Clubland Stories October - THE GRQ PODCAST EP103Join this channel to get access to perks:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/joinSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rulesGRQOTW102 - There are no penalty strokes, as any player is allowed to move a removed flagstick whilst a ball is in motion.Clubland Stories1. Known or Virtual Certainty Ball is in Penalty Area - Karin2. Player Wants to Continue with Provisional Ball But Another Player Finds Their Original - Sue3. Player Likes to Move Tee Markers - Webbo4. Player Penalised for Getting Angry in a Bunker, Finds Out Later it Shouldn't Have Been a Penalty - 5. Incorrect Line of Flight Relief From a Penalty Area - ColinGRQOTW102Big P is playing an individual stroke round at Wombat Hills. His tee shot on the 15th hole has come to rest in very thick grass near the top of a bunker. Big P decides to take unplayable ball relief, using lateral relief. There is GA and the bunker within the relief area. Prior to dropping, Big P replaces a divot in the relief area and then drops where the ball hits the GA first but rolls into the bunker. Marcela advises Big P that he needs to drop again as it rolled into another part of the course but also suggests that he has improved one of his CATS. For his second drop, Big P drops into the bunker, where the ball comes to rest in the relief area..GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. This is episode 103. We take a Part 2 of Clubland stories with the October edition. On this episode we hear from Karen about Jenny taking penalty area relief, but did she have at least 95% known or virtual certainty that a bull was in the penalty area? We also hear from Webber about one of his members moving tea markers and Mr. Roberts corrects a hilltop member that anger in a bunker is not always a penalty. Lastly, a scary one from Colin
about low handicappers thinking that line of flight is a viable penalty area option. So whether you're in your car or going for a walk, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions podcast. Stuart's one of our highest ranked working rules officials that we have one of the best we've got and he knows he's. Hey everyone, welcome to episode one O 3 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. You're here with Blakey and my Co host, Stuart Mcfee.
Hello, Blakey. Hello, Stuart. How are you? I'm very well, thank you. Now let's get straight into it, the GRQO TW1O2 which I was listening to and I actually saw that Ruin answered or tried to answer it for last week on YouTube. So I have a better, better, more up to date understanding now, you know, it's like I think I'm on top of it this time because.
I'm going to read it now. This days GRQOTW from episode 102 Blakey and Stewart are playing a match at Wombat Hills. It is Blakey's turned apart on the first screen and he removes the flag stick from the hole. Placing it on the green behind the hole, Blakey's putt is way too hard and believing the ball will definitely hit the flag stick, Stewart rushes over and picks up the flag stick. Blakey's ball continues to roll past where the flag stick was on the green. Blakey's not happy and he requests A ruling.
Are there any penalty strokes and what happens next? So he's moved the flag stick out of the hole, which is fine. And then the while the ball is in motion, the flag stick has been moved by someone else, which the ball could have actually hit the flag stick and stopped or not gone as far away from the hole if it the flag stick had been left there. So is there a penalty? And the answer is no, there's no penalty. You are allowed to move a flag
stick that whilst the ball was in motion. That's probably the easiest way to say it. So that's rule 11.3. Is that right? Correct. Yep, and podcast is going to read that out now. I was. Just going to say you know, so 11.3 covers deliberate, deliberate actions to affect the ball in motion. And we know there's lots of things you cannot move out of the way when a ball is in motion. You just can't. Excuse me. And one of the criterions to satisfy this rule to incur the
breach is not of course whether the whether the ball was going to hit where that item was on the ground. It's the deliberate action to remove it because you can actually never, you never actually prove whether it was going to hit it or not. So let's say a flag stick was something you weren't allowed to take out of the way, and we did move out of the way and the ball moved past. How would you then go about proving, oh, I might have actually just missed that flag ticket might just, you know, whatever. So anyway, there's no, there's
no test to see whether it actually would have hit it or not. The only criterion you need to satisfy, and I've said that in a very long way, is the fact that the action was deliberate. The action was deliberate, And if it was deliberate and that's proved, then you incur the penalty. But as you said, Blakey, the flag stick is actually one item. Which you can actually move and freely move about a remove flagstick. Sorry, a flagstick that is already out of the hole, and if it's already been removed, you can actually move it quite freely whether the ball was getting hit or not, as you see.
And that's actually quite an interesting sort of you did go around about way too. Away. So if if a ball was going towards a stick and you move the stick out of the way, is that allowed? No, that's deliberate. If that was a deliberate what? What is? So you move it out of the way, the ball goes past it, right? And it and the ball ends up in a space. Yeah, what is the rule? So doing so, if the action was deliberate, that's all we need to satisfy. OK, so it's you incur the
general penalty so there's no sorry if I may. So you, the players wouldn't gather or call in a referee and the referee wouldn't say, oh, can you put the stick back where it was, please, and just sort of show me where the Yeah, show me where the ball went. We'll just sort of work out whether it would have hit the stick or not. You don't have to have to satisfy that to incur the general penalty under 11.3. There's only one criteria. Was it deliberate? So that's for the stick. Yeah. But, and some other moveable obstructions. But if it's any player's equipment, the flagstick. Or a ball, Yeah, Including a
ball. Yeah. Full of rest. Yeah, the ball marker. Not. You can't move a ball marker out of the way. There's a ball in motion but you can definitely move a ball. But if it is your ball and we heard that in a Club land story last week, you'd have to put a marker beside it first before you moved it out of the way. Interesting. We the flagstick is another one of those unique things that you know, you're playing from the green like you were in this situation. You're playing from the green. Your ball hit something, you
know. Do you either play the ball as it lies or do you replay the stroke? In a lot of cases, you would do in fact replay the stroke. Yeah, if you hit a hat, if you hit a water bottle, it hits something like that. But the flagstick is not one of those. No. If it hits the flagstick, it's or, as long as you didn't deliberately put it there, any person holding that thing. Right, so the flagstick is a bit unique. In that sense, I mean it has its own little several 13.2 which covers the flagstick, you know, attending the flagstick, removing it and all those sort of things. But as you're Yeah, you're right.
In this particular Case, No penalty to Stuart Plakey can be furious, but you can actually move out. You can remove flagstick. Yeah, anytime instead of being furious Plakey to just learn how to play better. Not well. We only hit pups way too hard and leave them up. Why that happens one ahead of Off the Green. So let's get into We've got another series of clubland stories because we had to catch up on them after about two months. So these are clubland stories. October, Yes. What do you want? To say I just I am going to hit
you without notice here. One of the clubland stories we spoke about last week. I just wanted to throw another theory at you. So we're talking about the hypothetical about all the way down the right hand side of a hole was. Half was out of bounds and then the second-half was red penalty area as thick grass and we're and the players are trying to work out, you know did it go out of bounds or did it actually come to race in the red penalty area And of course both the player and opponent disagreed and he would resolve that. I just wanted to throw this at you. We were talking about we're going to work out which is it more likely to be in?
Is it more likely to be out of bounds. Was it more likely to be in the red penalty area? I just because you know, I re re listened to this, you know, once a day. To help me fall asleep. He likes listening to his own. Course, Definitely not. I thought about it a bit more when I heard that particular story thinking. There's only one of those areas of the course. If you call that a bounce area, of course there's only one one of those areas that requires significant proof and that's the re penalty area. So for a ball to be known, you know, to come to rest in a re
penalty area, we need that 95%. Knowledge or virtual certainty, that is a very, very high standard. That means 19 out of 20 times it's in there. It's a very high standard for a ball to have come out of bounds. We don't need that same level of proof. So really we shouldn't have. When I think about it, and I'm just throwing this at you as a theory, that rather than us working out, which was more likely because we said I was 51% likely to be out of bounds and only 49% penalty area, but we actually need a significantly higher level of proof.
Of 95% to say it's in the red penalty area. In other words, there's more burden required to prove that than there is for it to be anywhere else. That's I was just thinking about that as I said listening back to us, I see where you're going with that. I guess the fact is that because of those options B&C because if you you don't need any this integer proof if you want to take stroke and distance. No, I never do that either, correct? And that's the whole idea of it.
You don't need this massive amount of proof that's gone out of bounds because your only option is stroke. And distance only one option so if penalty area your only option was stroke and distance then. In this particular case, to go back and. Agree, but the player wanted to exercise 17.1 D three and that was take lateral relief and drop 2 club lengths from the entry point, which of course I estimated for that option you need to have knowledge of virtual certainty. So that's why I'm saying there's more level of proof required for that area of the course and for
it to be anywhere else. So that was really, really where I think the focus should be. 10 May be satisfied 19 times out of 20. That that ball is definitely. If not, you don't have to prove the others, that it's out of ants or lost. You don't have to prove that almost. You have to prove the other one. I guess it still can. Comes down to if if it's 200 meters to carry and you normally hit 240 and even with a dirty cut then nine out of twenty you probably get there.
But the other thing too is like, and I know that Keysborough and Melbourne, they had one on their 16th hole that is exactly like this. And so if you cross over the outer bounds, cross back over the outer bounds into the red penalty area, then you'd also need to have that local rule. No point of entry, yeah. You'd also need to have that local rule in place where you can, which they used to have as a rule of golf, and they took it out and now it has to be a local
rule if they want to allow equidistant art on that penalty area. Yeah, which would be, which would actually be quite hard to find. Because what you're saying is that the ball travels out of bounds and then intercept penalty area on an edge. Yeah, bordering out of bounds. There's no point of entry on the course. There's no reference point. Yeah. So you need to use that. Equidistant. What do they call it? Opposite size? There's a reference point, not general area or bunker penalty area. It's the outer bounds to penalty area, so and and If it's a
square like this and your grain's over here, then you're equally distant. Would have to be back here alongside the outer bounds, which I'm not even sure is a is an option. Even if the local rule would have to look that one up. There's another one for looking up and and I think they're finished with that one, aren't we? Well, Speaking of our GRQO TW101 and how we gave you the answer last week, but then we bought up
the what happens if they drop it And then without the KVC, the nano virtual certainly 95 at least 95% and then the ball was found in the penalty area. So that actual relief area was correct. While that we've worked it out now they've actually had the USDA have given us some feedback about that and they've actually when they took the drop, they didn't have that KVC. So that was a wrong procedure.
So it doesn't even matter what you find out afterwards, they have to pick that ball up regardless and proceed under one of their options. And I like the wording from the USGA. It said only the information you know at the time of dropping is relevant, yeah. And it's almost like, if you think about that situation, it's almost if the penalty area wasn't even there. Yeah. Because it had no relevance in what you're doing. Yeah. That could have just been a general area. Yeah. Anyway, good to know. So, yeah, you must correct that. Yeah.
Thank you to the USGA for getting back to us so quickly. Yeah right so into clubland stories. We've got one here from Karen. Jeannie played her tee shot and headed towards the penalty area. When she got to where she believed it would be and couldn't see it, she took penalty relief. 2 clothings from where she thought the ball last crossed the edge of the penalty area. She then walked towards the green and found her original ball 10 meters ahead on the edge of the fairway. How was the how was she to proceed?
Jeannie wanted to cancel the striking distance feeling and continue with the original ball. Her playing partner said that as she had played another ball that was the ball and played, Jeannie picked up her original ball and continued to play with her second ball. That happened Kings Cove or meet and Country Club. They had a name change about two months ago. So yeah, I think Karen's got that one. She's given me the question and also given me the answer. Basically if as long as, but
this this goes to our question from one O 1. As long as Jenny had at least 95% virtual certainty that her balls in the penalty area, then her drop was correct. And once she's dropped once she's dropped, her original ball is abandoned if that's the right word for it. And she it's so it's not even the shot once you drop shot at only when you tee it up in the teeing area, but in the general
area or bunker or whatever. It's it's when you drop. So the drop ball with the ball and play the original was out of play. And Jenny, even though you wanted to continue with the original ball, as long as you had 95% virtual certainty, you've proceeded correctly and you pick that original ball up. And again, just like one O 1, this one O one was very, very topical, just like one O 1.
If you weren't, if you didn't have at least 95% KVC, then the original ball is still the ball in play and the drop was the incorrect procedure. The fact that you've dropped and played, we've actually played from a a wrong place under 18.1 strike. So then you by dropping you and playing from wrong place, which was, it would most likely be a
serious breach. Now we're into a lot of strokes. Original ball off the tee dropping to You're playing from the wrong place to. That's right. Before then you have to go back and correct your mistake by playing from the tee shot as well. So. If a player's ball has not been found and it is known or virtually certain that the ball is under arrest in a penalty area, the player might take penalty relief under rule 17.1 D or 17.2.
Once the player puts another ball in play to take relief in this way, the original ball is no longer in play and must not be played. This is true even if it is in found on the course before the end of the three minute search time. If it is not known or virtually certain that the ball came to rest in a penalty area and the ball is lost, the player must take stroke and distance roof and .2. So now that was under 17.1 C podcast was reading there. Now we I did actually have
another situation emailed it through to me from Sue and basically it was very similar to this but not using a not into a penalty area and went into rough. I think it was a garden area, not not deemed a you know, a GUR area, just a garden rough grass type stuff area. And the persons hit a provisional ball, which they are allowed to do. They don't have to, They've hit a provisional ball, announced it onto the grain really nice and
close, walk straight over to that ball, want to use that ball. Someone has gone and looked for their ball, their original, and found the original ball. The purse of the player really wants to use the one that's on the grain. Of course it's closer now, but now the original has been found, she needs to come over and identify that it is hers. If a ball has been found in the area that the original could be and then so she does. Anyway, they have a bit of a debate amongst the group.
I'll I'll let the debate also continue because the ball was pretty unplayable. So the players with the original ball is going well. I'm not going to play from there. I'll probably take an unplayable. Maybe I can use the provisional as the stroke and distance. Yeah, unplayable option. Yeah, the provisional ball is not an option under stroke and distance. It's an option if you think your ball might be lost outside of heleny area or it might be out of bounds, but it's not an option and a 19.2.
OK, so you don't get to use your provisional ball as an option on the 19.2. Now the added to that it was in an unplayable area and the person that found it saw thought they saw a snake as well. In the end the player came back and did take an unplayable for the original ball. So that's two shots and then ended up with A5. I went back to them and said look, if if the animal was still there and the player thought that there was a dangerous
animal condition, they could have taken some kind of free relief. But the free relief only gets them so far away. And I think I added that it's only a dangerous, dangerous animal condition if the animal stays there and it's a dangerous animal. OK, not all animals are dangerous. And if the animal leaves the area, then there's no more, there's no more danger. So it's not a dangerous animal
condition anymore. So that was a similar one that I got on e-mail from Sue. So that was hopefully we've helped them out with that. Now Henry and I created a video a while ago about when you must abandoned the provisional ball. So if you haven't seen that, go and take a look at it. But I I get these queries a lot, so I'd send them around this. And it's just so straightforward though, isn't it like as soon as that original is found, identified the provisional ball
has like 0 status. I mean we know it's a problem ball and everything, but zero has no relevance on the rest of that hole. Sorry for the rest of that plug, that hole just has no status whatsoever. There is with the Sorry you go well and interesting enough, as soon as the original ball was lost. So after the three minute search, it has no further bearing on the call or if another. Ball's been put into play like the energy area and then found later even within the three minutes. Yeah, doesn't matter. It's now wrong. Also under 16.2, the dangerous animal condition it actually the
stroke must be reasonable. You know, we we, Jeff and I were talking a lot about this last night that. Almost every single free relief situation has this caveat has to be a reasonable stroke. So in this case, when maybe the ball was clearly unplayable, you may not get that free relief under the dangerous condition if that stroke is unreasonable. And unreasonable, it's an interesting one because unreasonable for me might be different. Unreasonable for you because you're, you know, handicaps a little bit higher, generous. And I'm I probably go to the gym
a little bit more than you can. So what I could possibly hit and what you could possibly hit could be two different situations. And looking at us, you know, from people that watch this, they might think, oh, there's not too much difference in age or ability or, you know, stature, which is probably true. So. Maybe our our mums who play golf, what they can do and what
we can do would be totally different. What would be unreasonable for her or them might not be might be reasonable for us to try and have a show. You know, I've had this conversation before about like if you have a referee, he plays off 25 his club and he's refereeing a player who would play off +7 at his club. Do they have the same look? Yeah, it's summing up a situation whether something's reasonable or not. A lot of time. That's why referees, they usually get people that are professional being professionals
in a past life as to what shots that they would hit. You know, and and funnily enough a ruling that was in the Ryder Cup, not the one just gone, but the. Before with Brooks, Kids, yeah, and was playing alongside Daniel Berger. The second opinion, I don't know about the first, the referee who gave the opinion, the first referee, but the the second opinion referee, he used to be on the European Tour, so he was a professional and you know, knew, knew how to play and knows the game very well and still
denied relief. And still denied relief and then. Which I mean seeing the situation and you see all the comments, oh, he hit, he hit it. He definitely hit it. But the fact that, you know it's a reasonable, whether it's a reasonable shot and whether the person's actually going to hit the thing if they go and play that shot is also slightly different. You know what I'm, you know what I'm saying? Like the referee could deny release because they don't think it's reasonable. And then if the person goes and
plays that shot anyway and hits. Has interference and makes a reason. You know, that doesn't necessarily mean that the referee was wrong. Maybe they'll look at it, re look at it and go maybe I could have given given relief there. But it doesn't necessarily mean that they were they were wrong because in their mind they were thinking this is not a reasonable shot and you're only just trying to get. Say that you have interference
to get free with them. Very good, Web O oh nice Web O again. And this was only sent in the end of September, but you're now in the late October club line stories. Web O1 member came in and said that he had checked and understood that he could do the following because he could find. Anything in the rules that said he couldn't because he could not find anything in the rules that said he could not. I'll set the same at Beverly and
East Riding Golf, where we're both as the secretary. Our team markers are 8 inches high, maximum, made from concrete poured into a plastic mold in the shape of an upturned cup. For what? Of a better description. The want of a better scripture. We have three sets of TS, white, yellow, and red. White being the back, yellow the middle, and red the front. Often all three TS are on the same team area, separated, separated by a few yards. Sometimes the red TS are on a
separate tee up to 50 yards in front of the other. So you get the picture. Yep, because this member hits a low ball. Ridiculously low in my opinion. He is often afraid that he may hit the tee marker in front of the tee he is playing from. He also does not like to see the other tee markers in front of him as it affects his mental game as well. He states that he can move, this is he'd be easy to play in match play. He states that he can move the TS in front of him, including those in his eyeline. As they are movable obstructions, they're not part of the course he's playing and
therefore does not even have to put them back. Even though they are teased for other courses. He does put them back though, I hasten to add. Good. Please can we have expert thoughts of bloking podcast? See your nickname's podcast. I've checked and unfortunately think he is right. There are no local rules in play about this. The T blocks fit the definition of a Movable obstruction as they're not the course he's playing. A lot of play definition fits and after consultation with other referees, one being a Level 3 Tars, I think he is right and I'd already mighty gurus to assist me.
I'd say he is right. Your first thoughts, Short answer definitely definitely correct. You can move because. The T mark is a movable obstructions. They're not part of the course that he is playing. We know that T mark is on other holes, even if they are the course that you are playing. So say the whites in this instant are movable obstructions because it's not part of the whole you're playing. So I would say that he is correct. As long as he puts them back, I don't have a problem with this.
I don't see an issue. I think you'd have a strong warning to them if you do not put them back. We have an issue because that's going to stuff up the rest of the field or the rest of the people playing off that other tee because they could get a penalty. So I think it's a strong warning that if you don't put them back if if we find any area out of position because of because of you. You know there is maybe a code
of conduct, maybe a two shot penalty, but usually you find these things after the fact, so it might be a case of a suspension of the of your next game. Or something along those lines. So I reckon this is covered in two spots. So movable obstructions covered under 15.2. We know the tee markers are movable. Obstructions without penalty apply. May remove a movable obstruction anywhere on or off the course, and may do so in any way. Except there's two exceptions, so I'll go to the second one first. You cannot obviously we just
spoke about this. Deliberately remove a movable obstruction, affectable emotion. But the first one is tee markers must not be moved when Baldwick played from the teen area, but as Blakey has just said, they are the very team markers of the team area that you're playing, not other team markers. This is also mentioned in 8.1 A about improving the conditions affecting the stroke except in limited wise allowed in rules 8.1 BC and DA player must not take any of these actions if they improve the conditions affecting the stroke.
Move, bend OR break team markers for the team area when playing a ball from that team area. So I don't think there's any issues ever with any other team marker for any other team area on that course, whether it's being used or not, as long as it's not the one you're about to be playing from. Yeah, I I can't see an issue here. The only issue I can see is if he just effects other people's play and doesn't put them. Back. So that's like a code of conduct, code of conduct thing.
So yeah, sorry, if you wanted us to tell him that he can't do it, but I think you already had. Come up with the answer and well it was a month ago you submitted this so I'm sure you have to. But yeah, a strong warning in the code of conduct breach if it does happen that to be a shocking result or a silly situation for others in the. In the course, you know, it's
almost a similar reason why some committees adopt A local rule deeming penalty area states as immovable. Because I don't want members moving them out of the way and not putting them back, which is this point. Yeah, move, move it out if it's going to bother you, but please. Put it back. That's a that's a that one there that you bring up. I see it all the time. You know, people just go in and make a comment online, wherever, whatever. Platform it's on and just say, oh, you're those stakes movable. You can just move them out of
the way. It's like, OK, but technically they are. But a lot of courses in Australia, they deem them immovable because of that reason, because people move them out of the way and then they don't put them back. My preference is they are movable so that we don't penalize the player if they do go and move them and he's in a penalty. Area and and then we just hope that you're good enough to put
them back but that's so not gonna happen because people don't repair divots and don't repair pitch marks so asking them to go and make sure to put a stake back is not gonna happen. So I would be in team to lane and this is the. Referee and the resource, we have a lot of resources when we're refereeing is, you know, go and put lines around your penalty areas, but that's a resource heavy and you need someone to go and do that, you
need someone to repaint the paint and and that kind of thing. So there is no easy answers. Get rid of penalty areas. Actually, that's the easy answer. But it is a good one. I mean, you see it all the time. You can just move those stakes. And then someone else says no, no, no, you can't move those stakes. It's appearing. Well, actually, that's a local rule, but it is a common local rule, right? Next clubland story from Mr. Roberts. He doesn't like me calling him anything other than Mr. Roberts. Firstly, may I say a big
congratulations to Golf Rules podcast for the Big 100. Thank you. When did he submit this one? 10th the 4th of October Thank you Mr. Roberts it was great to listen to Roscoe with early day memories and the contributions of Blakey and Stuart podcast. McPhee are fantastic for people like me can't trying to come to grips with the rules. As I've mentioned Blakey the podcast can be the highlight of my week can be. So it just depends. It won't be if I give him give him a bad rating.
As I listen at home or while I am working on the golf course, a big thanks for all you do for golf rules, which is such an important part of that great game. I will admit that I have problems following some of the stories and issues. However, I know that some things that happen at golf are real as they are beyond imagination. To make up. I have used Slash played some parts of your podcast to win discussions about rules. May I also add that a couple of weeks ago? I use a direct quote from podcast.
When a player picked up his ball, supposedly to identify it without marking it, I pinged him one penalty stroke. Then another player told me it was just a minor thing not worth worrying about. So I said, just tell me what other rules we should ignore as I walked away. Thank you Mr. I look. Forward to the next 100 episodes now. Yeah, he's done that now for a story. Safe question. Steve and Ray playing at Hilltop a few weeks ago.
Ray in a bunker and failed to hit his ball out and slapped his club into the base of the bunker several times. Steve gave him a general penalty. Climbing the belt in the sand improved the conditions where the ball rolled to. What actions were taken to resolve the situation? It was resolved on the spot. Steve insisted Ray add two shots to his score. Don't argue. Steve called for me a few days later about it. I said I would submit it to Glove then Stories, but I thought under rule 12.2 B2,
which Stewart's going to right now, it should not have been a penalty. Steve smiled and said it did him good and taught him a lesson about behaviour. So Steve, who gave the penalty to Ray? He's asked Mr. Roberts, and Mr. Roberts said you probably shouldn't have penalized them and Steve's gone. Yeah, well, it did him good and taught him a lesson about behavior. Podcast. Do you want to answer this one? So we're talking about restrictions on touching the sand in a bunker, and there's
certainly, I'm not even going to read for the rules here. I always say there's three things you can't do. One of them is certainly deliberately test the sand and the depth. You can't test it as you about to sorry can't touch the sand as you about to monkey stroke and obviously in a backstream backswing. But however there are times when you can touch the sand. Would it be fair to say you have a lot more freedom in the bunker now than you used to. OK, that's the understatement of the podcast. So removing loose impediments
and. Couldn't do that, No. All that sort of stuff. So one of. You couldn't strike anywhere, you couldn't touch anywhere in the sand with the club, right? While your ball was in that bunker, unless you were measuring that type of thing. So we know now that even if you take a couple of wedges into the bunker and you pick one, you know you can oh. You could do that. You could do that. You could lay one down, yeah, lay one down. You just you wouldn't. Allow it. You wouldn't allow it to lay little. Like lean on T club, right? So now you can do it.
Yeah, you can be waiting and just lean as long as you're not testing the. You weren't allowed to get angry and hit the sand right and of course that's now specifically mentions, but that's one of the options is sorry. One of the things you can do is striking the sand in frustration or anger. Yeah, there's no penalty for doing that as long as you're not improving one of the cases, as long as you're not testing the the sand depth, as long as that action is not oh good, I I thought it was a bit thicker something, you know. Yeah. So frustration. The rules ever Never mentioned
that. And that comes back the integrity of the player as to what they're actually doing. Are they testing or are they just striking the same frustration? So as long as you as I said, as long as it's not in your, you know, practice swing, sorry, It's another one practice swing. Making the backswing. You're testing, deliberately touching testing. So test the condition of the sand to learn more information for your next stroke. As long as you're not doing any of that, these are the things you can do digging in with your feet to take a stance for a practice or other stroke. That that one there, I just want to start the other one, because you just said and as long as you're not testing, but then you
said digging in with the feet. So go back to the testing one and it actually states before making a stroke at a ball and a bunker, the player must not deliberately touch sand in the bunker with a hand club rake or other object to test the condition of the sand to learn information for the neck stroke. But digging in with your feet is OK, so you can actually test the bunker when you dig in with your feet.
I mean, it would be very, it would be very hard for the rules to say. That you weren't allowed to test the sand, but you are allowed to still dig in with your feet. And we see this all the time. So I I have no issues with that. I mean, you can't dig in so far that you hit the base and go right, It's two inches. Yeah, well, hit the base and go, that's an immovable obstruction. I'm going to get free relief because as we know, wow, this is a sort of more of a tour hard card thing if the immovable obstruction in the bunker is in
his. Is in its intended position then you're not gonna get free relief from that but it it's just interesting. They say a club right hand object and other object but digging in with your feet and to to take your stance, I guess your your shoes are equipment aren't they? They're not. Wow. They're not an object like a something else. The ball retriever would be an object. Well, that's the equipment. As well. Well, now we're going down in the rabbit hole. We are ready to jump back here
because. If you mark your ball with a small object, yes, you can mark it with your foot as long as your sugar or sock is on. So that's another object. I actually mentioned that to someone last week who didn't like. That if if you mark it just with your barefoot that you, that's not allowed. But if you mark it and you've got your sock or your shoe on, that's allowed. So a small object could be your shoe or sock, so another object could be your, but it does say
feet. He said the last or marking last week and the guy said, I just know you can't use any of yourself any of your own body like you said, any said you're like you can't put your finger down on the green like that. I said yeah, but it had a if it had a glove on, you could. You don't want anything like that. Do you know one of those things? It turned pages away. Yes. Thumb, thumb, Thumb. Yeah, that seems. Yeah, if you had one of those on the yeah, that'd be fine. That's an object anyway. Getting back to when you can touch the sand, but it doesn't result in a penalty. Digging in with the feet to take
the stance for a practice swing or the stroke. Smoothing the bunker to care for the course. Replacing club's equipment or other objects in the bunker, whether by throwing or sitting them down. Measuring, marking, lifting, replacing or taking other actions under a rule, leaning on a club to rest, stay balanced or prevent a fall. Or striking the sand in frustration or anger. We're trying to. Yeah. So, Steve, good on you for penalizing Ray, but he didn't actually deserve the penalty. And thank you for to Mr. Roberts for his incredibly kind words.
Yes. And his support. Yeah. Thank you. Right, last clubland story from the form. Oh, Colon again. He's how many has seven? Seven. Colon has contributed 7 times to the clubland stories. A lot goes down well at Y made golf course. And while I mention this, hopefully we'll get it out. All Blacks are playing our Sunday morning in the World Rugby final.
World Cup final against South Africa. Hopefully I'm a happy man next week and so will Colin be. Next thing you know, tell me that he's born in South Africa and he plays. He supports South Africa instead. Anyway, Colin playing with par 5-6 power. Why, Maddy, we're going to know every hole. I'm Madison. Colin is playing with two locals and a visitor from Pleasant Point Golf Club. Our visitor Tees off with a massive slice. He's a left-hander, OK. He ends up lost in the penalty area near the 9th hole Fairway.
Having searched and grade the balls in the penalty area, he decides to take back on the line area and back on the line relief which would place him back into some Bush. Now Colin, having put the penalty stakes out as part of his duties at the club, couldn't believe his eyes after walking away to hit his own. The ball went out and visited drops his ball on the line that would have taken in flight into the penalty area. So he was lining himself up with a flag and taking a penalty drop along the line of the slice.
He dropped the ball in the rough 20 or 30 meters away from where he correctly should have dropped it. Colin not overly sure of the ruling as he had seen another player in a tournament a few months earlier do exactly the same thing but on a different hole. As our player was playing terrible and not in the best moods, we let it slide. Sorry. Like his G What? What other rules did he let slide? He did the same thing on a different hole later on. I do have an idea of what the answer is, but how many penalty strokes has our friend incurred? Stay off the ground and he's a single figure handicapper.
Oh my God, our visitor had a terrible day. Colin, that the main thing you do here is when we give you the answer, you have to send the answer to this person because there's no line of flight is not an option. Under 17.1 D Our visitor had a terrible, terrible day. Stanford Brown. He didn't feature in any prize results but bought myself and partner beer because we won the Hagel. I'm pretty sure I know the options take a lateral relief back in line relief play from
previous stroke players that lies. But this is not the first time I've seen the players do this. Is this something I'm not aware of? Colin, you are not incorrect. You are absolutely correct. This is not an option. On the 17.1 D you've got stroking distance. If you know that it's gone, you've got your 95% virtual certainty it's in the penalty area. You've got back on the line, relief back on the line, not back on the line of flight. So that's from the whole through. The last edge crossed, last edge crossed in the penalty area,
back on that straight line as far as you want, as long as you're on the course and then the last one. Excuse me, like from the point of entry, so that same last edge crossed 2 club links, no near the whole net, only for a red penalty area, which most penalty areas seem to seem to be red these days. But yeah, line of flight is definitely not. I'm definitely my next community question is definitely going to be like a I'll draw a picture
and it'll be the line of flight is the blue line and the line back on the Line relief is a red line. I go which line and you take back on the line relief and I'll see how many get that wrong. So just on the back of the line as well, you can drop in any area of the course, including another penalty area, except the same penalty area, yes. So when you drop, you've got to be out of that penalty area.
You can actually drop into another penalty area if you so desire. It can be anywhere on the course, any part of the course, just not the same penalty area they bring the. I was trying to work this out once and I sort of had it in my head. So if you take an unplayable, you can basically drop on any part of the course. However, this is where my GIQ ATW for this work is hitting is. That it is, and I'm not gonna spoil it. There's two parts of the course in the relief area. What do you mean it's two?
That's the Is that your gym? So the ball is unplayable. It's right there and we think 2 club lengths laterally by the side. It's right, I see. It's. Lying in one part of the course is another area. I won't. I won't ruin it because it could be 3. It could be right. But when you take an unplayable, you can drop on any part of the course, including the putting green. There's a couple of situations. Can you think of a situation? Unplayable ball in a tree. Ball in a tree overhanging the green. You can actually drop on the green. Yeah, OK, you can drop in any penalty area when taking an
unplayable. You can't take an unplayable in a penalty area and drop in the penalty area, but you can take an unplayable from the general area and drop in a penalty area if you wish, you can drop in a bunker. Taking an unplayable, you can drop in another bunker. You get the point. You can drop anywhere and unplayable. When taking relief from a penalty area, you can drop in as Stuart just said it. You can drop in any part of the course except the same penalty
area. When taking relief free relief, you must stay in the same part of the course, same area of the course, except oh actually when you do the no play zone. So you can for the unplayable and drop in the no play zone. That doesn't mean you get to play from there, but you can drop in that area 1st and then take your relief after that. What isn't getting back to the free relief?
I've asked you that before. I've asked you this. One OK, you answered that. So the question is, when taking free relief, you have to stay in the same area of the course, except I can think of 1 situation. Taking free relief, taking free relief. So if you go, if you take free relief from a bunker, you must stay in the bunker. Is there something to do with the no play zone? Is there something to do with the dangerous animal condition? No, they're all the same.
Well, the dangers there, dangerous animal condition could be it's that could be part of it. OK, we will. I've I've cut the 15 minutes that Stewart was thinking about it for and now I'm going to give him the answer Green. Oh yes, what? Of course, if you have interference from, say,
temporary water on your line of play, the nearest point of relief may actually be off the green, correct? And you? Place it don't throw up. Now this is my question. So this is my further question to this. What happens if there is a snake on the grain on your line of play? Yeah, and won't and it won't go and it won't leave. It's baking in the sun, enjoying it. Yeah, you're let's say you're 20 foot from. Would you consider that a dangerous animal condition?
That's a really good question. So it's clearly interfering with you, right? Clearly. But is it grounds? Because it's an animal, right. So what if you hit it? We replay the stroke. You just keep hitting it. Will that be enough to move it on its way? That's that's interesting. Just because you you go up to it and you, you know you. Try to keep it away. Keep it away. Keep it away and it just doesn't want to move right. It's it's warming up. It's not. It's not a fast. Move in no mood. Move. For some reason it just doesn't want to move. Sure. So at what point does it become it's not dangerous to you, It's
not dangerous. No, no, not yet, no. And you could walk around it to get to the hole, so you have to play your. Shot, Yeah. But I'm saying if you hit it, you have to replay it. Yeah, but you don't get your dangerous animal condition relief to be in place. And then if you say, if you're right on the edge of the green and your nearest point away from the that line was off the green, you'd place it. But you don't. There's no relief option because it's not a game. No, no, that's it. Not a long animal in your way. No, it has to be dangerous.
Has to. You have to actually think it's going to give you physical harm. Yes, a snake could give you physical harm, but not in the current situation that you're in. Once you're over, once you're over the ball, do you think that Snake's going to fire 20 foot? No, no and and current drama. Like no mood to move, it exists when a dangerous animal such as it gives examples. The first one is venom. Snakes near a ball could cause serious physical injury to the player if they had to play the ball as it was. And that snake there is probably
not now. If it's not going to move, then you probably get the pro shop slash committee on the phone. They changed that too. It used to be poisonous snakes. I always I made that, always used to make that make that mistake. And like, no, snakes can't be poisonous, they can only be venomous. Apply my take free relief. It might take relief under rule 16.2 B from interference. Well, now we do have interference because it's interfering with our one of our cats only if it's a dangerous animal.
Yeah, a player may take relief under 16.2 B from any interference by a dangerous animal condition no matter where the ball is, but it's not dangerous when it's 20 foot away. So a player may take from interference by dangerous to animal conditions. It is a dangerous animal, but it's not a dangerous animal condition, correct? Good one. So I'd be hitting it repeatedly with my parts, replaying the stroke every time. Oh, hopefully, yeah. But OK, here's another one. You hit the ball. Yeah, the snake. Yeah, that was a bit loud.
Yes, it hits the snake. Yeah, and the snake doesn't. Move OK, so you put another ball into play. Would you grab that one? Yeah, so that No, that one. So you can replay the shot where you have to. Replay the shot. You have to replay. I'd put another ball. I'd put another ball into play. Because the other one couldn't be easily retrieved, easily recovered. OK, I put another one in play, which means my ball is now not in play. Oh, you got to give me some credit. So that ball's not in play. So it doesn't. It's not going to give you a 2 stroke penalty if you hit it.
So you're going to end up hitting five balls towards a snake to try to move it, and none of them are going to count. Now, if you hit the ball, that's not in play, right? It's an abandoned ball, yes. So you've hit a movable obstruction, so you have to replay. So whether I hit the snake or the ball, it doesn't matter. And replay. And when I've hit it with a tenth time and I've asked you for a couple of spare balls, right. Hopefully that snake gets the hint, but that you know that then you find out. Then we've got 3. Then you find out, yeah, right
now you've got 3 grips on it. Then you find out. You go, you go, You find out the snake's dead. So I could have moved it after all. See, it was never a dangerous animal condition. It was never an animal. Right. No, since it was a loose impediment. Loose impediment. That's why I said you could have moved it, so if it was a loose impediment, you weren't allowed to replay the stroke. You know, it's funny that we can get back. So if you're not allowed to replay the. Stroke. You've had repeated stroke distances.
Yeah, yeah, repeatedly. But you didn't know you were taking stroke and distances. But you have, it's assumed you are. We've had this conversation, certainly I think you do. Well, you don't get lucky because you take a penalty stroke every time and you and the stroke counts now. Maybe it's the wrong place now, isn't it? No, because you've taken stroke and distance because you put it back, but you have to have the. So it's assumed you're taking stroke and distance. This is like when you think you've cancelled the stroke, you put it back. You don't know that the stroke
is not cancelled. It's stroke and distance. It's not wrong place because you're right. It's, I was going to say about loose impediment. Loose impediment's a dead animal, right? Yeah. So that's solution. This is where, you know, Jeff and I were talking about this recently. Sometimes the rules can be relatively straightforward. It's the facts for the heartbeat. Well, that's what he he said to us yesterday. He said the rules are easy but the getting the fact the facts are hard. So, you know, how close do we get to this snake of product to try to move it for someone to go?
You know what? There's no pulse. It's dead. It's not an animal at all. It's now a loose impediment. Well, yeah. Well, you think I don't want to say if you're. Alive or not, you check behind the neck. You know the neck, but you know, so which part's the neck? So, getting the facts, have you ever seen that movie Waterboy? Yes. I don't remember any of it, but this is really tasty. Not part of the, did he say
snake or is it? It was something. What part of the snake? Well, I I didn't know about Pennsylvania. These snakes have parts, but I would say that was the knee. What's your name Web Part? Hey, we should get back to answer Colin's goal. We should answer Colin's question. I think we did that. No, no, because he asked how many penalty strokes and we haven't answered that question. So you absolutely get one penalty stroke for taking relief from the penalty area. And he's done so in a wrong place. So he's going one off the tee.
He's taking the stroke. The 17.1, Yep, that's two. And he's done it. He's dropping in the wrong place and played from there, right? It's. Now on five, now on four and he's hit it. Well, you don't get that wrong place unless you've hit it. So now he's on five. But Collin needs to work out whether it was a sort of the committee needs to work out whether it was a serious breach, so if he's taking a line of flight and he gets to drop it here. Or he's back on a line and he's got to go out and he doesn't
have to go over these trees because he I mean it sound, probably. I would say it would sound like more of a serious breach than not. I mean he's definitely come away from the hole, but compared to where it should have been planned, I always think you know is it more than a two shot penalty considering the distance, probably similar. But so you you could have that argument. Well, you could just chip it out here and then you could put it there and that's about two shots. But you know, considering all
that Bush and, you know, it could be on a night he's on the 9th hole and all that kind of thing it that committee would have to work out whether it was a serious breach. We do know a general penalty. He's a pretty significant penalty. Yeah, 2 stroke penalty is pretty significant and a stale at this level. I mean, he's going to wipe the hole anyway. That's a big stale. But if it was stroke play, yeah. And he's a single figure hand handycam two shots a lot. So we did get there in the end, right GRQOTW number one O 3, that is your, as you said, one job. Only here for one reason. Now I've got to find it.
GRQOTW for episode 103, Big P is playing an individual stroke round at Wombat Hills. His T-shirt on the 15th hole has come to rest in very thick grass near the top of a bunker. BP decides to take unplayable ball relief using lateral relief. There is general area where his ball is lying and the bunker within his relief area. Prior to dropping, BP replaces a divot in the relief area and
then he drops where the ball hits the general area first, but then rolls into the bunker. I'll say that another way. BP replaces a divot in the relief area and then he drops his ball. Where his ball hits the general area first, but then rolls into the bunker. Marcella advises Big P that he needs to drop again as it rolled into another part of the course, but also suggests that he has improved one of his cats. But his second drop, Big P, drops into the bunker, where the ball comes to rest in the relief
area. In the bunker. How must Big P proceed? And are there any penalty strokes? Interesting. Very good. That was episode 103 for the Golf Balls Questions podcast. Thank you very much for coming along and again. Stu, my pleasure and good luck with next week. Thank you. You too.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...