OMAN That Was Good - THE GRQ PODCAST EP79 GRQOTW78 - No penalty stroke, but it is a recommendation. Clubland stories from Hurmeez. - Dropping in the relief area - Provisional ball after playing a wrong ball From Darrell - Playing from a wrong place and the intention to take an unplayable From the Tour - Truck that becomes a TIO (similar to Rory last year https://youtu.be/JSZQi6En8T4 - Burrowing animal hole - Taking advice from a four-ball partner when also playing an individual strokeplay. GRQOTW79 - Helen holes her provisional ball, but Charlotte finds Helen's original ball, what is the ruling?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
It's a big episode 79. We have mini clubland stories and cluding significant Advantage, the relief area. And what happens when the ball rolls? Outside that relief area. We also go to the tour for a couple of rulings including a pickup truck, parked halfway across the out of bounds line and on the course it doesn't have the keys in the ignition and we saw some interesting Rawlings at the Waste Management Open. Oh, and one of our favorite flowers picked up something else
at the AT&T Pro-Am that we discussed. So, sit back and relax and enjoy the chat between Stewart and Blakey about the rules of golf goal is a test of character. For it isn't just a skill and playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Welcome everyone to episode 79 of the golf rules questions, podcast, I'm flakey your host and with me is co-host against
Stewart. McPhee how are used to I'm very well Blake, you're good to see you wherever you are in the world, right? This second, you can probably tell us sir, we are where you've been where you are right now, and why? Yep. So currently, I'm in the Intercontinental, spa and Beach. I think this to ear in Doha, so got to make sure say the right one, but I'm in Doha, in Qatar, we have the international series Qatar this week so it's kicks off basically kicked off
yesterday. I guess the players are coming in practiced around and stuff like that and we've got a double shotgun. Proam tomorrow. Now I'm a fan of shotguns but a dull one is is a big day and then we've got the four days of the torment on Thursday through Sunday. Now, just been in Oman, for the international series Oman, and that was fantastic. I love the course. It was a coastal course, but had a warm season. Grass at that cut down and
rolled and made quite tough to play and win. Got up on Friday and Sunday, making it very, very tough. Slide the rounds down a lot where, as you could see on the Thursday and you see from the scores, you can see on a Thursday and, and the Saturday that the The conditions were amazing defiant and and hits the schools were so good. So it was a bit of a roller coaster United scores were low, and then sort of average was more on this Friday.
The average school was more like 75. So if he shot one over there, you actually went up the leaderboard. And then on the Saturday, the best score of the day was was 8-under. Great score. And then again on Sunday, you know, the best score of the day was think there was a sixth, the seventh it was 68 but they were the early players who played probably 12 Holes without the win and then yeah, the average
score on the Sunday was probably more like you are or 73. I did what you did on Sunday and it looked beautiful. You know, as you said Oceanside, but it looked really, really windy. As you just said it looked at and you could hear it through them. Mike's and I look forward to hearing any stories you may have from any of your rulings, including one. I saw involving a vehicle, which I'm looking forward to hearing about, yeah, for my mom. Yeah boys funny. Well, I'll kick off that in a second.
We better do the G RQ. O TW 78 answer, do you have the questionnaires? Do I do? I'm a bit embarrassed by this because it's involved me Stuart, I'm Ross, Flying. Imagine wombat Hills in the first round of the one. Back Hills cup, quite a prestigious event on the First Tee roske. Ross asked, Stuart what personal identification Mark. He has on his wall and Stewart. Refuses to answer, saying only I am playing as trypsin. This infuriates Ross, who asks
again, insisting, Stewart is required to answer when Stewart does not reply Ross requests, a ruling from a nearby referee. What is that ruling? It's an interesting one because we li are obviously there's a recent situation, A rules, mmm, grogg vo on the DP World Tour about the situation. But for mind, the answer is, you don't have to put in an
identification mark on your ball, but you really should You know, even if it was just your initials SM or for me with DB, you know, there might be a few other dbe's out there, but maybe they don't use maybe a use green pen, or blue pen or black think. So yeah, a good idea to put it identification. Mark, with no penalty. Ross can't penalize Stewart, but
It's a good idea to. Yeah, I'm with you there I think from a courtesy etiquette probably good practice like a mic on it just avoid so many issues potentially during your round but I would stop short of the referees going to go. I can't force him like I there's nothing I can do, I can't penalize him. I'm not giving you the first hole just because he doesn't have a mark on his ball or he refuses to show you. It's just a yeah. Similar question we get is does the player have to tell everyone
what ball though using or what Mark they or identification Mark have put on the ball before they tee off and the answer to that is also now. So there is no requirement that you tell someone what will you using. But again it's a nice thing to do. It's you know, each to be called. But etiquette we're happy to keep using that word but the word And the book now is behavior and you know, that good practice basically good behavior and that you show the other
people, when you get that you're playing with, you know, this the ball I'm using marked it with, you know, couple of red lines or a kangaroo or whatever you do. I know if you a few events I've been to with golf Australia that involve match play and they'll be a golf Australia staff member on the First Tee. Starting them off. And on might be there, standing on the First Tee waiting to drive off or follow them or something. The gulf is really a staff member as part of their procedure will say to each player, show each other, your golf ball and your mark, and
they're not as a ruling, but it's just a practice and of course, both players go, here you go. I'll put a, you know, an elephant drawn on there or something. But that's an interesting one too because, you know, just as a starter is about seven things as a Starter that you should say to your players before. They hit off one would be heavy, put of identification mark on your ball. Another one said he had counted your clubs. Another one would be heavy
already. The local rules. So you're saving got a copy of the local rules here. So I had one that leads me into Omar and a situation where guys headed out of bounds by way out of bounds. And it just so happened because this is where like half where the confusion came. Just so happened. That club captain of the golf club. Beautiful Golf Course was there and it was this Ridge left hand
side of 16 that they usually have white Peaks on top of the ridge. And that Define the out of bounds for that club and we'd come along the Asian to it. Come along the rules committee of ripped out those steaks and made it the edge of the road plus the paved. But so, essentially the pavement, although I doubt anyone's walking down there but we come along and said, and we've written that in the local rules, left hand side of 16
defined by paved area. And so the players like all my ball and has balls across the paved area across the road, into the other side of the road between two roads. And he said, well my balls over there I was like that's out of bounds you guys. Well I can't see any white line. I go. Well it's is no need of for a white line. It's defined by the pay a bitch. He goes or how do I know that. Okay. Well it's in the local rules and goes, are you sure?
Hmm. You know, yes. How's the you know I've Gotta Give an attitude and said between you and I only one of them is read it. I did not I'm not quick enough for that kind of thing. I just bought back in the city. Yeah, it's definitely an ace. Sure no worries went to his provisional Bowl. I mean, but I did on the same whole head of another interesting situation closely out of bounds, but it wasn't
where some person I have no idea who had just decided to park their truck or a ute. Okay. Pickup truck or youth whatever and it wasn't even parked in a nice space. It was just parked across the pavement. Sort of up on the curb half on the road up on the curb. And this player actually kind of got on TV, very Inson. It's a all left on the 16th and the second shot par 5 and and it comes to rest near this truck
and you want to Rolling you mainly want to ruin because it's his balls and this weed grassy area shit lie. So he definitely didn't want to play it from there and that's why I was looking for any type of free relief anyway. He was entitled to relief but if I could have moved the truck, if the keys are in the trucker, would have moved it. Because it was a movable obstruction. However, when it stopped becoming a move obstruction
because we couldn't move it. I mean no one was going to lift it off then instead of becoming I owe it became a TI o because it was only temporarily be. It was only there for the tournament. It wasn't dear all the time, say a cheer. You know, it's a park bench that hasn't been fixed into the ground is a movable obstruction.
But Doris who's 80 years old and being so then that's not a movable obstruction. It becomes an I/O it's always on the course but they can't move. Okay, so that's the difference between a move for obstruction, immovable truck. Action. Actually, I did one of the videos about that, but when becomes a TI 0 is when it's not normally there this truck, this unit is not normally on who I'm
not normally on the course, and definitely not normally where it was parked. So I've provided in the free or life. You know, I had the relay found that a, I owe more than one, less than 2 or you had the just normal because it was in his backswing just normal 16.1 and we basically got them to a relief area that covered one of those and he was happy with that. He actually hit it on the green and then received a three-part. So not good about the three part but it was a miraculous shot to
get on the Green. It was, I was watching. You told me about it and I went and had a look at it. Was his ball under the vehicle? No, not quite, not quite because your commentator mate. Actually said that unlike commentary so and you know who I'm talking about. But obviously, they, that was what I had thought that was actually straight underneath, but not quite. I need to help them out with their all of the gulf, but that we're actually on the bus driving back to the hotel and they like, how'd you know about that one?
I was like, ahh. What happened to Rory? Seven America and I pulled out my phone and showed them the video that I've got on golf balls, questions YouTube library and they're like, oh well, you're the right person for the job as I get surprised, you know, the rules. Yeah, that's right. Actually, I think of head.
I think I've had it before myself and I couldn't remember whether it was one of those. Superintendent, like John Deere or Toro type cars, or it was one of those. It was the maybe I'm thinking maybe the right hand side of hunting Dale on the first hole when they played the Masters, this one by first torment, they the TV guys would park their
cars and normally the wrong spot. Not realizing that some of the players, terrible that play the game. And we had to go through the whole procedure and ti0 that car from there, the tedious. Atonement at the time. Was not happy about that situation. So anyway, I have had it before but you know, it was even better that Rory had it last year and we pick that up, you grab it off the TV for me? Yeah, we compensated about it. So, when the bounce within about
four seconds, you have it on your phone playing. The showing everyone in the bus? Yeah, only finer, I can. I just rewind to your first story about the ball being out of bounds and the players hang? How do you know, how do I know clearly? All the players giving you attitude and as a human being, you want to give a bit back. But in that situation, do you find yourself using want to get out of there as quickly as possible and remove yourself and not talk to this player any longer than you need to, because of the clear attitude and how upset the clearly not happy?
Well, I'm not here because I hit a bad shot and they're trying to get away with it, but I'm not not necessarily that I want to get out of this. Probably I'm thinking about how to get the situation finished as quickly as possible. So that the players because if they're called infrared and to talk to me for a minute, You know, that the velocity minutes they've lost three minutes and so, suddenly, it did grow three
behind time. Now funnily enough, because Saturday was quite a nice calm day in the scores, reflected that, we were actually running ahead of time and so we could have lost a bit of time somewhere. And so everyone was sort of, you know, with the beer with the berrykins, enrolling in the car. I was taking my time to get there and then I was talking to him and I was getting a, what I would say, a little bit over involved as a referee.
And that situation, you know, I walked around the truck and tried the door to see if I could move. Open the door and move the truck. We can jump in and I'll run it. I would have moved it out of the way. But you know, I had, I knew, I had a little bit of time to kill and a little bit, you know, tried to delay it a little bit and Adelaide enough that we actually finished pretty much right exactly when we wanted to. So I've got Pat's on the back and everything from that but
normally normally I'm trying to get out of there as quickly as possible and I'm not quick enough. You know, why with Mae West is not quick enough. To fire back some kind of attitude to the player. I just whatever question, they ask. I'm just dead pan. What's the answer is it? Yes, 17.2. Is it any point? Yeah, just just give the answer. Yeah, I'm just basically not. I serious when it comes to them asking a question.
I don't think they do control. Hmm. I am. I was going to mention this to you last week at the TPS Murray River and then I Was it on Saturday and Sunday with the broadcast? The play? The field was moving so fast. Of course behind the scenes, the people you would know were concerned about the field finishing. The final work finishing too early and then being too much air time to fill on TV and that's a concern as you know. And so we were talking about on the radio about how fast the
field was going and then some of the conversation that happened and it was only four of us the tournament director and three others. And myself the conversations were having about slowing the field down. And when someone got called to a ruling, the TD jumped on and goes now make sure you take you through all of his options. Like it was really take your time because we needed that time. We need to actually slow the field down and Sarah Jane Smith on the Saturday. I helped you with a quick call search found it.
Within 40 seconds person you were. No, I won't name them gets on the radio to me. He was only 100 meters. Aye could see me say, Don't just tell Sarah. She needs to slow down a bit. She was in the city last group and so, I am were waiting for someone else to play. And I just jokingly said, I said, you wouldn't believe what I just heard over the radio. We really need you all to slow down because we're worried about finishing too early for TV and she just burst out laughing saying. We always get told to speed up, what we never told the Slowdown, but some of the other conversations were having about trying to slow the field down
for TV. So that's interesting. You talk about that and the Pats On the back, you got the doing just that. Yeah, it's something that people don't really know that. You know, the PGA Tour can play all day and and don't have to worry because they that book their TV time. And they their TV time goes until the last person. The last power, puck drops, that's not the same and Australia for the agent or for the European to it. We've got a certain amount of
time. That we have on TV and we're trying to get our TV groups. You know, the good players, we're trying to get them on TV as much as possible on Thursday Friday and then we're trying to get the last three or four groups on TV as much on the Saturday Sunday. So, the last putt drops and they've got five minutes to go before they will, they finish. So it's an interesting concept for a, you wouldn't know as a TV watcher And some of the
obviously, a lot of that older guys, that have been on the tour for a while. I know it. I heard all about it. I understand it. A lot of the younger, guys, they have no idea. First of all, they don't understand what people are pushing them to play faster. Second of all, they don't realize. When, you know, there is a gap, F ahead of them by someone hasn't come and talk to them. It doesn't happen often but we had it in Saudi. We thought the conditions would be a lot harder and Saudi that they weren't they were a lot better players there and so we
missed. I think we missed the TV. Tom by - 25. So we were under 25 so then TBF to filler neck, 25 minutes whereas a man on Sunday we missed by Tim as well plus 10 yes oh not not a good not a good tip on that. Whereas so that's a that's a big guesswork you know you're trying to work out from how they play the day before you've got to take into whether if the wind changes that make the day after you know it's going to play
slower. Because, you know, they have to readjust their well, I hit five iron here yesterday, but now it's a pitching wedge or the other way around. I had a pitching that would now it's a father. And then if you had a 5-iron, you're less likely to be on the green. There's more margin of error so you're going to further away. So it's an interesting concept that people really don't understand. So being a referee, I'm tour is really, you know, it's 80% well it's 90% pace of play. Say, you know, the rulings are
actually about pace of play. If they were, if there wasn't anything to do with pace of play, then you could just have one referee and one, referee would just go the whole course wherever they need to go. Yeah, yeah. Takes 30 minutes from the get one from one side to the other. So, you having more referees, you've got more chance to get there quicker, get the ruling done, and get him going. So it doesn't, it doesn't affect pace of play as much. And you know, the players some players are Keen to blame the
pace of Play. It's sorry came to playing, I had a rolling so that slowed us down. Yeah, well, you know, Now, you, you've got to hurry up. It's all right. You know, I can only just Give you some very upbeat. You're the one that has a club in the hand but then the ball on the ground, you're the one has to help us out. And, and it's all around, you know, Thursday Friday, thought her and get finished before the sun line. Are you going? You know, we're in Melbourne, at the moment, it's summer.
So even if you run door, 6:30 or 7:00, yeah, you missed TV time, but everyone can get finished. Whereas we've got 11 hours of daylight it, this is winter time. In the Middle East. And so daylight hours is short, we've got a full field, you know, we've got 132 players. So it's a testing time to try and get them to play within that time and before the daylight hours a dump, you know, and
What's the repercussions will people have to stay later or if we don't get finished, they have to come back in the morning which kind of works on Thursday because they're coming in the morning earlier. But, you know, they have to work wake up two hours earlier, see off and 7. Instead of 9:00 and A2 is very, very important partner is TV and broadcasts and keeping them happy. Absolutely. Absolutely. That's really important. Partner smaller to smaller to it like Page 80 so big that they demand that they support.
You know the TV Works around the PGA, pull the strings are it's the other way. I'm the agent or Australia australasian to is the to our works around the TV, you know. So you know, once you can start demanding, it's easier. But until then the referees job 1910 as pay Supply. And so you better know the pace of play policy as well. Now, The other thing I had for Omar we talked about last and
the last podcast about spotters. Oh, It has to be one of the most have got jobs, the try and get volunteers at these smaller. Membered, clocks and courses and areas where we don't have a lot of volunteers. So someone was saying that they got a group, but someone said they got people from the military and on Thursday to help out as fathers and volunteers.
And they didn't know anything about goal and they were that they were worse for the players. Then not having anyone. You know, one guy was on his mobile phone in the middle of the field and the players are trying to hit their second shots. And he just, he just walked just look to the side and it was just and then he and then he came up to me. He said, you know and there is speaking broken English. I appreciate that. I can't speak two languages. He's at least got one and a
half. You guys. I need to go back to the office and I'm like, well, okay, is it going to be a replacement? He couldn't answer me that he just, I could take it back. I was, you know, work and I had to do with spotting. a job now and then he just walked himself back and suddenly we had no spotters and, Hey, they all got shirts on the first day and then they didn't come back the next day. And so we need to get more volunteers and we had no shirts for them.
So there's some volunteers out of that were just wearing whatever they turned up and so, you know, just adding on to, I would do it. Almost rather have no spotters at all than have people that have no idea about God. Yeah, you can sir if there's some that you can teach, but you've got to have some kind of idea, you know, when were in Fiji Fiji was interesting. These guys, the guys that we got, I think we had to get it, we had to get a tribe, like it
was kind of, it's not. Let's thank all our Mafia. It was more just tribe and You know they were professional. There are some professional caddies Borden as ball spotters and they were going to get paid it because otherwise you know, they work normally going to get paid at their Club so we're taking them away from their job but then the tribe heard about this and they wanted to be involved and then they wanted also get paid but they didn't really know anything about Golf.
And the funny thing about the G is, you know, at the end of the day or after After the tournament after rakes would be gone. Thus the signs like the core flute signs would be gone. The roach would be gone. And then you know, when the operations go in round two, the tribe to try and recruit these good people. He found Hut's, built by signage.
Yeah, and this life you know, 40 reich's there and rope holding in cows and rope holding in sheep. And given the operations guys said, can you shed any light on what all that stuff in there? Is it just giving you this blank looks? What are you talking about? I don't know what you're talking about. It's ours, your, you're on our property, but basically I'm not saying them, as I said, I'm not saying the mafia is just more. Well, this is where opportunist So anyway back to just following
on from last week. It's a hard job to be a volunteer manager and I quit trying to get volunteers because that you know that's a big part of golf is that low cost labor just to help the players get through and if you don't have good people doing that those jobs it's just a waste of time having anyone there at all the singing of the Australian Open recently had close to 800 volunteers.
The Vic open just held recently. Wouldn't have had that many people but it would have had hundreds well-coordinated you know, 254 back open. And yeah, it's it's well supported Community down there is it brings a lot in for that community that Vic. But yeah, like a prison scap. I think they had 1200, you know, the bigger events are definitely like a delayed or for the live golf or probably ever thousand the bigger events bring more volunteers because a lot of them
are just wanting a free ticket. Yeah, exactly. Free shirt and a hat and a free lunch. Yeah, pretty sure the hair and a free lunch back, which is again, that's another thing. That's a bit of a A joke. But I'll tell you what the good volunteers, a good, spotters good volunteers. They are worth their weight in gold, you know? And and I say that they're worth, they have this value but then at the same time you can't
pay them. Because, you know, there is no money in that budget for that. If everyone came out, watch golf with everyone watched on TV, if you start increasing the eyeballs on the entertainment, the sport. Then more money can be put into the operations budget and that could mean that, you know, volunteers get breakfast and lunch. Is that kind of thing and now
but you and to your I know you've got a clubland story. So fire away with once your mom. Yeah - pretty straightforward. Mine involves match play and just two individuals playing a match there on one green. And one player is significantly further away sitting on the green than the other but he's taking his time eyeing up his buddies. Has looked at it from different angles, is actually walked the length of the green to stand on the other side of the hole and
look, back as he's walking back towards the ball. The other player is opponent. Who is closer to the hole without any doubt Parts? First and holes is Putt and then the player who's our return to his ball. Being a lot further away goes, is that an order of play thing? Like don't you think I was further away and the opponent goes on Yeah, I'm yeah. Now I think about it. You probably were further away than I was.
And so the plane of incidence is that mean I can cancel your stroke, like, is that how it works and he's going. Yeah, I think I think that's what you can do. Even though it's hold and and they said, I'll look the spirit. I got don't worry about it. You've hold a good part. No further action. They've been raised this with someone afterwards. Now, this person wasn't a referee in the sense that they weren't appointed by the committee to officiate, For this event. But this particular person is someone you and I know who is qualified and does actually referee occasionally, for golf
Australia. He was asked afterwards and now, are you happy with what's just happened? Is that okay? Just on a ruling perspective, the conversation, they had the fact that the player had the choice, had the right to cancel the stroke and decided not to are you okay with what's happened so far? Or not. Yes, alarm just just saying just thinking about that later but the slight change about the ignoring and whether they've had the discussion so but there's no
question was raised, you're going sorry. Well there's no wonder you keep going you keep going? Well I was going to all I was going to add was that the person who was our said, know you're both disqualified because you both Discussed. Why having a rule and you both agreed to that? And my take on that was, they haven't done that. They've discussed an option that one of the player has, one of the players has. And they've just had a discussion about that they
haven't actually decided and agreed to waive a rule. It just discussed what the rule was and the fact that the player had a choice to make, but in no way, was that person influence on what that choice was. He's just said, okay, thank you. We've discussed what that rule is my understanding of that rule was correct. Okay, I'm not going to cancel the stroke. Well, well puppet, you know, good good shot. Good putt. I would I would look at it slightly differently.
From both of those views in the fact that if the I would think that they did have a discussion definitely had to discussion. Yeah, that discussion head options. Yes. But that It was for me, it was more about. Is there a penalty? To apply if applying at soon. Is there a is rising?
The question was all sorry, you've played out a turn there. What does that mean? Have you played any, have you played at a turn and the players can all, you know, is definitely closer. I did. I had a brain fade. I didn't even think about it. And so that's why, uh, is there a penalty? That's what I'm, that's what I'm getting at. Is there a penalty is one of the options are penalty that the Player who's headed the opponent's head it. Yeah, let's call him liability. Also is there an option for the
player? To penalize the opponent. Is it a penalty? If the stroke is cancel, I would have thought. So it's not, it's not a penalty. If the straight, it's just you just canceling the stroke. I mean it just as if it never happened. Exactly. Right. And you know, some could say, well there's a penalty because he hold the ball. What we could have had it out of bounds. Yeah. Could have fit into the night. So it's to and fro so it's not appealed. So one point Outside 3.2 D4 if
the plan knows or believes that the opponent has breached, a rule that has a penalty. Very, very, very, very clear that so in my mind looking or thinking about it is, they can have a discussion. Because there's no penalty involved and then the way I can say, while my options are either get you to replay it or leave it alone, right?
You know, even if even if the opponent goes, I'll please please. Well you know, I think there's a discussion was now hang on a second you played out of turn what happens now. And I think they were having a discussion about the rules and then the two others in the fall below. All in a separate match have chimed in saying, I think you can cancel that. And what is that, right? Yeah. Okay, yeah, it's all correct. Yeah.
It's just whether they've agreed to and I can't see how they've agreed to breach a rule or another water that has a penalty. Most of the water that we say that it has, apparently, it doesn't have a penalty. I'm sorry, you know, that advice that that person gave I'd like to hear a bit more. I would like probably like the here is view. But I from what you've presented
to me, I wouldn't see any any breach there. Because they hate. That's how you saw it. Yeah. Look what I presented to you is what was presented to me on a phone call this morning, pretty straightforward. There's not much more to read into it that a very quick discussion about or what happens now and Someone's Child in a while? Well, that, you know, because he played out, or you can cancel the stroke or but it's my choice, right? Yeah, that's right. Okay. Are not aware of it. Any conversation is no breach.
There's not going to be involved in playing out Santa match play. So they have agreed to waive a penalty free. Not only would say, I bet yours is juice. Here, you have a juicier story than me. Mumbling. I've got a match play while just quickly do this one from Chip. Thank you. Chip for sending this morning. It's more a situation which is hilarious. Then the question for us.
But he they played a nine-hole round, robin team match play. Let me just get it up, so I don't misquote it. Yeah, a nine-hole, 18 flight, round robin. And then all nine holes are played in the team of the most one holes gets into a horse race. Which is a bit strange, so it's a horse race with the
first-place teams from other flights. So, That's a lot of teams by the way, that's an awesome competition. So there's eight teams here. 18 is here or eight teams here, whatever, and his team was third on this many wins. So first, let's save, let's save first. Was on five wins. Just put a number on it. Second was on Four Winds and the
his team was on frequent or whatever it was and then they played. Fourth first played second, third plague forth. And they smashed fourth 909 zit. and, first, and second had a Ty, Ty. Ty. Or ended in a tie.
So the competition condition said that whoever had the most wins whoever had the most wins. Yeah, the most matches won in the competition play one. So they've jumped from third to First just because they smashed the fourth bite on them. Now, he was in the winning team and he actually said There's nothing I could do but I wrote an email the next day and they
changed the format because he could see himself that it was quite unfair for the way that they had one. So that's that's a funny story from Chip. Thank you. Chip that chipping in. Okay. Can I just make a comment on that? You know, the course I did. Last week, one of the things that stuck with me, is that the brave one of the presenters said, the committee is always right, even when they're wrong. Yeah, ultimate ultimate power to
do really almost whatever they want. The committee is always right, even when they're wrong. So what we know particular case, yeah, sorry. What was it? That you were doing last week that you found out this gold information. I've had a few little nuggets. I did the USGA Workshop, right, right. And here we are over your presenters, it Craig, winter from the USGA, and Ryan farm from the USGA some pretty good teachers there.
Yeah, very very good. Really, really good. Yeah, so that's an interesting one that the committee is always right, even when they're wrong. What that basically saying there is Unauthorized rules, unauthorized local rules. Stick. So we can belittle the club on the, on the podcast. We can belittle them wherever we can go. If they have a local rule that we think sucks like an out of an ear out of bounds, worst, local
raw I've ever heard and are out of bounds, where if it crosses out of bounds, even if it comes back in bounds, it's out of bounds. Excellent covering Burger. They Had one hope they don't have it anymore but they used to have one. Now, the whole number is changed so I wouldn't know what it is, but they used to have one on. One of their holes, a dog leg is a dog leg. 4:30.
Anyway anyway yeah moving on so no unauthorized local rule can still be enacted by the committee even though it makes no sense. But free relief from Saint feel divots. I was at the club not so long ago. Yeah. Yeah that one or third life or forever preferred Life 4 inches from for Club lengths. Those kind of things. I mean they're not you know they're ordering on just
stupidity and that like a rule probably says through the green as well. I hear 25 Yeah. Well, go beyond that 3032. I'll 2501 sorry. I thought you were giving me a number that doesn't exist anymore $25.25 but it didn't it didn't last year but it does this to you. But the old local rules was 30 3-8. I think that's where local rules different. now, I've got a clubland story from good friend,
Darrell, they're all say, Is that it? That's being tears Mania or New Zealand. I can't work it out now. The ball was hit so it was Green Path and then there's a slope up to the next tee and he's hit on the path so that the nearest point was towards the next T,
but between the department and the next tee was probably let's say five Club things. So basically, just has to drop it on the slope. Behind the path so that he's heading back over the part. He's ended up dropping it on the tee. And then Darrell's told him that that's the wrong place and he still played at anyway. So they'll just wondering what the sort of situation there.
He saying he gained a significant advantage And is this possibly a serious break? So if you think about it, He's dropped it outside the relief area or if I'm problems back. Would that be considered a serious breach? And there's a lot of things that you have to take into consideration for a serious breach, the distance to the hole that he, you know, perceive easier conditions from which
that played from If there's anything in the row, you know, anything in the way before. Before they play it in after they play, there's nothing in the way that type of thing. I personally wouldn't consider that a serious break. I would think that the general penalty would be enough is enough. Yeah, it would be a three thoughts initial thoughts. One is there thinking? Well, it's not going to hold on. The slopes is going to roll back
to the path. Anyway, I might as well go to the flat is maybe one thing though, a thinking, maybe they thought there was some option for back on the line, Maybe? And we come back to the committee and this is another decision that committee we have to make, you said the word, I think a serious breach is whether the player could have gained a significant advantage and rather playing on the down slope. Would that play of gained a significant Advantage? Yeah, I'm with you probably not. Despite the fact it's only four meters.
Like I think it's just. Did they gain a significant Advantage? I think that for me personally, if I was the committee that Two shots would be enough. Yeah, would be enough of a penalty for that situation. Now, it was a two part question, that wasn't really a question, but I wanted to have that discussion, was a two-part. Question is question, is more about the fact that if he's dropped that on the tee, that was back on a line with in a club length. So it Satisfied 19-point.
Two. 29 in point to be taking up valuable now. Yeah, yeah, it's satisfied. 19.2 be unplayable but he didn't have that thought process to dropping it. Under nineteen point to be, can he get away with the one-stroke penalty rather than the two-stroke for wrong place? And the answer is Daryl. No, you to proceed under
19-point. Doing to me, you need to know that you're proceeding under 19.2. 19.2 a or a 10.1 is different but and and 16.1 there's also different. But back on the line and lateral relief, you need to know that you are doing that and you're progressing with that option,
otherwise. Yeah, you're just he was proceeding under 16.1, buddy, dropped outside 16.1 Relief area, played it from there, that's the wrong place. Breach, imagine the committee approaching that person you played from the wrong place. You need to add the general penalty to your whole school. And in the play goes on and I actually was taking up globe. For solitary stroke. Penalty is only one as you say that. Just that guy that can't fly. You need to make a pretty clear
at the time. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. You do. If they did, I'd hate for someone to do that, but if they did do that, I guess I'd go. Hey, will show me where the ball was showing me where you dropped it? Where did the ground first? And take them through the process and see whether there's any way actually did lineup until her now. Yeah, so so good questions there. But you can't proceed under, 90 point to be, unless, you know,
that you're proceeding at a 19-point, do be. Now I had a couple of clubland from our Google forms from the same person who is so thank you. Miz. Again, we have to add the actual name, we should just put nickname in the form and your nickname. So I'm not just quoting email addresses during struck
competition. The bunkers were ruled Gigi, you are Tenga Tim's Bowl, guys in the bunk at any marks is ball. Where? Where we get free relief rules, he can, then he drops it. Bought knee height at the back edge of the one Club lengths, where he marked his relief. This is all good. As I've stuffed up, what he's written. But he's taken relief in a bunker from GE you are and he's dropped it in the relief very well good. The ball then roles within one public hits. The ground also dropped in the
relief here. Hits the ground and rolls back to car blinks away no nearer the hole. Another plan the group Brian suggests that role beyond the one Club length. Semicircle the relief area but Tim claims. The rule was that must drop within two Club lengths of where he dropped it. Tim plays out two balls and then speaks to the golf shop. So that's all good. He's played the two balls. Very good. He the correct answer is Stuart,
you know the correct answer I do. Well, it certainly can't roll two Club lengths. So we find our nearest point of complete relief and then we have our semicircle, our relief area, dictated by the one Club length, but if you drop it towards the back of that one clubland, it can't roll that far at all. It certainly can't roll. Another club went the mainly about to roll 10 centimeters. It's nail already outside the relief area because you dropped it towards the back of that relief area it certainly can't roll anywhere near two Club lengths that's for sure.
Yeah can actually roll closer to the hole just as long as it's not forward of the nearest Point as long as it stays within that relief area and you don't have further interference from the condition. Now, the golf pro has come back and we, you know, you and I love golf pro rules advice and said that Tim's ball was in play as it had stopped within two Club lengths of where it was dropped as per rule, 20 Dash to CBI.
Which I think is actually the correct. Is actually the correct. When it was that, was that a real 20s? Resolving issues? Yes. And then is this correct? As I've never seen videos, demonstrating is 020 Dash to see this 2018. Well yeah browsing to say because now with resolving issues. Really think they're dropping lifting dropping and marking and
wrong. Place was under 20 sergeant. I don't want to get back into remembering all those numbers that I've tried to forget, but exactly the pick, the technical rule that is now rule. 14 used to be rule 20. So he's incorrect. Like, he's looked up the rule from five years ago and got it completely. He's had to go and blow the dust off it. So he means is this correct? It's not correct. What the golf pro said. It's definitely not correct.
It has To stay within the relief area is Stewart has said, and I mean, it's so much easier now, you don't have to get the club out to rise, your waffle rolled to Comics you. All you have to do is make sure that it's within that One Call Away. I mean I love it. I love the change. So yeah, Schumer's go back to the golf pro. Seen him this episode and say you were completely wrong and you're five years behind now, huh? Well I the person who won the big open on the weekend. I actually held him at Cobham
Brewer at the T vs Murray River. Where is this? Taking relief from a sprinkle here. Just off the green and we explained the club link because he only had his putter with him. So he's like the powder down to identify the relief area from the reference point. There is one of complete relief and I said, we actually can, you don't have to go and get your driver. We can sort of roughly estimate. How much longer your driver is from your putter. Because as you just said, as long as it stays within that relief area, whether we mark it or not, it's just got to stay within that area.
Yeah, well, I had a had a simple one asks, similar one as well, where someone just marked with, which I was like, you know, to it's almost too complicated. So well, you know, you can mark with the week but there's an actually matter because it's actually the driver anyway. But in the end of the day, the person dropped it within this far of the nearest Point, On the correct side, obviously, and some thinking, well, he's not even trying to get to the extreme edge of the club link, so it's not going to matter whether he suddenly got a cloned
or what does it matter if he marks in the first place? So drops it right. Stayed within this bar, you know, it's a, when a matter that could be headed driver wedge or a kids club, you know. And actually that leads onto I've got enough other one from Josh Thomas and is not a clubland story, but more I Josh's saying that Western Waste Management open on the weekend and Scott schebler who ended up
winning had interference from a grandstanding took 16.1 and he dropped it right on the edge and it's rolled not very far But he still had interference from the grandstand, so he drops it again and rolls, you know, not very far, but he still has an apparent. So he gets the play set and then when he places it, he doesn't have interference. Okay. So Josh is going well that doesn't seem like you know it doesn't seem very fair that you
are basically dropping it right on the edge. So you end up just getting a drop in it you know they're doing it on purpose just so they can place it in a really nice line. And Josh, I definitely agree with you, you know, they'll at the same time, there was a big push and recently in the rules to try and get them. So there is no drop. Eliminate the drop and you just have To place. There's a reason I like that idea. And there's a reason that it did I kind of agree with and why it didn't get over.
The line, the reason that I do for the reason that it didn't get over the line, it's that it's not random, okay? So if we go and place it everywhere, it's not a brand of you're just placing it in the spot and that's, you know, that's what you get, you get what you get. If if it was random, you get what you get. If you get to place it, then you don't get. Get that randomness of a ball bouncing around and we don't know where it's going to cover the rest. So that's why I didn't get over the line where it's just
placing. But the reason that I do like the just placing his, you eliminate that one club, let length relief area. and so they actually just have to place it on the nearest point of complete relief and we want to try and find a video of Xander shop Lane where you just managed to get this club length away from a tree. If he had to place it on the nearest point of complete relief will probably only would have been Bible five or six inches
from where the ball actually was and he wouldn't have been able to try and hit it on the green. So yes, you get a perfect lie. But the perfect line is closer to the condition. You know? It is just the nearest point. There is no nearest Point Plus Club length is just near as point. So you actually closer to the condition You know, if there's a tree there and you get near as point plus quadlings you can get nearly out the Fairway and not having the what tree, you know. So there's a reason that I'd
like that idea that you just placed near a point and then there's the reason why it didn't get over line because it wasn't random enough. I thought the idea why you would like placing it at the nearest point of complete relief, I thought your main reason would be speed of play. Why? And not going through all that dropping and it rolled out and grabbing it again and doing and then placed it there that would be my second reason my mom met a reason would be. It looks it's closer to where
the ball game actually. Yeah you're not extracting yourself completely that whole comic thing and then and then as Joshua saying he's got nearest point, plus a clubbing and he's dropping on this side of the claw of Ling. That it rolls out that way that he has to drop it again and then place it on that sent when it's rolled out now and on what are your most, sorry on the rare occasion that it dropped and rolls back in this way into a crappy lie. Then if there is a chance, but if you're on a downslope, you know, it's always funny. When you're one of your most
popular videos, is Rory McIlroy on the last hole of a tournament dropping, right next to the red line, knowing it's going to bounce in twice so we can place it. Yeah, and I've heard a player say to me. Oh actually I have another video on there. I think camilli over Jag, he drops it. Yeah. Right. Like this far from the red line knowing that it's going to be out soon. Drop again, bouncing and then place it. And with the knee-high drop, it
has been good and speeding up by because the ball doesn't roll the spa, but the players can be a lot more accurate with their drop resources. They can be more precise and with the berry hints and ruling beside. The car did the same thing. He dropped on the extreme dropped on the extreme so that he could place the ball. That's how they And I work the rules now is it undermining the the spirit of the game? Hmm, it probably is but it's
that is one that's within the rules. As you saying Henson or handsome, Henson's case could have easily Bounce Around the other way glue and to be in play and that was the end of that. It's the chance of that happening. Is really good because it was downhill, but it could have, it could have hit a rock and gone up here and, you know, golf camera. I was hoping for that but that's just one of his Mates is going to listen to this podcast and forward it to him but that's a
good thing. One of his Mates is probably the one that drove the car up there and now one I had another question from Dan, he was watching the AT&T Pro-Am at Pebble Beach. That was two weeks ago and he heard some advice giving Between the two of players and their amateur Partners notably swing tips and whole strategy. Add is the till I get around us from breaking the rules of golf in particular 10.2 there and partners are on that side for
the team event. But they are playing in the individual Tour event, in conduction and conjunction 49 million dollars and you just wondering if we could discuss it on the podcast, if I say that to you. So one person is playing in a nine million dollar individual stroke weight. Another person that playing in and there's some big prizes. I don't know if that cash prizes. I can't. Remember. I mean, they don't really care too much about amateur status over at the us but the other you
know the partner is just an amateur and he's playing for whatever prices they're playing for me. How do you see this? This advice-giving type thing. It's, it's really interesting. I can understand why an amateur so excited to play with a professional golfer, who they've watched for a long time. No etcetera, etcetera, wanting to get information from them about lining up apart. How strong do you think that wind is etc. Etc! Etc, but advice is pretty clear,
during around a player must not ask anyone for advice other than their caddy anyone. That person is playing in their competition, in another competition or is standing by the green watching. You can't ask anyone for advice. I don't know what the tour's view on. That is maybe they see that as just a more relaxed. Fun? I don't know. But to me, advisors whilst it can be quite subjective in what
constitutes advice. But clearly the players intention was to get information that was going to help them in how they play their next stroke, play the hole and they're asking somebody, you're asking anyone that person just happens to be in their group. you happens to be a partner of theirs for the purpose of maybe another, and I'm not really sure where the volm adverb. Yeah. So I mean We had a chat about couple of weeks ago, you had a club and story about two guys asking it's talking about each
other because they were Partners, but they were just Partners, they weren't Partners in a competition. I would have Partners at this haggle between them and others to group, but they were all all of them were playing an individual stroke. Blaming essentially that person giving advice on the line of a putt, for whatever it was playing out of turn to give advice on that. Line of, You Know, It Breaks the Rules. In this situation with this AT&T and let's not think about boobs running or whatever. But if you just look at what the competition is from a real golf point of view, you've got the
individual person buying strictly, he is not allowed to ask for advice from Department. He is playing this individual game. He is not allowed to ask for us, but if he gives advice I think that's okay. Who's giving you advice the amateur other professional professional? I went back to Dan and said, hopefully the tour players giving the advice and not the other way around. Sure.
So during around a player, must not give advice to anyone in the competition. That's right. So this, this guy here is not playing in this guy's competition. Correct? Sorry. Yeah, the pro and the amateur playing in one competition, the amateur is not playing in the tour players competition. So it's growing and not in my mind, as long as the Tour player is not accepting advice from the amateur. The to apply I can give advice
to his partner in the formal. Yeah, that is how that is, how traits because it actually, you know, reason again, the two sentences do, so during around a player must not one, give advice to anyone in the competition who is playing on the cause, or to ask addition, that is the competition that the AT&T Competition. He's not allowed to give advice
to someone else playing in that individual stroke weight. He hasn't correct. He's giving it to his fallible partner. That's fine. Next one. But however a player must not ask anyone for advice other than the players caddy. You're right so he hasn't given any advice the excess give it to his partner. That's fine because he's as partners not playing in his competition. He can't ask this guy for advice and was, but the an amateur cook and ask this person for advice because they are partners.
In that amateur that that's a amateur or the Pro-Am. Yeah. So other three events we'll just to is to just to write. So there's the professionals on their own and then there's the full ball Pro-Am. I don't think there's an amateur's on their own so yeah. Okay. Well, in that particular case he I sorry I can't see any breach then I just think that there's an individual Pro event and a thorough, there was an individual amateur one as well. Sorry that I don't think there
is. If there was that's a good question, if you want, I think I think they can give each other advice. I just kind of asked, they just can't ask, sorry, I think. Yeah. Hang on, what did I say before? But the amateur give advice to the pro. During a play around, a player
must not. Give advice to anyone in the competition, but that they're playing in a different competition. He's not definitely playing it correct. Yeah, and he's playing in the a so I think they can actually give each other advice. This guy cannot ask for advice. You can't ask anyone, right? That's right. Except the caddy, this guy can ask for advice because there's only two columns. If there are three columns they can give each other advice, but they can't ask for it. Because you can't ask anyone.
That's the, that's the way, the, Escalade, the rules written And just think. So thank you Dan. That's how we that's, that's what would come come up with. Now, I think I've got one more bubble and story from human ears. Again. Must be the same same Club 78 off a shot when to muddy rough money, but he took a provisional just in case it couldn't be
found finds a ball in rough, you know where this all going, oh, I've all before. Passing the ball. He realizes that the boy, hit out of the rough wasn't his fault. So Tim plays a provisional ball which hadn't yet reached the green chipped, it onto the green and puts it in for a score of 5. Plus general County. Two equals seven was his provisional still and not an option. After he played the wrong ball
or shooting it down, back to the tee to head. Another one. And what actions? Because we do love asking what actions they called the Pro Shop during the whole. So, on, well, it's yeah, I'll be interesting to hear what the actual Pro Shops it, but He's hit an original headed provision. Found what he thought was the original and headed realize that it wasn't his ball so he's fit of wrong book.
So I got one that second shot doesn't count because it was a with the wrong ball. So he's on three now, he has to play the provisional. Or what he actually has to do, is find his original be sorry, doesn't have to do it. He is option, is to go back and find the original. You know, if he's only taken a minute, he's got another 2 minutes, 3 minutes search, if he's already taken us three minutes to search, then, the provisional was the ball in play, or he'll just goes, or he can just go straight to the provisional. Now, if he picked the
provisional up yesterday of the shot, which is what? Yes, I did last week with James. And if he didn't pick the provisional provisional, he can just go straight to the provisional, play it. And then so three he'll be playing is six shot with a provision for moving along. The grain is adding another one and another 25.
So he'd been then, be cutting six. now, I think you're, I think the six shoulders to the groom We effectively lying 3 with the provisional budget. Provide the general penalty for the wrong Ball Z line 5. Yeah, I forgot the stroke at the provisional ball. So one one over here too for the wrong ball, that's three penalty and stroke and distance and the stroke at the second ball. Five.
That's five. Six under the green, correct. And if he puts it in the hole, that is a 7. So that's what But that's what a said. It was a separate so he's got the score right? It all, but it depends a whether he picked up his provisional. And if he did, you have to add another shot and then replace, it's not a drop, it's a re place that provision and that was a correct option. The other option was trying to
find that original ball within the total three minutes. So it means hopefully that helped you out. And that's how. And that's hopefully what the Pro Shop said when when you call them up, no doubt. Now was that. I think that was all from me. Did you have anything else? And I'm from clubland. I got another doozy, but we'll save that for next week. I think very similar to the one users gave very good. Now, do you have a GI Q 0 TW or week 79?
I do have a GI Q 0 TW for episode 79 on the par-3, 3rd hole at one bed Hills, Helens. Tee shot, might be lost at the back of the green, so she plays a provisional ball which goes in the hole. As they approach the green Howland chooses, not to look for the original ball. However, Charlotte simply out of curiosity wanders, out the back of the green for a quick. Look, Charlotte finds what she believes is, Helens, original ball and tells her Helen says,
it doesn't matter. Anyway, this ball here is hold and she retrieves her provisional ball from the whole, what is the ruling? So she retrieved it after hell, after Charlotte said that she'd found able, yes thanks, let's see what you can. What they come up with some the The Flies and also get your clubland stories. And Google forms will add oil, add right now to put in a
nickname so that will be very good and you can say whatever nickname you want. Thank you very much. Excellent episodes. Do it. You have. You've got some time off now. From refereeing. Yep. Nothing till next month. And I have one more time in in Qatar and then I'm home next week for about 10 days before I fly to Thailand. So, that'll be hot.
Hot hot hot and humid days. So all the best and thank you, everyone, for listening.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...