Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

Here's my TWOBOB - THE GRQ PODCAST EP84

Mar 29, 202357 minAudio

GOT A CLUBLAND STORY - Submit it here https://forms.gle/Jga9wNrnwUVFUQD98.Here's my TWOBOB - THE GRQ PODCAST EP84.GRQOTW #83The opponent has until one of the players tees off on the next hole to request a ruling..Player plays under stroke-and-distance instead of playing under Rule 9.6, and incurs unnecessary one stroke penalty plus extra stroke..Another declaring ball lost situation, but thankfully one of the players knew what the correct answer was..Player forgot which ball they had hit off the tee..Do we recommend Model Local Rule E-5.Repairing pitch marks off the green..Being Disqualified from the competition after the competition results have been published..Two balls of the same make and model that can't be identified as whose is whose..Ball moved by natural forces after player removed some loose impediments.Ball came to rest in a dead rabbit..GRQOTW #84Whilst playing a stableford round at Wombat Hills, Blakey has 238m to the pin for his 2nd shot on the par 5 13th hole. Thinking he cannot get there, Blakey plays and flushes his 3 wood, with his ball landing just off the green and rolling to within 30cms of the hole, while the group in front are putting. Blakey raises his hand to apologise. As he walks onto the green, he taps it in for an eagle 3. Pulling the ball out of the hole, Blakey realizes it is not his ball and believes he may have played a wrong ball on the fairway. He says to his marker, just me down for a wipe. As Blakey is walking to the next tee, a player in the group ahead comes back, gives Blakey back his original ball and says, "sorry mate, I marked and lifted your ball, and when we finished the hole, I mistakenly replaced my spare ball on the spot.What is Blakey's score for the hole? Does he need to do anything to correct?.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYHttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

In episode 84. We have lots of Plum land stories for you including a number one. Contributor to bulb and two longtime listeners. Also chip in both with the name. David popular name that one and there's why I go by the name. Blakey. So join myself and Stewart for the goq podcast. Goal is a test of character for it is a test of skill and playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Hey everyone.

Welcome to golf rules questions, podcast episode. 84 I am Blakey and alongside me we have Stewart podcast that fee. Hello Stuart. Good morning David how are you? I'm very good and a congratulations is in order. I believe for for you sitting through a USGA rules exam, 100 questions. Taste and getting a good score

by the sounds of it. Is that correct? Thank you. Yes. And she's the four hours. My brain was fried at the end of it but you and I met for a hot chocolate about two hours after I finish that exam and I couldn't even tell you 10 questions of the 100, which is interesting that just mentally. I just was drying to have not forgotten all the questions but yes, I did score over 90%. Thank you. So I was able to achieve the USGA expert rules certification,

which was very nice and quite a relief to get that school. That's fantastic. At least one of us is Advanced. And now so if anyone doesn't know what the USDA rules quiz or exam is all about do sit through how many days in the workshop was. It's yeah Yeah. Workshop itself is 5 days, 5 two-hour sessions. And for most Australians, it's usually really early in the

morning, certainly isn't in their virtual rule school, which was very, very good. What was that over 20 hours of video? And that's where I spent most of my time. Yeah. And then the as you mentioned the exam is for hours, 50-question closed book and then 50-question open. Look the first 50? Well, no, it's all about three or four options for multiple choices that, right?

Yeah. The hundred 100 questions. All of them are multiple-choice, all of them, have four possible answers of which, of course, only one is correct. But I'm well done on that, great achievement. And yeah, if anyone has a rose question since at the Stewart so there's an occupied carts ended up like him or talked about it. So we've had. Well, first of all we had a difficult question from last week's podcast which was the g

oq o TW 83. Do you want to go back through? What? That one wants to. Yes. Blake, Ian Stewart, applying them action. The men's final of the one bad Hills cup. During play of the 9th hole Blake, he becomes aware that Stewart played from a wrong place on the fourth hole. However, at the time Stewart thought he could take relief. What options are available to Blakey? Is it too late to request a ruling? Does the whole standards play? Can we request a ruling any time before the end of the match?

What can he do if anything? So because he found out the information for the end of that hole and it was new information to him. He can request a ruling of for any player tees off on the next hole. So he's always got until the 10th hole kill. Someone teas up in the 10th hole to make or request a ruling.

It's going to say make a claim. So that is the g oq o TW answer for 83. Now, this episode 84, we've got lots of clubland stories. Go back through. Some of them are more a situation where they answer it by themselves which is fine. And then we've got other ones that are asking us information. So let's get into them. We've got one here from Bob I was approached by flat and

marker and told that the Players Ball had been picked up by another player. They treated it as a lost ball and played accordingly and signed for that wrong score. They asked me if there was an option and I explained that when your ball is played as a wrong bull by someone else, you may substitutable under 6.3 see to it sounds like bulb. Well, I do know Bob he does know the rules very well. I assumed that lifting another Players Ball is the same as playing at the can't find in the clarification of that.

They were Supply surprised to find out about the rule. Yeah, if you move the ball Bob or something else moves, your ball, how they move it is indifferent. It's the fact that they moved it. And if it's fire shock, or they kicked it all, they picked it up. It's all the the same. It's moved. Interestingly enough Stewart.

These flyers took a penalty when they didn't actually need to because they knew that someone else had picked up their ball. So here's a situation of knowing the rules can actually help you. I'll just say two things about that. One is something not mentioned in that scenario was three minutes because if we're searching for it and we don't know where it is and we're still searching in the three minutes is now running that information about an outside influence.

Having either played it as a wrong ball or picked it up or a dog run across and taken it. That information must be known. Will be known or virtually certain that the end of the three minutes or by that in 23 minutes, you must know that information by then. So we assume in that scenario that they didn't know before. That three minutes was over that someone else. That either picked it up or played it as a wrong wall. I was just, I was just on a recent golf trip to ban Boogle last Thursday, Friday.

And it was, it was amazing. It was a fantastic and I highly recommend it to anyone that can make it. Down to bun burgle to get themselves down there, and give it a shot. We got perfect weather so that probably made a big difference. It can be pretty Willie where the diet down there. Sideways rain 5060 our kilometers an hour, wind, it can be pretty tricky, but we had

perfect weather hardly any wind on that Friday. And an interesting situation happened on the 12th hole loss Farm. There you have played a couple of times Stewart. So you'll know this whole their players, it didn't happen to us. What happened to us for two groups behind us, why? It's their ball straight down the middle of the Fairway. Get down there and they cannot find the bull. And they're all looking around, what's happened, what's happened? And I'm serious. I mean that that fear way is pretty wide. I mean it's as wide as a as a

cricket field so it's very hard to lose a ball. He hit the other middle of the Fairway and they couldn't find it. and so they said, I'll They didn't know. So they just said, oh, we just Place one down and you know, someone must have stolen it is is their assumption. They didn't have known a virtual certainty for that at all. And then they played the whole out, got to the Grain and the players behind them. He down the Fairway and they saw

this Crow. Take one of the balls from the Fairway. So they didn't know about their ball and what was missing. But when they got to the green, they look back and they could see this Crow have stolen a ball from behind. So they assume that that's most of what must have happened since then now, That's why they asking me for the official ruling and I'm finding it very hard to give this rolling. Knowing that it was indeed a

crow and if you hit your ball down the middle of the Fairway and you can't find it's not soft enough for it to plug. Yeah, and it's a very tough thing to say, oh, well actually that's a lost ball when you have to go back for Striking Distance, I mean, they weren't going to do that. And then the guys behind they didn't do that either. They just assume that someone must have taken it. And the guys, on the green didn't tell the group behind our you bull was stolen by a crone, they just left them to their own devices. But that last group, just assume

that it must have been stolen by someone or something. And just took the free place. Now, we were all playing a little competition. It was, it was a tough thing to say. I mean, the results are finalized after I found out about this. So too bad, but yeah, it would have been a tough thing to say. Oh, well, you've lost your ball. Even though it was hit straight down the middle of the Fairway. Was that a yellow title? It and it was a six and three. I'm very funny because I believe

the crows and this might sound made-up actually prefer yellow Titleist balls because it was, it was a story when I was there two years ago that they, and then someone's got a bucket in their backyard, somewhere around in that area. With of crows, are obviously trying to drop off the golf balls, but I think that's it's made up. But apparently, it was a yellow Titleist. We brought by these birds. But anyway, it could have been they, I think they, maybe they were getting about hard hard up

and they need some white ones. So, yeah, that was the point. I was going to make that Key Club Lane was the three minutes is the key is knowing that information by the time that expires, but the other one, of course, is we say it, every podcast 20.1 C3. And we should really be plugging, the es members Club Gophers should be using this all the time. This you know, proceed with two balls and stroke play sorted out later and there's no possible chance of disqualification. What about match points you've

made mistakes on both well? Now you know let's play is a different kettle of fish, but you only got to convince them. You've only got to get one over here partner. Then it's right. It's right for 100 size. Pull the wool over his eyes. Yeah. I mean It's like those lies ahead. They knew that someone stole their ball and they treat as a loss bullets to the tough very much.

So, but they have it. I mean, the only thing they've done wrong there is taking a penalty that they didn't actually need right. I've got one here from another. Pablo story from David, this should be much simpler than others. You have received a group of four men. Or mean by a plays. Second shot from a not-so-nice lie, the ball spins and hits a tree and no one sees where it goes. The four players look at all directions for about one minute.

Bye. Abby says we haven't got a clue where it went but a replies. Okay I will go back and hit another one where I walked about 20 meters back towards where head is last shot from only about 2 minutes. Has passed then player sees calls out player C calls out. I have found it over here. Fire a turns around goes to was born continues to play. Why Abby questions the right to play the ball? Arguing that when player said play a said he would go back and hit another one.

And by starting to walk back there, the big clear, the ball lost. His and should have proceeded under stroke and distance feeling. What actions were taken to resolve this situation played D. Put the case that the original was found within the three minutes and so Remain the ball in play which play Abby. And the others accepted and they lived happily ever after so. Okay. Luckily so player a turnaround

did the right thing player D who I think might be David has correctly identified that it was yeah. Ruled that was found within three minutes. They had it, they can't declare a ball lost and so the correct process was achieved in the end. Can I take that a step further? So we're all pretty happy. That was a pretty easy situation and that was all done correctly, but if if the player play, I

said, look, I'll just play a provisional, we weren't happy with the or Gunplay another, but I'll go and play a provisional went back and then it was found even the intention to apply. Is on enough to make that other ball out of play, even if you play a provisional ball and then your ball is found within three minutes, you're still. Okay. So that's obviously where there was a bit of confusion from Playa be. Yeah, so if player a says, okay, I'll go back and hit another one.

Would you believe that they are having a provisional or just hitting the hitting another ball under Striking Distance? If yeah, so if they had said, I'm just going to go hit another one, I'm not happy with that as I don't Point through, that's not enough for me. Okay. So hey guy, how about guys guys? You keep searching and I'll go back and just I'll just play another one is a little bit closer to an intent of you, keep searching because if you find

it, within three minutes that's going to still be my ball, because this is going to be a provisional a little bit closer. Now, I'm not still over the line, but Lisa is a Of intent there. Not enough of that. Right? So I'll go back and hit another one just in case as what they have to do. That's much better. Just in case is fine. Okay, that's all we need. Just in case or I'm going to proceed under rule 18.3 my favorite, okay? Yeah next I'm just reading these off the cuff.

So if there's any spelling mistakes or I'm surprised and you just have to go with it to Bob. To Bobby has been playing a red ball all day, and he and his mate tee off on the 18th hole. It's been hot and humid and unsurprisingly. To Bob hits his tee shot into the trees. His mate finds a white ball with

a shamrock marking on it and tells to bulb to Bob thinks it's odd that there is another ball out in the course. With the Shamrock marking he often uses but says that his ball was a Red Bull. So his mate picks it up and they continue looking for two bulbs bull a minute later within the three-minute limit tube of ask for. Look at the ball, his mate picked up and realize that hit actually teed off. With that white full with the Shamrock. And not the red ball.

What actions were taken To resolve the situation to bulb played his white ball with the Shamrock markings, from where his mate found it without penalty. Stuart, what do you think of that? Okay, we replayed it from but not so much fear without penalty. I'm a I'm in the grants that should have been a penalty of yeah. One stroke. Because although so so does make

pictures up, picks it up. So it's been moved under 9.6. But was it was it done with two Bob's authority to pick the ball up? Yeah, I think you can throw that from 9.6 back under 9.4 and acting with authority. It's pretty clear. How you've got this ball here. And it's almost to Bob saying, that's not my ball. It's almost a clearance approval, pick that one up mate. That's not mine. To of had the option to identify

that it was his ball. Well, it's not my ball. so you can go hit it but he didn't say can go and Hey, that's my ball in play. You can move it. He just says that he doesn't say that it's his ball. ASA. Is it on normally playing? I've been playing a Red Bull so it can't be mine. Yeah, but it also sees but it was his calling play. Yeah. It's just a matter of whether that it's just the one-stroke penalty, or not only climate think? Yes.

Because I think it's the clear and solve. No, that's not mine. That's enough to say, do whatever you want with it. It's on my ball. Yeah, but that doesn't mean he said, hey, pick that one up, dude? No, not directly. Definitely. Not I'm going to say I'm going to actually I'm gonna go with no penalty. Okay. So it's a 9.6 put exactly like I said, pick it up, you can have that one, pick it up.

Right. So that's a one-shoulder. I reckon he almost didn't directly. Yeah, but I don't think indirectly is enough. No, okay. I think he You're the one that just passed. 90% on your exam? What do you? What do you say? You're going to give me one shoulder. I can see the case for both. I really can't. Yeah I mean I if we don't know exactly the conversation, but I think that if the in to Bob

because if there was just a random ball And I've got a 6 and 3 out of here. Oh, that's not my ball. Yeah, then that saying that's not my ball doesn't say. Doesn't mean pick it up. You know, because it could be someone from another field way. But if you said, oh, that's not my ball, you can have that one. That sounds more like that sounds more. Like you can have that one, you

can pick it up and then your foot and then you find out that it is your ball because, you know why? You told that person to pick it up, 9.4. It's a, it's a funny on that one. It's a good one. Is a good. Yeah. So I'm going to say that. That was right without penalty, but you know, I can see what your argument for. So I can see. Definitely both sides would leave that to the committee and we know the committee's always right even when they're wrong. Yeah, that's right. And this see, some of these are

tougher than the carried away again JV. Here we go. Appreciate your views on the application of model or model rule. E5, should it be used in board events? Do you use model? Local rule 35. For a gardeners run. No definitely not. And I don't agree with it. These are agree with it for one particular type of play. But no, it's not easy. Do you use it for any type of player guns? Nothing nothing. I mean, you you're not on the

committee or the captain so it's you're just a member. So it's just it's just an opinion based but I at Spring Valley, they had it and then they got rich, they had it just for board events and then they got rid of it. And so we don't have it at all at wombat Hills, they do have it but they don't have board events. It's just mainly General play and handicapping. It is allowed like motor model. Local rule E5 is allowed under

the handicap system to be used. What it is is basically stroke. And distance is the only option when you lose your ball or you're headed out of bounds. But A committee can adult model, local rule, E5, which means if you work out the spot where it went out of bounds or you work out the spot where you lost it, you can go equidistant into the into the edge of the Fairway,

plus two Club lengths equidistant to the nearest. Are also known as closely known ice two Club lengths. and then you can drop anywhere back from that spot in this sort of tangent. Arc from the brain. So you could actually drop into feel, you could drop in the rough you know, depending on what you want and it's just so

from my mind, I don't like it that much because there's just so much vague. Miss as my word to it. So you know, suddenly the amateur golfer hits their tee shot that we haven't found 270 meters and you thinking, maybe 270 down when down downhill in summer, you know, there's no way

you flew. It 270 was a duck hook, but suddenly they're going. Yeah, must be around here. Not sure about that. Wombat Hills adopted it, basically, because a lot of our members are beginner members and they play a lot of their golf at public courses. So public courses, you've got people behind you and because they're beginning members, they sort of hit it off the tee, don't really look at it and they go up and they go.

Oh, where's my ball? So I go we're not going to go back and take stroke and distance when there's groups behind them. So just drop a ball. Take your two-shot penalty and carry on but I would I mean it's never going to be adopted in a tour competition and never going to be a doctor then any kind of elite competition. And Shouldn't be adopted than board event either. It's just because in my mind, it is so vague. I mean this, this is a local rule that was mainly designed in

the US. And a lot of the competition's, you know, that cultural difference. A lot of the competitions in the US are just mainly between the group themselves. A group of four or group, of three, whatever it is. So if that everyone and that for is happy with where they are dropping, then that's okay, but when you put in Australia, a lot of our competitions are over the whole day with fields of 100 to 300.

Sin, if all three hundred players were there looking going? Yes, we agree with where you dropped it. That would make sense. So that's not going to happen. So I'm not, yeah, I'm not a fan of it. Yeah, don't like it at all. Again, I've dumped it with one bat Hills but for the plates that I've I've mentioned through quick comments, one on with you with all of that. I think it was really good for just social and corporate day. It's a long way down from

Wayside, professional late, amateur events just the other day for Speed of play. But the other thing is he tied a visional. Yeah, just had a vision of all hashtag hit a provisional. Okay. Another one that no one likes, people don't like individual because it's so embarrassing. You know, it should be. We should what's the word? We should make it. So it's a more embarrassing to lose you first ball or something and not having hit a provisional.

Yeah yeah that's never come back. We should change the walk of shame that talk. Yeah. Reminds me of barn Boogle. They have they used to have this thing called Irish drop whereas if you're headed in the rubbish are you just get to drop it straight out sideways for a One-Shot period which is against the rules. But Barn Bogle, they are not with the handicap systems that are not affiliated to golf Australia. They someone has created a slope rating and a scratch rating for them mainly just for, you know,

to a groups. When they go down there, they can go. What's my handicaps? But I have no affiliation that. I probably I should face or anything like that, so they can make up whatever rules they want. Basically. So as act or group social group going down, there you create as a committee, you create your rules, just like as a tour, you know, a professional tour. Moving amongst courses to create a hard card to create local rules.

Now, most social groups are going to agree with whatever local rules are on the back of the card. Not knowing that they are actually against the rules of golf have changed it from this Irish drop to everywhere in the rough as appeal. The area which is totally fine. I totally agree with that. I mean a the rough is really long and there's snakes in there, but be you're allowed to do that. You're allowed to make this knee-high. Rough anywhere off the Fairway you could say as a penalty area the only problem is there's no

education around it so they still the players are still taking a drop laterally out from the from the grass and that's not correct. That's point of entry. So, they just need a tidy that thing up there and my first experience. Now, when I go back to know, to say, hey guys, all the rough is penalty area, but it's point of entry. Not drop people without swords points. Yeah, Spot on. But yeah, it was it was lots of fun.

They do have stupid rules like free relief from Footprints in a bunker. A lot of the public play and they don't write bunkers, don't go in the bunker, you know, out of the fan of the hazard of going in a hazard, is your stuffed. So the fourth hole on the dunes course that has the biggest bunker I've ever seen the full told ya. That's because that bunker. Yeah, I've managed to hit over, actually, I had a great foul on that whole hit. I lost my ball, right?

I nearly a must have gone into the beach. Hit another one. It's just it's about 3 foot above the greenside bunker on the left hand side. And the pain was sort of just at the front. I couldn't aim at the pain because it was so sloping that would just rolled off the green. So I'll hit this flop shot onto the top of the sort of the mound. It's just trickle Trickle, and then got some momentum straight in the hole. Very nice. I was very, very happy with that was my only good shot for the

whole week. Man 2 V again I think two bulbs going to be a massive contributor to This Club Lanes guys and we love them for it. Forgetful Frank hits his ball, onto the green and it pitches forward a few yards towards the flag. When he gets to the green here, appears his pitch, mark and a few others, including one. That is off the green. Where someone had previously had

an embedded bull. Can forgetful Frank repair pitch, marks off the green, Stuart, what do you think of that? Pretty simple. Yes. But for you can prepare pitch marks anywhere, but the but is if it improves one of the cats you cannot and you would think a pitch mark in the ground, the most likely cat. That would improve would be your line of play. If you are off the green, but in that particular case, if you're off the green, knock yourself out, if you've got time gun repair any pitch marks, anywhere

off the green that are not on your lawn a play. It's a very good succinct, answer and agree. He's with the action or reaction that was taken at the time to Bob, says there was no penalty given to forgetful Frank as he didn't improve his lie, off the green. So spot-on. Also just adding slightly to that. There's no you can't have the

intention to improve someone else's cats, either. So, if you, if you see someone with their line of play or lot of Park, going to be affected by a pitch, mark off the green. It doesn't mean that you can go longer, how? Hey, I'll just might, I'll just prepare that for you. That would be a breach to you or to them if they authorize you to do. It could be. It could be both. Yeah, it could be both so.

So it's I point three for you and 8.1 for them so if they did nothing to stop you doing it and they saw you're about to do it and did nothing to stop you. Usually, for both of you, it's a breeze for both of you. If you see someone about to break a rule that is going to help you help your play and you do nothing to stop it. Yes, yes, hello situations.

I think you can both get the penalty, but under several rules. I just wonder if I'm just trying to think of a situation where that would be so slow to happen. Like a pitch, mark, could have, you know, you could repair in 2 seconds. So, of course, there will be a tough one, whereas if someone was breaking off a branch and taking three minutes to do so, I'd that would be a better example of yeah, yeah, right next one.

I've got the chainsaw from DK. Player wins the B grade middle and clubland only to return the middle. Two days later. Saying, it has come to light that he signed for a lower score than he actually had. Interestingly, it was the market who had discussion with the player after the result was published to advise him, that he thinks there was a wrong score submitted after these private discussions. It was agreed. The wrong school was entered and by came forward hat, in hand to

advise the committee of the era to add insult to injury, the player had shouted, the players in the bar at presentation and drink, which is often customary I would love your thoughts on The Potter's to discuss Rollings after result of the competition has been finalized. Wow. Sorry it's been finalized results published. But then the player comes back and says, know I submitted a

wrong score. Now. We need to sort of know a little bit more information. You know, was it just a case of he forgot that he ducked a chip? Was it a case that he forgot to include a penalty? Was a case that he didn't forget it. All. He just hope that he you know, that no one saw they had in their swing. so a little bit more information would be necessary because if it was if

it was a genuine Didn't know then the result is as stands. If it was a cheating type situation. A finally got found out there, not only shooting hand back the middle but it will show also should be banned for six months at least. What do you think Stuart?

Yeah, I think it's only if it's in the event of serious misconduct or something that the committee would probably disqualify them. I'm just trying to I was just having a quick look through 3.3, then sorry, while you were talking about, has always been a bit of an area of I spoke to you about my exam about. I got a question about this about when the, you know, when the competition is closed or when the player has left, the scoring area and you know, the hard car will say when two feet are outside the scoring room so

to speak or building can they you know, the competition is closed. It is done and dusted. Another player has to live with it. Sorry, the action that was taken, the play was disqualified under rule, 20 point to e and the B grade medal was awarded some next best player to blow did not get his money back up, check out the bar. So if we look at 20.2 e, boot overlay, normally penalty must not be added or corrected after

a stroke play competition as flows, which is when the result has become final. In the way than the way set by the committee in stroke play qualifying for love. Bona fide. So when it says, here in the club and story that 24 hours after result was published then, A penalty must not be added or corrected. But a player must be disqualified. Even after the competition is closed, if they return to school

for any whole lower than actually taken, except that player is not disqualified. If the reason for the lowest scores the exclusion of one or more penalty Strokes that they did not know about before the competition closed. Okay. Yeah. Exactly. Noon for the competition. Closes are in breach of any other rule. Yeah, Sophie, let me put down a fool when he actually had a five and just forgot about adopt chip.

Then he, yeah, he can be disqualified. That's pretty simple pretty playing there and should be Says musti. And then they, and then they correctly, awarded it to the next player. He would have been. It would have been stunned that next player. But your how is she at the bar for free that guy? Yeah, that's right. Good on, am I good on this person for a great? You know, we shouldn't be the Bobby Jones quote.

We shouldn't be Praising wanting praising someone for finally adhering to the rules. But you know, there could be a time where you Duffer chip and you just forget You just forget that, you know, you had a five and a four and your mark down and, you know, you're so flustered or something and your Market goes, oh you had a 4-year. Yeah. The for thinking that it was a bogey on a pathway or something like that. I'm trying to think of situation, you know, even just a little tap in part and your putter head goes across the top

of the ball and you miss it, altogether and afterwards. You counting up, how many times did you hit the ball? And you're going? And five was actually six chords fail to register or Same time yet, left the shop but then you know, there was a distraction by other players or someone else or something like that and you all you can think about is you know the snake that was on the path rather than how many shots you actually here. That last bit of 28 .2 e is a bit. I remember the committee may also disqualify for serious misconduct after the competition

is closed, but the bit above that that you read is pretty Crystal Clear. Yeah, ready. I guess what? We've got. Another story from To Bob. Yeah, forgetful Frank tees off and puts it into the trees. He grabs a ball from his bag and says I'm playing a provisional you happy with that Stewart so far so good. What ball are you using say? Says, mate Damo, none of your beeswax. It's a myth that I need to tell you.

He hits his probie provisional number one under the Fela way, over the hill where the same direction as his mate Damo, they get over the hill and find two balls together. Both the probie number ones, Goodwin says day. Hello, sarcastically. You should get the general penalty, as you can't identify your ball, that'll teach you for being a smartass. Oh, no time. I might have a problem too. What action was taken to resolve

the situation players, agree, that Frank should get a general penalty and no penalty for jet for Damo. So, and they given him a general penalty. I'm lost. So guys, you know, ball obviously they yeah. Firstly, as he found his original. Yeah, if he hasn't, then this provisional will becomes the ball in play.

If it's a bit on searching for the original, sorry as well. Yeah, if is provisional becomes the ball into play after 3 minutes search or there was out of bounds whatever. Then how do they work out? Which one's is his provisional and which one is Deimos ball. If they can't identify both as to whose is whose they both have to go back to the tee and Damo be planned, three and Frank will be playing Five Spot on.

Wow, so just sort of within your group going, you know, if you get for Frank, you can just take a general penalty for this. We don't know what under, what rule, but you just can probably the biggest biggest supporter of this. Yeah, Frank. That'll teach you being a smartass, I mean, forgetful. Frank is correct, and he doesn't have to. We talked about this in last week's podcast, we did all the one before, ya know it was them. Miss that, you have to identify right?

Yes, it tells have to tell someone what you're you, don't even have to tell someone what your original ball is, let alone your provisional, but it's a nice thing to do. And, you know, the whole marking and then, you know, it's easier to hold that person to account for looking for their ball. And then when I play with you, you know, apparently I'm always using a fix and three All right next one from really from Benji Marshall you know who Benji Marshall with know he was one of

the one of the best New Zealand rugby league players so it's definitely not him. Obviously it's like that. It could be hit hit my driveway right into an adjacent Fairway on 15. tried to go over the Trees of my next shot and failed, hit the tops of the trees, hit the cart path, splitting Them Holes, And the ball came to rest. Close to a pine tree. With significant pine needles

around the base. If the car it is splitting the holes. All right, hit the car parts. Little also there's trees and underneath the trees as a cart path, and that's between they say he was on hole 14. So 14 15 underneath is it says hit the car park and the ball comes to rest and pine to a palm tree with significant Pioneers around the bases it's written perfectly. I just need to work that out. I'm marked with my Mac, my ball

with a tea and left it to identify. It was my bull recreated my lion remove the tea. Remove loose impediments around the back of my book and took my starts to see what shot I have. Everything sounds okay. So far realizing I don't know where I should be aiming to punch back on into the 50th Eli. I walked 20 meters forward toward the green, over a small hill to see what angle.

I need to taste to get back into play. I'm returning to my boy, find the boys come to rest and a new location a few inches further away from the tree and its original lie. As the ball was in play. After I remove my teeth from the initial inspection. I thought my ball comes to rest. A new location is valid and continue to play the hole. I made. Bogey the group on the 15th green saw this whole thing happen, a hundred meters away and one of them asked my playing Partners. What happened after the round,

it ended hoping to catch me cheating. Although I've seen is me lifting my ball and is it coming to rest in the new location? What should I have done? I don't think he's done anything. Wrong. I'm he wanted to identify his ball, he's marked before lifting, which is all good. You can get a replaceable on the spot. Any orientation as long as it comes to rest in the same you replace it on the same spot. He's gone away. The ball has then move. We've got to work out. What caused that oughta move there's only four causes if it

is not known or virtually certain that the ball was moved by you. Your caddy, your partner, he Partners caddy or an outside influence or your opponent in match play. Then we put it down to nine over. We said we put it down June Natural Forces if it's moved by natural forces unless it's been lifted and replace on the ground, we clay from its new spot. So he's done that. Played it from his new spot. I don't think that person from what I just heard has done anything wrong. Even removing the loose impediments and all that you can do all that. As long as your ball doesn't

move lose impediments are not part of the line of the ball. I don't think I've got the guys name now. Benji, you New Zealand make. I don't think he's done anything wrong. Also, missing something, but I don't think I mean, he said here in the thing that he recreated his life, but I don't think he, that's what he actually means. I think he meant it, just he just replaced the ball regretting. Why you put the ball back where it was? Because he didn't, he didn't, he didn't need to recreate a lot. So forget about that. The only thing he needs to do is work out who caused the ball to

move, as you said and or who or what? And if it was simply he replaced it and then the wind blew it. Or it was just gravity because it was just what's the word? It was hanging by a thread on whether it was going to sit there and stay You know, there is a chance that him moving the loose impediments. Makes it unstable around that area. Yeah.

But is there at least 95 percent certain or knowledge or virtual certainty that that's what caused it to move, right? Not really this case, if you if you like just think about this practically, if you see if you place your ball and then you remove loose impediments and your ball still stays. And then you, you know, it's been staying there for 5 to 10 seconds. You know every every second that stays there, reduces that 95% right agreed.

And so because then then it's a case of well you've moved away from the area. Now, you know, just because it was unstable, you know, it might have been gravity of might have been wind. It might have been water. In might have been humidity. I don't know. So I would say that an honest opinion, I would say that he's done nothing wrong. And is applied from the correct place. That was the place that the bull

would come to rest after being moved by natural forces. We don't know what natural physical forces they were Doesn't matter. It was moved by natural forces so I hope that that's the default, isn't it? Like you, that's the Natural Forces is the default unless we know 95% sure or more, that something specific has moved it. Yeah. If you move loose and pediments and then two seconds later your ball moves. I reckon you got 95% that it was you Right.

Yeah, but it was five seconds. Now it's, you know, now you're getting closer to 94% it just moved if it was 20 seconds, is definitely not 95%. I hope that answers your question. Benji, thank you very much. Okay, one from DG. Players Ball ended up in an animal carcass. So a dead rabbit during a

practice round. Wasn't sure what to do. Took a drop nearby. he's actually answered this one himself and I Just scrolling through it. I think I agree with this rolling. Discussed afterwards. Dead animal is a loose impediment. See. Definitions so rule 15, applies options, play the ball, as it lies, not favored and possible to move the carcass without moving the ball, which would be one fairly stroke replaced ball. So the only real option, he has there.

If he doesn't want to play, the lies is Rule 19. Unplayable, ball agree with that. Well, I agree. It's I thought straight away of loose impediment and I thought, wow, this is a bit of a problem here, because You move loose impediment and your ball moves. There's no, no exception there, you're going to get the penalty, you're right plays. That lies move the loose impediment, if your ball moves, it's a one-stroke penalty. Got to replace it or take an unplayable.

I'm just trying to think how you can take a free drop to the side. To get out of that as unfortunate as it might be. Well the only way you could take three drop and I'm not suggesting you do this but is too and it's pretty hard if it's a carcass as in the head has been removed by a fox or a bird or something. But if it's still, if the rabbit is still alive, you know, you saw it you saw it blink. What's different?

Yeah, let's roll 11.1 is if it's dead, it's 15. Silent one. Now you need to think of another one little Point ones ball in motion. Yeah, well the most times it's been accidentally. I've been accidentally. Sorry. Yes, you all emotion comes to rest on animal animal or movable of structure person. Yeah, it has so the internet. That's right. In an animal which is size 14. Yes, could happen. But if it's a dead seagull that

it's hit and got stuck up. Then it's going to be a case of well, you either play it as it lies. Or, as DG said, take take penalty relief. And then these people get, he goes on to say it reminds me. It reminds him of the Harry Bradshaw ball and a broken beer bottle in the 1949 Open Championship. You might not know about this one, but apply. Actually, hit the ball into a came.

Rest beside a broken. Beer bottle and he played it as it lies. But a broken beer bottle, or any beer bottle is actually a movable trucks, and it's not a loose impediment because it is an artificial object official. So he could have taken through and leave or what by move books. So she could have moved the beer bottle and gotten the out of his way, but he didn't actually play with his lies. You got to think. That's not you will die.

If your ball hangs up inside a rabbit. Yeah. That's right. You know, this is same as my video on the on the cow poo, if your ball ends up in cow poo, It's a play it as it lies or unplayable ball relief. It's not a It's not a abnormal course condition, but still it. You know what?

I'm going to say next. You don't get the poop. Yeah, but you can still get loose impediment on knows, you're right, a committee can adopt the low arm rule across if there is extensive Animal dung. If 12, I'm just looking at now, I was playing it. Five, thirty six hours yesterday, kill more Golf Club an hour and a half. North of Melbourne and Seymour Golf Club about two hours north

of Melbourne and They have kangaroos, lots of kangaroos. And this kangaroo done all over the place. Not enough in my mind to adopt if 12 animal dome local rule. This is a in the local rule itself, but there is a concern with the effect of dung on Fair Play, the committee can give the players. The option of treating done is ground and repair for which relief, is allowed under rule. 16 point one. There wasn't enough.

It was just, you know, you just flick it away. But if it, if it is a loss in some courses, when they have lakes or ponds around greens, there's, they can get a lot of ducks and the ducks can waddle onto the green and fertilize the green naturally. But obviously, that can get in, it can interfere with a lot of the players play so you can obviously get rid of the duns or if the committee adopt that

local rule, you can just move your butt. Brought that is our club line stories for this week or month. Keep sending the club later stories and they are amazing. We love it. Here is we actually test our brain. You can see that. We we've got stumped by a couple there but yeah, keep sending them in their fantastic, especially to bulb. There are some you really hear what happens in clubland when

with some of those stories. Right, G RQ. O TW 84 do it. Yeah, Blake. You're going to preempt this with saying I was very excited coming to this podcast with this gr Q 0 TW so much. So that you and I spoke before I press record and you say, Well it can't be better than mine. Said you, I'm going I think it might be. And within about five seconds, we realized we had exactly the same scenario told to us from two different sources. So I have Molded it a little bit

but I think I've got the gist. It's just of the question. If I don't, then you got another question for next week, but here we go. For GR Q. 0, TW, 4, episode 84 Blakey. I'm sorry, this involved. You always playing a stable foreground of one bad Hills. Blakey has 238 m to the PIN for his second shot on the par-5 13th hole. Thinking he cannot get their bike. He like he Plies but flashes his three would, but he's ball. Landing, just off the green and rolling can within 30 centimeters of hole.

While the group in front are still putting, like he does raise his hand as he walks onto the green. He Taps his ball in for an eagle 3, pulling the ball out of the hole and believes. He may have played a wrong ball back on The Fairway, he says to his marker. Well, I was walking to the next tee. A player in the group ahead comes back. Gives Blakey back his In a ball and tells him. Sorry, mate, I marked and leave heard your ball on the green. And when we finished the whole, I mistakenly replaced, my spare ball on the spot. What is Blake?

He score for the whole. Does he need to do anything to correct? That is a tricky one. And yes, I heard of this one, and I do now know the answer. So, we will give you the answer and episode 85, which won't be next week. It will The possibly whilst off. Refereeing. So Stuart away on holiday next week but podcast, as well as a holiday and I am, then after

Easter Easter Monday, hitting to Vietnam we've got the international series and Vietnam which is good. It's going to be. It's a new course over by the now, Tran airport camera, think the cameras, the airport. And then after that, I'm to Adelaide for the live event and then Singapore for the live event, and then I'll be back after that. But we are, hopefully, I'll take my podcast gear and hopefully we'll be able to do a podcast while I am on the road. As such you'll have to wait

until we get that episode 85 out to hear the answer for that question. That is a really I got it wrong. So I'm happy to admit that. I like the answer, it's a bit tough. But at the same time you know it's what the it's the way the rules are written and it's correct. So Go straight, go from the other night. So, yeah, thank you very much. Everyone for listening, Daddy for thank you, podcast and

enjoy. Enjoy your holiday and we will chat again, sir.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode