GUEST: Karen Lunn, current CEO of the WPGA Tour of Australasia, and former touring professional, chats about her playing days, and her view of the Rules, and referees - THE GRQ PODCAST EP118
40 minAudio
GUEST: Karen Lunn, current CEO of the WPGA Tour of Australasia, and former touring professional, chats about her playing days, and her view of the Rules, and referees - THE GRQ PODCAST EP118 In episode 118, Stuart chats with former touring professional, Karen Lunn, who is now the CEO of the WPGA Tour of Australasia. Karen answers some rapid fire questions from Stuart about her playing career. Karen talks about her experiences with the Rules, with Referees and provides her biggest tip to aspiring Referees on how to deal with players. Stuart then finishes with the latest GRQOTW.GRQOTW117Andy is disqualified. GRQOTW118 Blakey and Stuart are playing in the Winter Cup at Wombat Hills, a prestigious one round stroke play competition. On the 9th hole, Stuart hits his tee shot down the middle of the fairway. As they walk down the fairway, Stuart starts to get concerned that he cannot see his ball. In disbelief, Stuart starts to search for his ball however he cannot find it within 3 minutes. Stuart's marker, Blakey says, “that's not fair, you hit it down the middle. So just drop one here and keep playing.” Relieved that Blakey was also in disbelief but knowing that he really doesn't know for sure that someone else took his ball, Stuart drops a ball in the middle of the fairway, adds no penalty strokes to his score, and makes par on the hole. Stuart signs and submits his scorecard and later that afternoon, he is awarded the Winter Cup with a score of nett 70. Blakey came 2nd. Discussing it later in the bar, Blakey says, “well done, you would have been hard done by if you had to go back to the tee on the 9th hole.” Jeff, sitting at the next table, overhears this and asks for more details. Jeff, who came 3rd, approaches the Committee about what happened on the 9th hole. What is the Ruling?Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/joinSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
In episode 118 Stuart chats with former touring professional Karen Lund who is now the CEO of the WPGA Tour of Australasia. Karen answers some rapid fire questions from Stuart about her playing career and then she talks about her experiences with the rules with referees and provides her biggest tip to aspiring referees on how to deal with players. Stuart then finishes with the latest GRQOTW for episode 118. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this
episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Oh, you see referee David Blake there. He's obviously talking to one of the rules officials up by the green. Hello everyone, welcome to Golf Rules Questions Podcast episode #118 my name is Stuart Mcfee and it's my pleasure to be here with you for episode 118. I do have another special guest here for you today on the Golf Rules Questions podcast. But before we get to that
special guest, I need to answer the GIQOTW for episode 117. The question was as follows. Andy, the average golfer, is playing a stroke play event at Wombat Hills. On the 12th hole, Andy hits his tee shot into the left rough. The group searches for two minutes that may become key, 2 minutes and finds a ball in a bad lie. Andy identifies his ball and decides it is unplayable, so he drops it under rule 19.2 B and plays it towards the putting
green. When Andy arrives, he realizes that it isn't his ball, so he returns to the area to find his original ball and finds it within 30 seconds in a playable lie. Andy plays that ball towards the putting green and holes out in four more strokes before signing and submitting his scorecard. Andy asks you for help with his score on the 12th hole. What is his score? Well, assuming he has teed off on the 13th hole, Andy's score
for the 12th hole and every hole will be DQ, Andy will be disqualified. So what Andy has done is he has found a ball that is not his and taken an unplayable ball relief. And what he's done is incorrectly substituted a ball in a wrong place. And as soon as he's done that and made a stroke at it, the original ball, even if he goes back to find it and I mentioned 2 minutes and then he found it in another 30 seconds, it doesn't matter.
As soon as he made a stroke at that incorrectly substituted ball, which of course was from a wrong place, that original ball is gone. It's out. It's now wrong ball. If you if he had played a wrong ball and then gone back and searched, he could have resumed the search for that and actually found it within 30 seconds and that would have been OK. But he didn't play a wrong ball. He played an incorrectly substitute, a ball which he dropped under the unplayable ball relief option. So because he's played from a wrong place, we need to determine whether it's a serious breach or not.
The fact that his ball is now lost, his only option is to return to the T under stroke a distance. So the fact that he's played from way up on the fairway, clearly that's a serious breach. He would have gained a significant advantage from playing from that wrong place. And because it's a serious breach, a serious breach, playing from the wrong place must be corrected before teeing off on the next hole, or if it's on the 18th hole, before submitting your scorecard. Andy, the average golfer, didn't correct that mistake and soon as he teed off on the 13th hole, Andy would be disqualified. So that's the answer to the
GRQOTW for episode 117. Well, as I said, I'm thrilled to have a guest today for episode 118 of the Golf Rules Questions podcast. I'm joined today by Karen Lunn. Karen, welcome to the Golf Rules Questions podcast. It's great to have you. Yeah. Thanks very much to you. Thanks for having me. It is absolutely our pleasure and before we start, it is obviously appropriate that I just provide a brief introduction to who you are. Many in Australia will know who you are, but we do have an audience that's far and wide
listened to by people all around the world, which is very, very nice. And for those who don't know, Karen is a former professional golfer who is now the CEO of the WPGA Tour of Australasia, which is a governing body for women's Professional Golf in Australia and New Zealand. As a professional player, Karen played on all of the Majors women's tours between 1985 until her retirement in 2013 and was the winner of 14 international professional tournaments in 10 different countries, including Karen the 1993 Women's British
Open, which is just fantastic. Karen also represented Australia four times as a professionally major international team competitions during a time on the Ladies European Tour. Karen served on the Players Council as Chair and on the Board of Directors for 14 years, ten of which were as Chair. Karen also worked extensively as ATV commentator for Sky Sports in the UK and U Comm in Germany and has also been a mentor for many of Australia's young female, amateur and professional
players. Karen joined the WPGA Tour in September 2013 and as a part of this role also sits on Australian on the Australian Golf Industry Council and the Rolex Women's World Rankings Committee. In 2022, Karen was appointed as the first ever female to be elected as the Chair of the Australian Golf Industry Council. There you go Karen. It's great to have you. Thank you very much for joining us. No. Worries. Thanks. Jim, yeah, I've got to go back, please. Do you mind you on the British Open?
Do you mind just sharing with us just anything about that story, that whole experience, please? Yeah, I mean it was obviously a a memorable week. It is a long time ago now, I'll I'll give you that. But yeah, no, it was back in 1993. Yeah. No, I was, I was having a really good year. I was healthy, which is the most important thing. I had a few injuries in in my career as as players did more so back then because we didn't have physios and the light travelling around with us. So we're pretty much on our own. So yeah, just just, you know, I think during my career I was always a pretty good ball striker.
And when I hold some putts, I was usually in contention. And that week I actually hold hold a few putts. And yeah, managed to win quite easily in the end. But it was still obviously I think I had a five shot lead going into the final day, which as you know is, is nothing really. It can it can disappear in a couple of holes. So a few of my friends were like, oh, you've got this in the bag and all that sort of stuff. I was like, no, just leave me alone. I just there's anything can happen. There's obviously so much pressure and yeah, you know, some of the best players in the world were there, Annika Sorenstam, you know, Helen Alfredson, Laura Norman, Paddy Sheehan, Brandy Burt and Laura Davies.
So it was a good generation to be a part of and and obviously a good field. So yes, without a doubt the the highlight of my career and something that I'm very proud of and and no one can ever take away from me. Exactly the words I was going to use. No one can ever take that away. If you want me that, that's just fantastic. Isn't that the last thing you wanted to hear before you teed off on round four? Oh, you got this in the bag. You're fine. Absolutely, yeah, I was actually out for dinner with some friends on the night before the final round, a few of the caddies and a couple of players and and I was saying stuff like that and I just had to leave. I was just like, I can't be, I
can't be listening to this stuff. I just need to really focus on what I'm doing. So it's just very easy. You know, it's just like I said, five shot sounds a lot and it is. It's it's a big margin to overcome. But it also, as we know it can, it can go so quickly. I think if you look at Sebastian Soderbergh last week in the Scandinavian mix, I think he had an 11 shot lead at one point and ended up finishing second. But you know, that's golf as we know it can change very quickly. And that's a great timely example. I mean, that was incredible. And even on the last hole, even he's playing on the last hole
was a bit sort of scratch, you know, scratch their head a little bit. And when Lynn Grant finished, I think she chipped in on the last, but I still don't think at that time she thought she was any chance of winning. I think she thought, well, that probably ties up maybe second for me. But yeah, it was just watching a well, like watching a train crash unfold in front of your eyes. I really felt sorry for it. Of course. And yeah, no one takes any joy out of that. No, I think Lynn Grant was enough of disbelief in that particular case. But well, we're here to talk about rules, but I'm going to put you on the spot a little bit. I'm going to ask you some rapid fire questions more about golf.
So not about rules, it's about golf and your golfing. And just real quick responses is all I'm really after. Just for people to get a little bit more of an idea about who you are. How well do you play left-handed? Pretty well, yeah, my dad actually was left-handed. So the first set of golf clubs we had were left-handed. So I actually started applying left-handed so I can still. I've got a massive slice with the driver. Not that I play anymore, but when I when I played, I had a big slice with the driver. But yeah, no, I've, I've played OK. And every now and again, Sophie Gustafson, actually one of the
great Swedish players, used to travel with a left-handed club to sort of balance the swing and their muscles and all that out and, and every now and again we'd all have a hit with the left-handed club on the range. And no, I can hit them pretty good. Probably 15 meters, say seven. I probably would go 15 meters less distance than my right-handed one. But no, I I could go all right. I reckon I could probably shoot, I don't know, 90, something like that left-handed. Wow that's amazing. How many holes in one have you had? 9. Were any at the 1993 Women's British Open? No, no they weren't.
There were a couple on on tour. I had one at the Dutch Open, I think it was 2010 that I won a beautiful Omega. Watch for that one. I was close to winning a couple of cars over the years. But yeah, no, that was that was the the nicest 1 winning that one in Holland. So that was great. Any of those you didn't see the ball go in. No, I think I saw all of them going. OK, very good. Not necessarily best score, but your best round. Your most memorable round of golf ever. I think that that final round at the the Women's British Open,
under the pressure, I can't remember exactly what I shot, but it was a pretty good round. Yeah, I finished. I shot 63 at the Italian Open one year to finish second. Just missed the playoff there. Yeah, those two are probably the ones that that, you know, come to mind as the most memorable one. And you know, any, any time you win a tournament, the last round is incredibly stressful. So I think I remember all of those rounds really well. And the relief at the end. Relief. That's exactly what it is. Even if he shot 74 but one, not what I'm saying exactly, but just the relief, you know, I
think it's people lose sight. You know, the sort of rules, officials, referees. We're all golfers too. And we're not as good as the people we are looking after. But we're golfers and we're fans. So a lot of our audience, they all play golf and I'm interested in what you think if you were to take an 18 handicap, and I know you mentor a lot of, I know probably many of them don't play off 18, but you mentor a lot of golfers, amateur and professional. If you were to take an 18 handicap, that what's 1 simple thing you could tell them to perhaps help improve their game. Just one thing they could do. I think from my experience playing pro AMS, it's just take
an extra club. It's, it's amazing how often, you know, you're playing in a pro AM and they're just, you know, from 150 yards, they've got a 7 out. It's like, mate, you're not getting there with that. Just take an extra club. Trust me on this one. So yeah, I would say that and probably try and enjoy the game as well. You, you know, you play, you know, having played a lot of pro AMS, you play with people and they're so hard on themselves and they probably play, I don't know, 12 * a year. You know, it's not life and death. It's, it should be fun. So I think a lot of people are, you know, that don't have the time to put the work in and practice and go to the range.
They come out and have these unbelievably high expectations. So just enjoy it. It's, you know, you're out in the fresh air in the sunshine most of the time. So just, you know, really be grateful for where you are and enjoy it. That is a fantastic answer. I couldn't agree with you more on that and all the things I see at club level. You know, drivers being slammed into the ground after a bad drive and this guy plays off 14. His pre game routine is having three putts on the practice screen right? Plays once a week and the expectations are ridiculous. And there's a reason why we don't play off plus 6. Exactly.
Yeah, and it's, and you're right. It's amazing how often you do see it. And, you know, as a pro, you know, you have high expectations. And every now and again you do get disappointed and you might see, you know, we've all done it, you know, smash the driver on the ground if you haven't hit a good shot. But, you know, that's that, that's what the professional level. But there's there's no need to be doing it. I mean, yeah, we've all got a temper every now and again. And I've actually smashed a few tennis rackets in my time when I was a kid. So I probably shouldn't be saying this, but yeah, just enjoy it. I mean, that's why, that's why ultimately why we play the game, isn't it? Because we love it.
Couldn't agree more. Why any club golfers out there? They're not. I mean, one or two may win the club championship, but other than that, we're out there to just enjoy it. No, that's terrific. I think I know the answer to this question. Your most memorable moment in golf. Yeah, I mean, obviously the British Open win, but a few others as well. I won the ACTUAGL Canberra Classic in 2012 with my sister Marty cutting for me, so that was pretty special. And then I won the 2010 Portuguese Open with my coach who was one of my best friends, cutting for me too. So they were some pretty special
moments. But but as you said, you know you have so many special moments. It might be your best round, it might be winning a tournament, it might be holding a 10 foot putt to make the cut. You know, it's, you have so many memorable moments. Yes. Do you have a swing thought? I did, yeah. I was. I was, I don't know, it's interesting. I've read probably like every professional golfer, every sports psychology book that was out there. And, and obviously the school of thought back then was that you could, you know, you should only ever have one swing thought. But every now and again I had, I had a couple of swing thoughts,
but it just depends. You go through so many ups and downs in your career and you're just tinkering with your swings. So, yeah, but I had to have a swing thought. I mean, some players that stand there and say they don't, I don't know how they do it. So me, if I could get it down to one swing, thought that was ideal. But maybe maybe a couple. Maybe it's just you know, but again, you know, looking back it's more about your pre shot routine. If you get that right, then everything else should fall into place. At club level and I played yesterday, we we tend to joke that we try to keep our swing thoughts to under 20 swing
thoughts before before you. Well, you know what, let's say paralysis by analysis. I mean, if you're thinking of too many things, you just, you know, you can't just let the golf swing happened. So yeah, I think too many is definitely not good. No, as we find out routinely, the strongest and weakest part of your game, perhaps at your peak. My strongest was probably my ball striking. Probably my long irons were probably back in the day when we carried, you know, one and two irons. I think that was probably my strong point. My bunker play was very good, but my putting was always a weakness.
It was always the Achilles heel. You know, I, I look at some of the people now that are averaging 25 putts. I think the lowest I ever had in my life was 25. Putts. You know, so, yeah, that that was really my Achilles heel. I did. I went through a period where I did have the yips and it was awful. But I came out the other side. I think, you know, I learned a lot, a lot through that. But yeah, you know, putting it, I never mastered it. It was, I don't know, it should be the easiest part of the game, but it was always the hardest for me. Your favorite or best golf course you ever played?
Favorable best, my favorite course has always been NSW Golf Club at Laveruse in Sydney. It's just such a great test of golf. But there's so many, so many great golf courses that we get to play. And I think in Australia we're blessed with some of the most incredible courses. Obviously, you know, I've been blessed to play the, the, the women's courses on the open road. And so, you know, Carnoustie and Royal Birkdale and Lytham, St. Annes and Saint Andrews and, and all those courses. But if you look in our own backyard here, what we've got, you know, in Sydney, we've got some great courses. Obviously the sand belt in
Tasmania now. And in South Australia we're we're so lucky. Yeah. So I think NSW has always been my favorite golf course. So I'll stick with that. But you know, we're, we're, we should be so grateful that the number of, you know, high quality, amazing layouts that we have. And obviously the condition of our courses here is is so good. Terrific. Did you have a favorite club in your bag? Probably my, my sandwich, probably, yeah, my, my 56° sandwich, probably I, I enjoyed messing around, practicing, you know, chipping and outer bunkers
and all that sort of stuff. But yeah, back in the day I used MY2 arm a lot. That was well before we had 7 woods and all that sort of stuff. And you know, I think I could hit any fairway anywhere with that. So that got me out of a lot of trouble sometimes. Very nice. And then growing up, all throughout your career, did you have a favorite golfer, someone you looked up to? I think when I was younger it was Jack Nicklaus. I think back when I was a kid, we didn't. There was none of the women's golf events on TV, so the role models were all males. Jack Nicklaus.
I love watching Ben Crenshaw play. I remember him winning the Masters, sitting up on a Monday morning, getting up early and watching that. But I think it was Jack Nicklaus. I had all of his books, you know, read them all inside out and, and just love watching him play. But obviously then, you know, after that it was, you know, Greg and and Seve, I love watching Seve play. He was just a genius. And you never knew what was going to happen next. And the shots he could hit under pressure were just unbelievable. But yeah, I mean, you know, looking back now, we have, you know, like Jan Stevenson was a great Australian player, but you know, we never really got to see
her play. And when I got to the LPGA and I got to play with Jan Stevenson and Nancy Lopez and Pat Bradley and Beth Daniel Megmullen, Patty Sheehan, all those great players. Kathy Whitworth, I had the pleasure of playing with her. Joanne calmer. So, you know, I was really lucky. But that was sort of, you know, once I was on tour. But we we never got to see those players as kids. So it's great to see, you know, some of the footage of them, you know, watching Mickey Wright, her golf swing. My God, it's unbelievable when you look back at that. So, yeah, so many wonderful female role models. Unfortunately, we didn't get to see them.
So it was Jack Nicklaus for me. OK, very nice. And I'm sure that would be a popular answer. Well, we're here to talk about the rules. Thank you very much for spending some time just going through some of those questions that I put you on the spot with, I must admit. But thank you very much for some of those answers. And I, I really enjoyed actually listening to every single one of your answers. So thank you for that. But we are here to we are here to talk about the rules. I mean, obviously we have this very large playing field. So many other sports, you know, we have the black and white stripes, someone has a whistle, someone sort of governing play and watching stuff. But we have this very large playing field.
There's a lot of players out there in different Nicks and and we have this very unique situation where, you know, the game for the most part is self officiating. So where do we learn about these rules that govern our game that we have to play by? Excuse me, You know, as a junior growing up playing, did you receive any formal rules training? You know, even just an hour or so? Yeah, I think we did. I started off at some Junior Golf camps at Cara Golf Club, where I I grew up playing golf. And I think Peter O'Malley was at some of those camps with me as well.
We grew up playing it, playing together. So yeah, we they taught us some basic rules. But back then it was kind of like very much at sort of the beginner intermediate level. So I guess they didn't want to drown you in all this information. So now probably a little bit, probably when you get to be a member of the Golf Club and, and my coach Rick was strange when I was a kid, Rick would really, you know, just keep us up to date with what rules we needed to know. But he was more concerned about etiquette than the rules. Like, he really taught us the etiquette of the game because obviously if you're playing with members, you know, if you go and
tread on their lawn or do something wrong, you're going to get yelled at. So I think he was, you know, very determined to make sure that we knew the etiquette of the game along with the basic rules. But it's pretty intimidating when you're a kid to, you know, back then, the rule book was even thicker than it is now. So it was just like, where do you start, really? But, you know, all the basic stuff we, we were taught as kids. Yeah. It's funny you mention a a keyword there. I think that's intimidation. And I think even now getting people into the game and there's a big push obviously to get women playing, I think the keyword is intimidation. And it's not necessarily the rules.
It's excuse me when you know, when can I talk and when can't I talk? Where do I stand and where can't I stand? How do I move safely around the course is intimidation. So it's it's interesting that you talk about maybe more the etiquette less than the rules, as as important as the rules are, but the etiquette and and being being welcomed into that group that you're playing with and they want to play with you again next week. Do you think when we see amateur players who are have incredible potential? And the handicaps are dropping and they've clearly got, you know, some talent.
Do we focus a little bit more on them with regarding rules and and teaching them or no I. I think it's important to know them. I mean, obviously, you know, the rules can also be used to your advantage as well. So I think that it's, it's really important that when you get to that elite level, you know, the rules, I mean, at club level everywhere, every member thinks they know the rules. Well, you know, they don't. You know, they have their own interpretation of the rules of golf. And I know even growing up, you know, people would say, oh, you can't do this because this rule. And I'd go and ask Ricky's like, I don't listen to them. Yeah, no, it's, it's it's
interesting. And I think you make a really good point there about intimidation. I think the recent rules change just, you know, to to allow ready golf so people can play whenever they're ready. Obviously the perception is that golf takes too long. And so I think that's a great change to the rules and also being able to leave the flags to kit to speed up play. I think there's been a couple of really good changes to the rules. So like I said, it's been really good that the R and I have actually, you know, listened to the perception and, and the buzz out there about why people weren't playing golf and they've made some changes and obviously now golf is booming. So, yeah, I think that we need
to keep looking at ways we can simplify the rules. Obviously, as you said, they're all really important and we need to abide by them. But, you know, we need to simplify them because, you know, you don't. You shouldn't need a law degree to be able to to interpret the rules of golf. It is. I've just heard recently David Saber, a stalwart in the USGA in the rules department, said something and I'm going to paraphrase it. He said that you know, most golfers and we say club golfers, most golfers know a lot about the rules. The problem is around 25 to 50% of what they know is wrong. And that's that's the problem,
which makes it even worse. So when you're a junior, if you look back and go, I wish I actually really knew that rule because that would have helped me. You talk about sometimes the rules can help. Is there something that stands out that you would have liked to have known earlier? I think playing two balls whenever you're in doubt about the procedure, I think that that's something I don't think I even knew about that till I turned prior. So I think it's something that people don't know and you know, but it's something that you know, you can get clarified when you finish your round. So I think that's something that I wish I had have done and I wish, I wish more. Maybe not pros because often
there's rules officials there that can help you, but certainly in competition I wish people would use it more rather than spending so much time debating what they should and shouldn't do. That that's a I'm glad that's a great answer. I'm glad you said it. And I when I was at a club and the committee and stuff, I was really trying to push. I'll be nerdy here. It's rule 20.1 C three. You're playing two balls and stroke play. I really wanted to push that, you know, just stop talking about it for 5 minutes. Yeah, just just decide to play a second ball, work it out later, work it out when the game's done. That's a great answer. I wish NASA Hatayoko had done it
not so long ago because that would have would have avoided disqualification and they could have worked it out later. That was, I think, very unfortunate and I've spoken about that. But there's an example of playing two balls of stroke by and and you know, and I thought about it later thinking even if the referee came in and wasn't aware and said, can we go to the video? Even if that was going to take too long, they could have then said, look, just I'll drive you back to the team. We'll play a second ball. And in the meantime we'll work out the video evidence and work out anyway. That's in that case that could have helped her unfortunate as.
Absolutely. That was really, really sad. I mean, you know, I know the rules changes have, you know, hopefully I may need to stop these kinds of things happening. But, you know, for her to be disqualified the next day after shooting 65, that's just, you know, and it could actually cost her a place in the Olympics. She's dropped from 19th to 20th. Of course Ayako Furawai had a good week. Of course she did and and went past her. So it's all down to the last two weeks. So it's just really sad and just a sad set of circumstances that probably could have been avoided. Yeah, unfortunately, yes, I agree.
Yeah, I'm, I'm with you there. Are there any rules you don't like? Not really. The only one that's always sort of confused me a little bit is, you know, when when you hit off the T and there's a hazard there and there's OB there, but you don't know whether it's gone in the hazard or OB. You know, when you can play a provisional, when you should play a provisional, when you shouldn't and all that. That's probably the one that's confused me the most and but not really, I think I think the rules, you know, pretty much got it right. And then like I said, I think the modifications first in 2019
and 2022 have been really good for the game. So I think that, like I said, there's a lot of work being obviously done behind the scenes by the RNA and the USGA in this space, which is which is great. But no, there's nothing really that ever. You know, I know some people say that, you know, you should be able to drop out of a divot and all that, but I'm not one of those. I mean, I think that just because you hit the fairway doesn't mean you should have a flat stand to the perfect lie. You know, you see a lot of courses you hit the middle of the fairway and then you've got the ball above your feet below. You know, it's just because you hit the fairway just for me.
That's just my opinion. So. But no, there's none really that jump out at me. Yeah, you talk about the Divot. I I don't think that'll ever happen. I there to speak too much of an opposition to changing that particular rule. Are there rules you mentioned there, you know, ball maybe out of balance, maybe in a penalty area, maybe outside the penalty area. Do I hit a provisional? Are there rules that still confuse? You not, not really, no. It was just that one that probably confused me. Yeah, no, not, not too many others. No, I think, I think that like I said, they've they've been simplified a lot as well.
And, and obviously the language is, is there to try and make it easy for people to understand. So there's nothing really. I think I prided myself on having a good knowledge of the rules when I play because I think it's really important. And to be honest with you, I'm a bit of a nerd. So, you know, I always wanted to do everything by the book and do things properly. So yeah, no, there's nothing really jumping out. You know, I don't know if it'll make you feel better, but I can tell you probably if I was to ask any club golfer, the most confusing it would be combining a provisional ball and penalty area. Combining those two things into the same situation is where a
lot of confusion, Yeah. And I can assure you of that. Absolutely, Yeah. No, no, no, I can, I can definitely say that that's, that's the probably the one that could not confuse me. But as a pro, it almost scared me because I'm like, oh God, what am I supposed to do? And should I get this provisional? I'm pretty sure it went out of bounds, but there's a hazard down there and I didn't see it. So it's always, well, it's one of those where you're just really not sure what you should do in that circumstance. And excuse me. And unfortunately, it confused 22 referees early this year on the European Tour when the ball was in a penalty area and provisional outside. And anyway, excuse me, is there
any rule you'd like to introduce any anything you've thought about about introducing or changing an existing rule? Oh, really? No, I don't think so. Like I've, I've thought about this one and there's nothing that really jumps out at me either. No. What about you? What would you like to see? I'll put you on the spot now. Absolutely. That is fantastic. I appreciate you doing that. You have put me on the spot. I'm sure I've been asked this question before and I can't think of the maybe loosen the advice a little bit.
It doesn't happen because professional golfers aren't talking to each other pre shot about what they're doing. But at club level, you know, advice happens all the time. Maybe you know, maybe losing that a little bit. I mean, the players still need to hit the shot. The guy's playing off 22. He still needs to, you know, he still needs to hit the shot. Yeah, I know. I don't think about it and get back to you. Do a little post edit video after this and say well Karen asked me during the interview but here's my real answer. And it's, it's interesting, isn't it? Because you make a good point there, because even when we play in pro AMS where you're actually playing for a purse, you'll have
your amateur partners that walk on the tee and they'll be like, oh, OK, well here you hit it here, here, here. And you know, they're clearly giving advice. It's not, it's not asked for or solicited, but you know, there's advice being passed around. But I guess the only other thing that really doesn't allow me getting back to it is particularly in Provence when you go into bunker and the player or the caddy haven't raped the bunker properly. That is infuriating because that that can be changed. So to me, that's probably the thing that there's not a lot you can do about it. Of course they get fined if they get caught out, but it's so hard to find who that player was in a
field of 144. You can go back through the stats and see who was in a bunker and probably now with the the technology and up game and all, where they can tell exactly where they were On the whole maybe. But yeah, that's the one thing that drives me crazy more than anything when they didn't rate the bunker properly. It's only happened twice to me, but I've had two players till me and very unset, you know, very certain terms having just been in a bunker and it wasn't right and they were playing off the floor surface or footprint or something. Because they've gone to me find out who that was, you know, because it's not right. It's. Not right. When you've walked into a locker
room, whether you've shot, you know you're 65 or you're 75 and you walk in the locker room and there's a lot of other people there with different emotions. Have you ever seen a player flicking through a rule book? Ever seen a I've got 5 minutes, I'll just flick through a rule book here. Professional players. I don't think I have actually, no, no, I haven't seen a player. I mean, most of the time, as you know, there's referees around. If they have a a question, they'll find one of the referees and ask them you know what the goal was, so. Right. Did you ever carry a rule book in your bag? Yeah, always, always had a rule book and a hard card of whatever tour I was playing. Do you think, do you think that
was common? Obviously the hard card, but more so the rule book. Do you think a lot of players would have had a small little rule book in their? I think so. I think most players back in my day, I mean, now obviously players have it on the app if they need it. But yeah, no, 100%. I mean, it's just, you know, back when I started as well, there weren't five or six referees, There was maybe one or two. So if you wanted to to work something out during the round, it wasn't easy to get a referee. So you have to kind of work things out yourself a little bit too. OK, Have you ever received a ruling that didn't make sense or afterwards you thought that that's just so unfair? I've I've had I've had rulings.
I can't remember a specific example where I didn't think it was correct. And I've asked for a more senior official to give him a second opinion. I have had that happen a few times and I think a couple of times maybe they, it wasn't correct what the advice I was being given. So you know, I think that's, you know, you've, you've obviously got that up your sleeve. I know a lot of some referees, you know, I actually asked one referee once could I have a second opinion please? And he said, yeah, I'll tell you again, you're not getting a drop. That's the second opinion. Yeah. So, yeah, no, but, but, but, you
know, I think, I think in general, you know, certainly referees want to do the right thing. We're human beings. There's going to be mistakes made. You know, it's, it's interpretation. There's a lot of Gray areas on a golf course when you're playing and, and players will always try and get an advantage as well if they can. So, you know, you, you see players that can be really unreasonable. I think there was an example at the Vic Open this year, I can't remember exactly what player it was, but I remember Scotty was was the referee and it went on for a while and and the player obviously believed that they were in the right but. This is the last day, 11th hole
I think, so in the waste area. Yes, that's exactly. Right, I was standing up, I was standing up on the 12th team watching it all and listening on the Scotty and the referee on the spot. Just to just for everyone else's benefit, we need to make it clear, of course, within the rules it's quite clear. There's no entitlement to second opinion, but you can adopt A model local rule, which most of your professional tours do. Adopting a model local rule which does entitle apply to a second opinion as you mentioned. But it's very clear and I think for perhaps amateur level and
some of the lower levels, you can ask for a second opinion, but there's no entitled tomorrow, you know, the, the committee's going to stand by that referee's decision. If it's wrong and it can be corrected in time, it'll be corrected. Otherwise the wrong ruling stands. But just to clarify that you've obviously had a lot of issues though, sorry, not a lot of issues. You've had a lot of dealings with referees. I think that one you mentioned there was unfortunate. The fact that, yeah, I'll give it, I'll say to you a second a time. And that's your second opinion. Have you had any awkward situations with referees where you thought, oh, this is uncomfortable now it's getting a little bit tense.
I I don't like it, you know? Not really. I think that I, I hope that I was always pretty respectful of the referees, but as I said, you know, players are always going to try and not get an advantage, but to try and obviously get the best outcome of, of, of the ruling. I think for me, the, the, the most awkward ones have been when you've been timed for slow play, because as a player, when you're not the slow player in the group and you're getting timed, it's probably the, you know, and it's driven me crazy. I think I was always a pretty quick player and you get paired
with slow players that when there's no referees around, they play slow. All of a sudden the ref turns up they're, you know, Speedy Gonzalez, they're they're running, you know, and it's just like it drives you crazy and then you're on the clock, you know, and then it doesn't take much to be penalized. You get a a really couple of really difficult shots that you need to spend a bit of extra time on. And that used to drive me crazy. So, you know, and I think now that the way that players are timed is, is a lot fairer. And obviously now if there's one slow player in the group, they can be target time.
So the monitoring and and target timing seems to be a lot smarter way to do it. But that was probably the most annoyed I've ever been at referees, you know, because I'm not mate, hang on, seriously, you know, I'm not the culprit here. Focus on that player there, you know, and it's, it's just, it's just awkward. It's, you know, it is what it is. But I think slow play to me has always been a bit like cheating because, you know, you know, that player can play fast. They just use not to, you know, and that that is crazy. Which can, of course, can have an adverse impact on the other player. The other two players,
absolutely. I always thought it was grossly unfair that a group of three players could be penalized strokes when it was one person. I never understood the logic of that so. No, absolutely. And, and you're right. I mean, all of a sudden you start rushing and, and I've done it myself where you you end up dropping a shot or missing the car, you know, or something stupid because you've rushed. And probably you don't need to, because if you know, you're retaining, you know, you're not slow, you shouldn't rush, but it's human nature, isn't there? There's a guy standing next to you with a stopwatch.
You know, you don't want to get a penalty, but sometimes you can end up, you know, doing, you know, the wrong thing and, and, and, you know, making a double or something because of that. And. You're almost compensating because of that slow player. You're trying to balance it out, which yeah, Anyway, so as I mentioned is our audience is obviously golfers, but a lot of referees, a lot of help out at their local club. They might do state level, national level and we do have two referees listening all around the world, which is just fantastic.
But there's a lot of aspiring referees, people who want to take that next step and step onto a course with real players, amateur or professional. From a player's perspective, what advice would you give an aspiring referee? What's what advice would you give when they approach a player? What's the best way to to deal with that situation with a player? I think he's to just try and be as nice as you can about it. I mean, you know, you, you don't want the referee to come up and, and speak to you in a in a negative tone or a strong tone. And I think it's, you know, we're all out there together
trying to make a golf tournament successful. So I think just be as respectful as you can and for the players as well, be respectful for the referee. But, you know, I think that, you know, as you know, as you're here in Australia, you know, we, we struggle to get enough qualified referees, particularly women. And as you know, it's the best seat in the house. You know, if you're going to Professional Golf tournament, you're, I know it's long days, you're out there all day, but you know, you're inside the road. So you get to watch a lot of golf as well. So, you know, it's a great way and you know, you can earn some money, whether it be on the side or you know, and as as many of
our rules officials have had great opportunities going to major international events. So, you know, I would say for for younger referees, I would say always learn off the senior referees, the tournament directors and, and sort of look, look to them for guidance. But I would say once you get your draw sheet, have a look to see who are your slow players on there. And maybe if you don't know, go and ask someone more senior. So you know that, you know, you're not going to be putting the pressure on the wrong people. But yeah, no, I think that just, you know, we're all out there together.
It's a big it's a big team in a golf tournament. We all we're out there for the same reason. We want the tournament to be successful. So, you know, I would say just don't go in all guns blazing. Just be respectful and Give your opinion and and what you know and if you don't know ask somebody that does. You make a great point there. And I think it's very easy to lose sight of the fact that we are all presenting the same product and we're all part of the one team presenting that product. And golf is becoming more of a product for the fans with, you know, consumed, however it's
consumed. But we're all part of that same team. When it's not an US versus him, it's not a whether I'm a player or I'm a volunteer or I'm a, you know, in a scoring team or I'm a referee and on the course or the tournament director, whoever it might be, we're all presenting that same product. I think that's a great point and we really should be working as a team to present the best product we can possible. Well, Karen, it's been a pleasure. Thank you so much for taking some time out of your very busy day to have a chat with us here on the Golf Rules Christians Podcast. It's been great to have your company and to have a chat with
you. I really, really appreciate. It thanks very much, Stu. Thanks for having me on. You're very welcome and look forward to catching up with you on a fairway soon. Very good. Terrific, Karen. Thanks very much. Thanks, Jerry. Well, I hope you enjoyed that chat with Karen. What a person with an incredible amount of experience in our game, you know, starting with playing professionally and winning all those tournaments, including the Women's British Open, but winning in so many different countries. But they're not leaving the game once you finish playing, you know, moving into a commentary role and more recently into an executive role with the WPGA
Tour here in Australia. So a person with an incredible amount of experience, I'd like to advise at the end with regards to just being pleasant and being nice about it when you approach a player to help them. Well that brings the episode 118 to a close, but we do need to of course finish with the GRQOTW for episode 118 and it is as follows. Blakey and Stewart are playing in the Winter Cup at Wombat Hills, a prestigious one round stroke play competition.
On the 9th hole, Stewart hits his tee shot down the middle of the fairway. As I walk down the fairway, Stewart starts to get concerned that he cannot see his ball. In disbelief, Stewart starts to search for his ball. However, he cannot find it. Within 3 minutes, Stewart's marker, Blakey says that's just not fair. You hit it down the middle, just drop one here and keep playing. Relieved that Blakey was also in disbelief, but knowing that he really didn't know for sure that someone else had taken his ball,
Stewart does drop a ball in the middle of the fairway, adds no penalty strokes to his score, and makes par on the whole. Stewart signs and submits his scorecard and later that afternoon he has awarded the Winter Cup with a score of net 70. Blakey came second. Discussing it later in the bar, Blakey says to Stewart, well done. You would have been hard done by if you had to go back to the tee. On the 9th hole, Jeff, sitting at the next table over, hears
this and asks for more details. Jeff, who came third, approaches the committee about what happened on the 9th hole. What is the ruling? So that's the GRQ OTW for episode 118. Again, hope you enjoyed the podcast and we look forward to talking to you again next time soon.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...