Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

CLUBLAND STORIES June: a putter-sized relief area, raking footprints in a bunker, suspending a match, peeing on your ball, how strict are starting times in golf- THE GRQ PODCAST EP116

Jun 7, 202450 minAudio

Welcome to the 4th best golf rules podcast in the world, this is episode 116 of the GolfRules Questions podcast. Blakey and Stuart have another iteration of clubland stories, including: - whether using your putter to mark out your relief area is allowed, - raking footprints in a bunker before playing your shot, - causing a ball to move after your ball has been holed, - how strict are the Rules of Golf when it comes to starting times, - peeing on your golf ball, - can opponents who are losing a match suspend play, - and what happens when your club gets stuck in the sand underneath your golf ball. We hope you enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions podcast, as well as the weekly rules newsletter, and make sure you subscribe to the GolfRules Questions YouTube channel for more educational videos. We also have merchandise that you can purchase so that you are representing the best Golf Rules podcast in the world. Grab a t-shirt, a hat, or even a hoodie featuring the Rules Roo, or the Wombat caddie.And now whether you are in your car, or going for a walk, or just taking a break after mowing your lawn.Enjoy this episode of the GolfRules Questions Podcast.GRQOTW115:Blakey loses the hole because: Caddie's action breaches a Rule that if the player had taken would have been a breach, so Blakey loses the hole because the caddie gave incorrect information about the score that Blakey had had.GRQOTW116:Danny the D Grade Golfer is playing a stroke round at Wombat Hills. Danny makes her 6th stroke from the putting green on the 1st hole, and the ball comes to rest only 5cms (2in) from the hole. Thinking she is playing stableford and frustrated that she is going to score 0 points on the 1st hole, she turns her putter upside down and knocks the ball into the hole using the grip end of the putter. Andy the Average Golfer reminds Danny that she is playing stroke and not stableford. With Andy's excellent rules knowledge assisting her, and knowing she has not made a legal stroke, Danni replaces her ball back 5cms from the hole and putts the ball in the hole correctly. She asks Andy to put an 8 for her hole score (7 talent strokes and 1 penalty stroke for causing her ball to move). Before submitting her scorecard, she asks you if 8 is correct, as she is not sure about the penalty stroke - what is her hole score for the 1st hole?GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#GolfRules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to the 4th best golf rules podcast in the world. This is episode 116 of the Golf Rules Question Podcast. Blake and Stewart have another iteration of clubland stories, including whether using your pilot to mark out your relief area is allowed. Raking footprints in a bunker before playing your shot. Causing a ball to move after your ball has been holed. How strict are the rules of golf when it comes to starting times paying on your golf ball? Can opponents who are losing a match suspend play? And what happens when your club gets stuck in the sand

underneath your golf ball? We hope you enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. But just before we get into that episode, I want to encourage you that if you like these podcasts, please share it with a friend or two, send them a link and get them listening. As well as the podcast, Stuart and Blakey also produced The Drop Zone, which is a weekly rules newsletter that gives you some helpful hints, a few rules questions and there is usually a funny video to keep you entertained and educated. So send us your e-mail address if you have yet to sign up. And when you receive the newsletter, make sure to forward

that on to your captain or manager at your club. They are free to distribute it to all of their club members. We also have merchandise that you can purchase so that you are representing the best golf rules podcast in the world. Grab AT shirt, a hat or even a hoodie featuring the Rules Roux or the Wombat Caddy. And now, whether you're in your car or going for a walk or just taking a break after mowing your lawn, enjoy this episode of the Golf Rules Questions podcast. Oh, you see referee David Blake there.

He's obviously talking to one of the rules officials up by the green. Hey everyone, it's Blakey here back again for Golf Rules Questions podcast episode 116. And I'm joined by my Co host Stuart. McPhee. Hey, Blakey. How are you? I'm great. How are you? Yeah, pretty good. You always get sort of, I can feel some kind of nervousness when I you don't know whether I'm going to say Stuart or podcast. I'm not familiar with that second name, but no, I do get a little bit apprehensive.

I thought so, but I know you love both of them. So we had a ton of clubland stories to for May, and now I've got a ton more have come in just in the last week for June, so we're going to go through those ones. But first the GRQO TW115, which Ruin tells me was quite difficult. I saw that comment. Except we're tightening the screws or we're getting tougher.

Or something. Yeah, well, I mean, as as it happens, you know, people will listen and have a guess, whatever. But Ruin's the only one sticks, puts his balls on the line and actually puts a comment on YouTube. So we we appreciate him tuning in and. And we know you do get other answers from other people, but that's all privately to you, so no one else sees that. Whereas he's the one that goes out in public and says here's my answer. Yeah, not often, but yeah, that's that's right. I do get every now and again, but not as consistently as he is

doing it. Every episode. Well, I hope he enjoys this week's Yeah, GRQOTW. But until until we get to that point, last week's GRQOTW. Blakey and Stewart are playing a match at Wombat Hills. Blakey has holdout four or five. Stewart, who has a putt for A5, asks Andy, the average golfer who is Blakey's caddy. Hey Andy, what did Blakey have by mistake? Andy, the average golfer, states that Blakey has holdout in four

strokes as he thinks he has lost the hole. Stewart picks up his ball marker to head to the next tee. Before Stewart leaves the green, Blakey calls out. Hey, I didn't concede that part. Stewart explains what Andy had said when Blakey corrects his caddy that he actually had a 5 and tells Stewart. Stewart isn't sure of the rules when the caddy states the whole score, so he requests a ruling. Blakey, who is now no longer playing this match, who's now a member of the committee? Blakey, what is that ruling?

Well, I haven't actually done my homework, but just having a quick look. 10.3 B sorry. 10.3 B Three yeah. 10.3 And correct me if I'm wrong, in any of this, it says that caddy's actions that are not allowed, Caddy's not allowed to take these actions for the player can see the next stroke a whole or a match to the opponent or agree with the opponent. So what they've done is concede that next stroke and that's not

allowed. And then Stewart, I've forgotten the names. Now Stewart has acted on that by picking the ball up, right? So he would get a penalty, but I think the penalty's already incurred by Blakey and his caddy because there was an action by the caddy that he wasn't allowed to do. So I'm going to say in a match play situation that Blakey, because it was Caddy's breach,

he's going to get the general penalty and lose the whole. Yeah, So what's the rule about if I ask you even, let's forget the caddy and I asked you, Hey, Blakey, how many have you had? And you say 4, but you've actually had a 5. And I then take an action based on that incorrect information and you haven't corrected that information in time. Then that's the general penalty. Yeah, that's. Rule 3.2 D is that the one you're talking about. 3.2 D telling one telling opponents about number of strokes taken.

This is in match play, and when asked for the number of strokes taken and when given the information about without being asked, the player must give the right number of strokes taken. A player who fails to respond to the opponent's request. That's right. It wasn't a it wasn't a conceding. It was giving wrong information, right? And then was. That still under. Correct. Yeah, it is. And then the crux of the question is the fact that it wasn't you who gave me the incorrect information, it was your caddy. But the player is responsible for caddy's actions and breach

of the rules. Exactly so. 10.3 C tells us. Yeah, 10 points. So if a caddy's caddy's action breaches a rule, would breach a rule if the action was taken by the player. So this action would be a breach if taken by the player. The player gets a penalty under that rule. So under that rule, it's a general penalty loss at home. Right, straight away, yeah. That was quick, quick finger ring off the rules.

No, I'm cutting that out to find that answer. OK, so is that what Robin had with his answer? I'm sure it was. He's pretty good. He's pretty good with the rules now. Right, so now we're going to get on to our clubland stories for June and we have Colin Colin back again. This is his 10th submission. Just a question and I might have asked earlier, maybe in an e-mail, but most club days when

playing in a group and we are on the green, someone always asks if they can take relief from a sprinkler head or a second hole that is normally on our greens. That's fine, but they always use their paddle to measure out the nearest point of relief, which after listening to your podcast, I always try to inform them, inform them that they can't use their paddle without saying it loudly. But of course, they carry on doing it, they don't think it's a problem and it's what they always do. The game carries on and nothing

becomes a part of it. From a slightly frustrated column, what is the solution? This has happened at Wimati Golf Club. OK, so prior to, I don't want to confuse anyone here, but prior to 2019 you obviously could use your putter and it didn't matter what length it was from nine, 2019 they changed that and said no, those big, big putters that go up to your chin, we don't want anyone measuring with those anymore. So it's the length of your

longest club in your bag, except the putter, and the longest club in your bag is usually the driver, and the driver can only ever be a maximum of 46 inches. OK, so we're there, but are they going to be incorrect every time they use the putter, Stewart? No, not at all. In fact, So as you say, for relief from an abnormal cause condition, it's nearest point of complete relief and then you have a one club length relief

area. And as you just correctly said, the definition of a club length is the longest club in the bag, not the putter, 46 inches Max. If you want to use your putter to measure out that relief area, that's fine. But we know that the relief area is going to be a little bit bigger than that because the driver is longer what, 35 inches maybe for a putter, 46 for a driver. So it's a good, yeah. So it's a good, you know, extra 20 plus centimetres to change measurement there for the relief area. So, so yeah, you can use a

putter and if you know, if you're dropping within that putter then you're well within the one club length. Yeah, aren't you? Because you've got another, you've got that buffer there. So I thought they were going to talk about using the putter to simulate the stroke to measure the nearest point of complete relief. Because that is the correct procedure, isn't it? You actually have to work out what that stroke would be with the if. That you're gonna use, correct? If that abnormal cause condition wasn't there to measure that, sorry to identify the nearest point of complete relief. That clearly wasn't the question. It was. Can we measure the relief area using a putter? Yeah. So we can use whatever you want, just as long as it's not bigger.

Than the one club length, the only issue like some of the issues that could happen if you don't use the longest club in the bag is if you use a shorter club and then the ball hits within the relief here and rolls outside the shorter club, but it would actually still be within the longer club. There's there's the potential that you're picking up a ball and play that was dropped correctly and now you're re dropping it when you should have played from where the bull had actually come to rest. So there's a a potential issue there. The the only other thing I might

have read the question a bit quick but he said when we are on the green someone always asks if they can take relief from a sprinkler head or a second hole that is normally on the green if you're actually on the green. If your ball is on the green there is no reliefy area. No, you just move. It you just, it's just the nearest point of complete relief there. There's no, there's no using a driver or a putter or any clump. It's just the nearest.

And that could be off the grain and you always place the ball. So just Colin, if your ball is on the grain, you're not you're even using a having a relief area. It's just a relief point almost. Whereas if you're off the grain, yeah, it's it's as you said, use your longest club in your bag except the putter. But if you do use the putter, which is fine, just be wary in case the bull rolls outside that putter, or even dropped outside the putter mistakenly then rolls

back in, it actually would have potentially been dropped inside the driver length and then now the ball's in. Play. And we assume if we're talking about liner play, interference of model local rule, I think it's F5, you'll know it. Yeah, F5, yeah, if that obviously that's been adopted to allow you to take relief. When your ball's off the. Off the green, yeah. I hope that was helpful, Colin. Sorry if I might just add to that. We've said this before. You don't have to use the driver to measure the relief area. You don't need to put TS in the ground to measure nearest point

of relief. The the extent of the relief. It is really, really good practice. It shows others what you're doing and you know what you're doing. But you don't have to. You don't have to use the driver to measure the relief area. Yeah, right. Next one we have Mr. Roberts back and he starts off with Hello Mr. Blakey and Hello Mr. Podcast. Firstly, may I say great to see you both back in episode 115 for a terrific podcast. Now the story, Anthony, Mick and John playing the 18th hole

Hilltop. Anthony hits his ball into bunker left side of the green. When he gets to the bunker, his ball is about four metres from the rake. How many is that in inches? When he gets to the bunk, his ball is about four meters from the rake. Near the rake is footprints, divot holes and have not been raked over by some other ignorant person who should not himself be a golfer. Anthony proceeds to rake this area and clean up the mess. Anthony then goes to his ball and plays a stroke unless the ball hits the face of the bunker

and bounces off and comes to rest in the centre of the area which he raked just a couple of minutes. Yeah just a couple of minutes previously. John smiles and with $1.00 resting on the outcome of the round says bad luck. Anthony that's a 2 stroke penalty because you have improved conditions of your next stroke. Anthony says no way, I didn't do that on purpose. Nick says let's finish the whole then we have then we have finished the round. David is in the group behind us so we can just wait here and ask

him. With a bit of luck he will give us the rule. Mr. Roberts was called into the discussion as was as was Bale to prove to John that under rule and was able to prove to John that under rule 12.2 B to Anthony. Ken smooth the bunker to care for the course. David's final say was that the intent of Anthony was to care for the course and it was just sheer luck that his ball ended up in a nice lie in the bunker. John accepted the decision and also agreed to and also agreed

it would be a good idea to send the story to Golf Rules podcast to get an opinion. Was David correct? This happened Aenthol Hilltop two weeks ago. So you've got the ball and four meters away from the lip and the person is right in that 4m section towards the hole. When he gets to the bunker, his ball is about four meters from the right, near the right footprints. Divot Holzen had not been raped over by someone other ignorant

person who should not themselves be a golfer. So was this on their line of play? Well, that's what it doesn't actually state, OK, but let's say let's go with it was on their line of play. What is the Ruling podcast? So 12.2 B2 there are some acceptance, there are things you you're not allowed to touch the sand in the bunker for under one, but under two, one of them is A cause smoothing the bunker to care for the cause. Where it doesn't result in a penalty.

Right. Doesn't result in a penalty, except it's covered by one. The rule does not prohibit the player from touching sand in the bunker in any way, including digging in with your feet. You know, stopping yourself falling, throwing some clubs on the sand, smoothing the bunker to care for the cause. But. But the player gets a general penalty if their actions in touching the sand improve the conditions affecting the stroke, in breach of Rule 8.18. So if it was on their line of

play and it was the short shot to the green, they can care for the course unless it's going to improve their conditions, right? If their footprints, David Hulls were not on the line of play, not in the area of the stance area of the law of the ball, then they would be able to do it in for the purpose of caring for

the course. You know, they're not thinking, oh, I'm going to hit my ball into the face and it's going to rebound over there, so I need to rake over there. They're just doing it. You know, they're watching someone else play. They rake the bunker and then they go to play their shot and hit a terrible shot and it goes over here. So that's it. It all depends whether it's improving the conditions of your next shot. That includes line of play. It does. And The funny thing is, let's say you are four or five metres away from the lift, 15 metres from the hole, who wants to hit their bunker shot and have their ball remain in the bunker? No one.

No one, not one. Person, no. So it's interesting that you can rate the scene in front of you, but it is on your line of play. Sorry, you're not permitted to rake the there you go with this. So you physically can rake it, right? But it is on your line of play. But you have no intention of that ball after the next stroke ending up in that small, no way of saying, in front of you. But does that change your confidence and hitting the show? Ohh that's a good point. It may the fact that it's now. And if that does, then that's the.

Improving of the condition, that's never thought about that. I mean, we still don't want to end up in the sand. No, I mean you don't want to end up in the sand anywhere. What you're saying is if I hit this, at least I've prepared a nice area for it to, Yeah, hit the lip and roll back, correct? Yeah. Correct. And winding up in that animal hole. But I just smoothed. Out and again, that's one of those ones where you could make it a bit more Gray, but they've just tried to make it as black and white as possible if it's on this line that you are going to play. Corridor. You know, and you have improved the conditions. It doesn't matter if you had,

you know, actually in saying that, do they give that one about the divot, how far away it is or was that an 8 point? One, sorry, I just had a question yesterday when I was playing about someone was hitting from the back of the bunker, hit the lip and rolled back and they now raked from where their ball was to now where their ball is. And the question was, hang on, your ball's still in the bunker, you can't rake the bunker. But of course it wasn't on his line of play because he advanced the ball further into the

bunker. So he was raking correct towards that. Caring for the cause and then and then that allows him to rake the bunker this way, walk out that way, drop the rake over there and carry on. For a little bit of So the question was Hobbit. His ball's still in the bunker. He can't. Rake it. That's the one they changed. That's the one they. Removed. There is one in here. A clarification in here about. Where are we 8.1? When it might not actually mean much. 8.1 A1 The first one. Examples of actions that are

likely to create potential advantage and you'll see the first dot point a player's ball lies on a green side bunker and the player smooths footprints footprints in front of the ball on their line of play before playing a shot short shot intended to be played over the smooth area. So that's likely to create potential advantage. Hence it's going to be a penalty, but you'll see 8.1 A slash 2 The second dot point. A player's ball lies in the middle of a long, shallow faced fearway bunker and the player smooths footprints several yards in front of the ball and on

their line of play before playing a long shot over the smooth. This is the example of like a fairway bunker, so the. Fairway bunker, you know you've got 150 meters you're trying to advance at 150 meters. You're not it's it's unlikely to create a potential advantage like there is no advantage just chopping your border there, but but thinking about and you know. It it really depends on where you play. If you've got one of those green side pop bunkers where the where the faces are really steep, it

might actually be an advantage for you to chop it out from here to here. And you know, and that's on your line of play and you've raked it because someone forgot to rake it and then headed out onto the green because you're in that green side pop. Especially when the pin's only three meters. A lot. Yeah, it's a possibility. The ball's coming back towards you. Absolutely. So, so 12.2 Mr. Roberts, you just got to check whether that was actually going to improve his conditions and the conditions on his line of play, stance, live ball.

And we say swing, but swing in a bunker you're not really, you're not allowed to touch anyway. But well, there's not going to be trees in a bunker. But have a look at clarification 8.1 A slash 1 and 8.1 A slash 2 because depending on where the bunker is and what the shot the player has, it's not always going to be a creative advantage. The key is the line of play, that corridor in front, yeah. Good, good. Right.

Mr. Robinson is going again. A group of four players on a green 2 have marked their balls. Jeff has left his ball on the green, is nowhere near the line of Lee who is about to putt. Lee hits his putt into the hole with the flagstick in the hole. Lee walks to the hole, pulls the flagstick out and his ball which is in the hole flies up into the air, comes down and lands on Jeff's ball, knocking it about one metre to the left and a bit closer to the hole. Jeff claims a 2 stroke penalty

for you. Lee, Your ball hit mine on the putting green, Lee says. But I wasn't putting. Perry, Perry I. Don't know where Perry dropped in from, says Good one. We can find out soon. But where do you putt from, Jeff? I think you have to put your ball back where it was, not where it is now. And another quick rule book discussion over refreshments in the clubhouse. Before scores were submitted. It was decided that Lee had holed out so he'd finished the hole.

The cause of moving Jeff's ball was after Lee had finished the hole and was an accident under rule. Wait for this 31.1 D one and Perry was correct that Jeff had to putt from the original position. Were we all correct? There is no 31.1 D one. Let's go with 9.6 that Jeff. Jeff left his ball again so.

Jeff was correct. Lee's ball did his hit his on the funny so. Lee is correct. Lee Lee Lee's ball was not it wasn't from a part, it wasn't from a stroke. It was, it wasn't even it was a wrong ball. It wasn't even in play because it'd been hold. So yes, Jeff has to Jeff has to put his ball back. There's no penalty to anyone and there's no Rule 31.1 D one. And that happened at Hilltop two weeks ago as well. So just to overarching statement

for those people that, as you said, 9.6 is ball moved by outside influence. Yeah. So that ball coming out of the hole is an outside influence. Yeah. Whenever your ball is moved by an outside influence, you got to put it back. So Jeff's ball, you know, has been moved by something else that wasn't him, wasn't his caddy or anything like that. He's got to be put back. Yeah, you're going to try to think of 1 exception. Yes, there is one exception. But, but generally speaking, if your ball's sitting there on the green, if it's sitting there, you know, in the middle of the

fairway and something comes and moves it, you got to put it back. So generally speaking, that's what 9.6 is all about, if it's known or virtually certain that your ball's been moved by the outside. What is an outside influence? It's basically everything. Except water, land and gravity. And the player and the player's caddy and the player's partner and the player's partner caddy are also not outside influencers, but pretty much everything. Every person in the world, apart from a few people are outside influencers. Yeah, there you go. Except the player or the caddy

or the player's partner, partner or any of their caddies. But exactly what you said or what I said, except for natural forces. Yeah, basically everything else is an outside influence. It don't is an outside influence. I've got the one situation and it could be more. But oh, I'm sure we could think that as you've you've thought about it where? An outside influence causes your ball to move, and you can play as it lies God. And you know, I'm going to know this, I just can't think of it. Right. It's an easy one to you. No, I bet. It is it. Actually is. So I bet it is so easy. Can you give me a rule #3?

2/1 6.2. 6.2 So we're in the teeing area. Yeah. Balls beat. So someone's just knocked your ball off the tee and you can put it somewhere else. That's right. And it could be in play, remember, because you could have had the air swing. Or hit a tree and come back. I have an air swing which happens. No, it doesn't you. Fall over laughing, and as you fall over laughing, you drop your driver onto my ball.

It rolls over there still within the teeing area, and I just go stuff that. Smack it. That's good. So I reckon what you just said that is true, but it's that's a 6.2 rule rather than a 9.6 because you won't say that in 9.6, will you? That's just a 6.2 rule. Well, it can't be a 9.6 because you don't have to put it back. No, that's what I'm saying. It's not. Anyway, that's very good. Well done. Right, Mr. Roberts again, my third one for this week. He's just This is his 13th submission. Thank you.

So now he's now he's exactly the same as DKDK. You have to pick up your ACT. Yeah, Mr. Roberts, my third one for the week. Not a specific question but one that has cropped up a few times, mainly from smaller clubs in the Goulburn Murray District, the district home of Wombat Hills Golf Club. There it is, see if you can find it on the map. Would you mind a quick chat about rule 5.3? Start time 5.3 seems to be written like a few other rules for large clubs with timesheets and and or controlled start times.

Some small clubs have competition start times that can be expressed As for example, arrive between 11:30 and 12:00 noon and you'll be able to head off. Or if you get here by 12:30 you should be OK. Or give us a call if you'll be later. Or if you think you'll be after 1:00 PM, ring Joe and he will wait for you. Or we're going to head off at 12:15. But we are all here ready to go and it's only 12, not one in front. We may as well start. No, no one in front. We might as well start. Or another one. As a more specific example, a group of four on a timesheet,

head off at 239. Whole event, no committee person in attendance because fairly much a self operating comp. There are quite a few self operating rating cops at small clubs. No pro shops, no officials on duty. Jeff calls. I'm running late, can you wait for me? Yep, no worries, no other groups are held up. Jeff arrives at 2:45 and the group head off and enjoy the comp and then he goes on at rule 5.3. A has an exception 3 that committee can decide that no penalty of exceptional circumstances prevented the

player from starting on time. Above examples are not exceptional circumstances. I can't find a model like a rule about variation of start times. A committee cannot change a rule of golf. Can a committee decide the start times under rule 5.38 can be when your group is ready to go. Comments please. Mr. Blakey, Mr. Podcast, what are your comments about on about that? One, when it's what he's just saying, when it's so relaxed and smaller groups, the committee can do whatever they want. Like you can have all that as long as everyone knows what's going on and I should. So let's take it to the other

level. No offence but if we're at the Australian Open and Adam Scott's tee time is at 9:08 AM and he is not there ready to play at 908 AM, 5.3 kicks in and he's got another 5 minutes to get there. Otherwise he's disqualified. And 5.3 says when he wasn't there at 908 he gets a general penalty for that first hole but he's got another 5 minutes. Unless, you know, exception three, he saves someone's life getting there. You know, performs CPR on

someone out in the car park as he was running towards his tee. Some of some exceptions there, but this really doesn't matter long as long as the committee organizes it all and everyone knows and it's really a non issue. The fact is, you know, if we can have a window of tee times between 11:30 and 12:00, Yeah, organize your groups when that when those guys have hit their second shots, Yeah, go. Don't worry about waiting till 11:47. You know, yeah, I totally agree. Having being a member at a small

club, actually more around Geelong at Biragarra, this is exactly what it was like. It's, you know, the guy that I used to play with, he was always like, so you know, and, and one group would go off one, another group would go off three or four, another group would go off 7 and then another group might go off one after that first group, that type of thing. And it was always, you know, right between 11:30 and 12:00 or we're heading off at 12:30 or whatever.

You know, there's some of these guys are farmers and they're doing farm work in the morning. It it really comes down to exactly what you said. As long as the committee. Yeah, don't specify time and just say, oh, yeah, this is what it is. I mean, if you when, if it, if it comes to sort of, well, that sounds like you're just being quite grey or subjective with the rule. Well, it's actually to not enhance the enjoyment.

It's it's actually sort of to be accommodating, more practical, accommodating and practical for the actual competitors. You know, if Adam Scott turned up 15 minutes late, he's actually this disadvantaged or just, you know, sort of made made a mockery of the sort of competition. Whereas this competition with five guys or or eight people or 12 or whatever, there's no no one's been.

Disadvantaged. Disadvantaged. No one's been sort of put out too much. I mean, if, if someone does say, oh, I need to play at 12 and then, you know, and someone turns up late, yeah, then they might have a bit of a case. And then, you know, go to the comedian and say, oh, this guy keeps turning up late. I need to play on this. I need to finish by this time, you know, and then it's a case of, oh, we'll plan a two and a three. I mean, if there's some situations in country clubs where there's only two people,

there's only two people, like that guy has to wait for the other guy or that guy has to hurry up and, and be faster. Yeah. I mean it when it, it really, you know, it really comes down to the, the club, the committee, the club, what they decide. I mean, if, if one of these clubs was really like you have to all tee off by 12 and then there was a guy that was constantly late and constantly getting disqualified, I think that guy's going to leave.

And if he leaves and goes to a club that's more accommodating for him, you know, it's probably, it probably works out for everyone. But if there's not one within a, if there's not one within 150 kilometres, that might be quite difficult to, you know, it might be, might be stern words said at the pub, I think. Yeah. So I think, Mr. Roberts, what you're sort of alluding to there is if it's really annoying a group of people, you know, they

can work it out for themselves to tee off earlier or whatever. But speak to the committee and the committee, if they are really, you know, harsh and they're really just, this is black and white. You need to be here at a certain time. Let's see how long the club lasts kind of a thing. And if if it doesn't, maybe they'll have to be a little bit more flexible in the in the way they work things out. But certainly at, you know,

clubs where there is a big timesheet, there's a lot of people, there's 80 people, there's 200 people. You know, it's very difficult for the golf shop staff to try and move people around when people are late. Yeah, you can't be that relaxed. Yeah. And that and that's sort of what it comes down. If you've got five people, eight people or six people to look after, it's a lot easier. And and you know, you've got three or four Tees to tee off, it's a lot easier than looking

after 200 people. So yeah, I think a lot of flexibility when it comes to that one for those situations at those specific clubs. Good one. All right, we've got. Bob, Bob has asked the question. I had removed the position, sorry. I had removed the provision for preferred lies from the temp local rules. I was asked can I pee on my ball

to remove the mud. I suggested that it I couldn't keep a straight face. I suggested it that it moved it and it had to be replaced. And maybe rubber gloves would be appropriate. I mean, this is I think this is just someone being a smart ass to the club. The the club captain. If you, if you drop waters from

your water bottle to try and remove the the mud and you cause it to move, that is not natural force. That is you. Yeah, it's a result. The cause of the movement is as a result of you doing something. So yeah, it would be a one shot penalty and you'd have to replace it. Can you drop water on your ball to remove the mud? Well, as long as the mud is not

adhering to the ball, solidly adhering to the ball, and then it is a loose impediment. And that could be a way for you to, and that could be a way for you to, yeah, get rid of the mud. So you like to clean your ball if it's sitting in the middle of the fairway? Yes. Like you're not allowed to clean it right, but you are allowed to take a tee and try and move. Stuff off. It's easier to come off it right? Like a if a yeah, if a leaf's a

bad example. This is not attached, but Leaf's just sitting on top. Of it attached. Yeah, just sitting. Sticking to the ball, they've. Said so. There's mud sticking to it. You're not levering that off of the tee. You can try, yeah, but if you cause it to move, then you're gonna get the one shot penalty. OK, so if someone drops water on their ball and the ball moves. Yeah, what you just what you just showed down on the video would have been almost oscillating. He ended up in the right spot, but if it moved. If it moved doesn't stay on the same spot you've. Caused that ball to move.

Then you've caused the ball to move. But yes, I mean, I wouldn't say get your Willy out and do it in the middle of the fairway, but you can. I'm just thinking a drink bottle and you drop the water from your drink. Bottle if your ball moves. And if the ball moves, then you get the one shot penalty. But if the ball doesn't move and you've you've been able to dislodge, dislodge the loose impediment that's not sticking to the ball. That's OK if it's loose impediment. Yeah. I mean, if it doesn't come off, it's sticking to the ball.

So it's not loose impediment. You're just proving it or disproving it, yeah. That's right. But you know you can apply any stuff to your ball to clean it, and urine is one of them. You can get that water to a plot, but obviously it's no good when your ball moves. Unless we're going down that special, special substance, Was that the? Way, yeah, it's just sort of you can use whatever you really want to clean a ball. You can apply anything to the ball to clean it pretty much and that's a very general statement I've just made, but you can

without it as long as you don't change the characteristics of the ball. You can have a moist cloth and it's got some soap in a detergent just to clean it off and that's fine. Other. Than clean. You can use human waste product. Methylated. Spirits just don't move it when you're not supposed to move it. When you're not supposed. To because you are going to be the cause of that ball moving, yeah, not some liquid coming from your body. Correct. Right. Two ball Bobby and Brian were playing against Gary and Gordon.

This is going to be a tongue twister and a four ball beatable match play knockout tournament. It had been bucketing down with rain for weeks. In the four quarter final match, Play games are the only ones allowed out on the course. Everyone and everything was soaking wet by the time the match got to the 7th hole. Bobby and Brian were two up on the 8th hole. Brian and Gordon picked up their balls, both out of bounds twice, but both Bobby and Gary were on the green and two each with a 3M putt for a birdie.

Gary puttered and the bull rolled 1m before stopping in the sudden grain. It was bucketing down evermore and Gary and Gordon suggested that perhaps we all go back to Clubhouse and call it quits as putting was ridiculously difficult in these conditions. Bobby and Brian said that the conditions as terrible as they had been with the same baby run and what's more and more, what's more rain, what's more, more rain was forecast for the following weekend and they didn't want to come back and do it all again. Then Was going off even an option for this?

This is the question. It was going off even an option for this match. No other groups have withdrawn to the shelter of the clubhouse as far as this group knew. That's first question was your answer to that one. So players in a match may agree to stop play for any reason except if doing so delays the competition. If they agree to stop play and then one player, or in this case, you know, one player from the side wants to resume play, the agreement has ended and the other player must resume play.

So if they all said to each other, this is getting ridiculous, guys, I think we need to just, let's just sit out for 30 minutes and come back. That is perfectly fine. They don't need the committee's permission to do that. They can just walk off. The match hasn't ended, it's just paused. Provided that they can get this finished before the semi finals have been arrived. Right. So the fact that Gary and Gordon wanted to go off but Bobby and Brian didn't, that means that they have to stay out there or concede the match, yeah.

There's been no agreement. To Bobby and Brian and obviously Bobby and Brian are two up so they don't want to they want to finish then and there. Yeah, so that's the first question. Second question, when would it be an option to end the game as it was for that day, and if this was permissible would would they restart the whole round with the scores even or would they continue from the last completed hole with Bobby and Brian two up? It's easy, you can answer that one. So when would it be an option to end the game as it was for that day? Given the amount, if I might

just interject, given the amount of rain that's now on the greens, there is an argument where one of the players could get on the phone to the pro shop and say as a committee, is there any, is there any chance you may be suspending play surely and closing the course? True. And then they're forced off. That's true. That would be like a normal suspension, right? Or if there was lightning and intermediate immediate suspension. Yeah. So when would it be an option to end the game as it was for that day? Well, again, the committee could

do it or the group could agree. Obviously, you know, when it gets too dark and then they all agree, you know, unless Bobby and Brian are just going to keep going. But that would be, that would be a bit silly. So the committee could really interject then and say no, no, no, you can't play in the dark to try and win. You can come off if this was permissible if they restart, if they restart, no, the scores would just still be as it was

Bobby and Brian two up. They you wouldn't scrap the game that's already been played in that situation. OK, So you wouldn't just go clean sheet and that would be horrible if I was Bobby and Brian that were two up, that would be horrible. If I don't know, we'd come back tomorrow. If you said that to them, they would say no, we are not leaving, we're playing until midnight to get this thing finished and that happened at Dingo June's. I don't think that's real club.

Thank you for that too, Bob. And I was just to say, so if the two GS said, oh, this is getting ridiculous, let's go off. And the other two said no, and the committee hadn't suspended play. The two GS have an issue. Yeah, 'cause they need to keep playing. They need to keep playing. Or they've got no other choice. Or OK, go on your match. Which they probably should have. OK ruin. Mr. Carlsland senior, that's his dad is playing in a club tournament.

Strike play Stableford on the par 3 four 9th hole. W Finnan Golf Club Mr. Carlislin senior sends his T-shirt into a greenside bunker and the bull makes a fried egg in the sand of the bunker face. Not entirely sure what to do with it, he decides to try and blast it out with a wedge. He swings his wedge towards the sand right underneath his ball, but the bull doesn't move. His wedge is now sitting in the bunker face supporting the sand that holds his ball in its position. Unsure what he is supposed to do on a Friday, he'll get a penalty if he removes the club and hence

causing the ball to move. But remembering that a double hit no longer gives a penalty, he continues his stroke after the ball and the wedge have been at rest for at least several seconds by scraping the ball with the wedge out of the bunker and onto the green. He holds out two more strokes and marks a four, but brings the situation before the committee. Good idea. As Mr. Carson always attempts to follow the rules, he naturally told about the situation to the committee before he handed in his scorecard. They decided that he'd done nothing wrong and the four on the whole stood as a scrape was to be considered an accidental

double hit. His score was accepted and he did not score enough to receive a prize. Weeks later he came to me telling about telling me about the situation, still wondering if the correct ruling was made. I told him no. Correct, correct. Ruin. This happened at Westland Golf Club, Denmark last year. So how would you roll that cast? So it'd be interesting to see so we know. He's on the bunker for one and he's made a shot, so he's on two

and his club has come to rest under. Yeah, under the ball where he fears if he moves his club out, the sand is going to fall away and his ball's going to move. So I've never, never come across that ever. Never seen that. So let's just address the continuation of that second stroke, OK? There's no way that's a continuation of the second stroke, OK? The fact that he's had a stroke, the club has stopped, you can't tell me. Then a few seconds later, continuing to move that club forward is the same stroke, right?

No way in the world I agree. So we've attempted a third stroke. Now you don't have to take the club back to make a stroke. You don't have to make a backswing. The stroke is simply the forward move of the club. So let's say he's attempted to strike the ball again. The issue would be then for those witnesses, did he scrape? The ball out or? Scoop, yes, scoop it out. Scoop. Scoop's a good word. So was there a single contact with the ball and that was it? Or did it? Was there a bit of a scooping? It's going to say scrape and scoop a scooping motion because we know that's an illegal

scoping, we know that's an illegal stroke. You can't push the ball, you can't scrape it along, you can't scoop it. That's an illegal stroke. The stroke will count that you get the general penalty. So possibly he's on for three general penalty 5 and whatever was two parts I think it was will be a 7, so. Hang on, He's on for. He's on for five because you're saying 1-2. And then this Scoopers after several seconds, another shot. Yeah, definitely 1/3. Stroke. I'd say we agree with that. Apply the general penalty for an illegal stroke under 10.1.

I'd say it should have been a 7 as well. Right. And then whatever many parts it was. Right GRQ, thank you everyone for contributing. I mean that was 7 new Clubland Stories in a week. That was amazing. So thank you very much for contributing to Clubland Stories June. We've now got the GRQATW for 116. Now you know the answer to this one because I threw this one at you during the week. So you have heard this one in a different form.

Danny the D Grey golfer is playing a stroke round at Wombat Hills. Danny makes her sixth stroke from the putting green on the 1st hole and the ball comes to rest only 5 centimeters or two inches from the hole. Thinking she is playing Stableford and not stroke and frustrated that she's going to score 0 points on the 1st hole, she turns her putter upside down and knocks the ball into the hole using the grip end of the putter.

Andy, the average golfer, reminds Danny that she's playing stroke and not Stableford. With Andy's excellent rules knowledge assisting her and knowing she has not made a legal stroke, Danny retrieves her ball back from the hole and places at 5 centimeters from the hole and puts the ball in the hole correctly. She asks Andy to put an 8 for her whole score, 7 talent strokes and the one penalty stroke for causing her ball to move on the green.

Before submitting a scorecard though, she asks you is a if aid is correct and she's not sure about the one penalty stroke. What is her whole score for the 1st hole? So she hit the ball 7 times. We don't say talent strokes anymore. Talent strokes is a stupid way to say it. So she hit the ball 7 times or she made seven strokes. She. Physically hit the ball 7 times and then. She reckons she only had one penalty stroke and and you're saying that Andy's excellent rules knowledge? Well, compared to Danny's, it's all relative Andy's.

Average rules. Knowledge Danny Andy talks very confidently about the rules around Danny to do golf so so the question comes down to you know, is that a penalty stroke for, you know, tapping it in with your actually causing deliberately causing Oh so. The ball was in the ball to move. Because it's not a. Legal stroke. It's even though she actually had the intention to make a stroke. Well, yeah, but she just. She hit it with the grip of the putter. Exactly. So, yeah, correct. Yeah. So it's not a legal stroke I don't think.

And he's going well, I don't you can't putt that way. So I think you need to fix that. So she's taking the ball out of the hole, put it back again and actually made a proper stroke with the head of the club. Just not sure about the penalty, you know if it's causing the ball to move or so. Just not sure about the whole score. OK, let us know what you think. The actual score of Danny's is for the 1st hole at Wombat Heavens. Thank you everyone for listening in to episode 116.

Yeah, we love these clubland stories. So keep getting them in as many as possible, even if you have to make them up. I mean, no, we we love the ones that actually happen out there really happened happen out there in clubland, especially the ones like Ruin that just blow our mind. So thank you everyone, and we'll see you in episode 117. Make sure if you haven't already signed up for the drop zone, make sure you send us your e-mail. And if you know anyone that you think would benefit from having the drop zone sent to them, make

sure you get their e-mail to us as well. See you later.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode