CLUBLAND STORIES December: Podcast and Blakey finally disagree on a Rules situation. We have nearly ten outstanding ClubLand stories, including two audio questions - THE GRQ PODCAST EP130
ClubLand Stories December, and what an absolute doozy to finish out the year 2024. Podcast and Blakey finally disagree on a Rules situation, so let us know who you think is right. We have nearly ten outstanding ClubLand stories/Rules questions, including two audio questions, one of which is the GRQOTW for episode 130 and it is a head-scratcher. GRQOTW129: Andy the Average Golfer incurs a General Penalty for all of the breaches. GRQOTW130 Player hits her ball on a par 3 and it is Known or Virtually Certain to be in a Yellow Penalty Area. The player decides to correctly drop a ball back-on-the-line for a penalty of one stroke. The player then sees her original ball and decides to go and play that ball. She hits her original ball sideways and it rolls back into the same Yellow Penalty Area at a new entry point. The player goes back on the tee side of the Yellow Penalty Area and drops a ball back-on-the-line. She then hits this ball into the greenside bunker. Then she hits her bunker shot across the green and back into the penalty area at the same crossing point as the original ball from the teeing area. She goes to drop a ball under penalty of one stroke back-on-the-line but as her first dropped ball is in the same position she decides to play this instead. Hits that on the green and takes one putt to finish. What is her score? GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Gov rules questions Episode 130 brings us Clubland stories December and what an absolute doozy to finish out the year 2024 podcast and Blakey finally disagree on a rules situation. So let us know who you think is right. We have nearly 10 outstanding clubland stories slash rules questions, including two audio questions, one of which is the GRQOTW for episode 130 and it is a head scratcher. So whether you are sunning yourself beside the pool on 40°
Melbourne day or sitting inside a cold inbra winter, enjoy this episode of the golf rules questions podcast. Hi everyone, episode 130 golf rules questions podcast. I'm Blakey and with me is of course, rules extraordinaire, Stuart Podcast McPhee. Now the podcast name for you,
Stuart is really reaching depths and heights that we've never known. Is that correct? It's not a high standard to reach, but yes, levels we've never known before well. I heard that you were in a supermarket the other day, is that correct? I probably was, but no one called me podcast. It might have been. A good story we can run with it, It might have. Been a pro shop but don't let the facts get in the way of good story. No, I was in the fruit and veg aisle.
Of the pro shop and and someone yelled at your name. Podcast and I it took me by surprise until I realised he was looking at me. So I walked up and introduced myself. He goes, oh, I know who you are. I said, well, you know what's your name? And introduced himself and hello to Marcus, who said hello at the and he's a listener. He said hello at the Commonwealth Golf Club pro shop, and he's a listener to our
podcast. He said he enjoys it and he's learning things and yeah. And his name is reaching. He's starting his traineeship, yes, which absolutely rocked my world. Very happy to have Marcus as a listener. I'm probably going to join DK as as one of our rules aficionados from the PGA Tour or PGA traineeorpga.orgorpga.org dot AU.
Yeah. And working in golf operations. Working in operations staff in a Golf Club. Yeah, we we absolutely get so excited when we hear golf OPS people taking an interest in the rules. So, and as Marcus and I spoke about, you know, a member finishes their round, has a rules question, comes straight into the pro shop. And we're, you know, they see the staff and they ask them straight away. And there is an expectation that they know the rules. And as we know, what's worse is when they make it up.
Yep. Because they they don't, they want to say face, right? They want to be seen to know the answer. Yeah. That that's exactly right. They are the face, the front of the Golf Club effectively because they get seen all the time and they get the questions. I mean, it's very, and it has to be a very tough or hard or a question that, you know, someone gets stuck on for them to actually go home later that
night and then call or e-mail someone about it. Usually it's forgotten about within 5 minutes of signing the scorecard. But so within that 5 minutes they see a PGA pro, they're going to ask that person or just anyone behind or working at the golf shop, they're going to ask that person. That's why to us, it's so imperative that these people A, either know the rules or B, just know where to find the answers. So keep listening at Marcus and
if you need any help with anything, reach out. He actually has sent an e-mail about a question and I've got to get back to him. But reach out for any other answers at all. We are more than happy to help now. Episode 130. Episode 129. Fantastic. Done by yourself. Thank you. While I was away. Excellent. I just loved listening to John, so I'm glad you could interview him. He had an Andy, the average
golfer, GRQO TW129. What was it and what's the answer? Andy, the average golfer, is playing at Wombat Hills after an after some overnight rain. His ball lies on wet, compacted sand in a bunker on the 1st hole. Thinking that lift, rake and place is an option under the circumstances, Andy lifts his ball, Rakes the area, fluffing the sand, replaces the ball on the original spot and plays his ball successfully from the
bunker. How many penalty strokes, if any, does Andy incur? Well, unfortunately we know that Andy doesn't know the rules. So with all those breaches, there wasn't actually an IE of him going. I wonder if I'm breaking the rules. So he's going to actually get lucky and only get the general penalty of up to you which one you want to give it to for the plan for the wrong place or improving your conditions.
Up to you what you want to do, but it's. Not going to be. Maximum of two and yeah, well, if he was restoring the conditions, it wouldn't be a penalty for that. And if he was restoring the conditions and. Well sorry not re not recreating the original light as he was possible before replacing because it was sand. Yeah. But anyway, as you said, there was some multiple no. Yeah, no one had worsened his lie in the 1st place, had they?
Well, he did. Well, yeah, but no one that actually mattered. OK. No one that mattered that he could actually change it back. That's what I mean. And as we as you just said, the the lack of intervening events means you could bundle up and lifting the ball in the 1st place is a penalty stroke under 9.4. But bundling all those together? And, and this is where The funny thing is, if you actually the less, and I'd hate to say it, but the less you know, the less likely you are to have an IE and therefore you can't actually get
away with stupidity. Ignorance is bliss, as they say. Ignorance is bliss. Yeah, that hashtag is trending. Under Rules of Golf. So we've got a big episode, a big, big, big episode, because we've got a lot of clubland stories including audio files. Audio files, not just audio file. So we have a lot of rulings to get through and we're going to start with Bill.
Two players in club flight championship match play. That's match play for you Podcast on 12th hole. Player A plays the wrong ball. Neither know the rules and player A says it's a one stroke penalty. Player A makes 5 with the stroke and player B makes 6. So let's say that player A1. They tee off on the next hole. Player B found out later it was loss of hole for a player, but
he needed to make a claim for someone teed off on that next hole. This happened at Winter's run in August. Bill has basically given us the question and or the scenario and the answer, but I'd just like you to reiterate his answer there about B found out later it was lost a hole but he needed to make a claim. Yeah, well or request a ruling under 20.1 B2 but.
Oh, that's right, Bill. Bill makes a claim like me. Like still uses make of a claim. So that's a request, a ruling maybe, but the, the, the the most critical part of this is that when they started play on the next hole, they had agreed to a match score. That's that's the crux. And soon as one began the next hole, that wrong match score is locked in. There wasn't a request for a ruling in time or make a claim in time. There's nothing we could put in Asterix and go back, you know,
caveat on the result of that hole. So it was locked in and him finding out later he can be upset with himself, but it cannot change the result of that hole. It's locked in. See, just like I said, ignorance is bliss. In this case, ignorance cost him a hole. He player B should have won that hole. We make the claim, oh that's a loss a hole and bang, he moves to the next hole. So. So effectively the impact on him is 2 effectively, yeah, because
rather than being one up or if whatever the hold is, he's 2 away, that's. Right. The old two shot swing or two hole swing. And you know, I guess you'd say so. It's quite an impact, but that's the key. He's agreeing to a wrong match score and not requesting a ruling in time. We've got a question here from PW Pitching Wedge. This question has risen amongst the referees at our Golf Club. Oh no. A player puts their ball, which is on the green, it misses the
hole by 30 centimeters to the right, and the ball continues on to strike a nearest the pin marker, which is a meter behind the hole and off to the right. What should they do then? It says the actions were taken to resolve the player's ball's on the green. It's had a movable obstruction, the nearest the pin. If it is likely to interfere, move it. If not and the ball strikes the object, it is struck and outside influence. You would therefore expect the ball to be played as it lies.
But no into rule 11, point B2, which contains a caveat that changes the OI, the outside influence, into a movable obstruction, even though at no stage it was interfering with the player of the ball at rest. Therefore, Part 2 of this rule is invoked and the player is required, under threat of the general penalty, to replay the shot. So we have rewarded the player who has played an errant shot with the chance to do it all again for free. This is a hypothetical question and asked whether the summary
above is correct and if the rules anticipated this type of scenario and the applicable ruling. You said 11.1 B2, didn't you? 11.1 B Two yeah. Do you agree with the hypothetical question and answer? I mean it's. Not a hypothetical answer, it's a hypothetical question. Yeah. So his has hit a movable obstruction and therefore there is a requirement to replay the
stroke. I'll just say a movable obstruction other than the club used to make the stroke, a ball marker, a ball at rest or the flag stick. So if it hits any other movable obstruction, a stroke made from the putting ground hits anything else other than those few items. That's why if your ball hits a ball marker on the way to the hole, you don't replay the stroke because it's one of the exceptions under that 11.1 B2. If it hits your club, another ball at rest. We know there might be a penalty for that or the flag sick. But yeah, it's in a movable
obstruction artificial object. This, this is, I mean, he, he is right. So we rewarded the player who's played near its shot, but the chance to do it all again for free. I, I tend to agree with that. You know, there are going to be situations where it's going to be accidental or what it might be, you know, someone drops a towel and then it hits the towel then, you know, and if it was
before the whole, then yeah. But you can't differentiate between before the whole or after the whole. You know, this was a funny one because a certain person from a certain ruling body, before they started working there, made A and they, this person makes very good videos. They made a video that describe this exact situation where a person can get a free replay but.
It was slightly different, wasn't it? I can't remember, I thought it was very similar. No, no. But the the difference was his video said you could do it deliberately and therefore get a line on the part. That's what the delivers. Accidentally. Deliberately. Was that right? Yeah, yeah, something like that. It's like. Oh, this just happens to be left here by me. Yeah. But yeah, then then this was before they worked for this
ruling body and the another person told them they should probably take that video down, which I was happy to hear. But you know, it is, it does bring up a very interesting hypothetical question. And I'm sure it happens. I'm absolutely sure it happens whether the players know that they must replay. Replay the stroke. I I don't know, I doubt it, but and. Then they end up playing from a wrong place because they don't
replay the stroke. Then they play from a wrong place, incurring the general penalty, and they probably don't add that to their score because they count the first stroke. They wouldn't. I mean, when did that change? That's all I can say. It must have been in the latest rulings. Must have been December 1, 2024. Thank you. P Dub. The Do you know that you know that PW? No, I do not know those. Initials, OK, just checking.
Touching Ridge. OK, Jimbo from Canada is back. This is Jimbo's third go with us. Two players. Balls were each off the green, neither player could see the other. One puttered and one chipped their ball and the balls collided on the green. The ball that was helped the most likely would have gone over the green as it was sculled. It was a friendly match so each played the subsequent subsequent ball as it lied. Neither knew who hit first. If this was match play, what would the ruling be? And stroke play question mark The actions that were taken were
the playing the balls as they lied lay I've always I've always agreed with that. Like he's got played the ball as they lied in brackets. Lay question mark. Yeah, I it's always got me. I think play the ball, play the balls played balls as they lay, I think is correct. Laid lay. And that happened in Florida a week ago. So did you get that the two balls were off the green, one part of one chip didn't Didn't
know whose order was to play first. What is the ruling? You played as a lies. Sorry. Both are played as a lies only because both strokes were made from off the putting green. That's. OK, so that's stroke play. What about in match play? What would the ruling be? I think it's you having a go at me about stroking match. No, no, this is actual actual question. No, I believe the ruling is the same. It would depend on I mean it. Is the same order of plays that we're gonna say. Yes, it would depend.
So if they could work out who played first and that player was actually the second person that should have played in the order, then that person has played out of turn. But then. Yeah, you haven't cancelled it because you've played. The other person's already hit so they can't cancel it, so it's not going to matter, is it? No. Wow. That's if you're able to determine who hit first anyway.
And that wouldn't even matter if because you can't because you've already played. Good one, Jimbo. Good questions coming from you. What's that? All the way from Canada. It's terrific. OK, got one from Dino here. Stableford competition. Andy's second shot finished awkwardly on the tongue of a bunker, requiring an unfortunate stance with the ball in the rough grass well above his feet which were in the bunker.
He took a practice swing and in taking that action, although about 30 centimeters away from the ball, the movement of the grass rough caused his ball to dislodge and roll into the bunker. He asked what happens now. We determined that his action, while accidental head caused his ball removed, so he need to replace his ball back in the rough and take a one shot penalty. That happened in the greenside bunker. 5th hole at Victoria Golf Club. So local to us. OK, not not Victoria in Canada. Canada.
No, this is Victoria in Vic. So another example of Dino giving us the situation and the answer. Yeah, that's right. The the most important part here is just they determined that his action, while accidental, had caused the ball to move. So they obviously had that at least 95% virtual certainty that it was the player that caused the ball to move and therefore he had to replace it and take the one shot. If it wasn't enough, if there
wasn't enough evidence to suggest that the player had caused it to move, then the player would have to play it from the bunker with no penalty shot. But when he said, he said it was in the rough. So, you know, it was probably, it probably would have taken a fair bit of effort to move the ball, you know, more than just a bit of wind. So and, and you know, the
practice swing and then the ball moves a second later or whatever. It was pretty, pretty easy to get 90 at least 95% there I'd say. Yeah, for those listening to our podcasts and just getting into the rules and wanting to learn this stuff, this course all covered under 9.2 onwards that it's important to note there's four causes, right? The rules recognise for your ball to move, and in most of those cases the ball goes back. That's important to remember, yes. So if you move it, it goes back. If an outside influence moves
it, you go back. If your opponent in match play moves it, it goes back. And the only time it doesn't, of course, is the natural forces. Well, and and then there's also 2 caveats 2. Exceptions and 9.3 I was going to go through there but. Oh, sorry, I keep. Cutting that's no, no, I was going to, I was going to, but then I thought, no, that's enough for them to that you want for a bit. No, you're right. There are two exceptions to 9.3. Just good to have conversational banter on the Scalf Rules Questions podcast. The Ricky They're both the Ricky Fowler rule and the Billy Horser rule. Yes, that's what we call them.
Yes, that's right. Now Dino actually had another one that he sent to me. A player. What? What is the What is the Billy Horser rule and the Ricky Fowler rule? The Billy Horser was the one. We're on the 15th green at Augusta. He chipped onto the green. Then he placed his ball down, still had the ball marker down, but his the Augusta wind got up and blew it into the water. He's like Augusta wind. Yeah, good.
Then he had to drop it. It was a drop from shoulder height back then, back where he last played from, because his ball had gone into the penalty area. Now, I guess it's a drop from knee height now. And so they changed it that if he'd already marked it, which is what the rule is now, if he'd already marked it, lifted it, it's the most important, not the marking, the lifting and replacing, then that is where the bull owns that spot. And then the Ricky Fowler, he hit it a bit long over a green
par 5 green, went into a penalty area, took a drop from the penalty area, was sizing up what he was going to do after going drop, drop place, sizing up what he was. Well, what shot he was going to play came back to his ball and ball rolled back into the penalty area. So that was an extra shot. And then drop drop place again and made seven but still ended up winning the tournament on that one luckily. Oh wow, you know all those details. Can I just add some add some mayonnaise to those two things. Remember the the because again,
people listening and wanting to learn. Remember the rules with the Billy Horseshoe rule. Don't mention the word marked. So it's just if your ball is being lifted and replaced, because what that means is another player, an outside influence, could lift your ball and you or that person could replace it and it still then owns that spot even though it wasn't marked. And the other one with the, what's his name, Fowler, who I didn't know 1 and I didn't know his score on that hole. If a ball's been placed, replaced or dropped, put back into play and then rolls into another area, the course are out
of bounds. We put it back with that penalty. You know, I actually had a funny situation. I had a ruling with Brandon Grace the other day in Thailand and we it was a situation about if his balls moved and then does he get to clean it? And I I can't even remember what it was, but I just had AI got the answer to his question. But then the two of us sort of
came up with a hypothetical and I said, I don't mean I don't know the answer to that. I said I'll find out anyway. I found out and drove down to him half a hole later and was just talking through, you know, these situations where if you ball rolls onto different areas and blah, blah, blah. And he said, you know, in a South African accent, which I'm not going to do, He said that he was the one that was in the Ricky Fowler. Well, it wasn't in Ricky Fowler's group, but he was playing really well that day.
And he was in the group and head and actually was leading, made a putt and then was actually ended up being tie with Ricky and might even been leading by a shot. So Ricky was like leading by 5. And then suddenly all of a sudden because of that double bogey and more bogeys and Brandon Grace having birdies and Brandon ended up being equal leader or leading by a shot and then he just didn't quite get it finished. And Ricky actually came back and
won, which was probably good for the rules at the time, I guess. But yeah, it was just interesting. He was on the other side of of a fortunate unfortunate for Ricky and could have been fortunate for Brandon. So there you go. He is the other party in that almost benefited from that situation. Now Dino has another one player in our group playing with par three. 4th hole is at Victoria. Select his club from his bag and
before taking a stance, lay the club down at his feet to check his alignment. Let go of the club. I'd assume once content with the alignment he then picked up his club and that's why I think he laid it. He let go of it because he picked it up. Then declared to the group that this is OK as I will be using the same club to hit the ball as I used for the alignment. Never heard that. I've never heard that one but that's great. And then proceeded to tee off. He did not, once aligned, pick up his club and step away to
then retake his stance. He just bent down with his feet in place and took his swing quickly. Referring to the Rules app, I pointed out rule 10.2 B. We applied the general penalty, he didn't score on the whole and we moved on. Needless to say, he no longer uses this alignment process. Also add to that is you get penalised regardless of whether you take away the alignment. Is that right? So if you breach that rule and then you pick it up and try and retake your stance with that
one, you're still penalised. You can't get out of that one once you've done it wrong. Is that right? If the player breaches this rule, they cannot avoid penalty by removing the object before the stroke is made. Are you? Did you just read that? Yep, and set an object down means that the object is in contact with the ground and the player is not touching the object. 3rd sentence of the player that's right, that's what you said so and then but then he's asked. Have you ever had any examples of rule breaking alignment
taking place on the pro tour? Personally I have not other than the 10.2 B 4 situation where the caddy stands behind. I haven't had one myself, but obviously we've seen all that play out and I. Reckon that happens a lot at junior amateur golf where the parent is the caddy. Yep, trying to help. I get it. But like when you're in competition with others? Yes, yeah. Well, I mean, yeah, I that
situation, it talks about laying the club down that only that rule only did change in 2019. So you actually were allowed to do it before that and I had seen players doing it, but now, now it is a no, no and that. Includes because I knew a player who did this at my club, excuse me, in the teeing area on a cold winters morning. He'd create a line in the dew to help with his alignment. Yes, and because we know you can
do lots and lots of things in the teeing area, alter the surface of the ground, etcetera, etcetera. And it never mentioned dew. It talked about, you know, laying an object there. Yeah. So that now is now specifically prohibited under that same rule 10.2 B 3. It was on a train bound for nowhere and you met up with a gambler. You're both too tired to speak right Carrying on. Briggsie, Ben and Brad are playing the Saturday stroke round competition. Saturday stroke competition at
Adelaide's best Golf Club, Glenelg. On the short par for 4th hole, both Ben and Brad find their balls in the same bunker. Brad plays his ball out to the bunker, onto the green, out of the bunker, onto the green. Brad then picks up the rake and begins raking without being asking. Brad Rakes very close and deliberately behind Ben's ball such that Ben's ball has an improved lie. Ben responds with the comment. Well raked, thank you very much. Ben gets up and down for a
birdie. What actions would take and to resolve the situation? None. Brad was caring for the course and this happened in Glenelg 4th Hall. I mean, what do you think of this podcast? So I'll go to 8.2, deliberate actions to alter physical conditions or deliberate actions to alter other physically deferred. Oh no, no, No 8.3. Sorry.
Sorry, this rule only covers a players deliberate actions to alter physical conditions to affect another players ball at rest or stroke to be made by that player. Prohibited Actions A player must not deliberately take any of the actions listed in 8.1 A to improve or worsen the conditions affecting the stroke of another player. Exception There is no penalty under this rule if the player alters any such other physical conditions to care for the
course, such as smoothing footprints in a bunker or replacing a divot in a divot hole. So from the information, we probably don't have enough. I mean, they're saying that Brad was caring for the course. If that's the truth, that's fine. No action, no penalty, nothing. If he actually was caring for the course, you know, worsened conditions and he then restored those worsened conditions, it kind of doesn't really sound
like that, you know, caring for the core. I mean, if we don't know if the conditions were worsened, so let's say they weren't worsened and now he's but now he has improved them and he's done it sounds like he's done it deliberately. Well, it says deliberately so yeah, I I'd say that Brad probably should have got a
general penalty. How does a .1 D factor in here? Restoring conditions worsened after you've all came to rest. So let's say the conditions were worsened. Yes, someone else's actions. If Brad had worsened the conditions, it doesn't say that, But if Brad had worsened the conditions, then he's able to restore them. Not, I mean that's going to be an improvement, but it's just to restore them. You can't restoration if.
If the ball, if there's a ball in embedded in the bunker, you can't, you know, now break it out of the bunker and let it sit on top or whatever. It's just a restoration from the worsened conditions back to what they were prior. Because of someone else, the first person making their stroke. Yeah, yeah, I, I would say that if there were no worsened conditions, Brad saying that he's caring for the course is probably a a very fast stretch.
Especially if he's raking an area that wasn't impacted by his stroke. Because I mean you, you can care for the course, but you know you can't breach 12.2 B, which is improving your conditions. And then if you, as you said, if you'd moved to 8.3 and you're improving someone else's conditions deliberately, then that's definitely a penalty. And so when the other guy goes, oh thanks, good raking job. Yeah, that's right. Are they doing the old eye
contact and you know, doing can you just keep raking over a little bit further if you don't mind? It's funny they're playing against each other, but they're happy to help each other out. Yeah, yeah. This is why I love, This is why I love club champs. Cause usually club champs you you don't play in the same group of four with with your mates. No. And so. People we've never met. That's when that's when players, members of the club actually learn the rules. Yeah, I I didn't know you could do. That because they're held to account. They're held and you know the
other person's not their, not their friend, not their Saturday not doesn't want to, doesn't care about making it awkward, is just telling the truth. Have you ever seen balls land just short of a green on a par 3 and somebody else comes up and repairs a pitch mark in front of another player's ball to help them? Actually, I have seen that ruling back in 1999, I reckon. And I didn't know the ruling. And that was actually the first time it picked AI was playing a
tournament the first time. I actually was like, oh, I didn't know that rule. I should really start living the rules. And that's why it sticks in my memory so much. It was on the 15th hole at North Otago Golf Club and yeah, we're just playing in a random four in a tournament and someone's just fixed the pitch mark of it was off the air ball. So it wasn't quite the same. Fix the pitch mark off the green and then the other, another
person's gone. You can't do that, you know, And it's it's everything that everyone says, oh, that person's, you know, why do they need to get involved? We're not playing for sheep stations. All that stuff comes back and you're like, yeah, but that's the rules. Like, you know, Anyway, I. Would like to think that expression. I haven't actually. I haven't actually seen someone else improved. But I would like to think that expression is used as widely in New Zealand. Is it? It's more important, cheap
stations are more important in New Zealand. You know, you might get a date out of it. So moving on. So Brexit, I think Brad got away with one there. Next our Briggs is back. Adelaide's best Golf Club again. Recently completed the yearly renovation with all freeways being scarified as a result. Local rule lift clean and place one club length We implemented.
He's got UFN. I just, I'm sorry, I don't know that. Or maybe it was OFN. What? Until further notice. Yeah, that's that's probably a UFN. There you go. Brexit podcast helped you out. Help me out until further notice. The brilliant head pro, the brilliant man. That's a good start. The brilliant head golf pro observes scrum on the out. There must be a guy's name on the 18th Wednesday Staleford competition.
This must been that was October. Sorry, No, this must have been November. Applying the local rule by using his club to manoeuvre the ball under a preferred lie within one club length. OK, understood. The head pro approached Scrum after the round and inquired politely what score he'd submitted on the par 518th. Scrum replied. Par Why? The club pro said you had at least nine because you were not applying the local rule correctly. Scrum replied. Come on, we're not playing for
sheep stations. Beautiful. What educate, what actions were taken to resolve the situation re education of scrum, what a name and again another head pro who actually had some knowledge of the rules of golf. So they are out there Stuart, and we want to find more. We want. We absolutely want to find more. We. Want to find more because we know a lot that and not in that category.
So just make a point about that, sorry. No, go for it. Well, it's important, you know, you just can't roll your ball into place and put it into play somewhere. The ball must be replaced by sitting or placed by sitting it down by hand on the required spot and letting go of it or letting go so that stays on that spot. That's how you put a ball into play or. Place it all. Can't roll it with the club, can't roll it with your foot, can't even roll it with your hand. You have to place it. Place it and let go of it and it stays on that spot. Thank you very much Briggsy for
your last two questions from Adelaide's best Golf Club now. So I've got one more here from Sandy. Oh actually I've got 2 from Sandy and these are tricky. Can a player have a cord tied around their putter grip to help them place their hands in a consistent position? So the cord is wrapped around the normal grip, yes? Is that right? OK, my immediate guess is no.
Yeah, my immediate guess is no. I'd I'd say the chord is probably OK as long as it's symmetrical or asymmetrical, whatever it was. Yeah, but to put it, you can. Split it in half and it looks the same. But to put it in place like that? That's right, to put it in a place where maybe your thumb is in a certain spot. Exactly. Yeah, I would what I would reckon. So we're both saying no, but we'll check from the equipment rules because that's not in the rules of golf. That's in the equipment rules. And it basically says you aren't allowed to, you know, have one of those grips molded to your
hands. I mean, we know that over time, natural wear, it will mold to your grip. That's what I was about to say. I'd say if you have a new grip, no, you're right. If you have a new grip, get out there and spend 24 hours seven days a week for two weeks on the putting green, moulding it through wear and tear and you'll be fine. So. What about this though? That's allowed, but actually creating a moulded or putting a moulded grip onto your putter is not allowed. So how about a player may use
equipment to help their play during a round? Except that a player must not create a potential advantage by using equipment that artificially eliminates or reduces the need for a skill or judgement that is essential to the challenge of the game. Yeah. I mean, if you go to equipment rules, they have a bit more. It's specifics. Yeah, it's not down to what you can can. Lot more technical. Another question here from Sandy. In a match, Player A asks Player B to move his marker on the
green as it interferes with Player A's line of putt play. Player A forgets to move their marker back to its original position and putts from where he moved his marker to. Player A doesn't realize that Player B has padded from the wrong spot, but a spectator tells both players that Player B has paddled out without moving his marker back and the penalty has lost a halt. Can Player A ignore Player B's breach once he becomes aware of it?
Oh, sorry, I was nodding. Yeah, Podcast was nodding. That was a great silence on the great. Great. Material, great material, great silence. I mean, this is not Charlie Chapman. They can't see your podcast, but like some of them can anyway, so you can't ignore it. Player A can actually say to player BI realize that that is
the rule, but I am going to disregard it. That's not an agreeance to waive the rule. They wouldn't be able to say, ah, should I, should I penalize you and play? What do you reckon that goes? No, no, don't. Realize me. Yeah. That would be an agreement, so you wouldn't wouldn't be allowed to do that. But the to to your question, yes, Player A can ignore Player B's breach. You know, all he has to say is oh, thanks for that and let's get on with it.
The whole the score is still this. Yeah, you're missing hard anyway. Or. Yeah, that's right. Now, did you have any questions? Club Lanes stories. No, it's got a few rulings from the events, but we can. This has been a Club Land story podcast. We can save them for another day. All right, well, we might get to them after. I've got 2 audio. This is special, very special. We've got 2 audio questions. We are really elevating our game on this podcast. That we are going to call
through in the The first one's not too bad. The second one is an absolute doozy that I think we're going to take a fair bit of time on. Right number one, This is from Catherine B. Hi guys, someone said I should send you this rules question. I played Pennant on Sunday which was the first time and my opponent wasn't very experienced with match play rules either. But on one of the holes we were on the green and I was first to put. I missed the putt by about half a centimeter and just went and
tapped it in as I normally would. Then we both realized I technically played out of turn. We asked other players that were at the next hole experienced in match play and they advised that because I played out of turn I lose lost the hole. When returning to the clubhouse I asked the lady captain and she advised that I should have just replaced my ball with no penalty. Now that because I've read the rules online, my understanding is that unless my opponent objects to me tapping in my putt, it was OK to do so. But if she objected I would need
to replace the ball and wait for her to putt before I could tap it in without any penalty, my opponent needed to make a putt to square the hole. Could you please advise the correct ruling? Thanks. Is that our first ever audio question? It might have been the first ever with you and me. I think Roscoe and I had one or two because when when we started getting off topic here, but when we started this podcast, I was
using it through Anchor. Anchors now have been taken over by Spotify, but Anchor had a fantastic little tool where people could submit audio questions. And so we actually had, well, I say at least two. It might have been 5, but I think for you and me, that might have been our first. So thank you very much, Catherine B. Add some flavour and I don't know, something special to the podcast to hear someone else's voice. Yeah, it's like people actually
listen to this thing. Right. You tell me. People listen. So the rolling so basically. Well, she's got it right, doesn't she? Catherine. Yeah, to her disadvantage she Catherine played out of turn, but the there's no penalty. The only recourse that the opponent has is that they can get the player Catherine to replace and replay or they could if it was such a short putt,
they could just give them the putt. I mean just. Or leave it. Or not replay it, not cancel it. That's right. Or not cancelled. So yes, but as we said as before, because this was very similar to what? Similar to question 121, wasn't it, where if you accept the situation? Yeah, similar to question by Bill, if you accept the situation and because you don't
know the rules without requesting a ruling or what I like to say making a claim, then bad luck for you. Don't you love how often club golfers who do not know the rules, whenever they hear of a potential breach, it's automatically 2 stroke penalty, 2 stroke penalty, two straight, and then when they're playing match play automatically. Oh, that's lost a hole. Lost a hole straight away. Yeah. So go to move. It's the only ruling they know only penalty. They know match play. Yeah, but if they're playing, if
they're playing with their mates, automatic no penalty, of course. Didn't we have one someone when a friend of the podcast told us one that at one of their pro events recently where two professional women didn't know that there was a penalty for hitting a wrong ball? Wow, that's very surprising. Yeah, it's like you can just go and hit anyone's ball and just add it to your, you know, just that's your score for the hole. Or there's no penalty but it's a
mistake, but you still need to go and hit yours. Imagine if that like in speed golf, and it was just whoever got a ball in the hole. So you just found a ball that's nearest the hole and just hit it because you were the fastest there? I'll tell you what, where you and I were today, you could easily hit a wrong ball if you were looking and went off. On a three or three or one, I don't know, that one was just. In the I picked it up two so into the rough. Can I just quickly then say the rules for those again listening in who are learning?
6.4 covers order of play, stroke and match play. So, 646 point 4A two, if the player plays when it was the opponent's turn to play, there is no penalty, but the opponent may cancel. The stroke must be done promptly before either player makes another stroke. When you cancel, you cannot withdraw that cancellation. If the opponent cancels the stroke, the player must, when it is their turn to play, play a ball from where that stroke was made. If the opponent does not cancel
the stroke counts and the balls in play, it must be played as it lies, or in this case it would behold. Is it? Would it be a good thing to say? The only time that could be a penalty for playing in the wrong order would be if you do it deliberately to advantage one of the players. So I've had this conversation before that if you and I are playing a match and I run a par 3 and my T shot goes way left and I'm no guarantee to find it
at all. So after you play, I play a provisional ball, you know, that goes 1 centimeter next to the hole and you're on the green, but not 1 centimeter. And I run up to the green and I tap it in and you go. You played out of order. You played out of turn. No, yeah, yeah. But you can cancel it if you want. But it's now my ball in play, right? Because I've played at a spot closer to the hole than when the original was. Have I done that to take advantage of that situation? Probably. But the the rules allow that,
don't they? Sure. So is that different to what you've just asked? Yes, because in that situation it was taking advantage for his own good as opposed to playing out of order deliberately as an agreement between the two to advantage one of them. So this comes back to agreeing, I mean. And, and that's why it's not going to matter because if, if
I, if you and I are playing against each other and you agree to play first to help me out, then that's your, that's disadvantaging you. And that so you should get, you know, a disadvantage unless you, you know, unless you both know that you're waving a rule of golf. That's enough of a enough of a penalty. Sure, but in stroke play, because we're playing against the field, yes, then you advantaging me is disadvantaging
everyone else in the field and therefore that's why it would be a penalty. So there is no penalty if a player plays out of turn in stroke play, except that if two or more players agree to play out of turn to give one of them an advantage, and one of them then plays out of turn, each player who made the agreement gets the general penalty. Yep, that sounds all right. So if you're having a great day and we've got a few holes to go and you're already 37 points and I'm having a shocker again and I'll go to you.
I'm inside you. You're you're 1st to go. Let me go 1st and I'll show you the line because you're having a great day. I want you to get 43 points today. I'm doing that to give you an advantage. Yeah. Yeah. And I and the other players in the competition, the rest of the field didn't get that same advantage. Yeah, that's right. Yep, spot on. So that's a clear breach, right? That was a long way of getting a long way around to get to that point, but. We have another audio question. Two in one episode. That's unbelievable.
Yeah, that's a bit ridiculous. Tony has an audio questionnaire. You got to listen into the song because this is this is very, very tricky. We might have to break this down. I have a golf lands question on a par 3 hole. A player sees her ball land outside a yellow penalty area and rolls it and then rolls into
the penalty area. Thinking that the ball rolled deep into the water, she doesn't search for it. She correctly takes back online relief after dropping but before playing she sees her ball in the grass within the penalty area. Not sure if it will be playable. She leaves the drop ball, takes a club, crosses the bridge to her original ball. She then decides to play the original ball from the penalty
area. She Shanks the ball and exits the penalty area, but then rolls back in about 10 yards to her right. She retrieves the ball and correctly drops back on the line using the reference point where it reentered the penalty area. She plays the drop ball over the green and into the bunker. She plays the ball out of the bunker, but it rolls across the green and into the penalty area.
It crosses at the same point where the original ball entered the penalty area. She crosses the bridge again and since the ball she dropped earlier is in the same spot where she was about to drop, she plays the previously dropped ball onto the green and won putts. What is her score? Thank you. Look, to be honest, because we're recording this Sydney live, you know, not going back and stuff like that.
This is going to be super tricky, so the audience might have to help us out. But OK, one tee shot, we're happy with that. I'm with you so far. And it's guaranteed to be in the yellow penalty area. So we have KVC. So they took a correct drop back on the line from the yellow penalty area. So we're on 2 so far and then seen a ball and it's the
original ball, it's in the grass and they think that they might be able to play it. That is now wrong ball, correct? Absolutely correct. OK, so wrong ball, let's say the stroke play. Otherwise the the the questions all over then. Yeah, wrong ball plays that into the same penalty area. By shanking, it takes a drop from that penalty area, which means that the the dropped ball
that for the first time the original ball went into the penalty area from the yellow penalty area from the tea shop is now out of play because this was a correct drop. A correct drop. No, it's a, it's a, it's, how do I say this? It's a correct drop, but it's
dropping in a wrong place. So it's not, you're not dropping the ball for the wrong ball, you're dropping the ball for the ball that's actually in play. That was the originally or the this originally dropped ball? Clearly that's not their intent, but that's what you're saying. No, but that's that's what I'm saying. Well, that's a good point. Doesn't intent come into this? Possibly, but let's let's go
through. So then and because they've dropped it back on the line, back behind the bunk, the penalty area, it's just basically it's just sideways. So it's not going to be a serious breach. So they've taken a drop, another drop in the wrong place. So you're going to have to add 1 for the penalty drop because it's a 17.1 situation and then they've played for the wrong place. So that's going to be two shot penalty. Agreeing with this so far.
Not completely, but I would like you to continue, please. And then I'll just. OK, yeah, because this is my version of it. Of course, of course. Then then they've played a shot and they've hit in a bunker, then they've played out of the bunker and it's gone back into that same penalty area. Yeah. OK, so taking shot and then back in the penalty and then they should have taken a drop there, but they didn't drop their ball. And we had this question on the podcast few episodes ago because
that ball that they now played is actually a wrong ball because they took it out of play by dropping that second dropped ball. So they've hit that one on the green. I mean, they could have picked it up and dropped it and it would have put it into play and being the correct ball, even though there would have been millions of shots anyway. But I see that as a wrong ball because it was taken out of play and then they headed on the
green. So that wrong? Well, that doesn't matter because they haven't, they've said headed on the green and one padded. Well, they haven't finished the whole because I think that that's the wrong ball. What's your version? Can you remember? Do you need any other facts? No, why? All I'm going to say is, and I understand your line of thinking there, all I'm going to say is there would be people who listen to this scenario and say it's a lot simpler than that. Because what they'll say as soon as I made a stroke at that wrong ball, which was their original
ball that was taken out of play, as soon as I made a stroke at that wrong ball, it incurred the general penalty. The stroke didn't count and it must be corrected. And what some will say is that must correct the in stroke play the play against the general penalty and must correct the mistake by continuing play with the original ball by playing as it as it lies or taking relief under the rules, the stroke made with that wrong ball and any more strokes before the mistake is corrected, including strokes made any additional penalty
strokes solely from playing that ball do not count. And then we go to that clarification. 6.3 C 1/1 When the strokes made at a particular ball do not count in the player's score, any penalty strokes that the player gets while playing that ball do not count unless the player gets a penalty. That could also apply to their ball in play and it provides some examples of that. So I think I understand what you're saying. 14.4 kicks in by saying we've dropped another ball here with intent balls in play. I think some will look at that.
6.3 C and go wrong ball. General penalty stroke doesn't count and whatever you do after that really doesn't matter until you go back and fix the mistake and correct it and play the what is your ball in play. So you're saying 1/2 for the drop, 3/4 for the general, then they finally got back to hitting the hitting this that's five and then six for the one part.
So you think 6 whereas I'm. Not saying I think that, I'm saying no, no, no. I'm saying there would definitely be a lot of people who present that because they they look at the wrong ball as in everything stops and you've got to go back and correct that and and fix it. It's like playing out of order in foursomes. You play out of order. Nothing else matters after that. You've got to go and correct that. See, and and I can see what you're saying and you're saying on behalf of other people, OK, what is actually your, what is
actually your answer? Are you going with that or you're going with what I'm thinking? I understand why you're thinking that, but I'm tempted to lean towards the more simplistic. You've hit a wrong ball. Whatever you do after that really didn't matter unless you ask for advice that's going to count regardless of what ball you end up playing. But you know, I tended tempted to leaning towards wrong ball. Correct it. Go back and play the ball you dropped. OK, this is good. We're actually finally
disagreeing on something. This will be the highest rated podcast of the year. No, that'll be Fraser actually. Phrases were the end of last year anyway, so when see what trips me up here. I mean, if it's as simple as you say, that's fine because when he took the second drop, which was a drop for a wrong bullhead, into a penalty area, I can see
that you're saying that. Well, that drop was never allowed because it was the intent was with dropping from the penalty area for a wrong ball. Continuing play. Was that wrong ball? Was never in the ball, but I'm saying that he when he drops another ball with the intent to put that ball into play, he's actually taking a drop for the ball that's actually in play. I know, I know. That's what you're saying, So 14.4 is very clear and I. Can't see how 6.3 gets allows
you to get away with that I know it's a everyone says oh the world stops you know you can fix your mistake blah blah blah, but I yeah, I didn't someone tell me that's fine but I disagree with that. I think if you are taking a drop where you've you've. That while taking that drop, you've put that new ball into play and obviously it was in the wrong place. So Tony, I think Tony might
already know the answer to this, but if I'm looking at it not thinking that's, I can't see how 63.3 can have that overarching, you know? No, I understand. Be all and end all. And let you get away with all of that. Yeah, that's right. You know, I, I just maybe it is that simple, but I can't see why why it should be that simple. And so and I think the the
significant difference and cause of confusion is the fact that a ball has been dropped and dropped again. That's the issue, because 14.4 says that's in play. Yeah, yeah, that, that's right. That's right. And so if there was no dropping and it was just continuing to hit the wrong ball 17 times, it'll be a simple. Spot on, spot on, spot on. So, I mean, we had this conversation about, you know, those two kids and they go, oh, we hit the wrong ball and we just swapped our balls on the
green. Yeah, yeah. And we're of the opinion, well now you've put with the intent to put a new ball into play and you haven't. You've corrected your mistake, but it was a serious breach. Wrong place, serious breach. Yeah, that's right. I think Rune sent that question in. Because you should have gone back to where you where the wrong balls were hit from. Spot, spot on. So I'm saying that he's tried to correct playing the wrong ball by putting another ball in to play by dropping it somewhere where he shouldn't have dropped it. Meaning the original, the second original.
I guess you'd call it the original drop ball now becomes the ball out of play and because of that it's a wrong ball and the player has not finished the hole, whereas you're saying the player has finished the hole with a six. Well, we know. Well we hope that one of our roughly 5000 listeners, at least one of those will give us their thoughts. Well, I'd hope scenario. 50% of them say agree with me and 50% of them agree with what you are saying. I was having more 5149 but.
And, and I know you like sitting on the fence, so you're saying that you're not saying this, you're just saying that that's what other people would be. Saying I think I would right now having heard that for the first time, I think I'd like to listen to it again and start writing some notes to sort of come to A to follow your line of thinking of, OK, well that's been put with intent, that's the wrong place, there's another general penalty that stroke counts, etcetera, etcetera.
I did have the I had heard. I hadn't formulated an answer before, but I had heard it a couple of times and I did start writing down my answer while I was listening to it then and. If you have my e-mail address, would you mind sending it to me? And I didn't even I well, I have to write it. I might actually. I mean, there you go. That's that is the golf rules question of the week 1:30 So we don't even have to do the the The funny thing about it is I've already answered it for you. Or have I?
So I've given an answer too. Yeah, Stuart's already given an answer. So you've got an answer. You either agree with us, or you might have another one. You might think, Nah, you're both. Wrong. So did you just come up with a number? Which is completely. You end up with a score for that hole. Did you end up with a score? For me it was no score because he he played a wrong ball and then putted that in the hole. So he still. Needs to be corrected. Yes, he still needs to go and correct his mistake, whereas you're saying he finished with a six.
So I will write that in the show notes as the golf rules question of the week 130 and everyone can come at us with whether we're right, wrong or whatever. I assuming this is the last episode for the year, that is a very good question to end on. Yeah, I would hate that. 6.3 should be so overarching. I I guess, you know, I can agree that it would make it a lot simpler if once you hit a wrong ball, you know, the world stops
and you can don't worry about any other penalty that you get and just make sure you don't tee off and you've got to fix your mistake. I guess that does make it a lot simpler, but at the same time I don't like the fact that 6.3 would be that overarching. Sure, yeah. And on that note, since that is our GRQO TW130, which was semi answered or maybe not have everyone have a Merry Merry Christmas. I hope you've enjoyed listening
to the podcast and the podcast this year from Co host Blakey. Have a Merry Christmas and a happy New Year and we shall see you in 2025. Thank you also goes a massive thank you also goes to Stuart who puts a lot of effort in behind the scenes, especially for the drop zone. So thank you very much, Stuart, for all you do for golf balls,
questions, drop zone and podcast. Thanks, Blake. I think that's all I do is behind the scenes is right The Drop Zone newsletter. Yes, well, you and in the last drop zone last week, you actually made mention of the fact that you're the only person that does anything. No, I didn't know. I said it's one person. It was up to their imagination to try to draw some conclusion from that. I've just blown it wide open. I'll tell you this.
Thing is, although I don't do a great job, the Golfer's Question podcast is a lot harder to put together than the drop zone. I've done both and the drop, the podcast outweighs the drop zone. OK. Although you put together last, well, 90% of it put together last one with John, which was great, but I still have to it. Was actually pretty. It was pretty easy I thought. Yeah, I knew you'd say that.
I still have to add the extra bits, you know, in Premiere Pro or wherever I do it all our. Sponsors. Yeah, well, you never, you never know, 2025 might be the year of commercial success for the Golf Balls Questions podcast. Get some sponsorship from the PGA of Australia. You know we should get from thepga.org. Are you? Noitsjust.org. Oh, the American ones. uga.com. Oh, OK.
Oh, maybe I have. No, it's just.org. I think. Oh, I better look that up on air. We're just delaying the inevitable. We're finishing the wrapping this up. noitis.org dot AU. You're right. So, yeah, thank you everyone for listening in. You make you make it all worthwhile, especially with these Clubland stories. We enjoy them, you know, when you, when you try and answer them as well, We enjoy that too. It takes away our job, but you know, we, we enjoy that just as
much. So just emails, audio, we're loving these audio questions. Send them through. And yeah, we'll see you in 2025. Thank you.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...