For Feedbacks Language is more than vocabulary and grammar... It shapes the way we think, connect, remember, and understand the world around us. In this episode, I'm joined by Sena, a French Literature graduate who recently returned from France, and Koray, for a relaxed and thought-provoking conversation on language and society. Together, we explore how language influences identity, the experience of living abroad, accents and stereotypes, literature, translation, social media, and the subtle ways words that shape our relationships... This isn't a conversation about linguistics. It's a conversation about being human through language. Whether you've ever searched for the right word, felt different in another language, or wondered why certain conversations stay with us forever, this episode is for you. I hope you enjoy listening as much as we enjoyed recording it. If you enjoyed this episode, don’t forget to give us a 5-star review and follow Beyond The Surface for more deep and thought-provoking conversations. Your support helps us grow and bring you even better content 😊 I'd love to hear what you think; feel free to reach out at (muhamoet4@gmail.com)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello everyone and welcome back to Beyond the Surface Podcast. And today we have Sena.
SPEAKER_01Hi.
SPEAKER_00And Korai.
SPEAKER_02Hey folks, how are you all doing?
SPEAKER_00And today we're gonna talk about languages and culture. So my first question is for Sena. How would you define language?
SPEAKER_01I would define a language as a form of communication for humans, either through gestures or written or uh oral expressions.
SPEAKER_00Okay, and Croy?
SPEAKER_02Language in its essence is a method of relaying information in a manner that is reciprocal. But for a language to actually exist, it has to be somewhere spoken than more than just a single individual, right? It's a method of relaying information that exists in a social context, but doesn't exist in abstract in a vacuum. And it's in its essence defined by its function, that's how I view language.
SPEAKER_00Okay, how can we distinguish language from communication? Because I think most of us confuse language with communication, right?
SPEAKER_01For me, uh my uh the way I would distingu distinguish them would be well language has to have a certain structure, and also as we know it, language is something that is more specific to humans. So if you're communicating through um anything with a structure from human to human, I would call that a language. Uh and I can also exam like give you an example of that.
SPEAKER_01I don't think the dog is using a language specifically when we teach them tricks. We aren't the one that is. Like there's no
SPEAKER_02comprehension involved with dogs.
SPEAKER_01Um they do comprehend, but what they're doing is not language because they're not actually using the same structure, they're uh using uh just whatever a dog does, which is learning through experience.
SPEAKER_02Now, what you're talking of reminds me of uh the entire debate revolving around Coco the gorilla. You probably know of that. So it was this gorilla that had a, if I recall correctly, an exceptionally high IQ that, at least from our perspective, that apparently had a knowledge of about a hundred and fifty different words. At least when it comes to like sign language. But that's a story essentially. At least on the surface level.
SPEAKER_02When you do actually look at it from a deeper angle though, um I don't recall the peculiarities of it, but the argument, the academic argument, uh was essentially that Coco did not did not actually possess comprehension of the words that it was communicating. It was just sort of arbitrarily performing various different gestures in order to, let's say, I don't know, ask for food.
SPEAKER_02It's kind of abstract when I put it that way, but if you are to actually look at that study, you'll immediately get what I'm talking about.
SPEAKER_00So this is communication, you would say, not a language.
SPEAKER_02I mean the distinction between the two. I'd say with language, there has to be some comprehension involved. There has to be some reciproc reciprocity.
SPEAKER_00Do you mean consciousness?
SPEAKER_02Uh, not necessarily. Not necessarily. I mean Senna, what do you have to say on this? You're a bit well studied on the subject than I am.
SPEAKER_01Well, I wouldn't say that I wouldn't say that something um being comprehended by one of the parties that are that are that are involved that is involved is the measurement we can take here. I wouldn't say that uh something being reciprocal is um a very defining factor in languages.
SPEAKER_02Sure, that's not the only defining factor, but it's it's certainly a part of it.
SPEAKER_01I wouldn't agree. How come? Let's say that okay, let's okay, here's a food for thought.
SPEAKER_02Alright.
SPEAKER_01Let's say that there's only one person who is left speaking a language. Uh-huh. Alright. Now is that and not is not not a language anymore.
SPEAKER_02It's definitely a dying language. It's a language that is on its way out.
SPEAKER_00Did that person create his language by his own, or like was it inherited by his ancestors, I would say?
SPEAKER_01I would say that wouldn't matter. But let's say that the. Yeah, but if he inherited, I would say as
SPEAKER_00I would agree with Cryo probably on that, because we're losing a language here. But if he created his own language and now he's just the only one in the world who speaks it.
SPEAKER_01What if someone else learns the language that the person created? Well, my example was that the person was the last alive person
SPEAKER_00who's different then, okay,
SPEAKER_01the language. But right now I can say, yes, I let's say made a language because there has been uh an example of this. Actually, there have been examples of this where a person made a language, and there was, of course, a moment where that person was the only person who spoke it. At that moment, then you would say that it's not a language in that at that moment, no.
SPEAKER_02I mean, right, right. So uh what I would consider within that perspective is that so let's go let's go back to the original scenario. We're talking about a language that is intelligible only to the individual who actually came up with it. And let's say that it's the language itself is completely incomprehensible to us. So whether it actually has the potential to be understood or not, I feel like that plays a role either because hypothetically, let's say that the language that this individual comes up with is completely incomprehensible to us.
SPEAKER_02Only he can actually crack the code to it. At that point, at least from our perspective, would be would we would we be still uh looking at that at that uh form of communication? Would that still be language to us? You get what I'm talking about?
SPEAKER_01Alright. Um so I guess I would still define it as uh I would define a language not only by the by how comprehensible it is, comprehendable it is, but by the structure and the usage of it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but from personal experiences, uh both of you, I mean, you know, you studied French interpretation, I guess, right, Senna?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00And quite also studied music, which is also to some a language. So what led you to this point? Do you like always have this love for languages, like this uh affinity for languages, or just like why you like you studied this specific major?
SPEAKER_01Alright. Um well I personally chose to study languages because I love uh trying to at least understand how the human mind works. When I say that, I don't only mean psychology, as we know it, I mean I like understanding how anything about humans work. Let it be cultures, let it be society, let it be evolution. So that's what led me to be more keen on learning how languages work or what language is.
SPEAKER_02So, from my perspective, I got into uh studying languages as a hobby because I was just interested in the uh culture of certain languages. I mean, this is actually quite an interesting point because you have to consider the fact that when it comes to picking up any language, as a non-native speaker, whether you're actually interested in the culture that that language originates from will largely determine whether you're even going to be able to comprehend and pick up the language itself.
SPEAKER_02It plays a huge role whether you're so let's say you want to learn Italian, right? You're gonna have a much harder time picking up Italian.
SPEAKER_00What's that? You both like know a third language, right? Yeah, I guess you like to say that. And for someone it's French.
SPEAKER_02Hear me out. So let's say that you wanna pick up Italian, you want to learn Italian, right? You you'll have a lot harder of a time learning a language, even as relatively simple as Italian, if you're not actually interested in Italy or Italians, or Italian culture. You get what I'm talking about? I mean, it's way the language itself, it's just way too intrinsic to the culture. Rather, the culture, the way of life, it's way too intrinsic to the language itself. It's just an interesting point from my perspective, it's an interesting perspective.
SPEAKER_00Okay, how can we really resonate this with culture? Because you both studied a third language, and also you are familiar with the French culture probably and also the Russian culture. Define how we can resonate these both two separate things, language and culture, or can they like be really separated, or they cannot be?
SPEAKER_01Honestly, interestingly, I would say they cannot be separated. Um I would like to think about it this way. There are a lot of things maybe potentially that we cannot draw lines between um when it comes to humans. Uh I can give so many examples. Can you define where language starts and where culture ends? No, I don't think so. Can you uh tell me where, for example, language starts and mathematics uh end?
SPEAKER_01I don't think so. I think there are a lot of things that we are imprisoned by when it comes to language is uh then liberated from.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna have to agree with Senna here and in the uh in the idea that language cannot really be separated from the culture, even if it's just a particular method of speaking or dialect that we're talking about here. It very much is the culture and the uh surrounding sort of uh atmosphere that forms the language. The two are intrinsic. So for example, um certain methods of speaking tend to be a bit more vulgar than the other ones.
SPEAKER_02So, especially forms of speaking, uh linguistics, let's say, uh dialects uh that that are formed in environments that aren't exactly all that civil. That aren't all that civil, the kind of language that comes out as as a result of that also tends to carry that virtue, that aspect of uncivility. For example, let's say um prison slang, Russian prison slang.
SPEAKER_02I mean, prisons aren't exactly a very humane environment, right? They're certainly not an environment that I'd want to be in. And if you actually look at the uh sort of words that they use and how comparatively vulgar Russian prison slang is uh compared to regular Russian, yeah, that that point, the point that I'm making becomes very clear.
SPEAKER_00So let's move to a bit of psychology. Because we're all, I guess, interested in psychology, so let's ask uh a very simple question. Can we think without a language?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's a nice question. I love it.
SPEAKER_02Um there are certainly beings who do that who just well, I wouldn't say that that they necessarily think, they just act on a pure they just act behave on pure instinct. There's really not much thought involved. But at least within the cons context of humans, no, I I I don't think that's possible. It's very much the language that forms the thought, that forms the inner world. It very much is that whether it's the whether it's even the concepts that we're talking about here, it's the language that is the like yeah, the the thoughts, the terminology, the uh even concepts, they're derived from the language.
SPEAKER_02If a language doesn't have the word for something, it does if it does it if it lacks the vocabulary for it, you're just not going to be able to express that. Even if you're learning a language, you can study up the grammar all you want, but if you don't have the vocabulary, at the end of the day, you're not gonna be able to communicate. So, yeah, I'd very much say that it is impossible to think without words. You can feel, you can act on instinct, but that's not thinking. That's not conscious thinking.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but how do you really like define thinking?
SPEAKER_02How would I define I mean thinking would have to be conscious, wouldn't it? Would you would you not agree with that, Senna?
SPEAKER_01Well, um
SPEAKER_02It's gotta be conscious.
SPEAKER_01Well, honestly, purposeful.
SPEAKER_02Inner monologue.
SPEAKER_01So what's
SPEAKER_02how I would define thinking? Inner monologue.
SPEAKER_01What I know is that uh although this is not a very popular
SPEAKER_02perspective.
SPEAKER_01Uh actually a lot of people lack that in their monologues. There are a lot of people who cannot think in languages. That's
SPEAKER_02oh, so there are such people. I had no idea. Honestly, I had no idea.
SPEAKER_01That's the thing. Who think through movement or just basic feeling rather than languages?
SPEAKER_02Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_01That happens. And there are a lot of people who don't have languages in their dreams.
SPEAKER_02But they're still able to communicate with others through language.
SPEAKER_01They are able, of course, but they just lack that. At least they can
SPEAKER_02communicate to you in a language that is intelligible. They can communicate through vocalizations, yes, they're capable of that. That great
SPEAKER_00talent. So perception. What do you think about perception when it comes to languages? Limits or defines our perception in overall, or just
SPEAKER_01so as far as I know, there have there has been a lot of debate on that. Um I would like to think about it this way. Actually, let me ask you back a reflection question. So we have certain words uh that we know in English, in Turkish, but they don't exist in the other language, right? And I would say that that affects the way we think about our social interactions and our maybe even though it's a big s maybe um stretch realities.
SPEAKER_01I can give various examples of that too, but yeah.
SPEAKER_02So what you're essentially saying is that, at least, you know, uh following that train of thought, it's at first the geography and the conditions of living that forms the language, and is the form it is the language that forms the concepts, the ideas.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think what you're trying to get at the deal? I I it's not my only definition or condition only, of course. But I think that is c also part of the deal because as we said, we established before, we cannot differentiate or separate culture from uh language, right? And culture happens how, for example, let's say what
SPEAKER_02is it that's actually forms up the culture? What is it? Is it just the uh you know exterior circumstances? Is that what defines culture?
SPEAKER_01Um I would
SPEAKER_02say from I
SPEAKER_01wouldn't say
SPEAKER_02just the geography and the conditions of living, whether it's the weather, whether it's I don't know, the atmosphere, the air, the ground, the geography, the topography.
SPEAKER_01I would say that there are a lot of things that go into how you form a culture.
SPEAKER_02But
SPEAKER_01I think culture is the outcome of whatever happened within a society, not just one or two. Yeah, sure, sure. So it could be uh the um geographical or very material things that you face, or it could be the um social or interpersonal problems that you have faced. It could be the good things, it could be the bad things, whatever you have faced, and whatever response you gave to that as a society, as a community, I would say would give you as a if that became for some reason a ritual or something that everybody shared, I think that would then become a part of the So in
SPEAKER_02practice, uh what you're saying is that it is essentially the culture that forms the concepts that are being communicated, the ideas.
SPEAKER_01That would be too rigid of a statement. That's not exactly what I'm saying. Um I would say, because the question involved it, well, language, I think, to some effect maybe affects the way we think about anything.
SPEAKER_02Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_01Which we could
SPEAKER_02do.
SPEAKER_01It's a language
SPEAKER_02that makes up the inner world, even the personality to an extent, I would say.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's actually that's how my train of thought around that. I'll give you an example.
SPEAKER_02I'll give you an example. So if you're paying attention, so languages that are present within more warmer warmer climates, like let's say Spain, they tend to be a bit more melodic compared to languages that are that are present within cultures up north. So let's say compared to, I don't know, Norwegian and r or Russian. So if you're paying attention with how your average Russian native native speaker speaks Russian, it's very monotone. There isn't as much um cadence to it in comparison to, let's say, Italian or Spanish.
SPEAKER_02That's something to think about.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think what you consider melodic um could be not so melodic for someone else. So there's
SPEAKER_02some relativity to it, is what you're saying.
SPEAKER_01I believe a serious amount of a chunk of relativity there.
SPEAKER_02I I'm pretty sure there's some science behind this.
SPEAKER_01There probably is. Even just the
SPEAKER_02differences in pitch and cadence. That's what I'm essentially talking about here. Not the rhythm, but the differences in hertz. Some of it, some of them are a lot are a bit more volatile, they go up and down, whereas others are just in a straight line. If you were to look at it on a graph.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but how can we really think about personalities in this?
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's actually where I was going to get to. What I tried to say was that I believe uh language and culture together, they affect the way we perceive uh shared reality. Might be a big statement, I know, but I think I think they do. An example. Uh in Turkish, although that's a kind of it's a sad example. Um, not the prettiest part of the world, but nothing is all roses.
SPEAKER_01So
SPEAKER_02I'd say Anatolia's beautiful.
SPEAKER_01Alright.
SPEAKER_02It is pretty.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Nothing is all uh sunshine though. So there's sunshine
SPEAKER_02and rainbows, sure.
SPEAKER_01So there's something if we do a more motomo translation of it called the head money, which sounds wrong already, but uh in Turkish as you speak it, it's Pashtak Purasu, which which is something that you do when you're asking for a woman's hand in marriage, and um you have to pay the uh woman's father a certain amount of serious wealth in order to have her hand in marriage, right?
SPEAKER_01So that concept might not exist in a lot of cultures, therefore they do not have a word for it in those languages, right? And I think that kind of points out that there are things that you're not able to think of because there's not a word of it, or there are things that you're not able to think of because your society never had the need to name it. Which means that your your uh social structure, your culture, and your language is a part of how you perceive reality and how you shape your personality.
SPEAKER_02Dear listener, so keep in mind that this is just my anecdotal perspective. I don't have any studies whatsoever to back up what I'm about to say, but at least so far as my experience goes, I've noticed that uh languages that are spoken a bit in a manner that is more monotone, the personalities that they usually carry tend to be a bit more muted and nonchalant, like I don't know, Norwegian or Russian, for example.
SPEAKER_02In comparison to languages that have uh a type of cadence that is a bit more volatile, like Spanish or Portuguese, or Italian, or what have you. Though keep in mind, this is just my anecdotal perspective. I don't have I can't back this up with any qualitative or quantitative studies.
SPEAKER_00Okay, how can we really relate this to how we perceive emotions and even define emotions or feel emotions?
SPEAKER_01Well, I actually have a lot to say about this. So um this will be a philosophical point of view from mine, from me, uh, because well, as far as I've heard about it, there is again too much debate on this. Uh, there is Noam Chomsky, have you heard of him? Of course. Um, he doesn't agree that there is a strict or obvious relationship between relation between um how we name something or language itself and how we perceive reality.
SPEAKER_01That's that's his view, but again, a serious amount of scientists and researchers are not agreeing on this. So I would say personally that I think there is a correlation between the two, and therefore I would suggest that maybe if we are not able to name a specific thing, then we're not able to accept it as something very valid.
SPEAKER_00But can we feel them? That's
SPEAKER_01it possible for us. That's what I mean. If you
SPEAKER_00learned afterwards, let's say, for example, there's like this uh very specific word in German, Schadenfreud, which means you get a pleasure from someone else's pain, you know, like you just you're pleasant by their unfortunate, I would say. So if now you know this, probably, like yes, you just heard it and now you know what this word really means. If you like experience this in your daily life, would you like feel it?
SPEAKER_01So I would say yes, you feel it.
SPEAKER_00Maybe you already feel it, but we don't we don't have a name for it already. But you don't have
SPEAKER_01a name for it. And I think that uh in English we say I can't name it. And what do we mean by that? I I I know this, but I just cannot name it. I cannot tell if it's true or not. There is this slight meaning to it that I cannot say if it's true or not, right? So um a supporting argument could be in Italian, I think there is a biocco, which is the I think if I'm not mistaken about this, is the feeling that you get after eating too many carbon hydrates and then you get kind of sleepy.
SPEAKER_01Now we all know that feeling, don't we? But we don't have a name for it. So we don't know if it's actually a thing, although we're sure we feel it. So I think the emotions do exist, but when we do not name them, it doesn't get very real for us, maybe.
SPEAKER_00So language limits our perception of emotions, I would say.
SPEAKER_01I really have
SPEAKER_00a big statement to say I know. Yes, it's so I
SPEAKER_01never want to say that, but I've thought about that. I actually wrote some stuff on this. Uh yes, because I am not sure sometimes if language is a limitation at some point or a freedom. Maybe two things can be true at the same time because we're more able to name things uh and then feel like they're more valid, I think. Um an example could be sometimes when people go through trauma, if they know that that is trauma, they are able to make the feeling something more valid for themselves, and it feels more natural than
SPEAKER_00actually. This is like a study was done like two or three years ago by a scientist from uh Germany, as far as I remember. So there was like this uh girl who grew up like in a very chaotic uh household, I would say, and then she grew up like with her father being very aggressive and she was he was like just hitting her the whole day, and she wasn't like really able to distinguish this from being normal or this is just like too much, you know. But after she like went to school and told her friends in the university that, well, my father treats me this way, is this normal?
SPEAKER_00And then after the other girls like told her that this is not normal, like you're being like this is trauma, you know, like this is too much, the girl started to feel that it's a trauma, but before that she was okay with it. So, language here, what kind of role does it really play in terms of perceiving emotions?
SPEAKER_02I'd say that uh language very much makes up uh a great deal of the conceptual conceptualization itself. There is this quote that I believe to be true. It goes, What a man believes to be true about himself becomes his fate. So what sort of concepts that you're defining yourself with or defining and defining a situation with? I believe that so obviously it can't always just exceed physical, it can't overpower your self-belief, can't overpower physical reality, though it certainly plays a pretty huge influence.
SPEAKER_01Maybe we can look at it this way as well. Humans have uh maybe a tendency to categorize, right? I think that's something that we do a lot of people. There's a
SPEAKER_02study that I recall, so I I can't recall the details of it too much, but in essence, what this study pertains to is uh when it comes to let's say you have a patient, right? And you give the patient an ex a supposedly experimental piece of medicine, that is a placebo. But if the patient, let's say, ingests that placebo thinking that it's an experimental piece of medicine that has strong side effects, those strong side effects can eventually actually end up manifesting in his own body.
SPEAKER_00But in language, we call this nocebo.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. The concept of the nocebo. That's something to consider.
SPEAKER_01However, I would like to challenge this whole thing with one question, and it is this. So is it language itself that's making the effect, or is it the information that has been conveyed?
SPEAKER_02I'd say it's the uh it's the inner role the conceptualization and language plays a prey great deal and has huge influence on how that actually forms. The kind of very concepts and words that you're attaching to certain outcomes or to you know certain states of being.
SPEAKER_01I think um that's not exactly where maybe languages play a role. I think where languages play a role in terms of how they affect your personally or socially is maybe more in how you perceive reality again.
SPEAKER_00If everyone around you accepts this as a reality and you just live live with it, you know, you wouldn't really mind, right? Like you would just accept it as it is and you wouldn't bother and you wouldn't disagree because it's the reality, right? It's just what goes around you, and it's just part of your daily life because it happens to you, to your cousin, to your friends. But when you are like the only one who experienced such a thing, it starts to feel different. You start to realize things.
SPEAKER_01But I'm saying maybe it's more detailed than that. Maybe language is a natural reaction that we give to reality. So when uh and it's our way of conveying it. So it's not only because that word exists that we are able to feel it now, but it's because we are allowed to. And naming it is a natural process that when uh we have when we're expanding our reality. It's our natural um tendency when we meet something that exists out there that is new to name it.
SPEAKER_01So when someone doesn't give you a word but describes that it exists, you will, I think, still feel that it was not okay. Just because someone told you that it's not okay. You don't have to exactly name it, but um, so there are two parts here: the part that the information is is conveyed to you that it was not okay, and the naming part. I think naming part is our natural way of accepting things that are new.
SPEAKER_00So it's already there, like it already exists in our mind, in our perception, but feel it maybe?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, maybe.
SPEAKER_00Okay, what do you think, Corey?
SPEAKER_02So, what I'd say is it's very much the deliberate choice of language that plays an effect in how we actually conceptualize how you define the situation that you're in. The deliberate choice of language, the kind of words that you're using. And the words are obviously derived from culture, and yeah, it just goes back to the same point, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_00Senna, what do you think? Any questions?
SPEAKER_01Actually, yeah, I have questions. If you are interested. So one of them is do we only name things that exist?
SPEAKER_02That exist in like what sense? Physically. It doesn't have to be physical. There very much are there's a s there's such a thing as abstract concepts.
SPEAKER_01Honestly, I would leave it as however you take it because um the because I could also ask it as do we only
SPEAKER_02like unicorns, for example. We have a word for unicorns even though they're not real.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that was my point.
SPEAKER_02It has to be a concept though, at bare minimum. It has to exist as a concept within the uh cultural sphere, what's in somebody's mind at the time. What about
SPEAKER_00new developed words? Actually,
SPEAKER_02no, it has to exist within the uh c within this public consciousness for there to be for for a for for a word, for a piece of vocabulary to be for. Bare minimum, I'd say that for something to have a word to it, it would have to at least exist as a concept what's in the public consciousness. Doesn't have to be something physical, but it just has to exit exist as a concept, like unicorns, for example. Unicorns aren't real, but we have a word for them, and we can conceptualize them.
SPEAKER_00Well, a lot of myths and books and so many things were written about them, and they're like in the mythology, and they may exist, like we don't know for sure, right?
SPEAKER_02Far as we know though, they don't physically exist.
SPEAKER_00Maybe we don't have
SPEAKER_02We're just arguing semantics here. Put unicorns aside, just the sheer concept of abstract thinking, abstract thoughts.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, how can we relate this to abstraction to art? Because art is very unique. Yeah, art doesn't have to pertain right.
SPEAKER_02Art doesn't have to pertain to something that is real, that exists physically, like abstract art, for example, it doesn't have to derive from just the uh everyday reality of life.
SPEAKER_00That's kind of the core
SPEAKER_02idea of abstract art, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00And creativity?
SPEAKER_02Creativity. So you have to focus on the actual word there, creativity, to create. The ability to create, to come up with something new. How that process actually works in the brain. Honestly, I have no idea. It very much is a real concept. I mean, creativity doesn't exist physically, though it can manifest in physical ways. What I consider myself as a creative person, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01So, alright. I think this at creativity, something, uh the art, something existing in different ways, actually, right? These are still existence, but we differentiated them using abstract or concrete. Maybe. Alright. So then I would ask, does language have to involve something being real? Or what does that question mean to you?
SPEAKER_01Because to me, then I would have to ask, maybe it is not about something existing or not existing, it's not about real or unreal, maybe it's about shared reality, and language is a big part of it. So, can we say that language is a part of shared reality? And that's why we cannot differentiate um culture from language.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it could be. So, Koraya, any questions?
SPEAKER_02Not that I can think of, no.
SPEAKER_00Uh okay, before wrapping up, I would love to share that my gratitude for these two amazing guests. Really, I really love the way how they articulate themselves, and it's just amazing. It's such a pleasure to have you on the podcast.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. Thank you for inviting us.
SPEAKER_02Always happy to be here, Mohammed. Thank you very much. Glad to be here.
For Feedbacks Where Did Our Attention Go? In a world that constantly competes for our attention, what does it really mean to pay attention? From endless scrolling and digital distractions to the difficulty of being...
For Feedbacks Modern dating culture constantly sells us the myth of "the one" the idea that finding a perfect soulmate requires no effort, and that instant chemistry is the ultimate green flag. But what happens when the...
For Feedbacks What does it mean to feel at home? In this episode of Beyond The Surface, I sit down with Professor Ferit Güven for a conversation about belonging, identity, memory, and the places that shape us. Together,...
For Feedbacks A growing number of young men feel lost, isolated, and without direction. But why is this happening? In this episode, we explore the silent crisis of young men; examining the psychological, social, and...
For Feedbacks We inherit more than eye color and last names. We inherit definitions. Definitions of success. Of morality. Of masculinity and femininity. Of obedience. Of what is “normal.” Of what is “right.” But what if...