Welcome Onto our guest: Stuart McPhee Let’s start at the start: Explain to the listeners who you are, Trader by day, and desciple of golf Rules by night. How often you actually play golf Twice a week what you do in the golf world, and Dabble with internet Rules education and assisting Blakey in creating Rules videos Most importantly how did you and I become friends Sat through a Level 2 Rules course that Blakey presented and have been asking him questions ever since. What got you into golf, and where did your fascination with the Rules start? Started with playing competitions and having to know everything there was to know, because I was being given the wrong information by multiple people. Okay, now the tough questions: Why are the Rules of Golf important? The benchmark of how the game is to be played, and how best to measure how you played against previous scores and other players scores. What is your least favourite Rule? Advice. I thank you very much for your time, and would you like to read out Episode 52 GRQOTW: Marcela plays her ball from a bunker and her ball comes to rest 5cm from the hole. While Marcela is raking the bunker, and so others can putt out, Fraser asks Marcela if he can mark her ball and then does so. After all others have holed out, Fraser replaces Marcela's ball on its original spot and Marcela holes out. On the next tee Marcela realises that the ball she picked out of the hole was not her ball. Fraser had actually replaced his own ball on the green after having holed out, and Marcela hit the ball Fraser had replaced on the original spot. What is the ruling, is there any penalty to either player?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Personal rules of golf with thrown up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode of the golf rules questions podcast.
Hi everyone. Episode 52 of the golf rules questions podcast is about to happen in my special guest. This week is Stuart. McPhee is already laughing at me because of already Blended up the the start. So, thank you Stuart. How are you going, sir? I'm very well. Thank you. Blackie very well. Very excited to be eating. Thank you. So just a little intro from me first about Stuart, Stuart, and I met doing a rules. He was doing the rules course. Although I always think that I'm
doing the rules course, when I do the workshops because I always learn as much as, as the next person, sitting out there listening to me. But student, I met at a Royals course at Royal Melbourne. Was a student, it was, yeah, yes, which was fantastic. Fantastic venue. Because they've got this little area function area where we could fit about 40 of us. And then they've got a thirty seventh hole at Royal Melbourne, which we walked out to on day
two, and Brian, and myself and possibly the other Brian. Yes, were setting up the Practical sessions and showing everyone saw Some of the new rules of the game which was fantastic. It was just that. What happened on the first day still Well, first, I was a lot of theory. Is that what you're referring to? We certainly didn't step out on the course, very much. The first day, Royal were Sandy
some renovation work. Yes. Royal we're sending their flaws in Readiness for the Presidents Cup that they were to be held in about seven months later. So, There are a lot of headaches in that first day and not much was heard, I had to shout and Brian. And the Brian have to shout it out. Adam was there as well. So that was a bit painful but we got through it and that was where we first met and then everything ever since then Stuart.
You've now you've shown us a pest. It is that it was that too harsh. You've pissed at me for pestered me for had many questions. It's of the rules of golf. I'm not sure. I'm the best one to learn from, but together, we have together, we have definitely learned a lot more, especially with Stewart. If you don't know, helps me out with all the videos that I put up on YouTube, which is just a fantastic resource for everyone out there and I really appreciate all the work that he
does for that. And with that Stewart, I believe you do learn a lot in the process. I think so I think just, you know, do watch a lot of goals and you obviously seen you watch it as well and you send through. Hey, I heard about, you know, Dustin Johnson did this on the 7th hole. Let's go and investigate further and then I'm watching as well. And I see when things are, you know, when there's some rules issue. So I think just seeing those rules situations, all be it.
A lot are very similarly as a lot of free penalty area stuff and the like that seeing So those are all situations and then I have to go to the book. I will go to the book and I'll read word for word, exactly that scenario. So you can't avoid learning learning a little bit more every single incident you see? So it's been incredible over the last 12 months to have done, all those videos research, the commentary that you would say or maybe I've done two or three to research all those and word them all up you know read the rule
book again gives you a reason to go back into that book and just refresh. It's been invaluable and I did pester you absolutely, I did. So that's a great introduction there and think he's Joe and I do I want to find out a little bit more about you. But as always this time of the segment, we have to run through the answer for the previous G RQ. O TW still, you probably remember it off by hand but I don't want to embarrass you if you don't this was asked by Jerry Duffy or was us.
By myself, Jerry Duffy, send it through after we phrase, and I interviewed him so phrase mistakenly and runs over, blakey's ball with his car and beating it. Blakey showing his rules knowledge says, under the embeddable rule, he can drop the ball within one Club length from the relief reference point, which is immediately behind the blow behind the ball was Blakey. Correct, I'm sure. Stuart. This is a different Blakey. The answer is, the answer is no. The definition.
If you didn't read the definition of embeddable. You bought a exactly a ball. Can't be embedded by someone driving over it. So a ball was embedded from a previous stroke and obviously, yeah, so it's just can't be embedded by someone driving over. It's simply a rule whether it's in rule, 9 point 4, or 9 .5 or rule 9.6 situation where the ball Has been moved by either
the player, the cart, or opponent, or an outside influence. Now, Freya, phrases phrases, obviously, not the player. I was the player. If he was my partner, I would get the penalty, unless we were searching for it. If he was my opponent, then he would get the penalty. Unless we were searching for it. And if it Was an outside influence. I another player in a stroke play event and there's no
penalty and I just replace the ball as is the most, as is most cases with a ball that's rolled up. Been rolled over or run over the LIE. Most likely has been altered and so you would place it in the most nearest, most similar lie, Within a club length right? Getting at the GI Q, 0 TW 52 51 out of the way. And we'll hear from number 52 from Stewart at the end of the
show. But yeah. Stuart welcome aboard. The gulf rules questions podcast, you are an avid listener as you are important to the golf rules questions Corporation. Thank you. Thank you tgr. Like you all probably four of us. I'd say, plus plus many many more. I mean, you, you mentioned about you watching Golf and finding a situation or I watch golf and I find the situation a lot of the
time. It's someone that is watching the golf that I know, one of my followers subscribers Etc, and they'll send me something and say, hey what happened here and I'll send it to Stuart and go, Stuart, did you get this? Did you record it? Did you see? Us and he'll go to give me, give me an hour. Give me a day. Give me a week, but I'll get it for you. And really what we're doing is just trying to educate everyone out there as we are educating ourselves. So yeah, really, really
important member of the grq team you are Stewart. So thank you very much Winslow. So what what do you do? Apart from help, me and Makemake. Grq Who is there much better? What do you do yourself? And then, how did you get into golf? Give us a little bit of an explanation on who Stewart. McPhee is your. So work-wise involved in markets financial markets, whether they be stock markets, currency markets, and I trade myself have a retirement fund superannuation
fund but in the last 20 years, I've consulted to countless brokerage firms and companies around the world. In fact, mainly outside of It rather than in just helping them with media work appearing on TV for them representing their brand or doing market analysis, or commentary or staff training or client training. So I've been doing that for a long time. Have a book out on the subject. Yeah. Which what that does though is it gives me a lot of time to do other things that I have a great
interest in. SO trading can be a 12 hours a day job if you want it to be, I never wanted to It to be like that. So that provides me a lot of time which has allowed me to volunteer in a lot of different organizations whether it be my children's school or at golf clubs or helping someone like yourself something I've been interested in. So how did I get into golf? So I had I've only been playing competition golf now for six or seven years, like membership competition gold.
But I had growing up and as a young adult been invited to the occasion or just, Show hit corporate dialogue. There wasn't very many of those I had play golf, but it was like once every 12 months, but I remember just really enjoying it and the like a lot of people in your 20s and 30s. Just, you're busy doing other things like establishing a career and having a family and looking after children and that's sort of a time when a lot of people don't have the time to spend five hours, you know, on a golf course, or at a golf club.
So that was me as well. So I remember driving home after Christmas holidays, once back to Melbourne and were on the road for two days and I just said I'm going to do it. I'm going to go and join a golf club because if I don't do it, it'll never happen. Another things will get in the way. So I just said, when we get home January, I'm just going to go and find a golf club. So when driving around and saw a few clubs in the local area, found one thought it was a lot better than all the others and said about, how do I go and get jointly or join a golf club,
never done it. Before had no idea. And that's the sort of the really the beginning of it and join this golf club and I can keep going. If you want. There's a lot more to this story, but that's where I got into golf was just a bit of social once every 12 months. And then finally going if I don't do make this change and I'll never fly and I every time I played socially or corporate, I just really enjoyed it. I enjoyed the walk, the chat, the surrounds just golf course is going to be some beautiful places and I really enjoyed that. So that's what finally I just
said. No, I'm going to do it. I'm going to join a club and go and play and go enjoy it. So, how often do you play now? It's Joe. So since that time so it was about. So I've been playing comp golf down for six or seven years. I played regularly twice a week, every Wednesday, every Saturday, mornings regularly twice a week. Nice. What's your handicap at the moment? We have to get today's ran and got to 9 point. Something, is that the lowest? No, she don't think it'd be
asking me this. My lowest is early this year. I point something, I'd point 68.5 something like that. Then, of course, we're going to Winter and I guess something that I didn't appreciate it early on was, how fortunate we are that we did. We can actually keep playing, you know, during winter and ensure, it's a bit wet and muddy and cold, but we a lot of places in the world cannot and I didn't realize that until so, I started listening to some of your podcast. I think in learning more about golf around the world is some so, you know, invariably does. And you can't go out during winter in the colder and the
ball, doesn't travel as far and gets caught in the embedded, in the Fairway, more and doesn't run. So it's all happened this year though. You know, the shackles of, you know, office in at a club, you know, Captain the like came off me and all of a sudden you can relax a bit and enjoy your golf a bit more. And sure enough, I've hit my lowest handicap this year. So how did you get a And enjoyment or I just an interest in the rules of golf. Sorry if I just backtrack a little bit so because I've never been a member of a club and I've
never played competition golf. I had this Vision in my head that if you're on the First Tee at a club is like 40 or 50, people standing around waiting to have their turn to tee off and I saw I'm I must have seen a photo of some corporate day and I just saw a 50 people scenery in The First Tee. And I thought I'm not, I'm not remotely interested in being in that person with their ball, on the tee in the team. Are you ready to start a When this 50 people watching it, I do not want that. So I thought, no, I need to become a little bit better golfer.
So, for the first three years of membership, I didn't play any comps. I didn't know any members. I didn't have a handicap. I went out to this course 15 minutes drive away. I went four or five times a week and played nine holes or eight on the. We cannot play 18 holes just hitting off the tee and in the middle of the Fairway, I dropped three golf balls and hit them all to the ground. And then I put it all through and I'll go to the next. I'll do the same thing again, hit. Three balls, two it to you through a par 3. And you know that's that's how that started thinking I'm getting okay at this.
Now admittedly no one's watching but by the third time you know the three balls in the middle of the Fairway. Sure enough. One of them would be okay you know hit the green or something. So I think I'm doing okay it is and so that's where I started in golf and I'd go out there on a Saturday and Sunday afternoon at these courses and all the morning comes are all done. So I have this To myself and I thought this is just yeah, it's a course you. And I played earlier in the year, I'd be out there just beautiful surroundings and I'm the only person within a
kilometer and I'm just playing golf and it was just could not be more relaxing. So I was really enjoying that. And just as I said, just dropping a few balls, keep myself a few gimmes. And I was just enjoying my golf, so then I was at a golf club, the same golf club, which was going through some issues, which is putting it mildly. Just with the way and you know the clock, the way this club was run and just obviously the manager was just having some difficulties in with memberships and and I am a person always
have been. I'd like to think I always will be I'm always willing to put my hand up and just volunteer and help which is obvious obviously why I've come to help you, you know, I just I like helping and being involved in making a contribution. So this club going through some issues. I thought I would like to play my role and I approached the captain and the president at the time and they Yeah, we'd love to help. You know, in any help, we can get David to be great. We'll keep you in mind and towards the end of that year, the elections were coming up for the members committee. And so I thought this is my way of getting formally officially
involved in on the committee and doing my bit and helping out. So I've approached I email I don't remember which order but Ellen and Gregor their names and many people who are going to watch this all know who they are. So I approached one of them individually, both of them individually and said, Elections are coming up for the committee. Would you mind nominating Lee me please? Because I don't know any other members and both them came back to said no. And so it was no because I think you know, I would like you to get start playing in some
competitions, get to know other members. And then I think in due course you absolutely be more than welcome on the committee and I thought, no. Well, I just wanted to help both. These guys have said, no, I don't remember which order. I ask them. First person said I saw went to the other going on. What do I do now? Sure enough, one of them was actually running for captain and so he was going to be vacating his position on the committee. And so one day I'm out there and and there's a resident who lives there, who's a long distant second removed twice, removed
cousin that I not seen in a long time. And so, I got his number or something. I will have to hit something like that. Anyway, there was this vacancy on the committee and I said I'm going to get in there. I'm going to get on to this committee and filled out a nomination form. I got this long distant twice, removed cousin who lived there to sign it to nominate it. Here you are. I'll get my neighbor to S. It do On all civil it for you sure enough. The guy going for captain gets captain gets Club Captain, but the incumbent misses out altogether. Sure enough is an open spot.
I saw try getting don't even have a handicap yet. Don't know any members and now among the members committee, I wouldn't call it a coup, but I in a way, I had a bit of a smirk on my face. I felt great people have said, no, I don't want you on the committee yet, and here I've made my way on the committee, so I'm getting to your question about rules, but for the course, People thought this was hilarious, but I was on the members committee and didn't even have a handicap. So, I think one of the first things, the president said to me, was you need to get a handicap. I'm going.
How do I do know? I'd even do that. Well, you know, you need to submit three cards or five cards or whatever. And sure enough, the captain arranged for my first very first hit for a card with the president. And I went out there with one other guy, Don and had one of the worst rounds of golf I've ever had suffered from stage fright, you know. And Anyway, I put my three cards in started off, 20 years of playing off 20 plus and there's a lot more to that story but I think that's enough for now that I sort of an answer your question about getting involved in the rules of golf.
So to that very question, I knew you could use a tea in the teen area. I knew you had to mark your ball on the green before you picked it up, and I probably knew you couldn't ground your Club in a bucket. You on that? I didn't know a lot. And so now I'm playing regularly and course, and I'm playing with three other guys and they sort of know the rules and they seem to know what they're doing. They seem to know how to drop out of a probably them was Electra water hazard, a red penalty area. They seem to know how to do that. So, I'm now asking questions,
you know, I'm in a bind, I'm in a situation. What do I do? And the real motivation for me and I've told you this before the motivation for me to learn the rules, was when I asked my group. Hey guys, what do I do here? My balls, done this. What do I do? And I will get three different answers, three different answers. And I thought there has to be a better way of doing this. How am I getting? These guys are realize, I've been playing golf for a long time and not getting through, not to the same and the other guy, I'm not sure.
I'm getting three different answers on how I proceed. I thought there has to be a better way. So that was probably my first inkling. Well, there's clearly a demand here where you need to have people who know the rules and these three guys, and I couldn't tell you who they were cause it's probably happened more than once I've got three. Frances, I'm going. There has to be a better way than this. That was probably my first. That was probably, the Catalyst was me finding out then. For sure if that situation
happened, which of those three was correct, if in fact, any of them were correct in their ruling, you know? So that was probably the Catalyst for me learning about. I need to, there needs to be a better way and I'm going to set up out, of course, to learn a bit more. So why didn't you just choose the best option that you thought of it? The time and think it sounds the best. For me I probably did, who knows? But you know, a situation I've often found is that there are some people who think they know the rules, and they probably do reasonably well and they know
all the common situations I sometimes. See when you get three different answers, it's like the person will give you the answer. They're always listening out for the tone of the other potential rulings and how confident they are otherwise. And I think sometimes when they see a lack of confidence in the Winds from the other two that increases their confidence and also some no, no, no. It's definitely you could definitely take a free drop from that and you can proceed and you can do this because they listen to the other two answers and they wouldn't that convincing why they didn't seem like. That was sure of what they were
talking about. Now I feel a bit more confident in my own. So I'm going to say it again, louder. And with more conviction and that'll definitely be how we proceed. So I don't know what I did at the time. I can't think of too many specific situation. Yes, but that was generally. The Catalyst was when you look at people they're doing this, they're going. I don't know what you can do because no one, you know, not many people membership club level proceed under 20.1 C3, and play two balls and a strike plate.
That you just don't see that happening. It probably should have a mall and it doesn't happen a lot. They got anything I've ever seen. Anyone in. All my club membership golf proceed under that rule and it probably should. When was the first time you learned about that rule? Wasn't there when I was getting three different answers, probably I had heard about it before. I did my level 2 course. I'd heard that it was a thing and there, but certainly wasn't in the early days. That's official. So what, what, what year was
this? When you started first started with the competitions? 2016. Okay. So under the previous roles and then what was your process for? Working out how you're going to educate yourself on the rules of girl. Yeah, so I didn't know you at that point, I didn't even know the body you work for at the time, you know, had people there to help Club golfers? Is that, is that so?
Is that because of their amazing marketing program You setting me up a I really can't tell you why. That was the case but I probably just went to. It was definitely my initial was Club level. I had seen other guys these guys who talk with more confidence and louder than the others, I thought these guys know you could just tell they've been in this situation 50 times they know how to take a drop from a from red stakes, do know how to
do this and it. So I went to them and I Of emails in my inbox, you know, sent items of. Hey guys, this situation happened today. I've got no idea. This is how we proceeded, but I still don't know. And then there was a level to go. An experienced guy at the club, so I started pestering him. So this is before I started pestering you. So you know I was badgering him with questions and I was very yeah, he's pretty, he's pretty good with his rules. That's that's a good person to go to. Yes.
So you know who I'm talking about. So but I was very Very, you know, I believe in, you know, with the eyes and ears and mouth, you use them in proportion, right? So you've only got one, mouth your two eyes and two ears. So I was very, very open to I want to learn as much as I can, and when someone says no, you can't proceed that way. You need to do this. I wanted to learn that. And I wanted to do the right thing which is all the whole conversation about why I think rules is important but I can think of some scenarios I wrote down where you know, taking a preferred live, maybe just a mud
rule you know, hand span So we'll car because it's a mod, you know, but on your ball and you know, early days I'd sort of just grab my eye and just drag the ball over a little bit and just put it into that relief area and someone said to me ah no that's not a good look you shouldn't move your ball with your Club. You know you should Mark your ball, pick it up, give it a clean if you want and and place it on you know where you're placing it in the relief area. So I was moving. So I heard that and I thought okay I'm not going to do that ever again. I remember vividly on the Henley course on the sixth day.
Auntie putting a ball that could have easily been lost and I just simply said, guys, I'm going to get another one. And I remember God his name was Bruce and he played off 30-plus and he said, are you playing a provisional? I said, yeah, it's a provisional because no, no, no. You say provisional? And I said I'll do that from now on because I didn't do that. And so there was all these little situations along the way and I think of another one vividly on the 7th hole, it's and Jean, the path 3 and I was
just short of the green On The Fringe. And the guy says, can you mark that it's in my way, only good through there? I said, yeah, no problem. I can do that. Can I ever put a marker off the green? Sure enough. Put a market and pick my ball up and sure enough. I'm doing this and, you know, cleaning it and you know, it's got a bit of mud on it. Dirt on all this would be better for when I put it and afterwards, we're walking. Of hitting Mike, I say about this is Steve you didn't make a scene about it because you can't do that. You market for interference instead you need to do you know what a ball here. He said you need to you know hold it. I always hold it between his finger and the thumb and hold it.
Extend it from your body. So it's obvious so it's obvious to everyone, you're not cleaning it, right? So I thought, perfect, this guy knows what he's talking about. I'm going to do that. So, I was picking up all these things along the way, without any formal training or pestering anyone. This guy says, always say provisional. I always used to start saying provisional, hold your ball out when your market for interference. Always start, I started doing that making relief, you know, I didn't move it with my club, you know? So all these little things I
picked up along the way, I started doing it because I was open to learning how to do things properly. It's quite interesting, actually, the first thing that comes to mind there because a lot of people you know, the first person that they hear from, About what the rules should be or what, the procedure should be is who they believe for life, and then it's very hard to change their mind after that. So, I the amount of times that
I've heard that you must, you must hold the ball between your thumb and forefinger, you know, is I can't even count it on my fingers and toes and probably your fingers and toes as well. Stuart its, there is no rule that says you have known. Of course way. No, no, but but this is the thing though get and and I'm not pointing anything out for your rules knowledge. But did you, did you at any point? Have you ever been tripped up in
that situation? Where someone's told you something and you've gone. Yep. Sweet. And then, you've gone somewhere somewhere else and someone has told you something different. And I don't mean in the group of four and three people had different differing opinions. I mean, someone has told you something and then two weeks later, someone's told you exactly the opposite or slightly different from absolutely, the situation. And then, what do you how do you deal with that? What is your first thing to do once that happens? Yeah, absolutely. That's definitely happened and I've realized what that guy told
me was a right at all. He was he would have stake his life on the fact that it was right. Right? But that's how can, you know, confident? He was. But I have since found out, that wasn't correct at all. So I think that's when you know, this is back in the early days. I hadn't done, you know, level 1 course, I'd known the level to admit, you hadn't done any formal rules training but I was picking up stuff. So I mean no one came to me saying hey it's your what do I do in this situation? That is for certain, right? But but I was just building upon this knowledge and yeah I think I'd go to.
I remember once where I emailed the guy, you know, where I had a situation at provisional Lactaid are thinking. Hey, yeah and I emailed about six people. It was the president the captain Peter was one of them gone, the committee use of been an elite amateur golfer and then that's when I realized that just because you're an elite everything doesn't mean you're not But I would have assumed that this guy plays off plus eggs.
This guy knows the rules. He's an elite golfer with a wealth of experience playing gold playing tournaments playing events. This guy is going to know the rules, that's when I learned. No, no, that's not the case at all. And I'm not saying there's not a lie, amateur golfers, who don't know, the rules. Will what I'm saying is, there's no guarantee that they know the rules at all on. You have far more experience in that than I will. Yeah, I mean I had someone I had someone on Instagram. Tell me that their local Pro said, there's only read penalty areas now.
Anyway, probably said water hazard. You know, there is no such thing as yellow anymore. I was like having you watch the Masters recently. So yeah, that is a lot of courses don't have yellow panel. Here is only half red, but why? And a lot got rid of them, you know, they change the yellow and the Red Witch I'm more than welcome to do but there's still a lot. Have you got any yellow apparently areas at gardeners
run? No. So they're ready to potentially put in a hope. I'm not spilling the beans here but they're considering putting a water feature across one of the holes and I cause I play with and I can't finish this without mentioning our mutual friend Rhea seddon. Who's the captain there are gardeners run? Who's a fellow rules nerd? And I play with regularly and when he talked about that I said, oh, you'll be putting your I States it, he's gone. Yes, I guess we'll have to put your low-stakes it because there are no yellow steaks on. That course, it's quite a few
red but not yellow. And I said, well, why not understanding of yellow steaks or yellow? Penalty area is when the challenge of the hole is actually to go over that water then it should be yellow in Algeria, okay? And even your put, ya can't even think of what hole that is. I don't actually don't answer, don't answer that. Okay, so we don't we Try coming at us and saying magic out. You can't drop bombs about gardeners run on them, gr Q Podcast. Exactly. There's actual him yesterday and
I said, I'll hopefully I'll be going this, this chat with Blakey soon, but the we don't want to spill the beans on anything. There's actually interestingly enough that talking about red peony years where I've just started working Spring Valley. There's a penalty area that's both red and yellow, which I look forward to. Two doing in a video and upcoming videos a red for one hole in your life or another. Yeah it's red for the 12th hole and then it's yellow for the 13th. However you played Springville once.
Yeah it's it's a fantastic course. It's actually a lot of potential there. So beautiful. Mmm are used to fund this. Finish on these rules situations. I used to were just before, without even thinking about it, but one of the best bits of advice I got early on, with all these, Rule situations, certainly when you're playing match play but in any stroke play as well. The guy said to me when you were discussing rules on the Cause right there and there's something happening. Start your sentence with it is my understanding.
In Oregon was one of the best bits of advice. I thought it is. My understanding that you can do that or can take relief or. And this is before I learned the rules, it is my understanding, because what you are saying is not that you are correct, not that they're wrong, it's just what you believe the rule to be and therefore it's very it doesn't offend anybody doesn't put anyone off side, you could be completely wrong. But that's what your understanding that that rule is and I think it's one of the best and I can think Colin for that. That's one of the Best piece of advice I ever got. Was start that with it.
Is my understanding that. Yeah, I like this for like that. Yes, are going. Mmm. I like that. I like to ask questions rather than any, you know, where you and I are working an event soon together which is going to be a lot of fun. The Vic PGA. So we actually have to do this. I think I'll try and get this out before before we go and work that. So we might have to do a Cap on how it went after you. And my brother might be a bit of
an eye-opener for you. I'll tell you what, I'm looking forward to it. My biggest, my biggest tip is just be ready to look at your clock, or your stopwatch every five seconds because that's but that's basically what it is. But then the victory GA is a Pro-Am events. So, you know, you go and tell the pros to hurry up and they'll say, oh, it's the amateurs there. There. Ones that are going soon. So that's always an interesting conversation. But yeah, so we'll be doing that tournament together, which will
be a lot of fun. But yeah, very much looking forward to it. So yeah, but you just don't understand. So there was a stroke around and this guy didn't have a very good day and suffice to say, he's next score was 95. So there were three rules situations yesterday where the first one was on the 7th hole. He's ball was unplayable. He's just because he said, he
looked at the two of us, he didn't know, I knew the rules because I don't like to say. Oh, by the way, guys, you need to say that on the first be, by the way, guys, if you have any questions, just ask me today. I'm more than happy to help, but he straightaway on the 7 is gone. I'll look, I need to take an unplayable. What can I do again? And I've just gone without even thinking, I said you've got three options, go back to the tee, take literally two Club lengths or go back on the line. 19.2 are interested not just straight away right away. I know he's only interested in the role model but I just
straight away new. Be your three options under unplayable you then on the 17th hole just to rub salt in the wound. Having absolute horrible day hits a wrong ball out of the rough. And seized his original goal, literally a meter away. So this one is had it about in the Fairway and then he said this other one out I think he's just put two balls from the rough and he's walked out into the Fairway. Guys, are I hit her on wall? What's the penalty? So again, rather no, it's my understanding. I've just gone straight away. Any Strokes at the wrong ball.
Don't care. There's a two-stroke penalty. General penalty, your now, lying, full rule six point three. If you're interested and go, and go and go and go and pick up the other person's ball and take it back. So that to me is I love, you know, you asked about motivation, what got me interested in the rules, I'm probably really still haven't answered that. It's a fast forward, I love being in that position. When the guy goes, what do I do? If not pliable, what do I do for a rolling ball? And we all just looking at each other doing this, you know, I
was there some other guy close to within ask, you know I'd love just in my small group being able to say no, this is exactly your options are at. This is exactly what the penalty use and knowing any obviously, common more common scenarios. But I love personally being in that position where I know exactly what the answer is. I know exactly what the ruling is and I can help just right away. Speed. Apply is always an issue, just straight away. Telemann, let's move on. As opposed to, it's my understanding, you know, which was very, very appropriate at the time and was a very useful
way of having that conversation. But now I love just being in a position where I know what the ruling is. Mmm, very good, very good. Have you ever had someone disagree with you? When you know, and I'm not talking about our videos. Not that, I can think of no. No, I think, you know, I said this to someone the other day about doing the level 2 Port. So that's where you and I first
met and you talked about learning stuff on their course, you didn't learn that. Much on that course. You stood up there delivered your little segments on rule Aid or will Tina, whatever you got up and and one of the things that impressed me on that course and what was it about 30 on that course. And now I vividly remember all the noise going on in the room next door. Fortunately they weren't doing all that work in our knows he's next door but it was still pretty loud. But I But and you remember, these have any questions I asked. You remember where I said, you know, I set right next to the projector right at the front row
in the center because that's I wanted to be front and center and ask lots of questions. But what impressed me on that day was, I was asking lots of questions that weren't covered, but they were related to that rule. And what impressed me the most was if you didn't know the answer, you had it within a minute. Because you knew exactly where to look. And I that really impressed me that that's the beauty of knowing, you know, rules one through 24 and knowing what each of those ones are and knowing that, you know, 14.7 is that or
fourteen point two is that and knowing exactly how quickly you can go there but one of the things about level do cause was and I didn't appreciate this at the time. I go back into clubland having just done a level to cause and I had a pretty good school and I go back in almost with a bit of a hit wobble, you know, almost a bit of a spring in my step. that I now know the rules better than almost anyone else at the club and I'm Dare I say two rules Guru because I just did the level two pools and you don't appreciate at the time, how
little you still do. You know how little you actually know and how much more there is still to know beyond that level 2 course and the level true cause is a very thorough course, the exam is not easy. If you've never done rules before and but you go back thinking, I don't need to know anymore, you know that you qualify, you know? But that's I think it's very, would be very easy for someone to walk into a And go, I'm sit, I guys got your rules questions. I'm here, you know, I'll be happy to help. Not realizing how little you do know, relative to how much they
re still to know. And it's only if you commit to learning more and more and more. Do you actually now start to open up? Wow, there's just so much more to learn that I actually didn't realize when I did my level 2 course and walk out with my blue ribbon and thought on your door. Yeah, I mean, it's called the dunning-kruger effect, you know, I know you and I I spoke. It's my favorite chart in the whole world where you think you're an expert before you.
Really research and topic. Then once you start researching your topic, you realize how little you know, and then over a long period of time you work out, you know what the actual answers are. And the funny thing about that is then they go and change the rules in the book and you've got to relearn them all over again. I think just if I say that point again, about how much I didn't know, was when you and I met up for a coffee or something last year or something, and I was
Captain at this golf club and the 10th hole on us and John course has a yellow penalty area, just before the green you, and I did a video just before the group and there was a lot of grass and a lot of Earth within the confines of that yellow penalty area. So your ball could be in the yellow penalty area and very hittable, still. But on the green side, and Said to you as a time saving measure, it would be great if your ball goes in the yellow penalty area but still a long way away. And you can't see where it's playable or not, it'll be great because it's a yellow penalty
area. You've got to come back to the other side of the water, be great to be able to play a provisional to Simply Save time because if you walk around, the bridge come across or the green look in the yellow penalty Ringo. Well, I can't find it or I can find it but I'm not going to go to hit that but now I know I can't hit it. I'll hang on. What's my relief? Options or previous Place. Played or back on the line. Oh, not going to go all the way back across that bridge all the way back to the Fairway and I simply asked you as a time saving measure because we know you can't even provisional when your balls in the penalty area.
Could you adopt something would allow you to have that option on that whole. For example, now before I finish answering the question, you had already flipped through your phone here, I'm thinking asking your girlfriend to bail you out with a phone call or something, you know, and you're flicking through your phone through the app. And Gandhi go. There's the model local. You can use be well, I haven't even finished answering the question asking the question. And you worry found the answer and I saw that as well. That's the standard, you know, Here I Am My Level 2 course and but no, there's just so much
more. What about all the model local rules? Or the committee procedures, you know, all those things, and you knew that straight away. And I haven't even finished asking the question and you knew. And you immediately said to me, I don't like it as a local rule, but it is options. Available to you, right? It's true. I hated that and I put I thought that was a standard. I thought wouldn't it be great? There's just so much more you could learn and know about the rules beyond that level 2 course. Well as that's B B3 B1 nothing
is B3. I didn't mean to put you on the spot about it. Well, I should know it off by heart but you know there's some there's some that I just get tripped up on like I It's just the number its base 397. No D7. Very well know you lent now on now, because of that role on the European to US. But obviously, but yeah B3. Yeah. The playing a provisional with people's gone but it's only a local rule. Yeah but there's a cup there's a couple that you know like you always know like E5 is that new?
Local rule for stroke and distance that I hate as well. F5 is professional. No, it's sprinkler heads near the green. If E3 is preferred leise to is cleaning ball and E1 as drop things owns. But anyway and like you know it's a great point. You make you just keep you just we keep just keep learning you know, how many times could I say. Keep we just keep learning the rules of golf and I keep
learning and And you know, as I said, then you learn it and then they slightly change its, it's an ongoing process and ongoing passion can be a job for some you like giving other people technical knowledge, you know, educating them, that's your, that's what you do for a living. And now you're just wanting your pet really passionate about educating people on a sport that
you absolutely love. It's it's really interesting, you know, pay to who talked about. You know, one of the good things that makes him a really good rules person. Referee is that he if he doesn't know or he's not sure who ask us or ask someone higher than him, someone who he thinks knows the rules better than him. And this is an important thing that what you're really doing is you're asking someone who has a little bit more experience than
you is usually the case. But that doesn't mean that person should necessarily know, the rule better than you. I've said before that, some of the players on the European tour and the PGA Tour will know some of the most strangest rules situations that you'll come across and then they won't know the most basic. Common rose that you'll come across because they've been involved in that strange rolling there, but the common ones, they just, you know, their brain is
just thinking about the shot rather than remembering that you can take a drop off the path, and then you're not allowed to be standing on it. When you, after you wanting, when you wanting to take, make that shot or whatever, you got to take complete relief, is what I'm trying to say. But you know what, that's one of the things that makes Referees or just people interested in the rules better or good is because they actually know what, they don't know. They're unsure when they're 95%. Sure.
They still have this five percent uninsured. Miss not a word is over there. But You know, they do ask someone that they believe should know. And so if people ask me and I hundred, you know, if I've got this any element of doubt. And so you ask me questions. If I've got an element of doubt, I will ask someone else. I can't, I can't be giving you wrong information and so if someone you know, unplayable balls and it is a good one
because we all should know that one and it's easy, it's just back to the last place by, just what you said, you know, last place, playback online to clubbing. So, that's an easy one. You know wrong bowl will be a few people that wouldn't know wrong balls. So the fact that you can, you know, rain that off, that's easy for that person. You've helped them out but when you've got one like an incorrectly substitutable, might be a little bit more difficult for some people and so they might need to even me might need to either refer to the rule book
or ask someone that they know knows it better than them. So one thing I learned having done the course and then beyond that is I strongly believe that if you do not keep up with the rules and maintain your knowledge and keep on top of them, you lose it very very quickly, you lose that knowledge, very quickly. I strongly believe that if you've done the level 2 course four years ago and I've done nothing since Then I just don't think you absolutely must keep
at it and you must maintain it. Not only grow your knowledge and develop them. But you've got to at least maintain it which is why as nerdy as it is, you know, ideal rules because every day it's just that repetitive repetitive just in your head. You know what the definition of a wrong wall is what a imply means? What immovable obstruction is, whatever. It might be, whatever the definition is he I strongly believe that you've just got to. Kick that it which is why I did. And why how you and I eventually got to doing this together was
here. I am wanting to learn more. I might have sent you a question about something you've got to use a video. I've done it. I've gone didn't even know this existed, you know. So I started watching more and more videos. I'll put it in my weekly to do it. So I'm gonna go and check out what other videos you've done. Then you start doing the podcast and you remember this, but I'm one of those podcasts. You said I might need some assistance doing some video work. Getting situations and I'm sure you were after some first year university student to come along and help you. But I've contacted you said, that's what I'd like to help.
You know, I'm really passionate about this. I want to help you. And I remember having a chat with you and Ross and as I said, you're probably wanting to speak to some nineteen-year-old with limited rules knowledge, but just would do all the videos stuff for you. And I put my hand up because why? Because I had a real interest and passion for continuing to learn Learn and get better. And yeah, learn what I sort of discover what how much I still didn't know? That's what I wanted to do. So we we've talked about, you know, the important like how we've got into the rules and,
you know, the some of the situations but really what it all comes back to his one question. And I want to put that to you. Why do you think the rules of golf are so important? To answer that question, I'll start with something else. 10K actually can I can I just ask this? Because you and I have chatted and I just I just know that you may have played with some people along the way. They couldn't give two Hoots about the rules of golf and they get, they turn up every week and
they still play their game. So why do you think it matters? What do you think the rules of golf or so important? And how do you think some people like those people are able to ignore it? First thing I'll say is, you know, you held your book up before. He's my official guide here and it's just checked it the other day. It's like 500 plus pages. And one of the things I find fascinating about the game of golf, is that it might be one of the most complex set of rules
for any game in existence. I'm not saying it's hard to officiate, I think there are other games that are very difficult to officiate, but so far as a complicated set of rules, I think golf is right up there. There and I think many would agree with it. And what I find fascinating is as complicated as the rules. Are we expect individuals to be self officiating? So we don't even, we expect players to officiate themselves in one of the most complicated set of rules, you'll come across. And I find, I don't know if that's a definition of irony, but I just find that
fascinating. But yes, this is a really complicated pork and is so much in there. And by the way, we need you to officiate yourselves, I'll find that fascinating as a concept that but we expect all these players to know the rules, but coming back to your question. I think it's very much in my nature, one. I think, you know, my have a military background, somewhere graduate of duntroon Royal Military college. So I was an army officer, long time and in the mill in a
military environment, you know, attention to detail, is critical attention to detail, attention to details, attention to detail is important because the consequences can be quite severe. And we have been true dramatic. They can be fatal, right? So attention to details, really, really important. So, let's what the rules are about. It's a very precise are very precisely, but there's very few areas that are open to interpretation. There's some, but not many, they're very precisely written. I believe, if you're going to do something, do it, right? And so, I firmly believe that, I
my personal Nate, my personal or my nature is very, I see things very literal. And I don't think this is necessarily a good thing because I think there's a lot of things in life that are not black and white but I do see things very black and white and very literal I take things very literally and I think in the rules of golf black and white is a good thing because I think being precise is a good thing. Why is it important? I just think it's going to do it, do it, right? And if you get to play golf and
put in a little bit of money and have competition and prizes at the end, then, you know, you could say this better than me, but there's an expectation that, you know, you got to protect the field. Everybody else is expecting you to play by those same set of rules when you're in a calm. And of course you. And I've also said before, if you're playing, social Gulf, do whatever you damn, well, please, I don't care what you do. But soon as you're in a competition and others are playing in on that, I'm course sighing. You know, there's the same set of rules there is an expectation that everyone else is playing by the same set of rules. And I don't know if you wanted
to talk about this but as Club captain that I thought I took that as very much a very important responsibility of mine is we're going to run golf competitions all the time? Well I think they need to be run correctly and they need to be done with integrity and you have an expectation that every player in that feel, whether it be 20 or 220, you expect them all to play by the rules but I think it all comes. It's down to my if you're gonna do something, do it right? Let's all do it properly and that's just again, I'm very black and white, that's how I see it.
If you're going to play, if you don't play golf in a competition, do it right? Do it properly like that. I mean for me you know golf is the set of boundaries and as weird as some of the rules might be if you play Within those boundaries on this course that cause that cause then you can compare your scores. So One. It's the person you know, your personal best because golf is always You're trying to beat your personal best and then to I think you hit the nail on the head that if you are, if it's
going to affect, if your result is going to affect someone else, then you have to play by the exact same exact same rules. So yeah, I really like the way you've explained that there Just on that. If I may that that was one of the challenges I had as Captain was if you ever had a rule situation and you confronted someone or were discussing a situation, how often you would get the expression of our come
on made, we're not playing for shape stations. How often you would hear that? Aw come on. We're just Edith ever hit. We're just ready to enjoy our goal. And that was always, that was always the full bag of. Why are you taking it? So seriously, you know why? And I could tell you, numerous situations that I've specific situations, where was I? Come on, we're not playing for sheep stations and I we do know that you are playing for something. What about the other day competition? You're in a competition. You know, don't give me the
Sheep's. Nations routine. The other day is anybody else expect you to play by the rules the other day? You and I were playing it Yeldon and we filmed some fantastic videos there and I think we're on the eighth hole and I hit my ball way left. I actually run the 7th hole, hit my ball left, lost it when back to the T and then we found it after it hit my oh yes I remember that was horrible. Anyway, the 8th hole. Yeah. Thanks.
Well the match. So yeah. Good one on the A on the 8th hole hit left as well. Nearly killed. Those people that they were doing some work on that. And cause and we walked up there and my ball was plugged in. The GU are yes because it was a hole dug by a green. Keep even missing piece of Earth moved. Yeah, even though it wasn't wasn't Mark, so that was fun. And in the time that you're
explaining to them that I did something in the rules, I would took a drop, I took a drop from that GE you are, and then I go, oh no! I'm going to take a drop now from the wrong, the wrong room, putting green, and then you you sort of moved away to go to your ball because now that I've found my book cetera and that the couple Who would lovely couple doing some work on the course, as lot of country courses, have,
you know, volunteer greenkeepers Etc. And I sort of had a chat to them at while you were over there on the other side playing your ball and they said, oh, you know, we we don't know. It's I hope you've enjoyed the old and I guess. Yeah, it's lovely. It's fantastic. You know, we don't really play for sheep stations up here. I just I didn't mean to I mean to tell you the time because I couldn't believe it was exactly one of your quotes I was like yeah, just just crowded the oh
don't play fish eat stations of here while. I mean, what rules do you play by? Then? If you're, you know, is everyone doing the same thing or not? Exactly. And I remember, when I had done the rules cause then become Club Captain. Someone said to me, I said, don't be that person where other people don't want to play with. Don't be that person. And I was very, very mindful of that as Club Captain. I actually sort out to play with
as many different members as I could, so I actually would arrange games two or three weeks in advance, and I booked us all in and I just as a way of meeting other members. But he said to me, don't become that person where people don't want to play with you, and I was very, very mindful that, I remember vividly a situation where This very same yellow penalty area, on some John tent pole balls gone in the water. Just kept Lunker's, not officially certain, it's in me in the water and yellow penalty area and this guy who's been
playing golf longer than I've been alive. And knows the rules very well and is definitely mean a principles and he just dropped his ball. It would be closer to the yellow penalty area from where of just play, but just dropped it in the Fairway and I thought he is not playing anywhere. Year where he should be playing this ball from right now. I'm not going to pin the 14.7. I'm going to say something. So I never wanted to be that person were of, you know, you can't do that. What are you doing? You know, except I never wanted to take that attitude. So I simply as politely as I
could said, excuse me X, do you mind if I ask why you are playing from there, please? And he goes I will because the ball went in the you know, the ball in the water and I said that's fine, assume using back on the line. Look where the flagstick is identify your point of entry. You bought, you should be actually playing from 20 meters away, like, way over here on the, in the rough. Just simple drawing a line you guys are okay. So he fixes ball up and walked over there. And I could see probably wasn't particularly happy with the fact
that I just pulled him up, given that he's played golf longer than I've been alive. But I just Could not protecting the field. Could not in good conscience Club, Captain knowing the rules, allowing the play from the Fairway, given that he wasn't anywhere near where he should think like them. And so, of course, he drops over in the rough and somewhere else. Chimes, you know, you should be going back this way. You know, there's we went in and that's where the flag is over there, any? So, sure enough. He drops in next one, goes in the water. And now his wife, the hole, and then all of a sudden, I just get this feeling on the bag on, you
know, why did I even bother saying something? Yeah, he's just out there to enjoy his golf. We're just here to have a good time, you know, we're not playing for sheep stations, but here I am saying, well, I didn't say you can't play from the, I just see. Sorry, can I just ask why you are playing from me? I thought was a less offensive less confronting way of establishing the facts, you know. So and it guess what? I think he was a very person who months Don't be that guy who people don't wanna play with, you know, that was him, you know. And I could just sense that he wasn't happy because he said for
the other ball in the water and I felt like I was a bad guy and I think sometimes with the rules and at Club level you are often can be seen as a bad guy, but you shouldn't meet a bad guy, you know, but you can't help feel that way and I don't think that's fair or right, but I think that can very much happen. There's a couple other situations I could go through where I was definitely the bad guy not sure. In the room but but I think is certainly as Captain and then knowing the rules, I think you need to protect everyone in the competition. You need to ensure the Integrity
of the competition which is why I think rules are so important if you do it right do it right? Hmm. Yeah I mean you'll be stationed. So Bobby Jones, great quote about that. You know rewarding someone for playing by the rules as same as rewarding someone for not robbing a bank. Very much rings true in a situation like that. I'm sure Stewart and man of his principles like that was more disgusted at himself for being
wrong. Then he was that you pulled them up or he's disgusted himself for being pulled up by you in the fact that he should have just done it correctly the first time. So I'm sure he didn't hold anything against you. Other than Well, it was another situation on that, very same hole with that very same player involving that same yellow penalty area where you actually did play another ball from his previous Place, plays in the middle of the Fairway and then found his ball and yellow penalty area and looked at me sending on the other side of the
ring and I play this and I just instinctively said well you've just you've already put another ball in play. Is all well, I didn't know if I've got to play this or not and I'm going to put another balloon fly. Like did you even attempt to say provisional even though you could, you even, even make the inkling that this was going to be a provisional ball? Oh, you can't eat a provisional ball when it's in a penalty here. I said, yeah. And so this conversation is going from one side of the green to the other and came at the penalty area and that's when I got from someone else, the old
I'll come right, you know. Come on, not playing for I don't think he definitely didn't use the word sheep stations, but it was all come on. We're just out here to enjoy golf. No, I don't know. I felt like the bad guy. I mean I didn't even get into the conversation until he asked me. I cannot play this. I've just found it. I said well the answer is you put another ball in play from the previous Place playing. So you know it's like it's no it's not. It's like it's not permissible for us to enjoy a golf by playing within the rules a
little bit and I definitely win the other guy got involved are. Well, we're just headed by then. Felt like the bad guy didn't even get myself into the situation until he asked me the question and all of a sudden I, you know, I was doing whatever with my part or whatever and I look over and he's got this ball at his fan in the middle and just slam His heart is put into the water and I'm not someone like, oh, what did he want to punch me instead but it decided to throw the ball in the penalty area. Oh well, it wasn't his ball anyway so we just thought. Well let's see it you know and here it wasn't his ball. Did he fail?
Sure. Sure. Just let him just let him play it for wrong. But as I said you know I didn't even get myself involved in that situation until he asked me the question and I gave the answer and what was I going to give him a different answer year? Go for it. No, we don't like the Chiefs Asians, whatever you want to do, you know? I was never going to say that. Do you do you see? Do you see any development in the rules especially since 2023? They've touted, you know, fixing up a few of the holes in the rules of golf. Do you see any possible
developments in 2023 or Beyond? You know, personally I have seen a lot of Technology come into golf in the last 10 years which is just Technology comes in lot quicker than they can change the rules and they have to sort of make something up at the time. But for you, Pat for you, how have you seen the development and how do you think it'll go going forward? I really don't know, going forward. I'm probably not in a great position to.
I mean, you would have more visibility, know about that more than I would, and I do believe that I was so very beneficial for me to not really have learnt, the rules until 1190 And I really didn't know much about the rules before that, except your Market ball on the ground and use the team, the team here if you want. So, I was very fortunate. So, you know why, I'm always almost look forward to that 2023 as being a little bit anxious about it in that I've done so much work on the rules. Certainly, the last 12 to 18 months, I've done daily, work on the rules.
I'm always looking forward to. Wow, that's all going to become undone. You know, I'm glued and normal it, so they have to go back to square one. Hopefully you can tell me that's not the case. Case. But I'm probably not. I mean, I know there's a few rules. I wouldn't mind changed and I know sometimes you've asked some of your guests about those, I'll probably not one to talk about technology and what may happen in the rules. I'll probably don't keep an eye on or not probably just wait like everyone else and and see what I have to relearn or learn new stuff and hopefully not have to throw everything in the
office lured away. Do you have at least favorite rule? I, you know, I've spoken about advice and knows him only, you know, 10.2 because I think it's one of those rules that can be a little bit subjective. You know, it's an action or comment or whatever with the intention of influencing someone. In the way they play a whole place stroke or whatever. And I think that can be open to interpretation. So I don't like that too much. As I think your opinion is, you
should go to say whatever you want. The person still needed needs to execute the stroke. You know, if you find out What someone else hates you still need to hit the ball with. You know, I don't hit it for you, least favorite. I'd like one of the things I wouldn't mind changing is the dropping from the height because, you know, we've gone from shoulder to me, the drop, obviously still maintains the randomness. And we're comes to rest what I do. Not most of the people I play with the older than me and
they're not as flexible as they used to be. And what I often see is people bending. Down with a little bit of difficulty to drop from knee height. And what they don't know is when they are bending down, actually Bend at the knees. So by the time they get their ball gown to their need, the knee is not at knee height. When you're standing, it's actually now lower than what, you know, you can picture it right, someone bending over slowly and then these now no longer at knee height but they still get their borders and even drop it. So it's actually just an awkward and I reckon this should be a compromise. I reckon you would if you dropped it from the hip, for
example, I think that would be better. That's you know that's one of the least important things that should be changed but I just I think dropping from the hip would be very, very easy for anybody. It's literally just don't have to do anything, you just put your hip and drop it. I just see the knee cause a few issues of your the knee gets lower and lower. As the person bends down to get to their knee, their lower movie, they need moves lower and lower. There's two other rules. I wouldn't mind being changed. One is definitely from the book of unpopular opinions.
Most definitely And another one, which is probably a bit more obscure, I believe a player should must so I don't shoot must Mark table, that's what I believe. I think the play, every player must mark their ball with some personal markings. I think it would avoid a few issues, certainly a match play. The whole story of you're going to interject is this going to say you mean? Put an identification mark on it. Rather. Thank you. Yes. Rather than Tom Gotcha behind
your bull. No, no, sorry not mocking, but let me department is putting a personal identification. Mark on your ball. I think that should be a must. I think that would avoid a lot of issues certainly in match play, you know. I found it in the long run. That's my title is 3. And your opponent goes. How do you know what your title is? Sorry. Well, there's no, no, no, I don't know if it's yours or you know, that just that simple thing. You know, I'm Marco. My balls are thoughtless one. I think that should. I think that should be a must, for example, I think that would
avoid some issues, my rule. And I know you don't agree with this, but I, this is from the book of unpopular opinions, but I believe you should get free relief for a divot in on closely known. I think I saying filled divot even if it's not same field, I think is literally the definition of ground under repair, literally the definition and I think if you get to still drop it, you don't place it. If you get to drop it, 30 centimeters to the left, no
nearer. The whole from where your ball came to rest in the middle of the Fairway, when you're still under 90 meters out, I don't know what advantage that gives you like you're still hitting it from, you know, and it's your ball was just like this. Far away and it just takes away that it's a bit of a dis. I mean we have all 16 right. 16.1 is abnormal course, conditions we have that rule for a reason and that is it's not part of the challenge of playing golf. Well we have animal holes and Grant under a pier and a movable structures and temporary water. So I think divots is almost a grand on a repair and you could
put forward the I'll have, you know, over to do it or not. Well what does it matter if you move your wall 5 cm but you still dropping it, you don't place it. What's the difference if you still work 300 meters to the hole? So that's from the book of unpopular opinions. I just think it would make it. And, you know, that rules probably been you can't get relief from that. Probably, since going was the game was invented, right? So it's a tradition, it's one of those rules, but just because it's a tradition, doesn't mean it's a good idea. You know, week one of putting
the rules together, someone modest, and that's a stupid idea. Why don't you leave from a sin forgiven, you know, but it's been like that for a long time. I get that, I just think that is just a bit. I mean, you could, you could throw a few runners in that same bracket of, you know, Funk is not right. And I know it's the Rubber, the green and all that, but I just think, you know, well playing for Sleep stations, you know, you're out there, enjoy your golf, so I think Jerry last last podcast 51 mentioned that the ruling bodies are an A in USGA
when they got together. They talked for talked about sand-filled divot sore, divots in general, and a ball coming to rest in them and they spoke for 25 minutes on the topic and ended up with where it is now. So they had no intention of they were trying to find a way to change it possibly. But they just said, how do you define a Divots. And you know, you're more than welcome to your opinion Stewart probably a lot probably the last time you'll be on the podcast. But no, no, no, yeah, I have no issue with you with the opinion
and many people share, it, probably more people share at the, not sure, but I'm one of the rear ones. That really likes wherever the ball comes to rest. And is I've said to many Well, I'd prefer it if we didn't get so many freak drops. So in my mind, you could almost do away with 16 and I met. Yeah, and I mean the whole 16, I mean, 16 1 2 & 3, it's right and well maybe not 16.4. So 2016 point to thank in the bunker.
Yes. Yep, unplayable and pliable. So, yeah, it's just just bad luck and that's, that's the game of golf. But anyway, that's I'm extremists from. And so you're more than welcome to your opinion but you know if it did, you know, you mention it earlier, if it did change to it, I'd play by that rule. If the rule was that you could then now take a drop from a
divot in the Fairway only I would play by it, so there's like on principle. You wouldn't you wouldn't take free relief? You wouldn't be comfortable doing that on principle. Desk. That's true. It's true. No, no, no, that's not true. I do move with the times, whatever the rules are. It's so much in the job that I previously had whatever the rules are, is so much easier even if you disagree with them. It's so much easier to point someone back to. This is what the rules.
Are you have to play by this? I don't make the rules so much easier to play that way. Then it To say. Yeah, well, they're thinking about changing it a life, it was my idea. I would slide to change it so I'll give you a free. Drop. Mmm. But anyway, I I think that's it's been, it's been a really good chat we. I don't know if we talked too much about your captaincy at the
Heritage. Did you want to have you got any really ripping stories that you'd like to share about that? Well, yeah. You shared a couple about the whole tenets and Jones and then you had 16 in which is pretty good. It was one situation which wasn't overly Pleasant. We're over on the Henley course, there was a guy who very good, very good golfer plays off scratch or one or thereabouts, and he was over on the 18th green, having a putt before his round and sure enough.
He eventually a nose on the first two about to play and sure enough, he walks around back onto the First Tee and there's only thing Over there is yo don't great and you sort of knew what he was doing anyway. He's got back to the First Tee and a former Captain knowing the rule and this guy knows them all true. But knowing the rule the captain said, what are you doing? And the other guys, responsible other people do it and having a practice, but other people do and he said, give it all. You can see the other people I saw you. And I'm standing there listening to all this. I know, I know what the rule is
and I know what the penalty is. 5.2 off the top, my head. And I thought, ah, fortunately, I have a committee meeting this afternoon, not so long after I finish my round perfect timing for me to not make a scene. It's the last thing I do, I'm there to enjoy my golf, too. I don't have an altercation here before I start my round. I've got a committee meeting, we'll talk about it, I'll get their blessing. The comp wouldn't have closed. Will adjust the score. Apply the penalty for the first hole and and let him know, right
that Decision had been made by that match Community, perfect timing that I've got a community community. So off I go, I bring it to the attention of the committee or guys while the way before I take off this morning I wanted to let you know about a situation. I saw this happened. The guy was practicing on the Iron. Throne came over the captain asked inform Captain look I want to just have a vote to penalizing just to get your blessing. There's six of us. I'll abstain from voting. Make it a dog number and can you vote please to be penalizing or not.
I knew what the answer would be, right new, it's pretty clear rule on you, what the vote would be. So sure enough, the vote was five. Neil final pretty obvious. Unfortunately, that vote of five mill was to not penalize that player. I'm sitting there speechless. And this room included, you know, for what it's worth. The professional opinion player, another guy lady who held a key role and another referee,
another sorry more experience level to guiding me and the Volvo 25 mil. No penalty and I'm going. You don't have to explain that story correctly, if I miss something out. So instead of I think I've been grabbed this book, which I always took the meetings just to look important and I would take this and I said, can you just let me know? What are the other rules? Are we not going to enforce his? Let me know the other ones we're not prepared to stand by and you know back And of course crickets
you know the meaning just when soil but 20 seconds. Well, okay, I was riding the minutes. I'm gonna okay vote, no penalty. Unfortunately, I then heard from multiple sources so that particular player in drinks afterwards was saying, well the club Captain's Order, didn't do anything about it and I'm going, I'm sorry, I'm not going to let that fly. I've really pride myself on studying the rules, hard running competitions with integrity If
it was my way, there's no way he would have got away. I'm penalized. So I heard that it was all the captains or it didn't do anything. I'm going now. Sorry. So I then wrote to him actually contacted you in your previous role and I, and you said use the word disappointing. You probably had another adjective. You said that, I find that really disappointing that your committee voted that way. So I wrote to him and explained I didn't vote, it was my way, I can't they voted five mil to not penalize and I basically said to him, if you do it again, I'll be
adopting the committee of one approach and that is I want to go to the committee. I'll just I'll need to ensure the integrity and competitions and make sure competitions run fairly and properly. I'll be adopting the committee of one and I'll be applying the penalty myself and I'll go straight to the operations team and I'll say this is what's happened. Apply the penalty. That's what's gonna happen next time. I said that to him and that, that all that me a little bit because I felt like, I had been let down by the committee to be perfectly open with you and I felt like not my role to as
well. But the committee to ensure competitions and stuff run properly and I was really surprised that was a five mil vote. Actually, I wasn't surprised, I was surprised with the result of that 5 Novo and I just said, you know, I'll adopt the committee of one it's time so that can be a situation that a captain can be In where you have to be this person who uphold standards and upholds, the rules and upholds integrity of competitions. And I'm not ashamed to admit that not so long.
After that there was a shotgun competition. There were two other players. Who absolutely did not know the rule right there on the first green because I was hanging off on the second, some distance away, they'll having a little practice but in there five minutes before they tea time on the first hole. And I wrote to both of them and they both came back quite genuinely sit. All apologies, sorry, I didn't know that was a rule, please adjust my score, please put the panel deal. And I've gone, you know what, he's a genuine mistake and you could argue that the second team was close enough to the first
green to, you know, to be an exception but they were genuinely. Sorry, please adjust my score accordingly. Please put the penalty on and I said, now let's use this as education and I just saw that situation differently as opposed to someone who's just stubbornly saying. No. I know it's wrong, but other people do it. So what you gonna do about it? And I didn't like that. And I suppose the captain is, you know, it can be With situations like that where you need to maintain the standards and ensure the Integrity of competitions and if you become mr. Bad guy or mr.
Unpopular. Then so be it that can be a challenge as I see, that's pretty interesting. What do you mean by the seven green? You could argue that the second green is very close to Second a story second table. So close to all areas screen. Yeah, you're allowed to practice near the either. Tell you the first time All. Sorry they first told that I was the second hole so technically you know so they were allowed to
practice around the second T so if the first green was within x m and I don't there's a certainly not mentioned in the book but if the first green where they were practice putting was reasonably close to the second T they could make the argument that I was practicing near the second T. My First Tee of the day. How far as a captain how far would you say near how far would say mere is? This is certain in this is, come on, answer the question, but this comes back to me being, I love precision and I love black
and white and you know, the word reasonable is used a lot in the rules and one version, you know, one person's opinion of reasonable may be very different to someone else's and I don't like that ambiguity. I don't like that subjectivity in the rules. Because it's not very common in the rules where there is some open to interpretation. You think that might be why? I didn't know that speaking. I think I think reasonable and Common Sense a very similar comment come and sit come and since the funny thing about common sense is it's not that common so common exactly.
So if you were to pin me down and say what's a m, you know, how far I could that first brain be from the second tea. I'm thinking low numbers, I'm thinking, 10, 20, 30, 40, maybe under 50 meters. Wow, probably 50 is too far. You know? Yeah, I mean I would absolutely 50s too far but if I was the captain and it does come down to, this one does come down to the committee. If I was the captain of the sort of 10 to 15 10 to 15 meters,
which ID, which I don't. But you know it's up to each Captain. Turn to page can walk. Yes. What near Means if another example of that, sorry you go. Well, the 18th of the Henley is certainly longer than 15 metres, what it almost be more than 50 meters as well. Wouldn't close you in pretty close. And then what, what about the and you're talking about the first and second? It's in John's. When I was in that case, yes. Yeah, I don't think I know the front nine at Saint John's, but
See, another opening for interpretation is the 14.7 and whether it's a serious breach or not, and their committee has to determine right how far away, was that wrong place from where he's bought, where he should have been gleaned from and is no M, there's no yard set in the book, so it's up to the committee to go. Well, you should have been playing from way back there. That's 150 meters away. That's clearly a serious breach. That's take you as opposed to its x m. Ry M, well, it's not but DQ it's just the general penalty. So Few situations like that that
are open to interpretation and is to the discretion of the committee with us sometime. Because there's not that many of those situations. Sometimes in those situations or that exact situation you're talking about, it has nothing to do with it. Sometimes it can have something to do with distance and sometimes it won't have anything to do with distance. If someone has taken a drop 50 or 60 meters further up towards the green, but there have dropped themselves. And thick rough that only allows
themselves to get out to the same position that they probably would have been from that prior place where they should have gone. Then you'd almost say that there wasn't a serious breach, but if that's really sick, if they're 50 or 60 meters or even 15 meters made that they could get on the green rather than having to lay up then, possibly it is a serious breach. So, sometimes In that case, it's not distance at all. It's whether you're behind a
tree and not now not behind a tree or whatever. I can't, I can't go. I can't finish this core without us, of course, mentioning the committee procedures, which talks about sheep stations, because again, that's going to be the argument to and from, you know, just, you know, you try to make a decision and it comes down to are you know, how seriously we take this. You know, how, you know, especially when you're all fellow members, you know, you're all members of a club, you've been there for excuse, there's friendships as relationships and you're trying to do the right
thing by the field. The same time, you know, the individual very well and it's a challenge sometimes. Well before the actual. Yeah, there's a chance. The yeah, the actual reason they were the way that we are going to finish is you're going to ants. Ask me, gr Q OT w52. Have you got it there in front of you? I do, which I haven't had this vetted by you, so I hope it's appropriate if it's suitable.
Maybe gets a few. Comments. It could have, it could have three answers. Is that what you're saying? I'd like a think. It would have three answers at least a minimum. So here we go. So this is a GI Q 0 TW for podcast number 52. Yeah and is as follows Marcela plays her ball from a bunker and her ball comes to rest. 5 cm from the whole while. My seller is raking a bunker And
so others in the group can party out Fraser marks marcela's ball with permission from Marcelo. Once the others have holdout phrase that replaces marcela's ball on the spot then Marcella walks up and Taps it in types of ball in the hole on the next team. Our seller realizes she now has a ball that is not hers. Fraser had accidentally replaced, his own ball on the green, not marcela's, original
wall. What is the ruling? Is there any penalty to either player? Wow. Add at phrase already? Hold out. Yes, everyone else is hold out. Marcela was the only ones you're still raking, the bunker walks up to the green and goes, all you guys are done. No worries, Fraser puts the ball, back down, Marcel attacks, he didn't off, they go to the next week. That's a great question for g, oq o TW 52. Thank you very much, Stewart's your. I must I must say that your rules knowledge over the past
three or four years, having got to know, you better has really increased and Now it is you're less of a pest and I say that with a cheeky smile you're less of a pest and more of a colleague you know helping me as as much as I am helping you with onward, education of the rules of golf and it's always it's always fantastic to have someone of your caliber. with that, you
know, just that holding those principles and Understanding of where the rules come from and why they are important just having someone like that beside me to make sure that I'm not losing my way. It's fantastic. So thank you very much, still has. That is very, very kind of you to say and very generous of you to say and of course, I can't go pass saying how much of an influence and how much of a help you have been for me and you
know how many questions I've sent you over the last you know, one or two years. And that has helped me in, you've said straight away, go to 14.4, go to 14.2, go to x and you know, I throw Fraser in there as well. And when I see your level of knowledge and I'll see phrases knowledge, I see that's the standard and I see that as aspirational, I see that is not demotivating to me that to me is a motivation. But as much as I know, wow, this standard is still well beyond, it's still a long way to go. So thank you. That's the motivation to me
that's very kind of you to say all that. So thank you. Sign that. But you've been a huge part of that and maybe being involved in G IQ has obviously been a massive part of that as well and a new answering, all those questions for me and pointing me in the right direction has been huge. So thank you very much for calling no problem. That's why we're called golf rules questions. If you have any rules questions and would like to know the answer absolutely hit us up. And yeah we will if we don't know. We will definitely find out for
you. So thank you everyone for listening to grq episode podcast, episode 52. I've really enjoyed it, make sure to subscribe. Like share mainly sheer, get it out to those people that have three differing opinions in their group of four about how to proceed with a with with their shot or ball. Make sure it's not advice though. Yeah absolutely. Get the word out about going for those questions because that's, you know, we're a community, a
community of trying to help everyone play by the rules of golf so that, you know, exactly where you stand and how you've played against one of your other peers, and your personal best for that day that week that month. So, thank you everyone for listening so far. And we'll be back soon with episode 53 and the answer to Stewart's. 00:52 grq. OTW question. So thank everyone and thank you Stuart.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...