Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

CLUBLAND STORIES February: Ball deflected off a duck, ball deflected by artificial water, losing your ball marker, standing on a wrong green, and many more - THE GRQ PODCAST EP133

Feb 27, 20251 hr 16 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Episode 133 Clubland Stories Can a player go back and play a provisional ball, and how long does it take to jog back to the tee and then find the original ball? Ball in red penalty area, and feet standing on green. Ball at rest in bunker is moved by a ball in motion whilst player is in their downswing. Specific Rules in an Ambrose One stroke penalty relief outside a bunker Adjusting clubs without making a stroke Intervening events - breaching a Rule during a stroke. Is there any free relief from the spray of a sprinkler? Ball deflected off a duck Hole made by the maintenance staff, and the material that is out of the hole being piled for removal John Thurman - Larry’s ball is struck by artificially propelled water on the putting green. Losing your ball-marker, and what is reasonable judgement for replacing ball. GRQOTW 132: Blakey and Stuart are all square in their match at Wombat Hills GC, after 12 holes. As the light is fading and as they walk off the 12th green, Blakey says to Stuart, "how about we agree to halve the 13th, 14th and 15th holes and we just walk over and play the final 3 holes starting on the 16th?” Stuart agrees and they walk to the 16th tee. Blakey tees off on 16 when a roving referee drives up and investigates further. What is the Referee's ruling, if anything? Referee shouldn’t get involved. But if one of the players says something to the Committee, then it will depend if the players knew what they were doing was a breach or not. GRQOTW133: Late on a Friday afternoon at Wombat Hills GC, Blakey and Stuart are playing a match, and remarkably, Stuart is able to win the 18th hole to tie the match. Given the quickly fading daylight, both players agree to stop play and resume their match on Sunday morning at 8am. Two days later and just prior to starting their 19th hole of the match, Blakey tells Stuart that he had 39 points in the stableford competition played on the Wombat Hills course the day before. Knowing that an extended match is a continuation of the same round, not a new round, Stuart now knows that Blakey has practiced on the course during the match. He requests a ruling from the Committee before teeing off. GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadsh... (https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=product_shelf) DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE? Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_q... OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH #GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Club Land Stories February This is episode 133 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast and it is jam packed with so many weird and wonderful questions from our dedicated listers including what relief options do you have when your ball is in a penalty area and your stance is on a wrong green? Can a player go back and play a provisional ball after they have started looking for their original ball and does that count in the search time? A ball move by another ball just before a stroke is made and ball deflects off a duck or ball

deflected by artificial water and losing your ball market. It is all here this week. So whilst you're fixing a leaking pipe or painting the garage, please enjoy this week's episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Welcome everyone to the Golf Rules Questions episode 133. Blakey and my Co host alongside me is Stuart McPhee, also known

as Podcast and you can say that to him if you see him out in public as many have already have. Well done to those who have. He absolutely loves it. He wishes that his parents had called him Podcast. Actually, that's that's just a private fact that I've shared with the world. Is that right, Stuart? That's a true story Blakey. Good good morning and great to be with you 2 weeks in a row to record an episode for the fans.

Yes, for the fans, well the the Clubland stories have backed up so we have a ton to get through so let's get to them quickly. But firstly the GRQO TW132 which was Blakey and Stuart, we had, we had an argument as to who was going to answer this one, but would you like to read it out or would you like to read the answer? No, you go for it, Blakey. You're the you're the boss. Blakey and Stuart are all square

in the match at Wombat Hills Golf Course after 12 holes as the light is fading and as they walk off the 12th green, Blakey says to Stuart. How about we agree to half the 13th, 14th and 15th holes and we just walk over and play the final three holes starting on the 16th? Stuart agrees and they walk to the 16th tee. Blakey Tees off on 16 when a roving referee drives up and investigates further. What is the referee's ruling, if anything? What do you reckon?

Well, I wrote that if anything be just to throw people that we know that it's a RO and that's why I said roving referee not assigned to the match because assigned to the match would have stepped in pretty quickly, but a roving. So we're not supposed to interfere unless there's a few exceptions to that timing the ball search and disqualification penalties and the like. So I'm going to 3.3 the first, sorry, 3.2 the first clarification. Players must not concede holes to shorten a match. So we're sort of doing that here. We're trying to shorten a match, but that clarification refers

specifically to conceding holes, not a not halving them. But we also know under 3.2. If I flip that through here, my pages here, 3.282, we can agree to halve holes, but you don't do it in a batch. You can only do it one at a time and you can only agree to halve a hole if one of you has made a stroke to begin play that hole, which of course hasn't happened in this particular case. We're just blanket, hey, let's just call those three all square and move to the 16th.

So I have a bit of an issue with them doing that. Now, whether I can find that specifically, I'm struggling too, But we know if they do that and they're not allowed to do it, they're going to be disqualified. And what I'm starting to read here is if they don't know, then their match is going to stand as played. And that's what that clarification says, even though it doesn't specifically talk about halving holes, it talks about conceding holes. Well, I guess that's because you can't have. As you said, you can't have the

hole unless you start the hole, whereas you can concede a hole even if you haven't started. At any time, yeah. Yeah. But to your first point, yeah, I don't think the referee, I mean the referee shouldn't even be getting involved. But I guess he might have just been out of curiosity of why these guys are on the 12th and then they're now on the 16th. So but he really can't get involved unless someone didn't then turns around and say, Oh, well, what was that loud or something like that? So he should just he shouldn't even make he shouldn't even make

a comment. He's just oh, where'd you guys come from? Maybe? Oh, we came from 12 green. OH, OK. And then, you know, wait, I mean, I've I've done this in a match in a, you know, a very high level pro tournament. You know, the the players are staring at me, waiting for me to say if what just happened in front of us was allowed. I'm just looking at them like an idiot, but I can't say anything until one of them asks me a question.

Yeah. And so that's the that's the case of a referee that isn't assigned to a match and all out to make a call about the situation unless they are asked. Or as you said, if you go to referee, the definition of referee, there's, I think 4, correct me if I'm wrong, 4 Rawlings rules. Situation that you must step in, yeah. Yeah, yeah. So. That's why I thought when when there's a when there's a possibility of disqualification

in match play, when a referee is assigned, blah blah blah, multiple matches, blah blah blah. A player in a match asks for help. A player or players in a match may be in breach of 1.2 so misconduct a player arrives like to their starting point or a player search for a ball reaches 3 minutes. In that case you can step in. I love how we've done our homework beforehand. This is real. This is real. We sort of.

No. So, yeah, So what we're saying is the referee. So basically, let's make this real succinct. The referee can't do anything. They have to be asked because they have unless that it's a breach of a player of conduct. I mean, skipping holes isn't really player breach of player conduct because you both players sort of agreed. But at the same time, unless the players knew that they were breaching the rule.

So that's the big the big thing. If they don't know they're breaching the rule, referee can't step in, go to Aden. Whoever wins wins and the match with the result stands as played and they can't the other player can't then go, oh, we skipped three holes. So that's that's on them that they agreed to halve those holes. So on the three-point, got to go back a page here. 3.2 D4. If the player and opponent agree not to apply the rules, excuse

me, or a penalty they know applies and either of them start the round, they're disqualified. Have they failed or have they agreed not to apply a rule? Yeah, that they know applies. That's the key. Did they know or not? That's right. That's the most important thing I remember. This is a match. If players don't know the rules, they can sometimes get away with it. Whereas in stroke play. More often than not. Yeah, in stroke play, you shouldn't get away with it. Yes, you can get away with it down way, way, way down the track as long as you're not

cheating if you accidentally did something. But in match play, you can get away with it even if you it's seen and known, the other person can just ignore it. But yeah, yeah, the important thing is they're not allowed to agree together to, you know, forget about a. Rule. I mean, imagine if Stewart said to Blakey, hey, by the way, I don't think we're allowed to do this. In fact, I'm almost sure we're not allowed to do this. And you go, well, I don't care because it's getting dark anyway. It might be one of those situations where you let them go and they continue to play the 16th, but at the end of the

round, sorry, end of the match, you would maybe just pull them aside and say, just so you know, for a future, you're not allowed to do that. Yeah, Yeah, possibly. Yeah, possibly. You let the match stand and then 131415 didn't have and. Maybe, maybe they go, oh, you shouldn't have told us out. I didn't want to know. Can't do it in the future. Exactly. I've got away with it seven times. That's right. That's right. And they gave me a warning after every time. Rightio Let's let's get into a club name story.

We've got one from Zane Pittwater Golf Club in southern Tasmania. He submitted this just after New Year's Day, so we're only six or seven weeks late this situation. In the Saturday stroke competition, the player hooked his tee shot left into some heavy rough between their hole and the following hole. It was thought the ball could be lost, but the player proceeded on thinking he would find it. When they approached the area they thought the ball would be in, the player and his playing partners commenced a ball

search. Note for later that the ball search is not being timed by the player or his playing partners. About 30 seconds into the search, the player remarked to his partners that he was going to back to the tee to hit a provisional ball. While his playing partners continued the search, the player jogged back to the tee, which is around 220 meters away, and proceeded to hit another one down the fairway. As he approached the search area for a second time, one of the playing partners found his original ball. They assumed he would be able to continue with that original ball, and so he proceeded to

continue playing with the original ball, picking up their provisional ball and chipping back onto the fairway. He made three more strokes to finish the hole. The score was submitted and the competition results were finalized as usual. It was only after the competition was complete that the situation was brought to light. In discussions with the other club members, the situation was disputed for two clear reasons, whether or not the player was allowed to play a provisional ball after the ball search had commenced, and the answer to that is Stuart. A classic?

Well, that's obviously a What's the word when It hangs over from a previous rule, which has now been changed, obviously. Yeah, cause a. Lot of people still really believe that. And I kind of don't mind that they still believe it because you. And question it, yeah. Just trying. To find the clarification. The answer is it's changed now, so. 18.3 A slash 2A player may play a provisional ball for a ball that might be blah blah blah up to the three minute search time has ended, so even after the search time has started, you can still play a provisional ball.

OK, so that's number one answered and but the second one's the most important, whether or not it could be possible that the original ball was found within the three minute search time and thus was allowed to play the original ball. Therefore we'll get to that. Therefore, some members believe that he should be disqualified as the wrong ball was played and the situation was not rectified and the lowest score was assigned for score stands and the player was not disqualified as disqualified as they didn't win anything anyway. What is the correct ruling in the situation and therefore what is their whole score of

applicable? Well, it comes down to facts doesn't it? How long was the three minute? You know, how long was the three minutes? Was the three minutes 2 minutes thirty or was the three minutes 4 minutes thirty? And we won't know that. So all we can say is I'm, I'm going to go out on a limb and just say it's unlikely that he would have been playing the he would have the original would have been found within the three minutes, 220 metres, let's say 250 yards, goes down, has a

little search, then jogs back, then hits. I mean if he jogs both ways, runs as hard as he can. But didn't someone else find the ball, not the player? Yeah, but it was only when they got back to, it was only when he got back to the area that the ball was found. I reckon a player, a person who is half athletic, could get back to the tee in less than 60 seconds. Yes. Make a stroke within 20 and get

back to the spot within another minute. So that's 220 + 30 seconds of the initial search time. I think it is possible. However you make the, you nailed it on the head. It just comes down to 1 fact that needs to be established. And we know at club level it is really, really difficult to establish this fact because no one, no one times a ball search. Yeah, we did a video about timing a ball search recently. And also I would also put into

the fact that Club Land 30 seconds is more like a minute, 30 seconds, like you wouldn't believe. It. You wouldn't believe it, but we've already you and I have already been talking for 15 minutes. What? Yeah, I mean that's basically a club land level ball search, so and. We're not even finished with that ball search. Yeah, that's right. So I would say that it was very unlikely that the original ball

was found within the three minutes. But that is not an answer. That is just a suggestion that you know, it's a great idea to start a timer when you are determining whether your ball was still your original ball was still the ball in play. Right enough of that one next hope that helped Zane. Next one Mark player's ball is

just inside a red line of an red penalty area. The ball was pliable, but the player's stance will be on the putting green. This is not the putting green for the hole he is playing, is it? It is a wrong green. Is he required to take 17.1 penalty relief? This was a hypothetical situation, but that's OK because we love hypotheticals on this podcast. So OK, so the player is the

players standing has interference from a wrong putting green, but the ball is in a red penalty area. Now we know that you must take relief, just must take relief when you have interference with a wrong putting green. But is in this case, can he do it for free or does he have to take the penalty? What are your thoughts on this

one? No, you get, you get a free drop. Sorry, as you said, you must, must take, must take free relief from interference from a wrong room, which of course includes your stance, not just the ball, but stance as well. I've just gone to, excuse me, 13 point 1F22. The the key here though is you must drop in the penalty area as the nearest point of complete relief must be in the same area of the course where your ball is, so you're not dropping in the fringe.

You've got to drop inside the penalty area. So you just go nearest point where you no longer have interference from that wrong grain into the penalty area and drop there within a club line, no near the hole. So that's that's awesome. That's the answer. So he gets the free relief, but he has to be continue to keep his ball inside the red penalty area or he can take the penalty relief as long as he's well, that's I was just about to say as long as he's not standing on the green, he could actually take the penalty relief onto the green depending on where that

last point, I never get that right, the last point. Last edge crossed. The point on the last edge crossed. Sorry. Yeah, never. I'm never gonna get that one. Right. Point on the last edge crossed, but then if he drops it on the grain or he still has interference, he must then take further. Free relief. Or other relief to get himself off that wrong putting green. So that's the 6th one I've just learned. 6th time you get to drop for free when your balls

inside of an ulterior. And not counting a local rule. Is that what you're saying? Yeah, OK, OK. Yeah. Are we? Going through the list of 6. No, no, because I've forgotten the 3rd and 4th. No, that's not true. No, no, I could together we could rattle them off, but that's not the point. I just wanted to throw that out there. I just, I just hadn't come across. I mean I've read 13.1 F often but never thought about this scenario of the ball being that close to a penalty area and it being the wrong groan and having interference and your ball being in a penalty area.

I've just thought of a new segment and I'm writing it to you so you will remember. OK. Stewart's Lists. Oh, do you like my lists? Yeah, we could easily have a you know how many full stops are in the Rules of golf? That's not my cup of tea. But how many times? How many times does a how many? How many times does Teen Area show up in the Rules of Golf?

Yeah, that's a good scenario though. It is if you can remember them by the end of the show. We'll go with what was it? How many times you get free relief when your ball was inside a penalty? Area. How often you get a when your ball's in a penalty area and you actually get to drop it for free inside the penalty area? Yeah, OK, OK. Yeah, for example, I'll give you 1 dangerous animal condition. Here's one. Yes, yes, dangerous animal condition. We've just done wrong. Green no play zone. Interference to area of antenna

swing and stance, not the ball you get to drop for free inside the penalty room. We're gonna go through them. We're going through them without even going through them. Well, you can't remember the other ones. Well, I've got two more and. Go for. It all on a movable obstruction. Yes. Tio interference line of sight, right? Well, that's see, that's technically a local rule. Oh damn you it is too F23F20. Three but. Yeah, OK, That's fair. You and I.

You and I see that a lot anyway, so that's why we're so used to it. I mean, that's the funniest thing about Professional Golf. You know, you, you act under all these under the local rules that you start to think that they are part of the golf and you got to store it. Like that's the cool thing about doing a, an RNA or a USGA exam is that they don't put the local rules in there specifically. And so you're getting back to, you know, how Moat mainly how

the clubland situation is. Really. And model local rule F5 would be a very good example of one that we think is a rule of gold, but it's not. Yep, that's, that's very true. Yeah, because like in some courses, they don't want that local rule. They don't want you to get free relief. Although I like the the sort of the change now that you get free relief only if your ball and the immovable obstruction are in. Closely mine. Which I think that should become the rule of golf. It should be the model local

rule. And then if you want to that the no, that should be a rule of golf. And then the model local rule should say if you want to not allow it at all, or if you don't want to allow it because they're in the rough. Yeah, yeah. But anyway, Bino, a tee shot on a par 3, lands in the greenside bunker. As the player was on his downswing, a ball from an adjoining hole rolls into the

bunker, hitting the player's ball. The player's ball was knocked back and the offending ball stops where the player's ball was. The player, unaware of what actually happened, continues his swing and hits the wrong ball onto the green. This all happened in a split second. The player didn't realize he hit the wrong ball till he checked the ball that was still in the bunker. This happened at Northern Golf Course in Melbourne.

Did you understand the facts there? Unfortunately you cut out on our connection there. Just the first bit. All I heard was T shot par 3 greenside bunker and then I heard another ball. That was all I heard. I'm sorry. So no, I'm not completely all over the facts. Well, The funny thing is that the system that we use for podcasting, they match them together, so the the spectator, the audience will hear them anyway. But. I'll, I'll hear it fine, yes. Say that you hear it. So a ball was in a bunker and a

guy's at the top of his swing about to hit it, and another ball from another hole is coming along. Hit his ball out of the way, stayed in that spot and he's then hit the other ball. No. Why? I mean, yeah, believable. This this sounds like a hypothetical as well. But he just he says it's just a social round. So he elected to replay the shot, but he wants to know what the actual ruling is. What are the odds?

Trillion to one. Yeah, it's not even a one in one in a million. That's unbelievable on the surface. Balls being moved by an outside influence must be replaced and I I can't see the player getting away with having made a stroke at wrong ball. Does it depend when the downswing? Does it depend when the downswing was started? Tell you what, I have one of the worst Internet connections in the whole of the world. Does it matter when the

downswing started? So the downswing, so that's the forward movement of the club to strike the ball. That's when that's the stroke, yeah. When did the ball come in and move that player's ball beginning the backswing or something? I mean, it says here player was on his downswing. I mean I find the timing is just so incredible. So I would say he's already started his downswing, he says, as the player was on his downswing.

OK, now I've changed my mind. Yeah, I'm going to say he's not going to get a penalty because he's making the stroke. He's already started the stroke and he's making the stroke at his ball. Yeah, exactly. And then his ball has been moved, So what he is going to have is a stroke, yes. And he's hit a movable obstruction, not a wrong ball. Yes, no wrong ball because there was no intent to strike that ball when the stroke was made. Yeah. So unless he, because it says the player is unaware of what actually happened, he has continued his swing. So he hasn't tried to pull out,

because if he'd pulled out and he missed his ball and he hit a slightly hit the movable obstruction, then that's no stroke at all, no penalty, nothing. But because he can tenued his swing and would have hit his ball had it been in the place that he thought it was, the stroke still counts. As in my mind the stroke still counts, but he doesn't get a quantity of wrong ball. So then he just replaces his ball. The other person would have to wait until he's played and then

they would then get to recreate the lie in the bunker, right? Yeah, 14.2 D. Wow, OK. Because they need to replace their ball and the lie's been altered. So we're all, we're all in agreeance with that right now. What if he hadn't started the Downsling? So what's he done? Stopped. He's no, he's, he's on the backswing, yes. Then it's all happened, then the transition. Yeah, I probably feel differently now. Now you think it's a wrong ball.

Yeah, you're right. I think it's a timing issue. You're right. I think as soon as you clarify the timing, that's when I said I've changed my mind. I don't think it's a wrong ball at all. Does it have anything to do with intention though? Well, I think the word intention doesn't appear in the definition of stroke, but everyone accepts but that's it's in there. Now are you leaning towards wrong ball? Because if you if you don't go that way, then you could always

claim I had never had the intention to hit a wrong ball. Oh. Jeez, can of worms open. OK, so don't sit on the fence. What's your final answer for that situation where he hadn't started the downswing yet? I think they've made a stroke at that ball that's now in the place of their original ball. OK, I'm going to throw a. 3rd scenario. No, not a third scenario. I'm just going to throw out this answer. I'm going to say I'm not usually like this.

I usually penalize everyone. I'm going to throw out 20.3 and say in an equitable situation. What's very unreasonable? Regardless, regardless of timing, I'm going to say he never had any intention to hit his other than his ball, which he thought was in that place because he had identified that that was his ball. And I'm going to say regardless

of whether he started the backswing or not, I'm going to not penalize him. He's hidden, hit a movable obstruction and we just replace his ball. Now, for those who don't know, because it doesn't come up very often, 20.3 is really the last section in the rule book before we get into all the other forms of play. Situation not covered by the rules. Any situation not covered by the rules should be decided by the committee, considering all the circumstances and treating the

situation in a way that is reasonable, fair, and consistent with how other similar situations are treated under the rules. End. That's it. That's what 20.3 says. Yeah. I mean, because we said it's one in a trillion. There is just no, there's just no precedence for this type of thing. If I'm wrong, that's OK because I'm happy to penalize them. But yes. You are. But yeah, that's right. But in this case, I just think

it's so far out there. But I think the first scenario as described, we're both no wrong ball penalty because when the club was coming down there was the intent to strike their own ball. It just happens to be moved in the in the meantime. Yep, Yep, I'm totally. By an outside influence. Totally agreeance with that. Yeah, OK. Let's move on from that one, Brian. Good one. One in a trillion. Yeah, I mean, the funniest thing was he didn't say hypothetical, whereas the God force it hypothetical, but that one seemed more hypothetical.

Brian, I was playing before Christmas in a four player Ambrose. Oh, we love a Ambrose or scramble in the US event at my club. The four of us had a discussion on the first screen about whether or not we could stand behind or in front of each other's putts. It was clear that there was some confusion about the rules in this area, both for Ambrose but also for other forms of the game. Please can you provide a summary of the rules? We decided that we would watch the lines on the assumption that everybody else in the competition was probably doing

the same thing. It didn't help much as we finished well down the field with 28 points. No, they didn't say 28 points. That would be really bad if you're playing an Ambrose and then 28 points, 28 shots would be pretty impressive, but 28 points is terrible. They have been just up the road at Strathfield Golf Club too. Well, two things. I think it's a reasonable expectation they have that others would be doing it. Yes, agreed I. Think it's pretty reasonable expectation, but I don't agree with the there's a bit of confusion about how this is applied to other forms because there's no confusion. 10.2 B 4 is pretty clear about the

restricted area. Well, that's that's what he wants. Assisting with alignment and gaining information. I'm just going to go to 23 because I reckon there's a note. There's a note in 23 about. Can you stand behind on Ambrose? No. I mean can you stand behind on individual like it's your caddy or player partner in four ball foursomes? And the answer is no, you can't stand on extension of the line. But 23.8? And stand on the other side of

the whole. As long as they are not, they're not using you to aim as a something to aim at. Yeah, OK. So 20. Not allowed to stand behind, but you are allowed to stand in front on the other side of the hole because your line of play. Assuming the line of play stops at the hole, you are allowed to stand on that side as long as you're not going. I'll aim at your right foot. Stay there so I can get your right foot. 23.8 In addition to the limitations in Rule 10.2 B

for a player must not stand on or close to an extension of the line of play behind the ball while their partner is making a stroke to gain information for their next stroke. I think I get this one wrong because then you you they can actually say in a question, I wasn't standing there to help the player, I was there to help myself. And then so you penalize the partner, not the player, even though it was the player that was hitting the shot. That's I've, I've gotten that question wrong on an exam

before. So in Ambrose, this is what I want to say for Ambrose. Look, do what you if and want. I wrote, I wrote a web, a page on a website, A blog about all the things that a committee could change for an Ambrose competition. Basically because it's there for fun. It's there for, you know, the team camaraderie type stuff. You know, I like Tappans.

You know where you're going for a, you got a 15 foot of a birdie and then you putt up to about 6 inches. You tap in saying it's a four, but your teammates still have the opportunity to make a birdie. I like that. I reckon it's a good to play. Play to play. But that is not, you know, some committees could say, no, we don't like that. Don't do that. You know, there's there's plenty of rules and Ambrose that you already break. So it's a case of the committee saying, OK, you can drop here or

you have to drop here or you have to place here. I'd say place everywhere. I would say get your teammates to help you out. I would say, you know, maybe for cadding, you could say don't for caddy or something like that. But you know, the committee just needs to establish in an Ambrose. The committee needs to establish some of the common actions that team mates will do before the the players started. And I would recommend being a

bit looser than normal just because it's such a such a fun thing. And this situation will be right at the top of that list. And yeah, that's right. And people are going to cheat anyway. So you know what? What's was it matter? Well, I saw the other day on Facebook someone cat one team came in with A40I mean that's a joke. That isn't absolutely possible. They should be Exactly. They should be banned. There's no way they legitimately had a 40. It's that's just ridiculous.

There's like 3 eagle haul outs from 100 yards. Like just dumb anyway. That's about 12 twos and six threes. It's not quite that, but it's pretty close. It's stupid. It's we shouldn't even be talking about it. Right. Sorry, you go. Well, no, I'm going to go with a new question. What's your? No, all good comment. You've, I think you've, I think you've hit the null on the head about the committee before the play terms of the competition say you can and cannot do this. And yeah, and I wrote a few, I

think I've got 18 suggestions on what you might choose, what you might not choose. I mean, regardless, you know, if you have two low handicappers or three, hello. If you have the it's basically the team that has the most low handicappers usually wins even with handicap. So anyway, Brian, another one after recent rains. I was playing it around at my local course and found the bunker of on the left of the 1st hole filled with water. There was literally no piece of dry sand upon which to drop.

The bunker was not marked as DUR and there was no local rule on the day referring to flooded bunkers. After referring to the RNA app and finding rule 16.1, CI took a drop back on the line and a one stroke. One cannot be a stroke. Was this the right thing to do? Could I have taken free relief? Would the options have been different if there was dry sand, but it was nearer to the hole I took yeah. So we, he took back on the line 1 Peony stroke, which is very like, it's quite rare to hear that happen and obviously quite rare to actually.

I mean, he, he looked at the RNA app. So that's. Awesome during the round, during play to help him resolve an issue. I mean, I think it's fantastic. That's. Brilliant. And that happened. Unheard of. Massey Park, a golf course? Umm, or golf title. Yeah, it is unheard of, but he's used exactly what we keep telling people to do. What playing a second ball and stroke play just should happen but never does? Yeah, use the RNA app or the USGA app. Apparently the USGA app's got a lot better. You can actually write in notes now alongside some of the rules so.

I heard you had to be in the US to actually access it. You do. I mean, you go to the US next week, you'll be able to download it and then you'll be able to write notes. And I think you can still you can still access it around the world. You just can't. Yeah, unload it unless you're in the. US. So. So you'd answer a few of the things that this person raised? Yeah. Yeah. Well, Brian, well done. You've definitely taken the right, made the right, made a

right decision. Stuart, what do you want to say? I so just make a comment about his question about dropping nearer the hole. Sorry, if there is dry sand nearer the hole then you are not allowed to drop it on that. You must never, in this situation must never drop closer to the hole. I can't think of a free relief situation where you do drop near the hole unless it's a dropping zone. Dropping zone. It's the only one I can think of.

Or maybe a? I've got a new list coming. Must play again. Do you call that a free relief or not? No. OK. Oh, so replaying a stroke? No. Yeah. Replaying a stroke. Free Yep, we know there's with the bunker and putting green as well. 16.1 C You don't have to take complete relief if you're in that situation and can still find a little bit of sand but your left foot still standing in the water. You are permitted to take maximum available relief for free inside the bunker, but this

person's proceeded correctly with our relief option of actually going back on a line outside onto some grass and adding one penalty stroke. Yeah, and and it's very rarely happens. People would give it a shot or. Yeah, why would you add a penalty stroke when you think you can have a crack? Or complain that the bunker should be GUR or whatever. Take a drop anyway. But yeah, as as as Stuart said. Podcasting. Can take wow, wow, finally, finally he's finally clicked

over as, as podcast said, you can still take free relief, but it's going to be in the less least amount of water that you can possibly find. That's no nearer the hole. Or you've got the one penalty stroke back on the line outside the bunker. Or you can take unplayable and use your unplayable options. So that coming, did that come in 2023, that adding one penalty stroke and going back on the

line? No, it's not. Around for years. Years. That has been available for so long. OK, very good. OK, excellent, Brian. Hope that helped. See, we're getting through them all right. And well done for consulting the app during the round. Wonderful. I want everyone. To do that, there should be more. Of it absolutely nickname. Happy referee. OK in a stroke play championship. Starting with an easy short path 4, Stewart plays only on and makes a four.

The 2nd hole was a long path 5. Stewart pulls out his adjustable driver before lining up, he noticed that his driver is still on a high fade, a setting he practiced with on the driving range. Normally the the plays normally he plays the driver in a low draw, the exact opposite before he started to move the driver back to the original setting. His marker stops him and he as he's not sure that this is allowed, they call in a referee who has to help out.

What should the referee's ruling be? You can't answer this one as easy one. Yeah, I actually missed a bit of the stuff. Did he make the stroke or not? Sorry, he has not made a stroke. Oh, he's OK. Then that's Internet connection and we only do in case from each other I can. Always jump out of my balcony here and call you. The key is making the stroke. He has not made a stroke. He's just started to adjust it and. Yeah, that's fine. Got halfway through and someone said I don't know. Don't know if you can do that.

So he doesn't get penalized as long as he A doesn't use the club at all or B puts sets the club back to the high fade. Stores reverts. Yep. Yep, and then he can continue to use that club for the rest of the round. So a player must not make a stroke with a club when they have deliberately changed that club's playing characteristics during the round.

Is that 4.1 A? 24 so close 4.1 A3 2 is use repair replace 2. Is restore, repair, replace or whatever it? IS 3 is deliberately changing club's playing characteristics during a round. OK, so yeah, so he if you change it, you can change it back and without him making a stroke and you'll be fine. It's not that question you and I threw at each other about the

ball being warmed up, artificially warmed up, and my simple question was had they made a stroke at it. So you can warm up 10 golf balls, but there's no penalty if you don't hit any of them. Yeah, True, true, true. This is another example. OK. Oh, this is an interesting one. Just skim reading through it, Brian. Another one from Brian. This is Brian's fifth submission. Thank you. Brian, please can I get some clarification about the intervening events?

Don't ask me. Blakey's favorite topic 1.3 C 4 Let's go. I think that made it simpler, but I still can't get it. I have been reading John Thurman's Let's Get It Right and am confused about two of the rulings. In one scenario, page 54, a player hits his ball into a penalty area and takes relief by dropping a ball into play. He then finds his original balls playable from the penalty area and picks up the ball that he dropped. John calls out a one shot

penalty for picking up a ball in play and a general penalty for playing the wrong ball. So three shots, but as there was no intervening event, the player gets a total of A2 shot penalty. That's an easy answer. So you're happy with that? Yeah, but it's an easy answer though to explain why there's three. Do you want to answer it now? I can so right at the end of 1.3 C 4, which is about applying penalties to multiple breaches and introduces the concept of intervening events. The very last sentence Any

penalty strokes a player gets for taking penalty relief, such as 17.118 point 1 and 19.2 are always applied, in addition to any other penalties always applied. You don't look convinced. Well, he doesn't mention that one. That's the problem. Player heads it into a penalty area and takes relief by dropping the ball into play then. Finally, one penalty stroke. He then finds his original balls

playable from the penalty area and picks up the ball that he dropped. John calls out a one stroke penalty for picking up ball and play and a general penalty for playing the wrong ball. So three shots, 3 penalty shots, but as there was no intervening event, the player gets a total two shot penalty. So I think there should be one for dropping from penalty area that's you've got to include that and then you've hit a wrong ball. And then he's hit a wrong ball and then he's picked up which. Of course we know must be corrected before you. And then he's hit, he's picked up his wrong, he's picked up his

correct ball and play. Yeah. Now, is the timing of picking up that correct ball and play important? What was the order again? He says. Drop ball. Pick now, he says, picked up the ball and then played the wrong ball. OK, so where was the intervening event there? So that was only two, because that's the wrong ball. Was the intervening event right? Well, yes, which is for anything afterwards. So making a stroke at the wrong ball is the intervening event, but picking up the ball and making the stroke, there's nothing in between those two things. That's right. So it's only a total of 2, correct? But you also get the one for

dropping out of the penalty. So it's 3, but it's not 4. No. And but if he picked up the original ball and play, he picked up the original ball and play after playing the wrong ball. He's going to be an issue, right? Yeah, because stroke at the wrong ball is in a defending event. I hope that helps out Brian. Now Brian goes contrast this with another scenario from the book page 66, where the players ball lies in a penalty area next to a concrete bridge. He takes relief in the penalty

area from what he believes to be an immovable obstruction and then plays his shot. John calls out a one shot penalty for playing under an inapplicable rule and the general penalty for playing from the wrong place. Total of three shots. Can you help me understand why there is an intervening event in the second scenario that means all penalty shots apply. He takes relief in. The first one lifting the ball in play is it? No, I think it's because he took relief from the in the penalty

area 0. And he's dropped. Your shot, yeah. So what he's actually done is exactly applicable, said for the first one is that he couldn't take free relief in the penalty area. He had to take penalty relief. So he's, we, we haven't put him under 16.1, we've put him under 17.1. Because we need to apply a rule that is. That's right. And then he's just dropped in a wrong place and played from that wrong place. So he gets the as you mentioned in the 1.3.

C4. C4 he still gets the 17.11 stroke and then he gets the two shots for playing from a wrong place and then making sure it's not a serious breach. I'll tell. You what? It's an explosive topic, isn't it? Yes, yes, and it is. And, and a big thing about this is not, it's not only just the intervening events, but it's also the applicable rules and, and making sure to understand what type of one shot penalty it is.

Is it a one shot penalty of error or is it a one shot penalty of relief? I just have to highlight my attempt at a joke then that 1.3 C 4 is quite an explosive topic. C4. Anyway, yes, I'd say it's. I was thinking more like Star Wars, right? So I hope that, Brian, I hope that helped, But definitely get back to us if you still need clarification. But maybe don't get back to me 'cause intervening events is

definitely my worst topic. Favorite topic? E-mail Blakey. Golf rules don't question. Well, you know, The funny thing is golfrules.questions@gmail.com The funny thing is the only way I'm going to learn is by people asking me these questions. So the more you ask, the more my knowledge will get better. So yeah, if you do have a question, please, please ask. Right, Sue? Sue asked. This happened at the 4th hole at Moon and National Golf. Course actually she emailed me about this separately. So this is not muna golf course

is a national golf course, but the muna course. Muna Course, the 4th National. Oh, the 4th hole one which is which hole is the par 5? Is that the? 3rd or it's not one or two. Or the second, I don't think is the second to par 3I. Don't Muna is the one I don't know the least down there. I know the gun, of course. Because that one you, you play, I think you play at par 5 and then you come back and I think that the one you come back I think might be the 4th. Anyway, four friends, so this

from Sue. Four friends were playing stroke at their favorite club. It was a warm morning and the sprinklers were on and rotating on and around the centre of the fairway. 2 Golfers hit their drives nicely under the fairway but under the spray from the sprinkler. Free relief from the sprinkler head didn't stop them getting very wet. They won. They wondered if they could take free relief from the area receiving the spray. Ultimately, 1 Resourceful golfer bent the hose and temporarily stopped the water flow. Problem solved. But what is the ruling, if any?

Thank you Sue, what did you? What did you? What answer did you provide her? I think I made a mention about was there any temporary water in the area where their ball was? Were they entitled to free relief from temporary water? In other words, stomp their size 9 down and did any water appear? Anything on the surface of the ground. Yeah, temporary accumulation of water. And that sue come back and say yes or no. No, I think we texted or something, I can't remember now, But the other thing I said was I can't see any free relief for

the spray from the sprinkler. No, it's just like rain, right? Yeah, well, I know it's artificially propelled, I get all that, but. That's right. That's not natural forces, but. But it but it. Is it's not moving the ball, is it? It is treated like rain even it is treated like a natural force because you don't get relief from the artificial artificially prepared well. Water. I always wonder why is that? Why don't you get free relief from a sprinkler head that's spurring? Do just the stuff coming out of it.

Only when it's hit the ground. Yeah, you said free relief from a sprinkler head and of course you do get, but you're talking about the water coming out of it. Well, I mean, I did say that afterwards. You're just too quick to, you know, you just don't let me think. No, I don't. I mean, where's it? So it says under obstruction about what an obstruction has got. Is that where it's got artificial ice or wind or something like that? I think that's under Canberry.

Water has ice and stuff. I'll just say see there. You go outside influence. The artificially propelled air and water, such as from a fan or irrigation system, is an outside influence, and there's nowhere in the book that says that you get relief from an outside influence. Natural force is the effects of the effects of nature, such as wind, water, or when something happens for no apparent reason because the effects of gravity. So yeah, unfortunately, bad

luck. That's what I said. I said I can't see any reason for getting free relief. If it was one of those 40° days in Melbourne, it's probably a good idea. Be fantastic. Right, next one. So we're we're only two away and then we've got a couple of question audio questions. Mr. Roberts, this is Mr. Roberts 15th submission. Wonderful. Hello, Mr. Blakey and podcast. He did not write that. No, he wrote Stuart, but I knew what he is. Happy New Year to you golf rules

gurus. Here is a good question for you to laugh at. Have you ever had this one? Saturday morning, 8:20 AM, just finishing breakfast, coffee test, text mess. He's put test but text message arrived. Morning Dave. What's the rule if you hit a duck, do you replay the ball or play it as it lies? And he said he picked up the duck, took it home for dinner and then bad luck play or As It lies after it bounced off the duck.

Well, it depends, isn't? It if it's on the green or not. If no, yours and if your stroke was from on the green or. Not yeah. If you made the stroke from the putting green, you would replay that stroke. Well it sounds like he took it home for dinner. Sounds like it wasn't a putt, unless it's one of your putts that goes off the green. Into a bunker or penalty area. Correct. So let's say it was from the general area or bunker or a penalty area and it's just a outside influence. Just what we were reading before any animal and the ball in motion accidentally stopped or

deflected. Rule 11.1. You just play the ball as it lies unless it's been played. The ball was played at from on the green and hit the duck that was also on the green. Then it would be a must cancel and replay. Replay the stroke. Or a stroke doesn't count. I can't remember the exact. Word. That's right. Yeah. Replay the stroke. Yep. So I hope that helps. That's a pretty easy one, actually, Mr. Roberts. Thank you. And he's also got another one.

I knew I knew he'd come up with it. He only submitted these two days ago. Trenching down the middle of a trenching down the middle of a few fairways. Oh, I see. There's trenches, holes in the ground down the middle of a few fairways to lay wires in the sprinkler system. 30 centimeters deep, 20 centimeters wide with dugout soil on either side. It started a day earlier than planned. No local rules set as yet. David and Bill playing in a

twilight comp. David hits great drive down the middle which as discovered a few minutes later, came to rest in the bottom of the trench. It says hit 280 meters from the tee. Ha ha, I think that means rubbish. More like 180 meters. Bill hits a good drive under lovely POA grass. I'm finding David's ball. Bill very quickly and Ingest says there is no new local rule pinned up about the trenches. You will have to play it as it lies, which I would love to see

or take an unplayable. A good laugh and a chat continued. Common sense prevailed. A free drop was taken, after which David hit a shocker of a second shot, and a local rule was written at night and pinned up on the notice board. So I think the question is, without the local rule, was the free relief given allowed? Ground under repair also includes the following things, even if the committee does not define them as such.

Any hole made by the committee or the maintenance staff in maintaining the course, such as a hole made in removing turf, blah blah blah, laying pipelines blah blah blah. It says laying pipeline, so that's. Perfect. It does, yeah. Now, so that's fine. What about the stuff that's come out of the hole? It doesn't specify any other material pile for later removal. No, it's probably about to go

back in the hole. I mean, I would say that that stuff is exactly what you said. Then it is piled for later removal. Removal from where it is now back into the. Hole back into the hole. Well. It doesn't, but no, I get what you're saying, but it is. Like the definition doesn't say removed. From where it is? It removed. Where it's removed to it.

It it doesn't say it has to be more than you know, 3 meters or 10 meters or 50 meters. It just says removed. From there it is so that still that material left beside the hole that would then fill in the hole will be material removed to be removed later on, intended to be removed. Later on SO. Yeah, the whole area to me is GUR and I would probably say all, I mean this is the hardest,

this is the hardest bit is probably are they 2 conditions, Are they 3 conditions, Are they one condition? Spray can, white paint or fix it all. Right. But without that local rule, what do? You of course, of course. And you know you. Could and where's the edge? You could play where's the edge of it? Yeah, yeah, where's the edge? You could play 2 balls. You could also just take the risk and just say, Hey, I think I'm going to take nearest point here from all of them as one. And to be honest with, with the committee not doing their job,

you know, and, and that's not a, a, a slide on the committee. It's just saying, you know things happen without, you know, without them. Right, all the time. But it's just the facts are with without them doing getting to it in time. I think they would have to be pretty accepting of the player determining it as one. Although you know player plays 2 balls, 2 balls, 2 balls, but how many times has that happened? Never really.

I want to, I want to hear someone go to the RNA app and go oh I can play 2 balls. In a match. Fantastic. Actually when you open the RNA app it should be like if you don't know the rules go to this rule play. 20.1 C 3 then if you that doesn't help you, keep searching. Exactly, exactly. Right now we have a couple of, we have a couple of questions from and we mentioned it, one of the listeners mentioned it from

John Thurman's book Fantastic, spoken by the legend himself. Hi guys, this is a frustrating story. Larry has a 20 foot putt to save power. He carefully lines up the putt, takes dead aim and makes a smooth stroke. The ball's rolling at a good pace. It's starting to track, but just when the ball gets about 6 feet from the hole, an irrigation

head pops up and shoots out a jet of water toward the hole, deflecting Larry's ball. His ball comes to rest 2 feet to the side of the hole. What should Larry do so? Am I? Just talking about artificially propelled water. Am I to get this right that John's trying to test us on what what should happen? Well, I'm sure he's got the answer already. It'd be in his book. Right, right. So go and get his book. We won't tell the answer.

Is that what you're saying? No. Weren't we just talking about outside influences? And are they artificially propelled water? Yes. So in that case, bull in motion accidentally hits person or outside influence. Artificially propelled air and water. As it was on the green then I would say he see replay the shot unless it hits any person. Sorry. Replay the shot if it hits any person.

Don't replay the shot if it hits the player or a person attending the flagstick. Replay the shot if it hits a moveable obstruction. Don't replay the shot if it hits a moveable obstruction that is the club or a ball marker or a ball or the flagstick. Replay the shot if it hits an animal, any other than those defined as a loose impediment. So are we calling this, what are we calling it a moveable obstruction? No, it's it's an outside influence, artificially propelled water.

Well, that doesn't. Does that come up in 11.12? No No 11.1 as B. Motion if a player's ball in motion and played from the petting green accidentally hits the player or an outside influence. The ball must be normally played as it lies. Has it hit any of those things listed in the 11 point B2 11.1 B 2? None of the ones has need a person that you get free relief. It would just be a moveable structure. Just the so, but can can an

outside influence also be a moveable obstruction? Yes, a ball moving is by so. Could could this artificially propelled water? Could That is it? Be. A moveable obstruction. Is the water an artificial object? The water is not. Being obstruction, it's got to be artificial. Well, you've just hit the nail and hit there. OK, so play the balls of lies. Bad luck. I cannot see an out. Bad luck, Larry or what do we say?

Hard luck Larry? Lucked out, Larry. That's what it is. Lucked out, Larry. Not in America. If lucked out, that means you've got you've got. Good luck if you're lucked out. What it doesn't mean that you don't have any luck if you've lucked. Out. No, no. I learned that when I lived there. Hey, you've lucked out, I said. What are you talking about? That that is backwards, Well, it's you move you, you fly over there and you go into opposite land, don't you? I hope even the toilet's done, they go down the wrong way. How does that work?

Like John, terrific question, John. Thank you. Luck out means no luck. How can you luck out? And that means you're in luck. Well, you that's how they see it. Yeah. OK. Next one from that was a great question and I'm not even sure I'm we're correct, but going through reading through the rules, you know you're right. Water is not an obstruction, it's not artificial. What if you how about this? What if you added red dye to it? And what? If you added soap. What if you added blue dye?

Or soap or fertilizer? Yes. Suddenly it becomes artificial, doesn't it? That component surely Jesus. I'm going to have to ask John that one. Send Send him a message, say what happens if part of the water that's been pumped out. Artificially propelled is artificial. Was in the filter system, was a dye or. Fertilizer is a good one. Fertilizer, I said. Whatever nitrogen was added to it, does it now become.

Poison. Yeah, artificial. Wow. OK, what's his next one? That is a good one. Yeah, the. Hi guys, I have a ball marker story. Travis's regular group was playing on an autumn morning after an all day rain. The day before it was cart path only and the group was playing mark lift clean and replace in the general area. Local rule E2.

On the 9th hole, after the group hit their tee shots, Travis walked over to his ball in the rough to the right of the fairway and saw that it was a bad mud ball. He marked the ball with a black tee, lifted it, and walked back to his cart to get a towel and clean it. Upon returning, Travis couldn't find the tee. The spot was in the shadows amongst all kinds of leaves on wet grass. Is that a lost ball?

Does Travis get a penalty? What should he do? So he's marked the spot where he's left his ball. For his question before. He's still got the same, he's still got the same ball. So he hasn't lost his ball, but he's lost the spot. Yeah. So when he puts, when he puts the ball back down, effectively he's going to put it in the wrong place. No, you can use a reasonable judgement. Well, this is the spot. I was just getting to that. I'll shut up. No, no, no, I want you.

I want you to button. It just shows, sorry, how you really are to everyone, but I know I honestly like it when you when you button, but I just wanted to get this piece out. But is there something in the rules that says when you're trying to replace the ball as long as you do with reasonable judgment, estimated spot, is that does that occur in this situation or not? Am I allowed to talk?

Yes. 14.2 C spot where ball is to be replaced must be replaced on its originals original spot, which if not known must be estimated. So he's not going to get a penalty. Well, if he uses reasonable judgement under 1.3 C something. Yes, yeah. What do I not know? It's C2, C4, the explosive section, yeah. Surprised you didn't go with the

explosive one. What's C2C3PO? No C3PO that's. C3 is no discretion to vary penalties must be into two. Is it 1.2 reasonable judgement? It's here. OK. So we just got a 1.3 B2 reasonable judgement. You know, we often have rules that require a play to determine a spot, point, line, edge, area, location, and we can use

reasonable judgment. I think that's what Travis needs to do in this particular case. Can we penalize them if they put it, say they put it 10 meters away, it's 11 yards to though that one country. The Lucked Out Mall. Can we then penalize them for not being reasonable? Yeah, I think so. 8 metres. Oh, you're going to keep going, eh? So if you want me to, if you want to pin me down for a distance 8, yes.

You know, if it's now on the short grass, clearly everyone would agree in that group they're playing from a wrong place and haven't used reasonable judgement. And we know this is one of those committee discretion things, reasonable judgement. So OK. Committee discretion. Looking at it from another sort of way, it's more about if if. I mean, if he said if it found out it was 3 meters away, but he said, but I've still got that tree there in my way. I've still got this branch in my way or whatever it is. That's probably pretty

reasonable, right? Even though it's 3 meters away, he's probably pretty reasonable because he's still thinking he's got the same exact conditions that he had when he picked the ball up. But then in another case where he's 50 centimeters away, two yards, sorry, 2/3 of a yard. Which is 2 foot. Let's go. That's what I was trying to think. 2 foot right.

But he you know now and you say to him, but you know, did you have anything You I said, Oh yeah, I had that tree, but now I don't have that tree. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I had that branch in my backswing, but now I don't have that branch. That wouldn't be reasonable. So it's not necessarily all about distance. It's about you still have the same, you know, basically the same conditions. Would you agree with that? Yeah, so long as the player does what can be reasonably expected under the circumstances to make an accurate determination,

reasonable judgment will be accepted. Yeah. I, I mean, I, I would like reasonable judgment to be very minute, very narrow. Yeah, in that situation, I would be expecting it to be within a centimeter. The funny thing about that is if it was within a centimeter, he would see the T. Despite his late color. Obviously he can't find the T, so it's not going to be within the centimeter. It is going to be. It could be, it could be 10

meters. But if he says, look, it was in a sort of a not a great position. So I sort of tried to put it back into not a great position and I was attempting to chip out sideways anyway with both of them. I would be accepting of that reasonable judgement. But then, you know, if he got out of three would put it on the green when he was just attempting to. Was it initially going to chip out sideways? I'd say, well, that's not reasonable. OK.

So no penalties under John for for the player, No penalty there. I think the sorry the way. Just because he's lost the spot, that's doesn't mean that there's a penalty. It has to be an unreasonable judgement. And I think the way someone explained it to me was the fact that the ball's in your pocket or your hand means it cannot be lost. It's in your hand or it's in your towel being cleaned. And the other thing is if you are on the green and your ball

markers on the green and your balls in your pocket and you go to grab your ball out of your pocket and four other ball markers fall out and all fall around your real ball mark and you now have 5 on the green and you can't work out which is which. You can use your balls not lost. You're not going to play from a wrong place. You can use a reasonable judgement to work out which is which. You just use the one that's closest to the hole. That would be best. Actually, I might try that next time I'm playing with you. When we're playing, I'll just drop a whole. Clumsy. Oh no.

A load of casino chips because I. Love 5 cent pieces or something. And then I'll be like, oh, who won on the pokies last night? Oh, I think, I think my ball marker was this one, yeah. Is that reasonable? I'll be making a claim. Oh, I'm sorry, requesting a ruling. Yeah, what do I say? Making a claim. Make a claim. Yeah, I'll stick with that forever. I'm never changing that. So you can't teach old dogs new tricks. Right. And you are so old. That was a great a great

episode, a great session. And because of the clubland stories and we love them and thank you, John. Really special thanks to John. That's right. Thank you also to the to John and all anyone who wants to send in an audio question. We do love them too. But thank you to everyone who submitted a question. We were only about 7 weeks late for some of them. But then we also got 2 ones that just got submitted this week. So we're not doing too bad. But yes, in we've got, we've now

got no club land story, no new club land stories. So please keep sending them in. Oh, I've just before we go. So I learned something the other day. The USGA put up one of their questions on Facebook group polling one of their poles. And I learnt something where a ball that come goes out of bounds and comes to rest and then the wind blows it back in the ball was out of bounds. And I was like, how's that happen?

Like because if if your ball is inbounds and it's blown out of bounds, comes to rest out of bounds, it's also out of bounds. And I was like, what text? What wording do they need to use? And if you go to 18.2 and it states a ball that is at rest out of bounds is a ball out of bounds basically, right? So as soon as it's at rest, it's a wrong ball. It's not a ball in play. It can't a ball in play again, unless you make a stroke at it

off the tee or whatever, you know, that ball is gone. And so I learned that And so I put it on Instagram yesterday. Now I shouldn't have because it's it's, I get a lot of abuse. Oh no. When people can't accept when people can't accept the the rules, they love to abuse me. I'm just like I'm the messenger, but that's fine. So but that that is true, isn't it Stuart like that? That is incredible to me that they've specifically written

bullet rest becomes is out of bounds. It can't then become inbounds. And, and I was, yeah, I was sort of blown away. This is talking about at rest. This is not talking about flying over and out of bounds and coming. This is. Talking about at rest and yeah it's yeah. So I just wanted to mention that because that like I learned that and then I tried to teach everyone and I'll tell you the poll results so far. So I uploaded it about 18 hours

ago or. Something. So this is your poll now, not the USGA one. This is my poll and my my question was was this. David hits his tee shot left and all of it comes to rest out of bounds. The wind then blows his ball back inbounds. David's ball is considered inbounds and his ball in play true or false. And the numbers the. Answer is false and we've so far we've had 3000 people have an attempt and 520 have got it

right. So 2 1/2 thousand people. It's 17%. Just under 2 1/2 thousand people have got it wrong and to be honest, three years ago I would have got that wrong. Now, I've actually had a read of it and yeah, that is that is a tricky one. It is to me that is very tricky. But at the same time it's pretty straightforward. But it's, I think what people are, you know, annoyed about is a ball can, can roll out of

bounds and be out of bounds. It can't, but it can't roll from out of bounds to inbounds and be inbounds. It's still out of bounds. Now let's finish on the GRQO TW133. Did you have one? Would you like to be a little bit prepared? So yes, I do have one for you and we're playing a match again. You love you love just playing that slow play. Oh, it's funny. Go Go podcast.

All right, you, you and I are playing a match again. GRQOTW for Episode 133. Late on a Friday afternoon at Wombat Hills, Blakey and Stewart are playing a match, and remarkably, Stewart is able to win the 18th hole to tie the match. Given the quickly fading daylight, both players agree to stop play and resume their match on Sunday morning at 8:00 AM. So that's two days later. Two days later, and just prior to starting their 19th hole of

the match, Blakey tells Stewart that he had 39 points in the Stableford competition played on the Wombat Hills course the day before. Stewart knowing that an extended match is a continuation of the same round, not a new round, he now knows that Blakey has practiced on the course during the match. He requests a ruling from the committee before teeing off on the 19th hole. What is the ruling? Wow. That's a that's a great question.

Next time we do 134, I will then do my homework. I hope, I hope everyone's enjoyed that. That podcast, episode 133, I've actually really enjoyed it. I've probably enjoyed. I like to tell people about our tour rulings and situations and just being on tour just to give a heads up. But you know, I think both of us enjoy the clubland stories the most. So get in many, many, many, many more Clubland stories, as many

as you can. Thank you everyone and enjoy your golf.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode