Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

CLUBLAND STORIES For The Ages - THE GRQ PODCAST EP81

Mar 1, 20231 hrAudio

CLUBLAND STORIES For The Ages - THE GRQ PODCAST EP81 GRQOTW for 80 - Andy was permitted under Rule 18.3c(2) Exception to continue play with his provisional ball. Clubland Story #1 - Ball stuck in flagstick Clubland Story #2 - Marking ball with line drawn in the sand Clubland Story #3 - Protective fences and how to take relief from them Clubland Story #4 - Picking up a ball to take a preferred lie, done in error as they weren't in the required grass cut to fairway height. Clubland Story #5 - Forgetting it was stroke play, and then hit the ball away in disgust because they thought they couldn't score anymore points. Clubland Story #6 - Opponent talking about the ball in play like they owned it, but then informing the referee that they didn't after asking a tonne of questions. Clubland Story #7 - Player blatantly disregards 'known or virtual certainty'and 'ball in play' records a par, then has no regard for letting the Committee know. GRQOTW #81 - In which of the following is the player not required to drop their ball or another ball again? When the player drops a ball in the right way in the relief area such that it lands in the general area and then rolls: A. onto and comes to rest on a putting green when relief was properly taken under Rule 17.1 (Penalty Area) for a ball last crossing the edge of a red penalty area near the putting green. B. into and comes to rest in a portion of the relief area that is in a bunker. C. to and comes to rest in a position where there is interference for the player's stance by the cart path from which relief was initially taken under Rule 16.1b (Abnormal Course Conditions, Relief for Ball in General Area). D. when taking relief under Rule 16.3b (Embedded Ball), the player's ball rolls into a position where their stance is on the location where the ball was embedded.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Episode 81 of the golf rules questions. Podcast has a lot of clubland stories. Including a player that has no idea about known or virtual certainty from a penalty area. Neither do they understand the wrong ball or born play situation? We have a ball stuck in a flagstick and what you do there and we start off our section of myths that will follow up an episode 82, where a player had already started player. One hole found their ball from a previous hole that they had lost

and continue play of that hole which is a clear breach of the rules. So listen in to your federal rules are go podcast, the golf rules questions podcast. Now, goal is a test of character before it is a test of skill and playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Hey everyone. Bringing you the grq podcast. I am Blakey. This is episode 81. Welcome. My co-host Stewart. How are you?

I'm well, David. How are you? Good good. Just trying to find time to do stuff. Don't have specific things to do at the moment, but always seem to be busy, which is a bit of a strange one, but we'll get cracking into So 81, he g, oq o. TW from ATF you will Stuart please. This is big p and N to the average golfer playing a match

and in the average golfer and he tends to do pushes his tee shot. Well, right and thinking, it may be lost, he plays a provisional ball which lands on The Fairway. Of course, when they arrive at where and he's ball, is expected to be a group on another tea. Who saw Andy's ball confirms that he's ball entered and came to rest in a very large area of ground under repair. Andy considers his options for taking free relief. From the GU are and decides that his next shot over.

The GUI will be incredibly difficult for, he walks back to the Fairway and continues, play of the whole with his provisional ball. Big p is not happy. BP claims. The whole immediately, as any of the average golfer has played a wrong ball. You are called in as a referee. What is your ruling? Well, this is an interesting one Stewart, and I was laughing last week because we did talk about it and I actually couldn't believe the answer when I looked it up, and we will tell it told

me and I looked it up. So obviously the player and he knows that the ball is in G, you are That's the facts of the case, given to him by a group on another tea. So they're saying it's definitely in the GUI. Okay, so we know facts to definitely in. So Andy could take a free drop. If you can't find the ball so

it's a ball not found. Could take a free drop from the estimated point, where went into the GU are from that point in your workout, your nearest point of complete relief and then you've got two Club lengths from that nearest point of complete relief. He could drop it for free there. Or. Because he's played a provisional ball and I know this is really strange because he's

played a provisional ball. He can continue with the provisional ball. And that's going to be three off the tee and now you're thinking, why would he want to do that? I don't know either. I really don't know what these do that, but as the question States and he thinks that the snapshot over the GU are will be incredibly difficult.

So we ought not to Thank you for your life and be planning a second and like, stick provisional ball and plays that what's that under Stewart, that's the exception 18.3, see to the exception today. So adding Point 3 c 2 is when the provisional ball becomes the ball in play and there's an exception listed, it's on the bottom of page. When set to 51, if the provisional ball is not become

the ball in play, in a ball is found. So now that's a seat and there's 18.3 C2 exception player may substitute another ball under the Rule, winners known obviously certain what happened to the ball so they know eventually certain the ball is gone into the grr. When one of these applies, a player May either substitute another ball as allow them to that rule. Which would be fine at the under 16.1 or treat the provisional

ball as the ball in play. And the penalty stroke in distance. It's blunt, it's blown me away. It really has. I said this to you at the time, I sort of don't agree with that rule. I don't agree with the idea of it. I think we know where his original ball is. We haven't cited it, but we know exactly where it is. Sorry, exactly. Is a poor choice of words. We know where it is. It's in a condition which are included a free relief. Why you are given the option of playing Provision. No, I don't understand. We know roughly where it is and we know as I said what

condition, it's in many ways. That's the exception to that rule and big p. In this particular case was not correct and Andy had made a wrong ball. It actually just taken adopted that option where he could actually continue play with his provision of all and plays for stroke from the Fairway. I would love to know how many referees would get that one, right? I mean common sense you're looking at it going? No. You know, Comfort since you're

going to go no, you can't go and play the provisional. If you know, it's known or virtually certain what kind of people. But there's a it's incorrect. You are allowed to proceed with the provisional. which yeah, which is if they can do it for that one and point 3 c 2, Why can't they allow it? When as an option so that you

can actually physically verbally declare your ball lost or declare your ball unplayed. Let's let's forget about that. Lets you can declare your ball unplayable. And take the provisional ball. Exactly. Very, very similar. Yeah. So you provisional sitting in the middle of the Fairway, you go left, find your original go, I'm gonna have to take an unplayable. Why can't I just go and play the provisional and assume that I've actually taken that unplayable and proceeded under stroke and distance back to the previous

Place. Played, and I've already done it, so this is gone. So Stewart finds his ball in the left hand side and Ge You Are Sorry, it has to be known or virtually certain right? That we know what's happened to the ball. When the ball has not been found, it doesn't say the player has an extra option, doesn't say extra option and Bulls. Lost it says an extra option when the ball has not been found and it is no no virtually certain that the ball was stolen.

He came to rest in abnormal course, condition removal fraction. It was deliberately deflected or stop by Any person, but even so that last one. Yeah, just because it's been deliberately deflected, which if it was another player, they get the penalty for doing that, but we know that relief, procedure would had to put that ball back into play. But again, why are you giving the option of sort of roughly nowhere with a person deliberately deflected? We can estimate where it would

have gone ahead and not being Afflicted and drop accordingly. But they're saying that and I don't want you can vote by the provisional you one. Anyway, so Stewart's ball has come to rest. They abnormal course, condition, on the left-hand side of the Fairway. We know it's in there, not at least 95%, but we can't find it. Right. And David's ball is on the right hand side. Right behind a tree. Both played provisional balls, the right beside each other, in

the Fairway, you can opt to take yours. But I cannot the Dateline just because just because yours is known to be lost or known to be not found in, GR in the do or known to be in the GUI but not found. And that's why I put in the question. The fact that another group one another to actually saw her going and could verify that At Andy, the average golfer that no no, your ball is definitely in there. We saw it fly through the air was or a land in there.

We didn't go and search for it but we know it's there for sure, I'm sorry. Yeah, that's not a virtually sir, really? Yeah, we've got a big. It's a tricky one. Okay, so we've got a big episode full of clubland stories that have been rolling in fantastically. Well. So thank you everyone for contributing, and we just want to see more and more. We are going to have You know, do I was cover-ups know multiple of the same situation, but they

always might be a slight difference, you know, if in this situation where there's a bowl not found in that g oq o TW 480, it might be a case of Andy thinks that big p is right and then he goes and plays a balls from the G. You are When he didn't want to. And so he's done the, they're the right thing, one of his options, but he ends up having a

team. Whereas, if you take them provisional in Montana 9 or an 8, remember he is average. So, you know, so there's going to be little things that different clubs are going to have are going to have slightly different procedures for how they, you know, they are clubland stories. They're not how to play by the rule of rules of golf perfectly. Lee stories. So yeah, we've got heaps Rollin in. We've had a couple of requests to, for people to remain

anonymous, totally fine. Absolutely, totally fine. We're not here to embarrass anyone. Unless you want your brother or your mother or your dad to be embarrassed. But, you know, we are here to share the Situation's examples from our own quad blend. And we can all learn from them from really happened. They're all true stories. That's, that's the the main thing. Yeah, I've got one here. So I'm going to start off player, hits her tee shot on a

par 3. The ball, gets caught in a plastic sleeve attached to the flagstick for recording the nearest of pain. What is the ruling? Stuart, what do you reckon? You know, I'm just trying to picture, just trying to picture it. So it's the flags are going up from the hole. It's something on that flag, stick not the flag with the stick itself. Yeah. Well, I would think that certainly not hold but the ball

is sitting on a movable obstruction of fakes, it gives a movable obstruction and because it's sitting on top, You'd be taking relief from that. I mean you can play as allies if you want but you could take for relief from your ball, being on a movable obstruction on the putting green, that would be my Italy offer my initial effort. Where would you drop? Place throw your ball over your back, your head. I wouldn't do the over the back of your head. Well because directly below is the reference point is

effectively going to be a whole, isn't it? So are you placing it in the hull? No. Yeah. I don't think you're getting it in the hole. No, it's not definitely not on. Hold, he got me. I just need to check. Below its thank you. I'd say be pretty close. I'd say that you place the ball on the nearest point which in this case is going to be the lip of the whole. Yeah. So it's stuck in a move obstruction removal obstructions

on the green, you place the ball on the green at the nearest point which in this case is most likely be on the lip but can't be in the hole. There's no way it's going to behold. No no it's not. Considered hold under the definition of hold. So it you're not placing it in the hole so it's an interesting one. The also to that is brings into question, the equipment rules and whether their flag stick is actually conforming having that attachment there.

You know, the definition state that the flags that concludes the flag in any other material objects attached to the pole, you know, those little balls, you see C or flag is small mini flag. You see indicating whereabouts on the green? The, the whole is, if it's down the bottom and set the front of its up the back, it's right. If it's up top, it's right at the back, they can be conforming. But obviously there are some Standards about a half, a flag is needs to be needs to look and

you can find that in the equipment standards on the RNA website. I would say this is okay that you had I'd have to see it to really you know unfortunately who knows what actually going to happen with the bald gone. The whole probably not. But we don't know. We have to see it had a miss that. It could have been 10 meters Pastor. Exactly exactly. Had it not stayed in there. It could have been stuff going into a penalty area.

Right here you go. On Stuart. Yeah, playing tennis, are we back to me? Yeah, this happened. This happened in my group last Wednesday, so, I was invited back. This is a story we've spoken about before this situation. I was invited back to my old club for a guest, a last Wednesday, run the 7th hole, a par 3, I'd put my pitching wedge on the green and two other guys in my group were right next to each other. In the greenside bunker, just

short of the green. Soon as I saw the ball is running so each other almost touching. You knew there was going to be some interference and lifting a ball for interference. So I just stood there because I wasn't far away from eyeball and I just watched this unfold, the player who was to hit first. Said your balls in my way. Do you mind if I move it out of the way? Other guy goes, no problem, go for it. And, of course, it was just the procedure that he used to lift that ball or for interference. And what he did with his tea, is

from where the ball, the interfering ball was at rest is grabbed a tea and drawn A Line in the Sand. Maybe 40 to 50 cm long wasn't wasn't perfectly straight bit of a wobble in it. And then once he's finished drawing that line about 40 to 50 cm, he's picked up the interfering ball and place it at the other end of that line. And goes we're done. And of course, this guy knows I know a little bit about the rules and he looked at me.

Now, if I wasn't here, I wouldn't have said anything to anybody. He would have just played on. But he looked at me because that's okay. I said, well, not really because you're lifting the ball for interference and we need to lift a ball. You need markets spot and you need to Market spot with an artificial object. You need to Market with something. Yeah, I mean, I I just I don't think that guy doesn't make that Criterion side. I don't disagree with you because it you know, if you read the rules that is how it all plays out.

It's just funny to me because it's one of those. That's what we were going to talk about. We're going to talk about myths with me. Yeah, I was going to bring up meets. Yeah, after next. So Look like it. You know, it has to be a marker. Has to be a ball marker. Is something artificial. We've talked about, you can use your glove, but not a hand, here's your shoe. You can use a shoe but not foot. If it doesn't have a socket, you could use a sock, you know, your your, your foots, we're in a

sock, because it's artificial which just blows my mind, but the whole drawing the mark in the ground. That's something that someone's told me, you know, it is something that you can do over the period and whether it has been cleaned up in 2019, possibly or whether it was one of those myths that you are never allowed to do it. You know, I was someone taught was giving it a session on this

and actually put the afoot right beside the ball. To use the footprint as a mark. Hmm. And I yeah, I like it. I thought it was a good idea. Can't remember. I'm trying to save myself here. I can't remember ever teaching it, but it's definitely been taught to me and I if it's not allowed to do to be done, Be

happy for that. I'd be fine. I mean it's so easy to just put a tee in the ground. I mean, 14.1 is pretty clear though if you ever know just just talk about myths and talk about how long this has been going on for this, guy's been playing golf longer than I've been alive. And of course he very aggressively said to me, well, I've done that my entire life There's a friend is right. No that's right, that's right today in 2023 see how it says, hold a club on the ground right

behind the right next to the ball and and it's obviously that's typically used on the putting green, where you only want to lift it for a second. Rotate it, give it a scrub rotate and put it back down again. You'll see that on the putting green a lot. It says hold. So it doesn't say let go but I'm assuming can I assume That the club could be used as a, as a ball marker and artificial object. When used to Mark, a spot of a ball would be lifted such as the T coin and object made to be a bull market, or another small

piece of equipment, is a, is a 9-iron, a small piece of a, small piece of equipment. Maybe not. I mean, if they, if they think that a size, 12 shoe is a small piece of equipment. Then where's we had a small, really? Where's the line, of course? Yeah. Where's the line drawn? Exactly. But you know, ii-i'd happy to promote that, that don't do that, don't Mark a line, don't

do a footprint, just do the T. Now if we were to take this a bit further failure to do that, incurs a one-stroke penalty, but it would be a one-stroke penalty for the person whose ball is being lifted, even though he didn't do lifting because the other player was acting with that person's Authority. Yeah. Yeah. The bureau Fortunate. Yeah.

All right, you got a you want to stop myth, so you want me to carry on with going to cut more clubland stories. He constantly got some called a I think maybe it could take its own podcast and then hopefully that would generate people coming in and hey, you forgot this one and you've got this one. How about this myth? Hopefully, this is a few more out there. This is a good one. Here we go. Sandy She says this is more of a clarification and actual situation. We have three protective fences

in the general area of three different. Teas. All of which can come into play and have been identified as abnormal course, conditions being a movable structures in the local rules. All good. So far I was asked if a Players Ball was up against one of the fences. Does the does the plague get full relief? Being stance intended, swing, as well as line of sight next to the Green or line of sight to the next Green, we have referred to rule 60 and as far as I can, determine the player can only

receive free relief at the nearest point for this stance and intended. Swing and not line of sight in finding the reference point nearest point of relief have one Club link from the reference point to drop their ball and all very good Sandy. You're spot-on and a rule 16. The protective fences, you got any protective fences at Gardens run student. Know what? I don't know. Not, you know if you want to hit one button, it so particular fences.

Yeah. There's no line of sight. However, have you heard of this one? He's six ever have. Is it the new the putting green 135 sorry E6 ever heard of E6? No, line of play relate or protective Feats. So, Sandy listen, to this one, go and have a check out the local rules of model, local rules. And if you think, or if the committee think it's warranted, I mean to be honest I wouldn't

think it was warranted if it was way off course. If it was, you know, a greens here and you've had actually is one of my mum and Dad's course and Geraldine the path 36-hole. Is it on the tape? And the seventh is a fence particular fence. There's that. But that's actually a particular offense from the men's tee to the ladies tee or so. The white tee to the yellow tea

and I doubt with they would never have a local rule giving you free relief for line of sight. But if you do wish to have line of sight for a protective fence, it's got a purpose statement there and then model, local rule is 6 June. Play of the specified whole number, if the protective fence on the other whole number is on the line players line of play, the player may take free relief, we're dropping a ball in and playing it from the dropping

zone. So have the created dropping zone for the players, but this relief is only out of the blower is in play. If the ball was in play near the hole than where the dropping zone is located. Faded interesting. You don't necessarily have to adopt that last one. But Or I adopted and just make sure they're dropping zone is further behind so that players not dropping closer to the hole and make it an optional tropical

Zone. Yeah, they can always play if they Obviously, the drop-down is the only option. For free relief. Yeah. The other option being you just play it as it lies, there wouldn't be a case of you know turning into a TI o or anything just created drops. And the Drop Zone might just be you know a tree you know drop within three Club lengths of a tree or something, the nearest tree, whatever it is good once

any thank you very much. What do we got next? I had another one message. I've got a quick one for you go for Most. Most commonly broken rule. What do we think it is? What's often thrown out there the most commonly broken rule for me is advice. Yeah, it's gives you advice. So I'm at this guest day last Wednesday. Now I've obviously being a

former member and held a position at this club. I played the club and this particular course a lot, but the other two in our four ball was a member, and his guests, and his guests, having played a lot. So anyway, we're all in an individual competition, stroke-play competition. What did the other member talked to his guests about all day? All day? Almost every hole. Do you think how to play the hole? Absolutely, absolutely. And not, there's a bunker,

they're just little bit more specific than that night. I couldn't nail off the top, my head, give you any specific example word for word, but you could understand the general nature of those conversations about where to hit where the play. If you hit it in there, that's where the blah blah blah just all go because he had to guess their but ruling a stroke by competent competition. I reckon the third or fourth time they said it I just said so is that advice? Ice and then sort of laughing. And I think they understood that they probably probably were

doing it and continue to do it all day as is the nature of a guest day where you have people who may not have played the course before and want them to enjoy it as much as they can. Oh yeah, quick clean story for you. This is an interesting one because it's the first week of pennant. They put pennant last week. You don't have any stories from the pendant there. I have one. Yes, from Sunday. Well, I'll just quickly. Lee say that I know of a team, this came up when I was sort of working, it fell straight.

I know the team that actually In a messenger group. Sort of kind of gave advice. And if it was the team captain, it's okay, but it didn't come from the team, captain came from someone else. and I just, I told the person who told me I told

them well that's not you know that's not allowed in the lab to pass on advice especially not you know, even if it is a medium such as a whatsoever you can you can say are the pin on the third hole, it's on 15 foot on the right Edge. But you can't say it's on 15 foot on the right age. Don't go right as the Falls away, or it's a bouncy grain, so make sure you come up short. You can't say stuff like that. So they've just got to be careful with that. Kind of thing. Is your story shareable, they're

very much look. It's just a very quick, just an interesting scenario that ever happened to me. I at the back of a par three guys, gone. Well, left it a cup half bare hands in the air and disappeared in a very thick scrub. I started timing since I got to the area, didn't see the tee shots, but I just saw them going over and searching two minutes came up and I was about to get out of my cart walk over. And guys that's 30 seconds left or 40 seconds which I like to do but I didn't get to the point because I found it but then I was called over.

So I go over and he really really thick Scrub but he's going to be standing on like Mikey's next stroke, clear case of entitled to free relief from nominal Wall cause condition. The interesting thing was was so the guy called me over and I said, what do I do? Have I said okay we'll just need you to I'm having this conversation for about a minute and he says I said well if you want we'll just consider your option. What I'll get you to do is just take a stance off the path, will identify near. As point of complete relief, will then get a club length and

etcetera etcetera. So can you just do that for me? And we'll work our way through that. All of a sudden, the guy I've been talking to you for the last. 60 seconds says, it's not my ball. It's my opponent's ball who was standing near the entire Not saying a word, it was all that this whole conversation which easily was 30 seconds. A minute was with the opponent, asking me all these questions and imagines. They were, this is really it struck me, just for a second that through me. So, what I'm going to, okay, just stand over here. We'll get a bolide entity up,

not my ball, but here's but, uh, okay, you happy with all that you want to take you out. Okay, well, you need to just, you need to stand off the path. Small identify your nearest point of complete relief. I dropped it was a bit odd. That's the point of doing all the talking. So what do you learn from that as a referee? Probably, I just immediately shoot. It was his ball, then so you as one of the players as well from that, I think that's what I'm getting to is. You know, the teams are obvious because they're all wearing team

shirts. I could tell who the two players were and I he's the one that called me over for starters, so of immediately going up and started the conversation with him. He continues the conversation. I'm we going back and forth of course, off immediately assumed incorrectly. So it was his ball as it was the was the apparel of the opponent. Sorry, the players. So it wasn't the play, wasn't the opponent's ball.

It was the Players Ball, right? So you were talking to the opponent. Correct. Who was asking me questions? It was asking, you questions was the opponent. The older of the two. Was the player a young person. I reckon the person who was about to get in relief, was maybe a tad older was no older than me and said he was that old, but maybe if a little bit older but he was actually standing closer to me than the opponent was but I wasn't even facing him.

I was facing the opponent who was engaging me in this conversation? Asking me all these questions. Even we even talked about trampled grass. I mean, it was really thick bushes and there was a lot of trampling down, which I believe was, as a result of the Fear search. But anyway, just send you a new one for me. That realize that's not my ball. It's a similar. Yeah, it's a similar thing. You know, when you're on tour, you get to know the players, right? But if you first ornament or,

you know, you a lot of amateur tournaments where there's players, you don't know, one of the first questions that they ask you for a relief. Is he even look at the clubs or you say? Are you right-handed or left-handed? And then, you know, another or before, but before that the very first question should ask for four seconds? Whose ball? Is this? Yeah, it's it's a fun one and I think I'll do that. Just based on that experience.

And all this is experience and I think I'll do that as obvious as I thought it was. Yeah, it's not about money on Whose bullet was but it wasn't his ball through you. I don't think that's happened to me yet. I think I've had the left hand right one, but Ryan one, but I don't think I've had the, that's not my book, right? I have another one here from stat. What you want? I want some help with the ruling. Our club currently has a

preferred lie. Temporary local rule to do to extremely dry conditions. Yeah there's a few clubs like that. We're all applies to general area cap to feel eye height or less. It's really okay to feel a hot or less. So basically the away on some holes is difficult to decipher between Pol first cut of rough. But if you look closely, you can tell I should be saying this clever Legion Waldorf. AV come to understand a second bite at the end of this one.

Does it say, oh, by the way? Don't we don't mention any names. No, it didn't. When it was brought to his attention, he agreed and replaces replaced his ball on its original spot. He was not happy with it was then that he had incurred a one-stroke penalty under the bought wrist. Move rule his argument was that it was an honest mistake and

it's hard to tell between Theo and rough. They applied the one-stroke penalty and they just want to know if that's fair. I mean, press the new to apply the one-stroke penalty. This is really a nine point four billion or whatever it is. It's statler's, he's got this right on, the money are great work. Yep, one-stroke penalty, 9.4 causes board move. But what do you do in this situation? What pets do it? How would you do this? Because you think I was gonna say live golf. There are there are several exceptions. 29.4.

I think it's four or five exceptions like applying a rule and a few others, or seeing it that you have interference from an abnormal course, condition, etc. Etc. I don't like honest mistakes. You know, I'm very black and white and I think he has clearly lifted his ball when he wasn't allowed to, and this happened to a good friend of mine who, you know, as well as I do, who he was preferred lies in general. Area, he was in the penalty area, but it was just off the edge of the Fairway and so he's

gone. And we've been so used to marking lifting cleaning putting it back, and it just so happened. It was in the penalty area and he goes, I hang on a second. I don't think I should have looked at that. And, of course, he gave himself a one-stroke penalty, honest mistake. He just didn't even think about the fact that he was behind red stakes, honest mistake. But it's a one-stroke penalty. You've lifted your ball in play. Did you do it to apply rule? Well, I could go into the specific word being yes. But you shouldn't have been applying that rule.

Yeah so you know the guy that just one on the European tour Marcel sing Hated this. So four years ago, I recognize even referring the tournament. They have preferred lies on one day or maybe the week before. And then he started out in the Thursday morning, preferred his lyre, for the first seven holes called us in. And we said, well every time

you've moved your ball played from a play from the wrong place. That's two shots. Wow. So I think it it was either four holes or seven holes in. So he's either had an eight, he's added eight shots to his front nine or 14 shots, something like that, didn't make the cut as you can imagine. But yeah, it's like, you know, I see what you're saying. Honest mistake, it's still a mistake so you have to pay the price doesn't matter for it's honestly not one shot penalty is

its fear. It's definitely fear what he should have done. Dunn was said to his marker. Exactly. That's right. Go ahead. Ask the question. Hey, do you think that this is the Fairway? Yeah. Hey guys. What do you reckon? And if they all get it wrong, In, that's an honest mistake. And you're most likely going to get away with that. And unless some Hawk is seeing you from the clubhouse and manages to catch a group for

your hand in the scorecard. But you just ask and it's the same with the edge of the green, you know, as my ball on the greens and all the green just asking You know basically Club playing you're the only three or four or two around a neural. Most of your decisions are going to be right if it's a judgment, call the 5 x, 5 exceptions, 9.4 is when the player is allowed to live, if it will move the ball to his accidental movement in, trying to find or identifiable accidental movement on the

putting green number four is accidental movement anywhere except on the putting green while applying a rule. And number five is the ball moves after coming to rest against play. Our or equipment. So maybe the number four is accidental when applying a rule but again I don't think that person was entitled to apply any rule because they weren't on the closely mine. Well he wasn't told to apply 16.4 to see where the ball was, in the field way. Yeah, but Yeah, I once

established whether it was or wasn't then you can proceed and the preferred lie or you aren't allowed to proceed under their life. So if preferred life so good one thank you very much for seeing in stable and it won't shock the only differently. Yeah you got another one. I've got one more. No more yours. Oh we got a couple here now. This is a person that doesn't want to be identified. Totally fine. We'll just call him X. Publius stories have got first

story stroke ground wire. One not having a good hole. Has a downhill putt for his sixth hole. So downhill putt for six stroke. They were not having a good hole in a downhill putt for his sixth. The ball rolls past the whole thinking. It was a Stanford around, he walks know where this is going, you know, through their hord's having run out of shots as he did this, his playing Partners called out saying, it was a

stroke around. He hit again in disgust, but boars now about 10 meters from the whole, how should he proceeded No ice water. Well so he's planning to sixth and missed the ball with his sixth, he's then I would question whether he was whether he's actually made a stroke because I don't think he's made a stroke. I don't think he's made a stroke for the first one as he did this

his playing Partners called out saying, it was a stroke around, he hit it again in disgust. Yeah again that's not making a stroke. So I think what he's done is we're going to go to 11 and he's deliberately deflected. His wallet. I was just about to ask because he said the ball rolls past the whole thinking. It was a stupid man, he won around, he walks Towards his bow and taxes ball away, having run out of shots. I don't, I can't work out. Had to come to rest or not, whether it's come to rest. If it has come to rest, he just

needs to replace it on that spot and take a One-Shot Humvee. And what he did afterwards doesn't count because you hit it again. Remember, I started the non doesn't matter on Strokes, don't care if it is in, if it is moving, born Motion in, 11.1 on the putting green, then we're to

deliberately 11.2 on the pattern. Green The player may play The Stroke by playing his original Ball, but he gets that General penalty. So he's made a part. You cancel the stroke. That's what replay the stroke means, right.

Yeah. Yep, that's true. Can any other as don't care? Replay The Stroke by playing the original or another ball from the spot, but he gets to shot. So it was, it was there for five players, sixth nyorori places the ball. Six has been canceled. So I was hasn't happened yet. Above the hole playing his eighth shot. So he's lying 567, it will be playing as a shot. Yeah, that's right. Yeah. They the actions at the club

took the player one replaces ball above the hole and two parted reporting in 94 that hole. Yeah. So it must have been Still In Motion. Sounds pretty good to me. Thank you, X. Now X is also give me another one. Stay with the ground, this time glad to plays it. Tee shot on the 15th. Which I'm not going to say the time but it's more than a part 3 slight dogleg, right? There is a large made County

area along the right-hand side of the field. Our tall trees are thick, rough, surround the penalty area and like the sound of this being a big header, the player tries to take a direct line over the penalty area. The bald bull goes along the right side but no one is sure where it finished. Fire due to does not play a provisional ball, he cannot find his ball and decides to drop all adjacent to the Penalty area. This ball goes just off the back of the green, he walks on, and then finds his original ball,

past the penalty area. He is not sure what to do, so plays this ball, don't know the ball finishes about 3 meters from the holy, picks up the ball, played from the penalty, drop in finishes, the whole with the original ball. And reports of four and that whole or how should he was seeded when and what is this going? Well, Player 2 reported a for that whole to my knowledge. They did not follow up with me. Oh, this is horrible.

Okay, so that I didn't have No no, virtual certainty. That the ball was in the penalty area. As far as we know from the facts given in the in the story they didn't have, but then they've gone and dropped a ball and

played it. So, I can understand the dropping the ball and then you can fix that if you don't have that, no, no. Virtual certainty for penalty area relief. But he didn't, he played it? so then he's played under stroke and distance from a wrong place.

And it's a serious breach. Hey, happy with that. Yeah, well, I'm surprised that At Club level. That I would think a lot of golfers would know the soon as you put another ball into play, which this play did adjacent to the Penalty area, believing it may have been in the penalty area to put a ball in play, that's enough. But then they've actually then played that ball to then. Find your original Ballinger are forget about all that. Don't worry about. Sorry, about all that.

Here it is. Here, you would think there's probably a chance even if that was Bull, okay? It's probably Beyond three minutes. Anyway, they will clearly clearly the search time would have started because they're probably gone down to have a bit of a look about. Hey, is it anywhere obvious within the penalty area? Is it just beyond. I think the search time, it's pretty sure would have started. And, of course, that's search time doesn't end when you put a ball into play and keep going. That's search, time keeps going. So you think the three minutes is probably up?

Anyway, when they found the original ball, I can't believe someone I would have gone. Well, that's a bonus, isn't it? He's my original ball here. Forget about everything that just happened. What do you reckon guys? And everyone's gone? Yeah, you know, good, good luck. Well done. I'm surprised that no one said haven't already put another ball into play. I mean this is as blatant. I love taking my stupidity. I don't know as I can. You just can't do any of what he's done. Going off the facts that we've

been given. You can't do anything but it's close them. If it played the wrong place in, they've given that one up and play from a player roll roll. So, you know, forget that it's a serious breach from the Peoria area because your fault these four strokes are ready, okay? Not quite a wrong place in our own ball and the stroke and distance peony, right? Because you because you've all hasn't been found. Well they have to proceed under a A role in the only way to proceed. Under a rule is the stroke and distance Pim.

Hmm. So this 5 plus the shoulder 40 and it was supposed to go back and play from the T again. I mean that's it's almost if it decides to stay with a grin so it's just a white right? But it is but it is it's a wide but it's also could you cheat anymore here? How about how about have one month off or will give you a

one-month disciplinary? Suspect suspended sentence on good behavior. That's horrible. I'm going to do tr90 level 1 course. Yeah, it's very do that. How are you learning how to not cheat 17.1 C says that if you haven't found your ball? But it's in a penalty rebut you have knowledge or virtually virtual certainty which is person didn't and you put a ball in a play. Even if the original is found before three minutes, it doesn't matter because you put that on

the ball into play. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. And which actually took me a while to understand that rule? I thought that I don't confuse people, but I thought. Yeah. If you found it within three minutes, you've clearly proceeded under rule, which didn't apply. But the rule doesn't say that you put that ball in a play. You're stuck. You can be goes, It goes back to ball and play. So let's look at the slightly differently. Say that they did have knowledge of virtual certainty and they worked out.

There is tomato point where at last Ross, they dropped within two Club lengths that's just you know Jason and so there was a lateral relief. So that now played three right there, Then abandoned that ball. Pick it up, so that's for play the wrong ball, which is 6. And then I actually have to put back their penalty area ball. And to play their seventh, which

they didn't. So and of course, they've hold out of the wrong ball, which you cannot do. Stable fitting get away with it. As you say mr. Staffing is just going to be a white but there is no way to get, you know. yeah, it's just a shocker you know where one of the other people in the group doing here, Anyway. Right. And you got anything else. Sure, that's all it is. Thank you so much for everyone.

Something similar. Player is playing the 7th hole stableford, can't find this ball so watch the whole tees off on the 8th and while walking off the tee finds, the boy lost on the 7th, his playing partner. Ben encourages him to play out. The previous hole is he is playing as he is having a good round. The player knew the lost ball rule but decided to play out the seventh anyway.

I mean, I don't even. So we found that ball so you've the whole sevens finished wipe? You've started whole eight. You hit a ball off, the tee on eight, and then you've played another ball to a different green. This is not where you were. I mean, would you consider this practice? No. Because they have an intelligent shape there.

Yeah. Attention to play. Make a stroke and to score a score on a hole. So if we just so the t. Okay, so let's say, let's say the t is here and you've hit your ball, 250 meters. The green is you just walk in off the tee and the green is to the left, I don't know. The course, I'm just having working there for the viewers and listeners.

You've got a green, so the seventh greens 30 meters to the left of the 8T. So you walk off the eighth T to go and get your ball. It's 250 meters and you see a ball beside the green and it's yours. You now play that bolt onto that green. That's a wrong ball. Yep, it's a wrong book. So you hit the wrong ball, one to the wrong green, you put it

out. That is all we're not going to penalize you for a wrong path and green because they were all wrong. Ball shots? Yeah. So you just get the two shocking Aunty. Yeah. You just get the Duke two-shot penalty. Then you go and continue the 8th hole and you have to add the two-shot penalty to your eighth hole. Is that what you think? Yeah, may have about the three minutes as well. Clearly that person is looked started the search for that ball off the 7:30.

Surely they've begun to search for that ball. I couldn't imagine a situation where they didn't begin a search, if he's gone. All I can't find it. You guys put out. You can tell me the three minutes hasn't gone. You can't tell me. We're close to five to eight minutes. Yeah, yeah, for the time, they walk to the 8th tee. You know, it's definitely, it's definitely the treatments, is definitely our Well and truly gone the whole notion of oh wow look at this. It's been 12 minutes since I hit the shot. My t-ball. Here we go. Just give me a sec behind but

even if there wasn't a Groupon it's just silly. I think it's just almost farcical to think that all actually. I'll put a pause on playing the a tile because I just need to finish incident. Find it. Laughable isn't this? It didn't add to the myths. Last week, you can start Play of another hole. Whilst playing a hole. I know some people that have done that.

They got the t's were right beside each other. Was a 16th hole in the 70s. So you play 15 down here, you walk 216, you hit t-shirt. You walk to 17 and you hit a tee shot and then you go and put out or play your sand, iron, or whatever. And then you walk off that grain to your tee shot on 17 and they believe that that will not be equally as laughable. They believed that, that was

real. That that was a thing that you can do, that was a, it's a myth myth. Number one, I'm saving exercise. Mmm, did you want to go through the rest of the mr. Day or leave for next week? Now, I think there's a good content there for another podcast. It's miss you and I quickly work together, we should start. Get in contact with you with their own myths, well feeling wrongful lot longer than you.

And I have feel free to put the myths, your myths in the clubland stories. And we're just just just stay at a club and story, just put myth. This is a myth that I didn't. I didn't know it was true or that someone else told me and I was like no, that's not right? Or even if you have a question about one that is, you know, you like are we allowed to do this? Like just that one there. It's a perfect example that you can't start another hole whilst you're playing a different and

is not allowed. Rocco. We'll get that off and then we'll get the podcast on this. Now GI Q OT W 481. You might having a go this way. Thanks. Okay, this is a multiple choice in which of the following is the player not required. Not required to drop their ball or another ball again.

When the player drops a ball in the right way in the relief area, such as it lands in the general area and then rolls, and these are the options. So when do they are they not required to drop again? So we've started by the dropped it in the right way in the relief area in the general area. And then it rolls and comes to rest, on a putting green when relief was properly taken under rule 17, .14 ball, last

crossing, the edge of a red penalty area near the green. It's option. A or option b into. So then rolls into and comes to rest and portion of the relief area and is in a bunker. option C then rolls to and comes to rest in a position where there is interference for the players stance by the cart path, from which relief was initially taken under rule 16.1 be And option D, then rolls when taking relief

under rule 16.3, be embedded ball. The players ball rolls into a position where their stances on the location where the ball was in bedded. They are really good. So, it was dropped into a relief area that was in the general area. And then a was, it rolled onto a putting green in taking relief from penalty area. B, was rolled into a bunker that

was, but we're still within the relief area. C was rolled into an area where you had interference from cart path, from which the relief was initially taken and D. Was it rolled into an area? It's still in really barrier, but you The player is now standing on the pitch, mark of the embedded ball, so which one do you not or are you not required? To drop your ball again. It is Jackie ITW 81, you'll see that it's gone up a live all

this week and now I was kidding. Actually 80 was too hard for me, so 81 for the little bit easier. Any, any final last word Stewart 81 and I all good have a great week and catch everyone again next week. I'm actually off to Thailand for the international series Thailand at Black Mountain. So we may give the podcast and this for a week and we'll see you again two weeks. Hopefully by then we'll have ten

to fifteen hundred myths. But make sure you keep reading the pot or the drop zone, drop zone is. You've been doing some great work of late last year it so keep that up. If anyone has a rules to add like the sending you're more than welcome to, just add it to the clubland stories. All on Google forms will collected all in there. That would be fantastic. So, thank you very much. Everyone for listening in and

watching and thank you. To you, Stuart.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode