Viktor's Unplayable, Rory Bullies JT's Ball, and more... | THE GRQ PODCAST EP62
50 minAudio
Viktor's Unplayable, Rory Bullies JT's Ball, and more... | THE GRQ PODCAST EP62 GRQOTW62: Fraser has a small stone located immediately behind his ball which is lying in the bunker. Knowing he can remove loose impediments in the bunker, and after checking with his marker if he agrees, Fraser reaches down to remove it, and upon grabbing the stone, it breaks into many pieces as it was actually a clump of sand, not a stone. What is the ruling? Rory Hits JT's ball - https://youtu.be/HCCWIIJymNU Viktor Takes an Unplayable in a Bunker - https://youtu.be/g-8O105NuPc Community Questions - 107, 94, and 91. Double Greens at St Andrews Slow Play Money Fines vs Stroke Penalties
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
The first known rules of golf with drawn up in 1744 by the gentleman, golfers of Edinburgh in Leith, Scotland. Since then the game has changed dramatically golf courses equipment and not least the rules. So, where do I go? When I want to learn about the rules of the game today? Well, I go to the golf pros questions podcast with Blakey and Rosco. Of course. So sit back, relax and enjoy this episode of the golf rules questions podcast.
Hi everyone episode 62, golf of questions podcast coming at ya right now. I'm Blakey and with me is John McPhee. Welcome back Stewart. Thank you Blakey great to be here a regular on the grq podcast until you can find a better host slowly. But surely I'm becoming a regular that's good. Not to be it's going well and you've got a jam-packed and say you because you've put the agenda together today, go to jam-packed episode 62 for us. But first of all, Answer the g
oq o. TW from episode, 61 is, a question is, so the question was Jerry hit his tee shot. Way left innocent, thick bushes. So he played a provisional, and which Lanes in the rough. He found his original ball within three minutes but it was deep within the bushes, and unplayable, his lateral and back on the relief, options were equally impractical. So he decided really is only viable. Option was to return to the previous place. Play back to the tee having already. Ladies provisional from the Teen
area and to assure in to ensure he doesn't delay. Play any further, he plays his provisional ball from where it was lying and counts that his fourth stroke was that permitted or is that permitted? And I said to you, after I after we stop recording that podcast, I said to you, I shouldn't have said, is this permitted? I should have said, you know, hit his fourth shot, onto the green, to parted, what's his score for the whole, you know, then continued his around. What's his score for the whole? Because that would have made for a much more interesting answer. Is rather than a yes or no is
permitted. But anyway, to my answer. So he's found his original within three minutes. What two words, Blakey would you use to describe his provisional ball now and then, and bull abandon or wrong ball. So so now and therefore he has hit a wrong Ball even though he had hit it originally and it was sort of his for a little while, those are provisional but by hitting that provision of all is actually hit a wrong ball. And if he continues, play the
hole and then please off on the next hole than he's got some issues because then he would be disqualified. You can certainly complete a whole by playing from a wrong place, but you cannot complete a whole by playing with a wrong ball, which is what he did in a, not so nice, so he has to correct his mistake. Yep. Add two penalty, Strokes in stroke play and correct his error corrected. You know what? If he doesn't correct this error.
Well, if he's off on the next hole, he's got he's got an issue and you'll have a big DQ beside his name. Yeah. What if it's a stable fit around? I would think that's the same thing. It's a day he signs this one for the whole, right? Yes of course. Yes. Sorry and this is what I call yes. And what happens if it's the 18th hole before you return your scorecard, you still need to correct it. Yeah, correct. That's used to be walking off the last padding going but now it's returning a scorecard which is, which is better.
Actually, I think it's a lot better, you know, imagine if you're two steps like you're this far away, done done something, it just take care and you're like, oh, you know, where's the putting green or yes? Yeah, I didn't realize that. It's a much better one the way they're written in this these days. I mean, imagine going back, you know, three groups of finish since you and you go hang out what my score, okay? I just need to walk back out onto the 18th, Fairway, and fix it. And you sort of get yourself in
between two groups. Yeah, but if it's a problem mention that anyway, yes, it would have it would be a lot easier, some clubs and others, of course and it was, as you said just to stay with it, then you just want the whole. Yeah, that's right. Steve The Pod is what makes makes maximum School? Excellent School. Very good. Has your weekend. Be the first year? Not as busy as yours, but all good play golf yesterday not just starting to get back into some form. It was a four ball yesterday. So it was just interesting, just thinking about the rules because
I was asking about a couple of things yesterday, bill, can you give advice, you know, can you breach team point to and all this other stuff and standing on the line and all this business though? Anyway, good to play some golf. Did you go see? Play. Do you guys play a concurrent stove? Fedor individual game at same time. We just know the fallible. Current year, the best, the best way of the just, just stick with the club event of the day, the confidently. Yeah, and ice. So, did you guys win lose or draw?
I must say my partner struggled a little bit and, you know, I'm in a winning score was 49 which I thought was phenomenal. Yeah, that is pretty good. I mean, it's almost, it's .75. Almost. Her whole very hot. It's pretty good down. There is very good. It is very good. At least it was like soda, unless it was an aggregate staff. Wouldn't in? That's pretty bad. Bernard slot and we have you played the artist over is that
multiplier? Yeah. Do I can't say I like it but yes, I've certainly played a few of those have fun is that? I think I've had a 15 or 1 whole and then I've had a 20, I had a 20 Wow, four and a five, only because I push the two up on a path for making it a drivable, par 4, one guy, eagled it, and I actually chipped in from the back for a three. So I had a 34-year 244 245, his, that's brilliant. Yeah. But anyway, it's a lot of fun unless you have a few zeros.
Obviously, yeah. That's right. That's right. So moving on, we've got a video Rory's Ball moving JT's, ball in the Fairway, which That the Canadian open correct. So I think this was the first round, and Thomas has balls already sitting in the middle of the Fairway. So we start the video. This is on your YouTube channel. Start the video with Rory hitting. He's tee shot with an iron with a ball flight. I wish I could emulate every single time. I strike a golf ball, just a beautiful ball flight. And sure enough, it hits the
ground just rolls a little bit and just hits Thomas as ball moves it from where it was at rest. Obviously, Rory's ball comes to rest. That's where I mean they probably didn't even see it. But enough people were there to say oh by the way, there's one said the other and you need to sort it out so I would. Anyway that's the scene if you want to talk us through what the ruling is there. Please with Thomas's Ball moving or being moved? Well, they certainly took a lot of time to work out where the ball was at rest before it was
moved by. Justin's bow roarsville, Justin's Bowl. Justin hit first. So it took a long time, and I need to take that long. Well, they were a lot of divots around, so they're trying to work out. Exactly where Justin's ball was. I believe they had another camera angle that we never got to see that said, it was definitely not in a divot and then they called in a referee and move Beth, helped out with
that. On, I met Mary base in Argentina at the youth World Cup, which is pretty cool or in person. So she works for golf Canada was helping them out. And, yeah, they got it back to the position that estimate the position, where it come to rest before it was moved and some way I'm from there. So, in summary Blakey, so Rory's ball hits another ball, and then comes to rest as anything happened to Rory's ball. Rory plays it from Um, plays it
as it lies. Okay? So Thomas inaudible, sorry. An old term rubber, the green and taken out. But it's, you know, we still, we still in context and it still works even though it's not in the rule book anymore, it still works for over the green and then Thomas has more. So we're sitting there and it's been moved by an outside influence. What happens to his ball? Yes is bull was moved by another ball which is 9.6 rule 9. 6 and he must replace it but obviously
if you don't know exactly where it had been moved from you just estimate it so you still got to put it back even if you don't know exactly where that was with the location of it. Originally, you still got to put it back and then you just estimate it. So it could be two inches, you think are two inches or it could have been a foot, could have been three foot. So, you know, if it lands on the, for what it can and away. So I think we're seeing one of
those and the video with Rickie, Fowler and Jordan Spieth. Something similar happened to them about five years ago, so we're can off the green, but yeah, you just replace it and, and you play on and then Rory, didn't hit the best shot. But Justin managed to hit it close and make birdie Roy went on to win that tournament and I was actually in London live golf in the Canadian opens on. So certainly certainly saw
across the pond. I think they call going to talk a little bit about, you know, if you don't, if you need to replace a ball on the spot, which Thomas did, but if it's not known, then a player can use reasonable judgment. I just found, I mean, you mentioned right from your Start of your words, your comments were how long it actually took. You have any comments about how about? I mean, it's just there's a get-out-of-jail-free card, you know, a reasonable judgment. Even if it's proven later to be wrong. Yeah, I mean long, I guess, you
know, who has the facts there? Well, the facts, Rory and Justin women known anything, but they were just trying to make sure that it wasn't a divot, otherwise, they were there to replace it in the divot and so they're just going on The Spectators saying, I actually had this similar situation happen. I was Observer. For the Taiga Abraham answer match in the prison's couples. The first met Joe on the Sunday in the singles and same thing actually happened on the 17th hole.
The West course which at the time was the ninth hole then on a toll of the composite course and we were up there close and I can't remember. I don't know why I can't remember, but I can't remember. I think Tigers ball. Tigers ball was hit by Ira ham answers ball and so Tyga had to replace his ball memory serves me correctly.
So because of that, I just sort of walked over there and the referee was sort of coming up following the group, didn't quite get there as quickly. And I just said, yep. Oh, show them where the ball. Was it rest? And I sort of got in there and just see look, it was here, you know. Again, I was like 40 meters away, it was an estimate. I sort of, you know, when it happened I was sort of trained on that spot and then walked over there and you know, I could have been out by 2 inches, it
could have been out by a foot but that was a reasonable judgment judgment made me, you know, it wasn't necessarily the game cameras in there, you know, there were to just slow down play and I'm not, I'm not in for that. If one of them would say da no, that can't be right then yeah, maybe I would have asked for a camera replay but not really that necessary. Having to me yesterday, only, I don't hold my ball at rest on the ground and got shipping on and knock mind out of the way. So I'm just, you know, sort of stared at that spot where I know my ball was and just gone back
and just worked it to you in there and just replace my ball pretty quickly and you, you know, based on this video that we just done you that you know, if not known reasonable sorry if not known estimate and reasonable judgments. OK and acceptable know that, you know a few centimeters or millimeters out it's not really that big a deal. No, no. I mean, as long as it's that reasonable judgment, as you said, it's an estimation, you know. And did you penalize yourself the 15.3 for that agreement or Haley's?
Chipping, off the ground. We didn't agree to anything certainly not a backstop. I was about 15 metres away from the hole. That's for sure. Well, that's a pretty terrible shot by him. I didn't end up powering the identical, so it was nice. Okay, two parts. It was. Anyways, it was your partner wasn't just, you know, no, no what, no, what? No good question. No, it wasn't my partner in the for ball yesterday. Let's all we had, I think on Rory's ball, I think how many times would that happen at Club level and neither player would know. Yeah, I mean, if you got an
elevated green, It Could Happen a lot. And if the players never know if, you know, I get this question asked, if the Is annoying and it's wrong. If you never know before you make the next stroke and you never knew and you know, you can't be penalized for that what happens is what happens if that does happen. You've got a blind, tee shots and then you catch up with someone on the next hole and the guy did you put that ball back because, you know, role for your ball and you going? Actually we've already finish that whole didn't even know.
So that is my mission wasn't known to them at the time. No, that's right. You couldn't imagine pillars and someone for that. I'd start making that up, you know, I was kidding. I was kidding, I was kidding. I would not make that stuff up, especially we knew someone was having a good day and you have every day through. And did you, did you replace that ball? That was just beside the bunker. All right, we'll deal with it committee later. If we done with Rory's, we can get onto your most recent video and that's Victor hovland.
Yeah, the Open Championship. Join us and saying for this one, I mean the really cool. That Saint Andrews even though the ball and the driver beats it up, you know, can Smith finished on - 20, the cool thing is, if you do get in the bunkers, the pop punk is, you know, it's a real penalty and they probably need more of them. I don't think they'll ever touch the old course, but they probably need a few more. And that would you put a few more pop bunkers in there and,
you know, people Starting to have him to hit irons off the tee. It rolls into them even if you landed here kick on 40 meters. So I'm not certain touch the old course but you know it certainly would help reduce the score. The other thing you could, you know, I think it was perfect weather for 4 days if it was it was bad weather. Like it can be a car along that Coast then you know, you're not going to get the -20 either the In our, we've seen time from
their play idea, where, you know, it's it's howling a gale and you know, it's going sideways. You got to aim for a 40-foot before he made a cut and stuff like this. So yeah, it was pretty benign conditions. It was rolling really fast. Anyway Vic on this one short path 3, a short, par 4, Victor hog, one hits, a great drive and it goes in one of the pot. Punk is and because their bunkers have such a steep
vertical face, you know, gets up to the ball with right behind the face. No way that he could just pop that straight up and out. So he, he decided to take an unplayable. He's got as you said, you did the commentary on this one, he's got four options, for Philip, healthy options to in the bunker, one, back to the T, and then one outside. Bunker back on the line, and he opted for the back on the line, inside the bunker for the
one-stroke penalty. So good option, ended up saving his par. It did. I did think the caddy may? I mean, maybe I'm being critical, they spend a bit of time talking about it as in the caddy and player discussing their options and obviously probably wiser heads prevailed in that no not worth taking the risk of trying to you know just make this a turn this into a seven or an eight. I was just interested. Rested in my initial thoughts on the referee. The referee was standing off to the side.
There was one per group, I think was there one, referee, poo, grew. Yes, there's one there's always one per group in the first two days and then cry, and then there's the group's get smaller. There's certain amount of groups, get smaller, the referees, double up with the other groups. So if you were with that group then and you know that we're talking about the elite, Is in the world here and you knew they were four options. Do you not tell him about a? By the way, you can actually
drop outside the bunker an extra. I mean that's sort of that one that helps I think more your Club golfer get out of a bunker good ever precarious situation. Would you maybe not even mention that this is a referee? Yeah, an interesting situation because when should the referee, you know, does the referee the referee there to speak only when spoken to or Is he there to get in there and give Victor a hand and give him all those options? You know, to be honest I sort of
think that this was more a if you know the guy you know if you know Victor you could my maybe offer the four options but if you don't know my I'd stay back and just just watch until he actually had a question for you. I think the sorry what I'm getting what I'm thinking knowing he is not going to drop out of the bunker for to penalty Strokes. He's not going to do that. That would be his fault when I
know, I don't know. That's why, I guess that that's where I'm trying to get out of you is, you know, I remember being taught, you don't want to provide commentary, you don't provide commentary on the situation they're in and you don't want to say or here are your options. But coming, you're not going to choose that one. I you, you know, it's not to not to get involved in that way and it just be very clinical and And I just find that that particular option which wasn't around three years ago. Four years ago, you know, it's just is it really tailored towards the elite golfer? Who's I don't think I'll ever
find a professional golfer golfer perhaps taking maybe one day it'll happen but just your attitude towards that player if he says, all right, I want to take an unplayable. What a my options. Are you going to Rattle off all four over it? Yes. Yeah if he if he asked me Yeah, I've got a rattle off. All four, is he going to choose that one? Probably not but then you know, if it could be in a wet bunker and it could have plugged this, this likelihood that it will plug dropping from the knee but it could happen.
Yeah. But I see your point. You know, do you offer something to someone who that rule was basically created for, you know, the high handicapper, someone who really struggles with bunkers kind of like, Local bully 5, you know that you'd never see that on turn. And if you did you'd sort of calm, you know, you've questioned the legitimacy of that tournament but I, you know,
I still rattle it all off. You never know, you know, you don't put your ability or assume what their ability is. But yeah, if I didn't just going back there, if I didn't know them, I wouldn't offer up anything in this state Ask me and if I did know them, I just say, I do you want a hand with the four options if they said now they're good, be sweet. And if they said, oh yeah, what are they, right, real them off and and go from there. But you know, they took the
amount of time which sort of annoyed me because it seemed pretty easy. I you know, everyone gets a of, it's big, it's championships, the open, you know, that plan for their livelihood. if you're really concerned about your livelihood go and join live but it's just it just seemed like they took a little bit too long time for for that, but Yeah, it seemed, it seemed pretty easy to see that he shouldn't play it
and the wise decisions, man. Sorry if I just finished, if I can name drop as well. So, when I did the sand belt Invitational, and there was a amateur playing with Geoff Ogilvy, and she's just short of the green chipping, on, and skinnies her chip into the bushes of the back of Kingston who, and I just happen to be right there. Couldn't play it says to me. What are my options? The fact that her previous place play was only like 40 meters. I read it off quite as we can go back to where you were etc, etc. You would think that in Victor Holland's case the fact of his
previous Place, played was like 300-plus yards away. It's highly unlikely. He will take that option. It might be the last one you list, and you list them one by one and he's digesting them as you go through them and you might actually stop you. Okay, yeah, that's good. I'll take that one. So the thing anyone? Yeah, man. I mean, is it's really easy? Just to say you have go back to the tee with into club links in the bunker back online in the bunker or back the line outside. Exactly. Exactly line inside the bunker.
Yeah. Why. At the moment say he probably was, yeah, it was definitely not, was definitely unlikely to choose that option. I think has certainly a bright future that's for sure. Yes. Yeah.
Can I just make a one comment about rules specific? Certainly to the old cause and that is, I was surprised being a latecomer to the game of golf. And all these causes I was a surprise that the number of double Greens on that course. Surprised me I didn't know much about it or we can move past that point I can just introducing the fact that there are seven double green. There's only four holes and have their own green. Yeah. Well the double grains add up to 18.
So apart from 1 and 17, which they're not close enough to be a 72 are to be a double green, but every other 12 and 16 4 and 14. Every other one adds up to 1889 so we've all played a course which has maybe a double green on it and sometimes I'll use different colored Flags to distinguish. A little have a sign somewhere. Saying you need to go to the flag on the left, can you just run through if you are in the
unfortunate position of actually holding out in the wrong hole, on that double green and what you do, that's simple rule. Yeah. So if your heart if you hold out on the wrong hole, I want a double brain. You're actually on the right green, but you now the ball is in a movable obstruction or an abnormal address Condition. It's not going to matter what we term and it's the same thing. It's the same treatment so you can play as allies if you and
I've got a vacuum club or something, but the best bit is to place the ball at the nearest. Most. So I roll that off so quickly, but it's not right at the nearest spot, no closer to the hole. We you don't have interference with that. Abnormal course conditions. Oh, don't put it right behind the hole so the hole is on your line. A, that's not going to be very helpful and be because it's still have interference with
your line of play because you get a lot of play interference relief on the green. It's it actually copper to shop here. Only if you made the stroke because your place your ball in the wrong spot. So It's literally just putting the, it's literally taking a bowl out of that wrong hole and placing it beside the whole no nearer, the whole. So sorry. No neither real hole. Yeah, that's right. This is just an aside, it's either over that side or this side, you choose. It will be exactly the select, a
right-hander sort of thing are looking at the birds. Yeah, yeah, right, right. And it can still have the hole right in between their stance and their client. They really want to. Yeah. Okay. Might get a bit of might think I get a better line that way or something. Sure. So, That that hole is Grand under a chemical condition, and move will be reduction, whatever you want to call it. And and there's no no penalty for doing something interesting that wrong ball. Has its own rule 6.3. See, but wrong Hall, doesn't
have its own rule. But of course, as you just mentioned, we can find that in the definitions and the ground under appear as a whole mate by maintenance staff. Yeah, yeah, if anything goes wrong hole in it, another green. And a wrong green, then your honor wrong green, and you must take a ferry ride. The, what happens if you are, don't hold out on the wrong hole. But now, yeah, as you mentioned before, it's now actually on your line, apply on the same green. So you're on the double green, you just happened, the wrong hole. Easy.
Actually in your way, on your line of play. You're on the green though. So you have interference. Yes. Oh, you got an appearance by an immovable obstruction or a CC on your line of play on the green. You just find that it's like temporary water. Basically, you find the nearest spot where you get complete relief for that line of play and you place your ball there and that content it could be off the green. So it's not necessarily placing it on the putting surface.
It could be that you place the ball in general area. We're in that nearest. I mean you don't have to take relief for that one. You can play as allies if you want but You're the offer is therefore, free relief. Okay. Very good. Obviously, those sort of guys at that level didn't have too many issues with holding out the wrong hole or interference from a wrong hole but just wanted to raise that given that cause had so many double Greens on it. Yeah I think they didn't have
any too many tricky. I didn't find out all about the rulings and the share, but they didn't have too many tricky Rawlings but they said they were busy. So I guess with They would have had a lot of probably a lot not a lot, but it was a line of sight. T iOS. Now is like the camera towers around there because it's the other grandstands, a lot of people, I mean, a lot of the grand stands around advance so yeah, so there wouldn't be too fine. But you know, if the grandstand is out of bounds off the top of
my head, it's not too bad. But if the grand stands out of bounds and still a TI o and you still could get Free relief. If your ball was in bounds and you have interference of line of sight and line of play, but you know there's because the fjords kind of merge, you know, they've got to stick the TV tower somewhere and so they probably have a lot of ti0 stuff when the balls flying or rolling. So far you know I don't know if anyone would have hit the ball out of bounds on the first, but
I reckon someone want to hit the ball out of bounds on the 88. Let's connect easily die even though you can I eat out the first? Yeah, it's a pretty we're at War Wildfire. Why? They're definitely would have been people attended the ball out of bounds on 17. So yeah. What have been would have been great to be there but maybe maybe in 25 years time, Very good. So, you know, that two videos were spoken about already Rory, and Victor on both occasions. You mentioned time taken, both
of them determining where Thomas's ball was to be replaced and then hovel and nice caddy talking. So I just wanted to raise something that happened about a month ago at the women's PGA, when Lexi Thompson, and her group were all penalized for slow play, and I just found it interesting that the penalty was a fine. After the fact once the scorecards are in and they were fine two thousand dollars each at an event where obviously they're in a position. They're in the final group to make more than that. Do you have a comment on?
I don't think you need to comment on slow-play. I think we know your views on that but you have any comment on finding monetary or versus stroke penalty Strokes on the day? Yeah. Well the lpga's pace of play policy is Is if you're out of position and they consider out of position, determined by, where you are in relation to the group in front, it's something like a. If you haven't, if your group
haven't had a t-shirt on the path 3 and everyone is hit their tee shots on the next hole, then you're out of position. And then for a path for, I think it's if you haven't had a tee shot and They haven't heard t-shirt on the next hole, maybe. And then a par 5, it might have been if you haven't heard t-shirt and they have All finished putting or something like that, then you're out of position if you're out of position and the referee will come and give you your official
Warner, which and my experience doesn't seem to do much. And then the referees will monitor you after that, not monitor the referees, will observe you after that. And if you get out of position, again, they will start timing you, which was quite In this case, I think a lot of those groups were out of position, but they got onto timing that group,
with two or three holes to go. It's who else to go? And Justin Thomas, said, read the room, don't put them on clock. Three holes short of that finish, which I thought was ridiculous, you know, they probably should have got on the clock earlier, but just things happen or depends on the personnel as well. but, yeah, it's It's, it's an interesting thing on, you know, I've seen
some very slow, golfers Lexi. Certainly one of them and I find that's probably not enough. They need to start getting there a penalty stroke penalties, but if you get on the clock on the LPGA and then you do have a bad time, it's a two-shot penalty which I always think is a bit harsh. So I'm thinking well if it's Josh. What have you got it that way in the first place? Why don't you redesign it? So that it's not like that at
all. But if you do get put on the clock and you get a fine amount refine and think how much Buzz it's two to two thousand, two, two thousand. That's a joke. That's, you know, some of these people don't get out of bed for less than 20 so 2000s. Nothing, no over west of time, that one. Yeah. Yeah we know which will have more impact on the players, whether it be a fine or penalty
Strokes on that last day. Good morning everyone. Everyone knows that. Just with that. Certainly certainly on their last day. Definitely. And that was the last group. Now, I think I was going to raise Justin, Thomas has comments but you've actually addressed that and he's was along the lines of, as you said, you know, two holes, what does it really matter? But doesn't make you you've answered that, it actually does matter. It's more the principle Yeah. I mean if you let them plays slow as they want to, you know, people have to get home.
It's an Entertainer that the professional golf is an entertainment business and if if no one's coming up the eighth because the whole out of two holes out, where's your entertainment? You know, you need to be a needs to be. We're seeing these days that that fast format in most other sports as really. What people want to see and golf seems to be going the other way, we simply allowing them to play as slow as they want. You know, there's always situations where it's going to,
you know, you're going to be put out but You know, it's they'll either lose a ball and then they're searching and then you got them on the clock and then they searched for another while they're having to someone's having a really bad day. It's always going to be those kind of situations, but it's important to get on to them early and try and get them to keep up with the group in front, at least. You know, I think there's that constant policing. They know it's an issue that's being taken, seriously. Yeah, they need to be mindful of it. As you say, there are in the entertainment business, whether
they like it or not, but I don't want to be in it. Then played a lower level you don't get as much money. Yeah. Unfortunately doesn't doesn't seem to be getting, it seems to be the tail wagging, the dog at the moment, but hopefully things can get fixed. Let's Golf all though. I don't have much. Hope in the fact that live golf will be playing fast. But the good thing is they only have one field so you only got five hours and then you're done whereas you know some of those
hundred and fifty six Fields, I mean the open was the one t start 156 think it was 14 hours from first eatable last last which you know there's six our rounds for some people. So someone said that one. It took an hour to play, which is what this is. Just unbelievable. Take an hour to play one anyway. Okay, find that difficult to believe I could play nine holes in them.
Do you want to go through some Community questions? How we going for time? It's like to. Yeah, absolutely one or two. This is one from a few months ago, regarding penalty areas. So this is when Andy, the average golfer pull His tee shot left in the wear red penalty area, he and his group search for a little while, trying to find his ball at may have been playable, couldn't find it and then decided right guys, where do you think I've gone in? Where's the last Point cross into the red penalty area? They've identified or estimated that spot.
He's then dropped using lateral relief, say, or back on the line. And then another person in this group finds his ball which actually finding his ball has proven That the point is, estimated were at last cross was incorrect. So I was just wondering about he's procedure to, you know, what does he do? He's already dropped that ball. Sort of in play, he's already dropped, but they found that perhaps that was incorrect. What do they do in that situation? So what were what? We're four options that we gave
the Quan was, he could go and play the ball that has been found. Another one was well, the balls in play. You need to play that. Another one was well. He's made a mistake where his estimated with the last Point cross. He needs to perhaps choose a new reference point which is based on where the original was found was probably three of them. I can't think of the fourth, but disqualify you, we probably through and disqualified. Maybe I'd say, dancers see. See ya Tom was that I didn't put him in the right order.
I'd say the one where the original ball is now been found and they worked out that the spot where the ball crossed was not significantly. But a lot different from where Andy had estimated and drop the ball. So he now needs to pick that ball up. Figuratively hasn't done anything wrong but just found new information. It's sort of similar to what we were talking about. that before when You know, they found
information before they made a next roke that the board been moved on this case, they found information for the next stroke and they can fix it. That the estimation point was actually wrong, he didn't do it on purpose, but he just needs to fix his mistake and work out the new estimation point, you know, in that case. Like if you think about it, practically from, if you're out playing golf and you think of one of your, the holes that you player, it Garden is run that
You know, if you get up there and you go, okay, I'll drop a ball and then you find your ball and it's a meter to the side you go. Well, it definitely could have gone in exactly where my estimation point was. How am I to know I'm estimating if it's a really sick, really big sort of change you, okay, I've dropped in the wrong spot. Now if you if you drop it you play it and then you find this information yet we haven't done anything wrong. See you? You just go and pick the original up if you want and carry on, you haven't, I Room.
So, it's under seven. It's an interpretation. I think and the 17 points. One, if you go to the top of your head, just, you know, I'm in the right here. Obviously 17.1, this is getting to be under D for the options available. Yeah. So yeah. So that's what you do. So that was a good one. It's very few occasions. When 8.1 D 3/2 the eager to. Yeah. So very Really do you actually drop a ball and then pick it
back up again? Assuming you have dropped directly come to rest in the relief area. Very few situations where you go. Actually that balls are gone. Oh I need to actually pick it up again. Yep. Doesn't happen very often does it. It doesn't happen very often and Even if it was supposed to happen, it wouldn't happen because no one really knows that rule. I also wanted to let everyone know that Andy. The average golfer now has an official golf golf link handicap of 26.5.
Well done. Andy for getting out there and he's actually a member it wombat Hills. So great. Great work. Andy, very good. Can I throw a couple more questions that you? Ice on that interpretation. So now we found out that the information was incorrect. Sorry, the reference point was incorrect and we need to change the reference point. Could I change my relief option? After you've dropped it, right? I've dropped it using back on the line and then I'm about to play and someone goes and ENT,
hang on a second, are you playing a Top Flight? 47. Yeah, that's me. And we realize that in fact is ball. Was another 20 meters further towards the hole, then the reference point that he chose, and where he had dropped them was about to play and we've realized that the reference point was wrong. We've now found their knees original. We've walked up to 20 meters all that's obviously gone in here. Here's the new reference point. Phenomenal, change because I chose back on the line before. Can I now take a lateral relief with that new reference point?
Well, luckily, for me, luckily for me right at the bottom of this interpretation, it's a States in doing so the player must proceed under all 17.1 with respect to the creek, reference point. So they can't go and decide to play the ball because they've already played and dropped a ball in toward awaited, right? But May use any relief option under that rule so they could actually go back to the teen area. If they really wanted to, you know, they might find that their ball was further back there and
that that dropping area was going to be in the trees and they go back a line sucks that relief sucks Striking Distance, which will be my best option. I think probably there was going to be a confusion with that rule. It would be if that original Ball was found within three minutes and I might be inclined to go. Actually, I can hit that out of there, even though he's dropped using the wrong reference point and he goes, well, I can actually hit that you found it. Within three minutes, I might go
and play it but of course we know that's but I think that would be a common. Maybe a common misunderstanding. Yeah, man with his family than three minutes. Yeah, sorry exactly. Right. Like, you know 14.4 once you have the intention to drop ball back into play, That is the ball that is imply. And as you said, even if the reference point, chosen mind being wrong, we need to correct that. But you still must proceed under one of those three relief options. Yeah, spot on and playing.
It is not one of them. No. Not that ball. That you now that you found more information out, right? Right. Stuart believes, his T-shirt, has reached the yellow penalty area, question, 91, Community question, 91 go for us to put. This does have a bit of a look. If there's one thing a minor standing around the pliers and I was on, I can't find it, it's
clearly in there. So I've dropped back on the line from the yellow penalty area, and I have hit my ball onto the groove, and then someone goes, you playing your Top Flight 45 today it and we've actually been founded in the yellow penalty area and this question was just simply, could I be sitting on the ground He's got got some issues there with Stewart's.
Technical technology, but I think we ended up, we ended up getting that one. So he says it's very similar to the one that we just covered. So you've dropped a ball to undertake in relief under similar import 1D. You've hit that and then you found your original ball. Well, as soon as you drop the ball as soon as you drop the ball, that original ball becomes, what are you? What are the words that you use? The original Bowl. It's a role model. There is a yeah, he should have
been done but it's wrong. Well, I was wondering where the inside band in the world. Anyway, it's the same thing. So yeah, it's a no big. No, you can't go and play the like the other voice. You can't have your cake and eat it too. Now I found out what that actually means. I was like, I never really understood. You can have your cake and eat it too. As I like art, well if you've had your cake, you've you know, If you've ate your cake, you've had it as well. So you know.
But someone explained it to me that or you've got this cake, so you've got it. You have it. Once you eat it. You don't have it anymore. We can't have it and eat it. You either have it or you eat it. If you'd eat it you don't have it so you can't have your cake and eat it too. I didn't you know I don't think I agree. There's no I agree with it but I don't think I would. I liked it better than one when I had no idea what it meant.
Ignorance is bliss. Like so many plays with the rules. It seems stupid. So anyway, so yeah. So with this. And if you've already put another ball into play, you can't heavy original bowl and eat it too. I mean, okay very good life lessons with Blakey there we go. Open up another podcast and like it might get a few more listeners. All right, let's get into as I
think we covered that one. Let's get into the gr Q 0 TW for number 62 and then we'll sign off. Okay so here's my GI Q 0, TW 4 episode 62. So Fraser Frazier has a small Stone located immediately behind his ball, which is lying in the bunker, knowing he can remove loose impediments in the bunker and after checking with his marker. If he agrees phrase of reaches
down to remove it and upon grabbing the stone, it breaks into many pieces. As it was actually a clump of sand, not a stone. What is the ruling? Good one. And we will leave you that with that. I know David grieve had a crack at as had a crack at last. He so please have another crack at that one. David number 62. Thank you Stuart. If it got any got, have you got any golf? This week usual, Wednesday,
Saturday? Yeah, Wednesday so, but you do have to have some, you know, your normal work you do work, then you stir occasionally, if you haven't listened to the my golf life, my love. Golf podcast Stewart is a what would you call yourself a share market currency Trader, currency Trader. Share market entrepreneur extraordinaire as what I was trying to say. So if you haven't listened to it, give a listen to it.
But his new passion is the rules of golf and he's definitely more than willing to help me out, which is amazing. So, thank you very much and I hope everyone enjoyed that episode though. I was a bit more. Update this one. I think the other ones when we do it, it's like 6:00 in the morning and I can handle it. That was that was a real cracker so we'll get some more videos out. There will get some more Community questions out there, I'll put it in real easy Community. Question number 108 so hopefully everyone's gotten that right and it will get another one out
there soon so I'm glad you. Glad you can only see me and or listen to us rather than smell me because I Doing a bathroom renovation at the moment, so they have a share, you can smell me. But, you know, getting out if I get in the golf course with you soon, stay on the other side of the flower, appreciate that. Appreciate your time. Stewart have a golf course. Always my pleasure.
You too good to chat speaks will speak soon. Thank you for coming.
Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...
ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...
Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...
GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...
GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...