For Feedbacks In this episode of Beyond The Surface, we dive into how social media is quietly reshaping the way we talk, listen, and connect. From the illusion of “being connected” to the rise of shallow conversations, we unpack the subtle shifts happening in our communication today. Drawing on Sherry Turkle’s powerful insights and Paul Grice’s conversational maxims, we explore why our interactions feel more fragmented, why attention has become a rare currency, and how digital habits influence the quality of our relationships. Together, we break down the psychology, the philosophy, and the real-life consequences of living in a world where online presence often replaces genuine presence. Whether you’re a creator, a thinker, or just someone trying to communicate better, this episode will make you rethink the way you talk to the people you care about... If you enjoyed this episode, don’t forget to give us a 5-star review and follow Beyond The Surface for more deep and thought-provoking conversations. Your support helps us grow and bring you even better content 😊 I'd love to hear what you think; feel free to reach out at muhamoet4@gmail.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes I look around and wonder, how did we get to this point? We can talk to anyone, anytime, anywhere in the world, yet somehow we have never felt more misunderstood. It's like we are surrounded by voices, but nobody's really listening. Think about it. We've got social media, instant messaging, voice notes, video calls, group chats. Communication has never been faster. But when was the last time you truly felt hurt? Not replied to, not reacted to, just understood.
SPEAKER_00I think about this a lot actually, because not so long ago things were different. People talked, really talked. Conversations used to have silence, pauses, and eye contact. People used to sit across from each other with no distractions, no phones lightening up every few seconds. They would share stories, opinions, laughter, even disagreements. And somehow, even when they didn't agree, they still understood each other. Because back then, conversation wasn't about winning, it was about connecting.
SPEAKER_00There was a kind of rhythm to it, a heartbeat. Words carried weight and so the spaces between them. But today, that rhythm is fading. We have replaced conversation with communication and they are not the same thing. We communicate constantly, but most of it is surface level. We text, we scroll, we react, but do we really engage? Somewhere along the way, we stopped listening to understand and started listening to reply. And I don't think it's because we have become less capable, it's because the environment changed.
SPEAKER_00We are overstimulated, constantly exposed to a flood of content, opinions, and updates. We really slowed down long enough to think, let alone to feel. Maybe that's why conversations don't feel as deep as they used to. We are old here, connected through pixels and Wi-Fi, but emotionally it feels like we are miles apart. And that's exactly what I want to explore today in this episode. This episode isn't about blaming technology or glorifying the past.
SPEAKER_00It's about rediscovering the essence of what makes us human, the ability to truly connect through dialogue, not debate, not comment sections, not quick reactions or emojis, but real meaningful dialogue, the kind that changes how we see the world and how we see each other. To understand that, we will look at a fascinating idea by philosopher Martin Buber, who believed that all real living is meeting. He saw dialogue not just as an exchange of words, but as an encounter between souls.
SPEAKER_00So before we scroll to the next thought or notification, let's pause for one minute and try to remember what it means to really talk, to really listen, and to really meet. You know, it's kind of strange. We have never been more connected, Yet we have never felt so alone, right? We are constantly surrounded by messages, stories, and updates, but most of them feel empty.
SPEAKER_00We scroll for hours, talk all day online, but somehow the more we connect, the more disconnected we become. The irony is we believe we are closer. We have this illusion that we are part of something bigger, a community, a network, a digital world where everyone's only a click away. But what if that sense of closeness is just an illusion? When we take someone, it feels like communication, but we miss the tone of their voice, the look in their eyes, the energy of their presence.
SPEAKER_00We interpret emojis, not emotions. We read between lines of text, trying to guess what someone meant, and sometimes we get it completely wrong. The truth is, what social media offers us isn't connection, it's contact. Quick, convenient, endless contact. But contact alone doesn't equal closeness. We are always reachable but rarely available. We are always speaking, but hardly listening. We are always online but emotionally not there. And the platforms we use, they are designed to keep it that way.
SPEAKER_00Every notification, every scene message, every like or comment triggers a little burst of dopamine, a reward that says, you matter, you are seen. It's addictive, which is that validation, not realizing that it's changing how we communicate, how we perceive connection. We start tailoring ourselves for attention. We post what gets engagement, not what's honest. We express feelings through filters and captions instead of voice and vulnerability. And the more we do it, the less we remember how to be real.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes I wonder if we are losing the ability to sit in silence. To just be with someone without the need to post, record, or share it. That moment when two people are simply present, no camera, no audience, it's becoming rare these days, right? And maybe that's why loneliness feels heavier today. Because loneliness isn't about being alone, it's about being surrounded by people and still feeling unseen. And that's exactly what happens when connection becomes performance.
SPEAKER_00There's also this constant pressure to stay updated and not to leave someone unread. But think about it, when was the last time you had a slow conversation? One that unfolded naturally with pauses, reflection, and presence. We don't allow space for that anymore, right? Unfortunately. If a reply takes too long, we assume this interest. If someone doesn't post, we assume something's wrong. It's like the digital world rewired our patience. We crave instant closeness, but real closeness takes time, it takes attention, it takes intention, and most importantly, it takes dialogue, not just talking but meeting.
SPEAKER_00But here's the interesting part. We didn't lose dialogue overnight. We replaced it with convenience. Typing became easier than talking, liking became easier than listening, and scrolling became easier than sitting with silence. We traded depth for speed, and somehow in doing that, we lost the magic that used to make the conversations meaningful. I think deep down most of us missed that, right? The feeling of truly connecting, of looking someone in the eyes and feeling understood without saying too much.
SPEAKER_00That's what this whole episode is about, actually. Finding our way back to to that human space again. Because before we can talk about the art of dialogue, we have to admit that somewhere along the way we forgot what dialogue even feels like. There's this philosopher I came across a while ago, Martin Buber. He lived in the 20th century, long before smartphones, social media, and all the chaos we live in today. But somehow his ideas feel more relevant now than ever.
SPEAKER_00Buber believed that life at its core is about relationships, the kind of relationships that define who we are and how we see the world. And he said that there are two ways we relate to everything and everyone around us. He called them I it and I though. At first it sounds abstract, right? But it's actually very simple and very impacting. The I-it relationship is when we treat people or even the world as objects, as things that serve a purpose.
SPEAKER_00It's when we look at someone through the lens of usefulness, benefit, or even curiosity. We analyze, categorize, and sometimes even consume. Think about scrolling on Instagram. We see faces, but we don't see people. We see stories, but not the lives behind them. Everything becomes content, even emotions. That's the I-it relationship in action. It's not that it's bad, we all need the I-it. You can't live without some I-it in your life, but the problem is when it becomes the only way we relate to others.
SPEAKER_00Because the opposite, the I-the relationship, is where real life happens. It's when you encounter another person, not as an object, not as a role, not as a data or entertainment, but as a soul. A though is someone you truly meet, not through filters, not through expectation, but in their full presence. It's the kind of meeting where time slows down, where you are not thinking about what to say next. You are just there fully. Listening, open, connected.
SPEAKER_00No performance, no agenda. Buber believed that in those eye though moments, something sacred happens. Something real. He said, all real living is meeting. And I think that line holds a lot of truth. Because look at our world now. We meet thousands of people online, but how many of those are real meetings? We see names, faces, usernames, but how often do we see souls? We talk every day, but how often do we actually meet someone's truth?
SPEAKER_00It's not that technology destroyed our ability to connect, it just made I-it interactions the default. Every platform encourages us to treat people as content, data or audience. We start measuring relationships through likes, followers, or engagement. Even our sense of self becomes dependent on how others perceive us online, right? And maybe that's what hurts the most, that even we have become its in our own eyes. We present ourselves as profiles, brands or personas.
SPEAKER_00We shape our image before we shape our thoughts. And the more we do it, the harder it becomes to find authenticity, both in ourselves and others. But when you have an either moment, you know it instantly. It could be a deep talk at 2 am with a friend, a random honest exchange with a stranger, or even a moment of silence shared with someone who gets it. Those are the moments that make life feel real again. They don't happen often, but when they do, they remind us what being a human feels like.
SPEAKER_00Buber's philosophy isn't about rejecting modern life. It's about remembering that behind every screen, every username, every it, there's still a though, a living, breathing person with fears, hopes, stories, and dreams. And maybe if we remember that more often, if we saw people instead of profiles, our world would feel a little less lonely. We craft how we appear, how we speak, how we react. Everything is carefully created. We don't just post a photo, we post a version of ourselves we think people want to see, right?
SPEAKER_00We don't just send a message, we send a version of our thoughts that's safe or engaging or liked. Even our emotions become performative. And it's not just us, the platforms themselves encourage it. Algorithms reward attention, not authenticity. They show us what keeps us scrolling, what makes us click, what validates our image. So naturally we start prioritizing performance over presence. This is where the echo chamber comes in. Algorithms aren't neutral.
SPEAKER_00They learn what you like, what you agree with, what keeps you uncomfortable. And then they feed you more of the same thing. They build a wall around your mind, a loop of sameness, a constant echo of your own beliefs and tastes. You think you're having a conversation, but really you're just talking to yourself. And here's the kicker: the more time you spend in this loop, the harder it's to have real dialogue. Because real dialogue requires listening to perspectives that challenge you.
SPEAKER_00It requires patience, curiosity, and vulnerability. But the digital world rewards speed, comfort, and agreement. So the eye at way becomes default, and I though feels foreign, even risky. And this doesn't just affect politics or opinions, it touches everything. Friendships, relationships, work, family. We start performing for everyone, editing ourselves constantly, fearing judgment, craving likes, and even in our closest relationships, we might be more concerned with how we appear than how we connect.
SPEAKER_00It's exhausting when you think about it, right? And yet there is a strange beauty in noticing it. Because once you see the filters, the echoes, the performance, you can start peeling them back. You can start remembering what real connection feels like. You can start looking for those rare eye though moments in a world of I it. And maybe that's the challenge for our generation. To navigate a world where connection is easy but true presence is rare. To learn to meet people and ourselves before that, beyond the filters, beyond the likes, and beyond the created self.
SPEAKER_00Because until we do, we are not really talking, we are not really listening, and most importantly, we are not really meeting each other. So before we go deeper into the long-term psychological damage of this issue, I want to introduce you to two people who basically mapped out the communication crisis we are living in today. She Turkel from the MIT and Paul Grice, the legendary British linguist and philosopher of language, which I believe most of you at least heard of his name.
SPEAKER_00Turkle examines how technology shapes our relationships. Grice, on the other hand, explains why communication works and why it breaks. Put them together and you get a full picture of why we are struggling today. Terkel spent more than 30 years observing how people interact with technology. She didn't study phones. Actually, she studied us. One of her most powerful insights is this. We are lonely because we are terrified of intimacy.
SPEAKER_00So we hide behind controlled communication, texting, typing, editing, deleting. Technology gives us distance, it gives us safety, it gives us a version of ourselves we can polish before sending. But when communication becomes safe, it stops being real. She calls this mindset the Goldilocks effect, wanting relationships that are close enough to feel connected, but far enough to avoid vulnerability. Then we have Grice. Grice believed real communication is a collaboration, two people trying to understand each other.
SPEAKER_00He created the cooperative principle, which says conversations only work when people follow four simple rules, maxims. The first maxim is quantity. Say as much as needed, not more, not less. But online, messages become short, dry, and lacking context. People send hmm ok, low, or enumoti instead of real thoughts, right? Meaning becomes vague, and we start reading between the lines, usually assuming the worst, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_00The second maxim is quality. Be truthful, say what you actually mean. But created online communication pushes people to be performers, not communicators. People write what sounds good, not what they feel. Authenticity becomes optional. Turkle actually calls this identity editing. Then we have the third maxim which is relation. Be relevant. Today, relevance collapses because conversations happen while doing something else, right?
SPEAKER_00Multitasking, replying half-heartedly, jumping between apps. We are never fully present. Turkle says multitasking isn't a skill, it's a form of emotional distancing. And finally we have the fourth maxim: manner. Be clear, orderly, and avoid ambiguity. We experience that through delayed replies, scene without responding, messages cut into pieces, and emojis replacing clarity. Grice says misunderstandings become inevitable when manner breaks.
SPEAKER_00Turkle, on the other hand, says this is exactly why relationships feel emotionally unstable today. Turkle shows us the emotional consequences of digital communication. Grice shows us the structural linguistic consequences. Together, they explain why modern conversations feel shallow, misunderstood, fragmented, emotionally risky, and easily replaceable. We aren't bad communicators, we are just using tools that break the basic rules of communication without realizing it.
SPEAKER_00Turkel says we expect more from technology and less from each other. Grice, on the other hand, would probably say we broke the cooperative principle and then wondered why we don't understand each other anymore, really. The scary thing about all of this is not the arguments, not the misunderstandings, not the awkward moments of you are not getting my point. The scary thing is actually the long-term impact. The slow, silent erosion that happens inside people over the years.
SPEAKER_00Because when communication breaks down, when dialogue collapses, when everyone is stuck inside their own mental bubble, something deeper begins to die. Our ability to relate, to feel understood, and to understand others. And humans don't survive without that. Researchers have been trying to warn us about this for years. There's a famous study from the University of Michigan. It found that empathy among college students dropped 40% over the past few decades. Especially after the rise of social media.
SPEAKER_00And most of that decline wasn't dramatic or visible. It was slow, invisible, gradual. Like a muscle that stopped being used. Another study from MIT professor Sherry Turkle also showed that people today avoid face-to-face conversations because they fear unpredictability. They fear not to be able to control the conversation like they control a text box. And because of that, their emotional tolerance shrinks, their patience shrinks, their capacity for nuance also shrinks.
SPEAKER_00It's like we have built a generation of people who can communicate faster but not deeper. And when you look at a long-term impact, it's honestly heartbreaking. People become more isolated even when they are surrounded. People become more defensive even when no one is attacking them. People become more reactive even when the situation doesn't require it at all. Actually, there's a lot of studies on the subject of loneliness and how lonely we became in the last two decades. But of course, I'm not going to mention all of them.
SPEAKER_00We need a whole different episode for that alone. So for now, let's just stick with the negative communication impact. Communication issues don't just make relationships difficult. They slowly shape your identity, they shape how you interpret the world, they even shape the narrative you build about yourself. And this is where the echo chamber effect becomes really dangerous, because when you are only exposed to people who sound like you, think like you, validate you and even mirror your opinions, your inner world will eventually shrink.
SPEAKER_00It feels comforting at first, yes, like a warm, safe, familiar room, but over time that room becomes a prison. People inside echo chambers slowly lose the ability to tolerate disagreement, ask genuine questions, update their beliefs, hold complex ideas, and communicate across differences. Actually, here's what's really interesting. Researchers at Yale University discovered something they call identity protective cognition. It means that the brain literally changed how it interprets information just to protect your group identity.
SPEAKER_00So even when you are wrong, your brain convinces you you're right because the alternative feels threatening. That's how closed-off communication becomes a long-term psychological pattern. Over time, you confuse certainty with clarity. You confuse agreement with connection, and also you confuse being right with being understood. And with every passing year, you become a little less adaptable, a little less open, and a little less resilient. This is why so many adults today feel unheard, misunderstood, lonely, and disconnected, even though they are constantly communicating.
SPEAKER_00Because communication is not about speaking, we have talked about this. It's about being in the presence of another mind, genuinely. And when a person grows up without that, it shows it shows in the way they shut down during conflict, it shows in their inability to handle criticism, shows in how quickly they take things personally, shows in their fear of vulnerability, shows in the way they avoid deep relationships because deep relationships require deep communication. And long term damage doesn't explode, it accumulates, it builds slowly like dust.
SPEAKER_00One missed conversation at a time, one avoided apology at a time, one black person at a time, and one you don't get me at a time. So when people look around one day and feel disconnect. From their friends, from their partner, from society, even from themselves, it's not because something suddenly went wrong, it's because communication quietly stopped growing and everything else followed. And that's why this episode matters. Because this isn't just about talking better. This is about mental health.
SPEAKER_00This is about relationships, this is about identity, and this is about your future self also. So if we don't fix the way we communicate now, we won't just lose conversations. We will even maybe lose each other. The other day, actually, I came across a very beautiful quote from the ethologist Conrad Lawrence. It goes like, What is thought is not always said. What is said is not always heard. What is heard is not always understood.
SPEAKER_00What is understood is not always agreed. What's agreed is not always done. And what's done is not always done again. So when dialogue fades, something deeper fades with it. Empathy, for example. When we stop meeting people fully, when our attention is split between notifications and half-listening, we lose the ability to feel what others feel, right? We might hear the words, but not the heart behind them. Also, patience is another casuality.
SPEAKER_00Real conversation takes time. It's messy, it's unpredictable. You can't rush someone's story or shortcut their feelings with an emoji. But in the age of instant replies and constant scrolling, patience is almost a lost art, and even trust, trust suffers too. When every interaction is filtered, created or performative, how do we ever know what's real? When people talk at us instead of with us, we start adopting sincerity. Even the people closest to us.
SPEAKER_00We forget what it feels to be truly seen and understood. Even our sense of self takes a hit. We start defining ourselves by how we are perceived online rather than how we exist. We live in mirrors, reflections that distort who we are really. And slowly we stop connecting with ourselves as well as with others. And the most heartbreaking part is we don't always notice it. We think we are connected because we are talking, because we are messaging, because we are active, but being heard and being seen are not the same thing.
SPEAKER_00Real dialogue isn't just about speaking, it's about being present, being human, and being willing to meet another soul without filters. It's rare, yes, true. It's precious also. And the cost of losing it is immense loneliness, anxiety, shallow relationships, endless performance, and a quiet erosion of what it means to be truly human. But noticing the loss is the first step toward reclaiming it. Because if we can't see what's missing, we can start looking for ways to bring it back, right?
SPEAKER_00So now that we have seen the problem, the filters, the echo chambers, the iEt overload, the question is what can we do about it. The good news is it's possible to break the cycle. You don't have to quit social media entirely, although it helps. But you just need to start choosing presence over performance, even in small ways. One of the simplest things is to start slowing down. Not every message needs an immediate reply.
SPEAKER_00Not every thought needs to be shared online. Sometimes just sitting with someone, looking into their eyes, listening without interruption, can remind you what dialogue really feels like. Even five minutes of undistracted attention can change the quality of a conversation drastically. Another idea is to create your media consciously. Follow voices that challenge you, not just comfort you. Read books that make you reflect deeply instead of scrolling endlessly. Books like Shea Turkle Reclaiming Conversation.
SPEAKER_00She explores exactly how a digital life affects our ability to connect and offers practical strategies to rebuild real communication. And also call Newport Digital Minimalism, a guide to taking control of your attention so you can focus on meaningful interactions. Even listening to podcasts can help you with that. And then there is practice. Sounds simple, but real dialogue is like a muscle. It strengthens when you use it. Ask questions that go beyond the surface.
SPEAKER_00Listen without planning your reply. Share your own thoughts vulnerably, and notice how that feels. You might be surprised at how rare and valuable these moments are and how they restore a sense of humanity. Even writing can help. Journaling your thoughts, reflecting on conversations, or even drafting letters you may never send, it's a way of reconnecting with your own voice so you can bring authenticity into your interactions with others. And remember, it's not about perfection, it's about trying.
SPEAKER_00Every little effort counts actually. Every intentional conversation is a step back toward presence, empathy, and real connection. Because the truth is there is no app, algorithm, or platform that can replace an I though moment. Those rare instances of authentic connection are what make life meaningful, what make us feel alive, seen, and human. So maybe the challenge isn't to escape technology, but to learn how to meet each other through it without losing ourselves.
SPEAKER_00To slow down, to reflect, to listen, to be present. To remember that behind every profile, every screen, every message, there's a person, as though, waiting to be met. And if we can do that, even just a little more often, the digital age doesn't have to be the age of loneliness. I'm Muhammad and this was Beyond the Surface Podcast. Thanks for listening. Stay curious and see you next episode.
For Feedbacks Where Did Our Attention Go? In a world that constantly competes for our attention, what does it really mean to pay attention? From endless scrolling and digital distractions to the difficulty of being...
For Feedbacks Modern dating culture constantly sells us the myth of "the one" the idea that finding a perfect soulmate requires no effort, and that instant chemistry is the ultimate green flag. But what happens when the...
For Feedbacks Language is more than vocabulary and grammar... It shapes the way we think, connect, remember, and understand the world around us. In this episode, I'm joined by Sena, a French Literature graduate who...
For Feedbacks What does it mean to feel at home? In this episode of Beyond The Surface, I sit down with Professor Ferit Güven for a conversation about belonging, identity, memory, and the places that shape us. Together,...
For Feedbacks A growing number of young men feel lost, isolated, and without direction. But why is this happening? In this episode, we explore the silent crisis of young men; examining the psychological, social, and...