For Feedbacks What does it mean to feel at home? In this episode of Beyond The Surface, I sit down with Professor Ferit Güven for a conversation about belonging, identity, memory, and the places that shape us. Together, we explore questions that many of us carry throughout our lives: Is home a place or a feeling? Can someone have more than one home? What happens when you no longer feel at home where you once belonged? And in an increasingly connected world, has the meaning of home changed? Drawing from philosophy, personal experience, and reflections on culture, this conversation goes beyond geography and explores one of the most fundamental human questions. If you enjoyed this episode, don’t forget to give us a 5-star review and follow Beyond The Surface for more deep and thought-provoking conversations. Your support helps us grow and bring you even better content 😊 I'd love to hear what you think; feel free to reach out at (muhamoet4@gmail.com)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello everyone and welcome back to another beautiful episode from Beyond the Surface podcast. And today, as usual, we have Professor Ferriad Kiban. Welcome back.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_00It's always nice to have you back.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_00And today we're going to talk about continental philosophy and its effect on language, linguistics, in overall, and many other aspects. So stay tuned and let's get going. Welcome, Professor.
SPEAKER_01It's very nice. I always enjoy the nice weather and yeah, this time of the year.
SPEAKER_00It's always nice to have you back. As I mentioned. So, first of all, uh, could you please tell us more about yourself? Uh, what kind of um majors? What what did you do? Like what do you study and what do you do at the moment?
SPEAKER_01Okay, so reintroduction from our last podcast. I graduated from Boazichi uh in 1992, and I went to the United States to get my PhD at DePaul University, and then um I got um a job at Erlham College in Indiana, and I've been working there for the last 27 years.
SPEAKER_00Very nice, very nice.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And um you're back finally in Istanbul. I think you come every summer to Istanbul.
SPEAKER_01I come every summer, uh, but I'm going to finally return to Istanbul as a part of my retirement next year. Oh, really? Yes.
SPEAKER_00Such a nice plan.
SPEAKER_01Next year, yes.
SPEAKER_00Sounds very um patriotic, I would say. It's
SPEAKER_01just coming home. Uh
SPEAKER_00it's
SPEAKER_01more like my inability to live in the United States anymore. So it's more like coming home. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Mentioning home, what's what's even like home for you, really?
SPEAKER_01Well, okay. So it's
SPEAKER_00like a place, a feeling, uh, a person.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's really the the main thing is human relations. Honestly, like the not that I know so many people anymore in Istanbul, but it's just like the familiarity that I walk differently here, I talk differently, I feel differently. I sometimes tell people like I always feel some kind of under existential threat in the United States. Um, I feel more relaxed and more, I mean, just feeling of at home.
SPEAKER_01Not that I agree with everything, not that I, you know, have everything. Yeah, so not that I accept everything, not that people accept me. It's just like sort of going back to your past. I mean, we are in a neighborhood where I grew up. So
SPEAKER_00yeah, I grew up in in Shishli, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, in around Nishantashi, yeah. So it's just that feeling, and I came here this time with my daughters and showing them where I grew up in a way that they never knew before. So
SPEAKER_00have been reacting to it.
SPEAKER_01They are very much into my older daughter, is not
SPEAKER_00like surprised or like uh I don't know, admired by the place, or are they like really enjoying their time here?
SPEAKER_01Yes, they are, and my older daughter is learning Turkish. Well, they don't really feel that they connect to my roots more like, but uh she wants to learn Turkish, she is learning Turkish, and she finally got into a um, I mean not finally, recently got into a graduate program in creative writing. So she wants to come to Turkey and write, which is
SPEAKER_00for me, like
SPEAKER_01yeah. And so that that has been really good. Um
SPEAKER_00how does it make it like make you feel, you know, this that your daughter is like really wants to connect with her roots and wants to come back home and uh do something for her country, you know, her homeland, I would say.
SPEAKER_01Um, I mean, of course, emotionally it's very nice, but also that she is interested in sort of cultural difference and uh having a different kind of part of her heritage from Turkey and connecting that into her writing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that'll be
SPEAKER_01really interesting.
SPEAKER_00I would say because it's not that easy in my experience.
SPEAKER_01Well, we'll see. She is she got into this creative writing program, and then she she needs to do some translation from Turkish to English, but she all I mean it's a three-year program. So, anyway, so we came with her, and then we are sort of walking around, visiting museums, going to bookstores. It's yeah, that's a lot of fun. And the other one is studying philosophy, which is our topic today. Uh uh, she's not uh she's not doing continental philosophy, but she's doing sort of history, and um, yeah, my even though I uh got my PhD in the United States, it was a continental philosophy department, which as you probably know, there are two main traditions in philosophy: continental and analytic.
SPEAKER_01And even though I um got my initial undergraduate education in analytic philosophy, my graduate education was in continentals. Do
SPEAKER_00you like feel that continental philosophy represents the the majority of people? Like, because when you when you talk about continental philosophy, we we mainly talk about Europe, right? It's focused on Europe.
SPEAKER_01Europe, yes,
SPEAKER_00right? So how does that like really affect or even I don't know, uh make sense of other cultures as well? Because it sounds very specific, you know, in a way.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's different here in Turkey. There's a lot of analytic departments here too, like Waziji, for example. Um, but in the United States, 90, 95% of philosophy departments are analytic. So continental philosophy is really a minority, it's a very uh few departments. The one I went to, a few more, and then less and less now with all the fundings, etc. But in Europe, ironically, even European philosophy is not more popular than analytic philosophy.
SPEAKER_01So, and when I say European philosophy, we are talking about a tradition that pretty much comes uh together until Kant, and then it separates in continental tradition into Hegel and you know, Fichte Hegel, Heidegger, Sartre, and French Derrida, etc. The analytic tradition after Kant more like turns to Frege and then Wittgenstein, early Wittgenstein, Vienna Circle, and that kind of like branches out into different epistemology, philosophy of mind, philosophy of language.
SPEAKER_01So it's a quite recent, I mean, recent in the history of philosophy, recent, but it's like a more than 100 years sort of separation. But even in Europe, there is a strong analytic tradition. And in terms of the representation of philosophy, when people say it's more like at the university level, it's very academic, etc., people are really talking about analytic philosophy because continental philosophy tries at least as much as possible, as much as language allows it to engage with everyday life.
SPEAKER_00What do you mean as language?
SPEAKER_01Well, philosophical language is difficult and it's not like an everyday language. I mean, I sometimes use terms everybody does, that people
SPEAKER_00would understand, but
SPEAKER_01but not I mean it's not like they don't, but it's not their common vocabulary. But we are trying to understand everyday life, yeah, issues that matter to people in a language that is sometimes theoretical, conceptual, and that's why it sort of seems to be divorced from life. But to me, contental philosophy is really that tradition of understanding life, existence in terms of philosophical language. Analytic is more technical, it's more logical, more
SPEAKER_00math involved, I would say.
SPEAKER_01But nowadays, in like cognitive science and sort of epistemology, even the epistemology is sort of different than what happens in the continental tradition. So I always was interested in the continental tradition, and I wrote my dissertation on various figures in the continental tradition in Hegel, Hardiger, Foucault, and Derrida. And the theme was madness and death, and they all have very specific takes on that. Now, of course, when you say madness and death, that also sort of sounds like uh, you know, but
SPEAKER_00there's like a hidden layer there, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. So, like, what do we consider to be like proper psychologically acceptable, etc.? And then death is always, I mean, I don't know what else in life is important, yes. So um that's what I studied. Uh
SPEAKER_00think about death.
SPEAKER_01Do I think about death? Um, well
SPEAKER_00in the term of like philosophy or like the I mean, you did your PhD probably on that specifically, but on that thing. General, general
SPEAKER_01well, I don't know whether any more than any other average person, but it's one thing to think about death, and usually your response is that like I'm too busy to deal with that in life. But to me, the interesting question is like not to think about death, but having the awareness of mortality, how does that shape your life? That to me is the more interesting question about that. Like, what difference does it make? Balance, I don't know, but affect your life.
SPEAKER_01Somehow, you know, sometimes I wake up and it's like, okay, I'm awake alive today, etc. And then sometimes it gives this like nice amount of sort of fatalism. It's like, whatever, this is life, it's not that important. But a lot of sort of capitalist psychological issues, it is a kind of re-centering thought if you think about that. And after COVID, this has been very popular in various circles in terms of like the re-emergence of stoicism and various
SPEAKER_00very popular nowadays. Yes, I can't. I didn't even I did an episode actually uh last year, I guess. It was on stoicism, and because everyone around me in the campus, like our my friends, like, hey, I'm becoming a stoic. Hey, I like Epithetus, hey, I like Michael Sorrelius. Did you read meditation? Like,
SPEAKER_01yeah,
SPEAKER_00why it's really common like these days? I mean, why it's so popular, really, especially among young people, young generation.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that there is a certain response to the life of living under capitalism to me, like this kind of constant anxiety, constant worrying about the future, but also like whatever historical significance COVID had in terms of how people imagine their lives and how like well-laid out plans may turn out to be not so certain.
SPEAKER_00Did the pandemic really shift our mindset to the worse or like to the better? You think, like personally?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, that's really hard to say. To me, what maybe didn't happen that I wish it happened was to recognize our interdependence. So during COVID, certain people's work appeared to be much more pronounced and important, and how we really dependent on certain people that we don't really see as much in society. So I was hoping that it would bring some kind of a sort of wave of solidarity, wave of sort of socialist thinking as a kind of society togetherness, etc.
SPEAKER_01That obviously didn't happen as much as I imagined because our capitalist structures are very powerful. So we went as much
SPEAKER_00as you hoped or you imagined?
SPEAKER_01I hope I hoped. Yeah, I don't think it I imagined it. I mean, imagine is that's complicated. I I hope very
SPEAKER_00much
SPEAKER_01hope is sort of like you know it's not gonna happen, but you hope it anyway. So
SPEAKER_00yeah,
SPEAKER_01yeah. But I did recognize that certain people sort of changed their lifestyles, way of, but it was more like everything else in societies as a sort of expiration date. It's a fashion, it's a fad, and it disappears. So it's really hard to stick with something that's no longer getting, you know, like hashtags and like likes.
SPEAKER_00Vanished over time.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. I think with stoicism anytime. So that's really the But the
SPEAKER_00interesting thing is uh stoicism like it's still going, you know, it's it's really going, like still it keeps its momentum, I would say, until this day.
SPEAKER_01That's good. I mean, I live in the United States, it's different, like people's relationship to intellectual life and uh everything is you
SPEAKER_00do like see curiosity.
SPEAKER_01The what
SPEAKER_00curiosity do you feel like do you see curiosity in young people's minds?
SPEAKER_01I think okay, so I I'll sound like an old person, which is fine. Uh I think yeah. Which
SPEAKER_00you're not, by the way.
SPEAKER_01That's fine. I mean, I I take certain pride in that now. I think people are very concerned about well, they are so overwhelmingly concerned about their future, they don't even care anymore.
SPEAKER_00Was it the same for you when you were young?
SPEAKER_01Um, well, of course, like there was a sort of generation of people trying to get jobs, struggling, etc. To me personally, I was like, I'm gonna study philosophy, whatever happens. I don't care. Was it
SPEAKER_00like really common to just sit with your friends and just talk about future and worry about what you're gonna do? And like you
SPEAKER_01I don't think I mean I
SPEAKER_00having a stable job, also.
SPEAKER_01I don't really
SPEAKER_00concerned you at the time.
SPEAKER_01I don't remember. I honestly don't. I just like I remember talking to friends about you know whatever we were discussing in class at the time, etc. at the university, especially. But I don't really remember, like sort of so concerned about being future. Not that I came from a good family, I mean, like rich family or something. It's just like it was different. Like, this is what I'm gonna do in life, not shaped in terms of whether this will buy me a house or a car, etc. That's what I'm gonna do.
SPEAKER_01That's what I love.
SPEAKER_00Honestly, like back at your days, uh, community, community feelings, like I mean, feeling belong, like to the to the public, to the to the family, was way much stronger than now. Because right now, all you see is individuality, you know, everywhere. I think that really affects how we view this.
SPEAKER_01I think maybe we are partially responsible for that because my generation is sort of responding to that sort of family pressure, etc., and the societal pressure. We sort of valued individuality, independence, etc. Uh, so we kind of created this sort of environment, but also because of the way in which human economic life is organized. So that if you go where the job is, you know, where you can make a living, and then once you start your job, it's like takes over your entire life, then you really don't have time for your friends or any kind of social life, whatever you socialize, it's true job.
SPEAKER_01So I don't know. That's
SPEAKER_00can we say that young people right now are more aware of things? Because they see a lot, you know.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I feel awkward to say that. I mean, I don't know. I don't know young people. I mean, sometimes when my daughter speaks
SPEAKER_00speaking of like your your children.
SPEAKER_01Well, they the only thing that they do that I know is different than other people is they read. And then that's the only thing that to me is sort of the test. Is too
SPEAKER_00satisfied, yes,
SPEAKER_01as a
SPEAKER_00parent.
SPEAKER_01Yes, in many, they read more than I do, honestly. Like uh that I don't know how that develops in an individual, it becomes a need, it becomes a habit, etc. That I don't observe. Like, I don't even get people. It's even
SPEAKER_00like a family culture. If they didn't see you and they're probably their their mother reading all the time while where they were like growing up, they wouldn't probably like uh pick it up and just do it, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I hope so. I mean I yes, I think
SPEAKER_00so.
SPEAKER_01But uh that's like
SPEAKER_00a very exceptional, like a very it doesn't really represent the the public in overall, because you know, when you say that, okay, my like my children read and I'm satisfied with that what they're doing, and that's really amazing, you know. But when you think about other families, like for example, my parents weren't like uh weren't in academy, you know. So they didn't read much, honestly. Like I never like saw my dad reading anything, you know, until this day. Well my mom does, but it really affects how you even enrich the family root and also habits overall.
SPEAKER_01But like my parents, my mother, my father died when I was JDR. But my mother didn't read that much either. But you don't really need to read yourself as much or show it to your children in order to sort of make them feel that it's important to read.
SPEAKER_00But
SPEAKER_01so that's a different
SPEAKER_00thing. You don't have to, but maybe when you impose it, when you
SPEAKER_01Well, if you value it, if you value reading, even if you don't always read and show them examples of reading yourself, if you value it and if they understand that, that to me is like because not every family is like academic or like readers, etc. But you still in my generation there was value of reading, value of being an educated person, value of being not smart, but thoughtful, sort of like you know, kind of having good relations with people and being able to be social and be able to talk, be able to engage with people.
SPEAKER_00In a way, maybe
SPEAKER_01well it's a deeper than etiquette, it's sort of more kind of like being human. That was Val education. Like here
SPEAKER_00maybe I would say being real, being authentic.
SPEAKER_01You said it, I agree, yes. And now it feels like we are creating jobs that for people, yeah. Okay, so we were talking about what the status of education was. I mean, part of it is like what happened uh in Western education. I don't really know uh much about other parts of the world. Western education is kind of creating individuals to perform certain functions.
SPEAKER_01So education sort of initially maybe thought as
SPEAKER_00a label, I would say, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Job, label, sort of and then it's ticket
SPEAKER_00maybe
SPEAKER_01yeah, definitely a yeah, ticket a sort of like job or whatever, career. Uh it was always privilege of the few to sort of think of education as a kind of self-discovery, etc. But there's a growing discourse about like learning yourself through learning the forces that created you. I think that's part of the education. And obviously, language to me is the most important aspect of this because you are born into a language, you're born into what someone like Lacan would call a symbolic order.
SPEAKER_01Namely, there are certain rules, uh rules of language, rules of symbolic behavior in society, etc., that you learn as a subject, as an individual.
SPEAKER_00And you perform also over time.
SPEAKER_01You start performing it, you speak a language that you know by imitation mostly, and then try to figure out like how to express your desires, if you have any desires, and then you form your desires.
SPEAKER_00Behaviorism is also a thing here, I would say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, how to how to become an individual of sorts. So that that to me became this sort of main focus. Now, if we sort of approach this philosophically from a continental perspective, there are two schools of general, okay, two not schools of thought, but two tendencies within continental philosophy. One commun uh language uh conceptualized through communication. I have something to say, I'm saying it to you, it's a communication. That kind of uh structures language from the perspective of consciousness, like I have something to say and I'm saying it, etc.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and that tradition leads all the way from probably Rousseau to um more sort of existential tradition, like you create meaning, you create your the meaning of your life, which is a very problematic and complicated idea because we as individuals do not really have the same kind of power that we think we do. So this is a tradition that starts with Descartes giving the sort of uh primacy to the individual, individual consciousness.
SPEAKER_01There's also in the more like the turn of the 20th century, the sort of what is generally called the structuralism, which in linguistics starts with Ferdinand de Saussure, who sort of understands this in terms of the relationship between the signifier and the signifier and the sign, and generally sort of um the linguistic I think that's actually the title of his book, General Linguistics. That's the title of it. There, the main idea is which is very interesting, which is obvious, but it's kind of interesting to think about the relationship between the signifier and the signifier.
SPEAKER_01And signifier is basically the material aspect of the science. When I say a word, it makes a sound. When I write it on a piece of paper, it has certain letters, right?
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_01So this is semiotics, right? And the signified is what it's supposed to mean. Uh sort of I say like table, table is signifiers, sounds like T A B. B L E and then it's this flat surface on which you do certain things, eat, write, whatever. Now that connection
SPEAKER_00There's like a context in there involved.
SPEAKER_01Context tries to give us the impression that the connection between the signifier and the signified is necessary, but it's not. So Sassur's insight is the fact that this relationship is arbitrary. What's that mean? We could just as well call this object, which I'm pointing out to a table, chair or cloud.
SPEAKER_00Who decides? You know, that's the question. Who decides?
SPEAKER_01Well, that's the thing, it's completely arbitrary, it's sort of like a convention. So the problem then is like, well, since nobody decided, I mean, I don't know whether anybody finds a point in history that's like, oh, let's, you know, have a meeting and then decide to call this a table or something, it didn't happen. So it is a convention. And what he calls convention is the idea of arbitrariness, in which case, then language becomes some kind of infinite loop in which it takes you from one signifier to another without ever getting to an ultimate meaning.
SPEAKER_01So when I teach this in class, I say, like, we arbitrarily stop the signifying chain. What does that mean? For example, I say, like, what is love?
SPEAKER_00Woo.
SPEAKER_01And then you say maybe a feeling. Then I say,
SPEAKER_00What's a feeling?
SPEAKER_01What's a feeling? And then you say like something that and then go on, and now at some point, you sort of keep that entire thing. Well, you either hit the fall or you accept it. So, like, okay, I got it. So, when you learn a foreign language, that's for example, is a very sort of significant aspect. So, if you don't know a word, you just try to search the word that you mean so that you get a grasp of the whole signifying change. My favorite example when I was learning uh English was the term virtue.
SPEAKER_00Virtue.
SPEAKER_01Virtue. What is virtue?
SPEAKER_00I first heard it from Aristotle, I believe, while I was really philosophy, and then it just blows my mind, you know.
SPEAKER_01But even the word uh in Turkish, it's Adam. It's like I don't even know the Turkish one. Like, what is Adam?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we know it, but what does it really mean, you know?
SPEAKER_01And then you say, like uh quality or excellence or
SPEAKER_00the whole book on that only.
SPEAKER_01So then they say, like, oh, you are too philosophical, you are questioning everything. I'm not. If you know it, you tell me. No, you tell me if you know it. So what we do is to kind of pretend when I say, like, oh, you are a virtuous person, you say thank you. That's very nice. We we sort of act as if we understand what that
SPEAKER_00is.
SPEAKER_01No
SPEAKER_00one no one really digs beyond the known, you know.
SPEAKER_01Well, exactly. I mean, and even like if you keep digging, then you create a loop, and that's sort of what he calls the signifying chain, Lacanda, which really fascinates me because he defines the subject as one signifier signifies to the other one. It's really this movement.
SPEAKER_00They're all connected somehow. Exactly. So,
SPEAKER_01and then then you search for the meaning of your life. So, in the continental tradition that I was talking about earlier, there is this sort of like you create the meaning of your life, you create some kind of a narrative about your life. What you are really doing is that moving with the signifying chain from one to another and trying to create a loop. That that's really what is happening. Like, I got to this point. But then whenever you tell about your life, there's also
SPEAKER_00is there like a destination for that?
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Then you was like, so what? My life is over? Like, what am I supposed to do? Oh,
SPEAKER_00just keep looking and uh there's nothing to find.
SPEAKER_01But I mean, that's the expectation that there is one thing, and that one thing is really where you stop, honestly. Like at that point, I stopped. Like, if you are satisfied, like I got there, I wanted to go, and I'm here. This is the meaning of my life, and people make a big deal out of this. I always wanted to be a philosophy professor or whatever. I wanted to be a father, I wanted to be this and that.
SPEAKER_00I was born like this. I was born as a philosopher, you know. They all go like this.
SPEAKER_01That's a song. Yeah, that's I was born, I was born as a philosophy. You
SPEAKER_00know, that's why I mentioned it.
SPEAKER_01I was born to be like that, but that's really something that we create retroactively in terms of everything that happens. So, but Lakan said, which really fascinates me, is that imagine everything in your life happens by chance. Yet we always think of
SPEAKER_00Total randomness.
SPEAKER_01Randomness, yes. And now we sort of say, how is that even possible? Because what I did before caused what I did later. Otherwise, I cannot even think about that.
SPEAKER_00Actually, it drinks a bell for me, you know, because this morning before recording and even having you at my place here today, I was wondering how I like I even really met you, you know. I mean, like, you know, attending an event and then we met there, then we had a small like, you know, chat, and then after that we contact each other or through email, and then we did a whole episode also online, and now we're like in person having another discussion on philosophy. It really fascinates me how we just meet and interact and just keep doing it the whole time, you know.
SPEAKER_00It's just like a small example.
SPEAKER_01But isn't that everything in your life?
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. I like I you work for something, you have a purpose, you have an aim, and then you say, like, everything that I did led to that. So you probably like you worked for the university entrance examination, you sort of like put yourself some goals and then like desires, etc. And you get there, and then you realize like there has to be a connection between the whatever happened before to what happened. Now, but there are lots of people,
SPEAKER_00but there's free will involved.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, we can't I'm
SPEAKER_00not asking if you believe it or not, I'm just asking if it's really involved.
SPEAKER_01Well, free will is like sometimes we misuse that term. It's not like doing something that the conditions do not allow you to do. You still do the things that conditions allow you to do. It's just that also doing
SPEAKER_00the unusual is a thing.
SPEAKER_01Well, unusual according to whom? I mean, according to society,
SPEAKER_00societal norms, societal expectations.
SPEAKER_01But isn't that like a trend now? Everybody like
SPEAKER_00try to be different, start to be unique in a way, but
SPEAKER_01yeah, think outside of the box, be yourself, very popular
SPEAKER_00lately.
SPEAKER_01So, even that is a sort of conventional discourse that you learn. So, why do I want to be an individual? Not because there is some force inside me, but there's a discourse that values individuality and uniqueness and difference, etc. And then in certain contexts, it doesn't. So, and then a lot of people try to do that, not everybody does it or can accomplish it because their conditions don't allow it, so that something happens. I don't know, like they I don't know, they have children, they will go like
SPEAKER_00the American dream. I moved to the US and I made it, I gained a lot of money and I earned it, I worked so hard, blah, blah, blah. But
SPEAKER_01which is the narrative that we love, except for every American success story, there are 100,000 failures.
SPEAKER_00Failures, but we never mentioned them. That's
SPEAKER_01exactly so, yeah. So that's why that's the kind of um structure that interests me, but not structure in the sense of determining who you are, but at least sort of defining the limits of your possibilities and your free will for that matter. So yeah,
SPEAKER_00so there is a limit, you believe.
SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely. I mean, historical limits, economic limits, um, linguistic limits. You know, if you are born into a language that you cannot sort of use in your whatever your aim is, like for me, like I want to be a philosopher, I want to study philosophy, but I need to first learn a foreign language and do it at that, and then yeah, and it's not like oh, this is disadvantaged, this is more difficult, etc. It's reality, it's what it is. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00it's always possible, but life is like full with exceptions as well, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and what we do is actually concentrate on exceptions because those are the good stories.
SPEAKER_00They are. I
SPEAKER_01mean, nobody wants to the story of like 600 NBA players who didn't make it, but they want to LeBron James because he's the greatest story. So that's the kind of uh psychological or even psychoanalytic unconscious uh messages that we are getting, and we learn certain narrative structures and stick to those narrative structures, and and then evaluate ourselves in terms of those two. So
SPEAKER_00but who really defines these narratives?
SPEAKER_01That's the question of Are
SPEAKER_00they like defined by society, family, friend? A friend could be
SPEAKER_01well Lacan's answer, which is not very satisfying, but it's more like it comes from the unconscious, it comes from the signifying change, nobody controls it. It is not something that Oh,
SPEAKER_00I love it. Now we're digging into Freud's psychology in a way.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, obviously Lacan relies on um actually Lacan finds Freud is even more sort of individual, like thinking about psychoanalysis as something to healing and making a whole individual, etc. But for Lacan, it's more like an existential condition of human existence in terms of relationships. And that's really the key that we don't think enough, relationships. Like what I am is not some substance, some subject isolated from others, but it is the
SPEAKER_00it's a runaway, you know. They always say they we usually like lay it on the third person, you know. For example, it's not you, it's your mother, it's not you, it's your it's your friend's circle, it's not you, it's like the country you're born into. I mean
SPEAKER_01most of it is true though, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but can we really change it?
SPEAKER_01Well, we don't not only well, I don't know how much. Well, for me
SPEAKER_00personally, I don't like to just to you know uh brag about something or even like you know, victimize myself in a way.
SPEAKER_01Yes,
SPEAKER_00it doesn't really sound authentic to me, honestly.
SPEAKER_01To attribute to other people,
SPEAKER_00exactly, yeah.
SPEAKER_01But what Lacan says is that we actually take responsibility for things we are not responsible for.
SPEAKER_00Can you say that one more time?
SPEAKER_01We take responsibility, that's what it means to become a subject. You take responsibility for things that you are not even responsible for. You say it, it's like yes, your mother did it to you, but you say, Yes, my mother might have done to me, but now it's me. Now it's
SPEAKER_00now it's your responsibility.
SPEAKER_01It's
SPEAKER_00I I believe uh Paul Sadre also says something uh familiar. We are can condemned to be free, I guess, and to be responsible. Some others also translate it that way.
SPEAKER_01That depends on sort of how you read Sarch, because such sounds to like if you read him deeply, maybe it's not as much as like that, but like it's he sounds like you create your conditions, you create your destiny, you make decisions.
SPEAKER_00Very American of him, huh?
SPEAKER_01That's why he was very popular. Existentialism is very popular in the United States. Uh, I mean, of course, that's a misreading of Sartre. He's not that sort of straightforward, but that is the tension. Like, how much of it is your own sort of doing and choices, and how much of it is conditions, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So, language, how does it really affect our perception?
SPEAKER_01Perception of the world, perception of ourselves,
SPEAKER_00ourselves, I would say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, that that's a very I mean, that's very complicated to me. I mean,
SPEAKER_00you just mentioned before, uh, recording the episode, that really Turkish as a language didn't really allow you to do philosophy as much as you hoped in the past, right? Because it had limits.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So does really knowing a certain language limit our perception?
SPEAKER_01Uh
SPEAKER_00or perspective in a way,
SPEAKER_01or ability,
SPEAKER_00or ability as well.
SPEAKER_01I now yes, but I don't think that's kind of necessary because there's a sort of European tradition of re-repeating, reiterating a certain European thought. So it's produced in English. Like the reality is that I mean I read it somewhere, I don't want to like exaggerate, like, some 90 plus percent of all scholarly articles in the world is published in English.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Uh, I mean, you can look that up through AI or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Similar thing, that's true.
SPEAKER_01So that's overwhelming. Like, that's like if I'm shut out of 90% of knowledge or sort of whatever the scholarship produces
SPEAKER_00any door to just know a certain one specific language, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and not knowing that shuts you off from that. And that's
SPEAKER_00blocks you from all the articles you just mentioned.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. So that's why it's a reality, but if there is a politics behind it, there's a economics behind it, there is a history behind it. We live in a colonial world, neocolonial structures, as you know nowadays, it's even more obvious than before.
SPEAKER_00Way too much.
SPEAKER_01Yes, a little too much, yes. So that that fascinates me because those are the kinds of forces. Foucault says somewhere when he's talking about I understand that human beings cannot accept that their consciousness is determined by stories that took place hundred years ago. Uh, he's a historian, like generally,
SPEAKER_00but
SPEAKER_01he's a sort of intellectual history, but also uh to me is like power structure, like how power structures function and discourse, and he has this archaeology, etc. I mean, we don't have to get into Foucault, it's just that idea of how my understanding of myself today and the tools that I have for that is determined 200, 500 years ago. So then I when I look at myself, I sort of like use concepts to describe
SPEAKER_00we inherent them, right?
SPEAKER_01But that's I mean, I learned that it's English. I'm not even using the Turkish ones, I'm using the English ones, and I try to give examples to my students and explain it. So it's kind of this exteriority of language, it's something outside of you which you internalize. You make it Is there
SPEAKER_00like a certain area where English or any other language blocks you from teaching? Because you're in academy, so
SPEAKER_01certainly, yes, and that's what I'm struggling with. So I'm sort of I've been teaching over 30 years now in the United States, it's always in English. Now that I mean I feel embarrassed when I try to explain certain things in Turkish, I sort of struggle. And
SPEAKER_00because you feel like incapable or
SPEAKER_01well, partially definitely incapable, but also the concepts are not the same. So when I
SPEAKER_00it's different, right?
SPEAKER_01And it's not something we use everyday life. Like it's not something that philosophical concepts that is at ordinary language. This is the best example is Heidegger. People have really difficulty understanding Heidegger because all his terms in English sound technical terms, but almost all of them are just regular German terms. So this is sort of like Freud. Freud says I, and then somebody translates that as ego into English, and then that becomes a whole problem because nobody says ego during like everyday speech, like ego is running or something like that.
SPEAKER_01I am running, and Freud really uses I. He doesn't use like ego or id or superego or things like
SPEAKER_00that.
SPEAKER_01And like Heidegger is similar, like he says like being, and then for Handensin, which is like being at hand, uh uh yeah, ready at hand.
SPEAKER_00Like,
SPEAKER_01what is ready at hand? Who uses ready at hand in everyday life? But for Heidegger, that's just like it literally means yes, there is, it's there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_01so this is part of like how philosophical thinking is part of everyday language. If we use it, if we uh have part of our understanding of the world, then it is much easier to understand the philosophical underpinnings of those terms. And I didn't have that in Turkish. Uh well, I didn't study Turk uh philosophy here, but even here, when I studied philosophy, it was in English in Bosphorus. Like we already
SPEAKER_00you are like immersed by the language all the time, so
SPEAKER_01yeah. So that really definitely affected, and I assume that it continues to affect people, and I think younger generations are more comfortable than I am in terms of their use of language. I think that their relationship to sort of concerns about colonialism is maybe different a little bit, they are more relaxed. We were a little bit more sort of defensive,
SPEAKER_00yeah,
SPEAKER_01and um, they are more relaxed. What do you think
SPEAKER_00about the idea? Like we're all having the same culture right now because of the social media, you know. I mean, that also certainly affects language and our take on it.
SPEAKER_01I'm very doesn't
SPEAKER_00it's
SPEAKER_01careful in someone who is I mean, I'm on social media, but not like for and like anybody else, and um I don't want to make generalizations on things that I don't really know, but as far as I observe, I mean I teach this. Yeah, from like
SPEAKER_00what you observed, what do you think really about this?
SPEAKER_01Well, it is a
SPEAKER_00because the world is changing and we're like seeing it, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, and I think this I mean, in addition to all the sort of intellectual impact on this, on human beings, intellectual as well as psychological, how it affects self-image, your presence, etc. What interests me the most nowadays is not interest, but concerns me is how technology, especially AI, is using natural resources that are for both human beings but nature in general.
SPEAKER_01Like, you know, these data centers that are created in the United States, they use
SPEAKER_00an
SPEAKER_01exorbitant amount of water
SPEAKER_00a lot, actually.
SPEAKER_01For what? So that you can chat with Chat GPT or so that you can post your you know image online. I mean, what is the gain from this? What is it that now always You're
SPEAKER_00not saying that there's no use, right?
SPEAKER_01Unfortunately, there is use. I just
SPEAKER_00Oh, why you say unfortunately though?
SPEAKER_01Well, because use justifies it. And then what is the ultimate justification? It makes money, it makes it create profit, and that's why AI is so popular today, not because it has changed technologically, etc. It's now for profit. And once that becomes, then the question becomes a more general sort of what's the purpose of capitalism? Like, what is it that like growth, like economic growth? Like that, what is that? Like a cancer? Like, I don't understand like the purpose of growth for the sake of growth, like more profit.
SPEAKER_01Well, then you have very
SPEAKER_00Americanized, you know, you
SPEAKER_01know. Yeah, yeah. So that that to me is what philosophy is most important today to be able to think
SPEAKER_00so you you view philosophy as a tool, don't you?
SPEAKER_01I see philosophy as I always say that, a kind of ability to live. To me, is like something that uh allows you to live, and quite literally, I believe if you are not philosophical, what you are doing is not living. I know it sounds a little like uh
SPEAKER_00no, but can you say it one more time?
SPEAKER_01Well I I always imagine I'm maybe
SPEAKER_00put it in a different way so the general public could really grasp it.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so I always have this fantasy of coming to Turkey and writing this book that I
SPEAKER_00you have already written.
SPEAKER_01I I written two in English, but I want to write in Turkish if I can. I will try. I mean I'm I'm writing best with that. Yeah, and so this is I'll do this in Turkish if that's okay. Uh Yasheya Bilmek Ichin Falsefe. That is in order to be able to live philosophy, but Yashea Bilmek also means knowing life.
SPEAKER_00In a way, it does.
SPEAKER_01So Bilmek has these two aspects, like one capability, one knowing.
SPEAKER_00It's more just beyond knowledge, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yes, Yashea Bilmec. Yeah, in order to be able to make it. So to me, philosophy is to be able, I mean, and I don't mean like you need to be from philosophical tradition and read philosophers, etc., but being able to think different moving parts of life together. Now
SPEAKER_00pay more attention in a way
SPEAKER_01to the whole, to the universe.
SPEAKER_00That's so hard, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Incredibly hard,
SPEAKER_00especially with all the distractions we have today.
SPEAKER_01And we are going the opposite direction. So we value expertise, we value somebody who is good at something. Like, oh, that's so incredible. And what we are missing both in education but in general value is someone who can think different aspects of human life together. And this has been a it's not
SPEAKER_00a teacher's. Career student, huh?
SPEAKER_01Well, not in order to create a narrative, but be able to see connections. That's and that was really university education. That was like what was called liberal arts or sort of like a general education. And we don't value that anymore. General education is like a you know failure nowadays. Like, oh, you have a general education. What do you do? So
SPEAKER_00academia maybe like disappointed you in a way.
SPEAKER_01Oh, every didn't it? Everybody, like a lot of people are disappointed now. I went, I just talked to a friend, like they're just firing 600 people from one university. Like, I think university education is a huge crisis. Education. As a job training, it will continue, whatever the market is, but using human as a resource, not as a
SPEAKER_00to gain and earn money in order to.
SPEAKER_01So I think to me, of course, I'm old, I sound like you know. But it's a bit different in
SPEAKER_00Turkey, right? Because in the US, like you have this uh, you know, student loan, and you go and like it have a credit card, and also you like take a loan from the from the bank just to study, right? But in Turkey, you can also like find public universities, which are like good ones, really. You know, you can name some of them actually. So
SPEAKER_01but what do they do? Do they also create jobs?
SPEAKER_00No, they they never do.
SPEAKER_01What do they do?
SPEAKER_00They just give you the tools, I believe.
SPEAKER_01Well, then it's just
SPEAKER_00so you can find your own way.
SPEAKER_01Then it's then I'm very well. I
SPEAKER_00don't really believe that the university does it. I think the campus does that
SPEAKER_01campus life, yeah. No, that we talked about it a little bit in terms of like where do you get your education? I mean, I still believe in the classroom because I love the classroom.
SPEAKER_00I also love the classroom, by the way.
SPEAKER_01But it's also like I encourage my students to talk about whatever is happening in the classroom outside of the classroom, without the teacher, without the sort of formal structure of the class. But do you see
SPEAKER_00them like doing it?
SPEAKER_01Well, I don't because I mean I'm not with them, but
SPEAKER_00hope to.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And I think like, you know what happens at universities, like we have these assessments now. Like, I don't even know how I should or would affect students. That's really up to them to be able to sort of um connect to their lives, whatever happened in the classroom.
SPEAKER_00How do you like view your role as a as a professor in the university?
SPEAKER_01Well, now it's very different. I mean, now it's
SPEAKER_00certainly not just giving some random info and just
SPEAKER_01well, I never really saw it that way. We really had like uh language, we used that, we got comfortable with that, things like uh critical thinking and things like that, which was really a cop-out. We really didn't think about our role for a long time. Now it's actually a little bit simplified in my mind, in the sense that what is it that I teach or whatever happens in my classroom that cannot be appropriated by AI?
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a deep question, really.
SPEAKER_01That's my only question right now. And
SPEAKER_00it's very real.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because if I teach, is I don't know whether this is a word, but AIable.
SPEAKER_00AIable,
SPEAKER_01AIable. If it is AIable,
SPEAKER_00now it is a thing, I guess. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01it is AIable, like AI can't do it, then it's not worth for me to do it. It's really like why should I? Why would
SPEAKER_00the student is not like involved at all in the whole process?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so why and why should they come to my class? Why should they learn anything if it is already existing somewhere that they have instant access to access
SPEAKER_00to, exactly?
SPEAKER_01So that to me like really shaped like towards the end of my career, like the fact that we were not well prepared for the invasion of AI, and some of my colleagues appear so thoughtless to me in terms of their relationship to AI. One camp is like, oh, it's not gonna do anything, it can never replace human beings. And the other is like
SPEAKER_00it's good to be optimistic, but yeah,
SPEAKER_01the world is
SPEAKER_00changing. It's
SPEAKER_01stupid, it's
SPEAKER_00stupidness in a way,
SPEAKER_01and the other is like it's the greatest thing. And I obviously where
SPEAKER_00do you stand?
SPEAKER_01I think
SPEAKER_00we maybe
SPEAKER_01maybe it's sort of like it is a unnecessary evil, but since it's evil, I have to deal with it. So I don't even want to say it is necessary because sometimes we create technology to make our lives easier. My purpose for my students is to make their lives more complicated, not easier, because you you can't really live life life easy because what is the alternative? Like, okay, so you go learn this for me, you go have sex for me,
SPEAKER_00yeah,
SPEAKER_01you go do this for me, and what am I doing as a human being? So
SPEAKER_00what's my role?
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00even after, like, let's say, yeah, you you used AI like for a lot of assignments and projects during university, but you graduated, and now what?
SPEAKER_01Yeah,
SPEAKER_00who's gonna work for you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you can't
SPEAKER_00do it.
SPEAKER_01But the thing is
SPEAKER_00there are like new agents, like AI agents who can just work for you and
SPEAKER_01you
SPEAKER_00can just sit at home and you know, you earn money,
SPEAKER_01yeah,
SPEAKER_00do nothing exactly.
SPEAKER_01Well, if you have the money, if you have enough money, uh other ways you have to
SPEAKER_00I think about it if you are smart enough.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, you know, with
SPEAKER_00basic tools, you can really make a lot of money out of it, uh just using AI, you know, in a very simplistic way. You don't have to be an expert in it, honestly. I I've seen it like among my friends, you know.
SPEAKER_01But
SPEAKER_00do I really like value this just sitting at home and make others or like other tools, not even like humanistic tools, do the job for me, and I just sit and do nothing. It doesn't, it's really against all of the things I I stand for in life.
SPEAKER_01Well, well, that's the direction, I guess. I think
SPEAKER_00we're missing passion here, even purpose.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was gonna say something about AI, but um
SPEAKER_00AI is like a really big topic, and we can't really just finish it in today's episode.
SPEAKER_01Let's connect it to the language at
SPEAKER_00the end.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we'll just like
SPEAKER_00recall and recap our whole episode.
SPEAKER_01Well, a good way would be sort of like connecting to this language. I mean, one of the things that really interests me about Lacan is that how we create language or symbolic orders that trap us into certain impossibilities. That idea is fascinating for me. He gives this like really famous example of even like flipping a coin, and then you start naming the sequence of the flipping, like head head, head, blah blah.
SPEAKER_00A lot of people did it in the past, but no one really succeeds.
SPEAKER_01What he does is you name them, and then you create impossibilities within the symbolic order. So if you I mean, this is very simple. Like you say head head, tail tail. So one is one, one is three, and then you name all those random events, and then one can never come after three, and three never never come after one. That didn't exist as an impossibility, it only exists as an impossible. It's a
SPEAKER_00deduction reasoning, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01No, no, it's random naming in language, random naming. So if if I name the sequence uh tail tail one and head head three, since in order for the head to come after tail, you can never have one coming after three. It's very simple, silly. I mean, it's not silly, it's interesting example. So what this means for me is that like we create a language with AI.
SPEAKER_01Like people are coding and like and it's almost like
SPEAKER_00a whole different world, you know.
SPEAKER_01So you put all this data into a box, and you have no idea what's going to come out of the box.
SPEAKER_00Because it's very creative, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Processing power. It is something that I cannot even imagine. Like, you know, how much data points can you process in one millisecond? Human brain cannot even imagine this, sort of like imagining the infinite space. But do you
SPEAKER_00think that this box is conscious?
SPEAKER_01Well, if we define consciousness as a processing power, yes. But to me, consciousness is not just processing power. And even the word artificial intelligence to me, that's not even intelligence in the sense that I would never call the machine intelligent. I would call it processing power because initially this was called machine learning.
SPEAKER_00Machine learning, exactly.
SPEAKER_01And they said that doesn't sound good. Let's find it. The ML a
SPEAKER_00more popular, a more appealing name for it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, artificial intelligence data. Now, as long as we define human intelligence as processing, we lost that game because there, I mean, AI is always going to process it faster. Because that's what we used to think that smart people did, like you know, calculate, you know, we'll
SPEAKER_00filter things out and try
SPEAKER_01to me. It really requires us not just redefine human intelligence, but what does it mean to be human? If you really want to escape the sort of replacement of AI, you really need to rethink what it means to be human. And I don't know any other discipline.
SPEAKER_00Go to the beginning. Way
SPEAKER_01yeah, and I don't know any discipline than philosophy that is capable of doing that in a real way, because like biology does it in a certain way, anthropology does it in a certain way. What about
SPEAKER_00psychology though?
SPEAKER_01No, definitely not, because psychology is also to me is a very sort of highly curated, very structured language right now, and that's sort of based on a certain conception of what it means to be human, and that to me is not working anymore. Because you know, it's sort of creating like healthy functional individuals that take uh part in the workforce, etc. That to me is not a very sort of um deep enough understanding of what it means to be human.
SPEAKER_00So you're looking for something authentic in the general sense
SPEAKER_01something different, something something definitely forces us to think beyond the categories that we employed if we if AI is going to have any kind of positive. Well, it's doing the
SPEAKER_00opposite, actually, AI right now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00And this is like really worrying me like a lot. Concerns me.
SPEAKER_01Exactly why we should need that. Yes, I agree with that. Doing exactly the opposite, and we should do exactly the opposite of what is happening. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00yeah. I mean, going against the flow is a bit hard, you know, a bit troubling, but it's always possible.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, we'll see.
SPEAKER_00We did it, and we know how to find a solution for it, I guess.
SPEAKER_01Did we do it then?
SPEAKER_00I guess do we?
SPEAKER_01Well, in history,
SPEAKER_00well,
SPEAKER_01like I mean, we have always been a little bit enslaved by the machines that we created. I mean, we created the world machine, we created the sort of like our lives now are a little bit sort of in terms of the
SPEAKER_00civilization, exactly. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01so uh hey, you should be hopeful and optimistic. I am very
SPEAKER_00optimistic, by the way. As you can see, uh, I'm a bit yeah, I love classes, I love conceptual general ways, you know, of teaching, even but that would change, and I'm like seeing it in front of my eyes.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so you're not optimistic.
SPEAKER_00No, I'm just observing, and uh so I can like just know where to go.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00To find my my way out of all of this.
SPEAKER_01Do you feel a community or a kind of structure that will allow you to do that?
SPEAKER_00Uh, there's no community involved at all.
SPEAKER_01Well,
SPEAKER_00everyone is going in a different path.
SPEAKER_01Well, that goes back all the way to the or
SPEAKER_00diverged, I would say.
SPEAKER_01All right, all the way goes back to what we talk about the human individual as opposed to relations. So your luck in life or like thereof would be to be able to find connections that embrace that and support you in doing that. Because as an individual, you're absolutely we need an
SPEAKER_00environment so we can exactly yeah.
SPEAKER_01So we need to create different ways of interacting with each other outside of this transactionality.
SPEAKER_00We have put to put the effort, right?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, unfortunately, in this day and age, that requires a certain economic power.
SPEAKER_00It does.
SPEAKER_01I mean,
SPEAKER_00especially in Turkey, I mean, you know,
SPEAKER_01everywhere
SPEAKER_00as a student,
SPEAKER_01yeah. Hey, United States is equally comp difficult. I I think, yeah. Well, right, we can talk about that in a whole different episode, how the United States looks to me, is like honesty, at this point, is like I need to escape. I need to
SPEAKER_00from what? From who
SPEAKER_01from the United States. I need to get out of here.
SPEAKER_00But is there like a place where you you feel that okay, this is where I want to be?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, here. I but I mean initially, like any place but the United States, right?
SPEAKER_00But aren't you like a bit eliminated
SPEAKER_01from
SPEAKER_00pollination, I mean, from Turkey after all these years?
SPEAKER_01Oh, absolutely. Yes. I mean, that's it's not gonna be like something easy. It's
SPEAKER_00like easy to to come back.
SPEAKER_01Yes, it's it's never going to be like coming back to what I left. I don't mean
SPEAKER_00like physically, but like
SPEAKER_01I think.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I understand mentally.
SPEAKER_01It's never going to be back, it's never going to be what I had before. That's just the
SPEAKER_00it's going forward, you
SPEAKER_01know.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't have to be go backwards. Yeah,
SPEAKER_01so to me it's like honestly, it's gonna be different. It's gonna be different than the United States. I don't know how it's gonna be, even though I come here every year and I you know talk to people, etc. I really don't know how life is gonna be. But
SPEAKER_00you just feel that you can't contribute to the to the public.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, that's I just need to get out. I just need to get out
SPEAKER_00of here.
SPEAKER_01And
SPEAKER_00figured out by all I mean,
SPEAKER_01yeah, exactly. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00there's only way one way to know it, which is by doing it, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly. And then, you know, like our job, I mean, our jobs are in you know jeopardy anyway, so like there's like universities are changing in the United States, there's no funding, there's that there are a lot of people losing their jobs, which is all the better. Like, it's time to get out, and like this whole political system, the whole I don't even know what to call it, like neo-fascism, like postmodern fascism type of thing. Uh, so yeah, I need to get out,
SPEAKER_00get out and explore new, unexplored.
SPEAKER_01Well, not even like I don't know, just live, just like I don't like just sort of live your life, just breathe and like don't think of your function, don't think like my contribution, just being able to just live and like
SPEAKER_00now you're being a bit stoic, aren't you?
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, yeah, maybe, maybe. I mean, not as a sort of philosophical attitude, but maybe that's like you weren't
SPEAKER_00aware of it, probably that you're thinking, what if this way, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know. Like
SPEAKER_00you wouldn't go and like you know, just define yourself or like introduce yourself as a stoic, but deep down you are maybe.
SPEAKER_01Well, I don't even know what that means, but yeah, I mean I don't I wouldn't I don't mind labels because I don't think they mean anything.
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_01but I
SPEAKER_00hate that. That's the problem.
SPEAKER_01Well, if it allows, like, oh, I am a stoic, I cannot do that. No, of course not. If if those you know labels don't sort of restrict you from doing things, I think that's the main issue. Like you say, like, oh, I am a this, so I can't do that, I am that, I can't do that, and that's the imposition aspect of it. But I always think like labels are the things that other people give to you, and I don't care.
SPEAKER_00You're always open to new things, but
SPEAKER_01although sticking with
SPEAKER_00one certain thing, it doesn't really allow you to grow and expand your horizon, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. But although sir has this concept of appellation, like so they always call you something, like you are a stoic, and then you say like, no, I'm not. So like you are at this, and then you you sort of reject it because it actually traps you. Maybe it
SPEAKER_00doesn't really define who you are, you know, it doesn't really represent you as a person.
SPEAKER_01I I'm not even interested in defining who I am, I just want to like live.
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_01like you know, sort of without these kind of linguistic and conceptual restrictions. Just sort of breathe, like take a walk, don't think too much over like who you are, what you are, what's the meaning of your life, etc. Just sort of being able to exist. And yes, that that's a little stoic here, right?
SPEAKER_00Very stoic of you. Anyway, now we can wrap up the whole episode. We talked about uh content philosophy, also we then explored linguistics, how it really affects
SPEAKER_01you need to edit most of this. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00I will, I probably will.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, good luck with
SPEAKER_00yeah, and then we also touched on AI and shed likes on how it really affects young people and uh how we can really grow out of this, you know.
SPEAKER_01I and I hope there is a sort of trajectory to this talk about like how human existence is shaped with uh language, linguistics, and culture, and then where we came with AI. So yeah.
SPEAKER_00I see. So it's always nice and it's always wonderful to have you back, Professor Ferrit. Until next time.
For Feedbacks Where Did Our Attention Go? In a world that constantly competes for our attention, what does it really mean to pay attention? From endless scrolling and digital distractions to the difficulty of being...
For Feedbacks Modern dating culture constantly sells us the myth of "the one" the idea that finding a perfect soulmate requires no effort, and that instant chemistry is the ultimate green flag. But what happens when the...
For Feedbacks Language is more than vocabulary and grammar... It shapes the way we think, connect, remember, and understand the world around us. In this episode, I'm joined by Sena, a French Literature graduate who...
For Feedbacks A growing number of young men feel lost, isolated, and without direction. But why is this happening? In this episode, we explore the silent crisis of young men; examining the psychological, social, and...
For Feedbacks We inherit more than eye color and last names. We inherit definitions. Definitions of success. Of morality. Of masculinity and femininity. Of obedience. Of what is “normal.” Of what is “right.” But what if...