CLUBLAND STORIES May: Wrong Balls, Intervening Event for a Deliberate Stop, Moving a Loose Impediment in a Bunker, Dropping a Ball with No Intention for it to be in Play - THE GRQ PODCAST EP137
CLUBLAND STORIES May: Wrong Balls, Intervening Event for a Deliberate Stop, Moving a Loose Impediment in a Bunker, Dropping a Ball with No Intention for it to be in Play - THE GRQ PODCAST EP137 Blakey is back, by himself this time, hopefully the audio is a lot better. There are some fun ClubLand stories this time, and of course the GRQOTW's and we serve up an easy question for Golf.Ai. GRQOTW 136 Blakey and Stuart are playing each other in a match at Wombat Hills. As Stuart is preparing to make his 2nd stroke in the general area on the 3rd hole, his ball moves backwards slightly. Before Stuart can remove his club, the ball comes to rest against the club, which stops it moving. Blakey is standing close by watching and both players agree that neither Stuart or any outside influence caused the ball to move. Just to be sure of what to do next, Blakey calls in a referee. What is the ruling? Answer: The movement of the ball was caused by natural forces, so no penalty. The stopping of the ball was accidental, so no penalty. The player is to remove their club, and if the ball moves in that case, there is no penalty and the ball needs to be replaced. GRQOTW 137 GRQ137 - David hits his tee shot to the right of the fairway and it comes to rest inside a wombat hole that is on the side of a cliff face. The ball is not visible from the ground, but it was known to have gone into the hole, and the hole is very visible from the ground and it is easy to see that it is a wombat hole. David can't walk up the cliff face to get to the ball nor the hole, so he says to Andrew that he will take free relief, and use the nearest spot to the hole that he can reach as his reference point and drop a ball within a club-length of that spot. Andrew is not sure about that, and doesn't even think David could actually play a shot at the ball, as he can't climb the cliff face. Andrew calls in a referee, and that is you, what is your ruling? GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/ DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @GOLF.AI_ OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY LISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules #golfrules #GOLF.AI #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome everyone to the GRQ Podcast presented by Golf dot AI. I'm Blakey all by myself today, but we're just going to go through because it's been a long, long time. Just going to go through some clubland stories. OK? Just going to go through the GIQO TW136. Blakey and Stewart are playing each other in a match at Wombat Hills. As Stewart is preparing to make his second stroke in the general area. On the 3rd hole his ball moves backwards slightly. Before Stewart can remove his club, the ball comes to rest
against the club which stops it moving. Blakey is standing close by watching and both players agree that neither Stewart or any outside influence caused the ball to move. Just to be sure what to do next. Blakey causing a referee? What is the ruling? So in this situation they've decided that Stewart nor any outside influence have caused the ball to move so that defaults to natural forces. The so they don't get Stewart
doesn't get penalty under 9.4 for causing it to move. It was natural forces and then he stopped it, stopped the ball with his club. We're going to say that's an accident. He wasn't meaning to do that. So because it's an accident, that's also no penalty and then you just play the ball's lies. Now when Stewart removes the club, if the ball moves, that means that time he would they've
caused the ball to move. But that's an exception under 9.4 and exception 5 that if the ball was at rest against the the equipment or the player when they move it, there's no penalty and you just need to put the ball back. So when he moves the club and puts the ball back, so there's no penalty when he moves the club and then he just needs to put the ball back. So that is the GIQO TW136.
So it's probably going to be just by myself. So I'm probably going to be mighty quick. But some of these stories are from April and before. So yeah, we need to get into them and get them out to the airwaves. So first one, Jonathan, they were scoring for a group at the national tournament. This must have been on the PGA Tour of Australasia. Player A headed into a fairway bunker. The ball came to rest very close, but not touching a stone
about the half the size of a ball. Player A declares he's going to move the stone. The scorer and Player B proceed to the green where Player B's ball is, and then Player A removes the stone, tosses away and lines up to player's shot. He then steps back and says that his ball has been blown by the wind. There was a time gap of maybe 10 to 15 seconds from the moving of the stone to the ball moving. That is according to Player A.
It was a very windy in an exposed bunker, so the wind could have definitely moved the ball. That's according to Jonathan. They called in for a rules official who actually called in for another rules official and judgement was made. The ball had been at rest after moving the stone, so no penalty was given. The ball was played from the new location. Player made a bogey. So in a situation like this, we're heavily relying on the eyewitness who is the player who
has a lot to lose, but we're trusting his integrity that he was giving the facts as he saw them. So he moved the stone. The stone is a loose impediment. I mean, I remember back in the days, don't want to cause confusion, but when you couldn't back in the day when you couldn't move loose impediments in a bunker, then someone there
was a terrible accident, someone took their eye out with it, hit by hitting, trying to hit a golf ball and hit a stone. So then the RNAUSGA brought in a local rule saying that stones could be made movable obstructions by the committee in a bunker. And most committees did that. So then you could move the stone because it was a movable obstruction, but now since 2019 they've changed it so that they've gotten rid of that local rule.
The stone is a loose impediment which you can move but you take the risk of if you cause your ball to move on moving a loose impediment in a bunker fairway rough penalty area, then you would get a one shot penalty for causing a ball to move under 9.4 and then you just have to replace the ball. But the facts that the player who was the only person there
gave to the referee was that he was lining up for a shot. So it was about 10 to 15 seconds later that the ball moved and it was moved by wind, which knowing this golf course, the National, it's very exposed to the wind. So that definitely could have happened. I haven't heard too many stories about bulls moving in bunkers due to wind knowing that, you
know, the sand usually has enough friction in it that stops the ball from moving. But I'm not saying it couldn't happen. It really depends on the type of sand and how hard packed it is etcetera, etcetera. I mean, this is a fairway bunker. So it leads me to think that it's more likely to be quite hard packed and not very much loose grains of sand to sort of stop the ball from moving. But it sounds like what the
facts that they gave, they gave to the referee sounds pretty much like they got it spot on, Jonathan, from what what you've given me there. Right next one from Ruin. I'm struggling to find the right words, but I'll try nonetheless. The format is match play baseball with the twist that there is also an individual Stanford round running for the players. Yes I know he says. I think that's a bit of eye roll.
I'm a bit foggy on the specific details here. It's the 18th hole and they are all square. Daryl and Dean are playing Lassie and Blake. Sure, those are made-up names. Daryl's tee off Daryl. Daryl Tees off and immediately realises that it's the wrong T, so they move to the correct T where they all tee off. Nobody cancels Daryl's first shot. OK, so yeah, match play and they must have played from the wrong
teeing area. Nobody cancels Daryl's first shot. They play out the hole and Daryl and Dean wins. And after the result was finalised they asked me if they needed to give Daryl 2 penalty strokes. There was no request for a ruling made prior to this. They asked me for a ruling after the result was final. I said given the circumstances and since since they had finished the round without requesting A ruling, the result stood spot on row and that there was no penalty for playing from a wrong Tang area in match play.
Exactly right. Also it's saying that since neither of them are clear on the rules, they agreed that there was no penalty and they at all finished the hole within the rules of match play. So they they didn't know that they were breaking a rule so they accepted the situation. So that sounds fine so far. He did mention that they had request. If they had requested a rule and Daryl's ball would have been played from a wrong place when he retained from the right team area and hence disqualifying him
from the hole since nobody cancelled his first stroke. But since nobody cancelled his first stroke, then they agreed on the ruling and didn't request a ruling. There was no breach to the rules. Yeah, or they overlooked A breach. As for the individual Staleford, I said deduct 2 points from the hole, 18 if he even got that, and you're good. Turns out he made 21 points on the 18 holes and so they didn't have the heart to do it. Oh that's right. So less than 28 points usually. No one.
No one penalises anyone extra who's had less than 28 points. Usual story but Ruin sounds like you've got it all right. Deduct 2 points. I mean he's played from the wrong T or outside the correct teeing area. So match players no penalty. He continues play or the opponents can cancel the stroke and get him to replay from
within the correct Tang area. But in stroke play there is a penalty of two shots and you do have to correct your mistake. There's no option to just continue on with that ball played from outside the Tang area. So deducting 2 points and then he's corrected a zero, that sounds pretty much spot on, so well done Roman. Thank you. All right, next one. Brian, this is a question arising from a hypothetical
hypothetical event. Something similar almost happened but was averted at the last minute, but LED to debate around a what if? It's the monthly medal stroke event. The player had to drive down the right hand side of the 7th hole, finishing in the rough balls are really lost in this area. However, the heavy rain has led to longer, thicker, rough than usual player is having a bad day and is already well over handicapped. So after 2 minutes declares clearly I'm going to dequeue so
we'll drop another one for practice. They then drop a ball and make a stroke. Seconds later, their original ball was found, still within the three minute search time. So the question is, can they continue to play the original ball? My view is that due to their clear statement that their DQ and the action are dropping and playing a ball for practice means they're now out of the event. Another view is that they can continue subject to the general penalty for practicing during the round.
Does your decision alter in any way if they only drop the ball and do not make a stroke at it before continuing with the original ball? And then, he said, almost happened. This is this is an interesting one, I'm going to say. And then drop a ball, make a strike seconds later. The original span, I mean, the dropped ball was the drop ball with the intent for it to be put
into play. No, effectively, that's an interesting one because you're actually, you are dropping a ball with intent to hit it, but you don't have the intent for it to be in play. So let's say it's not dropped with the intent for it to be in play. So then they've hit a wrong ball. They've just hit a ball, right? It wasn't in play, so they've just hit a ball. So I can't it's not an
incorrectly substituted ball, it's just a wrong, it's a wrong ball. So they get two shots for that, but that's actually going to save them. They get two shots for hitting a wrong ball, but then they have to correct their mistake and the mistake they found the original within 3 minutes, so they carry on. So they're just going to get two shots, two shot penalty and the stroke doesn't count. But that's actually, that's actually better result because if they'd intended to put that
ball in play, I'm going past something that I should have addressed earlier. I'm going to DQ. You can't really say that. I mean, you can say that, but that doesn't mean that you're disqualified. The disqualification is more an action AAKA or ETC, walking off the course, not continuing, playing a wrong ball into the
hole and then teeing off in the next hole. You know, so it's I'm going to DQ is kind of like saying I declare my ball lost, just can't do that or it doesn't mean anything. You can do it just doesn't mean anything. So let's say he did have the intention to drop the ball and put it in play. Well then this is this is similar to a drop zone question recently. Then he's now taken the original
out of play, even if big it wasn't found. But now it's taken that out of play and he has to because it wasn't found. He has only has 19.2 A going back to previous plays played. So let's say back to the T then. So again, finding the original ball, that's now the wrong ball. So you're playing from a, you're not playing it wrong ball,
you're playing it wrong from a wrong place. But it's a set of be a serious breach is my assumption and very likely. And then you have to go back to the team area and it's going to be more complicated. So yeah, as I said, as I said, the the wrong ball situation would actually be a better and easier win from just add two shots and carry on. Yeah, because you're dropping
one for practice. Well, that doesn't mean that you're dropping one to put it into play. You've got to have the intention that you want to put it into play. Interesting 1 Brian, thank you. It's always all being quite tricky. GB during stroke play championships. Player a Ted off and hit a ball. Sorry Player a Ted off and hit a tree. On finding the ball he hit the next shot across the fairway towards the 150 marker and the adjacent fairway. On approaching the marker, he
found a ball and played to a greenside bunker, then proceeded to play the that ball onto the green. We identified that he had played the wrong ball. Another wrong ball. His original ball was found on the adjacent fairway directly across from the 150 marker. Player hit his ball onto the green and then four parted how many shots his player had. Player A and his scorer conferred and scored eleven shots. Subsequently reading the rules and using golf, AII have got
differing results regarding the penalty shots. OK, this is what let's just start. OK, so T Dove had a tray and then he found his ball, so that's one. He hit the next drop across the fairway towards 150 meter marker, so it's two. And then he found a wrong ball and played it to a greenside bunker and then out of the bunker onto the green. Well, those shots don't count, but the two shot penalty does, so we're now on 4. He went back and found his
original ball. We have to make an assumption that it was found within the three minutes. So whether that's one minute of searching at the start and then another less than another 2 minutes the second time or they just found a ball straight away, you know, within 5 seconds of searching, then they would have still had the 2 minutes 55 to find the original ball. So it doesn't mention anything about that. So we're just going to assume that it was found within the three minutes.
So he's on four and then he hits it onto the green. So that's five and then he 4 putts. So that's nine. So GB, I worked out that he had nine shots. Hope that helps you out. OK, Karen, balls are often hit into the Ruff. Yes, they are under trees. Yes, where they may be a where
there may be a considerable collection of leaves. In general debris, players clear the debris around the ball by brushing it away with their hands. I've noticed that often there is loose soil under the debris that is also brushed away. I haven't said anything because I think I may be being far too pedantic. I think that most of the players at the club are unaware of the rule regarding loose soil. Should I say anything or am I being too pedantic? Wow, that is an interesting
situation, Karen. So let's first go through the rule. You are allowed to move loose impediments, so the collection of leaves and general debris however you like. So with your hand, with a club, with a towel. I've even seen leaf blowers out there. On the other hand, pun intended, you're not allowed to remove sand or loose soil that isn't
that is anywhere else but the green or the Ting area. So but when you're moving loose debris, leaves, if some loose sand or soil, sand or loose soil is removed in the process. As long as the removal of the leaves was reasonable, then the removal of some of the sand or loose soil that is under or near
the leaves is OK as long as it was reasonable. Now what is reasonable? Well, that's, you know, the pub test. I guess that's up to you, your marker, anyone watching. No, you, your marker, you know, to decide what is reasonable. And as long as you're doing it reasonable is sort of as long as you're doing it with no ill will and in mind, you know, no strategy or scheming to say I'll
just move these leaves, but I'll do it in a very rough or digging in with your hand type of manner, then you should be should be fine. If you move the leaves and then you keep going, Well, yeah, that that's not reasonable. So I'll leave that up to you to decide. But Karen, I would just make mention of it more in, in a way of, hey, guys, did you realize that you're not allowed to remove loose the sand or loose soil other than on the green on
the Tang area? And then let the ladies or the players, sorry, the players decide what they're going to take from that. And you, you might even wish to give an, an example. So you see some leaves, you go, OK, I can do this. But if there's some dirt there, I couldn't do that. And hopefully they might connect the dots that they're not allowed to remove the loose
soil, but the the leaves are fine. And again, the leaves and loose soil is fine as long as it's reasonable. But you don't have that scheming that I'm just trying to drag these leaves across the ground to also move the loose soil. But the rules have, you know, placed more emphasis on the integrity of the player, the trust on the player to do the right thing. So let's hopefully believe that they will.
Thank you for the question Karen right. Brian, my playing partner, landed his tee shot in the rough on the left hand side of the 12th hole Strath at Strathfield. It landed next to a large section of a cut down tree. I have no doubt that this log is not intended to be a long term part of the course but has been there for some weeks now. We what actions were taken? We agreed that the log would at some point be removed, so I decided that it constituted
material piled for later removal under the definition of GUR. And so free relief was allowed. Were we correct? Well, Brian, I can't really tell you whether you're correct or not. Only the only people that will know will be the committee or the Superintendent. So those are the people that you have to direct your question to. What I probably would have done since in your situation not
knowing is either get on the phone, so call the Superintendent or call the captain and they can make a decision or play 2 balls in stroke play, in match play, you can just have a make a decision. You know, the opponent disagrees. You can say, OK, well, I'll agree with you. I won't take free relief and I'll just play it. Or you can say, well, stuff you I'm going to play it. And if you don't like that, I if
I'm going to take free relief and if you don't like that, you have to make a claim, request a ruling. I never get that right. I think it's request a ruling now and then the committee will decide at the end. But if it's stroke play, then you've got the two ball option, which you can take relief, say this is the ball that I want to count and then also play the ball as it lies that is right
beside the tray and just play those two balls out and then tell the committee. You have to tell the committee at the end before you sign the scorecard, hey, this happened. What's the actual ruling? And then they can make a decision right then and there. So I can't actually give you, I can tell you what the procedure is, Brian, or what you could have done, but I can't actually tell you whether the trees that have been cut down or parts of the trees that have been cut down were intended to be left there or removed.
Another one from Brian. I am hoping to get some clarification about a ruling provided in John Thorman's book book which I don't really agree with. A player hits his ball left of the fairway and clips a tree near a pond. After a minute search, he makes the assumption that the ball has gone into the pond, the red penalty area and takes lateral relief before playing his next shot. A playing partner then finds his original ball in the general area. The player picks up the substituted ball and plays on
with the original. So the player had a lift in the fir clips of the tree after a minute. Here he makes assumption that the ball. So he's made the assumption that the ball has gone into the bed penalty area. So does he have known or virtual certainty? Takes lateral relief. He's dropped his ball. But then before playing that shot, the playing partner finds the original ball in the general area. So the player picks up the substitute ball and plays on with the original. My understanding of the rules is that he is in big trouble.
To the player's mind he must have had KFCKFC, he must have had KVC, that he was in the penalty area so his drop ball was the ball in play. He has now played a wrong ball so needs to correct this or face disqualification and John's ruling. He allows the player to continue with no penalty on the basis that he could not have had KVC and so proceeded under an inapplicable rule which he corrected before taking a further stroke. Is this really correct? I know that many golfers I
reluctantly include myself in this probably take penalty area area relief when in truth there is more than a 5% chance that they are not in the penalty area. If you take the drop and then your ball was found. Surely it is fair and reasonable to insist that you stick with your initial KVC decision. This is awesome. This is interesting Brian. The I can see where both of you are coming from and as you state, it definitely just comes down to KVC. If the player doesn't have KVC
then they weren't allowed to proceed under rule 17.1 D in this case 3 because he took lateral relief. They weren't allowed to proceed under that rule, so it would have been incorrectly substitutable and played from a wrong place and probably a serious breach as well because he would have to go back to the T because it would have been considered. Committee would consider that
lost outside the penalty area. So S&D stroke and distance. But he's assumed that he did have KVC. Sorry, sorry. So yeah, so if he didn't have it, then he needed to continue with the original ball is what I'm trying to say, which is what John has said. But you're saying, well, why did he drop in the 1st place? He must have KVC. Well, not necessarily.
As you said, there's a lot of clubland golfers out there that will just wrongly assume that they've got KVC just because there's rough and there's penalty area, you know, oh, I must have gone in the penalty area and they probably don't want to walk all the way back to the Tang area. So he got lucky there that he didn't play the drop ball and the original ball was found outside and he got lucky that he hadn't didn't have KVC. So ineffective in effect.
And I'm not really that good with this cliche, but he was trying to have his cake and eat it too. So he was trying to say I have Ki have KVC. But then when the original was found outside, he then changed his mind and said, Oh, no, I don't have KVC. I don't reckon he did have KVC based on what the question was in the first point. But if he did, then he would have to stick with the ball that he's dropped.
So what John's saying is correct, Brian, what you would like to sort of happen? I would like that too. I would like everyone to only drop their ball only to to only take free relief, penalty relief from a penalty area when they had KVC. But that is not club land. People will proceed under that rule without KVC. But yeah, so it would be better if he had not dropped and he'd
taken his medicine and gone back to the T 1st and not tried to proceed under a rule that wasn't applicable. But this club land person didn't do that and then got lucky because the ball that they dropped couldn't have been the ball was the ball in play but wasn't put into play under an applicable rule. So he got to pick it up and correct his error. Get out of jail free card is what we say. I hope that helps.
Brian Radio DK last one. I bet he answers this for me. Playing stroke player. Player is in a green side bunker. They make a stroke and blade the ball into the lip of the bunker. The ball then slowly rolls back down the bunker face and hits the player's foot. The player then plays out the hole with the ball from where it came to rest. The player asked the golf shop if there is a penalty after the round. The player was asked if they had the opportunity to move out of the way of the moving ball. The player said I could have, but I didn't want the ball to end up in the footprint, my
footprints in the bunker, so I didn't move my feet. Please discuss on the pod. For your information, we handed out the general penalty for deliberately deflecting a ball in motion should there be another GP for playing for a wrong place. Well, DK in in a bunker at the Artificial Intelligence Golf Club. Yeah. So this is an interesting one by
DK. Well, this actually happened, yeah. I mean, if you see a ball coming towards you and you've got the opportunity to get out of the way, then you should get out of the way. Now, if you trip over and trying to get out of the way and the ball hits you, that's an accident. But it's not an accident if you just stand there and wait for the ball to hit you. And especially if the player then says I didn't want it to go in the footprints, well, that's just absolutely deliberate. Fair play that he's being honest
about being dishonest, I guess. But yeah, so that's a two shot penalty. Now what do they have to do if they deliberately stay there or they deliberately deflect or stop their ball at rest, stop their ball in motion? They need to estimate where the ball would have come to rest, work out that reference point and then drop their ball within a club length of that spot, no nearer the hole in the same area
of the course. Yeah. So DK, you've given him two shots for a breach of 11.2, B, 11.2, and then he was actually had to go through the procedure of dropping it possibly around where his footprints were. But is there any intervening event? And the answer is, if he didn't have a clue, like he knew that
he knew that there was a breach and now he didn't know that there was a breach. We're assuming that he didn't know that there was a breach by stopping the ball in motion and then he also wouldn't have known that he's supposed to drop it because he didn't know it was that. There's a difference between an accidental deliberate and so it's 2 two shot penalties, but you just take the highest of the
one penalty, which is 2 shots. So he would just get the two shot penalty for playing from a wrong place as well. I hope that helps. OK. And as per usual, I've got a question for golf dot AIA rules question. So let's bring them in. Call them up. Hi, I'm Chris, your rules official from Golf dot AI. I generally look up information, so be patient with me as I search the rulebook. What golf rules question can I answer for you today?
OK Chris, true or false? A wrong ball is any ball other than the players ball in place, provisional ball, or a second ball played in stroke play. That's true. A wrong ball is indeed any ball other than the players ball in play, provisional ball or second ball played in stroke play. This is according to the definition in the Rules of Golf. Is there anything else I can help you with today? No, that's all good, Chris. Thank you. See you later. And there you go. As per the definition of wrong ball, that was true.
OK, GRQOTW 137 David hits his tee shot to the right of the fairway and it comes to rest inside a wombat hole that is on the side of a Cliff face. The ball was not visible from the ground but was known to have gone into the hole and the hole was very visible from the ground and it is easy to see that it is a wombat hole. David can't walk up the Cliff face to get to the ball nor the hole, so he says to Andrew that he will take free relief and use the nearest spot to the hole that he can reach as his reference point and drop a ball
within a club length of that spot. Andrew is not sure about that and doesn't even think David could actually play a shot at the ball as he can't climb the Cliff face. Andrew calls in a referee and that is you. What is your ruling, right? Yeah, that was the GRQ podcast presented by Golf that AI. I'm Blakey. It was weird to do it all alone. We're going to have hopefully more guests coming up soon on the show. We love the Clubland stories, so
please get them in as often as you can. Other than that, I hope you get out on the golf course very soon and bring me more content. Cheers.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...