Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beyond The Surface

Beyond The Surface artwork

Do we have free will ? | Episode 2

Dec 12, 202537 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

For Feedbacks In this second episode of our mind series, we explore one of the most debated questions in human thought: How much of our “free will” is actually ours? From the shaping force of our upbringing to the subtle expectations of society, we reflect on how environments sculpt our choices long before we’re aware of them. We discuss Robert Sapolsky’s provocative challenge to free will; drawing from his book Determined, and contrast it with Daniel Dennett’s more hopeful, compatibilist view... Together, these perspectives open a deeper conversation about agency, responsibility, and the invisible threads that guide our decisions. Rather than offering a final answer, this episode invites you to rethink what it truly means to choose 🙌 If you enjoyed this episode, don’t forget to give us a 5-star review and follow Beyond The Surface for more deep and thought-provoking conversations. Your support helps us grow and bring you even better content 😊 I'd love to hear what you think; feel free to reach out at (muhamoet4@gmail.com)

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hey, hello everyone, and welcome back to Beyond the Surface Podcast. You know, every time we talk about the mind, I like to start with something very simple. Something human, I would say. So let me ask you this question. When was the last time you made a decision that felt completely yours? A choice where you didn't hesitate, didn't overthink, didn't feel pushed or pulled by anything around you. Maybe it was something tiny, choosing to take someone first or deciding to take a different road home, or even saying no when you usually say yes.

SPEAKER_00Whatever came to your mind, just hold that for a second. Because in that small moment, right before you acted, something interesting happened actually. There was a pause, a flicker. That tiny space where we feel like we are the ones steering the wheel. And today that's exactly where we are going. Into that small mysterious space between what we think we choose and what might be already chosen for us.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to episode 2 of our mind series. And today's topic is free will. Are we really free? Are we responsible for our actions? No preaching, no answers forced on you today, no, just an honest exploration with you guys. And maybe by the end of this episode, you will walk away with your own definition of free will. Or maybe even more questions. Either way, I'm glad that you're here. So when we talk about free will, most of us picture something very simple.

SPEAKER_00I think, I choose, I act. That's a clean straight line. That feeling of being the author of our own choices. We grow up believing in this, right? Our cultures teach it, our parents repeat it, and our teachers reinforce it. And society builds entire systems from praise to punishment on that simple idea that we are the captains of our own ships. Especially in the Western cultures, the message is very loud. You are responsible, you decide your life, you choose your future, but in other parts of the world, in more collective societies, the story is softer, more intertwined.

SPEAKER_00Your choices belong not only to you, but to the group, to the family, to tradition, to the environment you grew up in. So your decisions don't just say who you are, but where you also come from. Both cultures carry part of the truth, but neither shows the whole picture, unfortunately. Because the more we look beyond the surface, the more we realize that a decision is never just a decision. It's a layered thing. It's a whole world. So let's just imagine a decision, okay?

SPEAKER_00On the outside it seems simple, right? But beyond that surface, there are layers. So many layers really. So let's start with biology, hormones, neurotransmitters, brain pathways, childhood, the way you were raised, what you were rewarded or punished for, personality, introversion, implosivity, sensitivity, mood, are you tired, anxious, excited? And timing. Honestly, this one is more powerful than we think, I guess.

SPEAKER_00There's a well-known study on judges that still shocks me every time I think about it, actually. Researchers looked at thousands of parole decisions and found something strange. Right before lunch, judges were far more likely to deny parole. And after lunch, after they had eaten, rested, or reset a little, the chances of granting parole jumped dramatically. Same judge, same loss, same prisoner, but two completely different decisions, just because of timing.

SPEAKER_00Because hunger and fatigue were quietly influencing the feeling of I choose. This example fits perfectly into the layers of a decision, you know. It shows how even something as basic as your blood sugar can shape what you believe is a rational, fair choice, you know. Then we have culture, the values you observed without noticing, and also trauma, the invisible barriers you carry, also memories, everything similar that ever happened to you, and environment too, the room you are in, the people around you, the pressure in the air.

SPEAKER_00And we have also social expectations, what you think you should do, and finally the unconscious biases, the patterns your mind turns automatically, and also habits, the things you do without thinking. All of these whisper into your decision. Nudge it, shape it, tilt it in one direction or another. And yet, you only feel the final result. You feel the choice, not the layers, you feel the action, not the silent forces guiding it. This doesn't mean free will is an illusion.

SPEAKER_00I'm not I'm not saying that at all. It doesn't mean we are robots, also. It simply means that the story is more complicated and also more interesting than I chose this. Because maybe the real question isn't did I choose freely, but what shaped the version of me that made that choice? This layered view prepares us perfectly for what's coming next. Sapolsky's perspective on determinism, where every choice has a cause and every cause has another cause behind it.

SPEAKER_00But before we go into the scientific side, take a second, please. Think of a decision you made recently and imagine the layers behind it. Not to judge it, not to question it at all, no, just to understand it. You know, understanding is the whole point of today's episode. So when we open the door to determinism, we are stepping into one of the most uncomfortable, but also one of the fascinating ideas about the mind generally.

SPEAKER_00And Robert Sapolsky, the neuroscientist who wrote Determined, I read that book and it's amazing by the way, even though I don't agree with everything he has written in the book, but it's truly amazing. One of the most interesting books about the topic, the topic of free will. So, Sapolsky argues that every single decision we make is the product of causes we didn't choose. Your genetics, your biology, your childhood, your hormones, your culture, your stress travel, your access to opportunities, your trauma and your environment, and even the timing of the moment.

SPEAKER_00According to him, when you finally make a decision, you couldn't have done otherwise. Not because you are controlled, not because you are weak or something, but because you are the end result of billions of moments, pathways, influences, and forces that you never personally selected. It's a bold idea, it's a bold claim, I know. And it's one that makes people maybe feel uncomfortable because it touches our sense of responsibility, our pride, our guilt, our identity. But Sapolski doesn't say this to make life meaningless, no.

SPEAKER_00He says it to help us understand compassion, forgiveness, and the hidden forces behind human behavior. Still, even if we respect his work, it's important to be honest. Neuroscience doesn't always paint the full picture, you know, and sometimes it oversimplifies things. For example, a brain scan can show activity, the brain's activity, right? But it can't tell you why you chose something, why it felt like that, or even the personal history behind it. Most neuroscience studies, including the famous ones about decision making, measure extremely small, often meaningless decisions like moving a finger or pressing a button.

SPEAKER_00Real-life decisions are deeper, emotional, and contextual, and more complex, I would say. But neuroscience often focuses on the brain in isolation. No human mind exists without society, culture, relationships, or environment. These play a massive role in shaping decisions, right? So while Sapolski's determinism is powerful and clear, it's not the whole story. This is where the tension appears between the biological causes behind our choices and the lived experience of feeling like we're choosing.

SPEAKER_00Before we move forward, try this. Think of one decision in your life that shaped who you are today. Now imagine that millions of invisible causes leading up to that moment. Does it make the decision feel less free or more understandable? This tension is where the entire debate lives. Whenever people talk about free will, there's one experiment that always finds its way into the conversation. Benjamin Libet's famous study from the 80s.

SPEAKER_00And honestly, even after all these years, it still raises big questions. Here's what happened, in the simplest way possible. Libet asked participants to do something tiny, move their wrist whenever they felt like it. While they did that, he measured two things. First, the readiness potential, the RP, the brain's buildup of activity before the movement. And second of all, the moment the participant decided to move, to move that finger.

SPEAKER_00The surprise about the study is the brain activity started before the person reported deciding to move. In other words, your brain begins preparing a decision milliseconds before you become aware of making it. Some people hear this and immediately jump to a dramatic conclusion. They go, see, free will doesn't exist. The brain decides, not you. But if we just slow down for a second, things are not that simple. Because here's what this experiment actually shows and what it really doesn't.

SPEAKER_00What Lubet's experiment does show us? Well, for small, quick, meaningless movements, the brain kicks into action before we become conscious of that decision. There is a delay between unconscious preparation and conscious awareness. Our awareness isn't the first spark, it's a moment that arrives after the brain begins its work. This is fascinating, isn't it? It challenges the idea that we consciously initiate every action. But here's what the experiment doesn't prove.

SPEAKER_00And this part is often forgotten, unfortunately. It does not show that complex decisions are unconscious. Choosing a career, ending a relationship, apologizing, these involve memory, values, reasoning, emotions, not just neural impulses, you know? It does not say that consciousness is irrelevant. It only highlights a delay, not the absence of agency. It does not mean free will doesn't exist. It simply shows that consciousness might not be the start of the process.

SPEAKER_00And it does not capture real life choices. Lebet measured tiny finger flicks in a lab, not moral decisions, not political decisions, not life-changing choices, you know. And there is another twist, the veto. Even Lebet himself believed we have what he called a veto power, meaning the brain might initiate the impulse, but the conscious mind can still say no. A kind of last-minute gatekeeper, I would say. Some call this a tiny form of free will, but others call it a comforting illusion.

SPEAKER_00We don't need to pick aside guys, okay? It's enough to sit with the complexity. So what do we take from this? Loubet doesn't approve determinism, but he does show that the story of decision making is far more complicated than I decided, so I acted. He opens the door to the idea that maybe the brain prepares options, maybe consciousness chooses among them, and maybe both are influenced by things we are not always aware of.

SPEAKER_00But we still feel the decision as ours, right? And that feeling really matters. Now that we have looked at how the brain behaves before a decision, let's move into the philosophical side. Specifically, incompatibilism, one of the core positions in the free will debate, and honestly, it's one of the most misunderstood. So what is incompatibilism in the simplest, most human way?

SPEAKER_00People who defend incompatibilism say something very direct. If every event has a cause, then free will cannot exist, and if you could not have done otherwise, you could not be responsible. This is incompatibilism, simple, clear, and brutal in its honesty. Imagine your life as a long chain, okay? Your genetics, your upbringing, your culture, your environment, your emotions, your thoughts, your brain's impulses, your final decisions.

SPEAKER_00For the incompatibilist pupil, if every link in that chain is shaped by something before it, then the idea of free will slips through your fingers. According to them, you don't freely choose your thoughts, you don't freely choose your desires, you don't freely choose your mindset, your triggers, your fears, your identity. You simply express what all those forces create. And here's the part that makes incompatibilism so challenging. It feels intuitively true, right?

SPEAKER_00Because when you look deeply into our lives, we see the causes everywhere. You didn't choose your genetics, your parents, your environment, the culture that shaped your norms, the trauma you carry, the opportunities given or denied to you, the emotional patterns you picked up as a child. Yet all of these shape your choices. Incompatibilism says, if the causes are not free, then the result, your decision, cannot be free either. Now we have something called PAP, the principle of alternate possibilities.

SPEAKER_00PAP says you are only responsible if you could have done otherwise. If there was no other possible path, then responsibility collapses. That's why incompatibilism and PAP kind of related somehow, they reinforce each other, right? If incompatibilism is right, then you could have done otherwise is never true in the first place. And here's where the tension becomes emotional, the moral weight paradox. Let's be honest. Even if incompatibilism makes sense logically, emotionally it hits something fragile inside us, right?

SPEAKER_00Because even if everything is determined, we still feel guilt, we still feel pride, we feel regret, we feel responsible. If someone apologizes to us, it still touches us, right? If someone hurts us, it still feels personal. If we achieve something, we still feel like we did it. So the paradox is this. If we cannot do otherwise, why do praise and guilt still feel so real? Maybe it's biology, maybe it's evolution, maybe it's social conditioning, as Ivan Pavlov says in his book.

SPEAKER_00Or maybe it's something deeper in human psychology, a built-in need to feel like an agent in our own story. Incompatibilism forces us to sit with this uncomfortable duality. Logically, we may not be as if we as we think. Emotionally, we still live as if we are. That tension is going to follow us for the rest of this episode, actually. Especially as we start exploring our responsibility, culture, and environment intertwine with our decisions.

SPEAKER_00Okay, now that we have unpacked incompatibilism and all the uncomfortable beauty inside it, let's step into something a little more subtle, a little more psychological. Because if incompatibilism is the big picture, disturbed causality and the recursive loop are the inner mechanics of how our choices actually unfold. So let's start with disturbed causality. When the cause isn't as clean as we think. We grow up imagining choices in a simple structure.

SPEAKER_00A cause B, I thought, I acted, right? But real decision making is messier. Sometimes your past interrupts your present. Your emotions distort your reasoning. External noise mixes with internal biases. Or an event from 10 years ago quietly rearranges the meaning of something today. This is what we call disturbed causality. Your decisions aren't formed by a single cause. They are formed by a storm of interacting causes, most of which you didn't invite in the first place.

SPEAKER_00A simple example, okay? Let's just try this. You think you are choosing to stay calm in an argument because you decided to be uh the bigger person, right? But in reality, it might be your childhood environment, your attachment style, your past relationships, your current mood, the tone of the other person, subconscious fear of confrontation, and the desire to perceive it in a certain way, all mixing and reshaping the final choice. It's still your choice. You feel it that way, but it isn't isolated.

SPEAKER_00Its roots are everywhere. Then, after disturbed causality, we have the recursive loop, the environment chooses with you. This part is really fascinating, and honestly, it changes how you see people. Because the truth is you don't just make choices inside your environment. Your environment is actively participating in your choice. A recursive loop means you influence the environment, which then influences you, which then influences your next decision, which then influences the environment again.

SPEAKER_00It never stops, it keeps looping. You're not a chooser standing outside reality. You are inside the system, and the system reacts to you and shapes you back. You choose your friends, right? Your friends shape your personality. Your personality changes how you choose people. Another example, you choose your job. The job shapes your habits. Your habits shape your ambitions. Another example, you choose silence in a conflict. The silence shapes the relationship. The new tone of the relationship influences your next choice.

SPEAKER_00It's it's a dance, you know? And you are not the only dancer. The environment has its own rhythm, and your choices move with it, not apart from it, believe me. So the big question is why this matters for free will. Well, because in classical free will debates, the individual is imagined as a separate, clean, isolated agent. But the recursive loop says, you are woven into a web, you are not choosing alone, and your choices aren't created in a vacuum.

SPEAKER_00Even what feels like a purely internal decision, like deciding to forgive someone, change careers, or walk away from a relationship, is actually the outcome of thousands of feedback loops between you and the world. So, understanding this doesn't make life deterministic or hopeless. Instead, it gives you this gentle clarity. You weren't weak when you made a bad choice. You were responding to a system bigger than you. You weren't broken when you kept repeating a pattern.

SPEAKER_00The loop hadn't changed yet. And sometimes healing isn't about forcing a new decision, it's about changing the environment, so the environment helps you choose differently. It's not excuses, it's context, it's compassion. So, if everything we have said so far is true, if our choices are shaped by genetics, upbringing, culture, hormones, timing, environment, loops, causes, then the natural question emerges almost quietly.

SPEAKER_00What happens to responsibility? What happens to morality? What happens to meaning? Because it's one thing to talk about free will in theory, but the moment you bring real life into it, the conversation becomes personal, doesn't it? So let's break down everything we've talked about gently, without preaching, without telling anyone what to believe. Let's start with responsibility. Responsibility doesn't disappear when free will gets complicated. It just becomes contextual.

SPEAKER_00A few examples. If someone harms another person, we still have to respond, but instead of imagining they acted from a pure free vacuum, we understand the causes behind their behavior. Justice becomes less about punishment and more about prevention, rehabilitation, and understanding the system that created the behavior. Responsibility becomes more about capacity than blame. What someone could realistically control based on their background, biology, and situation, right? Sapolsky defend this, and Daniel Dennett criticize him.

SPEAKER_00But meeting somewhere between the two is a healthy human middle. So we hold the people accountable, but we also recognize the causes that shape them. That's not weakness. That's wisdom, honestly. If choices aren't isolated, then morality isn't either, right? Morality becomes something that grows between people, not inside a single person. It's shaped by the culture you were raised in, the values around you, your experiences, your emotional development, the behaviors you were exposed to.

SPEAKER_00This is why two people raised in opposite environments can see the Same action through completely different moral lenses. So instead of imagining morality as this perfect objective thing that we freely choose, we see it as something as we inherit, we negotiate with, something we refine and sometimes even outgrow. Morality becomes a process, not a switch. And somehow that makes it feel more human, doesn't it? And by the way, meaning doesn't need free will to exist.

SPEAKER_00Meaning can come from the roles you play, the relationships you nurture, the goals you pursue, the narratives you reshape, the patterns you choose to break, the impact you leave on others. None of these require a perfectly free chooser, right? They just require awareness, participation, intention, even if intention itself is shaped by causes. Meaning isn't destroyed by determinism. Meaning survives determinism. Because meaning is something we create individually and collectively with the tools we we were given.

SPEAKER_00And maybe that's the most honest way to live. Not pretending we are in control of everything, but using the small room for influence, we do have to shape our own world and environment in a better way. Determinism doesn't kill meaning, by the way, it just makes meaning a shared pursuit. So now that we have explored responsibility, morality, and meaning, this one last important angle we need to shed lights on.

SPEAKER_00How do culture and environment, especially East versus West, shape our perception of free will itself? And why do some cultures believe in strong individual free will while others emphasize collective responsibility? Well, to understand that, let's just zoom out for a moment. Because when we talk about free will, we often imagine it as a human idea, as if everyone on earth understands choices the same way. But that's not true, right? The culture you grew up in quietly shapes your understanding of what a decision even is.

SPEAKER_00Some societies raise you to feel like every decision is yours, an expression of your identity, right? Other societies raise you to feel like every decision is ours, a contribution to the group. And depending on where you grow up, your relationship with free will might look completely different without you even noticing it. So let's try to break that down. In most Western individualistic cultures, you create your own life. Your choices define you. You should follow your dreams.

SPEAKER_00Autonomy is a moral value. Personal responsibility is central. You hear phrases like, be yourself, take control, the future is in your hands. So naturally, people from these cultures lean toward believing in strong free will, right? Because the entire social structure is built on the idea that individuals choose. Success and failure become personal. Responsibility becomes internal. Freedom becomes an identity for them. And that's one of the reasons Western philosophy produced thinkers obsessed with the free will, like uh Immanuel Kant, Jean-Paul Sartre, Daniel Dennett, William James, and so on.

SPEAKER_00Now, contrast that with many Eastern, Middle Eastern, African, or even Latin American cultures where the group matters more than the individual. Family expectations shape your decisions. Elders guide your younger generations, generally, right? Harmony is valued over personal preference. Duty is often more important than desire. Here, the self isn't imagined as an isolated island. It's imagined as part of a larger organism, a family, a tribe, a community. You hear things like, think of your family.

SPEAKER_00Don't break the harmony. What will people say? You know? In these cultures, the idea of complete individual free will feels unrealistic, even immature sometimes. Not because people don't believe in choice, but because choice is negotiated with social reality. Responsibility becomes shared. Identity becomes relational. Freedom becomes contextual. And suddenly determinism doesn't feel threatening here, right? It feels even familiar. A Western person might feel, I chose this because it's what I want.

SPEAKER_00A collectivist person might feel, I chose this because it's right within my community. Same decision, different meaning. Just different psychological experience of freedom. Culture teaches you what a good choice looks like. Culture teaches you what control feels like. Culture teaches you whether free will is a personal project or a relational one. And this is why debates about free will often sound like people talking past each other, you know. They are not disagreeing about neuroscience, but they are disagreeing about the story they grew up inside.

SPEAKER_00I know it's a lot, but when you step back, you realize one thing. You are not choosing alone. You never have. Your culture is choosing with you, your environment is choosing with you, your upper gringing is choosing with you, your social expectations are choosing with you. And by the way, none of this kills free will. It just shows how human it is, how connected, how cultural, how emotional, how inherited. Free will isn't a switch. It's a feeling, as I mentioned earlier. And that feeling is shaped by the world you were born into.

SPEAKER_00Now that we've explored culture and the environment, we can move into one of the most intriguing parts of this episode. How AI challenges our understanding of free will, and whether machines decide in ways that expose the illusion in ourselves. So let's talk about AI. Because whether we like it or not, AI forces us to confront something uncomfortable about free will. How similar we actually are to the systems we claim are just algorithms. How how similar are we?

SPEAKER_00Machines don't have free will, right? Okay, but look closer. When people say AI doesn't choose, it just follows instructions, you can almost hear a quiet question hidden underneath. And how different are we, really? Because think about this really. AI makes predictions based on its training data, right? We make decisions based on our past experiences. AI adjusts itself according to patterns. We respond according to habits. AI has biases built into its dataset.

SPEAKER_00We have biases built into our upbringing. AI reacts to inputs and conditions. We react to context, hormones, memories, environment. At some point, the line between algorithmic decision and human decision gets blurry. And that's the part that makes people uncomfortable most of the time. You know those moments when Spotify recommends a song and you think, oh wait, I actually like this. Or Netflix suggests something and you end up watching it without thinking twice.

SPEAKER_00Or your phone shows you a video that somehow aligns with your mood. This isn't about manipulation, it's about something more subtle. AI learns you through your patterns. Your patterns are learnable, right? And when a machine can predict your future choices better than you can, it forces you to ask if a pattern can predict me, how free am I inside that pattern? AI doesn't steal your free will, no it doesn't. It just reveals how much of your will is shared by habit.

SPEAKER_00The uncomfortable part about this is AI systems show us how predictable we are, how influenzable we are, how much our choices follow prior causes, how easily context nudges behavior, how rarely we choose from a blank state. When an algorithm can tell you what you will buy and what you will watch and even who you might date, doesn't mean you are controlled. It means you are not as random as you think, and that pushes the free will debate into a new arena. If machines can model human behavior, maybe the human mind isn't magical, maybe it's just extremely complex.

SPEAKER_00Robert Sapolski loves this point, but Daniel Dennett pushes back. And somewhere between them is the real human experience. We are predictable, but not programmable. We are influenced, yes, but not controlled. We are shaped, but not raised. Even if AI highlights the algorithmic parts of us, there is still something beautifully human remaining. Our ability to reflect, to pause, to question, to resist a pattern, to rewrite a narrative, to grow. AI can reveal your tendencies, right?

SPEAKER_00But it can't live your life for you. You can step outside a loop. You can change your environment, you can choose a new meaning. And that capacity, not absolute freedom, is where our humanity actually shines. Now that we have seen how AI mirrors our patterns back to us, there's one last major layer before we move into the conclusion. Bayesian thinking. How our mind constantly updates beliefs based on prior experiences and new evidence, and how that process quietly shapes what we call free will.

SPEAKER_00Before we wrap up this episode, there's one last piece of the puzzle we need to touch on. And it's actually one of the most elegant ways to understand how the mind works. Bayesian thinking. The core idea is this. Your brain is always updating itself, quietly, automatically, moment by moment. It's constantly asking two questions. What did I expect to happen, your prior, and what actually happened, the new evidence? And then it blends both together to form an updated belief, a posterior.

SPEAKER_00You don't do this consciously, no. Your mind does it beneath the surface all the time. Imagine you are deciding whether to trust someone, okay? Your brain doesn't start from zero. It uses your priors, past relationships, childhood patterns, culture expectations, your attachment style, small emotional memories you forget you had. Then it mixes in what's happening now, their tone, their behavior, today's situation. That's the new evidence. And before you even consciously decide, your mind has already formed a prediction.

SPEAKER_00This is safe, this is dangerous, this person is reliable, this feels familiar, your decision is often your brain's prediction. This is where it gets really fascinating, actually. You don't choose your priors, you inherit them from your environment, your childhood, your trauma, your culture, your memories. You also don't choose the evidence you encounter. Life presents them to you. So when those two combine inside your mind and shape your beliefs, preferences, fears, and desires, how free is the choice that comes after?

SPEAKER_00Here's the beautiful part. Bayesian updating means you are not stuck. Your beliefs can evolve, your priors can be rewritten, your predictions can change. Every new experience becomes a chance to expand your prior self. That's the soft, realistic version of free will. Not total independence, but the ability to update. Your freedom grows as your priors expand. Bayesian thinking explains why some people repeat cycles, some people break them, some people fear what others find normal, some people trust what others avoid.

SPEAKER_00Some people heal when the right evidence enters their life. All this means one thing. Your mind isn't fixed. It's learning, updating, recalibrating. And maybe that's the closest thing we have to real agency. Not the power to choose anything, but the power to grow into someone who can choose differently. So here we are at the end of this journey through the mind. Biology, culture, philosophy, psychology, AI, patterns, prediction, everything.

SPEAKER_00And the question that started all of this still sits quietly in the center. Do we have free will? But after everything we've explored today, you'll probably feel what I feel. It's not a question with a clean answer, as always. And maybe it was never meant to have that one. Maybe freedom isn't absolute. Maybe it's gradual. Maybe we are not fully free, yes, but maybe we are not also fully determined either. Maybe we live somewhere in the middle also, in that human space where biology pushes, culture shapes, habits, guides, but consciousness still opens a small door.

SPEAKER_00A space where you can pause, where you can reflect, where you can update, where you can grow. Maybe that tiny space, not huge, not perfect, but real, is where our humanity lives. Not in total freedom, but in the ability to make meaning within the conditions we were given. You don't choose everything, but you can choose something. You didn't choose your genetics, you didn't choose your childhood, you didn't choose your culture, your past, your timing, your hormones, your traumas. But you can choose how you interpret your past, the environments you place yourself in, the stories you attach to your identity generally, the patterns you challenge, the narratives you stop feeding, the beliefs you update, the meaning you give to your experiences.

SPEAKER_00These choices aren't free from causes, but they still matter. They still shape who you become. Your agency isn't infinite, but it's not zero either. So if there is something this entire episode shows us, it's this probably. You are both the product of everything that came before you and the beginning of everything that comes after you. You are shaped by causes you never chose, but you also become a cause for things that haven't happened yet, right?

SPEAKER_00Your decisions ripple, your growth changes the world around you. Your updates reshape someone else's priors. Your healing becomes someone else's evidence that change is possible. That's not perfect freedom, you know, it's not perfect freedom at all, but it's not determinism either. It's something human, something real, really, something meaningful. We promised at the start that this episode isn't here to preach or to convert someone or even claim to have answers for the question. So here's where we leave it.

SPEAKER_00Do we have free will? Maybe yes, maybe no, maybe something in between, but the truth is your answer. Your answer says more about your view of life than about the question itself, right? And that quiet moment of reflection might be the freest thing we do. I'm Mohammed, and this was Beyond the Surface Podcast. Thanks for listening, stay crazy, and see you next episode.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why can't we focus anymore ?

    Oct 17, 202615 minAudio

    For Feedbacks Where Did Our Attention Go? In a world that constantly competes for our attention, what does it really mean to pay attention? From endless scrolling and digital distractions to the difficulty of being...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Relationships: Communication, Commitment and Connection | With Dr. Chris Grace

    Jul 27, 202652 minAudio

    For Feedbacks Modern dating culture constantly sells us the myth of "the one" the idea that finding a perfect soulmate requires no effort, and that instant chemistry is the ultimate green flag. But what happens when the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. More than just words | ft. Sena & Koray

    Jul 6, 202636 minAudio

    For Feedbacks Language is more than vocabulary and grammar... It shapes the way we think, connect, remember, and understand the world around us. In this episode, I'm joined by Sena, a French Literature graduate who...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Beyond The Norms | ft. Professor Ferit Güven

    Jun 17, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    For Feedbacks What does it mean to feel at home? In this episode of Beyond The Surface, I sit down with Professor Ferit Güven for a conversation about belonging, identity, memory, and the places that shape us. Together,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Why Young Men Are Falling Behind ?

    Mar 16, 202627 minAudio

    For Feedbacks A growing number of young men feel lost, isolated, and without direction. But why is this happening? In this episode, we explore the silent crisis of young men; examining the psychological, social, and...

    Credit the people on this episode