Down a RABAT Hole | THE GRQ PODCAST EP71 Blakey reports back on the International Series Morocco event. Played at Royal Golf Das Es Salam in Rabat. Including information about pace of play, and a couple of rulings that he had. Stuart & Blakey both share a clubland story, and cover the answer to GRQOTW70. Which brings us to: GRQOTW for #71 - Andy the Average Golfer sprays his tee shot right on the 4th hole at Wombat hills and his ball comes to rest in thick bushes. He decides to take unplayable ball relief and drops his ball using lateral relief. He asks Big P to pick up his provisional ball which is on the fairway. Andy the Average Golfer plays his next stroke into a greenside bunker. As he starts walking towards the green, only 15m on, he sees his original ball in bushes and realises the ball he dropped was not his. With the dropped ball near the green, and his provisional ball in his pocket, how must Andy the Average Golfer proceed and are there any penalty strokes?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode and Opals questions podcast.
Everyone go for those questions podcast. Episode 71 coming at you from where am I Morocco. I'm just about to leave Morocco and Stewart. We're about to you. Well, nowhere near as exotic as that, but I'm in Melbourne today at home, Very good and the weather's. All right over there just starting to warm up a little bit which is nice. Yes that's this. Is it an exotic location for the agent or first time here? I believe and then where I'm
heading off to Cairo this afternoon so It was probably the the golf course was club's top. It was all right, that the grains had life but they say buried elephants under the ground, they were tired at all. But so it was top like that. In terms of the climate temperature, this has been the best stop so far. It's like 26 every day. Sonny, we had no even hint of rain.
Although, you know, and its first world problem. The funny thing about a ditz It's very dusty. So your cart gets full of dust. Your pants will get full of the last year from get full of dust. Probably a fashion here, and everything like that. It's very dusty. You drive down the gravel paths, and you can see the small Breeze, blow the dust onto the players as they're putting on the green yet. He's here to drive faster and
get out of there or you try and stop straight away. But yeah, Morocco. And It's good. Torment only the winner had -12 shop 3-under in the last two holes to win. So that was fantastic. So en Tu Carro next And we have anything. Well we'll come back to that. After we answer the grq OTW 470 from last week. I asked, I asked it straight.
You have in front of you, No, I don't, but in very very short, I think whole Marcella Marx, who ball lifts it and then basically fails to hold out and picks and marker up walks off in the lounge afterwards, having a shot. So, I'm wondering how many sheets, how many shots she had on 18? So the question was just, what is the procedure? What's the ruling? So, yeah. So, that's right, that's right. What is the what can she do? She disqualified, you know, she
just stay in the bar and hang around there, but she does have the opportunity to go back to The 18th hole place the ball, or the ball marker down, she placed a ball marker down. She then obviously going to replace the ball, but base of ball or ball marker. Eventually get the ball back in play and then finish out, it's going to. She's gotten care. A one-stroke penalty.
But lifting, her bull market deliberately on the putting green, but that's at least, that's better than the failure, the whole out penalty. So just just a One-Shot penalty there. Now, if their competition had closed, obviously she'd failed to hold out and in a stroke ground would be disqualified. I'm in a stale for drowned. It's just going to be a wipe for that last hole.
So she bought 10, technically speaking disqualified for the 88 whole but the other 17 holes are fine. But yeah. Yeah. when she walked off the green, She? Failure to hole out, parity didn't apply there, there was built before you sign the scorecard. essentially, so she was able to walk back down to
the 88 and Break bicycle and how that with some awkwardness you know getting involved in another group or interfering with another groups play. I'm sure. Yeah, that certainly be embarrassment when the little bit embarrassing I did actually go to rule 21 today thinking about this particular question because it was obviously stroke. Then what you just said is all true, but then I'll sing it was par or stable Federal maximum score then Marcelo if she chose
didn't have to return to the 18th green and could have actually elected or chosen to have, you know, a minus for the par or zero points or the maximum score for that whole without holding out because I actually just read 21 and each different form of stroke. Play it actually talks about the whole is completed when the player holds out chooses not to do so. So she could have chosen not to hold out and to set off and get it. Just give me the maximum score will give me zero points. If it was stable for will give me a minus so wipe if it was a
par round, but as you save, it was stroke stroke proper stroke. Then either DQ or go back and, and holy out and fix it. There is that famous story of the guy that played in the morning had nine up after nine holes? Ben went off to the races. so that he Sign of scorecard is nine losses on the back nine. So he shot it is it is Pascal
was even or Square and end up winning the comp. It's rather whether that's true or not. That's another question, but good story mention how much you would have won by. Had he actually played the back nine. That's that's right, that's right. I think it's one of those stories that girl that does the round, but, right, so that's the G RQ o TW 460 470. Now, so being in Morocco for the
tournament. Let's just finished. It wasn't too much going on. There are a few immovable obstructions in terms of cart paths. It was a bit of a few tire tracks in the rough. I've got called over a couple of those months. They were a fear while away the away, there are feel way away from the field way. Sorry, I'm less there were really deep and really abnormal to the area.
I didn't provide any free relief option there. they you know, it could have been a car track from six months ago, who's the towel, but most of the tracks were sort of flat with a small very very small bridge but the player wasn't really affected by the bridge itself and you couldn't really tell from the start, whether they would You know, whether it was as I said it
deep. Well, rushd tire track, so on the three occasions, I think I've denied relief from those ones. Have you like the course? You play at Stewart. BC tire tracks will marks a lot. Is there is there? A Bible rule? You have a local girl foil. She's booked me on the spot. Yes, I think there is a local rule, but I don't know that for sure. It seems to be one of those ones that it's just I'm into being a, you know, everyone just accepts
that you get free relief, but it's not, it's not true. You need it as a loan, we talked on a hard card. But we in the rules committee meeting we didn't speak of any massive areas, Plus in the rough as a little, was a bit more of a Sandy area. So you know, it's as I said, it's not abnormal to their course or the area they have those kind of tracks. So we owe my Johnson was that
you're not much else going on or not too much. I mean it was a big pace of play week and we didn't quite get that one right? Which annoyed me to know him but Yeah, the players seem to be difficult. The winner still you know still shot 12-under so I wasn't super difficult - just seem to take a lot of time a lot more than
they're allowed to take. If it is the hard thing is you know the cool thing about live golf was the shotgun start because he runs to the sitting on the same footing and you've got most of the time you've got a hole to play into you know you've always got a hole in front of you give It's got a hole behind you so you can see the groups that are going slow straightaway because then they'll have a whole and a half or two holes in front of them and I'll be right up you know the group behind me right up so you know that they have gone
slow somewhere. So you can try and give them attention. Whereas, in the tube of talk, the two will start slow group, you know they lose a ball that or they just go slow, you know, they Then they just got to hold everyone up. So suddenly the group behinds, five minutes late and the group behind that six minutes and seven minutes and if every group you know, if you regroup you've got 18 groups or 13 because they say that and groups you got
there in groups and their runs two minutes out. You know, that last group is going to be 26 minutes out straight away. That's, you know, just yeah, just the you know, that Time is. You can't get that time back, basically. Hmm, can I talk to ghosts to go faster? So the first group go fast and they might make up that two minutes but then the next group has to try and make up for minutes and the next group has
to make up six minutes and it's just not going to happen. That's why yeah, that's why I really like the shotgun start or but It's a little while. I think the price is just tend to take too long. Surely, they must be some players at that level that they're in a three ball. They've been told to move on, you know, hurry up. You need to pick up some time, it must be one player in their group, it says not, my problem. My comment is going to keep
doing what I do. The other two want to hurry up and that helps us in Soviet, but otherwise, yeah, I was going to do my thing. Surely, that must happen in talking about at least two players, every group Well, there's not many that for look around and go. Okay, we have to hurry up. They listen real close. Maybe they were all good friends. The three of them play with it, you know. And they said, I have say collectively, just go. Let's just pick it up a little bit, but I guess there's a lot of professional players in those three balls. At probably hardly say, woo, hoo each other.
Yeah, absolutely. I never think of that slow or they think that the course it's too hard or, you know, they give me your any any excuse under the sun And then a few of them also have a have a timing. Set up like you see it. You'll see a player, you're not timing them, and I'll take 50, 60, 70 seconds to play a shot. And then you get them on the
clock and they suddenly 25. 30, 35 seconds. Just within that a lot of time But the stuff around you know it's usually the stuff are round. When? when they're getting ready or whatever that they take a long time, if you think about like a path for 15 minutes, You've got so you get from Green?
From the last green to the next day. Say that's around 60 seconds to get ready. Okay, been basically someone has to hit and if everyone get takes as their maximum, a lot of times the first person's 50 seconds, second the third people 40 seconds its 9:58, right? Then basically to walk to your balls, you've got about two minutes, two minutes 30. And then you got another 2 minutes, 10 to hit your ball. And this is all my favorite part
2 minutes. 10 eight-year-old. Then you got another 2 minutes, 30 to walk to the green. Then again, you got two minutes, ten to, to make one part, and then you go another two minutes, ten to make another part. So then everyone has a two-part that's about 15 minutes. And you're thinking about. Okay, so where can people make up time? They could run to the ball and turn that to 30 into a 130?
The most likely not going to do that. I would have thought so no they can make all make birdies and then I'll make up to bullets. That's definitely not going to happen but it's funny though people do make birdies while I'm timing them. It's not like you know suddenly they all play crap, they're professionals. No no. it wasn't that mean to what they learn to play with them. Yeah, as I said play, if they're under time duress or something like the only emotion, is there a tad annoyed? They're being watched.
It's probably only emotionally wouldn't affect their golf too much. If only thing is, they think that I love doing that, they think that I love Putting them on the clock. I would much prefer just sit in the trays and walk some golf. Good, golf play the Good pace and to go and talk to them and have them on the clock. But you know, it's the job that they pay me to do. But yeah. It's you thinking about that 15 minutes prepare for about 380 meters and see if they if
they're not going to choose to run. In basically, they're 50 40, 40. That's the seconds. That the three players had quite. They have to cut that down. And you cut that down to see the me. And I tell people, this is the first fire took, 60 seconds, not not when being timed, but just normally, if the first player took 60 seconds, then the neck, the second player, they've already had 60 seconds to assess
exactly, exactly. Exactly. Take 20 seconds. And the next part they've already had 80 Seconds to assess. So there is, you should only take 20 seconds or 15. It's the hip. But this is this is where the slow group to give me trouble because that third person, they will have had two minutes or they actually end up hitting their shot. And in some cases for them to get, slow becomes slow. They've actually taken long and
that, that is the issue. So, what I see the most of it is that third Player won't be ready after a minute and a half. And they'll take a another 60 seconds foot that. Yeah, I'm with you. The third place should have their clubs out, should wait for the other players ball to come to rest on the ground and they should be hitting mine. You can tip you can spend all that time. You can see some players. You know. You see the players that do that, they won't need the time
and never be time that, you know, but the players are starting fires that just get started after the other two. As a pet. Yeah that's where they definitely going to lose time and they're definitely going to have me coming up behind them with stopwatch. Yeah. Anyway so that was just in terms of pace of play as I said the greens this week were really slow P. So there weren't that many pain positions at the guys could put them on, they tried to keep the
greens. Like around 10 because if you play them anything above if you probably played in my ear King about nine and a half, they were sort of ridiculous that apply to part on the slope just too big. So they would have been slow this week, but that was a necessity to, you know, make sure I got finished and And even that was a tough one, but it's a
bit the course set up. Was I mean, the course out was spot-on. Was minus 12, which is what you're sort of looking for. Although there's the guys said it was there was a par-4 17th. That was only 270 meters. So people were hitting it on with two lines and stuff like that. It was downhill shoes. So effectively, if most people make is free on that hole. So effectively the School was monocyte, although the guy that came second who lost he effectively lost it, he made
bogey on that 17th hole. So, you made a, for a lot of it was intimate by making three, so it wasn't as easy as a vibrant sort of making out, but it was a short, very short, par 4. I did have another interesting ruling in that they sort of had some little fence, but really small wooded fence palings around, some some areas of trees and whether they were landscaped
areas or not, there was sort of up to us as the rules committee and you know some of that obviously landscape is such a Gray beard. Read term. And so, This one was surrounded by car parked and now hard guard. If it's if it's a garden landscape area surrounded by a car, it becomes one with the car part of one-on-one time because Normal course condition when
you're taking relief. You're taking relief from the whole thing, not just the cart path and not just the Garden area. That would, it mean that the dropped the guy behind a TI 0? And then I'm kind of glad that he chose not to go that direction. He just said, I can I hit it? I said, yeah, of course you can hurt. He goes over, this little wooden fence thingy is in the way. Can I move it and sort of
discussed it over the radio, got on the radio? It was easier to do that and just said, hey, there's just this fence and it's, it's movable enough. In my mind to make it movable without damaging it. So in my mind it's very similar to that well yeah. And it was kind of similar to that Tommy. Fleetwood thing but tightly Fleetwood video from last year that So in typical fashion, I'm on the radio, trying to get an
answer, someone's already moved. It just like just flattened it and I'll turn the tighter it's like yeah. But you know with the players sort of not stopping him. Yeah, that's right. You know with the so I turn around guys guys it's quite just wait and so I was over on the radio. You look I'm happy that this is A movable part of an immovable obstruction, you know, are they
ever? And then you know there's always a language sort of barrier over the radio and you're trying to explain things. You know, I'm not sleeping, I'm not discouraging using a radio, I would definitely always try and get on the radio, even if your own if you're a 95% confident, still use the radio. But I was happy that it was a movable part of an immovable destruction and so I said, okay that's fine. And then we flattened it down and then he his chip on the green and then I tried to put it
back into its position. And we got on with it. So there are another couple of ti0 sort of rulings and that and that was about it. It was A few penalty areas, Red, Pony areas, obviously. And yeah, that, that was probably about it so good week, but as I said, 5% of your time when you're a referee is Giving rulings and you heard me right?
5% is giving Rollins 95% is looking at your stopwatch and making sure that they're on time. So let's do it. Good, good. How was your week? We're how was your, I've got a club lay and one. I've got a club last story. Well, my eternal actually, I'll go after you. You go with your clubland story food. Well, I think I know what your Club Lane story is. Is it involve H2O? Yeah, it does. Okay, did you want to make a mention about the new rules
book? I think it's released tomorrow. As we record this, you said about ordering because ordering a actual physical bound copy. I got my old one here. Actually ordering these. Yes. Yes, I was. So I'm just going to do more for Victoria because of becoming to one location. But if you are in Victoria and want to order your thinking about ordering one of those books, I was just going to do a
bulk order for anyone who wants one and then hand them out distribute them. I was going to do it just for ya just from day one Melbourne or Victoria. Otherwise, I have to on send it so. So if you are in Melbourne, and let me know if you want a copy of the official guide for next year, and I was going to order bulk bulk water on. Amazon, or something like some
way. Yeah. Okay. Very good. Mine's a simple. It's really not any problems. Just more a, you know, I did my set of Ryder Cup type equivalent trip a week or two ago. 24 players to team to 12, we did the full ball. The foursomes all match play finished with individual singles and on the first night at dinner, Someone walk with a dog with a bone. The first actual round was Tootie, start for our group.
So you had half the group's after matches starting on the 10th day and I just made the comment that, you know, you play the course in the order set by the committee and that means the first hole is your first hole. It just happens to be the 10th hole on this course but it's still your first hole of the match and I said there for you still need to follow the max play index. As if you are playing the first hole and the conversation simply came up at dinner from this one person, dog with a bone. So well, why do you then, why do
you play? If you're starting on the 10th hole and you're playing stroke, stroke play index, you still use the index for the 10th hole. If you start on the 10th hole, I'd say that's that's fine. Because that's, you know, the way the index is done for stroke, play is to assess the difficulty of each hole rank them, accordingly, and develop a stroke. Index based on that doesn't have to be precisely but that's certainly the foundation for having the index. So much playing index is different. The one that we've adopted in Australia, and I think it's widely used that it spreads The
Strokes out across the 18 holes. No, no. But if you start on the 10th hole, stroke play index stroke you, you know, use the index for that whole. Why don't you use the match Phi index? Which I think is 5 for the 10th hole for the first hole? And I just really had to say, well, you're talking about two completely different forms of golf. You know, one is you're playing against a field of 20 to 120 120 whereas in a match you playing just those people whether we one
person or a team. So I just try to impress upon him, the fact that it is a different form of golf and the match play index doesn't reflect necessarily the difficulty of the whole what doesn't? It's more to spread out The Strokes. So I'm just wondering if you had any comments on that or whether that's enough. But is this is guy not. Stroke play you play. The 10th is the 10th. Why do you, you know wrench? My index. Don't do that. I was just trying to say they're different, that's spot-on.
They are different. And the design of the match by index was exactly, as you said the spread out the stroke, so that It's a you and I we're be pretty close and handicap these days. Quite you're going to Fusion somebody that's for sure. I'd say we're pretty close in playing ability at the moment because I can't remember the last time I played anyway. if, if I was to give you two shots,
and, You know that number one number two because a lot of course is the hardest hole on the course is the 18th hole and number one, or number two was the 88 being, you know, you wouldn't get your shot until that a tent pole and the match might be over by that. Now I'm not saying you deserve them, but how about we move it a little bit closer and then when
it comes down to the The if you've already got got your shots, you might be one up or you might be square. And then when we come down to seven and 18, there's no shots to get so. You know, you've already, you've already got it and the same with number one. If the one or two is the hardest holes, any getting shots, they're in a really tight clothes match. And it goes to extra holes, then you're going to get these extra
shots and those extra holes that will whether that's right or wrong. That was the reason why it was designed that way. Why did widely used? It's basically just in Australia that it's used. I don't know, it's not it's not really used outside anywhere else outside the world, it was mainly just developed in Australia for Australians when I was, when I was in New Zealand
we just you we actually had No, we didn't. We just we just had one index, and it was just stroke and match play off that. I mean things. And, but most courses in New Zealand. They don't necessarily. Even out those Strokes. It's just all the odd numbers are on the front, nine and all the even numbers are on the backbone.
So you work out what? The hardest break holds 129 are. And then what's the hardest ranked? Holes tend 80. And then you just Success and then you just get make your strike a match and necks off that and as we know committees can do whatever they want. And and that's that's probably the bigger Point here is the community can use the stroke play mix for the bench play. They can. You know, I could have a match
by a dick so that way backwards, 18 17, 16 15, 14 13, if they want you to him as long as everyone's playing under the same conditions, it is what it is. but, in terms of, You know, just the match play index that's used in Australia. Versus The Stroke by index. That each Club develops. Yeah, the match by an X. That your first hole you play is
always going to be number 18, on the match play index. And M8, the atoll you play is always going to be number one, you know, whether it's a par three of 100 meters or par-5 700 meters. So that was your you've got another club lead story. No, I think that was it, I think. Was a better one. Well, I was just driving around doing a course. Marshal lasts, not the cell. They just go on set the Saturday
before and I'm not going to, it was at Spring Valley, but I'm not going to beat, you know, thoughts. But I see the player. Also near the gray and they were merely a teashop excuse. Not sure the T-shirt would have gone that far as probably the second shot and they're in the penalty area. I see them looking for the ball when I sort of. Was maybe 120 meters away through the 16th hole that's just me guessing. Yeah it's a 6-day poet, Spring Valley and so you can see the
rate of steak the round the red stakes are around this sphere is going to ditch. It is so clear that it's in the penalty area. and, See the guy pick up the ball as I. Okay going to take relief from the peony relief, from the peony, he goes slightly outside the water that he was standing in or all with it and drops his ball. And I was actually what they have.
Let's just gone on here. He's sorry. Still within the penalty area though. These Founders ball in the penalty area and water. And he's gone slightly up the slope to drop it, where there's no water, but still in the penalty area, I go over there. I go, you notice. It has named ago. What are you doing? You guys are just taking a drop out of the water. I was like, what do you mean you're in a purely area? Do I have the right amaka said
that I could do that? Oh, I said, if you take parent, if you take a drop, you got to take a drop from the Peoria area. It's a purely area really for a purity of what And you should our, I'll just put my ball back then. Hmm. And obviously, it's a One-Shot penalty. If you move your ball with that situation, you know, being ignorant of the rules doesn't Inception, doesn't expect get
you out of that one shop penalty for moving your ball because you think you can take free really? I'm pretty sure he why. I'm pretty sure he wiped the whole after that, but I didn't realize that that was a thing that people People thought that because the ball was in water and a penalty area, they were entitled to free relief from the water in McDowell County area. Please Marcus thought it as well. That's right. I mean that sort of control over that sort of goes down to that. Hole mean?
We've been playing together. Oh yeah, it's all right. Don't worry about it. But when whereas, when women do play together, I like not. I think you can do that or basically don't say anything and then they say it after the person sign for the car. I didn't think you could do that on the Sixth Day. Pal. Hmm. We like Well why'd you bring that up at the time? Whereas mean or just lately break the rule and let their let their other player in their
group, their friends, you know, because this is the funny, I think I think I brought this up before but When they play on the Saturday, there was sort of pioneer same for both. Yeah, I'm blocked. And if, if they all don't know the rules, then they're not going to get any better. They just going to make it up on the top and the spot and usually, as we've said before, usually it's whoever speaks the loudest, but when they play in like a when they play in a club Champs or they play in a board of it and have to play other
people that have never played with before. Exactly. Yeah, suddenly the rules become a thing because I got, you can't be doing that. I've always done it with my thought so that doesn't mean it's right. Now, you know how you always used to laugh, because we used to get most of the calls, Brian. And I got We're around February March, maybe a little bit of April and then October November like why do we always really am
main calls? Get only. I think, I know the answer have been around these times from cancer and stuff like that. It's because they're playing with people that they don't usually play with. And start get away with stuff and certainly the rules matter. It just blows my mind, but Now, at least of solve that puzzle we've educated to people, but it comes back to also a rule that is very rarely used, but should be used almost all the time and
that's 20.1 C3. Yeah, it's a provision in the rules to do that. And how often do you see that used? And it probably should be used often, you know, that because people don't know the funniest thing about that is people don't know about that rule. Let alone all the basic rules. So yeah. And you know, and it's lovely, and I guess with that rule, I like, oh, that's just going to take more time. And if you know, I don't have time for that. Okay. You know, it. but then, you
know, I was thinking about this the other day, I was like, didn't you know, do the rules need to adapt to The common denominator because please don't because people people just don't seem to be picking them up that. Well, or that easily or they just too complicated. But he's a, he's a scenario and we've spoken about this before but how about undertaking pursuing a game? And not really caring too much about the rules of the game? How, how do people do that?
You know, sports sports that you don't need to know the rules because there's a guy running around with a whistle or a girl running around with a whistles that tells you about the rules. Yes. And that's the reason like play basketball. We got two referees. Yeah, maybe one, I don't know. Social rascal you play footy. Then that's thinking about the AFL. They're thinking about having for referees on the field net. No, I can't because it's a fair point.
Is someone there officiating? Umpires is two. Umpires breakbeat, isn't is a referee and rugby league. These two referees. It's, that's the biggest difference and the recreational golfer will never see referee. So that's why they always have the So if we we really need to make the rules as easy as possible for their common denominator that won't look at the rule book and we'll just
think, okay? What is common sense in this situation? Now, if you're thinking about a person who always and water and you go, is it common sense that that person gets a free drop out of water? Then the answer is probably yes, anywhere else on the course, that's right. You know, I can't say that it wasn't, you know, you couldn't see that, it was apparent here. Surely, you know, one of the things this guy he would have
been playing for a long time. Surely those what a penalty areas. What a hazard whatever you want to call it. So I was I was a bit I'm very baffled by that one like that is I thought I thought you couldn't make that one anymore. Simple example penalty area, there is no free relief. But they still managed to get it wrong. So you know the rules are difficult because of the varied nature of the course and the
field, sporting field that we play on. I have no problem with the rules you and I have taken time to study them and enjoy them. And enjoy playing a game within the boundaries that it's meant to be played. But it's still every, you know, and I see Referee professional golfers and I see they have no idea. I'm feared their task. Their skill is wielding that metal Club to try and get the ball in the hole.
They're not thinking about, you know, not hating it down the Fairway. That's thinking boa grade, feel like green, but then sometimes they get into tricky situation, but I just go back to this. Common denominator of the most common sense situation. Do the rules need to be dumbed down even more. It's a tough one. It's probably one that I grapple with every day. Well, we know it's not happening in two months, I think also.
Well, not yet the to quit too soon. I also think in the absence you make a very good point about every other, almost every other sport, there's an official and very obvious playing an active role, not active. But certainly being there to officiate when now, we're going to have one. So when you come into golf at clubland and there's someone where you have to report your score to after every, Whole and they've sort of have to agree with it. They almost take a de facto role of being an official rules, official, referee. That's how a player would see that marker.
And that's why we see markers become a little bit, too enthusiastic with their role and, you know, giving the player permission to do stuff and well, knowing that's not their role. But that's, as I said in the absence of an official, it would be easy to think they take that assume that role. Yeah, that's a good point. So, it stores are reporting the school to them. Hmm. Already, in that case, it's a majority rules that the rules are created to say, well, if you don't know, or if someone needs to look after you, someone needs to be your supervisor, that is
the marker because they are playing with you you know you can't play by yourself because who's going to supervise you. Hmm. And he's going to agree to your school. He's going to agree to your score. The you had that 50 shot that 58 I've seen on Twitter recently, so many people want to hand in handicap cards for solo rounds. And I that blows my mind that we
would be allowing, you know, you've got to let you know, the rules are going towards that integrity and honesty, okay? I get that. But knowing knowing the integrity and honesty of most people just you know the what would happen there if you were able to handle the solo around you know what would what would actually happen is 95% of people would have a lower handicap and they actually should Sorry.
You know, someone who needs shot. 84 guy all year, but I You know, that pops that was two foot. I would have given myself that I would have made that another time. So I'll just give that myself and shot 79. And so I'll actually 95% of people have would lower head cap. I don't care about them, it's the fog. I would have thought the old, a thought, the other the other way. It's the 5% better have the higher handicap that we do that. That'll be the scary. Yeah. The guy or girl should be flying off five but they playing off 25 and when the see grow Club
Championship, right? By Twenty, Eight Strokes spot. Mmm, that'll be the scary ones. That's why you don't lie are so low rent. Hmm, well, we know Board of Ni major event. That is a handicap event and they hang in there, three cards the week before that event, you know, that's been wrong. Yeah, that's right. I mean, the number of the numbers will eventually work themselves out but not if they're doing it just leading into a major event. Yeah yeah that's right.
Doesn't matter if you win a cell type are called get 40 bucks but if you're the Windsor Club championships and you know your name is up on that board forever. Not coming off people walk past and they go oh that guy go check it passed it kind of ruins. It doesn't And, of course, disadvantage is the more deserving winner. Anyway, we could go in a bed that for a long time. But so you sent me a video from the woman's Asia Pacific.
Is that right? Yeah, the Women's Amateur asian-pacific. Just got played on the weekend just finished yesterday. Correct. Yeah. Now you've showed me a video which is amazing example. So thank you, I will get that up as soon as I can. I'll probably be in transit but hopefully I can try and put it out before we drop the Zone next. Tried to work that in didn't quite work. We drop the Zone. He's own. Drop the next newsletter.
Yeah, I'll try and get that onto YouTube because it's a great example and that would be what I've seen is blatant, but it's also common. That would be a common thing that people think that they can just press grass down behind the ball. It certainly clubland. Yes. There's not the scrutiny, but That's one of those situations are if I might say it's preaching 8.1 I think that's one of those things in the rules that can be a little bit subjective and a player or a
sorry referee can be observing live or watching the video replay and going. Yeah it's sort of maybe moving bending breaking its maybe improving one of the conditions. Maybe not not really sure as opposed to did the ball move or not or was it out of bounds or not which can be a lot more decisive but I think as you use the word blatant as I I did as well. When I maybe send it to you, that, that was just to me a latent. Clearly a misunderstanding of the rule or just a brain fade or
something or not realizing that she couldn't do that because that was so against a point one. Yeah, let's say really was. Let's say that she didn't realize that she couldn't do it. You might have seen someone who local Club do it. She thinks that that's normal. Let's say that she she didn't actually cheat on purpose and you could have just been frustration as well, you know, she just dropped the previous stroke of Dropping out of a penalty area so she's hit through there and realize this isn't a mess, had a swing at it
in the balls gone nowhere. So she's now a Additionally, you know, additional frustration, as you ended up taking unplayable, then of course you got the general penalty on top of that. So I end up getting a 10 on a par 5, but it should probably just frustrated to that point, but Realizing that the tournament that she was well and truly in and as much of a shot as anyone at winning it was probably just going to dissipate really really quickly on that one hole. Yeah yeah anyway I'll get the get the video sorry reg.
We see that one and like make comment whatever you want to do. Did you see actually defined mention before we go into g oq o TW 71. I was having a bit of a comment war with someone. About the related acts. You see that video where the guy for practice swings in the bunker and then grounded his club Behind the ball?
No, the practice swings in the bunker, etops the same and any groundless club Behind the ball before he played the shot, how many penalties would you give for that? So, if you're talking about related acts, so we know that how you break up related acts as like making a stroke at the ball. Makes it a separate act. Putting a ball into play, makes it a separate act. Being advised of the breach makes it a separate Act. But if you just take multiple, I think it's just a one General
penalty. Unless there's an intervening act, you know, hey, you can't do that, you and I know the rules and then going, yeah, that's how I read it, and that's how I roll, you know. It was a it was a multiple breaches of 12.2. Do not be too or something like that. And so it was just one General penalty, it's which is different, say you, okay. If I give you another set example, say, if you Put a towel
under your feet to stand on. And then you also face down grass right behind the ball. Yeah. What do you reckon is are they related? Yeah, I don't think they are. And I don't think they are either. I think you're doing two things to improve your conditions. Yeah, maybe that's what I so I would, I wouldn't say they were later. I'd say that unrelated. Then you get to General killings
unless you were using the tail to press down the grass. But I don't think he described it there like a point. Yep. Whereas, but they do give an example in the rules where if I said to you, hey, I'm using a 6-iron. And also, if I were you because the pins on the left hand side, I would hit a little draw. Would you say that there was related or unrelated? It's a really, really good question, has a I'm in, is to
me, has been very much two separate pieces of advice given their so they sit in the same sentence. Probably didn't draw a breath. But I think look, I don't know for sure but I'm I'm tempted to think there's actually two bits of advice. That are related to the next stroke, do that's the link. That's right. And that's that in that case, it's related to one stroke. And so they they they give an example of that, is the relate to that. I'm intending to influence the
plier and how they play the whole than in shot on walks. The next shot, not two shots so that's they give that example. Anyway, they're going, they're making it simpler and next year. And you, and I are going to talk about the new rules. As soon as we can but they're make it simpler. So basically any breach any multiple breaches. Between an intervening Act. Is just going to be the one
General penalty. So everything that we've just talked about described is just going to be one General Kelly so you could build a start improve your conditions behind the ball. Filling a hole on your line, apply all those which we consider multiple breaches at the moment. We've just be and this is how I'm reading it under that 1.3.
It would just all be considered related accident. Okay. The, you know, that the penalty drop from a penalty area of the unplayable. You still incur that penalty. So if you drop your ball from a penalty area and you drop it in a wrong place. Play from the wrong place, it's going to be three purely. Still come from the mall. Yeah, right. So you still get that only for the era of play, but the way
it's reading now is that just make it really simple as you stuff up multiple times, you still only going to get the general kill. Anyway, we'll go further into that once. We've had a bit more of a study of the rules of Go, Now, gr Q OT w71. Is it back to me Martin? Yeah, sure, you know, it's not
really. It's not really fair to say that. It's it's at a we take it in turns it's more. You you do most of it and I just jump into laughs. All right. Well I think you well I know you know the answer to this but here we go. Bit of a long one G RQ, o TW 4 episode 71 Andy the average golfer sprays his tee shot right on the fourth hole at one bad Hills and he's ball comes to rest in thick bushes. He decides to take unplayable
all relief and drops his ball using lateral relief, right? Two Club lengths. He asks big p to pick up his provisional ball which is sitting on The Fairway and in the average golfer plays his next stroke into a greenside bunker as he starts walking towards the green, only 15 meters on, he sees his original ball in the bushes and realizes the ball that he dropped was not here. With the dropped all near the green and his provision of all
in his pocket, how must Andy the average golfer proceed and are there any penalty Strokes? Wow. That is a tricky one. So he's played a ball off the tee. he's been to some people wishes, he's them found able that Ritchie things, this is what she thinks is, his is in an unplayable lie so he takes an unplayable, drop His provisional
ball. Did he ask for his provisional ball to be picked up? Yep, he asked big p to pick up his provisional ball which is on The Fairway. So be pleased on, you know, you go got it. It wasn't a case of big teeth picking up the ball by himself. He got the answer permission from a family book, found my ball. Can you pick up on provisional for me? Please, I don't have to come. Pick it up. Drop it in there. Correct. He's dropped it in the relief area for that table. He's played it into the greenside bunker. Phoenix, walked forward to find
his actual ball. That he played from the teeth because I'll know what do I do now? Jesus, that is a tough one. I'm a tough for you, the Echoes of is it's not. It is that right? Yeah. There's a good one. Fat 71. Anything else you wanted to say? Let's go before we wrap it up. Well, good site travels. I believe you traveling today, safe travels, and I hope you
will more the Exotic Adventures Continue. This week in Egypt. Oh, I'll be back in Melbourne, in a week's time and we'll catch up there. Well, I'll be a way to myself. I'll be on holiday, but right when I get back, so, yes, we'll catch up soon. Excellent. Well, enjoy the rest of your week and I'll speak soon. Thank you.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...