Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Blakey Rules

Blakey Rules artwork

CLUBLAND STORIES March: Mixed Gender Match Play, a gate on the course boundary, determining the reference point, accidentally substituting golf balls, and marking a ball - THE GRQ PODCAST EP135

Mar 25, 202554 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

CLUBLAND STORIES March: Mixed Gender Match Play, a gate on the course boundary, determining the reference point, accidentally substituting golf balls, and marking a ball - THE GRQ PODCAST EP135 We are back with Episode 135 of the GolfRules Questions Podcast, and this week it is our favourite episode of the month, Clubland Stories. DK has a hypothetical question about a mixed gender match, whilst pedanticus is a little too penaltycus over a pitch mark. Then we have the nerd and bill tell us about some more golf shop stuff ups. We also have another audio question sent in by Dear John, and this time he gives us the answer, just in case.So whether you are cooking rice, or melting gold, please enjoy this episode of the golfrules questions podcast. GRQOTW 134: In stroke play, a marker enters the scores in the wrong boxes on the scorecard, can they correct it after they have returned the scorecard, or is it too late? It is too late. Whilst the hole numbers could be changed prior to the scorecard being returned, it is too late if this is not done before the scorecard has been returned. If a marker signs in the player’s spot, and the player signs in the marker’s spot, and the scorecard is returned, is that also too late to correct it, or does it even need to be corrected?It does not even need to be corrected. As long as their are two signatures on the scorecard, it will be accepted.GRQOTW135: A player's ball, played from the putting green, is deflected into the hole by another player's caddie, who accidentally walked across the line of play. The original ball, or another ball, must be replaced on its orginal spot and the stroke must be replayed.GOLFRULES QUESTIONS MERCHANDISEGet yourself a Roo&Coo polo: https://golfrulesquestions.myspreadshop.com/.DO YOU HAVE A RULES OF GOLF QUESTION:Email - golfrules.questions@gmail.comWANT TO TEST YOUR RULES OF GOLF KNOWLEDGE?Head to: www.golfrulesquestions.comWANT A QUICK GOLF RULES REFERENCEHead to Instagram: @golfrules_questions (https://www.instagram.com/golfrules_questions/?hl=en)OR JOIN THE FACEBOOK COMMUNITYhttps://www.facebook.com/golfrulesquestionsLISTEN TO THE GRQ PODCAST ON APPLE OR SPOTIFYClick here: https://anchor.fm/golfrules-questionsSUBSCRIBE to GOLFRULES QUESTIONS https://bit.ly/2I8KrVH for all your golf rules#golfrules #GolfRulesQuestions #blakey

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

We are back with episode 135 of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast and this week it is our favorite episode of the month, Clubland Stories. DK has a hypothetical question about a mixed gender match while Pedanticus is a little too penalty kiss over Pitchmark. Then we have the Nerd and Bill tell us about some more golf shop stuff UPS. We also have another audio question sent in by Dear John, and this time it gives us the answer just in case. So whether you're cooking rice or melting gold, please enjoy

this episode of the Golf Rules Questions Podcast. Welcome everyone to what do we do here, Stuart? Oh, that's right, the Golf Rules Questions Podcast, episode 135 this week or this episode we're talking about Clubland Stories, one of our favourites. So it's Clubland Stories from

March, episode 135. How are you, Mr. McPhee? Also known as Podcast. I'm fantastic Blakey, great to be here. Great to chat with you again on another episode. So big. Congratulations. We saw it in the drop zone but we haven't mentioned it on the podcast yet. Surprised you haven't mentioned it already. You got 100 out of 100 in the USGA Referees Exam Rules exam.

Rules exam. Yep, 101 hundred question for our exam. You actually flew all the way over to Dallas. Yeah, I, I didn't fly over there to do the exam, obviously. I flew over to go through the three days of really outstanding, highest quality instruction from those 3 gentlemen who were just fantastic. And then I think I said this to you a few days before. I wasn't even going to do the exam. And then someone just said just do it anyway. You'll be fine.

So I did it on the day four, and I walked out thinking, well, I've easily got 95. Easily, because I just knew the questions that I'd got right. But never in a million years did I think I get 100. Because you're always going to miss 123. You're always going to miss one word here or there that we've done enough questions to know that. So when I got the e-mail, I was in utter disbelief and for several days afterwards. So, yeah, thank you. And when you say you are, you are always going to miss. You're talking about me.

No, I'm just saying, generally speaking, when we do. And Jeff, no. No, no. When we do exams, when we do questions, you know, and there's a hundred of them. So you have to get, you know, it's a lot of words to read and you think you just accept you, you're going to get one or two wrong. You're going to just miss one word here, one word there, you know, and some of those answers when they're multi, you know, multiple lines, a lot of sentences, and the answer is just one word different here or there. It's pretty easy to just miss one of those as we all know too. Well, look at my RNA Level 3 exam, you know, we stand on A2

pointer because I forgot the fourth word in the question was match. So I read the rest of the question, got all that, and I forgot the word was match or the former play was matched. So I got that wrong so well. It was an amazing effort, but then again, it wasn't really an amazing if it was just for you, it was a good effort. No, no, I'm OK. Thank you. Obviously, I am thrilled, Blakey, right. But let's say it, let's say it. For those who do not know, we

are in a WhatsApp group which I formed one or two years ago, 18 months ago. Maybe you've been in it since the start. And our very, very good friend Jeff Ward, who's well known amongst the golf rules community, is also in it since day one. And we are in constant contact and challenging each other with situations and helping each other. So that has been a huge part of me getting to this point, yes. So thank you. I don't think I will ever get

100. I, I actually don't, but so getting 100 is an impressive, very impressive effort. And you have put in a lot of work. And it just goes to show that even if you pass one exam, you can't stop. You really just can't stop learning. You know, if you, if you break par, I'm not sure if you've felt that yet. So if you break, that's maybe 11.

I still have over you. If you break par, do you stop learning? You know, do you go, oh, this is it, I'm good enough. Yeah. I'm never gonna need another lesson or need another range session ever again. The answer is no. And it's just like when you're a referee. If you get a hundred 9998 as you have not done, you don't just go sweet. I know it all now. I don't need to learn anything else. It's it's just not, it's just not like that.

Golf balls are constantly evolving as well. You and I know that and a few others know that, but as we've said before, and we know a few people that do the RNA Level 2 exam and think they are set. And then when you and I now look back, all I do look back on the RNA level 2 exam and think, Oh my God, that's just so easy. So it's so straightforward. The Level 2 exam, at the time, I thought it was pretty challenging. Well, we look back now and think it's pretty straightforward, but. Yeah, yeah, possibly. I mean, I don't think any exam,

golf rules exam is that easy. I mean, that's the that you know, of the questions that I got wrong when I did it, you know, I could have easily have gotten them right and then other questions wrong. So yeah, it's an interesting situation. But anyway, enough of that. Well done. It's an thank you for just. Yeah, and I'm thrilled. Thank you. The Golfers Questions podcast and the Drop Zone are excellent

go to's for people who know the rules and one in particular. So excellent work. You know, there's just a good qualification and to have for the stuff that we we put out here. Yeah, yeah. The golfers question of the week 134. When I was talking to Clive from Golf dot AI, I asked this question and we've got the Golf dot AI answer here and I want

you to listen to it and you can tell us whether Golf dot AI have got it right in this occasion. So the question is, in stroke play a marker enters the scores in the wrong boxes on the scorecard. Can they correct it after they have returned the scorecard or is it too late? If a marker signs in the players spot and the player signs in the markers spot and the scorecard is is returned, is that also too

late to correct or does it even need? Does it even need to be corrected? So there's two questions there and I've copy and pasted that into Golf dot AI and this is what Golf dot AI have come up with. Scores in wrong boxes if a marker right scores in the wrong boxes on the scorecard, but the correct score for each hole is evident, they can correct the whole numbers to match the scores before returning the card. If the mistake is in court until

after the scorecard has been returned and it results in a whole score that is lower than the actual score taken, the player is disqualified. If the recorded score is higher than the actual score, the highest score stands. Incorrect signatures. If the player and mark assigned in each other's designated spots on the scorecard, this is considered an administrative error. As long as the correct scores are recorded and the scorecard has been signed by both parties, it is acceptable and no

correction is required. Sorry, did you hear the distinguished 2 answers for the two questions there? I did. Very animated, emotional voice. Yeah, very enthusiastic response. The funny. Thing is you can choose who like what kind of voice, what sounding voice and I usually choose the Kiwi female golf pro but for some reason this Tyrone Greens African American male golf coach from the US keeps popping up. Oh, I thought that was your

drunk voice. No, you. Selected no OK. You can choose father of golf too. But anyway, that was the that was the answer. Now is that correct? Is what Tyrone said correct? Good on you Tyrone. I'll go to the second one first. All all this stuff is in clarifications. I'm in now 3.3 B slash 2 if the oh now I've missed the point. Now hang on a second.

The first, the second one is fine if they certify in the wrong spot. If the player marker certify, the whole scores in the location where the other was meant to certify the players scores have been certified as required under Rule 3.3 B. The same would be true if initials were used to certify rather than the full name. So that is absolutely perfectly fine. That probably happens more than you, probably more than we realize. People signing in the wrong box. So to our question, perfectly fine and does not even need to

be corrected. No, that's perfectly fine. Wrong. Wrong scores or scores in the wrong boxes. So yeah, that won't be an issue. Say they started on hole 10. Yeah. And as you normally do, you put the whole scores in the hole one and then hopefully you catch it. But if you don't, you don't, and you hand it in, what's the Can you get it back and correct it, or is it too late? Yeah, I think it's too late, but

that's one of the benefits of the digital scoring apps. Of course, if the system not just starting on 10, it doesn't throw you up the box for the 1st hole, that's for sure. Yeah, each score must be identifiable to the correct hole. No surprise there. If a market enter supplies front 9 scores in the back nine boxes and the back 9 scores in the front, the scorecard will still be acceptable if the mistake is corrected by altering the whole numbers so that they go with the right score for each hole.

If this mistake is not corrected and as a result, just like Tyrone said, score is lower than actually taking on that hole, which is absolutely bound to happen. Surely guaranteed to happen. The players disqualified under 3.3 B 3. So there you go. Golf dot IAI was correct. Does that surprise you? You said that for rhetoric. Is that a rhetorical question? Well, you know, I was talking to club last week and he's pretty

excited about this product and and to be honest, I am too. I, I would love, you know, as I said last week or last episode, trying to get this information to the masses. And this is one way to do it. I mean, there's even a WhatsApp number you can call up or you can text a question to WhatsApp and you'll get an answer that, let me just check that number is +1415, 517-0843. So you text or call, you can

actually call them up and say something. Yeah, I'm, I'm, I haven't tried the calling yet. I'm sure it'll be a bit difficult if it can't understand what you're saying. But I mean, you're out in the golf course. You know, we, we talk about, well, you can call Stuart or you can call me, but no one's ringing me at 2:00 in the morning. Or let's say if they do, I'm not answering. So you can call golf dot I. So it's it's important that it's right. But what's, you know, is it

going to be better than the the golf shop pro? Probably. So yes, it's not we, you know, I've had heaps of people e-mail me, which is great. They've tried it out. They've been giving it feedback. That's excellent. There's all there's things that you know are amiss, but you know it'll get better or learn with all the feedback that we give it.

So I was just thought I'd ask your opinion. Are you surprised that it got it right? Oh no, I'm not just my brother uses it all the time, not golf dot IO, but you know, AI tool and some of the things he sends me that he does with it just blows my mind. Absolutely. I can't get my head around. So the fact that both of those answers, whether we're in clarifications, therefore written in text, you've just got this tool which has been able to, you know, analyze that, get

the information and just read it out from the clarification. And we know most club golfers don't go through the rules and they certainly don't go into the clarifications even if they do go into the rules. So no, not surprised. I'm being blown away every day with what this stuff is doing, and in a little way it scares me with some of its other applications. But in this space? Not surprising at all. Yeah, I'm, I'm with you there. I'm, I'm excited about it. You know, is it going to take my

job? Possibly, Who knows. But I'm excited that it's going to make the rules of golf more accessible to every golfer out there, which is what we want. Yeah. You know, I, I just received a, an e-mail from someone who's playing in the club championships and he is knowledgeable, the one that people go to for the rules of golf knowledge in the club. And he is asking me for advice on whether he should instigate

or, you know, uphold the rules of golf and risk, you know, having a bad name in the club. I guess you know, that whole thing of to know the rules of golf, you consider the bad sportsman, which is just, which is just ridiculous. I mean, and I just sort of reiterated, like in match play, if you're playing match play, you have the option of ignoring it and educating. It's great. Now you can actually educate the person without an agreement to

waive the rules. So you can say, oh, you're supposed to drop from knee height. I saw you drop from shoulder height. You've played already. That would normally be blah, blah, blah, but I'm not going to worry about it. Just do it right next time. That's in match play, in stroke play, you're there to protect the whole field. And that's what I said to him and said you're there to protect your whole field. You know, it would be pretty crappy if you lost by a shot because someone else didn't

protect the field or your friend lost by a shot because you didn't protect the field, because you saw the person who actually ended up winning do something, you know, had an indiscretion and you could have saved that actual winner, but you chose not to. So just think about that next time. So that was that was an interesting one, right? Let's get into clubland stories. So we've got Dino Division One women's Pennant round one at the

National Golf Club Gunnamatta. I'll. Be there on Wednesday. Victoria versus the National. OK. He's happy to tell us about all the details. A competitor Tees off. He didn't. He didn't use Wombat hills. A competitor Tees off the 1st hole and senses a rattle from her driver head. Upon investigation, it is discovered that the holding screw has come loose. The question arose whether she could tighten the screw to how it should be with or without penalty.

A discussion between the team managers took place and it was deemed that as long as the loft of the lie of the club head was not changed and a rule 4.1 a. She was able to repair the club head by tightening the screw even though she had started her round. No penalty applied. What do you think of that one? Yeah, I think that's OK. Isn't this a little bit easy? Sorry, Go on Blankie. No, you go your question because I was just about to tell you what my answer was. You know, I was just going to

say it's an interesting point about how what was the club's state when they started the round as the start of the match, But isn't this whole club thing a lot easier now? A lot simpler now, so far as we know that any club damaged during the round, except in cases of abuse, can be repaired, can be replaced and unless G nines in place, can be any club. So it's a lot simpler now so far as repairing and replacing.

But it's interesting about what we know about playing characteristics that's different, but that's covered under 4.1 A 3 when they've deliberately changed that club's playing characteristics during the round while using adjustable feature, blah, blah, blah. But they're allowed to repair that damage. And if that damage is the screw coming loose, they're they're fine to do that. So what I wanted to know a little bit more was did did the

did they start the round with the loose head or raffle in the head or did? That's my only gas breaks over this. Did it become loose from that first shot or did they even notice it after the first shot? I don't know. I don't know. So I said to back to Dana, given those facts that possibly the first stroke caused the driver had to become loose, the player would would be able to restore the club to its original state.

But if if the player actually starts with the rattle and knows there's a rattle and hits the first stroke with the rattle, they can't now tighten it up because they started with it loose. So if they tighten it up, they'd be improving the characteristics. The Yeah, they're using an adjustable feature or physically changing the club. Yeah, that's. What they're doing, you can, you can take it back to its normal state on that when you first started that first shot, but you can't make it better. Player must not make a stroke

with a club when they have deliberately changed that club's playing characteristics during the round, for example by using an adjustable feature or physically changing the club. Except when allowed to repair damage, and I suspect when your club is falling apart, I would classify that as damage. OK, Marty, I'm moving on, unless you've got something else to say. No, it's all just, I think just

six adjusting the feature back to where it was. There is no penalty and the club may be used to make a stroke in the following two if the club's playing characteristics were changed by using adjustable feature. Oh no, no, that's just if you haven't made a stroke with you, you can restore it and put it. Back and one way you can know that you're improving the characteristics and then you change it and then you're allowed to change it back before a stroke. It's not with that club, it's a stroke, right with any. Good question, just turn the

page. Is it the next stroke before the club is used so please? Tell me, I thought. No, that's it. No, before the club is used to make a stroke. So you can have another 30 strokes that specific club. Yeah, before, before the club, not a club. Yeah, before the club is used. That sort of saves more people from penalties, I guess. Yeah, you have 40 more strokes as long as you don't use that club before a story. Yeah, Yeah, OK. Right, this is next Clubland story from Pedanticus.

Player A's ball pitched on the apron of the green, leaving a deep pitchmark. Player B's ball landed just short of the apron. Player A's pitchmark was on Player B's line of play. Player A repaired his own pitchmark on the apron. Players weren't sure whether A was entitled to fix his pitchmark on the apron before B parted from off the green and sought clarification. Well, doing a dive into the rules rule 8.3 B in

clarification 8.3 slash 1 suggested that both players incurred the general penalty. It would have been OK if Player A's ball created the pitchmark after Player B's ball finished short of the green, IE Player B would have to be entitled to their line of play before Plat A's ball created the pitchmark. But in this case, Plat A's pitchmark was already there before Player ball. Player B's ball kind of race short of the green and therefore was part of the cats that Player B had to navigate. This happened Feb 2025.

Keysborough. I'll just say one thing about their response. Answering their own question was the only way. I forget the order now. The only way IE gets a penalty is if they did it deliberately to help be. That's the only they've got to go. Oh, I now recognize that's on Bees line of play. I'm going to go and fix that to deliberately help be. That triggers the general penalty. If they were oblivious, didn't even think about it and just went over and thought, oh, that's my pitch mark, I normally repair them.

I'll go and repair it and someone asks you, why did you do that? It was all I left a big hole in the ground. I just wanted to fix it. Do you realize that was on Bees line of play? Didn't even think about it. There's no penalty. It must be a deliberate action to alter physical conditions to affect another player's bullet. Rest or stroke. Stroke to be made. That's what 8.3 is. There's only one criterion that's deliberate. So you're saying there is intention, There's intention to improve? Absolutely. There's no automatic penalty. The player.

I had to do it deliberately to help Player B to improve that cat, to improve the line of play cats. And does that and does that same principle apply if you were doing it for your own pitch, Mark? Is it same principle as 8.1? So so there was a pitch mark on your. Line. Is it deliberate? Sorry, is that what you're? Saying there's a pitch mark on your line of play and you just go and repair it. Deliberate's only for 8.2 and 8.3, it's on 8.1. And then you realize that is now

on your line of play and you've improved your cats, but you'd never had the intention to try and improve your cats. Do you still get the penalty? You certainly do 8.1. There's nothing to do with deliberate, it's just your actions. 8.2 and 8.3 both have to be deliberate actions. And can you restore that pitchmark to avoid the penalty? Yeah, Blake, I think you know the answer to all these questions. You're just doing this for good discussion and it's just good. So we know because it's ground based, you cannot restore that condition.

You cannot fill in a hole, put the pitch mark back in. You can't do it, no. That's that's why I wanted you to ask you that question, because I wanted you to say that phrase ground based. Well, that's how it was taught to me because we got under 8.1. Where is it 8.1 A and we've got the five parts and it's one and two you can fix up but 345 you cannot and all the 3-4 and five are all the ground based things.

You can't. If you're filled in a hole, you can't get the, you know, the sand back out again on the soil base. Is it? Tree root that's just sticking out of the ground? Ground based? Or is it similar to a branch? Will you tell me what you've done to the tree root 1st and then we'll work it out? You've caught up with a Chainsaw I. Think you might have an issue there? Let's talk about let's go back to duct tape. Well, no, let's go back to the original question. Why are they suggesting both players get the penalty? Why is B getting penalized?

He didn't do anything. He or she didn't do anything. Why is B being penalized? Blakey? I think they're saying that that penalized them because it improves their conditions, but B never asked for it to happen. No. So why is B being penalised? There's only one reason why B will be penalised. I'm just wondering why. Yeah, I. I'm I'm with you, I don't think either player gets penalised if I've got it right here, if neither player realised what they were doing. But if they did realise what

they were doing, B would only get penalised if he asked or if he saw what was about to happen and didn't try and stop it. And when I say that, you know, the fact that it's a pitch mark would be very hard to see what was about to happen and stop it there, there wouldn't really be much time. So I wouldn't be too. I wouldn't be too harsh on be handing out a penalty in that case.

The player So a player sorry. A penalty applies when a breach of rule results from a player's own actions, all the actions of the caddy. But it also applies when the player sees another person about to take an action concerning the player's ball or equipment that they know would breach the rules if taken by the player or caddy, and does not take reasonable steps to object or stop it from happening. So B saw A with a pitch repair tool going over about to repair that. The committee would have to look

at did B have enough time to go? Well, you can't do that. Or they just sit back and go, oh, this is good. He's about to repair that pitch mark on my line of play. I'm not going to get penalized because I'm not doing it feels like. And they see them. Feels like a Mr. Bean skit. You know, player Player B's over there and Player A is Mr. Bean and gets out the pitch mark. He's like. Pretty bad though. Spotify listeners can't see what you're doing now, but.

It's all slowed down. Well, actually on Spotify you can watch the video. Oh, you've got the video. I'll pick it up. You've got nothing else to. Do you're the production person, not me. And you can watch it on YouTube, but if you choose to just listen to it as most people do, then you wouldn't be able to see me do the Mr. Bean impression. But we digress. So there's the possibility we're both copper penalty. Yes, but given the information that we've been given here, we

both agree that it's no penalty to either player. Oh, so you're thinking back. So there was no deliberate act to help player beating. Yeah. Against. If if they put in deliberate or asked or anything like that we would say yes. But in this case I mean if player A repeated it to try and help player B out, then player A yes would get the. Absolutely. I mean, rule 8.3 starts with the

This rule only covers a player's deliberate actions, Yeah, to alter physical conditions to affect another player. If the Danticus had, as in deliberate for us for the benefit of us, we would definitely give them the penalty. OK, I agree with that. Right next one from Murray playing the 4th hole at Wombat Hills. Frantic, Frank was in a car while his three mates walked after they hit to the green.

Frank rushed forward and upon getting to the green decided to assist his mates by marking their balls. Due to his frantic nature, he hadn't put any ball markers in his pocket and and decided to scratch AV for his ball, the NTP and two of his mates. As he was about to do the same for the last ball, he thought that scratching the ground might not be a correct way of marking the ball, so he simply lifted it. What penalties apply to whom and

for what infringement? Would it have altered the situation where Frank had? If Frank had lifted his own ball, which marked without marking or scratching the ground? Would it have altered the situation if Frank had lifted his own ball without marking or scratching the ground? How was this resolved? All players marked the spot where their balls were and played on. I'm guessing he threw the balls back to them, they put them down, marked them again, lift

them, clean them, whatever. I guess you replace with a ball marker or replace with the ball. What do you think of that one podcast? Did Frank lift his own ball by scratching the surface of the grain, or did he have a ball marker for his own? He scratched the AV for his ball, that NTP marker, and there's the pin marker and two of his mates, they were all scratched. And then for the third player, he just picked it up. Yeah, OK, so we know this is pretty straight.

This is like one of the first things in Rule 14 and pretty straightforward procedure. Before lifting a ball under a rule requiring the ball to be replaced, put back on the exact same spot, the player must mark the spot, put a ball marker right behind or right next to it, or put your club down on the ground. So Frank is going to incur one penalty stroke for lifting his own ball on the putting green without marking the spot. There'll be no penalties for anyone else for any of the other balls that were lifted unless Frank did it with the authority permission from the other

players, which from the question that hasn't happened. So and we know Frank is just an outside influence to those other players balls, so there's no issue there. So it's just his ball gets the one shot and. He will get one shot for being OK, just too frantic. He just probably just needs to relax a little on the golf course and enjoy it a bit more. Enjoy it by playing by the rules. Oh, just don't be so rushed, you know, don't just run, not rush so much and just relax and.

Well, maybe you could change his name to chill out, Chad. Yeah. Right next one from The Nerd. Two players A&B on the green, but in the way of a third. Player C for pace of play reasons. Player C marks both balls after asking A&B permission to do so and rolls rolls them to the side. A&B pick up their balls, putt to the hole and discover they have

played each other's ball in error. The four scores were submitted. Each player requested a ruling from the pro shop and we're told because the balls have been marked and lifted, no penalties applied. Oh. Sorry. I think the correct answer is one stroke penalty to each player for incorrectly substituting a ball. This happened last Saturday at our Golf Club. I was asked to my opinion post event so their scores will

stand. Another another pro shot gets us. I bet it doesn't mention the club at the bottom of that submission. It does. We know it's not one for hills. Probably done it. Whatever is put on here, I I tell it out loud. So OK, if they put their club, I will say it, if they put their own name, I will say it. But if they put a nickname, if they don't, if they put Wombat Hills, I will just say them so. We know it's made-up. I don't hold anything back, I tell you that, OK?

So I well I don't think I need to add much more than what you just said. If a player makes a stroke at an incorrectly substitutable, the player gets one penalty stroke and must then play at the hole with the incorrectly substitutable. We know when you are replacing a ball in the spot you must use the original ball and the 14.2 and there are 4 exceptions to that, but none of them apply to this situation. Quite funny. Do tell. Yeah, it would have been funnier if they'd gone, oh oops, we played the wrong ball, swap them

back and then they get an extra two shots, but then the pro shot would still say no penalty. It's pretty bad. So if, of course one of them hold out with the incorrect and then pulled it out of the hole and goes, oh, hang on, we know it doesn't matter what happens after that because the hole is done for that person. Yeah, but yeah, who knows what the pro shot would come up with at a few more strokes. That's one of those. That's one of those ones when you can use someone else's ball, but it's now out of play so it

doesn't matter. Righty. I hope that helped the nerd. You got that right. Well, the nerd, Yeah, it was spot on. Did not. OK, we've got another one from an old mate of ours, DK. This is his 18th submission. We haven't heard from him in a while, I don't think. He says hello lads, long time no speak. I have a hypothetical rules situation to discuss. Playing match play, Player A is male and player B is female. Players arrive to the T of the last hole all square.

Oops I mean tide. You can say you can say all square. For us, the last hole happens to be a par 4 for men and a par 5 for women. Both players are called 5. Strokes and Player A says we're heading into sudden death. However, Player B claims that she has won the hole in the match because her paw beats his bogey. What is the correct result in this situation? What do you think? You'd like to think, because we know these situations do occur

from time to time, you'd like to think the committee are all over this and have got ahead of this and already have some something in their terms of competition which clearly stipulates what happens in this situation. I do have some guidance from the World Handicap system where, excuse me, where it is different pars for women and men, and we do. In fact, it's not the net or the gross score that matters. It is the relationship to par. So in that particular case, the

woman, I don't know if there was names attached, the woman does actually win the whole because she had a par, the guy had a bogey, she wins the whole even though they both had a 5 on that whole is what the World Handicap system would suggest. That's great that that says that now because back in the day Golf Australia did not say that. They said that the scores are halved because the handicap looks after it. So I'm glad it has changed so. Now of course if it's a handicap

match and obviously the net scores, but it's still in relationship to par. Yeah, that's right. And effectively, if the guy's given the girl a shot on the hole due to handicap, well, the guy's given two shots on that hole because the par's different. Yeah, yeah, that's right. If she'd had a buggy and he'd had a buggy, she would still win because she gets a shot. But it was, yeah. DK goes on to ask what would the answer be if they are playing handicap match play and player A

scores a net four and player B scores a net 4 birdie, she gets a shot on the whole, keeping in mind that the daily handicaps are calculated on the course as part of the formula. Yeah, but still its relationship to par. Yeah, it is. So again, you you hope the committee's ahead of it, but. I mean, I, yeah, she would win. I, I that makes simple sense. It's not the actual number, it's to par as you keep saying now, sorry.

DK asked the player. DK said the players asked you and Porter on Golf dot AI. That's one of the voices. And the result in the first scenario was a halved hole after sudden death, which we disagree with. And in the second scenario, the net birdie beats the net par and handicap match play despite the net strokes being the same, which we agree with. And this happened at Dingo Jones

on the last hole. Yeah, that's a good hole. Speaking of a golf dot AI and we I know we talked about it before, just after it must have been last week I asked it if sand is a loose impediment and last week it said yes. So I provided it some feedback that that is not correct, that sand is not a loose impediment, but you are allowed to remove it

or move it when on the putting green. Now I've just typed it in again. Is sand a loose impediment and this is what it's come up with? No, sand is specifically not a loose impediment according to the Rules of Golf. While you can remove loose impediments without penalty, you generally cannot remove sand except on the putting green. So This is why feedback to it is very, very good.

I mean, that's within a week, things have changed and and it's updated its database and that's the correct answer, so. Is that your drunk voice? That was who was that? That was Jasmine Maple, an African Canadian female golfer. Right. Yeah, no, that's terrific. That's just good feedback. But so just one of those. If you if you this is this is this is what I would like you to do if you are trying this golf dot AI stuff.

If you're not happy with them, no. If you're not, I was going to say if you're not happy with the ruling, see this is this will be the trouble would be when they are happy with the ruling, but it's actually incorrect. Wrong. But if you're not happy, then you can e-mail us and say, hey, is this correct? And then we'll provide feedback on whether it is or not. But in the end, someone somewhere will provide feedback eventually that is knowledgeable and will help the system out.

That's one of those classic quiz questions. Sand and soil are not loosen impediments except on the putting ground. Everybody goes, yeah, that's that's right. That's right. Well, that's what it was in 2018. Oh, don't want to, don't want to hear that. Yeah, well, that's that's why, you know, someone like myself would get get confused because in 2018 it was a loose impediment on the grain, but now it's not a loose impediment anywhere, anywhere you are allowed to move it on the grain. Right. So that's why I can understand why people get a. Little bit.

Ah, OK. Well, thank you for. OK, last one is from Bill. The 6th hole has a fence that defines out of bounds. The fence has a gate. You know where this is going, Player. I do because I reckon the gate's open or. Flash They had a shot that was near the gate which was not open but not locked. It was not open but not locked. Player A asked the pro who said it was a boundary fence and relief not available. Player took relief for an

unplayable lie. We have another golf shop pro sabotaging the rules of golf. This happened October 2024 at Prospect Bay Country Club I. Wonder where that is? Canada. Wonderful. Actually, no it's not. It's my I'm lying that is not great. Not great from that pro. A gate that's not open but not locked is what podcast?

Well, it's movable, I'm just going to say so. Boundary object under the definition. This includes any base blah blah blah, but does not include any gate, steps, bridge, or similar construction used for getting over or through the wall or fence gate. And if it is locked? Oh, sorry, the gate is locked. Well, I guess it's any movable 1, isn't it? It is. It's not. It's still not part of the boundary object.

It is an immovable obstruction. And you? If your balls in the general area, you're OK. Or you you can get free relief if you're as long as your balls not in a penalty. Penalty area. All right, Events. All right, excellent. So we've hopefully Bill can pass that on to the pro shop. Now we have had an interesting one pop up. So I'm not in, I wasn't in Macau last week.

I was there last year for the Asian Tour and I wasn't there this year. And someone I would have loved to be, but someone sent through a video, they were watching the footage of an interesting situation with their Australian, Lucas Herbert. And the referee was there on the spot. And I didn't quite see where the golf ball was, but it was interference by this path in the general area. And they were trying to work out

the nearest point of complete relief and then taking the drop from there. And the player, Lucas was getting quite confused with where this reference point was. And the referee didn't quite help himself. As I said, I don't know where the actual ball was, but the referee didn't quite help himself. And Lucas was getting quite animated about, well, depending on where this reference point is will change my swing, but it's

not the swing. This is the important part. It's not the swing for where the ball for where the reference point is. You'll still have to use the swing that you would use for where the ball is currently at rest. If the condition was not there, so. He's going, well, hang on, I'm going to, I'm going to be going flatter to go into this Bush. I'm going to be flatter. And then this. That's my, my nearest point of cling complete relief.

It sort of it spreads him out and he you know, now he's almost getting down on his knees and he's squatting down and getting lower and the club head is getting further away from the feet, which means that reference point, he's thinking that reference point gets further away from the car path and then he shouldn't be dropping on that side. But what that really ends up being is becoming a nicest over nearest. And yeah, it was an interesting one for those people out there that are watching that it wasn't

quite wasn't quite right. The explanation that is it's the shot that you would play. So it'd just be a normal shot. And then if that means that you're in a Bush, then that is your nearest point regardless. Yep, so. Then you take a club length and then if you're you're shot or your club, they can all change after that. Yeah, had one of those on the weekend. So nearest point estimated spot, No near the whole required area

of the course where there is no interference from the condition from which relief is being taken for the stroke the player would have made from the original spot. If the condition we're not there requires a player to identify the choice of club, stance, swing and line of play they would have used for that stroke. Yeah, yeah, that's exactly right. So I just wanted to point out someone sent that to me. I didn't actually see it. And then they sent that to me. I just wanted to clarify that would have used not. Well now the spot has changed,

exactly changed the way I'm going to play and that changes the reference point. That's not correct. There's only ever going to be 1 reference point. If that puts you in the middle of a tree, then you're hoping that your one club length gets you away from that tree. Exactly did the caption read? Is this you Blakey? Was that the caption to that video? It didn't say Is this you, Blakey? But it did say, are you there? OK. So. Can you get over there and sort this out? Something something like that.

I like you did in Hong Kong right when you just walk through and push spectators out of the way to get to the. Yeah, although that didn't really work. Anyway, right now we've got another one from another question and answer from John and you can give us a bit of John Thurman. You can give us a bit of a background on this because you got the e-mail. He felt sorry for me, which I told you he didn't have to feel sorry for me. Yeah, he did e-mail me that the

other day, just about the last conversation. So as we know, in two episodes ago, we had two audio questions from John Thorman, who is the author of the book. Let's Get It Right. And the book has been a work in progress for quite a few years now, where John would receive rules questions. He basically coined them as Dear John and he got lots of rules questions about various scenarios, very, very similar to our clubland stories. And he provided accurate, you know, relevant information on

the rules for those. And he started to put them together in a book. It's a wonderful service to those interested in the rules of golf. It is available for free. You can just go and do a search for let's get it right. You know, the rules of golf book interesting and novel golf rule situations defined. There's over now 400 pages in that book and we had John on a previous episode and he was terrific on that episode and he's now started recording some audio questions for us. So he's contributing to our podcast, which is terrific.

And you have one ready to go there. I do and I just want to say thank you now. Last time he didn't give us the actual answer. So you and I went through and we thought we were pretty close and it even popped up a few things into his head what we were talking about. This time he's actually given us the the answer, but he because he felt sorry for me that he did and and fair enough, but he said, you know, going cold or going live without hearing the audio, which I haven't heard

this one either is is a tough thing to do, But you know, I really appreciate where he's coming from. But when I put myself out here on this podcast and try and come up with the ruling on the spot, you know that that's from that's my burden to beer and something I really enjoy doing. And hopefully I get it right. But unlike John's book, maybe I don't always get it right. But I will continue to do it as

long as we've got three people listening. So the question that we have this is this is from John Thurman. Hi guys, this situation happened in a league individual stroke play competition. Allen's 90 foot chip shot rolled to rest mere inches from the hole. A kick in as they say. Indeed, Allen walked directly to the ball and literally kicked it

into the hole for a par. Or so he thought until another player said that wasn't legal. Why not? Does Allen get a penalty? Isn't the ball hold? So that was from 1 footer and which is quite a funny story. I thought a funny name. What is the answer to that one podcast without reading it from the answer that he's provided? Oh well, I was just going to say we're going to go to the definition of stroke, the forward movement of the club

made to strike the ball. So we know we don't make a stroke with any part of our body. We don't certainly don't do with a foot. So that ball is not holed the play, the hole is not complete and we need to replace the ball where it was, however far it was away from the hole. If that spot is not known, then we estimate and use reasonable judgment to do that. But the hole is not complete. But we do need to add 1 penalty stroke because we know we can get away with accidental

movement of our ball on the putting green. But I would argue that someone kicking the ball in the hole is not accidental movement. That was a deliberate action. Therefore they've moved their ball in play on the putting green deliberately. One penalty stroke. Replace a ball and hit it properly with some part of the club, preferably the head of the club. That pretty much sums up exactly what John has said. He just the added bit was if he if the player fails to hole out and subsequently makes a stroke on the next hole, they'll be disqualified. So good one there Stuart, and

hope everyone at home got that one. I've never heard that expression a kick in, but I've heard tap in. No, not a kick in. I've had. I've heard both, but yeah. They have different distances. No, I'd say that. Different ranges, a tap in is from here to here and a kick in is a bit. Have you ever heard the term $1.50? Yes. What does it mean? Well, normally I hear people say $1.20 or $1.50 means 120 a 150. Yeah, yards or most most likely

yards from the whole rather than metres. But I think we use it in Australia too in the metric system. Right. That brings us to the end of the podcast. But before we end it, the golf was Question of the Week 135 from Blakey. That's me. I don't know why I said that. In third person, A player's ball played from the putting green is deflected into the hole by another player's caddy who accidentally walked across the line of play. The original ball or another

ball must be replaced on its original spot and the stroke must be replayed. True or false? Very interesting. Can I just ask one question of fact? Yes, the caddy of another player. It was accidental. Is that right? Yes, correct. Not deliberate. Very interesting. Excellent. Thank you everyone for listening in to episode 135. We've enjoyed bringing it to you

and we will speak to you or someone will speak and you will listen next time. 136 See your podcast. See you, Blakey.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. TOUR Report November 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 143

    Nov 4, 202641 minAudio

    Blakey Rules Podcast Episode - 143 Golf is a test of character before it is a test of skill, and character is best shown when no one else is watching. In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. CLUBLAND STORIES October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142

    Oct 1, 202639 minAudio

    ClubLand Stories October 26 - Blakey Rules Podcast Episode 142 In partnership with Fraser Nicol from The Golf Rules Samaritan - if you want to learn the rules, I mean really do a deep dive, then you have to sign up to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1

    Sep 9, 202629 minAudio

    Latest Rulings - Viktor Hovland, Shaun Norris, Moa Svedenskoild, Niall Shiels Donegan, the Question of the Week and the Question of the Episode -Blakey Rules Ep 1 Hello, Blakey is back for episode 141 of the previously...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. GUEST: Marcela Smith, shares her path to becoming a rules official, U.S. Open qualifier stories, and fun clinics via Girlfriends Guide to Golf and SCGA volunteering. - THE GRQ PODCAST EP140

    Jul 7, 20251 hrAudio

    GUEST: Marcela Smith shares her journey to becoming a golf rules official and stories from two U.S. Open Qualifiers. She teaches fun, experiential rules clinics through Girlfriends Guide to Golf and volunteer officiates...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139

    Jun 25, 202559 minAudio

    GUEST: Jason R. Smith, co-author of A Guide to Being a Rules Official, joins Blakey for his second guest appearance, and they go through some gnarly Rules of Golf situations - THE GRQ PODCAST EP139 Jason brings his own...

    Credit the people on this episode