be three. Okay, and what is that? Local rule do more importantly Yeah. It is a local rule chip that you are able or your committee is able to adopt and it means that you can play a ball provisionally. If you're not sure whether a ball has gone into a penalty area or is lost outside the penalty area.

In Elder Blakey be throat. So, there you go. So get your committee to look up. Local rule B3. and then potentially that will be Exactly what you you doing at the moment, which is playing a ball provisionally. Under one of the penalty area, rules the penalty area options. And then, but then this is what why I don't like it. But as I said, it's probably the best best thing that you can do for your situation of the club

can do for the situation. We just have to educate the Gophers. On your actual. How to proceed their procedure after they find beer original ball, if they find it in the penalty area, it's got a list there Stewart doesn't, you can modify the rule? I don't point three is modified to allow players to play football, provisionally, under rule, 17 point 1, d, 1, 2 and 3

for a red penalty area. Sorry, those three options for Relief under a penalty area, rules 18.3, B and C are modified to state that when Such a provision of all my store may be played or abandon as stated by the Mughal local rule modulo crawls down here. Further if a player does not know whether the ball is in a penalty area, the player may play provision of all under rule unemployed three in playing the provision of all the player may use the stroke and distance relief, option, just 17.1 D1, the back on the line relief option, or if it's a red penalty or either lateral relief option

as well. Or if a dropping zones available, you can use that once the player has played a provision of all under this local rule, they may not use any Options under 17.1 in relationship to the original. All going to get further in deciding when that provision of all becomes of players ball in play, or if it must or may be abandoned. When the original ball is found in the penalty area within three minutes. Each time, the player may choose either to continue to play the original as it lies in the penalty area, in which case the

provisional ball must be not play. Demanded all Strokes. Are that provisional ball? Yep. That can't or they can continue to play the provision of all in which case original wall must not be played. So what you probably don't like about it is you actually have a choice now. Yeah, that's right. A convenient choice but she won't like yeah as as as I said the basic as Gypsy they're basically greater breaking the rule at the moment. So this will actually help them out to not break the rules by

adopting that local will be through. And of course, the key is, you know, why would the committee Adopted, it's all about time. If it would unreasonably delay, play, if the player had to go forward to look for the ball before returning to play another ball under one of the options under rule 17, it's all about saving time. Yeah, spot on radio. We have have another one here from mr. Roberts all players. And the group playing a stable food event.

Planner a, it's a big long slice out into trees. Scrub wild animal country. He says, we will never find that. I will hit another one. He didn't say anything about hitting a provisional. Why a bathing sighs? Well that is now your ball in play and you are three play a see pipes and I think we will have to look for his first shop for three minutes by a bee replies. He might be better off playing

his fourth shot, the second ball. Then if we find his ball in all that, junk Lassie maintains that we have to look for his first ball and Fe, if we find it, he has to play it by ear. Abby keeps going well, he might declare it unplayable. I think you can do that anytime you like by a cement tanks that we have to find it first before he can declare an unplayable. Lady gets into the discussion.

I agree with see that? We have to look for it and if we find his ball it is the one in play. We don't find it. He's lying three with his second ball. Seen in size. If we find it, he has to play it any cops apparently for hitting the second ball. And not saying it's a provisional. I think that sending a wrong ball or wrong substitutable. Let's see what happens and when we get and we will ask mr. Are mr. Roberts, what should happen? So what so what actions were

taken to resolve each? Hope you keep him. Stephen tractor is playing, huh? As above the group decided to ask when they finished the ramp they found the first of all, when all the rough trees, scrub and play a hack, his way out, and ended up with a seven on the whole and did not score any stale food points, the group came into the clubhouse after the round and found mr. Roberts happily enjoying a drink. After his round of 33 points, describe the situation. Just found the rule book and

referred to rule. 18.1 of stroke and distance relief at any time and went through the rule with the four guys Lassie was a bit quiet but they said I could have played the second ball and scored a point or two. Player B. Jumped in and said, one more Point won't help your 22 points. Much mr. Are then suggested that he send the story of clubland stories in the podcast rules questions with the lake Ian Stewart. Hey, so that we can get the

correct answer from the experts. The group of four said, what is that? And mr. Are explained and they all said they would listen sit down and have another drink. It's awesome. Okay, let's let's go through it. So first of all, why IA has hidden into the scrub Which is not out of bounds. And he says, so this is your test Europe. He says we will never find that. I will hit another one.

Is that a provisional ball or not? Stuart certainly is not in my book. So what we're saying guys listening is that is not enough to say that you're hitting a provisional. You either have to say, hitting a provisional Or you're hitting another one, just in case, or you're proceeding, this is Stewart's. Favorite one, Isabel you're proceeding under rule. 18.3 so though, one of those three sayings has to be said before you hit another ball, which you

want, cause you don't have that a provisional, but we encourage it. If you want to have original, you have to say that for you here. Now I think even the first words, reply Ray was we will not find that. Yeah it wasn't. We're going to have trouble. I may not find it. It was we're not going to find it. I mean if he'd said we might find that, but I'll hit another one. Just think eyes, right? But you know, he might not want to find it course which leads us

onto another comment. Someone else made about, we have to go in. Then I have a the insides well that is now your ball in play. And you are three and that she'll probably wasn't Blackie. No, it wasn't. But that is actually correct player. B is spot on there but then player cease pipes and I think we have to look for his first shot for three minutes. What do you say to that to do it? Well, I don't agree with this but certainly rule sevens pretty clear that you don't you. There's no obligation for you to go look for you or you don't have to look for it.

Others can go and look for it. You can ask them not to unless you physically arrest them and tackled him to the ground. They can go look for it. If I really wanted to. We have that conversation about your opponent in match play. Going to look for a ball of yours even though you've asked them, not to that's another matter but now you don't have to look for your ball. So you don't have to look for you born, our player B replies, he might be better off playing his fourth shot for the second ball, then if we find his ball and all that junk, I mean he's bawling play. Yeah, correct. He might be better off as in he

needs to go and play the one from particular like that's implied. They know where it is. I Believe by a sea maintain that we have to look for the first ball in that yet. As we said, that's not incorrect, play it now this is re still going because there's a few other things that they've said we need to clear up by. Abby keeps going well. He might declare an unplayable I think you can do that anytime. Locked. What do you say that? Now, that's not quite correct. There's two things one. If your balls in a penalty area

you can't declare it unplayable. Anywhere else on the course you can. The second thing is though, you can't always the clear unplayable, there's one key Criterion. You need to meet to be able to declare ball unplayable unless you're proceeding under stroke and distance but to take collateral relief, will back on the line. The first box you must tick is actually locate and identify and find your ball. Yeah. You gotta find it first. Or so, I would say one is correct about the penalty area, I'd say to you can declare it unplayable at any time from in

the penalty area. But if you want options, B, and C, correct back on the line, that'll leave, you must find the ball. If you don't find the ball, you've still always got stroke and distance. Place a maintains. We have to find it first before. You can be cleared up Bible. You have to find it if you want the back on the line or the lateral relief period. And then player D got in and said, I agree with c and we have to find the ball and play. If, if we find the ball it's the one in play. If we don't find it.

He's lying. Three with the second ball. We both of us would say, he's already lying three, others all in play. That is as second ball perfectly. Done. Simply the word wording used on the tee. Yeah, that's right. And intention and the fact that he's gone and played the original ball which is now out of play. When he played the second ball, he the original ball is the wrong ball. Yep. There's a general penalty feeding the hungry. I'm glad it was a stable for the

event and he got zero points because that's basically exactly what he should have. Got otherwise, you would have been disqualified. Correct. It was a stroke around and he didn't and he went and played the wrong ball. You get the penalty and you need to fix your mistake. So hopefully we've cleared that up for the golfers there at mr. H club now to Bob is back All this is. Relative it relates.

So, to what? I just went through and Adelaide. So three players in the team event playing in a group. Can they give advice to each other about, which clubs to use Etc? Watching the first round of live Adelaide as I type this and I see that many of groups are made up of from one only one of the lib Dems. Are they permitted to give advice to each other as they play as live as both an individual and team event? And other specific roles in the lift on. At that permit. This looking forward to hearing more from Blakey, bad at all.

Keep up the good work with podcast and golfers videos. Cheers to Bob. So yeah. We, we did the draw on Tuesday night or Wednesday morning or live Adelaide. And we put all the team captains together in the first four groups, and then we put all the team members. From the 12 teams, all together and and three balls off the rest of the holes.

So the Majestics were playing together, the cleats are playing together, the range goats Ripper GC or plan together. And we actually sent a message out to the team saying. Don't ya, you know there is no your it's all an individual game so you know there is no giving advice between your even though that teammates on your team. There is no giving of individual

advice, giving advice to individuals because you're still playing an individual game. So I hope that clears that up to Bob. There is no allowance Of teammates giving advice to each other. It was awesome. Putting them in teams, I watch them come down, the freeway and their uniforms with such a, like a really cool experience. Yeah, I really like that. I think that might be something that we do going forward as

well. Well, it's not the live podcast but just a side comment, there's certainly several innovations that this new tour is brought to golf which I think people are loving and I think the team is one of them. Listening part of the whole event. I said, I don't think we stopped that I think will be continually innovating innovating innovating all the time to make sure that we you know this was this this tournament here and I'll give in to live in a second but this time he was Awesome spectator

experience. You know, it's five hours, we had people turning up an hour two hours before, but it's not all it's not all day necessarily and you know we spread the players around the course so you can get a good view of you know your favorites, we have a fan Village, all that type of thing so that this one here in Australia and end of that and Adelaide was a Food Fan Experience, but we still need to

continually make the TV product as best as possible because when we go to Singapore, leave for Singapore soon. We you know we've got live golf and Singapore when we go to Singapore. We won't have crowds. There will be maybe 500 people then it's hot, it's humid, it's chances of thunderstorms. It's just not conducive place with lots of people to come and watch.

So we just need to make sure. You know the biggest the biggest F20 F1 fans is sort of take comparison to F1. These the F1 fans are in the UK And you know they only they only drive around the UK f 1 so we'll sell sterling silver stream, still Wilston, silver sun stone, they only do that once but, you know, so they need to make sure they have a great TV product for people when they in the UK were watching, when they go all over

the world and the same thing of this live golf when we go all around the world, we need to make sure that the TV product is fantastic to. So there's always going to be really Innovations, making sure that the TV product is spot-on, people tuning in Right. Last one. Another one from Colin, loving these questions on the 9th at why? Matty? Why Matt is a small, small town in South, and the south island

of New Zealand, only lived about 45 minutes from it. And I grew up my drive slightly sliced, down a hollow near a fence, which includes a wet area running along it with a bank that runs up to the fence. Exactly can be worked out. What? That is trying to picture that you. It sounds like a Watercourse or a drainage ditch Down a hollow near the fence which includes a

wet area running along over the bank that runs up to the fence. It kind of sounds like that but also could just be depression or or the low part of that fee waiver or whatever. Normally a weak shot would run down the bank that heads towards the we area and vents into signing a bank and we would find it nine times out of 10. But this club day, we couldn't find it. I knew one option was to play my third off the tee. One of my group said, it's a

lost ball. So take a drop from where we thought it into the temporary water and Long Grass, couldn't go back in line with the pain because of the bank. What is the correct ruling? Their action was, they took to Publix and play the sir their third from the greed area. What do you what do you think about that once? Do it. So if they're preceded by taking relief from temporary water and abnormal course, condition, it needs to be known or virtually certain that the balls in the air. That's the first box we need to

check. Is it known or virtually certain that ball is in the temporary water? Because that's the only way you can take free relief from there. Even if you don't find it in any, it still would be known or virtually certain if you don't find it in there that may just change where you actually take relief from that water. But you've got to be known or virtually. Certain that it's in there in the first place. Yeah, I to me it doesn't really sound like temporary walk. Temporary water either kind of almost sounds like a penalty area. If it's sort of a low part of a

fear way, it could be temporary water, but they, it doesn't actually sound like they have that 95% virtual certainty, that it's in the temporary water or the long grass. So he's been taking a penalty drop. And drop it. Drop that within to Publix, you can only do the two Public's penalty drop. if you know where the boards and they didn't know where the ball was, So, the only

option is to go back and take stroke and distance from the tee. now, if your Club operates, the local rule, 85 and alternative to stroke and distance, Then you could. You could possibly do what you did but you'd have to take a 2-stroke penalty, but that's only if that local all has been adopted, you can't. Yeah to say that.

It's in the temporary water and needs to be temporary border. Not constant water, like what you'd find in a penalty area. It needs to be temporary and you need to have Stuart said you need to have at least 95% virtual certainty that the ball was in that temporary water. If I didn't mention going back on the lawn, you mentioned going back on the lawn but it wasn't an option. And then he's actually taken two Club lengths which immediately makes you think of a penalty area. Yeah that's two of your options for a penalty area Collins, definitely thought I'll take it

as well, he said but one of my group said, it's a lost of also take a drop from where we can. You bring into war do Wonder? Hmm, you can't take if you lose your ball, your only options stroke and distance. Unless as I said the The committee of adopted, the local rule E5. You can't say, oh, there's a lost ball. I don't know where it is. I'm just going to take a drop from where I think it went admitted into the temporary order unless That local Rory fibers and then it's a to strop

two-shot penalty, not one. So I need a pill freak on to email, me golf rules doc questions at gmail.com with a picture of the area. I'd like to have a look at it. See whether it should possibly be a penalty area instead, you know, because if you even if, even if it was sort of water course in by definition, it is a penalty area or it could be an

area where the committee might want to call. Little County area. And then you could type the tube table length drop from point of entry. If it was a penalty area and that might speed up play as well, so there's no no virtually certain. Yeah, correct Hannibal. Thank you, everyone for the club and stories, they were fantastic. And if you have any more or anyone else has any more, you hear of any in the bar, make sure you try and get them submitted and we will read them out on the golf balls.

In podcast. Now, Stewart, did you have one? I only had a simple one, you know, my love and admiration for markers, you know, a stroke play event. And this was at clubland, this is last Wednesday. And on one, I've finished, I'm sitting on the back deck, enjoying a snack and a drink with my group that I just finished with. And I see a group on the 88 and just 20 meters off the green on the Ada.

As I know plays, I'm now a captain who will listen to this, won't be saying is it could be better marked, but it is Mark but just not that well. But anyway, these are no plays. I know it's and there's a group looking for a ball in that area, everything around that no play zone, which is not a very big area, everything around. It is either the concrete path or closely, mowing grass, Fairway length and I could see them looking and we're just chatting away. Still looking. I can hear their conversation. They talk. About provisional and and I

thought I shouldn't do this, but I will, I'm a nerd. I'm a rules guy. You see a situation? You want to help? I'm 20 meters away? I know the player I just walked over said, John can I help in any way he goes? You're my balls that have come into this area here into the thick scrub, we can't find it. I'm about to go and play my provisional. I said, we know that there is a no Blazer you guys, all He said, yeah, but we can't find it, that's if that's okay. If it's not all virtually certain to be in there, you don't have to you know, you don't take the provisional.

That's what he's Market shifted marker. We are. We can't find it. I said no, that's okay. But if we known or virtually certain that it's in there, that's enough for us to proceed and take free relief from the no plays. Oh yeah. But we can't find it, I'm going. Okay. So and then the player himself then chimes in IE, I sort of need to convince my marker. Nice. Run going to understand this whole relationship that applies everyday markets and I think a lot of players and you can have your own point of view on this.

I just feel that putting it. Bluntly your marker. Could be an idiot. All right? Your marker could have the worst rules knowledge of any of your thousand members at your Club. They your Market may have no idea about the rules. And this whole idea of I well I sort of need to convince my marker. I need to make sure my marker is okay with the way I'm proceeding. I don't see it that way and as you taught me years ago, the marker is the eyes and ears of the committee. And we have a process where if the market doesn't agree with a school bus on the card, raise it

with the committee and there shouldn't be any, you know, black mark on that. Just the process we can follow and the player goes no I know I'm allowed. Had to take free relief. In fact, I must take free relief from the snow play zone. I'll do that with the my marker. Likes it on up because I know the rules anyway. That's just a goblin real happen. I walked away thinking. The market was getting a bit upset with me and I'm going, look at the not interested in this. I'm not here in any official capacity. I was just trying to help. I'm not going to get involved anymore. I've told you what I think and I walked away and let them.

I don't even know how they finished because I sort of thought of I've said too much and tried to help, and it probably didn't work out as well as I would have liked. So your your line of thinking here is You don't have to convince your Market, but if your Market has an issue with how your proceeded, they don't Scots on the scorecard and they bring it up and have a conversation with the committee,

I think. I think it's very, very helpful, and I think you should do everything you can to talk to your marker. Let them know what you're doing. I think this, I'm going to proceed this way and I think ultimately, it's the Players Ball. All and it's their right to play that ball how they want. And I think if your marker disagrees but you know the rule you're pretty comfortable with what you're doing. I just have I find it funny relationship between I find it funny about what the marker is and I think some people take on

the role of marker. It's a very serious responsibility with some Authority and I don't see it that way. I see it as just a second opinion on what happened and I think the play is it. I think the play has a right to play their ball as I And yes, I think you should for for all the right reasons. Try to explain to your marker. Why you're doing something? But I think if your Market doesn't agree, but you want to proceed that way, then you're entitled to do that. Yeah, so if the market doesn't agree, that doesn't mean you should stop and debate it for two, three, four minutes.

We'll find out, right. I'd probably agree with that, too. I think that's, that's that's spot-on. I mean, you know, the market might be an idiot, the player might be in even more of an idiot as well, but if you're not sure, don't let them the other one convince you to say, okay, that's fine, you do what you want to do. Let's bring it up with the committee at the end and it's not a it's not a hate you. I'm going to bring it up with the committee.

It's a I'm just not sure. And I want to learn about this you could be completely, right? I just need someone to explain it to me. Me when we're not right in the middle of battle. And you know that would be easier that way. You know, the last thing that would across their mind is 20.1 C3. Would have been the last thing they would have considered you although obviously the last thing they considered was asking someone who has some rules knowledge in the group but

Charlotte film was the easiest one but that's like that. That's very good. Now I am just going to do a quick wrap-up of live golf in Adelaide, which was unbelievable. The build the Builder, Australia has never seen a build on a golf course that big Ever, actually, that's a lie. The Presidents Cup was probably slightly bigger. So sorry, I forgot about the

prison scum, but certainly in Adelaide there's never been a build that big and it was, it was incredible. So with, with a build that big, you know, all the buildings, all the TOs, like every hole has a TV Tower and so they're all T, iOS that we have to take into account when we're giving Rawlings where, you know where players are when we're setting up. The course we players are going to hit their balls. It's amazing. The actions and the that we are under.

Now we can't just put the tee markers wherever we want on the T. We have to put the tee markers, certain distance for away from the board for for shocked racer but not too far away. Otherwise it doesn't pick it up, we can't put it too close to the board in case the player actually hits the board and Yeah, so we need to sort of work, all that stuff out before they start installing boards,

the tea backing signs so that they don't be a, don't make a mess of the place and be. So just it runs as smooth as possible. We had a really cool thing. Having 16 guys from the green keeping start, which is very lucky because they have a bigger staff than normal At the Grange being that they have 36 holes. So we had Rowan the superintendent who didn't absolutely amazing job and

preparation. And now, here we go back to us and we going back to a course, where all the grass is dead and they won't get too much growth coming into winter. So hopefully, hopefully it repairs itself. They might be playing the other 18 holes that wasn't in play. Although that was where the parking now parking was so that might be dead as well, but, you know, he did. Nice job and gave 16 blocks the opportunity. 16 people, the opportunity to rake, the bunker will be a carrier rate around

with every group and rake bunkers after the players played out, which was awesome and had really helped with the pace of play. So I think that's something that we really want to implement going forward. And you know, all you got to do is find 16 people who are capable of Reiki bunkers. So Oh, that shouldn't be too hard to accomplish. So we had a lot of tea iOS. Have one player asked me if he could remove a leaf in a bunker,

it's only been four years since that was, that rule would being implemented. So, I was a bit surprised, but it was a, it was a, it was a quick and easy. Yes, you can. I had a water hose connection. And this was a really funny one actually, because I I thought he just wanted relief from the water. Hose connection. And then we gave him relief and he dropped his ball twice, his ball, can't arrest. And then he said, oh, what about the hole that I'm standing in?

I was like I know you could have brought that up because I didn't really think it was a whole, I thought it was just more undulation in this. This water hose connection was just at the bottom of it, but I was, it was really funny because I was arguing against him saying. No, no. That's just undulation buttons in my head. I was going. Yeah, he's right. That is part of the, it's a hole created by the green Keeper in the design of the of the golf course. So all the design of that

immovable, instructions is a better way to put it. So, I actually canceled the drop that we gave them and started the process again. After getting a second opinion which was fine. I had another one where guy was up, right up against a small stump of a tree. and the reasonable stroke that he would have to play would be backwards down the Fairway, and in playing that shot, he was going to have

interference with This move obstructionist little railing. So I looked at it and I was like, yeah, well that's that really is the only shot that he's going to be out of play, and it's reasonable. So I gave a relief and then he chipped it out anyway but it was just going to be a better chip out for him, but it was a reasonable shot and We There were sort of some logs over the I said over this movable and this one's movable and then we looked at this one I go it's movable because I just thought it was sitting on the ground but

it wasn't. It was actually in it was attached growing it's not growing anymore but it was attached and I went to push it and I pushed and moved it a couple of a centimeter or so I was like I know that that's that's definitely attached. So don't let's not do that. So end up giving him relief and had one that was it was an interesting one with Sergio. You where his balls behind a TI o and he said, first of all, you know, someone said that someone picked it up and then they, you know, so then I had to ask the

crowd old. Did anyone see this year? Yeah, I saw it, a person picked it up and then they just dropped it. And I said, okay well how close is it to where it was picked up from? I it's pretty much right there and Sergio is like yeah but yeah, hang on, hang up. Was it right there or was it little bit back further down the hill? And the guys, I know that I was right there and another guy goes. Yeah, and I was there. There he goes. No, no, but this is serious. This is really serious. I wasn't there, or was it a little bit further down the hill?

And these two Aziza like they always there, they felt that Sergio's to the trying to take the piss out of they said, no, it was right there, okay, but it was right here, I mean you can take it out to ask, you need to pick it up and just put it back and then he found like the best spot to put it in, you know, as you would I said it's an estimate. So what are you going to do? And and then Benny went through potentially this ti0 But he didn't like where the ti o was

going to drop him. So he just started moving this movable part of a TI o and I was like, oh hang on, hang on, we did a check about that one. So got on the radio. Hey, I just wanted to confirm that. You can move a movable part of t.i., O and no one seemed to have an objection to it. I know that you can move a movable part of it. Ayo. I'm but I just want to check it out. Temporary and move. So no one had an objection so we let him go bit and then he didn't take them free relief.

He just headed over it. Anyway. That was that, was that one. And then I had another one where ball came to rest in a Spectators arm and they had already taken it out when I got there and we're giving it to the player. And then I was like, that was like, okay, so where was it? And they pointed at the spot down on the ground. And I was like, okay well, why is it not there? Now I'll go Noah came to rest of my arm. I was like, okay.

Okay, so where were you standing or sitting? Okay, I was here right here. I got great. Let's get a spot underneath there and then I go Peter, it's going to be a drop because it didn't have, it didn't touch, of course. So it's going to be a drop within a club, link and drops. It gets back in good. So, that was my six or seven rulings. Plus I saw a guy got hit in the shoulder. Blade. So, I went over to him and said, are you okay? Do you need first aid? He said it was okay. He said, it was okay. He said, one of his mates piped in and said, I was hoping he's

looking for a sign above. I was like, don't ask me, I'm just a referee and I said, you know, you deflected into the rough if you deflected in fear way, you might have got a cycler. Anyway that was it was seriously amazing. It was I was sort of nervous because I was like there's so many people out here like we would have had 20. That it was over 20,000 people that turned up and you could see them floating after cam Smith, you can see them, they love Phil Mickelson, Dustin Johnson, got a

little bit of love but he's not, he's not in huge, really good form at the moment, but yeah, they love Jam Smith, they love filming. And they love Bryson the Shambo, they love Bubba, you know, those real big personalities and that's what lives done lives that gone out and got the personalities of the golf world, the professional golf world. And and that's the marketing. But of the whole thing and it's an entertainment product and that was really entertaining.

I was alive for Brooks brother yesterday. Yeah, that, that was insane. I was on the fifth hole which is Miles Away From the 12th. It's actually the furtherest away. You could get from the 12th hole. You just the interruption and the noise was unbelievable. I could remember what I said, you just feel like it felt like an atom bomb just because what you said, I messaged you. I said, did you see, did you hear that? And he said yeah, it's a no I'm the furthest point away and it sounded like an atom bomb going

off. It just you could just, you know, because it was like there was a sound of an atom bomb. The imagine, you know how there's that mushroom cloud. And in it. That's what it was like because I, you know, this music, people don't quite understand it. You can probably hear it on The Telecast, a little bit, but there's music playing on every T, all the time. Like, like that doesn't quite down for a player to stop in at the shop. It's just constantly going in the players really get into. This is something so different

for them. But as I was talking with another referee, it is exhausting. And this week in Singapore. We won't have the crowds like that, but we'll have the heat and that, that's what it will, make the players exhausted. But yeah, hopefully you wouldn't want to do. You wouldn't want to do too many of us? - if you had 14 Adelaide's, I think people would break down and go. No, I can't. I can't keep going because it's exhausting being. It's exciting but it's

exhausting sure. The money would help them here. Yeah, money would help. yeah, I sleep on dollar bills at night, I dream But, you know, it was an awesome experience. And, you know, the thing about having to in Australia, which I reckon they'll get to you don't want to ruin it. But I think, I think there is a massive Demand for it down here in olds. So it was pretty evident on the weekend or think. Yeah, spot-on.

And you know, the number of people I spoke to who actually traveled from Melbourne to see Ben and we saw people from Sydney, as well. So, you know, make sure it's make sure it's good value. You've lots of extra stuff, you know, that fan Village People can go and chill out there. Have the music pumping all day because then it just feels like an absolute vibe. And you know, get the golfers, playing some good golf on a great Golf Course.

I think that almost wraps us up like Stuart, can you wrap this up with a GI Q? OT wat6, please here we go. See ya que o TW 86, do it take it away. GI Q OG W. 4 episode 86 is pretty easy for you by key big, please ball lies, just inside. I read penalty area on the fourth hole. At one bad Hills, his ball is playable, and in taking his stance for a reasonable stroke is Left foot is standing in temporary water in the general

area. He takes free relief and drops correctly within the relief area within the penalty area. He plays his second shot, chips, onto the green with his third and has two putts to hole out pretty straightforward. What is his score for the whole and why? Yeah, interesting. One that one I need to go and check out my book and study get that grow like your Excellency. Oh well we'll get the answer to the GAO Quixote wat6 next time

we schedule the podcast hopefully next week and I hope everyone's enjoyed listening to the club and stories. Remember if you have a clubland story or know of one, get it in and we will Talk about on the air. Okay. Please, we love them. I guess you have a good week and will until next time. Thanks. Bye. Cutie safe travels.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode