Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

VIC Open Rules Review, Rory McIlroy and Joaquin Niemann make Rules blunders on Tour, and we have a couple of ClubLand stories to delight - THE GRQ PODCAST EP109

Feb 6, 202458 minAudio

VIC Open Rules Review, Rory McIlroy and Joaquin Niemann make Rules blunders on Tour, and we have a couple of ClubLand stories to delight - THE GRQ PODCAST EP109GolfRules Questions Podcast Episode 109 is all about the Vic Open, with stories from the Tour by Podcast Man of the People Funny Man McPhee, but Blakey and Stuart also cover a couple of incorrect drops by two of the best players in the world in Rory McIlroy and Joaquin Niemann that were costly.There are also a couple of clubland stories to keep you on your toes. BUT just before we get into that episode, I want to encourage you that if you like these podcast, share it with a friend or two. Send them the link and get them listening.As well as the Podcast, Stuart and Blakey also produce the Drop Zone, which is a weekly Rules newsletter, that gives you some helpful hints, a few Rules questions and there is usually a funny video to keep you entertained and educated. So send us your email address if you have yet to sign up, and when you receive the newsletter, make sure to forward that on to the captain or manager at your club, they are free to distribute it to all of their club members.We also have merchandise that you can purchase so that you are representing the best Golf Rules podcast in the world. Grab a t-shirt, a hat, or even a hoodie featuring the Rules Roo, or the Wombat caddie.And now whether you are in your car, or going for a walk, or just taking a break after mowing your lawn.Enjoy this episode of the GolfRules Questions Podcast.GRQOTW108:Andy scored a 9 as he incurred a General Penalty for his caddie deliberately deflecting his golf ball in motion. As it was known that the ball would have gone into a penalty area, he wasn't required to proceed under Rule 11.2 if he was going to proceed under Rule 17.1d for an extra one stroke penalty, but there was no issue for him doing so, as he may have decided to play it as it lies.VIC OPEN referee run-down by Podcast McPheeRabbit holesBall moved on the greenTransportation of players for S&D, but how about other situations, and does it have to be a Rules Committee memberA player found their ball on top of an abandoned oneWhen a car can’t be moved, what is it determined to be under the Rules?Hitting a ball out of bounds from the wrong teeing areaWhat is a broken piece of boundary fence wire determined to beGRQOTW 109:Danni the D Grade Golfer hits her tee shot way left into thick bushes on the 14th hole at Wombat Hills.After 1 minute of searching, she finds and identifies her ball and decides to take unplayable ball relief. Unable to retrieve her original ball, she drops another ball correctly in the lateral relief area. As she is working through her yardage book and waiting for others to play, a child crawls under the bush and retrieves her ball. The child asks the caddie if he can keep the ball, when the caddie realises it is not Danni the D Grade Golfer's ball. The caddie advises Danni, and they continue searching for her ball, finding it about 1 minute later, however now 5 minutes after they began searching originally.She picks up the dropped ball and continues play with the original ball, holing out in 5 more strokes. She tees off on her next hole - what is her hole score for the 14th hole?GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Golf Rules Questions Podcast Episode 109 is all about the Victoria Open, with stories from the tour by podcast Man of the People Funny man McPhee. But Blakey and Stewart also cover a couple of incorrect drops by two of the best players in the world in Rory McIlroy and Yakko Nieman that were costly. There are also a couple of clubland stories to keep you on your toes. But just before we get into that episode, I want to encourage you that if you like these podcasts, please share it with a friend or two, send them a link and get them listening. As well as the podcast, Stuart

and Blakey also produced The Drop Zone, which is a weekly rules newsletter that gives you some helpful hints, a few rules questions and there is usually a funny video to keep you entertained and educated. So send us your e-mail address if you have yet to sign up. And when you receive the newsletter, make sure to forward that on to your captain or manager at your club. They are free to distribute it to all of their club members. We also have merchandise that you can purchase so that you are representing the best golf rules podcast in the world. Grab AT shirt, a hat, or even a

hoodie featuring the rules Roux or the wombat caddy. And now, whether you're in your car or going for a walk or just taking a break after mowing your lawn, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Stuart's one of our highest ranked working rules officials that we have one of the best we've got and he knows he's. Welcome everyone to episode 109 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast Blakey's Back and so is

Podcast Man of the People McPhee. Jeez, your title is getting longer and longer, but you really are a man of the people. I mean, how many people did you speak to at the Vicar Open? Just volunteers, Scorers. Other referees. There were more people flocked around your car than there was the players, I'm pretty sure. I don't know how to come back. He's got no I've got no words and hello to you and hello to everyone listening in and

watching. I will say that with my With the Victorian Open, which we may speak about. The volunteers love when you thank them at the end of their day if you go up and say thanks very much for your help today, really appreciate it. You know, you did well with the crowds well, but you know, they love it. They're all volunteering and the events would find it very difficult to run without them, extraordinarily difficult to run up without all those volunteers. And the volunteers do like to,

because I've been one of those, you know, before I got into this, I did a lot of volunteering at events and I've volunteered the Victoria Open and the Australian Open and and sometimes you feel like, am I actually valued here? And so for an official, you know, come up who's got a lanyard around or a radio on to come up and say thanks for your help today, You know, it's the power of words. So yeah, I don't want to not trying to blow my own trumpet. I think it's just such a simple thing that we can do to thank those people who are putting out their time and giving it their time. And you can see they love it if

you say great job, they love it anyway. That's not what we're not here to talk about that, but. Well, we are here to talk about the Vergovern that just happened at 13th Beach. It's one of the only tournaments in the world that has men and women playing at the same time, not in the same groups. They usually stagger them. Boy group, girl group, boy group, girl group, something like that. There was 132 men and 90 women. That's the $0.90 right? Or. Was it 144 men? Might have been 132 men, 90

women planned for 420,000 or 450,000. And great international feel in the women, a lot of people from Korea, Japan, US, Europe, yeah. Yeah. So that's affiliated with the WPGA. There's women's side and the men's side's affiliated with the PGA Tour of Australasia. So that's where the players are coming from. It's on those order of merits and they play for a separate check of $425,000 each, $450,000

each, sorry. And a separate championship trophy and and it was a great week and it didn't didn't rain at all and it was super hot on the Saturday, Sunday. Did the wind blow at all? It did. It definitely blew on the Friday my. Cart was shaking on Friday. Physically shaking. That might have been the baked beans though. No. So I only work for two days.

I only work Thursday, Friday because we have it's two courses. So to fit that many players on you've got to have two courses. So we've got the Creek course down there, the beach course and I worked the Thursday, Friday, I was Thursday, Friday on the back nine of the Creek course, which probably my favorite 9 on the Creek course. It's sort of just this one big paddock, whereas the front nine sort of goes around the houses and sort of resort type. But yeah, we saw, I saw some awesome golf.

There was some tricky whole locations. We got to watch players, you know, work their way around and it was, yeah, it was lots of fun. And then you were there still for the Saturday, Sunday and even got to walk with the final groups. Yeah, the, you know, we've become desensitized to how good these players are and how far they hit it. And I remember my first professional tournament, which I did with you, I'm standing there with my mouth open and how far they are driving it and how far away. I don't feel that way anymore. But every now and again and I

remind myself when I say guys hitting iron off the tee, so the hole's like 360 meters, let's call that 400 yards and they're just sitting at 3 on off the tee and they are hitting that 3 iron, 2627280 meters, 300 yards plus or miners, that's a long way. They're hitting that 3 iron a lot further than 90% of club members of their driver. Yeah, I mean, they just hit the ball a long way. Time to roll back the ball. Oh sorry. I didn't didn't mean to open up that topic but it's just they

are we watch great golf and the courses were in incredible condition like I didn't see the Creek where you were but. And I heard it was in incredible condition. Yes, like. So Steve does a great job down there putting the two courses together with I think he's just got just over 20 staff to Ted more than 20 staff, so does a great job and it's quite funny. I've been involved with the Vico the Beach apart from the last maybe the last three years

before that was about eight years in a row more in operations than refereeing. So I'd stay see Steve and talk with Steve quite a lot about where we're going to, you know put buildings and marquees and all that kind of thing. And a few a few of the years they've actually, it's rained on the Monday or Tuesday, like absolutely bucketed down and they've spent two days trying to fix the bunkers instead of working out some other things. But you didn't get any rain in

the lead up to the tournament, which was amazing, but it still had a grass tinge on it because we have had a lot of rain. Early January, mid January, so but it at the same time as that green tinge because of the last two weeks hot weather, no rain, it really played hard and fast and yeah those three islands were bouncing out down the field. It was it was a fantastic time and I didn't stay for the the weekend. You can give us a shout on who

won and how everyone played on the weekend. Do you? Want to go to the GRQOTW? Is there a way? Sure. And then we'll come back to the tournament stuff. Is that all right? I'll just you just run this thing. Certainly run a bit more efficiently, but OK. All right, go for it. The GRQ RTW One O 8. Right, playing in playing in a stroke round at Wombat Hills, Andy, the average golfer has a 12 year old caddy as part of a school program.

He's playing the driver with half four 5th hole and he plays his second shot to the green. However, it goes too far and over the green towards a red penalty area. As Andy arrives behind the green he finds his caddy who had walked ahead standing there near the red line laughing with some of his friends. Andy, the average golfer, inquires about his ball and discovers that his caddy had deliberately kicked his ball as he was approaching the penalty area which kept it out, and he estimates the spot where his

ball would have come to rest in the penalty area. Based on a brief conversation with his caddy and the friends, he drops a ball inside the penalty area based on that estimation. He then decides to take penalty area relief and drops his ball again outside the penalty area and he holds out in four more strokes. What is Andy, the average golfer's score for that hole? Well, I've got a fair few questions from that question, but basically his caddy's caused the ball to move, sorry, stopped

or deliberately deflected the ball while it was in motion is what I meant to say. That's a two shot penalty because it's his caddy. So I think that gets him to four because that was his second shot and then he dropped it in the PA where it was going to come to rest. But then he gets to take relief under rule 17.1. Sorry, that might get him to four. No, no, that gets him to five for taking penalty relief and

then he holds out in four more shots. So he had nine for the hole. Is that what you got? Yeah. So what if he drops in the penalty area? Is that for free or is that a penalty? Well it's a two shot penalty and he need for the caddy deliberately causing the ball, deliberately deflecting the ball and then the procedure is you can't play as it lies. It needs to estimate where it's going to come to rest, where it would have come to rest. And if that is in the penalty area, general area, bunker Tang

area, you drop the ball. Whereas if it was on the grain you place the ball. So you had to drop it in this area within the club length, in the penalty area where he thought it would come to rest. And then after that he could have played as it lies. So he gets that two shot penalty for the the breach, but then he could have played it as it lies. Or he could take an extra penalty stroke under 17.1 and get it outside the penalty area. So my next question to you is, once he worked out that the kids stopped it from going in the

penalty area and he's going well, I don't want to drop it in the water down there. Can I just rather than dropping it based on the estimated spot where would have come to rest, can I just drop it outside the penalty area instead? Yeah, instead of going through that procedure of where it would have come to rest, you know if there was 2 foot, 3 foot of water, it would just be ridiculous to make him drop the ball there. So he could have just proceeded under 17.1 straight away and that would have he wouldn't have

had to drop it twice. There's no penalty for that drop for what he did, but there's a penalty for taking relief from the penalty area. Anyway, now I've got a couple of questions. Why was his caddy down behind the grain? He's a. Kid if he was. Learning the game. If he. Was learning the game, he would be there. You can't. Tie him to the bag with a rope and then. And then his friends are playing truant. So the kids are at the back of the his friends are down the

back of the green, and they're waving at him, giggling and laughing. He's going right. I'm going to go down and spend a few minutes with him. He's allowed to be down there and and Andy's going, oh, I hate this school program. They run it every year. Yeah, do whatever you want. Just don't get me into trouble. So off you don't. You've gone to the back of the ground and he has got him into trouble. He's. Caused Andy's score to be higher than it should be. Right. Well, Andy's gonna cop that. Yeah, so nine was the final score. I think that's right. Right. Yeah, I. Think a few people got that wrong.

So can we get back to the? Sure we could do that few rabbit hole one was probably the most obvious rabbit hole relief I've ever given in my life. Right. It was dirt everywhere, droppings everywhere in holes everywhere. It was just so blatant. And yeah, I mean it was actually the nearest point was a little distance away and then even then there was heaps of dirt. So he was even the I guess the full relief area wasn't available to that person to drop into.

And we know based on our hard car, you can stand on the on that area. You just can't put the ball in play there. Lots of that Had one ball move on a green. They're all looking at each other. I've got a funny one about a. Mark, how's that? Two on the beach course. In fact, let's go 50 meters before that green. This is the same group I'm walking past. I'd see this guy. He's hit iron off the tee to lay up and then just hit an iron hit it right into just the right rough. And I walk over and I thought, oh, it's probably a rabbit. Look at the all the scratchings

everywhere. And so I walk over and he goes, as he's walking back because he's walked up to the green to check it out, come back to me. And he saw me standing at his ball and he says, oh, what do you reckon? I said, yeah. And then he turns around to his marker and says there's another player and says, oh, can you come over and check this out? And I'm thinking I'm standing right here, right next to his ball. His marker said to me, do I need to come over? I said it's all good, don't worry about it, because he was basically, I guess they're not used to playing with a walking referee, right? And so he wants to check,

rightly so, with his marker. His markers. OK, with him taking relief, right? But it was funny when the marker immediately realized that I was standing there and he's going, do I need to come over? That's it. Don't worry about it. It's all good. I have more authority than you do. I didn't say that, but that's the reality of it as a referee, so. Yes, as being on the committee. Yeah, and on our local rules, it says you are authorized to make a final decision. Players are not entitled to a second opinion. We saw a second opinion, very well televised on TV on the

Saturday, which we can talk about if you want, but on that same green, you're all, I'm just standing at the back, you know, I'm learning more and more now to just completely get away from the cameras. After you were known as the camera chaser. Not called Hollywood fan. That's not true, no. You just the easiest spot to stand is behind the tripod of the camera. That's by far the easiest spot. But I was standing at the back of the green and all of a sudden one of the players, you know, at

the ball and he looks up, looks at the other players and they're talking. At least they've gone. Oh hang on, we do have a referee with the group and they've looked over them. It was just a simple ball moved, he said, oh, the ball just moved. I said if you marked it, I knew he hadn't, he said. I said no, just play it from this new location. But I just thought the marker one was funny. Hey marker, can you come over and check this and I'm standing right at the wall and the marker going, do I need to come over? No, you don't need to come over. Did you have any others? You're good. Definitely had an so this is

we're talking about great international representation in the women's event and I was with the leader on the Saturday on the 8th hole pushed, probably landed on the groom and then just rolled out to the back of the the grass. And now again standing on the camera and you know just minding my own business, watching the play and she makes a stroke. It was pretty obvious it was a stroke because she's looked up at her caddy in disbelief that the ball didn't go anywhere and I thought do I go over and confirm with her right there and then that that was a stroke? I'm 90% sure it is, but at at

some point I need to make sure that that was definitely a stroke. I thought, no, I'm not going to go yet because she's clearly not happy. She's leading. She's just had her ball go nowhere. 20 seconds later she looks over at me and calls me over. This woman was from Japan. Her English was not great and she somehow got out the syllables that sounded like unplayable. And the first thing I said was, was that a stroke? And the Katie said, yeah, it was because I didn't know how I was

going to ask her. You know, her English was not great. I mean she could understand zero through to 9. She somehow got out two club lengths when she was asking that the. But it's just that you don't even think about that. I mean how would I have got over that message to her about what you can do and what you can't do. And a lot of it is just acting it out. Anyway. She said unplayable was very broken. And I've just sort of pointed, you know, back, pointed back on the line. I said like this and she said two club lengths, although it wasn't that articulate and I said Yep, either side.

We marked it out, first drop went out. So again I had to motion to her that that ball's on in blight. You need to do it again. So I send those words as you would naturally, but it doesn't mean she understood them. And I've sort of just motioned that ball's outside the reliefer, you need to drop it again. She picked it up. She's asking can I pick it up initially? Can I clean it? And all those sort of things. But again, it's just how many people who play World Golf speak English. A lot of them, even if it's not their native tongue, this well,

it's English wasn't great. They do say that communication is 8090% body language and tone, so the words really don't matter too much. Yeah. As long as you can, you know, point at a club or point at a. Yes. Area and drop? Yeah, look like a monkey type. Thing. Yeah. And that's why, you know, when she marked out the relief here, I thought she was doing herself a disservice. She wasn't coming out far enough to give herself, you know, so there's no near in the hole. And I've just actually moved to a club for her and just done this. I've done this and pointed at

the hole and without really saying too much, but I think, yeah, you're right, she probably understood what I was doing. And yeah, I mean that was a good one. We had we sort of the hard card under transportation. We know players and caddies can't get a lift and there's an exception in the hard card and that is if they're proceeding under striker distance, right, They're allowed to jump in a car. Yeah, and get a drive back. Just told by the committee that they can get a ride. So we had remember the I length hole at the beach course, which

is a dog leg left and a lot try to cut the corner to get to the green in two. And of course, what's all that on the left? It's all red penalty area, right? And there's no way the ball can be lost outside the penalty area because it's all close enough. So you've either cleared it or you haven't. Yep. And of course we had lots of ball searches in that penalty area and I have one when I was on the I don't toll doing a lot of tio work with the marquee where I'm looking over and I see the commentator on course

commentator drive up in his car and he goes straight in behind the scoreboard to start searching. So of course I drive over, player hasn't arrived. I asked the commentator whose ball is it and he said it's his and he was about 30 meters away and I've gone bang with the timer when he arrived in. But of course that's a situation where you know that model, local rule, which you don't like about a provisionable in that case would help save time. But of course they're not allowed to do that. So they don't do it. But he's entitled to his three minutes of search, right? Even though it is 100% known,

the ball's in the Ben Algieri, they're entitled to that 3 minutes. And we're all searching. This is all on camera. This is actually all being broadcast, this entire search. Can you believe that? And funny, the camera guy is holding the camera right down at his almost below his knee to capture the thickness of the grass, just for some artistic effect. And the commentator saying, oh, it could be some snakes in here. And anyway, of course we didn't find it and of course the last point crossed was like 200 meters drive back and he said,

can I get a ride? Well technically he can only get a ride if he's proceeding on a stroke and distance. So you would be splitting hairs if you say, well no, I can't give you a ride. But of course because timing is so critical, I said yeah, jump in the car. He was proceeding under either back on the line or to Clublands lateral. He ended up proceeding on back on the line. He was nowhere near his stroke and distance. That would be splitting hairs to say no I can't, wouldn't it, when the drive back is like 200 meters? Yeah, I don't know the wording

exactly of the. It definitely says stroke and distance. But I wouldn't. I wouldn't limit it to striking distance. There might be other times when someone's dropped a towel back on the tee. I'd either go and grab the towel or I'd take the caddy back. And you know, that kind of thing. If if the Rules Committee are doing it, that is OK in my opinion. That's how I would write the local rule. Or the hard card. Whatever. Yeah, I mean, I. Wouldn't you know we saw on Live

Live Yeah we're Jochen Nieman who we will talk about with the rules blunder. He won the tournament yesterday in my Cobra in Mexico and I'm in the playoff because they'd actually taken a bit longer to play than what they what they should do or wanted to daylight was escaping them and they had this playoff of four holes between him and Sergio, and

after they hit their drives down, this ad told the Par 4 the tour referee Brett Olin actually said, guys do you want to lift up to your balls? And they gave them a lift from the tee shot to their second shots just to try and speed them up, you know, at 2 minutes, whatever. It was. It's going to help out so. Especially when it's the same for every player in that. Yeah, I mean, that's what that's what you try and get to. The same for every player, you know, if there's a where do we

play the the Heritage. The Heritage had a shuttle service from the 9th green to the 10th tee. I didn't. Think it was that like 100 meters. I didn't. Think it was that big a walk but they decided they want to give the players some support from the 9th to the 10th and so everyone had that opportunity of using it And so they yeah, so so it was no issue. There was that was a a shuttle service put in place for the players but other than that only

the committee. They don't want someone some drinks guy going, oh, I'll give you a lift back here or whatever. No. Well, that happened on the weekend. How did? It we're a course, Marshall, like a volunteer, gave a plan a ride and the referee came on the radio and said, oh, just we're going to be a few minutes behind. He had to take stroke and distance and this person gave him a ride back. And one of the sort of tournament directors came on pretty hard and said no, we don't do that. It's up to the committee to do that.

It's up to the referees. It's up to the officials to do that, not to have anybody, any Tom, Dick and Harry, you know, resident on a Sunday drive, taking that player back. Yeah, yeah. So that was quite interesting. That something I'll learn. So, so the the drinks guy? Of course, yeah. Actually, the drinks guy. Actually did it. Yeah, correct. So did. The player get penelized. No, because effectively the referee was there, sort of allowed it to happen until the tournament director came on the radio and said no we don't. Do that, that, that.

Let's don't allow that to. Happen. Don't let sort of anybody to give a player because then. Once you start, then you yeah, then they have this idea in their head that they can just give anyone. They let me do it on hole three. I'll do it on. Hole or a player can think that in the next tournament. Hey mate can you give me right back. And so like I'm not saying I would have done it or not done it but I now know not definitely not to do do that after that. Did you. I had another one on that on the 3rd hole Remember the path through called over.

I was sitting on the forward tee which no one knew I was sitting there for a little while. I was just so relaxing all the players and there's actually a lot of people spectating on the weekend well right past with 10 meters and I was hid behind all these bushes on the tee and group on the green called me over and we've heard about this and we've read about this situation heaps, but I've never seen it happen real and that was the players ball came to rest on top of an abandoned ball. Yes. And it was on the left hand side of the green as I'm walking over.

How can I help? Just was it my ball? I've had one. I don't believe. That I've lost one left there. Might have been as I'm walking over, she's smiling and going, Oh my ball's coming on top of another ball and I joke because she was obviously in a good mood. I said try doing that again 1000 times and everyone had a good laugh at that because I'm a funny guy anyways. Here. We go, no, I just said try doing that again, having your ball come to rest on top of another ball. So of course who made the thought was, So what do I do,

you know, do I place it next? And I said, well, eventually get a club land, which got her out of the rough. So she, I mean, she had a difficult shot, but at least the ball was sitting on, yeah, closely mine grass. But she didn't have much of A backswing I saw. I watched the rest of the play. She ended up with a four, but never had that happen. Yeah. And I'm glad I knew the rule. So what'd you do? Well, she was entitled to a drop. For free, which she did. She move the ball. So did she get rid of the abandoned ball? She did. She did pick it up and go

anyone. Player strips and threes. She said to the rest of them and the volunteers, everyone else, because she obviously didn't play that ball. But I said just mark the spot of that ball and you can pick up both and clean yours and drop it. And but again, never had that happen. Read about that 50 times and you know, I had that conversation it. Would have been caller if she actually hit the ball and then goes. Well said. That happens a lot, doesn't it? That happens more often. Well, the play makes a stroke and two. Balls come out by a lot I've seen. This happen three times, and

I've only seen this happen once, right? Yeah, so it would happen more often where a guy hits a ball out of the rough and two balls come out or a girl. But for a ball to end up on an abandoned ball is unusual. To know also that, hey, it's sitting on top of another ball that happened. What else is there? If you're on playables, we'll talk about Rory, you know one of the leaders on the 5th hole back on the line, he said. Can I drop it on that tee? In other words, it was another that was the next holes teeing area, right?

Can I drop it on that tee? He asked that question. Was he did? Was that? On the back on the line. Path 3. So this is the 5th hole down the fence and he wanted to drop it on the 6th tee, coming back before that beautiful path. Three 7th hole. This is one of your countrymen. Yeah, right. Yeah, so. You want to drop it on the 6th T? Yeah. Well, because he hit it right, he. Hit it back onto the 5th green. Right. Yeah, OK, so he's hit his second. It's a part five hit his second

shot 3 would just hooked left and he looked at me and I was just standing off to the side. He said. Should I hit another one? I said it might be worth just hitting a provisional. Here's the interesting thing, he said. Do I need to drop it right here? In other words, he thought, well, this is Rogers made that stroke from. I need to drop this ball as close as possible to that spot. I said no, you've got a club length from that spot. He goes, oh, so I can drop it. I said drop it within a club. Well, that was the rule back in

2018. OK, so he was pleased with that and he took advantage of the full club length because it got him out onto a flatter spot on the fairway. So he was quite pleased and unfortunately he pushed that one right threw some spectators into my Bush. I've walked over left, found the ball out of bounds. I asked the referee on my on my way I said can you drive over and secure that provisional? It was in amongst a lot of people. I just want to make sure it's OK because it's probably about to become the ball in play.

I walk over, spectators are over there. I said is that the ball? I said yes. I turn around to the player. He sort of realized in at that point I picked it up, gave it back to the caddy, but then he's provisional now, ball and play. It was unplayable. So that's when he asked can I go back on that tee. I said that's fine and it came back to that on the line. So I've actually gone flagstick, it's only 60 meters flagstick, his ball and I've picked a fixed object in the distance and I've walked straight towards it and I went on and got on that teeing area. He'd already thrown a tee on the

ground. I put a tee basically on that line and I said that's your line right there. I said anywhere on that line. He actually paced it out and they went back another 3 meters. The only 6768. OK, I'll drop it here. Dropped it on the line, probably removed 10 centimeters in play, penalty of one stroke. But you want to talk about Back on the Line Relief? Yeah, well, we saw that Rory made a big mistake at a recent tournament where he went to take back on the Line Relief and he

dropped it because the this rule changed 2023, so he dropped it. I mean, this rule is back on the line. We've spoken about it before. It used to be in two prior to 2019 that you could drop, you had to drop it on the line, but it could roll up to two club links in any direction. So it's like a big circle. Then they changed in 2019, so it had to stay in the relief area. The relief area was one club

either side of the line and you could drop it anywhere within that relief area, not it didn't have to just be on the line. So it was like 1/2 circle. And then they found that players were stuffing it up and playing it from where it rolled closer to the hole because that's what they were used to in 2018. So they came out with this local rule saying that if a player does that and they'd weren't, didn't realize that they can either drop it again or they can just play it and it's not going

to be appealing. I mean that is just there's an option, there just is crap. So they went and fixed it again, went back to what previously was, which makes so much more sense considering it's called back on the line. So you drop it back on that line, but now it's only got 1 club length in which you can roll. So it's a one club length circle that it can roll. That's the relief area that it can roll up to within stay within the one club length circle.

And Rory was playing like 2022 rules and so he decided to drop it within the club length because it probably helped him out, probably got him away from a tree and so he dropped it to to the side. Now if you drop it, if you don't drop it on back on the line, even if you played it from the relief area, you played from the wrong place, right?

So still a two shot penalty, which is different to the one that Joachim Nieman. Oh no, it's it's similar to the one that Joachim Nieman had in Lev where he took free relief from a cart path and then measured out two club lengths and dropped it within the second club length. You only get one club length free relief from the nearest point of complete relief. And so he actually did play from wrong place as well, and it took his he was a leader at the time, took his score back two shots, but he ended up winning in a

playoff, which was fantastic. 1.3 B2 Is that reasonable judgement somewhere in that region of the rules it's in there. 1.3 somewhere here, reasonable judgement. So obviously the committee had a conversation with Rory afterwards, and if that's said to Rory, talk us through your drop on X hole. And he said, well, I worked out where the line was and I dropped it and the video showed afterwards, yeah, it wasn't quite where it should have been. But he said no, no, I thought it was.

He'd be OK, wouldn't he, Because he'd get away with through the reasonable judgement. But the fact that he probably said, well, I worked out where the line was and I knew I could drop it up to a club length off that line. If he said that, that's where the committee would have said no. Well, I'm sorry, you can't. Chance. Yeah, I'm coming back from that one. But had he said no, I thought that's where the line was. And if gone well, I was probably a bit off that Oh well, that's where I thought it was. He'd probably be OK. Yeah, but if they didn't think it was reasonable. Then no, no, of course he. Wouldn't be OK. Of course, but it was within a

club length and he's sort of lining it up, I mean. If you can't see the flag. For example, he's hidden by a tree obscured something. Possibly, but if you can see the flag, it's very unlikely that that would be a club length would be. So again, and we like to, I like to do this, OK, So what is the line in which you cross in which it becomes reasonable? He's a half a club length at some point you've got to say that's fine. Look he did everything he could under the circumstances to establish where that line was and he's dropped and we've worked out now is 27 centimeters off.

That's OK. But what you're suggesting is maybe a club length for the side is not reasonable judgement. But at some point the committee would have to say unreasonable, reasonable and and they're never going to write that into the rules because that's up to the committee on the day to decide. But the fact that he's come out and goes, no, no, I definitely dropped it off a club length off. They've gone well. We haven't followed correct procedure. It doesn't matter how far off it was. You've admitted that you didn't drop it on the line, reasonable judgment or otherwise. Yeah, and suddenly some of with Yaakam or Yaako.

I didn't actually know how. What do you you know how he's Mate's calling? I've all tell me that I've done that. I've announced that wrong, but I think, well I think Allo why it was called just calling Yaako. So that must be the end, must be silent. Is that why, Ken? Wow. That's how white people would say, but I'm not sure that's how the. Span of course, of course. So he yeah, he obviously thought and why he didn't get a referee

and I don't know, some of them try and avoid the referees whether they just don't like them because you know, Yaako's always getting timed because he's so slow. Doesn't want to see them I. Just want to try and avoid them all together and get they maybe they get in his vibe or something like that, but it's just so easy just to get a referee to help you out. Even though those ones are the simplest rulings, like taking a drop off a car path, it's always nearest point of complete relief plus a club length. It's never been two club lengths.

It would have been funny if he said oh actually no, no, I was just taking unplayable. He could have saved. Himself a shot. Yeah. Gosh, very funny. You know, but it would be from where the ball is, not nearest point of complete complete relief and then two club links. It would be from where the ball is. So if you dropped within, drop it. Two club links where the ball was, he could get away. If he said no, no, I was just taking. If someone worded him up beforehand, yeah, so he's saying you want him to cheat. I definitely do not want him to cheat.

So yeah, I mean, it's it's a interesting situation. And they he signed the card, but he didn't realize what he'd done was wrong. You know and years gone past decade ago that was DQ and he's leading the tournament, so he should. He's very lucky that they've changed the rules so it's not a DQ if you don't know the rules. So they just added the two shot penalty on the next day. It's funny how volunteers can get very sensitive. Sorry to send your topic. Volunteers get very sensitive to

when you try to help them. And like, there was one situation where I was talking to a walking scorer about a ruling I just gave and she just wanted to clarify, is that a free drop? You know, that sort of stuff. They know it is, but they just want to confirm. And then she came over to me like 60 seconds later and said, oh, now while we're doing a Latin talking, I think I've missed a shot at each from the other two players. I said, oh, just just ask it. Katie, you know, afterwards, she absolutely bit my head off. And I know that. Like I I know to do that.

OK. Would you rather me say nothing, You know, I'm just saying don't go and ask supply direct. First thing is just go and ask circadian. So just I was saying it so innocently, just, you know, just kind of circadian. I've got a supply. Was that a double or a triple? Did you just bit my just bit my oh, I know that, I know that. It's like, you know, they've been doing it for 27 years and they don't like being told how to do their their walking score. Or I've got another two more stories if I made from the tour go for it. One was in that same penalty area on BJD on the corner and I

see them searching. So drive off, start the time I drive off, get in there, who's following me searching for. Another player enters very, very thick grass in there. And he said, why are we in here searching for it? We know it's in here, it's just, I said to I said straight back to that player. I said if we find it within 3 minutes, he's entitled to hit it, at which point he didn't like my answer, at which point he turned around and exited the search area. What is it?

It's like. To be to be honest, I don't like your answer either, but Michael Long did his shot from the penalty area in 2018 I think and got it out of there and won the tournament. So if it is in a position where they can hit it potentially. But it's interesting that it's like a 3 minute search time doesn't apply when a ball's in a penalty area. That's almost what that player was implied he. Was saying get on with it. I mean, he's had a terrible shot. Just take your penalty. But that's not his call.

Like, no, it's not, unfortunately. He's caddy can say that to the player, but that's not his call. And as I said, I said what I mean, what I said, like if he finds it, yeah, now he has a choice. Yeah, he can either play it or take penalty area relief. One more ball, cleaning a ball. You should have said to him, Are you suggesting, are you giving advice that the player shouldn't play it from where it lies? Right, player lifted for interference, right. And the referee on hand just

said, and this is where a player could go. Yeah, I know, but I don't think the player said that you'd done the play. You were talking to him, we were talking to you, we were talking to him. So they afternoon after play, so you know who is and the referee said make sure you don't clone it and because again the player could have come back with the like of course I know. Anyway, the player said, You know that's fine, so held it with the old pincer movement and then without even thinking or something, at some point later the ball went into the pocket and so there was some concern about was that ball cleaned or

not. And there was a question raised before signing the scorecard and they just simply and and that's a good one I think and that is how can you be cop a one stroke penalty for cleaning a ball when lifted for interference if the ball was already cleaned and. Was the ball. Already cleaned and that's what it came down to. The ball was like there was not a mark on the ball. There was no way that ball could have been cleaned any further. Because. It was already fine, there was nothing on it. Why?

Because it was already clean. Because they've had that conversation and the tournament director went in and spoke to the player about that particular situation, right? And it was like, well, I've just pulled out the box on that too. He's like 1. Shot and it's gone in the dirt. No, no, no, no. It's just on the fringe of the grain. So that's where he's. Got a small piece of grass? That's where establishing the facts is important. And rather than going hey your balls in your pocket, you clearly cleaned it. It was the common sense of, well, probably couldn't have been cleaned at all. Why'd he put it in his? Pocket. Oh, correct. He just just forgot. Just, you know, he was doing

this. He was doing this knowing that I want, don't want to be seen to be cleaning it. And then at some point in the next 60 seconds while waiting, he was just checking his yard. He's doing something, checking the greens. But whatever he's doing and he's going, oh, this is a bit of a baller in my pocket. Instead of just putting it down on the ground. Correct. Yeah. Which I think a lot of players wouldn't know to do that. If you didn't know the rules, you would think, hang on, if I put this on the ground, it's like I put it in play or something and we know that's not the case. 49.4 says that.

But I think a player would think if I put this on the ground, there's some consequences of that. And we know there's not. But you think if you put it on the ground, let go of it, it's like I put it back in play which? Where are these people learning golf? Well, they learn golf, not the rules. Strange, we know Fort 8.4 they don't. Have you got any others from the? Probably I just didn't come that well prepared. I'm sorry, did you have any balls go right on hole one while you were there on the weekend? Hole one on the beach, of course.

Neither maintenance yet just ever so slightly run out of the fairway. Not really. Because we had a They had a big rule in there on Thursday. Night they did. Thursday or Friday, did you see? What it was all. About No, no. But I saw the area on Saturday. I saw what they were talking about it. Was half of it half of the penalty area? I think the almost the whole area was penalty area. Really. Yeah, and there was a went right on that fairway penalty area, yeah. But what we're talking about is,

in fact, behind all that was the ground staff maintenance area. Yeah, And so the ball was very playable sitting in the middle of nowhere inside that maintenance area. There just so happened to be a car, actually. It was right underneath one of the wheels. So it was actually right underneath, very right underneath one of the cars parked in there. And it just came down to was that car a movable or immovable obstruction and whether the play could get relief given that the ball was in the penalty area. Yeah, that was an interesting

one. Someone came across and said if it's not movable, if the keys on it, it's an immovable. And I was like, I was like, I'm pretty sure if it's not movable, it's a TIO because it's a temporary. It's not normally there and that's what they. I gave similar relief Rory. We've got a video on YouTube of Rory having similar relief where they couldn't move the car, so they gave him TIO relief. That was about 2-3 years ago, and then I had one last year in Oman actually, as players hit it

so far left not out of bounds. His trucks parked up there, which is fine, they're probably maintenance staff or whatever, and I ended up giving him 16.1, but he could have actually asked for TIO if he if he was smart enough because we couldn't move the truck. So yeah, I think we I think it was clarified afterwards that it was indeed at TIO, if it wasn't. Movable, right? Not an immovable obstruction,

but it's temporary. It's very important that. Very important, especially when the ball's in a penalty. Area yeah. So one of the things I learnt on the weekend was if your ball's in a penalty area, we know 78.3 says you get nothing when your ball's in a penalty area, you either play it or you take relief. But what I learned is if you have interference by ATIO and your ball's in the penalty area, you are entitled to free relief inside that penalty area regardless of where that TIO is. Yeah, Tio can be in the penalty area, outside or as you said,

not even on the course. Yeah, it could be out of bounds. It could still get relief from at TIO. That's out of bounds. So when we're doing the ball search left of 18, if we found it, the big scoreboard there left of 18 was right on the right on the line of play. And so I'm going through my head, if he does find it, he's going to ask me for relief. And I now know that if it's a Tio, no problem. Yep. It's one of the times you can drop for free inside a penalty area, yes, which we're not going to go through. But no. So I've got a couple of stories

as well. So we obviously went through Rory and then I think we've pretty much gone through Yakko as well. He just dropped, tried to drop free relief in two club links, not one. So you got the two shot, Penny. And now I had a listener seen through a bit of a story. So it's not through clubland exactly, but it is clubland. They were playing middle, middle day off the blue Tees, but for one for some reason they forgot and off one of the holes they played off the white Tees, so

outside the blue blue Tang area, and three of them hit it down the middle or in the raft, whatever, and one of them hit it out of bounce and then he hit off again and hit down the middle. That was Shark Bite. That's his nickname. Please do shark bite. Hoo ha. And then they realised what they'd done. All three of them. Four of them had realised what the mistake they'd made was playing from the whites, not the blue.

So they all corrected their mistake. But they were wondering whether shark bait is five off the tee or three off the tee like everyone else. And I came back to them and said, look, they had to fix the mistake. The This is under rule 6.1 and the fact that one of them hit it out of bounds and he's hit it off the whites again, he's continued play with the same ball. Effectively, even though it's not the same ball, he's continued play with the same

ball. So they actually haven't tried to correct their mistake. So none of those strokes count, none of the penalty stroke stroke counts, and they're all just playing all four of them. Shark, Bait, Gab, Pid, and Soz. So thank you souls for sending that through. So they're all three off the T. 6.1 V 2. Yeah, and now if they had finished the hole and teed off on the next hole, or in the case of the 18th sign, their

scorecard walked off the green. Actually, I think it says they would all be dequeued. Returning the scorecard. If it was a Staleford round, the only dequeued for that hole, but if it's in the middle round it'll be dequeued for the round. But they did manage to fix error and obviously had to add the two shot penalty. Player gets a general penalty and must correct the mistake by playing a ball from inside the team area. The ball played from outside the team area is not in play. That's stroke and any more

strokes before the mistake is corrected, including strokes made and any penalty strokes solely from playing that ball do not count. If the player does not correct the mistake before making a stroke to begin another hole, or for the final hole around before returning the scorecard, the player is disqualified. Yeah, so that was, that was a good one to send through. Thanks Soz. Now another one. Bob sent through a clubland story and this is an interesting one.

It got me certainly got me thinking. A fence with an outer bounds fence with posts and three wires and where one of the wires is broken off and they discussed at the time and they said no, the wire is still part of the boundary fence. But they got further clarification from the RNA and they said no, the wire broken off the boundary fence is actually a movable.

Obstruction and it came into the course. Yeah, it came into the course. By some. So the player could have actually moved that broken off wire, which is quite interesting because if you like, if your fence is leaning over onto the course, what's that? Is that still just part of the boundary fence or? I don't think so. Do you get to? Push it back. Push it back.

No, the first two days I was on the 18th hole a lot. There was a lot of TIO relief for the Beach Club Marquee, positioned very close behind the 18th green. And we know that if the ball comes in on or under the TIO, they're entitled to use the drop sign. There were two there with an arrow, you know, pointing in all directions to direct the player. I have one player and I always say to the player you can still take nearest point of complete relief and one club length and you can play with the drop zone.

Now of course all players bar one use the drop zone and some of them even looked at me silly when I suggested they could take nearest point and one of the girls laughed, said why wouldn't I use a drop zone. I said well and she said it in a very joking tone. I said I'm just telling you what your options are. I'm not directing you to what you should use. Yeah, the drop zone is. The dropping zone is the obvious option to use, but it doesn't mean I just wanted to run through your options. One of the players chose nearest point because it was closer to

the hole than where the dropping zone was. The dropping zone, interestingly the one on the right was on quite a slope that even when they dropped it at the top of the circle, it actually rolled out the back and required two drops and then a place. And even then it required a drop drop place, place move a few times because of a slope of the dropping zone. I had one girl fly the beach club marquee completely, didn't even look like coming in on or under. The Tio actually flew muscling

40 meters, let's say 44 yards, 40 meters beyond the flagstick. At which point, of course she was not entitled to use the dropping zones because her ball was not in, on or under. But she had interference, obviously. Line of sight. So I just did the old more than one club length lesson 2 relief. No near of the whole. The spectators were pretty chuffed to see a ball fly that it was almost on the 14 crane. There was almost a wrong grain interference before the Tio, but.

That sounds like you had a lot of fun at the Vicar it. Was a great event. Yeah, it was a great. Event and spectator of a lot of people. Interestingly, you know with that last men's group, when they fell out of contention, the crowd just died of following that. And because I said to one of the marshals on the weekend, is there any other golf tournament in the world or country in the world that encourages spectators to be that close to the players? It can't happen that often. Sure. No. When the people are literally standing, For those who don't

know, you can have the entire gallery following that group, literally standing 8 to 10 meters behind the player about to play on the fairway. One of the, you know, that's one of the sort of selling points, points of difference for that golf tournament, as well as the fact that we don't really want the spectators walking around in the snake and fest in grass. A lot of snakes, yeah. So never thought about that. When they were starting the tournament back in 2013 that was one of the main reasons let's a let's not put up ropes because

you know they're a waste of time. We'll have the point of difference that the players earning their spectators would come and be so close to the players and and the tagline back then was walked the fairways with the players and we've only ever had. I think we've only ever roped off like one or two holes. 15 on the beach sometimes gets roped off because what will happen is the players will be on the green and. They're driving it. And if they're not driving it, they're just laying up, or they can't get to the green.

But the spectators will be in that little valley bit where maybe the players can't see them, Yes. Or they don't turn around and they never seem to turn around and go, oh, those players were all. Right. So sometimes we write that off, but if there's volunteers there to just tell the spectators to get out of the way, then that that usually works better. But it is quite unique, yeah, Yeah, the spectators that close, Yeah, they're all standing around the edge of the green. Yeah, very, very close. And on the fairways.

Lange's will tell you that one of the reasons that they put ropes in because way, way back they used to spectators would just walk the course. But one of the reasons they put ropes in was to keep them out of the way of the TV cameras. Yeah. And so the TV cameras have access to the players, you know, and and it doesn't delay there missing the shot and stuff like that, right. So I think we've what's your next tournament then Podcast.

Well, you've got some more over for me. I've just done four in a row. Yeah. So now I have February off. My next event will be the National, which is the last, not open to all, It's quite a small field. It's the last event of the season to determine the Order of Merit, winner and etcetera etcetera. I think that's around mid March is my next next event, yeah. Very good. Yeah, mine is Oman. Then I head to mid February and

then I've got Lib Jetta, Lib Hong Kong and Asian Tour Macau, which would be fantastic. Now the golf balls question of the week one O 9. Yes. You have one for us. I do just got to write this. Just finishing here for the four time call. All right, GRQOTW for episode 109.

Danny, the degrade golfer. OK. Danny, the degrade golfer, hits her tee shot way left into thick bushes on the fortnight pile of Bombay Hills snake territory. After one minute of searching, she finds and identifies her ball and decides to take unplayable ball relief. Unable to retrieve her original ball, she drops another ball correctly in a lateral relief area.

As she's working through her yardage book and waiting for others to play, a child crawls under the Bush and retrieves her ball. The child asks the caddy if he can keep the ball. When the caddy realizes it's not Danny the degrade golfer's ball, the caddy advises Danny and they continue searching for her ball, finding it about one minute later. However, now 5 minutes after they began searching for the ball originally, she picks up the drop ball and continues play with the original ball holding

out in five more strokes. She then Tees off on her next hole. What is her whole score for the 14 hole? Interesting, need a bit of maths skill in there I reckon. May need some letters rather than that's, but anyway I'll leave that with the listeners and viewers. Oh, hopefully you'll have a crack at that. I know that Ruin will have a crack at that on YouTube, which would be fantastic. Yeah. Yeah. So thank you everyone, for tuning in for episode 109 of the

Golf Rules Questions podcast. You've been Blakey. We've talked mainly about Victoria Open this week with Podcast Man of the People, Funny Guy McPhee and Blakey. So signing off. See you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode