Stuck Range Ball, Incorrect Scorecard, and a GUR that borders a Penalty Area - THE GRQ PODCAST EP88Join this channel to get access to perks: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC_GzvxPbX1UQBeFluD3OLQg/join SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules. GOT A CLUBLAND STORY - Submit it here https://forms.gle/Jga9wNrnwUVFUQD98. .GRQOTW #87Blakey and Ross mistakenly hit each other's ball on the 1st fairway (ie. a wrong ball each) and this is only discovered when they arrive near the green and Blakey is 1m from the hole and Ross is in the greenside bunker. They both walk back down the fairway to estimate where the balls were lying, and Blakey finds the divot Ross made. Using that divot as the reference point, Blakey drops a ball and plays it back on to the green. How many penalty strokes must Blakey add to his hole score?. CLUBLAND STORIES- A range ball that is stuck in the ground- Signing an incorrect scorecard in a multi competition - When a Penalty Area and GUR are side-by-side. PODCAST MCPHEE'S GOLF TRIP STORIES- Local Rule E-3 and substituting in a different ball. GRQOTW #88 Blakey and Stuart are in a stroke-play play-off. Stuart gives a wrong score to Blakey by mistake, which causes Blakey to lift his ball from the putting green without marking it, as he believes he cannot win. Stuart then corrects the misunderstanding. Who gets a penalty and what is the penalty?.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISE Get yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/. DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION: Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.com WANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE? Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.com WANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCE Head to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en) OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITY Https://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestions LISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFY Click here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questions SUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules #GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
This way we talk about an abandoned pool, that could be an immovable obstruction. What to do when you hit in an area that has GUI and penalty area but you don't know which one it has gone into. Exactly and what happens if you put the wrong hole scores down but you've got the total correct and the scorecard that you've signed and handed in to the committee. So grab a cup of sit back and relax and let Blake Ian Stewart bring you the golf rules questions. Podcast. Golf is a test of character. Before it is a test of skill and
playing by the rules of golf will definitely test your character. Hey everyone, welcome back to the golf pros. Questions podcast, I'm Blakey. This is episode number 88 and alongside me as podcast. McPhee. How are you going podcast? I'm well, thanks bike, you know, you know this, I thought I'd just tell the listeners that you and I had lunch yesterday and during that lunch, I received an email from a friend, Of the podcast, someone you, and I both know quite well, I be and it
starts with thanks to you in Brackets or mr. Podcast, if we go with Blake, he's suggested. Monica. You are having some influence with this? Yeah. Well, I mean, you are famous in the podcast world. I wish there is really only one nickname for you. So how you been very well? Thank you. Oh good. So how was your golf is today?
So we applied we unite lunches today so I'm a golf on Wednesday, Wednesday actually walked off after nine holes. Unfortunately due to significant discomfort somewhere in my body which I didn't want to push through so that was the end of that move on from that very interesting, the guy throws Christian of the way of the last week, can you remember? Yep, I've got it right here. So G IQ o TW from episode 87,
Blake. Ian Ross mistakenly, hit each other's ball on the first Fairway. In other words, if you to rumble each and this His only discovered when they arrived near the green. And Blakey, of course, is 1 meter from the hole and Ross is, in a greenside bunker. They both walk back down, the Fairway to estimate, where the balls were lying. But fortunately, for Blakey, he found the divot that Ross had made in hitting the wrong ball using that divot as a reference point. Blakey drops a ball and plays it back to the green. How many penalty Strokes must Blakey? Add to his whole score one for
the coming 24, the wrong ball. Not take the wrong boat and then he was supposed to place the ball and he dropped it instead. So that's another too. And there was the intervening event of the stroke. Still, it's four shots. Yeah, and we didn't say this specifically, but someone could have been clever and said that had, you dropped it, but it actually ended up coming to rest. Exactly in the correct spot and he wouldn't have copped two
strokes but in this case, just wishing that would have been one. But in this case, we have assumed that it had, it hasn't actually gone back to the original spot. Yeah, the likelihood of that happening is very you could try a hundred times and I probably wouldn't happen. I've got a question, put you on the spot here. So, when you need to replace your ball on the spot, we know you need to use the original ball. And one of those exceptions to that is, if someone actually hits your ball as a wrong ball, you don't have to actually use the original ball.
Can you think of any of the other three exceptions? Weather delay. Where this obscene suspension? Very good. Suspension is one of them. We don't have to. Are you changing it because of its color? Correct, very good. Blakey one more. This is all thought. This would be the easiest one, the one you haven't got yet. Right. How about I'm the player?
I mark my ball. I lifted I throw to you as my caddy and you drop it. It rolls into a penalty area. Yeah. Used to be a penalty to but now if as long as you haven't deliberately done to get rid of it, it's substituting a ball under that scenario is okay. Yeah. If your original wall can't be recovered, within reasonable time. Yeah, I've got one for you actually. Just thinking about it. What happens if they couldn't find the divot or there was no divot sure.
Well in this case you just its best estimate. So the original spot is not known, it's just best estimate. Even if you're found later that that's not actually the correct spot, the players allowed to use reasonable judgment to, determine that it's Testament. Yeah, a reasonable judgment. Turn that would say if you use all the facts and knowledge that you have. Well one of the sorry I was just singing is also obviously the information from other players who will go. Yeah, I think you're probably right around there because I was watching from here in the tree
was behind you. It could be what distance you do. Have on the laser, just find that sort of, you know, it was 167 out. Okay, make sure your 167 from the flagstick so you're going to be pretty close so I'm not asking or answering your question directly, but you talk about getting as much information as you. You can and then what have you, whatever you do, don't spend eight minutes. Trying to work it out. It was you know you had a bit of a tree anyway but now there's no tree anyway. Well that's not reasonable, that's not a reasonable judgment, very interesting. Right?
So we have it, we're just going to try and do a quick. We are not sitting beside each other. By the way, we're not seeing this. Is some kind of Zoom act that we've downloaded immersive view. It's cool but we have got three Club lanced. Instead it's got a couple of goblins stories and self going to run through them. We always say this would be the quicker of the episodes but in the end we'll probably talk and talk and talk but: from why Maddie is back.
Like ask questions on the par-5 5th, on the par-5, 17th at 180 on the right about 50 meters down as an area of gu R which is right next to a pond which is Marked with red eggs. So we've got gu R&B the penalty area, right? Soldier, the GU are the ground under a pier is about 100 meters long. The same length as the pond: is playing with Bill Bill, tees off. And of course of course, Bill slices into the GU, our pond
area, near the bottom of the G. You are after a search Colin and Bill can't find the ball because it's G. You are Bill wants to take a dropper. He thinks it crossed into the G. You are But Colin things are would it could have gone into the pond and should take a penalty drop, right? Because the GUI goes up to the pond. Where would he drop? And in back in line, with the pain would either be on a path or in a farmer's Paddock. Take a lateral drop would be in the G. You are. What actions would touch and resolve the situation Bill took
the easy options and freely from the GUI Cullen was slightly unimpressed because so Colin wants to know the ruling what the ruling could or should have been? What do you think of that so far? We'll talk about reasonable judgment. Yeah, because we don't know where the ball is and we need to be known or virtually certain as to which one it's in either. It's rather obviously either in the ground under a pier or the penalty area. I was a couple of things, I think I'll just go to the relief. They'll talking about taking relief from the penalty area and dropping in the GU R which is perfectly fine.
Taking lateral relief because then you've got a separate procedure. If you were to take penalty relief into the GUI, then you can elect to take that separate procedure to get out of the abnormal cause condition for free. So that's not an issue that the G you are. Sorry, the relief area for lag, for Relief would be G. You are, that's not an issue but this just comes back to where do we think it is? We have to be known or virtually certain It's in one of them. It's a Pity though. There wasn't a third or a fourth player that probably could have weighed in.
I'm just see well, it's clearly here or it couldn't be here or something, but sounds like to play it. You took the easy option and just took the free relief from the abnormal course condition. There is that rolling on clarification about if your ball has this temporary water And penalty area 70.1 I won or lost another penalty area or abnormal course. Condition and Jason the penalty area of the players ball is not found in the area where there is
a penalty area and Jason abnormal course condition, the player must use reasonable judgment. When determining the location of the ball, if after applying reasonable judgment is known or virtually certain that the ball will come to rest in one of those areas, but both are equally likely, the plan must take, little pain relief, Under rule 17, but it does clarify. That in fact, you must proceed under penalty area relief. Yeah. So if you're not sure it's in the G you are or you're not sure it's in the penalty area but you are sure.
As you said I'm gonna send in one of those then you must proceed, under rule, 17, so: who are slightly unimpressed was right. To be unimpressed was right to be unimpressed, and was right that he said that bill should take. Fielding drop. And as you said, he can drop laterally into G. You are if that is in with them, within his relief area and then
it could take three relief from the GUI if he so desired, it's a separate procedure. Yeah. Because it doesn't say here that the GUI, it was a no play zone. You still can drop into the no glazing just can't fly from it and you're months. So you must be a must to take free relief. Very good, very good question. Yeah, really good question. so yeah, hopefully Hopefully next
time they'll encounter playing that one though, I'll get it right. Very interesting. Right? I've got I got one from DK. So, three separate. 18-hole. Stroke events are held over three consecutive days at different golf clubs, there are prizes awarded after each event and overall prize is awarded in conjunction for the 54-hole and get total. So you've got Four competitions here effectively, you've got a
38 in whole competitions, and then you've got a 54 whole competition. Before taking off on day three, the runner-up day two was congratulated by a fellow pet player. For their result in there too Eagles, the runner-up advisor, they didn't have any Eagles and I'm reviewing the online stores. Realize they had signed for incorrect scores on some holes. 18-hole total score was correct.
The number of Hole by hole scores were not correct. Well, some scores lower in some schools higher than actually taken the player. Properly reported to the committee and asked for himself to be disqualified. So, That's an interesting point because just going off on a tangent here slightly we saw a player who shot 62 and a Monday qualifying event the other day. Actually play, he pressed down.
Aeration holes on his line of play when passing so press down damage on the green. But it's not damaged that you are allowed to Repairs by an animal or person one. So he pressed down, aeration, holes, shop, of course, ready to record 62. Then someone said I have bad, was it putting on those aeration holes? And he went in and he actually disqualified or said he disqualified himself? But technically, he didn't know,
he incurred a penalty. Even though that's a pretty simple one, he didn't know, he didn't could have Hillary. So really his score could have still stood and they just assess him a penalty of every time he did it. Let's say, let's say he did three times your ad, six Strokes, let's say you did it on every hole he adds 1836 Let's say, you did it on a two part of every grain which you wouldn't record forever third 62, but into kind of eerie green.
He did it before every pup that would be including the sapiens. So his 1762 would turn into 134a before he actually went into school for yourself. So, back to DK story, why I promptly report of the committee and asked himself to be disqualified, the player was disqualified from the date who have been and the rule 20 .2 e. And also, this is the tree whose only point three. Well, I was disqualified, the day 2 of N and the road 20.2 e and also disqualified for the
54-hole event under rule. Three point three, be the hand back there prize and said they look forward to hearing about this clubland story on the grq podcast. Next week, we appreciate you sending it through DK. Yeah, thanks. Take a podcast. You have anything to say about that situation. No, unfortunately, the rules pretty clear cop pretty straightforward. In this case is little room for interpretation. If you record a score for a hole, that was less than the one you were actual score and you
sign that scorecard. And it's in the committee has only one option and we all know what that is. Yeah, in this case, it wasn't disqualified for Rounds 1 & 3 because they are. As, as we said there's four separate tourneys here, but he He was disqualified for second one. And then obviously that also meant. He's disqualified for the 54-hole of the Yeah and unfortunate sort of situation.
We don't like to see it, make sure that you when you're handing in your scorecard even if it's the digital thing that you've you have a responsibility to get it. Right? And interestingly enough, you know, in this particular case, we had some, I mean, the actual overall school might have been correct but we've had the above the actual score and Below balance each other out. So the overall gross and net score may be incorrect, but if you record a school for a particular hole that was less
than what you had. Yeah. Yeah, you know, you you might say it happened once. But that many times is is uncommon. I'm saying saying that happened with they added up, they forgot to put in the last hole, the score for the last hole and then they added up the score and then included the last score for the last hole but got to actually write it and say it's added to
34, the put 34 and whole nine. And so, when the hand the card and have signed for the score, they thought they were saying 471, but they signed for 107 was coming 34. So they signed so they definitely didn't make the cut. No, but we're not disqualified but not disqualified far above what? They actually have to put. Yeah, maybe not very interesting.
Okay, podcast, I've got another one from Deep. Okay. Play our a this is a good one. We've both had read over it and can't wait to talk to about this one player, a playing stroke-play pulls her tee shot on the par-4. 12th hole towards the driving range. The player finds her ball at rest in the general area very close to an old range ball. If I wanted to move the range ball, as it interfere with its area of intended sling, however, the range ball was embedded, very deep likely from being
driven over by car traffic or the range ball, picker-upper that didn't manage to pick it up and it was not easy, or not able to be easily removed to paint the picture of more clearly. 75% of the ball was embedded below, the surface of the ground, which was a dirt surface that had hardened by hot dry conditions. The only way the player could remove the Stray range ball was to use an iron or a divot repair tool to wedge. The ball out with some Force player was worried that doing
this would alter the surface of the ground and possibly improve the conditions affecting the stroke. What actions were taken to resolve the situation, the player played the ball, as it lies to ensure they avoided any potential penalty. Are there any relief options available to this player? And the situation? Would you penalize a blab? They improve their cats as a result of moving the range bullsh podcast. What do you recommend? We come back to the range ball
and what we would describe that as and I think we would describe that range ball as an obstruction and you and I We chat about this, you ask me this and I said, due to the difficulty of moving it, I think you could quite easily, categorize that obstruction as you movable and immovable obstruction. In other words unable to be moved without reasonable force and effort and potentially damaging the course or the obstruction itself. And therefore, if that player deemed it to be an immovable obstruction and the ball was lying in the general area and it
interfere with one of those cats and they were entitled to free relief, find the nearest Point where they no longer had any interference from that obstruction and drop and play on with no penalty. Yeah, an interesting one, having an abandoned ball or a range ball considered to be an immovable structure that I can't see any other way. That, you know, it wouldn't be if with the removable obstruction with our parenting a player May remove a movable
traction. Here we are on or off the course and may do so Oh, in any way. Yeah, it might do. So anyway, and then you look at rule 8.1 be two actions that are allowed in improving your cats, take reasonable actions to remove loose impediments and movable obstructions. Now reasonable actions which is allowed the removable, listen
pims will move instruction which is allowed to extend provided and rule for 15 in real life we need to just states that you may remove a movable fraction here on or off the course and may do so in any way. But I think it then comes back down to the definition of movable and immovable. And I think you can make an argument that that's immovable. Is, you're taking reason, you know, taking a reasonable amount
of effort to try to get rid of it. Imagine if you spend five minutes, kneeling over trying to get rid of it, get rid of it. And another player says, oh, they moved a immovable obstruction and the way to improve one of their cats. Yes, sir. Under the definitions and obstruction that can be moved with reasonable effort and without damaging damaging the obstruction or the cause Well, you're not going to damage the bull with you picking that up with the pitch repair. But I you damaging the coolest by making a big hole.
I mean, that's that's probably what it comes back to DK is where they going to make a big hole and damage the course. And if the answer is, yes, In the abandon ball range ball becomes an immovable obstruction. If the answer is it would have taken a little bit of time, you know, half a minute. And they would have just plucked it out, then it would more likely be a movable obstruction.
And that's one of the permissions, as you say, under rule 8 .1, it's always going to be situations where, you know, a immovable obstruction for Stewart, might be a movable obstruction for me, just because I'm A Little Bit Stronger. Definitely. So, yeah, it could always be the case, especially with women and men and not Being sexist, but
mean being stronger. But generally that is Correct. And so they are more likely to have movable obstructions where someone might have an immovable obstruction and juniors as well. You know, I'm sure that we can even on my worst day I could probably move something in an eight-year-old. Probably couldn't, I would think so. I hope TK took that into the other player took it into the pro shop and see what the staff come up with is regarding that
scenario. Yeah, well whatever. Or the main thing about this question is the player because it was a practice range, bore and a bendable, the player did have options other than just playing the air ball as it lies. They could take relief or scrape this thing but other ones easily removable. Yeah, yeah. Okay, we're all done with Club scenario though. Really good one this. Yeah, that was really good.
I like that very interesting and now now, you use podcast, have your own couple of But I'm on, I'm on a pretty straightforward just model, local rule III has just been brought into their club which is preferred lies. And the relief areas is simply a hand span and all throughout the last. My last two rounds Wednesday and Saturday in the general area of you know, anything on your ball. I've just obviously taken the opportunity to Market and give it a bit of a clean And all
Saturday and Wednesday, a few times I would Mark the original ball, lift it and then just throw it to the side and then put another one next to it within the relief area and I had a guy at the end of the round going. I saw you throwing that ball away all the time. How I didn't think you could do that? Why we allowed to do that and I'll say, well, why couldn't I do that? Well, it sort of a mud rule, you know, it's the idea that preferred lies is in there to clean your ball. So the idea is your Market lift, it clean it and put it back and I had to explain that. That, of course, when you take relief, under any rule in here,
on the course, you don't have to use the original ball and the other one, which was blue and he'll be listening to this podcast, blew his mind. A little bit was on Wednesday. I did did this quite a few times and I called him over for one particular instance, where I was taking preferred lies relief in the general area. So my original ball is lying there and without marking anything. I just grabbed a second ball and put it right next to my original ball about 10 centimeters away. There were now two balls. Sitting right next to each other and I picked up my original and
threw it away. And I just said to him, is that okay? And of course, the whole idea of having two balls sitting right next to each other, just threw him a little bit, but, of course, perfectly fine. I've just put another ball and apply, which means the original ball wherever it is on the course, is no longer in play and is now wrong Ball. Even though it was still sitting there on the course, they're my two very basic simple Club Lane stories and then when that player goes and plays under local rule E2 and does it Yeah exactly.
One shot for a bunch of cleaning or cleaning. Yeah. Incorrectly substituting it. Sorry, yes. Anyway, there are two very simple problem stories. Well fantastic. That means we've managed to wrap it up quicker than ever before. Stuart sorry, / podcast. What is the G RQ 8? Ew, 4 episode 88 please. Yeah. Q, I ask you is question the other day so here it is. A gr Q. O2 W 4 episode 88. So this is you and I playing together, but you and I are in a
stroke play. A playoff. What? So Blake. In shooter in a stroke, play a playoff on the putting green Stewart, gives a wrong score to Blakey by mistake. However, this causes Blakey to lift his ball from the putting green without marking it as he believes, he cannot win the playoff. See what then? Immediately. Corrects the misunderstanding. Who gets a penalty. And what is that penalty? Yeah, that's a good one. Is a good one.
Well, we'll find out in him. Said, 89 look forward to seeing you there podcast and spiky, just be the grq.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...